Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Counseling Beyond the Law: The Rise of Business Therapy
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone, and welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Counseling Beyond the Law, the Rise of Business
- 0:10Therapy. I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of Education
- 0:13and Professional Development at Beverly Hills
- 0:15Bar Association, and today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:17our speaker, Talin Yakubian. Talene is a partner
- 0:21and founding member of Yakubian and Powell LLP.
- 0:25She has over three decades of experience in environmental
- 0:28litigation, business law, and dispute resolution.
- 0:31She held an instrumental role in the Iron Mountain
- 0:34Mine Superfund Settlement, one of the largest
- 0:37environmental settlements for federal and state
- 0:39agencies in California. Tallin represents clients
- 0:42across a broad range of matters from renewable
- 0:45energy and intellectual property to civil rights
- 0:47and construction, and serves as general counsel
- 0:50to an international conglomerate. Beyond her
- 0:53legal practice, Talene is deeply committed to
- 0:55public service and her community, having organized
- 0:58the 2015 Armenian Genocide Centennial March of
- 1:01160 ,000 people in Los Angeles. She currently
- 1:05teaches legal writing and advocacy at USC Gould
- 1:08School of Law. We're so excited to hear what
- 1:10she has to share with us today. Please submit
- 1:12your questions in the Q &A box below. And now
- 1:14I'm going to turn it over to her. All right.
- 1:17Thank you very much, Ella. I appreciate that
- 1:19introduction. Again, just to recap, I am Tallinia
- 1:23Kubian. I am a civil litigator and mediator.
- 1:26I'm based in downtown Los Angeles. Thank you
- 1:28for being here today. My plan is to keep you
- 1:32interested for the next hour or so, and then
- 1:35we can look at the Q &A for questions at the
- 1:37end. And I really encourage you to ask questions.
- 1:41I'm excited to talk about this and excited to
- 1:44answer your questions from your lens, because
- 1:48this is just all me right now. A little more
- 1:52about my practice. My practice spans civil litigation
- 1:55and mediation. I do business and commercial matters,
- 1:59IP, employment, environmental, and a lot of real
- 2:04estate. I've represented individuals, small businesses,
- 2:08large companies, public entities. I've been in
- 2:12courtrooms, deposition rooms, and conference
- 2:15rooms trying to hold a deal together until all
- 2:17hours of the night. I've spent the last several
- 2:20years building a mediation practice alongside
- 2:23the litigation work, which means I've now sat
- 2:26on every side of the table as an advocate, as
- 2:30a neutral, and sometimes as the person in the
- 2:33room who's just trying to figure out what the
- 2:35two sides want from each other. So what I want
- 2:40to share with you today is a framework that has
- 2:43come out of all of that. 33 years of watching
- 2:46what actually works and being honest with myself
- 2:49about what doesn't. By the end of this hour,
- 2:52you'll have a concrete set of tools that you
- 2:54can take back to your own practice and use right
- 2:57away, hopefully. Not theory, not soft skill seminars,
- 3:02just really practical tools that'll make you
- 3:05more effective with the clients who are hardest
- 3:07to help. As I've said, I've been practicing for
- 3:13several decades, long enough to know that the
- 3:15cases that stay with you aren't always the biggest
- 3:18ones. Sometimes it's a conversation. Sometimes
- 3:22it's a single sentence that lands away that you
- 3:25weren't expecting. A few years ago, I had a client
- 3:29who was herself a lawyer, which as many of you
- 3:32know, who have represented lawyers, comes with
- 3:37its own particular dynamic. She was going through
- 3:40something difficult, a personal dispute that
- 3:43had crossed over into litigation, and she was
- 3:46handling the underlying matter herself, but she
- 3:49brought it to me because she felt overwhelmed.
- 3:52She was just too close to the matter. At some
- 3:55point during one of our calls, she broke down.
- 3:58She was crying, like really crying, and I'll
- 4:01be honest, it was uncomfortable for both of us,
- 4:04even over the phone. There's something particular
- 4:08you're disorienting about having a fellow attorney
- 4:11fall apart. We're trained to hold it together.
- 4:15We're trained to be the ones who hold it together
- 4:17for other people. And here we both were. I did
- 4:21what I could. I didn't try to fix it. I just
- 4:25let her be, like, you know, in the moment. And
- 4:28eventually the conversation found its footing
- 4:31again. Then a few days later, she called me back.
- 4:36Just a regular check -in, and almost as an aside,
- 4:40like she'd been quietly turning it over in her
- 4:42head, she said, you know, you don't just practice
- 4:45the law, you also do business therapy. You know,
- 4:50the phrase just really struck me. I wrote it
- 4:53on a post -it, and I stuck it on my computer
- 4:55screen. I just kept looking at it. And I just
- 4:59started thinking about it all the time. I started
- 5:02seeing it everywhere. I'd be in the middle of
- 5:04a client meeting, walking through strategy, and
- 5:07I'd realize the legal question isn't really what's
- 5:10driving this conversation. What's driving it
- 5:13is fear or grief or a pattern this person has
- 5:17been repeating for 20 years and doesn't know
- 5:19it yet. I started going back through the years
- 5:23of client work in my head, things clients had
- 5:26said, moments where something shifted in a meeting.
- 5:30representations that went unusually well or unusually
- 5:34sideways. And what I kept noticing was how much
- 5:37of it had nothing to do with the law, at least
- 5:40not directly. It was about trying to understand
- 5:43each person's particular circumstances, what
- 5:47drove them, what they were afraid of, what they
- 5:50actually wanted underneath what they said they
- 5:52wanted. Eventually, I wrote an article about
- 5:56it for the Daily Journal. In that article, is
- 5:59what led to today. The article was called How
- 6:03Business Therapy Helps Lawyers Solve What Clients
- 6:06Don't See. Writing it forced me to do something
- 6:10I hadn't done before, to take something I had
- 6:13been intuitively for decades doing and try to
- 6:17articulate it, to give it structure, to explain
- 6:21not just what it was, but why it worked. That
- 6:25process of putting it into words changed how
- 6:28I thought about it. It made me more deliberate,
- 6:31more teachable. And the response to the article
- 6:35told me that I wasn't alone in recognizing it,
- 6:38that a lot of practitioners, a lot of you probably
- 6:41out there, had been doing some version of this
- 6:44without ever really having a need for it. That's
- 6:48what today is. It's an attempt to take what that
- 6:50client identified, what that article tried to
- 6:53capture, and turn it into something that you
- 6:55can actually use, a framework, a set of tools,
- 7:00and enough real -world illustration that you
- 7:03can walk out of here and recognize the moment
- 7:05that you need it. So, what is business therapy?
- 7:11It's not a formal credential. You won't find
- 7:14it in any law school classes. It does not require
- 7:17a clinical license. What it is, is a way of practicing
- 7:21law that takes seriously everything the client
- 7:25brings into the room, not just the legal problem,
- 7:29but the whole context around it, their history,
- 7:33their fears, the patterns they can't see themselves
- 7:37because they're just too close to it. So my goal
- 7:41for the next hour is to give you a framework
- 7:43for what that looks like and some concrete tools
- 7:46that you can start using right away. Before I
- 7:50go any further, I want to be clear about what
- 7:53this is not. This is not about playing amateur
- 7:56psychologist or psychiatrist. It's not about
- 8:00venturing into territory that requires a different
- 8:03kind of license. It's about being a better lawyer,
- 8:07a more effective one, and yes, a more compassionate
- 8:10one by understanding the full context your client
- 8:15is operating in. All right. Let's start with
- 8:19what clients actually bring into your office.
- 8:25Nobody hires a litigator because things are going
- 8:28well. By the time someone ends up in your office,
- 8:31something has already gone wrong. The legal problem
- 8:34is real. But underneath it, almost always, is
- 8:38something messier. I've come to think of every
- 8:42client matter, especially complex high stakes
- 8:45matters, as having three layers. Layer one, the
- 8:51legal problem. This is the one you are trained
- 8:54to handle. There's a contract dispute, an employment
- 8:59claim, a partnership that fell apart, a piece
- 9:03of real estate somebody is fighting over. You
- 9:06know how to do this. This is the easy part. And
- 9:09if, or if not easy, at least it's the familiar
- 9:11part. Layer two, the emotional experience. The
- 9:17client is not experiencing this matter the way
- 9:20it looks in a complaint or in a demand letter.
- 9:24They're afraid. They're angry. They feel betrayed.
- 9:29They're embarrassed things have gone this far.
- 9:32They're worried about what their employees think
- 9:35or their family or their business partner who
- 9:39they still have to see at industry or community
- 9:43events or maybe even still at their own office.
- 9:46Most lawyers address this layer adequately enough.
- 9:50You listen, you validate, you move on. That's
- 9:54fine as far as it goes. But here's the problem.
- 9:57If the emotional noise is loud enough, it will
- 10:01drown out your legal advice. The client who hasn't
- 10:05been heard won't be able to hear you back. I
- 10:09want to pause on that for a second because I
- 10:11think it's underappreciated. When a client is
- 10:15in genuine distress, and I mean not just annoyed,
- 10:18we've all had annoyed clients. No, something
- 10:23beyond that. When they're really frightened or
- 10:26angry or grieving, their cognitive bandwidth
- 10:30is compromised. Research on this is pretty clear.
- 10:34You can give them the most precise, well -reasoned
- 10:37legal analysis in the world, and they will absorb
- 10:40maybe 30 % of it. The rest? gets lost in the
- 10:44noise. We've all been there, right? Someone is
- 10:48speaking, but nothing is landing, especially
- 10:50after a long day. Maybe your partner's talking
- 10:53to you. Maybe your children are talking to you.
- 10:56It's just not coming through. So addressing the
- 11:00emotional layer isn't a soft skill or a courtesy.
- 11:04It's a precondition for doing your job effectively.
- 11:10Layer three. is what I call the blind spot. This
- 11:14is the one almost nobody addresses, and it's
- 11:18the one that matters the most for long -term
- 11:21client relationship and honestly for the quality
- 11:24of the outcome. Every client who ends up in your
- 11:28office has, somewhere in their history, a pattern,
- 11:33a behavior, a habit, an avoidance strategy that
- 11:37contributed to the problem they're now sitting
- 11:40in front of you with. The founder who never put
- 11:44anything in writing because she didn't want to
- 11:46make things weird with her business partner.
- 11:49The executive who knew his employment contract
- 11:51had a bad non -compete but kept telling himself
- 11:55he'd deal with it later. The landlord who ignored
- 11:59three early warning signs from his tenant because
- 12:01he didn't want conflict. The legal problem is
- 12:06the symptom. The blind spot is the diagnosis.
- 12:11I had a client years ago who had built a business
- 12:14from nothing. Absolutely nothing. A remarkable
- 12:17story, genuinely. But the business had grown
- 12:21so fast that he had never stopped to build it
- 12:24correctly. No real employment agreements, vendor
- 12:27contracts on handshakes, equity arrangements
- 12:31that existed in his head and in emails and nowhere
- 12:34else. Every month, the revenue went up. And every
- 12:39month, the legal exposure went up right alongside
- 12:43it and he couldn't see it because he was sprinting.
- 12:47What I had to help him understand was that the
- 12:50very thing he was most proud of, the speed, the
- 12:54growth, the momentum, was the thing that was
- 12:58going to take his business down if he didn't
- 13:01stop and address it. He was so focused on building
- 13:06that he couldn't see he was also building the
- 13:10risk. As we all know, an ounce of prevention
- 13:14is worth a pound of cure. In his case, it was
- 13:18worth about 10 pounds. Thankfully, he did a complete
- 13:24180, and I mean that literally. Today, he sends
- 13:27me almost everything before he signs it, before
- 13:30he commits, before he shakes hands on something
- 13:33new. The blind spot, once you could see it, became
- 13:38the thing he was most vigilant about. That's
- 13:41what addressing layer three can produce. Not
- 13:44just a better outcome in the immediate matter,
- 13:47a different client on the other side of it. So
- 13:52business therapy is the practice of helping clients
- 13:56see that pattern. Gently, clearly, and most importantly,
- 14:03without judgment. while also, of course, solving
- 14:08the immediate legal problem. That's still our
- 14:10job. We have to do that. Now, I want to say something
- 14:14about why this layer almost gets no love or very
- 14:20little attention. It's not because lawyers don't
- 14:24notice it. We do. Most experienced practitioners
- 14:27do notice it. You can see it in the intake. You
- 14:30can hear it in the way a client tells their story.
- 14:34The reason it doesn't get addressed is that it
- 14:37feels a little like it's outside our lane. We're
- 14:40not therapists. We don't want to overstep. And
- 14:44frankly, it can feel like a little bit of a detour
- 14:48when there's a problem, legal problem on the
- 14:51table that needs solving, that needs immediate
- 14:53attention. But here's the cost of skipping it.
- 14:59The client who doesn't understand their own pattern
- 15:03will often make decisions that undermine their
- 15:07legal position. So really take a moment to review
- 15:14that in your own mind. The client who doesn't
- 15:18understand their own pattern will often make
- 15:21decisions that undermine their legal position.
- 15:24Why? Because they're reacting from the same blind
- 15:28spot that got them there. The client who avoids
- 15:32conflict for example, will agree to a settlement
- 15:35that they can't live with just to make the process
- 15:38stop. How many of you know exactly what I'm talking
- 15:41about? I'm sure many. The client who needs to
- 15:45feel heard will keep escalating. Discovery disputes,
- 15:50motion demands, calls to be more aggressive,
- 15:53more assertive, not because strategy requires
- 15:57it, but because they don't feel like anyone is
- 16:01actually on their side. fighting for them. Again,
- 16:05I'm sure many of you can relate to this. When
- 16:08you address layer three, you don't just help
- 16:11the client. You make your own job easier. You
- 16:17make the representation cleaner. You help yourself.
- 16:22The case becomes easier to manage and more likely
- 16:25to produce an outcome that everyone can live
- 16:28with. Now, why does this matter to you as their
- 16:32lawyer beyond just this case? Two reasons. First,
- 16:37clients who understand their own patterns are
- 16:39easier to advise. They're more likely to follow
- 16:43your guidance. They're less likely to make the
- 16:46same mistake again, which means they're also
- 16:48less likely to end up back in your office in
- 16:51another crisis. Second, and I say this practically,
- 16:57the lawyers who do this well are the ones clients
- 17:01remember. Not just my lawyer got me a good result,
- 17:07the ones who say, she helped me, he helped me
- 17:11understand my business in a way I hadn't before.
- 17:16That's client retention. So moving on, what does
- 17:22this actually look like in practice? I'm going
- 17:28to give you five tools. We can move to the next
- 17:32slide. The intake question nobody asks. Five
- 17:43tools. Excellent. Most attorneys start an initial
- 17:47consultation by asking, tell me what happened.
- 17:52I've said it, you've said it, and that's fine.
- 17:56But there is a question that is asked less often,
- 17:59and it opens everything up. What do you think
- 18:03you want to happen at the end of this? Not what
- 18:08are you asking for legally, not what does the
- 18:13contract say you're entitled to. What do you
- 18:16actually want at the end of this? I can't tell
- 18:21you. How many times the answer to that question
- 18:25has completely changed the shape of my representation.
- 18:29Clients come in asking for a full litigation
- 18:31and they actually want an apology. They come
- 18:34asking for a settlement and they actually want
- 18:37their day in court. They say they want money
- 18:40and they actually want the other side to be held
- 18:43accountable publicly. When you know what winning
- 18:47actually looks like for your client, you can
- 18:50give them advice that is actually aligned with
- 18:53their goals, not just technically correct. Let
- 18:57me give you a concrete example. I had a client
- 18:59in a defamation matter, real damage, professional
- 19:04reputation, relationships, kind of thing that
- 19:07follows you. He came in ready to litigate. He
- 19:11wanted damages. He had a number in his head,
- 19:13and I asked him early. Before we had gone too
- 19:18far down the road, What do you actually want
- 19:21at the end of this? He was quiet for a moment
- 19:25and then he said, I want them to admit they were
- 19:29wrong. I want an apology. He went a step further.
- 19:35He told me he would take less money if you got
- 19:38an apology. That one sentence completely changed
- 19:41the shape of the representation because an apology
- 19:45is something that you can negotiate for. It's
- 19:49something a motivated defendant can actually
- 19:52give you. It is not something a jury can award.
- 19:57If I had never asked that question, if I had
- 20:00just taken his stated position and built a damaged
- 20:03case around it, I might have gotten him a number.
- 20:08I probably would not have gotten him what he
- 20:10actually wanted and needed. The question cost
- 20:14me 30 seconds. The answer was worth the entire
- 20:17case. And here's the other thing that the question
- 20:21does. It slows the intake down. It signals to
- 20:25the client that you're interested in more than
- 20:28the cause of action. That signal matters. It
- 20:32opens a different conversation. Just as an aside
- 20:39here about the intake, I also wanted to add that
- 20:43try not to take your cell phones in with you
- 20:47when you're doing the initial meeting with the
- 20:50client. That is going to signal that they are
- 20:55the focus, your 100 % focus, that you are not
- 21:00distracted by anything else. And that attention,
- 21:04that detail really matters. So tool number two,
- 21:12addressing the emotional layer first. Here's
- 21:16the practical truth. If your client walks into
- 21:19the initial meeting frightened and angry, your
- 21:24legal analysis is not going to land. Not because
- 21:27it's wrong, because they're not in a position
- 21:30to receive it yet. So before you get to strategy,
- 21:35you spend five minutes, really just five minutes,
- 21:38doing nothing but listening. Not problem solving
- 21:42in your head, not advising. not asking questions,
- 21:48not taking notes. Just walk me through what happened
- 21:53from your perspective. Let them finish. I know
- 21:59it's really hard. I know your mind is racing
- 22:02with your questions, with legal theories, with
- 22:05the timeline you're already trying to construct
- 22:08in your head. Try to sit on your hands. Think
- 22:12about what you tell witnesses when you prep them
- 22:14for deposition. Active listening. Don't interrupt.
- 22:18Let the other person complete their thought.
- 22:21Apply all of that advice to yourself in that
- 22:24moment. Then reflect back what you heard, not
- 22:28the facts, but the experience. It sounds like
- 22:33what's been most difficult is the feeling of
- 22:37being taken advantage of by someone you trusted,
- 22:41not how many of you had. How many of you have
- 22:46had partnership disputes between best friends,
- 22:49between family members? Heartbreakingly, this
- 22:52happens so much. Sounds like what's underneath
- 22:58this is real concern about whether the business
- 23:01survives, right? That reflection does two things.
- 23:07It makes the client feel genuinely understood
- 23:09and it clears enough emotional space that they
- 23:13can actually engage with the strategy conversation
- 23:17that follows. So five minutes. That's the investment.
- 23:21And the return on it is a client who actually
- 23:25hears you for the next 55. Third, the pattern
- 23:30question. This one takes a little bit more confidence,
- 23:33but it's most powerful. Once you have a clear
- 23:37picture of the matter and the relationship is
- 23:41established, you ask something like, has anything
- 23:44like this come up before? Not necessarily this
- 23:47exact situation, but this kind of dynamic. Or
- 23:54something like, looking back, what do you think
- 23:59was the earliest sign that this was heading somewhere
- 24:01difficult? How often have we found during discovery
- 24:08all of the red flags which telegraph things were
- 24:11Heathered South? Quite often. These questions
- 24:16at the outset invite the client to see their
- 24:19own pattern without you having to diagnose it
- 24:22for them. And clients who arrive at their own
- 24:26insight are much more open to changing their
- 24:29behavior going forward than clients who feel
- 24:32lectured. I want to be clear. You're not looking
- 24:36for psychological history here. You're not asking
- 24:39them to lie on a couch and tell you about their
- 24:41childhood. You're asking a specific forward -looking
- 24:45question about this matter and this dynamic.
- 24:49The answer tells you a lot about what you're
- 24:51actually working with and what kind of client
- 24:54that you're working with. So the fourth tool
- 24:59is the reframing move. Sometimes, clients come
- 25:04in with a stated goal that is not actually in
- 25:07their best interest. Shocking right? The classic
- 25:11is I want to go to trial and sometimes that's
- 25:15the right move but sometimes what's underneath
- 25:18it is I want the other side to feel the consequences
- 25:22or I want to feel like I fought back or I don't
- 25:29want to be taken advantage of. I've even heard
- 25:33I want to be able to look my children in the
- 25:36eye to be an example for them. When you can surface
- 25:41the underlying goal, you can often find a strategy
- 25:44that achieves it without the cost and risk of
- 25:47full litigation. That's not scaring the client.
- 25:50That's serving the client. Question I use is,
- 25:55help me understand. If we achieve that, what
- 25:59does that give you? And then you listen. The
- 26:03answer to that question often reveals the goal,
- 26:06the real goal, and the real goal is often more
- 26:10achievable than the stated starting position.
- 26:16Number five is the slow down move. This one doesn't
- 26:25get talked about enough. Sometimes the most important
- 26:29thing you can do in an initial consultation is
- 26:33resist the pull toward immediate action. And
- 26:38I know, I know this is hard. They've come in
- 26:42to your office because they need action and they
- 26:45want it right away. The client is in distress,
- 26:49wants you to do something. They want to file,
- 26:51they want to send a letter. They want to put
- 26:54the other side on notice immediately. that very
- 26:56day and sometimes again that's exactly what you
- 27:00will be doing but sometimes it's driven entirely
- 27:04by the emotional layer by need to feel like they're
- 27:08fighting back and acting on it before you've
- 27:12assessed the situation clearly can damage that
- 27:16client's position the slow down move is simply
- 27:21naming that I hear that you want to move quickly
- 27:24and I want to help you do that. But I want to
- 27:28make sure that when we move, we move in the right
- 27:31direction. Can we take the next week to get the
- 27:34full picture before we decide on our first step?
- 27:39Most clients, when they feel heard, can tolerate
- 27:42a week. What they can't tolerate is feeling like
- 27:46nothing is happening and no one is paying attention.
- 27:50So the slowdown move works best when you pair
- 27:52it with a concrete next step. A call, a document
- 27:57review, a follow -up meeting. Give them something
- 28:01to hold on to. And when you get in return, is
- 28:04the ability to make a strategic decision from
- 28:07a position of clarity rather than reaction. That's
- 28:13almost always worth a week. I've had this come
- 28:21up more than a few times, more than probably
- 28:25I can count, and I'm sure you have as well. A
- 28:28client walks in on a Tuesday and wants a letter
- 28:30out by Thursday. The other side did something.
- 28:33They're furious. They want to put the other party
- 28:36on notice immediately, today, before anything
- 28:39else happens. And I understand that impulse.
- 28:42It feels like action. It feels like control.
- 28:47But there have been situations where sending
- 28:49that letter on Thursday would have been a disaster,
- 28:52where we didn't have the full picture, where
- 28:56a threat we couldn't yet back up would have tipped
- 28:59off the other side, or where the client's own
- 29:02exposure wasn't yet clear and we would have been
- 29:06waving a flag before we understood that what
- 29:08we were walking into. In every one of those situations,
- 29:13the slowdown move Naming what we didn't yet know
- 29:17and why it mattered was what protected the client.
- 29:21Not from the other side, but from their own urgency.
- 29:27Urgency is not a strategy. Reaction is not a
- 29:32strategy. The slow down move is how you turn
- 29:35a client's emotional momentum into something
- 29:39that they can actually use. Next slide. Thank
- 29:48you. I want to pause on something before we get
- 29:52into the scenarios. We're going to be walking
- 29:55through the scenarios in a few minutes because
- 29:58there's a dimension of this work that the framework
- 30:00doesn't fully capture and I think it matters.
- 30:04Clients who trust you, really trust you, don't
- 30:08just see you as someone who handles their legal
- 30:11problems. They see you as someone who makes them
- 30:15stronger. more capable of facing hard things.
- 30:19They walk into a difficult situation differently
- 30:22because you are in their corner. I hear it all
- 30:25the time in different words. I sleep better at
- 30:27night knowing you're with us. You've heard that.
- 30:32That's not about legal skill exactly. It's about
- 30:36presence. It's about a client knowing that there
- 30:39is someone who understands their situation fully.
- 30:42not just the legal surface of it, but the history,
- 30:46the stakes, what they're afraid of, what they're
- 30:50capable of, and who is genuinely invested in
- 30:53how this goes for them. That combination of knowledge
- 30:57and care is what makes a client feel like they
- 31:00can handle what's coming. Not because their lawyer
- 31:04promised them a result, and it's really important
- 31:08to distinguish that, but because they don't feel
- 31:12alone. in it. I take that very seriously and
- 31:16I'm sure you do as well. Because if a client
- 31:19feels stronger with you in their corner, that
- 31:22means they're counting on something real. And
- 31:25that's a responsibility worth naming. It doesn't
- 31:29mean you guarantee outcomes. It doesn't mean
- 31:32you absorb their anxiety or become their emotional
- 31:35support system. What it means is that you show
- 31:39up prepared You communicate honestly and you
- 31:43make sure they never feel like they're navigating
- 31:46something difficult without someone who truly
- 31:49has their back. Business therapy is part of that
- 31:56relationship and how it gets built. When you
- 31:59understand what a client is actually carrying,
- 32:02all three layers, you become someone they can
- 32:05be honest with. And when they can be honest with
- 32:08you, they can let you actually help them. That's
- 32:13when the relationship stops being transactional
- 32:16and starts being something they value in a completely
- 32:19different way. Not just, my lawyer got me a good
- 32:24result, but my lawyer knows me and that makes
- 32:29all the difference. That is client control that
- 32:34helps you do your job well. Okay, next slide,
- 32:41please. Four scenarios. Let me walk through four
- 32:51hypotheticals that show how this plays out across
- 32:53different practice areas. Scenario number one,
- 32:57the business dispute. Your client is a 50 % owner
- 33:02of a small manufacturing company. His business
- 33:05partner of 12 years has started making unilateral
- 33:08decisions, cutting him out of operations, and
- 33:12your client wants to sue for breach of fiduciary
- 33:14duty. Layer one is clear. Layer two, your client
- 33:21is devastated. This was his best friend, or a
- 33:27sibling even. Layer three, and here's where it
- 33:31gets interesting. As you listen, it becomes clear
- 33:34that your client saw this coming 18 months ago
- 33:37and said nothing because confronting conflict
- 33:42in the business felt impossible to him. The business
- 33:47therapy move is not to ignore the legal claim,
- 33:50maybe strong one, it's to help your client understand
- 33:53that his avoidance of difficult conversations
- 33:57is what turned a potentially resolvable business
- 34:01disagreement into a lawsuit. Because if he doesn't
- 34:04see that pattern of avoidance, he will recreate
- 34:07it in his next business relationship. How many
- 34:10of you had clients that are serial offenders
- 34:13doing the same thing over and over again? And
- 34:18practically speaking, once the client sees that
- 34:22pattern of avoidance, he may also become more
- 34:25open to a mediated resolution, which might actually
- 34:29give him what he needs, an exit, their value
- 34:32for his interest and closure. What I'm noticing
- 34:40as a lawyer in a room. Sorry, small detour. Scenario
- 34:55number two. Your client is a mid -level executive
- 35:00who was terminated. She believes it was pretextual.
- 35:05She had complained about something internally
- 35:07and two months later she was let go. She wants
- 35:10to file a wrong for termination claim. Layer
- 35:13one, potential retaliation claim. Layer two,
- 35:18she feels humiliated. She gave this company eight
- 35:21years of her life. Layer three, as she talks,
- 35:26you learn she never documented a single thing.
- 35:29Not the complaint. not the subsequent friction
- 35:33with her manager, not anything. She kept it all
- 35:37in her head because she didn't want to seem like
- 35:39a troublemaker. For those of you who practice
- 35:43employment law out there, I'm sure this is a
- 35:45very common scenario and you've seen it hundreds
- 35:48of times. The legal challenge is real. The pattern
- 35:54is also real. She downplays her own concerns
- 35:58to avoid conflict. and then gets blindsided when
- 36:02the conflict arrives anyway. You can't go back
- 36:07and create documentation, but you can have an
- 36:10honest conversation with her about what her case
- 36:13looks like, with the evidence she actually has,
- 36:17what it would cost to litigate, and what a realistic
- 36:20outcome looks like, while also gently communicating
- 36:24the pattern that left her exposed. That's not
- 36:28discouraging her. That's preparing her. When
- 36:34I'm talking to her in that room, what am I noticing?
- 36:37What are you noticing? She's sitting there. She
- 36:43seems competent. She's holding it together. She's
- 36:47using the right words, asking the right questions.
- 36:51But underneath that, she's asking herself, did
- 36:53I do this to myself? Did I make myself invisible
- 36:57for eight years? and then wonder why nobody fought
- 37:01for me. That's not a legal question, but it is
- 37:05the question that's going to determine whether
- 37:07she can make a clear -eyed decision about this
- 37:10case, or whether she's going to litigate to prove
- 37:13something to herself that litigation can't actually
- 37:16prove. Scenario number three. The estate or real
- 37:24property dispute. Your client is one of three
- 37:29siblings fighting over what to do with the piece
- 37:32of property they've inherited. The other two
- 37:36siblings want to sell. Your client wants to keep
- 37:39it. It was the family home. She wants your help
- 37:42to block the sale. Layer one. A partition action
- 37:47or a defensive one depending on the posture.
- 37:51Layer two. Grief. She's not ready to let go of
- 37:57her parents' house. Layer three. She hasn't actually
- 38:02talked to her siblings about what this property
- 38:06means to her. She's gone straight to the lawyers.
- 38:10The business therapy move is to slow down and
- 38:12ask her, have you told your brother and sister
- 38:15what this place means to you? Often, the answer
- 38:20is no. Often, not always. There is a conversation
- 38:25to be had before there's a lawsuit to be filed.
- 38:30You are not a therapist and you are not a mediator
- 38:33for your own client's family dispute, but you
- 38:37can ask a question that nobody else had asked.
- 38:40And that question sometimes changes everything.
- 38:45So during the intake, what am I noticing when
- 38:47I'm in the room? I'm noticing that she came to
- 38:51me because she needed someone to fight alongside
- 38:54her. And filing a lawsuit felt like fighting,
- 38:59but what she actually needs is permission to
- 39:02grief. She hasn't gotten that yet, not from her
- 39:06siblings who want to sell and move on, not from
- 39:09the process, which is already moving toward legal
- 39:12postures. The single most useful thing I might
- 39:15do in the first meeting, isn't to explain the
- 39:18partition statute. It's to say, losing this house
- 39:22is a real loss, and I understand why you're not
- 39:25ready. Let's figure out together what you actually
- 39:28need here. Scenario number four, the HOA or insurance
- 39:34dispute. Your client owns a unit in a condominium
- 39:39complex. Anyone out there who's done insurance
- 39:43lately will relate to this. There has been water
- 39:48intrusion damage, ongoing, significant, affecting
- 39:51his ability to use the property. He's been going
- 39:54back and forth with the HOA for two years. Now
- 39:57he wants to sue. Layer one, potential negligence
- 40:01by the HOA, breach of the CCNRs, possibly bad
- 40:06faith, depending on how the HOA's insurers handled
- 40:08it. Layer two, your client is exhausted and furious.
- 40:13Two years of this, living it every day. He feels
- 40:17like he's being gaslit, told the problem is minor,
- 40:20when he can see with his own eyes that it isn't.
- 40:23Layer three. As you get into the timeline, you
- 40:27discover he has almost exclusively communicated
- 40:30by phone. There's almost no paper trail. Every
- 40:33time the HOA manager told him something reassuring,
- 40:37he accepted it and stopped pushing. Because he
- 40:40wanted to believe the problem was going to get
- 40:43resolved without a fight. people don't want to
- 40:47deal with problems. They hope time will solve
- 40:51it. The business therapy move here involves two
- 40:55things. First, you name the documentation problem
- 40:58directly and without blame. He was trying to
- 41:02resolve it cooperatively, which is completely
- 41:05understandable, but it is creative factual record
- 41:09problem you're going to have to work around.
- 41:13Second, You ask the pattern question, has he
- 41:17been in situations before where he accepted reassurances
- 41:21and waited and the problem continued to grow?
- 41:25Because the answer to that question tells you
- 41:28a lot about how to counsel him going forward
- 41:30and about what he's going to need from you in
- 41:34terms of active communication and regular updates
- 41:38so he doesn't feel like he's waiting again with
- 41:41no more information. Understanding the pattern
- 41:45isn't just therapeutic insight. It's case management
- 41:49intelligence. What am I noticing when I'm in
- 41:53that room with him during the intake? What I'm
- 41:57noticing is that two years of being ignored has
- 42:00made him simultaneously desperate for action
- 42:04and deeply skeptical that action will produce
- 42:08anything. He's not just frustrated with the HOA.
- 42:11He's frustrated with himself for waiting. And
- 42:16if I don't name that, it will show up sideways
- 42:19in his representation, in unrealistic expectations
- 42:22about how fast things will move, in frustration
- 42:26when I tell him we need more time to build the
- 42:28record, in calls on Friday afternoons asking
- 42:32if anything has happened. Managing this client
- 42:35well means understanding that his urgency isn't
- 42:39just about the water damage. It's about two years
- 42:43of feeling powerless. My job is to give him back
- 42:47a sense of agency starting in the first meeting.
- 42:55Let's move on to the next slide. The ethical
- 43:01dimension. I want to spend a few minutes on the
- 43:05ethical dimension because I think it's important
- 43:08and because it comes up every time I talk about
- 43:10this. California Rules of Professional Conduct
- 43:141 .4 requires us to keep clients reasonably informed
- 43:18about the status of a matter and to explain matters
- 43:21to the extent reasonably necessary for the client
- 43:25to make informed decisions. Business therapy,
- 43:29in the sense I've described it today, is simply
- 43:32doing that job well. You can't give someone the
- 43:35information they need to make an informed decision
- 43:38if they're not in a position to receive it. Addressing
- 43:43the emotional layer is a precondition for doing
- 43:47your actual job. Rule 1 .2 requires that we abide
- 43:54by the client's decisions concerning the objectives
- 43:57of the representation. Surfacing what the client
- 44:02actually wants, asking what does winning look
- 44:06like, is how you comply with the rule in substance,
- 44:10not just in form. The client who says, I want
- 44:14to go to trial, without knowing what they're
- 44:17actually seeking, hasn't really made a decision
- 44:20about their objectives yet. They've made a reflexive
- 44:25choice under stress. And rule 2 .1, allows us
- 44:30to refer to moral and ethical considerations
- 44:32as well as law when rendering a device. It explicitly
- 44:37contemplates that sometimes the most useful thing
- 44:40we can do is step back and help the client see
- 44:43the bigger picture. Why am I telling you all
- 44:47this? Because none of what we've been discussing
- 44:49today or what I've been talking about today crosses
- 44:53any professional line. What crosses a line is
- 44:56if you are making decisions for your client rather
- 44:59than helping them make their own. The role here
- 45:03is to ask better questions and listen more carefully,
- 45:07not to become the client's de facto therapist
- 45:10or to substitute your judgment for theirs. I
- 45:14also want to address what happens when you don't
- 45:16do this because I think the ethical risks of
- 45:20skipping layers two and three are underappreciated.
- 45:25When you skip the emotional layer, and go straight
- 45:28to legal analysis, you risk giving technically
- 45:32correct advice that the client can't act on.
- 45:36Why? Because they're too overwhelmed to process
- 45:39it. That creates a communication breakdown that
- 45:43can lead to misunderstandings about strategy,
- 45:47decisions the client later regrets, and in some
- 45:50cases grievances or malpractice exposure when
- 45:53the client says, I didn't understand what I was
- 45:57agreeing to. And we've all heard that. When you
- 46:01skip the blind spot entirely, you risk letting
- 46:05the client's unexamined pattern drive the representation.
- 46:10The client who needs to feel powerful may push
- 46:13for aggressive tactics that damage settlement
- 46:15prospects. The client who avoids confrontation
- 46:19may accept a result that doesn't serve their
- 46:22interests just to make the process stop. You've
- 46:26done the legal work correctly, but the outcome
- 46:29doesn't serve the client because you were solving
- 46:33the wrong problem. Addressing all three layers
- 46:36isn't just good practice. It's a protection for
- 46:40your client and for you. Done right, business
- 46:44therapy doesn't blur professional lines. It honors
- 46:47them. I want to come back to where I started.
- 46:56to the client, the lawyer, who said what she
- 47:01said that I couldn't stop thinking about. What
- 47:04I've come to believe is that what she identified,
- 47:09you practice business therapy, maybe without
- 47:12fully realizing it, is that the best legal representation
- 47:17has always done this. The lawyers who are remembered,
- 47:21who build practices over decades, who have clients
- 47:25that send their children and their business partners
- 47:28and their colleagues to you, those lawyers have
- 47:34always understood that a client is more than
- 47:36just their legal issues. The framework I've given
- 47:41you today just makes explicit what good lawyers
- 47:44have always done intuitively. Three layers, five
- 47:48tools. and the underlying principle that when
- 47:52you understand what's actually driving a client's
- 47:55situation, you can serve them better, not just
- 47:59legally, but fully. I want to close with something
- 48:04a colleague said to me that I think about alongside
- 48:09that post -it note. He said, the clients who
- 48:12remember you aren't the ones you won for. They're
- 48:16the ones you understood. Think about that for
- 48:19a second. I know that's right because I lived
- 48:26it actually very recently. I was at a gala a
- 48:30few months ago, kind of event where you run into
- 48:33people from different chapters of your career
- 48:35and your life. And someone came up to me who
- 48:38I hadn't seen in about 15 years, a former client.
- 48:42He had inherited a legal problem from his father
- 48:45who had passed away. the really hard matter,
- 48:49the kind that arrives already complicated and
- 48:51only gets more so. We went to trial, we fought
- 48:55hard, and we settled for less than what had originally
- 49:00been sought from him. For some reason, I always
- 49:05carried that one. I thought about it more than
- 49:08he probably knew, that feeling of wishing the
- 49:11outcome had been different, wishing I could have
- 49:13done more. He recognized me across the room and
- 49:17came straight over. And before I could say anything,
- 49:20he said, hold on, hold on. I want to go get my
- 49:22wife. And he went and found her and brought her
- 49:25back. And then he said, I've thought of you often
- 49:29over the years. I always wanted to thank you
- 49:33for being there alongside us during the toughest
- 49:36times of our lives. You understood us. Not you
- 49:40won for us, not you got us everything we asked.
- 49:45You understood us. And I'll be honest with you.
- 49:50I often feel the losses harder than my clients
- 49:52do. I replay them. I second guess them. I'm sure
- 49:56you do too. I carry them in a way that probably
- 49:59isn't entirely healthy. That night reminded me
- 50:03that clients are measuring something differently
- 50:06than we are. They're not keeping score the way
- 50:09we keep score. What they remember is whether
- 50:12someone was truly present for them when it mattered.
- 50:20So I want to close with something personal, and
- 50:23I'm sharing it not because I figured it out,
- 50:26but precisely because I haven't. Everything I've
- 50:31described today, the patience, the non -judgment,
- 50:35the willingness to sit with someone in a hard
- 50:37moment and not rush to fix it, We are almost
- 50:41universally better at extending that to our clients
- 50:44than we are at extending it to ourselves. We
- 50:48see clients blindspot with real clarity. We are
- 50:52considerably less clear -eyed about our own.
- 50:56I carry things. I've always carried things. A
- 51:00matter that didn't go the way I wanted will stay
- 51:02with me long after the client has moved on. I
- 51:05replay it. I overanalyze it. I go back through
- 51:08the decisions, the strategy, moments where I
- 51:12wonder if I could have done something differently.
- 51:15I would have never sit across from someone I
- 51:18say and say to them, let's go back through every
- 51:21decision you made and find the ones that were
- 51:23wrong. You don't do that. That's not how we help
- 51:26people. But somehow it's exactly what we do to
- 51:29ourselves. How many of you out there can relate
- 51:32to that? I'm sure many. When a client replays
- 51:36a loss, we tell them you did everything right.
- 51:40The outcome wasn't entirely in your control.
- 51:43What matters is how you showed up. When we replay
- 51:47a loss, we hold court on ourselves, prosecutor,
- 51:52defense, and judge all at once. And the verdict
- 51:55is rarely kind. What I'm working on, and I say
- 51:59working on because it's genuinely a practice,
- 52:02not something I've solved, is reminding myself
- 52:06that perfection is not the goal. It was never
- 52:09the goal. For our clients, we understand that
- 52:13intuitively. We know that outcomes depend on
- 52:16facts we didn't create, judges we didn't appoint,
- 52:20opposing counsel we didn't choose, and a thousand
- 52:22variables outside our control. We counsel our
- 52:26clients around the reality every day. And then
- 52:29we hold ourselves to a standard that ignores
- 52:31it entirely. We are our own harshest critics.
- 52:37I think most of you in this room know exactly
- 52:39what I mean. And I think most of you would agree
- 52:42that if a colleague came to you after a hard
- 52:44loss and described themselves the way you describe
- 52:47yourselves after yours, you'd stop them. You'd
- 52:50push back. You'd say, that's not a fair accounting.
- 52:55So here's what I'd ask you to consider. Just
- 52:58consider. The next time you're in that place,
- 53:02What would you say to a colleague you respected
- 53:04who was sitting where you are right now? And
- 53:07then try to say that to yourself instead. Business
- 53:12therapy is a practice of genuine attention to
- 53:15the person across from you, to what they're carrying,
- 53:19to what they can't see. I believe you deserve
- 53:24that same attention. I'm still learning how to
- 53:27give it to myself, but I think naming it is a
- 53:31start. In closing, we are hired for a legal problem.
- 53:39That is real. It deserves your full attention
- 53:42and your best thinking. But the client sitting
- 53:46across from you is more than their legal problem.
- 53:49They are a person in the middle of something
- 53:51hard, often something they contributed to, often
- 53:57carrying things they have not fully articulated
- 54:00even to themselves. The attorneys who build practices
- 54:04they're proud of, who have clients that come
- 54:07back, that send their families and colleagues,
- 54:11that stop you at a gala 15 years later to introduce
- 54:15you to their wife, those attorneys have learned
- 54:18to meet people where they actually are, not where
- 54:22the complaint says they are, not where the demand
- 54:25letter positions them, where they actually are.
- 54:30That's the whole thing. That's business therapy.
- 54:35Thank you for listening. And we can look hopefully
- 54:39at some questions in the chat. So one of the
- 54:52questions is, have you done mediation arbitrations
- 54:55where you shift roles and how? I think I know
- 55:01what that means. I guess shifting roles to a
- 55:06neutral would basically just be applying these
- 55:11tools to both sides instead of just one side.
- 55:15And actually, yes, and it does help with bridging
- 55:20the gap between the two sides, because as a neutral,
- 55:22what you're trying to do really is even more
- 55:27than as an advocate is to understand each sides
- 55:30true end goal. And using these tools to understand
- 55:37and to learn the end goal does definitely facilitate
- 55:41a resolution. Another question is, In our 21st
- 55:55century AI world, aren't more and more clients
- 55:58becoming more and more transactional? So isn't
- 56:02it your practice's goal really becoming more
- 56:04and more rare? All ask kindly, great job. Well,
- 56:08thank you for the compliment. I don't know. I
- 56:13don't know if I completely agree with that. I
- 56:15mean, in a way it's more transactional, but I
- 56:18think in a way people are missing the human element.
- 56:22even more so than before. People I think still
- 56:28need the connection and people still need to
- 56:31feel understood and understanding them. I mean,
- 56:36they're in your office because they have an issue
- 56:38and understanding them is definitely going to
- 56:41be something that you need to solve their problem.
- 56:51more expeditiously, more compassionately. So
- 56:57that would be my answer to that. I hope. All
- 57:03right, let's see what else. This one is, do you
- 57:12have any practices that actually help with being
- 57:15kinder to yourself? Or is it just something that
- 57:19you live with? Honestly, it's something I'm still
- 57:23working through more than something I've actually
- 57:25solved. I wish I had a tidy answer for you. What
- 57:29I can tell you is that one thing that's helped
- 57:32is to reframe what I mentioned earlier. When
- 57:36I catch myself replaying a loss, I try to ask
- 57:40what I'd ask a colleague that I respect. And
- 57:44that question alone Asked to myself changes the
- 57:48tone of my internal conversation. It's much harder
- 57:50to be cruel to someone else's effort than it
- 57:52is to be to your own. The other thing I try to
- 57:58remember is that outcomes are not the only measure,
- 58:00and I think that we as attorneys really don't.
- 58:07Don't allow for that. I think we need to be more
- 58:10cognizant of that. If I prepare thoroughly, devise
- 58:15honestly, and stay present with the client through
- 58:17something hard, that's the job. The result is
- 58:20only partly in my control. All right, there's
- 58:25one more here. Do you find that doing such a
- 58:29deep dive into the emotional drivers of client
- 58:32conduct opens you up to more pain than that is
- 58:36difficult to manage, meaning harder to compartmentalize
- 58:39and be objective? That's a really good question.
- 58:43I don't think so, because I think it also allows
- 58:48me to empathize. And I think I already am very
- 58:55a little bit maybe overly attached to the outcomes
- 58:59and to the client's needs than maybe is healthy.
- 59:03But I think doing it intentionally and deliberately
- 59:07actually helps with the representation. because
- 59:12it does actually achieve better outcomes. So
- 59:17I hope that answers that question. All right.
- 59:22It doesn't look like, oh, here's one more. You
- 59:25haven't talked about what you might want to say
- 59:27to opposing counsel or not say. I spent years
- 59:30working out mutual clients issues in that manner
- 59:33through my practice over 40 years, allowed for
- 59:35some honesty. You're right, actually. I haven't
- 59:40looked at it from the lens of opposing counsel
- 59:42at all, except for the one really important part,
- 59:46which is during settlement negotiations, almost
- 59:49every opposing counsel, or during settlement
- 59:53negotiations, it always comes up, right? How
- 59:55much client control do you have? Is the client
- 59:58actually going to follow legal advice? Not to
- 1:00:03put our conclusions onto the client. And having
- 1:00:08that connection with the client, having that
- 1:00:10trust from the client does allow you to represent
- 1:00:15to opposing counsel that you do have client control.
- 1:00:17Because how many times have you heard from opposing
- 1:00:19counsel that I will try, but my client won't
- 1:00:22listen to me. I don't have any client control.
- 1:00:25And then you're negotiating with opposing counsel,
- 1:00:28and they are basically not able to get anywhere
- 1:00:33with their own client. So just from our side.
- 1:00:37Obviously, engaging in this practice, and it's
- 1:00:42amazing that you have been for 40 years, will
- 1:00:46get you the trust of the client, will allow you
- 1:00:49to have more client control, and will allow you
- 1:00:52to be able to negotiate on behalf of your client
- 1:00:55with certainty, with more certainty than someone
- 1:00:58who doesn't have the client control. OK, so it
- 1:01:03looks like we're exactly at one 31, which is
- 1:01:06the hour really appreciate everyone's attendance.
- 1:01:10I hope. My response to council says, oh, it says
- 1:01:18somewhat last person a 40 year practice as my
- 1:01:21response to council who says he has no control
- 1:01:23is BS. You shouldn't be representing that client.
- 1:01:26Fair. That's fair. But how many of them do anyways?
- 1:01:32Anyways, thank you again and I hope to see you
- 1:01:35out there and I hope everyone has a great rest
- 1:01:40of the day. Thank you so much. This concludes
- 1:01:43today's presentation. Thank you so much, Talene,
- 1:01:45for an excellent presentation today and thank
- 1:01:47you so much to our audience. Have a great day,
- 1:01:49everybody.