Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #84 🎙️ |Public Inquiry Self Reflection 17th July 2026 |
Transcript
- 0:02Unknown: Before we begin, a quick word to anyone who has
- 0:05only recently discovered the podcast. If this is your first
- 0:10time listening, or you've only joined us over the last few
- 0:14weeks, I'd really encourage you to go back and start at podcast
- 0:1840-one. That's where this journey really begins, the story
- 0:23of the Kurnault public inquiry, the campaign, the people
- 0:27involved, and the events that have brought us to where we are
- 0:31today unfold from that point onwards. I think that you'll
- 0:36find that many of the issues we discuss in these episodes make
- 0:40much more sense when heard in their proper context. Of course,
- 0:45you're very welcome to dip in wherever you like, but if you're
- 0:48wondering how we arrived here, podcast 40-one is probably the
- 0:53best place to begin. Now, with that said, today's episode is a
- 0:57little different. Normally, I spend time reflecting on the
- 1:01events taking place around the public inquiry. Today, I'm
- 1:06reflecting on my own part in them. Over the last few days,
- 1:11I've been listening back to a couple of recent episodes, and
- 1:15doing some thinking. I've come to the conclusion that on this
- 1:19occasion, I reacted when I should have responded, so that's
- 1:23where I'd like to begin. I've been doing a bit of thinking
- 1:30over the last few days. One of the advantages of recording your
- 1:34own thoughts is that you also have to live with them.
- 1:38Unfortunately, they don't disappear into the ether.
- 1:41They're still there, waiting for you to listen back, and so I
- 1:45did, and I came to a conclusion that wasn't particularly
- 1:48comfortable. I wasn't at my best. Following Carmack's
- 1:53exclusion from the public inquiry, I reacted to what was
- 1:57happening around me instead of responding to it. There's a
- 2:00difference. One comes from emotion, the other from
- 2:04reflection, and that time emotion won. I don't take back
- 2:10the fact that I was deeply concerned. I do take
- 2:12responsibility for the way I allowed those concerns to be
- 2:15expressed. If I expect members of Save Our Spurns to conduct
- 2:20themselves with dignity, respect, and fairness, and have
- 2:23to prepare to live by exactly the same standards. Leadership
- 2:27doesn't work any other way. So I've written to the three
- 2:31commissioners and offered them my sincere apology. It's all
- 2:35very well asking others to reflect on their actions. Every
- 2:39now and again, it's no bad thing to look in the mirror yourself.
- 2:43I've always tried to ensure that this campaign passionate,
- 2:46without becoming hostile, and determined, without losing its
- 2:51sense of proportion. On this occasion, I let myself down. In
- 2:56doing so, I also let down Savour Spurns, and I regret that. As
- 3:01for the podcasts themselves, well, one has now been humanely
- 3:06put out of its misery, and the other has received what can only
- 3:09be described as a rather severe editorial haircut. The
- 3:13interesting thing about all of this is that it has reminded me
- 3:16of something. There is a world of difference between speaking
- 3:21out and simply speaking in anger. One requires conviction.
- 3:28The other only requires a bad day. I spent years encouraging
- 3:33people to pause, to look at the evidence, to think before
- 3:36reaching conclusions. It would be more than a little
- 3:41hypocritical if I wasn't prepared to do exactly the same
- 3:44when it comes to my own words. Many years ago, I made a promise
- 3:49to myself that I would never remain silent in the face of
- 3:52something I genuinely believed to be wrong. I still intend to
- 3:57keep that promise. I've realised that speaking up isn't the
- 4:02difficult part. The difficult part is doing it in a way that
- 4:07people can actually hear what you're trying to say. This
- 4:12podcast has always been about trying to make sense of the
- 4:15complicated process of the public inquiry, asking difficult
- 4:20questions, and giving a voice to people who often feel they
- 4:24haven't been heard, and that won't change. If anything, this
- 4:30episode has reminded me that how we say something can be just as
- 4:34important as what we say. So thank you to those who continue
- 4:40to listen, even when I occasionally need reminding that
- 4:44I'm as human as everyone else. Right, enough self-reflection,
- 4:49and normal service will now resume.