Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Murdaugh Murders Archive: Alex Murdaugh And The Lies That Caught Up To Him
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the program. The
- 0:04Alec Murdau trial is coming to its conclusion and to
- 0:08say that it has been explosive would be an understatement.
- 0:13But now that we're getting down to the nitty gritty,
- 0:16the thing that stands out to me the most is
- 0:19that Alec Murda admitted that he was a liar in
- 0:22open court. And once somebody does that on the witness stand,
- 0:26I think it's very difficult for the jurors to look
- 0:29at him as anything else but a liar. I mean,
- 0:32you have this guy admitting in his own words that
- 0:35he lied to the police the night of these murders
- 0:38and continued on with that life until video evidence was
- 0:41provided in the courtroom and in front of jurors. So
- 0:45if that video evidence was never provided, we all know
- 0:48that Alec Murda wouldn't have got up on that stand
- 0:51and admitted any of that. His whole entire story was
- 0:54blown out of the water because of that video. And
- 0:57for me, if you're lying about the very basics of something,
- 1:00I am certainly going to assume that you're lying about
- 1:03everything else. So I'm sure that there are at least
- 1:05some members of the jury that feel the exact same way. Now.
- 1:09I don't know which way the verdict's going to go,
- 1:12but in my opinion, Alec Murda is certainly guilty of
- 1:16these crimes. Today's article is from CNN headline Alec Murda's
- 1:22lie about his whereabouts and is reversal waigh heavily as
- 1:26murder trial finishes, Legal experts say. This article was authored
- 1:32by Elizabeth Wolfe. With Alec Murda's murder trial nearing its end,
- 1:38legal experts who have participated in some of America's most
- 1:42high profile cases joined CNN Wednesday night to examine key
- 1:46questions that have loomed over the preceding, including whether Murda's
- 1:50admission of lying to investigators could help or hurt his case. Murda,
- 1:56a once prominent attorney in South Carolina's Low Country, is
- 2:00accused of fatally shooting his wife, Margaret Maggie Murdau, and
- 2:04son Paul Murda on the family's expansive hunting estate on
- 2:08June seventh of twenty twenty one. After hearing weeks of
- 2:13witness testimony, jurors will continue hearing closing arguments Thursday before
- 2:17they deliberate over whether Murda is guilty of two counts
- 2:21of murder and two weapons charges to which he is
- 2:25pleaded not guilty. It comes down to two things that
- 2:29every single prosecutor has to contend with. I'm talking motive
- 2:34and opportunity, said CNN Senior legal analyst Laura Coates, who
- 2:39anchored the televised panel discussion. Here are the key takeaways
- 2:43from the legal experts discussion of the case. Well, in
- 2:46my opinion, he certainly had motive. We have the whole
- 2:49situation break off with his son, the boat accident that
- 2:53really spiraled things out of control, and from there people
- 2:56started taking a look at the financials and it was
- 2:59all for Alec Murda once that started happening. Bro is
- 3:03involved in all kinds of financial malfeasance, embezzlement, stealing from clients.
- 3:08I'm sure there's more that they missed too. Murda's lied
- 3:12to investigators could undermine his credibility with jurs. I know
- 3:17if I was a jur this would be a huge
- 3:19problem and it would be a gigantic roadblock for them
- 3:23to get over. Meaning the defense. Now, I know that
- 3:25the prosecution hasn't hit a grand slam here the investigation
- 3:30was sloppy. Some of the testimony wasn't great, But Alec
- 3:34Murda is such a boob and his performance on the
- 3:38stand was so bad in my opinion that as a
- 3:41jur when you add all of that up, plus the
- 3:44fact that he was lying, then it would be very
- 3:47difficult for the defense to convince me, even within a
- 3:50reasonable doubt, that Alec Murda was innocent. In his two
- 3:55day testimony last week, Murda admitted he lied to investigators
- 3:59when he told them he hadn't been to his estate
- 4:02dog kennels on the evening of the killings until he
- 4:04reported finding the bodies there. That admission came after multiple
- 4:09witnesses for the prosecution identified his voice in a video
- 4:13taken on Paul's phone at or near the kennels at
- 4:16eight forty four pm, shortly before prosecutors contend the killings happened,
- 4:21and that video is what sunk them. He would have
- 4:24went on with that alibi until the San Janad festival.
- 4:28This guy wasn't going to admit anything. He lied from
- 4:31the beginning. He lied to his family. In fact, he's
- 4:33been lying for all of these years that he was
- 4:36a drug addict. So he was well versed with lying.
- 4:39He was very comfortable with it, and that's exactly what
- 4:42he did. According to the prosecution, Murda testified that he
- 4:47lied because of paranoid thinking stemming from his opioid addiction.
- 4:51During Wednesday's panel discussion, attorney Glenda Hatchett said that his
- 4:56admission might have come too late. I think the fact
- 4:59that he waited until there was testimony in the courtroom
- 5:02from multiple people and then said, oh, yeah, I was
- 5:05there and I was paranoid, Really, I think it creates
- 5:08a credibility gap, said Hatchet, who represented the family of
- 5:12Falando Castile, a black man fatally shot by police in
- 5:17twenty and sixteen. And that's the rub for me too.
- 5:21The fact that he waited until there was open testimony
- 5:24in court that was challenging his assertion is just bananas.
- 5:28And I don't know any jer could look at that
- 5:31and say to themselves that the testimony he gave after
- 5:34that is credible. Once you have that credibility gap, I
- 5:38think that it can also take your other testimony, whether
- 5:41you're credible or not. Hatchet, also a former Chief Presiding
- 5:45Juvenile Court judge and Georgia's Fulton County said prosecutors have
- 5:50tried to paint Murda as a dishonest and disgraced attorney
- 5:54who killed his wife and son to draw attention from
- 5:57investigations into financial misconduct allegation against him. In his testimony,
- 6:03Murdau repeatedly denied carrying out the killings, but admitted to
- 6:06stealing millions of dollars from his former clients and law firm.
- 6:11Did you see the video of the one gentleman the
- 6:14name is escaping me right now that he stole money
- 6:16from the guy that was a paraplegic and the whole nine.
- 6:20What sort of animal does that? And even if he
- 6:23was found innocent of these murders, he's still an absolute
- 6:27complete scumbag for stealing from his clients. You know, the
- 6:30people that can least afford to be stolen from. That's
- 6:33who Alec Murdau was targeting. This kennel video is the
- 6:38most important piece of evidence. Prosecutors have tried to overcome
- 6:42a lack of direct evidence, such as eyewitnesses linking Murda
- 6:46to the killings. They have built their case in large
- 6:49part using videos, photos, and cell phone and location data
- 6:53to try and convince the jury that Murda is lying
- 6:57about his actions that night. The prosecut Hkushan to get
- 7:00their conviction, has got to do away with to exclude
- 7:04every reasonable hypothesis of innocence, said criminal defense to lawyer
- 7:09Marc O'Mara, who represented the man who fatally shot Trayvon
- 7:13Martin in twenty twelve. I think this kennel video is
- 7:17the most important piece of evidence in this case for
- 7:20the prosecution because it explodes the big lie, said Lonnie Coombs,
- 7:25a former Los Angeles County prosecutor. I'm talking about the
- 7:28big lie of his alibi where he initially said I
- 7:32was not there at the crime scene. And for me,
- 7:35that's what it always comes back to. And the fact
- 7:37that his defense team put him on the stand knowing
- 7:40about all of these credibility issues shows you that they
- 7:43were really grasping at straws here and they knew that
- 7:46they were up against it. Murda maintains Maggie and Paul
- 7:50were alive when he left the kennels to return to
- 7:52the house, and that he eventually drove to visit his
- 7:55mother in a nearby town. He found the bodies near
- 7:59the kennels after returning. He said, authorities say he called
- 8:03nine one one after ten pm. Prosecutors, however, have argued
- 8:08he carried out the killings and then tried to create
- 8:10an alibi by leaving the property. They also appoint the
- 8:14videos showing he changed clothes sometimes between when he was
- 8:18with Paul that day and when he called nine to
- 8:20one one, though the defenses suggested the change wasn't unusual
- 8:25for him, and the defenses contended that Paul Murda was
- 8:28a heavy sweater and down in the humidity of the South,
- 8:32he was always changing his clothes. And honestly, I'd be
- 8:36changing my clothes all the time if I live down
- 8:38south too. I cannot stand the humidity. I hate the sweat,
- 8:42and I really hate when my clothes are stuck to me.
- 8:45The big question for juror's coach said, is did Murda
- 8:49have time to commit murder, get rid of the guns,
- 8:52clean himself up, leave and return in about an hour
- 8:55and seventeen minutes or is there a reasonable doubt? And
- 8:59you can certainly make the case that there is some
- 9:02reasonable doubt here. But for me, I keep going back
- 9:05to the fact that this man lied, and not only lied,
- 9:08but admitted to it in open court. Murdach claims that
- 9:13he was taking two thousand milligrams of opioids a day
- 9:16is medically possible. During his testimony last week, Murda said
- 9:21he had a decade long addiction to opiate painkillers and
- 9:24that it contributed to paranoid thinking that led him to
- 9:27lie to investigators. He testified he took more than two
- 9:31thousand milligrams a day of oxy codone in the months
- 9:35before Maggie and Paul's death. As my addiction evolved over time,
- 9:39I would get in these situations or circumstances where I
- 9:43would get paranoid thinking, Murda said on the stand on
- 9:46June the seventh. I wasn't thinking clearly. I don't think
- 9:49I was capable of reason, and I lied about being
- 9:52down there. Oh, give me a break, such bs. Oh.
- 9:56I was on opioids, so I didn't know the difference
- 9:59if I was there or not, and I was paranoid,
- 10:01so I lied. I don't know who's buying that. Patients
- 10:06typically start at about ten to twenty milligrams a few
- 10:09times a day, CNN Chief Medical correspondent Sanjay Gupta said
- 10:13Wednesday night, while two thousand milligrams sounds astronomical in comparison.
- 10:18Taking that much daily is possible. Well, there's no doubt.
- 10:22I've had friends who have had pill addictions and they
- 10:24were taking a insane amount of pills each day. But
- 10:28the problem is they didn't have the money that Alec
- 10:31Murda has. So eventually that pill addiction, well you know
- 10:35the story, it became a Heroin addiction, people can gradually
- 10:39build up increasing tolerance to these drugs, these opioids. This
- 10:43is not unheard of, Gupta said. Over time, people can
- 10:46increasingly escalate the dose. It is tough to know what
- 10:50the impact of opioid addiction would have on a specific
- 10:53person's behavior, Gupta said. Murda, who says he is now
- 10:58drug free, testified he took the high doses in part
- 11:01to avoid the symptoms of withdrawal, which can include vomiting, dizziness, depression,
- 11:06and confusion. People can start to develop significant tolerance to
- 11:10the point where they're no longer taking the medication to
- 11:13get high or to develop euphoria, but rather just to
- 11:17feel normal and not have withdrawal, Goopeda said. And that's
- 11:21with all opiates, whether they're street level or coming from
- 11:24the doctor. A lot of people think that if they
- 11:27get pills from the doctor, then they're safe. But the
- 11:30fact is they are not. And whenever you're dealing with
- 11:33opioids you need to be very, very careful with what
- 11:36you're doing. It's very easy to get a Jones. But
- 11:39do I think that affected Alec Murda and is thinking
- 11:42that night. I do not. And do I think that
- 11:44his alibi is credible? I do not. But at the
- 11:48end of the day, it doesn't matter what I think.
- 11:51It matters what the jury thinks. And soon we should
- 11:55all know exactly how they feel. All right, folks, that's
- 11:59gonna do it for this one. All of the information
- 12:01that goes with the episode can be found in the
- 12:04description box.