Latest / Newcomer Pod / Josh Wolfe on America’s Next War and Why It Isn’t Taiwan
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the newcomer podcast. I'm Eric Newcomer.
- 0:03I'm here with Madeline Renbarger.
- 0:05Tom is sick. It was like I'm hard to work on
- 0:08the draft. He's doing doing work, but we're
- 0:11we're not making him jump on the podcast.
- 0:13You were in DC yesterday for the Hill and Valley Forum.
- 0:17We're going to have Josh Wolf from Lux in the second-half of
- 0:20the episode. Before we get into it though, we
- 0:23have to talk about the drama. The drama in Silicon Valley.
- 0:27This episode is presented by Brex, the financial stack
- 0:31founders can bank on. Brex knows cash is king for
- 0:34start-ups, so they build a banking experience that takes
- 0:37every dollar. Further, unlike traditional
- 0:40business banking solutions, Brex has no minimums and no
- 0:43transaction fees, and you can get 20X the standard FDIC
- 0:47protection. Even better, you can earn
- 0:49industry leading yield from your first dollar while still being
- 0:53able to access your funds anytime.
- 0:55Get the business account trusted by one in three US startups at
- 0:58brex.com/banking Dash Solutions. That's brex.com/banking Dash
- 1:08Solutions. Talking of course about the
- 1:12group chats. Madeline, what is the state of
- 1:15your group chats? My group chats, I, I'm not in as
- 1:18many group chats with, you know, world leaders and billionaires.
- 1:21Eric, have you ever been out? No cabal, no cabal group chats.
- 1:24Eric Thornberg, who sort of kick started some of this
- 1:27conversation, announced some of them on Twitter.
- 1:29And I tried to get in, but no, I think I was exactly the type of
- 1:32person they were trying to keep out of the group chats.
- 1:36You know, obviously I have my what?
- 1:38I have MSM talking. I have a small thread we call
- 1:42MSM talking points. Another one, you know, debate
- 1:45club with reporters. Anyway, let's let's give the
- 1:47context on the story. You want to give the quick sort
- 1:50of rundown just so people have that.
- 1:51Ben Smith published a story about, you know, the group chats
- 1:54that changed America, which was basically group chats kind of
- 1:57really spearheaded, you know, by Aaron Torberg and Marc
- 2:00Andreessen and the Andreessen crew, you know, putting all of
- 2:02these Silicon Valley leaders together with influential people
- 2:07in Washington. And his conclusion is that it
- 2:10really led to this moment that we have now politically with,
- 2:14you know, Trump coming back and Silicon Valley is kind of all
- 2:17gathering in boosterism of Trump.
- 2:19And that pitch. Part of it is that these chats
- 2:23are, you know, behind closed doors with the most powerful
- 2:25people in the world. They're not they're not building
- 2:27in public. And they began because backlash
- 2:29to the the wokeism and the scolding on Twitter.
- 2:32Exactly. I think they would say, oh,
- 2:34cancellations and wokeness started this and then we got
- 2:39chased off the Internet. We created group chats.
- 2:42I mean I think a key one. Just being chased off or, you
- 2:45know, just like choosing to leave, you know, like.
- 2:48I listen, I've been the loudest on say what you can't say.
- 2:52Like isn't bravery there? This is a class of people who
- 2:56talks about sort of manly virtues, you know, and bravery
- 3:00is a big one. And then they are not, they
- 3:02don't have the courage to say what they actually want to say.
- 3:05You know, it was such a game of like, oh, I, what can I, I, I
- 3:08don't know what I can't say. And then they go to the group
- 3:11chats. I mean, you can talk to your
- 3:13friends in private. And in some ways people are
- 3:15like, did you know about this? It's like, oh, I knew they had
- 3:17group chats. And certainly we knew when the
- 3:19Silicon Valley Bank crisis that some of these group chats were
- 3:22key to passing the message along.
- 3:23And I think we put that either in the podcast or some stories.
- 3:27That was kind of that. I mean, that was kind of an open
- 3:29secret at the time, right? Like how everyone reacted, you
- 3:31know, like, we kind of knew about them, but we just weren't
- 3:34in them. Yeah.
- 3:35I mean, Ben Smith's story in some ways, you know, you add
- 3:39mystique to these things. It's like, oh, a bunch of people
- 3:41talking in a thread, you know, not that shocking, but then it
- 3:45is. It was it was definitely
- 3:47interesting to see and that I didn't know like, for instance,
- 3:50that it's funny that Mark Cuban ends up being the great advocate
- 3:53for Democrats like he's I. Know out.
- 3:56There, but he's not like our best policy mind necessarily.
- 4:00I don't know, I I do think sometimes he's like conservative
- 4:03LED discussion groups sort of pick, you know, it's like Jason
- 4:07Calacanis is the best we have to put on the all in podcast to
- 4:10respond to David Sacks. Like often it's not, we're not
- 4:14sending our best. You know, they're not, they're
- 4:17not picking among the most sophisticated thinkers.
- 4:20They're they're picking people who are going to play nice.
- 4:23And you know, a big point from the group chat story, which just
- 4:26sort of Marc Andreessen and people like being like this.
- 4:28You need to stay on message like, and we're going to leave
- 4:31if you don't like it has this great image of, you know, David
- 4:33Sacks and I think Joe Lonsale leaving a group chat.
- 4:37It kind of forms its own groupthink within the group
- 4:40chat, right? Like that was the conclusion I
- 4:42got. You know, where it's like you're
- 4:44mad about the groupthink on your other platform, but joining a
- 4:48group chat of your, you know, people who have intellectual
- 4:51debates but are all kind of within one set parameter.
- 4:54You don't really have the like, iconoclastic leftists in this
- 4:58group chat. It's still kind of your network.
- 5:00So how much of that is just furthering the group think you
- 5:04claim to protest? To me, they read as they exist
- 5:08to workshop compelling arguments and reasons that could be used
- 5:12to further a sort of established conclusion that you need to be
- 5:16sort of against the Democrats. And so then it's like, if you
- 5:19can come up with good arguments for us to use that hit
- 5:23Democrats, like welcome. But if you're really just going
- 5:26back to the sort of core argument of sort of Trump versus
- 5:29the Democrats, then you're wasting our time.
- 5:33It it's sort of more evidence that Twitter is not real life,
- 5:36that like people are not sort of sincerely putting their views on
- 5:40on Twitter and everything. But, you know, I think we've
- 5:43known that for a while. Do you feel like they have the
- 5:46same level of influence now that the the chats are kind of
- 5:49mainstream and that's that's the whole culture like it's broken
- 5:53through now? Their secret, How are we
- 5:55supposed to know? No well, I think right after it
- 5:59came out we're in a brief period of like, oh, you know, follow on
- 6:02VCs like I need to get in the chats.
- 6:04So I don't know, there's a spurt of enthusiasm and like people
- 6:07want to be relevant. I mean, I Andreessen hired Eric
- 6:11Torenberg, you know, to I think create more chats.
- 6:15They'd had Sriram, you know, who's now in the Trump
- 6:18administration making chats too. So I think this sort of
- 6:22community building through private discussion groups, I
- 6:25mean, why see, you know, has always had book face.
- 6:28So private, private groups where people are keeping secrets
- 6:32pretty well is it's not totally new.
- 6:34So no, I I think this continues. I mean, hopefully if only the
- 6:38Trump people can rattle eradicate cancel culture, then
- 6:41they'll start seeing what they think online.
- 6:44But. Only we can abolish woke and
- 6:47then real discourse can make it back into the arena.
- 6:50We're obviously, you know, at newcomer and as reporters, fans
- 6:53of building in public. I'd love to either be added to
- 6:56the group chats, but more importantly, I would love the
- 6:58conversations to just be had. Like I like when people just say
- 7:01what they're doing. And I think that kind of candor
- 7:04and open dialogue. Obviously people are afraid of
- 7:06it, but it feels like we've switched to a degree where it's
- 7:10like, who gets to say? I do think the.
- 7:12Shortcoming of the media and like our or not even the media,
- 7:17but sort of the environment is that if you're an important
- 7:19person and you put a take on Twitter, it seems like you're
- 7:23like fully baked opinion. And if you're sort of in a group
- 7:27chat with friends, you're sort of talking through your opinions
- 7:30and formulating them. And so how do we make a sort of
- 7:35Twitter for tentative thoughts and a Twitter for this is my,
- 7:40you know, established take? Even from the like the left,
- 7:44there's no room for breathing, you know?
- 7:47And some like prominent left figures have been cancelled for
- 7:50being not left enough when they're just, you know, out in
- 7:53the shit, you know, and trying to talk through ideas and
- 7:55workshop stuff. And if it's not fully baked,
- 7:57they get come forward too, you know.
- 7:58So I think like it's it, it is worth it to have a place where
- 8:02you can do that openly and, you know, workshop what you're
- 8:05thinking and be able to freely post.
- 8:07Chatter baked. Baked, right.
- 8:09I mean, we tweet like headline da, da, da, da, da da.
- 8:11You know, I don't know. Yeah, I do think chats are good
- 8:15for ideas that you're formulating.
- 8:18You were in DC yesterday for the Hill and Valley Forum.
- 8:22What? What was the mood there?
- 8:24The mood was really celebratory, Eric.
- 8:27I mean, it felt like honestly, the on stage panels were a bit
- 8:31of a victory lap for the Silicon Valley China Hawks and defense
- 8:36founders who, you know, have been pushing this agenda of, you
- 8:39know, how tech and national security can work really well
- 8:41together, should work really well together.
- 8:43Everyone in the room was really in consensus on ideas that, you
- 8:46know, event Co host Jacob Helberg has been pushing for
- 8:49both and, you know, as an advisor to Palantir and then in
- 8:52his own work lobbying in Congress for, you know, China
- 8:55hawkishness and better synchronicity between cutting
- 8:59innovation in Silicon Valley and defense and government
- 9:03operations. I mean, really, it felt like
- 9:05that idea theology has kind of like become the mainstream in
- 9:09Silicon Valley, Like everyone there is totally bought in.
- 9:12If you zoom out last year at Hillen Valley, we were saying,
- 9:16man, they're trying to normalize Trump.
- 9:17They snuck Trump in. We were a little bit like, oh,
- 9:21they're trying to make it OK to be a Republican.
- 9:24On the one hand, it seems a little more like they've got a
- 9:26mix of sort of Democrats and Republicans.
- 9:28On the other hand, it's like Trump won.
- 9:31It's you can't normalize him anymore.
- 9:33It's like he's governing. So they there was clearly just
- 9:35like the victory lap on, you know, we're in charge.
- 9:38We get to set the mood. But we did end our story with
- 9:42the like, you know what, it felt like morning in America.
- 9:45But if you look outside, you know, it's like the world is not
- 9:48as bright necessarily as it seems in the room.
- 9:52Do they talk about like the markets and how they can
- 9:55idealize tariffs and say, oh, we should be competing with China
- 10:00on stronger footing? But then as implemented, the
- 10:03tariffs are like insane and going to cause a ton of problems
- 10:06and it's sort of a nearing train wreck.
- 10:08Very hard to deny that the situation is going to get worse,
- 10:12not better unless situation changes soon.
- 10:15Or did they, did they touch on any of that?
- 10:18The tariffs did come up because one of the biggest themes of the
- 10:20day was reshoring American manufacturing.
- 10:23Like, in addition to, you know, defense and space investing,
- 10:26there's was a huge emphasis in the panels about how important
- 10:29it is that startups be at the forefront of setting up, you
- 10:32know, this new manufacturing core in America.
- 10:36And so in a sense, the tariffs came up because that's kind of a
- 10:40part of the policy to do that. It was muted skepticism from the
- 10:44people who were a little bit more, you know, hesitant to say
- 10:47that these were a good idea. They were not saying, oh, the
- 10:51markets are, that we're about to enter a recession and that all
- 10:55our enthusiasm could be dampened by no, no, OK.
- 10:59Yeah. Which felt, which always, which
- 11:00felt a little bit, you know, just the better narrative of the
- 11:03event. It was clearly successful, but
- 11:05it was so bizarre to, you know, be in this kind of bubble
- 11:08inside. A theory, you know, part part of
- 11:12investing and being a good investor is making sure you have
- 11:15follow on capital, right. And so there's sort of a
- 11:18rational cult like behavior that you get into Silicon Valley
- 11:22where you're like, I need to make sure if I take this risky
- 11:25defense tech investment, somebody else will be the dumb
- 11:29money after me or at least sort of have conviction that there
- 11:32will be more money until it finally gets to where it needs
- 11:35to be. And so these events, they all
- 11:38need to psychologically brainwash themselves.
- 11:41All right, we all, it's, it's sort of a group sharing that
- 11:44we're all going to lock in, we're going to do defense tech.
- 11:47We're going to be hawkish on China.
- 11:48We fully divested from China. America is coming back.
- 11:51It needs the cult like behavior, which in some ways is a positive
- 11:55sign for the category because they're saying we're all going
- 11:58to dump money into defense tech, circumstances be damned.
- 12:03You mentioned, you know, I, I love Emil Michael and Bill
- 12:06Gurley, but Emil, you know, X Travis Kalanick, deputy, former
- 12:10Uber guy from much of my coverage, sort of took a subtle
- 12:14dig at Gurley and Benchmark on stage.
- 12:16What was that? You know, Meal's now Under
- 12:17Secretary of Defense and was on a panel with Kevin Wheel from
- 12:20Open AI and. So you don't lose your petty
- 12:22gripes. You don't.
- 12:24You don't lose your petty feuds when you become Under Secretary
- 12:26of Defense. Yeah.
- 12:28I mean, it was basically just, you know, there's been the
- 12:30Bloomberg reporting that benchmarks invested in Chinese
- 12:32company Manus AI's. Arfur Arfur.
- 12:34Rock Scoop. Yes, and I've rock scoop that,
- 12:37Bloomberg confirmed. And they did not.
- 12:39Credit they didn't credit. We credit our for rock if he's
- 12:42first. I don't think Bloomberg
- 12:43mentioned him. I think the rest of the tech
- 12:46press kind of just like. Treats him like he's just a
- 12:49chipster, like he's right, he's getting it right.
- 12:52Almost at the time. It's one thing if he's like,
- 12:55sort of. Anyway, yeah, keep going.
- 12:57Anyway, Benchmark. Emil was just kind of like, you
- 12:59know, there's not, it's not like there's not a plethora of U.S.
- 13:01companies doing AI to investing right now, you know, So it was,
- 13:05I would say it was like, you know, subtle, but not so subtle.
- 13:08Sorry, he was shitting on benchmarks investment in Manus
- 13:13and say, no, he could have found it, could have found U.S.
- 13:15companies. And I, I mean, we said this in
- 13:17the story. What's more contrarian than
- 13:19being pro China? You know, a lot of these people
- 13:22self criticize VC's for not being contrarian.
- 13:25And then what? It would be truly contrarian, a
- 13:27little sort of like Comfort with China from Benchmark, which I
- 13:31think is an interesting theme. It's strange to have that
- 13:33posture when you're on top, you know, I don't know.
- 13:36I think like there's still was certainly, you know, I would say
- 13:39a boogeyman in China that really like covered almost every single
- 13:43panel. It was very, you know, that was
- 13:45the tone in this circle in particular.
- 13:47And I think honestly more broadly in Silicon Valley now,
- 13:50that's just established to be the case.
- 13:53Yeah, I want to hear the first principles reasoning from Josh
- 13:56Wolf, who we'll talk to in a second from Lux.
- 14:00Josh was actually one of the voices that was like a little
- 14:02more moderating on the tariffs for sure.
- 14:04We should be, you know, ramping up this onshoring before we put
- 14:08the hammer down entirely, you know, and try like targeted
- 14:11efforts rather than blanket price increases on all of this
- 14:15before we have the technology really here.
- 14:17So that was, you know, refreshing to hear.
- 14:19The whole point of the tariffs is supposed to be, I mean,
- 14:23there's an American resilience and sort of National Defense
- 14:25part, and that's important. But for the Trump people, it's
- 14:28about jobs and what sort of American life works.
- 14:32Like where, where was the Silicon Valley set salivating
- 14:37over robots at this event? Or what was the balance between
- 14:40excitement over robots and human American workers getting jobs
- 14:44because of all of this? That was also a thing where I
- 14:47feel like, OK, you're having both, you know, like, where did
- 14:50you land on this? Where's the reality?
- 14:52But I think people were very on message about the robotics boom
- 14:57in factories enhances our workers to do be more productive
- 15:01rather than they'll totally take all the jobs.
- 15:04Jensen Wong spoke on stage from NVIDIA and, you know, touted his
- 15:07plan to invest 500 billion in ship manufacturing in the US
- 15:11over the next few years. And within that, you know, he
- 15:13was talking about all the work that will come from skilled
- 15:17laborers modeling the factory with digital twins to, you know,
- 15:20ramp out, you know, solve all the problems before they get on
- 15:24the floor and then have all those jobs to be manufacturing
- 15:27chips. And that being, you know, really
- 15:28important for our trade workers to bring in, you know, and also
- 15:31just, you know, building the factories themselves will take a
- 15:33lot of American labor. So that was kind of the, I would
- 15:36say, the party line of the event about how this would work.
- 15:39I do still feel like it wasn't really answered how all of this
- 15:43will happen when all the raw materials are tariffed out of
- 15:47existence coming into the country, but.
- 15:50If we don't have the minerals from China, we're in big
- 15:52trouble. Excited to hear from Josh.
- 15:55He was on stage at Hill and Valley.
- 15:58Any What should people know about what he said on stage
- 16:00before we start grilling him? Yeah.
- 16:02Josh moderated a panel with Senator Jack Reed.
- 16:05And Josh's panel was all about autonomy and National Defense
- 16:09against China with Senator Jack Reed and case our units from
- 16:12Applied Intuition and where AI technology and robotic intersect
- 16:17with national security and how all of that is really relevant
- 16:20going forward. So happy to chat more about that
- 16:22too. Josh, good to see you again.
- 16:24Thanks so much for coming on. Great to see you both how you
- 16:27doing? For for those of us who were not
- 16:29at Hilton Valley, do you want to just say what was your like core
- 16:31message on your panel or what do you, what do you think you were
- 16:34trying to get across? Well, our our core message was
- 16:36very focused because I had an amazing entrepreneur that we
- 16:38back from the beginning, Caster Eunice, who was the founder of
- 16:41replied intuition. I got to tell you, we've got
- 16:43hundreds of companies that we've invested in.
- 16:44It is, I believe, the only actual cash flow positive
- 16:48business, which is just insane. He's a, he's a crazy operator.
- 16:51He is all focused on autonomy for a VS for commercial sector
- 16:55and then for defense, because it's effectively the same thing.
- 16:57If you're trying to figure out how to get a car to be
- 17:00autonomously navigated and you're trying to figure out how
- 17:02to get a tank or a plane or something else, you know, it's
- 17:04vehicles and, and things that are moving.
- 17:06So a big focus on our center, which was also with Senator Reed
- 17:08from Rhode Island, was how do you balance American
- 17:13competitiveness? How do you balance the fact that
- 17:16these things are effectively these things being autonomous
- 17:18vehicles, data centers on wheels and the security and
- 17:22vulnerability because those are threat factors that adversaries,
- 17:24particularly China, but you could also think about Iran,
- 17:27North Korea, Russia want to penetrate.
- 17:29Kassar had just gotten back from China, so he was able to sort of
- 17:32report out. He would tell you that the AV
- 17:34industry and the EV industry there are not only huge but but
- 17:38but winning. He also talked about the
- 17:40surveillance state experience being there, like how different
- 17:44it is technologically. Yeah, that.
- 17:46I mean, that's no surprise. I think the last time I was in
- 17:48Beijing, Shanghai, Hangzhou was 2019, right before COVID, maybe
- 17:52it was really 2020. I think it's the last time I'll
- 17:54be able to go for a while until there's regime change, which may
- 17:56not happen in my lifetime just because of how outspoken I am on
- 17:59the Chinese Communist Party. But I remember when my wife was
- 18:02saying, you know, make sure you use separate phones and all this
- 18:04kind of stuff. And you know, and I do and I
- 18:06did. But the second you land, you
- 18:08know, it's fingerprints, facial ID like you're captured and
- 18:11you're tracked everywhere. And that's only improved.
- 18:14And that was really before the rise of the data capture was
- 18:17there, but the AI and the algos to do identification were just
- 18:20coming to Fort. So, you know, that's one of the
- 18:22great things that I think people think that technology is always
- 18:25this great democratizing force, and it's going to give people
- 18:27more expression and more freedom and more access and more
- 18:30connectivity, and it can do that.
- 18:32But not necessarily. Yeah, but anybody can also be
- 18:35used as a tool of oppression. Private companies there, as you
- 18:38know, are mandated to be part of the military civil fusion, which
- 18:42is if you make something the government, you know, has
- 18:44effective full margin rights to basically just say that's going
- 18:46to be used by us to make sure we advance whatever principles we
- 18:49need to advance here or abroad. What in some ways this event was
- 18:53cheering the a military civil fusion of American companies
- 18:57with U.S. government? Or how do you, as someone sort
- 18:59of troubled about that in China, how do you see sort of the US
- 19:03taking sort of a different, more noble path while making sure
- 19:07that the government is getting the best technology it can?
- 19:11Well, it's something Castor and I, the center we're talking
- 19:13about, which is, you know, there's a few lines in our
- 19:16Constitution which are the distinction between a
- 19:18surveillance state and individual freedoms.
- 19:21And, you know, as many have said, democracy is, you know,
- 19:25the worst of all systems, but, you know, it's the least worst
- 19:28or the best of a whole bunch of bad systems, but our system is
- 19:31the best in the world. I don't want to live in a
- 19:33theocracy. I don't want to live in
- 19:34authoritarian or authoritarian state.
- 19:36Technology can be used by leaders of those States and has
- 19:40been from Hitler and Mussolini who commandeered radio.
- 19:45You know, we thought that would be a great liberating thing.
- 19:47But I but I think that the big message here was like why the US
- 19:50is different? Is it isn't like this BS rah
- 19:53rah, you know, freedom jingoistic.
- 19:55It really is not trying to suppress individuals.
- 19:59It is not trying to create a social score based on whether
- 20:03you pledge fealty to the great leader and whether you will be
- 20:06allowed onto the train or whether your kids will get
- 20:09admission into a school where you will get shows to show
- 20:13tickets to the concert. This mechanism, which is
- 20:15straight out of Black Mirror, it makes Black Mirror writers look
- 20:18totally uncreative because it's real.
- 20:20It might have been presaged half a decade ago, but it's very
- 20:23real. Did we just see, you know, Chris
- 20:26Krebs, who had sort of spoken out against Trump, is now
- 20:29alleging literally today he lost Global Entry status because of,
- 20:34he presumes, sort of anger from the Trump administration?
- 20:39I have, I have no. Idea that you don't know that
- 20:41example, but I'm just saying what you're describing it sort
- 20:43of fit. I don't think it's so.
- 20:45We're so insulated from that potential in the United States,
- 20:49are you? Feeling I think look that is a
- 20:51right and just fear that anybody should have about people
- 20:54pledging loyalty or authoritarian instincts and and
- 20:57how technology can be used in those ways and you know all
- 21:00those things are are very complicated.
- 21:01But we do have freedom of speech here, and we do have freedom of
- 21:04expression and freedom of religion, freedom of sexual
- 21:07married. Yeah, Ryan Peterson just posted.
- 21:10Like, I've been shitting on the Trump administration over
- 21:12tariffs, and nobody's coming for me.
- 21:14It's been great to have freedom of speech, right?
- 21:18Look, I I I did not vote for Trump.
- 21:20I didn't vote for Kamala, you know, I voted, actually.
- 21:23Hold. Hold on.
- 21:24Ready. I think there were seven people
- 21:25in my party. I know Romney well.
- 21:30I'll be. Honest, Hold on, hold on.
- 21:31I made these hats before I consulted with my boss, which is
- 21:34my wife, OK. And, and one of the top issues
- 21:38in our household is women's rights broadly and reproductive
- 21:41rights. So she reminded me that I needed
- 21:44to flip the ticket, which I did when I voted.
- 21:46It was Bloomberg, Romney, but. So I got asked at Human X, my
- 21:51favorite billionaire and I, you know, I worked for Bloomberg.
- 21:53I said Bloomberg I think was my favorite billionaire.
- 21:55So I, I not, not, not wrong. Never going to get elected
- 21:59unfortunately. No, he, I mean, look, he, he, I
- 22:02truly felt, and this is a weird thing to say, that I think that
- 22:05billionaires should run for office and hold office.
- 22:09And whether Mitt was a billionaire or close to 100,
- 22:12Trump was not really a billionaire when he was running.
- 22:14You know, maybe he became profiting off his name later.
- 22:16But, and the reason is I don't think that they could be bought.
- 22:18I don't really think that there was anything when Mike Bloomberg
- 22:20was running the city of New York where he could be bought.
- 22:22And frankly, when there were cuts to the arts here in the
- 22:26city, he reached into Bloomberg Philanthropies and it was like
- 22:29100 million plus to keep up the arts.
- 22:32That's the kind of benevolent mayor I want.
- 22:34And is he driven by pure virtue? Probably not.
- 22:36It's probably his legacy and, and his reputation and his
- 22:40family and all that kind of stuff.
- 22:41But man, you know, I I wish he was a better debater and you
- 22:45know. Yeah, you got to win the stage
- 22:48presence. I do want to circle back a
- 22:50little bit to what we talked about at what was what was
- 22:53discussed at Hiland Valley this year.
- 22:55One big conversation of course was, you know, around reshoring
- 22:57manufacturing. And part of that is made
- 23:00complicated by the fact that China has so many of the
- 23:03critical minerals. So with this aggressive tariff
- 23:06policy, there's they have things that we don't have yet and maybe
- 23:10we do under reserves, but we need to get them and that's
- 23:12going to take time. Where do you land on that
- 23:15liberating stance between A1 size fits all tariff policy and
- 23:18not? Like how does that score with
- 23:20the reindustrialization mission? Let me break it down from the
- 23:24top layer, which is the tariffs and I will say either this was
- 23:27the greatest policy blunder and worst roll out in the history of
- 23:31presidential decrees and economic sphere or and and I'm
- 23:35giving a lot of credence here. This is not what I believe, but
- 23:37I'm giving credence. It is part of a grander bargain
- 23:40and particularly China and and the game theory that I can see
- 23:44playing out. And again, I don't know that
- 23:45this was a priority planned. I'm not giving them the credit
- 23:49to say that this was, you know, some grand scheme of 40 chess,
- 23:53OK. I think it was most likely that
- 23:55this was haphazard and chaotic, maybe ideological driven.
- 24:00I personally think that what happened is post election, you
- 24:03had this boom of rah, rah golden age of America.
- 24:09It was like a just a echo Chamber of homogeneous only up
- 24:14from here. And then you started to see big
- 24:16tech with the recomposition of Zucks board and meta.
- 24:20And you started to see one by one people taking the literal or
- 24:25figurative knee and the $1,000,000 for the inauguration,
- 24:291 by 1. And they're all lined up and and
- 24:31I think that they're starting to be a confidence from the
- 24:34administration of we are running the table and everybody is
- 24:38bending down to us. And I think that that then got
- 24:41exacerbated onto the global stage.
- 24:42And it was sort of like when the tariff thing happened.
- 24:45We control the cards and China's like, yeah, we make the cards.
- 24:48So so that you're. Saying tech capitulated so well,
- 24:54the Trump's like, oh, we're so powerful.
- 24:56We're going to, we're going to keep running the table, right,
- 24:58Right. I think that that is probably
- 25:00the psychological confidence slash overconfidence that led to
- 25:05that, that first part of why this rollout happened.
- 25:07Now from here, I am more sanguine than everybody and I'll
- 25:10tell you why. Beginning the tariff rollout 3-4
- 25:13weeks ago, whatever it was 4 weeks ago, I had friends that
- 25:16were reading hundreds of papers, hundreds of research reports,
- 25:18sell side by side everything they could get.
- 25:20And I had other people that were reading nothing.
- 25:21I said, you know, come Monday morning, both of you will know
- 25:23the exact same thing, which is nobody knows nothing.
- 25:25You have no idea what's going to happen.
- 25:27I was shocked by only one thing, which was that people were
- 25:30shocked by the tariffs. I mean, Trump has been talking
- 25:33about for 25 years. He campaigned on them.
- 25:35Democrats hit him on the fact that he was going to do tariffs
- 25:38repeatedly. And then they do it and it's
- 25:40like, okay, wait, there's a shock.
- 25:41So if you were long volatility, if you bought deep out of the
- 25:43money puts like you did great. We happen to do that as a
- 25:46family. Because I was like, all I hear
- 25:47is positive, positive, positive, nowhere but down to go from
- 25:51here. So I don't know what the
- 25:52catalyst is going to be, but it just feels like something is
- 25:54going to crack. OK, so that's the first part.
- 25:56What happens from here? If you were long volatility, you
- 25:59were right. Because Trump 1.0 it was all
- 26:02about chaos and crazy and volatility.
- 26:04Well, now you have volatility. If you are a country or a
- 26:07company, the number one thing that you hear from CEOs and
- 26:09executives and boards, they all have the same uniform consensus,
- 26:12which to me is always like, where's the variant perception?
- 26:14Everybody's like, we're paralyzed.
- 26:16We don't want to make CapEx decisions.
- 26:18We're not going to hire. Our demand signals are really
- 26:22noisy because a lot of people pulled forward demand.
- 26:24Consumers bought a lot of stuff because they're not sure of
- 26:26themselves. And so you have this aberrant
- 26:28spike in sales for a lot of companies, but you have CapEx
- 26:31that's super low. You have GDP that came out
- 26:33negative for the first time in, you know, a very long time.
- 26:36So what's scarce today is predictability and stability.
- 26:41OK, Now go to the global stage. If you're Japan or Korea or
- 26:45India or Germany and you are feeling the same thing because
- 26:49of this chaos, would you pay a premium to get stability and
- 26:53certainty and predictability for the next five years or 10 years?
- 26:56I think you might. Now, I don't think that was
- 26:59calculated, but my prediction, which is why I'm more sanguine.
- 27:01A week ago, JD Vance, Indian wife goes to India, not a deal,
- 27:06but a deal to do a deal in India.
- 27:08OK, But that's an important thing.
- 27:10It's a billion 5 people of the world.
- 27:12OK. Next, you know, most populous
- 27:14country, China billion 4. We're 375 million people.
- 27:17So if India looks and says we can do a deal here, maybe boost
- 27:22our aerospace and defence, maybe boost partial but.
- 27:24This so you think the outcome is that we have lower tariffs in
- 27:29some of these allied countries at the end of this or that's
- 27:31what the wins certain situation is like he wins if it get but he
- 27:35likes tariffs. You just said that he he like he
- 27:38believes it. What he likes is winning.
- 27:40He likes deals. He likes leverage.
- 27:42It isn't the sake of tariffs, it's the sake of feeling that
- 27:45there's inequity, that somebody's getting a better
- 27:46deal. So twist the table so that we
- 27:49get a better deal, right? That kind of thing.
- 27:50Now, if Japan comes to the table, and they are, and I got
- 27:55to tell you, Scott Besson, close friend, I think he's one of, if
- 27:58not maybe the adult in the room. He is erudite, sophisticated,
- 28:02knows markets and currencies and bonds and history, but he also
- 28:05knows human nature. And people are like, why isn't
- 28:07he speaking out? Because he knows human nature.
- 28:09He's not going up against his boss so that he can get fired.
- 28:11And none of us want him fired, right?
- 28:14So increase the most hysterical television interviews where he
- 28:17can't really. Yeah, anyway.
- 28:19Scott's. Scott's recipe for the US and
- 28:23when he was interviewing for the job and got it as Treasury
- 28:25Secretary was predicated on the Japan model of the sort of three
- 28:28arrows. And so I think that he will get
- 28:31a deal with Japan, a deal with India, a deal with South Korea.
- 28:33And by the way, if you're a South Korean motor manufacturer
- 28:36and you have like, I don't know, 4% market share in the US or
- 28:38something like that, because China's got 50 or 60%.
- 28:40Would you do a deal that says, Hey, we'll do a 10 year deal
- 28:43with you, The government and defense and a bunch of our other
- 28:45industries are going to buy from you.
- 28:47We're going to keep tariffs high on China.
- 28:48Your market shares can go to from 4:00 to 12:00 or 16.
- 28:51You're going to triple or quadruple your, your, your
- 28:54ownership. I think that we might see a, a
- 28:56grand bargain with a bunch of those countries.
- 28:58And then the big thing, which is probably going to take two years
- 29:00is China. And the optimistic view here is
- 29:04you get not just trade, but remember it's a whole bunch of
- 29:08stuff that's on the table. TikTok.
- 29:10Is the delay on TikTok really about the delay so they can
- 29:13figure it out and find a buyer? Or is it that and part of a
- 29:16grand bargain with China, fentanyl IP?
- 29:20You know, there's a whole bunch of other things to figure out in
- 29:22this grand bargain and all these things are shits on the table.
- 29:25So I'm a little bit more sank. I am much more skeptical than
- 29:28you. I mean, first of all, Japan, it
- 29:30could very well drive them closer to China and there have
- 29:32been signs of that. You're omitting Europe, which is
- 29:35our most important set set of allies, which are are really
- 29:39turned off by this. And finally, we just had the
- 29:41Canadian election where Trump rallied the whole country to the
- 29:45Liberal Party when they probably would have gone conservative
- 29:47like I just that is a great bellwether that the our global
- 29:52allies are not reading this tariff strategy as making
- 29:56friends and bringing them closer.
- 29:57I'm shaking my head violently because you are 100% correct.
- 30:01On the media, the newspapers, the popular opinion culture.
- 30:05OK, but. Canada, but like if you're.
- 30:09Sweating by Canada relatively irrelevant, like in the big
- 30:13scheme of things, certainly for our.
- 30:14Defence, it's one of our closest trading.
- 30:16Part it's right yeah and then and they need us and we need
- 30:18them and it'll work out and OK it'll it'll be fine we'll have
- 30:20like a little bit of schoolyard fight but it'll work out Europe
- 30:24who are they turning to for the security umbrella literally who
- 30:28are they turning to they're. Going to go themselves.
- 30:30They're going to go how? Long is that going to take?
- 30:32How long is that going to take to build up a defense where who
- 30:35who's making F30 fives for them? I, I just I am way more I am.
- 30:40You are 100% correct. The popular opinion tourists,
- 30:43The media? Entertainment companies like the
- 30:47Max. That's not the media.
- 30:48It's the regular, regular people, human beings, the
- 30:50massive, right tourists, right? 99% of people could be like,
- 30:55Americans suck under Trump, I'm not going there, whatever.
- 30:57But the people that matter are the generals and the war
- 31:02fighters. And they're not saying, yeah, we
- 31:04don't like Trump, he's a Dick. We're not.
- 31:07We're not going to buy weapon systems.
- 31:09The entire world depends on cheap manufacturing from China,
- 31:15oil and that gas mostly from the Mideast and weapon systems from
- 31:19the United States. And unfortunately, those weapon
- 31:23systems really matter. They do matter, but I guess I'm
- 31:26curious to see if if they're the only thing that matters, you
- 31:29know, there's lots else going on.
- 31:30No, they don't. No, but but I just think that
- 31:33the average person on the street is not like I hate America.
- 31:38So I'm not. So like you have no say in
- 31:40whether weapons systems are sold.
- 31:42You have a say whether you're subscribing to Netflix or you're
- 31:45buying American fashion brands or you're tweeting and yelling
- 31:49about America. But I'm telling you that the
- 31:51trillion dollar defense budget and the enormity of our
- 31:57industrial defense base globally, which needs to be
- 32:00refreshed domestically, is just a major source of leverage that
- 32:05the average person takes for granted because they never think
- 32:07about it. I mean, what do, what do you see
- 32:09as like the goal here? I I mean, like, to me the goals
- 32:14would be, yeah, like get to a free trade environment, avoid
- 32:19war with China, which would include avoiding an actual like
- 32:22invasion of Taiwan. Like I guess to me the Trump
- 32:25stuff I'm seeing where eroding free trade we're making it with
- 32:31with Ukraine and other things. The signals are that we're less
- 32:33likely to defend Taiwan. So I I don't know what are we
- 32:37building up all this military might for if at the same time we
- 32:41seem totally disinclined to mount the the 2 greatest fronts
- 32:47we're likely to face, one being Ukraine and the other one
- 32:50defending Taiwan. Like what?
- 32:51What is all this militarization? For pretend that the two biggest
- 32:55fronts were ones that people are not talking about and I'll give
- 32:56you what what they are in a moment.
- 32:58But Ukraine minerals deal either imminent signed but like going
- 33:06to get done. The US cares a lot more about
- 33:10Ukraine when we do that deal. OK, so now Trump.
- 33:16Specifically feels like OK, yeah, but OK, yes.
- 33:19But just in general, like it could be about defending Western
- 33:22democracy or the buffer of Putin's encroachment into NATO
- 33:25and our allies. But now America cares whether it
- 33:28was about. Oil America cared most of.
- 33:31I just am taking issue with this idea that America didn't care.
- 33:33Trump didn't care. America cared about Ukraine
- 33:36because it was a buffer. All the other things were true
- 33:39besides the mineral deal. The mineral deal exists to make.
- 33:42Trump care, yeah, but but what I'm saying now is if you're just
- 33:45again seeing like a state, if you are Ukraine as a state and
- 33:49you're America now I've given you America a interest, would
- 33:56you persuade interest, not reason.
- 33:58We are all aligned like American values, Western values, right?
- 34:03Now we have a Whiting. Reason to care about dictators.
- 34:06One that might be compelling to Trump, Yes.
- 34:07OK. And and, and Trump, and because
- 34:10as a country, it's sort of like, well, even Americans who vote
- 34:13for Trump, I'm just not one of them.
- 34:14That's like, why do we care about Ukraine?
- 34:17OK, well now there's a reason to care about Ukraine in your own
- 34:19self-interest. There are minerals there that
- 34:20affect the jobs and the robots and the autonomous cars and the
- 34:23future machinery that we have because we need that stuff.
- 34:26So we're going to protect it and not let Putin get that.
- 34:28OK, so that's Ukraine. Taiwan.
- 34:30There won't, in my personal opinion, be an invasion.
- 34:34Interesting. China will take Taiwan I.
- 34:38Don't know, it just won't need an invasion.
- 34:41OK, Yeah. We'll, it'll be, it'll be Hong
- 34:43Kong. Now, what they will do because
- 34:47they can is continue to build up.
- 34:49They've got 200 X the shipbuilding capability that we
- 34:51do. They've got roughly 400 war
- 34:55fighters today on maritime. We've got 300 and something the
- 34:59shape of the battle that they have in their ability to spend
- 35:02to build that up is sort of not entirely, but sort of like what
- 35:06we did during the Cold War where we effectively bankrupted Russia
- 35:10with this arms race, OK. So it is in their strategic
- 35:13economic interest to get us to try to match parity with what
- 35:15they're building. But they're what they're
- 35:17building is useful for other conflicts that may arise in the
- 35:19future. OK.
- 35:21But all they have to do, there are 100 flights a day or
- 35:24whatever it is, you know, between Taipei and Shanghai.
- 35:27You just send the equivalent of like the little orange men and
- 35:30all of a sudden one weekend there's some mainlander that
- 35:35gets beaten up by a bunch of thugs or something like that.
- 35:38And they're a peacekeeping force that comes in and it's Hong
- 35:41Konged over a weekend. So I don't know why they would
- 35:43go to kinetic battle. You know, I am friends with Sam
- 35:46Paparo Indo Paycom. He wants to create a hellscape.
- 35:48I applaud it. I think we should do it.
- 35:49We we stand to benefit as all the treatable systems and drones
- 35:53from Androl and sale drone and others help to blockade and
- 35:57prevent freedom of navigation maneuver for the Chinese around
- 36:02important strategic areas. But if I'm China, that's like
- 36:06checkers, right? Like so?
- 36:08You're saying Taiwan's lost? America shouldn't invest in
- 36:11trying to stop it. No, China's smartest thing that
- 36:14they can do is continue to build up their arms.
- 36:17Let the America do it. Do their little exercises,
- 36:19provoke people, provoke the Philippines, you know, just try
- 36:22to do all that stuff and then let America build TSMC in the
- 36:27United States. Let Intel finally convert into a
- 36:32manufacturing for other people's semis, which is what they should
- 36:34have been doing and I called for over the past 10 years because
- 36:36they no longer make competitive chips.
- 36:38And then Americans are looking at like, why do we care about
- 36:41Taiwan now? We 3 and the rest of you know,
- 36:44democracy might care about it because it's a values based
- 36:47thing. But in pure economic interest,
- 36:49why would we care about Iran other than the fact that our
- 36:52chips are made there and if chips are now made in the US?
- 36:54And what what I'm very interested in your OK, I don't I
- 36:56don't we equivalent. To by the way, I'm, I hope you
- 36:59see, I'm not being like ideological about this.
- 37:00It's real politic. It's like really understanding
- 37:03what are the interests, what are the means, what motivates
- 37:05people. But what you where do you think
- 37:09the real conflicts are you sort of alluded to not Ukraine into?
- 37:12OK, you make me SEC deaf or SEC state for the day or you let me
- 37:15advise, and I've said this publicly.
- 37:16There are two areas, 2 regions, one broad, one narrow, that I
- 37:21think are going to be the next chaotic areas.
- 37:23And the problem with so much conflict and war is that we
- 37:26react to things instead of proactively preempt.
- 37:30The first is the Sahel and Maghrib.
- 37:34I pause. Yeah, you know, we're, I have no
- 37:37idea what you're talking. About and that's why and most
- 37:39people are listening. Most people, Sahel and Maghrib
- 37:42are the latitudinal areas of Africa and they have had coup
- 37:46state after coup state. Most people couldn't even name
- 37:48some of the countries, Chad, Niger, Mali, Sudan, etcetera.
- 37:53OK, three forces are am I allowed to curse here are
- 37:59fucking this place up. OK, big time.
- 38:02You got Russian mercenaries who are coming in making money,
- 38:06propping up warlords, propping up coups, extracting resources.
- 38:09There's a whole economic chain of what they do with those
- 38:11resources and how they clean them and get money.
- 38:13OK, and other people that are involved in that.
- 38:15The second are Chinese Communist Party that are coming in with
- 38:19infrastructure, telecom, roads, etcetera, and having influence.
- 38:22And the third are Islamists that are coming from Syria,
- 38:26Afghanistan, Iraq, that have fought wars for the past 20
- 38:29years and are radicalizing young men and spreading this violent
- 38:35extremism. We are, in my opinion, I don't
- 38:38know if it happens in six months or six years, but I think that's
- 38:41the Window 1 terror event away from one of those ISIS in Africa
- 38:47or Al Qaeda in Africa type groups projecting into Paris or
- 38:51Barcelona or London, away from that entire region becoming our
- 38:55next Afghanistan at a time when U.S. troops have been pushed
- 38:59out, French troops have been pushed out.
- 39:01And I think that is going to be like chaos central.
- 39:06OK, so and again, my life is spent trying to find a low
- 39:10probability, high magnitude thing that other people haven't
- 39:12found. I do.
- 39:13In technology. If I was in the music world, I'd
- 39:16be trying to find the next band. If I was in real estate, I'd be
- 39:18trying to find the next hot neighborhood or fashion or art
- 39:20or whatever. But in geopolitics, it's what's
- 39:22the thing that nobody has attention on, where there are
- 39:25bad actors convening, like out of a movie, and we are not there
- 39:30proactively. Friendship building, winning
- 39:33hearts and minds, doing commerce, all the things that
- 39:36can diffuse these people. I'd say also we've, you know,
- 39:39seen a lot of cuts to USAID and a lot of what I would call our,
- 39:43you know, soft power mechanism over the last, you know, three
- 39:47months. Like how does that play into all
- 39:49of this? Should we be ramping that more
- 39:51up as well, in addition to military force?
- 39:53Strategically, yes, soft power matters.
- 39:55Soft power matters. But if you know we're funding
- 39:57stupid shit, it should be cut. And if we're funding smart, why
- 40:00strategic stuff that is aligned with?
- 40:03A, a broader strategy. I mean, the problem is you have
- 40:06different, you know, different government entities that are
- 40:07focused on different things, but you need a grand strategy to say
- 40:12Africa is a concern for us all. Right.
- 40:14So, so number one is terrorism 2 point O out of Africa, which is
- 40:18interesting and the other. I would create a Monroe Doctrine
- 40:23#2 which shores up a Pax Pan Americana of north-south and
- 40:29Central America. And the reason is, if you've
- 40:32been down there, my bet is you went to Patagonia or Brazil, or
- 40:37you saw Guazu Falls, or you went to Costa Rica, maybe you went to
- 40:40Honduras or Jamaica. The infiltration of the Chinese
- 40:46Communist Party into all of these places that Americans
- 40:49travel is like what the Russians did with Cuba back in the 40s,
- 40:52fifties and 60s. Right, which is why we shouldn't
- 40:54be alienating in Mexico like there's no country I love.
- 40:57Well, that's what we really loves us too.
- 40:59But. But I know we're fine but like
- 41:01it was too dumb. That, but it's the rest of this.
- 41:03Region right we've. Got a billion people that mostly
- 41:06speak 80% Spanish and English except for Portuguese.
- 41:10In Brazil you have abundant natural resources, abundant
- 41:13agriculture, highly trained, highly literate populations, and
- 41:17the quiet Chinese infiltration literally into our sphere of
- 41:21influence on this Western Hemisphere.
- 41:22We should have a hemispheric hegemony that creates a new
- 41:26allied longitudinal axis so that we can project power from the
- 41:30Atlantic and the Pacific and not be vulnerable from all these
- 41:33states. I was in Nicaragua in December.
- 41:34I was terrified. You literally have Iranian
- 41:37Hezbollah forces in Nicaragua. I I have a best friend who's a
- 41:43journalist, A prominent 1 and and our families were travelling
- 41:47together and he was stopped at the airport in Miami and denied
- 41:51boarding the flight because he was a journalist.
- 41:55We're going out of leaving the US.
- 41:57From the US to Nicaragua, yes. But by the US or by.
- 42:00No, by, by, by, by the by the Nicaraguan government, They,
- 42:03they, they said you can get on the flight, but if you land,
- 42:06we're detained. Interesting the I would I guess
- 42:10what I want to understand. I think these are both
- 42:11interesting and like provocative, but like to me, a
- 42:16premise of what's going on in Hill Valley and American dynism
- 42:20and and all the defense tech investing is sort of this global
- 42:24face off with China. And like a key question is what
- 42:27types of companies do we invest in?
- 42:29Because like what does the nature of that conflict look
- 42:32like? I mean, do you do you think
- 42:34China is powering this investment movement?
- 42:37And if you don't see it as a sort of head to head war between
- 42:42the two countries in Taiwan or, or you know, even the sort of
- 42:46like proxy Taiwan where like what, what is it?
- 42:49It's like fighting terrorism again, because there are
- 42:51influences in these regions you talked about.
- 42:54Or why? Why is China so important if
- 42:56you're not bringing that up? I I think the catalyzing force
- 42:59over the past few years was people complaining about the
- 43:05defense base we have that is slow and bureaucratic.
- 43:08Whether people were criticizing the F35 Joint Strike Fighter
- 43:10being made in 350 plus congressional districts and
- 43:13being overtime and over budget. And that's the thing for
- 43:15taxpayers justly. Or that China was developing
- 43:19hypersonic missiles or when people saw DeepSeek and that's a
- 43:24whole other complicated thing, but more efficient, maybe less
- 43:27GPUs stolen, not whatever it is. And people saying, are we losing
- 43:32on a bunch of different fronts. And I think there are 44 key
- 43:34technological areas and some studies have shown that on 37 of
- 43:37them we are losing to China 50% of undergraduates in AI.
- 43:42Are China's more of a benchmark? It's more like we just need to
- 43:45do things really well. And you're like China's like a
- 43:47comparison point. Yes, and and so if we are but
- 43:50but Sputnik was that moment for us that persage the Cold War and
- 43:53build up and whatever, but it was like, holy shit, America is
- 43:56great. That's great.
- 43:57But if we're not great and they're actually beating us, you
- 44:00know, you can be the president. You could lie about how big your
- 44:02buildings are and how big your bank account is and how big your
- 44:04crowds are. But you can't lie about the
- 44:06market, right? Market goes up or down.
- 44:08You can't lie about how much it went up or out.
- 44:10Everybody feels that. And you can't lie when you see
- 44:12that China's flying a satellite or launching a satellite or
- 44:16releasing an AI tool that actually empirically, observably
- 44:21shocks you. And so I think people have been
- 44:23shocked now to say, are we behind?
- 44:25Do we risk being behind you take shipbuilding something, you
- 44:29know, I mentioned before the stat 200 times the capability in
- 44:31China that we have. We have one major shipbuilding
- 44:34area in Hampton Roads. We've run these risk games at
- 44:36Lux to analyze the vulnerabilities of this kind of
- 44:39stuff. We used to have 25 and so
- 44:41reassuring something that you mentioned before.
- 44:44It's not, you know, Scott Besson said America first does not mean
- 44:48America alone. Are we going to truly do
- 44:50shipbuilding here alone? I don't know.
- 44:52There's going to be probably in this, in this defense budget
- 44:54with reconciliations, something like 47 billion of the trillion
- 44:58dollars that gets allocated for shipbuilding.
- 44:59But South Korea, Norway, a bunch of people are amazing
- 45:03shipbuilders and we should be partnering with them, whether
- 45:05there or here or both to do that same thing.
- 45:08Taiwan coming here, building Intel should probably team with
- 45:11TSMC. Maybe TSMC buys them.
- 45:12I don't know. But we should be friend shoring
- 45:16to do re shoring. It shouldn't be alone.
- 45:17I think that's foolhardy. Same thing by the way, with
- 45:19minerals, even more reason to be in Africa and South America.
- 45:23But the big grand strategy here, the big like why hill and
- 45:26valley? What's happening here is what
- 45:29people have been talking about for a very long time of like,
- 45:31we're falling behind. All of a sudden you had a
- 45:33culture shift with Project Maven, Google employees walking
- 45:37out, a bunch of other companies, including one of ours clarify
- 45:40that came in and won those contracts.
- 45:41You had the rise of DIU. You had the founding of Andrel 7
- 45:441/2 years ago and we were founding investors there and
- 45:46people thought Palmer was a joke.
- 45:48Peter Thiel and I are at the Reagan National Forum and
- 45:50Palmer's in his Hawaiian shirt, cargo pants and flip flops.
- 45:53My guess is 5% of the people, maybe 10% of the people that
- 45:55attended there back 6-7 years ago have applied for a job at
- 45:58Andrel since, right? And so Andrew went from nothing
- 46:02and nobody to a $30 billion company and people are like,
- 46:07holy shit, this thing is working.
- 46:08And it inspired other people to be like, we're going to go do
- 46:10that, but in a different sector or whatever it is.
- 46:12And so you have a move of self-interest and motivation
- 46:16that people don't want to work on ads and video games and
- 46:18bullshit. They want to work on things that
- 46:20matter. And right now there is a
- 46:21zeitgeist that feels that American defense matters.
- 46:25And you have the Hill and Valley where you have aging politicians
- 46:28that get lobbied from like the big primes and get donations
- 46:32from the big primes. But now they see.
- 46:33Wait a second, there's a lot of money here, venture capital in.
- 46:36Some ways what's happening is what we're telling ourselves,
- 46:38the psychological story. There will be more money to
- 46:40come. Silicon Valley is committed to
- 46:42this area, telling politicians that they need to like look to
- 46:45startups and not just rely on the primes.
- 46:48And and leaders seem more bought into it too.
- 46:50I would say like the event was very positively received.
- 46:54I mean, I can tell you from conversations with people that
- 46:56are doing these budgets and doing these bills, you're going
- 46:59to see big wins for new manufacturing technologies.
- 47:01You're going to see big wins away from the major primes who I
- 47:03think are sitting there fat and lazy and they're going to be
- 47:05shocked. And so you had this generational
- 47:08moment from like that Last Supper, you know, when when
- 47:10defense was told post Cold War budgets getting shrunk, you guys
- 47:13all have to merge together and they merged into an oligopoly.
- 47:16And you had Raytheon and L3 and Boeing and Lock, etcetera.
- 47:19OK. And now you have a emergence of
- 47:22winning tech companies that are tracking the best talent,
- 47:25innovating and making technology faster and and winning.
- 47:28And I think it's a wake up call. So let me be clear.
- 47:33The big take away I had from Hillen Valley is that the
- 47:35politicians keep getting older or the attendees keep getting
- 47:38younger. And the younger people are the
- 47:41ones that have the mix, which is that beautiful cocktail
- 47:45combination of ambition, naivete, and they're the ones
- 47:49that make shit happen. They're the people that we
- 47:51invest with. And so those people are inspired
- 47:54and excited and they're not naive in how long it will take.
- 47:57They're not like suddenly, oh, we're going to get a billion
- 47:59dollar contract this year. And it is always dangerous to
- 48:01say this time is different, but there is something palpably
- 48:03different that I think we're going to see in this budget when
- 48:07it gets done, next year's budget.
- 48:09And you're going to start to see like, Wow, market share is
- 48:11really accruing to these new primes, these new entrants like
- 48:14Andrel and Sale Drone and Hadrian and Varda and Impulse
- 48:17Space. We'll let you go, but in a way,
- 48:19do you think the enthusiasm from the administration and from
- 48:23funders can overwhelm potential economic headwinds?
- 48:28Like if, if the economy is in a bad place, do you think this
- 48:31enthusiasm is misplaced or you think you know some trends can
- 48:35overwhelm A broader economic situation?
- 48:38The evidence that it will overwhelm is again, if you look
- 48:41right now at Andrew as one example, 8 1/2 billion dollars
- 48:45of demand for a 2 1/2 billion dollar round.
- 48:48You know, nobody there was like, you know, like we're feeling
- 48:50really nervous, like interest rates are 4/2 the 10 year
- 48:54despite unemployment, the GDP print, like nobody cares.
- 48:59There are going to be isolated pockets that will overcome the
- 49:01economic thing. But you are naive.
- 49:03Anybody is naive to think that the macro doesn't matter.
- 49:06I always say we pick individual companies, we find individual
- 49:09entrepreneurs, the most micro decision that you can make.
- 49:12And it's the equivalent of picking the best dish on a menu,
- 49:15having selected the best menu from restaurant and best
- 49:17restaurant from a city and a state and OK, and you're about
- 49:19to eat that delicious morsel and Godzilla comes and just steps on
- 49:22it. Right.
- 49:23Yeah, exactly. We need to have an appreciation
- 49:26of the macro and whether that's the cost, capital and rates,
- 49:29whether that's the flow of capital and if Japan and China
- 49:31sell our bonds. It's just complicated.
- 49:34I do believe that there are these long term trends that you
- 49:37can be relatively insulated from the volatility and vicissitudes
- 49:41of the here and now in markets. Josh, thanks so much for coming
- 49:44on. This is awesome.
- 49:45Great to see you both. See ya.