Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Why High Performers Leave Good Managers
Transcript
- Lucas: I was reading a piece in the Harvard Business Review last week that really stuck with me. It wasn't about compensation or benefits, which we talk about constantly. It was about the silent killer of high performance: the manager who avoids giving honest feedback. Luna: That sounds counterintuitive. Most people think good managers are just supportive and nice. Why would being too nice drive people away? Lucas: Because high performers interpret kindness without direction as a lack of confidence in their potential. If you never tell someone where they are falling short, they assume you are either afraid to do it, or worse, that you don't see enough value in them to invest the effort in correcting course. Luna: So the 'nice' manager is actually telling the employee they aren't worth coaching? That is a brutal way to put it. Lucas: It is brutal, but it is accurate. The article cited data showing that employees who receive consistent, candid feedback are significantly less likely to leave their roles. Conversely, those who feel their manager is protecting them from reality end up feeling invisible. Luna: Invisible. I have seen that happen. A star employee who stops asking for projects because they realize no one is watching closely enough to notice their stagnation. Lucas: Exactly. And it often starts small. The manager skips the tough part of the one-on-one because they want to keep morale high. They focus only on the wins. But over six months, that employee hits a ceiling. They realize they haven't grown, and they start looking elsewhere for a leader who will actually challenge them. Luna: It feels like a betrayal of trust, even if the manager's intentions were pure. They wanted to be a friend, but the employee needed a coach. Lucas: Right. There is a massive difference between being liked and being respected. Many new managers confuse the two. They think if they make everyone comfortable, they are doing a good job. But comfort is the enemy of growth. Luna: So how do you draw that line? How does a manager know when they are crossing from supportive into enabling mediocrity? Lucas: Look at the cadence of your conversations. If every meeting is just status updates and no one is ever pushing back on priorities or quality, you are in trouble. A healthy team has friction. It has moments where the work is dissected, not just approved. Luna: Friction. That is a word most people hate hearing, but it makes sense in this context. Without some resistance, there is no traction. Lucas: Precisely. Let us look at a specific example. Imagine a marketing analyst who produces beautiful reports but never challenges the underlying assumptions of the campaign. A weak manager praises the design. A strong manager asks why she didn't question the data source in the first place. Luna: The second conversation probably hurts more in the moment, but the first one leaves her unprepared for the next level. Lucas: Yes. And here is the tricky part. The employee might resent the strong manager initially. They might view them as difficult or critical. But over time, that same employee will defend that manager fiercely because they know they are getting better. Luna: Whereas the other manager gets the employee's loyalty for all the wrong reasons. The employee stays because it is easy, not because they are engaged. Lucas: And then one day, the employee realizes they have been coasting. They check their bank account, compare it to their peers who are growing faster, and they leave. The manager is left wondering why their best player walked away. Luna: It creates a cycle of disappointment for both sides. The manager loses talent, and the employee loses momentum. Lucas: So what is the practical fix for a manager who knows they are leaning too far toward the 'nice' side? They need to structure their feedback differently. Luna: Structure. I like that. Because feedback can feel so informal and messy sometimes. Lucas: Start with the SBI model. Situation, Behavior, Impact. When you frame feedback this way, it stops being a personal attack and becomes an objective observation. You are describing a specific event and its consequence, not labeling the person. Luna: That removes the emotion from the equation. It makes it harder for the manager to get defensive and easier for the employee to hear the message. Lucas: It also forces the manager to be prepared. You cannot fake the SBI model. You have to go into the room with a clear example of what happened. That preparation alone signals to the employee that you take their development seriously. Luna: It turns the one-on-one from a casual chat into a professional session. Which is exactly what a career-driven person wants. Lucas: But there is a risk here too. If you are too harsh, you burn out your team. The goal isn't to be critical for the sake of it. It is to be constructive. There is a nuance there that many leaders miss. Luna: Which is that the feedback must be paired with support. You point out the gap, but you also help them bridge it. Lucas: Absolutely. The strongest managers are the ones who give the hardest critiques and then immediately follow up with resources, training, or mentorship. They show that the criticism comes from a place of investment. Luna: That changes the entire dynamic. It shifts from 'you failed' to 'we have a problem to solve together.' Lucas: And that is the key distinction. Isolation versus collaboration. When a manager hides problems from an employee, they isolate them. When they bring problems to the table, they collaborate. Luna: I think a lot of new managers struggle with this because they are afraid of conflict. They worry that pointing out a flaw will damage the relationship. Lucas: They are wrong. Avoiding conflict damages the relationship much more. Silence breeds resentment. Uncertainty breeds anxiety. Clarity builds trust. Luna: Clarity. Even if the clarity is negative. So the lesson is to stop trying to protect your team from reality. Lucas: Exactly. Your job is not to be a shield. It is to be a mirror. Show them clearly what they are doing, and help them decide how to change it. Luna: That is a powerful reframing. Being a shield feels safe, but being a mirror feels responsible. Lucas: Responsible leadership is rarely the easiest path, but it is the only one that retains top talent long-term. People stay where they grow. Luna: And if they aren't growing, they are leaving. It is that simple. Lucas: Before we wrap up, I want to mention something quickly. If today was worth a coffee to you, that is the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: It helps keep these conversations going and keeps the show ad-free for you listeners. Lucas: Thank you. Now, back to the topic. I wonder if you have seen this play out in reverse. Where a manager was too harsh, and it drove people away just as fast. Luna: Oh, definitely. But that is usually easier to spot. The soft failure is the one that sneaks up on you. Lucas: It does. And that is why we need to be intentional about it. We can't just hope for the best. We have to build the habit of candor. Luna: Building the habit. Starting with the next one-on-one. Just one honest conversation. Lucas: One conversation can change the trajectory of a career. Or save a team from slow decay. Luna: So the question for our listeners is, when was the last time you received feedback that actually made you better? Lucas: And did the person giving it to you care enough to follow through? Luna: Those are the questions that matter most when you are deciding where to invest your energy. Lucas: If you find yourself answering no to either of those, maybe it is time to look for a manager who answers yes. Luna: Or perhaps, if you are the manager, it is time to step up and become that person. Lucas: A challenging thought to carry into your Monday morning meetings. Thank you for listening.