Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / ACEC Research Institute's Greg Kelly on the Engineering Workforce Shortage
Transcript
- 0:00And he's also vice chair of the ACEC Research Institute. He's got a lot of titles,
- 0:05so we're going to find out what the heck he really does.
- 0:08By the way, Frank, you graduated from Clarkson with two degrees,
- 0:10so we're going to be talking to another engineer.
- 0:12You speak the same language, you people. You peeps. You people. Good morning, Greg.
- 0:17Good morning, Taylor, and good morning, Frank, and good to have a kindred spirit
- 0:21on the other end of the line. Well, there you go. I know I need it every day.
- 0:25Yep. So what is STV?
- 0:30STV is an engineering, architecture, and construction management firm.
- 0:34And what we do is help clients conceive, plan, design, and help get built infrastructure.
- 0:44And that infrastructure would define in three ways. I would say transportation in all its modes.
- 0:49I would talk about buildings. So think of schools and hospitals.
- 0:53And I would say water systems, so pipes and pumps and treatment systems.
- 0:58So what's the shortage like on engineers? I know Frank went to Clarkson a long
- 1:02time ago, and I think how many women were in your classes?
- 1:05I was like 28 or so in the freshman class. Right.
- 1:10I mean, now it's changed. But what's happening in the engineering department
- 1:14there? I mean, why are we not seeing more engineers?
- 1:17Well, I think what we're seeing is, to use an engineering metaphor,
- 1:21I think the pipeline is beginning to collapse.
- 1:23We're short about 18,000 engineers each year. So, in other words,
- 1:28we're losing more than we're adding, and the math is getting worse.
- 1:32And part of this is baby boomers retiring and leaving the workforce.
- 1:37And so that's one of the issues. I think a second issue that we're faced with
- 1:42is large numbers of international students are trained in American colleges
- 1:47and universities. They're engineers.
- 1:49But they're forced to leave after graduation. We train some 40,000 students
- 1:54that are here on visas annually, but only about 9% of those students are able to obtain work visas.
- 2:01So the H-1B visa is something that could correct, that should help mitigate
- 2:09some of that shortage of the engineers. Right.
- 2:11You know, we've got to work through that. Are you, I'm sure you're out there
- 2:15talking to all the universities where they're having engineers graduate.
- 2:19Are you offering a package that would be, you know, palatable to these students that are graduating?
- 2:24Well, absolutely. When you look at starting salaries for engineers,
- 2:28they're very, very competitive.
- 2:30If you're a parent trying to guide a middle school or high schooler towards
- 2:35a career, an engineering career is a very solid career. Starting salaries coming
- 2:39out of school are pushing $80,000.
- 2:41And a survey we've done through the ACC Research Institute has the average salary
- 2:47well over $100,000 a year for engineers. Well, in today's market,
- 2:51that's about the average salary.
- 2:53I mean, nurses are starting with that as well. I mean, you know,
- 2:56our world is gone. I mean, this is a new world, especially since the pandemic.
- 3:00What do you do to try to, you know, go to the colleges and try to enlist these
- 3:04young students that are coming out?
- 3:05But a lot of the ones, and I've spoken to a few heads of universities about
- 3:11this, the ones that are being sent back because their visas expire,
- 3:15a lot of them don't want to stay here. They want to go home now that they got their degree.
- 3:19So I think it depends on which country or where these young students are from
- 3:23and what they're looking for as well.
- 3:25If they're being sent back, they can come back in six months.
- 3:28I mean, each country, I guess, has its own rules.
- 3:31So why are they not even attempting to come back?
- 3:34Yeah, that's a question I just really couldn't answer in terms of every situation is bespoke.
- 3:41But what I will tell you that is if we could open the pipeline a bit to allow
- 3:46more of them to stay, I think we would begin to mitigate some of the shortage. But it's not just that.
- 3:52I think part of the issue, Taylor, is another part of the issue is we've got
- 3:57to encourage students to think about those careers in engineering.
- 4:00Because if you look at this generation, and you just alluded to this,
- 4:04this is a generation that is purpose-driven.
- 4:06And if you think about the work engineers do,
- 4:10It makes a difference. Think about the infrastructure today.
- 4:15You turn on the tap, you get in your car and you drive across a bridge,
- 4:19you enter a school building or a hospital.
- 4:22There were public works that were planned, conceived and designed by engineers.
- 4:28And think about a future that doesn't have enough engineers to maintain or expand
- 4:34or build that new infrastructure.
- 4:35So I think we need to go back into schools at the middle school and high school
- 4:39level and encourage those meaningful, purpose-driven careers in engineering.
- 4:45You know, thinking about it this way, too, with today's technology,
- 4:50with the advent now of AI coming into play.
- 4:55Could it be that the engineers, even though we have less of them out there,
- 4:59can actually do more using those tools?
- 5:01So, in essence, we wouldn't need as many engineers out there as we did before
- 5:05because the work will be, you know, One engineer can now do a lot more,
- 5:10sort of like when we went from the slide rule to the calculator.
- 5:13You could definitely do a lot more a lot quicker. One person can do it because
- 5:16he had a device in his hand.
- 5:18Well, Frank, I'm glad you mentioned that. When you think about AI,
- 5:23it's on the cusp of transforming so much of what you do in our daily lives.
- 5:28And I don't know of a profession that will be unimpacted by it in a very positive
- 5:34way. So just specific to engineering.
- 5:37Certainly, AI is going to help with some of the more redundant type of tasks
- 5:43that are necessary in engineering projects.
- 5:46However, AI is not going to replace the experienced engineer who has that wisdom
- 5:53and judgment to say, okay, this is the right selection.
- 5:58We can't rely on AI with,
- 6:00If you think about, you know, what we do, if an engineer gets it wrong or if
- 6:04AI gets it wrong, you know, the bridge may not be able to hold itself up.
- 6:08So I think it is a tool that will be helpful, but it's in and of itself,
- 6:13Frank, it's not the solution.
- 6:15Yeah, and here's the other thing. What people fail to realize is AI is people
- 6:19putting the information on the Internet and they're picking it up.
- 6:22It's just the tool to pick up information.
- 6:24It didn't create, AI didn't create the information. It's gathering it.
- 6:28And I think that's what people are failing to realize.
- 6:30You're not getting some artificial intelligence that's brighter than you are.
- 6:34It's just been programmed to pull all your information together.
- 6:38And why wouldn't that be wrong on occasion?
- 6:40Yeah. So, you know, Taylor, what I would say is it's important to remember the
- 6:45humanness of what engineering does.
- 6:48You know, we're solving problems for a community, for a client,
- 6:52in the built environment. And you can't take away that human judgment that's
- 6:58necessary to say this is the right solution. 100%. Yeah.
- 7:03That's the big thing we're missing with the kids today, too,
- 7:06because they're all on their digital devices.
- 7:08They can be standing next to each other and text one another.
- 7:10We need communication back. That's what creates creativity and going forward. We're missing that.
- 7:16Another thing that always frustrates me on the construction end of it,
- 7:19when you're watching programs like House Hunters and people are looking for
- 7:22homes, it's interesting because they're looking at homes, a lot of them want
- 7:26character in a house, and they get that thing called cookie cutter,
- 7:30which I don't want a cookie cutter house.
- 7:32Well, guess what? That cookie-cutter house was designed by an engineer to make
- 7:35that home the most convenient and accessible to you and your family so that
- 7:39that house is very livable, not like an old house.
- 7:42I was watching one the other day, Greg, where the lady said,
- 7:46I don't want my daughter buying a house that was made in the last 10 or 20 years
- 7:49because I don't want her falling through a floor.
- 7:52And I'm like, seriously? You ever hear of codes and construction and all the
- 7:57new techniques that are out there that engineers have designed make the homes
- 8:01today more safe, more fire resistant,
- 8:03more sturdy and for better use for people?
- 8:07It's kind of funny when these people go and they look and they always go into a condominium.
- 8:11They go, I want to buy that because somebody designed that, some engineer designed
- 8:14that with the big closets and the big bathroom and they're wowed over by it.
- 8:17But I always get frustrated watching that show when people say things like that.
- 8:21People appreciate as much as they, because they don't understand what an engineer does.
- 8:25Now, but, you know, between the codes that we have out there today,
- 8:27which engineers have to comply with, especially construction.
- 8:30You know, we know a lot more now than we did 30, 40 years ago. Right, Greg?
- 8:35Absolutely right, Frank. And you're channeling your Clarkson days.
- 8:41One-on-one. Yeah. But you're absolutely right. And you talk about codes and
- 8:46standards. You know, they didn't just appear.
- 8:49They were built up over time. As we as we understood, you know,
- 8:54new materials that are created, new ways of applying those materials,
- 8:58everything you're talking about is exactly what engineers do.
- 9:01And that's what we need to maintain a growing, thriving society.
- 9:08By the way, Greg, are you actually, or someone from your company,
- 9:12do you go to the universities, you know, like MIT and Clarkson,
- 9:15etc.? Do you go to them to talk to the students and also the undergrads?
- 9:21Absolutely, Taylor. That is something we do on a regular basis.
- 9:26In our organization and many of the organizations of ACEC, we have very robust internship programs.
- 9:32So we're constantly out there talking to engineers and creating pathways for
- 9:37them to enter the workforce.
- 9:39The ACEC and the Research Institute, we have 5,500 companies across the U.S.
- 9:47And some 600,000 engineers that work here.
- 9:50And for the most part, all those companies are very engaged in trying to build
- 9:55that pipeline up of engineering students to come into the workforce.
- 9:59What do you offer that another company would not offer to entice these young
- 10:04people? But we have a young man who came to talk to Frank who lives locally
- 10:07who is going to Clarkson.
- 10:09Actually, we'll be at Clarkson for Frank's anniversary this year, right, Frank? Right.
- 10:14Yeah. So, I mean, what do you offer that no other company offers that would
- 10:19entice them to come to your company first?
- 10:22Well, at STV, we're very intentional about growing the next generation.
- 10:26And it starts with internship programs.
- 10:29But we're not, you know, many of the firms at ACC do the same thing.
- 10:33So you start with internship programs and you give them real life experience,
- 10:37working alongside engineers, shadowing what they do and creating and unlocking
- 10:43that passion for seeing what you build.
- 10:46You know, I think if you talk to engineering interns and students,
- 10:52what gets the most excited is that they can see what we do.
- 10:57Unlike a lot of other professions, you can see the outcome, whether it's in
- 11:01a new street or road that's created or a water system that's upgraded or a bridge.
- 11:08There's a lot of emotional pride that comes with that.
- 11:11So what we do is try to unlock that with our students. And we pair them with
- 11:16senior technical leaders and pass that
- 11:19knowledge on, Craig, that you were referring to, why we do what we do.
- 11:25Is there one field in engineering that's lacking, you know, because there's
- 11:29so many different fields in engineering, you've got civil, electrical, mechanical.
- 11:31Is there one field that really needs students to get more into it?
- 11:36Well, I think, Frank, it's across the board in terms of where we need the students.
- 11:42Each of those different disciplines can prepare you for different specific areas of the profession.
- 11:49A civil engineer will be involved in the built infrastructure.
- 11:53A mechanical engineer will be involved in perhaps creating a data center,
- 11:57as would an electric engineer, or they might be involved in creating the next version of an iPhone.
- 12:04It can go in many different directions. But what engineering does is train you
- 12:08for very broad career opportunities.
- 12:12You know, if you look at leaders of many companies, they come from an engineering background.
- 12:18It teaches you how to think. Think of people like Jeff Bezos or Larry Page or
- 12:23Michael Bloomberg, as an example.
- 12:25We're all trained as undergrads, as engineers, and the career can take you in
- 12:30many different directions.
- 12:32Yeah, somebody just texted, and we have texting in here. We need engineers to
- 12:36work with AI to ensure that the information it has is correct.
- 12:39Well, that's an interesting concept.
- 12:41Really, that is absolutely true. Who's checking the, you know,
- 12:45normally if somebody gives you, somebody works for you, they give you whatever
- 12:48information you're asking for, and then you have it checked to make sure it's correct.
- 12:52I mean, nobody's checking AI. They're just assuming everything it gets is correct.
- 12:56That is a good point, actually.
- 12:58Well, Taylor, you're making a point where that's where we need engineers that
- 13:03can evolve with the tools and technologies that are in front of us.
- 13:07And I think you've just reinforced what we're seeing out there is that we need
- 13:11more trained people that can help make a difference.
- 13:16That was from Aaron Ubeides. So by the way, I worked with Lally Weymouth.
- 13:21I don't know if you remember that name, but she was the daughter of the gentleman
- 13:26who built Washington Post, Graham, and his wife, Catherine Graham. them.
- 13:32And her husband, also last name Wayne, that's where Brian Pye,
- 13:36and I remember him saying that, you know, the structures that we leave as engineers,
- 13:42as builders, is there, you know, forever how long it stands. So it's a legacy.
- 13:46And I think, you know, do engineers understand that part of it too?
- 13:50Because I know with Frank, it's all about the numbers and putting things together
- 13:55properly and very concise.
- 13:57But I hope that they realize also these graduates or these kids that are graduating,
- 14:02that you're leaving a lasting memory for many people, especially if you're building hospitals.
- 14:07I mean, you know, the people see the signs, you know, built by.
- 14:10It really does leave a legacy.
- 14:12Taylor, I'm so glad to hear you say that. When you think about the infrastructure
- 14:16we live with today, whether it's a healthcare facility you're alluding to,
- 14:20or the bridge we crossed this morning to get to work,
- 14:23those assets were planned and conceived, designed and built by our parents and
- 14:30their parents and their parents.
- 14:32And what we're doing today is,
- 14:35For our children and the next generation, the generation after that.
- 14:39And that should inspire people. That should inspire engineers,
- 14:43future engineers, because it is truly a legacy.
- 14:46And that's, I think, what motivates many of us in the profession,
- 14:50that you can look around with a sense of pride to say, what I did is help people get to schools,
- 14:57get to businesses, get to jobs, and unlock economic mobility for a region.
- 15:02And that's really, I think, the essence of what engineers do.
- 15:05It's not so much about the bridge that might be built. It's about the economic
- 15:09opportunity that it unlocks as a result of connecting one shore to another, as an example.
- 15:15So how about somebody put together a program that says, here's the real reason
- 15:20we need these engineers that are going to school here to stay here.
- 15:23And how can we vet them to make the government happy so we can keep them?
- 15:27How about something like that?
- 15:29Well, Taylor, I think you're directionally where we need to go.
- 15:33We need to be having more conversations like this and engaging with the public
- 15:38and with decision makers that can help us build that pipeline of engineers that
- 15:45will be there to help us continue to thrive as a society.
- 15:49And, you know, the other aspect of this, too, is a good engineering school is
- 15:53a pretty good expense on the family to send the kids there.
- 15:58Maybe some help on that end would be kind of nice. Yeah, we went up a couple
- 16:01of years ago, one of your reunions. That was at least 10, 15 years ago.
- 16:05No, it was that long? 10 years ago, at least, yeah. Oh, my gosh.
- 16:07Anyway, Frank goes, you know, I wouldn't mind going back for another degree.
- 16:10I'm like, you have two already. Leave it alone.
- 16:12So we went to talk to them anyway, and he said, yeah, we could do that online.
- 16:16I said, really? What's the cost?
- 16:18$50,000 a year. That was 10 years ago. As a graduate, online.
- 16:23So how are people affording to be able to go to college now unless there's a
- 16:26number of scholarships. At least it's an option. Add room and board.
- 16:30Yeah, well, this wasn't for room and board. No, but that's what I'm saying.
- 16:34Can you imagine if you had to add room and board? Absolutely.
- 16:37So, Greg, what is the answer to that? How can people, you know,
- 16:40make it more affordable?
- 16:41Because I, you know, a lot of, you know, let's put it this way.
- 16:43A lot of folks that maybe were great in sports, academically,
- 16:47they're not necessarily on top of the game to go for something that's really...
- 16:51A little stereotyping, aren't you? Yeah, I definitely am.
- 16:54Remember, I went to a school where there was a lot of hockey players.
- 16:56They did not go into the engineering.
- 16:58They were more in the other end of it. Yeah, that stuff, too.
- 17:01But it is expensive and it's not easy to do.
- 17:04But if you have that passion for it, Greg, and I think the thing that is also
- 17:07a lot of kids today, what do they want to do?
- 17:09They want to anything with computers and anything online, Internet.
- 17:13They want to become celebrities. They want to, you know, have their own channel.
- 17:17Influencer. They want to be an influencer.
- 17:19So, you know, how do we ship these more people into the more expensive engineering
- 17:24field and the excitement about, you know, you've got to remember,
- 17:28too, Greg, that when we grew up, we were building things.
- 17:31I was building model train sets. I was building car models.
- 17:34Legos. I was, you know, Legos were a little later on, things like that.
- 17:38Today, the kids, what are they doing? They're playing with the computer all
- 17:40the time or computer games or, you know, they're not even active that way.
- 17:43How do you bridge that gap?
- 17:46Yeah, I think you raise a very interesting question about how to afford college.
- 17:52And it is very expensive on families.
- 17:54And I think if I were advising my children what to consider as a career and
- 18:01the return on investment of a college education, I think I would encourage them
- 18:06in a career of engineering now.
- 18:08So I say that for obvious reasons, but what you do know with an engineering
- 18:12degree is that the return on investments can be quite high.
- 18:16But the affordability side of a college education, I think that's a much bigger
- 18:21question to try and answer, and I'm probably not the best spokesperson on that.
- 18:25Yeah, so just before we let you go, somebody just texted, well,
- 18:29Aaron, you'll be, it takes engineers to design medical devices we use need.
- 18:33Skilled labor is vital. Yeah, if we want to look at the future,
- 18:37it absolutely is, because who's doing that?
- 18:39Yeah, you'll always have a job, no doubt about that. So it's,
- 18:41you know, we're very worthwhile.
- 18:43Greg, if people want to get more information about, you know,
- 18:46your companies and how they can find out if that's the one for them, where would they go?
- 18:50Absolutely. So what I would recommend is the ACEC, which is the American Council
- 18:55of Engineering Companies.
- 18:56It's made up of member organizations across the country. In New York,
- 19:01we have one that's based in Albany, ACC York. And there's a whole group of company
- 19:08like ourselves that are members of ACEC.
- 19:10And so that would reach out directly. Go ahead.
- 19:13Do you offer scholarships for young people who are interested in going into
- 19:16engineering but can't afford all the money it takes to get there?
- 19:20Absolutely. ACEC has a very healthy scholarship program to help students defer
- 19:26the cost of the education.
- 19:27That's a really important point for people to hear. Yeah.
- 19:30Yeah, I will actually send this segment to a couple of the schools that we have
- 19:36on the air with us and let them hear about this.
- 19:38I think they need to share the information with their students that are interested
- 19:42in maybe engineering. And I'm talking at the high school level.
- 19:46Right. And I would refer you specifically, Taylor, to the ACEC Research Institute
- 19:50and the scholarship program, and that's on our website.
- 19:54Okay, great. Well, Greg, thanks so much for coming on the air.
- 19:57Really continued great success. Love to have you on again to kind of remind
- 20:01people of all this as well.
- 20:03Thank you both. This has been fun. Have a great rest of the day.
- 20:06You too. Take care, Greg. Bye-bye. Bye-bye.