Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / Khubilai's Chinese Capital: How Yuan Sinicization Fractured the Mongol Empire
Transcript
- Lucas: Welcome back. We've spent many episodes picking apart the Mongol Empire's fractures — succession crises, civil wars, economic breakdowns. But there's one subtle, persistent cause we haven't touched on directly: Khubilai Khan's decision to sinicize his rule. Luna: You mean his move away from the steppe and into China proper? Lucas: Exactly. After Möngke died in 1259, Khubilai was leading a campaign in China, not up in Karakorum. He proclaimed himself Great Khan at his own camp in Kaiping — later Shangdu — in 1260, bypassing the traditional kurultai on the Orkhon River. That alone was a break from Chinggisid tradition. Luna: And his brother Ariq Böke held a rival kurultai in Mongolia. Lucas: Right. Khubilai won that civil war, but he never moved back to Karakorum. Instead, he built a new capital, first Shangdu — what Coleridge called Xanadu — and then Dadu, which is present-day Beijing. That shift had enormous symbolic weight. He was physically locating himself inside Chinese civilization, not on the steppe. Luna: So to the other Mongol princes, it looked like he was abandoning the homeland. Lucas: Absolutely. And it wasn't just location. He adopted Chinese court rituals, took a Chinese reign name — his era name was Zhongtong, later Zhiyuan — and surrounded himself with Confucian scholars like Liu Bingzhong and Yao Shu. He even issued a new legal code, the Zhiyuan xin'ge, which was based on Chinese law, not the Yassa. Luna: Didn't the Yassa still hold authority in the other khanates? Lucas: In theory, yes. But in practice, each khanate developed its own legal traditions. The Golden Horde under Berke and later khans used the Yassa combined with local Islamic law. The Chagatai Khanate claimed to uphold the Yassa, but they also adopted steppe custom. The Yuan under Khubilai started moving toward Confucian legalism. So there was no shared legal framework anymore. Lucas: Khubilai also embraced Tibetan Buddhism, appointing the 'Phags-pa lama as his imperial preceptor. That tied the Yuan to a specific religious identity, whereas the Ilkhanate under Ghazan converted to Islam in 1295, and the Golden Horde had already become Muslim under Berke. The religious landscape was fragmenting. Luna: So the split wasn't just about power—it was about identity and culture. Lucas: Precisely. And the clearest opposition came from Kaidu, the Ögedeid prince who controlled the Chagatai Khanate. He made it his mission to preserve Mongol tradition. He refused to recognize Khubilai as Great Khan, held his own kurultai on the Ili River, and waged war for over three decades. Luna: Kaidu is one of my favorites — his daughter Khutulun was a famous wrestler. Lucas: Yes, she's legendary. But Kaidu's rebellion wasn't just personal ambition; it was ideological. He argued that Khubilai had abandoned the ways of Chinggis Khan — the simple life of the steppe, the Yassa, the mobile court. Kaidu kept his own court on the move, like the old khans. Lucas: This cultural alienation is something that often gets overlooked. For the average Mongol warrior, seeing their Great Khan wearing Chinese silk and receiving Confucian officials must have felt like a betrayal. The unity of the empire had always rested on a shared steppe culture. Luna: It's fascinating how cultural choices shaped political boundaries. And you know, conversations like this are exactly why listeners like you support the show. Lucas: Yeah, we've been building this narrative episode by episode, and it's listener support that keeps us ad-free and independent. If you've been coming along with us on this journey through Central Asia, a couple of dollars at buymeacoffee dot com slash fexingo genuinely makes a real difference. Luna: It really does. Every bit helps us keep digging into these stories. Lucas: So let's get back to Khubilai's court. Another major signal was his introduction of paper money — the chao. This was a Chinese innovation. He made it the official currency in the Yuan realm, but the other khanates refused to accept it. They minted their own coins — silver dirhams in the Ilkhanate and Golden Horde, copper coins in Chagatai. Luna: So the chao actually created economic separation. Lucas: Exactly. Marco Polo described the chao as a marvel, but it only worked in China. Trade between khanates declined because they had different monetary systems. The unified imperial economy that existed under Ögedei and Möngke disappeared. Even the Yam, the postal relay system, fell into disrepair across borders. Luna: And Rashid al-Din's world history — didn't he write for the Ilkhanate? Lucas: Yes. Rashid al-Din's Jami' al-tawarikh was commissioned by Ghazan Khan, who was a Muslim convert and hostile to the Yuan. Yet the book emphasizes the unity of the Mongol lineage. It's a fascinating tension — Ghazan wanted to claim Chinggisid legitimacy while rejecting Khubilai's authority. Lucas: Let me circle back to the appanage system. Chinggis Khan had divided the empire into uluses for his sons — Jochi, Chagatai, Ögedei, and Tolui. These were meant to be part of one empire, but they had their own armies and resources. When the central authority weakened, they became de facto independent. Luna: And Khubilai tried to reassert control over them? Lucas: He did, but it was too late. The Golden Horde had already gone its own way under Berke. The Chagatai Khanate resisted Yuan influence. The Ilkhanate was far away in Persia. Khubilai's sinicization only accelerated the separation, because the other khans no longer saw the Yuan as the true Mongol Empire. Lucas: Even within the Yuan, there was tension. Khubilai maintained the kheshig, the imperial guard, but he reorganized it into twelve commands, mixing Mongol and Chinese troops. The palace rituals became increasingly Chinese. And by the time of his grandson Temür, the Yuan was essentially a Chinese dynasty that happened to have Mongol rulers. Luna: So the Mongol Empire split because there was no longer a shared political culture to hold it together. Lucas: Exactly. Conquest and family ties weren't enough. The empire needed common symbols, a common law, a common purpose. Khubilai's choices were rational for ruling China, but they fractured the broader Mongol world. Lucas: And we see this reflected in the sources. Juvayni, writing for the Ilkhanate, praised Hulegu but barely mentions Khubilai. Rashid al-Din mentions Khubilai but emphasizes Ghazan's reforms. There's no single voice calling for unity anymore. Luna: It's a classic story of empire — too big to hold together with one cultural framework. Lucas: Right. And it's a reminder that unity isn't just power; it's also trust and shared identity. For anyone wanting to explore more, the primary accounts of Marco Polo and William of Rubruck give eyewitness glimpses of this divide. Luna: Thanks for this perspective, Lucas. I think it ties together a lot of what we've discussed over the past many episodes. Lucas: Absolutely. Next time, we'll look at something else — maybe the role of climate and environment in the empire's decline. But for now, thanks for listening.