Latest / First Trust ROI Podcast / Ep 68 | Bob Stein | How Will the War in Iran Impact the Economy and Elections? | ROI Podcast
Transcript
- 0:10Ryan: Well, there's a lot going on in the economy right now.
- 0:12Ryan: Everything from the war in the Middle East to concerns about inflation to, well, concerns about what the Fed is going to do.
- 0:20Ryan: Who's the next nominee?
- 0:22Ryan: Is it going to be Kevin Warsh or not?
- 0:24Ryan: All these questions and more, uh, I have the chance to discuss with Bob Stein, Deputy Chief Economist at First Trust on this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 0:34Ryan: So, Bob, um, we were talking before, and you asked me um what number episode of the ROI podcast this was for you.
- 0:43Ryan: And I I did a little research.
- 0:45Ryan: This is your eighth appearance on the podcast.
- 0:47Ryan: Really?
- 0:48Ryan: Really?
- 0:49Bob: Holy smokes.
- 0:50Bob: Is that the most for anybody?
- 0:52Ryan: Uh I mean, I should be the most, but it means the quality of the quality.
- 0:56Ryan: If we're waiting by quality, you're definitely near the top.
- 0:59Ryan: Um, I think Westbury has been on nine times.
- 1:02Ryan: Really?
- 1:03Bob: Really?
- 1:03Ryan: So you're you're right on his heels.
- 1:05Bob: Okay.
- 1:06Bob: Well, we need to do a few extra later this year so I can catch up.
- 1:09Ryan: Um, so of course, we're recording this right at the beginning of the NCAA tournament for men's basketball.
- 1:16Bob: March 19th.
- 1:17Ryan: And um, you know, you and I, I'm a longtime Syracuse fan.
- 1:21Ryan: You are a longtime Georgetown fan because you're an alum of Georgetown.
- 1:25Ryan: And uh, you know, both of us uh are in the same boat that we don't have anything to cheer for this year.
- 1:30Ryan: Uh maybe you've got another team that you're following, but I I just looked and both teams have losing records for this particular season.
- 1:38Ryan: What do you think about that?
- 1:39Bob: Um, it's horrible.
- 1:41Bob: Well, I mean, Syracuse is a school of traders for betraying the Big East and defecting to another conference, which shall go unnamed.
- 1:51Bob: Georgetown um has just been led by incompetent selectors of coaches.
- 1:59Bob: The ED's office is a travesty, horrible, awful, run, uh awfully run.
- 2:05Bob: Um, they had a chance to get Danny Hurley and instead chose Pat Ewing.
- 2:11Bob: They had a chance to get Rick Pettino, who was perhaps the best coach in college basketball.
- 2:16Ryan: Who was once an assistant of Jim Beheim?
- 2:17Ryan: Oh, many years in assistant.
- 2:20Bob: Oh, before he was the head coach of Providence back in the day.
- 2:22Bob: Interesting.
- 2:23Bob: Interesting.
- 2:23Bob: Yeah.
- 2:24Bob: Well, Beheim has a pretty good coaching tree then.
- 2:26Bob: Um, but yeah, they had a chance to get Rick Petino a few years ago and instead chose Ed Cooley and had to steal him from Providence in order to do so.
- 2:36Bob: Horrible choices.
- 2:37Bob: Their AD's office, the athletic director's office, is very mismanaged when it comes to the basketball program.
- 2:43Ryan: Well, Syracuse just cleared the decks, new uh actually all the way to the top, the new chancellor, new uh AD, and uh they're bringing in a new uh basketball coach as well.
- 2:54Ryan: Maybe by the time this airs, that decision will have been made.
- 2:57Bob: Well, the most well, the most important position of those three is obviously the basketball coach.
- 3:01Bob: And so hopefully they'll make the right choice then.
- 3:03Bob: Exactly.
- 3:04Ryan: All right.
- 3:04Ryan: So uh now that that's out of the way, I I do want to ask you some more uh, you know, your day job as as an economist, um, you know, as a uh in Moonlight as a basketball commentator.
- 3:16Ryan: But um the topic that's on everyone's mind right now is kind of this this, I don't know if it's a black swan, but it was a little bit unexpected that uh we would uh be in a uh kinetic hot war, um if you want to call it that, with Iran, at least when we're recording this episode, maybe, you know, I hope it'll be over by then, by the time it airs.
- 3:39Ryan: But um, I guess my question is um, what do you expect the longer-term impact to be on the US economy and even the global economy?
- 3:49Bob: Okay, so I don't think the long-term impact of the conflict itself is going to be that great, because I think sometime in the next uh two to three weeks, the conflict will resolve with some sort of military coup.
- 4:04Bob: It will not be a popular uprising.
- 4:07Bob: Uh I'm hoping for it.
- 4:09Bob: Um, but I I think the potential, the downside risk associated with that in terms of chaos and anarchy and um uh the disintegration of of Iran to some extent, um, the risks there are too great.
- 4:23Bob: And so I think you're going to see a military coup um from people perhaps the IRGC, uh the Revolutionary Guard Corps for Iran, um, where um eventually enough of the leadership who are ideologues are killed off to get to the lower rungs where you have the lower rungs of the upper portion or of their hierarchy, where you just have corrupt people um who would be interested in staying in power and lining their pockets with oil money, which Trump could effectively offer to them if they just secularized our government a little bit.
- 5:06Bob: And they don't necessarily have to ask for a democracy.
- 5:09Bob: I mean, that's not what happened in Venezuela.
- 5:11Bob: We just took out, we decapitated the government.
- 5:14Bob: We took out Maduro and and the first lady of Venezuela, his wife, and the rest of the government is still in place, but they're dealing with us a little more.
- 5:23Bob: Have you noticed the absence of drug boats getting shot out of the water uh in in the you know in in the Gulf ever since that happened?
- 5:33Bob: Like I there's uh I think there's a connection there.
- 5:36Bob: So as long as the Venezuelan government, as long as the Iran, Iran government doesn't pose uh um a threat to the US in any way, we're willing, we're willing to deal with them.
- 5:46Bob: They don't have to be friendly, they just have to not be a threat or try to export their view of the world.
- 5:52Bob: Um uh and so I think that will probably happen with Iran.
- 5:57Bob: We could offer them the ability to export uh oil, uh which they have a lot of, and and line the pockets of of a new ruling elite.
- 6:07Ryan: So one of the concerns, depending on how the conflict plays out, how long it lasts, is that some of the production infrastructure, some of the ability to pull oil out of the ground gets damaged, gets blown up.
- 6:20Ryan: Um I guess we don't really know how that's gonna play out, but what we do know is right now, oil prices have really surged.
- 6:27Ryan: You know, some of it's probably just a risk premium that's attached to that.
- 6:30Ryan: But I guess my question for you is if oil prices stay high as a result of kind of what's going on in the Middle East, um, the Strait of Hormuz, all the issues related to that, what does that mean for inflation and what does that mean for the economy?
- 6:44Bob: I'm not I'm not I'm not as worried about inflation um as many people are because inflation is ultimately a monetary phenomenon.
- 6:54Bob: So if people have to spend more on gas to fill their tanks, which they do when oil prices are up, then they have less money left over to spend on other goods and services.
- 7:04Bob: And so the overall inflation rate should not be um noticeably or dramatically affected by the short-term gyrations in the price of oil.
- 7:15Bob: In terms of the U.S.
- 7:17Bob: economy, I'm not really worried either.
- 7:19Bob: And the reason is because this is not the 1970s anymore.
- 7:23Bob: We are a net petroleum producer and exporter to the rest of the world.
- 7:29Bob: Um, and so because of that, you know, when oil prices go up, um there are people in the United States who make more money and who have more demand for their labor, more demand for their research.
- 7:42Bob: There are more wells that are going to be uh uh drilled.
- 7:46Bob: So I think in the end, higher oil prices um don't affect the U.S.
- 7:52Bob: economy the way they once did back in the 70s, 80s, and 90s.
- 7:57Bob: And so it will definitely hurt regions around the world.
- 8:01Bob: Um uh Japan's gonna get hurt, Europe's gonna get hurt um in terms of higher prices, but I'm not worried about dramatically higher prices globally, even dramatically higher than where they are today, which I think the NIMAX is like $100 a barrel, Brent's about 110 as of this morning, um, even dramatically higher from where they are today, um, significantly hurting the US economy.
- 8:25Bob: Other economies, yes.
- 8:26Bob: US not so much because of our petroleum position.
- 8:29Bob: Like imagine in the 1970s, and someone had said, well, oil prices are up.
- 8:34Bob: So do Saudi Arabia's economy is gonna get hammered.
- 8:36Bob: I mean, that would be ridiculous, right?
- 8:38Bob: Of course not.
- 8:39Bob: They're not gonna get hammered, okay?
- 8:41Bob: Um, uh, because they're obviously a huge exporter of oil to the rest of the world.
- 8:46Bob: Well, the U.S.
- 8:47Bob: has kind of been a neutral position.
- 8:49Bob: Back then we were an importer.
- 8:50Bob: Now we're neutral.
- 8:51Bob: And so we're roughly neutral in terms of um how the oil affects the economy.
- 8:57Bob: Now, here in on net.
- 8:59Bob: Now, here's the deal: the coasts of the U.S.
- 9:02Bob: are gonna get hurt by higher oil prices.
- 9:04Bob: Many of the people listening to this podcast are going to be hurt if you're in the financial services sector, are going to be hurt by higher oil prices.
- 9:13Bob: But there are other people in the interior of the United States who are gonna benefit.
- 9:17Bob: Many of them, again, are gonna make money hand over fist with higher oil prices, and they're gonna go out and spend their money and they're gonna demand goods and services as well.
- 9:25Ryan: So I think there's a question of um correlation and causation when people look back at maybe the uh wake of the invasion of Ukraine from Russia and the the sort of follow-on of high oil prices that did correlate with inflation.
- 9:41Ryan: What was the difference back then?
- 9:44Bob: Well, back then, I mean, remember the invasion of Ukraine happened in 2022.
- 9:49Bob: And 2020 and 21, we had a 40% increase in the M2 measure of the money supply and the loosest monetary policy going back to the early 1980s.
- 10:00Bob: So it should be no surprise that we eventually had 9% inflation, but that had nothing to do with the invasion and um very little, if at all, to do with um any secondary effects on the oil market.
- 10:14Bob: It really had to do with an overly loose Federal Reserve.
- 10:19Ryan: Um okay, so I'm glad you mentioned the Fed.
- 10:22Ryan: Um, first off, hats off for uh predicting Kevin Warsh is the Fed nominee.
- 10:26Ryan: I I on this very podcast, you predicted that when the prediction markets had a very, very low probability.
- 10:33Bob: They were at 12% at the time.
- 10:35Bob: Like there were there had been there was what I call the Kevin Hassett bubble.
- 10:40Bob: They should have been focusing on the other Kevin instead.
- 10:43Ryan: So given all that's happening, concerns about inflation, whether you think it's gonna happen or not, um, because you know, uh always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.
- 10:53Ryan: Um it is related to the the Fed and what the Fed's doing.
- 10:56Ryan: Um and so the question is um, you know, we've got Kevin Walsh.
- 11:00Ryan: Will he be uh will he be confirmed in the Senate?
- 11:04Ryan: Uh, but also is he as hawkish as people fear because he's you know kind of got a hawkish reputation.
- 11:13Bob: Uh he will be confirmed later this year.
- 11:15Bob: Um I think he'll be confirmed early enough so that he's uh in place by the June meeting.
- 11:22Bob: I think the Trump administration will back off of these uh lawsuits and uh investigations related to Jerome Powell, and Powell will will um leave as uh both chairman by mid-year as chairman and as a member of the Board of Governors.
- 11:43Bob: So um I think Walsh will be in there by the June meeting.
- 11:47Bob: In terms of his statements, a lot of people are really worried that he's gonna be a hawkish chairman.
- 11:54Bob: Um, I actually worked uh indirectly with Kevin Walsh back in the early days of I guess I think it was uh Bush the Younger's first term in office.
- 12:06Bob: Kevin Walsh was a staffer at the National Economic Council.
- 12:09Bob: I was uh an official at the Treasury Department, and so we overlapped to some extent on some policy matters.
- 12:16Bob: Um Kevin Walsh's statements about, and by the way, I think he's uh very well qualified to be uh AFED chairman, and I think he will do at least as good of a job as anybody else that that President Trump was considering.
- 12:32Bob: Um I I think that all of his statements since way back when have been designed to maximize Kevin Warsh's chance of eventually being appointed the chairman of the Fed.
- 12:46Bob: And so he made a lot of hawkish statements to curry approval and potential future favors from who he thought would be sitting in the Oval Office one day, probably uh a Republican president who looked favorably on hawkish monetary policy.
- 13:02Bob: But he's been able to tailor his views over the past few years to suit somebody in the Oval Office who's not as hawkish and a Republican.
- 13:11Bob: So um, everything he said in the past should be looked through that prism or lens of trying to maximize his chances of being a future Fed chairman.
- 13:18Bob: Now that he's Fed chairman or about to be Fed chairman, he doesn't necessarily have to hew to those views that he previously set out.
- 13:25Bob: I think he will be roughly in line with what other chairmen and chairwomen would do in the same situations.
- 13:34Ryan: So as we're sitting here recording this episode, um, there has been, I'll call it leakage in the number of cuts that the Fed is um or the markets pricing in for the Fed.
- 13:46Ryan: Uh I think coming into this year, uh the the expectation was two cuts of uh you know, total of 50 basis points.
- 13:53Ryan: Today, I think the the chance of two cuts is uh viewed by many as off the table, um, maybe even no cuts.
- 14:01Ryan: Um so what's your what's your take?
- 14:02Ryan: Is that um because people are worried about Kevin Warsh?
- 14:05Ryan: Is it because they're worried about inflation?
- 14:07Ryan: What's going on there?
- 14:08Bob: No, I think they're worried about Iran, and I think the Fed's view um is that if oil prices go way up, they should do nothing.
- 14:16Bob: And so I think people are projecting a little too much into the future.
- 14:20Bob: I I'm actually um I I I hesitate to say optimist on the situation in Iran.
- 14:28Bob: Uh, I'm not optimistic in the sense that I think there'll be a popular revolt and like a Western-style democracy put in place.
- 14:35Bob: I I'm not optimistic about that.
- 14:37Bob: But I am optimistic on the conflict winding down over the next few weeks.
- 14:44Bob: Um, I could be wrong about this.
- 14:46Bob: Uh, you know, I've been wrong about things before.
- 14:48Bob: Sometimes I'm right.
- 14:49Bob: I'm not an oracle, okay?
- 14:52Bob: Um, but I think it'll wind down, and we'll we will be back to where we were pre-Iran in the financial markets at that point in time.
- 15:00Ryan: So you think that the market will then begin pricing in cuts again once that winds down?
- 15:05Ryan: Okay.
- 15:05Bob: Exactly.
- 15:06Bob: And I think Warsh will likely have room for a June cut.
- 15:11Ryan: So let's let's say the uh the war extends and that weakens the economy, doesn't that mean that the Fed is gonna need to cut rates?
- 15:18Bob: Well, why is it gonna weaken the economy?
- 15:20Ryan: I'm I'm just I'm giving you what the uh conventional wisdom is, not necessarily what uh I think.
- 15:26Bob: Yeah, if it weakens the economy because uh prices have gone up and inflation's a little higher, then I don't think that gives the room, Fed uh room Fed room to cut.
- 15:37Bob: I I think the Fed's approach to a situation like what's going on in Iran and much higher energy prices um is uh kind of kind of a deer in the headlights view.
- 15:50Bob: They're gonna pause and do nothing.
- 15:52Bob: They're not gonna hike, they're not gonna cut.
- 15:55Bob: They're just gonna let it play out.
- 15:57Bob: Um, and they see it as a as something that's passing through and not something to overly react to because two months, three months later, that event might be off the like completely gone and no longer affecting the economy at all.
- 16:12Ryan: Okay, I want to talk about tariffs because that's a topic that we've discussed before.
- 16:16Ryan: Um, you uh, you know, talking about the the Bob Stein, the Oracle, you did predict that the Supreme Court was gonna overturn uh the AIPA tariffs, the ones that were uh put on by the Trump administration.
- 16:29Ryan: Um that's just a portion of the tariffs.
- 16:31Ryan: Um, but you did also say that you didn't think that the uh that the administration was gonna issue refunds of those tariffs.
- 16:38Ryan: Uh where were you right?
- 16:39Ryan: Where were you wrong?
- 16:40Bob: So I was right on the court over or striking down those Trump tariffs.
- 16:45Bob: Okay.
- 16:45Bob: Uh not all of them, but many of them.
- 16:48Bob: Um, I also thought that the court would not order refunds.
- 16:54Bob: They actually didn't order refunds, but they deferred or sent the issue back to a lower court and allowed the lower court to do so.
- 17:02Bob: So I got that part wrong.
- 17:05Bob: Um, although some people thought the Supreme Court itself would order uh those refunds, and that didn't happen either.
- 17:13Bob: Um So I think it's gonna play out over the next two years.
- 17:17Bob: I don't think the all the refunds are coming next week or next month.
- 17:21Bob: I think it's uh I think the Trump administration is gonna find ways to drag its feet on the issuance of the refunds, and it's gonna play out over, say, the next two years rather than uh uh rather than overly quickly over the next couple of months.
- 17:37Ryan: Would that uh I mean, essentially that's an infusion of cash back into the economy, right?
- 17:42Ryan: I mean, why why wouldn't the Trump administration want to return that?
- 17:46Bob: Well, I I also think they want to make the deficit look a little smaller going into the midterms and say we're making progress on that.
- 17:52Bob: Um the other thing is is it's not direct to consumers.
- 17:57Bob: It's it's it's a windfall gain for companies.
- 18:00Bob: And uh for a windfall gain, they it doesn't change their incentive to invest or or expand.
- 18:07Bob: And so um uh most of the money would not be immediately channeled into economic activity.
- 18:15Bob: It's not like mana from heaven.
- 18:18Ryan: What's the longer-term uh outlook for tariffs?
- 18:22Ryan: Is the Trump administration now gonna throw their hands up and say, yeah, we were wrong.
- 18:25Ryan: We should probably just abandon our tariff hopes.
- 18:28Bob: No, what was interesting is that the very day the Supreme Court struck down many of the Trump tariffs, um, he reimposed different tariffs under different legislative authority that's now being challenged in courts, courts.
- 18:40Bob: And I I think this is going to be a feature, the higher tariffs, it's gonna be a feature not only of the Trump administration from now until the end, but um probably for the next generation.
- 18:53Bob: Tariffs are gonna play a bigger economic role and a bigger budgetary role with the federal government than it did in the previous several decades.
- 19:02Bob: Um, let's imagine that a different Republican becomes president in 2029, wins the 2028 election.
- 19:09Bob: They're not going to casually abandon this new policy course set out by another Republican president once they take office.
- 19:17Bob: Let's imagine it's a Democrat instead.
- 19:20Bob: Um Democrat wins in 2028.
- 19:22Bob: It's possible the Republicans will retain control of the U.S.
- 19:25Bob: Senate, in which case the Democrats can't pass any of their preferred tax hikes.
- 19:30Bob: They can't raise income taxes, they can't raise taxes on corporate profits, they can't raise taxes on inheritances.
- 19:37Bob: And so where are they going to get the revenue they need to expand the programs that they want to expand?
- 19:43Bob: I think the political compromise will be to leave many, maybe not all, but many of these tariffs in place.
- 19:49Bob: Um and uh to spend more money as well.
- 19:54Bob: Um, otherwise, you there there's a gaping hole here, you're a bullet hole in the deficit, as Bill Clinton used to say.
- 20:00Bob: Um, but but even a let's imagine that the Democrats sweep in 2028.
- 20:07Bob: That's not my base case, but it's possible at this point.
- 20:09Bob: We're two almost you know, two and a half years away from that election.
- 20:13Bob: Even if they sweep, how would you like to be the Democratic president who uh reduces cuts taxes on China, and then six or nine months later they invade Taiwan?
- 20:25Bob: You look absolutely ridiculous.
- 20:27Bob: Remember, Joe Biden in 2020 ran in part saying he was gonna cut tariffs, including on China, and then he never cut tariffs on China.
- 20:37Bob: Why?
- 20:37Bob: Well, I think his political advisors told him you'll look ridiculous.
- 20:40Bob: You can't control what China does next.
- 20:42Bob: You'd look absolutely ridiculous if you cut tariffs on China and then they invade Taiwan or do something else geopolitically that's very harmful to the U.S.
- 20:51Bob: and our interests.
- 20:52Bob: And so they ended up not cutting tariffs on China.
- 20:55Bob: And I think um even if, again, even if they sweep and have the power to raise other taxes instead, they're gonna keep the many of these Trump-era tariffs, whatever he leaves off with when his term ends, um, because it would make us look ridiculous to to uh cut tariffs on China.
- 21:15Ryan: So will tariffs ultimately be included in legislation as opposed to just sort of uh for the executive branch saying that the tariffs are gonna be in place?
- 21:25Bob: Not under President Trump, because the the Democrats who are gonna take not it's not gonna happen this year.
- 21:31Bob: Um there's no consensus for that.
- 21:34Bob: And um the Democrats are never gonna pass that control, uh or or the Democrats are not gonna enact that over the next couple of years under President Trump.
- 21:43Bob: It would look like they're capitulating to his agenda and and are have changed their mind and decided he was right.
- 21:50Bob: So it's not gonna happen.
- 21:52Bob: Could happen under a future president.
- 21:54Bob: Um I do think presidents, however, like some of the discretion that Trump.
- 21:59Bob: Is exercised with various countries.
- 22:02Bob: Maybe he's exercised it too capriciously.
- 22:05Bob: But there are times in the future where legislators can see a president wanting to negotiate with a different country and to impose a certain level of tariffs and then change his mind based on what that other country does, based on their trade practices, for example.
- 22:23Bob: So I think it the odds of legislation go up the neck uh the when when Trump leaves office, uh, but not under his presidency will that happen.
- 22:37Ryan: Yeah, he really does seem to uh use it as a tool for uh negotiating whatever whatever area of his administration, whether it's you know geopolitics or war or you know, all these other things.
- 22:49Bob: Whatever side of the bed he wakes up on.
- 22:51Ryan: Yeah.
- 22:51Ryan: Uh a little difficult, difficult to predict sometimes.
- 22:54Ryan: Um I want to uh ask you about your views on something else that people have been talking about, and that is artificial intelligence, um, especially with respect to you know concerns that it's going to displace a lot of the labor that we need.
- 23:09Ryan: You know, basically there's gonna be mass unemployment with that, there's gonna be universal basic income.
- 23:14Ryan: Um, what's your take on AI?
- 23:17Ryan: Is this gonna result in a lot of unemployment?
- 23:19Ryan: And then what about the UBI question?
- 23:21Bob: Yeah, I'm not worried about high unemployment resulting from AI.
- 23:25Bob: I think there are a lot of AI people who think that because they can see right in front of them the jobs that are going to be displaced or substituted for by AI.
- 23:36Bob: So I understand whether why they have these fears.
- 23:39Bob: Um in the first internet revolution of the 1990s, before that, actually, um, if you wanted airplane techs or airline techs and you needed them quickly, you would often go to an office to get them and they'd be printed out.
- 23:56Bob: People don't do that anymore.
- 23:58Bob: There were there are tons of jobs that have been substituted for.
- 24:01Bob: And yet in the 1990s, the labor market was fantastic.
- 24:04Bob: And here's why people overestimated the amount of substitution for labor that would happen, and they underestimated the complement to labor provided by computerization and the internet.
- 24:18Bob: So a worker at a desk with a computer hooked to the internet is more productive than a worker with a typewriter, right?
- 24:26Bob: It's a pretty straightforward comparison.
- 24:28Bob: Clearly, obviously so.
- 24:29Bob: Well, if your worker is more productive, are you gonna hire more of them or fewer?
- 24:36Bob: You're gonna have a more productive worker is a more profitable worker.
- 24:40Bob: If workers are more profitable to employ, you hire more of them to make more money.
- 24:45Bob: And so I think there are um there's a complementarity to labor that is being overlooked, and that there are gonna be many things that that, many more things that can be done um with AI, and that's going to create jobs we can't even think of right now.
- 25:02Bob: So the AI people who are worried about jobs, they they see what's right in front of their face.
- 25:06Bob: I get that.
- 25:08Bob: Um, but they're not looking at what can't be seen yet because uh the demand hasn't been created yet, and the demand will be created by the ability to supply it.
- 25:17Bob: I'll give you an example, it's a personal example.
- 25:20Bob: Um my son is involved, my son who has minimal computer background, computer science background.
- 25:28Bob: I don't even think he took computer science as a class in high school or college at all.
- 25:33Bob: Okay, he's a senior in college.
- 25:35Bob: Um, he's using Claude to write code so he could develop a fine a financial app and he's getting some backing and he's making some progress with it.
- 25:45Bob: He never could have done it, he had the idea, but he never could have brought it to fruition or brought it off the ground at all, were it not for AI.
- 25:55Bob: Okay, so so think about Mark Zuckerberg.
- 25:58Bob: Why did he become so wealthy?
- 25:59Bob: Well, um, there was an idea for replacing what used to be the hard copy Facebook, okay, like that you get when you were a freshman in college, everybody's picture and name.
- 26:10Ryan: Like a yearbook before you know at the beginning of the year, so you could tell who was who.
- 26:14Ryan: And exactly.
- 26:16Bob: Yeah.
- 26:16Bob: So um uh he had the the the technological and computer background in order to do that.
- 26:25Bob: Okay.
- 26:25Bob: So that's why he could be Mark Zuckerberg.
- 26:28Bob: So he was able to do that because of his computer background.
- 26:31Bob: Well, now there are a lot of people out there without a computer background who could do the same thing.
- 26:36Bob: They're basically they could just contract out to to to AI that part of the workload.
- 26:45Bob: And you can see more ideas coming to fruition from more people without a computer science background in the techno uh technology field.
- 26:53Ryan: Okay, so the other part of my question was universal basic income.
- 26:57Ryan: Maybe, maybe um, we don't get to a point if what you're saying is, you know, plays out that way, but it's certainly a topic that I've heard more discussed in the last couple of years than maybe ever.
- 27:08Ryan: And that's, you know, it's it's something that's been bouncing around for the last few decades.
- 27:11Ryan: But um what's your take there?
- 27:14Bob: Yeah, my personal view is it's a horrible idea.
- 27:18Bob: Just horrible.
- 27:20Ryan: And and let me back up because the idea of universal basic income is massive unemployment.
- 27:25Ryan: People aren't gonna have jobs, so you got to make sure that they're able to put food on the table.
- 27:29Ryan: So you cut a check to everybody, and you know, maybe they get a a thousand or two thousand dollars a month or something like that.
- 27:36Bob: Yeah.
- 27:36Bob: So as as I said before, I don't think we have to worry about mass unemployment because of AI.
- 27:41Bob: Right.
- 27:41Bob: Um, I think it's gonna be more of a complement to labor than people currently understand.
- 27:46Bob: Um I do not believe there's going to be a need for UBI, for a UBI, universal basic income.
- 27:54Bob: Um, even if there were, I think it's a horrible idea.
- 27:57Bob: And the reason is because, you know, you look around the country and you have people out there who don't seem to have anything better to do with their time than then protest, then harass law enforcement when they're doing their jobs, whether you like the job they're doing or not.
- 28:15Bob: It's what it's what our democratic process results in.
- 28:19Bob: Um and uh protesting on campus and harassing other students and professors and things like that.
- 28:26Bob: Um, those very same people who have nothing better to do with their time but protest and harass would get a universal basic income from everybody who is working.
- 28:36Bob: And I just think that's horrible.
- 28:38Bob: I I think we should be finding ways to make those um uh, you know, those lifetime protesters and harassers their their lives more difficult, not easier.
- 28:51Bob: And we shouldn't attract more people to that lifestyle.
- 28:55Ryan: All right.
- 28:55Ryan: So it's all political, right?
- 28:57Ryan: I mean, all these protests are uh political.
- 29:00Ryan: So I want to transition to politics because that's uh, you know, it's we're in a midterm year.
- 29:07Ryan: Uh it seems like we're always in an election season here.
- 29:10Ryan: Um, but we're in a midterm year, and we're starting to look down the road to November, and we're hearing more and more sort of predictions of what's likely to happen.
- 29:21Ryan: Um I would say that the MAGA base has become a bit fragmented and fractured uh for a number of reasons.
- 29:29Ryan: Um, so what are the implications going forward?
- 29:33Ryan: Um what what's your take on the fragmentation of the MAGA base, first off, but also what is the flow through for some of the elections that'll happen this year?
- 29:43Bob: Okay, so um I think the the fractures within the Republican Party are there, they're real, they're going to probably grow over time.
- 29:55Bob: Um uh and they're similar to some of the fractures occurring in the Democratic side as well.
- 30:02Bob: So it's really hard to see how sh things shake out over the next 20 years, okay, with those fractures and whether they're different factions within each party that join together or separate and things like that.
- 30:14Bob: It it'll be fascinating, especially from a political science perspective.
- 30:18Bob: But I'm gonna try to focus on what's going on later this year with the midterm cycle, because I don't think I think it's an overrated factor.
- 30:27Bob: It's an online thing that people are focused on.
- 30:31Bob: But in the real world, if you actually look at election results, and we just got some election results around the country, and it seems to be that uh the relatively more moderate people are winning, both on the Democratic and uh uh to some extent on the Republican side as well.
- 30:46Bob: Um, all this chatter you see online is being exaggerated, um, at least for now.
- 30:52Bob: Um so, in terms of the midterms, uh, I'll lead with the bottom line in the House.
- 30:58Bob: I think the Democrats have about an 85% chance of taking it and taking it back.
- 31:02Bob: I've been saying that for the last few months.
- 31:05Bob: Um, unfortunately for me, that's what the prediction markets are saying.
- 31:08Bob: So I'm not really saying anything interesting here, but I got there first.
- 31:12Bob: Okay.
- 31:12Bob: So I want to mark my territory that way.
- 31:16Bob: So, but I think it's right now the prediction markets are right.
- 31:18Bob: Uh, oftentimes I'm different from the prediction markets.
- 31:20Bob: Right now, I think the prediction markets are right about the House.
- 31:23Bob: 85% Democratic odds.
- 31:25Bob: Historically speaking, the out party, the party not occupying the White House, does very well in midterm election cycles.
- 31:33Bob: Um, there have been 20 midterm cycles since the end of World War II.
- 31:37Bob: And in 18 of those 20, 90% of the time, the out party gains enough seats so that if it were applied to this time around, Democrats only have to gain three on net, uh, that the Democrats would take over the House.
- 31:51Bob: Uh, exceptions are 1998 and 2002, um, just two in a row.
- 31:57Bob: But every before and since, they've the out party has gained a lot of seats.
- 32:01Bob: Now think about what's happened over the past couple of years.
- 32:03Bob: In 2024, uh Vice President Harris lost the national popular vote by one and a half percentage points.
- 32:11Bob: But while she was losing the national popular vote by one and a half, she was winning in Virginia and New Jersey by six percentage points each.
- 32:19Bob: And so you would think, you know, she did seven and a half percentage points better on those two states than in the country as a whole.
- 32:25Bob: So, in a neutral national environment, you would assume that the Democrats would win in New Jersey and Virginia by seven and a half percentage points.
- 32:33Bob: Well, we just had gubernatorial elections in those states last year, 2025.
- 32:37Bob: And the Democrats won them, but they didn't win them by seven and a half.
- 32:41Bob: They won them by 14 percentage points each.
- 32:44Bob: So that's a dramatic change over the past year in the terrain, the political terrain that we're working with.
- 32:50Bob: Um, another thing is that the polls have changed.
- 32:54Bob: Back in 2024, the national popular vote for the House, the Republicans won by 2.7 percentage points, 2.7.
- 33:03Bob: They're now down by about five.
- 33:06Bob: And so that's a turnaround of what, you know, roughly seven and a half to eight percentage points.
- 33:12Bob: That translates, in my opinion, to a loss of about 22 or 23 seats for the Republicans.
- 33:19Bob: Now that would take them from where they left off in 2024 was 220.
- 33:24Bob: If they lose 22, they'd be down to 198.
- 33:27Bob: They'll gain a few back from redistricting around the country.
- 33:30Bob: And yes, California's doing it.
- 33:32Bob: Uh, Virginia might do it.
- 33:34Bob: Depends on the outcome of a referendum as well as a potential court ruling later this year.
- 33:39Bob: Um, but uh, I think in the end, on net, the Republicans will gain slightly.
- 33:44Bob: So that puts them at, you know, around 200, roughly.
- 33:49Bob: That's 18 short of where they need to be.
- 33:52Bob: Democrats are clearly the favorite favorites in the House.
- 33:55Bob: In the Senate, however, um it it's uh yeah, I I think the majority for the Republican is on Republicans is on sturdier ground.
- 34:06Bob: Right now they have 53 seats.
- 34:08Bob: Democrats have to gain four.
- 34:10Bob: Four to pick up a majority.
- 34:13Bob: Because if they only gain three and it's fifty-fifty in the Senate, JD Vance, Trump's vice president, will break ties to the Republicans' advantage, right?
- 34:20Bob: So um he hasn't had to do that so far, but he might be called upon if it's 50-50.
- 34:26Bob: So um uh right now it's 53.
- 34:30Bob: I think the Republicans dropped to 51 or 52.
- 34:33Bob: They do have to defend a lot more seats than the Democrats do.
- 34:37Bob: They have to defend 22 seats, the lion's share of seats, almost two-thirds of them, um, of the seats that have to be defended later this year.
- 34:45Bob: But 20 of those 22 are in red Republican states.
- 34:49Bob: It's gonna be, you know, historically speaking, there are wave elections, but usually in wave elections, there are a lot of um vulnerable senators in purple states, and they get taken down of the wave.
- 35:01Bob: It's not the red or the blue that move so much.
- 35:03Bob: So um of the of the 22 seats the Republicans have to defend, 20 of them are in red states.
- 35:10Bob: And I think their Democrats gain maybe one, maybe, could be zero, out of those 20.
- 35:17Bob: Where they're gonna aim most of their fire are on the uh uh uh um is on the states of uh Maine and North Carolina.
- 35:24Bob: In North Carolina, Democrats are likely to win uh because Tom Tellis, the incumbent Republican senator, decided not to run for re-election.
- 35:33Bob: And Roy Cooper, the former Democratic two-term governor of the state, is running for that seat.
- 35:40Bob: So Roy Cooper is probably gonna win that seat.
- 35:42Bob: In Maine, um, even though the prediction markets disagree with me, I would take Susan Collins to win that seat.
- 35:49Bob: And here's why she has a proven track record of winning Maine, even in bad years for the Democratic Party.
- 35:56Bob: I'm sorry, bad years for the Republican Party nationwide.
- 35:58Bob: Back in 2008, Barack Obama is wiping the floor with John McCain by seven and a half percentage points.
- 36:05Bob: Susan Collins wins easily in the state of Maine.
- 36:07Bob: The last cycle, 2020, six years ago now.
- 36:10Bob: Doesn't seem like six years, but but it was.
- 36:13Bob: So um last cycle, she uh she was down in the polls at every single poll in the month of October and early November.
- 36:25Bob: Every single, even her own polls showed her down.
- 36:28Bob: And she ended up winning easily.
- 36:30Bob: And that was the year when Joe Biden was beating Trump by four and a half percentage points in the national popular vote.
- 36:37Bob: Um, and so if she wins in those two environments, I still think she's gonna pull a rabbit out of her hat and win the race this year as well.
- 36:46Ryan: Yeah, it seems like Susan Collins is viewed as a bit of an independent more than a Republican.
- 36:52Ryan: She certainly has uh, you know, she's she's one of those carve-outs that uh sometimes says things that are against what Donald Trump says.
- 37:00Bob: Yeah, I I I I sometimes get a chuckle out of these Republicans who always bash Susan Collins.
- 37:06Bob: And here's why.
- 37:07Bob: She is the most conservative senator that they can get out of the state of Maine.
- 37:11Bob: People have to be judged by the state that they're representing.
- 37:15Bob: And so you're not gonna get it, like I could see comp complaints from conservative Republicans about Lisa Murkowski, because Alaska is a state where you actually might be able to get somebody more conservative.
- 37:27Bob: Uh, maybe not uh every cycle, but I could, I could, I could see that argument.
- 37:32Bob: In the state of Maine, it's either gonna be Susan Collins or a Democrat.
- 37:37Bob: They wouldn't want that situation.
- 37:39Bob: So people on the left do the same thing.
- 37:42Bob: They're like, why can't, you know, why can't uh uh uh somebody from Pennsylvania be as left-wing as as somebody from New York?
- 37:52Bob: Well, look at the state they're representing.
- 37:54Bob: You have to judge based on the state.
- 37:56Ryan: Is that go what's going on with John Fetterman?
- 37:59Ryan: Because he has pivoted uh big time in terms of his messaging, and you know, he's been embraced by some of the the podcasters on the right, even.
- 38:08Ryan: Um, is he just um is he making a political calculation?
- 38:12Bob: I I think there's less calculation there with him, and he's he he has some true beliefs.
- 38:19Bob: He doesn't care if he loses his seat.
- 38:21Bob: I think he will have a very tough time winning a Democratic primary again.
- 38:26Bob: However, if he were to switch the Republicans, I think he'd have a tough time there as well.
- 38:33Bob: So um maybe his only road is independent.
- 38:37Bob: Um, I think he probably ends up being a one-term senator.
- 38:41Bob: Um, and I think he just he's just he at a certain point, he just decided to say whatever he wants.
- 38:47Bob: He's gonna buck his, he's gonna support his party when he when he they're doing things he believes and oppose his party when they do things he does not believe.
- 38:55Bob: And he he he really is like he's an independent voice.
- 38:59Bob: That doesn't mean uh uh uh he takes every position that's popular, uh, but he I think he really sticks to his own personal beliefs when formulating his views.
- 39:10Ryan: Yeah, he's definitely stuck to his uh wardrobe choices the whole way through.
- 39:14Ryan: That's been a consistent thing.
- 39:15Ryan: Like he's always got the sweatshirt hoodie on.
- 39:18Bob: Yes.
- 39:18Bob: You know, the interesting thing about him is I think uh what we're probably gonna see is something like happen to, I think it was Kirsten Cinema from Arizona.
- 39:26Bob: She turned into she started out in the far left and turned into a gadfly taking both right and left positions, and she was not able to get her to keep her Senate seat, and I think that will probably happen to Federman as well.
- 39:39Ryan: Okay, so you say 85% chance that the Democrats take the House.
- 39:44Bob: Uh but Republicans, it uh I would put I would put 70% that they keep the Senate.
- 39:52Bob: Maybe even I'm I am more confident about the Republicans clearly than the prediction markets are.
- 39:57Bob: Uh the the and I'm not always that way.
- 40:00Bob: But um uh uh if you look at um uh the prediction markets, I think they have a 50-50 Senate, is the most likely outcome.
- 40:11Bob: So I'm saying 51 or 52 Republican seats.
- 40:15Ryan: Is it too early to ask you about the the presidential nominees for 2020?
- 40:19Bob: It's never too early, right?
- 40:20Ryan: Okay, so where do you think that breaks down?
- 40:23Ryan: Uh let me let me let me give you my guess what you're gonna say.
- 40:26Ryan: On the Republican side, you're gonna say uh JD Vance.
- 40:29Ryan: I think that's I don't know what the prediction markets are saying, but that's a pretty strong um assumption, right?
- 40:34Ryan: Is that is that true?
- 40:35Bob: Yeah, so the prediction markets give JD Vance a roughly 40% chance.
- 40:40Bob: I would definitely take the over on JD Vance.
- 40:43Bob: And I'm I'm using the language of wagering on purpose.
- 40:47Bob: Like uh, so uh I think he has more like a 65% chance of being the nominee.
- 40:53Bob: People are um thinking that maybe Marco Rubio is gonna run for president instead.
- 40:58Bob: I don't think Marco Rubio runs because I think he realizes that if he runs against his good friend J.D.
- 41:05Bob: Vance from out of the Trump administration, there's a good chance he would lose the nomination fight.
- 41:11Bob: And he also realizes that if J.D.
- 41:14Bob: Vance is the nominee, um, if he doesn't run, he has a good chance of being his vice presidential candidate.
- 41:21Bob: And so you can you can take a year away from the campaign trail and actually spend time with your your family, your loved ones, um, and doing things in the government rather than campaigning, and end up as vice president or the vice presidential nominee.
- 41:38Bob: And then if that ticket loses, he'd be he'd have a path to the 2032 nomination instead.
- 41:44Bob: Um, so I I think he'll go that route.
- 41:46Bob: Rubio won't run, and JD Vance is going to be the nominee um running with Rubio as his running mate.
- 41:52Ryan: Um, on the Democratic side, before you get to Democrats, I've heard you say this before, and I I just wanted to double-click into the height question because it's it's one of these fascinating dynamics.
- 42:03Ryan: You pick running mates that are shorter than you are.
- 42:06Ryan: Is that part of your thinking as well?
- 42:08Bob: So here's the deal.
- 42:08Bob: I and I say this, you know, kind of as a joke, but I mean it seriously.
- 42:12Bob: Like, so who would Vance pick as his running mate?
- 42:15Bob: Well, he's gonna pick Rubio, okay?
- 42:17Bob: Because number one, they're friends.
- 42:19Bob: Number two, which is part of the reason Rubio is at the State Department already, you know, Vance is fashioning for him with Trump.
- 42:26Bob: Um uh number two, he would entrench Hispanic support for the Republican Party.
- 42:31Bob: Number three, he's an articulate spokesman for conservatives in both domestic and international affairs, but he also has that one quality that J.D.
- 42:39Bob: Vance is gonna search for, which is somebody shorter than he is.
- 42:42Bob: Okay.
- 42:42Bob: So um Rubio fits the bill.
- 42:45Bob: No one wants to like hold up the hand of a guy at the convention um who's towering over him.
- 42:53Bob: At least no man's gonna do that.
- 42:54Bob: Like you want, you want to pick somebody shorter.
- 42:56Bob: So so I think he picks Rubio.
- 42:58Bob: Rubio fits the bill.
- 42:59Bob: Some people talk about Glenn Youncin from Virginia.
- 43:02Bob: The problem, the guy's 6'5.
- 43:04Bob: Okay, Tom Cotton from Arkansas, 6'5.
- 43:06Bob: Okay, you're not gonna pick somebody who's taller than you, you'll pick somebody shorter.
- 43:10Bob: Democratic side, they do something similar, um, uh, but it's with intelligence.
- 43:16Bob: Okay.
- 43:17Bob: Uh Barack Obama looked around in 2008 for a running maid.
- 43:20Bob: He told his advisors he wanted somebody dumber than he is.
- 43:23Bob: And he came out with Biden.
- 43:25Bob: And Biden told his advisor, well, in 2020, or yeah, 2020, I want somebody dumber than me.
- 43:30Bob: They got Harris.
- 43:31Bob: And then Harris said, I need somebody dumber than me.
- 43:34Bob: And out Palp Tim Wals.
- 43:36Bob: Okay.
- 43:36Bob: So works the same way on the Democratic side, but with a different quality.
- 43:40Bob: I love it.
- 43:40Ryan: Um, that's uh all right.
- 43:42Ryan: So maybe I'm going way too far down this rabbit hole.
- 43:45Ryan: So let's say you end up with JD Vance, Marco Rubio on the ticket.
- 43:50Bob: Um, and eventually that gets to by by the way, I don't want to make it seem like I was saying Barack Obama was dumb.
- 43:57Bob: He was very bright, actually.
- 43:59Bob: Very bright.
- 43:59Bob: Exceptionally bright uh as presidents go.
- 44:01Bob: One of our one of our brighter presidents.
- 44:04Ryan: Um okay, on the Democrat side, um, where do you see the nomination kind of hashing out for next cycle?
- 44:11Bob: There is no front runner on the Democratic side.
- 44:14Bob: The prediction markets give Gavin Newsom maybe a 25% chance.
- 44:19Bob: They previously had him as high as 35%.
- 44:22Bob: I think he uh all along I've thought 20% at most for Gavin Newsom.
- 44:28Bob: Now, maybe 20% still makes you the front runner because it's still more than anybody else, but you know, there's an 80% chance you're not gonna get that nomination.
- 44:37Bob: So um I think he's gonna have a big fat target on his back during the campaign as well as during the debates, which will probably start uh, you know, late summer, early fall of next year.
- 44:52Bob: Like we're a year and a half away from those presidential debates.
- 44:55Bob: Exactly, exactly.
- 44:58Bob: You and every other American, Ryan.
- 45:00Bob: So I think uh uh I'll have a big fat target on his back.
- 45:04Bob: I I I don't think Harris runs because I I think the donors are not gonna pony up money for her.
- 45:10Bob: Remember, she was well financed in 2020 in that presidential race for their in the Democratic primary, okay?
- 45:19Bob: And um, she was out before the Iowa caucus.
- 45:22Bob: Like she didn't even make it there.
- 45:24Bob: I so I think the donors are not gonna pony up for her again.
- 45:28Bob: They blew a lot of money on her in 2024 as well, billion dollars.
- 45:32Bob: She was well financed and didn't lost a popular vote to Trump and the Electoral College by more.
- 45:38Bob: So I don't think that happens.
- 45:40Bob: AOC, people are talking about her trip to Germany, everything like that.
- 45:44Bob: I think in the end she decides to run for Senate from New York instead.
- 45:48Bob: But if I'm wrong and she does run, she has a better chance of getting their nomination than most people understand.
- 45:54Bob: And the reason is because she might end up being the only hard-left Bernie Sanders acolyte in that particular cycle.
- 46:01Bob: And if she is, she gets into every state with about 35% of the vote already hers.
- 46:06Bob: Um, now 35% isn't 50% plus, but every other candidate has to scramble over their slice of the remaining 65%.
- 46:14Bob: She's got 35% from the get-go.
- 46:17Bob: So she can soften her image.
- 46:19Bob: She has a fighting chance to get that nomination.
- 46:21Bob: I'm not saying if she ran, she automatically gets a nomination.
- 46:24Bob: Not even close, but she'd have a fighting chance.
- 46:26Bob: The two dark horses, uh, one, JB Pritzker.
- 46:31Bob: He's a billionaire.
- 46:32Bob: He checks the box and everything the hard left wants, but people don't know him well enough around the rest of the country.
- 46:40Bob: And so because he's a white guy, um, he can portray himself as not being as hard left as he actually is.
- 46:48Bob: Um, and so he can try to be many things to different constituencies on the Democratic side.
- 46:54Bob: And that's usually a successful strategy to getting a nomination.
- 46:58Bob: Um, in uh the other dark horse would be Stephen A.
- 47:01Bob: Smith.
- 47:01Bob: Yes, I mean the guy from ESPN.
- 47:03Bob: He is not he is not beholden to a series of positions that he's had to take in the past because he was running for a nomination or any office.
- 47:15Bob: Um he's never held public office.
- 47:17Bob: And so, to a some extent, he kind of resembles Trump in 2016, in that Trump got up there and all the other Republicans said that they're gonna 100% defund Planned Parenthood.
- 47:28Bob: They're going to uh reform Social Security and Medicare.
- 47:32Bob: They supported the Iraq war under Bush, too.
- 47:36Bob: And I'm not arguing for or against that war, but the other candidates supported it.
- 47:40Bob: He did.
- 47:40Bob: He took the opposite of all those positions, and he ended up being the more popular one.
- 47:45Bob: So I think in the end, um Stephen A.
- 47:48Bob: Smith, not beholden to having previously taken uh some wacky positions on the Democratic side, just like there were wacky positions on the Republican side that office holders thought they had to take for their side, he's not beholden to that.
- 48:02Bob: He doesn't speak like a politician.
- 48:04Bob: He's not trying to sound profound every time he speaks.
- 48:07Bob: He speaks like a normal person.
- 48:09Bob: All he does is talk.
- 48:10Bob: He talks for a living.
- 48:11Bob: So I think in the end, he would be a breath of fresh air to many Democratic voters in the same way that Trump was for Republican voters in 2016.
- 48:19Ryan: Does he actually want to be the nominee?
- 48:22Bob: Great question.
- 48:23Bob: I if you held a gun to my head, I would say he probably ends up not running.
- 48:30Bob: I think he's kind of publicly negotiating for more money from ESPN and wherever he goes to next.
- 48:36Bob: Okay.
- 48:36Bob: But if he runs, he would be that breath of fresh air on the Democratic side.
- 48:41Ryan: All right, Bob.
- 48:41Ryan: Well, uh, once again, uh spectacular insights and content.
- 48:46Ryan: That's why we've had you on.
- 48:48Ryan: Uh, this being your eighth time, I I think uh, you know, we can sign in the line for a ninth appearance at some point here, too.
- 48:54Bob: I'm looking forward to number nine, Ryan.
- 48:55Ryan: My final question for you.
- 48:57Ryan: Uh I've asked you the other seven times as well.
- 49:00Ryan: And that is uh, what are you reading these days?
- 49:02Ryan: What's uh on the Bob Stein reading list?
- 49:05Bob: I'm about to finish a fantastic book.
- 49:07Bob: Um I think uh I might get the author's name pronounced incorrectly, but I think it's like Frank or Francis Decotter.
- 49:15Bob: He's written extensively about China in the past, the Great Leap Great Leap Forward, Cultural Revolution, things like that.
- 49:21Bob: This is called Red Dawn over China, which has to do with 50 to 60 years leading up to Mao's communist takeover in 1949, and the decisions that were made along the way, both on the communist side, in Moscow, um, in Japan, and in the United States, that paved the way for Mao's takeover of China.
- 49:48Bob: It's really interesting.
- 49:49Bob: The portrayal is like a popular revolution that sweeps the country, but it was more like the Mongols from 700 years before sweeping into uh you know Western Asia or Southwest Asia and just taking over and destroying everything in their path.
- 50:09Bob: It was that would be a more similar analogy, but but unlike like the Mongols, uh, if people gave up, they would rule that area.
- 50:18Bob: Um, and they didn't really care what the people, how the people ruled themselves.
- 50:22Bob: You know, like they would they would put a a chief Mongol person there and like, oh, if you want to be Christian, you could be Christian.
- 50:29Bob: If you want them to be Jewish, if you want them to be Muslim, whatever.
- 50:31Bob: They didn't care.
- 50:32Bob: Um, where the communists cared.
- 50:35Bob: So they would just go through and destroy everything.
- 50:38Bob: And if you didn't want to be part of what they did, they would just kill you and and take everything you have.
- 50:45Bob: So it was more like a Mongol invasion of the capital than anything, than a popular revolution.
- 50:51Ryan: Okay, so Red Dawn over China.
- 50:54Ryan: I'll have to check that out.
- 50:55Ryan: Um, I I remember uh back in, I think it was the 80s, there was that movie Red Dawn.
- 50:59Ryan: Remember a movie Red Dawn about the invasion from the Russians in the U.S.
- 51:04Bob: Yes, this is a little different.
- 51:05Bob: Yeah.
- 51:07Ryan: I'll still uh check it out.
- 51:08Ryan: Um thanks for the book recommendation.
- 51:10Ryan: Thanks for joining us on the podcast once again.
- 51:13Ryan: And thanks to all of you for joining us as well on this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 51:18Ryan: We'll see you next time.