Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow with Force: Chapter 2 - The Fixer Identity
Transcript
- Catalyst - Chapter 2: Think about a person you can rely on, a person who knows how to calm the room, the one who tends to notice problems others might. The one who organizes, repairs, guides, and often steps forward when something needs Most of us appreciate those people. We trust them, depend on them. What we don't discuss is the cost of becoming that person. Because usefulness can become all-encompassing, not in a loud way, in a quiet, seemingly stabilizing way. The more useful we become, the more we are rewarded for being useful. Eventually, stops being something we do and becoming part of who we are. Welcome to Catalyst, the podcast of thought. I'm Dr. G, an executive coach, trained ethnographer, and nonfiction nerd. I read nonfiction stuff and annotate it obsessively and spend a great deal of time thinking about how ideas shape the way we live, lead, and notice the world around us. In this episode, I'll explore how the fixer identity develops, why it feels so rewarding, and what happens when a strength quietly becomes a burden. Sometimes the very thing that makes us valuable can also become the thing that exhausts us. There's a certain kind of person we rely on. Not because of their title, not because they were formerly appointed. They just show up when something needs attention. Maybe it's just a problem, a conflict, a broken thing, a different conversation. Uncertainty something they notice. Move it and engage with it. If you tend to fix ⁓ over something subtle can happen. What began is your behavior, can become your identity. You stop being someone who occasionally helps, ⁓ you The helper, the fixer, the one people call on, the one people expect from, one people trust. At first you feel great, valuable, Those matter more than most of us may realize. My personal sense ⁓ of a identity began long before I knew what to call it. As a kid, I couldn't actually fix much of anything. It wasn't like rebuilding engines or you know, rewiring our house, but I could organize, I could clean, I could maintain stuff, I could improve it from my point of view. When my mother left for work during the summer, she'd leave a list of chores waiting for me. I completed them immediately, every one of them. Then I'd disappear into the adventure of, you know, summer childhood, fishing, exploring, biking, whatever the day offered. But first, the list. lawn would be mowed, the leaves would be cleared, the garage would be organized. Not mostly, completely. If there were leaves tucked between tree roots, boy, I'd get those two. You know, missing spots really wasn't my thing. And looking back, I can see something forming, like this high level competence, just a reliability. And reliability carries rewards. People noticed, people trusted me, people depended on me. Those rewards felt really good. and years later, during college, I worked ⁓ summers campus, most of the crew consisted of football players and wrestlers, my friends. We're just a bunch of boneheads with strong backs and highly questionable decision making skills. At the beginning of my first summer, our supervisor gathered everyone together, the previous year's student supervisor stood nearby. He'd assumed he'd get to continue in the role. Instead, our boss named me. My teammate and now co-worker asked why he wasn't getting the position. And a as bold as he was, looked at him and said, because I know Schnagel will show up. And then he me the key to the kingdom: fifty cents more an hour, ⁓ more responsibility, more more usefulness. And I carried that master key physically and emotionally for the rest of my college years. At the time, I thought I was being rewarded for reliability. I was also being rewarded for becoming useful. Not only showing up, but showing up to a certain degree. And that sense of usefulness is You know where you fit, you know you can contribute, you know your The challenge is that usefulness rarely stays contained. It expands, it spreads into other areas of your life. By twenty two I was managing a toy store. Ironically, the most meaningful part of the job wasn't inventory management operations, it was people. I started in the warehouse and on the sales floor, and eventually I requested a transfer to the customer service, the front end, the human end. That's where the energy was. That's where the problems were. Angry customers, nervous employees, difficult conversations, conflict. I discovered something about myself. I helping people navigate difficult situations. ⁓ And I was pretty good at it. I wasn't necessarily fixing the situation or them, not yet. I was becoming a a guide, a stabilizer. I was trying to find simple solutions to complex problems. I could de-escalate, I could clarify things, calm people down. The work energized me. I didn't know it then, but I was laying the foundation for my future teaching, consulting, and executive coaching roles. My fixer identity was evolving, just fixing things, but fixing situations. Fixing relationships, fixing emotions, fixing uncertainty. Over time the question quietly became, needs to be fixed here? It's not a bad question. Sometimes it's exactly the right question. When it becomes your default question, it shaping how you see the world, your point of view. You don't simply hear people, you start diagnosing them. You don't simply experience situations, you Assess them. And you don't simply sit with uncertainty. You feel obligated to move toward resolution. And again, not intentionally, just automatically. is where force begins taking root as default, not as aggression, as an orientation, as a learned response to validate your own worth. And here's the important part. I don't believe most fixtures are born. I think they're built, programmed by situation experience reinforced by the environments they live in, rewarded through repetition, and ⁓ resulting in a hyperattunement. Now this is the the the kicker. Hyper attunement develops when we repeatedly learn that noticing problems and responding effectively reduces the tension. We notice, we respond, relieve stress, we get rewarded. We wash, rinse, repeat. Eventually you become very good at reading situations, needs, good sensing the emotional weather. The problem is that hyperattunment eventually becomes hypervigilance, self-imposed hypervigilance. don't notice because you choose to. You notice because you can't not. So you enter a room and immediately assess it rather than experience it. You monitor moods rather than participate them. You track tension rather than just exist. You scan for problems, needs, and while everyone else appears relaxed, part of your mind is already working, already calculating, already preparing to fix. Because where the rewards were found. And the rewards do continue, but so do the costs. The cost being the fixer of heart and home can be high. Exhaustion, resentment, anxiety. The inability to fully rest, the inability to fully stop your mind, the loneliness of constantly supporting others without expressing your own needs. I know all these things personally. And there were times when I wasn't simply helping people, I was carrying them, or at least carrying what I imagined needed me to carry. Their worries, their uncertainty, their struggles, their fears. Key point here. No one asked me to do that. No one asked me to do that. I've only told myself to do it subconsciously. Because caring felt useful. felt useful. I felt valuable. And look that lesson took decades to fully understand. Some of the hardest lessons ⁓ I learned ⁓ about force in fix when it unnecessary came through One of those mistakes happened. Many, many years ago in a hockey ring parking lot. Our son was nine years old. mind you. He had just finished a summer league game. Summer league. From my perspective, though, he kind of coasted through the final periods. So ⁓ my fixer identity, I decided this required an intervention. Yep, you know where this is going. A conversation, a correction, a lesson from the fixer. So there we sat in the parking lot, the dreaded post-game car convo. As a father, coach, and fixer. ⁓ I explained. Effort, reliability, expectations. All the concepts that had served me well. Finally he spoke. Okay, I get it, okay? He pushed back appropriately, advocating for himself, and he I deserved it. That moment still hurts. I wasn't helping him. I was imposing my fixer identity him, onto the situation that wasn't asked to being fixed. A force applied in a complex environment like that, that I created, it produced pain, not growth. It actually parallels what happened before in first year of teaching. I was twenty two years old, and my student, Alan, spent the entire day wearing a red Power Rangers costume. Lunch, recess, every t everywhere. He was six, you know, and his Power Ranger themed birthday party was that night. He could barely hold himself together. So as we lined up for the buses, he excitedly told me every detail of the upcoming celebration. At the exact same moment, I was trying to hear some of the bus announcement changes over the loudspeaker. Right? Simple situation that I chose to turn complex. In that instance that required my presence, I force, fix her identity. I abruptly turned and said, Alan, ⁓ shut to six year old. Tears filled his eyes, ⁓ shame filled heart, right? Alan didn't need correction. needed connection. He needed participation. I presented him with control, a fix with force. So ⁓ like this taught me something important. Not situation is a problem, Greg. Not every requires your intervention. And not every requires you being involved. That realization deepened significantly when I discovered. at the time instructional coaching, helping teachers. While supporting some well seasoned educators, under the career, very competent, I found myself receiving difficult feedback from them. Words like condescending, patronizing. Yeah, those comments stung, they also accurate. I was using the same approach I'd use with beginning teachers that didn't know what they didn't know: observation, diagnosis, direction, correction, which is appropriate for people into a new space. The problem was that these educators weren't looking for a supervisor. They were look or a mentor or a sensei. They were looking for a thought partner, a compassionate colleague, an active observer to help them grow in their profession after decades of experience. Around that time, I encountered Michael Benge Steiner's book, The Coaching Habit. introduced me to three questions that changed the way I saw myself ⁓ the way I interacted. The three questions are: what's on your mind? And what else? How might I help? Three simple questions, many powerful results. What fascinated me was what happened after the second question. He called it the awe question, A-W-E. And what else? The real issue at hand only appeared after that question was asked. we're talking 45 minutes to an hour into the conversation. Not five minutes, not but but 45 minutes. The first answer wasn't the answer. The second answer wasn't either. The real challenge Lived deep under the cover of many assumptions. Those three questions taught me patience, taught me participation, taught me discovery unfolds often when we stop trying to force revelation. Flowing with the conversation rather than managing it, rather than leading, participating rather than directing. Then came a lesson I couldn't fix my way through. Mesenteric paniculitis, the name, a rare autoimmune condition. Severe pain, no known cause, no known cure. For years I cycled through denial, anger, bargaining, you know, that was levels depression. I diets, eliminated foods, modified my habits, analyzed the analysis of my analysis of behaviors. I researched endlessly, I treated my body like a puzzle waiting to be solved. a fixer. Nothing worked. Eventually diagnosis arrived. With it, something unexpected. Not because I a cure. I finally had an answer. The answer was, Greg, you can't fix this. And strangely enough, that's when my healing began. Not physically healing, I'm it's still there, but my healing of identity. I started recognizing how often I had been carrying things that didn't belong to me. My worries, other people's worries, my anxieties, other people's anxieties. The emotional weight of entire rooms, thought carrying all of it made me valuable. My usefulness expressed. Instead, it was just exhausting me. And nobody was asking me to carry it. Nobody. I've come to accept that the strategy that built me was longer. Sustaining me. The identity that protected me was beginning to constrain me. The effort that once produced movement was not producing friction. that realization resulted in some grief. Not grief over losing a diagnosis, grief over losing a point of view. The belief that if I simply tried hard enough, could solve it. Whatever it was. today when the condition mesenteric paniculitis flares up, I respond differently. I don't fight it. I don't negotiate it with it. I don't try to overpower it. I acknowledge it, listen to it, then, as one of my cellophane guests and childhood friends, Jennifer Colletti said, I surrender into the experience. Not surrender to it, but surrender into it. And there's a difference. Perhaps where this episode ultimately leads. ⁓ For years I thought usefulness meant carrying things, carrying problems, carrying responsibility, carrying uncertainty, carrying the emotional weight that no one asked me to carry. What I've learned is that participation not require possession. Participation does not require possession. I can walk beside someone physically, emotionally. Without carrying them. I can help uncover an answer without becoming responsible for it. can contribute to the fix without leading an intervention. That realization changed my coaching, my teaching, my leadership, my relationships, and most importantly, my relationship with myself. My my sense of usefulness. ⁓ Is no longer determined by how much I can solve or improve or carry. Sometimes contribution looks like intervention, sometimes participation. wisdom is knowing which one the situation requires. The fixer identity doesn't develop because we're trying to control people. It develops because helping works. It earns trust, creates value, and provides a sense of purpose and belonging within us. Over time, however, usefulness can quietly become an expectation. An expectation can become our identity. The challenge begins when we continue applying the same fixer strategies long after the situation has changed. When helping Becomes carrying, when guidance becomes intervention, when effort becomes force. Those strategies work so well for so long that our first instinct is rarely to question them. Our first instinct is usually to try harder, to push more, to tighten the grip. Then comes a moment when more effort no longer produces more progress. A moment when the strategy that built us no longer sustain us. ⁓ That's where we will begin in the next episode. Chapter three Effort Stops Working. I'm Doctor G, those my thoughts. Thanks for listening.