Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Shanghai Express (1932)
Transcript
- 0:13everyone and welcome to once upon a time at the
- 0:15oscars the show that takes you through every
- 0:17best picture nominee from 1927 to today i'm kyle
- 0:20i'm ryan and all aboard yeah we're here we're
- 0:25covering the shanghai express today we are a
- 0:27little behind the scenes first before we get
- 0:29into it would you say that this movie of this
- 0:33year is the one that like is the most like maybe
- 0:36not notorious but most known like everyone knows
- 0:38the name at least probably Yeah. Yeah. I would
- 0:42say so. I think this is the one that I've definitely
- 0:44seen like the poster floating around for the
- 0:47most. Right. Yeah. Yeah. I'm going to go with
- 0:49that. It's one that I feel like I've kind of,
- 0:51obviously not to a degree of like a Casablanca
- 0:53or anything like that, but certainly when I've
- 0:55heard Shanghai Express, there's like a little
- 0:57notoriety behind it. And I don't know what that
- 0:59like led me to expect watching something like
- 1:03this. Like, okay, cool. Here's a classic that
- 1:05I'm going to watch now. I wasn't sure if that's
- 1:07how you felt walking into this. You know, I don't.
- 1:10I don't know if I look at movie posters and start
- 1:13to form an opinion or hear their movie title
- 1:15and form an opinion. I literally just said, oh,
- 1:19I've seen this a lot. I should probably watch
- 1:21it someday. I have no idea what it's about. The
- 1:24good news is that Shanghai Express, at least
- 1:26the most notable poster, the poster on Letterboxd
- 1:29and everything that I know of from this movie,
- 1:31because I agree with you, I've seen the poster
- 1:32a bunch of times too, is, so there's a woman
- 1:35and there's a train. There better be a woman
- 1:37in a train in this movie. And the good news,
- 1:39there is both. Yeah. Multiple women. One train.
- 1:43One train. One train. The Shanghai Express. The
- 1:46titular train. That's the one. So, do you want
- 1:49to get into nominations? Totally. So this was
- 1:52nominated for three Academy Awards, which is
- 1:55a big deal because it seems like every movie
- 1:57we've covered has been, this was nominated for
- 1:59Outstanding Production and that's it. That's
- 2:00it. Go away. But three Academy Awards, Best Director
- 2:04for Joseph von Sternberg, Best Cinematography
- 2:07for League Arms, and Outstanding Production.
- 2:10So still only two. This is a low numbers year.
- 2:15Yeah, I think we'll get there in a year or two
- 2:18where we start seeing a bit of a sweep in terms
- 2:21of who has the most nominations. Yeah. Looking
- 2:23at you, it happened one night. But there's a
- 2:25lot to come. right? Three, not the least that
- 2:27we've seen. There's still some to come this month
- 2:30where we're going to see only one nomination
- 2:32for Best Outstanding Production, so interesting.
- 2:35Worth noting, this is Paramount Publix. That's
- 2:38the company behind the Best Picture nomination.
- 2:40This cast does include Marlene Dietrich as Shanghai
- 2:43Lily, Clive Brooke as Captain Donald Harvey,
- 2:47Anna May Wong as Hufei, Warner Oland as Henry
- 2:50Chang, and Eugene Pallett as Sam Salt. So I didn't
- 2:54have a ton of expectations going or knowledge
- 2:57going into this movie. Expectation, I just kind
- 3:00of expected like cinema classic. And not in terms
- 3:03of like, this is gonna be a five star, but like
- 3:05there's something extremely notable about this
- 3:07movie. And I want to get into that. But before
- 3:10we do, we'll go ahead and talk about the plot
- 3:11here. So help me through this. It's been about
- 3:14a week or two since I've seen this movie. And
- 3:16the plot that I can gather from this is almost
- 3:19we're following a group of strangers. Yeah. A
- 3:21lot of people who don't know who each other are,
- 3:23two or three that may have some connection before,
- 3:25but all of them gather onto the Shanghai Express
- 3:28on the way to Shanghai and shenanigans ensue
- 3:32and result in a near war crime committed. Yeah.
- 3:37Yeah, it's kind of a... It's set up almost like
- 3:40a murder mystery, except there is no murder mystery.
- 3:43Correct. But you're introduced to these characters
- 3:45where it's like, okay, well, that's the kind
- 3:47of nagging Karen lady with the dog. Okay, that's
- 3:51the American man who gambles on everything. Like,
- 3:55they're all very interesting kind of, what is
- 3:59it, murder on the Orient Express? Yeah. That
- 4:01kind of thing. Or even, like, Clue. Death on
- 4:03the Nile. Yeah. There's a lot of, there is a
- 4:06vehicle. Here's a cast of characters and we're
- 4:09putting them into a situation. Right. And it
- 4:11feels like a setup to an Agatha Christie type
- 4:13situation. Yes. But there's not any mystery to
- 4:16be solved here. The only mystery really is seeing
- 4:19the kind of reluctance in confrontation between
- 4:23Shanghai Lily and Captain Donald Harvey. Doc.
- 4:26Doc. They clearly have some history. Yeah. How
- 4:30do I want to start this? I think let's go ahead
- 4:32and focus a bit on. Shanghai Lily, the Marlene
- 4:36Dietrich character. I think the other thing this
- 4:39movie is known for outside of that poster you're
- 4:40talking about is her look in this movie. Totally.
- 4:44She is wearing a lot of black, a lot of veil.
- 4:47A lot of feathers. A lot of feathers. She honestly
- 4:50looks like, have you ever seen the, oh, what
- 4:52is it? It's the Phantom of the, it's not opera.
- 4:56It may not be MechaPlex. Phantom of the Paradise?
- 4:58That's it. With, what's his name from Titanic?
- 5:02That's correct. I haven't seen it. Do you know
- 5:04what I'm talking about when I say Phantom of
- 5:06the Paradise? Yes. Compared to this. She's a
- 5:08little bird -like. Yeah, yeah. And she looks
- 5:10a little bit like the Phantom of the Paradise
- 5:11in that sense. So my point in bringing that up
- 5:14is, was this at the time, like, what do you think
- 5:18this was communicating? Was this like of a high
- 5:19class? Was this like a specific style? Do you
- 5:22have any knowledge on that? Well, I mean, ultimately,
- 5:25the character that Shanghai Lily is, along with
- 5:29Anime Wong's character, Hu Fei, they're both...
- 5:34prostitutes is is what is insinuated interesting
- 5:37yeah that was that's so interesting because i
- 5:40i don't know if that's something i missed but
- 5:41i never picked up on that yeah i mean because
- 5:44of the the haze not code at the time but like
- 5:47with the how involved the mppda was do you think
- 5:51that was a result of just we can't say too much
- 5:53so we're going to imply yeah i mean i don't think
- 5:56they can ever just straight out say these are
- 5:59prostitutes right Marlene Dietrich is, both of
- 6:02them, they're introduced as quote unquote coasters
- 6:05who drive along the coast of China and serve
- 6:09as high class prostitutes. What are they called?
- 6:13Like escorts? Escorts. Yeah. Yeah. So. But none
- 6:16of those words are ever used in the movie. No.
- 6:18No. Obviously, because then otherwise it would
- 6:20be leading the witness. The word coaster is.
- 6:22So there is that. And they do kind of describe
- 6:25it like, oh, they travel across the coast and
- 6:27just things that. Shanghai Lily says she has
- 6:31a very, very famous specific line here where
- 6:35she is talking to Doc and he says he asked her
- 6:38about her name change. Oh, you've had a name
- 6:40change. Are you married? And she goes, no, no,
- 6:42no. It took more than one man to change my name
- 6:45to Shanghai Lily. So it's it's she has a reputation.
- 6:50And clearly that's true because we see just about
- 6:54everybody on the train seems to know who she
- 6:56is before. they have a chance to speak with her.
- 6:59That's true. And for me, the reason I thought
- 7:01that was, was again, a notoriety to her of like,
- 7:04oh, well, there's Shanghai Lily. And Shanghai
- 7:07Lily is also just like a dope name. Like, kind
- 7:11of like Billy the Kid, where everyone's like,
- 7:13oh, it's Billy the Kid. Yeah. Where I was like,
- 7:14oh, yeah, she's killed a man. So, like, I wasn't
- 7:17totally sure with that. But that context makes
- 7:19a ton of sense. So then that makes a bit more
- 7:21sense why she has, like, the upper class. Like,
- 7:24she has this wealth. Like, she dresses in this
- 7:26way. So, okay, that makes a bit more sense. I
- 7:28didn't have that knowledge going in. So I'm really
- 7:30curious, then. There's a moment that comes up
- 7:33later that is also implied. I wonder if you picked
- 7:37up on that. I'm sure I didn't. Interesting. This
- 7:41is a completely different movie. My rating might
- 7:44be different at the end of this than what my
- 7:46letterbox says right now. Yeah. So we'll see.
- 7:48So we were talking about her style, her dress.
- 7:50So yeah, she is high class escort. And yes, I
- 7:55mean, her costumes are amazing in this movie.
- 7:57This would definitely have won, I think, had
- 8:00there been a costume. design nomination yeah
- 8:03i wonder if this uh actually started opening
- 8:05some eyes of like oh look at what's going into
- 8:08these costumes of we have to dress people according
- 8:11to where they're going because now movies especially
- 8:13since last year now movies are beginning to be
- 8:16more period piece uh we're traveling across the
- 8:19country or across the world to be able to film
- 8:21here maybe we have to change the costuming so
- 8:24i think this is kind of opening the eyes a bit
- 8:26to like what goes into costuming to give it the
- 8:29award. Yeah. And I wonder how, I'd love to do
- 8:33the research of all of the different departments
- 8:35in the film industry and see like when certain
- 8:39unions were formed and when that lined up with
- 8:42categories appearing in the Academy Awards. I'd
- 8:45love to see that. I also wonder if maybe we're
- 8:48a bit jaded in the sense of like. they start
- 8:50seeing some things, they're like, hey, maybe
- 8:52we should open that up. Because we also just
- 8:54celebrated the 98th Academy Awards, and that
- 8:57was the first time they've introduced casting.
- 8:59Right. And casting has been something that should
- 9:01have been acknowledged. forever yeah like so
- 9:04maybe it's not one specific thing but you'd like
- 9:06to think that at least they're kind of looking
- 9:08i mean we're even looking at the ceremonies we're
- 9:10getting off base here so my apologies but we're
- 9:13looking at the ceremonies and saying how they're
- 9:14addressing well we're getting bigger maybe we
- 9:16need to do this so you want to think that they're
- 9:18also looking at the movies that are being nominated
- 9:20and saying okay costuming have we thought about
- 9:23doing that before sure so hopefully that's the
- 9:24case but to your point marlene dietrich and her
- 9:27character shanghai lily her costuming in this
- 9:29phenomenal oh yeah it's it's She's beautiful
- 9:32in this movie. She is. And she's so cool. She's
- 9:36definitely one of my favorite female leads that
- 9:39I've seen in any of these movies, just because
- 9:41the way she has a comeback for everything that
- 9:45is said to her is just... It's such a boring
- 9:48word to describe it, but she's so cool. You know,
- 9:51there's a lot of behind -the -scenes stuff we
- 9:53can talk about, but this clearly isn't her only
- 9:55film with Joseph von Sternberg. No. So there's
- 9:58a... I think both in terms of how long she's
- 10:01worked with them and also the affair that was,
- 10:03I saw alleged, but I think also just true. Like
- 10:07it's documented at this point, their affair.
- 10:09I'm sure that brings a comfort for her where
- 10:12she feels like she can be any version of herself.
- 10:15Yeah. Like she can kind of let it loose. So I
- 10:18imagine that also helped her case in this movie
- 10:21to feel as in command as she was. Yeah. And at
- 10:25this point she had done. two or three movies
- 10:28with von sternberg already and she was kind of
- 10:31i don't i don't know how people feel about this
- 10:34word anymore but like his muse yes yeah i think
- 10:37she had done the blue angel and morocco for sure
- 10:40and maybe dishonored maybe even blonde venus
- 10:43because this came out in 1932 So this is the
- 10:46first one we're talking about from a new year.
- 10:48So happy new year, Ryan. Happy new year, man.
- 10:50It's a 32. We've made it. So this also introduces
- 10:53the role of Captain Donald Doc Harvey and his
- 10:58involvement with Shanghai Lily. The way that
- 11:01this came across to me, at least now knowing
- 11:02the context of Shanghai Lily's occupation, we'll
- 11:05say, is it doesn't seem like, hey, we had one
- 11:09really great night together. It seemed like there's
- 11:10more history than that in their communication.
- 11:14And this is where I think the only mystery of
- 11:16the movie really lies in terms of like their
- 11:19actual involvement together. And ultimately,
- 11:21I think the easiest answer here is they were
- 11:23romantically involved and they'd like to still
- 11:25be romantically involved. But you never really
- 11:27truly know what happened between them. And I
- 11:29think that leading into this movie, we were kind
- 11:31of looking for the narrative. That's really where
- 11:34you're thinking the majority of the story lands
- 11:35is between them. But the thing that I think I
- 11:37like most about this movie is that this isn't
- 11:40just their movie. This isn't a movie about Doc
- 11:42and Shanghai Lily. I mean, they're the leads,
- 11:44but it's also the cast of characters. And this
- 11:46is a supporting cast. Yeah. There's a very large
- 11:49supporting cast here. I want to point out, and
- 11:52I'm not exactly sure what his name is, but he
- 11:56introduces himself. He's the man who always wants
- 11:59his window closed or the fans turned off. Invalid,
- 12:05if you will. His words. Yeah, the invalid. Sam
- 12:08Salt. That was Sam Salt. Oh, no, no, no. You
- 12:10know what? I don't know. I believe Sam Salt is
- 12:13the man who's a little more like Gruff, the bigger
- 12:16guy. The gambling man? The gambling man, yeah.
- 12:19Let me look it up so I know for sure. Okay. Yeah,
- 12:21Eric Baum is his name. The character? Yes. Okay.
- 12:25Played by Gustav von Seyfertitz. So the Eric
- 12:30Baum character. That's a tough name. We're going
- 12:33to stick with Eric. So you're right. You just
- 12:36did the research here. Eric Baum is the character's
- 12:39name. So I want to start with him. There's a
- 12:42couple lines in this that I wanted to talk about.
- 12:44And this one specifically was from Eric Baum.
- 12:47This movie, more than any of the others that
- 12:49we've talked about, has kind of almost been like
- 12:51a challenge to me of I need to look up what these
- 12:54words mean back then. Because... In the context
- 12:57of 2026, there are some words that are used in
- 12:59this that aren't offensive or anything, but when
- 13:01you hear it, it's like it's a comedy. There's
- 13:03a line specifically where Eric Baum is in a train
- 13:07car, and he's clearly not extremely well, and
- 13:11they try to open a window, and he's like, are
- 13:12you crazy? Are you trying to kill me? I could
- 13:15stand up and just walk and fall right out of
- 13:17that. Close that window. And they close it. Later,
- 13:19he walks into the dining car to eat with everyone.
- 13:22And there's fans on overhead. And he looks at
- 13:24them and says, turn these fans off. I'm an invalid.
- 13:28And I was like, that's a really funny line. And
- 13:31I was like, but why would he say that? And I
- 13:32started doing some research. Imagine my surprise.
- 13:35Like I wasn't even really fully aware of the
- 13:37word invalid and like what this referred to.
- 13:38I don't know if you can relate to this. My parents
- 13:41at one point, if I'm ever like, yeah, I don't
- 13:43feel like doing that. Like I'm lazy at like 11
- 13:45years old. They're like, are you an invalid?
- 13:47Like, what are you doing? And I always thought
- 13:48invalid was just like, you don't want to do anything.
- 13:50And that's why I was like, that's a funny line,
- 13:51him say that. No, invalid back then was like,
- 13:53I'm extremely ill and could like die at any moment.
- 13:57So I wasn't aware of like the context of this.
- 13:59So that line, I think there's supposed to be
- 14:01a little like humor behind it, but it's not like
- 14:03a comedy or a funny line by that means. So that
- 14:06line specifically stuck out to me. Another is
- 14:09Sam Salt. We talked about the gambling man. He
- 14:12has a line that absolutely destroyed me. And
- 14:15I thought this was, this honestly felt very modern.
- 14:18So I was kind of surprised that this was like,
- 14:20you know, about roughly 90 years old. But there's
- 14:23a moment where a character is speaking to him.
- 14:26And I believe they're speaking Cantonese. And
- 14:28he says, I don't know what you're saying, brother,
- 14:31but don't say it again. And I thought the writing
- 14:36in this was really good. I really enjoyed it
- 14:38overall. And what I really especially appreciate
- 14:40is that they didn't just give the lines specifically
- 14:44to the leads. It did feel well -rounded in that
- 14:47sense. So imagine our surprise when Henry Chang
- 14:52reveals himself to be the leader. of a war organization.
- 14:57How would you describe it? It's not like a terrorist
- 14:58thing. It's like a resistance. That's the exact
- 15:00word. He's the leader of a resistance within
- 15:03Shanghai. Yeah. And he takes the train captive.
- 15:07And do you want to take it from here? What's
- 15:09his goal? What's his purpose? Well, before the
- 15:12train had left Beijing or at a stop shortly after
- 15:16leaving Beijing, it was taken over. by the the
- 15:20chinese government correct and they they took
- 15:22one of his men a spy or or something somebody
- 15:25important to the resistance there's actually
- 15:27a moment where a uh one of the female supporting
- 15:30characters has smuggled the dog right onto the
- 15:33train so she believes that she may be the reason
- 15:35that they're being pulled over yeah so not my
- 15:37dog yeah but once he is taken Mr. Chang decides,
- 15:42well, the only thing I can do then is to take
- 15:43over the train and hold someone hostage of equal
- 15:46importance so that I can get my man back. And
- 15:49that person of equal importance ends up being
- 15:51Captain Harvey. From that point on, this really
- 15:55is kind of like a very small, compact story.
- 15:59Not a lot happens. No, not a lot at all. Ultimately,
- 16:02after that point, Shanghai Lily, who is madly
- 16:06in love with Doc. decides that she is going to
- 16:09trade her life for his freedom. And she tells
- 16:13Chang, hey, take me like I'm yours. I will be
- 16:17with you forever. Just let him go. And he's like,
- 16:19sounds great. The big twist here, and this is
- 16:24where I'm curious if you picked up on context,
- 16:26after this deal is made and the train is about
- 16:29to leave the station and Doc is free, he doesn't
- 16:32know what Shanghai Lily has done. He does notice
- 16:36that some of the luggage is being taken off the
- 16:39train. And he asks, whose luggage is that? Well,
- 16:42that's Shanghai Lily's. And he's like, what?
- 16:44What? He goes to check on her. And ultimately,
- 16:46we find out that someone has snuck into Chang's
- 16:51quarters and stabbed him in the back. And who
- 16:53would that be other than Hu Fei, Anna May Wong's
- 16:56character? Right. Do you know why she did that?
- 16:59No. She was raped. Did you not pick up on that?
- 17:02Not at all. Yeah, it is so subtle. And I think
- 17:05that goes to show like the, just how much these
- 17:09films had to tiptoe, but how much they were willing
- 17:12to put in the films, even if it was like a minor
- 17:15implication. This is a dark movie. Well, here's
- 17:19the only bit of like, now that I'm revisiting
- 17:20my head, the only thing that stood out to me
- 17:22was that after she returns, Shanghai Lily returns
- 17:25to the train, there's a scene where Hufei is
- 17:29like. standing in the doorway of their car and
- 17:32she looks like visibly shaken like she looks
- 17:34like her hair is kind of in a mess that she's
- 17:37not okay but i didn't even remotely put the context
- 17:40behind that i i think what that is is that this
- 17:44is a movie from 1932 right we we really are at
- 17:48a point i think you and me collectively where
- 17:51we go back and we say oh this is pre -code so
- 17:53they make like little saucy sexual innuendos
- 17:57and things or they imply that oh he's sleeping
- 18:01around maurice chevalier that kind of thing what
- 18:03a scamp and we don't we don't think about like
- 18:07the darker context that could be possible and
- 18:10present in these movies right where even on like
- 18:13the smallest most subtle implication that maybe
- 18:18a character had an abortion or uh maybe we we've
- 18:23talked about multiple times in multiple movies
- 18:24how oh, well, they stayed the night together,
- 18:27but we don't really know if anything happened.
- 18:29And I was like, well, I'm just going to assume
- 18:30from this point out that if a man and a woman
- 18:33stay together overnight, they've slept together.
- 18:35Right. Like what we talked about with Aerosmith,
- 18:37where the implication's there. Exactly. And I
- 18:39think that's what it is. We also have to add
- 18:42into our palette, if you will, that there could
- 18:45be darker things that occur in these movies based
- 18:49on the most subtle implications. And that is...
- 18:52100 % what happens here with Hufei's character.
- 18:55She comes into the room and like you said, she's
- 18:58visibly shaken. You can see that she's, her hair
- 19:01is kind of a mess. And not that Anime Wong is
- 19:05given much to do in this movie prior to this.
- 19:07So you don't get a good sense of her personality.
- 19:10But she has changed just like the way she's presenting
- 19:14and holding herself from that point on. And that
- 19:18is why she was sexually assaulted by... Chang.
- 19:22I'm really glad that we have the interviews that
- 19:26we do for this season or this year lined up because
- 19:30I think there's so many questions that I and
- 19:32the general public have about pre -code. And
- 19:35even in this time, like when the code is kind
- 19:37of being like, you know, on its way to be formed,
- 19:39how much of it is what was said versus like to
- 19:42Shanghai Express's credit, not said. Right. Things
- 19:46that are implied. I wonder how much of that is
- 19:49like, hey, we caught that. And that can't fly.
- 19:52Yeah. Because that's obviously, to your point,
- 19:54extremely dark themes. We talked about Five Star
- 19:56Final talking about double suicide. There's a
- 19:59lot of darker themes this year specifically,
- 20:01more than what we talked about before, that are
- 20:03kind of eye -opening to that. And it makes me
- 20:05have an appreciation that they can put that in
- 20:08there. At the same time, it's kind of like, I
- 20:10think, oh, I thought I was paying attention.
- 20:12But you miss it because you're not looking for
- 20:14those things. Right. And to your point, this
- 20:17movie doesn't feel dark. Those are very dark
- 20:20themes. And it feels almost like an adventure.
- 20:23Right. Yeah, yeah. Because the cast and characters
- 20:25and the way that they communicate with each other,
- 20:27the lines that I mentioned here, they are very
- 20:29kind of brisk in pace. The thing that I want
- 20:33to talk about with that is that Joseph von Sternberg
- 20:36specifically said that he wanted this pace of
- 20:40the movie to match that of a speeding train.
- 20:43So of the Shanghai Express itself, he wants the
- 20:45pace to kind of be nonstop and moving. And in
- 20:48a movie where we talk about how they are on this
- 20:51train, they are traveling across the country,
- 20:53they are on their way to Shanghai, they get captured,
- 20:55all these things happen. This is like 90 minutes.
- 21:00It's not very long at all. No, it's very quick.
- 21:02So I see, in theory, I understand what he's going
- 21:05for when he says he wants the pace to be like
- 21:07breakneck speed. I didn't necessarily feel like
- 21:09every scene was just like bam, bam, bam, happening,
- 21:11happening. But in terms of like the overall story,
- 21:15to your point, you could say this and like...
- 21:1725 seconds like what actually happens yeah it's
- 21:20a very like a small story really yeah and i don't
- 21:24and to your i think you mean this as well but
- 21:27that doesn't mean that it's insignificant but
- 21:29there's just not much that happens right right
- 21:31compact i guess is more of what i mean perfect
- 21:33yeah it's still a very large tale if you will
- 21:37for sure and we can't overplay the effect that
- 21:41this movie had at the time because shanghai express
- 21:43itself is the highest grossing film of 1932 both
- 21:46in u .s and canada so this was clearly a lasting
- 21:50effect on audiences totally and i okay i want
- 21:55to get into it the story yeah itself we're we're
- 21:59saying yeah it was kind of compact that like
- 22:01not a lot goes on i think i think it's honestly
- 22:03more of a character study yeah yeah it's The
- 22:07characters are presented, like we said, like
- 22:08a murder mystery, like Clue or something. They're
- 22:10all very unique. There's something memorable
- 22:13about all of them. You have the Frenchman who
- 22:15has to be translated, the woman who's obsessed
- 22:18with her dog and just complains about everything.
- 22:20So to me, the story and even the characters are
- 22:25kind of like the bottom tier of what is important
- 22:29to me in this movie. Correct. The characters
- 22:31probably more so than the story. This movie is
- 22:35style. Yes, that is what sells me on this movie
- 22:39so much. It is shot in a way that I think, you
- 22:43know, a lot of times people will watch a movie
- 22:45and they'll be like, well, why'd they do that?
- 22:46Why'd they do that? This doesn't make sense.
- 22:49Narratively, blah, blah, blah. And sometimes
- 22:52you just have to say, well, just look. Look at
- 22:55what's happening on screen and like enjoy the
- 22:57visual. Enjoy the fact that this is an art form
- 23:00and kind of take in every frame as like a painting
- 23:04and enjoy that. Who cares what the story is?
- 23:07Like, yes, there's a minor thread that you can
- 23:09follow. Right. But to me, this movie is like
- 23:12a masterclass in just filmmaking that doesn't
- 23:17exist now. Really? No, you're right. As far as
- 23:20visually? I think so many, like, when we talk
- 23:23about cinematography, even to this year, 2026,
- 23:26we look to see, okay, what was the most impressive
- 23:29thing that they did? Like, did they use a one
- 23:31take to film the I lied to you sequence in Sinners?
- 23:34Right. How difficult was that to pull off? Did
- 23:37we find the ability to film on these roads, like
- 23:41one battle after another? And did we match the
- 23:43pace of the movie to how the camera was moving?
- 23:45Great. Something like Shanghai Express is really
- 23:47just more like, where is the best possible place,
- 23:50one place for this camera to be that captures
- 23:53everything that we're looking to do? Yes. All
- 23:55the characters, all the themes, people walking
- 23:56by, what is the one spot? Because for the majority
- 23:59of this movie, even though it is like... The
- 24:01Shanghai Express, and it's supposed to match
- 24:03this frenetic pace. The camera does not move
- 24:06much at all. There's some scenes outside of the
- 24:09train where we're tracking Shanghai Lily as she's
- 24:12getting onto the train for the first time, and
- 24:14we catch all these glances of people on their
- 24:17way, or passing by the train. But once you get
- 24:20on the train, it really is, cool, we're in this
- 24:22car set up right here. Cool, well, now we're
- 24:24in the dining car set up right here. And then
- 24:27you have one of my favorite shots. And this isn't
- 24:30even like, you know, oh, wow, what a just beautiful
- 24:32shot altogether. It's when Shanghai Lily and
- 24:35Doc first kind of like see each other on the
- 24:37train and they're leaning outside of windows
- 24:40on one car. And it's perfect because it looks
- 24:43kind of like the whole like neighbors and like
- 24:45an apartment complex, but they're in the same
- 24:47car and kind of leaning out and talking to each
- 24:48other. And it was the perfect like little like
- 24:50coy, like, you know, no one could see anything,
- 24:52but you hear the conversation. And it really
- 24:54is a masterclass to your word. of where to put
- 24:58the camera and not in you know we talked about
- 25:01uh george arliss in something like disraeli and
- 25:05how they're more like i don't know put the camera
- 25:07uh there sure right and it's just this wide shot
- 25:10and you kind of have like everyone walking in
- 25:12and out of where can we have like the shot where
- 25:14people are going to walk in and out of this in
- 25:16the right frame and you have that right mindset
- 25:18like this is the same mindset as that but in
- 25:21this there's much more intentionality And there
- 25:23is more, no, this is the right spot and here's
- 25:25the reasons why. And it is beautiful. You can't
- 25:29disregard that. To a point where when we talk
- 25:32about this movie won, it won cinematography.
- 25:35It did. So the work that Lee Garns is doing here
- 25:37is remarkable. And it is beautiful. And I think
- 25:40that was the difficulty of my experience with
- 25:42this movie is I was trying to get it. And clearly
- 25:46I didn't because I was missing some important
- 25:48context here that you need to be digging into.
- 25:52The thing that you can't deny about this movie
- 25:54is how gorgeous it looks, whether it comes to
- 25:56that costuming that you mentioned or the cinematography.
- 25:59This looked breathtaking. And for that to be
- 26:02a 90 minute like, you know, adventure type movie,
- 26:05I thought was remarkable. I it's 100 percent
- 26:10the what you're talking about with the camera
- 26:12and like, OK, we have to place it in the best
- 26:14position to get what we need. Not only that,
- 26:17a big thing about this that I don't think we
- 26:20have seen. to this degree in any of the movies
- 26:23we've covered, is where do we place the lights
- 26:25for this movie? The skill that is shown and on
- 26:31display with shadows is insane in this movie.
- 26:35That shot you're talking about when you first
- 26:37see Doc and Shanghai Lily on the train, the way
- 26:41that blocks of shadow will go across her face
- 26:44on a diagonal and cover half of her face, it's
- 26:47very proto -noir. It's done in a way that adds
- 26:51like a beauty and a mystery to Lily without having
- 26:56anything spoken. There's a great scene towards
- 27:00the end of the movie where Lily is smoking a
- 27:02cigarette after she has a long talk with Doc.
- 27:05And it's the same thing. Just all of the way
- 27:08that Shadow is on display, it adds to the emotion.
- 27:12And I think when the camera is able to do that
- 27:14and the lights are able to do that in tandem
- 27:16with the actor or the actress, like... You're
- 27:19doing things that no other medium really can
- 27:22do. The closest thing you can get is, like, painting
- 27:24or photography. But you're allowing the actor
- 27:27to play on this, like, I don't know, this work
- 27:30of art, this perfectly framed everything. I wish
- 27:34I had better words to describe it. No, I think
- 27:36that you're describing it perfectly well. A painting
- 27:40is exactly. the right words like it almost is
- 27:43what's the the the meme that goes around is the
- 27:47renaissance painting whenever there's a picture
- 27:49where there's a lot of people and they're all
- 27:51doing interesting things they people coin that
- 27:53as the renaissance painting there's a couple
- 27:55shots like that in this where specifically we
- 27:57have people kind of like exiting the train and
- 27:59you see certain people looking at each other
- 28:01and the chinese army like trying to abduct a
- 28:05dog or whatever it might be I specifically think
- 28:08of whenever they're all being held captive by
- 28:11Chang, they're in this like house or like a room
- 28:15and they're all standing at the bottom of the
- 28:17stairs. And someone will come up or come down
- 28:20from the stairs and bring another person up almost
- 28:21one by one. And the shot of all of them kind
- 28:25of waiting for the next person to be taken to
- 28:27me is like a Renaissance painting where you start
- 28:29seeing like the nervousness of these characters
- 28:31that didn't exist before. And then more of the
- 28:33coolness of your docs and your Shanghai lilies.
- 28:36I thought that was another great example of what
- 28:39you mentioned is like a painting. Yeah. It felt
- 28:41intentional where the camera needed to be. And
- 28:43it's not flashy. I think that's the thing that
- 28:45like the overarching theme of what we're getting
- 28:46at. It's not a flashy camera. It's just more
- 28:49this is exactly where it needs to be and the
- 28:51confidence that you have behind that. And also,
- 28:53one thing I appreciated was even though this
- 28:55is a frequent collaboration between Joseph von
- 28:58Sternberg and Marlene Dietrich, that there was
- 29:01never really like, okay, cool, this is her movie.
- 29:04Now it's like, come close up on her. She has
- 29:06plenty of close ups. But it did feel like it
- 29:08could be her movie and Clive Brown's movie as
- 29:11well. So I liked the balance of that. Sorry,
- 29:14I said Clive Brown. Clive Brooke. Clive Brooke's
- 29:16movie as well. I really liked this. So a couple
- 29:20things I want to talk about first. So there's
- 29:22a couple of things that were removed from this
- 29:25movie. One thing is that the Hays office, the
- 29:27MPPDA, prompted, even before it was filming,
- 29:31script revision. around uh the months your character
- 29:34or sorry not months here the minister character
- 29:36i didn't see a ton of reason of why this was
- 29:39but there are some things in the script that
- 29:41they thought was questionable this makes sense
- 29:43we talked about five star final whenever the
- 29:45idea of boris karloff's character uh had to be
- 29:49revised because he was attempting to impersonated
- 29:54clergyman. Right. But then all the other accusations
- 29:57against him leading into the clergyman, that
- 29:59was too scandalous, and they had to take that
- 30:01out. So it makes sense that in the same year,
- 30:03they're doing a similar thing with Shanghai Express
- 30:05over a minister character. But that was something
- 30:07that they got involved with. The second thing
- 30:09here is that it's around the 40 -minute mark.
- 30:12This is when everyone's kind of being interrogated
- 30:14by Chang and his resistance members. There's
- 30:18a conversation with Major Leonard. I don't know
- 30:21if you know what I'm talking about. He's kind
- 30:23of talking about like why he was removed from
- 30:25serving in the military. And at this mark, there's
- 30:29actually a pretty obvious jump cut. You can tell
- 30:32that there's like a cut in the editing and not
- 30:35just like an edit, like, hey, here's the next
- 30:36scene or a different camera angle of that. But
- 30:39it's more you can kind of see like. He's not
- 30:40in the same position as he was a second ago,
- 30:42and now it's a cut. And this is when he's talking
- 30:44about the details around his disgrace of being
- 30:47removed from the military. So there's some theories
- 30:50out there about what exactly was in the script,
- 30:53or what was added, at least, about his disgrace
- 30:55from the military, and how that wasn't appropriate,
- 30:58so they ended up cutting that, too. I see. So
- 31:00it's interesting how we see in this movie, Shanghai
- 31:02Express, that there is an edit made before the
- 31:05script. And then even once it's filmed, edited
- 31:08out of the movie as well, but not like perfectly
- 31:11paced. So I thought that was really interesting
- 31:13to see those kind of things. I mean, this movie
- 31:15was not without its controversies. It was originally
- 31:18banned in China. Did you read about that? Yeah.
- 31:21And that was kind of due to the way it presented
- 31:24China. Well, specifically like Chinese politics.
- 31:27Right. Yeah. To talk about the priest moment
- 31:32as well, shout out to Precode Essentials. by
- 31:35Kim Luperi and Danny Reed, who we just interviewed
- 31:38Kim last week, and Danny will be on next episode.
- 31:42But in the book, it does specify that Mr. Carmichael,
- 31:46his original storyline was he was a crook also
- 31:49posing as a priest. Interesting how that exact
- 31:53situation is what we're talking about with, maybe
- 31:56not crook, but at least a very... sketchy individual
- 32:00portraying a priest or clergyman. Right, right.
- 32:03Interesting how it pops up twice in one year
- 32:05with these Best Picture nominee movies. I wonder
- 32:07how many more times it was happening. But again,
- 32:09the work that Danny and Kim did in that is incredible.
- 32:13Such a good book. I'm excited to talk with Danny
- 32:14on our next episode about that. Yeah, I mean,
- 32:17we talked about how it was banned in China. It
- 32:20was lifted, though. And did you read how it was
- 32:23lifted? I did not. It was lifted when Paramount
- 32:25Publix pledged not to film another movie. That
- 32:29involved Chinese politics. Oh, really? So it's
- 32:31interesting because it's not like, hey, we won't
- 32:33film in China anymore. Like, you know, we won't
- 32:35talk about China. It was like, well, we can still
- 32:36do this. We're just going to avoid talking about
- 32:39Chinese politics. And in other years that we've
- 32:43talked about, you know, how we can't portray
- 32:45Chicago in certain ways and we can't portray
- 32:47the police in certain ways or even like journalism.
- 32:50It's interesting to hear that this also goes
- 32:53across the ocean as well for other countries
- 32:56saying, hey. You can't talk about our politics
- 32:59that way. This is really dangerous. And I see
- 33:01what they're talking about, especially at a very
- 33:03tumultuous time. It's difficult to kind of portray
- 33:06these things. And of course, it's not given us
- 33:10like, hey, this is the right thing, right? We
- 33:12all feel this way. It's a complicated subject.
- 33:14So I understand why they did that. But very interesting
- 33:17that with that ban that it had in China, that
- 33:19it was lifted once Paramount disagrees. We just
- 33:22won't talk about politics specifically with you
- 33:24again. Right. And that was enough for them. So
- 33:26they did end up lifting that ban. Cool. Yeah,
- 33:29that's awesome. Now, yeah, all of the pre -code
- 33:32stuff is just always so fascinating to me and
- 33:33like what got cut and what things are like so
- 33:37secretly hidden in the movie, which, you know,
- 33:41again, I think that's our brains. Just saying,
- 33:43oh, this is a movie from the 30s. Surely they're
- 33:45not talking about sexual assault. Right. And
- 33:48prostitution. When really it's there and it's
- 33:51looking at us straight in the face. But we're
- 33:54just so used to the idea of, well, they didn't
- 33:56do that 100 years ago. Right. I mean, we're thinking
- 33:58they couldn't. Right. We don't even think about
- 34:01that. Exactly. And again, every time we cover
- 34:04a movie, I get more and more sad that we're going
- 34:05closer to when the production code is in full
- 34:08effect. And these things will be all but. completely
- 34:12removed. And I really don't know what that's
- 34:14going to look like for us. I think it's going
- 34:16to be good and bad. I think there's the bad in
- 34:18the sense of the censorship, but I think it's
- 34:20also the good because what I enjoy about this
- 34:23conversation is the kind of person that I am
- 34:26is I think that I look at what's happening in
- 34:29this movie and all the other movies we've talked
- 34:30about, and I don't see a reason that there has
- 34:33to be a censorship or like a code or anything.
- 34:36It's more, hey, we've never... We're doing this
- 34:39for the first time. We've talked about the development
- 34:42of cameras and microphones and how we're learning
- 34:45how to do this. I think it's the same thing when
- 34:47you're talking about these. The way you talk
- 34:49about Chinese politics, the way you talk about
- 34:50sexual assault, the way you talk about crime,
- 34:53double suicide, these horrible things that are
- 34:55very much a reality for many people in this day
- 34:58and ours. You find ways to incorporate that and
- 35:01you fail and you say, OK, that was wrong. Sorry,
- 35:05China. This is an exaggeration, but like, sorry,
- 35:07China, for talking about your politics. But you
- 35:09learn from it and you say, cool, what can we
- 35:11do? Like you you break it so you can fix it.
- 35:14And I think the Hays Code isn't a fix. I think
- 35:17that it's well, let's just not do that altogether.
- 35:20And that's not growing. That's like preventing
- 35:21yourself from failing again. You got to fail
- 35:24and then rebuild this stuff. That's my personal
- 35:26belief. So I'm interested in talking about the
- 35:29code and how it affects these movies and what
- 35:31it could have led to. But I agree with you. These
- 35:33movies are extremely interesting because they
- 35:36are given the ability to go out there and talk
- 35:38about some stuff that is more scandalous. And
- 35:40some fail, some succeed. But we're not going
- 35:43to be talking about that for much longer. That's
- 35:45for sure. Yeah. I'm just so curious as to what
- 35:49it's going to look like. If they're just going
- 35:51to be the most dull movies. You and I might be
- 35:54smoking cigarettes within like seven months.
- 35:56It's true. Just like on the pod, just like getting
- 35:57through some of these. Let me tell you, I watched
- 36:01this movie with Ziggy. Yeah. And this is maybe
- 36:03the second. Was she excited to watch it? Was
- 36:05this one where she was like, hey, I want to be
- 36:07a part of that? It was more, hey, I've had a
- 36:10really busy week and I know you want to watch
- 36:11Friends, but I have to watch this movie. Do you
- 36:14want to watch it with me? And she was like, yeah,
- 36:15I'll watch. Copy. And then we sat down and we
- 36:18watched it. And there were so many different
- 36:19things. The reason I bring it up now is we both
- 36:22were like, man, they look cool smoking those
- 36:24cigarettes. They look so cool. What? Yeah. Dude,
- 36:29like if Marlboro was to come out with a commercial
- 36:32tomorrow that just highlighted all of these old
- 36:35Hollywood stars smoking cigarettes and they were
- 36:37like, don't you want to be cool like them? I'd
- 36:39buy a whole case of cigarettes tomorrow. Yeah,
- 36:41we're extremely impressionable here. I'm so impressionable
- 36:44when it comes to looking cool. It's so funny
- 36:46because I love that you and Ziggy were watching
- 36:48the movie and you saw people smoking cigarettes.
- 36:51You're like, man, that's so cool. You see yourself
- 36:53a little bit in those characters and you're like,
- 36:54yeah, that would be me if I was on that train.
- 36:56Now, unfortunately, if I was on that train, I
- 36:58would be the guy begging people to turn the fan
- 37:00off because I'm an invalid. Well, that's what
- 37:01I was going to say. I would hope that I looked
- 37:03like Captain Harvey. Yes. But I would be like...
- 37:07I'd be Sam Salt. I can't smoke this. Have you
- 37:09read the Surgeon General's warning? I'd be the
- 37:11guy that's like, brother, I don't know what you
- 37:12just said, but don't say it again. I would pop
- 37:14the cigarette in my mouth and just keep it there
- 37:16and not light it. One thing I wanted to talk
- 37:19to you about was Eugene Pallet, and this is totally
- 37:21me bringing... myself into the movie and not
- 37:23just reading the movie for what it is. Eugene
- 37:24Palo to Sam Salt. I kind of rock with this guy.
- 37:28Like this actor specifically, I really, really
- 37:31like him. Is this the gambling man? Yes. Okay.
- 37:33I really like him. And the first person I thought
- 37:36of, the way he spoke, the things he said, the
- 37:39way he carried himself. I thought of William
- 37:42Peltzer, Billy Peltzer's dad in Gremlins. Okay.
- 37:47And the way that he talks, the way he's like
- 37:49a salesman, he does the whole like, it's the
- 37:51Peltzer 5000. And here's what this does. And
- 37:53it's going to change your life. And the way he
- 37:55is almost like a southern man on the Shanghai
- 37:58Express. I was like, what are you doing in this
- 38:00movie? And I was like, fascinated with him specifically.
- 38:03So whenever they're like, so here's what's happening
- 38:05with Shanghai Lily. I'm like, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 38:07Let's go back to Sam Salt. Yeah. And it's a cool
- 38:09name too. So I really, really liked him. That's
- 38:12just one thing that I noticed on him specifically.
- 38:14I want to play a fun little game with you if
- 38:16you'll let me. Okay. This movie with Shanghai
- 38:19Express, they're in first class for a portion
- 38:21of it. I want you to tell me what you thought
- 38:23it would have cost in 1932 to have a first class
- 38:28ticket for Shanghai. $2. So it was $35. What?
- 38:37First class, right? Not just to be on the train,
- 38:39but first class itself was $35. Yeah. In today's
- 38:42currency, how much do you think that is? This
- 38:45almost shocked me more than that price. First
- 38:48class ticket to go from Beijing to Shanghai?
- 38:51Correct. Specifically? In today's currency. In
- 38:52today's currency. $3 ,000. Over $700. I don't
- 38:58know if that's good or not. I feel like that's
- 38:59not that bad. It's not that bad. I completely
- 39:01agree. I'll do it. I'd do it. Let's do it. Let's
- 39:04go. Let's go to Shanghai. You can dress like
- 39:06Doc Harvey. Okay. And I'll dress like Shanghai
- 39:09Lily. Perfect. I got the veil and everything.
- 39:12You gotta get cigarettes. I think, honestly,
- 39:14I'm gonna be more like Sam Salt. Okay. And I'd
- 39:17be happy to be like Sam Salt. That's fair. But
- 39:19I wanted to bring that up. I'll be the woman
- 39:20with the dog. Okay, I might be the woman with
- 39:24the dog. But my dog is 90 pounds. So like me
- 39:27trying to smuggle him on is just like, sir, we
- 39:29need a ticket for whatever that person is next
- 39:31to you in the trench coat and the hat. Maybe
- 39:33I'm the dog. Dude, I love the idea of us smuggling
- 39:37you onto the train. And then I have to go in
- 39:39cargo. Oh, God. I love the idea of one day us
- 39:43getting invited to like a movie themed costume
- 39:46party. And we both show up specifically as the
- 39:49woman. And we're just like, oh, we should have
- 39:51coordinated outfits. And nobody knows who we
- 39:53are. It's great because then I could have used
- 39:55my catchphrase of, well, one of us has to change.
- 39:57Yeah. Oh, man. That would have been so good.
- 40:00I really enjoyed this. And to be honest, the
- 40:02context that you're providing that I completely
- 40:04was devoid of. That does change things a lot
- 40:07for me because it shows that there's more going
- 40:10on in this movie than really was on paper. Yeah.
- 40:13Or at least on the front that the eye can catch.
- 40:17Because a lot of that is missing. And a lot of
- 40:18that is... credited to where he puts that camera
- 40:22the cinematography that you mentioned i mean
- 40:24that shot that the lights and the lights the
- 40:26the shot that i mentioned of when anime wong
- 40:30yes i'm sorry i was like and i made sure i got
- 40:32her name right when anime wong was standing in
- 40:35the doorway visibly shaken the way that that
- 40:38camera is placed you don't expect someone to
- 40:39show up right in that doorframe like it's right
- 40:41in the center of the screen but your eyes are
- 40:43really focused on shanghai lily and then she
- 40:45just appears and like That says, now that I'm
- 40:49revisiting my mind, that says so much about that
- 40:51shot specifically and where that camera was placed,
- 40:53that it has to be there. So there's so much intentionality
- 40:55in that, too, that I really appreciate. The other
- 40:58thing that I appreciate about this movie is that
- 41:00it is not one of those that it's like, well,
- 41:02the man's the hero, and he ends up saving the
- 41:05day. It's really Shanghai Lily. Oh, man. And
- 41:07when we come to that conclusion that she is the
- 41:09hero in this movie, it's such a cool moment because
- 41:12I believe it is, what do we say, Eric Bach? eric
- 41:17uh bomb eric bomb he is the one having the conversation
- 41:21with doc who's who's kind of like i'm done with
- 41:24shanghai lily like i can't believe she was gonna
- 41:26stay with that guy what a loser and he's like
- 41:29what is wrong with you what is the matter with
- 41:32you and specifically he says she's worth a dozen
- 41:34of you yeah and and he's just like oh okay sorry
- 41:39Sorry, you're right. And that's what leads him
- 41:41to be like understanding and realize she was
- 41:44going to sacrifice her life essentially for his
- 41:46freedom. Yeah. And then they end up happily ever
- 41:49after together or at least until, I don't know,
- 41:51Shanghai Express 2. But yeah, like she is the
- 41:56woman in this movie. It's so cool. She has so
- 41:59many cool lines. I love when she's talking to
- 42:01him specifically and he says something like,
- 42:04oh, I, you know, I wish we could go back and
- 42:06like. essentially change the past you know if
- 42:09if you could go back what would you change she's
- 42:11like i'd only change one thing i wouldn't have
- 42:13bobbed my hair like she's just so comfortable
- 42:16with the way that her life has gone yeah so cool
- 42:20such a powerful empowering female character i
- 42:24love her well and for them to portray that kind
- 42:27of character behind at the time who's their words
- 42:31a coaster Like, I think that goes a very long
- 42:33way in kind of like showing the humanity behind
- 42:35people despite their title or despite like what
- 42:38people may think of them. So I like that. I love
- 42:41the idea of kind of flipping the what you would
- 42:44expect is like and what kind of is to come. The
- 42:47gender swap of the hero versus like the damsel
- 42:51in distress, who in this case is Doc. Exactly,
- 42:54yeah. I thought that was great. I also really
- 42:56was fascinated by the idea of, you talked about
- 42:58the noir -ness of this with the shadows and everything.
- 43:01I think there's some character work in Doc that
- 43:03kind of lends itself to the detective in Noirs
- 43:06to Come, where a lot of him is hands in the pockets,
- 43:08just kind of like, that's Chinatown, baby. Right,
- 43:11yeah. A lot of that. Little Humphrey Bogart.
- 43:13Little Humphrey Bogart in him, for sure. So it's
- 43:16interesting to see what this leads to. And I
- 43:18think the first thing that people would look
- 43:20at when they see a movie like this is like, oh,
- 43:21like adventure movies. No, to your point, the
- 43:24shadows, the cinematography, the character work
- 43:26in like Doc Brown and like the mystery behind
- 43:29like Shanghai Lily, the mysterious woman who
- 43:31walks on the train. A lot of it leads to noir
- 43:33crime. Right. So this is, it's a really interesting
- 43:37beginning of where this leads to with something
- 43:39like this. So I understand the. The notoriety
- 43:43behind this movie. I understand the importance
- 43:45behind why this is the movie that we know walking
- 43:49into this year. What a good end cap. Look at
- 43:53us. We started and ended right at the same place.
- 43:55We did. Yeah. 100%. Can I go off for like two
- 43:58minutes on just... Are you timing me? And go.
- 44:02Okay. So I have said this before. I do work on
- 44:05film sets. And usually it's like background acting.
- 44:09At the very most, I'm like a stand -in. So it...
- 44:12It ends up being you get placed on a set and
- 44:15then you stand there and you wait until everything
- 44:17is set up where they need it set up. So a lot
- 44:20of that time you spend looking around and seeing
- 44:23what everybody else is doing, what all of the
- 44:24crew members are doing. And most of it is seeing
- 44:28where they're placing the lights and then seeing
- 44:30where the PAs and the AD are placing their background
- 44:34talent. And the whole thing is to get exactly.
- 44:38what they want in frame. And it's what they call
- 44:41blocking. I think the reason I enjoyed this movie
- 44:44so much is because the things that it excels
- 44:47at are all of the things that I have spent countless
- 44:50hours now on a film set, watching them set up
- 44:53and perfect the lighting, the blocking. And when
- 44:56I'm on these sets, I don't get to look at the
- 44:58monitor very often. Right. Obviously. So I'm
- 45:01just like, I wonder what that'll look like. And
- 45:04if I'm lucky, it ends up being something that
- 45:06I want to watch. So a year later, I'll pop on
- 45:08the TV, won't see myself on screen at all because
- 45:11I'm just a blurry little boy in the background.
- 45:13But I will be like, wow, they spent six hours
- 45:16on that shot and it looks awful. That doesn't
- 45:20happen here in Shanghai Express. No. This movie
- 45:22is gorgeous. I think that is its huge selling
- 45:24point. Are my two minutes up? No, you have like
- 45:2830 seconds. Oh my God. Okay, so. You're good.
- 45:30That was another thing that when I was watching
- 45:32with Ziggy, like immediately she pointed out.
- 45:34There's a scene where. I think the news comes
- 45:37out that the Shanghai Express has been captured
- 45:40and it cuts to the British legation. And there's
- 45:44this slow push in on two men in suits like at
- 45:47a party and just the blocking of that shot. These
- 45:49two men with their back to the camera answering
- 45:51the phone to like hear the news and they're on
- 45:54a balcony. And in the top right corner, you can
- 45:56see a big, giant, bright chandelier. And somehow,
- 45:59even with that chandelier being the brightest
- 46:01spot in the frame, you also have the plants outside
- 46:04the window that are lit, but the men are cast
- 46:07in shadows. And it's something that you cannot
- 46:10replicate today on film. And I'm sitting there
- 46:13with Ziggy and we're both like, my God, how?
- 46:16How are we getting excited about light on these
- 46:18bushes? And that's the selling point to me. So
- 46:22I just wanted to hype that up for two minutes
- 46:24time. I think that actually would be two minutes
- 46:28exactly. Look at you. Mic drop. Mic drop. It's
- 46:31too expensive. Fortunately, I'm going to ruin
- 46:32it and keep talking about it. It's interesting
- 46:33that like with black and white, like I think
- 46:35a lot of people would be like, okay, yeah, it's,
- 46:37you know, only two colors. There's different
- 46:40like tones. There's different colors to even
- 46:43like gray, black, white, like off -white. There's
- 46:45a lot going on there. So it isn't just as easy
- 46:48as like, you know, blocking or lighting, you
- 46:51know, one or two colors. But obviously, much
- 46:54different than now. Like, now we have so many
- 46:56colors that are on screen that there has to be
- 46:58a level of intentionality of how you use lighting
- 47:01on those colors. And unfortunately, to your point
- 47:03of what we talked about with, like, you know,
- 47:04newer movies, things just kind of look bland.
- 47:08And there's the superherofication of, like, this
- 47:11is dull, and it's gray, or it's beige, and there's
- 47:13not, like, huge pops of color. And it's because,
- 47:16like, it's difficult to film, at least practically,
- 47:19film, like... Some of these, even light, some
- 47:22of the colors. Yeah. So I love when you can see
- 47:25movies like this where they have only like maybe
- 47:27three or four that they are working with at the
- 47:29time, color -wise. There's an ability to light
- 47:32it a certain way to where it pops that way. And
- 47:35I miss that. I don't think that means that we
- 47:37can't ever have it again. There's just such a
- 47:39level of intentionality we need to have with
- 47:41the way we light certain things to get to that
- 47:45point again, where the lighting is really almost
- 47:47like another character of the movie. Totally.
- 47:49So I'm with you on that. I think that's why I
- 47:51get a little... I don't get as excited as others
- 47:55do when they take a big movie and they say, oh,
- 47:57and we also have the black and white version.
- 47:59And a movie just comes with that. Like Logan
- 48:01did that. Nightmare Alley. Nightmare Alley. Which
- 48:04I haven't seen Nightmare Alley in black and white,
- 48:06so I don't know. You need to hit that. Really?
- 48:08Yeah. My fear with that is always like you kind
- 48:11of have to plan for a film to be filmed in black
- 48:14and white. Sure. To really. Fury Road did it
- 48:17too. Yeah. Like it doesn't just happen. Things
- 48:20have to be set up specifically knowing that you're.
- 48:23going for that look. So Godzilla minus color
- 48:26did that as well, which I think the reason I
- 48:29enjoyed that was it was more like a nostalgia
- 48:32kind of factor. Like watching the original Godzilla.
- 48:34Yeah, exactly. I think there's a couple scenes
- 48:36where that does really work itself in both ways.
- 48:39I think the opening of Godzilla minus, it was
- 48:42minus one, right? Minus one, yeah. Yeah. So Godzilla
- 48:45minus one, the opening on the island when Godzilla
- 48:48first appears. Yeah. I think the way they use
- 48:50light in that with like the spotlight. I think
- 48:52that can really lend itself both to the black
- 48:55and white and kind of against it because so much
- 48:58of what I love about that scene is the look of
- 48:59Godzilla. And like, I think there's a lot of
- 49:02like grays, greens, browns, almost to his texture
- 49:05that stand out in that. So there's almost some
- 49:08like, oh, what did we lose in that? But also
- 49:10to your point, the nostalgia of it and just seeing
- 49:12that shot. I love that scene, that scene specifically.
- 49:15We're talking about Godzilla minus one of the
- 49:16Shanghai Express episode, my bad. But there's
- 49:19definitely. Some good and bad to the black and
- 49:22white. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, ultimately,
- 49:25how did you feel about Shanghai Express? And
- 49:27how do you feel now knowing like the additional
- 49:29context in the movie? Well, I think this is the
- 49:31portion where we give our ratings. Sure. Right.
- 49:33So I'll go ahead and dive into that answer with
- 49:35kind of the rating that I had. Walking into this,
- 49:38I'd rate it three stars. And I think there's
- 49:41some important context that I missed that I think
- 49:43really unlocks the rest of the story. And it
- 49:46doesn't change it dramatically. To me, I think
- 49:50this is something that I appreciate fully. And
- 49:53especially with what it leads to. But I kind
- 49:56of take some umbrage with the phrasing of this
- 49:59movie being like the pacing of a speed train
- 50:03in the Shanghai Express itself. I don't really
- 50:06feel that. It's a short story. There's a lot
- 50:09that happens, but it's in 90 minutes. But it
- 50:11doesn't feel like it's moving at a frenetic pace.
- 50:13There really is one event that happens and some
- 50:16instances around it. So for that, with the pacing,
- 50:19I'm not as in love with it as I think I want.
- 50:22to be sure i really do want to love it but there
- 50:25is some incredible examples of cinematography
- 50:26and everything so where while i gave it three
- 50:28stars again letterboxd get at me we need 0 .25
- 50:32on this i'd love to give it like a 3 .75 i don't
- 50:34think it's quite a four for me but i'm gonna
- 50:36go with the 3 .5 okay i think that's where i'm
- 50:39at with this it is very good i i ultimately may
- 50:42come back and rate that a little higher but my
- 50:44initial thought of this is 3 .5 so i i did really
- 50:47enjoy this yeah the you cheated You haven't posted
- 50:51on Letterboxd. I didn't. So I don't know your
- 50:53rating. And not because I'm a cheater, but because
- 50:55I forgot. It's both. Fair. Yeah, the third component
- 51:01when I was talking about working on a film set
- 51:03that I forgot to mention was background. And
- 51:05I think when this movie first opens up, the amount
- 51:08of background actors to make the train station
- 51:11and Beijing just look alive. It's large. It's
- 51:14so impressive. And there are so many characters.
- 51:18extras rather, like running in the foreground
- 51:21of the frame. And I think that's kind of what
- 51:24adds to that pacing. It makes everything feel
- 51:27very lived in and very chaotic. And I think without
- 51:31all of that masterful placement of background
- 51:34actors, you wouldn't have that same kind of kinetic
- 51:37energy building this universe and making it feel
- 51:39real. And I think with the trifecta there of
- 51:43extras, blocking, lighting. It propels this movie
- 51:46for me, even though the story itself is kind
- 51:49of like, yeah, it's fine. Right. I gave it four
- 51:52stars for that. Okay. It's a gorgeous movie.
- 51:55I love almost every shot in this movie. I think
- 51:59it's perfectly filmed. I think it's a good rating.
- 52:01I think ultimately I may be closer to you than
- 52:03I am right now on that. But yeah, that sounds
- 52:06like a really fair rating. So let's get into
- 52:08our double features. I'm going to have to insist
- 52:11that you go first. Well, mine's chaotic. Mine's
- 52:14uninspired. Well, not uninspired, because I'm
- 52:16inspired. Let me hit you with it. Okay. As we
- 52:19mentioned, Marlene Dietrich worked with Joseph
- 52:22von Sternberg on six films, I believe. It's a
- 52:26good time to note that the only way this is available
- 52:28on physical media with Criterion is the Dietrich
- 52:31and Sternberg collection. Exactly. So it's one
- 52:34of five or six movies. I don't know how many
- 52:37are on that collection. There's a good bit, but
- 52:39that's the only one that's available through
- 52:41Criterion. And actually, the way I watched this
- 52:43movie is Good Friends Videodrome out in Atlanta.
- 52:47I went and I rented Shanghai Express from that
- 52:49collection specifically. And it did come with
- 52:52a really cool 25 -minute supplemental piece.
- 52:55I would have loved to have seen that. Yeah. Thank
- 52:57you, Videodrome. Oh, my God. I forgot who the
- 52:59guest was on that, but it was so good. But yes.
- 53:01I love von Sternberg's style here. I love the
- 53:05way that he allows Dietrich to, like, just be
- 53:09the coolest woman in Hollywood ever. So I really
- 53:12want to watch Morocco, and I'm going to pair
- 53:15that as my double feature. Oh. I've never seen
- 53:17it, but when we talked to Rachel with Cult Classic
- 53:21Cinema Archive, she did bring up Morocco specifically
- 53:23and how big that is as not only a public domain
- 53:27movie, but also a pre -code film. Marlene Dietrich
- 53:31has the, like, top hat and the tails, and she
- 53:35does a little dance, and then she kisses a woman
- 53:37on the mouth, and I'm just like, okay. Yeah,
- 53:40I'll watch that. What year is that from? 1931.
- 53:43Oh, wow. No, 1930. It was nominated last year.
- 53:47Oh, but not Best Picture. Yeah, not for Best
- 53:48Picture. So we say, did I miss that? You didn't
- 53:51do your homework with me. So that's my double
- 53:53feature. Sorry that I didn't actually see it,
- 53:55but I'm sure it'll be great. No, that sounds
- 53:58great. I think it's more... I don't want to say
- 54:00inspired, but less chaotic than what I have for
- 54:02you. I looked at the cast of supporting characters.
- 54:06I thought the idea of the characters surrounding
- 54:09this movie and kind of how they lend themselves,
- 54:11they're not the focus, right? And this isn't
- 54:13a movie about a group of people. It really is
- 54:15Doc and... shanghai lily it really is them but
- 54:20they are present and they are there and they're
- 54:22kind of like helping them you mentioned the was
- 54:25it the frenchman or the invalid it was uh eric
- 54:27bomb that convinced or not convinced but told
- 54:30uh doc about she's worth 12 of you he's the invalid
- 54:33yeah so i should not call him the invalid so
- 54:36eric bomb he convinces him like this is you're
- 54:40all wrong about this you need to look at her
- 54:41and then who saves who The idea of, like, you
- 54:44think it would be the captain who saves her,
- 54:47but it's Lily that saves him. And I thought of
- 54:50Beauty and the Beast. Oh. Weirdly. The 1991 Disney
- 54:53classic that was directed by Gary Trosdale and
- 54:57Kirk Wise. I thought a lot of how Eric Baum,
- 55:01and especially Sam Salt, kind of felt like...
- 55:04the Lumiere and Cogsworth, like kind of like
- 55:08helping him get to this point and kind of helped
- 55:11him see over his pride. It was weird. Cause when
- 55:14I first like finished this movie, I was like,
- 55:16what's my double feature. And I thought of the
- 55:17things that I liked the most about this movie.
- 55:19And I didn't look at the cinematography or the
- 55:21lighting. I looked solely at the performances.
- 55:23Sure. And the performances to me, it was definitely
- 55:25like, why am I seeing beauty and the beast in
- 55:26this? And the more that I broke that down, I
- 55:28was like, yeah. I want to clarify a few things.
- 55:31Lily, nothing like Belle. I'm not saying that
- 55:34at all. They are both beautiful. But the idea
- 55:37of the beast needing to be saved in that and
- 55:40Belle being the one to do it, I saw those connections.
- 55:43I was like, that's a really... I'm not going
- 55:45to say it's as good as that movie. I'm not trying
- 55:47to say that at all. But certainly the dynamics
- 55:50of that make an interesting double feature. Now,
- 55:53certainly you bringing up the fact that like
- 55:55there's prostitution at play here, that changes
- 55:57some things in terms of what I recommend it with
- 55:59the Disney movie. Sure. But you know what? We
- 56:01make the rules. We do. So, sure. That's my double
- 56:04feature. Remember when I made the, not rule,
- 56:06but the suggestion of not to double feature with
- 56:09Best Picture nominated movies? Yeah, I just said,
- 56:11I don't care about that. I said whatever. Look,
- 56:15if it helps you, we can always say the Beauty
- 56:18and the Beast from 2018. No, that's fine. We're
- 56:22good. Does that help you? I can do that. It's
- 56:24fine. It's not a big deal. I take back any rule
- 56:27that I once presented. Because we could totally
- 56:30have that on the podcast. Doesn't that feel like
- 56:32a good thing to do? Boy, I don't like that movie.
- 56:34Yeah, it's not good. Yeah. I think the only one
- 56:37that stands on its own for live action is Mulan.
- 56:41I think Mulan is like an actual question. Did
- 56:43you ever see that? Are you being for real? In
- 56:46terms of live action? Yeah. You think that's
- 56:48a good one? You hated that? There's no Mushu.
- 56:51There's differences. She has like superpowers
- 56:54too. Kinda. I might be wrong about that. I think
- 56:56the Jungle Book is my favorite of the live action
- 56:58adaptions. Well, that's because we haven't seen
- 57:00Moana yet. This is... We have talked about Godzilla.
- 57:04We have talked about Disney live action remakes.
- 57:06And it's all because of Shanghai Express. It
- 57:08is. And it led the way to this. So again, I invited
- 57:11the chaos. I really enjoyed this and I would
- 57:14love to eventually pick up. And final note here,
- 57:18the way that Sternberg has decided to like film
- 57:22this and have it lit to the credit of Lee Garns,
- 57:25who again was one for this. I really am interested
- 57:28in picking out that collection. I am too. And
- 57:30watching the rest of those. This is the last
- 57:31thing I'll say. The last time I went to McKay,
- 57:34that collection was there. Dog. And I was like,
- 57:37yeah, I don't know if I'm really into this. I've
- 57:39never seen a Von Sternberg or a Dietrich. And
- 57:43it's like 60 bucks. And that's only a little
- 57:45bit cheaper than this. Sure. If Criterion did,
- 57:48it's 50%. Whatever. I talked myself out of it.
- 57:51And now I'm like. Well, it's out of print now.
- 57:53What? I think so. Maybe it's not. Maybe I made
- 57:57that up. But either way, I would have picked
- 57:58it up. Dude, I'm so upset with myself. Well,
- 58:00you know what? If you have it out there and you
- 58:02think it's great, you let us know and you let
- 58:04Kyle know how much you messed up. Yeah, please
- 58:06do. And if you have thoughts about this movie
- 58:08or any of the other films nominated at the Fifth
- 58:10Academy Awards, shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 58:13at gmail .com. Let us know who your favorite
- 58:17or what your favorite Marlene Dietrich performance
- 58:19in collaboration with Von Sternberg was. And
- 58:23be sure to check out the Patreon, patreon .com
- 58:26slash O -U -T -A -O podcast for access to the
- 58:30community Discord, the watch parties, episodes
- 58:33available early, and movie reviews, all kinds
- 58:37of things, all kinds of fun. And rate and review
- 58:40the podcast because that does help us out. And,
- 58:43yeah, next episode we'll be covering one hour
- 58:45you. Nope. We'll be covering one hour with you.
- 58:50Our third. lubish film and this will have a special
- 58:54guest along with us danny reed of pre -code essentials
- 58:57uh the other half of the uh pre -code essentials
- 59:00when we spoke last week so yeah it was yeah it
- 59:04was the five -star final was uh friday yeah no
- 59:06uh it was wednesday but it was still last champ
- 59:09was friday yeah nailed it we're nailing it we're
- 59:11doing great we're doing great very excited to
- 59:13talk with danny me too me too can't wait but
- 59:15that's gonna do it As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan.
- 59:19And we'll see you at the movies.