Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Hopefulness vs. Hopelessness
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. Welcome, everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:20It is November 2nd, 2023 at 7:38 PM Pacific Daylight Time.
- 0:31I'm I'm trying. I've been trying to formulate
- 0:34the last couple of hours what it is that I I wanted to talk about
- 0:38and it it hasn't filtered its way out of my mind in a in a
- 0:43clear pithy sort of statement that I can riff on very well.
- 0:53So we'll see how that it unfolds in terms of.
- 0:57Whether it makes a lot of sense or not, I have been talking
- 1:05about the aspect of cultural conditioning that that's so
- 1:14pervasive and and the state that the world is in at the moment it
- 1:20it's particularly with the war in the.
- 1:26Middle East and the potential of the expansion of that and and
- 1:32climate change coming in and it just seems like a very
- 1:39interesting time as the Chinese would say.
- 1:43And how does one come into balance with that the
- 1:47polarization of of the the body politic we used to call it?
- 1:56The rise of fascism. And if you look at these cycles
- 2:00of history, it's unremarkable to note that the arising of fascism
- 2:07and the arising of inequality are essentially the same thing,
- 2:14that this increasing, ever increasing inequality that
- 2:18comes. And then these remarkable
- 2:22fantasies of technology rescuing us in this iteration of that,
- 2:29we're going to invent some crazy technology, and that's going to
- 2:38be the thing that rescues us from all of this.
- 2:51And so that really sets me into this place of a hopelessness.
- 3:01And I was reading something this weekend.
- 3:04There was a quote by Mike Davies in Mike Davies wrote City of
- 3:09Quartz, which was a a wonderful description of the of the the
- 3:14development of the city of Los Angeles.
- 3:20There's another book if you wanna understand this place
- 3:26where I live is the the four ecologies of Los Angeles and we
- 3:34have this unusual experience of of an environment that's Alpine.
- 3:40We have high desert, we have low desert and we have coastal, all
- 3:43within an easy driving range. He said fight with hope or fight
- 4:00without hope, but just fight. And so we have this perception.
- 4:07I think I was talking to a friend of mine about this shift
- 4:13from hopeful to hopeless in the crossing of the 1 degree of
- 4:21heating. Happening and thinking that that
- 4:26means that we're just going to have climate change.
- 4:31There's nothing to do about that now.
- 4:34And so really where we should be is in understanding that that's
- 4:38going to happen and that the different effects that are going
- 4:41to happen as a result of that aren't going to be solved by
- 4:46some new technology that comes along.
- 4:51When you look at that arc, that arc of heating, it hasn't even
- 4:55we haven't even slowed down the the, the admissions that will
- 5:01cause this from happening. And we and I keep hearing in the
- 5:06news these ideas of different technologies that are going to
- 5:09come along and rescue us from this.
- 5:17You can hear in in the way that I'm describing it.
- 5:19It's a rather hopeless point of view the the way that the habit
- 5:28I have of creating reality. And So what that means of course
- 5:37is that the. The the hot part of the planet,
- 5:43the equator area, the tropics are going to be uninhabitable
- 5:47part of the year and it's going to change the agriculture, which
- 5:55is going to affect the food supply.
- 5:59I know I've said this year before in North and South
- 6:03America in this stretch. We're we actually do pretty,
- 6:07we're going to do pretty well with the the adjustment in food
- 6:10because we're meat centric in our diet, 70 portions of grains
- 6:16equals one portion of meat. If we stop eating meat, the 70
- 6:22portions of grains can then go to feed us And so as we begin to
- 6:28eliminate meat from the diet. Even if the the capacity to grow
- 6:34food falls by half, there's still going to be food.
- 6:39But this isn't true in India and China where they're they're
- 6:45already vegetarian, a vegetarian centric diet.
- 6:49They don't have that, which means there's going to be this
- 6:52flow of people and it's not going to be the trickle that we
- 6:56have now. It's going to be hundreds of
- 7:02millions of this is kind of the, when I think of climate change,
- 7:06what I'm seeing is hundreds of millions of people being
- 7:10dislocated by the change in the environment.
- 7:14And and then what I see here is we tried building a wall between
- 7:21Texas and Mexico and that didn't work.
- 7:23So now we're building it between Mexico and Guatemala.
- 7:27Because it's a shorter distance and the the the the harshness of
- 7:37the response to people trying to cross it can be greater than
- 7:43here, or it appears that way to me.
- 7:47Instead, shouldn't we be recognizing that we're going to
- 7:50have to integrate into our society all of these people that
- 7:54are being displaced? By the actions of our society
- 7:59and releasing the the missions in the 1st place, the other
- 8:04thing about being in North and South America that makes us
- 8:07advantage in this is that we're surrounded by water.
- 8:12They can't walk here. We can build a wall between
- 8:17Mexico and Guatemala and the tropical space between.
- 8:21Then we'll have to go South into South America.
- 8:31But in Europe and Asia, they're. Connected.
- 8:34It's one landmass. They can just walk over what you
- 8:37see happening, so. I guess the question is then,
- 8:41how do we attend to these kinds of existential fearfulnesses
- 8:52that come up around this idea? We get very bogged down, I
- 8:58think, in. In the day-to-day, and it's
- 9:01harder to imagine a bigger picture and in the extremes of
- 9:07inequality that we allow, mainly through the way that the
- 9:14taxation of corporations and the banking system and the wealthy
- 9:19has been allowed to happen. And then I I am aware that this
- 9:28is a. I love you keep going, and we're
- 9:31talking about meditation. But I am also describing the
- 9:37current environment that we're in and how these extremes of
- 9:43inequality are are exploding and how one response is really this
- 9:52neo fascism. And the other response then
- 9:56would be this. Compassion for the difficulty
- 10:03that's arising and responding in a way that that is actually
- 10:07helpful to people. How do you do that in these
- 10:16extremes that are arising? I was reading in the paper
- 10:25today. About the zombie forests in the
- 10:29Sierra that the climate change shifted the Alpine spaces is
- 10:39essentially wiped out the forest and what's standing are the the
- 10:43trees that are no longer alive, which they'll do for years till
- 10:48they decay enough to fall over. We used to go up to Zaka Lake to
- 10:55retreat when that was still viable and you could begin to
- 10:58see that happening in in the pine forests.
- 11:01They would turn a kind of rust colored rather than that that
- 11:06pine green and you would begin to see over the years that we
- 11:09went this increasing number of of the rust colored trees.
- 11:18So part of this, of course we is not to turn away from what is
- 11:23unpleasant, but to to stand in equanimity and allow this
- 11:29information to come in, and then that in seeing clearly, to
- 11:35inform our response to it so that we have some engagement in
- 11:41what's actually happening. It is certainly easy to
- 11:50disappear into some forms of unconsciousness around this and
- 11:55not address it particularly, I find in in the reading that I do
- 12:06that there's really good solutions to almost all of these
- 12:11difficulties that we face. But what seems to be absent is a
- 12:16a will to engage in them. You get very caught up in the
- 12:24sense of ourselves, very caught up in the the identity of
- 12:29ourselves. And we are programmed,
- 12:34particularly in the West, to think of it as a 0 sum game
- 12:38where there's one pie and if we cut it up.
- 12:51And there isn't enough to go around.
- 12:53We really need to to to grab our piece.
- 12:59And my understanding, and this is really influenced by the
- 13:03ideas of attachment, is the the search for the meaningfulness of
- 13:09of this human life. What are we in in this for?
- 13:19And how do we know what we're in for?
- 13:23What are we in it for? What is it that that is the
- 13:27thing that ignites a sense of meaning, a sense of fulfilment?
- 13:37I remember hearing in the media world that we're in now that the
- 13:45purpose of life according to the Dalai Lama.
- 13:48Was happiness. But I wonder if he's said that
- 13:56or if that's what he meant in the translation of happiness,
- 14:03because the there is a superficial quality to that that
- 14:09doesn't actually provide much in the way of meaning.
- 14:17Even at the level of privilege that I have, which is
- 14:20extraordinary in the whole picture, but in our society, not
- 14:26much, just a contradiction. I think the the, the, the main
- 14:37value that I got out of my childhood was not material
- 14:40particularly, but it was being around educated parents who
- 14:46could think. Critically.
- 14:48And so I learned all of those skills which are invaluable to
- 14:54me in terms of the of my particular search for meaning.
- 15:03How do you organize your life in such a way that you can spend
- 15:07time each day in the pursuit of things that you find meaningful
- 15:13in the doing of them? And not in exclusively the
- 15:22pursuit of time, energy and resources to survive on in the
- 15:28world. Many, many people are at a level
- 15:33where that is really all of the energy that there is available,
- 15:37that pursuit, but in privileged communities.
- 15:49And I think that the meditation community tends to be on the
- 15:52privileged side of things. There is the additional space
- 15:57where. Primary exploration for meaning
- 16:01could happen and the resistances to doing it.
- 16:09And keeping your balance in the end, it really is that piece,
- 16:12the balance piece, can you allow yourself to experience.
- 16:17Not only your individual world or the small world of your
- 16:22immediate social network, but can you also be open to your
- 16:29position and role in our community and step up for that
- 16:34responsibility and at the same time find the meaningfulness of
- 16:45each of your days? As we grow older the the ease of
- 16:55slipping into despair seems to intensify in the sense that the
- 17:02ordinariness of things is harder to do and the energy
- 17:06restrictions are much greater and letting go of that that
- 17:12primary exploration because it's effortful.
- 17:19Leads to a despair. Back to hopelessness is a topic.
- 17:32How do you have equanimity with that?
- 17:34Maybe that's a good title for this.
- 17:35How to be a quantumist with Hopelessness at the state of the
- 17:41world and its current and this current moment?
- 17:49What I find makes that possible is the turning toward the
- 17:56sacredness, the experience of sacredness of of being alive.
- 18:01One of the reasons I was talking about the anxiety around death
- 18:09and how the the major religion religions that we.
- 18:14We have active in the world really solve this problem of
- 18:22that existential terror by offering solutions that are the
- 18:30next life. And from the Western psychology
- 18:35point of view, even if those aren't true and that they're
- 18:38relieving of that anxiety, is that useful?
- 18:43A friend of mine as she died her her last words were I'm excited
- 18:50for what's next which I thought was a remarkable mindspace to be
- 19:00in in in that point of transition.
- 19:07I'm 70 and and as it turns out when you look at the statistics
- 19:11of. Life expectancy, most people,
- 19:1480% of people live into their 70s, but not not beyond.
- 19:19And so when you, when you age to to this point, there is that
- 19:26experience of of the people that you've known over the course of
- 19:31your lifetime, many of them not making it past there.
- 19:41What does this mean, this human life?
- 19:43What does it mean to be alive? What is it that you're doing
- 19:47with this one precious life? And how has the conditioning,
- 19:56particularly that early childhood conditioning that
- 19:59informed so much affected your your capacity to find that thing
- 20:09that this life is? And if there, if it was a
- 20:17difficult childhood and it imposed a lot of limitations,
- 20:22how do you come into peace with that limitation over and over
- 20:28again appearing in your life so that you can settle into where
- 20:34you are right now and and be at peace and at the same time
- 20:40capable of acting in a way that you find meaningful?
- 20:49Well, that's my current thinking process and I will let you know
- 21:00where I arrive at this. And the cognitive aspect of
- 21:06understanding why this all makes sense is not that clear to me.
- 21:10But I do know, and sitting in some of the practices that I do,
- 21:16particularly the bypassing visions practice from the Bond
- 21:19tradition and coming into the the experience of the sacredness
- 21:27of of of everything is, is completely believing of the
- 21:33distress of considering all of this Christian.
- 21:41Because I wonder, you probably have quite a bit of perspective
- 21:45on this. Being a meditation teacher, I
- 21:49wonder about like the ebbs and flows of of practice and I guess
- 21:55specifically like meta practice where seems like I've.
- 22:00I've had stronger meta practice before and then sometimes lately
- 22:03it's like it's kind of tough. It's kind of tough generating
- 22:06meta. And so maybe there's, you know,
- 22:09internal factors, maybe there's outside factors.
- 22:14That's a kind of a big question. But I'm I'm curious about your
- 22:17thoughts on sort of the ebbs and flows and dealing with that and
- 22:21planning for it and reacting. The way that that lands to me is
- 22:30the movement between the identification with the self
- 22:35experience and the moving out of the identification of the self
- 22:38experience and noticing the self reaction when you do the
- 22:45practice. So it isn't really the quality
- 22:52of the sitting experience as the self experiences that matters.
- 23:00The self experience could be totally bummed out by the
- 23:03practice and bored and wanting to be entertained.
- 23:06And if you still engage in the practice, what you'll notice is
- 23:10that the fruits of the practice arise as the identification with
- 23:16that constricted self experience relaxes.
- 23:22So you do the Met to practice. You establish the view and
- 23:26maintain the view, even with the tantruming self experience as
- 23:32part of the view, because the self experience is not actually
- 23:37what's happening. The self experience is the the,
- 23:41the, the record of what's happening in this using the
- 23:46printer metaphor, the CPU and the programming, the
- 23:50conditioning all work it out and then they send a copy to the
- 23:54printer and then the self picks it up in the printer and looks
- 23:58at it and that's what's happening.
- 24:00But the process of getting that to the printer was unconscious
- 24:04and automatic and based on the conditioning.
- 24:07And so in evaluating what that outcome is, we can mentalize the
- 24:15the process and the meanings that we use to get there.
- 24:19And in that back and forth between, this is what I've made,
- 24:23this is the data, this is what I've made, this is the data.
- 24:27If we need to correct it. And we can in an expansive
- 24:33awareness allow that self experience to to come and go
- 24:38even when it's disgruntled and not affect the view that much.
- 24:48I don't know how long ago this was.
- 24:49Maybe seven or eight years ago. I would go to Shinzen's here and
- 24:56retreats maybe longer and I would sit for four hours in the
- 25:04morning and then I would sit for four hours in the afternoon
- 25:09depending on what the, the Dharma, the, the his class.
- 25:14He hasn't usually has a class in the morning or did on his
- 25:16retreats, and if I was comfortable with the the topic
- 25:22and already had a sense of of that, I understood it well
- 25:26enough. I would sit for four hours and
- 25:30if you did a two week or 15 day retreat, something like that.
- 25:34Usually for the first couple of days I would just do breath
- 25:37counting. But I was really concentrated,
- 25:40and what that meant to me was that I could hold attention on
- 25:46the breath for about an hour without getting caught up and
- 25:49thinking too much, not enough to lose the count.
- 25:53So using breath counting and then shifting into the inside
- 25:59practice. And I typically would go to
- 26:01retreat with an idea of what I was going to practice if it were
- 26:04available to practice. And I went on this one
- 26:08particular retreat and I couldn't get three or four in
- 26:12the breath gouting even one time without getting distracted.
- 26:17And and I did that for 15 days, 4 hours in the morning and four
- 26:21hours in the evening, not making any progress at all.
- 26:24And the self experience just became completely distraught
- 26:28because there was some ego involvement about what a great
- 26:32meditator I am. And and then about six weeks
- 26:36after the retreat, one of the most significant breakthroughs
- 26:40in my practice happened. It was quite clear that the
- 26:44attention and the pressure on pushing through, that, the
- 26:50unwillingness of the of the body mind to attend to what was
- 26:57happening, required that. And had you asked the self, they
- 27:04would say it was completely unproductive and awful
- 27:07experience that should never be repeated.
- 27:10And yet it the the unconscious automatic responses shifted
- 27:19significantly. So when you look at the ebbs and
- 27:24flows of practice, it isn't really the the pleasantness or
- 27:29unpleasantness that the self experience is having, It is in
- 27:35the Longview. Are things changing, are they
- 27:38shifting? And that's really where you you
- 27:41pay attention. Particularly with meta practice.
- 27:45I noticed if I'm doing the meta and the self is suffering and
- 27:50doing it as soon as the suffering self experience goes
- 27:55away. If I'm able to hold the view, I
- 27:57noticed that the view is quite different and an ordinary view
- 28:04that makes sense. One of the thing that I find so
- 28:10enjoyable about the meta mind is that everybody looks so
- 28:13beautiful to me when I'm in meta mind and that's usually the 1st
- 28:19place I go. Do people look unusually
- 28:22beautiful? And then I that's one way of
- 28:32understanding that, that that's the view that I'm in.
- 28:39Did I answer your question well enough?
- 28:43I think so. I I guess I heard you to say
- 28:47keep practicing essentially and just like sorry, go ahead and
- 28:54have insight into the nature that the self experience,
- 28:57whether they enjoy the whether the they enjoy the practice or
- 29:02they don't. Since each one that arises is
- 29:04different, that actually isn't how you evaluate whether the
- 29:10practice is productive, right? Yeah.
- 29:16I guess sort of. Aside from that aspect, there's
- 29:21like there seems to be like a sort of beginner's fervor to
- 29:25practice, right? So like.
- 29:29Dealing with like getting out of that phase or like I've never
- 29:32been a better meditator than like when I had no idea what I
- 29:34was doing, it seemed to the self it.
- 29:38Seemed to it seemed to the self where I I recognize I have a
- 29:41more nuanced practice, but there is kind of a beginner's fervor
- 29:46that takes you over some initial humps.
- 29:48If there's a sophomore slump, what is the junior period, I
- 29:51think? That's when you get your car.
- 30:02So the junior period is where you're pretty good meditator and
- 30:06you meditate and the the the big shifts haven't happened and
- 30:12you're taking it on on faith in the way that we mean it in a
- 30:17Buddhist understanding. You, you, you take on, you take
- 30:23it on faith that the the teacher is telling you what's true and
- 30:31and and is intending to be helpful to you and then you have
- 30:34to practice and get. It through direct experience.
- 30:45To be skillful is to understand that the self experience,
- 30:49whether it's suffering or it's enjoying, whether it's hopeless
- 30:53or hopeful, is not the whole thing, not even the bigger part
- 30:59of it. And that the ability to respond
- 31:09to the conditions of the present moment in a skillful way,
- 31:15regardless of the that experience is what's necessary.
- 31:21But. Also a desirable goal of
- 31:24practice. So why don't we do some
- 32:00practice? All right, let go of the
- 32:08meditation. So any comments or questions
- 32:13about that? So we have a new thing that I've
- 32:27not not done before on November 17th, I think that's a Friday.
- 32:33Let me look and make sure it's a it's an hour and 15 minute long
- 32:42class. All how to date, like a secure
- 32:46person, even if you're not yet secure.
- 32:52Which is talking about how attachment patterns form
- 32:59relational patterns and how to manage that.
- 33:03So that even if you don't do the deep work of uprooting your
- 33:06native attachment strategy, you can begin to form secure,
- 33:11functioning relationships. And then if you can put those in
- 33:16place, maybe use those as a platform to explore the deeper
- 33:23attachment conditioning you faced.
- 33:25Anyway, we've not done it before.
- 33:27The first one is going to be on the the 17th of November in in
- 33:32December, the four Saturdays of December we're going to do a
- 33:36level one in the morning and then in January we're going to
- 33:42start a new level 2 in on Friday mornings which is good for also
- 33:48the Central European time. So take a look at that, that's
- 33:54what's coming up. I will be travelling next week
- 33:59so there there'll be no, I love you keep going next week but it
- 34:03will return the week after that. Ioffer the teaching freely but
- 34:10if your resource that are able to do appreciate making a
- 34:14donation, there's a link on the website to do it.
- 34:17Any amount is fine. It really helps support me and
- 34:20also the work that Medigroup is doing.
- 34:22Really appreciate your practice. Thank you for practicing tonight
- 34:26and we'll see you soon. Bye.