Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / A New Way to Invest: How the ALM First Loan Fund Works
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark t Trico with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I've got an exciting podcast here.
- 0:05Today we're gonna talk with two gentlemen from a LM first about their
- 0:09recent announcement and launch of a loan fund investment program under
- 0:13N NCAA's pilot program, I've got Travis Goodman and Mark Sun from a LM
- 0:18First Gentlemen, how you doing today?
- 0:20Travis: We're doing great.
- 0:21Thanks for having us.
- 0:22Mark Sun: Thank you.
- 0:23Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 0:24And give, maybe if you could give a little bit of your background, what it
- 0:27is you do with a LM first, and then we'll just dive into this exciting news that
- 0:31you announced this week or last week.
- 0:34Travis: Sure I'll jump in first.
- 0:35This is Travis Goodman.
- 0:37Been with a LM first since 2003, so just past my 23 year mark with the firm.
- 0:43And over that timeframe, I've worked with a lot of different groups within
- 0:47our company, but more specifically as our advisory services group which
- 0:50handles our client relationships.
- 0:52Then also work with our loan trading group which is where this loan fund
- 0:55ultimately sits within the firm.
- 0:57So we've been very active over the last, I would say almost 10 years or so in terms
- 1:01of trying to pair up and match buyers and sellers for loan participations.
- 1:06Which kinda a matchmaking service if you will.
- 1:09We've been working with third party origination channels.
- 1:11We do securitization advisory work for credit unions that are trying to come
- 1:14to market with large scale transactions.
- 1:17And the loan fund that we're gonna talk about today was a natural
- 1:19extension of that as we've been evolving some of these services.
- 1:22So I've worked with all of those things over the last five or six years or so.
- 1:25Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 1:26And Mark?
- 1:27Mark Sun: I'm Mark Sam.
- 1:28I'm the newbie, so he is been 20 plus years.
- 1:31I was brought on board very exciting about this new opportunity of creating a new
- 1:35loan fund on behalf of a credit union.
- 1:37So the concept itself is extremely exciting.
- 1:40So my background has been predominantly me in the institutional side.
- 1:44So I've been on the buy side, sell side with money center banks doing
- 1:48securitization product as well as about four years worth of portfolio
- 1:52management in qip style investing.
- 1:56For a small fund, roughly 300 plus million.
- 1:59And Travis saw the need for a portfolio manager with some of my experience
- 2:04going through several economic downturn.
- 2:07So I said, sounds like an interesting challenge.
- 2:09So here I am very excited to to be able to bring his concept and mind into a reality.
- 2:15So that's why we're here to talk about it.
- 2:18Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 2:19And, before we started up, we were chatting a little bit about the
- 2:22intensity of getting to the finish line and getting a product launched.
- 2:25And it reminded me of the N-N-C-A-N-G-N program and the road
- 2:28shows that needed to be done to go out and try and sell the product.
- 2:31Because if you're gonna launch it you wanna have buyers, right?
- 2:34I'm envisioning that might have been a little bit of what you
- 2:36guys were going through recently.
- 2:38And I saw in the press release that you had a call with potential
- 2:41buyers, I think in the last few days.
- 2:43But but hey explain what it is how it works from the 10,000 or 5,000
- 2:49foot level, and then maybe we can dive into the, some of the specifics.
- 2:53Travis: Sure.
- 2:53Yeah.
- 2:53I think your analogy is pretty accurate in terms of the NGN notes back in
- 2:57was that like 9 0 9 maybe, or 10?
- 2:59Something like that.
- 3:00Mark Treichel: Yes.
- 3:00Travis: Yeah.
- 3:00So I, I remember those coming out.
- 3:02Those were those were really interesting.
- 3:03It is probably, again, very similar.
- 3:04I've told Mark a lot in this, 'cause, we've done some new innovative things at
- 3:08Alum first over the last, 10 or 15 years.
- 3:10And every time it's, it feels different than a, a process that is.
- 3:14Well structured and figured out, and you know exactly when you're gonna go
- 3:17left and when you're gonna go right, because the map's already been set.
- 3:21Whenever you do something for the first time for an industry and for your
- 3:24company and for everything else, it, there's a lot of questions that have
- 3:27to be answered as you go along the way.
- 3:28That's what's been really fun and exciting for us the loan fund itself.
- 3:31If I would just wanna give an overview of what it is, it's a completely new
- 3:35way for credit unions to buy assets.
- 3:37That has never been permissible prior to December of 2024 when
- 3:42NCUA approved the pilot program.
- 3:44And what it essentially does is it allows credit unions to come together
- 3:49with collective purchasing power under a fund structure to go buy whole loan
- 3:54assets from other entities, primarily through through credit unions.
- 3:58The loans that we purchase have to be memorized, so we have
- 4:00to stay within our industry.
- 4:02But there's all kinds of really.
- 4:04Amazing and unique things that this new structure allows the investors and
- 4:08for sellers to, to come together to do.
- 4:10But essentially it's that kind of pooling of assets and the collective
- 4:13purchasing power of that pooled benefit.
- 4:16Mark Treichel: And when I, what.
- 4:18When I hear that, and I think about a typical loan participation, right?
- 4:22If I'm a credit union that has excess capacity for Bo members who want loans
- 4:28and I find other credit unions I can sell to that there's a certain particular
- 4:33process with that, and then there's loan participation contracts with that.
- 4:37And I'm guessing that the way this product works, there's some advantages and it
- 4:43works different than loan participations.
- 4:45And it it might have some different bells and whistles or it might have some
- 4:49different limitations relative to that.
- 4:50Could you come in, maybe walk through?
- 4:52Yeah.
- 4:53So if someone calls you and says, Hey, I'm doing loan participation.
- 4:56Why would I wanna do this instead?
- 4:58Travis: Yeah, that's a great question.
- 4:59I think, maybe another way to think about that is to compare all the
- 5:02different buying opportunities that credit unions currently have,
- 5:04and where this fits into that.
- 5:05Because when you look at participations, which is predominantly how credit
- 5:09unions buy and sell assets today.
- 5:11To your point, it's a, bespoke transaction between two parties.
- 5:15There's a legal discussion that's going on between the two of them.
- 5:18And, there's, all kinds of individualized negotiations that
- 5:21are happening at that level.
- 5:23Typically the transactions are smaller in size.
- 5:26They, five to $50 million.
- 5:28Sometimes they get bigger than that for the very largest, transactions.
- 5:31But for the most part, they're probably, in that 10 or $15 million range.
- 5:35And a transaction is a lot of work, right?
- 5:38There's a lot of things that have to get done to make sure that you've done
- 5:41all your due diligence and you've priced it correctly and all of those pieces.
- 5:45And when you start doing it for small sizes, it can be challenging.
- 5:48When you think about on the seller side of that.
- 5:52Certainly someone who's selling a lot, let's say they're selling, $300
- 5:54million a year and they're doing 10, $30 million transactions a year.
- 5:59That's a tremendous amount of legal review pricing negotiations that
- 6:05are always happening that become really difficult to do at scale.
- 6:09So what ends up happening in those cases, as you start doing more and more trades.
- 6:13Because you start thinking about what other markets can I go to?
- 6:16And so institutions from our clients as an example, that wanted to do that, started
- 6:19going to the securitization market.
- 6:21And that's a place where you go and you can sell $300 million in one transaction.
- 6:26There's a standardized legal document.
- 6:28There's a defined due diligence process that's done by third parties.
- 6:31You may have s and p or Moody's that come in and do a loss estimate.
- 6:34You're gonna have KPMG or somebody like that come in and do what's
- 6:37called agreed upon procedures, which is the due diligence document.
- 6:41And then you're gonna install a payer agent, that collects all
- 6:44the money on behalf of them.
- 6:45And that helps serve that kind of scalable benefit.
- 6:48The loan fund kind of sits in between those two things, where it wants to have
- 6:53the same process that securitization has, so it has a loss estimate that's
- 6:57coming from a third party, from like s and p in this case, our first one.
- 7:00And then we have our due diligence document coming from,
- 7:02a, again, a reputable third party.
- 7:04In this case it was KPMG.
- 7:07And then, after that we have to have a cash management process.
- 7:10'cause we don't want it all come into a M first.
- 7:12We want it to be in a secure kind of third party place.
- 7:14And so Wilmington Trust comes in and acts as that third party for
- 7:17us to collect all the payments.
- 7:19So when you go back to the original question of why would
- 7:22a buyer want to come into this?
- 7:23They get to come in and buy in a similar fashion that you would in a
- 7:27capital markets transaction, a very securitization like transaction.
- 7:30But you get to share the resources and benefit with other investors
- 7:33in a large scale purchase.
- 7:35So that helps the buyer side.
- 7:37The seller side gets the same benefit if you think about it, because
- 7:40now they don't have to deal with.
- 7:4130 different institutions that are constantly coming to them with
- 7:44different bespoke legal reviews.
- 7:46Arguing over pricing, arguing over credit.
- 7:49There's a more defined process that makes it easier for both
- 7:51the seller and the buyer.
- 7:53That's I think one of those other pieces.
- 7:55And then if you think about any other transaction where you have
- 7:5710 buyers coming together and say we want to go buy this one product.
- 8:01And I can give you an example of kind of what, what helped us lead to
- 8:04this loan fund to begin with, but.
- 8:06You get more purchasing power by coming in together as one versus
- 8:09individually going to that seller and saying, let me buy it out.
- 8:12So that's the other benefit from an investor who wants to become
- 8:15a little more sophisticated.
- 8:16They wanna either want some more due diligence, they want some more third
- 8:18party benefit of, loss estimates that help moving from a participation
- 8:22transaction into a loan fund, if you will.
- 8:24Transaction.
- 8:26Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 8:26And as you just described that, I've seen some challenges, from loan participation
- 8:31side, where you're describing you have a lot of credit unions buying from you.
- 8:35And they and the first three that you do have one standard contract
- 8:39and then the next one comes in and they wanna tweak this and the next
- 8:41one wants to come in and tweak this.
- 8:43And then you've got your six, seven years out on your duration there of
- 8:46having done all these participations.
- 8:49And then you've gotta track those 7, 8, 9 different versions
- 8:53of that loan participation agreement and make sure that.
- 8:56As lead lender if if something happens here that you're looking at the right
- 8:59one where you'd change the rule in that way, there's a maybe a little bit
- 9:02more standardization here than that scenario and you alleviate a little bit
- 9:07of that pressure from the originator.
- 9:10Does that make sense?
- 9:11Travis: Yeah, definitely.
- 9:11We're trying to standardize all of those processes so that they're
- 9:14very consistent and uniform.
- 9:16I think if you take that even further.
- 9:18Where you were thinking about, let's go back to the 21 and 22 timeframes when
- 9:23everybody's working with, these FinTech operators and that's the kind of buzz
- 9:26word of the day and everybody's trying to look at these different solutions.
- 9:29I come in and work with one of those parties, but I'm the last one to join.
- 9:33There's been 20 other credit unions before me.
- 9:35The credit union that was, 20 before me, they get a much better
- 9:38price because they came in earlier.
- 9:39Right now I'm the last one coming in.
- 9:41I'm not getting the same price.
- 9:43And so you don't get that benefit of being the early adopter.
- 9:47You're actually the late adopter and you get, it's reflective in
- 9:50your return as a result of it.
- 9:51Whereas, structure like this can say, look, we're all getting the
- 9:54same thing because we're coming in together and therefore we're
- 9:57gonna have standardized documents.
- 9:59We're gonna have standardized pricing, we're gonna have
- 10:00standardized underwriting procedures.
- 10:02And because you're only dealing with the one party here coming into it.
- 10:06It doesn't matter that there's 30 people behind it or 50 people behind
- 10:09it, because it's all being viewed by the seller as the one channel coming in.
- 10:13And that creates all kind of operational efficiencies for the seller and
- 10:17for the investors, whether it's legal, pricing, credit, you name it,
- 10:22Mark Treichel: And that's interesting.
- 10:23And then if I understood this right the.
- 10:27And correct me if I say anything that's wrong.
- 10:30The first fund is there's a limit of 30 participating buyers of that have to
- 10:36be complex, meaning over 500 million.
- 10:38Did I get that right?
- 10:40Travis: Yeah.
- 10:40This is probably one of our most challenging aspects of this this process.
- 10:44And when everybody comes back to you, we are actually only allowed to work with
- 10:4830 ever, not in the first fund and not per fund, which would be way easier.
- 10:53But we're only ever allowed to work with 30 total.
- 10:57So that means that, the investors have to be willing to work with us in terms of
- 11:02being able to look at multiple strategies.
- 11:05We have to be able to deal with certain size and investing benefits.
- 11:08We are allowed to have up to $10 billion outstanding at any one point in time.
- 11:13That's a pretty decent amount of money.
- 11:15It's not insignificant by any means but if we only have 30 institutions that can
- 11:19work with it, that's pretty interesting.
- 11:21That changes how it works.
- 11:23And beyond that, we are actually, are allowed to work with state
- 11:26chartered credit unions as well.
- 11:28But they have to have federal parity with NCA regulations, so
- 11:31that doesn't count against R 30.
- 11:33So that's how we can broaden the the universe.
- 11:35Oh, that's interesting itself.
- 11:37But we're only allowed to work with 30, but that $10 billion cap does
- 11:42not determine, it doesn't matter how many people are involved in
- 11:45it, we still, whether we have 30 federal and another 30 state, we
- 11:49still can't go above the 10 billion.
- 11:51So that's something that we are always mindful as well as we think
- 11:54about who can come invest with us
- 11:57Mark Treichel: and thinking out loud.
- 11:59I saw reference to a five year window and a seven year window.
- 12:04I think the longer might have been from approval, what is it?
- 12:07The earlier of one of the, if you could maybe kinda walk through
- 12:10Travis: that.
- 12:10Yeah.
- 12:10We'll give you the update there.
- 12:11So we from the time that we were approved, and maybe just going back a little bit
- 12:14in terms of yes, this process took about three years for us to get approval with.
- 12:18There was a couple of, large market dynamics occurring, if you remember
- 12:21between Silicon Valley Bank and some of those other things that, I think
- 12:24helped, maybe distract N-C-U-A-A little bit from our our little
- 12:27pirate program here, but that's certainly reasonable and justifiable.
- 12:30But we started at the application in 2021, in addition to some of you've
- 12:34already talked about, because we felt like credit unions needed a way
- 12:38to be able to pull the money have a disciplined asset pricing approach.
- 12:42We saw a lot of transactions that were occurring.
- 12:44Where trades were happening without kind of good pricing methodologies behind it.
- 12:49And we saw some opportunities to work with third parties that would be
- 12:52beneficial for credit unions to work with.
- 12:54And so we submitted the application in 2021 and we didn't get approval
- 12:58until 2024, December of 2024.
- 13:00As part of that though, they said.
- 13:02How long should this last?
- 13:04And we said let's talk about that.
- 13:05And they said we'll, we think that we'll give you seven years from when the product
- 13:10was approved, which is December 20, 24 or five years from your first trade.
- 13:16If you don't get a trade done for a couple years, this thing will expire.
- 13:18No matter what.
- 13:19And that way that will be the first litmus test.
- 13:22And the second one is if you get a trade done, which we did last week, that will
- 13:25start the clock for now five years, for us to evaluate whether or not this is
- 13:28truly a better way for us to buy assets.
- 13:31And that gives them that window to evaluate our process.
- 13:34They get to come in and take a look at the investors that are in the book.
- 13:38They get to look at our books and processes and due diligence.
- 13:40They get to do a joint exam with the SEC when they come in.
- 13:44It, it allows for that kind of to occur and for them to evaluate whether
- 13:47or not this makes sense for credit unions to have on a more permanent
- 13:49basis after the five years is up.
- 13:52Mark Treichel: And I'm glad you brought that up.
- 13:53'cause before we, again, before we hit record, we, you and I chatted
- 13:56a little bit about the derivatives pilot program from 20, I don't know,
- 14:0025 years ago, probably 23 years ago.
- 14:03Yeah.
- 14:03Which ultimately led into some authorities being granted by NCA
- 14:07'cause they were comfortable with how pilot programs were working.
- 14:10And that's why if someone's listening to this to, and saying, wow, I'm,
- 14:13I'm 490 million, so I'm not complex.
- 14:16And I can't be one of those 30 credit unions that participating.
- 14:20That doesn't mean at the end of this, at the end of this pilot, that maybe
- 14:25NCUA tweaks some regulations to the extent that's what it would take
- 14:29to offer this on a broader scale.
- 14:31There, there's still that option down the road.
- 14:33Is that, am I interpreting that right?
- 14:35Travis: Yeah, I think so.
- 14:36And if we do our job correctly, this will hopefully become a more
- 14:38permanent program for NCA to be able to offer to credit unions which I
- 14:42think will be trend, tremendous for them to be able to go buy assets and
- 14:45pooled format, especially for smaller credit unions, if you think about it.
- 14:48Like those are the ones that could really benefit from pooling assets together.
- 14:52So that would be really advantageous for them.
- 14:55I do think while we can't put you in the fund, if you're, below that
- 14:58threshold, if you reach out to us, we may have some other solutions that
- 15:01might help you, that could piggyback along certain aspects of this.
- 15:04I wouldn't say that the benefits are completely off for those credit unions.
- 15:08But yes, we can have you in the funds, but we may have something
- 15:10else that can be, similar to that.
- 15:13Mark Treichel: Got it.
- 15:13Got it.
- 15:13And then you walked through the.
- 15:15The different the independent side of it and the loss determination.
- 15:19So how now we've talked more about the investor, but, so let's talk a little bit
- 15:22about the loans that would go into it.
- 15:25I think I saw somewhere there consumer under 10 year maturity.
- 15:29Travis: Yeah.
- 15:29And maybe Mark, if you wanna talk about the underwriting process and
- 15:32the vendors we worked with, but I'll just give you the guardrails.
- 15:34We're allowed to work with any.
- 15:36Asset that has a maturity date and an amortization schedule
- 15:39that's less than 10 years.
- 15:41So I think NCAA's thought process there was, they didn't want something in a pilot
- 15:45program that ends five years from now.
- 15:48Let's say that, they decided not to continue with it.
- 15:50They don't want something sitting out there for 30 years or 25 more years
- 15:53because of, there was a bunch of 30 year mortgages I have purchased.
- 15:55So they wanted to keep it at least initially to short term assets.
- 15:58So maybe that'll be something that changes when they hopefully make
- 16:01the pro the program more permanent.
- 16:03But maybe to talk about some of the pieces of like when we buy assets and
- 16:07the third parties we're working with.
- 16:08Mark, why don't you, do you wanna describe a little bit, what we did there?
- 16:11Mark Sun: Yeah.
- 16:12Everything basically starts pretty much in terms of how you evaluate credit is
- 16:17looking at the different aspect, the consumer product, auto being the primary.
- 16:22So everybody has pretty much a large percentage of the investment in the
- 16:27auto, so it wasn't as difficult, but the pro, but the process that you have
- 16:31to go through is you wanna at least benchmark what versus what individual
- 16:35credit union has been producing the product, so that means static pool
- 16:39information and looking at losses over time, particularly doing through crises.
- 16:44Those are the one that tells you how well from a collection as well as risk
- 16:48adjustment that the company has made.
- 16:51Everybody points to the 2223 as the, oh my God, era.
- 16:56And that certainly we are seeing a level of stabilization, but we
- 17:00are stabilizing at a higher value than what we saw pre COVID crisis.
- 17:05So when I say that is because if you look at the affordability as well as the.
- 17:09Loan balances.
- 17:10They are a lot higher than previously.
- 17:13So that's a challenge for us as we go through that process with Radiancy.
- 17:17Why we need a rating C is because Ency sees so many institutional deals that
- 17:22come across is for us to have a third party valuation, is if we show you this
- 17:27particular portfolio, how they underwrite.
- 17:29What do you think the expect a loss would be?
- 17:32And we take that in and we work with the the seller in here.
- 17:36And the way we look work with seller is we wanna produce a buy box that's
- 17:40incrementally for a efficiency on their end as well as from a risk
- 17:44perspective that we can accept.
- 17:46That means when we have to develop that static pool loss information
- 17:50to the third party to evaluate, we're very much focused in terms of
- 17:54what we're buying, not a complete.
- 17:57Here's the book.
- 17:58When you guys take a look and tell us what it is, we wanna be very
- 18:00focused in terms of what we back buy.
- 18:03So that's about a three weeks process and it's a very extensive operational review.
- 18:08So if you have gone through securitization, one of the benefit
- 18:11is the operation review is more of an update, but it allows us, as a portfolio
- 18:15manager to listen to the differences that they have progressed through the
- 18:19time that data securitization to now.
- 18:21So for us, it's more of an update and allow us to follow the progression.
- 18:25Of the way they underwrite, the way they collect, the way, how the
- 18:28portfolio has been performed over that, that period while they do
- 18:33securitization after securitization.
- 18:35So that's the framework for ways to, to which we look at losses.
- 18:39On a operational side equation where a UP comes in, which is agreed upon procedure,
- 18:45that's when you start underwriting the pro the collateral itself.
- 18:49So that's when we'll take samples of those loans that we anticipate to, to purchase,
- 18:53and they, that give us a sample in terms of how those loans are matching to the
- 18:59way the underwriting process has done.
- 19:01We go a little bit, step further than the traditional securitization, A UPA.
- 19:06In the sense that we also do an audit on the vintage.
- 19:10When I say vintage, is basically following through certain loan through
- 19:14their collection process, making sure they are managed as well as conforming
- 19:20to their own collection policy.
- 19:21That includes skip a pay that include extension and what have you.
- 19:25That way we know that they're doing their collection as described in their manual.
- 19:31Since all of our loans, our preference is having servicer.
- 19:35Retain the seller retain the servicing so that in the cell is what
- 19:40delivered the performance back to us.
- 19:43So we wanna make sure that they're following their own steps
- 19:45in terms of how they collect.
- 19:47And also more importantly, is is defaults is how you progress through the default.
- 19:52And that is something that we also tested to make sure that it is following the
- 19:57right collection in terms of how you, how you repo if you call repossession timing,
- 20:03and there's certain timing, we wanna make sure that it's following their own process
- 20:07and that we can see from the performance that are they typically 45 days out or
- 20:11are they 60 days out from a cashflow perspective, that, that is important
- 20:16in terms of how we look at recovery value coming back into the system.
- 20:19And that's how we, as a encompassing everything that give us a overall view.
- 20:23What we should be paying.
- 20:25For collateral, how you should be valuing this collateral that we are we're wanna
- 20:29buy on behalf of the credit union.
- 20:32Mark Treichel: Got it.
- 20:32Got and you, I might be oversimplifying this, but so someone gets into
- 20:37the fund and there's cash flow monthly on the loan portfolio.
- 20:41They get cash in on the.
- 20:44On the program, I'm presuming monthly.
- 20:47The somewhat, there, there's x number of charge offs at a loss
- 20:52of Y, but there was also yield.
- 20:54Of a bigger number is that netted during netted in the and then at
- 20:59the end, at the takeout, right?
- 21:01When the, when there's the, when it all comes to maturity later that
- 21:07would be the great equalizing moment.
- 21:09As the loans have all matured and then the cash is just paid out,
- 21:12or a, that might be over some.
- 21:13Travis: Yeah, that's exactly right.
- 21:14So basically what happens is on a month to month basis the seller
- 21:18is remitting payment to our collection agent, essentially.
- 21:21Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 21:21Travis: From there expenses are removed from the fund structure and
- 21:25then everything that's left over.
- 21:27Is remitted back to the investors on a prob rata basis.
- 21:29They're getting a full, principle and interest cash flow.
- 21:32Now as charge offs and things like that are coming in, it's obviously reducing
- 21:35the overall cash position, but, this is not a structured fund, if you will.
- 21:40There's no like priority of cash flows that are pushing up or down.
- 21:44It's just coming back to the investor based on their ownership percentage
- 21:47of how they invested coming in.
- 21:49Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 21:49So like there, there's no super tranches and the these guys get paid first.
- 21:55It's everybody's an equal buyer.
- 21:57Travis: That's right.
- 21:57Mark Treichel: Yeah, that's
- 21:58Travis: right.
- 21:58Yeah,
- 21:59Mark Treichel: that makes sense.
- 21:59And then the credit unions that are putting loans into the program how are you
- 22:06looking for people in, on that side of the equation or is that side already lined up?
- 22:09Or how does that work?
- 22:11Travis: Yeah.
- 22:11Yeah.
- 22:11We have a couple of entities that we are currently working with.
- 22:14And the every loan that we purchase has to come through a credit union.
- 22:20The first purchase was through a single entity credit union.
- 22:22And they sold us a pool of assets.
- 22:24We are working with other people to bring on more.
- 22:27We can also look at, for example.
- 22:30A third party that wants to sell into credit unions.
- 22:32And let's say that we like the attractiveness of the product but they
- 22:36have no existing way to get into the credit union industry, if you will.
- 22:40Then we have a credit union that we put on the front end of the
- 22:42cashflow, front of the process.
- 22:44They memorize and essentially bring the loans into the credit union system.
- 22:48Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 22:49Travis: And then that credit union then turns around and
- 22:50sells it to the loan fund.
- 22:51And that allows us to work with, FinTech partners or third
- 22:54party origination channels.
- 22:56And I think that's, the second phase or third phase of like where some really
- 22:59value comes here, where we can then work with entities that would normally
- 23:02not work with any one credit union.
- 23:04Because there's not enough purchasing power from that one party, but the fund
- 23:08itself has a much more, much greater amount of purchasing power and therefore
- 23:12gives the collective benefit to its investors through those channels.
- 23:15Mark Sun: Yeah.
- 23:15I just wanna add a little bit to the investor base.
- 23:18Having 20 plus years dealing on the institutional side when the when the
- 23:23top approach, Hey, why don't you come in and help us with a credit union?
- 23:28To me, it was like we never heard credit Union having the ability
- 23:31to invest in product like this.
- 23:33So when we did our initial outreach to some of third party, they realized
- 23:39that the funding that's coming from, it's very different than
- 23:42what you typically would see in the institutional funded private credit.
- 23:47Because what typically happened there is everybody have a
- 23:50different investment threshold.
- 23:53So the.
- 23:53Portfolio manager is always tasked which dollar do I need to invest
- 23:57first to get the best return for my investor in a credit union setting?
- 24:03One of the thing that I realize, again, I'm a newbie in the in
- 24:07the credit union space, is how steady and stable the funding.
- 24:11Dollar is meaning if there is a decline in the economic scenario, you
- 24:16actually see the deposit rate goes up.
- 24:18That is something a lot of folks out in the institutional side do not recognize.
- 24:23So I think credit union actually have advantage because we are actually
- 24:27providing an incremental amount of funding into the system that is not as
- 24:34volatile as you will in a traditional private equity or private credit form.
- 24:40Mark Treichel: Interesting.
- 24:40Yeah.
- 24:40And
- 24:40Mark Sun: secondly,
- 24:41Mark Treichel: go
- 24:42Mark Sun: ahead.
- 24:42Yeah.
- 24:42Secondly, for credit union investor coming in, because now you're you
- 24:46have a marketing not marketing, but a avenue for third parties such as
- 24:51any OEN, any financial independent finance companies or even FinTech
- 24:56company, as we talked about quite a bit.
- 24:58They also recognize that this is a separate pool of fund that's available.
- 25:02And they're more willing to start working on the one central point, just
- 25:07because we are bringing more of an institutional way of looking at this.
- 25:13As I, if I was an institutional buyer today, I like to know that there is
- 25:17standard pro process and policy that's in place that could easily identify radiancy.
- 25:24I could easily identify a UP process.
- 25:26I could easily identify.
- 25:28That takes a lot of that mystery, if you will, from the third party
- 25:33while you guys are credit union, how are you guys looking at this?
- 25:36We're standing in between showing them, look we're following exactly
- 25:39how you guys do securitization, but our process is to make sure that
- 25:44we bring that knowledge base in.
- 25:46The disseminate into our investor, which are credit union that you guys
- 25:50had not seen before, other than maybe indi individual discussion that you
- 25:55have maybe didn't have, we can't keep doing this 10 million, 5 million
- 25:59or a hundred thousand dollars loan.
- 26:01Here's a way for us to create a big scale at the same time protecting the
- 26:07credit union investor that's coming in.
- 26:09Mark Treichel: No,
- 26:09Mark Sun: that's, yeah.
- 26:10It's something very interesting in the marketplace that, again, I 20
- 26:14plus years in the institutional side.
- 26:16When Travis asked me to join, I go, credit union.
- 26:19Are you freaking kidding me?
- 26:21Really?
- 26:22So when he showed me the number, I go, wow.
- 26:25Really?
- 26:25So even someone like me has been in the profession this many years.
- 26:29I never really took a look at what the credit union can
- 26:32really bring to the table.
- 26:33Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 26:33Mark Sun: And this is something that we did pitch to a few, even OEM.
- 26:37They thought that this was a very.
- 26:39Interesting product because we are bringing capital in
- 26:42without asking for leverage.
- 26:44That's one of the, one of the thing about the fund is we're truly a cash
- 26:48increment to the capital market today.
- 26:51For a lot of folks that are doing a, b, s Secur or whole loan, if you know
- 26:55all, a lot of the whole loan that's being created today, it's almost I would
- 26:59love to buy a whole loan, but you guys gotta gimme leverage at the same time.
- 27:02'cause this is a traditional private private credit is I need to make
- 27:06sure that I make the most money and that what we're coming in is
- 27:09I'm willing to buy your product.
- 27:11I don't need leverage, so I'm not gonna compete against your own capital market.
- 27:16Banks that providing you leverage today because we're truly are
- 27:20incrementally adding additional cash value to your program.
- 27:24Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 27:25That's exciting.
- 27:25It's the credit union difference, I guess is what you're experiencing here.
- 27:30Travis: Yeah, it's been really fun to see Mark, his eyes illuminate about,
- 27:32working with, in this industry and all the really great benefits of doing so.
- 27:36And Mark touched on a really great one, which was that like funding benefit that
- 27:40most credit unions don't really, I think really quantify well enough because
- 27:45when you look at credit unions that that are high, highly retail, deposit based.
- 27:49They're usually below the the excess capital, at least the the $250,000
- 27:53threshold for uninsured limit.
- 27:55That means that depositors, especially in times that are
- 27:58tough, is trying to save money.
- 28:00They're putting money like they're hoarding back away that cash, and that
- 28:03brings cash to the credit union system where they're getting excess liquidity
- 28:07when everybody else is needing it.
- 28:09And that creates an amazing opportunity to provide liquidity to people
- 28:13who want it at a better return.
- 28:15And we used to always say, we talk about this to our clients all the time.
- 28:19I want to give my liquidity when the market needs it so I can get paid for it.
- 28:22And then when the markets have excess liquidity, I'm gonna pull it back.
- 28:25And that's a great way that we can think about the benefit of this fund being able
- 28:28to do as markets are fluctuating around.
- 28:31Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 28:31No, that makes a lot of sense.
- 28:33Looking at the notes here from the release and or the NCA website.
- 28:38Let's see.
- 28:38It looks like there's a 50% limit on net worth for all of the funds and
- 28:43a 15% net worth for any single fund.
- 28:46Do I have that right?
- 28:47Travis: Yeah.
- 28:48And what NCUA did that I think makes things pretty simple for the investors
- 28:51to come in and take a look at is that they said that no one fund first of
- 28:56all, they're gonna be closed end.
- 28:57So they're open for a window and then they close.
- 29:01And so the first two fund windows are six.
- 29:04And that allows them to go, okay, we closes, no new money can go in there.
- 29:10It just goes back to the investors fund.
- 29:12Two opens up after six months and it's open for another six months.
- 29:15After that, total 12 month window, it closes as well.
- 29:18And they said that in aggregate as you invest in all of these funds,
- 29:21'cause they're just gonna be kind.
- 29:23Terminating and then, reinvesting cash flow into new ones.
- 29:26You can't have more than 50% of your net worth in all of them, and you can't
- 29:29put more than 15% in any one fund.
- 29:32And so that just helps distribute from a concentration risk perspective.
- 29:35Sure.
- 29:35But because of the closed end nature of this and they open, essentially every
- 29:40three months after the first year.
- 29:42Be really hard to invest 15% of your net worth into one fund, but that
- 29:46also helps with tracking performance.
- 29:48So we now get to look at individual funds historically and say, fund one has this
- 29:52return, fund two has this return, and we're not adding new dollars into that.
- 29:56So it doesn't make the tracking of performance, of fund over
- 29:59time very muddy if you will.
- 30:01Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 30:01That makes sense.
- 30:02That makes sense.
- 30:03Gentlemen this has been a lot of fun.
- 30:04What is there anything that I didn't ask you that you'd like to highlight as it
- 30:08relates to this exciting new opportunity?
- 30:13Travis: Mark, anything you wanna add before I jump in?
- 30:15Mark Sun: Besides, trust us other than that it's an exciting opportunity.
- 30:19I want to, just to make sure that, that credit union that participate in the fund
- 30:23as well as that they're looking to sell.
- 30:25And this is something that's very unique in the marketplace.
- 30:29I'm certainly excited to be part of the team.
- 30:31I think as we continue to build success on that I think for the folks gonna
- 30:35realize that this is truly a wholesale level of bringing a lot of benefit
- 30:40to both sides, both seller and buyer.
- 30:44Travis: Very good.
- 30:44I, what I would maybe add is that I would think that, whenever you do
- 30:47something new or different like this, there's obviously a lot of questions that
- 30:50come up from everyone because they're understanding how to, how does this work?
- 30:53How am I protected what, what is the real risk associated with these
- 30:56transactions and things like that.
- 30:58And certainly from a risk perspective, you're buying whole loans.
- 31:00So we wanna make sure that you understand that you're just
- 31:02like buying a participation.
- 31:03There's credit risk in that transaction.
- 31:05And there's credit risk in this transaction as well.
- 31:07But one thing that I think Mark and I have tried to do really
- 31:09well is to understand that.
- 31:12Not everyone understands all of this stuff right away.
- 31:15This, a fund structure is not common in credit union land.
- 31:18So if you have questions, please ask us.
- 31:21We're happy to walk through all of these pieces and there's, all of our
- 31:24investors that have, participated with us.
- 31:26And these are some very large investors that, that are, 10
- 31:29plus billion dollars in assets.
- 31:31They've had tons of questions and it's okay to do that.
- 31:33So we've spent hours on the phone going through all these little scenarios
- 31:37or how we're gonna do stuff and what we're gonna do and what the process
- 31:39looks like and how does this reflect in the legal documents, how think
- 31:42that's more than fair from anyone who's considering something like this.
- 31:45So if you have questions, feel free just to ask and we will talk through it.
- 31:49And there's no shortage of or no maximum limit as to how
- 31:52long we wanna do this 'cause.
- 31:53We know when we do something new that there, there's some,
- 31:55questions that have to get answered.
- 31:57So we're happy to do
- 31:57Mark Treichel: you, and that's a perfect segue to, so if someone is,
- 32:00has listened to this or watched it and they're going, Hey, that I'm really
- 32:03excited about possibly talking to you guys about participating, what's
- 32:08the best way for them to reach you?
- 32:10Travis: I would say we have an email address it's loan fund@aamfirst.com.
- 32:13That goes to Mark and I, that's an easy place to go and
- 32:16probably the most direct place.
- 32:17But if you go to our www.aamfirst.com
- 32:20as well, there's a bunch of links related to the loan fund additionally there.
- 32:23So you can go to either avenue, but loan fund at a first is probably the easiest.
- 32:27Mark Treichel: Perfect.
- 32:28And I'll put that in the show notes.
- 32:30Travis: Great.
- 32:31Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 32:31Guys.
- 32:31This has been a lot of fun.
- 32:32I wanna thank you for your time and talking about this exciting
- 32:35new opportunity for credit unions.
- 32:38Travis: Absolutely.
- 32:38Thanks for having us, mark.
- 32:39Mark Treichel: Thank you.
- 32:39You got it.
- 32:40And listeners, watchers, I want you, I wanna thank you for listening or
- 32:44watching, whichever you're doing.
- 32:45I hope you'll do that again soon.
- 32:46This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.