Latest / The Vegan Report / Exposing Anti-Vegan Media Bias. With Donny Moss | Ep. 84
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:02and today we denounce the complicity of the media
- 0:06in animal exploitation, how they have accepted
- 0:10so much money to carry water for this cruel industry,
- 0:15promoting meat, dairy and egg, while perpetuating
- 0:19biased and deceitful anti -vegan beliefs. To
- 0:23discuss this topic, I have with me Donnie Moss,
- 0:26a lifelong animal rights activist who launched
- 0:29my new favorite activist project, Veg Media Watch.
- 0:34What Donnie does is scout through all mainstream
- 0:37media coverage of veganism or the animal cause
- 0:41and call out media organizations or journalists
- 0:44showing a clear anti -vegan bias. I asked Donnie,
- 0:50Who should we trust in this media landscape?
- 0:53Does he think our movement has been infiltrated
- 0:56by fake vegan media outlets or activists backed
- 1:00by Big Ag? Does political affiliation affect
- 1:04how we cover the animal industry? And much more.
- 1:09Visit the episode notes and follow the link to
- 1:12Veg Media Watch social media pages. It is so
- 1:16satisfying to see someone expose those outrageous
- 1:20anti -vegan stories we all come across. And as
- 1:24always, please help this podcast grow by sharing
- 1:27it with the vegans you know. You can also subscribe
- 1:31and leave a good review. Every gesture is appreciated.
- 1:35Thank you. My first question for you is, what
- 1:40is driving that anti -vegan bias? Maybe it's
- 1:45Big Ag funding that kind of content, pulling
- 1:49the strings, or is it just conditioning? I think
- 1:53it's a couple of things. I mean, if you look
- 1:55back to, was it about 10 years ago when Beyond
- 1:58Meat and Impossible Foods came onto the scene,
- 2:02and all of a sudden there was tremendous buzz
- 2:05about plant -based meats that really came very
- 2:09close to beef, you know, beef, you know, for
- 2:15a lot of people who would take a bite of a Beyond
- 2:17Burger or an Impossible Burger, especially someone
- 2:19like me who hadn't eaten meat in about 20 years,
- 2:23like it felt like I was eating a burger again.
- 2:25And so for good reason, the meat industry, especially
- 2:31the beef industry was afraid. And so, you know,
- 2:35they they launched a campaign and to to marginalize
- 2:42these plant -based burger alternatives and to
- 2:47scare people away from eating them. So all of
- 2:50a sudden, we started to see these news articles
- 2:52about ultra -processed foods. I don't think we
- 2:55had really heard that word before, at least I
- 2:58don't remember it. And all of a sudden plant
- 3:01-based food was not only ultra processed, but
- 3:03unnatural and artificial. And then meat was being
- 3:08rebranded as whole foods and simple and clean.
- 3:13And of course we know that's not true at all.
- 3:15Meats are highly processed. And so I think that
- 3:18was the biggest I think that's probably the main
- 3:24reason why we see so much anti -vegan bias in
- 3:27the mainstream media because these meat and dairy
- 3:30companies spend a fortune on advertising and
- 3:34I think to some extent these media outlets are
- 3:36beholden to these meat and dairy companies when
- 3:40their publicist call they pick up the phone because
- 3:43they're advertisers so they're spending money
- 3:45on advertising they're spending money on PR and
- 3:48they're also spending money on influencers all
- 3:51to spread this anti vegan pro meat propaganda
- 3:56and so that's what we're up against and also
- 3:59you just got media outlets maybe who aren't getting
- 4:02advertising dollars from big ag and maybe aren't
- 4:05being pitched by you know, publicists from Big
- 4:09Ag. But they post articles with clickbait titles.
- 4:14Vegan isn't healthy. Wait, I'm going to click
- 4:16on that. You know, these provocative clickbait
- 4:18titles that and those titles have consequences.
- 4:23You know, people, you know, I've seen many instances
- 4:26since I started Vegmedia Watch of these articles
- 4:31that are really scare people away from a plant
- 4:35based diet. And that's dangerous because that's
- 4:38leading people to eating more meat and dairy
- 4:40and other animal foods. That's a great point,
- 4:44because people are not reading the article. They're
- 4:47just reading the headline and they're getting
- 4:49what they want to get from it. And that's it.
- 4:53But going back to that anti vegan bias, it's
- 4:57funny because I was I had a conversation with
- 5:01a friend recently, and she told me about an organization
- 5:04called the Animal Agriculture Alliance. Do you
- 5:08know of them? I was at where they rebranded that
- 5:13use or that is that an industry organization?
- 5:16It is from Big Ac. Yes. Definitely sounds familiar.
- 5:20Yes. Well, they have some initiatives where they
- 5:24sponsor content creators to put out good content
- 5:30about meat. Well, my question is, how do we know
- 5:34who to trust? Where do we turn to? What are the
- 5:38media outlets that are on our side and which
- 5:42ones have chosen to go against veganism and the
- 5:46whole animal cause? So are there any signs to
- 5:50look for to see if the media outlets that we
- 5:55normally follow have been captured by Big Ac.
- 5:59Yeah, I think we need to look at not necessarily
- 6:02the media outlet as a whole, but each individual
- 6:04outlet, because you'll find that every media
- 6:09outlet might do, I shouldn't say everyone, but
- 6:12many media outlets will post both positive and
- 6:15negative stories. Um, and so I can't make any
- 6:19generalizations. What I will say is that, you
- 6:22know, as part of what I do at veg media outreach
- 6:24is roll up my sleeves and investigate what's
- 6:27behind a story. So there's one, uh, publication
- 6:31in India that w in which a doctor was, uh, was
- 6:37writing. So I guess as a guest, I don't know
- 6:40if she's not a journalist, but a doctor writing
- 6:42maybe op ed pieces, uh, disparaging plant -based
- 6:47diets, just attacking veganism, using the credibility
- 6:50of her medical degree to do so, and that makes
- 6:53it even more dangerous. But when I look into
- 6:57her affiliations, I saw, wait, she's tied to
- 7:02the beef industry. I don't remember that in that
- 7:05particular case, but often you have to follow
- 7:09the money to understand why. why an article is
- 7:14biased. But again, sometimes it's just as simple
- 7:17as plain old click bait. But yeah, it's a good
- 7:21question. How do you know? what's fair and what's
- 7:27truly biased. I mean, sometimes it's just so
- 7:30clear that it's an anti -vegan propaganda piece.
- 7:35But sometimes when they, you know, if they present
- 7:38both sides, sometimes we just have to accept
- 7:40that they've included the other side. And I can't
- 7:43really call that out because there's some fair
- 7:45balance. So I'm looking at each article on its
- 7:49own, not in the broader context of the media
- 7:51outlet. And I've seen that you focus a lot on
- 7:55traditional medias. And I was wondering, what
- 7:58is your opinion on them? Because for me, those
- 8:02are a dying breed. You know, we won't have them
- 8:05around in maybe 10 years. Who knows, I might
- 8:09be wrong. But I'm all about, you know, independent
- 8:13medias, like the one I'm building with this podcast.
- 8:17So what do you think about them? And of course,
- 8:21I should add the reason why they're dying out
- 8:24is because they have lost the trust of the public.
- 8:29Ed's Veg Media Watch, I can't go after everything.
- 8:33You know, I do see what you're referring to,
- 8:35these influencers who are using their platforms,
- 8:38and they might have hundreds of thousands, if
- 8:40not more followers, and they're posting this
- 8:42anti -vegan propaganda. And I do think we need
- 8:45to go after it. The problem is with these influencers,
- 8:50they don't have a boss. They're not accountable
- 8:53to anybody, except maybe their followers. Whereas
- 8:57in the main When I target, let's just say a particular
- 9:04reporter, and then I copy in a tweet, for example,
- 9:08the editors and call out the recklessness or
- 9:12the bias, then it's conceivable that the editors
- 9:16would go back to the reporter. um you know and
- 9:19say something or say maybe we have to be more
- 9:21careful about this there's more accountability
- 9:24you know there are many instances in which a
- 9:26reporter has written maybe a balanced article
- 9:29or even a favorable article but the editors who
- 9:33choose the the headline pick something provocative
- 9:36that has a negative sort of connotation and so
- 9:40sometimes i'll call that out and i'll say this
- 9:43it doesn't matter how fair balanced an article
- 9:46is if the headline, which is what more people
- 9:49are going to read, is anti vegan and unfair.
- 9:55There's just with the mainstream media, there's
- 9:57more accountability, there's more of a system
- 9:59in place to hold sort of decision makers accountable
- 10:03than there is on social media. But I agree with
- 10:06you, we're going to have to go after these influencers
- 10:09are probably being paid a lot of money by the
- 10:11meat industry. Spread pro -meat anti -vegan propaganda.
- 10:16But again, there's just there's less accountability
- 10:19there. There's less of a way to hold them accountable.
- 10:22That is very smart and insightful from you. Yes,
- 10:27definitely. I see it. I see the value in targeting
- 10:31them because also they are organizations that
- 10:36call themselves objective and, you know, following
- 10:40the truth and all of that. So yeah, we expect
- 10:45more from them. Yeah, also keep in mind that
- 10:48just because the mainstream media does seem like
- 10:52it's sort of a dying breed as is K or you know,
- 10:55cable cable networks, the mainstream media still
- 10:58uses social media to post its content. And there's
- 11:03still a lot of engagement there. So I do think
- 11:07there's value and targeting the mainstream media
- 11:10and there are a lot of people who are in their
- 11:1440s, 50s, 60s and over, who rely on the mainstream
- 11:19media. And of course, the older the population,
- 11:22the less likely they are to use social media.
- 11:27People like my parents don't use social media
- 11:30at all. They get all of their news from the mainstream
- 11:33media. And I want to be sure that the news that
- 11:36they're getting about veganism is fair and balanced.
- 11:41You know, I'm all about independent medias, but
- 11:46they're not at the point where they can break
- 11:49stories or send people in war zones to cover
- 11:54an international conflict or something like that.
- 11:58We're not at that level yet. And so their importance
- 12:02of mainstream media is still there. Now, if you
- 12:05had to rank them, Is there a mainstream media
- 12:11organization out there that does worse than others?
- 12:17And also, is there one that does better than
- 12:21others in terms of, I guess, fairly reporting
- 12:25on the vegan and animal cause? Well, I'll say
- 12:29that I'll often complain about the New York Times
- 12:33and the Washington Post when I see an article
- 12:37that it feels unfair, you know, and of course,
- 12:40we're hypersensitive because we know the stakes
- 12:43are so high with between the animals and the
- 12:45planet and human health. But I will say that
- 12:49both of those media outlets do have regular contributors
- 12:54who report on factory farming and the impact
- 12:59of animal agriculture on the planet. And so But
- 13:04after doing Veg Media Watch for a couple of months,
- 13:08I can't see that I've seen any trends. One might
- 13:11make certain assumptions about the New York Post,
- 13:13which is a more conservative media outlet, but
- 13:15then I'll see positive stories coming out of
- 13:18there about veganism and animals, and then negative
- 13:22stories coming out of publications or media outlets
- 13:25that we might think of as being more progressive.
- 13:28So sometimes I think we tend to think that animal
- 13:33rights and veganism is more of an issue on the
- 13:35left, but that's not always the case. And we
- 13:40shouldn't speak in such a way that it is because
- 13:43then we alienate people on the right who embrace
- 13:46the vegan ethic and believe that animals should
- 13:52have the right to live in peace. I second your
- 13:58point. I mean, let's remember that Matthew Scully,
- 14:01one of the most ardent defender of this cause.
- 14:05Now he has written two books, denouncing factory
- 14:08farming and promoting veganism is a was for a
- 14:13long time. I think chief editor of National Review,
- 14:17which is pretty, you know, right leading. Yeah,
- 14:23exactly. I mean, and we have people in the animal
- 14:26rights movement in New York City. who for years
- 14:30have leaned to the right politically and many
- 14:33of us have been quick to dismiss them. But we
- 14:37do that at our own peril. We can't afford to
- 14:39alienate people on the right or left or center.
- 14:42We need everybody who believes in this cause
- 14:46to join us and speak out. You know, it's interesting.
- 14:50Right now we have a mayoral race taking place
- 14:54in New York City. The primary just took place
- 14:57and the general election is in November, and
- 15:01there are four candidates. There's a Democrat,
- 15:05there are two independents, two candidates running
- 15:08on the independent line, and there's a Republican.
- 15:11And the Republican has a much better record on
- 15:18animal rights. than any of the other candidates
- 15:23to the left of him politically. And so in the
- 15:27past, I wouldn't have considered a Republican.
- 15:30But this particular Republican, his name is Curtis
- 15:33Sliwa, he accompanied me and another animal rights
- 15:37activist to live animal markets a few months
- 15:39ago when there were bird flu outbreaks at many
- 15:42of the live animal markets in New York City.
- 15:45and we wanted to go in and document the conditions
- 15:48and to show the public that despite the bird
- 15:51food outbreaks, these markets are still operating,
- 15:53that people, members of the public are still
- 15:55going inside of these markets with no PPE, no
- 15:59masks, nothing, and shopping in a area where
- 16:05there are absolutely birds who are carrying bird
- 16:07flu. And so because walking into these markets
- 16:11and filming is dangerous, and we know that the
- 16:15employees can get violent, Curtis Lee, the Republican
- 16:19running for on the you know, the guy running
- 16:21on the Republican ticket, accompanied us and
- 16:24used himself to shield us from the employees
- 16:28who were spraying hoses and getting physically
- 16:31violent. He's a big guy. There was no media there.
- 16:35There was no one to give him credit for what
- 16:37he was doing. He was just doing that because
- 16:39he believed and this is kept my during a campaign
- 16:42when he should have been out doing campaign events.
- 16:45He was with two animal rights activists helping
- 16:48us document conditions in a wet market and then
- 16:52saying to us after, you know, I can't believe
- 16:55I ever ate chicken. um you know because it's
- 16:58mostly chickens in those markets poultry and
- 17:01so yeah so you know i guess the point i'm trying
- 17:04to make is you just don't know where you're going
- 17:06to get support if it's from a right -leaning
- 17:08person or a left -leaning person and um as it
- 17:11turns out this particular hand it is moderate
- 17:13he's not a right wing anything um and so right
- 17:18as of now i'm planning to vote for this guy despite
- 17:20the fact that he's a republican i've never done
- 17:22that before That's a really interesting story.
- 17:26So I Guess the vegan candidate who was the mayor
- 17:32in right those past few years was a disappointment
- 17:36Yeah, you know, it's a good point I forgot. I
- 17:40mean, you know, Eric Adams, who is our mayor
- 17:43and is now running on an independent on the independent
- 17:45line, and who is not doing well in the polls
- 17:48and is really just going to be a spoiler. He
- 17:51came into office espousing a plant based diet,
- 17:55which is terrific. And I think he, you know,
- 17:57maybe introduced, you know, some meatless Fridays
- 18:00and, you know, and vegan options and hospitals
- 18:04and schools and all of that's great. You know,
- 18:06he wasn't You know, he didn't lead by example,
- 18:08really, because, you know, he'd be out in restaurants
- 18:10eating fish. And he wasn't an animal. He didn't
- 18:13subscribe to the vegan ethic that animals exist
- 18:16for their own purposes that they're not here
- 18:17for us are here with us. And they're entitled
- 18:20to live in peace with their families just like
- 18:22us. You know, he didn't subscribe to any of that.
- 18:25He was just plant based for his health. And so
- 18:28when there's no ethical mandate tied to it, then
- 18:30of course, you know, you'll add in fish and,
- 18:33you know, you know, we are vegan for ethical
- 18:35reasons. So we're not going to consume anybody.
- 18:39That's not the case with him. So he didn't set
- 18:41a great example. But I give him plenty of credit
- 18:44for talking about plant based diet, keeping it
- 18:47on people's radar screens, you know, but no,
- 18:51his his his You know, he was such a disappointing
- 18:56mayor for so many other reasons, the corruption,
- 19:00his ties to Donald Trump, you know, in order
- 19:02to get all the legal, you know, the legal work
- 19:06against him, you know, thrown away. So he's been
- 19:11a disappointment. He's not going to be our next
- 19:13mayor. And then the other two independent candidates,
- 19:18the Democrat has no real record on animal rights
- 19:21or veganism or anything like that. That's Mamdani.
- 19:25And then Andrew Cuomo doesn't have much of a
- 19:28record either on animal rights. You know, I used
- 19:32to criticize him on social media because he would
- 19:35post photos of himself with, you know, trophy
- 19:38fishing, you know, with these huge dead fish,
- 19:41you know, smiling. So that's to me, just trophy
- 19:44hunting in the water. So not not an animal person,
- 19:48but this the Republican is. Well, that's a really
- 19:53interesting take. And what a story, you know.
- 19:57If we put the media organizations on the side,
- 20:01what about the journalists, the reporters? Nowadays,
- 20:05I feel like journalists, reporters are not really
- 20:09committed to one media organization. They usually
- 20:12write articles for multiple media organizations.
- 20:16They are contributors for different media outlets.
- 20:22You do highlight through your initiative how
- 20:28some of those reporters have a tendency to hit
- 20:31on the animal cause and to negatively cover it.
- 20:39So are there some reporters worth mentioning
- 20:44in terms of really badly covering the animal
- 20:50cause or really putting a great light on the
- 20:56cause? Yeah, of course, I'm blanking out on names.
- 21:01But there's a New York Times op -ed writer who
- 21:05for years has been covering factory farms in
- 21:10depth. And he's terrific. Maybe his name will
- 21:16come to me. I've been reading him for years.
- 21:18And I'm so grateful every time I see his name
- 21:22come up in an article about factory farming,
- 21:25which is, you know, one of his beats. But, you
- 21:29know, I wonder with regard to reporters, and
- 21:32you said that some work for multiple media outlets,
- 21:35I mean, I think they probably get assignments.
- 21:37And then if assignment editor has a mandate from
- 21:41above to do a hit piece on plant based meats,
- 21:44which we've seen a lot of, then they're probably
- 21:47going to take take that on because it's money
- 21:49in their pocket, you know, they get an assignment
- 21:51and they want it. um and they probably know that
- 21:54an article like that will get a lot of clicks
- 21:56so uh and then there are probably there there
- 22:00as i said earlier there are some uh people who
- 22:03aren't necessarily journalists but they write
- 22:06they submit op -ed pieces using their credentials
- 22:09as a nutritionist or a physician um and they
- 22:13use those credentials and post and submit articles
- 22:17that trash uh veganism and promote meat and we
- 22:20know that they're employed by or supported by
- 22:23you know meat and dairy industry lobbying groups
- 22:28so it comes in all shapes of sizes sort of this
- 22:32the negative the negative these hit pieces come
- 22:35they arise for many different reasons for many
- 22:39different sources so i'm just looking at each
- 22:42one individually trying to figure out what what
- 22:44is that how did this one come about uh what was
- 22:47the Purpose of this the article is good, but
- 22:50the headline is bad Oh that just probably means
- 22:52that the editors who picked the headlines were
- 22:55looking for clickbait to get eyes, you know Maybe
- 22:59to get eyes on the article, but then the article
- 23:01might be good. So that's a good thing It really
- 23:04every article is is different. I'm sure over
- 23:07time I'm gonna really pick up trends, but this
- 23:09is I'm only a couple months into this So I'm
- 23:12still getting my feet wet, but I'm learning,
- 23:14you know that reporters do care, because in at
- 23:19least four occasions, they've responded to me,
- 23:23mostly defensively, but there's been an apology
- 23:27about for omitting something, omitting fair balance.
- 23:33So, so they're paying attention, despite the
- 23:35fact that I don't really have much of a following
- 23:37yet. You know, I thought once I have thousands
- 23:41of followers and more engagement than reporters
- 23:44and editors, the media outlets would be more
- 23:49sort of alarmed to see people amplifying what
- 23:55I'm putting out there. But that amplification
- 23:58didn't need to occur. for at least some reporters
- 24:01to get back to me and respond. And when they're
- 24:04responding defensively, you know you're getting
- 24:06to them and maybe they'll be more careful next
- 24:09time because they don't want this criticism.
- 24:11They don't want to be challenged from higher
- 24:13up. Reporters don't like to be in the spotlight
- 24:19in a negative way. I've learned speaking to reporters.
- 24:22And so they're vulnerable, as I said, more vulnerable
- 24:24than the influencers, though I do think we need
- 24:27to target them too. And let's make something
- 24:31clear. Are you covering any kind of negative
- 24:34coverage of the animal cause or are you really
- 24:39targeting unfair coverage of the animal cause
- 24:44that happens to be negative? Yeah, no, I'm covering
- 24:48what is clear bias and what is clear propaganda.
- 24:55If there's an article that is accurate and fair
- 25:00about an ingredient used in a plant -based food,
- 25:06and it's based on science, I'm probably not gonna
- 25:09call that out. If it really feels like it's a
- 25:12good faith... news or ever to report on news
- 25:16If I think it's just a hook to bash veganism
- 25:20if I can if I detect that then I'm gonna call
- 25:23it out Sometimes it's a judgment call Sometimes,
- 25:27you know, it's conceivable that you would see
- 25:29an article that is upsetting to you and would
- 25:32be upsetting to me But I feel like I can't really
- 25:34call it out because it doesn't really demonstrate
- 25:37bias Um, it's just information that we might
- 25:42not be happy about, but that's rare. More often
- 25:45than not, I'm finding that the negative articles
- 25:49don't have fair balance or they're just, you
- 25:52know, they're just straight out attack, you know,
- 25:55anti -vegan propaganda that feels like it's coming
- 25:57from the meat industry via the mainstream media.
- 26:00So you're just, you know, it's called VegeMedia
- 26:05Watch, but could have been called lies media
- 26:09watch, you know, you're you're actually just
- 26:12looking for dishonest media coverage. It's it's
- 26:19it's more than just dishonest. It's just it's
- 26:21you know, it's it's just clear bias. It's it's
- 26:27it's propaganda. It doesn't seem fair. And so
- 26:32that's what I'm calling out. And so I'm sure
- 26:36this will continue to evolve over time. I'm finding
- 26:40my voice, trying to figure out what works, trying
- 26:44to figure out what will engage people in the
- 26:47vegan community to take part in this, because
- 26:49there's power in numbers. Although, as I said,
- 26:52reporters are still responding despite how little
- 26:55engagement there is. So yeah, I think it'll continue
- 27:00to evolve. And maybe over time, mainstream media
- 27:05becomes less less relevant maybe I'll shift to
- 27:09influencers and social media or maybe more people
- 27:12will come on board you know I just do this as
- 27:14a volunteer it's not you know but maybe other
- 27:17people who care about this will help out and
- 27:20want to join me and calling out influencers or
- 27:23even mainstream media outlets who are spreading
- 27:27anti -vegan pro -meat you know propaganda What
- 27:31consequences in bad media coverage have on the
- 27:35progress of this cause? Well, just take a couple
- 27:39things. Just take what happened to Beyond Meat,
- 27:42which is a publicly traded company launched,
- 27:44you know, IPO with so much fanfare. The price
- 27:48shot up from I don't remember. what it came to
- 27:51market at, maybe $60 or something. I might be
- 27:53wrong about that. But at one point, it shot up
- 27:55to $250 and now it's at about $3. And that is
- 27:59absolutely a result of this campaign to attack
- 28:04Beyond Meat as an ultra processed unnatural food.
- 28:09Thankfully, a few days ago, CNN wrote a long
- 28:13piece saying that Just because something is ultra
- 28:16processed doesn't mean it's unhealthy. When you
- 28:18combine a bunch of healthy ingredients and process
- 28:22them together, that doesn't necessarily create
- 28:24an unhealthy product. In the case of Beyond Meat,
- 28:28which is probably made from pea protein and soy
- 28:30protein, and I'm not exactly sure, but plants
- 28:33and other healthy ingredients, it's not... You
- 28:36know, it's still a processed food, right? You're
- 28:38still better off eating a carrot stick than a
- 28:40Beyond Burger. But there is some nutritional
- 28:43value. And it's not nearly as bad a processed
- 28:47food as, let's say, a piece of bread, which is
- 28:50made from white flour, or potato chips, or cookies,
- 28:55or soda, or some salad dressings, or all of these
- 28:58other processed foods that people eat. But these
- 29:01articles this negative coverage is giving people
- 29:04a free pass to eat regular beef instead as if
- 29:09that's healthier than a plant -based alternative.
- 29:13It's not. It's dangerous. When I see these titles,
- 29:17vegan diet is unhealthy. Something is just egregious
- 29:21as that. And I've seen that. I think, boy, there
- 29:23are people who are going to just consume meat,
- 29:27dairy, eggs, and they think that not eating a
- 29:32healthy plant -based diet of fruits, vegetables,
- 29:35whole grains and legumes that they're going to
- 29:36think that's okay because the media told them
- 29:38that veganism is unhealthy. It just feels very
- 29:43dangerous. And I definitely call that out. I
- 29:50should add though, because we're only talking
- 29:52about calling out the negative articles, I'm
- 29:54definitely using Veg Media Watch to amplify the
- 29:57positive stories like the CNN story that I just
- 29:59mentioned. I mean, I was so grateful to see CNN
- 30:03acknowledge what we all know, that not all processed
- 30:06foods are created equal, and in some cases they
- 30:08might even be healthy. And also CNN acknowledged
- 30:11how much better a Beyond Burger is for the planet
- 30:14than a beef burger. And so we also need to encourage
- 30:20mainstream media outlets to publish stories promoting
- 30:25a healthy plant -based diet. Because if we encourage
- 30:30them to do it, and we share those stories, they'll
- 30:32continue to do it in the future. Because that'll
- 30:35bring in more ad dollars for them if people see
- 30:37all you know, if they can show engagement, and
- 30:40clicks. Yes, well, that's the thing, I feel like
- 30:45there's more power in denouncing, you know, the
- 30:49negative articles than promoting the positive
- 30:53ones. I think that for vegans, we want to see
- 31:00those, uh, this positive coverage and we want
- 31:04to see it being highlighted by, uh, veg, vegetarian
- 31:08watch or anyone. But what, what is liking, what
- 31:14was liking was the denunciation part of the negative
- 31:18coverage. Um, so I, I talked to one of the co
- 31:23-founders of beyond meat and he, he said they,
- 31:27invested lots of money in marketing campaigns
- 31:34to counteract that negative messaging. But now
- 31:39I'm realizing they did not invest money in denouncing
- 31:43that horrible coverage of their products. They
- 31:49kind of tried to promote back their product into
- 31:53existence. instead of, you know, denouncing the
- 32:00kind of coverage they received and complaining.
- 32:04So all of that to say they should pay you they
- 32:06should send money your way because you're really,
- 32:10you know, helping them out here. Yeah, you know,
- 32:15I read I have nothing to gain financially from
- 32:17any of this. I'm just, you know, volunteering
- 32:19my time to do this. But it might make sense for
- 32:23the plant -based community to come together and,
- 32:26you know, formalize, you know, Veg Media Watch
- 32:29and back it and we could get more people, you
- 32:31know, they have an army, the other side has an
- 32:34army of people. I mean, you hear about these
- 32:36war rooms of publicists and influencers who the
- 32:39media industry has hired to go after the plant
- 32:43-based food industry and to promote the meat
- 32:44industry. It would be nice if we had something
- 32:47like Veg Media Watch, but bigger, where we're
- 32:52fighting back on behalf of an ethical vegan company
- 32:57like Beyond Meat. We want those companies to
- 33:01survive for the planet, for our health, for the
- 33:07animals, for the people who work there doing
- 33:09good work. So yeah, I'm sad that they should
- 33:13even have to fight for themselves. in the court
- 33:16of public opinion and the media to defend against
- 33:20these attacks. Look, there are lots of communities
- 33:24that have watchdog groups. There's a gay and
- 33:28lesbian alliance against defamation where I volunteered
- 33:31many, many years ago. writing letters to the
- 33:34editor of newspapers, this was before the internet,
- 33:36writing letters to the editors of the newspaper
- 33:38when there would be sort of a hit piece on gay
- 33:40people. The Jewish community has the Anti -Defamation
- 33:45League to speak out against, you know, anti -Semitism.
- 33:49So likewise, we should have a group fighting
- 33:53against anti -vegan bias and supporting those.
- 33:57publications and people who promote veganism
- 34:02fairly and accurately. Let me find back my tinfold
- 34:07hat. And let me ask you, do you think that there
- 34:12are some vegan media outlets out there are vegan
- 34:19influencers that are just, you know, have been
- 34:25captured or are actually part of that big, you
- 34:29know, media campaign, sponsored by Big Ag, because
- 34:36I see them pop up all the time, you know, all
- 34:40sorts of media initiatives around veganism. And
- 34:44I often wonder, who are the people behind that,
- 34:48you know, sometimes I contact them and I get
- 34:53no answer, which makes me even more, you know,
- 34:56suspicious of of those initiatives. But is that
- 35:00something you ever wondered? Well, I mean, you
- 35:03know, I do set up Google alerts for vegan veganism,
- 35:07plant based. And every day I get in, seemingly
- 35:10every day I get an onslaught of of Articles that
- 35:14come through from an organization called veg
- 35:16out and the titles are appalling so it bills
- 35:21itself as a plant based lifestyle. Magazine online
- 35:25it's a website and the articles might be okay
- 35:29but the clickbait titles are are just you know
- 35:33are are awful really that would really. Would
- 35:38really turn people off from veganism why vegans
- 35:41are to eight ways how vegans are alienating their
- 35:43friends, you know It's one title after another
- 35:47so I call them out and I do wonder if all of
- 35:50those articles are Sort of AI generated because
- 35:54when I look on their website, I can't even really
- 35:56find real people And so it does feel like this
- 36:00particular website is exploiting us For exploiting
- 36:06the interest in plant -based lifestyle for clicks
- 36:09making money out off of it and sort of throwing
- 36:12us under the bus That's the only one that comes
- 36:15to mind that veg out magazine Is that what you
- 36:19were referring to? Well, yeah, I was thinking
- 36:22about that since you know, you you covered it
- 36:25That also bots on social media accounts that
- 36:31you know always disparage and and and say some
- 36:36anti -vegan stuff online or on Reddit. I've seen
- 36:43so many accounts on Reddit profiles labeling
- 36:49themselves as vegan, but then you wonder, are
- 36:51you really vegan? Why are you saying that kind
- 36:54of stuff? We need an army of people. I mean what
- 36:58you just described I mean I'm not on reddit and
- 37:01I don't spend a ton of time on social media because
- 37:04right now I'm focused on the mainstream media
- 37:06but The as as we've talked about the industry
- 37:09the meat and dairy industries are so big and
- 37:12so powerful and so wealthy That to content, you
- 37:15know to do justice and combat and then we need
- 37:17to be there needs to be more of us now granted
- 37:20You know even before i was doing veg media watch
- 37:23of course i would comment in an article that
- 37:25was negative or you know send a letter to the
- 37:28editor here there but and lots of people do that
- 37:30which is terrific which i just think we need
- 37:32to do it in a much bigger scale and in a more
- 37:35organized fashion like other communities do.
- 37:39You're right about that and i jokingly you know.
- 37:43talk about conspiracies and all of that. But
- 37:47we're not talking about aliens here. It's not
- 37:51really that much of a crazy conspiracy to believe
- 37:55in because we have so many examples out there
- 37:59of, for instance, foreign nations playing the
- 38:03cultural wars to get what they want. And, you
- 38:08know, we're capable of that, you know, in the
- 38:11US, in North America. It's just It's not just
- 38:14for a nation. For many years, I worked for in
- 38:19public relations. I worked for a big PR firm
- 38:21in New York and we had divisions. We had consumer
- 38:26tech, pharma. And so I'm sure I don't remember
- 38:30offhand if our company had any clients who were
- 38:35meat, dairy, egg, whatever companies. But I'm
- 38:39sure they would have if they had been and they
- 38:41would have probably been paid hundreds of thousands
- 38:45of dollars a year to do PR for them. That was
- 38:49a long time ago. Now they're PR agencies that
- 38:53probably just specialize in social media. The
- 38:57landscape has changed dramatically. But of course,
- 39:00the meat and dairy industries probably spend
- 39:03hundreds of millions of dollars on lobbying,
- 39:06advertising. a PR to get their messages out.
- 39:10And I have no doubt that there are publicists
- 39:12working at mainstream PR firms who are calling
- 39:16and pitching anti -vegan propaganda stories.
- 39:20Hey, we got a new bit of information about some
- 39:23ultra -processed meat. Will you run a story?
- 39:29And then if that media outlet knows that this
- 39:32company is advertising also, then maybe they
- 39:35might feel sort of an obligation to run a story.
- 39:37We don't know what goes on behind the scenes,
- 39:39but surely that kind of thing happens. They want
- 39:42to support their advertisers. But more than that,
- 39:46do you think they fuel, for instance, the infighting
- 39:50in the vegan movement? Because I see the state
- 39:55of this. community, so to speak. And I sometimes
- 40:00wonder, um, was that all designed to, to fail,
- 40:04you know, by, by someone, by a force? Um, and
- 40:08does that include, you know, um, a social media
- 40:11strategy to, to, to reach that goal, um, with
- 40:16big money from a big industry? Um, yeah. Yeah,
- 40:21it's, you know, I wouldn't be surprised. First
- 40:24of all, of course, we know that the meat industry
- 40:26and all of our all of the industries that we
- 40:32oppose, whether it's animals for food, clothing
- 40:34or entertainment, they must rejoice when they
- 40:37see infighting in our community in the same way
- 40:39that we would if we saw infighting and in their
- 40:43community, whether or not they actually produce
- 40:46campaigns that would that would trigger infighting
- 40:50among us and keep us all week or focused on something
- 40:54else, like issues outside of our world, I don't
- 40:57know, but I can tell you that there are all of
- 41:01these human causes that are unrelated to animal
- 41:05rights that take up a lot of the oxygen in the
- 41:08animal rights community, and that takes away
- 41:11so much desperately needed attention from the
- 41:14animals. I mean, I participate, you know, over
- 41:17the years, of course, I participated in gay rights.
- 41:20events, BLM events, and you know, there's never
- 41:25discussion about veganism or animal rights or
- 41:28anything. There's no consideration for animals
- 41:30at those events at all. But now there's an expectation
- 41:34among people in the animal rights and vegan movement
- 41:37that we focus on human issues and it just takes
- 41:41away, it tears us apart as a community because
- 41:43we don't all agree. We're not all on the same
- 41:46side of those human issues. Um, so, and it takes
- 41:49away so much attention from the animals who are
- 41:53not getting that attention and all of these other
- 41:55human rights causes. So I wish we would just
- 41:58stick to the animals. I wish we would use our
- 42:01animal rights platforms to focus on, uh, on animal
- 42:06liberation and not on all of these other causes.
- 42:11Do you know what I want? I want to an investigation
- 42:15on, you know, the state of this media vegan community
- 42:23and have an idea of, you know, the percentage
- 42:29of traffic driven by, you know, vegan discourse
- 42:34and all of that. What's the percentage of bots
- 42:38there? What's the percentage of people, you know,
- 42:41from Pakistan that and I'm taking just one random
- 42:45country, but that have been hired to pass themselves
- 42:49for vegan activist online and what kind of things
- 42:54they say. I really want to have some answers
- 42:59and some hard data. And you look at social media
- 43:05and the discourse online and you feel like sometimes
- 43:10the majority is against you or backing up something
- 43:14that you disagree with. But once you understand
- 43:19that 50 % of those likes, those, you know, comments
- 43:24came from bots or something like that, then you,
- 43:28you understand that this is not real, that really
- 43:31social media is not real, which is very cheesy
- 43:34to say, but yeah. You know, I It's interesting
- 43:38that you say that because I, you know, before
- 43:41I started Veg Media Watch, I was working on this
- 43:43Adidas kangaroo, you know, this kangaroos are
- 43:45not shoes campaign trying to compel sports for
- 43:48companies like Adidas and Nike to stop using
- 43:51kangaroo skin. And so the last target was Adidas.
- 43:54And thankfully, they announced, you know, a few
- 43:56months ago that they would stop using kangaroo
- 43:58skin and that campaign is largely over. But I
- 44:02would I would post videos I would I would post
- 44:05videos from the protests that I would organize
- 44:08and some of them had millions of views on TikTok
- 44:12literally and there would be thousands of comments
- 44:16and many of them would be the same and I had
- 44:20to wonder are these real people or are these
- 44:22bots and sort of you know language that people
- 44:27of my generation on 53, we don't language that
- 44:30we don't use in words that I had to look up.
- 44:33You know, this is gonna sound so stupid, but
- 44:34like, thousands of comments that would start
- 44:36with the word brah, B -U -R -H, you know, brah,
- 44:41I -D, you know, I don't, I don't give a fuck,
- 44:46I whatever the word initials are there. It was
- 44:48just, and so many of them were the same. Use
- 44:53the same language were these real people were
- 44:55these real like teenagers posting these comments
- 44:58I score bangers and I don't give So were those
- 45:04bots do you know, I don't even know Yeah, I think
- 45:08that we're putting our finger on the problem
- 45:10here. We don't know we don't know how much of
- 45:13that is real and I feel like your initiative
- 45:17is the first step towards having answers to those
- 45:21questions. I think that we have some homework
- 45:24to do. Yeah, you know, I haven't been looking
- 45:27so much at bots and comments on social media,
- 45:32because I've been so much more focused on going
- 45:34after the mainstream media for their coverage.
- 45:39But yeah, I agree, this is something that we
- 45:41need to understand too, because it's, you know,
- 45:45potentially tearing our community apart. And,
- 45:48and and moving people away from veganism. And
- 45:52at a time when it's more important than ever
- 45:53that more and more of us make the switch to a
- 45:56plant -based diet. I can't believe we haven't
- 46:00used the expression yet, but fake news is, I
- 46:04think, the technical terms for, you know, dishonest
- 46:07media bias. Although it has, you know, a political
- 46:14connotation to it, as you know. Right. Then,
- 46:18you know, the lines are blurred between news
- 46:20and opinion, right? I mean, it used to be, I
- 46:24can remember when I was younger, that it was
- 46:27clear what was on the news pages of, let's say,
- 46:30print media versus what was on the opinion pages.
- 46:33But that feels more blurred now. The bias is
- 46:37coming out in the news pages where it shouldn't
- 46:40be coming out. And of course, that's very true
- 46:42of the, you know, cable news networks like CNN
- 46:47and MSNBC and Fox, where so much of it is just
- 46:52sort of opinion, you know, you can kind of hear
- 46:55it in the anchors voice. No, they're still and
- 46:58maybe you're too young to remember this. But
- 47:00you know, in the 70s and 80s, and I guess the
- 47:0490s mean the main source of news for so many
- 47:08people was a 630 evening news on CBS, NBC and
- 47:12ABC. And you know those anchors would really
- 47:16just deliver the news there was never a hint
- 47:18of bias that i can recall but. And that could
- 47:22very well still be the case on the evening news
- 47:24at six thirty but. Apart from that it just feels
- 47:28like so many media outlets are you know the bias
- 47:30comes through on their news pages or words you
- 47:33know it should just be objective. That's very
- 47:36true the number of you know on youtube videos
- 47:40covering those. uh, people reading the scripts
- 47:44and you know, they're from different, um, media
- 47:47outlets, yet they're reading the same script
- 47:50about the same story. And there's this eerie
- 47:53feeling that, you know, this is propaganda and
- 47:56it's, this is not, you know, objective reporting
- 47:59of facts. Yeah. It makes it so much more difficult
- 48:02for us to know now what's true and what's not.
- 48:06And it didn't used to feel that way. And you
- 48:09used to believe the news. Now, even when I read
- 48:13the news and, you know, reputable media outlets
- 48:17like the Washington Post and the New York Times
- 48:19or the Wall Street Journal, I, you know, I second
- 48:22guess everything. You know, I guess years ago,
- 48:24when I worked on the I was really involved in
- 48:27the campaign to ban horse -drawn carriages, and
- 48:28I still am, by the way, in New York City. And
- 48:30I made this documentary film called Blinders
- 48:33about the plight of the horses and took viewers
- 48:36behind the scenes. So I had to learn a lot. I
- 48:39had to dig really deep on that one issue, and
- 48:42I learned a lot. And then I would see the reporting
- 48:44in the New York Times about the horse -drawn
- 48:45carriage issue and think, this is just factually
- 48:48incorrect. You know, what they're stating here
- 48:51is incorrect. And then when they would opine
- 48:53about the horse -drawn carriage industry on the
- 48:55editorial page, they got it wrong, too. You know,
- 49:00they just got it completely wrong. And I thought,
- 49:02if they're getting it wrong on this issue that
- 49:04I happen to know a lot about, then what else
- 49:06are... What else are they getting wrong? So I
- 49:09do feel like I read the news with more of a grain
- 49:12of salt now than I did in my, you know, when
- 49:16I was in my 20s, down 30s. Definitely. What do
- 49:21you make of the fact that now if you open the
- 49:26news app or think of a title of a media outlet,
- 49:30you get incredibly depressed. What is this about?
- 49:35Is this done on purpose? you know, because those
- 49:38negative emotions are drivers of engagement more
- 49:42than, you know, something more positive. What
- 49:46do you make of that? Well, I mean, the opposite
- 49:50could be true for other people who look open
- 49:53their feeds. And it's all stories about kittens
- 49:56and puppies, you know, frolicking. I mean, I
- 49:59think so much our feeds are curated now in a
- 50:02way that we were unimaginable, you know, maybe
- 50:0515 years ago. And so I think that we're being
- 50:11delivered what they think we're going to read.
- 50:15So for their advertising purposes. So, but yeah,
- 50:20they're capitalizing on our emotions and our
- 50:24interest to deliver us news that is going to
- 50:26make these outlets more the most money. It's
- 50:29definitely, it all feels manipulative and a little
- 50:32bit dangerous. Do you get depressed from doing
- 50:36this coverage of anti -vegan and also pro -vegan
- 50:43media coverage? I guess my first emotion would
- 50:48be frustrated to see the propaganda and to know
- 50:56what we're up against and then a far distant
- 51:01emotion is grateful for those who are doing it
- 51:05right and who are being fair and giving us a
- 51:10true shout out where we need it. And so those
- 51:12are the emotions. I wouldn't say depressed. Depressed
- 51:17is how I feel when I watch, you know, the video
- 51:22footage of what goes on inside of factory farms
- 51:24and slaughterhouses. But the news coverage itself
- 51:27is just making me frustrated. and angry. Well,
- 51:32it must feel good to, you know, have an initiative
- 51:37to, you know, vent, you know, on those on those
- 51:41issues. Must feels like must feel like journaling.
- 51:47Yeah, it feels like I'm doing something I'm fighting
- 51:49back. I know it's making a little bit of a difference,
- 51:52as I said, because some journalists have reply,
- 51:55despite the lack of engagement, you know, from
- 51:57our side. So it feels like, you know, something
- 52:01good could come of it. You know, look, we're
- 52:03all spokes in a wheel, the people who do undercover
- 52:06investigations, or open rescues, or the people
- 52:09who are out on the streets doing vegan outreach,
- 52:11education, websites, you know, campaigns, you
- 52:14know, street camp, we all have something to contribute
- 52:17here. This is just a very tiny spoke and a very
- 52:20big wheel. But if I find that, you know, continues
- 52:23to make a difference, if I feel like it's making
- 52:25a difference, I'll keep at it and, you know,
- 52:27and solicit people to help me and, you know,
- 52:30maybe eventually get funding and, and, and turn
- 52:33it into something, you know, an official entity.
- 52:36Right now, it's just sort of a social media platform
- 52:38on, you know, on all the platforms, basically,
- 52:41at Veg Media Watch, trying to demand accountability,
- 52:44and trying to augment, you know, and amplify
- 52:49the the pro vegan stories, and affair stories.
- 52:55Wonderful. Donnie, it's an amazing initiative.
- 52:58It really is. And it has great potential. I think,
- 53:04you know, you said we're all doing our own thing.
- 53:07But I feel like this, this is, you know, affecting
- 53:11everyone, and the efforts of everyone. So thank
- 53:15you for that. So, Donnie, did you want to add
- 53:18something before I stop the recording? Yeah,
- 53:21just that if people could please go to the veg
- 53:24media watch on Twitter and Instagram and Facebook
- 53:27Threads and you know LinkedIn veg media watches
- 53:30on all of those platforms and each one of them
- 53:33sort of the posts are a little bit different
- 53:35tailored to that platform Do you know if there
- 53:38are reporters who use some platforms more than
- 53:40others like I find out where they are and I target
- 53:43them and the editors and you know the media outlets
- 53:45so find me on the platforms that you use and
- 53:48you know share it, comment, like, engage in some
- 53:52way, because there's power in numbers. And so
- 53:56the more engagement we have, the more likely,
- 53:59you know, the bigger impact we'll have, I believe.
- 54:03Well said. Donnie, thank you so much for your
- 54:06great work. And thank you for having me. taking
- 54:09the time to answer my questions. Thanks for your
- 54:14interest and your support. Of course. Well, you're
- 54:17a returning guest of the show. I should have
- 54:20mentioned that, but I discovered Veg Media Watch,
- 54:25and I'm always pronouncing it veg, but it's Veg
- 54:28Media Watch through LinkedIn, and it was recommended
- 54:32to me by the algorithm. I thought this is amazing.
- 54:36I need to have the person behind this initiative
- 54:39on the podcast. And it happens to be you. So
- 54:42I'm really happy about that. You can't get rid
- 54:46of me. Well, for the best. Thank you so much.
- 54:52Thank you, Tony. Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 54:55I kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 54:58the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 55:01to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 55:05caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a
- 55:08new episode.