Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #27: Separation of Powers, Its Debates, and How Trump Factors in
Transcript
- 0:01It is time for another episode of the Politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:07That's me.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about the separation of powers in government.
- 0:14In his first few weeks, Donald Trump and his administration have been moving at a blistering
- 0:18pace to implement his policies, including enacting tariffs and reducing federal spending
- 0:24and government employees.
- 0:27Beyond the debates of whether these policies are harmful or beneficial, however, a new front
- 0:33in the debate over separation of powers in government, how the responsibilities and duties
- 0:40of each branch of government, are divided has been opened up in the eyes of opponents of
- 0:46Trump.
- 0:47Many of the actions by him and his allies, such as Elon Musk are a serious overstepping of the
- 0:53boundaries of executive branch power.
- 0:55In the eyes of supporters of Trump, he is operating well within his rights and doing what
- 1:00should have been done before.
- 1:02Now, of course, as is typical policy, I'm not here to say if there is a particular side of
- 1:07support and by how much I do support them or don't.
- 1:12But I am here to, as objectively as possible, lay out the arguments that both sides have for
- 1:17why they feel the way they do.
- 1:19So today we are going to discuss the separation of powers, a key component to our system of
- 1:25government, what it looks like, why we have it, what it means for today's politics, how it
- 1:30closely relates to the concepts of checks and balances and so on.
- 1:36So let's get to it.
- 1:40So first of all, why do we even have a separation of powers?
- 1:44We have three branches of government.
- 1:46We have the executive, which executes or enforces laws.
- 1:50We have the legislative branch, which writes laws it legislates.
- 1:56And we have the judicial branch, which interprets laws.
- 1:59And these branches of government also extend to the state and local levels of government,
- 2:04though how they look differs from the federal government, and we're really, just for today,
- 2:08focused on the federal government in particular.
- 2:11Although you will see some of these similar kinds of debates and concepts be applied to
- 2:18those levels of government as well.
- 2:21But the separation of ours is kind of used interchangeably between or with with checks and
- 2:27balances, checks and balances being the methods by which each branch checks the power of the
- 2:32other so that one branch doesn't get a leg up over the other.
- 2:36So they're technically different concepts, but you can sometimes consider them the same thing.
- 2:42Separation powers being specifically what duties are given to each branch and checks and
- 2:47mounts as being how each branch checks the other, but more or less the same overarching
- 2:55concept.
- 2:56And the concept itself is credited to the eighteenth century French philosopher,
- 3:01Montesquieu.
- 3:03And a lot a lot of governments around the world who implement a similar separation of powers
- 3:09concepts.
- 3:10They have Montesquieu to thank for that original concept.
- 3:16And in particular, for the case of the American form of government, we have Federalist papers,
- 3:22numbers, 47 to 51 that talk about the separation of powers, how the, at the time new
- 3:30constitution kept separation of powers as a thing and why it was fundamental to freedom and
- 3:38good government and how the new form of government would have or would keep checks and
- 3:47balances in place, why it adhered to those concepts better than what was then the
- 3:53governing document of The United States, the articles of Confederation.
- 3:57And the Federalist Papers were a series of papers that defended the new constitution and
- 4:03and and told people why exactly it was needed to replace the articles of Confederation
- 4:08Federalist papers, all written by either Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, or in a few
- 4:13cases, John Jay.
- 4:15And so in again, Federalist papers, forty seven to fifty one, those described separation of
- 4:23powers in the new government.
- 4:26So the whole idea was to prevent excessively concentrated power in one branch, according to
- 4:33James Madison and Federalist fifty one.
- 4:35Prevention of excessively concentrated power, quote, consists in giving to those who
- 4:41administer each department the necessary constitutional means and personal motives to
- 4:46resist encroachments of the others.
- 4:49End quote.
- 4:50So short answer is that checks and balances, separation of powers is designed to keep
- 4:55singular entities within the government from deriving too much power.
- 4:59So you think about what if the president could also write laws or make judicial rulings?
- 5:06What would that mean for government function and personal freedoms?
- 5:09What if you had that with judges instead, or with the speaker of the house being able to
- 5:16execute and enforce laws or make judicial rulings or for judges to be able to enforce
- 5:22laws or to write laws?
- 5:25So we have different branches of government that relate to those specific functions.
- 5:31Now the exact functions of each branch and how they have administered their duties.
- 5:38That's somewhat changed over time as new policies have been implemented.
- 5:42Branches have gotten bigger.
- 5:43Political norms have changed and so on, but largely, the fundamentals of separation of
- 5:48powers haven't changed.
- 5:52Or have they?
- 5:53In some people's eyes, some of that separation of powers, the line between the powers of the
- 5:59branches has been somewhat blurred, and, obviously, we'll get a little bit more into
- 6:03that soon.
- 6:03But first, what does the separation of powers look like specifically for the executive
- 6:08branch?
- 6:09So at the federal level, we have president, vice president, fifteen cabinet departments,
- 6:14and a lot of independent agencies.
- 6:16Cabinet department examples being defense, health and human services, interior, Homeland
- 6:22security, commerce, independent agency examples being the central intelligence agency, CIA, the
- 6:29securities and exchange commission, sec, federal trade commission, environmental
- 6:34protection agency, the equal employment opportunity commission, national science
- 6:39foundation, small business administration.
- 6:41These ones are still technically within the purview of the executive branch, but are
- 6:45considered independent in that the president's power over them, such as the ability to appoint
- 6:51or dismiss members is more limited than it is with the cabinet departments, though they are
- 6:57still considered executive branch agencies.
- 7:01So, as we said before, the basic duty of the executive branch is to execute slash enforce
- 7:08laws.
- 7:09And what does that look like?
- 7:10Well, each cabinet department and independent agency has a specific policy area they handle.
- 7:16So Department of Commerce handles commerce.
- 7:20Health and Human Services handles health policy, so on and so forth.
- 7:25President, in particular, is the commander in chief of the military, picks the heads of the
- 7:30various executive branch agencies, enforces laws by congress, assuming they weren't vetoed
- 7:36by the president and congress didn't override the veto, and enforces interpretations of laws
- 7:42by federal courts.
- 7:45Now checks and balances, how does it check and balance against the legislative branch?
- 7:50It can, the president can veto legislation passed by Congress.
- 7:54He can propose legislation to Congress through the State of the Union, and he can issue
- 8:00executive orders that have the force of law like a congressional law.
- 8:04Although the nature of executive orders in even whether the president is a is allowed to
- 8:13administer executive orders or how much he has the power to do that.
- 8:17That is a controversial power, which we'll get into later on in this episode.
- 8:23But, and a check and balance against the judicial branch is that he, the president
- 8:28appoints federal judges though, with the advice and consent of Congress.
- 8:34Speaking of which, what a separation of powers look like for the legislative branch.
- 8:40So at the federal level, you've got the US house and the US senate, which are the most
- 8:44obvious ones, but you also have a bunch of special agencies that provide support services
- 8:49to congress, employees for specific members of congress, so chiefs of staff, legislative
- 8:55assistants, press secretaries, and so on, and employees for the parties in Congress.
- 9:02Sometimes it might be for the overall parties, overall Democrat and Republican party in
- 9:09congress, or they might be for a specific chamber, so specifically for the US house or
- 9:13the US senate.
- 9:15And as we said earlier, basic duty of the legislative branch is that they legislate slash
- 9:21right laws.
- 9:23Or in the case of their support staff, they help them research or, you know, set up
- 9:29meetings with president or with lobbyists and so on and so forth.
- 9:35And in Congress, in particular, there's a unique there's sort of in a way, a separation
- 9:41of powers within the legislative branch that you don't find in the judicial branch or the
- 9:47executive branch.
- 9:49In Congress, there is a, what we call bicameralism, which means there's two chambers,
- 9:54the US house and the US Senate.
- 9:57And all state legislatures, except Nebraska's, also implement that.
- 10:01They just have a state senate.
- 10:04US senate has much more of a role in treaties and foreign policy, whereas the US house is
- 10:10where all appropriations, which is another word to say funding, originate.
- 10:16So funding for all sorts of government programs or for states to implement their own programs.
- 10:23All the funding bills originate from the US house, although an identical bill does need to
- 10:28be passed in the US senate.
- 10:29But that is the US House is where appropriations bills originate.
- 10:35And what does the implementation of these duties look like?
- 10:39So there's a general path that laws follow for for most most things.
- 10:44Again, there's a little bit of a difference when it comes to things like appropriations or
- 10:48treaties or or impeachments, but they, generally speaking, they pass laws through.
- 10:55They, a bill starts any committee.
- 10:58It goes to the full chamber might have to get some things hammered out before the whole
- 11:05chamber passes it.
- 11:07And then the other legislative chamber must pass the exact same bill.
- 11:11Now exact path for that bill depends on various factors.
- 11:16It might require multiple committees or a subcommittee to deal with it.
- 11:21And that just depends on what the subject area of the policy is, whether it's health or it's
- 11:28economy or, guns, all sorts of thing.
- 11:35Depending on what the subject area is, it will originate in a different committee than a bill
- 11:39with a totally different subject area will originate in.
- 11:43And then like we said before, legislative staffers help with the day to day operations of
- 11:48Congress, like researching bills, preparing members of Congress for meetings and press and
- 11:54so on.
- 11:55Now how do they check and balance against the other two branches?
- 11:59So the legislative branch checks and balances against the executive branch by providing,
- 12:05quote, unquote, advice and consent to the president in appointments and treaties with
- 12:11other countries.
- 12:12They can override the president's veto of legislation with a two thirds vote by both the
- 12:18US house and the US Senate.
- 12:21So if they pass something, president says, I don't like that.
- 12:24I'm gonna veto it.
- 12:26If enough of the US house and US Senate, really back that bill, then they can override that
- 12:33president's veto.
- 12:34It's quite difficult to do though.
- 12:38With the house specifically, they have the power of the purse, although senate does have
- 12:44to sign on for an appropriations bill as well.
- 12:46So power of the purse being controlling funding for, in this case, executive agencies.
- 12:53And of course they can impeach the president.
- 12:55And we saw several recent, instances of that with Donald Trump and his first term.
- 13:02And then back when bill Clinton was president, there was an impeachment proceeding there
- 13:09checks and balances from the legislative branch, but are between the, from the
- 13:14legislative branch against the judicial branch is that they can also impeach federal judges
- 13:21and judicial nominees still need to be confirmed by Congress in order to take office.
- 13:28And those judicial nominees, let's move on to the judicial branch.
- 13:33What does the separation of powers look like for the judicial branch?
- 13:37So at the federal level, we have the Supreme Court of the United States or SCOTUS for short.
- 13:42We also have 13 US courts of appeal, 90 four US district courts, 90 US bankruptcy courts, and
- 13:50then some specialized courts called article one courts, which includes courts like the US tax
- 13:57court.
- 13:57Most federal judges are called article three judges because article three of the
- 14:01constitution primarily deals with these judges, but these specialized courts are actually
- 14:06established in article one.
- 14:08And unlike article three judges, article one judges actually have a fixed term.
- 14:13I believe it's fifteen years, but article three judges have those lifetime terms.
- 14:19So as we said before, the basic duty of the judicial branch is to interpret the laws, which
- 14:25is otherwise known as judicial review.
- 14:28So whenever congress passes a law or the president administers an executive order or
- 14:36whatever sort of actions government takes, the judicial branch can review those actions to see
- 14:43whether they are constitutional.
- 14:45So what does the implementation of these duties look like?
- 14:48Specialized courts handle their specific subject matter.
- 14:52General courts handle anything within their jurisdiction that is brought to them and has
- 14:56followed appropriate channels to get there.
- 14:58The higher up appeals courts, some court cases might've already been heard by a lower court.
- 15:04And if they appeal, it'll go to a higher level court.
- 15:07So might go from district court to us court of appeals, and then potentially even the Supreme
- 15:12court of the United States.
- 15:15But in which case SCOTUS is the absolute last court of appeal, and it only takes cases with a
- 15:22particular significance in terms of national impact or precedent setting.
- 15:27And usually, it hears cases through what we call writs of cert, which is short for
- 15:33certiorari.
- 15:34Hopefully, I'm saying that right.
- 15:36It's a Latin word.
- 15:38But basically, litigants ask SCOTUS to grant a writ of cert to review a lower court ruling
- 15:44that the litigant isn't satisfied with.
- 15:46And at least four of nine justices must vote to grant that writ.
- 15:52Now how does the judicial branch check and balance against the executive and the
- 15:57legislative?
- 15:59In the case of the executive branch, they can declare executive branch actions, like
- 16:04executive orders, unconstitutional, And they also have lifetime terms so that the president
- 16:10can't just dismiss judges based on politics, although this is only for article three judges.
- 16:15Remember, article one judges have a fixed term, so is that they could be not renewed.
- 16:21They can't just still can't just go up.
- 16:23You're out of here.
- 16:24But article one judges have a lot less protection in that regard than a article three
- 16:30judge does, as it is as it is described in the they shall serve during good behavior, which
- 16:38means as long as they're not impeached.
- 16:40And then judicial branch checks and balances against judicial branches, they can also
- 16:45declare legislation unconstitutional and lifetime terms so that Congress can't just
- 16:50follow the president in dismissing judges based on politics.
- 16:58So while that is the basic rundown of separation of powers and it is a fundamental
- 17:04aspect to how our government operates, there are still many challenges that separation of
- 17:10powers faces and has faced over time.
- 17:13And we've talked about some of these challenges in previous episodes, such as episode 18, which
- 17:19focused on US presidential power.
- 17:21But this is much more of a deep dive into the implications for separation of powers and
- 17:27checks and balances.
- 17:28So I talk about several general, areas where we see potential issues for separate separation of
- 17:38powers at some point in time or now.
- 17:42And eventually, we'll get more to how some of these relate to Donald Trump.
- 17:46But right now, just specific or not specific challenges, general challenges for the
- 17:53separation of powers.
- 17:54So executive orders Executive orders are declarations by the president that have the
- 18:00force of law.
- 18:02Individual orders are not always controversial, and they don't always impose some sort of major
- 18:07policy, but the most prominent ones are often contentious, at least for their time, but
- 18:13sometimes also further down the road.
- 18:15So, for example, the Emancipation Proclamation was an executive order, but so was the
- 18:21internment of Japanese Americans during World War two.
- 18:25So you've had some unequivocally good outcomes and some unequivocally bad outcomes and some
- 18:31that are a bit more of a gray area.
- 18:34We'll get a little bit more into whether that matters, though, when we talk about the
- 18:40ultimate questions for separation of powers.
- 18:42So some food for thought when it comes to executive orders.
- 18:47Is an executive order an instance of the president circumventing the power to write laws
- 18:54that the legislative branch has?
- 18:57Is he basically just saying, I'm making laws now.
- 19:00I'm making policies now.
- 19:02I don't need the legislative branch doing that.
- 19:06Is that what executive orders are?
- 19:10Does the president have the power to enforce laws if there is a, quote, unquote, do nothing
- 19:15Congress?
- 19:17A lot of times, congress gets the label of being people who just sit on their hands all
- 19:23day and and don't do something.
- 19:25So if they don't do something, is the president within his rights to enforce the laws or to to
- 19:35enact executive orders to enforce laws, in in or in his eyes and maybe in the eyes of his
- 19:41supporters say they're not making laws like they're supposed to, I'm going to do it.
- 19:49Is that justified?
- 19:51When are executive orders simply enforcing laws that congress has already made or judicial
- 19:58rulings that have already been made?
- 20:01And when is it executive orders just making laws up as they go along?
- 20:06Because in some cases, a president writing an executive order, they'll say, oh, well, this
- 20:11this is actually already a thing.
- 20:13We're just making sure it happens.
- 20:17It's already been on the books, or they have a certain interpretation of a law, and their
- 20:22executive order enforces that interpretation of the law.
- 20:26So does that have any consequences for the separation of powers?
- 20:31Is a potential breaking of the separation of powers through executive orders good if the
- 20:37ultimate outcome could be considered a good thing by a significant number of people?
- 20:43Or is it just under no circumstances is this okay?
- 20:47Obviously, that in large part depends on whether you think a particular executive or is
- 20:52a break in the separation of powers and of checks and balances.
- 20:57Another question to also think about, is the court sufficiently exercising its power to
- 21:02declare executive actions unconstitutional?
- 21:05For people who are very much against executive orders in general, they might see the court as
- 21:12the court's not doing what it's supposed to do.
- 21:14It's just letting the president run roughshod or that congress is just letting the president
- 21:19run roughshod.
- 21:21So not only is is there a question of is the president just taking power for himself,
- 21:27there's also the question of is congress and or the courts just letting them do that.
- 21:34Now, of course, I'm not saying that this is, or this isn't the case.
- 21:38These are just questions to think about when you dis when you discuss the implications and
- 21:45the consequences for the separation of powers.
- 21:49These are very important questions for making sure that the system of checks and balances
- 21:55stays solvent.
- 21:58Another case where we can talk about the implications for separation of powers is war
- 22:07powers.
- 22:08So there are is there's a debate surrounding where the constitution vests the power to
- 22:14declare and make war.
- 22:17How much of it belongs to congress?
- 22:19How much of it belongs to the president?
- 22:22Is there a concurrent responsibility by both?
- 22:25Does it is it just congress that has that ability?
- 22:28Does the president get to take the lead on it?
- 22:32How much should each of those two branches be able to do in regards to declaring war, making
- 22:39war?
- 22:39For some, congress is specifically given the power to declare war while a president is just
- 22:45commander in chief.
- 22:46So Congress says we're going to do this and a president carries out the will of Congress.
- 22:52And in this instance of executing, executing slash enforcing the law, for a lot of these
- 22:59people who think that our president has very little, if any, power to declare war, they also
- 23:04say that the power of a president to unilaterally unilaterally declare war is
- 23:11inherently abusive of power and that courts have not stopped presidents like they should in
- 23:17the past.
- 23:19And if for others who think the president can and should take more of a trying to think of
- 23:27the word.
- 23:29Take more of a in in impetus.
- 23:31I can't think of the word I'm looking for.
- 23:33But for that, I think the president should have much more say in declaring war.
- 23:39They say that war powers are ambiguous and or vested in both the president and Congress that
- 23:46the president is allowed to repel invasions of their own authority and that Congress has
- 23:52willingly ceded power to the president that they should not have ceded.
- 23:58So these questions have also become even more pertinent with the war on terror, matter of not
- 24:05just whether being expeditious or cautious regarding presidential war powers is the way to
- 24:11go, but what are the consequences for separation of powers and such consequences to
- 24:19think about are through these ultimate questions.
- 24:22How much of the power to declare war belongs to congress, and how much of it belongs to the
- 24:27president?
- 24:29Is the president supposed to just carry out the will of congress?
- 24:33Is the president does the president need to take more of a forward approach in the
- 24:42declaring of war?
- 24:43Have they already taken a lot of that forward approach to declaring war in the past, such as
- 24:50with LBJ in the Vietnam War or or George Bush, with the war on terror?
- 24:57Is the executive branch or the legislative branch getting too much power on the issue, or
- 25:02are they seeding too much power on this issue?
- 25:05Should the court step in more than they have in the past on this issue?
- 25:10All these things here to really consider about what's best for separation of powers, what
- 25:16powers have been separated between the two branches.
- 25:20But it's it's not a even though the sides have certainly argued that their constitution
- 25:28clearly says this about my side, Maybe it's not so clear because there's a lot of debate about
- 25:35what the constitution says in regards to the declaring of war.
- 25:40And this may be more so than a lot of other cases has particular implications for
- 25:48separation of powers, checks, and balances.
- 25:51Who gets to actually declare war?
- 25:54Who actually gets to or or or is it a matter of both congress and president, or is it just one
- 26:01or the other?
- 26:02Is it a little bit murkier?
- 26:04That's for you to think about.
- 26:07Another case, of or another matter to think about the separation of powers in is at some
- 26:15points in time, presidents have sometimes disregarded SCOTUS rulings.
- 26:21Alexander Hamilton called the judicial branch the inherently weakest branch because it has no
- 26:27power to actually implement its rulings.
- 26:29It has to rely on Congress to write laws that adhere to those rulings.
- 26:36It depends on the president to enforce and execute its interpretation of rulings.
- 26:43For Alexander Hamilton, he says, executive branch has the power of the sword, legislative
- 26:49branch has the power of the purse, but the judicial branch basically has nothing like it.
- 26:53It has no analogous powers.
- 26:55It just makes rulings on laws, and that's it.
- 26:58In fact, much of the judicial branch's power comes from citizens' confidence in and respect
- 27:04for SCOTUS's legitimacy, supreme court in particular, but federal courts in general
- 27:10obviously matter, but usually think about it in terms of how they think about SCOTUS'
- 27:17legitimacy.
- 27:18And one really high profile instance of a president ignoring supreme court rulings was
- 27:25Andrew Jackson following Worcester versus Georgia.
- 27:28Basically, the state government of Georgia was trying to force native Americans, particularly
- 27:34Cherokees, off lands that they said were within Georgia's jurisdiction.
- 27:38Treaties had been made between United States and Cherokees previously, which inherently
- 27:45treats them as a sovereign nation.
- 27:47Supreme court basically said the state government has no authority to do that because
- 27:54interactions with a sovereign nation are within the purview of the federal government, not the
- 27:59state government.
- 28:01Andrew Jackson said, well, I don't care.
- 28:03Let them do whatever they wanna do because Andrew Jackson wasn't exactly a a nice guy.
- 28:08And so the state government still pushed a lot of those Cherokees further out.
- 28:15So that was maybe the most high profile instance of a president ignoring SCOTUS
- 28:21rulings, but presidents over the years have been accused of ignoring the Supreme Court on
- 28:26issues, various issues, including more recently.
- 28:31But ultimate questions for separation of powers here.
- 28:35And, again, I'm not saying that those were well, in Andrew Jackson's case, that was
- 28:41definitely ignoring Supreme Court rulings, but there are some murkier concepts where, the
- 28:49president has been accused over time of ignoring the Supreme Court whenever they rule
- 28:54on something or the executive branch in general just dragging their feet on things.
- 29:00And so that that's for you to, to, decide on, but don't wanna get too much into the weeds of
- 29:08that because we wanna talk about ultimate questions for this disregard for SCOTUS
- 29:14rulings, what those mean for separation of powers, whether these actually were and in
- 29:20cases where SCOTUS rulings were definitely dismissed by a president or legislative branch,
- 29:29or whether it's an accusation that somebody feels may have been the case, but there's some
- 29:36debate as to whether the court's interpretation of a ruling was being carried out or wasn't
- 29:43being carried out.
- 29:45So questions to think about.
- 29:46Is there ever a justification for a president to defy SCOTUS rulings?
- 29:52That is to say, a president thinks SCOTUS had an incorrect interpretation of the constitution
- 29:57because we don't always agree with SCOTUS rulings.
- 30:01Sometimes we personally think an interpretation is wrong.
- 30:05But if we think an interpretation is wrong, is that okay for a president to or the or the
- 30:11congress to also think this ruling is a bunch of crap.
- 30:15I'm not enforcing it.
- 30:16Is there ever a justification for that?
- 30:19Is the decrease in public confidence in the judiciary threatening the judicial branch's
- 30:25ability to check and balance against the executive and legislative branches.
- 30:31Again, a lot of that power and authority for the judicial branch comes from how we as
- 30:38citizens view the court.
- 30:40And in recent years, their legitimacy has been threatened or or, excuse me, the approval of
- 30:49the judiciary has gone down quite a bit.
- 30:52So does that threaten their legitimacy, and does that threaten their ability to check and
- 30:57balance against the executive and legislative branches?
- 31:01Do the executive and legislative branches do enough to ensure the judicial branch's
- 31:06authority and legitimacy?
- 31:09How much should they be able to ensure the judicial branch's authority and legitimacy?
- 31:18How do you do that?
- 31:20All sorts of things to really consider when it comes to separation of powers in regards to how
- 31:26much the executive branch enforces judicial rulings and how much Congress adheres to
- 31:32judicial rulings when it's writing its own laws.
- 31:38Or how about the fact that SCOTUS nominations and confirmations, that whole process has
- 31:44become more partisan over time?
- 31:47Undeniably so.
- 31:48It's undeniably become more partisan overall in recent decades, more bitter and divisive, and a
- 31:56lot of that is traced back to the confirmation process for Robert Bork in the nineteen
- 32:02eighties.
- 32:02Now he was not ultimately confirmed to the Supreme Court, but a lot of that bitterness and
- 32:08controversy there has really, you've you've seen it again multiple times over time since
- 32:17then from the nineteen eighties to now.
- 32:20And in some more recent examples, you have a lot of bitterness and controversy regarding
- 32:26nomination battles such as with Brett Kavanaugh or the or congress declining to vote on the
- 32:32nomination of Merrick Garland by Barack Obama when he was, about to end his second term.
- 32:40So ultimate questions for the separation of powers in this regard is, are presidents taking
- 32:45too much of a lead in nominating judicial nominees, particularly those for SCOTUS?
- 32:50Should congress be exercising its advice function more when it comes to advising
- 32:57presidents on nominees?
- 32:58For some people, they're really just adhering to the consent function of the advice and
- 33:06consent aspect that congress is supposed to provide to the president.
- 33:12They a lot of people would argue that congress was much more, giving much more of the advice
- 33:19aspects in previous times.
- 33:23So is congress not doing its job well enough when it comes to partisan nominations of
- 33:34Supreme Court justices or federal judges in general?
- 33:38When Congress is controlled by the same party as the president, is Congress ceding its power
- 33:44to check the president on nominees?
- 33:46Should it be doing much more?
- 33:48Is is it just serving as a rubber stamp for the president?
- 33:55And in terms of rubber stamps, are judicial nominees becoming rubber stamps for presidents
- 34:00when they are confirmed, thereby blurring the line and separation of powers?
- 34:04Because you have a lot of these unofficial, what they call litmus tests for a president or,
- 34:10excuse me, for judicial nominees where judicial nominees have a certain whatever their question
- 34:19about their views, they they make clear what their views are on certain issues.
- 34:24And and congress obviously questions them too.
- 34:27But presidents, a lot of times, they will pick them based, if on whether their viewpoints
- 34:34align with the president's on various issues.
- 34:39And then, obviously, congress will accordingly vote when they or when the senate votes on
- 34:47judicial nominees, it will accordingly vote based on whether their views are in line with
- 34:53the judicial nominees.
- 34:56So is there too much of a partisan feeling going on, which is thereby presidents and
- 35:05congress are just going along with the supreme court nominee purely because they just think
- 35:10the same exact way and going against the nominee currently because they don't think the
- 35:17same exact way.
- 35:18Are outside groups having too much of an influence on in putting nominees forward for
- 35:24the president to nominate and for congress to confirm the nomination of?
- 35:31So it's not just a matter of it's one of those cases where it's not just a matter of whether
- 35:37the president is taking too much of a lead and too much power on the initiative, but whether
- 35:45another branch of government is basically just letting them take too much power.
- 35:52And then lastly, before we move on to more specifically Donald Trump and the separation of
- 35:59powers is we have what's called the political question doctrine.
- 36:04So this is a pretty murky concept, but the basic idea is an issue is so politically
- 36:11charged.
- 36:12It's so divisive.
- 36:14Federal courts should not hear it.
- 36:16And it's typically a case that involves a spat between the executive and legislative branches
- 36:21as to which branch thinks they have the power on a given issue.
- 36:28And SCOTUS Supreme Court expanded on this doctrine in the Baker versus Carr case in 1962,
- 36:35and they came up with six factors to determine if something was a, quote, unquote, political
- 36:40question.
- 36:42If there is something in The US constitution that dictates which part of the government
- 36:46handles the issue, if there is a judicial standard for resolving it, if there is a
- 36:51nonjudicial policy determination that decides the issue, if the court can independently
- 36:58resolve the issue while respecting the role of the other two branches of government, if there
- 37:04is an unusual need to fully adhere to a political decision already made, and if there
- 37:10is a potential for embarrassment from multiple pronouncements by various departments on one
- 37:15question.
- 37:17So it's not a really straightforward process.
- 37:20Even with that criteria, what constitutes a political question is inherently ambiguous, and
- 37:25there's been much disagreement among both current and former justices as to what falls
- 37:32into the category of a political question or even if the political question doctrine has a
- 37:37constitutional basis.
- 37:39Some some justices think it's a bunch of crap anyways and that they should rule on these
- 37:44issues anyways.
- 37:46But the ultimate questions for separation of powers when it comes to the political question
- 37:51doctrine to think about, does the political question doctrine allow for the executive or
- 37:56legislative branches to take too much power on a given issue?
- 38:00Should the courts step in regardless and say, this is the executive branch's responsibility.
- 38:05This is the legislative branch's responsibility.
- 38:07This is both their responsibility.
- 38:11Are the courts not properly asserting their responsibility?
- 38:14Again, we talk about how the judiciary naturally has a limited range in being able to
- 38:23administer their powers.
- 38:26Whereas Congress can write laws, executive branch enforces laws, judicial branch doesn't
- 38:32have that kind of power, but are they still not properly asserting their responsibility?
- 38:38Should they step in regardless of what the issue is?
- 38:41Is the political question, a, does it have a constitutional basis?
- 38:44And b, even even if it has a constitutional basis constitutional basis or not, is the
- 38:51courts not sufficiently asserting its responsibility in interpreting the constitution
- 38:59in these cases?
- 39:02So that's just an, general overview of some real key debates that deal with the separation
- 39:09of powers and checks and balances and what what the implications are.
- 39:16And it's food for thought for you to think about as to what actually upholds the
- 39:22separation of powers, what powers have actually been delegated to each individual branch.
- 39:27None of these are easy questions to answer.
- 39:29They don't have easy answers.
- 39:32A lot of people in politics like to make things sound simpler than they actually are.
- 39:36And the separation of powers is one such case.
- 39:40So it's, it's really is a complicated matter that needs more discussion on it, especially
- 39:48now when we consider Donald Trump.
- 39:53Is his administration adhering to the separation of powers of checks and balances?
- 39:59Obviously, for some people, he is.
- 40:01Some people, he's not.
- 40:03As alluded to at the beginning of the episode, we have some considerably divergent views on
- 40:08Donald Trump's second term in particular in terms of separation of powers, but that debate
- 40:13can also be applied to his first term.
- 40:14So for opponents, Donald Trump and allies such as Elon Musk with Doge, which is the Department
- 40:20of Government Efficiency, they're overstepping the bounds of executive power circumventing
- 40:26Congress, bending courts to their will for supporters of Donald Trump.
- 40:31Say say Trump and his allies are acting within the confines of executive power, that he needs
- 40:36to act more expeditiously and that some cards are trying to infringe on his powers.
- 40:43So in terms of those separate that separation of powers, is Trump going outside what powers
- 40:49he has allowed as president?
- 40:51Is he thwarting checks and balances from the legislative and judicial branches?
- 40:56For a closer examination of this debate, let's look at the following three subject areas and
- 41:02discuss potential implications for separation of powers.
- 41:06Executive orders in general, which both both for his first and second term, but more so for
- 41:12his second term.
- 41:13We just talked about in the last section about executive orders as a whole regardless of
- 41:17president.
- 41:18Now let's apply it more to Donald Trump's case, cuts in federal spending, and the end of
- 41:25Chevron deference.
- 41:26And I'll explain that a little bit more.
- 41:28That technically happened near the end of Biden's term.
- 41:31It was in 2024, but it happened in large part because of three Supreme Court nominees by
- 41:39Donald Trump being part of the majority decision to end Chevron deference.
- 41:45So first, executive orders in general.
- 41:48Donald Trump's executive orders.
- 41:50As of 02/12/2025, Trump has signed 65 executive orders.
- 41:56It's a far faster pace than any president ever including Trump's total of 220 from his first
- 42:02term.
- 42:02Now that doesn't mean that he's going to break any records.
- 42:06It's just so far, his pace is a lot faster in terms of executive orders compared to any other
- 42:11president, except maybe a couple of other ones, maybe like FDR, because FDR also did also
- 42:18signed a lot of executive orders.
- 42:21And these executive orders cover a wide range of subject areas, including the southern
- 42:26border, cuts of federal spending by Doge, second amendment, paper straws, sanctions on
- 42:32the international criminal court, and tariffs.
- 42:35Course, there's a lot of other topics covered as well, but those are just some of the
- 42:39examples.
- 42:41So the implications for separation of powers, whether they're being broken or not, Consider
- 42:48our previous questions that we asked on the last section and some more specifically related
- 42:54to Donald Trump's executive orders.
- 42:57So is Donald Trump circumventing Congress to enact these laws?
- 43:03Or is or is Donald Trump simply enforcing laws that are already on the books or judicial
- 43:08rulings that have already been made, or is he just generally acting within his bounds to to
- 43:16administer his do the the executive branch's duties and responsibilities?
- 43:21Is it more just a matter of whether these, policies are harmful or beneficial, or is a
- 43:29real concern with separation of powers here?
- 43:34Is it the president's duty to enforce laws or to enact laws when Congress won't act or
- 43:40wouldn't act before a situation.
- 43:43Obviously, that depends on whether you think Congress is a, quote, unquote, do nothing
- 43:48Congress where they weren't doing what they were supposed to do.
- 43:51A lot of times, presidents on both the Democratic and the Republican sides have argued
- 43:57that about Congress before, particularly when Congress is controlled by the opposing party.
- 44:05Is Congress simply letting Donald Trump usurp the power to write laws, assuming that we
- 44:11believe that the executive orders are just simply.
- 44:16Writing legislation and not letting Congress do that.
- 44:20Are the courts simply letting Donald Trump exercise power unchecked and not declaring them
- 44:26unconstitutional?
- 44:29If the ultimate outcome of these executive orders can be considered good, is there a
- 44:35potential breaking of the separation of powers through executive orders?
- 44:39Is that potential breaking warrants it if we consider the outcome good?
- 44:45How many people need to consider that outcome good?
- 44:49Or is it under no circumstances should we be breaking that separation of powers?
- 44:55All sorts of questions here that we really need to consider here.
- 44:58And I'm not, I'm not saying that Donald Trump is or isn't breaking the system of checks and
- 45:05balances of separation of powers.
- 45:07This is just these are questions to think about, and these are a lot of concerns that
- 45:11people have raised or have said is not actually an issue.
- 45:17Obviously, a large part depends on whether you support Donald Trump or not, but, nonetheless,
- 45:23these are questions that do need to be considered.
- 45:29Next area to talk about is the cuts in federal spending.
- 45:32So these cuts in spending on federal agencies and programs has primarily happened through the
- 45:39Department of Government Efficiency or DOGE for short short.
- 45:43Excuse me.
- 45:44And that was created through a Trump executive order, And that's included firing of employees,
- 45:50budget cuts, canceled contracts, and cuts either partially or fully include the consumer
- 45:59financial protection bureau, the CFPB, USAID, Department of Education, Department of Energy,
- 46:06US Forest Services.
- 46:08So pretty wide ranging cuts.
- 46:12The exact breakdown, we don't necessarily know for certain, but, obviously, there's been a lot
- 46:17of news stories about what has been cut.
- 46:20But in any case, we need to think about what these cuts in federal spending, the implication
- 46:26for separation of powers.
- 46:27Never mind the fact that or, I mean, of course, one considers the fact that Doge was done
- 46:33through an executive order.
- 46:34So then you go back to the debate regarding separation of powers for executive orders.
- 46:40But besides that, some other questions to really think about.
- 46:46Given many of these executive agencies funding from Congress is the executive branch,
- 46:51essentially taking the power of the purse away from Congress by cutting programs and
- 46:57workforce.
- 46:59Since Congress has the power of the purse, they control funding for executive agencies,
- 47:05especially from the US house since that's where appropriations originate.
- 47:10Is the president basically taking the power of the purse to determine whether these executive
- 47:17agencies get funding?
- 47:21Or is it within the executive branch's power to do that because these are executive branch
- 47:25agencies regardless of whether Congress has funded them?
- 47:28Cause Congress doesn't just fund executive branch agencies.
- 47:31It funds all sorts of things related to the judicial branch, to the states, to local
- 47:35governments.
- 47:37So if it's an executive branch agency, is the president or and the executive branch in
- 47:43general well within their rights to make these cuts because these are executive branch
- 47:48agencies?
- 47:50Because some of these are independent agencies where the president is supposed to have more
- 47:55limits on removing leadership, is the president circumventing these limits?
- 48:02And another question to consider, do federal courts have any capacity to limit Trump and
- 48:07Doge in their attempts to make these cuts, Or would this be a matter of the political
- 48:14question doctor we talked about where something is so highly charged the court should not step
- 48:19in?
- 48:21All sorts of things to really think about when it comes to these these when it comes to these
- 48:29cuts of federal spending.
- 48:30It's not just a matter of whether we think this cut needs to happen or this cut should not have
- 48:36happened.
- 48:36It's what does it fundamentally mean for checks and balances?
- 48:43Is the executive branch going too far in its powers to cut its own agencies?
- 48:51And then lastly, talk about the end of Chevron deference.
- 48:56So Chevron deference is the principle that federal courts defer to a federal agency's
- 49:03interpretation of an ambiguous statute that congress delegated to the agency to administer.
- 49:11And it derives its name from the case Chevron USA Incorporated versus Natural Resources
- 49:16Defense Council Incorporated.
- 49:18That was a 1984 ruling, and it concerned disagreement over a change in the EPA's
- 49:26interpretation of a permitting provision of the Clean Air Act of 1977.
- 49:31Now the actual arguments of the case are not not particularly relevant here.
- 49:37We're just worried about the actual results of the case, which is that Chevron deference.
- 49:43So federal courts basically just say the federal agency was tasked by Congress to figure
- 49:50out the meaning of a statute.
- 49:51So it's up to that federal agency to determine that.
- 49:57So the, the, the, the review process for Chevron deference courts consider one
- 50:03congress's clear intent in passing a law, and two, if the courts found ambiguities in the
- 50:09law, whether an agency's rule was reasonably construed and not arbitrary.
- 50:16But in 2024, a couple SCOTUS cases overturned Chevron deference.
- 50:21Again, three of those supreme court justices who are part of that majority ruling were, Amy
- 50:29Coney Barrett, Brett Kavanaugh, and Neil Gorsuch who were all three of them were Donald
- 50:35Trump nominees from his first term.
- 50:38So the courts ultimately ruled that against Chevron deference, meaning federal courts may
- 50:45not just defer to an agency's interpretation of an ambiguous statute.
- 50:51So some of the implications for the separation of powers here was in the case when Chevron
- 50:57deference was intact, was Chevron deference giving too much power to the executive branch
- 51:04in interpreting congressional statutes.
- 51:07Did Chevron deference leads to the court seeing too much of their own responsibilities in
- 51:12interpreting laws to the executive branch?
- 51:16Well, should the courts have taken much more of an initiative in that regard?
- 51:20And was Congress also ceding too much responsibility by having an executive branch
- 51:25agency figure out what the statute meant?
- 51:28No.
- 51:30Those questions, even though Chevron deference is now defunct, that is still those are still
- 51:36things to consider in case Chevron deference ever became a thing again in the future.
- 51:42Or even though the court has ruled that Chevron deference is not a real legal concept.
- 51:51If executive agencies attempt to interpret an ambiguous statute in the future might might
- 51:59still be an issue.
- 52:00But in any case with Chevron deference now defunct, has the executive branch become too
- 52:07limited in their power to execute laws?
- 52:10Do they need the ability to interpret statutes from Congress that may be ambiguous so that
- 52:16they can perform their function in executing laws?
- 52:21With Chevron deference now defunct, is the judicial branch now infringing too much on the
- 52:26ability of the executive and legislative branches?
- 52:31So there's a lot of things to really, consider here when it comes to separation powers.
- 52:39Separation powers as a concept is pretty straightforward.
- 52:44It's the idea that executive branch has some duties which regards enforcing and executing
- 52:51laws.
- 52:51The legislative branch has some duties which concern writing slash legislating laws, and
- 52:57additional branch judicial branch has specific duties of interpreting laws.
- 53:03So that is pretty straightforward.
- 53:08But in practice, how those branches actually get to perform their functions becomes a lot
- 53:16murkier.
- 53:18And and when is is there a when when the branches are interacting with each other, are
- 53:24they is one branch infringing on another branch's ability to perform its duties in
- 53:31certain regards?
- 53:32Like with presidents with executive orders, are they infringing on congress's ability to write
- 53:39laws?
- 53:43Or so or, again, separation of powers isn't necessarily just about is one branch taking too
- 53:49much power for themselves.
- 53:50Is there one or both of the other branches?
- 53:54Are they willingly ceding power to another branch too much?
- 53:59So it's a little bit of a fault going all around, not just the one who's taking too much
- 54:04power.
- 54:05If we assume that they are taking too much power is the, are the other branches basically
- 54:11just laying down for that other branch to take the reins.
- 54:16All sorts of questions to really think about, and hopefully, I laid laid them out in a
- 54:25hopefully, I made the questions themselves actually clear.
- 54:28The actual debate and factors in the questions are not clear, but, hopefully, the question
- 54:36itself is clear enough that you can really start to think about it yourself.
- 54:42And sometimes with the separation of powers, we also there's also a tendency for people to
- 54:48filter it through their partisan lens or their ideological lens.
- 54:52If it's a president that somebody likes, they might be a little bit more lenient on their
- 54:59interpretation of separation of powers.
- 55:01Whereas if it's a president they don't like, they might suddenly care a lot more about the
- 55:05separation of powers.
- 55:07And it's it's unfortunate.
- 55:09I think there is a lot of and this is this is much this is more of an opinion I'm talking
- 55:13about now.
- 55:14One of the relatively rare instances where I talk about my opinion, but I think there is a
- 55:19serious issue with people's concept of separation of powers also being too predicated
- 55:31on whether they actually like the president or whether they like the majority of the Supreme
- 55:37Court or whether they party in congress, but the that that is con a majority in one of both
- 55:44chambers in Congress, whether somebody likes that majority party or or strongly dislikes the
- 55:54majority on the Supreme Court or the majority control of Congress.
- 55:59It's something that we you know, it's this separation of powers, all these questions about
- 56:05whether checks and balances are being upheld, is one thing, but are we also letting our
- 56:10personal opinions about these individuals also cloud what we think about whether they are
- 56:19overstepping their boundaries.
- 56:21If if we said it wasn't Donald Trump that was doing all these specific actions and it was Joe
- 56:26Biden or vice versa, whenever Joe Biden in implemented executive orders and instead it was
- 56:32Donald Trump, Do our opinions change?
- 56:35And for some people, those opinions do shift a little bit.
- 56:38Maybe they don't realize it, but sometimes we let our opinions on these specific individuals
- 56:45dictate what we think about whether the separation of powers is being infringed upon.
- 56:54So just a little bit of food for thought.
- 56:57It is.
- 56:59These are very important questions because undeniably checks and balances are a core part
- 57:05of our political system, but how do we best uphold them?
- 57:11How best do we determine how much each branch can check the other, or what is a case in
- 57:19certain cases, are they checking and balancing against one or two other branches?
- 57:26So just some proof of thought.
- 57:28But anyways, that is today's podcast episode.
- 57:31A little bit of a longer one, but these are when you talk about these kinds of questions,
- 57:36it it it definitely gets a little bit more into the you get a lot more into the weeds and have
- 57:42to have to discuss it a little bit further now.
- 57:46So, obviously, love to hear what you think about all those questions, but we are gonna
- 57:51wrap up today's episode.
- 57:52So as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 57:55I have, the show notes, my Facebook, LinkedIn, my book, why independence rarely win elections,
- 58:01and now they could become more competitive on an ebook and paperback format on Amazon.
- 58:07There are some other bookstores in particular, but Amazon obviously gonna be the more, well
- 58:13known one.
- 58:15I have an educational email course, a very short series of emails, emails on how, we
- 58:23unintentionally.
- 58:25And whenever we're trying to decrease polarization in this country, several of the
- 58:30ways that we unintentionally increase polarization and how we can correct those
- 58:35issues.
- 58:36I have the link for that in the show notes as well.
- 58:40But other than that, we're gonna wrap things up.
- 58:42So, again, thank you so much for listening.
- 58:45Until next time, take care.