Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Understanding California’s New Peremptory Challenge Law: What Trial Attorneys Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to understanding California's new pre
- 0:06-emptory challenge law what trial attorneys need
- 0:09to know. I'm Laurie Critt Martin I'm a certified
- 0:12family law specialist and the past vice Chair
- 0:16for the litigation section. I'm delighted to
- 0:19introduce our speakers today. The first is Martin
- 0:22Aarons Martin I Aarons has been an employment
- 0:25Law trial attorney for more than 18 years is
- 0:28a trial lawyer. Martin has handled all types
- 0:31of employment related cases on behalf of people
- 0:33who suffered a workplace injustice. He specializes
- 0:37in cases involving discrimination, sexual harassment,
- 0:41sexual abuse, retaliation and whistle. lower
- 0:45cases of all kinds, shapes, and sizes. Our second
- 0:48speaker this morning is Justin A. Palmer, who
- 0:51is the founder of Palmer Law Group in Long Beach,
- 0:53California, where he advocates for clients in
- 0:56civil rights, personal injury, and criminal defense
- 1:00matters with a focus on protecting individual
- 1:03rights and securing meaningful justice. Recognized
- 1:08as a super lawyer selectee from 2020 through
- 1:122023, Justin combines a results -driven approach
- 1:16with a deep commitment to standing up for those
- 1:19facing some of life's most difficult challenges.
- 1:22And now let's get started with today's presentation.
- 1:27Wow. Thank you, Laurie. That was... Very humbling.
- 1:30Thank you for that great presentation. I'm really
- 1:31excited to be here. I just got out of the three
- 1:35-month trial. Justin himself just finished a
- 1:38one -week, two -week trial in federal court.
- 1:40And so this couldn't be more timely to talk about
- 1:45California's the new jury selection law. Justin,
- 1:48did you want to say hello as well? No, I'm happy
- 1:51to be here. We hope to make it entertaining over
- 1:54your lunch break. And if you have any questions
- 1:56during the presentation, feel free to jot them
- 1:59down and we'll do our best to fold your questions
- 2:01into the presentation. Yeah, I don't like waiting
- 2:04to the end. So if you've got something that's
- 2:05timely, throw it into the question and we'll
- 2:07try to answer it right then. So let's go ahead.
- 2:10We put together a little slide deck for everyone
- 2:13to try to educate about the new jury selection
- 2:17peremptory challenge law. So we'll go ahead and
- 2:20get that started from the beginning. So just
- 2:23so you know, everything here is in the California
- 2:27Code of Civil Procedure 231 .7. So if you want
- 2:31to ask, what's the law? What are we talking about?
- 2:35The answer to all your questions is 231 .7. So
- 2:39go ahead and write that down now. CCP 231 .7.
- 2:44And if in case there was any confusion, once
- 2:46again, it's CCP 231 .7. So let's go ahead and
- 2:50get started. All right, so what we're gonna cover
- 2:56here today. First, why the law changed. Talk
- 3:00a little bit of history. We'll do a little Batson
- 3:01Wheeler refresher. Cover the framework. Talk
- 3:06about the presumptively invalid reasons. We're
- 3:09gonna talk about, there's no slides on the appellate
- 3:11cases, but we're gonna talk about some of the
- 3:13cases so that you can hear all the cases right
- 3:15now are criminal. Because actually, when this
- 3:18law was put into place, it was put into place
- 3:20for criminal cases first. And it's only now,
- 3:23as of January 1st of this year, apply to civil
- 3:25cases. And then we'll talk about some practice
- 3:27strategies. Next. Go ahead, Justin. So what?
- 3:36Are you going to lead off on this slide? Oh,
- 3:39I'm sorry. I was hitting the buttons. To organize
- 3:44our thoughts about the topic and why we've been
- 3:47asked to talk to you today, we want to frame
- 3:48out what 231 .7 was drafted in response to. Traditionally,
- 3:55if you wanted to make, you have your peremptory
- 3:58challenges, of course, but courts are mindful
- 4:00that those peremptory challenges aren't used
- 4:02in a discriminatory manner. And so the two Bellwether
- 4:06cases that identified, examined, evaluated. whether
- 4:10or not peremptory challenges were used in a discriminatory
- 4:12fashion where the Batson case and the Wheeler
- 4:15cases. Those motions, I can tell you anecdotally,
- 4:21and I'm sure I can point to studies, that those
- 4:23are very seldom, if ever, granted. And really,
- 4:29I think it inversely placed the burden on plaintiffs'
- 4:32lawyers to demonstrate that these challenges
- 4:35were made in a discriminatory fashion. I can
- 4:38remember a case years ago in state court in Palm
- 4:42Springs where we had exhausted our four cause
- 4:47challenges. And then we got to the peremptory
- 4:49stage. And I think this was like maybe my second
- 4:52or third trial. And candidly, I didn't even know
- 4:54about Batson or Wheeler. And so the dude on the
- 4:57other side, all of his peremptories were going
- 5:00for people of color. And the first time I didn't
- 5:02really make a big deal out of it. Oh, okay, fine.
- 5:04We knew you were going to get rid of him, but
- 5:06I didn't know about the framework. And the second
- 5:08one, it's like, wait, what? And then the third
- 5:11one, I'm like, OK, that doesn't seem too right.
- 5:13So I'm sure that if I had exercised my Batson
- 5:16rights at that point, it would have been granted.
- 5:19But I wish that I had attended this session years
- 5:23ago, and I wish I had known about those cases
- 5:25before then. In fact, one of the places where
- 5:29this update came about was there was a Berkeley
- 5:32law death penalty clinic article that came out
- 5:36in 2020 that went back and tried to evaluate
- 5:42whether or not these peremptory challenges and
- 5:45Batson and Wheeler was actually having an impact
- 5:47or not. What they found was that because these
- 5:51Batson -Wheeler motions were not being granted,
- 5:54hardly if ever being granted, that the exclusion
- 5:57of minority jurors still persisted over time.
- 6:01Now, Batson -Wheeler is still a law in federal
- 6:04court. Let's go to the next slide. For refresher,
- 6:07if you've got a case in federal court, you know,
- 6:10whoever's making the motion, whether it's the
- 6:15prosecutor, the criminal defense attorney, the
- 6:17plaintiff's side in a civil case, the defense
- 6:19side, if you're saying, hey, the other side is
- 6:22excluding somebody for an invalid peremptory
- 6:25reason, the person making the motion has to first
- 6:29make a prima facie showing that that protected
- 6:34category discrimination was why they're excluding
- 6:37that juror. And then the judge has to rule and
- 6:41say, yes, you've made your prima facie showing.
- 6:44And now other side, madam attorney on the other
- 6:49side, what's your race neutral reason? And then
- 6:53the court makes a determination on that. And
- 6:59so that's still the process in federal court.
- 7:03You still have to sort of convince the judge
- 7:07And it's really broad discretion. And it's very
- 7:11much like, it almost is that, is it more likely
- 7:14true than not true that the race neutral reason
- 7:16is legitimate? And it could be almost any reason
- 7:20given. And the courts have been very freely.
- 7:26overruling those bats and wheeler motions. I
- 7:28had a recent trial where just, and we made two
- 7:31bats and wheeler motions during the trial, even
- 7:33though the other side kept challenging all of
- 7:36our jurors of color and not one of our bats and
- 7:40wheeler motions were given. Just so you know,
- 7:43the materials link is in the chat. So if you
- 7:46look at the chat, I think it's been posted a
- 7:48couple of times. Let's go to the next slide.
- 7:51All right, so weakness is a Batson Wheeler that
- 7:54pushes the burden initially on the objecting
- 7:56party. You've got to show that there was some
- 7:59race or some other protected category. That's
- 8:03part of that prima facie showing. Again, we just
- 8:06talked about that those racial neutral explanations
- 8:10can easily be provided. And right, appellate
- 8:13courts are deferential to trial judges. And then
- 8:17I think that was, and there were very fewers
- 8:19of remursals. And that was something that that
- 8:22study from Berkeley highlighted. So kind of around
- 8:27this time, let's go to the next slide. So back
- 8:29in the aftermath of all the protests in 2020
- 8:34and what was going on with the Me Too movement
- 8:38as well, there were changes. Things were going
- 8:43on. There was a change in the Racial Justice
- 8:46Act even, where now you could go back and look
- 8:49and see if prosecutors or defense lawyers or
- 8:53judges made comments to anamorphize the criminal
- 8:57defendant that they could even get a new trial.
- 9:00There was all the new laws related to sexual
- 9:03harassment in the workplace. And this was one
- 9:05of the laws that kind of came out from that as
- 9:07well. So we added, once again, CCP section 231
- 9:12.7. to the code. And the goal was to eliminate
- 9:17the unconscious and conscious biases. And the
- 9:22idea was to prevent discrimination and to encourage
- 9:25and to see a more diverse jury pool. That's the
- 9:29beauty of practicing here in California and here
- 9:32in Los Angeles as well, is that we have, if not
- 9:35one of the most diverse populaces in the world,
- 9:39I would say. Every jury that I've had, whether
- 9:42we've downtown Santa Monica or downtown LA, we
- 9:46always wind up getting a broad range of people
- 9:49of color, Asian descent, Latinx descent, Black
- 9:53Americans, people, Muslim Americans, all sorts
- 9:56of different walks of life. It's been really
- 9:58great. Have you had that experience as well,
- 10:00Justin? Yeah, I have. So this is an important
- 10:05thing to know. All right, next. All right. So
- 10:09in 2022, it applied to criminal jury trials,
- 10:12and as of 2026, it applies to civil trials. And
- 10:16so all the cases that have come out, and there's
- 10:20about a dozen or so cases that have come out
- 10:22in the last two, three years, are all criminal
- 10:26jury trials. And so I imagine that over the next
- 10:29two to three years, we'll start to see more cases
- 10:32coming out. on the civil side as well. And I
- 10:35believe there's one case right now that's actually
- 10:39pending before the California Supreme Court.
- 10:42We'll get to that a little later. All right.
- 10:46Go ahead, Justin. So 231 .7 lists out the protected
- 10:50categories. Justin, you want to take us away?
- 10:53Sure. So with 231 .7 that you're all going to
- 10:57remember after we finish talking to you today,
- 11:00there are protected categories. They include
- 11:01race, they include ethnicity. gender and gender
- 11:05identity, sexual orientation, national origin,
- 11:08and religious affiliation. And Martin alluded
- 11:12to this before, and I just want to underline
- 11:14it. It's intended to broadly apply to weed out
- 11:18and ferret out any potential challenge for peremptory
- 11:23uses against protected classes and categories.
- 11:29Yeah. Keep going. Oh, yeah. So what I like about
- 11:34the change, one, because it's been operating
- 11:36in the criminal space for the last few years,
- 11:39you have a lead time to figure out what courts
- 11:42are doing, albeit in criminal cases. If you try
- 11:44criminal cases, that might be of interest to
- 11:47you. But first, either party can make that objection.
- 11:51So the plaintiff's lawyers can, the defense court
- 11:53can, the court even can make it on its own motion.
- 11:55And if you read the statute itself, it prescribes
- 11:58specific steps to then evaluate whether or not
- 12:02those challenges are utilized in a discriminatory
- 12:06manner. But be aware that you must raise the
- 12:11challenge before the jury is impaneled. Because
- 12:14if you wait later, that might create some issues
- 12:16on appeal. And I think, much like with Batson
- 12:20Wheeler, I think the best practices here is to
- 12:23raise it. right in the moment. So if somebody
- 12:27stands up and says, we'd like to thank and excuse
- 12:29juror number nine, and you want to use that objection
- 12:33231 .7, I think the best practice is to write
- 12:36that in there, stand up and say, Your Honor,
- 12:39we need to have a sidebar objection 231 .7, and
- 12:43then see what happens. And actually, it has to
- 12:46be done. outside the presence of the jury, so
- 12:49either in chambers or at a sidebar. And so you
- 12:52can make that motion later, like if you're seeing
- 12:55a pattern and you get to the end. But again,
- 12:58if you get to the end and you've got 12 people,
- 13:00it all happens so fast, right? And all of a sudden
- 13:02the clerk, the judge says, all right, you 12
- 13:04stand up. And the clerk's like, raise your right
- 13:06hand. If you think there was a problem, you got
- 13:08to make that objection right then and there.
- 13:10Be like, your honor, before we swear the jury
- 13:12in, can I? we need to do something outside of
- 13:14the President's 231 .7. I think that's the best
- 13:18practice because one of the remedies is to keep
- 13:20that juror there. And there's other remedies
- 13:25as well that we'll go through later on here.
- 13:30But that's, I think, from a strategy standpoint,
- 13:36you got to do it right away. That's what I would
- 13:38say. And where this differs from the Batson and
- 13:41Wheeler challenges is, in Batson and Wheeler,
- 13:44the jury is still there. So you may be having
- 13:46this conversation at sidebar, depending on who
- 13:49your judicial officer is. And with 231 .7, you
- 13:53stand up and say, hey, let's have a conversation.
- 13:56The jury is removed from the courtroom. And then
- 14:00the burden is shifted to the person. exercising
- 14:05the cause and then they have to specifically
- 14:07articulate the reasons why we're getting rid
- 14:10of this particular juror which is yeah go ahead
- 14:14sorry No, I was going to say it's an interesting
- 14:17dynamic because, hey, we just don't like this
- 14:20person because they're wearing a polo shirt,
- 14:22or whatever your reason is, to then now be put
- 14:25on the spot to say, well, Your Honor, they ate
- 14:28grits this morning. It seems a little weird,
- 14:32and the judge can use that information to evaluate
- 14:34whether or not that cause would use in a discriminatory
- 14:37fashion. You were going to say something, Aaron?
- 14:39Yeah, we got an interesting question about like
- 14:42FRCP is silent, can 231 .7 be used in federal
- 14:45court in diversity cases? And I think the answer
- 14:49to that question would be like, probably not,
- 14:52because I feel like jury selection is procedural.
- 14:55And so when you do procedural, I think you can
- 14:58probably try to make an argument in a diversity
- 15:00case that this is a change in substantive law
- 15:03and that the goals here are admirable. I just
- 15:06don't know that that that would work in federal
- 15:09court, because right where it's procedural, we
- 15:12file the FRCP, but where it's substantive, we
- 15:15follow California law. And so I think in a diversity
- 15:17case, you could definitely make the argument.
- 15:20And I'd raise it at your final pre -trial conference
- 15:23with your federal judge. That's what I would
- 15:25do. You just did a case in federal court, Justin.
- 15:27That was a federal question case, but. I did,
- 15:31but you know what I'm also thinking too is your
- 15:34ability to do jury selection in federal court
- 15:36largely depends on who your judge is. I was lucky
- 15:39enough to get jury selection and I got 15 minutes
- 15:41to do it. I've had other cases in federal court
- 15:44where the judge is like, I'm doing all the selection
- 15:47and then you're just going to exercise the causes.
- 15:49So yeah, you would be entitled to make the causes,
- 15:52but you won't really have the opportunity to
- 15:54develop the record in the way that you would
- 15:56have if you were asking more expansive questions.
- 15:59That's true. And many judges, federal court are
- 16:01like, you want to ask a question, write it down,
- 16:03and I'll decide whether or not I'm going to ask
- 16:04your question. So let's go to the next slide.
- 16:07All right, so what's the procedure? OK, so remember,
- 16:10Batson Wheeler, you make your objection, and
- 16:13then you have to make a prima facie case. That's
- 16:15no more. Once you make that objection, the objecting
- 16:20party, all they have to say is, objection 231
- 16:24.7. I think you could probably even, to highlight
- 16:27it for a judge, what I might start doing is saying
- 16:29objection, Batson Wheeler under the new provisions
- 16:32231 .7. Just so the judge has an understanding,
- 16:36because they all know what Batson Wheeler is,
- 16:38they might not all know what 231 .7 is. And then
- 16:41in that step, well, so you just make the objection.
- 16:43Step two, the reason has to, it's outside the
- 16:46presence of the jury. Whoever used the peremptory
- 16:51challenge, they have to give their reason. The
- 16:55court evaluates the reason under this new standard.
- 17:01And this is, I think, the biggest change. The
- 17:05two are the biggest change. The first big change
- 17:07is there's no more pre and fashion case. You
- 17:10just say your objection. And then the second
- 17:12biggest case changes this new standard. Let's
- 17:14go to the next slide. All right. Go ahead and
- 17:18click through. OK. So the court has to do their
- 17:21own internal monologue. and decide would someone
- 17:27looking from the outside in as an objective,
- 17:31reasonable person see this as a protective standards?
- 17:35And is it more than possible? So it's not just,
- 17:41it's like substantial likelihood means is a substantially
- 17:46likelihood that race are protected category.
- 17:49And that means more than a mere possibility but
- 17:52less than a standard of more likely than not.
- 17:56And so it's kind of in that like 40 % range,
- 17:59I would say, 40 to 50, right? Because more likely
- 18:01than not is 50 plus one. And so is it more than
- 18:06possible that race or ethnicity or gender, gender
- 18:12identity, something like that, motivated this
- 18:19peremptory challenge? this thing. And I think
- 18:23that's huge, because before there was really
- 18:26no standard really given. It was sort of how
- 18:30the judge felt. But the statute specifically
- 18:34defines substantial likelihood. And so I think
- 18:39that's something that the courts of appeals might
- 18:42even struggle with when we're looking at and
- 18:45evaluating the trial judge's rulings about whether
- 18:48or not there was a substantial likelihood that
- 18:51the whether or not there was a reason and if
- 18:54the reason given passed muster. What I like about
- 18:57it too is if I'm looking at my notes but if you
- 19:01guys want to write this down too if you look
- 19:04at 231 .7 subsection D as in David Three, when
- 19:09you're in this realm about what is substantial
- 19:12likelihood look like, when you're looking from
- 19:15the outside and what an objective person think
- 19:18that these were used in an improper way, you
- 19:21have factors that you can push the judge towards
- 19:24to really push that point home. For example,
- 19:27is the person part of a perceived cognizable
- 19:30group? Does race, gender, ethnicity in those
- 19:35groups bear on the facts of the case? Did other
- 19:39jurors of the perceived cognizable group give
- 19:43similar answers but they weren't excused? Was
- 19:46this reason supported by the record? And G, has
- 19:52the lawyer of the lawyer's office who exercised
- 19:54the challenge used challenges disproportionately
- 19:57against a given race or gender? I heard the last
- 20:01one, subsection G, and I automatically teleported
- 20:04back. years ago, where I was like, yeah, if I
- 20:08had the benefit of this subsection, then my jury
- 20:12would have looked completely different. Right.
- 20:15And when you think about that, that's a really
- 20:17good point. So that's 231 .7 D3, and it's A through
- 20:22G. And it gives all those seven different non
- 20:27-exhaustive lists of things that the court could
- 20:29look at. And so the one that jumped out at me
- 20:33was did other jurors of other groups give similar
- 20:37answers, right? And so like, you know, the, the,
- 20:42oh, well, they said that they're part of a, a
- 20:44union or something like that. But, but the other
- 20:47jurors, you know, you, maybe you had a, a, a
- 20:50male juror give, say that they're also in a union,
- 20:53but here they are and they're using the peremptory
- 20:55on, on, on a woman. And their reason is because
- 20:59that she was in a union or things like that.
- 21:01And I think those are You've just got to kind
- 21:04of learn. If you go to the next question, right?
- 21:09So these are some of those factors, right? That's
- 21:13that comparative jury analysis. How does that
- 21:16one juror compare to the other juror? Did the
- 21:21prosecutor or the defense lawyer or the plaintiff's
- 21:23lawyer, did they not question that juror at all?
- 21:25And all of a sudden, they're just challenging
- 21:27them. Disparate questioning, same idea. That's
- 21:32that history of challenges, did they? So maybe
- 21:35some of these things, like Justin was saying
- 21:37at the end of that trial he had all those years
- 21:39ago, he's like, wait a second, as I sit here
- 21:42and I think about it, they challenged all of
- 21:45my Hispanic jurors. They challenged all of my,
- 21:48you might be trying a case and you might have
- 21:50six or seven gay or lesbian jurors on your panel.
- 21:54And all of a sudden they're all gone. So you
- 21:58definitely want to look at that. And so then,
- 22:04go ahead. So now, the statute gives a list of
- 22:1113 reasons that are historically linked to discrimination.
- 22:16Go ahead. And so if one of these reasons is given,
- 22:28then they have to rebut it. only by showing clear
- 22:33and convincing evidence that an objectively reasonable
- 22:38person would view the rationale at being unrelated
- 22:40to their race, ethnicity, gender, et cetera.
- 22:44And so these 13 things are presumed invalid.
- 22:49So if somebody stands up and says, well, the
- 22:53juror said that she has a distrust of law enforcement,
- 22:57then then the prosecutor, let's say, or the defense
- 23:00counsel has to get up and show by clear and convincing
- 23:03evidence that the reason given are unrelated
- 23:09to their race or their ethnicity. And the judge
- 23:14has to bear in mind unconscious bias. The judge
- 23:18has to think about that unconscious bias and
- 23:21think about whether or not that factures answer
- 23:27it. if one of these 13 reasons is given as one
- 23:31of the reasons. And so that goes back when we
- 23:33talked about that the objection is made and then
- 23:36the reason has to be given immediately. You might
- 23:40wanna print this one page out from the materials
- 23:44and put it in your binder. And this is under
- 23:47231 .7E as an echo. Because if the other side,
- 23:53if you make your... your new Batson -Wheeler
- 23:56motion to 31 .7, and they give one of these reasons,
- 24:00then you can point out to the judge and say,
- 24:02look, hey, Your Honor, this is a presumptively
- 24:05invalid reason. They have to show by clear and
- 24:07convincing evidence now that it's not due to
- 24:11their race. We're going to walk through these
- 24:15in a little more detail. All right. So distrust
- 24:20of law enforcement. Belief in racial profiling,
- 24:26relationship with someone arrested, jurors' neighborhood,
- 24:29or receiving state benefits. So unfortunately,
- 24:35these are things that have been historically
- 24:37associated with minorities and people of color.
- 24:42And it's just, this is what the evidence has
- 24:45bore out from our history of racism in this country
- 24:50and discrimination in this country. And so somebody
- 24:54who's had more experience with law enforcement
- 24:57and negative experience with law enforcement,
- 24:59just because they say they have a distrust of
- 25:01law enforcement, that's presumptively invalid.
- 25:07Right. Belief that they believe that cops racially
- 25:11profile, that's presumptively invalid. That,
- 25:16you know, when we look at the mass incarceration
- 25:18of people in this state and in this country,
- 25:21the likelihood of a person of color, nobody,
- 25:24somebody who's been arrested is just greater
- 25:27than somebody like me. Where they live, there
- 25:32are just higher to higher instances. So, Justin,
- 25:39one of the questions we got, what does belief
- 25:42in racial profiling mean? Well, how would you
- 25:45answer that? Well, I likened it or I connected
- 25:52it to the first bullet point about distrust in
- 25:55law enforcement. So, and I handled a bunch of
- 25:59civil rights cases. And so in the very rare and
- 26:03limited opportunities I have to do my own voir
- 26:06dire, one of the questions are, I asked the jury
- 26:10to get a vibe check about what are your thoughts
- 26:12about law enforcement in either direction. And
- 26:15sometimes, jurors explain to me that they feel
- 26:19communities of color are profiled. You know,
- 26:22they feel like that's not OK. That is what I
- 26:26believe. That's what I'm interpreting in terms
- 26:28of the belief in racial profiling. I'm sorry,
- 26:32go ahead. And the statute says like a juror expressing
- 26:36a belief that law enforcement officers engage
- 26:38in racial profiling. That's that's what that
- 26:42specifically means. But I mean, you might. you
- 26:45might actually get jurors that just come out
- 26:46and say that. Right, Justin? Mm hmm. Mm hmm.
- 26:50Yes. The short answer is yeah. Yeah. You know,
- 26:56you want to know that, you know, and one of the
- 26:59things I learned because all of it, I didn't
- 27:01have any lawyers in my family. I didn't come
- 27:03up in a firm. You're learning this on the fly,
- 27:06too. So you want to time these questions so that
- 27:09they're not poisoning in state court all 60 or
- 27:1270 jurors that you're getting or all 24 that
- 27:15you're getting in federal court, too. And then
- 27:18you're leaning in and being here. But that's
- 27:21separate from the actual peremptory discussion.
- 27:24Yeah. And part of that question that was asked
- 27:26by one of our attendees was, is it that the potential
- 27:30juror believes that one party or the other engages
- 27:33in racial profiling and the potential juror believes
- 27:36this is OK? I think it wouldn't matter if the
- 27:39juror thinks it's OK or not OK. If they just
- 27:42believe in racial profiling, the statute doesn't
- 27:45say if they think it's a good thing or a bad
- 27:47thing. They just say, hey, do they believe that
- 27:50law enforcement officers engage in that? For
- 27:55me, if that was the reason that the other side
- 27:58gave, I'd be like, that's a presumptively invalid
- 28:00reason, which leads to the next question that
- 28:05we got. And I think that this is good. Clear
- 28:08and convincing evidence will overcome the presumption.
- 28:10So what's an example? You would need to give
- 28:15detail more than I think if you're trying to
- 28:18justify your objection, you'd have to explain
- 28:20that and give more information about other indicia,
- 28:26about what happened. They were evasive in answering
- 28:30questions, their demeanor, they had a tough time,
- 28:35you know, other types of, you know, their other
- 28:42things about what they said. I think you need
- 28:44to get more of that. So if you're giving an answer
- 28:48in, you know, back at that beginning, right,
- 28:52the reasons required immediately, I think strategy
- 28:55wise, your best bet is to list out 10 different
- 28:58reasons. Because if one of those reasons is one
- 29:02of these invalid reasons, but you've got nine
- 29:04other legitimate reasons, I think you would have
- 29:06a better argument to say, look, it's not because
- 29:08they're fill in the blank. It's because of these
- 29:11other that that might be a presumptively invalid
- 29:15reason, but it's not the only reason. So that's
- 29:18the pro hack, too. I'm guilty of it. We all consume,
- 29:24we receive information completely differently.
- 29:27So if you say 10 words, I may catch six or seven.
- 29:30You have to be. dialed in when you're asking
- 29:33these folks these questions and practice active
- 29:36listening, because the statute, I think, specifically
- 29:39addresses that. If you're unable to articulate
- 29:42why you want to get this person off and then
- 29:44you resort to these examples, well, they don't
- 29:49like law enforcement. Okay. And like, it doesn't
- 29:52matter if they can, can they be fair and impartial?
- 29:54If you're just repeating or parroting things
- 29:56that you think are going to torpedo your case.
- 29:59that's not going to fly. So really lean in when
- 30:02they're asking these questions to determine whether
- 30:04or not you want to keep them, but also to survive
- 30:07this type of challenge under the new structure.
- 30:11Most definitely. And one of the questions we
- 30:13got from somebody else was like, why not show
- 30:15social or sociological studies that show that
- 30:19racism is institutional racism is embedded? I
- 30:22think I think. in the fly of the moment at trial,
- 30:26you're not going to have that there. I think
- 30:28the argument you could make to the judge is be
- 30:30like, look, Your Honor, these things are here
- 30:31because those studies exist already. We know
- 30:34these things to be true. And so I think you probably
- 30:40even have a better argument to substantiate your
- 30:43objection if they list out two or three of these
- 30:46things as their reasons, like when they're listing
- 30:48out all their reasons, if they go. So go to the
- 30:51next slide. Actually, it's got more of the the
- 30:54presumptively invalid reasons, the last ones.
- 31:00Not a native English sneaker, speaks another
- 31:02language, how they dress or appear, their employment
- 31:07field, unemployment. And it's not just their
- 31:10employment field. It talks about employment in
- 31:12a field that is disproportionately occupied by
- 31:16members in that protected category, or that serves
- 31:19a population disproportionately comprised of
- 31:23members of that group. So if you're serving,
- 31:28maybe if you worked as a probation officer or
- 31:31if you're working in some other field that you
- 31:37could say like, hey, look, your honor, like the
- 31:39reason they just gave us because of their job
- 31:41as an ex and people that work as an ex, we know
- 31:44from common sense disproportionately support
- 31:47that can fill in the blank community. And so
- 31:50that's that employment field. That's what that's
- 31:53talking about. It's not just what do they do.
- 31:56It's do they work in a field that you've seen
- 31:59supports that group? I mean, you could be like,
- 32:05hey, they work at a church. And if your emotion
- 32:09is because they're getting rid of all the people
- 32:11that are very faith -based because of their religion,
- 32:15then that would be an invalid reason, right?
- 32:18So that that would be the type of thing. And
- 32:21on that on that study, too, I think it's a good
- 32:24point. I might read the study and then fashion
- 32:27a series of topics or questions to examine the
- 32:30entire veneer about them, because you get the
- 32:33entire group talking about these things. And
- 32:36you can use those also as additional data points
- 32:38to either make these challenges or to resist
- 32:41the peremptory challenges later and in a creative
- 32:45way. Yes. So one of the one of the cases that
- 32:49came out. So this is where I wanted to add. So
- 32:51there's a case called People versus, you were
- 32:53at Swiggy, and I'm sure I'm pronouncing it wrong.
- 32:56It's 101 Calab 5th, 271. In that case, a Hispanic
- 33:03juror, the reason that there was a preemptory
- 33:05challenge made, and the prosecutor said, oh,
- 33:09it was lack of her life experience. And the court
- 33:13said that wasn't enough to overcome. the invalid
- 33:17reason, because for a lack of employment or underemployment,
- 33:21it was a presumptive or invalid reason. And so
- 33:23the prosecutor just gave lack of experience and
- 33:27unemployment or underemployment here is one of
- 33:30the lack of employment or underemployment, unemployment,
- 33:34right? Under 231 .7E11 says lack of employment
- 33:39or underemployment. And so when the process is
- 33:41like over lack of experience in the work field,
- 33:43that was not enough to overcome that clear and
- 33:46convincing standard. There was another case,
- 33:50People versus Ortiz, 96 Calab 5th, 768. And the
- 33:56prosecutor said that this juror wasn't able to
- 33:58answer or understand some very basic questions.
- 34:03And the trial court made its own observations.
- 34:07And then defense counsel was like, hey, those
- 34:09are invalid reasons. And then the trial court
- 34:13then went to the prosecutor. And they sort of
- 34:17worked together. And the prosecutor said, well,
- 34:21we don't know if that person is being truthful
- 34:23or if he might be hiding some kind of bias. That's
- 34:26what the court asked. the prosecutor and the
- 34:28prosecutor said yes, and that this juror hasn't
- 34:32been able to answer questions in a certain way.
- 34:35And so they don't understand the questions. They
- 34:39don't answer the form of the questions. And so
- 34:41that evasive answering and that evasive questioning
- 34:45done, the court found was sufficient. And so
- 34:50it was sort of that more of an explanation that
- 34:53was given by the prosecutor that overcame that.
- 34:57presumptively invalid reason. So let's see if
- 35:02we've got, I saw some more questions come in.
- 35:06So yes, of course. In other words, it's not just
- 35:08come up with a different reason. You're really
- 35:10supposed to come up with the reason in the first
- 35:13place. There were some other demeanor -based
- 35:14reasons, right? If they're inattentive or there's
- 35:22a secondary list, like there's that kind of a
- 35:25catch -all. if they give these answers and stuff
- 35:29like that, that you can use to support your objection.
- 35:39If these demeanor -based reasons are given, you
- 35:42could say that it's because of one of these,
- 35:46you'd have to kind of tie it back in if you're
- 35:48the one making the objection to the presumptively
- 35:50invalid reasons. So again, this is the new standard.
- 36:00Board asks whether an objectively reasonable
- 36:02person would see the protected status as a factor,
- 36:06that something less than, substantial likelihood
- 36:09factor, and then is it more than possible, less
- 36:15likely than not? And then again, I wanted to
- 36:17highlight that new procedure. All right, so.
- 36:24Yeah, so this is a really good point. So CCP
- 36:272031, this is a question. Does not expressly
- 36:31state that it applies to potential jurors with
- 36:33disability. But then the statute says, I'm reading,
- 36:40this is from a person named Richard Prager. This
- 36:43is great, thank you so much for sharing this.
- 36:46CCP section 231 .7 does not expressly state that
- 36:49it applies to potential jurors with disabilities.
- 36:52Yeah. CCP section 237 .5 reads that a party shall
- 36:57not use a peremptory challenge to remove a prospective
- 37:00juror because of the characteristic listed in
- 37:03government code section 11135, which includes
- 37:07disabilities of class. And so does 231 .7 apply
- 37:12to potential jurors with disabilities? I would
- 37:17argue to the court that it does. because I think
- 37:22the purpose of this is it was supposed to be
- 37:26read and interpreted broadly. And I think you
- 37:29just did the legislative and legal analysis in
- 37:33your question. And I would argue yes, that that
- 37:36would be an improper basis to exclude people
- 37:41and persons with disabilities. The hard part
- 37:45about that, I think from a strategy management,
- 37:50you don't always know if someone's got a disability
- 37:53unless they come out and tell you. So we're talking
- 37:57about sidebars, right? Hey, I wanted to share
- 38:00with you that I have this fill in the blank.
- 38:03It could be many disabilities now are not visually
- 38:07obvious. And so I think that might be the hard
- 38:11part where you might not know that information.
- 38:15And something, whether or not it's a disability,
- 38:17it could just be somebody has a broken body part
- 38:20or they're walking just with a limp and it couldn't
- 38:22be necessarily a disability. What do you think
- 38:24Justin? I had a case where we had selected a
- 38:29juror and I was really like stoked about her.
- 38:33Like she had great energy, her reasons were great,
- 38:36she was laughing at all our jokes and so she
- 38:39sat and then She starts to cry a little bit,
- 38:42and I'm like, uh -oh, that's not good. And then
- 38:45she passes a note to the clerk, and then there
- 38:48was a whole sidebar situation as she expressed
- 38:50that she had a disability. And we were trying
- 38:54to figure out on the fly what to do there. And
- 38:57to Martin's point, yeah, I think in a room full
- 39:01of strangers, you don't want to bear that much
- 39:02vulnerability and to share that particular detail.
- 39:06But we were able to excuse her and to thank her
- 39:08not only for her bravery and... mentioning that
- 39:11to the group and also to fashion a different
- 39:14juror to get back and to do the work. But yeah,
- 39:17I agree. I think 231 .7 would include that discrimination
- 39:22as a protected class. And somebody responded
- 39:26in the Q &A, where an objection to the use of
- 39:29a peremptory asserts a protected group covered
- 39:32in 231 .5 but not 231 .7. She's saying though
- 39:36there was a case that came out, People versus
- 39:38Hernandez. I must have missed that one. That
- 39:40that should be litigated as through the objection
- 39:42fails under Batson Wheeler. So maybe this is
- 39:45an area where we need to write our legislators
- 39:47and be included with that. There was another
- 39:51question. If a juror is wearing a button that
- 39:53says challenge authority, is that clear and convincing?
- 39:57I mean, I think I'd want to know what they mean
- 39:59by that. I would ask them, be like, can you tell
- 40:01me a little bit about that button? What does
- 40:03that mean? That's how I would approach that.
- 40:06And and very likely would then it only has to
- 40:10be that clearly convincing. Remember, is if it's
- 40:12in one of those presumptively protected. Yeah.
- 40:15Let's let's click through. We've talked a lot
- 40:17about this defending a peremptory challenge.
- 40:19State your reasons clearly. Link. Go back. Link
- 40:22explanation to impartiality. Avoid generalized
- 40:25statements and a dreamt the invalidity directly.
- 40:29You really need to someone made an objection
- 40:31that that that I was excusing jurors and made
- 40:35this one of the objections, I think you just
- 40:38need to be as detailed as possible. And that's
- 40:43where when you do your jury selection, you're
- 40:45writing all your notes, or if you've got co -counsel
- 40:47with you writing notes about their answers to
- 40:50their questions, if you've done a good probing
- 40:54voir dire, you should have lots of reasons of
- 40:57why that juror just makes you feel uncomfortable
- 40:59and it's just not the right fit. for this case.
- 41:03So what happens if the objection is sustained?
- 41:11So if that juror is still there, you could actually
- 41:16keep that juror in the box. That's one of the
- 41:22remedies. If there were, if you make it later
- 41:28on and there are let's say there were two or
- 41:30three people of color or women or something that
- 41:34you thought was the reason for the improper,
- 41:37you could ask the judge to give you, hey, Your
- 41:39Honor, I think they improperly used these two
- 41:44or these three peremptories. I should be given
- 41:48additional peremptory challenges. If it's bad
- 41:51enough, you could quash the entire veneer. And
- 41:58you could even declare a mistrial. And those
- 42:01options are in the statute, that those things
- 42:06are what could happen. So if the mistrial, I
- 42:12think, would really happen if the jury wasn't
- 42:15paneled, and then there was the objection, and
- 42:18you're not supposed to do it that way, but I
- 42:20think the legislature saw that that's just a
- 42:23reality, that that could happen. And of course,
- 42:29under 231 .7, this is subdivision H. If the judge
- 42:33and counsel can get creative, they could come
- 42:35up with other reasons as well. Next slide. So,
- 42:42right? Just do it, right? Do a good one, dear.
- 42:48Next slide. Create a clear record. Don't use
- 42:54stereotypes. And I think that's that's really
- 42:58important. I think the more the more cases I've
- 43:01tried, the more I've realized that it's really
- 43:04important to listen to jurors. When I've sat
- 43:10in on trials and and the other side gets up and
- 43:14it's just the lawyer speaking. I'm like, this
- 43:18is they're not learning. Right, you know, right,
- 43:22Justin? Yeah, it's it's not intuitive. Because
- 43:26some people, I won't use generalization, some
- 43:30people like to, they listen to respond rather
- 43:35than listening to engage and vibe out. And it
- 43:41took a while, I don't think I'm perfect at it,
- 43:43but the goal of this whole thing is where are
- 43:47you from and how do you think? Not to challenge
- 43:51those thoughts, not to challenge those beliefs,
- 43:53because you're not. You know, and the example
- 43:56I use is just leftovers. I think fresh food,
- 43:59well, Martin's a cook. I don't know if you guys
- 44:01knew that or not. He's like a Michelin chef.
- 44:04That's this guy, that's Justin. Then show them
- 44:07your garden, dude. Anyway, I think fresh food
- 44:12is superior to anything in the world. You know,
- 44:15so every night I make a fresh plate. I don't,
- 44:19people have leftovers and that's totally fine.
- 44:22I think those people are wrong. but I'm not going
- 44:25to change their mind about leftovers, right?
- 44:29You tell me your reasons why you like them and
- 44:31we'll agree to disagree. I take that same mind
- 44:34frame when I'm interviewing prospective jurors.
- 44:37I'm not going to change you that reheating food
- 44:39and glass jars make sense. And I don't want to,
- 44:43but tell me that if there is a case about a microwave,
- 44:47this isn't the case for you. You know what I'm
- 44:49saying? Like use that approach to learn. to being
- 44:53curious and to listen with an open mind to better
- 44:58help your client. Yeah, I think from a trial
- 45:02perspective, that's the best way, right? And
- 45:06I've had people say really mean things to me
- 45:10in jury selection about the cases that I've got
- 45:13and attorneys and things like that. And I just
- 45:16say, to me, that's gold. That's a gift. Thank
- 45:20you for sharing. that for me doesn't sound like
- 45:23you're the best fit for this case. I like to
- 45:26use mini openings. And I think if you can get
- 45:29and if you if you ask for a mini opening, it's
- 45:32required to give it to you. Use the mini openings.
- 45:35Talk about your case. Have the defense talk about
- 45:37their case. And then with that little nugget
- 45:41of information, jurors are going to start to
- 45:44tell you what they think about. to your case
- 45:47or about the defense case or the prosecutor's
- 45:50case. And when you get that kind of more specific,
- 45:54as opposed to just like, this is a personal injury
- 45:56automobile case, or this is a med mal, or this
- 45:59is a breach of contract case, or this is a fill
- 46:02in the blank kind of case, when you can give
- 46:03them a little more meat on that bone, they'll
- 46:07start sharing things with you. Go to the next
- 46:10slide, actually, Justin. I think this kind of
- 46:12hits on it, right? You can ask them those clarifying
- 46:14questions. You can tie the concerns to the facts
- 46:18of your case. And you can get that information,
- 46:24which will help you, frankly, make more educated,
- 46:27peremptory challenges across the board. Forget
- 46:29about the Bats and Wheelers and the 231 .7. You're
- 46:33just going to do a better job finding better
- 46:35jurors. for your case. Yeah, someone put it in
- 46:38the Q &A. We need to learn to listen and listen
- 46:42to learn, right? And just, I mean, just listen
- 46:47and say thank you. Thank you for sharing. And
- 46:50knowing when to stop too. If the juror gives
- 46:53you a bad fact and you know it's bad, don't double
- 46:56tap on it. Thank you very much for your courage
- 46:59and really telling me that. I appreciate that.
- 47:02Miss Jones, do you mind if I ask you some questions?
- 47:05There you go. Keep the push. Go to the next slide,
- 47:09maybe. We're kind of making good time. So make
- 47:12your objection, raise it immediately. Let's just
- 47:15move on to the next one. We've already covered
- 47:17that stuff. Prepare your questions, track the
- 47:20responses, right? Link your challenges, your
- 47:24peremptory. If you stand up and you have a peremptory
- 47:26challenge in your heart, in your mind and in
- 47:29your heart, you should know the why. Build your
- 47:33record. What's next? key takeaways, right? Definitely
- 47:39changes it, lowers the threshold. You have to
- 47:42adopt and adapt a good idea or strategy and build
- 47:46your record. And so there's a next slide gives
- 47:51a summary, right? Just like A versus B, because
- 47:54you still are going to have to use bats and wheeler
- 47:57for certain things. I guess for the disability
- 47:59ones right now, until that gets remedied. Thank
- 48:03you so much. Whoever put that in the Q &A. Sydney,
- 48:07thank you for doing that. That was great. Little
- 48:09nugget right there. And then, you know, follow,
- 48:15read the materials. It's just an article that
- 48:19I wrote last summer comparing these. And then
- 48:23there's been new case laws that have come out
- 48:26even since then. And there is currently a case
- 48:31before the... California Supreme Court, which
- 48:36was whether or not you can, and then go, go to
- 48:40Q questions and discussion. So how will this,
- 48:43you know, things for you to think about, right?
- 48:46What concerns do you have? How will this change
- 48:48it? And then that's, that's, that was it. I wanted
- 48:51to talk, go ahead and hit stop share Justin.
- 48:55And what I wanted to point out that that California
- 48:59Supreme Court case is people versus Sam Miguel.
- 49:02So keep your eye out for that. And the question
- 49:04was whether or not the trial court overruled
- 49:07defendant's 231 .7 objection to the prosecutor's
- 49:12challenge. And at the lower court, the Court
- 49:16of Appeal held that the lack of attention by
- 49:18that prospective juror overcame the presumption
- 49:21of invalidity based on the prosecutor's use of
- 49:25their peremptory challenge. The prosecutor actually
- 49:27asked that person whether or not, only one question,
- 49:32whether he would require the victim to testify,
- 49:35to reach a decision. And that juror was of Latino
- 49:41descent and was the only Latino man left of the
- 49:4418 in the box. And the prosecutor, so responses
- 49:49to why they got rid of them were extremely brief.
- 49:52And it sort of went back and forth and the trial
- 49:54court found that that was enough. and overcame
- 49:57the 231 .7 so that's an interesting case that's
- 50:00coming up so those those are kind of those are
- 50:03my anybody have any other questions they want
- 50:05to throw and and in the in the chat or in the
- 50:09q a um but one thing that and if not i have one
- 50:13other thing that i want to address justin do
- 50:15you have any other thoughts uh nothing other
- 50:18than to express my gratitude for you spending
- 50:20two minutes on a monday hearing me and martin
- 50:25talk This was great. I'm glad that I was able
- 50:28to meet you all virtually, and I hope that you
- 50:30guys stay in touch. We dropped our emails in
- 50:32the presentation, but feel free to reach out
- 50:34if you have any questions. You want to talk shop,
- 50:36you want to hang out, grab a drink, whatever.
- 50:38Yeah, most definitely. Thank you for allowing
- 50:40us to share a little bit of information and knowledge
- 50:44on something that's new and kind of interesting.
- 50:47So get out there and try more cases. I think
- 50:53that's it. Oh, so we've got nine more minutes.
- 50:56I wanted to fill up. If we had a little bit of
- 50:58time, I wanted to share. So a friend of mine
- 51:01started trial today and he said, Martin, how
- 51:04do I, it's been a while since I tried a case.
- 51:08What's the process for college challenges and
- 51:13parametries? And what I realized is there's like,
- 51:15there's this dance that nobody, that people forget
- 51:18about, right? So you got your 12 in the box.
- 51:22And in a civil, I'll talk about civil cases.
- 51:25If it's a challenge for cause, the defense goes
- 51:27first, and then it goes to the plaintiffs. But
- 51:31when you get to the preemptories, if you lose
- 51:34a juror, you usually have those six down here,
- 51:37and that's where the comes in. And so one thing
- 51:41that I've noticed is that, what do you do if
- 51:43you get down to that final 12, and you're thinking
- 51:45about challenging juror number nine, but there's
- 51:47nobody down here? And the laws, the laws unclear.
- 51:51And I just wanted to throw that out there because
- 51:53I think, oh, because I think, you know, you're,
- 51:57you have, you're allowed to question jurors to
- 51:59intelligently exercise your peremptories. And
- 52:01if you don't know what's coming, and I've had
- 52:03about 50, 50 success with judges on this saying,
- 52:07look, I don't know what's coming. I can't intelligently
- 52:10use my peremptory. Let's fill those six and talk
- 52:13to those six. Some judges allow that. Some judges
- 52:15are like, no, you, you got to have an empty seat
- 52:17in the box. So I just think it's it's an interesting
- 52:22fact. I think it benefits both sides of the aisle
- 52:24to know what's coming Whether you're the next
- 52:28thing up. So that was just something I wanted
- 52:30to thought about Oh the name of the question
- 52:33the name of the case pending is people versus
- 52:36San Miguel and the court of a it was 105 Calop
- 52:425880 was the the lower court but people versus
- 52:46San Miguel before the the supreme court is 327
- 52:50cal reporter 3d 897 so um that's it any other
- 52:59last that those that those are my thoughts