Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 15)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deservan listeners. This is chapter fifteen in our dugg Or Deep Dive.
- 0:04Chapter fourteen and chapter fifteen are a follow up to the first thirteen chapters
- 0:10in which we go over your emails and your comments, not all of them,
- 0:13but a selection of them that actually furthered my understanding and also are helpful
- 0:19for us to talk about. I think it furthers the knowledge and the learning
- 0:23and the understanding and the empathy and the things that we need to know about.
- 0:26It's not just people saying great job, Kirk, you know, thumbs
- 0:29up or you suck or whatever people say. So let's read these emails and
- 0:34these comments and comment on them. Berto, what do you say? Let's
- 0:38do it. This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast. What it says right
- 0:42there and everyone. My name is doctor Kirkanda. I am a therapist and
- 0:47I'm also a professor. Berto, who are you? My name is so
- 0:50Umberto Casa and I blow the lids off of glass jars. So middle tier
- 0:56patron and YouTube member Mari from Arizona. They say, I'm listening to your
- 1:02deep dive on the Douggers right now. Thank you so much for sharing your
- 1:03frustration about the failures of the system in this case, it makes me feel
- 1:08validated regarding something similar in my life. For those of us who are in
- 1:12situations where we know that children we know are being abused and the system is
- 1:17failing them in the same way, can you talk about things we can do
- 1:19to support these kids and how we can take care of ourselves in these situations.
- 1:23Doctor Kirk, would you be willing to share anything about how you handled
- 1:29your experience with disillusionment with the system? Well, first, Burdeau, any
- 1:33thoughts. The bottom line is this feeling of helplessness, Like I have no
- 1:37saying this. I can only imagine if it was like but wait, my
- 1:42child or the kid or the thing or the stuff, and you have just
- 1:45like this feeling of helplessness. Wow, it's got to be crazy. Yeah.
- 1:51Yeah. So for Mari, what I'll say is that first off,
- 1:56you're asking, how do we cope with this or how do I cope with
- 2:00the dissolution? Well, what I guess, looking back, how I coped
- 2:04with it was I said, well, I have to live with the system
- 2:07as it is, and I decided to do what I could do within the
- 2:12system. And there are a lot of things we can do, and here
- 2:14are some of the things that I did. I found allies within the system.
- 2:17I befriended a lot of people in the Department of Child and Family Services
- 2:23and found that there's a wide variety of folks that work there. There's some
- 2:25people that are very much in alignment with how I think and act, and
- 2:30there are others that aren't so aligning myself with those people finding out how the
- 2:34department works and the politics of it. I would also talk with the kids
- 2:38there be that are being abused. I would validate them. I would confirm
- 2:43that it is abusive or it just even introduce that idea to them. Sometimes
- 2:47I would apologize for how the system harmed them, and I would say that
- 2:53I'm sorry that I guess I'm kind of even a part of it, and
- 2:57you deserve to be apologized to. I would tell them that. I would
- 3:00have a number of conversations with teenagers about how they just have to hold out
- 3:05for you know, if I determined that they were in an impossible situation,
- 3:07you know, like I'm thinking of one kid who was in a family with
- 3:12a mom that I had diagnosed without telling her, I diagnosed in my head
- 3:16that she had narcissic personally, So it was a pretty classic case. And
- 3:20she talked incessantly. She was lacking an empathy, she was determined to blame
- 3:28everyone else for her problems. She had a very fragile ego, but she
- 3:34wasn't physically violent. And so I was talking with one of the kids in
- 3:38individual therapy for a while, and I was trying to work on the mom.
- 3:43I was trying to work with the dad, I was trying to work
- 3:46with the kid, I was trying to work with the siblings, and I
- 3:47was trying to do a lot of things to affect change so that the kid
- 3:51would experience less abuse. And then in the end, I predicted it was
- 3:55going to take a lot longer than the kid had left in the house for
- 3:59me to put significant dent in the abuse that was happening, in the emotional
- 4:03abuse that was happening in the family. And you know, CPS was involved,
- 4:08and they were saying, well, it doesn't really rise beyond the threshold
- 4:13to take the kids out of the home or anything. And so I at
- 4:16some point a year into it, I think I said to the teenage boy,
- 4:20I just said, look, here's how I see it. You're being
- 4:24abused and that is real. And the best thing I can do for you
- 4:29right now is to tell you that, is to valuate, validate that,
- 4:31and to continue to validate that and all of our time that we have left
- 4:34together in therapy. And also if you want me to try to be an
- 4:40agent of change. You can't tell your mom that I said that to you,
- 4:43because she will pull you out of therapy or she'll I don't know what
- 4:46she'll do, but it won't go well. And so when I'm interacting with
- 4:49your mom, you have to understand that I am interacting with someone that has
- 4:54a disorder and I have to accommodate that to some extent just to hold on
- 4:58to her in therapy, but I will be subtly working on her. But
- 5:00especially if she if she's narcissistic, you can't There's a lot of things you
- 5:04can't say because it'll trigger. Yeah, I can't criticize, I can't say
- 5:10I can't even raise a question as to like, have you thought maybe there
- 5:14might be some change in parenting? You're done out of here, like really
- 5:17what it involved to be honest? And this is true for a lot of
- 5:20people with more severe narcissistic personality. Is. I just listened to her for
- 5:27hours at a time while she just ranted and raved about everything, and I
- 5:32just validated, like a captive audience at a rally or something like a parent
- 5:39hearing from a five year old as they talk irrationally about what happened. You
- 5:45witnessed it. You're like, that's not what happened, kid. But you
- 5:47know they're in a state, they're in a they're very hurt or you know,
- 5:51their ego is bruised, and they're ranting, and you know, you
- 5:55don't go like to a five year old, you don't say your perspective is
- 5:59wrong. Like everyone. You listen and you're with them and they're five,
- 6:02you get so a situation. I'm telling him, I'm telling him this the
- 6:08client, and he's agreeing in a very somber way, like, oh and
- 6:14we and this was. This was many conversations that I'm describing here, and
- 6:16I mean I even remember, like where he was sitting in my office and
- 6:21I'm telling him all this, and I'm also telling him that we have to
- 6:27do what we can to mitigate the risk of you being harmed or lower the
- 6:33harm from here until you turn eighteen, because once you're eighteen or when you
- 6:38graduate from high school, you have the power to do whatever you want to.
- 6:43What would you do? And you know, he's telling me something like,
- 6:45well, i'd move out, I would I have a cousin or something.
- 6:48And he, you know, because he was doing while in school.
- 6:51He was a responsible kid and there was no doubt that he was going to
- 6:55be successful. And so I said, okay, so you just have that
- 7:00amount of time, so we need to do everything we can, because essentially
- 7:03what he was doing was at you know, the age of sixteen ish,
- 7:08he was realizing that it was all bullshit, and he was he was fighting
- 7:12against her. He was saying, no, you can't talk to us like
- 7:15that. You can't talk to me like that. You can't rant and rave
- 7:19all the time. It's not the you show, it's it's you know,
- 7:23there are other people in this world. And that would cause him a lot
- 7:26of problems because then she would attack him. And so I was trying to
- 7:30explain to him what I saw in his mom and what I don't know if
- 7:34I used the diagnosis, but I was telling him that there are some people
- 7:39that have certain disorders or certain schemas or behaviors and traumas that lead to them
- 7:44doing this, and da da da, and he was like, oh,
- 7:46okay, that makes sense. And we worked together and collaboratively came to the
- 7:49conclusion that the best course of action, the best plan is to not fight
- 7:54against her, but to internally validate himself as he's being bulldozed, and to
- 8:03get by as best he could until he can get away. That is rough,
- 8:07because you know, emotional abuse is real, it's not lesser than physical.
- 8:13But with the government, they generally speaking, in my anecdotal experience,
- 8:16they tend not to react to emotional abuse as much, especially if it's in
- 8:20this category. Right, So they have a lot of kids who are stuck
- 8:26in and in my view, they should have CPS react to that absolutely.
- 8:31I mean, this situation was completely ridiculous. It was obvious what was happening
- 8:35to these kids. I mean, all you had to do was talk to
- 8:37the mom for fifteen minutes and you're just like what I mean, the thing
- 8:41she would say about our kids, you just you're like most even though I
- 8:45don't know your kids, I'm pretty sure that is not true, Like that,
- 8:48the way she would characterize these people. Yeah, And so I had
- 8:54to work within the system. Well what could I do. I don't just
- 8:56give up. I don't throw my hands up and say, well, this
- 9:00system has failed, so fuck it. I guess that's the end of the
- 9:03game. I said, okay, to work within those constraints and here are
- 9:05the rules. Well what can I do? You know? And and and
- 9:09I did that a number of times. You know, I can think of
- 9:11a handful of the top my head where I was having those conversations with kids.
- 9:16Oh, quick question for you, what do you call this? Like
- 9:18not necessarily diagnosis wise, but like I mentioned this to you a while ago,
- 9:22but years ago, it was actually during the pandemic. Yeah, I
- 9:28was having this conversation with this gal who I literally just met in that moment
- 9:33someone introduced me, like, oh me so, and so I'm like okay,
- 9:37and the gal, an older, older individual, started talking about her
- 9:43daughter and how a daughter or son I think it was a daughter, and
- 9:48how much of a genius her daughter was, how amazingly accomplished, and I
- 9:56was like, oh, that's okay. And I was trying to follow along,
- 9:58maybe ask a quot. I could barely even ask any questions. It
- 10:01was just constantly like it keeps going and I'm like, Wow, that's incredible,
- 10:07and I'm like, and I'm valid I'm like, oh wow, that
- 10:09is genius, Like that's incredible. It's like, oh yeah, he keeps
- 10:13going and going. And then I would try to like offer like a little
- 10:16oh because you know this, and then she would just come right back and
- 10:20keep going and it never stopped. I basically she couldn't care less about anything
- 10:26I would have had to say, even about the validations about what she's saying.
- 10:31Right, what is that It wasn't about her, It was about her
- 10:35daughter. I mean, I don't know, but it is. But it's
- 10:37like it is a hallmark of narcissies. It's so frustrating though you're trying to
- 10:41like interact with it, but you can't even interact. Yeah, I mean,
- 10:46what is potentially happening and who knows. But often what I find when
- 10:50I assess folks like this over time is that internally what's happening for them is
- 10:56they equate safety with being the center of a tension. And it's not just
- 11:01like they prefer to be the center of attention. They actually feel tremendously unsafe
- 11:07and just untethered potentially to reality when they're not the center of attention to the
- 11:13point where if their narcissistic supply dries up, they fall off a cliff and
- 11:18they fall into an abyss that they don't know which way is it is.
- 11:24It is terrifying to these folks. You'll hear borderline personality sort of individuals talk
- 11:30about how they'll fall into this abyss, but they are more willing to acknowledge
- 11:33it to people because they're more likely to reach out for help. For narcissistic
- 11:37people, they don't want to acknowledge this. They don't want to and they
- 11:41certainly don't want to ask for help because of their defensive structure. So they
- 11:45have the same abyss though, and they are terrified. So they're in this
- 11:48constant treadmill of narcissistic supply. And I'm the best. I'm not just like
- 11:52okay, but I'm the best because I have to counteract this massive you know,
- 11:56It's like you have this scale and there's this there's this giant tanker truck
- 12:01that is like on one side, that is saying you're a piece of crap,
- 12:05you're irrelevant, you're nothing. So on the other side of that scale,
- 12:09I can't just be like you're normal, No, you're average, you're
- 12:13you're mostly a good person. You have to be the best I had.
- 12:18There was this moment too, where they had set something along the lines of
- 12:24oh, and you know, and they were working. I'm mixing the facts,
- 12:26but it's like and they were working on this project and like the they
- 12:30basically like didn't interact with anyone for weeks and they were and I said something
- 12:35like, oh, that must have been hard, like basically because the way
- 12:37they were describing it sounded like, obviously I'm not getting the facts right,
- 12:41but if you heard it, it sounds like someone being a little unbalanced on
- 12:46the scale of like being too focused or maybe issuing social relationships. So I
- 12:52said something like, oh, that must have been hard for them, And
- 12:56they were like so confused by my statement, like oh no, no,
- 13:00no, no, no, no, not at all, like they did
- 13:01well it was their kids that they're talking about. Yeah, yeah, So
- 13:05that scale for you to suggest, and it's it's barely imbalanced it at a
- 13:11given time, And so for you to suggest, I'm just going to take
- 13:13a guess. Basically, the way you're describing it is that the child is
- 13:16suffering in some way, even though and in a positive way, like meaning
- 13:20like, oh, that must have been hard for them, you know.
- 13:22Ye, not that you're not saying it's the pact or that it's the parent's
- 13:26fault. You're not saying, how did you Why did you put your child
- 13:30into that line of fire? You're just saying, oh, that must have
- 13:33been tough. It's possible, quite possible that the parent any implication that they
- 13:39aren't perfect, and thus their parenting isn't perfect, and thus if their kid
- 13:41is suffering in some way, then the scale and the scale doesn't do this,
- 13:48the skill does this, you know what I mean. They're just all
- 13:50or nothing. And so for these individuals, they will be compelled, not
- 13:54always that there's certain types of people with narcisism, but to show off.
- 14:00And one of the styles that they can do that, and they learn this
- 14:01when they're very young, is if they just talk and talk and talk about
- 14:05things that are impressive. Sometimes they'll talk about themselves, sometimes they'll talk about
- 14:09their kids. Sometimes they'll talk about things that they did, you know,
- 14:13like you wouldn't believe this vacation I went on, and they'll just detail like,
- 14:16you know, event after event, and it's all the best I had
- 14:20the best champagne and the best food, and all these important people were there,
- 14:24and they're not bragging about them. They might even be bragging about these
- 14:28other things that are outside of them, but it's associated with them. Okay,
- 14:33so they're bulldozing. They're bulldozing. They also have so little tolerance for
- 14:37other people taking up space because that means they're not taking up space, and
- 14:41that's again terrifying to them. But anyway, let's take a break, Burtow.
- 14:45When we get back more emails, what do you say, Let's do
- 14:46it all right back from the break. This next email is from anonymous patron.
- 14:54She writes, when talking about the reasons why a child would sexually abuse
- 14:58a younger child, you mentioned that a surgery when the perpetrator was young could
- 15:03possibly be one contributor, one contributor that may do that. Can you provide
- 15:09more information and clarify about that. Thank you so much so. I can't
- 15:15imagine that I said that directly, like kids who have surgeries when they're young
- 15:20become perpetrators when they're older. But I'm guessing that I was referring, possibly
- 15:24to the case of Jeffrey Dahmer and my speculation and maybe other people speculate this
- 15:31as well that if I remember correctly, he had several surgeries as a young
- 15:35child because he had some sort of medical condition. I think, like dozens
- 15:39of medical procedures from the ages of like two to five or something. And
- 15:43you could absolutely imagine a child, especially back then, when I'm guessing the
- 15:48bedside manner or the emotional care of children going through surgery wasn't exactly the focus
- 15:56that that could lead to a feeling as it for a child of being abused.
- 16:02And I've had clients who actually would eventually disclose this to me. You
- 16:06know, you have a four year old child that has to have a pretty
- 16:10difficult procedure, and they're strapped up to a bunch of monitors, and they're
- 16:15in a strange place a hospital. They're all these strangers, the doctors,
- 16:21the nurses. They want to go home. There's a difficulty making them comfortable.
- 16:26It's heartbreaking as a parent. And even if you do everything right,
- 16:30even with the best bedside manner and the best parents, it's it's terrifying.
- 16:36It's terrifying for me as an adult, as a fifty two year old man,
- 16:38when I have to go through things like that. Yeah, it's a
- 16:41thing and imagine being four years old and you don't even understand how the world
- 16:45works, and you don't have ways of soothing yourself, and you're terrified of
- 16:51everything potentially and not only that, but you know that they're breaking into your
- 16:56body, not only with needles and with ivs, but they're potentially cutting you
- 17:00open. It is, yeah, it's You could imagine a child interpreting this
- 17:06as as invasive and maybe even kind of like sexually abusive. There's a lot
- 17:10of hands on you that you don't want. You might even be fighting against
- 17:14it and saying, do not touch me. But it might be a life
- 17:18saving procedure that you need. And you know, even if you're going along
- 17:22with it, it four like you basically know this is a good thing.
- 17:25It could be really traumatic for people so well, like even today, I
- 17:30took my seven year old to get a blood draw and oh it was.
- 17:36I could see it be traumatizing. She really didn't want to and I'm holding
- 17:41her whispering, oh, we have to do it. I'm so sorry.
- 17:42It's gonna be quick. And the lady was so nice and it was quick
- 17:45and it was okay, smallest on and she was in tears. So imagine
- 17:49that time's a thousand where it's like a whole seventy two hours that have multiple
- 17:56surgeries, like you know, forty times. You can imagine how how traumatic
- 18:00that would be, how horrific that would be for you. So with Jeffrey
- 18:04Dahmer, one of the speculations that I had and maybe others have. I
- 18:07don't want to take credit for it if it's out there, but is that
- 18:11that could lead to someone coping with that trauma by trying to identify with the
- 18:18abuser or recreate it or get their hands around it. He at an early
- 18:22age was dissecting animals, liked to find animals roadkill, and he was very
- 18:29fascinated with body parts operating on them. Yeah yeah, and then later,
- 18:33of course he took humans and did that as well. So I'm not saying
- 18:37that being having surgery trauma, if you will, at a young age leads
- 18:42to those kinds of things, but we could imagine that being a factor for
- 18:47some people. Unfortunately it's one of those situations where it was absolutely necessary to
- 18:52save their lives. Well, and if so, obviously you're talking about an
- 18:55extreme with so many operations, probably the predisposition blah blah. But yes,
- 18:57it's just steven in general, Like if you don't have a way to talk
- 19:00about it with your kids and stuff about it, about an operation or taking
- 19:04blood or things, it can be Yeah. Can if Jeffrey Dahmer had a
- 19:10better family life that wasn't constantly conflictual as reported I think by all three of
- 19:15those individuals in that house, right, the parents and Jeffrey Dahmer, Or
- 19:18if his parents were more attuned or something, could that damage have been healed
- 19:22and mitigated? Ninety nine percent? Yeah it could. Yeah, I'm not
- 19:26saying kids are doomed. I'm just saying that, you know, it's it's
- 19:30a difficult thing to deal with. Listener Charity. She wrote in and said,
- 19:34dear doctor Kirk and Umbardo, and then there's a whole section where she
- 19:38talks about how she was raised in a fundamentals Christian church. She goes on,
- 19:41from my earliest memories, I was taught that men are completely uncontrollable,
- 19:47no matter what their age. They don't have the power to control their own
- 19:52sexual urges. So it's our job as women to protect them by dressing a
- 19:56certain way, speaking a certain way, and acting a certain way in order
- 20:00to help them out as much as possible. With this defect of theirs,
- 20:03I was made to wear baggy clothes to remain modest. I was often severely
- 20:10overdressed and immensely uncomfortable. I was made to wear multiple airs in hot summer
- 20:15or loose baggy clothes. Both were methods of shielding my body from the world,
- 20:21or some might say, shielding the world from my body. When I
- 20:25was around seven years old, I had the shirt and it had a strawberry
- 20:27on it with the phrase too Sweet. It was one of my favorite shirts
- 20:32because it was more girly than the stuff I would usually wear at this age.
- 20:37I hadn't developed breasts yet, by the way. At seven, my
- 20:41mom and I were about to go out to meet my grandpa for lunch.
- 20:45Her dad she saw I was wearing the strawberry t shirt and she told me
- 20:48I needed to go back to my room and change because quote, your grandpa
- 20:52will see that it says too sweet, and he'll be able to see your
- 20:56nipples poking through and he might stare at them. Ah. She goes on
- 21:03to say the emailer, it makes me feel sick to my stomach writing this
- 21:07about my seven year old self. Oh what do you think, oh,
- 21:14it's heartbreaking. So here's the thing, right, Because what happens is that
- 21:18you observe a natural phenomena, which is, you know, teenagers, both
- 21:22boys and girls, but definitely boys go through hormonal phases. And in those
- 21:29hormonal phases, you know, you're getting boners all the time. You are
- 21:32like, oh god, this is fascinating stuff. And you observe that I'm
- 21:36talking about like you know, thousands of years ago, million years ago,
- 21:38you ob served whatever, and you see that it can cause issues, right,
- 21:42because like you might have some uncontrollable behavior, you might act out,
- 21:45you might grab someone and stuff, and your conclusion is, oh, well,
- 21:52that's impossible to address through any other means than through we have to criminalize
- 21:57and subjugate the women. Instead of like, oh, I wonder if we
- 22:03could have conversations starting from early ages about our feelings and about how to control
- 22:07our minds, not only about sexuality, what about violent impulses, what about
- 22:12any number of things? Right? Yeah, Like, how come no one's
- 22:15saying, well, you know, boys can't control their violent impulses. So
- 22:18when you're on the field playing football, you can't show any aggression to the
- 22:23boys because it might punch you in the foot. Each equally is victim shaming
- 22:27and also sexualizing a seven year old and her nipples. You're trying to avoid
- 22:33the problem, but you're actually creating a problem. You know, she wasn't
- 22:38thinking about her as a sexual being at the age of seven, but now
- 22:41she is because and you're saying, Grandpa thinks well, and now you're putting
- 22:47these weird dynamics in place, like what are you saying Grandpa is turned on?
- 22:52We could see, given everything we've heard and read, that the mom
- 22:56was literally just indoctrinated into this notion of just like from the day a girl
- 23:03is born, her body is shameful and has to be covered. So I
- 23:06have a seven year old and you should see the outfit she decided to wear
- 23:11for her first day of class, a faux leather black jacket, a leoper
- 23:17print skirt. I can't imagine, in my wildest dreams, shaming her or
- 23:22something right now, what I post her pictures with like those kind of things
- 23:27on public forums where people would sexualize her and stuff. No, of course
- 23:33I want it. One of the major realizations that I had in doing the
- 23:37steep dive is that the way in which they tried to prevent sexualization of any
- 23:44kind, whether it's children or adults outside of procreation. Right has this effect
- 23:48where it's sexual you're sexualizing everyone because you're constantly talking about it. You're so
- 23:55hyper vigilant about it that you're raising this idea not only for seven year olds,
- 24:00but you could, you know, for sixteen year olds. You're telling
- 24:03these boys like you have to, you know, constantly be vigilant about not
- 24:07looking at porn and masturbating, and you know, the devil is in your
- 24:11soul just trying to get you to have sex or to think about sex.
- 24:17And to a sixteen year old boy, it's like, you know, well,
- 24:18I wasn't thinking about sex, but I am. Now. There's this
- 24:22old sermon from this guy named Oral Roberts. Oral Roberts that was his name.
- 24:27He was a big preacher, very famous, and there's this sermon where
- 24:32he's talking about how you got to push these feelings away because but the way
- 24:36he's talking about it is like, oh, because you know these feelings and
- 24:38it feels good. Oh, I can't tell you how good it feels.
- 24:44That's how he's talking about it. By the way, I think in some
- 24:48of those sermons, he's actually talking also about homosexual impulses, and he's like,
- 24:52oh, and it might feel really good, but you gotta push those
- 24:56away. And I'm like, all you're doing is making everyone who's listening to
- 25:03want to go do the best sex things they can. Yeah, it's all
- 25:08you're doing right now. Yeah, anonymous patron, She writes, and it
- 25:11says, Hi, I've been a patron since early twenty twenty. Ah,
- 25:15well, thanks, anonymous patron. While listening to the Dugger Deep Dives,
- 25:18I was shocked to hear you talk offhand about someone who quote unquote hung herself.
- 25:23You've done deep dives on suicide before, so you should know better than
- 25:29to talk about someone's means of suicide. The best practice is to not talk
- 25:33about someone's suicidal means. Every discussion of suicide means should be done thoughtfully and
- 25:40for a reason. You could have said that she died by suicide instead of
- 25:45saying what you said. I don't see any reason why you needed to say
- 25:48how she died by suicide, Birtle. I hadn't thought of that. I've
- 25:55talked about before how I have had and still have mixed feelings about suicide because
- 26:02I had my uncle when I was little died by suicide. But I had
- 26:10never thought and so you know, I was you made me aware of,
- 26:12like not saying like they committed or whatever. I hadn't thought about, like,
- 26:17oh, not talking about how they did it, I guess. But
- 26:19at the same time, part of me is like, well, wait a
- 26:22minute. At some point I want to have a discussion about things, and
- 26:27you know, okay, so maybe we could have the debate of like,
- 26:30well, but does discussing the different means of doing it is that productive?
- 26:33Or is that actually bad? And I hadn't thought about it. It's an
- 26:37interesting thought, yeah, and it is something that, of course I know.
- 26:40And anonymous patron, I appreciate you raising this thinking back. So for
- 26:45those who don't remember I was talking about, I believe what I was talking
- 26:49about was one of the girls, teenage girls who since she was a very
- 26:56young child, she was involved in pageants pageants. Yeah, and she was
- 27:00on that reality TV show Tiars and so there's a famous meme of her.
- 27:06And anyway, she grew up and was subsequently in a lot of in a
- 27:11lot of pageants, and she was good and she would win a lot.
- 27:15And then she at the age of I don't know, sixteen or seventeen,
- 27:18just north of Seattle. Actually she took her own life. She died by
- 27:22suicide, and it speculated that it might have been because of the pressure that
- 27:26she was under. And also she had recently lost a very important pageant,
- 27:30pageant that she was hoping to win. And so as I'm telling the story,
- 27:36I not necessarily I didn't preamble it with anything. I didn't prepare anybody,
- 27:41and then I just said, da da dah. You know, she
- 27:44blanked herself and you were mortified by yours, like, oh my god.
- 27:48And other people were writing in saying like Jesus Christ Kirk, like give us
- 27:52a warning. That was rough to hear, And I totally understand that,
- 27:57and that was a stake of mine. I in the moment I was thinking,
- 28:03I wanted to narrativize it, so it did have not a harmfully shocking
- 28:10value, but a shocking value. Nonetheless, that was for the purpose of
- 28:14there are so many children that are being abused in this way, and there
- 28:18are these because the broader topic we were talking about was exploiting children for reality
- 28:25TV or exploring children for entertainment on YouTube or even in movies. You know,
- 28:30in movies and that sort of thing, and how children are being you
- 28:33know, very very much harmed, and the cases where we have children who
- 28:40die, then we can point to those as examples of an extreme case of
- 28:45a whole spectrum of harms that are happening to kids that aren't dying. Right,
- 28:48these are the outliers. They're not common, but they illuminate something that
- 28:53is happening on a different way that's harming children all the time. And this
- 29:00idea of pumping kids full of ideas, you know, can a child be
- 29:03involved in a pageant and have it not be harmful? Sure, but why
- 29:07take the risk, And especially with the reality TV show and so there's so
- 29:12many other things that you can do with kids, Like you can put on
- 29:15like a like a like a harmless little neighborhood pageant where you don't prepare for
- 29:21it for literally all year round. You just prepare for it for the morning
- 29:23and you put on a sash and you create around like you have to have
- 29:29a gauge of how much pressure am I putting on these kids about winning and
- 29:34beating other kids and looking perfect and being with all the makeup and bathing suits
- 29:38and things that do sexualize that right exactly. So I was trying to organize
- 29:47my notes in a way that actually did have some impact. But I went
- 29:52too far, and I get that not only was it triggering to people,
- 29:56but I also did stray from the best practice of not necessarily talking about the
- 30:02method the means of suicide. But the thing here is that it's not a
- 30:07rule that you never talk about the means. It's just that an anonymous patron
- 30:11put it well that you don't talk about the means unless it's really relevant,
- 30:15right, And it wasn't really relevant to the story. I didn't have to
- 30:18say the means. I could have just said that she died. It would
- 30:21have been equally as shocking to know that she died by suicide. And the
- 30:25reason why there's this rule is there's a number of things that people will experience
- 30:30when either they have attempted in the past or they have loved ones that have
- 30:34died by suicide. Is that whenever people like, you know, if I
- 30:38have a friend that died by suicide and I told someone and I said,
- 30:42oh, yeah, you know, my friend died by suicide, a lot
- 30:45of people will say, oh, how did they die? And you think,
- 30:49well, why do you what is that's just scandalizing and your spotlighting.
- 30:56Yeah, I don't want to talk about Yeah, you're just morbidly cure.
- 30:59In this moment I'm telling you about my grief. You need to know the
- 31:03least important thing about what I'm saying right now. Yeah, I get the
- 31:06curiosity, honestly I do, but have some empathy here, So I totally
- 31:11get that. I have a negative reaction when I am asked, and I
- 31:17realize that it's not always healthy, but when I'm asked to not say something
- 31:21a certain way, to use different words and things of that, and the
- 31:23reason is because I feel that a sometimes it's done in a way that assumes
- 31:29that I should already know not to do it. This is not what This
- 31:33is not an example of that, but it has happened to me where it's
- 31:36like, how can you say that you should know? I'm like, no,
- 31:38I don't. Actually I've said that for thirty forty years, however long
- 31:41I've been alive. Yeah, I totally get that. I just want to
- 31:45have a little asterisk to say that there are some instances where we should do
- 31:49due diligence to figure stuff like that out before we have to be told you
- 31:55know what I mean. But there are a lot of times when as an
- 31:57example, there was one time where I said, I now forget what the
- 32:01word was, but it was it was a word about uh and then it's
- 32:06got a connotation about ableness. And I was like, oh, I didn't
- 32:09think about that, but you know you just kind of lame. Yeah,
- 32:14lame. Actually you're all lame. And I didn't ever think about that,
- 32:16and you let me know. And I was like, oh, and I
- 32:20would not have shamed you, but no, of course not. And you
- 32:22didn't do that. But I could imagine someone being like, you can't use
- 32:24that, don't you know anybody? And I'd be like no, And and
- 32:29part of it is because like I could all of a sudden come out and
- 32:30say, you're like, oh, you're you're from Columbia right next to why
- 32:37would you say that? I'm like, what do you mean? I'm not
- 32:39from Colombia, Like I'm a human, Like that makes me sound like i'm
- 32:45another. That makes me sound like I'm less than And maybe I have a
- 32:49legitimate claim. But if I'm going to introduce a new rule like that,
- 32:53I would do it. I would do it empathetically, like you know,
- 32:55what uh, Kirk. I know it's weird where, but can't I'm asking
- 33:00you as a favor. Can you not say I'm from by the way,
- 33:04this isn't real, But can you not say I'm from Colembic? Can you
- 33:07just say, like whatever, I'm Colemban or whatever? Right? Yeah,
- 33:09and you can or cannot support me in that. Well, but I certainly
- 33:14wouldn't expect that from the get go. You would know for a fact that
- 33:16that's how you need to do, unless it's one of those topics that you
- 33:21probably should have looked into it. Yeah, maybe, Yeah, sometimes there
- 33:24is that case. So another reason why we don't want to talk about the
- 33:28means is because for people that have had deaths like this, or people who
- 33:35think about this or even attempted, it's it's even triggering to talk about suicide
- 33:38to begin with, let alone to talk about to put a vision in someone's
- 33:43head, you know, to put like an actual picture in someone else's head
- 33:47is particularly hurtful and particularly triggering. Right, So you know, we could
- 33:52imagine if I went further down that road of just like, okay, this
- 33:54happened, and you know, let me show you a picture. Right,
- 33:58So what's relevant is that to the story that I was telling about this Tyler's
- 34:04and Tiara's cast member was that she died by suicide. We don't know why
- 34:07she died by suicide because she left a note that didn't illuminate anything, but
- 34:14you know, it does raise a question. That's all that's relevant. Doesn't
- 34:17matter the means Okay, So next email, Seattle area patron says. She
- 34:23says, I was taken to a Bill Gothard seminar at the age of fifteen
- 34:30whoa and I was swallowed whole. I think the beast, I think,
- 34:35meaning that I was completely indoctrinated into the Bill Gothard universe. My marriage was
- 34:42arranged at the age of twenty two to someone I barely knew. The marriage
- 34:45was abusive from the beginning, but I didn't even realize it, probably because
- 34:51she was in this cult that didn't allow for her to recognize that. A
- 34:54therapist helped me realize that I was being abused after my husband's sudden death.
- 35:00I didn't kill him, FYI. My whole world was shattered at that point
- 35:05when I learned that I was in a cult, and we are all trying
- 35:09to figure out what's real now. Moving forward, any thoughts on that.
- 35:14Yeah, it's one of those movie moments you know in the movies, in
- 35:19the Matrix or in Fight Club when spoiler alert you learned that Tyler Dirdon is
- 35:24really an alien. No, but it's those moments in those movies where you're
- 35:30like, wait, what everything I thought I knew up until now I have
- 35:36to question everything. Yeah. I went through moving away from religion and there
- 35:42were some shock moments for me where I really felt betrayed, felt betrayed,
- 35:50and I was so angry. Oh, I remember being so angry at the
- 35:55system and even to some extent my family. Like, as an a sample,
- 36:00when I was reading the Da Vinci Code, this is how Naiba was
- 36:04about some of the stuff. I was reading the Divintion Code with my wife
- 36:07and we were both Catholic, and at that point in our life, she
- 36:12was still I was a Christian. You transferred from Catholic to Christians. I
- 36:17was a Christian and she was still Catholic. Catholic Yeah, okay, but
- 36:22either way, we were reading the Divintion Code and we get to a point
- 36:23in the book where they talk about the Council of an Ica, where this
- 36:28group of dudes decided what the reality of certain chapters of the Bible was going
- 36:32to be in all these things, and I'm I'm thinking this is made up
- 36:36for the book. But she had gone to college, taken history, knew
- 36:42a lot more than me. It's like, no, no, that was
- 36:44real. This happened and I'm like what And I'm like you and knew I'm
- 36:47like and it was this moment of anger and realization of like what the universe
- 36:52is a lie? Like some dudes in a room decided with ah, you
- 36:59know, like the tumbled, like the ceiling came crashing down on me.
- 37:01Yeah, and that is not anything compared to like being raised in a full
- 37:07on cold and all these things and then realizing that but I can relate to
- 37:10in those ways. You know, where is my mind? Right? Yes?
- 37:14Yeah, It's hard to imagine if you haven't gone through something like this
- 37:19where every fiber of your being, all the assumptions that you make are potentially
- 37:25wrong. Right, Because for these folks that emerge out of these cults,
- 37:30whatever the cult may be, or out of a gas lit high control relationship,
- 37:35they initially hopefully know that some maybe some of the major things are false,
- 37:42but you don't necessarily know all the things that were false that you were
- 37:47indoctrinated into. And there's so many things that don't have checks and balances in
- 37:52the world, like just as an outside experience that we might be able to
- 37:58relate to is whether you wipe sitting or stand, you know, like,
- 38:05for a long time for myself, and I've heard this from other people that
- 38:09they just thought that the way they did it was the way everyone did it,
- 38:13because of course, how else could you do it? And then at
- 38:14a certain point you learn, oh, no, no, there's this whole
- 38:16other camp of people that do it the other way. And you're thinking,
- 38:21so, I've been doing it like there's an option, you know what I
- 38:24mean, I didn't even think that was possible. And when you were growing
- 38:30up up until the time maybe you're thirty years old, you're just like,
- 38:34this is the way the universe works. Of course you stand up. That's
- 38:38just I mean, how could you possibly do it when you're sitting down?
- 38:42Yeah, Like the physics don't even work at that point. And then all
- 38:45of a sudden you find out no, no, no, there is another
- 38:49way, and maybe you even find out that you do it in a minority
- 38:52group, right, And then you think well, my god, what else
- 38:55am I doing? Like, there's so many things we do by ourselves,
- 38:59and there's so many thoughts we have up to ourselves, so many assumptions we
- 39:02have. We don't talk about all the assumptions that we make, right,
- 39:06we don't talk about all the perceptions we have. We don't go by the
- 39:08way, right now, I'm seeing an airplane. Is that what you're seeing?
- 39:13By the way, I just saw two cars crash. We're seeing a
- 39:15salmon, I mean an orange, I mean a pink. Yeah, sure,
- 39:17I just saw two cars crash. We all agree that's a bad thing,
- 39:22right, like that, that's that's destruction of property. Okay, Like
- 39:25we don't do that. There's so much that we just absorbed through observation.
- 39:30As children, we watch everyone around us. We're like, oh, cars
- 39:35crashing is bad. Oh that's an airplane. Oh of course we stand up
- 39:37because freaks sit down. Okay. So we just have these like you know,
- 39:43absorbs, absorbs. We just absorbed. We have absorbs. Yeah.
- 39:46And and so once you're out of the cult and you start to entangle,
- 39:52disentangle your your brainwashing, it calls everything in a question and you're left wondering,
- 39:59I don't have enough years of life to ask what am I right about?
- 40:05Doors? Are little baby brains absorbs? I know, that's what I
- 40:07thought. I was like, there's adorbs. Anyway, So, as a
- 40:10kid growing up in Columbia, at my house, the main bathroom had the
- 40:15toilet and uh bidet. But as a kid, I didn't know what the
- 40:19bidet was. I knew it was I sat on the toilet and there's always
- 40:22this thing in front of me that had a little water spout that could go
- 40:25like this, And what I would use it for is to wash my feet.
- 40:30But why were you washing your feet? Were your feet dirty? Particularly?
- 40:34No? I just assumed that that's what it was for. So every
- 40:36time you went to the bathroom. You also now when I went to the
- 40:38bathroom, like when I would take a shower, sometimes always you take a
- 40:43shower, and then you'd sometimes not always, would wash my feet in the
- 40:50You know why, because you were just saying, as a child, you
- 40:52brainwashed yourself. I assumed this thing has little water. It's not for my
- 40:59face, it must be for my feet. Yeah. Well, so in
- 41:02that moment you might have wondered what else in the bathroom times am I not
- 41:08aware of? I've given another example where I used to hear when my dad
- 41:13was showering. I would sometimes hear these padding noises, padding noises, and
- 41:19what I thought was happening. When you shower you have to like pat with
- 41:22the soap and that when you were done showering to get as much water off
- 41:27before you use your towel. You have to get the water off your body
- 41:30to make the towel less wet. Okay, I would say I did that
- 41:36for years. When I would shower, I would pat myself with the soap,
- 41:42and when I was done showering, I would spend like five minutes wiping
- 41:45water off my body and then use that towel. And then there's a ceremonial
- 41:52grunts at the end that you wait, is that what you're talking about?
- 41:57That's what I'm dying, Yeah, right, right, right right, yeah,
- 42:00yeah, Well, I mean I'm assuming I never asked, but I
- 42:02never thought of that. Of course, why would I. Yeah, okay,
- 42:05d one last story that's similar to this. So I would watch commercials
- 42:10as everyone did in the seventies of Cologne and back then, the Colone commercials.
- 42:16They would have these guys in these fancy bathrooms and slow motion. They
- 42:22would be taking the aftershave or the Colonne and splashing it, right, they'd
- 42:30be just splashing it because they just figured out how to use slow motion in
- 42:34commercials. I mean, it doesn't make any sense, and that's what they
- 42:37teach you to do. So my dad had some cologne, a big bottle
- 42:44of something that he was done with or he didn't want, and for some
- 42:47reason it ended up in my hands. And I'm like, I'm in the
- 42:51second grade or something. And because I'm like, well, okay, I
- 42:55guess I should try to be a man or something. And I don't know
- 43:00anyone else in school that we're Colone, but this was Colonne days. So
- 43:05in the morning before school in slow motion, so I put like, you
- 43:09know, just a full pool of the Colonne in my face and splashed it
- 43:15into my face and I was, you know, and it just gets it
- 43:19just goes everywhere, you know, and I'm thinking, all right, well,
- 43:22off to school. So you know, imagine having everything that you learn
- 43:28from zero to twenty. And and also it's not just like Colonne and bidets.
- 43:32It's it's your fundamental understanding of who you are and your place in the
- 43:37universe and how physics works, you know, regarding God and heaven and hell
- 43:43andy, how morality works, how sexuality works, how your body. Everything
- 43:47has been invaded upon in your mind and then you merge out and it,
- 43:52you know, it takes a long time to disentangle, and it's very disconcerting.
- 43:57You feel very untethered, very upsetting. So yeah, anonymous patron wrote
- 44:04in and said, in the early two thousands, when I was a young
- 44:06mom, I asked some leaders in my church for some resources. They pointed
- 44:12me towards Michael Pearl. Do you remember Michael Pearl? He wrote this famous
- 44:15book that is promoting corporal punishment. It's famous because a lot of these evangelicals
- 44:22or IBLP people would be prescribing this book as this Bible of parenting because it
- 44:30was, you know, promoting religious ideas along with very harsh sorry. It
- 44:34has a lot of that same language as the eight is enough, gal right
- 44:37a past eight passenger passengers, It is enough, Ruby, Frankie and Jodahil.
- 44:44That's a TV show from the seventies that I loved and you're too you're
- 44:47too young for it. I was barely open. So it's called eight Passengers.
- 44:52Yeah, okay, yeah, But anyways, but a lot of that
- 44:54same language of corporal punishment and like nothing is too much and right. So
- 44:59when we were doing the steep dive, one of the realizations was like,
- 45:01there's this whole cult that is promoting child abuse and it's right under our noses.
- 45:07And then that was just ancerted because it's not just a cult in Waco,
- 45:12Texas of like fifty people. It's this whole swath of the Central States.
- 45:15It's all over the country, maybe all over the world. Then we
- 45:19hear about Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrant. That story comes out while we're doing
- 45:22the deep dive, while we're recording and publishing this deep dive on the Duggers,
- 45:27which blossoms into a whole other thing that I look into, and then
- 45:29I start learning about all these because not only does it play into this Michael
- 45:32it's not Michael Pearl specifically, but it's this fundamentalist Christian movement to abuse children
- 45:37and to make parenting great again, you know, also to indoctrinate children into
- 45:42whatever cult that they're in, whether it's IBOP or some other religious cult.
- 45:45But it also involves the exploitation of children on YouTube, which was right up
- 45:51it was just so interesting that in the middle of us ranting and raving about
- 45:54these things, this humongous case just like emerges. Anyway, by the way,
- 46:00my seven year old is such a character. Yeah, and I film
- 46:07her all the time and she does the most outrageous, hilarious things. And
- 46:12she wanted She's like, oh, I want to start a channel. And
- 46:15I had to have this like conversation with her about why we can film and
- 46:22send it to our families and relatives, but how it's probably not a good
- 46:27idea for us to start channel. But how did you justify it? Well,
- 46:30she was confused because she sees channels with with kids kids. I think
- 46:36what I said I said basically like yeah, I think I said some variant
- 46:40of what happens is that when you put this on actual, actual YouTube,
- 46:46anyone can see it and you don't get to control who sees it or what
- 46:51they think of us or you. And I think I give an example,
- 46:54like imagine it, you know it was like this. You know, when
- 47:00she does perform at school or whatever. I said, do you do you
- 47:04wonder what you know people might have thought about your performance? Like yeah,
- 47:08and you know, do you maybe get some sometimes self conscious like yeah,
- 47:13and said, well, imagine if everyone in the world has an opinion and
- 47:15you can't control any of it. And I don't know if it worked,
- 47:19but it was like that was kind of the analogy. Yeah, it's great
- 47:22because that is at least one of the non harmful ideas, because if you
- 47:27talked about her being sexualized, well, right, well you don't want to
- 47:30tempt Grandpa with here and so yeah, and by the way, it's not
- 47:35even like I certainly wouldn't post any YouTube videos with her being like sexualizer,
- 47:39but even just like just the fact that she is a child doing funny things
- 47:44as much as attempts me to like, oh, let's get the world to
- 47:45see this. We've talked about it, I've seen I know, so it
- 47:50says. I know why, Like, ultimately, if I do it,
- 47:53it'd be for my own narcissistic needs, not for her. Yeah, well,
- 47:59I mean, you know, and maybe for her. I mean,
- 48:00she's asking for it, But it's the parents responsibility to protect children from their
- 48:06impulses, right well, And I get I have impulses sometimes of like that
- 48:09is so funny. My child is so interesting and interactive. I want to
- 48:15show this to the world and I have to fight those simples and be like
- 48:17why yeah, anonymous patron, She writes in in the early two thousand,
- 48:22when I was a young mom, I asked some leaders in my church for
- 48:25some resources. They pointed me towards Michael Pearl and his book and his teaching.
- 48:30I read the book and immediately asked for a meeting with the leaders in
- 48:31the church because I was worried about what was in the book. The book
- 48:36says. To what this anonymous patron is pointing out to us is we had
- 48:40highlighted some of the problems with this book, but she is saying it's worse
- 48:45than what you thought. And let me give you some details. The book
- 48:50says to punish children with a rod children as young as five months old burto
- 48:57So we went over this no about this teaching by Michael Pearl. And it's
- 49:02not just Michael Pearl and his teaching. It's that a lot of people are
- 49:07rallying around this book right and holding it. You know, ministers and whole
- 49:13organization IBLP, Bill Gothard are saying this is the way and so not only
- 49:19using a rod on children but as young as five months old Berl. Can
- 49:24you imagine even verbal, the world is this dangerous place that is gonna at
- 49:30any moment kill them. So if you're going to indoctrinate children into maybe not
- 49:37necessarily a cult, but if you're going to indoctrinate children into the idea they
- 49:42have no power and that they must obey, and that is the primary goal
- 49:45of parenting, as we have been learning, often is present in this way
- 49:50of thinking that is prevalent in a disturbingly high percentage of Americans and maybe around
- 49:57the world. Right, you need to start early. So can you imagine
- 50:02what kind of sick, disgusting monster of a parent would strike a five month
- 50:12old child. It's monstrous at any age, but five months old burto like
- 50:17that. You know, I'm not I'm not a proponent of the death penalty,
- 50:22but when I hear stuff like this, it's just like, you don't
- 50:27deserve to enjoy the fruits of life. So I have you know, I
- 50:31have memories of when my firstborn was little and we started discussing how to discipline.
- 50:38We had read, we had thought, and so here's what our plan
- 50:42was. Okay, here's what we're gonna do. And we're talking about maybe
- 50:45she's two or something. We're thinking Okay, what we're gonna do is we're
- 50:51gonna do a little timeout. So what we set up and by the way,
- 50:55later with our second one, we did time ins actually even when the
- 50:59first one was older, time ins where one of the parents was still with
- 51:01them, but at first we didn't know that part. But we would basically
- 51:05do this thing where we had this little gate. It was the little child
- 51:08gate, the safety gate, and when she would do something like she was,
- 51:13you know, really throwing the food and refusing whatever, Okay, it's
- 51:15time for a time out. Very sorry, So we would go put her
- 51:19there with the little gate and then be like, all right, so when
- 51:22you're ready to talk, because she's like screaming, it's like, when you're
- 51:24ready to talk, let me know. So once you calm down a little
- 51:28bit, it was like, okay, now we're gonna have a little conversation.
- 51:30Like I said, later on we learned that maybe time out still feels
- 51:34like so we started doing time ins, which is like the same thing,
- 51:37but one of us basically sits right next to the whole time. We might
- 51:39not be talking, we might just be waiting for them to come out while
- 51:42we're there the whole time, And even that when I was leaving her there
- 51:47in her little thing, and I'm like that was so hard for me.
- 51:52Yeah, because I'm like, oh, the poor little thing. But you
- 51:54still have to do something because if you don't, then they really don't learn
- 51:59bound recent things I cannot imagine, Like, yeah, so going on Burdo,
- 52:07it gets worse. That passage you mentioned about a child eating oats.
- 52:10So I read this passage about how you can you know the child won't eat
- 52:16the oats, and then the child turns to mom and says, Mom,
- 52:20I don't want to eat the oats. And then the prescription is mom comes
- 52:23over and beats the child to make the child not triangulate, not to reach
- 52:30out to the other parents. That passage you mentioned, you mentioned, and
- 52:32into my head I thought, and I might even portray it this way,
- 52:36that it you know, maybe it's like a five year old or a seven
- 52:38year old song. That passage you mentioned about a child eating oats is about
- 52:44a very young baby just learning to eat solid foods. So in the book,
- 52:49according to an a patron, they are explicit that story about the oats
- 52:53is a baby, is a is a toddler. It's horrendous. However,
- 53:00take it. But that's interesting because that is part of the indoctrination, right,
- 53:05You can't let them enjoy their early childhood without indoctrinating them into the idea
- 53:12that they don't matter and that they must obey without question, and that they
- 53:15don't exist in the world. You know, these are like old rules for
- 53:21dogs. Yeah, that you wouldn't even do now to a dog, right,
- 53:27being applied to human babies. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Then there's
- 53:31blanket training, where you lure your baby off the blanket and then punish it.
- 53:37Have you heard of this? Oh, when we talked about it and
- 53:40they talked about it in the microphone. Sorry, well, we talked about
- 53:44it and they talked about it in the documentary. But you know, so
- 53:49I had a little blankie when I was a little kid. It was a
- 53:52blanket that my grandma put together and she embroidered these beautiful little teddies and stuff,
- 53:58and it was my security. The thought of that being taken from me
- 54:04as a punishment and withheld and all that stuff. No, I don't think
- 54:07that's that. I mean, that's awful. Oh no, no, right,
- 54:09right, right, I remember the other thing they talked about. Oh
- 54:13yes, yes, yes, this one. This is also horrible. Well,
- 54:15what do you remember, because I have a vague memory of I mean,
- 54:19what do you remember? Yeah, they talked about it in one of
- 54:22those documentaries. It was basically the you you take the child and you it's
- 54:30something where you like isolate them with I think what it is is they take
- 54:36the child. And don't quote me on this, but from early pre verbal
- 54:40they are on their blanket and you tell them not to move, and then
- 54:46you tempt them with something else and if they move, then you punish them
- 54:50physically to get them to follow your direction move off the blanket. I think.
- 54:54So, don't quote me on that, but I know that that is
- 54:57part of what's in this book. There are things like that where they will
- 55:00tempt infants, pre verbal infants with temptation while the parent is saying, do
- 55:06not do this, and then when they do it, they will strike the
- 55:09child. That makes sense or this is horribly That makes sense, but there
- 55:14was I thought there was another aspect to the whole blanket piece, which was
- 55:16you might be right, but anyways, anyways, either way, it's like,
- 55:20yeah, going on it. It says to only breastfeed every four hours
- 55:24and only for like twenty minutes. If I recall correctly. Unless you're naturally
- 55:29gifted, that's nowhere near enough to keep milk production up. The Pearls state
- 55:35Michael Pearl and his wife state that you shouldn't give a bottle. You should
- 55:39just trust your body is enough. Even back then, I was able to
- 55:44find a few cases of failure to thrive, meaning death of a child due
- 55:49to the Pearl's recommendation of breastfeeding practices, which of course makes sense. And
- 55:54plus, why what is the purpose do you not want your child to have
- 56:00nourishments? Is it just this general hatred of children and infants? I mean,
- 56:06it kind of looks like that, right, because it's one thing to
- 56:07try to make children obey, Like I guess I get their twisted logic there,
- 56:13But what would be the purpose in saying you can't give children a bottle
- 56:16and you should only feed them every what every four hours for twenty minutes like
- 56:22the bottle I quote get as in that they're saying it's got to be all
- 56:30from the breast. This is very important, the bottle thing. But I
- 56:34think the other part might be about teaching that they are not in control,
- 56:39that they have to be subject right to absolute right, right, right,
- 56:45exactly because you know, our infants will cry out or older children will even
- 56:51you know, reach out and say, hey, I would like and so
- 56:53this is teaching the child that it's on a regiment and they have to follow
- 56:57a schedule. And look, us progressive modern parents do struggle. I know
- 57:02we have with over indulgence, over coddling and stuff. It's true, but
- 57:09oh my god, the extremes. Why the extremes. Yeah, well I
- 57:15don't know what you mean by what do you mean by overcoddling? Yeah,
- 57:19like basically, like especially with our first child and me, I was definitely
- 57:23guilty of this, like oh no, they scraped their knee, Oh did
- 57:29you fall? And then the child actually gets anxious about that, like oh,
- 57:32with my second child, I was a lot more like eh, they
- 57:36felt it's okay, you know, but but or just things like like with
- 57:42my again, with my first I always had this dream in my mind that
- 57:45everything was gonna be perfect. I was going to homeschool my child. They
- 57:50were gonna were oh yeah, at every I was gonna be independently wealthy so
- 57:53I could homeschool, and at every I was going to turn them into these
- 57:57perfect geniuses and they were gonna be train and all the martial arts and all
- 58:00the music and all the math and other things. Reality crashed into my head
- 58:05and my face and everything and I was like, oh, that's not work.
- 58:08Throw away about ninety percent of that. But still with this ten percent,
- 58:13I'm going to make sure everything's perfect. Yeah, going to buy everything
- 58:15organic. Nothing not organic is going to touch their skin. Everything's going to
- 58:21be flawless. You're concerned, and you see how fragile they are when they're
- 58:25young, and you also know that there's damage that can happen and damage that
- 58:30will happen. So you're doing everything and then imagine that you prescribe, and
- 58:34then you have people that are prescribing this, the leaders of the church,
- 58:37and there's all these parents that are following it where it's just like, yeah,
- 58:40throw that all out the window. You're creating an obedient automaton. And
- 58:45the way to that is to deprive and to beat your five month old child.
- 58:52I just can't imagine what would motivate anyone to even think about even putting
- 58:59a five old in time out like that. I would if someone put a
- 59:04five month old to time out, they're a monster to me too, Like,
- 59:07what does that even mean like, well, so extend that to beating
- 59:12a fire, Like, what do you think you're teaching a five month old?
- 59:15What? What behavior does a five month old child do that you're thinking,
- 59:21Yeah, you deserve to be disciplined, Like what could you possibly have
- 59:24in your head? You're part of this bigger mission which is not about how
- 59:29cute this baby is. It's that you are trying to create these kinds of
- 59:35creatures with a certain mentality that again, it's part of this meta reality that
- 59:38you need to fulfill. Not what you see, not not the little cute
- 59:43little creature defenseless that you see, It's about this other thing. Yeah,
- 59:47And when I think about cults or you know, super religious fundamentalist people,
- 59:52I usually think about what I've seen, the things that I see in the
- 59:55news, or the most salacious things, you know, the lea reader is
- 1:00:00having sex with all the wives or something like that. What is forgotten or
- 1:00:04ignored or not talked about or is invisible is this If it's fifty people in
- 1:00:09Waco, Texas, like terrible, But if you're talking about millions of people
- 1:00:14that are still around doing this. Michael Pearl's book is still selling on Amazon
- 1:00:20today. It is still you know, very successful book. Their parents out
- 1:00:23there doing this right now. You know, the Dugger documentary and our deep
- 1:00:30dive has not eliminated this practice. It's still strong. It could be even
- 1:00:34stronger now than it was before. In fact, statistics show, as we
- 1:00:37talked about in another deep dive, that fundamentalism is on the rise. Yeah,
- 1:00:40and there's a renaissance of like we're turning our kids intoss feminizing them.
- 1:00:49Got a tough enough yeah, yeah, so going out with the email.
- 1:00:53So after reading the book, I was concerned. I told the leaders I
- 1:00:58had a lot of concerns for child abuse of neglect within this book. They
- 1:01:00explained to me that I just didn't have enough life experience to understand the truth.
- 1:01:06The meeting was like two hours because I was really trying to convince them,
- 1:01:09but I was dismissed for being in my early twenties and I just wasn't
- 1:01:14godly enough to understand. I often wonder about that congregation and how the kids
- 1:01:21fared. Maybe I should have done more, but I did what I could.
- 1:01:25I brought it to their attention with scientific studies to back up my claims,
- 1:01:29and then I raised my own kids with as much love and grace as
- 1:01:32I could. So yeah, yeah, I don't think you could ask yourself
- 1:01:37to have done anything more. You did a lot more than what a lot
- 1:01:39of other people would have done. And yeah, what were you going to
- 1:01:44do change their minds? I mean that does not seem like a likelihood.
- 1:01:47So yeah, you absolutely did what you could. All right, let's take
- 1:01:51a break, BIRDO, and when we get back, it will just be
- 1:01:54for patrons of the podcast, and we are going to finish this chapter.
- 1:01:59What he say, Burt, let's do it. And if you're not a
- 1:02:01patron, we're going to say goodbye, and until next time, take care
- 1:02:05of yourself because you deserve it.