Latest / Shades of Murder / 57: Two Graves and A Diary - Thrill Killer Alyssa Bustamante part 2
Transcript
- 0:06Hello and welcome to Shades of Murder.
- 0:09I am your host Alita Caldwell. In this podcast, I discuss cases
- 0:14of murder from around the world and throughout history,
- 0:18attempting to unravel the layers of darkness that help make
- 0:23humans and to monsters. Please be forewarned that each
- 0:29episode contains specific and at times very graphic and
- 0:34disturbing details of the case. This show is not intended for
- 0:39all audiences and listener discretion is strongly advised.
- 1:25In the last episode, I discussed the horrifying and tragic murder
- 1:29of nine year old Elizabeth Olton and her unexpected killer, 15
- 1:34year old Alyssa Bustamante. This is the second piece of the
- 1:38shocking true story of a child murderer who by all accounts,
- 1:42was a child herself when she committed this heinous, vicious
- 1:46crime. It would be so easy, even lazy,
- 1:49to call Alyssa Bustamante an evil monster and end the
- 1:53discussion and her story there. This is what most people,
- 1:56including fellow true crime podcasters, do when discussing
- 2:00her and this horrible, tragic case.
- 2:04However, the reason I wanted to cover her case and I chose to
- 2:08extend it to two episodes is that she is a compelling
- 2:11offender to me for multiple reasons.
- 2:14Please be aware that I am not a psychiatrist nor am IA licensed
- 2:18therapist. However, I do have a degree in
- 2:20criminology and hopefully it has been demonstrated to you, my
- 2:25dear listeners, by now that I conduct extensive research for
- 2:29every episode. I think it's critical that as a
- 2:34society we attempt to comprehend how and why an individual,
- 2:39especially a child or youth, can commit inherently evil acts.
- 2:44It is easy to label persons who murder as monstrosities whom we
- 2:49can't possibly relate to on any level.
- 2:52When we do this, we dissociate ourselves from them and their
- 2:56crimes. In this goal to separate them
- 2:58from us, we have created an almost mythological aura around
- 3:03serial killers and other similar depraved violent offenders.
- 3:07I think in some ways it's easier to deal with the darkness that
- 3:10exists within others if we place them into compartment of evil,
- 3:14rather than acknowledge that most of them are shattered
- 3:17individuals who weren't capable of processing and handling the
- 3:21trauma and abuse they were dealt with in life in any normal or
- 3:25healthy manner. The criminal profile and story
- 3:28of Alyssa Bustamante is important to know and discuss,
- 3:31not because of her shocking and vile crimes, but because of how
- 3:35much of an anomaly this young woman truly is.
- 3:41First of all, her youth and gender made her highly unlikely
- 3:44to commit such a heinous, premeditated crime.
- 3:46By making her sister Emma an accomplice and leaving behind a
- 3:50trail of evidence for law enforcement to find, Alyssa
- 3:53Bustamanti exhibited arrogance, sloppiness, and a lack of
- 3:56organization. This was likely a reflection of
- 3:59her youth, in particular her impulsiveness, recklessness, and
- 4:03poor judgment, all well known characteristics of a developing
- 4:08typical teenager's brain. If it weren't for these crucial
- 4:12mistakes, Alyssa Bustamante may never have been caught.
- 4:15Secondly, although some signs point to her being a psychopath,
- 4:19other factors and traits don't. Don't get me wrong, Alyssa
- 4:23Bustamante deserves to be in prison for the rest of her life.
- 4:26Despite her age at the time of the offense, she will most
- 4:29likely continue to be denied parole based on the evidence of
- 4:33premeditation, the degree of brutality of the crime, and the
- 4:37victim having been an innocent and helpless child.
- 4:41However, it is critical to discuss her from a
- 4:43criminological view and analyze the various aspects of her life
- 4:47and behavior which culminated in this tragedy.
- 4:50Alyssa Bustamante was described as being a very bright and
- 4:54clever girl in a sneaky kind of way, but who openly struggled.
- 4:58With her depression. She had never been in trouble at
- 5:00school or involved in any sort of juvenile delinquency outside
- 5:04of a few incidents of not being where she said she would be.
- 5:08There was an occasion where she snuck off to a music concert in
- 5:11Saint Louis and she spent the night out in the woods a few
- 5:14times without her grandparents knowing.
- 5:17However, she had never had any encounter with the justice
- 5:20system before being arrested for first degree murder.
- 5:24Her grades were above average and at the time of the offense,
- 5:26she was in the top third of her class.
- 5:29Alisa Bustamante did not fit any kind of violent offender
- 5:33profile, especially for a girl. It is a criminal fact that males
- 5:39commit far more homicides than females.
- 5:43Official crime data from 2023 revealed that of the 21,504
- 5:49known homicide offenders, 14,327 were male compared to only 1898
- 5:57females. Interestingly, there were an
- 5:59additional 5279 perpetrators of homicide whose gender was
- 6:04unidentified or unknown. This equates to approximately
- 6:09.88% of all murders being committed by females.
- 6:14This is an extremely low percentage of homicides being
- 6:18committed by women and girls, which is why when females commit
- 6:22murder, it is still perceived as a shocking and very rare
- 6:26incident. Women and girls who commit
- 6:29murder overwhelmingly do so for the means of utility, usually
- 6:32for the gain of money. Studies on female offenders
- 6:36revealed that they also killed primarily for means of survival.
- 6:40It could be to survive violent abuse from an intimate partner
- 6:44in a moment of self-defense or their desire to end prolonged
- 6:48abuse. And sometimes it's just to
- 6:50survive the streets. Girls who kill share very
- 6:53similar traits and characteristics to women in
- 6:56terms of their motivations, and even fewer studies have been
- 7:00conducted on them. This is very unfortunate and
- 7:03irresponsible, since murders committed by girls and younger
- 7:06women appeared to have become increasingly more common in
- 7:09recent decades. Other.
- 7:10Females kill in what are described as crimes of passion.
- 7:13These incidents involve either their lover, boyfriend,
- 7:16girlfriend who has rejected or betrayed them, or their love
- 7:19rival, and sometimes both. An example of this kind of
- 7:23killer would be Tennessee Death Rose Krista Pike, who brutally
- 7:26slayed a young woman in 1995 whom she believed was after her
- 7:30boyfriend. For some female offenders, the
- 7:33motivation can stem from a darker, more psychopathic plays.
- 7:38Sometimes it can arise from a desire for power, control and
- 7:42domination. It may derive from the desperate
- 7:44need for her attention or even a bizarre sense of mission driven
- 7:49killing. Women and girls tend to murder
- 7:51those closest to them. They prey on the weak and the
- 7:55vulnerable, in particular when the motivation is financial.
- 7:58Female juvenile murders are by far the rarest of violent
- 8:02offenders. Most of these killings involve
- 8:04crimes of passion, as aforementioned, where envy and
- 8:07jealousy of another female are the primary motive, and they
- 8:11often involve more than one offender.
- 8:14This kind of murder can be seen in the horrific attack of 12
- 8:18year old Shonda Shearer in Indiana by a group of girls led
- 8:22by the jealous 16 year old Melinda Loveless.
- 8:26In the case where the victims are family members, they tend to
- 8:29revolve around a forbidden love interest.
- 8:32Typically, these events involve a younger female who becomes
- 8:35obsessed with a much older male suitor whom the parents attempt
- 8:40to keep apart. This can lead to further
- 8:43obsession and eventually a plan to eliminate those who are
- 8:47interfering in the relationship. In the twisted perception of the
- 8:52lovestruck teen, the only way to be with a man they love is to
- 8:57kill their parents and sometimes even their siblings.
- 9:01This kind of family killing was demonstrated in the case of 16
- 9:04year old Aaron Caffey from Texas in 2008.
- 9:08All three of these examples have become quite notorious in the
- 9:11world of true crime because they were so disturbing, brutal and
- 9:15most of all, extremely rare. Another more well known scenario
- 9:21involves a young female. At the behest of the older male
- 9:25partner, he becomes involved in killing and sometimes even the
- 9:29torture of another individual or multiple persons.
- 9:32This has been demonstrated through various killer duas
- 9:35throughout history, in particular serial killer
- 9:37couples. Whether the female is a willing
- 9:40and active participant or a compliant accomplice, they
- 9:43traditionally commit the crimes to please their MO partner or to
- 9:47prevent him from causing them harm.
- 9:49Or at least that is what most of these family offenders claim to
- 9:53be their motivation. Such an infamous case is
- 9:56illustrated through Canada's Carla Harmonka.
- 10:01What is almost unheard of, and the most shocking to hear, is
- 10:06when a young woman kills someone of her own accord, her own free
- 10:11will, her own premeditated, vile plan to take another's life for
- 10:18pleasure. Alyssa Bustamante did not fit
- 10:21into the typical profile of a delinquent teen, much less a
- 10:24cold blooded, sadistic murderer. And yet there were many, many
- 10:30alarming signs of pending violence, up to and including
- 10:34her potential for homicide. Born to a drug addicted teen
- 10:38mother and abusive father, Alyssa Bustamante was exposed to
- 10:42domestic violence, her mother's sexual activity with multiple
- 10:45men inside the home, and substance abuse.
- 10:48Her mother had a criminal record which included mainly petty
- 10:51crimes like drug possession and a DUI.
- 10:54Her father was sentenced to 10 years for felony assault and had
- 10:57not been in her life since she was a very young child, except
- 11:00for the occasional letter from prison.
- 11:02Alyssa and her three younger siblings were faced with a life
- 11:05of continuous hardship. Her mother had run away from
- 11:09their home, abandoning her four small kids on multiple
- 11:13occasions. This was all before Alyssa had
- 11:17turned 7. It was during this time that her
- 11:19grandparents felt they had no other choice but to intervene
- 11:23and help. They didn't want the children
- 11:25split up into foster care and so they took it upon themselves to
- 11:29care for them all. Since her mother was neglectful
- 11:32and randomly disappeared on them and her father was in prison,
- 11:35her grandparents were granted guardianship over all four young
- 11:39kids, Alyssa being the eldest. One particular time when her
- 11:43mother took off, it had dire consequences.
- 11:46On Labor Day weekend, 2713 year old Alyssa Bustamante was found
- 11:51unconscious. She had been discovered
- 11:53collapsed in the shower by her grandmother after swallowing a
- 11:56large bottle of Tylenol. Her arms had hundreds of tiny
- 12:00cuts on them made by a razor blade.
- 12:03The girl had carved the word hate into one of them.
- 12:07She survived the suicide attempt and was sent to a healthcare
- 12:09facility for evaluation and treatment.
- 12:12There, Alyssa Bustamante was given a prescription for Prozac,
- 12:15a common antidepressant, and it seemed to do its job for a
- 12:19while. Alyssa's grandparents were very
- 12:22religious, and although they made sure that she and her
- 12:25siblings were well taken care of, I don't know how their
- 12:27relationships were. Were they affectionate and open
- 12:31with her? Did they discuss the trauma and
- 12:34abuse she had experienced as a child and how she was suffering
- 12:37emotionally and psychologically as a result?
- 12:41Alyssa regularly attended their Mormon church and did so right
- 12:44after brutally slain a child, as recorded in her diary.
- 12:49It was clear that religion didn't seem to make any impact
- 12:52on her moral compass. If anything, she mocked it.
- 12:57I wonder if her grandparents thought that if she read the
- 13:00Bible and went to church enough, it would miraculously fix her
- 13:04issues and save her from the looming darkness.
- 13:09There were many signs that Alyssa Bustamante was spiraling
- 13:13down a dark path which were essentially ignored by those in
- 13:18her life and in the very least, were not taken seriously enough.
- 13:22Everything Alyssa Bustamante portrayed on social media, the
- 13:25words and pictures that decorated her bedroom walls and
- 13:29especially those inside her journal, was strong evidence of
- 13:33a young girl who was obsessed with death and violence and
- 13:37wanted to die. Earlier in the year, at her 15th
- 13:40birthday party, Alyssa Bustamante made a shocking and
- 13:43disturbing statement to her once best friend, Jennifer Meyer.
- 13:48According to Jennifer, out of nowhere, Alyssa pulled her aside
- 13:51and said to her, and I quote, I just wonder what it would be
- 13:55like just to kill someone, see the life just drain out of
- 13:58someone. I wonder what it would feel like
- 14:00that type of power to take that away from someone.
- 14:03Jennifer just thought at the time she was being weird and
- 14:06dark and did take her words seriously.
- 14:09A week before she murdered 9 year old Elizabeth Olton,
- 14:13Alyssa's cell phone charger was dead.
- 14:15One night she was all alone in her room and she couldn't talk
- 14:19to anyone about the depression and pain she was drowning in.
- 14:24She wrote in her diary in a quote.
- 14:27If I don't talk about it, I bottle it up, and when I
- 14:30explode, someone's going to die. On Twitter, she wrote that there
- 14:35must be some reason for all this pain.
- 14:41All of these expressions of her rage, sadness, and darkness were
- 14:46in full display for not only those closest in her circle to
- 14:51see and hear, but for the entire world if they had listened.
- 14:56She did not hide her sickness, but rather she played it up,
- 15:00almost reveling in it, crafting a dark, dramatic, and alluring
- 15:06image of herself. This resulted in a harrowing
- 15:10persona of how she wanted to present herself and what she
- 15:13wanted to project into society. Alisa Bustamante has been
- 15:16described as a thrill killer in large part because the main
- 15:20detective stated that the reason she murdered Elizabeth Olton was
- 15:23because she wanted to know how it felt to kill.
- 15:26As I pointed out in the first episode of this case, these
- 15:29exact words were never spoken by the offender to law enforcement.
- 15:33However, since she did express this specific desire to kill to
- 15:37one of her close friends, it is impossible to deny that her main
- 15:42motivation was to experience the power and pleasure of taking a
- 15:46life. This kind of offender is the
- 15:50rarest of them all. They defy all understanding and
- 15:54possible explanation as to what triggers this kind of thrill
- 15:59killing behaviour, especially in a young woman.
- 16:03So what exactly defines the actions and profile of a thrill
- 16:07killer? Thrill killing, a type of murder
- 16:11committed for the reasons as defined by its name, for the
- 16:15thrill of taking a life, sounds pretty straightforward as to the
- 16:20primary motivation behind such an offender's purpose for
- 16:23killing. However, what makes an
- 16:25individual into a thrill killer is seemingly much more complex.
- 16:30For the majority of society, we struggle to comprehend, much
- 16:34less understand, such an act and the type of person who commits
- 16:39it. Thrill killers are a typology
- 16:41that was developed to understand different types of serial
- 16:44killing, specifically those committed by males.
- 16:46This type of murderer kills to obtain gratification and
- 16:50pleasure through the act of killing.
- 16:52Thrill killers are driven by the ACT alone.
- 16:56They are excited and energized by the pain and terror they can
- 17:01inflict on their victim. Traditionally, they are not
- 17:04interested in the body post mortem.
- 17:07Unlike other sadistic killers, they don't mutilate or play with
- 17:10a corpse. They rarely commit any sexual
- 17:13acts during, much less after the kill.
- 17:17Psychologists have observed that their thrill from killing is
- 17:20intertwined with the power and control they exert over their
- 17:23victims. People who kill For these
- 17:26reasons very often are associated with severe childhood
- 17:29trauma, specifically abuse. They suffer from feelings of
- 17:33unworthiness and have a great desire for power and control.
- 17:37This trauma has been noted to desensitize some individuals
- 17:40toward pain and violence, leading them to lack empathy and
- 17:44have minimal attachment to others.
- 17:47Women who kill for the thrill, who are stimulated by the act of
- 17:50murder and torture, are extremely uncommon.
- 17:54They are pretty much nonexistent.
- 17:57There are very few known female thrill killers, or at least
- 18:00those who have been properly identified.
- 18:03Multiple murderer Joanna Dennehy of the United Kingdom has been
- 18:06deemed by some to be a thrill killer.
- 18:09Jane Taupin, the 19th century serial killer nurse of Boston,
- 18:12who might have covered in a previous episode, openly
- 18:15expressed how she murdered for pleasure.
- 18:18Even the infamous Aileen Warnos has been described as a
- 18:21thriller, although I personally don't agree with this label to
- 18:24define her motivations. Needless to say, most women who
- 18:28have been described under this motivation have almost always
- 18:31been part of a murdering duo, usually headed by a male.
- 18:35The motivations of Alyssa Bustamantes were undoubtedly
- 18:38sadistic and pleasure driven. Based on her journal entry,
- 18:42after she murdered 9 year old Elizabeth Olton, Alyssa
- 18:46Bustamantes suffered severe trauma, abuse, and neglect
- 18:49before she was even born. The teenager struggled with her
- 18:53inner demons and battled against depression and feelings of
- 18:56worthlessness. She did not feel of any value
- 18:59and she lacked control over her life.
- 19:03All of these. Characteristics to find what is
- 19:05known about throw killers in the act of luring in or stalking
- 19:09their victim, taking them by surprise, inflicting brutality
- 19:13upon the individual, and causing the person terror and pain.
- 19:17They regain their sense of power, strength, and control.
- 19:21The pain and suffering that define their very existence is
- 19:26now erased, at least temporarily, by causing pain and
- 19:31suffering to another and having the power to end their life.
- 19:36Upon close analysis though, I tend to think her motivations
- 19:39were much more complicated than simply killing for the thrill.
- 19:43Alisa Bustamante was an extremely disturbed teenage girl
- 19:46who was fascinated with death and violence, and the concept of
- 19:50killing herself was projected onto her victim.
- 19:53I think to some extent she was trying to get rid of herself
- 19:56hatred by victimizing the most innocent.
- 20:00Everyone has labeled this girl an evil monster.
- 20:03Were her actions those of 1? Undoubtedly yes, and there were
- 20:07clear signs of her being psychotic.
- 20:10But is she evil? Is she a psychopath, or is she a
- 20:15tragic result of her upbringing? Perhaps a little bit of both.
- 20:21Psychopathy is a mental disorder that is manifested from a
- 20:24culmination of factors believed to be likely caused by genetic
- 20:27factors which helped to mold and influence cognitive development
- 20:31and personality traits. It is also a reaction to social
- 20:35and environmental elements. Psychopathy as a clinical
- 20:39construct is defined by a pattern of interpersonal,
- 20:43emotional, and behavioral traits than an individual exhibits.
- 20:47Considered one of the most serious of the personality
- 20:50disorders. The recovery rate of individuals
- 20:53suffering from psychopathy is very low and the effects it can
- 20:57have on a personal and social level are extensive.
- 21:01The prevalence of psychopathy is thought to affect anywhere
- 21:04between .5 to 1% of individuals in society.
- 21:08However, it is believed that as high as 20 to 25% of all
- 21:13prisoners could be diagnosed with the disorder.
- 21:17Research indicates that psychopaths are responsible for
- 21:20more than half of all serious crimes committed.
- 21:24Studies on psychopathy in men and women reveal that the
- 21:27condition is very rare in females.
- 21:31However, along with male prisoners, female prisoners
- 21:34often exhibit signs of the disorder.
- 21:37One study showed that as high as 17% of female prisoners could be
- 21:41diagnosed as psychopathic. This is in comparison to roughly
- 21:4531% of male prisoners. Emotional traits of a psychopath
- 21:50include flat effect, lack of empathy, Morser guilt and
- 21:54egocentricity. Alyssa Bustamante fully exhibits
- 21:58these traits when she writes in her diary about how killing
- 22:01Elizabeth Olton made her feel. There is 0 expression conveyed
- 22:06about what a horrible thing it was to do.
- 22:09Elizabeth Olton is not a child she murdered, but she merely
- 22:14becomes an object. That was used to fulfill her
- 22:17homicidal desires. Interpersonal characteristics of
- 22:21a psychopath show themselves in acts of arrogance,
- 22:24impulsiveness, lack of responsibility, grandiose sense
- 22:27of self, and manipulation. Elsa Bustamante's act of killing
- 22:32was not impulsive since she planned to commit murder based
- 22:35on her pre emptive digging of the graves, but her selection of
- 22:39Elizabeth Olton does not appear to have been planned, at least
- 22:42not on that particular day. During the interrogation video,
- 22:45Alyssa Bustamante attempts to manipulate the detective and the
- 22:49juvenile officer into believing her version of events on the day
- 22:52she killed Elizabeth. She is bold, confident, even
- 22:57arrogant, while she sits back in the chair with ease, casually
- 23:01painting a story she is trying to sell them.
- 23:04The behavior of a psychopath has been observed to show dismissal
- 23:08of social norms and rules and display scary, violent and
- 23:12irresponsible behavior. Alisa Bustamante portrayed
- 23:15herself across social media as someone who rebelled against
- 23:18society's expectations, especially expectations of a
- 23:22young female. She chose dramatic, often
- 23:25violent imagery and expressions to depict her persona, whose
- 23:29main purpose appeared to be for the attention it received.
- 23:34The characteristics and traits of psychopathy vary from person
- 23:37to person, but there are a few core features.
- 23:41These include an uncaring temperament, boldness, and
- 23:44social dominance, in addition to disinhibited behavior.
- 23:48An uncaring temperament is the social and emotional foundation
- 23:51of being a psychopath. These kinds of individuals
- 23:55exhibit no remorse, regret, or guilt over their actions.
- 23:59They are liars, manipulators, and use people to get what they
- 24:03want. Secondly, they are known to be
- 24:05risk takers. Their appearance and demeanor is
- 24:091 full of confidence, even arrogance, and they fail to
- 24:13avoid behavior that in the past has already led to problems.
- 24:16The third core trait is disinhibited behavior.
- 24:20This involves actions and behavior that are spontaneous,
- 24:24random, and often unplanned. These individuals fail to uphold
- 24:28their promises or commitments, including work or school, or to
- 24:32their personal life. There is a divide amongst
- 24:34researchers on whether or not criminal behavior is a key
- 24:37element of psychopathy or if it is a consequence.
- 24:41As in most areas of criminology, the majority of studies
- 24:44conducted on psychopathy have been focused on males.
- 24:48However, the research performed on male psychopaths versus
- 24:51females have revealed some interesting differences.
- 24:55Research on psychopathy has been conducted in two distinct ways.
- 25:00One school of research has been focused on behavior, where the
- 25:03other is centered around personality.
- 25:05The behavioral approach is the one which the APA or the
- 25:08American Psychiatric Association employs in its diagnostic
- 25:12system, also known as the DSM 4, where psychopathy falls under
- 25:17antisocial personality disorder. This diagnosis primarily
- 25:20includes concepts of behavior with emotional traits associated
- 25:24to them, but it is not a prerequisite to the diagnosis.
- 25:28This category far exceeds the realm of psychopathy and would
- 25:31encompass most criminals. The other school is based upon
- 25:35personality and is represented in the World Health Organization
- 25:39diagnosis of Dissocial Personality disorder under their
- 25:43International Statistical Classification System.
- 25:46Also known as the ICD, this disorder is characterized by
- 25:49individuals who pose a sharp resistance to the expected
- 25:53behavior and codes of conduct. They are indifferent toward
- 25:56these rules and norms and lack empathy.
- 25:59They fail to experience guilt as the rest of us do, and they lack
- 26:02the capacity to feel remorse. This kind of individual does not
- 26:07respond to negative reinforcement of behavior, such
- 26:10as punishment, which does not deter or change their bad
- 26:14behavior. They also have a tendency to
- 26:16blame others for their actions, and they are at constant
- 26:20conflict with society. It is estimated that 1/3 of
- 26:24people who would be diagnosed as antisocial meet the criteria for
- 26:28psychopathy. The latter criteria, defined by
- 26:32disocial personality disorder, leans toward a closer match to
- 26:36the definition of psychopathy, although neither school
- 26:39thoroughly covers the term. How is psychopathy even measured
- 26:43and thus diagnosed, you may be wondering?
- 26:45The most common and validated tool is the Hair Psychopathy
- 26:49Checklist, which includes a checklist of 20 items to which a
- 26:53patient is assigned a score of 0 to 2 based on how close they
- 26:57align to each trait. These include many of the well
- 27:00known characteristics and behavior of a psychopath such as
- 27:03lack of guilt, no empathy, superficiality, shallow affect,
- 27:07grandosity, lying, parasitic lifestyle manipulation,
- 27:11impulsiveness, and the adolescent crime, among others.
- 27:14Amongst researchers, the accepted threshold for
- 27:16psychopathy is 30. The differences between genders
- 27:20and psychopathy are noted as being significant in the ways
- 27:23the disorder manifests itself. Researchers for Rosen and Cook
- 27:28suggest that there are four points in the ways these
- 27:31differences surface. These include behavior,
- 27:34interpersonal characteristics, underlying psychological
- 27:37mechanics, and different social norms.
- 27:39Female psychopaths are often impulsive and characterized by
- 27:43behavioral problems. They demonstrate this mainly by
- 27:46running away, displaying signs of self-destructive and self
- 27:50harming behavior, and various acts of manipulation.
- 27:54Regarding behavior, Whereas men tend to run scams and commit
- 27:57crimes of fraud, female psychopaths tend to use their
- 28:01feminine Wiles, so to speak, to manipulate others.
- 28:04In other words, they flirt to get their way, or at least
- 28:07attempt to. Their criminal behavior leans
- 28:10towards committee acts of fraud and theft rather than violence.
- 28:15Forms of aggression vary between men and women who are
- 28:18psychopathic, with females being aggressive verbally and within
- 28:22their relationships and males being more physically
- 28:25aggressive. These acts of aggression by
- 28:28females can occur through manipulating others in their
- 28:31social circle with the goal to ouster reject their targeted
- 28:35victim. It also manifests itself in
- 28:37threats of self harm. It has been observed how female
- 28:40psychopaths do not necessarily share the traits of
- 28:43superficiality or grandosity like their male counterparts do.
- 28:48It has been suggested that this may be due to differences in
- 28:51culture and their upbringing. The underlying psychological
- 28:55condition and its motivations also differ between men and
- 28:59women and has also been discussed how social norms
- 29:02affect the perception of psychopathic traits differently
- 29:06between males and females. A study of female inmates
- 29:10revealed that they are diagnosed with emotionally unstable
- 29:13personality disorder much more often than antisocial
- 29:17personality disorder, which is a medical term for the presence of
- 29:22two or more medical conditions existing in a patient, is
- 29:25thought to possibly be a link with female psychopathy.
- 29:29Few studies have been done in this area, but what does exist
- 29:33suggests that both male and female psychopaths are suffering
- 29:36from more than one medical condition.
- 29:40In the case of Alyssa Bustamante, we can see her
- 29:43depression, anxiety, ADD, borderline personality, in
- 29:48addition to her antisocial or dyssocial personality disorder
- 29:53are all strong evidence of her being inflicted with
- 29:57comorbidity. This is an interesting concept
- 30:00that warrants much more research to possibly understand the
- 30:05complexities of the brain and thus the personality and
- 30:09behaviors of someone afflicted with more than one medical
- 30:13condition. When psychopathy begins to merge
- 30:16differs between the gingers as well.
- 30:18Where males typically exhibit signs as early as childhood,
- 30:22females initially show symptoms in adolescence.
- 30:25Young women display relational forms of aggression, which are
- 30:29brought on by jealousy, manipulation, self injury or
- 30:33harming, and verbal aggression. At first glance, Alyssa
- 30:36Bustamante doesn't fit the typical profile of a psychopath.
- 30:41However, when you read about and consider some of the distinct
- 30:45differences between male and female psychopaths, the pattern
- 30:49strongly align with her personality and behavior.
- 30:53She. Was an abandoned, neglected
- 30:55child whose grandparents seemed to love her and take care of
- 30:58her, but they didn't really try to understand her.
- 31:01Maybe this is simply a reflection of the large
- 31:04generation gap? And or they're being highly
- 31:08religious. There were so many signs, both
- 31:11physical and psychological that were screaming for serious
- 31:16intervention. Placing someone on Prozac is not
- 31:20sufficient enough treatment for someone suffering from this
- 31:24degree of mental illness and suicidal ideation.
- 31:28I don't blame her grandparents at all, but the healthcare
- 31:33facility and the therapist really failed when they let this
- 31:36girl's psychosis slipped through the cracks.
- 31:40During her stay at the hospital, she allegedly conveyed to one of
- 31:44the counsellors that she wanted to kill someone and she had set
- 31:48her eyes upon Elizabeth Olton. Elizabeth Olton was everything
- 31:55Alyssa Bustamante was not. She was a girly girl who had a
- 32:01loving home with a mother and siblings who adored her.
- 32:05She was from a normal and healthy functioning family.
- 32:10Elizabeth Olton was full of light, hope and purity and
- 32:16Alyssa Bustamante's twisted and depraved mind which was over
- 32:22running with thoughts of self hatred and darkness.
- 32:26She sought to destroy something beautiful, somewhat entirely
- 32:29innocent. There has been much speculation
- 32:32as to who her initial intended victims were.
- 32:36Since Alyssa Bustamante had dug 2 graves, some believe that the
- 32:41graves were dug for her twin brothers.
- 32:44This theory surfaced mainly due to how Alyssa expressed A
- 32:47sadistic pleasure at seeing them electrically themselves in the
- 32:51previously mentioned YouTube video.
- 32:54However, I don't think that reaction was intended to mean
- 32:57she actually wanted her little brothers hurt, much less dead.
- 33:02I mean, how many millions upon millions of YouTube and TikTok
- 33:07videos demonstrate teens and preteens making light of
- 33:11themselves and or their friends getting harmed or hurt in some
- 33:15capacity by acting out in reckless, idiotic ways?
- 33:19They intentionally create videos for that primary purpose.
- 33:24Now the other individual some people believe Alyssa initially
- 33:27set out to murder was her little sister Emma.
- 33:30This theory is mainly based upon the crude, violent depiction of
- 33:34her little sister in the drawing found in her bedroom.
- 33:38But we don't know the context around the sketch, and by all
- 33:41accounts, Emma was not afraid of her big sister.
- 33:46From what we do know of how Alyssa treated her younger
- 33:49siblings, at least according to her grandmother, she cared for
- 33:52them as if she was their parent and she did not abuse them or
- 33:57cause them any intentional harm. That Alyssa Bustamante primarily
- 34:02placed harm upon herself. Is what makes her distinct from
- 34:05many other psychopaths. But after reading the research,
- 34:09self injury or self harming in female psychopaths appears to be
- 34:14pretty common. A typical psychopath is defined
- 34:17by their highly narcissistic personality, their grandiose
- 34:21sense of self. Someone who cussed themselves
- 34:24all over and has attempted to kill themselves does not seem to
- 34:28fall within this trait. However, when you look at her
- 34:30social media presence, there is some indication of narcissism
- 34:35there. There were signs of her desire
- 34:37for attention, to craft an image of herself, this alluring
- 34:42darkness around her, flirtatious and seductive in a bizarre,
- 34:46gothy teenage sort of way. They are bold in your face,
- 34:51glamorized depictions of violence.
- 34:54The images of her are not frightening in a traditional
- 34:58sense. They are over the top dramatic,
- 35:01as if she is simply playing to the camera.
- 35:04Alyssa Bustamante was an attractive young woman, and she
- 35:07expressed a sense of confidence and playfulness in her online
- 35:11presence. In this regard, she does match
- 35:13the narcissistic characteristic of psychopathy.
- 35:18Now, these images have been given far too much attention in
- 35:21the press. After her twisted attack and
- 35:24grisly killing of a child, all of her past posts and writings
- 35:28somehow became indicative of her sickness.
- 35:31But was that just an after the fact perception?
- 35:34If she had never committed this horrific crime and bragged about
- 35:37it in her diary, would these images and videos ever have been
- 35:41at the forefront, used to prove how depraved and weird and dark
- 35:45and evil the young woman was? I think it's pretty safe to say
- 35:49that there are countless teenagers in particular of the
- 35:52goth emor or alternate lifestyle or look that portray themselves
- 35:58in bizarre, even creepy and dark sinister ways.
- 36:02That is not an indication or evidence that they are violent
- 36:06or have the tendency to commit homicide.
- 36:08In my opinion, it is not the dark imagery or words that make
- 36:13Alyssa Bustamante terrifying. Rather, it is when she looks and
- 36:18behaves like a normal teenage girl that she is the most
- 36:24disturbing. That is why I selected the photo
- 36:28I did of her for the cover. It is much scarier to see her
- 36:32smiling the picture of a cute 15 year old small town girl who was
- 36:37plotting to murder a neighborhood child.
- 36:41Alyssa Bustamante's psychopathy truly shines through during her
- 36:45interrogation video. It is truly astonishing and
- 36:49almost surreal how this 15 year old girl smirks, jokes and rocks
- 36:54easily back in the chair while talking to a homicide detective
- 36:58about a missing girl. She shows not a care or worry in
- 37:04the world, there's no anxiety or depression or display.
- 37:08Knowing that she committed this horrific murder of a child and
- 37:12exhibits no concern at all of being discovered reveals her
- 37:18inner psychopath. One of the trademarks of
- 37:21psychopathy is manipulation in chronic lying and how they
- 37:26believe they are smarter than everyone else in the room.
- 37:32Alyssa Bustamante goes from denying knowing anything about
- 37:35Elizabeth's disappearance to attempting to sell a story about
- 37:39her accidentally killing the little girl.
- 37:42It is only when she is faced with the evidence they have on
- 37:46her that she cracks and breaks down into any sign of genuine
- 37:53emotion. About the emotion is not for
- 37:57Elizabeth, it is for herself. After the confession, Detective
- 38:03Rice leaves the room briefly. Alyssa Bustamante turns to the
- 38:07juvenile officer Toby Meyer with authentic terror and trepidation
- 38:12in her face and voice and ass. What are they going to do?
- 38:16To me? It is difficult not to feel some
- 38:18ounce of compassion for this teenage girl who is now
- 38:23petrified. But her concern is not for
- 38:27Elizabeth and her family. This outburst of emotions
- 38:31revolved around what was going to happen to her now that the
- 38:35hideous truth of her crime wasn't covered.
- 38:41Now, whether or not her apology to the family during her
- 38:44sentencing hearing was sincere or not, only Alyssa knows, but
- 38:48I'm sure that it was brought on by the advisement of her
- 38:51attorney. Expressing guilt and remorse
- 38:53over 1's violent actions can only benefit the outcome, not
- 38:58harm it. Yet it didn't seem to make any
- 39:01difference in the sentence she was given, nor in the parole
- 39:04board denying her conditional release.
- 39:07In previous episodes, I have discussed the matter of the
- 39:10juvenile waiver. For those of you new to the
- 39:13podcast or who need a refresher on the subject, it's a legal
- 39:16procedure for a juvenile to be tried as an adult instead of a
- 39:20minor. There are several different ways
- 39:23this can't be done. First, there are discretionary
- 39:25waivers where a judge solely decides whether a juvenile will
- 39:28be charged as an adult. This requires an official
- 39:31hearing in which evidence is presented from both the
- 39:34prosecutor and the Juveniles Defense Council.
- 39:37The judge then determines the offender's potential for
- 39:40rehabilitation based on various factors of the case, including
- 39:44any prior delinquent behavior. Secondly, there are mandatory or
- 39:47statutory ravers, which are laws that are established by a state
- 39:51that mandate A juvenile be charged as an adult for specific
- 39:54felony offenses. These traditionally include more
- 39:58serious violent crimes like homicide and rape, but in
- 40:01certain states they can encompass even nonviolent crimes
- 40:04like drug trafficking. The third type of juvenile
- 40:08waiver is known as a prosecutorial waiver.
- 40:10These differ from judicial since they don't require an official
- 40:14hearing to present the factors of the case under consideration.
- 40:18Instead, these waivers are solely up to the prosecutor's
- 40:22judgment, which gives them the power to directly file a case
- 40:26against a juvenile and adult court.
- 40:29This last transfer or waiver process is highly controversial
- 40:33and is at the forefront of much discussion regarding the
- 40:36fairness of how these laws are implemented, specifically
- 40:39surrounding issues of racial disparity.
- 40:43Scholars and critics also point out how the likelihood of
- 40:46recidivism among juveniles prosecuted as adults
- 40:49significantly increases once a minor is handled as an adult in
- 40:53the system. It removes a minor from the
- 40:56jurisdiction of a juvenile court system and allows a state
- 40:59prosecutor to charge an individual under the age of 18
- 41:04as an adult. The age at which a child can be
- 41:07transferred to Criminal Court, also referred to as adult court,
- 41:10varies widely from state to state.
- 41:13Many states have legislation that sets the age at 14, but
- 41:17others allow the transfer for children as young as 10 for more
- 41:21serious offenses. For example, in California this
- 41:24age is strictly set at 16, whereas in Arizona there is no
- 41:28minimum age. In Missouri, where this crime
- 41:32took place, the minimum age is 12 years old.
- 41:35This means that if a 12 year old commits any felony, the court
- 41:39can petition to relinquish the rights of the juvenile court.
- 41:44It is required that a hearing be set in order to properly and
- 41:47thoroughly determine whether the child should be handled by the
- 41:50juvenile system or they should be tried in Criminal Court as an
- 41:54adult. Before any official hearing, a
- 41:56written report must be prepared for consideration to transfer.
- 42:00This includes everything from a child's history, delinquent
- 42:04record, the offense, any prospect for rehabilitation,
- 42:07amongst other factors. If the court determines that the
- 42:11child cannot be properly handled in the juvenile system is
- 42:14decided in the case of Alisa Bustamante, the child will then
- 42:18be transferred to adult court. Once a minor is transferred to
- 42:23Criminal Court, they are forever seen and therefore treated as an
- 42:27adult. In other words, if they are
- 42:29tried as an adult once, then they will always be handled as
- 42:33an adult. The only exception to this rule
- 42:36is if the juvenile is found not guilty, then the child will
- 42:41revert back to the juvenile system if and when they have
- 42:44committed a future offence. Research has shown that only
- 42:48harm can come to a juvenile house in an adult.
- 42:52Jail or prison, Not only are these facilities not designed to
- 42:56hold kids, but there is nothing positive for juveniles to gain
- 43:01from their growing up behind bars.
- 43:03Youth need and require certain types of services and programs
- 43:07that they cannot receive in adult confinement.
- 43:10Jails and prisons are not set up to provide juvenile offenders
- 43:14with sufficient education. Their services and programs
- 43:18don't address their health and medical needs, nor can they
- 43:21fulfill their specific requirements for potential
- 43:24rehabilitation. Everything from classification
- 43:27tools to facilities and programs are inappropriate for treating
- 43:31youth because it does not address their unique stages of
- 43:35development. It is impossible to deny that
- 43:39adolescence is a formative stage for human beings, and each stage
- 43:43of growing up brings with it a unique set of challenges,
- 43:46vulnerabilities, and needs that differ greatly from those of
- 43:50adulthood. Juveniles in institutions for
- 43:53adult incarceration suffer greatly from being thrown in
- 43:56with adults. They are exposed to career
- 43:59criminals and violent offenders, including predators.
- 44:03The research shows that kids inside prison walls are more
- 44:06likely to commit crimes, in particular more serious
- 44:10offenses, once they are released.
- 44:13They are also the most likely to become victims of physical and
- 44:17sexual assault. There is no data on the
- 44:20percentage of girls assaulted in adult facilities, but the rate
- 44:25inside state and local juvenile facilities is disproportionately
- 44:30high. Girls comprise approximately 15%
- 44:33of youth within juvenile facilities, yet one study
- 44:37revealed that they represented 26% of all cases of abuse.
- 44:42Even more alarming was a study that showed 51% of the cases of
- 44:47abuse that were perpetuated by staff members were committed
- 44:51against girls. Given that the majority of
- 44:54female offenders, both youth and adult, are victims of physical
- 44:58and or sexual abuse and trauma, these girls and young women face
- 45:03a disproportionately high risk of being re victimized once they
- 45:08are placed in the adult system. Statistics on this particular
- 45:12group of offenders also shows that due to their past history
- 45:15of abuse and trauma, they have a significantly high rate of
- 45:20emotional instability and mental health disorders.
- 45:23Youth in adult jails and prisons are also more vulnerable to self
- 45:27harm and suicidal ideation. Offenders under the age of 18
- 45:31are much more likely to kill themselves while in adult jail.
- 45:35With a rate of twice that of adults, it doesn't take an
- 45:39extensive period of incarceration either to break
- 45:41them mentally. In fact, 48% of these suicides
- 45:46occur within the first week. Juveniles are also frequently
- 45:50isolated from adults in jail, which only lends to escalating
- 45:56their mental and emotional instability, increasing their
- 45:59risk of suicide. Now, it's important to realize
- 46:02that the vast majority of youth are not being transferred to
- 46:06adult Criminal Court from its peak seen in the mid 1990s when
- 46:11the development of such juvenile waivers increased in number and
- 46:14harshness. With most juveniles being
- 46:17transferred for nonviolent drug offenses, that percentage of
- 46:21teenagers or minors being waived has declined by over 700%.
- 46:28The data, however, varies greatly depending on the year
- 46:31and can fluctuate wildly depending on the state where the
- 46:35juvenile resides. It is estimated that between
- 46:38200,000 and 250,000 youth under the age of 18 are transferred to
- 46:43Criminal Court every year. Male youth offenders were eight
- 46:47times more likely to be waived to Criminal Court than female
- 46:50youth were between 2017 and 2024.
- 46:54There was much progress made in the areas of what were known as
- 46:58Raise the Age laws, which sought to minimize the number and age
- 47:02in which the criminal courts could handle juveniles.
- 47:05For example, both North Carolina and Louisiana had legislation
- 47:08which prevented a juvenile 16 years or younger from being
- 47:12considered an adult, but these laws have recently been reversed
- 47:17as a result. This makes it even easier, and
- 47:20has become more rampant for juveniles to be waived.
- 47:24There are roughly 4600 juveniles being held in adult jail on any
- 47:30given night in the United States.
- 47:33Rehabilitation, Redemption. These two words which once
- 47:37defined the purpose and structural of the penal system
- 47:41in the United States and still do in many countries now, they
- 47:47feel almost surreal they are so detached from our current crime
- 47:52control model. Our present day penal system is
- 47:55centered around punishment and does little to help inmates
- 48:00develop and progress as human beings whether they are ever
- 48:03eligible for parole or not. Should we be treating 12 year
- 48:07olds as adults, even in the most horrible and violent of cases?
- 48:13Should we as a society be prosecuting a child as an adult?
- 48:19These questions are not answered easily in the case of Alyssa
- 48:23Bustamante. She was only a few years older
- 48:26than the minimum age in Missouri when she was sentenced to life
- 48:30in prison for committing the most heinous crime imaginable.
- 48:35She brutally and viciously murdered a child when she was
- 48:40still a child herself. A disturbed, emotionally
- 48:44enraged, abused child. Does killing an innocent child
- 48:49mean that Alyssa Bustamante is incapable of being rehabilitated
- 48:55and therefore redeemable? It is not an easy question to
- 49:00answer from someone who has a degree in criminal justice.
- 49:05I tend to think in general we over penalize offenders in this
- 49:09country, including violent offenders.
- 49:13Our country has one of the highest rates of incarcerations
- 49:17in the world, period. No data shows anything positive
- 49:22about the current model employed.
- 49:25On the contrary, offenders who are incarcerated only become
- 49:30worse in our prisons, not better.
- 49:33It is often been said that even if someone is innocent of their
- 49:37crime, once they are imprisoned in our country, they will learn
- 49:40fast to become a criminal. We do little to nothing to
- 49:45identify and help heal the issues that lead offenders to be
- 49:50triggered in committing crimes. They are too often raped and
- 49:55abused by their fellow inmates and by prison guards.
- 49:59Our mental health care system inside and outside of prison is
- 50:02a joke, as evidenced by Alyssa Bustamante's treatment before
- 50:06the murder. We set up our convicts to fail
- 50:09and return to the system instead of preparing them for a life
- 50:13outside of it, no matter the severe degree of depravity.
- 50:17What does it say as a culture that we penalize kids to this
- 50:21extent? I understand we can't and
- 50:24shouldn't slap them on the wrist, so to speak, and send
- 50:27them to counselling for killing someone or committing any kind
- 50:31of violent offense. There are seriously dangerous
- 50:35and depraved children out there. Alyssa Bustamante proved to the
- 50:39world that she was a serious threat to others when she
- 50:43savagely murdered Elizabeth Holton.
- 50:46The vile words she expressed afterwards cast doubt on the
- 50:50concept that juveniles don't fully grasp the consequences of
- 50:54their actions based on their age and lack of cognitive
- 50:58development. Alyssa Bustamante fully
- 51:01understood that strangling, stabbing and slitting a girl's
- 51:06throat and dumping her into a grave would end in her death.
- 51:13That was the entire purpose of her digging a grave, selecting A
- 51:17victim and carrying out the crime.
- 51:20She also demonstrated full awareness and intelligence and
- 51:24how she plotted out the crime and manipulated and used her
- 51:28younger sister to be her unknown accomplice.
- 51:32There is no denying that every element of the crime was
- 51:36calculated and done with the sole intention of causing
- 51:40another's death. So how do we justify not keeping
- 51:43a twisted child killer like her locked away for life?
- 51:47How, as a society, do we take the chance of releasing her
- 51:50after 30 years, knowing that she may well have been fantasizing
- 51:54about her next kill once she is free?
- 51:58Maybe I am completely wrong and time, in particular prison time,
- 52:02has set her on a different, sincere path.
- 52:06But psychopathy doesn't just go away.
- 52:09It's like the inner lining of her mind.
- 52:11She can conceal it from others, pretend it was just her
- 52:16tormented upbringing and that as a full grown woman, after having
- 52:20served her time, she is no longer a threat to society.
- 52:23I am not a mother, at least not of any human children.
- 52:27I can't begin to comprehend the dark, endless well of emotions
- 52:34that Elizabeth Olton's mother was forced to endure after
- 52:38losing her precious baby girl especially.
- 52:42In such a horrifically violent manner and even worse by a
- 52:48neighborhood teenage girl. If I were her, I would wish only
- 52:53hell upon Alyssa Bustamante's every breathing moment and do
- 52:57everything in my power to ensure she is never freed.
- 53:03But again, this doesn't answer any question about how to handle
- 53:09children, including teenagers, in the justice system.
- 53:13It only invites more How young is too young to be labeled an
- 53:18evil monster and be locked away for life?
- 53:23What age is appropriate to destroy the rest of a child's
- 53:27life when they commit the most atrocious of crimes?
- 53:31The only answer I do have is that each case must be handled
- 53:35on its own unique circumstances. Everything about the crime, the
- 53:39offender, the victim, any attempt to conceal it, the
- 53:42aftermath of being caught, the emotions or lack of shown by the
- 53:46juvenile, all elements must be carefully measured and looked at
- 53:51by different kinds of specialists and judges to
- 53:54thoughtfully and carefully determine how a child offender's
- 53:57crime and life should be handled.
- 54:01The justice system and its players hold incredible power
- 54:05over the direction of an offender's life, no matter their
- 54:08age. The worst thing and the most
- 54:11irresponsible thing they can do is not take under careful
- 54:15consideration how their decisions will make a lifetime
- 54:19impact on the child offender and their future.
- 54:25The other side stems from the other part of my degree, which
- 54:29is criminology. The calculated cold and sinister
- 54:33plan Alyssa Bustamante set in motion almost a week before
- 54:37fulfilling her fantasy, the repugnant words she spilled into
- 54:42her diary after the murder. Her diary was her trophy of the
- 54:47crime. If she hadn't felt the need to
- 54:50write down how amazing it was to kill someone, I highly doubt she
- 54:56would have ever been caught on some levels.
- 54:59The most unsettling aspect of her as an offender can be
- 55:03visibly seen and heard within the interrogation video.
- 55:07She strikes off almost every box of psychopathy at only 15 years
- 55:13old. A lack of effect, No empathy,
- 55:17Pathological line, Arrogant, manipulative.
- 55:21Among the other well recorded traits, children can't be
- 55:24diagnosed with psychopathy since they have not reached full
- 55:27cognitive development. From what we know of the
- 55:30disorder, at least from what researchers have gauged based on
- 55:33other criminal psychopaths, something in a child's life
- 55:36helped to trigger the disorder. I have read some speculation
- 55:41about her having suffered sexual abuse.
- 55:43I have also read claims that she killed animals.
- 55:47Unless these come from the case or from her words, which neither
- 55:52of them have, I don't choose to presume either way.
- 55:55She mentioned burying dead animals, but she never said she
- 55:59killed them. I think some people out there
- 56:02want to paint her as this blossoming serial killer because
- 56:06to them that would make her even more captivating.
- 56:10What is known is that Alyssa Bustamante grew up in an.
- 56:13Emotionally turbulent, unstable and violent household in her
- 56:17most formative years. I have often heard others say
- 56:20that doesn't explain or justify what she did.
- 56:23Of course not. Nothing ever could.
- 56:27But it is critical to understand from the perspective of
- 56:30criminology that not everyone has or has learned healthy
- 56:33coping skills. Alyssa Bustamante was hit with
- 56:37one trauma after another from before.
- 56:40She was even. Born.
- 56:42Her resentment, rage, and depression, combined with her
- 56:46genetic propensity for violence and her emotional imbalance
- 56:52caused her to boil over. She embraced darkness, violence,
- 56:56and became obsessed with death. As she got older, something made
- 57:02her completely detach from her emotional connection to others.
- 57:06Alyssa Bustamante was a budding psychopath and no one noticed
- 57:10its formation until she had made her first kill.
- 57:15Does that mean she is still a psychopath?
- 57:18Or is a psychopath even possible of changing?
- 57:22Do they have the ability to change or progress without the
- 57:26most extensive of therapy? Most research indicates that
- 57:31they can't. They are resistant to change.
- 57:34And don't progress in therapy much, if at all.
- 57:38Could a child with psychopathy be different from an adult with
- 57:41the disorder? Is there a chance that once
- 57:44their brains are fully developed, they could be
- 57:46altered? It's impossible to know,
- 57:49especially given that juveniles can't be officially diagnosed.
- 57:54From what I have found about her life in prison, Alyssa
- 57:58Bustamante is a model prisoner. Her grandparents and even some
- 58:02of her siblings, including Emma, visit her.
- 58:05I came across an interesting article that referenced Alyssa
- 58:08Bustamante in relation to a woman who had spiraled downward
- 58:12after becoming addicted to meth. A military wife whose life,
- 58:16marriage and family completely unravelled when she became a
- 58:19drug addict and was sent to prison.
- 58:22She met Alyssa Bustamante and even though she was at first
- 58:26freaked out to meet the most infamous convict at Chillicothe
- 58:30Women's Prison, this woman saw something else in her.
- 58:35The two women fell in love and consider each other wives.
- 58:40This woman has since been released but still visits Alyssa
- 58:45often. While performing research for
- 58:47this case, I noticed how there are quite a few Alyssa fans
- 58:52supporters out there. I wouldn't be bothered by this
- 58:55fact. If they wanted her to be free
- 58:58for the right reasons. Advocating for her parole based
- 59:01on the premise of juvenile justice and that she was a child
- 59:04when she committed the crime and they believe she should be given
- 59:07another chance would be one thing.
- 59:10If they believe she should be released because she has
- 59:12expressed genuine remorse and has taken major steps to prove
- 59:16that her life is worth saving, then maybe I could get behind
- 59:21it. But they are more fans than
- 59:26supporters. People who comment on her hot
- 59:29looks, people who express awe at what she did.
- 59:34These individuals are disgusting and as disturbing as the words
- 59:38she left behind in her diary. It's not at all surprising
- 59:42though, given how many men and women have become obsessed and
- 59:45even get romantically involved with the most depraved and
- 59:49violent of criminals. I believe as she has proven to
- 59:53be a real danger to herself and others and is capable and would
- 59:57likely reoffend if given the opportunity.
- 1:00:01I have little doubt that if Alyssa Bustamante had not been
- 1:00:04caught at 15 years old, there would be a row of graves filled
- 1:00:10with the neighborhood kids of Saint Martin, Missouri.
- 1:00:20Thank you so much for listening to Part 2 of 2 Graves and A
- 1:00:24Diary of Female The Real Color. I would love to hear what you
- 1:00:30have thought about these two episodes.
- 1:00:33I know I went into a lot of tangents this time, but I became
- 1:00:37very compelled and invested in this case and looking at it
- 1:00:42through different lenses. If you have any questions,
- 1:00:45comments, or ideas for future episodes, I would love to hear
- 1:00:49from you. Please reach out my contact
- 1:00:51information you can find in the episode description.
- 1:00:56Until next time, stay safe and watch out for shake and murder
- 1:01:05happening on the streets next over, especially inside your own
- 1:01:12home. Shades of Murder is created,
- 1:01:19researched, written and edited by Alina Caldwell.
- 1:01:25Original music stranger composed by Stereo Code.