Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Trump’s Workforce Cuts Hit NCUA: What’s Changing - What’s Next -Special Edition
Transcript
- 0:01Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04Are you going to need a hard hat in your credit union because
- 0:07of the NCA reorganization?
- 0:09Or is NCA staff gonna need a hard hat or should I just take this hard hat off?
- 0:15Well, I'm gonna probably talk through a few of those things.
- 0:18By the way, I got this hard hat when a staff member who shall Rena.
- 0:23May who shall remain nameless gave this to me.
- 0:27After we got through a particularly rough budget process with the NCA
- 0:31Board, I came into work one day and I had this on my on my chair, and it's
- 0:36one of my prize possessions for my time at NCA as executive Director.
- 0:40All right, so you can take me seriously.
- 0:42I'm going to take this hat off.
- 0:45And we'll set it down over there.
- 0:46By the way, if you're listening on the podcast, you're saying what hat
- 0:49This is also going onto YouTube, and this is a special edition episode
- 0:54based on what NCUA just communicated.
- 0:57Kyle Halman, Larry fao, and one of Larry's staff members, Amanda Parkhill
- 1:03had discussions about the NCUA buyout program, which was driven by President
- 1:09Trump and initiatives to have a downsize in force, a reduction in force at federal
- 1:16agencies, and they walk through all that.
- 1:17And I'm going to walk through a highlight version of what it means for
- 1:21credit unions, what it means for NCA.
- 1:23I'm gonna follow that up.
- 1:25A couple additional podcasts, and I'll talk through that here at
- 1:28the end, and you can expect them.
- 1:31To come out in the next couple of Tuesdays.
- 1:33As a reminder most new episodes come out Tuesdays, Thursdays.
- 1:38We have our Evergreen episodes, which are topics that that live forever that
- 1:44may have a new intro to them because they of things that we're seeing in
- 1:49credit unions with our clients in our conversations, et cetera, et.
- 1:52Et cetera, et cetera.
- 1:54So without further ado let's talk a little bit about what happened
- 1:57at NCUA at the board meeting today.
- 1:59And I'm calling this podcast Trump's Workforce Cuts hit NCUA.
- 2:04What's changing and what's next?
- 2:06As a result of President Trump Executive Order, 1, 4, 2, 1, 0, federal agencies
- 2:12were being pushed and are being pushed to downsize and streamline.
- 2:16They offered the buyout program, the buyout.
- 2:19Program has closed for 99% of those who accepted it.
- 2:23And they have some near final stats that I'm gonna walk through here.
- 2:26NCA was striving to AEA achieve a 20% headcount.
- 2:30Headcount cut by the end of the year, and why by the end of the year, 'cause
- 2:35the Trump initiatives were to get to a certain size by the end of the year.
- 2:40It's married to the Trump anticipation, so that would be about 250 people.
- 2:46Out of the 1200 employees that were in the budget for NCUA for the year it's
- 2:52it's been reported here and elsewhere that they've been very successful
- 2:54with the programs that they have.
- 2:56Number two.
- 2:57A point I wanna make is that the, these are not layoffs.
- 3:00They did not have to go to an official reduction in force.
- 3:03Why is that?
- 3:04Because the voluntary programs were so well received by
- 3:07staff for whatever reason.
- 3:09It could have been because of the money, could have been because of the volume
- 3:13of people that NCA has who is ready to retire or eligible for early retirement.
- 3:17But in any event, because NCUA is a.
- 3:21Independent agency, LL some, although some would argue that independence is being
- 3:25challenged by the Trump administration because they're independent, they have
- 3:29more powers to pay higher amounts, and they were able to offer $50,000 lump sums
- 3:35for those people who agreed to sign away their career, sign away that they would be
- 3:39retiring early or by the end of the year.
- 3:42It's voluntary.
- 3:43No one was forced out.
- 3:44That's a good thing.
- 3:45That's a good thing for everybody.
- 3:47The target was met and then some, the they've got several different
- 3:51acronyms for what they did.
- 3:52I'm not gonna get into those details here.
- 3:54But their goal was to get about 225, as I mentioned, 250, excuse me.
- 4:02Their goal was to get 217 participants, but actually they had 297 that took it.
- 4:10The central office.
- 4:12And by the way, after.
- 4:14Rescissions after people who took it and then decided later
- 4:19that they wanted to stay.
- 4:20They're expecting about 250 to be gone.
- 4:24There were net 257 that took it.
- 4:27There's 14 that still are within their window for.
- 4:30Deciding that they want to pull it back.
- 4:32So in the end there will be between 243 and 257 NCA staff that take it.
- 4:40There was a stronger participation by those in the central office
- 4:44versus those in the regions or ones.
- 4:46Again, ones is the Office of National Examined Supervision, regions plus
- 4:50ones is what is known as the field.
- 4:52Central office is what you would call generally mission support.
- 4:56Although the office of examination of insurance, you
- 4:58could argue goes both ways, but.
- 5:0130% of the folks that were in the central office.
- 5:04So that could be attorneys, that could be the office of cure,
- 5:07where field membership is done.
- 5:09That could be human resources, that could be the office of the executive director.
- 5:1330% of staff took it at that level, 20% of the field took it.
- 5:18And you could argue that's because there's more senior people in the
- 5:22central office, which is what.
- 5:24What they said was the case.
- 5:26The, for whatever reason is generally going to be a good thing because they've
- 5:31built up the central office over time and those central office positions are
- 5:36not what you'd, I don't wanna say they're not productive because I fully believe
- 5:40in mission support, but those hours do not directly get spent in credit unions.
- 5:45To do exams, and that's where it impacts credit unions.
- 5:49These people going away, these 20%, they're not gonna be the new folks.
- 5:52They're not gonna be the people that have been here 10 years.
- 5:54They're not gonna be the people that have been here 15 years, not gonna
- 5:57be the people that are 20 or 23.
- 5:59There were stories of that.
- 6:00I heard of people who wanted to be part of the early buyout but couldn't because
- 6:04they didn't have the 25 years in too.
- 6:06Do early retirement.
- 6:07And by the way, when they do early retirement, they take a big
- 6:10hit on what their retirement is.
- 6:12But some people may have been financially positioned, some people thought, Hey,
- 6:16I'll take this 50 K kicker and I got a job offer that I can go do something else.
- 6:2030% of central office folks left 20% in the regions short term.
- 6:25That's a good thing.
- 6:26Long term, that's probably, it's probably better if you're gonna lose some
- 6:28people in the central office, although I did hear they lost all of their
- 6:32human resource supervisors and who's going to process all this paperwork?
- 6:36You might say if all those folks are gonna be leaving and some of 'em have already
- 6:39left there are going to be situations.
- 6:41And NCA talked about the fact that some places were hit harder
- 6:44and they're working around that.
- 6:45They didn't go into the specifics.
- 6:47And I'll talk about a little bit of that down the road in another podcast.
- 6:52Okay, so they hit their target and then some central office took the biggest hit.
- 6:56There was some discussion around the hiring freeze that Trump put
- 6:58in place being until at least July 15th, emphasis on July 15th at least.
- 7:04Because once you hit that point in time and by the way, last Trump
- 7:08administration, they indicated, and I believe this is true, that the
- 7:12hiring freeze lasted about a year.
- 7:14Under the hiring freeze, assuming they don't extend it, you can only replace
- 7:19for every Ford jobs that went away.
- 7:23You can only hire one now that, the problem with saying, okay, they can
- 7:29start hiring and filling positions in July, is that most of these people are
- 7:33on the rolls until the end of the year.
- 7:35That in order to entice people to leave, they said, we will pay
- 7:38you till the end of the year.
- 7:39If you leave, you can just go on leave.
- 7:42If you stay, we'll give you a 50% bonus in your pay.
- 7:45So you're essentially making 50% of what you could to work, but you're
- 7:48getting paid one and a half times.
- 7:50So they can build up some cash and cash prizes and they can't really replace any
- 7:55of these folks until the end of the year.
- 7:58Now I did a previous post or podcast where I showed you there are no
- 8:01federal jobs out on USA jobs.gov,
- 8:04which is where everybody posts them.
- 8:06It's a long tail to get those.
- 8:08People up and hired.
- 8:09So hopefully at some juncture they're able to say, okay, we get to October, November.
- 8:14The Trump administration says, yes, you can start hiring for next year,
- 8:17and they can start gearing up.
- 8:19One of the challenges they'll have is they don't have a lot of people in HR right
- 8:22now, so it's gonna be a bumpy road, and that's where the that's where the hard hat
- 8:27could be a problem for some folks at NCUA.
- 8:29All right.
- 8:30I think it'll be less so at n for the credit unions, but you will
- 8:32feel it and we'll get into that in.
- 8:35Perhaps another episode that's coming out.
- 8:37Alright, so that gets me to the internal realignment that's coming.
- 8:42There's a lot of verbiage that I've gone through and come up with.
- 8:45They talking about potentially streamlining operations alluding to fewer
- 8:49departments, saying that there, at the time there were 23 department heads.
- 8:53What does that mean?
- 8:54That some of them have left?
- 8:55Yes.
- 8:56But I also think it means that they're going to be shrinking.
- 8:58Some departments, and I'm going to save my details relative to
- 9:01that, to another episode that will be coming out specifically on.
- 9:05The shrinkage at NCUA and the reconfiguring at NCUA.
- 9:11I'm gonna apply what I know for my 34 years at NCUA, my 10 years in the office
- 9:16of the executive director, seven of which as executive director working directly
- 9:20for the NCA board, and I'll walk through.
- 9:22How I think they might realign.
- 9:23'cause there's some pretty obvious things that I would do if I was there.
- 9:26And I will probably come up with a a flow chart, a org chart of what I think
- 9:32NCUA should look like moving forward based on what they are planning on doing.
- 9:36They also, it talked about exam cycles being extended
- 9:39for cr strong credit unions.
- 9:41Talked about what, the timeline for the billion dollar to $15
- 9:44billion credit unions that those can now be stretched up to.
- 9:47Up to every 20 months, smaller credit unions.
- 9:50So smaller being under a billion could be between 14 and 24 months.
- 9:54And they talked about how that's driven by Camel, how that's
- 9:59driven by management consistency.
- 10:01They made reference to one of their websites on the exam flexibility
- 10:05program, which I want to go do some research on, and I thought, I heard
- 10:09them say that if you're a Camel Three or Newly Chartered, that you'll
- 10:12see us every eight to 12 months.
- 10:14That's different.
- 10:14It used to be six months that you had to have an examination, a
- 10:18follow-up examination at a code three.
- 10:20It's quite possible that they're, they put that in there.
- 10:24Only relative to full exams because camel threes, fours and fives are
- 10:27gonna get them more frequently.
- 10:29Frequently.
- 10:29But I'm going to be watching what's going to happen to Camel code threes 'cause
- 10:33I'll be very surprised if they don't try and keep those on a six month cycle.
- 10:36'cause if they don't, that will lead to bigger losses in credit unions.
- 10:42And oh, by the way in the earlier briefing they talked about the insurance fund.
- 10:46I will have a separate.
- 10:48Podcast on that.
- 10:50They've changed their, they're very excited about their new dashboard.
- 10:54The public can't see all of the dashboard yet.
- 10:57I'm going to look at the old PowerPoints they did and how much they revealed
- 11:02about camel codes and see if they're being as transparent as they used to be.
- 11:06I don't know the answer to that because they only had two sentences
- 11:09on Camel Threes going down.
- 11:11No references to four or five.
- 11:13They quickly showed the screen on the camels, which would've had
- 11:17some detail about fours and fives.
- 11:19I want to dig into that and I'll have a podcast relative to that to see
- 11:23if I believe that their transparency has stayed the same, gotten worse or
- 11:26gotten better, but stay tuned for that.
- 11:28That'll be a separate podcast coming out as well.
- 11:31They also talked about budget savings of 75 million in 2026, so again.
- 11:37N NCAA's budget will be tight this year, and that's because they're
- 11:40paying 50 k roughly to everybody who is going away as a lovely parting gift.
- 11:45And I say that tongue in cheek.
- 11:46To encourage someone to leave because of the safety of of their government job.
- 11:51They needed to entice 'em.
- 11:53So I'm it's a little tongue in cheek hey, if you're an NCOA staffer listening
- 11:56to this no, ill will makes sense that they gave you a decent amount
- 11:59of money to make a decision to leave.
- 12:02Et cetera, et cetera.
- 12:03But $75 million in savings anticipated in 2026.
- 12:08That would be salary, that would be benefits, that would be payments
- 12:11they make to OPM for those benefits that would be travel related to
- 12:14those people who are no longer going to be there, et cetera, et cetera.
- 12:17And they talked about the fact that they will take some of that
- 12:20money, improve their technology.
- 12:22They talked about the fact that they would be.
- 12:24Using that technology to do exams in better ways.
- 12:27They talked about that some of that money will go back to credit unions in
- 12:31a reduced operating fee, which is good.
- 12:33But again, as I always, I.
- 12:35Like to say, and it's something NCA never really talked about.
- 12:38The cost of the NCA program on a credit union's budget is essentially
- 12:42a little bit less than what credit unions do to train their staff
- 12:46to go to CUNA meetings, America's credit unions, et cetera, et cetera.
- 12:50And so it's really not all that material even though the trades like to make
- 12:53it a big deal, but it is saving.
- 12:55So I don't wanna discount that as well.
- 12:57And if you're a credit union that would lose money.
- 12:59If but for a reduced, and so a budget, I'm sure you'd rather make money and
- 13:04save a few thousand dollars depending on where you're at in the cascade
- 13:07of assets and the costs of all that.
- 13:09So there was a quote about Less with less, not more, with less.
- 13:12He's, he helpmann, said, we're not gonna do more with, we're not gonna
- 13:15cut, have less and be able to do more.
- 13:17That's a nonsense type statement.
- 13:19So that's, it's good that they have that reality, but they're re.
- 13:22Rethinking processes.
- 13:24They imply that they've got a good lot of good suggestions from NCOA and they
- 13:28joke that one of the things that they, one of the suggestions from NCA staff
- 13:31that they would not be taking was to have the thermostat at 78 in August.
- 13:36Little bit of tongue and cheek there.
- 13:37They got a good laugh about that.
- 13:39And what else?
- 13:40Tech and talent and tech and talent investments are coming.
- 13:43They implied that they're gonna have better technology and that they're
- 13:46gonna do hiring and that they're gonna fill some critical roles.
- 13:49They talked about, and I've posted on LinkedIn a little bit,
- 13:52inwe will rise to the occasion.
- 13:54They are losing a lot of really talented people because if you're
- 13:58eligible to retire, you've been there a long time and they're, they've
- 14:01made reference to executives I know.
- 14:03I've had conversations with some executives who I know are
- 14:05leaving, some I know are staying.
- 14:07I don't wanna get into specifics here but they're losing a lot
- 14:10of really talented people.
- 14:11Let's just leave it at that.
- 14:13But there's people in the wings.
- 14:14I can figure out who I think might take fu future positions if I was
- 14:18still there, who I'd be saying, Hey, I think you should apply for this job.
- 14:21Not pre-selection, by the way.
- 14:23No.
- 14:23You're just encouraging people to, to participate in the
- 14:26opportunities that are here.
- 14:27And there will be people that rise to the occasion.
- 14:30We used to call that a deep selection when someone's been there a short
- 14:33time, but has a lot of opportunity.
- 14:36May not be perfectly positioned for a position yet.
- 14:39There's gonna be people that will rise to the occasion relative to that.
- 14:42Alright.
- 14:42That's it in a nutshell here on this first episode.
- 14:46Central office hit harder.
- 14:48Exams hit pretty hard.
- 14:49There's gonna be a realignment coming.
- 14:51I'll have a separate podcast on that.
- 14:53And again, I'm gonna put the hard hat back on.
- 14:57I think NCA staff should be, be prepared for some challenges,
- 15:01but they are up to the occasion.
- 15:02You don't wanna, take a blunt force trauma to the head credit unions your exam.
- 15:07You might not have the same examiner, you might not have
- 15:10the same supervisory examiner.
- 15:12But the reality is you will have an exam and if you find out that you need
- 15:16some help with that, who to reach out to you can reach out to find out how we
- 15:20help our clients save time and money.
- 15:23With NCUA so that they have a smoother exam process.
- 15:27That's it for this episode.
- 15:29I hope you have a fabulous Memorial Day weekend and that you're somewhere
- 15:34in the country where it's not raining.
- 15:36As always, I appreciate you listening.
- 15:38I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 15:40This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.