Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Should Government Be Able To Rewrite The Rules For The Law Society?
Transcript
- 0:24Michael Mulligan: Well, this is the continued litigation over changes that the uh provincial government has been trying to make to the regulation of lawyers.
- 0:33Michael Mulligan: And the lawyers, there's an act called the Legal Profession Act that's been in place for decades that uh deals with uh the regulation of lawyers, ethical conduct, uh, you know, rules of practice, uh, you know, educational requirements, that kind of thing.
- 0:48Michael Mulligan: Um, and the provincial government has passed a thing that's the same thing with an S on the end, the legal professions with an S on the End Act, uh, is otherwise referred to as Bill 21.
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: And it makes a bunch of changes to the regulatory scheme, including things like uh changing what the object of the law society is.
- 1:05Michael Mulligan: It currently includes things like upholding and protecting the legal rights and freedoms of all people in British Columbia, and they've replaced it with things like implementing DRIPA.
- 1:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and so it's uh and the other changes involve the government trying to have more control over who operates the law society and makes rules for them.
- 1:24Michael Mulligan: Uh lawyers are currently a self-governing profession independent of the government, which is an important principle because often the government's on the other side of litigation.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: And so the challenge involves whether uh that concept, the independence of the uh legal profession, is a uh constitutional requirement, and if so, does this these changes breach that?
- 1:45Michael Mulligan: That's the legal issue.
- 1:46Michael Mulligan: The political issues would be is this a good idea?
- 1:49Michael Mulligan: But I guess that'll be answered by the uh electorate, although I rather imagine people you know who's uh recovering from forest fires are waiting for the uh in the emergency department.
- 1:59Michael Mulligan: Perhaps the uh fact that you might want to have an independent lawyer may not be top of the mind for them.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: But nonetheless, this is one of the uh things which has been a political issue.
- 2:09Michael Mulligan: So the the case goes to the Court of Appeal, it's scheduled to run November 16th and 17th.
- 2:15Michael Mulligan: Uh but what's just occurred is an application by these twelve different groups to try to intervene in that appeal, wanting to participate in the appeal.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: And that is indeed a thing.
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: Uh and in the case of uh appeals in British Columbia, there's a particular Court of Appeal rule, number sixty one, for those paying attention at home, uh, that uh dictates when and in what circumstances a group would be able to intervene to participate in an appeal.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: Um and so that's what was just dealt with.
- 2:46Michael Mulligan: Um and so the the case also deals with that.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: And it sets out really the it starts with a proposition that there are two categories of individuals or groups that might be allowed to like uh participate in an appeal.
- 3:00Michael Mulligan: And the first of those is if the person or group has a direct interest in the matter, like the outcome will just directly affect them.
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then the second category would be if it even if it won't directly affect them, is it uh a circumstance where it would be in the public interest uh to uh on if there's a public interest in a public law issue, like a broader issue in the uh affects the public generally?
- 3:25Michael Mulligan: Uh and would that group or individual bring a different and useful perspective on those issues to be assessed by the court?
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's a broader category.
- 3:35Michael Mulligan: And then uh when the uh assessment's being made, there are a number of things that uh a judge from the Court of P appeal would need to consider, including these things.
- 3:44Michael Mulligan: Like, does the proposed intervener have a broad representative base?
- 3:47Michael Mulligan: Is it just this one guy in his basement, or is this represent quite a few people, right?
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: Uh is they are they legitimately engaged in uh what the issue is here?
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: Is this just some busy body, or do they have some particular uh legitimate interest in it?
- 4:02Michael Mulligan: Would they bring a unique perspective that might not be raised by the parties, for example?
- 4:06Michael Mulligan: And then the flip side, you don't want to avoid expanding the scope of the thing, raising new issues that the parties aren't actually fighting about, potentially delaying things and getting the case off in a tangent.
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: And so that's what the uh the judge from the Court of Appeal had to consider with respect to these dozen uh uh parties that wished to participate in the appeal.
- 4:29Michael Mulligan: Uh and a couple of them maintained the position that they had a direct interest in it, and they included the Canadian Bar Association and the Criminal Defense Advocacy Society, but those, as well as the other ten, uh all took the position that they also would fit under that category of that sort of public interest category, even if it's not a matter of directly affecting them, arguing they might have a new and interesting uh uh perspective uh on it.
- 4:53Michael Mulligan: Um and so the judge went through the process of looking at, well, who are all these groups?
- 4:58Michael Mulligan: Do they have that kind of uh uh a useful additional perspective?
- 5:02Michael Mulligan: You you don't just want a bunch of people repeating one side or the other or saying, yeah, I agree or disagree.
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: It's not a vote after all at the end of the day.
- 5:09Michael Mulligan: Yeah, and in the case of all twelve of them, interestingly, the judge from the Court of Appeal uh concluded that yes, they do all have uh that legitimate public interest standing and that it would add to uh the uh hearing of the appeal.
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: And they range from, for example, there's a group called the Federation of Law Societies for Canada.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: It's like a group that represents all the law societies across the country.
- 5:32Michael Mulligan: They want to intervene, they found that would be useful.
- 5:35Michael Mulligan: On the government side, one was the Indigenous Bar Association, uh, because one of the issues is this um new legislation, in addition to having goals like implementing DRIPA, also creates an Indigenous council that would have powers uh if the new scheme comes into uh effect.
- 5:53Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh the Indigenous Bar Association represents 290 Indigenous lawyers and judges, academics and law students, and they've been given leave to intervene, presumably to advocate uh for that, or to argue that that would be a constitutionally permissible approach.
- 6:10Michael Mulligan: Uh one of the one of the particularly interesting ones here I noted when I went through this, though, was a group which is uh deals with uh mental health and uh ethical substance use policy.
- 6:24Michael Mulligan: I found that really interesting.
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: It's called the WESUP, the workers for ethical substance use policy.
- 6:30Michael Mulligan: And the interesting reason they wish to intervene in it is one of the issues in here is that this new legislation, if uh is constitutionally valid, may permit this new version of the law society to require treatment, medical treatment of members, including mental health treatment.
- 6:48Michael Mulligan: Um and their one of their concerns there is the idea that you could have imposed mental health treatment by this regulatory body.
- 6:56Michael Mulligan: And I must say, when I listened, uh thought about that, I thought, geez, you know, you hope that's not gonna come about.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: But it actually caused me to think of um you you may have read uh recently uh of the uh passing of Barbara Finley, who is a uh uh well-known uh lawyer in the province who advocated uh for uh rights involving uh uh gay and lesbian groups and individuals.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: Um and one of the things I recall her talking about at a law society meeting was the fact that uh she in fact was, before she was permitted to become a lawyer, forced to go into mental health treatment institutionalized on the basis that being gay was at the time viewed as a mental health problem.
- 7:38Michael Mulligan: Wow.
- 7:38Michael Mulligan: And so she was in fact put in an institution against her will for that reason.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: Uh and so there's gonna be some real sensitivity to perhaps the idea that uh you might have uh the law society requiring forced mental medical treatment, including mental health treatment, uh, on people who are members.
- 7:57Michael Mulligan: And so that group is being given leave to intervene as well.
- 8:01Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the judge went through all of these uh groups uh and their perspectives.
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: Another interesting one was uh there's a group which is uh deals with um uh it's called Lawyers' Rights Watch Canada, and they're a group that deals with uh uh protecting lawyers and independence, in particular in the context of international law considerations.
- 8:24Michael Mulligan: And so they want to make submissions about things like UN principles of independence of the bar, and arguing that uh some of these changes would violate international law norms and obligations.
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: So all of them were granted leave to participate, uh, but also interestingly, uh the judge and the appeal itself will be heard by a panel of judges, or nearly three or five.
- 8:44Michael Mulligan: But this decision about intervening is made by one judge in advance.
- 8:48Michael Mulligan: Um, and so the judge granted leave for all of these twelve groups to participate on the basis they had this public interest standing, but set some rules to try to keep the thing on track, including saying each of these may each of these groups may file a fact and like a written argument uh of no more than 15 pages, and those have to be filed by uh October the 5th, so a short timeline to keep things on track, hopefully for that November hearing, um, and then indicated that the actual panel would get to decide whether they were going to permit these or any of these groups to make oral submissions in addition to their written submissions, again, to try to keep things on track.
- 9:27Michael Mulligan: So I thought it was an interesting decision, uh, both in terms of that uh controversial piece of uh legislation uh and also an example of uh how a court decides whether to allow third parties to intervene and participate uh in it.
- 9:42Michael Mulligan: And so we'll have to uh keep our eye on it and see what happens uh come November.
- 9:46Michael Mulligan: Uh I guess all of this may be uh, of course, contingent on what happens in the current election, uh, because I think the NDP was the only party that was in support of these changes.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: So if there's a change there, maybe all of this becomes uh moot.
- 9:59Michael Mulligan: Uh but otherwise we'll wait and see what happens uh uh in November in the court of appeal.
- 10:03Adam Stirling: All right, Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense or continue right after this.
- 10:12Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with mulligan defense or Michael B is liable for more than$4.8 million uh brain increase that occurred in 2007.
- 10:23Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 10:25Michael Mulligan: Well, uh it's a the real tragedy in a pool is the short answer to that.
- 10:30Michael Mulligan: Uh but uh does raise a number of interesting things, including, as you mentioned, when this happened and sort of how this figure was arrived at.
- 10:36Michael Mulligan: Uh, and you're quite right.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: The actual accident here was a tragedy.
- 10:40Michael Mulligan: It involved a four-year-old at the time, uh, and the four-year-old was in swimming lessons at a pool that was operated by the municipality uh there in Burnaby.
- 10:49Michael Mulligan: Um and the swimming lessons that was for you know young kids under six, he was four, uh, and the background of it is that uh it was the last lesson, um, and the last 15 minutes of the 30-minute lesson, the last one, involved what was described as quote, playtime, where the children were permitted to uh go on different things as they saw fit.
- 11:11Michael Mulligan: Like there was a slide, play with toys, go to the shallow pool, or in this case use the diving boards.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: Um and the uh pool had uh apparently two diving boards.
- 11:22Michael Mulligan: One was a one-meter diving board, the other is a three-meter diving board.
- 11:25Michael Mulligan: And it sounds like they may not have been those springy ones, but rather like uh, you know, concrete thing you could walk up to and jump into the pool from.
- 11:32Michael Mulligan: Um and the uh at the time, interestingly, the pool apparently had a sign up that said children under seven must have a like a supervisor or adult in the pool if they're gonna be jumping in off the diving board.
- 11:44Michael Mulligan: Um and so this particular child during playtime, uh, who had a life jacket on, because it was still, you know, wasn't a the instructor hadn't seen him uh swim the length of the pool, uh first of all uh showed the instructor that he could jump in from like the edge of the pool, uh, and then went up and jumped in from the one-meter diving board.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: And when he jumped in, interestingly, the instructor said he went over and was helping him get to the side of the pool to get back out, uh, and the child pushed him away and wanted to go do it himself.
- 12:14Michael Mulligan: And the child then went up to the three-meter diving board and very tragically fell off the side of it, like didn't go into the water, but somehow fell off the side and landed on the concrete pool deck, um, which caused tragically, he hit his head on the concrete, um, and uh his mother rushed over.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: She was a doctor, she was there, but not directly supervising it, and he eventually he wound up taken to children's hospital, he was put into an induced coma, and he wound up having uh quite a severe traumatic brain injury as a result of this that's had impacts on him ever since.
- 12:49Michael Mulligan: Now, the next thing to know, which is I think maybe of news to some people, is you're wondering why is this case taken since 2007?
- 12:56Michael Mulligan: Uh, because ordinarily uh there are sort of limitation periods.
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: If you're suing, you've got to get on with that, right, through different time periods, through different things, but you gotta get going.
- 13:04Michael Mulligan: But those are suspended for children until the child ordinarily, until the child becomes the age of majority, uh, and then they would be able to sue.
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: Um, and sometimes, like in this case, there's a good reason for that, because you want to see, well, how does this play out?
- 13:19Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 13:19Michael Mulligan: You know, some children might bounce back, maybe they recover from it, maybe there aren't from, but on the other hand, there might be.
- 13:25Michael Mulligan: And so now this child would now be 23 years of age and is now a university student.
- 13:31Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so there was all this evidence in this case about, first of all, the issue of who's responsible for falling off the diving board.
- 13:39Michael Mulligan: And the way that works from a civil perspective, when you're analyzing a claim in negligence, which is what this is, yeah, is first of all, a judge would decide, like, you know, what is the standard of care, and do do they owe a duty of care to the child?
- 13:52Michael Mulligan: It's not hard to conclude that a swimming instructor owes a duty of care to the kids he's teaching, right?
- 13:57Michael Mulligan: I don't think that's too challenging.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: And here the swimming instructor was employed by the city of Burnaby.
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: That's why the city of Burnaby is being sued, not, you know, the swimming instructor.
- 14:07Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 14:07Michael Mulligan: Um, and then the judge has to decide, well, what is the standard of care?
- 14:12Michael Mulligan: Like, how careful do you have to be?
- 14:13Michael Mulligan: And the way the judge defined that is that the uh swimming instructor needs to act like a reasonable and careful parent.
- 14:20Michael Mulligan: That would be the threshold.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: Um here the instructor was supervising four children within the pool, obviously was engaged, wasn't just you know, paying no attention, but you know, didn't go with the child up on the diving board.
- 14:32Michael Mulligan: The child wanted to do it himself, and he let him do that.
- 14:35Michael Mulligan: Um and so the judge ultimately found that the uh that was negligent.
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: It just was didn't meet the standard of care to let the uh four-year-old go up this concrete diving board.
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: And the judge had the benefit of um some expert evidence, including from a uh doctor who specializes in that, about pool safety.
- 14:54Michael Mulligan: And there's this evidence about you know what should you do to mitigate risk for children using diving boards.
- 15:00Michael Mulligan: Amazingly, there is an expert about that topic.
- 15:03Michael Mulligan: And, you know, first of all, it may be a good idea to have uh a parent or adult go up the diving board with the child or supervise them.
- 15:10Michael Mulligan: Uh but barring that, there are other things that might uh increase safety, including things like having soft landing areas and so on, so you don't, if you fall off the side, just land on the concrete or having like a uh railing, you know, so somebody isn't can't just easily fall off the side of this thing where there isn't water.
- 15:25Michael Mulligan: Um and so the judge found that indeed uh they had fallen below the standard of care of a reasonably reasonable, careful parent.
- 15:33Michael Mulligan: The municipality tried to, what's called third party, or say, well, you know, it's really the fault of the designer of the um diving board.
- 15:42Michael Mulligan: Uh that didn't get anywhere with the judge.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: The judge found that really wasn't the cause of the problem.
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: He said that was a misinterpretation of what the expert was saying about things that could have been done, and so that didn't go anywhere.
- 15:54Michael Mulligan: But uh because you can wait and sue, you could now the judge had the benefit of seeing, well, what impact did this have on this now?
- 16:01Michael Mulligan: I think he was now 20, he would be 23 years old.
- 16:04Michael Mulligan: And so there was all this evidence about like the impact this had on him, and it had lifelong impacts on him.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: Starting as a child after he got out of children's hospital, he became clumsy, struggled with balance, uh, was slow to complete tasks, had trouble through school with migraine headaches, uh, challenges, being able to answer questions, needing to take breaks, and he's clearly a determined uh fellow, like he's can't he's carried on uh into university.
- 16:33Michael Mulligan: Um and the other interesting element of it, and this is something that occurs in the civil case like this, the test for the judge is to try to put the person back in the position they would have been in, but for what happened, right?
- 16:47Michael Mulligan: Kind of restore you to what would have been, you know, how would your life have been to best you can with money.
- 16:52Michael Mulligan: Um and so it's like the opposite of how it would now work under like no fault.
- 16:56Michael Mulligan: If this is a car accident and a child gets injured, well, you don't do any assessment as to what might the child have earned in the future, you just say they're earning nothing now, and so you don't get anything in terms of the largest part of this kind of a claim is typically, as in this case, what impact did it have on the child's capacity to earn an income?
- 17:13Michael Mulligan: And in Canada, that's particularly a focus because uh there's a limit on what somebody can get for you know what are called non-pecuniary damages, like pain and suffering.
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: You may hear about like in the news from the United States these giant awards for people that you know burn themselves with coffee and so on.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: Um and we don't have that in Canada, and that's as a result of this series of cases from 1978 where the Supreme Court of Canada at that time, it's called the trilogy, is often how it's referred to, limited the amount of money you can get for pain and suffering to at that time$100,000.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: In the most severe case, if somebody became a quadriplegic, for example, as a result of an accident,$100,000 was the max.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: And that's been over time kind of grossed up for inflation, and so now it's about$470,000, is the most you could get if you had the most impact possible on your as a result of pain and suffering.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: And so in this case, that amounted to$300,000.
- 18:11Michael Mulligan: It had a serious impact on this child, now adult, which will be ongoing the rest of his life, but that's the amount that's awarded for that.
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: And so the large part of the award, the$4.3 million, was an award based on an assessment of what will this child, what now this adult, be able to earn.
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: He's now uh going to university and he's going to become a physiotherapist.
- 18:33Michael Mulligan: His goal was to go to medical school, uh, but uh, and the judge found that that was a reasonable goal for him.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: He's very determined.
- 18:40Michael Mulligan: Both of his parents are doctors, interestingly.
- 18:43Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the other interesting thing is the judge pointed out from some of the expert evidence about it, the most relevant evidence is the educational and career paths of the parents and family members of somebody because you're trying to predict what might happen.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: And so he found it would be reasonable to think he could well have gone to medical school, but for the fact that he has attention deficit problems and executive dysfunction issues and you know can't work for long periods of time.
- 19:09Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found that was quite reasonable that he might well have become a doctor, but applied a contingency of 70%, saying he might not have got there.
- 19:18Michael Mulligan: Various other reasons he might not get in.
- 19:19Michael Mulligan: Competitive to become a doctor, right?
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: It may not have happened for some other reason.
- 19:23Michael Mulligan: Uh, but ultimately concluded that was reasonable, could well have happened, and then computed what he would make as a physiotherapist who can only work part-time uh because of his injury, concluded that he could work only about 20 hours per week, needing to take breaks, but that's what he was doing.
- 19:39Michael Mulligan: Um, and uh concluded that the difference between what he would make as a physiotherapist able to work twenty hours a week and what he could have made as a doctor for the rest of his career, uh, that is what amounted to four point three million dollars.
- 19:53Michael Mulligan: Um the other thing inter and then other heads of damages would be things like future care costs, like you know, counseling and things he might need.
- 20:00Michael Mulligan: And then the other final interesting element is$22,000 awarded for the Health Care Recovery Act, which is money designed to pay back the cost of the medical care that he got when he went to, you know, uh the children's hospital in Vancouver.
- 20:13Michael Mulligan: So that'll go to the government.
- 20:15Michael Mulligan: Um so that's how the total award was arrived at, and I thought it was a case worth commenting on because it has all of those elements being able to wait and see what happens for a child, how they assess those damages, uh, and how in actual civil cases you the judge is trying to figure out what would have happened but for this accident to make the person whole uh rather than going down a chart or saying, well, just multiply what you're currently making by the number of years until you're likely dead or retired.
- 20:42Adam Stirling: Um and so that's the outcome, and it'll be a big bill for the city of Burnaby.
- 20:46Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan is all the defense lawyers legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 20:51Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 20:52Adam Stirling: Pleasure is always thanks so much.
- 20:54Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 20:54Adam Stirling: All right, quick break.
- 20:55Adam Stirling: More after this.