Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yore De'ah 221:2-4. Vows: Parameters of Benefit

Transcript

Yore De'ah 221:2-4. Vows: Parameters of Benefit · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Fine, OK, good morning. We are some ration of Aleph
• 0:04
  who's adorin safe base Boulder Hana make a Vero someone who
• 0:11
  again his mother Hana makes another against his friend.
• 0:14
  Now again I know Yahoo Leafra Hovo.
• 0:17
  So even though so the you know the meaning he's not going to
• 0:22
  give middle Hana here means he's not going to give his friend any
• 0:25
  Hana. He is allowed to go ahead and to
• 0:29
  pay his debts. Pay his debt.
• 0:34
  A feeling higher Loma. The the reason Ignar says the
• 0:38
  reason the reason is because it's Maria Hari.
• 0:41
  It's not Maria Hari is is a concept that that you're trying
• 0:48
  to escape. You're trying to help him escape
• 0:51
  damage. That's not fun, No, and if, for
• 0:53
  example, you know exactly lions coming to the the the mushroom
• 0:57
  is lions coming to attack a person, then you scare him away.
• 1:00
  So then so then that's not Hana, that's not that's not getting
• 1:05
  benefit. That's that's like a very it's a
• 1:10
  very low. It's it's not considered giving
• 1:12
  benefit. It's considered like doing.
• 1:17
  It's stopping stopping him from getting hurt or in other cases
• 1:23
  if there's a flood coming and he diverts into his feet towards
• 1:26
  his field and he diverts the flood these types of things.
• 1:29
  That's called Maria Kharis. It's ultra over here.
• 1:31
  The for Ajovo is not giving him Hana.
• 1:34
  It's not being Mahana him. It is it is considered, it is
• 1:38
  considered Maria Khari, although the others, there are others who
• 1:42
  say that the, that the shot is that, you know, there's a,
• 1:46
  there's a question, the Gemara that it's, it's also the point
• 1:53
  over here is also that he's not going to, you know, he and he's
• 1:57
  not going to and he's not going to get paid.
• 1:59
  He's not going to get paid back for it.
• 2:01
  He's not paying his clothes and asking him for money.
• 2:05
  He's just paying the Cove, meaning his his money's he's
• 2:09
  throwing. You know, he's just helping the
• 2:10
  guy out from not getting the from pushing off the the ball
• 2:14
  Cove, but he's you know, and if he was doing like a Schlikos and
• 2:19
  things like that, then that would be an issue.
• 2:22
  The Filu Imhayelo Mashkun, Miata Malva power is there.
• 2:26
  We should be low and not on Mashkun.
• 2:28
  And even if the Malva had a Mashkun and he paid the Hove,
• 2:31
  sorry to laugh 0 the Liva Hana, sorry, he has to give it back to
• 2:35
  the Liva, who is awesome. Now, for example, let's say the
• 2:39
  guy you guys going to he has that money to pay his electric
• 2:42
  bills. He pays his electric bill even
• 2:43
  though, yes, he's going to go ahead and he's going to get
• 2:48
  electricity now or you know, but that's not the you know, but
• 2:52
  that you know it's not going to get cut off.
• 2:53
  But that's not that that wouldn't be considered the on
• 2:55
  the electricity is put back on even that it's called it's like
• 3:02
  the mash gun. It's it's not giving him on.
• 3:05
  No, it's taking away Hezek. I know you're right.
• 3:08
  He ain't put back on. That sounds to me it's not
• 3:10
  listen, it's not worse than than a mashka because it's something
• 3:14
  Mamela. It's not anything coming from
• 3:16
  him fresh him also it's not it's it seems to be match man like
• 3:27
  that. It sounds like it yeah, but also
• 3:31
  the shock points. The shock points out a little
• 3:34
  bit straighter that it has to be.
• 3:36
  He pays it without his Das because if he becomes, like I
• 3:38
  said, it becomes a schlea for him.
• 3:41
  We're going to see is if Shlikos is is doing him a favor with Tom
• 3:45
  Shlikos. But if he just does it with all
• 3:47
  his knowledge, so then that's that's OK.
• 3:50
  The Yahoo loves an Asisto bottom and he's allowed to support this
• 3:54
  guy's wife and kids if they need it because he's not going to get
• 3:59
  my he's not going to get even the the point over here.
• 4:04
  What's the Shyla? The Shyla is, is that all this
• 4:06
  guy's high have to go ahead and support his family.
• 4:08
  This guy sends a monthly, you know, monthly thing to support
• 4:12
  this guy's family. Now he doesn't have to go ahead
• 4:14
  and put the money out. The Alpha Ponting is not Hana
• 4:22
  and even still, you know, the the point is also that they can
• 4:26
  go ahead and it's not mavish, not Mamish David, because he
• 4:31
  could go out. He you know, if he didn't have
• 4:32
  the money, it could be he could go, he can go snoring or he can,
• 4:38
  you know, or, you know, or or they could, you know, live on a
• 4:40
  loaf of bread, whatever the that he can do the basic, basic
• 4:43
  Mizonos, you know, and he's supporting more.
• 4:46
  That's not the, you know, that, that that's not enough, but a
• 4:50
  few like Kanani, even a lot of Kanani, but also Lozenbei bane
• 4:56
  to me, a bane to her because that's because that that's
• 4:58
  saving him money. He has to, he has to go ahead
• 5:01
  and feed, feed his animals. So that's not a that's not a
• 5:07
  few. Why isn't edit different than
• 5:12
  the because it's part of the Yeah, it could be or yeah, he
• 5:23
  could go he could go he could go make go make his own money go
• 5:26
  get get a job make his own money with obviously for sure.
• 5:29
  So the of the of the other he can go make his own money, you
• 5:34
  know, to support himself. You know he's he'll be allowed
• 5:36
  to do that. Yeah, but only cow OK, so or so
• 5:42
  has to take it out or someone you know it's.
• 5:51
  You know, it's considered Hana's giving him Hana to his Mama, not
• 5:55
  you know, it's it's giving also, you know it's not they're not.
• 5:58
  People are different. People are different.
• 6:00
  People have to live. You hear your hear your Bahamas
• 6:04
  Mama is is is Mimono. And yeah, like, I guess it's a
• 6:08
  shy like it could go out the past year.
• 6:09
  I don't know about the Yeah, I know, I know in the shop.
• 6:15
  I know, but upon him then there is a discussion in the
• 6:19
  discussion. I didn't get into it in the in
• 6:22
  in the Farsha in the in the tour in the in the bar about what's
• 6:27
  the difference between Evan and Bahama.
• 6:30
  I I didn't get into it so much, but there is a discussion there
• 6:34
  also alarm during Micra and it's also to teach him teach him to
• 6:41
  the question is Micra mean commercial doesn't mean to read
• 6:49
  also Lando Mika kiven schmoter Leto scar Allah since it's
• 6:53
  motive to go ahead and to take and to take get paid for
• 6:57
  teaching him teaching him teaching him Tara teaching him
• 7:03
  homage Vumalando kinam into Shimahano.
• 7:07
  It's most it's also to do it because he person can take wages
• 7:11
  for that he can take money. He can take money, he get paid
• 7:15
  for it. And even if he even if and he's
• 7:22
  you know, since it's motor to take scar and he's he's not
• 7:26
  taking money. If he takes money, it's OK, but
• 7:28
  he's doing it for free. So he's saving him money.
• 7:31
  The Gemara Shyla and the Gemara, What Mikra is, does it mean?
• 7:35
  Does it mean that Well, you know, it's it's because it's,
• 7:41
  it's the reason why he can take money.
• 7:43
  The Gemara says an Ibakina of A10 Burkina that it's that it's
• 7:48
  also to take to take money. We'll see of a Malando Madrid
• 7:51
  Salahos to teach Madrid, but he can teach him that because that
• 8:03
  is Afan Ibakhina. I mean he can't take money for
• 8:05
  that. The reason he can take money
• 8:07
  Mikaradin for Mikra is because either he's teaching him how to
• 8:11
  read and that's a that's a technical skill or he's, you
• 8:15
  know, teaching him Dick Duk, which is a technical skill or
• 8:18
  he's teaching him or for kids, you know, we'll see kids.
• 8:22
  You know, we'll see my kids. He's there.
• 8:24
  He's he's babysitting them. The Hushalayomahanes or the
• 8:29
  oyster Shalam Denu but. What Mikra because it's
• 8:39
  contrasted with, right? No, the Kumar, the Kumar.
• 8:41
  The Kumar discusses it. The Kumar goes those often.
• 8:44
  The Kumar where it says it's different that that the reason
• 8:46
  why you can take Scar is because he's teaching him a skill as
• 8:50
  well. Actually, the grasses could be a
• 8:52
  piece of palm him. You know, they didn't have, you
• 8:56
  know, reading books they had Kumish and including Kumish is
• 9:01
  also learning how to read and learning, you know, whatever all
• 9:04
  these things like that. So you know, so the but those
• 9:10
  are motor because they're they had he can't take money is no
• 9:14
  Hana with is no Hana with it. And even though it could be he
• 9:17
  would he would the guy enjoys, you know, stuff.
• 9:20
  It's admits, it's lovely and it's admits.
• 9:23
  So I think it's not considered Hana as long as the guy doesn't
• 9:28
  make him a Schlitz to ask him to learn because then he's giving
• 9:30
  him a knob by asking him. But how you know Shimoto lethal
• 9:34
  scar. They know that's motor to take
• 9:36
  to get paid off all of Madrich a call ulcer nowadays.
• 9:41
  We'll see that Iran ratio involved.
• 9:42
  It's a discussion and then the rush Tysius everyone, everyone
• 9:48
  everyone says it says that it will Texas 2 reasons why it's
• 9:53
  mutter nowadays 1 is because it's either it's Carbatala.
• 9:57
  Well, one is because people if people put in their are putting
• 10:00
  their you know their time into it.
• 10:02
  You know they have to live. You know they don't.
• 10:06
  You know the guys are prisons are ready.
• 10:08
  A person's teaching all day. He needs he needs Pranasa also,
• 10:15
  it says also Equili Alma. We're not here.
• 10:18
  We're talking about proper, proper wages.
• 10:20
  If someone just takes car batalo, like a very like minimum
• 10:23
  wage, you know, just so, like, you know, to teach someone
• 10:27
  something just like he can, you know, you know, make it, make a
• 10:30
  minute, make it make make make a minimum salary.
• 10:33
  He's not getting like, you know, paid, he's getting like a
• 10:36
  minimum salary. So that's also Tasa says is is
• 10:39
  pusher. That's that's motor even could
• 10:41
  be even then that's not considered right, right.
• 10:48
  I'm saying mutter Mitam. Now I'm saying these are all the
• 10:50
  hovamine is but Mitam Nidari it's going to be is going to be
• 10:55
  all sort of all I made is Benoy Philo Mikra motor.
• 10:59
  But to go ahead and to teach his son because the guys have to pay
• 11:05
  a pay Ravi. So then a Philo Mikra motor.
• 11:10
  Even even then even Mikra is is is motor is motor motor le
• 11:21
  Shamshoi because and he's allowed to be crucial base of
• 11:26
  Oval crucial base Americas. He's allowed to pour him a cup
• 11:29
  something to drink if he's using coast of a base of Oval of base
• 11:35
  of base America, which is not exactly becovered.
• 11:38
  It's a bit of a you know, here, so you I'll pour into the chill
• 11:43
  sedan cup here. You take a drink from that.
• 11:45
  That's not that's not normal and that's a bit of a stickle
• 11:48
  bizarro. Even so that's OK.
• 11:50
  I'll go on the Lam. It is Benoy the material or the
• 12:00
  Madrid afilo Amarloche antenna. Some say even if he says I'm
• 12:04
  Daniel, what we said before by Madrid, it's a schlichos.
• 12:07
  Schlichos is motor. In this case, the it's only a
• 12:10
  schlichos, which is something which is high in schlichos like
• 12:13
  by truma or something which is which needs schlichos.
• 12:17
  He's an actual schlichos. He was just asking him.
• 12:20
  No, I didn't hold the drar mitzah any any drar mitzah
• 12:23
  except like korbanus and and truma.
• 12:26
  Also the the truma. Basically, we go litro and
• 12:32
  Trumos, like I said, also the ice look, the only things where
• 12:35
  he where he needs to have a shlia.
• 12:37
  He can't do it. Or, for example, if he wants the
• 12:39
  guy, the guy can. Can a guy be his moyal?
• 12:43
  Not so simple because he has to he's a he's he's he's he's a
• 12:47
  shlia to do it 'cause he misses little on the AAV.
• 12:49
  So he's high to Amana shlia. So it would be that would be
• 12:54
  that would be awesome. This would not affect the issues
• 12:57
  paying back. We won't even know.
• 13:04
  Yeah, no, Yeah, it doesn't. Yeah, it doesn't.
• 13:05
  It doesn't. Freshman Pierre Alcovitzva,
• 13:07
  because it's because he could go ahead and their wake and push
• 13:10
  out. He doesn't have to pay it.
• 13:11
  Who says he has to pay it now? If if he has to pay it now, it
• 13:14
  could be. It could be.
• 13:15
  There's different discussion about it.
• 13:17
  But. Right.
• 13:19
  But yeah, but Pierre Alcovitzva, it's all it's the whole
• 13:23
  question. What?
• 13:24
  It's not. It's a mitzvah, but it's a
• 13:25
  different type of mitzvah. It's like a bit of a, we'll have
• 13:28
  to get into that, but it's, it's a little bit a bit more of a
• 13:32
  vaguer mitzvah. Exactly.
• 13:35
  It's a bit I'm, it's a bit tired of talking about over here, even
• 13:38
  though it is. But I'm saying like, you know,
• 13:45
  you know fine Gimo Ruin also in the House of Al Shimen, also Al
• 13:51
  Cibito. If someone he answers the House
• 13:53
  of on Shimen, it's also to get to marry his his daughter,
• 13:57
  Cibito Tano Naira. It's also to marry to Shimen.
• 14:01
  Ruin can't marry, can't can't offer his daughter to Shimen if
• 14:04
  she's a Tanner or an IRA Lafisha die in Hebrew Shusoi and Skilu
• 14:10
  Shifko, the sham show. OK, I mean the be careful for
• 14:14
  the trainers here. I'll get tomatoes thrown at me,
• 14:16
  but I'll hold on him. It's it means that Alpha pique
• 14:21
  he's giving him it's it's obvious.
• 14:23
  You know, again, we're talking about the, you know, the Levites
• 14:26
  of it is he's giving him Hana because he's giving someone to
• 14:30
  to Mashamish him and to cook for him and stuff and whatever.
• 14:33
  So that and and she is Neksha of a type of his vicious because he
• 14:38
  has vicious to go ahead and to discussion the Gemara.
• 14:41
  Well, he's he has a certain amount of vicious over her.
• 14:43
  It's just to marry her after Mukashrain.
• 14:48
  He has a certain amount of Rashef.
• 14:50
  So therefore it's it's a will be also remix a shimin of
• 14:55
  Surinalov. And if Nix a shimin is also is
• 14:58
  also to him Montalisa Vito he then he he's he's allowed to
• 15:04
  then he's allowed to marry the daughter Alphabisha Patroy Mikhi
• 15:08
  of Mizaya Saha. Even though even though he's
• 15:13
  pottering the this, you know he's pottering, you know, he's
• 15:18
  getting puzzled from having to support her.
• 15:21
  But uncle panning that's that's OK.
• 15:24
  That's not a big deal. Even like ton of an IRA, because
• 15:30
  because that's that's not it's not his.
• 15:34
  It's not it's it's nothing, it's it's he's not giving him he's
• 15:38
  not getting enough from Shimon that even though they he has not
• 15:41
  the support that's not called that's not called Hana.
• 15:43
  That's like said before his, you know, no, this is even if it is
• 15:51
  Peter Abdullah Afiluktana, the Shah says anyone.
• 15:56
  What's the difference between the Ruben is up to Shimen or
• 15:58
  Shimen is up? Because if Ruben, if Ruben
• 16:01
  Austin his stuff on Shimen, so then he's giving him hung off
• 16:05
  from his shows. If Shimen is all if Shimen is
• 16:10
  ulcer to Ruben. So then and Ruben marries his
• 16:14
  daughter to Shimen. So then he's not getting hung
• 16:17
  off from Shimen. He's not he's not giving any
• 16:20
  physical hung off from Shimen. So that's fine.
• 16:24
  And Max all of it. I'm sorry.
• 16:26
  And he is allowed to go ahead and and to do Shabbos Aveda
• 16:33
  bench. And if say Bala Veda Surin the
• 16:35
  master, whether the nips, the Hussain of the Bala Veda is also
• 16:40
  to the master bench. And if, say master Surin the
• 16:42
  Bala Veda, it is mostly to go ahead and to and to master it
• 16:52
  well, Malcolm Schneider in scar Alzar again, because it's a
• 16:55
  mitzvah. Malcolm Manolin scar al
• 16:57
  observeda. However, in a place where the
• 17:00
  many gives that he gets a reward for returning for returning the
• 17:03
  return for for you know, Charles Aveda, which is a thing in this
• 17:09
  say Bala Veda assuring the master if the Hussain of the
• 17:14
  Bala Veda is also to the Mahzir also the kabloid, he can't take
• 17:20
  scar from him because he's getting on the the scar.
• 17:25
  Yeah, he has to give it give back the Aveda Bala Veda.
• 17:36
  And if the Newton, the custom of the Mahzir is also Bala Veda
• 17:39
  ain't a Russia and the Hafsila Burkina, then he can't give it
• 17:43
  back to him Burkina, he can't be Nevada.
• 17:45
  He has to take scar. Like we said, doing him a favour
• 17:48
  is giving Hanabi and if say shame as soon as Elsa in a Yahoo
• 17:52
  of Kabul, A scar Shin Kane who who Nana and he can't and he
• 18:01
  can't. He can't be Mavator either.
• 18:07
  Shinkenhu Mahaneh because he's being Mavater to him.
• 18:10
  Ella Lipol Lipol Scarla hectic and the guy can't.
• 18:13
  He can't not pay him because it's Hana.
• 18:16
  You know he can't just so therefore he has to go ahead and
• 18:21
  and give it and give the scar to hectic should suck or whatever.
• 18:31
  Dalit Ruben should also and also shimin Ruben.
• 18:35
  The offices are not on Shimon Vachalo Shimon and then Shimon
• 18:40
  came sick. Yahoo Ruben the conocile of
• 18:42
  Aqua. He could do bigger Hola over
• 18:45
  Marco. I'm she nice in scarlet Mishi a
• 18:47
  shave. It's all Kayla suddenly give
• 18:49
  money to say the guy's a medical clown, right?
• 18:54
  And he gets paid to go ahead and to entertain him or just to sit
• 19:00
  by him. You know, let's have a let's
• 19:03
  have a oh, this is right. The tab is all right.
• 19:09
  Yeah, yeah, right, right. Tabs Obama to to to to sit and
• 19:14
  and just to be with him. Loyeshe or he paid an attendant
• 19:18
  Loyeshe Edsa El mavacro Umar. He shouldn't up upon him, but he
• 19:27
  shouldn't sit if it's in the guy's house.
• 19:28
  I guess hospital's different. He shouldn't sit by him.
• 19:31
  He should stand. He should stand when he you
• 19:39
  know, he's getting getting scar, then then right then he he's you
• 19:46
  know, he's he's he's he's he's he's not getting it.
• 19:49
  It's like a certain amount of no, but if he if he's if he's if
• 19:54
  he's getting scarred for sitting, it's fine.
• 19:57
  Also indirectly think Scarlet Rife, Yahoo, our fossil feel be
• 20:01
  a dime. If we're talking about a doctor,
• 20:04
  he's Buddha from the doctor. He can still he's if.
• 20:09
  The Derek is not to not to give money.
• 20:11
  He's allowed to Marapa him feeling Yesh Royfe Akashirpan or
• 20:15
  even if it's another doctor, he can still treat him well in
• 20:18
  Derek Litaine's heart, the Royfe.
• 20:20
  But if you pay the doctor, lawyer per end or Burkina, he
• 20:25
  can't go ahead and and do him a favor and give him free medical
• 20:29
  advice or anything like or anything like that.
• 20:35
  You know, here, I guess a more socialized medical system could
• 20:39
  be it would be it would be better if you paying the
• 20:41
  government. The government pays same.
• 20:42
  It's a grammar. It's that will be fine.
• 20:44
  Below your app in the main mouth.
• 20:46
  Sorry. Or the insurance company pays.
• 20:49
  I don't know what Below your app in the main mouth.
• 20:50
  Sorry, but he can't heal his behema.
• 20:53
  But feeling ain't directly taint Scarlet Rafe.
• 20:57
  Even if it's a place where they don't usually pay pay the
• 20:59
  doctor. But yeah.
• 21:00
  Hello, Marlo Samplona, ya fellow.
• 21:02
  He can still tell him, give him advice, medical advice and say,
• 21:06
  all right, take this. You'll take this medicine for
• 21:09
  who Ya Sena, All right. And he and and he he can, he can
• 21:18
  make some medicine right for by the for the Bahama.
• 21:21
  But who ya Sena? He may know your day a lot, a
• 21:24
  lot, So you know how to make it. But he, Thomas Julia Sena and
• 21:29
  the animal's going to die if he doesn't make it.
• 21:35
  The doctor, whatever. The veterinarian, the
• 21:38
  veterinarian, he can't even make it himself if the animal's going
• 21:41
  to die. The Mace Yahoo Lahavi, the Mace
• 21:46
  if there's if and if someone is lifter and the motor Hanaz Yahoo
• 21:52
  Lahavi or Taqriqan, he can bring over Taqriqan because ahen all
• 21:56
  the Mace he's not a Mace doesn't get hung up.
• 22:00
  So that's not that's OK Khala Benjamin.
• 22:03
  But if and if Shimon's son gets sick Yahoo moving the
• 22:07
  connoisseur, the he can go ahead and go in and sit with him and
• 22:12
  and and the vacuum him. That's OK.
• 22:17
  That's not considered that that's even the place where he
• 22:21
  gets money that he he he the the Honda is on Shiman.
• 22:28
  You know, Shiman gets a get to grandma to Shiman that he
• 22:30
  wouldn't even if they get even he wouldn't have to pay him.
• 22:33
  I don't know whatever of the party that he he's allowed.
• 22:35
  It's it's a consider Hana to the son, the initial Shiman of Surin
• 22:42
  all Ruvain. But if it's if it's it's a
• 22:44
  Shiman is also on Ruvain. She Hadira Shivam in the House
• 22:47
  of Akala Shiman and Shiman came. I'll Niknas ruin the backroom.
• 22:52
  He's allowed to to visit him about low Miyushov, but he can't
• 22:57
  he can't sit down Khala Binoy and if his son gets sick ain't
• 23:02
  on Nicholas club, then he can't go ahead and and go to the sun
• 23:06
  and show you all of the shock. But he's allowed to go ahead and
• 23:09
  ask how he's doing in the shock. The Yahoo ruin the hurry the
• 23:13
  Shiman again also bicker Holland is also is is is also the idea
• 23:21
  see from here is what do you mean that show all of the show
• 23:23
  is the idea of bicker Holland is we'll get there hold the Holden
• 23:27
  later is to check on that is also to check on the on the
• 23:30
  person who's sick and to be sure he's getting what he needs.
• 23:33
  You know person they unfortunately people that people
• 23:35
  are ill you know sick for a long time.
• 23:37
  They sit in their house. I thought I'm in the hospital
• 23:39
  that's easy. People are sick in their house
• 23:42
  and the point and the point of Dick Colin is to go in and check
• 23:47
  that he's doing OK, right check on him.
• 23:50
  You know it's also to sit with him, but also to check on him So
• 23:58
  right, right, he's that he's that, but but he can ask about
• 24:05
  him in the show. Riyako Ruben, the hide, the
• 24:07
  Shimmen and also if if he's also in his the Hussain Rubain, it
• 24:16
  can be made for Shiman Hanasar vain ages, woman being ages, the
• 24:20
  functions a this is motor for motor Hana.
• 24:23
  It doesn't make a difference. That's not called that's
• 24:26
  alcohol. Whether it's grandma, whether
• 24:28
  it's a Bravia Hari or whatever it is, then it's going to be
• 24:31
  motor.