Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E047: The Dollar Endgame with Peruvian Bull
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:10What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 1:15we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 1:18excrement ever assembled in the history of Darkness. 1974,
- 1:25198792972000, and whatever we want to call this.
- 1:29It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:31We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell.
- 1:37Hey, I. Say.
- 1:44When we sell, we're in epoch #5. First rip of epoch #5.
- 1:51How we feeling? Feeling good feels feels like
- 1:55nothing's changed. Feels like the halving didn't do
- 1:58anything, guys. You didn't.
- 2:00We're in the death spiral right now.
- 2:02This is a this is a funeral episode death spiraling.
- 2:07Yeah, I don't know. I heard.
- 2:08I heard the fees are, you know, the block reward's so low now
- 2:11that everything is gonna die, right?
- 2:14Bitcoin's over. It's cancelled.
- 2:16Yeah, we should all go home. The overwords give up.
- 2:21All those people who are excited about the having, they really
- 2:23have egg on their face because nothing happened and nothing
- 2:27will happen as a result of this having, I'm sure.
- 2:31I will say the death spiral FUD was not as pronounced as it has
- 2:34been in cycle test. Last cycle it was really loud,
- 2:39like, you know, they, they're serious.
- 2:42People were concerned that mining would, you know, be
- 2:45unsustainable and that we didn't have that at all this time.
- 2:49They're they're perceived to be serious until they start talking
- 2:52about this viral phone. Ari, Paul, Gentlemen, we're
- 2:57joined by Peruvian Bull, the infamous Peruvian bull, founder
- 3:02of the dollar end game Sub Stack.
- 3:07Welcome to the show. How have you been?
- 3:08It's been like a year since I caught up with you.
- 3:11Yeah. I've been good.
- 3:13I've been good. I've been busy.
- 3:14I quit my job in fintech and I started doing this full time,
- 3:20doing research and writing. Yeah, went to the Adopting
- 3:24Bitcoin conference in El Salvador, spoke there.
- 3:27I've been in, living in Medellin, Colombia, meeting a
- 3:29ton of bitcoiners, making a lot of great connections.
- 3:32So a lot of huge changes. But I'm bullish on the future of
- 3:37Bitcoin. I'm bullish on my future.
- 3:39I'm, I'm excited to be here. I'm bullish on on RAMP
- 3:42everything. You weren't just fintech, you
- 3:45were in like, fintech PE, right? Yeah, yeah.
- 3:49I was doing like evaluations for early stage startups, mostly
- 3:54software companies and some biotech for a couple years.
- 3:58And then I was I was so interested in macro, I was
- 4:02diving deep down the rabbit hole and I started writing on Reddit.
- 4:05I wrote this series called Dollar End Game which was about
- 4:08the monetary system and changes of reserve currencies and why
- 4:12the dollar and Trip and Solema would eventually cause things to
- 4:19run up and this. Is just a.
- 4:22This is just a camera switch, you.
- 4:24You OK? OK, yeah.
- 4:25This I I thought you guys dropped me.
- 4:29Yeah, so I I wrote this series and it's funny, 'cause I I
- 4:32didn't even. I think I told Marty this.
- 4:34I didn't anticipate it being anything bigger than what it
- 4:37was. I wrote the 1st post and then it
- 4:38went to like 500,000 views on Reddit.
- 4:40And I was like, whoa, like, this is huge.
- 4:43And so a lot of people said we want to hear Part 2, what
- 4:45happens after Nixon goes off the gold standard and Triff and
- 4:49Solema starts kicking in. And so then I wrote Part 2, Part
- 4:513 or the whole series, and then just started going on Twitter,
- 4:55started writing Twitter threads. Those started blowing up.
- 4:57And I was like, wow, there's enough demand for this content
- 5:01that I'll I'll quit my job and do this full time.
- 5:03And so that's what I've been what I've been doing for the
- 5:06past six months or so. Yeah, it's awesome.
- 5:10And and I I just love how people like you you know come from a
- 5:15background of of like doing macro analysis doing like
- 5:20evaluation analysis and then things aren't adding up and you
- 5:24know it's not like you're uninformed.
- 5:25In fact, you're too informed and then you figure out you know
- 5:29this this doesn't make sense. Something's wrong here.
- 5:32And then you go down the rabbit hole.
- 5:33And I I think that that's very telling, that people who who
- 5:38know too much end up bitcoiners. Yeah, we all get we all get
- 5:44orange peeled eventually right? Like that's that's the thing.
- 5:47I I actually, unfortunately in about 2018 I was flooded out of
- 5:50Bitcoin because I read a a book written by a software engineer
- 5:53and hedge fund manager Eric Townsend that basically said
- 5:56hey, the blocks, the block space is too small to challenge and or
- 6:01to allow enough, you know, transactions for global output.
- 6:05Like you know this is 7 transactions a second.
- 6:07We need 60,000 so it'll never work and so don't buy Bitcoin.
- 6:11And so I was a gold bug up until about 2021 and the GameStop
- 6:15situation occurred. And then after that happened, a
- 6:19bunch of like, I I blew up. That's when I started really
- 6:22exploding and going viral and a bunch of Bitcoin started
- 6:25messaging me and saying like, hey, you should look into this
- 6:27again and arguing with me. And I was like, you know what?
- 6:30I maybe I should. And then once I read Safe Dean's
- 6:33book and I read Block Wars, Block Size Wars, I was like, OK,
- 6:38I'm, I'm, I'm in. Eric, Eric, if you're out there,
- 6:43I've emailed with Eric before being like, hey, let's talk
- 6:46about Bitcoin. He's like, no, it's not gonna
- 6:47work. It's a shame.
- 6:49The Macro Voices podcast is a great podcast.
- 6:51Actually, it's one of the few that I still listen to from time
- 6:54to time. But yeah, they the macro.
- 6:59Some of the macro guys, particularly the gold bugs, Not
- 7:01that Eric's a gold bug or anything really misunderstand
- 7:07Bitcoin. It's a fascinating dynamic
- 7:11because don't think natural or like every couple months they'll
- 7:16have somebody that's a, quote UN quote Bitcoin expert, come on
- 7:18and talk about it. And like, they're just
- 7:20consistently getting peppered with like, different versions of
- 7:23the value prop. And where it sits like, it's
- 7:25almost like a Peter Shift. Sorry.
- 7:28I mean, like, do they get it? They just do.
- 7:29They just, like, are building up that persona that they're not.
- 7:32They'll never get Bitcoin, but they have a bag.
- 7:34Why don't you write a book about it?
- 7:36It's hard to. Yeah.
- 7:38It's out there. It's publicly accessible.
- 7:40It's hard to to save face. Yeah, the the gold bugs really
- 7:43suffer from escalation of Commitment.
- 7:46You know, as like a psychological trap where they've
- 7:49invested so much of literal money, but also time and energy
- 7:54and and and ego in being right about gold that they don't want
- 7:59to be wrong. It's a financial and
- 8:01psychological sub cost fallacy that they're stuck in.
- 8:05Great. Where was he?
- 8:09Well, is he going full time? I couldn't imagine a better time
- 8:12to go full time in the space from like, you know,
- 8:16geopolitical perspective, what's happening, all the craziness
- 8:19that we saw going on the past two weeks in the Middle East.
- 8:21And there's a lot of discussions around, you know, Bitcoin being
- 8:25the first kind of alarm when stuff goes a little hairy.
- 8:30So yeah, I'm sure you have a lot you're writing about right now.
- 8:33Oh yeah. No, that's it.
- 8:35It's well also I mean it's not only that but the Fed's tools
- 8:39and ability to you know stealthily add liquidity into
- 8:43the system is is expanding. You know things that I wouldn't
- 8:47have found two years ago happening.
- 8:48I I'm finding that are I'm finding today like one example
- 8:53is I was doing a recent piece I wrote it called Stealth QE.
- 8:56It was about different ways that the Fed can add liquidity back
- 8:59into the banking system without actually technically expanding
- 9:01the balance sheet. And I did a breakdown of the
- 9:06Fed's balance sheet since the taper week over week changes and
- 9:11I did it by maturity of their Treasury debt.
- 9:14And I found out they actually haven't been selling any of
- 9:16their long bonds, like none. Anything past 10 year maturity
- 9:20they haven't been selling, they've only been buying.
- 9:22And So what they've been laying off for the taper is just the
- 9:25T-bills, the two year notes, the five year notes and the
- 9:28seven-year notes and some tips. And so that was pretty shocking
- 9:31to me because again, like this isn't stuff that's that's
- 9:35advertised in the financial media, even though you can find
- 9:38it if you, you know, know how to use Fred Charts well enough to
- 9:42breakdown, breakdown what's happening.
- 9:44But yeah, it's this is a really interesting time to be in global
- 9:47macro. It's a really interesting time
- 9:50to be in Bitcoin. I think, you know, the the FUD
- 9:53that came out that weekend was hilarious because, you know,
- 9:56Iran did that drone attack within a within 10 minutes
- 10:00Bitcoin price begins plummeting. And then you have people, you
- 10:04know, I think Nick Timorios from the Wall Street Journal or
- 10:07whatever coming online and saying, hey, how is this a store
- 10:10of value? It's falling.
- 10:11Oh my God, like this isn't the store of value.
- 10:14It's falling during a conflict. How can you claim this, you
- 10:16know, Bitcoin thesis, dead bulls are, bulls are are ended.
- 10:20I just had to laugh so hard at that 'cause I was like either
- 10:23you're you're just ignorant to the point of like stupidity or
- 10:28you're willingly trying to spread FUD and spread
- 10:32disinformation because that that kind of, that that kind of talk
- 10:36is ridiculous. I mean even treasury bonds were
- 10:39fire sold during March 2020 and that's high quality, you know,
- 10:43liquid asset. So it's ridiculous to to make
- 10:46that assumption. I mean, it's important to
- 10:47understand the context that Nick is essentially the the Fed
- 10:51whisperer is what he's referred to from the Wall Street Journal.
- 10:55And so he's got a position of access to the Fed and loves that
- 11:00position of access 'cause he gets a beat on all the stories.
- 11:03And so it's not surprising that he would bad bad talk Bitcoin,
- 11:10which is a a big competitor to this thing he has access to and
- 11:14makes his career as successful as it has been, relatively
- 11:17speaking. With that like with that in
- 11:20mind, just like the macro outlook, I'd be interested to
- 11:24get your thoughts on a few of the things going on right now
- 11:26whether it's that sneaky liquidity operations that the
- 11:29Fed is running. A couple of things in the
- 11:33headlines this week. Japanese yen at 155 seems to be
- 11:39the Bank of Japan seems to be losing control of of the yen.
- 11:43You had China and Russia come out and announce that they
- 11:46haven't done trades between each other, settling in dollars for
- 11:51some time now. And then we had the BTFP and
- 11:57last month and it looks like the reverse repo market is draining
- 12:01as well. So there's a lot of things
- 12:04happening both geopolitically on the global macro level and then
- 12:10here at the United States level, particularly at the Fed.
- 12:13It seems like there's like a a ticking time bomb going off in
- 12:17terms of liquidity that will probably need to be dealt with
- 12:21at some point. Yeah.
- 12:24All of the inflation's flying. Yeah.
- 12:28Yeah, it's accelerating, right. The the last three months have
- 12:31seen increasing prints, which is interesting given that we
- 12:33thought that inflation was cancelled if the Fed hikes rates
- 12:36to 5%, right? Yeah, they they they already
- 12:39defeated inflation. So they're not going to remark
- 12:41on how it's going up right now at War One.
- 12:46It's already over. Exactly, yeah.
- 12:50There's a so there's a lot of threads to pick apart there.
- 12:54I can start wherever you want me to, but.
- 12:56Let's let's start with Japan, because Japan is notoriously for
- 13:00a long time been considered the Canary in the coal mine.
- 13:03A lot of people in the macrosphere saying if
- 13:05something's wrong in Japan, that is the leading indicator that
- 13:09something's wrong systemically throughout the global financial
- 13:12system. Yeah.
- 13:14And I I actually think that that's an apartment metaphor.
- 13:17I've written a lot about the Bank of Japan, actually, in my
- 13:19newsletter, Probably more than any other country except for the
- 13:22US, Japan was at the forefront of, you know, monetary
- 13:27innovation. They're the ones who started QE
- 13:29in 2002. They're the ones who created
- 13:31yield curve control in 2016. They've pioneered a lot of you
- 13:37know novel ways to add liquidity to the system without trying to
- 13:40cause inflation and then eventually they tried to cause
- 13:42inflation and for years it wasn't working until now it's
- 13:47actually working and and causing them a crisis there.
- 13:51I I can't I I have this saying of the Bank of Japan is caught
- 13:54in a black hole of their own design.
- 13:56And the reason why I say that is because you know, for years, I
- 14:01mean Japan has has been farther along the curve in terms of debt
- 14:05creation than any other country for years just because of their
- 14:08demographics and because of their extremely low monetary
- 14:11velocity. And so they've been able to
- 14:13create massive amounts of credit without causing inflation in the
- 14:17traditional sense because of those underlying factors.
- 14:21And to save the the slowly deflating economy, the Bank of
- 14:27Japan in 2016 started yield curve control.
- 14:30They brought rates down to zero and actually in negative in in
- 14:33some senses like on the very, very short end it was negative
- 14:37.1% I believe and even on the 10 years -.1% was part of the ban
- 14:43for yield curve control and they kept it there for, you know,
- 14:47basically a decade. And what happens when you have
- 14:50Zerp for long, long periods of time is the debt creation just
- 14:55continues and just expands and has no, there's no natural brake
- 14:59on lending because there's no cost to lend and there's no cost
- 15:03to borrow. Like why would you care about
- 15:06your debt levels as a company or as an individual when it costs
- 15:10nothing to roll over and you're not paying any interest.
- 15:12And so by doing this, the Bank of Japan piled more and more
- 15:16debt and this creates this financial gravity of more and
- 15:20more debt means that if you raise rates, the interest
- 15:22expense will go up. So now you have even more of a
- 15:25reason not to raise rates. And so rates have to stay lower
- 15:28for longer. And so you just keep, you keep
- 15:30adding to the argument of why you should stay in this trap and
- 15:34that works until your currency starts to blow out, right,
- 15:39Because this is the issue that the Bank of Japan has been
- 15:42having for like the last two years.
- 15:45I keep saying that they're they're on a train and they
- 15:47they're slamming the gas and the brakes at the same time.
- 15:50And the reason I say that is because on one hand it like in
- 15:53September of 2022 when they began intervening it in their
- 15:56bond or in their currency market by selling bonds, they were
- 15:59selling U.S. Treasuries to get dollars to buy
- 16:03yen. But at the same time they were
- 16:04still continuing their yield curve control program to control
- 16:07their own bond market and keep yields suppressed.
- 16:10So they're printing yen on one hand and then they had they were
- 16:13selling treasuries to get dollars to buy yen on the Forex
- 16:16markets. And so it it's a nonsensical
- 16:20monetary policy that that's self defeating.
- 16:23You're right you're you're burning the candle at both ends.
- 16:24You can't keep doing 22 opposite things at the same time and
- 16:28except except expect both to work out and so they they did
- 16:34this for for months in September 2022 they began doing this again
- 16:39in in December and then in July of last year they kept they
- 16:45started moving the bands of yield curve control because what
- 16:48they were trying to do was they're trying to alleviate this
- 16:50pressure building on their currency.
- 16:52You know with this massive debt level and with inflation
- 16:56beginning to reappear in Japan it it printed I think 2.2% in
- 17:00February which again for for us doesn't seem that bad but for
- 17:02Japan that's like a 30-40 year high.
- 17:07Their currency is just getting weaker and weaker and the yen
- 17:09shorts continue to pile up and as the delta between the the
- 17:15Japanese interest rates and the American interest rates domestic
- 17:18interest rates rise. Carry traders can come in borrow
- 17:21yen at 1% and buy treasuries at 5 and profit from it.
- 17:25And essentially what that is, is that's like a synthetic yen
- 17:28short. And so the Bank of Japan is
- 17:30stuck with this choice, right? Like what are they going to do
- 17:32if they raise rates to stop the carry trade and stop their
- 17:36currency from blowing out, Then their entire economy starts to
- 17:40run into severe depression and deflation because it can't at
- 17:43263% debt to GDP you can't support 5% rates.
- 17:48Like it's impossible. And if you're.
- 17:52I think, I think I did the math, I think it was like for every 1%
- 17:56they raise, they would spend 13% more or something like that of
- 18:01their GDP on on interest alone. Like it's it's ridiculous.
- 18:08I mean, this is of course in the long run like over 20 or 30
- 18:10years, but it's just they can't raise it that much higher.
- 18:14And so they have this choice of letting the yen blow out or
- 18:18raising rates and trying to stop the yen blowing out, but at the
- 18:22risk of basically pulling their own government into a severe
- 18:25fiscal crisis and pulling their economy into deflation.
- 18:29And so they've been stuck in this trap.
- 18:31And you know, I when yen was at 1:50, I wrote this piece and I
- 18:35said, you know, the bank Japan had an imagine a line that said
- 18:39this is their line of no return. If they if this gets crossed,
- 18:41they're probably not gonna ever go back.
- 18:43Well, we may not see again at 1:50 again.
- 18:46And that was last August. And then in March it crosses 153
- 18:51and now it's at 154.8 and it just keeps, it keeps going.
- 18:55And their only real recourse which can buy them time is
- 18:59selling their $1.1 trillion of U.S.
- 19:02Treasuries and using that to buy get dollars and using the
- 19:06dollars to buy yen to strengthen their currency.
- 19:08And they can do that, but it'll run that will they maybe have
- 19:12about, you know, 10 to 12 months of of capital to do that based
- 19:17on their prior run rate of of 80 billion or so that they were
- 19:22spending in in September and October of 2022 to to
- 19:24intervening as their currency. So they're kind of trapped, you
- 19:27know, or not kind of they are trapped.
- 19:29And so I think the only choice is to either let the yen blow
- 19:34out or you know, let their economy suffer deflation.
- 19:37And we know central bankers and and you know, government
- 19:41officials hate the idea of of the government defaulting and
- 19:44then losing control and losing funding.
- 19:46And so I think the what's going to happen is the yen is just
- 19:48going to have to blow out and they're going to have to suffer
- 19:50currency depreciation for the next 10 years.
- 19:55Wow. Yeah, that.
- 19:56That's a great summary of the situation.
- 19:59But what do you say to people you know?
- 20:01I I used to spend more time paying attention to that part of
- 20:05macro and when I talk about it, everyone, a common rebuttal
- 20:11would be, well, the Japan's been in trouble for 20 years.
- 20:14You know the the the numbers have looked bad for 20 years and
- 20:18yet they've made it work. And and I have my opinions on
- 20:23why that is. But what do you say to that?
- 20:27I would say like, yeah, yeah, they have been able to kick the
- 20:31can. They have been able to delay the
- 20:32problem. But when it comes to a like a a
- 20:36fiscal situation this dire, you can't escape it forever, right?
- 20:40Like math eventually catches up to you.
- 20:43And especially for a country that's not a reserve currency,
- 20:46you have the issue of the currency trilemma.
- 20:49You have to either hold, you have to have an open capital
- 20:52account, independent monetary policy.
- 20:56If you choose two of these three independent monetary policy,
- 20:58open capital account and freely voting or or pegged exchange
- 21:03rate. And so if you pick do you want
- 21:05the pegged exchange rate and you want independent monetary
- 21:08policy, then you have to close your capital account.
- 21:11And if you want an open capital account which you need for
- 21:13global trade, then you need to give up either the, the exchange
- 21:18rate or you need to give up the monetary policy.
- 21:20And So what that means is that you basically become like a
- 21:23vassal of the Fed. You have to say, OK, if the Fed
- 21:26raises rates, I raise rates in in, in synchronicity.
- 21:29If they lower, I lower. I have to follow whatever the
- 21:31Fed does just so that I don't attract, you know, capital flows
- 21:35or capital outflows to to destroy my currency.
- 21:38And you know, these processes as as we're seeing with the debt
- 21:41crisis, right, these processes are are exponential.
- 21:44And So what happens is nothing happens, nothing happens,
- 21:47nothing happens, little bit happens, then everything happens
- 21:50at the end. And so for the last 20 years,
- 21:52they've been able to kick the can because nothing was
- 21:54happening and they were able to keep rolling the debt at 0%.
- 21:58And then once the Fed raised rates in 2022, they their
- 22:02currency started to weaken substantially and now they're
- 22:06stuck. And unless they can give us the
- 22:08Fed to cut to 0 again, which may happen, they're going to be
- 22:13trapped. Yeah.
- 22:16But in what you said earlier about the Fed choosing to roll
- 22:22over the choosing to hold the long term bonds that they're
- 22:26holding, doesn't that imply if anything they expect inflation
- 22:31rates to remain higher than than the the, you know, the coupon
- 22:37rate on those bonds And so those are the attractive ones that
- 22:40keep holding? I think personally I think it's
- 22:44less of a, you know, like profit motive play and and trying to
- 22:50make money off of which bonds are going to make money or which
- 22:53bonds are going to you know be returning real returns versus
- 22:58nominal and more of a liquidity and overall market structure
- 23:03play. Because from what we've been
- 23:06seeing, you know the treasury itself also has been switching
- 23:10its issuance from the long end of the curve to the short end.
- 23:12So last November they put out a press release saying, you know
- 23:15hey we're reducing the amount of 30 year and 20 year bonds and
- 23:18we're increasing the amount of two, five and seven-year notes
- 23:20we're issuing. And we're doing that on a go
- 23:23forward basis. And this is like a permanent
- 23:25change. And if you look at like the
- 23:27chart of T bill issuance, which I can, I can maybe throw up and
- 23:32on a tweet or something, you can see this exponential rise since
- 23:35COVID of how many T-bills they're issuing this quarter in
- 23:38Q1 of of this year. Yeah, I guess last quarter
- 23:42Michael Howell pointed out that 71% of the Treasury's funding
- 23:45was coming from bills. And I I think this is because
- 23:49there's a structural shift away from the long end of the curve
- 23:52in terms of demand towards the short end.
- 23:54And so when you have that happen, you can't keep off
- 23:58laying and trying to sell long bonds because the the interest
- 24:01rates are just going to blow out exactly.
- 24:04So I think the Fed did that more as a strategic play than a a
- 24:07financial one. More that there's a market for
- 24:10for the higher rate short end of the curve bonds and so that's
- 24:14what they're going to go OfferUp and.
- 24:16They probably don't want to refinance longer and longer
- 24:19duration bonds at these interest rates, so it makes sense, but
- 24:23it's a Frankenstein response. Sorry.
- 24:27To derail you, derail you from from Japan there, 'cause that
- 24:29was, you know, an awesome amount about what's going on there
- 24:34right now. And I mean, so to bring it all
- 24:37back together though, like what you're the picture you're
- 24:40painting feels like AG7 nation that is circling the drain and
- 24:48will be the first domino to fall in in our debt based Fiat era.
- 24:54Is that your your sense? Yeah, I would.
- 24:58I would agree with that sentiment.
- 25:00I just agree. I just think that's a slow
- 25:01motion train crash, right? And ironically, which is this
- 25:06has also been pointed out. Ironically, everything that
- 25:08Japan does will make the problem worse, right?
- 25:10We already covered. Raising rates will cause them a
- 25:12fiscal crisis immediately, right?
- 25:15They can't afford 13% of their GDP every year spend on interest
- 25:20and they can't really cut without causing more inflation,
- 25:23although that's probably the choice they're going to make.
- 25:25But more than that, if they sell U.S.
- 25:27Treasuries, there's another hidden feedback loop where when
- 25:30they interest rates rise in the US, obviously because bond
- 25:34prices and rates are inversely correlated.
- 25:37And then the carry trade just opens up even further and more
- 25:40people pile into the carry trade and their currency blows out
- 25:42even more In the long run, right?
- 25:45In the short run they can, they can tamp the price down, they
- 25:47can use those dollars to buy back yen.
- 25:49But in the long run it just widens the delta between the
- 25:51rates and then more and more is more and more profitable for
- 25:54hedge funds and institutions to pile in on the yen carry trade.
- 25:58So they're trapped does. This go the shit up.
- 26:01Does this scare the shit out of the Treasury 'cause you consider
- 26:04the fact that they had a weak 10 year auction a couple of weeks
- 26:08ago and then the Treasury just recently opened up the buyback
- 26:14window. They announced it last year.
- 26:16It officially opened back up a couple weeks ago as well.
- 26:20So many people. It's the first time they've
- 26:22opened it up since post 9/11, 2001.
- 26:25They opened it up during the chaos of that era, and
- 26:30interestingly enough, they opened it again.
- 26:32Not as much chaos, one could argue, so with the looming
- 26:38specter of Japan losing control of their currency and trying to
- 26:42maintain control by dumping treasuries.
- 26:45You couple that with like weak auctions that have been
- 26:48trickling in over the last six months and this buyback window,
- 26:52like it seems like the Treasury is scared.
- 26:55And what would lead me to believe they are is the fact
- 26:58that they opened up the buy back window 'cause they're going to
- 27:00need somebody to buy these treasuries as Japan's dumping
- 27:04them. Nobody else wants to buy them
- 27:06due to the fracturing in the multipolar world that we seem to
- 27:10be moving into. Yeah, I think, I think that
- 27:14that's probably accurate. I, I there's one you know
- 27:16headline you guys might have missed a few weeks ago in in
- 27:19early March the International Securities Derivatives
- 27:23Association which is essentially all the large banks wrote a
- 27:26letter to the Fed and the OCC and the CFTCI believe and
- 27:32believe and basically said hey look you know you granted us an
- 27:36SLR exemption for treasuries in March 2020 for a year and that
- 27:41was massively helpful in absorbing treasury issuance and
- 27:44we want you to grant that again and we want it to be permanent.
- 27:48And basically what they were saying behind the curtain is
- 27:51look like the treasury issuance is starting to grow
- 27:54exponentially. We can't we don't have the
- 27:56balance sheet capacity to hold all this.
- 27:58And if if you grant us an SLR exemption which is basically in
- 28:04like bank capital terms means that they won't have to hold
- 28:07capital against their against any treasury holdings because
- 28:12what the SLR is, is basically it's called the supplementary
- 28:15leverage ratio. It's basically a ratio that they
- 28:17used to hold to calculate how much capital they need to hold
- 28:20against an asset losing value. So if it's, you know, if they
- 28:24have reserves or cash to the Fed, they don't.
- 28:27They don't need to have any. If it's an MBS or an agency MBS,
- 28:31they need to have a little bit. If it's a treasury, they need to
- 28:33have a little bit. If it's obviously a higher risk
- 28:36loan or some other investment they didn't have a lot more.
- 28:38And so by doing this, it would basically free up a bunch of
- 28:42bank capital and allow banks to acquire almost infinite
- 28:46treasuries. I mean this is basically like QE
- 28:48for the banks. And so Luke, Luke Roman has
- 28:51pointed this out and it's it's very telling that we're we're
- 28:56not in any sort of conventional crisis.
- 28:58But what I would say is the debt is the crisis and this is what's
- 29:02causing these moves to be made behind the scenes of the
- 29:05Treasury shifting issuance and the banks requesting SLR
- 29:08exemptions so that they can just absorb this massive wave.
- 29:11Yeah, I think we talked about this a few weeks ago, but it's
- 29:14hilarious that they're doing this, particularly on the back
- 29:18end of last year because of they were able to take the treasuries
- 29:22out of the leverage ratio last year during the banking crisis.
- 29:25It's arguable that like SVB, First Republic, Silvergate
- 29:29Signature would not have gone down.
- 29:31And it highlights the, the not the ambiguity, the the
- 29:41arbitrariness of all the rules. It's like, oh, we'll just change
- 29:44them on the go. What was a rule last year and
- 29:48forced many banks to fail? It's not there anymore.
- 29:52It's convenient. They're changing everything on
- 29:55the go, which is not confidence inducing in any way.
- 30:00Yeah, there was 11 more headline that people might have missed
- 30:05from Japan recently. It's about a month ago.
- 30:09I forget what the exact you know who, who, who said this or what
- 30:12it. But it amounted to Japan is
- 30:16pushing hard to open up immigration and bring a lot of
- 30:20immigrants to Japan And. And that to me sounds like a bit
- 30:25of a a desperate attempt to try to stave off deflation and and
- 30:34and bolster their economy and and spread out that financial
- 30:37pain that that they're going to have to digest at some point.
- 30:41You know it it and and in doing so kind of turns its back on
- 30:48thousands of years of of of Japanese heritage and and pride
- 30:52in in their social social set up in that country as as
- 31:00homogeneous as it as it may be. It's it's that that approach to
- 31:05culture has resulted in you know a a country they're very proud
- 31:09of and a culture they're very proud of and and they're trying
- 31:13now to change that all of a sudden.
- 31:15And that's remarkable to me because it it is the potentially
- 31:23the early death rattles of of Fiat you know trying to
- 31:28sterilize the world by well an an outcome of of Fiat trying to
- 31:35protect itself or or propagate itself and and survive and is
- 31:40willing to pull a desperate lever to change the social
- 31:43composition of a country that prides itself on its history and
- 31:47and composition. Yeah, I would agree with that.
- 31:50I mean they an interesting fact. Fun fact for you guys is for the
- 31:55last I think it's been like 17 years more adult diapers for
- 32:00seniors have been sold in Japan than baby diapers.
- 32:02There you go, there's a stat machine.
- 32:05That is a stat, so. They have a demographic crisis,
- 32:10and if they're going to try to grow their way out of this
- 32:13problem at all, which it's too late, but they're going to try
- 32:16now to grow their way out of it. A way you can do that is bring
- 32:20in people who have more babies than the Japanese now do and.
- 32:26Like they're not going to do that, though.
- 32:29There's a huge resistance from the people of Japan to you know
- 32:35what they would, what they would view as you know casting out the
- 32:40the homogeneity that they are proud of and and historically
- 32:45have maintained in their country.
- 32:48And that's going to be a major source of friction if if the,
- 32:54you know, the government and the G7 basically pushes that angle
- 32:58for how Japan might be able to shore itself up for a little bit
- 33:01longer and and there might be a lot of pushback from the public,
- 33:07I think. I think it's actively happening,
- 33:10right? Like I think if you're what
- 33:11you're referring to is I think Peter St.
- 33:13Honans. They said they're shipping like
- 33:14some crazy amount of now. That's where I got.
- 33:16It from from external countries to Japan and this is like this
- 33:21is kind of like fringe. But I think I've heard from
- 33:24multiple people. This is the their thesis on
- 33:25what's happening in the States from a border perspective of why
- 33:29so many people are coming in to the US and it's allowed from
- 33:32from all over the world. I don't know how true it is, but
- 33:35what Jesse just described is like what some people will look
- 33:37at from the. Border prices.
- 33:39Here you look at the job numbers.
- 33:40It seems to be playing out, whether it's explicit or
- 33:42implicit in the Biden administration's efforts and
- 33:48their end goal. But you just look at the job
- 33:50numbers, the amount of foreign born individuals who are taking
- 33:55most of the jobs these days. I mean, that is an attempt to
- 33:59tamper wage inflation so that people don't have more money to
- 34:03spend a bit up the price of goods.
- 34:05Peruvian hit us with a a stat. I heard one today, one out of
- 34:10318 year old. The high school diploma males
- 34:16are out of a or don't have a job.
- 34:19So 2/3 of people that went to high school are working. 1/3 of
- 34:22all males aren't working right now currently.
- 34:25Wow. That's unreal.
- 34:28Like, in what age bracket? That's incredible.
- 34:33That's a good question. Like age bracket in the from
- 34:37like like 20 to 40 prime. Working years.
- 34:41Brutal. Yeah, yeah, the the employment
- 34:44numbers are are all just like absolutely insane on how and
- 34:48that's with two trillion deficits.
- 34:50Like, that's with the the getting Jews.
- 34:53And and this is like what we're talking about here is such an
- 34:55outcome of Keynesian policy deciding that the important
- 35:02metrics are these certain growth metrics.
- 35:06And you know, and oh, we can continue printing money and
- 35:09running up the deficit and whatnot so long as we deliver
- 35:13GDP growth, so long as we have job growth.
- 35:17That's what matters. And you know, that's such a
- 35:19shame because in my opinion and I think all of our opinions,
- 35:24that's that's the wrong metric. You know it it a better metric
- 35:28would be purchasing the power of the, you know, the median
- 35:35citizen growing over time, which is is diametrically opposed to
- 35:40what Fiat can do because Fiat is designed to debase.
- 35:46And whereas Bitcoin delivers on that kind of metric and allows
- 35:52the average person to grow their purchasing power over time by
- 35:55saving in Bitcoin and utilizing it's increasing scarcity, it's
- 35:59saving technology properties that allows for that metric.
- 36:04But since Fiat doesn't allow, doesn't optimize for you know,
- 36:08the growth of the median net worth basically or purchasing
- 36:12power, then you better not pay attention to that and and hold
- 36:17that up as an important metric. Instead you should find other
- 36:20metrics that you can make look good like jobs growth or GDP
- 36:24growth because in that you know in the nominal world where
- 36:28you're printing more money those things end up looking good.
- 36:31And like that's the the source of all this bad policy is that
- 36:36we have because of Fiat, because of our monetary system.
- 36:39We have spotlighted the wrong metrics because those are the
- 36:44metrics that we can make look good.
- 36:46And and I think to a large extent people at the top have
- 36:50convinced themselves those are the metrics that matter.
- 36:53When, you know, if you take in any sort of rational, reasonable
- 36:57approach to thinking about what actually matters to the average
- 37:00American, it's it's their life getting better over time, not
- 37:04how many jobs they have to hold to make ends meet.
- 37:08And the The funny thing is, if you look below the surface too
- 37:11like the jobs numbers aren't even as good as they claim they
- 37:13are. I'm actually doing providing
- 37:15them down. Yeah.
- 37:17Well, so that's the first thing I I'm doing a research piece
- 37:20right now on, you know, government manipulating jobs
- 37:23numbers. And the the more I dig into it,
- 37:25the more and more suspect it gets.
- 37:28Yeah. Last last November, the BLS came
- 37:31out and said they had to erase 400 backwardly erase 439,000
- 37:35jobs from their numbers for the year because they overestimated
- 37:39how many full time and part time workers there were.
- 37:42And did they do that loudly or quietly after the fact?
- 37:45They did it quietly after the fact.
- 37:47Their their policies. Basically they'll put out a
- 37:50really great jobs number and two months later there's a quiet
- 37:53revision where they drop about 30 or 40%, even sometimes 50% of
- 37:58the number from the official stat, and then just never
- 38:01mention it. And only people who are
- 38:03journalists or statisticians find the changes in the data.
- 38:08But even if you believe the headline numbers, if you look
- 38:11below like the surface, it's not great.
- 38:13It's the entire rise is coming from part time workers.
- 38:16Full time workers has actually been falling since 2022.
- 38:20And so we're in a kind of a quiet recession where all these
- 38:23full time workers are getting laid off and people getting part
- 38:26hired for part time gigs for Uber, you know, for Lyft, that
- 38:30kind of thing. But they're not getting, you
- 38:32know, software engineers and lawyers are are losing, losing
- 38:36employment. And so that's that's not a sign
- 38:38of a healthy economy. And the fact that they keep
- 38:41putting this stuff out there is is ludicrous.
- 38:44One other last thing I'll mention is a few days ago Jim
- 38:47Bianco pointed this out. There's an unemployment filings
- 38:50number that the government releases every, every week.
- 38:53And he said for six of the five of the last six weeks, the
- 38:56number has been exactly the same.
- 38:58It was 212,000. I saw that.
- 39:00And that's that's like that's impossible.
- 39:03Statistically impossible, Yeah. They ran like the standard, like
- 39:06the, you know, the probability of it.
- 39:08It's literally some. It's some crazy infinitesimal
- 39:12probability where it's impossible.
- 39:16This is also why it's been important the past year as folks
- 39:18who come on and we we talk about the feds speak, just calling it
- 39:21out. Because anecdotally, we all have
- 39:22to live in the real world and we know this is happening and
- 39:25nobody goes and talks about it. They just talk about inflation
- 39:28being, you know, reduced and like employment coming back in
- 39:31reality is like the economy is fucked.
- 39:34Keep getting let laid off. Yeah We we do fall for we we've
- 39:38we talk about the numbers that the headlines talk about and
- 39:41that's like jobs numbers and GDP growth and and we don't talk
- 39:45about the metrics that matter to real people because it's kind of
- 39:50as as you know Peruvian Bullets pointed out it's kind of hard to
- 39:53find those those numbers and and you know reliable numbers for
- 39:59metrics that matter more. Yeah, completely.
- 40:04It's it's a disconnection. So I've I've actually wrote a
- 40:06piece about this and it's a disconnection of the financial
- 40:10and the real economy, right. What what the Fed has done is
- 40:13essentially financialized the entire market to the point where
- 40:17now, now stocks can just keep rising due to liquidity programs
- 40:22without any fundamentals because the correlation between central
- 40:25bank assets and, you know, broad equity indexes is nearly one and
- 40:29just everyone on wall. St.
- 40:31Ratios. Yeah, exactly.
- 40:33Everyone on Wall Street can think that everything's great
- 40:36just because the the spy keeps rising and because QQQ is
- 40:39rallying hard and in reality, the amount of homeless, the
- 40:42amount of drug addicts, the amount of people without full
- 40:45time employment keeps dropping, you know.
- 40:48And so it's this complete disconnection between the
- 40:50economies and it's, it's really sad to see because, you know,
- 40:53the the market should be driven from fundamental growth, not the
- 40:55other way around. We shouldn't be saying, oh, the
- 40:57market's rallying, what's the fundamental justification?
- 40:59We should say, oh look, we had a great, you know, quarter of
- 41:03economic growth and therefore the markets will rally because
- 41:05now there are people more investments, more savings.
- 41:08They can, they can buy a home, they can pay for college, they
- 41:11can go to do something, business owners can create more
- 41:14productive uses for their capital, etcetera, right.
- 41:17And instead it's the opposite. And you see this anecdotally, I
- 41:22mean, I'm sure we've all seen the Tiktok videos on Twitter of
- 41:27people complaining about inflation, whether it's here
- 41:30we're in Canada. I think it's at the point where
- 41:33I think I see 10 or 11 of them a day where it's not, it doesn't
- 41:38seem to be people cloud chasing for views.
- 41:40These people seem genuinely in distress.
- 41:44And it's the same story. It's like I I go to work, I work
- 41:48multiple jobs and I can't afford my life.
- 41:51And it's that's where we have to break out of The Mirage of the
- 41:58fake data that all these institutions are putting out
- 42:01there. And like you said, Michael just
- 42:03got to call it out. It's complete bullshit.
- 42:05And like bringing this back to Japan and thinking of like, how
- 42:09do you fix this. Like, I actually wouldn't be
- 42:12surprised that Japan, considering all the pride that
- 42:14they have and their strive to preserve their culture.
- 42:23If they're one of the first G sevens through the Hail Mary and
- 42:25say, you know what, we're dumping our treasuries and
- 42:27putting a big portion in a Bitcoin.
- 42:29Because if Bitcoin succeeds and we have that asset on our
- 42:35country's balance sheet, maybe we can solve some of these
- 42:39systemic demographic problems that we have throughout the
- 42:42economy. Well.
- 42:45Yeah, I think. I think that that's accurate.
- 42:47I mean, last year I read, I think there's a History of Money
- 42:53in banking the United States by Rothbard and one of the things
- 42:55that surprised. Me that recently too.
- 42:58It's a great, it's a great read. It's a long read.
- 43:00So I'll just warning to anyone who wants to to dive in.
- 43:04It's the it's very dense and he's very technical and has a
- 43:07lot of like you know, key data and and source data that he he
- 43:12gets. But one of the things that's
- 43:14fascinating is like in the period from 1883 to like
- 43:1819031904, there was compounding 5 percent 6% real wage growth
- 43:24every year for 20 years and there was almost no inflation.
- 43:28There was extreme growth in in productivity, in capital capital
- 43:33growth, overall capital growth and Capital Management.
- 43:35The ability of $1.00 of new capital to create X amount of
- 43:38dollars of GDP, like in every single metric, right?
- 43:42The US was just booming. And in 20 years we experienced
- 43:46probably one of the first large periods of of great innovation
- 43:51that propelled us into, you know, the 21st century, what we
- 43:53are now, the digital age ever because we had the internal
- 43:57combustion engine, we had the cotton gin, we had telegrams,
- 44:03Telegraph wires being being invented, you know, the the car
- 44:07at the the early stages of what would become planes.
- 44:10So it was just a massive period of innovation.
- 44:13And that period was marked by basically no inflation, sound
- 44:16money, minimal government and minimal intervention in the
- 44:19economy. And so I I think people don't
- 44:22realize, like on the one hand it is easy to get black pilled,
- 44:25right, of saying, hey look, things are so horrible, like the
- 44:28Fiat has fucked everything up so badly.
- 44:29And that is true. But it's also good to know,
- 44:31like, on the plus side, things will become so much better under
- 44:35a Bitcoin standard or under a sound money standard than anyone
- 44:38can ever believe. Thanks for tuning in.
- 44:40If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 44:43further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 44:46a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 44:49our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 44:53you on your Bitcoin journey. No, just say we're we're right
- 44:56there. That's the funny part.
- 44:57It's like the the features here, it's just not evenly
- 44:59distributed. It's like how do we get there?
- 45:01That's what we're all trying to do is like accelerate it, but
- 45:03like what you just referenced between the the Internet,
- 45:07Bitcoin, you know, let's call it AI, like somebody with a laptop
- 45:11can create so much value to increase that, you know, $1.00,
- 45:15one Bitcoin spent year over year.
- 45:18It's just we need to get there and and that's the whole part.
- 45:20It's like everybody else catching up, but you can see it.
- 45:24Yeah. It it's interesting that that
- 45:26that time period that you referenced the 20 years or the
- 45:29end of turn of the century back then it had such tremendous
- 45:35economic productivity. And yet there's like a dual
- 45:39narrative about it about that time period that you know, it's
- 45:42referred to as the the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era
- 45:46which really speaks to the two sides of the coin there of like
- 45:50Gilded Age because so much wealth was created but
- 45:53Progressive Era because there was these advancements of social
- 45:58causes and trying to you know rein in the the robber barons.
- 46:03You know you have that famous photographer go take photos of
- 46:06child labour and then push for child labour laws.
- 46:09Lewis Hines I think And you know it's kind of which side of the
- 46:15coin do you look at, do you focus on.
- 46:16And I think the narrative that has perpetuated from that time
- 46:20period is that that the robber barons were like evil and
- 46:23grabbing power and and money and and wealth and while building
- 46:27railroads. You know that like that that was
- 46:29a somehow a bad thing. But the, you know, if you look
- 46:34at the data there like you have, it sounds like pretty, pretty
- 46:39darn good for the average worker if you're going to have 5% CAGR
- 46:43in in real wages through that 20 year period, that's incredible.
- 46:47And so I I think that, you know, it's also probably a a bit of a
- 46:52premonition about what we'll be dealing with from a narrative
- 46:54point of view about Bitcoin. As you know, the Bitcoin
- 46:58standard in States and amplifies the sort of deflationary
- 47:04advantages that the gilded Asian Progressive Era enjoyed with the
- 47:08gold standard. But we will have the same
- 47:11dynamics of like massive productivity and wealth creation
- 47:17centralizing to some extent in a few hands but but also being
- 47:21passed down to you know the average person.
- 47:24But that the spotlight will be on the the wealth creation and
- 47:28and we'll have sort of our our new Bitcoin robber barons that
- 47:31will, will get terrible press from the public and we'll see
- 47:35what the narrative is about about an age of prosperity.
- 47:39Is it is it going to be a Gilded Age?
- 47:40Is it going to be Progressive Era sins?
- 47:43It'll probably be both. Yeah, that's that's a really
- 47:47good point to bring up. Because, you know, a lot of
- 47:51people point out that, yeah, wealth is on a pirate of
- 47:53distribution, right? Like wealth is unfortunately an
- 47:57exponential function where a few people have a lot of wealth and
- 48:01a lot of people view that as as an outcome of the system being
- 48:04unfair or the system, you know, being rigged in some way.
- 48:08And of course, there are, you know, obvious ways in which the
- 48:11wealthy can manipulate things and use government subsidies for
- 48:16their own benefit. But broadly speaking credo
- 48:20distributions are found everywhere in nature.
- 48:22I mean it's the size of, it's found in the size of stars and
- 48:25the size of holes, in the height of trees in the Amazon
- 48:27rainforest. It's found in the number of
- 48:29plays on Spotify per artist and so or or the amount of paintings
- 48:34or the value of painting sold, right.
- 48:36And nobody would claim that, you know Vincent van Gogh or Beyoncé
- 48:42was taking advantage of other artists just by them being so
- 48:45great. And so I think it's more of a
- 48:48function of, you know, once you become successful, success
- 48:51becomes more easy to. And so as as wealth is built and
- 48:56accrued, the people who who built it first get the get the
- 48:59lion's share of the benefits, but the benefits still do rise,
- 49:03you know, rise the tide for everyone else.
- 49:05And that's the thing that is missed about the 1800s.
- 49:07Yes, there were robber barons, you know, yeah, there were
- 49:11massive railroad railroads built and there were problems
- 49:14obviously with child labor. There were problems with
- 49:17overall, you know, I guess humane treatment of employees is
- 49:22definitely is definitely true. But we probably had to go
- 49:24through that to from to evolve from an agrarian economy to an
- 49:28industrialized one. There were we just had to make
- 49:31some sacrifices along the way to to get there and we did get
- 49:34there eventually. And so I think, yeah, I think
- 49:38under Bitcoin standard what will happen is probably what you're
- 49:40saying. A lot of people will be jealous
- 49:41of the whole coiners and saying it's not fair.
- 49:44They all have all the money. You know, you got one Bitcoin,
- 49:46you're rich, what the hell? And yeah, it is.
- 49:50It is unfair. But then you can work to try to
- 49:52to try to get there. Completely agree.
- 49:56Life isn't fair. It's the lesson my mother taught
- 50:00me. But like, it's something that
- 50:05people are gonna have to come to grips with.
- 50:07It's like, yes, you didn't get in early, but it's still
- 50:13advantageous for you to use this monetary standard because it'll
- 50:18even if you're on the lower end of the economic stratum, it
- 50:22increases your quality of life. Like, compared to the lower
- 50:26rungs of the economic ladder today, you'd much prefer to be
- 50:30on the lower end of the economic ladder under a Bitcoin standard
- 50:33than a Fiat money to monetary standard.
- 50:35It just creates that even playing field.
- 50:37I had a mentor growing up. Used to say a fair is a place
- 50:40where you go throw darts at a balloon.
- 50:45That's good, Marty. You said criticism there.
- 50:50He was an old, old guy. He was actually from Jersey but
- 50:53he was in Texas when he when he shared that that with Marty you
- 50:57said something earlier that's like really positive in the
- 51:00sense of we was talking about incentives and Japan.
- 51:03And whether it's Japan or somebody else like at the end of
- 51:04the day people have to worry about their constituents like
- 51:06the people that they serve. And this idea of a country
- 51:11putting Bitcoin on their balance sheet to protect their capital
- 51:15and their currency is also on the.
- 51:17I thought of the other side of that, which is we're talking
- 51:20about the Gilded Age and having to wait for a Bitcoin standard
- 51:24for some of this like productive productiveness or productive use
- 51:27of capital to return. And I think part of it is just a
- 51:30bureaucracy that exists from the state and taxes and all the
- 51:32things associated with it. And from a game theory
- 51:35perspective, we're seeing this right with the UAE, but there's
- 51:37other countries, El Salvador, I don't know what their, their tax
- 51:41policies are, but you can imagine a world where maybe even
- 51:45before it's a proxy for putting Bitcoin on the balance sheets.
- 51:48You have a favorable tax climate so you can bring more business
- 51:53growth or business formation to your local region.
- 51:57And then you start to, you know, have that favorable tax, you
- 52:00know, accepting put Bitcoin on balance sheet in that way as
- 52:02well. You can see how this actually
- 52:04has a smooths, another one of these versions of transitions
- 52:07where we don't have to have. Obviously it's still going to be
- 52:09bumpy but you can like see a version of how this can play out
- 52:13and then becomes I don't know if uniform but like accepted by
- 52:17others and looked at as a playbook versus we just have to
- 52:21see what we saw and why are Republic and other places with
- 52:23hyperinflation you can start so like get ahead of that and I
- 52:27think like the again the UAE, El Salvador probably some of the
- 52:32first but there's going to be others and it isn't even
- 52:34necessarily have to be putting Bitcoin on the balance sheet.
- 52:36It can be also with just having entrepreneurs go there and make
- 52:39it favourable and then starting to like stack or accumulate the
- 52:42the human capital there to help with that transition.
- 52:48Yeah. Which ideally we see this more
- 52:52in the states right? So we can like not have to
- 52:54leave. Well, that's what I was at an
- 52:57event last night in Dallas and that was one of the questions
- 52:59that was asked. Like, are you worried about an
- 53:03executive order 61 O2 in the context of Bitcoin?
- 53:05Like the government, there's an insane amount of debt.
- 53:07It's losing control. Yeah, it's something everybody
- 53:11should be worried about and have top of mind, but maybe I'm too
- 53:15much of an idealist or an optimist, but you have to
- 53:18imagine there has to be people in the government looking at the
- 53:22situation and be like we're fucked.
- 53:24There's nothing we can do to fix this.
- 53:26Like if the government wanted to create a path of least
- 53:30resistance, they would just let it flourish.
- 53:32Like no capital gains on Bitcoin.
- 53:33People can use it as money, build industry around it, let
- 53:37the mining industry go go nuts and just let the big link, let
- 53:42the market fix the problem. We're here.
- 53:44We're already fixing it, despite efforts by the government to
- 53:49make it as hard as possible in some respects.
- 53:52Imagine if they just open up the floodgates and let us run wild
- 53:56to fix these problems. I imagine we'd look back in a
- 53:59decade and be like, wow, we fix a lot of these problems rather
- 54:02quickly. I think one way, sorry one way.
- 54:09And I've been having this this talk a lot with with Bitcoiners.
- 54:14When I was in, in Santa Marta, Columbia, I met up with a
- 54:16bitcoiner who was trying to, he's trying to start a business
- 54:20creating lightning channels for for small companies and then you
- 54:25know, custodying it and taking a portion of the fees that they're
- 54:27receiving. And the issue he was finding is
- 54:29that especially in these rural areas, you know in Latam was
- 54:32that there wasn't, there wasn't enough demand for Bitcoin.
- 54:36Like the the companies might say OK, I I get the thesis of
- 54:40holding a little bit of Bitcoin as an investment, but what can I
- 54:42actually do as a business owner? How can this actually work
- 54:45towards my working capital? How can I actually utilize this
- 54:47on a day-to-day basis to pay my bills.
- 54:50And so he's actually chemical engineer.
- 54:52And so we started talking and realized that probably the best
- 54:56and quickest path towards hyper bitcoinization is bitcoinizing
- 55:00the energy and utility industries.
- 55:03Because the main thing that these restaurants needed was the
- 55:06ability if they received Bitcoin, they wanted to pay
- 55:08someone else in that Bitcoin as well.
- 55:09They didn't want to just hold it, even though they might.
- 55:11Some of them might be Bitcoin bulls and say I'll take some of
- 55:14it. I wanted to have 5% of my
- 55:16treasury in Bitcoin, but more than that they would.
- 55:18They got uncomfortable and they wanted to have some ability to
- 55:22pay. And so I think what I'm really
- 55:24interested in seeing is getting some energy companies to accept
- 55:28Bitcoin as payment for oil and gas or for some utility company
- 55:31for water or electricity. And allowing that to kind of
- 55:36percolate through the base chain of the of the production system.
- 55:41And allowing now that now that you know, electricity, water,
- 55:45gas can be paid for in Bitcoin. Now restaurants, now
- 55:48manufacturers, now service providers, can all start
- 55:50receiving Bitcoin because now they have obviously have bills
- 55:53that they can pay for it and you can start creating that circular
- 55:55economy. Yeah, we're starting to see this
- 55:58form at the base layer and where it makes most sense right now,
- 56:04which is between miners and the utilities companies that are
- 56:07selling them the electricity. You have companies like Satoshi
- 56:10Energy and Sonoda which are creating lightning enabled
- 56:15payment channels between miners and the utilities companies that
- 56:19provide them the electricity where you can literally mine a
- 56:22block, get a reward payout from the pool and then disperse the a
- 56:28payment to the utilities company to pay for your electricity on
- 56:31the go as you're consuming the electricity.
- 56:35And so I think that is very encouraging in the sense that
- 56:40that's where you need to start to get to the point that you
- 56:43just described proving bull, where it's like you start at the
- 56:45lowest layer of that stratum, which is where the miners are
- 56:50actually consuming the electricity from the utilities.
- 56:53And then you build up there. Once the utility gets
- 56:54comfortable receiving Bitcoin payments at that layer, they
- 56:59would be more open to receiving it from a retail consumer, a
- 57:04business that's paying for electricity.
- 57:06And so I think. We're.
- 57:08Taking the first steps toward that path that ends up at that
- 57:12that place that you just described.
- 57:14Yeah, that's great to see because again, I think that
- 57:17that's what's going to accelerate the adoption faster
- 57:19than anything else, right? If you can pay for your gas in
- 57:22Bitcoin and you can pay for your electricity in Bitcoin, now
- 57:25suddenly millions of businesses will want Bitcoin because now
- 57:30they can pay. And especially if you get a
- 57:31discount, right? If if they can say, hey, I'll
- 57:32offer you 10% discount in electricity bill, if you pay in
- 57:34Bitcoin, then now there's this huge reason for all these
- 57:38companies to on board and so that'll be that'll be huge.
- 57:41I'm excited to hear that. And that's, that's long been my
- 57:46thesis since I've been in the mining space for about 6 years
- 57:49now, is well, many people are understandably and righteously
- 57:55focused on getting large institutions allocated to
- 57:59Bitcoin, whether it's corporations, pension funds,
- 58:03countries for that matter. I think that's all well and good
- 58:07and something that we should strive for.
- 58:08But I've been thoroughly convinced that we just need to
- 58:12get the energy sector, because energy is arguably more
- 58:16important than money. It is what allows us to do
- 58:18everything that we do throughout the economy so that we can go
- 58:20spend money to buy goods and services.
- 58:23And if you get the energy sector, which is the most
- 58:26important sector of the global economy, bought in on Bitcoin, I
- 58:30don't think there's any turning back.
- 58:32They're gonna be like, no, we need this to provide you
- 58:36reliable electricity, so you can't take it from us.
- 58:41Interesting, I I agree and but I think that the one thing that in
- 58:46there that I think that you know, money matters to all
- 58:51industries and all, all people, all, all entities and energy is
- 58:57the most important industry of all.
- 58:59But you know, money is that base layer that it touches absolutely
- 59:03everything. And and I actually, at Pub Key
- 59:06last week, Pierre Rochard was in New York right, at an event.
- 59:10And so that was that was the pub discussion late at night, late
- 59:14into the night on Thursdays. What's more important, energy or
- 59:16money? And if you get back to like
- 59:17first principles, it's like literally humans when they're
- 59:19agrarians, just like needed to eat to get energy into things.
- 59:24I I haven't been able to dig as deep.
- 59:25I have this book still looking. That's the.
- 59:29What's the? Fuck.
- 59:31What is I'm sitting over here and it's upside down.
- 59:35It's the it's what is Daniel Yergin, the prize.
- 59:39I'm I'm convinced like all of the geopolitical setup that
- 59:42exists specifically right going on right now but for the past
- 59:45hundred plus years ties back to what Marty's alluded to.
- 59:48It's it all goes to the Middle East, the energy, how it
- 59:52dictates all of, you know, economics from recessions to
- 59:58growth and the price of oil and the intermediary step that they
- 1:00:03had to go from oil to dollars. And so it's like that base
- 1:00:08level, if that changes, then everything else is a derivative
- 1:00:10of that. And so by proxy, if you can have
- 1:00:15a different form of currency or value required for the thing
- 1:00:20that everything's a derivative of like petroleum across
- 1:00:23everything globally, you can actually influence downstream.
- 1:00:27Everything else and how you value the the currency there's
- 1:00:31there's a thread there and minimal fully tags I need to
- 1:00:33finish reading this book. But to to Marty's point, like
- 1:00:36all of the oil sitting in the Middle East has historically had
- 1:00:38to go into dollar before it can actually get turned into
- 1:00:41anything else. And that idea goes back to like
- 1:00:4450%. And in a future state in the
- 1:00:46Bitcoin world is half energy that goes to Bitcoin and half
- 1:00:49goes into, you know, economies to serve whatever is needed of
- 1:00:53that energy. That's how this ends up.
- 1:00:55Insults for a lot of that, like geopolitical strife.
- 1:00:58That happens right now. Yeah.
- 1:01:01And we're, you know, we're seeing the early stages of that
- 1:01:04play out, right? Like I, I've done a lot of
- 1:01:06research on what's been happening with the BRICS.
- 1:01:08And this year, this last year, BRICS went further than ever
- 1:01:13before in expanding. They added like 6 new members,
- 1:01:17the Chinese central bank signed a swap line agreement with the
- 1:01:21Saudis to the tuna for oil transports in yuan.
- 1:01:30And so that's that's a huge development and and Egypt as
- 1:01:33well issued a panda bond, which are bonds denominated in yuan.
- 1:01:38And so there's been a move across the Middle East to start
- 1:01:43to de dollarize and to remove, you know, dollar exposure from
- 1:01:48their oil trade. And it's been really interesting
- 1:01:50to see because that move alone has started to flow funds back
- 1:01:55into China. And now these companies can use
- 1:01:58yuan to buy gold on the Shanghai exchange, which is physically
- 1:02:03settled and that can push the price of gold up, which has been
- 1:02:06pulling up Western gold prices as well.
- 1:02:09I looks like my internet's a little slow, so apologies if any
- 1:02:12of that cut out, but. It's all good.
- 1:02:14I think the one stat was the, the amount that the swap swap
- 1:02:19line was, was it 10 billion, what was it?
- 1:02:2358 billion fifty I remember, yeah. 58 billion.
- 1:02:27Pretty substantial. Yeah.
- 1:02:29And that's and now you mention all that it really makes the the
- 1:02:35mainstream media narrative which has become very anti China with
- 1:02:40the TikTok ban and conversations about Chinese meddling in the US
- 1:02:49are picking up steam. And I wonder if that's just an
- 1:02:53externality of the situation you're describing between the
- 1:02:57bricks where the American government and the intelligence
- 1:03:02apparatus and the military industrial apparatus sees these
- 1:03:05economic moves that China's making and is lately retaliating
- 1:03:10in other ways. Whether it's a TikTok ban or I
- 1:03:13saw that they're looking to sanction some banks as well,
- 1:03:18which is just like, hey, don't do that, we'll cut your
- 1:03:22companies out of the US. What was the thing it's kind of
- 1:03:28on that thread of like I forgot who shared with Russia and like
- 1:03:32they took the top ten company like assets.
- 1:03:35It was an American company it was like a tit for tat for the
- 1:03:38the treasury for the the treasury sanctions or or taking
- 1:03:43their their their bonds. It was in, I don't know if Marty
- 1:03:48you shared it but there was a top ten I want to say like wheat
- 1:03:52producer, US based firm in Russia that the Russian
- 1:03:56government effectively like sees and said like hey this is ours
- 1:04:00now from I forgot where it was. But from a geopolitical
- 1:04:05perspective, this whole notion of, like the idea that, you
- 1:04:09know, with global politics and having a country's assets sit in
- 1:04:13a different form, region like China and it's the US base or
- 1:04:17like TikTok, Now this whole thing is like up for grabs for
- 1:04:21like what is actually owned, IE, you know, treasury bonds.
- 1:04:28Yeah, it's really sad too. Just think about it.
- 1:04:31I mean, I don't want to come off like an idealist hippie, but
- 1:04:36like, we should live in a world where Russia can produce their
- 1:04:38gas, their wheat, whatever. China can produce their cheap
- 1:04:41goods and we're able to trade freely.
- 1:04:45We shouldn't have all this xenophobic posturing in terms of
- 1:04:52like we need to cut this company out of this country and that
- 1:04:55company out of that country. You should be able to trade
- 1:04:59division of Labor globally, produce your own goods, sell to
- 1:05:02the world. Again, sorry if I'm coming off
- 1:05:05like a hippie, but I think the governments have, they're
- 1:05:09really, they're in this Dick measuring contest for control of
- 1:05:13the global monetary system. And it it leads to all this
- 1:05:17strife and potentially unnecessary conflict.
- 1:05:23Yeah, 'cause that in the Bitcoin mining industry, I mean, we work
- 1:05:27just naturally with a lot of Chinese people.
- 1:05:30And from what I've observed, like, the Chinese miners are
- 1:05:35arguably like the most capitalistic individuals within
- 1:05:38the Bitcoin space, bar none. And it's extremely impressive
- 1:05:42what they've been able to do over the last 15 years.
- 1:05:44And I don't know, I personally admire what they've been able to
- 1:05:49do and and how they operate. It's just weird that the
- 1:05:54American government wants me to hate these people.
- 1:05:58Yeah, I I think that a lot of this comes from you know the out
- 1:06:03the outcome of of there being centralized global reserve
- 1:06:06currencies that are Fiat based, right.
- 1:06:08Because this is and Triffin pointed this out, Robert Triffin
- 1:06:12an economist pointed this out in in 1960 in an address to
- 1:06:14Congress that you know we we had a dilemma where we could either
- 1:06:19continue to run current account deficits and they got more money
- 1:06:22into the world to fund global trade.
- 1:06:24But that would bury us in debt and cause a an eventual crisis
- 1:06:28and eventually cause us to lose our global reserve currency and
- 1:06:32break the gold peg. Or we could not do those fund
- 1:06:36those deficits. We could not send out money to
- 1:06:38the global economy on net. And then that would mean that
- 1:06:41the global economy would stop because there wouldn't be enough
- 1:06:43dollars to fund global trade and to settle that and for currency
- 1:06:47reserves for central foreign central banks.
- 1:06:50And so the the US obviously has a huge incentive to maintain the
- 1:06:55hegemony and to maintain the dollar system working as it does
- 1:06:58today. And bricks obviously now is is
- 1:07:01making moves to try to counteract that and to create a
- 1:07:04bricks currency. But you know, Brent Johnson
- 1:07:07points, points this out wonderfully like if you don't
- 1:07:09trust the dollar, how much less can you trust China and Russia
- 1:07:13and India, their currency. Yeah it's it's, it's ridiculous.
- 1:07:18And that's why it's so funny to me that they don't see Bitcoin
- 1:07:21as a solution yet. Because Bitcoin as a non
- 1:07:24centrally issued currency, right, a decentralized currency.
- 1:07:27It doesn't. Trifa's dilemma doesn't apply.
- 1:07:30It solves the dilemma. It doesn't have the issue of of
- 1:07:33external demand versus internal supply.
- 1:07:35And so once you adopt Bitcoin as a as the neutral global monetary
- 1:07:41asset, you don't have to worry about these issues about, you
- 1:07:44know, currency blowouts or you know, one country having too
- 1:07:48much of A current account deficit because all of it
- 1:07:50becomes self settling. Just like it was in the 1800s.
- 1:07:53When if a country does has too much deficits and too much
- 1:07:56inflation, their currency will devalue and gold will flow out
- 1:08:00of that country until they raise rates and have enough deflation
- 1:08:03to pull it back in. And so that the same thing could
- 1:08:06happen on a Bitcoin standard. And so it's I'm I'm excited to
- 1:08:11see which country will start being the first one to stack
- 1:08:14Bitcoin on the balance sheet. I know sounds like El Salvador
- 1:08:17already has some, you know, I think is it the Central African
- 1:08:20Republic of the Congo or Central what?
- 1:08:23There's a small culture in Africa that that it does as
- 1:08:25well. Butan has it in the sovereign
- 1:08:28wealth fund. The Central African Republic
- 1:08:33kind of went down the shit coin path real quick after they
- 1:08:36embraced Bitcoin. That's not reliable anymore.
- 1:08:41No, but it's, I mean, it makes sense that the bricks would do
- 1:08:45this. I mean, they've just watched the
- 1:08:46United States dominate the world over the last 50 years because
- 1:08:51they had control of the global reserve currency.
- 1:08:53And you can see why they would want to have similar control
- 1:08:59moving forward. I mean, it's very alluring.
- 1:09:03Being able to control the levers of the global monetary system,
- 1:09:05but as you mentioned, like to think they're gonna be able to
- 1:09:09competently manage a Fiat monetary system is laughable.
- 1:09:13They should all just stop the Bitcoin standard as quickly as.
- 1:09:15Possible Marty. To your point earlier, like
- 1:09:19everyone's searching for a reliable neutral reserve asset.
- 1:09:23They can, they can trust and and the bricks won't just won't be
- 1:09:26able to offer that, the reliability portion of it being
- 1:09:31insufficient I think. But everyone's searching for a
- 1:09:35neutral reserve asset and the energy industry more than
- 1:09:38anyone. And you know that there's
- 1:09:44there's a a give and take where the energy industry like blesses
- 1:09:48a certain currency as like OK, we're going to do trade in this
- 1:09:51currency and then that becomes the single biggest like like you
- 1:09:57know weight on the scale of of what's going to become the
- 1:10:00global reserve currency for that period, that era.
- 1:10:03And obviously the US the, the thing that can the feedback loop
- 1:10:07is, is force, right. So you if you have the strongest
- 1:10:11military you can impose that, all right we're going to use our
- 1:10:15currency to to settle energy trade and then that helps that
- 1:10:20currency become the reserve currency for the world and
- 1:10:23that's what we we saw over the last half century.
- 1:10:27But the energy industry is constantly searching for, you
- 1:10:30know, the best currency for them to use, a neutral reserve
- 1:10:34currency that they can settle in.
- 1:10:36And and the way that Bitcoin integrates with the energy
- 1:10:40industry makes it sort of inevitable that it's, it's
- 1:10:43energy money, it's it's rooted in the energy industry.
- 1:10:48And that eventually will mean the energy industry increasingly
- 1:10:53putting their chips on that currency, this new upstart
- 1:10:58currency and eventually the the, you know, the weight that they
- 1:11:02have on the scales on the side of the US dollar will shift to
- 1:11:05Bitcoin. And you know, you've got the
- 1:11:07vote of confidence of the the biggest industry in the world
- 1:11:12that's going to move the needle more than anything else could
- 1:11:16towards global, global reserve currency status for Bitcoin.
- 1:11:24Yeah. I completely agree it.
- 1:11:28It's like a flywheel effect, right?
- 1:11:30Like once you get and I think I talked to, I was on Oh no, I cut
- 1:11:40out again. We just.
- 1:11:41Launched the last five seconds. OK.
- 1:11:45You talk to somebody. Dang, it's sorry about this
- 1:11:49Internet problem. It's Wi-Fi here in Columbia spot
- 1:11:53even though I'm in a Co working spot and paying for premium.
- 1:11:55But yeah, no, I think I was talking to you about this,
- 1:11:59Marty, on our podcast last year that, you know, it's a flywheel
- 1:12:03effect Where once you get a few countries accepting Bitcoin,
- 1:12:06especially like what you said, Jesse, accepting Bitcoin as
- 1:12:09payment for energy, then other countries will suddenly have a
- 1:12:12need to have it in their treasury.
- 1:12:14And other businesses will need, need to have in their treasury.
- 1:12:16And they'll have to all scramble to rush and buy Bitcoin and
- 1:12:20it'll just drag in more and more countries and then see a super
- 1:12:26majority of countries needing and owning and trading Bitcoin
- 1:12:30for their energy and and their financial needs right to settle
- 1:12:35energy trade. You know it's.
- 1:12:38Yeah. So I was just saying, you know
- 1:12:40what's so exciting is that like thought or that notion would
- 1:12:43seem so insane. But it's it's going to happen in
- 1:12:47like just by what we just saw with like Hong Kong and the ETFs
- 1:12:51in the West. Like that idea would have been
- 1:12:54crazy years ago and it's about to happen gold competition for
- 1:12:57the asset and so it's already there it's like it's just how
- 1:13:01and it's I don't even think it's years from now it's just a few
- 1:13:03you know whether it's 6121824 months for this all to start.
- 1:13:07Happening. What it really is, is it's a
- 1:13:09liquidity problem. So I've talked to Anas El Haji a
- 1:13:12lot about this over the years, who's an oil and gas expert,
- 1:13:15really understands the international oil and gas
- 1:13:18markets intuitively. And I brought this up to him
- 1:13:22because it makes a lot of sense. It's this apolitical settlement
- 1:13:25layer that people should be doing trades in, and he brought
- 1:13:28up a good point. It's just a liquidity problem at
- 1:13:30this, this point. If you wanted to do large
- 1:13:32international oil trades using Bitcoin, the the liquidity
- 1:13:37profile simply isn't up the snuff yet.
- 1:13:39So maybe when we get to a 5-10 trillion dollar market it makes
- 1:13:43a lot more sense. But yeah, I think that will come
- 1:13:46whether or not it's in two 5-10 years, whatever it may be.
- 1:13:49It's just the timing of how quickly can Bitcoin developed
- 1:13:52the liquidity profile that would be necessary to facilitate these
- 1:13:55trades and this apolitical settlement layer.
- 1:13:59It's just like the first part of that like when you think of this
- 1:14:05the asset like it's a great asset to do these trades and
- 1:14:08then you think of the tech of it like again on Ramp's working on
- 1:14:11like multi sig escrow, like you can really innovate when it
- 1:14:15comes to credit lines for these large trades.
- 1:14:18You put Bitcoin in a in a multi sig with three different parties
- 1:14:23that have different incentives within that trade, 2
- 1:14:26counterparties in the trade and an impartial third party to
- 1:14:29release the funds when the goods have been delivered.
- 1:14:31Like that creates capital efficiencies that simply don't
- 1:14:35exist are impossible today. So the benefits of doing this
- 1:14:39over Bitcoin are are multifaceted.
- 1:14:43Yeah, I mean that's the thing that from the miners hearing
- 1:14:46about how people bought miners for years and just somebody
- 1:14:49sends a wire and they hope to go or Bitcoin and they hope to God
- 1:14:52they show up. Been thinking about it about
- 1:14:54like this idea of multi sig and escrow and it's actually, if you
- 1:14:58think about it, it's a problem that exists in everything
- 1:15:00specifically even in Bitcoin buys right now somebody has to
- 1:15:03send the dollars and somebody has to send the Bitcoin.
- 1:15:05And as we if we're in a bull market for trust breaking down,
- 1:15:09you're going to have to have other trust minimized ways to
- 1:15:11deliver goods and services, IEA billion dollar oil tanker or a
- 1:15:16billion dollars of Bitcoin for whatever unit you're buying,
- 1:15:18whether it's gold. And so the natural like multi 6
- 1:15:21properties were just in the first early innings of that.
- 1:15:24The I think Marty, I think the liquidity is like 1 aspect of
- 1:15:28it. I think it's the education as
- 1:15:30well, right. Like the idea is because you can
- 1:15:32say. Education.
- 1:15:32Education begets liquidity right?
- 1:15:34As people become more educated, like I need Bitcoin, they dump
- 1:15:37their money into it and liquidity comes well.
- 1:15:40I guess the other side is because you could settle $10
- 1:15:41million or $100 million for oil or even potentially a billion
- 1:15:44with what we know a Tesla coming in and and the liquidity was
- 1:15:47there. I mean more of like just the
- 1:15:49fact that you can trust a multi sig and understand it because
- 1:15:52the other side of this is like everything BlackRock and all the
- 1:15:56token eyes and all the crap that's coming.
- 1:15:58It's like the game's not going to be as easy as convincing
- 1:16:00everybody Bitcoin's the thing because everybody else is going
- 1:16:02to go shill everything else under the sun that's crypto or
- 1:16:05blockchain related and it's going to just like obfuscate
- 1:16:08what's actually happening. So we're just going to it's it's
- 1:16:10going to be a, it's going to be a cat and mouse game of like
- 1:16:13just people getting rugged on a geopolitical scale.
- 1:16:17This panel I was on last Thursday unfortunately leads me
- 1:16:22to believe we're not getting away from the stuff anytime
- 1:16:23soon. But if you're out there and
- 1:16:28you're in the International Energy trading markets, don't
- 1:16:31fall for the token. You don't need to tokenize your
- 1:16:33barrels of oil or your units of natural gas or your LNG.
- 1:16:38You simply, you do your work. You you extract the the energy,
- 1:16:44you package it up, you put it on a ship, you deliver it.
- 1:16:48You don't need to tokenize. You just put Bitcoin in a multi
- 1:16:50sig escrow. You deliver the goods.
- 1:16:52Your counterparty puts Bitcoin in a multi sig escrow.
- 1:16:55You deliver the goods and you get the money.
- 1:16:57It's very simple. Don't complicate it.
- 1:16:59You don't need to tokenize everything.
- 1:17:00You don't need to take on all that compliance and tech costs
- 1:17:04that come with trying to tokenize the world.
- 1:17:06It's simple. Do your thing in the physical
- 1:17:08world, deliver your goods and you'll get the Bitcoin.
- 1:17:11You don't need to do anything else.
- 1:17:14We're going to have like 5 years of rugging.
- 1:17:15If you think about the past five years of FTX, it's going to be
- 1:17:18that, like Ted act in what you're describing.
- 1:17:20Because it's just not how do you extract rent from that system.
- 1:17:24You got to build a bunch of wallets and, you know, smart
- 1:17:29contracts. And you had a tweet yesterday
- 1:17:32about like the fire in India. Was it like one of the carbon
- 1:17:35credits to offset that fire? They're literally.
- 1:17:40I think it's emitting. It's very ironic too.
- 1:17:43I found out today that that fire was started by a lithium iron
- 1:17:46ion battery. That was sort of ours though.
- 1:17:49And and yeah, I I think that thing's emitting more methane
- 1:17:55than in like an hour than the UK does in a year right now.
- 1:17:59And apparently it's not going to stop burning anytime soon, so.
- 1:18:03Yeah, This is why the whole BlackRock thing was always
- 1:18:06worrisome for me. It's like the, you know more.
- 1:18:08We've been talking about it for over a year.
- 1:18:10It's like this slow drum beat of securitization and digitization
- 1:18:14of all assets is like permeating traditional finance and it's
- 1:18:18only going to continue and Blackrock's going to lead the
- 1:18:20charge and it's just going to completely obfuscate like what
- 1:18:22is Bitcoin, What's exposure to Bitcoin?
- 1:18:24What are all the things around it?
- 1:18:26So I'm just going to see all the.
- 1:18:28It's coming from all sides. That's the Tradfi thesis, this
- 1:18:32cycle. And then this panel I was on,
- 1:18:34somebody was seriously shilling meme coins, replacing social
- 1:18:38media. This is the future of social
- 1:18:40medias, meme coins, and. There's a they conflate like the
- 1:18:46bureaucracy and the muckiness that exists in the traditional
- 1:18:49world. And so they believe like a
- 1:18:50blockchain fixes it. It's like they're they're miss
- 1:18:52missing, like the forest of the trees, like what's actually
- 1:18:56fucked up because like directionally they know
- 1:18:58something's wrong. So they're assuming like you
- 1:19:00need a blockchain to fix. This stuff again?
- 1:19:03Anybody listening what? What's been fucked up is capital
- 1:19:06markets. They fucked up capital markets
- 1:19:08cause the capital underlying those markets is not real.
- 1:19:11It's fake money. You just need to fix the capital
- 1:19:14markets with good money and then you keep doing what you're doing
- 1:19:16in the physical world. You don't need to tokenize and
- 1:19:18digitize everything. The the the thread or narrative
- 1:19:23we have to hammer on is Bitcoin is money and everything else is
- 1:19:25credit. So if you want the money and you
- 1:19:28take, you hold the Bitcoin, if you want to claim on some other
- 1:19:30crap, then you can have the token or whatever that's out
- 1:19:32there. It's just.
- 1:19:33It's very simple. Don't overthink this.
- 1:19:35Don't overthink this. It's Bitcoin is the great de
- 1:19:38financialization. Yeah.
- 1:19:42And that's actually what we want, right.
- 1:19:44We don't want things to be over financialized.
- 1:19:46We don't want things to be over overly overly leveraged, overly
- 1:19:50traded, right. We don't want, you know, 200
- 1:19:53times the gold mining production in the world being traded every
- 1:19:57year. We want things.
- 1:19:59We want markets to be real and to be based in reality.
- 1:20:01And so by going back to the Bitcoin standard or sound money
- 1:20:05standard, that will fix this underlying issue.
- 1:20:08And it's not even to mention right like on the blockchain
- 1:20:10point blockchains. People think that blockchains
- 1:20:13are like. The silver bullet that will
- 1:20:15solve every single problem. You could throw it at anything
- 1:20:17and it will make it better, right?
- 1:20:19Oh, if I have cancer, if I have a blockchain token, it'll, it'll
- 1:20:21cure me, right? And that's completely
- 1:20:24ridiculous, because blockchain's, you know, it's
- 1:20:27kind of like a tank, right? It's a really specialized tool
- 1:20:30that can do one thing really well.
- 1:20:32But you wouldn't want to drive a tank, you know, to work every
- 1:20:35day. And you wouldn't want to use it
- 1:20:37to do a road trip or to pick up your grandma.
- 1:20:39And so if you're going to use a blockchain, you have to know
- 1:20:43that you're giving off, you have massive trade-offs and you're
- 1:20:47optimizing for, you know, one or two things, which is
- 1:20:50decentralization and security. And so if you want to optimize
- 1:20:53for that, then you can use a blockchain.
- 1:20:54But all these tokens that they claim that they can do
- 1:20:57everything right, they have more throughput than Visa and they
- 1:21:00have more a faster finality than Bitcoin and better throughput
- 1:21:05than ETH. And you know, it's just it's
- 1:21:07just ludicrous. Like Solana is a good example.
- 1:21:10Solana I think has, I think I remember reading that Solana had
- 1:21:13like a block time of like 200 milliseconds and they said
- 1:21:18basically like that means no, but like 85% of the world
- 1:21:22doesn't have an Internet, Internet speed fast enough to to
- 1:21:26finalize transactions in the Solana blockchain.
- 1:21:29And the only ones who can do it are software engineers sitting
- 1:21:32at data centers in at Google or Facebook or Amazon, right?
- 1:21:37You have a super fast Internet speed to do it, and so you're
- 1:21:40giving off those trade-offs. Yeah, yeah, it's block chains
- 1:21:48only. I mean, we can get into block
- 1:21:51chains only work too. They're slow, dumb.
- 1:21:53I mean, the ones that matter are slow, dumb, and specialized, and
- 1:21:57they're only incentivized via hard money.
- 1:22:00Like it only works block production.
- 1:22:03The blockchain only grows if miners are incentivized to keep
- 1:22:08it growing and to validate and process transactions.
- 1:22:12And you need a scarce token, a good money, to incentivize that.
- 1:22:16And it's Bitcoin. Once you have that, everything
- 1:22:19else is competing with Bitcoin, and it's far, far inferior
- 1:22:25monetary properties compared to Bitcoin.
- 1:22:26So it doesn't even make sense trying to spin up another
- 1:22:28blockchain. And yet we're gonna have to.
- 1:22:34Live through it. Yeah, you need the implicit link
- 1:22:37to the real world, which Bitcoin has through its connection to
- 1:22:41the to energy production. But you need you.
- 1:22:47You need there to not be an explicit link to the real world.
- 1:22:50Like all these tokenized real world asset of bullshit that
- 1:22:54fundamentally like you can't put a a real world asset on the
- 1:22:58blockchain because at the end of the day there's a link between
- 1:23:02that blockchain and the real world that is just enforced by
- 1:23:06law. Yeah, you put a Pepsi on the
- 1:23:09blockchain and you go to the vending machine.
- 1:23:11You buy your Pepsi, you own it on the blockchain.
- 1:23:15But if I come and I rip it out of your hand and drink it, that
- 1:23:17was my Pepsi. You need to not have an explicit
- 1:23:22link, but you also need to have the implicit link, so it's a.
- 1:23:25It's a funny thing that people have not yet wrapped their heads
- 1:23:28around. Gentlemen, this would be great.
- 1:23:31I know you gotta run, Michael. Michael's gotta go Take the tank
- 1:23:35to pick up grandma. Ravine.
- 1:23:40Bull Any? Any final thoughts before we
- 1:23:42wrap up here? No, nothing.
- 1:23:45Nothing huge. Thanks for inviting me on.
- 1:23:49I'm pretty active on Twitter and I have my sub stack, so if
- 1:23:52people want to read more about macro stuff you can go and sub
- 1:23:55there. I'm gonna try to make it to the
- 1:23:57Bitcoin conference and so if you guys are going to be there let
- 1:24:00me know. I'll definitely be down to meet
- 1:24:02up and talk and hopefully I can squeeze into to have a speech.
- 1:24:08We'll see. I I was able to do that at the
- 1:24:09Adopting Bitcoin conference which was a great time and and
- 1:24:12hopefully I'll be able to do that again.
- 1:24:14So we'll see. Hell yeah.
- 1:24:16It sounds like Marty's having a big event in the conference.
- 1:24:19You want to, You want to show the event?
- 1:24:20Just heard about that. Well, Pub Key and Rabbit Hole
- 1:24:23Recap teamed up to do a live event Thursday, I believe the
- 1:24:2825th of July. The name of the venue is
- 1:24:32escaping me, but we're going to do live shows. 600 tickets.
- 1:24:35Not on sale yet, but we'll keep you guys updated.
- 1:24:38Is it on a rooftop or? No, not this time.
- 1:24:41It's it's in a venue that's. Upgrade I guess.
- 1:24:47Less or more than 100K by conference.
- 1:24:51I'm not doing supposed by conference day.
- 1:24:54That meme? It's Haunted Rabbit Hole Recap
- 1:24:57Matt specifically in the past. I'm not going to make the same
- 1:25:00mistake that he made, but 150K. Awesome.
- 1:25:07We appreciate you coming on proving.
- 1:25:09Hopefully we can. We'll see you in the States at
- 1:25:11some point this year. Absolutely thanks for inviting
- 1:25:14me on. Yeah.
- 1:25:15Thanks for coming. Thanks guys.
- 1:25:17See you guys next week.