Latest / Braver New Worlds / Trust as the Currency of Change: Storytelling, Persuasion & Narrative Leadership
Transcript
- Nathan: All right, welcome back to another episode of Brave New World's podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young and I am your host we're gonna do another solo episode today. got a bunch of speakers lined up in the queue, but just didn't come together for this week. So solo episode it is. And also like before I get into it, I just want to do a quick plug for a recently started speaker series here in San Diego called Big Idea Night. And very much along the theme of this podcast too, where I'm getting together leaders and different people from the community here in San Diego that I know that have an important idea to share about how our world can be better and how we can move ourselves forward towards that better world. like I'm inviting them into an opportunity to share this idea that they have on a stage and a bar with. group of people there in attendance, and we can like be there in person, like write with each other and talk about it. of I'm doing this is to create a real life community and also create a space for us to like talk these things with each other and not just, you know, listen to other people talk about these things on podcasts, right? So if you're in San Diego, I'd love for to it out. The event series is called Big Idea Night. Just go to You'll find it. or you can find Big Idea Night on Instagram. and I'll be posting about it on my own personal feed too. And all right, let's get into the topic of this podcast. And I think what I wanna do this time, so I'm gonna build upon where I started last talking about storytelling as a mechanism for sharing ideas and like why storytelling is so important for doing that. And today I want to take a step further to talk about the intersection of storytelling and persuasion and how those two of communication work together. Because last time I talked about why storytelling is important and it really comes down to just two main factors for what storytelling does for us as humans. it comes down to trust and predictability. ⁓ helps us understand who or what to trust, what sort of ideas to trust, what sort of ideas to believe in. It also gives us some notion of like, what's going to happen next in our world? How do we understand the our world is oriented, the way our world is operating and be to have a sense of like, what's going to happen next or what sort of actions we could take to lead to a certain set of outcomes And this is very important because it goes back to our survival as a species. I talked about this last time also, we ⁓ these cognitive abilities to start to see the world in a lot more complexity than our earlier evolutionary ancestors had. ability to the world differently and to develop some cognition enabled us to be very, very to change where we could go into new habitats and new situations ⁓ and figure out how to make our work there. And a lot of that came down to telling a story which is essentially a theory or process or scenario for what we thought might be a way to adapt to a new environment and survive there. And so that storytelling became this very important cognitive tools, evolutionary advantage that our earliest ancestors had. that still comes into the way we operate today. And this is why storytelling is like so valuable and important as a communication tool. and this is all sort of theoretical, none of us were alive back then, but the theory would be that a lot of times the people that would emerge as leaders of these different tribes or social groups or communities that they were a part of back in these ancient, ancient times, they're often the best storytellers because they could propose the best ideas and propose those ideas in the most persuasive ways. And that method of storytelling and proposing ideas and presenting those ideas as persuasive scenarios is still a very, very valuable tool for leadership today. that's what I'm gonna be getting in here too. So when I talk about storytelling leadership and persuasion, there's a framework I always like to come back to. and this framework goes back to ancient Greece. Aristotle is the one that gets credit for it. But who knows if, you know, it's actually him that invented it or him that just actually like put it down on paper. But it gets this idea of rhetoric, which is presenting a argument. And he talked about there's three elements of rhetoric. And those elements are ethos, pathos, logos. And some of you might be familiar with this, but I'm gonna talk a little bit about what that means, ethos pathos logos. Ethos comes down to the person that is speaking, the person that is presenting the idea. And this is about either like the credibility of that person or the stature of that person or the respect that that person commands in their community. this could also be seen as a relationship you have with this person is a persuader. second one is pathos. pathos is more the emotional argument behind the idea. So this is putting together a plea that's gonna tug at the emotional heartstrings or get somebody excited about what could possibly happen as a result of this idea that you're trying to persuade them on. or inspire fear, get people afraid of what's gonna happen. ⁓ that's part of how you make your emotional pitch for the idea that you're presenting. And the third is logos. Logos is a logical pitch. or data-based argument for the idea that you have. That's what Logos is. And so one of the things that comes up is if you think about this, ethos, pathos, logos, which of those three would you assume would be the most persuasive? Like how would you think that those three pieces would balance on each other? Would it be about equal or would like one of them be stronger than the other? Would one of them be like way stronger than the other or would it be just like a little bit stronger? I'll give you a second to think about that here. as if like, you the stature and credibility of the communicator is the most important thing, the emotional argument is the most important thing, or if the logical argument is the most important thing. And for those of you that said like the stature. credibility, trust, relationship of the speaker being the most important thing, ding, ding, you got it right. a lot of arguments about how important the stature or credibility of the speaker is, but you know, some people will say that the stature of the speaker is as much as like 90 to 95 % of the argument. Maybe you might say a little bit less, like 70 or 80, But for some people, that still seems like a very, very outsized portion of persuasion coming from that alone, just like who the speaker is and the credibility of the speaker. A lot of people think that the more emotional argument would be more powerful, that you might be more prone to listen to the emotional argument. But I want to propose a hypothetical for you here just to think about this. Say you get an email tomorrow and that email is from in Nigeria and they're like, hey, I got something for you that's gonna change your life. I a Nigerian prince and if send me $500, I'm gonna be able to get back to you with like a million dollars. And just think of like how your life will change with that million dollars if I'm able to send that to you. Like, wouldn't that be amazing? Wouldn't you be excited to have that million dollars? And you might even sit there and think like, man, a million dollars. Like I wouldn't have to go to work anymore. I'd be Scott free for the rest of my life. Or maybe like, yeah, maybe mostly Scott for you, maybe you just buy a house. Maybe that's all you get with a million dollars. Who knows? That's still a lot though. That's a lot of money. I mean, that's a pretty persuasive emotional argument, right? But do you believe it? Do you buy it? Are you persuaded? No, because the credibility of this person sending you this argument isn't, they're not credible. You kind of know we already know it's a scam, right? Now the flip side, suppose your best friend comes here tomorrow and they're like, hey, I need $5,000. I can't tell you why, I just need $5,000. What are you gonna do? You gonna give it to him? You might have some reservations, but you're probably gonna consider giving your friend that five grand more than you considered giving that Nigerian prince $500, your friend, he didn't present any of persuasive argument in this. He's just like, I just need $5,000. Imagine as a friend that you've known forever and you believe that he's totally trustworthy and you believe that he's good for the money. You'd give it to him, right? you might be like, I could do like two grand today. But you'd be more likely to give him the money than you would to that Nigerian prince. And that goes back to, you trust this person, you know this person, you believe this person. They have more credibility in eyes than this Nigerian prince out there. And it gets back to this idea that persuasion requires trust. I think a lot of times when I talk about persuasion, people seem to believe that you can go in there and you can just wow them with some idea, get them so excited about the possibilities that you're sharing that they'll just be blown away and you can somehow impress somebody. And that can go for, you know, even just presenting an ad on the internet or, this could be any sort of communication that you're gonna send out there trying to get some kind of reaction from your constituencies, whether that's, you know, want them to participate, you want them to follow you on social media, you want them to donate to your cause, you want them to your product. You can present this very, very persuasive argument there in that moment, but unless you have, unless you're coming to that moment with some credibility, you're not going to be able to really make that persuasive argument at all. And so really like a lot of persuasion comes down to way before you're even in the same room with the person you're trying to persuade. It goes way, back further than that. And the more trust you have though, then the more ability to persuade that you were able to create. So let's back up then, let's talk about this idea of trust. We talked about trust a lot last time, but we'll talk about it a little bit more deeply here today too. Because we need to think about, what is it gonna take for if you're trying to persuade somebody a cause or an idea or a notion, they're gonna have to have trust in two things be persuaded by you. One, they're gonna have to have trust in you, and two, they're gonna have to have trust in your solution. And by you, mean, you know, either that could be you as a person or it could be you as representative of an organization or it could be you as, you know, your own business that you run So you can think about you as like either like a very specific you or it can be a more of a collective or a group or a brand even. Cause that's a lot of how brands work. Brands sort of create trust. depending on what's going on in your world right now or what you're working towards, the solution could be, if they donate money to your cause, you're able to create some sort of change. The solution could be a product that you offer them that'll. that will implement some important solution for them or their work life or their home life. The solution could be you, could be a service you offer, or it could be a way that, you know, if an organization hires you, what would you be able to do as a solution in their organization? And so we're go through each of those in turn. Like what does it take for somebody to trust you? And what does it take for somebody to trust your solution? And I will say my work, this is the kind of thing that I do with lot of organizations I work with is trying to, how to figure out how to generate this trust in the way that you're communicating what you do. And this could take on a lot of different forms. On some level, it's very easy to complicate this. Think you have to do a lot more than you need to do. And it really doesn't have to be that complicated, but you just have to be cognizant of it. You have to be thinking about like, what does create trust? What helps somebody understand who I am and in what I'm putting out there. And so there's just like basic stuff of being reliable, being good with your word. There's another one of like being seen and being recognized and so showing some social proof. We tend to trust the people that we see or the organizations or the brands that we see the most often because the fact that they're out there so consistently makes us believe, okay, well, there's something going on with this person or this brand. Like they're doing something right. got some credibility to be so out there everywhere. So you start to develop some trust based on that. And this is essentially like what brands like Coke do. They just flood everything with Coke, Coke, Coke, Coke, Coke. And so you're like, ⁓ yeah, Coke, Coke, Coke, good, right? You trust Coke. And Coke's also like, you know, they're good with their word, right? Their product is a very consistent product. You know what you're to get. It's going to taste that certain Coke-y way, right? Another important way of creating trust is just with your general aura around you, like how you are presenting yourself. Are you presenting yourself? Are you cleaned up? Do you look nice? you look appropriate for the situation you're in? Are you able to ⁓ talk coolly and collectively? Are you able to present your ideas in a very cogent and understandable way? This is all gonna lead towards some more trust than somebody might have in you otherwise, as opposed to if very flustered with your words, if you're kind of like shaking and nervous or fidgety. That's going to take away some trust. going be like, what's going on with this person? And then there's just like an obvious truth here in our world today. aren't the rules that I made, but yeah, we do tend to trust good looking people more than not as good looking people. We tend to trust taller people. We tend to trust men with deep voices. We tend to trust people that look healthier. I'm not saying any of this is fair. it is part of the game too. It is part of what happens in the world. hopefully you're able to think about how you can institute these in your life or where you're communicating on some level and think about like who in your life do you trust and what is it about them that helps you to trust them? Think about that on both an interpersonal level, like who are some people in your life that you trust, also on a consumer to business level, like what businesses do you trust? What organizations do you trust? What brands do you trust? Who are you likely to give money to? who you're likely to contribute time to. What is it about what they offer that makes you feel more comfortable doing that? And so there's some other elements of generating trust too that are really important. And again, these aren't like necessarily the rules that I wanna see in the world or how I'd like the world to be operating, but this is very much part of how it is, is we do tend to trust people that look like us or come from similar communities or backgrounds to us. And so that can be like similar religions, similar nationalities, coming from the same community, maybe growing up in the same area, similar life stories, having gone to the same college or. prep school or whatever you went to, a sort base level understanding of who the other person is. and it helps you feel like you can trust them. If you like sports, might be inclined to trust somebody else who likes sports more than others. If you like to read Dostoevsky, you're probably gonna trust somebody else that likes to Dostoevsky more than you might trust someone that likes to read. The Twilight series. No shade on the Twilight, I'm just trying to make an example here. And so there's another piece of all this too, which is also having similar values. We trust people that we know that have similar values to us. so this all kind of gets back to storytelling. Part of how you ⁓ people understand who you are and whether or not they can trust you, whether or not they can believe in you is by the story you yourself. And again, on some level, like, sure, it is a story about your life of like, ⁓ maybe you grew up on a farm in Iowa and you moved to ⁓ the big city and you got job in a big corporate office and ⁓ then you realized that job wasn't you. And so you You suddenly leave that corporate job and develop a new role for yourself. And that's like what the current thing is that you're doing now. And that's great. That's an important story to share because it would help anybody else that's from a similar background as you. maybe they grew up in a similar circumstances and they thought they had it made when they hit the corporate world, but then they realized it was kind of an empty shell of a life for them and they needed something different too. ⁓ And now they're like, okay, I can to this person. They have just shared with me their story about. what they understood and like what they experienced. And so they probably understand my problems. And so maybe I can trust this person. Maybe what this person has to share will be of value to me. But on another level too, another piece of that also, it really does come down to your values. Like what you think is important, what you believe is important in this world, how you believe that you as a human should operate and how you believe that other humans should operate. It's essentially the expectations that you create for yourself for the kind of person that you want to be. And so if you have this similar background story to share, then you're also able to like exhibit some similar set of values to the person you're trying to communicate with. That's a much stronger basis for trust than you would have, than you'd have otherwise. And by values, could mean anything. I mean, maybe you value creativity. Maybe you value of expression. Maybe you value the environment. Maybe you value bringing community together. And so one of the things whenever I'm working with somebody new that really wants to like, oh, they want to tell their story. They want to be able to project themselves as a leader and understand how they communicate who they are to a wider world. one of the exercises I always have clients go through is to actually figure out like, what are your values and really figure out is important to you and make a list of five to eight things that are like really represent your values. And all of us have much broader values than that, but learning to really understand what your values are, have them written down and be thinking about them and communicating from those values on a regular basis and recognize that the actions you take tie back to those values and the way you project yourself tie back to those values, making sure your integrity with that. you can even be quite explicit about it. Just an example, I'm doing this work here, this podcast, the speaker series I'm doing because I believe community is important. think community is gonna be what's going to bring our world forward into a better era for all of us and this sort of detachment that we have for community is what keeps us all lonely and makes us much more vulnerable to disinformation. And so I always try to create community in anything that I do. Another one of my values is I believe that we can all be living very differently than we are right now, but we're sort of stuck in a story and a narrative that makes us feel like we have to keep living a certain way, even though to be the case. And unless we think about that shift en masse, we're gonna be stuck in the same sort of cycle that we've been in for decades, not centuries. And so this is my values. And lot of times you'll hear me on this podcast or when I introduce or when I do the introduction for the events I host, I reference these ideas. I think these are important. These represent what I think is valuable in the world and like what the set of values I'm operating from and all the work that I'm doing. And I communicate that out when I'm sharing what I'm doing. And so when people can connect the work I'm doing with the values that are behind that work, they have a better sense of who I am. And that sets the stage for a lot more trust and connection and ultimately persuasion with ideas from there. And so part of what this means for you is like, you've got to get clear on your values. Like I said, make that list of what those values are. But also like know the story behind how you got that value. What made you think that that was important? I can say for myself, I've lived my life in many different ways. I've had the other sort of nine to five corporate job. I've lived a very entrepreneurial life. I've spent periods of time not working. I've been lucky enough to be able to do a little bit of traveling or take some time off. or engaged in creative work. And I know that like, just felt so much more fulfilled when I was able to. slow down, engage in some real creative and community-based work, and I felt like I was contributing more to the world, to society, to my circle of friends, doing that than I was able to do in working more corporate jobs. It's not like I come from a lot of money, got some, but not a ton. to live my life that different way, it came at a cost. And I've had to manage that. And that's the decision I made. I feel much more happy and fulfilled for it, but you know, it was difficult. But it's part of the story that I like to share about myself and my own background and upbringing and the things I've experienced as an adult that led me to the place I'm at right now. So that's what I'm getting at. Know your values and know where your values came from. did you come to get those values? And if anybody's interested, me a message or something. I'll share some exercises I offer for understanding what those values are for yourself. And there's another component of this too that I won't be able get into here right now, but like part of this also is like really like learn how to know yourself and believe in yourself and trust in yourself because I think maybe a lot of us, we sort of think we have certain values, but we actually don't trust or believe in ourselves strongly enough to be able to like fully affirm like, no, no, these are my values. I get this, I understand. might be in a place where we might be inclined to say like, well, I think these are my values. I don't know. What do you think? Do you like my values? Are you? Are you willing to work with me based on these values or should I change my values to like make it so we can work together better? And you can do that, that is a strategy. But I don't think a lot of us are this conscious that we're doing that. And that's more what I'm getting at. We're just so used to being whoever felt we feel like we need to be to be able to fit in in a situation. often consider an alternative way of being. That's a whole other topic too. If you're intrigued by this, me know and maybe I'll do a future episode about that also. So that all gets back to the trust in you as a person or as representative of an organization or as the marketing or presentation of an organization. So now we get to that other piece of trust which is important towards persuasion and it's trust in your solution. And this is where I see a lot of people get lost. And again, this is both individuals trying to represent themselves or this can be organization trying to talk about the service they offer or. product they have or the or the work they do for the community. because we're so close to it sometimes We know all the features of the product or we know all the different ways ⁓ that our service works. We know the mechanisms of doing the job. And we can point to case studies of previous successes. have eight years, 10 years, 12 years, 14 years experience doing this kind of work. And all that has value. There's nothing wrong with that to share making a persuasive argument. But a lot of that, ⁓ that's logos. So like. It's like, know, ethos, it got you at the table. It got you in the room with this person that you're trying to persuade or this group of people you're trying to persuade. And then you go in there, you share logos. You just show the logistics of what you do or how you operate or what you have to offer. You're not making an emotional argument. You aren't offering the pathos. And this is where a lot of people I work with where they really need help is like really getting into that emotional argument and figuring out what that is. And the truth of it is it's actually quite simple, but it requires you to step outside of yourself and try to think from the point of view of the person you're trying to persuade. What are they worried about? What are they thinking about? What keeps them up at 4 a.m.? What solution can you offer to that challenge that they have? What's something you could take off their hands that would represent the biggest relief to them? When I say relief, yeah, I say that very specifically, like relief, like, you're able to take this work off their hands, like, ⁓ my God, thank you, thank you so much, ⁓ my gosh. I feel like a weight is lifted. That's the emotional argument. the features of the way things or the ABCs of the service you offer, you more want to talk about the outcome you can create. and how that outcome is going to feel communication. Are they gonna feel gratified that they were able to donate money to a cause you're working on and help a certain community lift itself out of some problems that's going through right now and set a path for a more vibrant and sustainable life. and they would all give the person that gave the money a lot of pride and gratitude to be able to do that. is the outcome you're gonna create is you're gonna take a lot of stress off this person. You're gonna take a lot of work off their plate, handle it all for them. They're not gonna have to worry about a single thing. You've got it from here. They don't need to worry about it anymore. They don't need to think about it anymore. They can go put their energy into something else. Is that the outcome you could create? is the outcome you're going to create is you're to make this person a of money. You're going to ramp up sales, you're going get the marketing out there, you're going to make sure that everybody knows about this product and so many people buy it, that this person's gonna hire you or work with you. they're gonna finally have that money to afford to buy that like new dishwasher to replace the one that broke last year or catch up on bills or hire the next person to help their business grow, just not be as stressed about money, not be as stressed about the state of their business anymore because they brought you on board to fix a problem for them. That's what you want to share. You want to share that outcome you can create. And like maybe part of the sharing that is getting to the logistics of what it is you're going to do to create that outcome. But you still need to talk about the outcome. and I'll reference this more specifically the kind of work I do now too, is when I work with entrepreneurs or leaders, and especially I've been helping leaders a lot lately with job interview coaching, interviewing for more CEO and vice president level positions. These are very smart, accomplished people. They can do the job. and the reference to years of experience. They'll reference some of the relationships they have. The reference that they've done some of the similar things before, they'll reference like the ideas they have, but they'll never reference the outcome. The outcome they're going to create is they're going to move the organization into 21st century or the outcome they're going to create is They're gonna make this organization be a highly regarded. nonprofit or philanthropy in the city. They're gonna turn this product into the first thing anybody thinks about when they need a certain solution. they're gonna take over this job and people doing the hiring are never gonna have to think about who's gonna be the vice president for the next three, four, five years. thinking about what the concerns would be of the person that's on the other side of the table, the person that's interviewing you or it's looking at your product or looking at your service, think about what those concerns are and being able to address those concerns and offer a solution towards that is one of the most important things you can do towards generating trust in your solution. And usually it's going to come down to like, you're helping them save time, helping them save or create money. helping to alleviate stress, helping to make them feel like they're doing a good job in the world by hiring you. or just helping them to like make their business or their organization run more smoothly. Whatever it is, you want to be speaking to that outcome. Because if you're set at the table, the ethos already got you that table. They have that least enough trust in you to spend minutes to an hour listening to you. Now you gotta address the pathos, which is the trust in your solution. And what is the emotional payoff that's gonna be the other end of that for them? This is part of the story you tell. When I talked earlier about how, you know, some of the leaders in ancient society, they were able to propose a solution, set of scenarios for how they might tackle a new environment or a new ecosystem that they're moving into, how they might survive in a new part of the world that nobody of their species had ever been to before. This is part of what you're doing too. You're trying to be that leader that says like, I have an idea, I have a scenario, I have a story to share about how I can move us forward into. bigger better world for all of us. And so part of the reason why I do this work too, and now we're sharing some of my values with you here too, is because, you know, I think like a lot of us, we see the world that we're living in now and we realize it's not working. We're actually like kind of in a scary situation. like wealth inequality is off the charts, AI is showing up, it's taking away lot of the jobs that were some of the more like intellectual or managerial class, we're like losing those jobs now, and we're not really sure what we're gonna do and what the world's gonna be. you know, new wars are starting, nobody's doing anything about climate change. Like, it's a little bit scary if you sort of think in the bigger terms of things. And a big part of my belief is the ideas are here. We've got them. People listening to this podcast have the ideas and we have the thoughts and we actually like kind of know what we can do. We just need to sort of do it on a larger societal level. ⁓ And of doing that is going to mean that those of us that believe in these ideas, that see the in these ideas and want to move our society towards something more equal, sustainable, and thriving, like we need to speak up. We need to have our voices be heard. And we need to say what our values are. And we need to propose our solutions. We need to do this out loud. ultimate hope is that through the tools and ideas that I'm able to share here, whether that's in like the work I do with consulting and coaching, whether that's in the podcast that you're listening to right now, whether it's in the Big Idea Night events that I'm hosting now, my hope is that I can start to filter this. filter these set of ways of being persuasive and communicating what matters to us and being confident in our own ideas and communication. I hope that I could like just filter that out into society amongst the good leaders out there that wanna see our world go to someplace better. And doing this, we'll there. We'll find our way there. Because yeah, it's not like there's not gonna be any one big hero. It's gonna be all of us that are gonna be the hero. and it's gonna take a critical mass of heroes. So it can't just be like five or 10 of us or even a thousand or whatever. It's gonna have to be like large groups of people that are willing to think differently about the world we're living in now and start to propose the shifts and even like take action on the shifts and even like, know, endure some sacrifices towards those shifts that they're gonna have to take. I made some sacrifices to live this lifestyle I live where I'm working for myself and have lot of over how I spend my day and able to engage in a lot more creative work than I would otherwise. I know the sacrifices I would make, they're not for everybody, and I definitely underestimated how big those sacrifices would be, but at same time, no regrets. I'm in. And you know, this, this idea of persuasion, it's such a rich topic and there's so much more to explore here that I'm not going to get all the way into it today, but I just want to put these ideas out there. These kernels, these these seeds of thought out into the ether here on, on YouTube or wherever you're listening to this podcast. And hopefully, you know, get you thinking that. Like, okay, what, how can I be thinking more persuasively in the way I present myself? How can I be? sharing who I am and sharing my values and sharing what's important to me and sharing where those values came from and sharing the outcomes I want to create and sharing the outcomes I can create. and helping people believe that we can work together towards A bigger cause and a braver new world. And I think, you know, I'll just kind of sign it off right there. the way back to the title of the podcast. And that always just seems like a great place to end it when that happens. So yeah, with that, I'll leave it here, but yeah, if anything that I talked about here. really stood out, is interesting to you, you want to hear more. and want me to go a couple steps deeper, I'm happy to do it. Either, you know, leave a comment here, send me a message. And if you want to talk about this one-on-one, how I can help you out with your organization or I can help you out individually, I'm happy to do that too. I'm just kind of talking about this extemporaneously right here. but actually like have workshops and trainings I offer in a lot of these ideas where I'll actually have people develop these stories in session share them with each other and like share them with the whole group and we can kind of workshop towards how you can be sharing your own personal stories or your own team stories or your own organizational stories for the value of the work that you're doing, why you do the work you're doing and how it's moving the world forward too. So that, thank you so much for listening. This has been Brave New Worlds and I will talk to you next week.