Latest / Radio Baloney - The Richie Baloney Show! / TRUDEAU'S Online Censorship Bill Begins It's Work
Transcript
- 0:03So I've been talking about Bill C eleven in Canada, Trudeau's online censorship bill
- 0:08since it was conceived, but it looks like the world is starting to take
- 0:12notice. Now here's from Glenn Greenwald. The Canadian government, armed with one
- 0:16of the world's most repressive online censorship schemes, announced that all online streaming services
- 0:23that offer podcasts podcasts mine you must formally register with the government to permit regulatory
- 0:30controls. And let's take a look at this news release from the CRTC,
- 0:34which is the regulatory body in Canada for traditionally for radio and television. Now
- 0:40it's getting its clause into the Internet as well, and part of its mission
- 0:44is to force Canadian content on us. That's why I know all the words
- 0:48to Life as a Highway. Believe me, I wish I didn't thanks a
- 0:52lot CRTC, And in typically a euphemistic language, it says CRTC takes major
- 0:59step forward to modernize Canada's broadcasting framework. And I think that what they really
- 1:04meant was control Canada's broadcasting framework. But they choose to say modernized because I
- 1:11think it doesn't sound as bad. And as we go through this, it
- 1:12doesn't actually sound that bad, but I'm going to explain to you just how
- 1:17insidious it really is. Says First, the CRTC is setting out which online
- 1:23streaming services need to provide information about their activities in Canada. And actually that
- 1:30does sound a little authoritarian, doesn't it. Online streaming services that operate in
- 1:34Canada offer broadcasting content and earn ten million or more in annual revenues will need
- 1:41to complete a registration form by November twenty eight, twenty twenty three. Registration
- 1:48collects basic information is only required once and can be completed in just a few
- 1:53steps. And I wonder what comes after those just simple few steps guests are
- 1:57going to find out and to how they send it? It to ten million
- 2:00or more in annual revenues. So it's not just Twitter, it's not just
- 2:05YouTube. Right, If you're an independent media organization making ten million or more
- 2:09in annual revenues, well the CRTCM, well they want to talk to you.
- 2:15But anyway, Second, the CRTC is setting conditions for online streaming services
- 2:20to operate in Canada. These conditions take effect today and require certain online streaming
- 2:25services to provide the CRTC with information related to their content and subscribership information related
- 2:34to their content and subscribership. And I wonder why they would need that,
- 2:39but I mean, they're definitely not looking to control what Canadians can see.
- 2:43Don't worry about that. The decision also requires those services to make content available
- 2:47in a way that is not tied to a specific mobile or internet service.
- 2:52Blah blah. And in the quick facts, they're saying social media services must
- 2:55register, however, users do not are on that. In a little bit,
- 3:00online services that offer podcasts must register, however, individuals who use social
- 3:06media to share podcasts do not. Again, more on this than a little
- 3:10bit. This is where the insidious part comes in. Online services that only
- 3:15provide video game services or audiobooks do not have to register, and list of
- 3:20services will be published on the website. Blah blah blah. Now I'll show
- 3:23you a tweet here from Billboard Chriss, who does great work, but on
- 3:25this issue here he doesn't quite understand what's happening. He says, no one
- 3:31is censoring user content. No podcasters have to register. Everyone, and it
- 3:37does seem to be literally everyone is falsely reporting on this story. And I
- 3:42have to disagree with this. Yes, no podcasters have to register, not
- 3:46yet, but as for this. No one is censoring user content. That
- 3:50is the purpose of this bill, Bill ce Levin, and what the crt
- 3:53C is doing. And if it weren't doing that, it wouldn't exist,
- 3:57It wouldn't have a purpose, there would be no reason for it to exist.
- 4:00But again it's quite insidious. Now let's go to this CRTC facts fade
- 4:04here, Facts and myths. Myth. The CRTC will regulate content and digital
- 4:11creators. Fact, we will only regulate broadcasters, including providers of both traditional
- 4:15broadcasting services and online streaming services. Okay, but want does regulate broadcasters being
- 4:25exactly what they're just gonna go for lunch with what they're just going to watch
- 4:29them and chain smoke? So want does regulate broadcasters? Actually mean though?
- 4:34I mean it has to be something they're doing, something that they're setting rules
- 4:40that the broadcasters have to go by. And what do the streaming services do
- 4:45they provide content to people? What are the rules going to be, what
- 4:47are the regulations going to be? YouTube has to make sure they have maple
- 4:51syrup in the cafeteria. How about this myth? The CRTC will regulate social
- 4:57media users and user content. Fact, we will only regulate broadcasters broadcasting services
- 5:03and online streaming services that make programming available to the public. Okay, so
- 5:11I am not going to have to get permission from the CRTC to upload a
- 5:15video. But where am I uploading that video too? To the streaming service?
- 5:18And that's who the CRTC is going to be regulating. It's not going
- 5:24to be happening on an individual basis with me, although I mean, if
- 5:28there's no power to regulate what the broadcasters can show, there's no point for
- 5:32this to exist in the first place. It says the goal of the Modernized
- 5:36Broadcasting Act is to ensure that content made by Canadians and Indigenous creators is supported
- 5:44and promoted on traditional broadcasting services and online streaming services. And here we start
- 5:51getting to what's really going on, and what this is about is picking winners
- 5:57and losers. Can you guess who the winners might be? There might be
- 6:00people who like the Trudeau government, like I don't know, maybe the CBC.
- 6:04Say, now we get to this one myth CRTC will regulate the algorithms
- 6:11of online streaming services. Fact, we will not regulate algorithms. We want
- 6:16to encourage innovation to make Canadian and Indigenous content easier to find all of it?
- 6:24Do you think they mean all of it? They say we cannot order
- 6:27online streaming services to use specific algorithms to promote Canadian and Indigenous content. There
- 6:33are many other ways to make Canadian and Indigenous content easier to find, which
- 6:39could include promotional campaigns or featuring content on the services home page. So again,
- 6:46who's going to get promoted? Am I going to get promoted? Is
- 6:49the CRTC going to demand that I get promoted or one hundred thousand other Canadian
- 6:55content creators? Or are they going to be certain ones they want promoted?
- 6:59Are they going to be giving them a list of people they want promoted?
- 7:01Well, they'd pretty much have to, wouldn't they. They have to.
- 7:04Who's going to pick the winners and losers YouTube? No, that's obviously know
- 7:09what this bill is about. This bill is about the CRTC and by extension,
- 7:13the Liberal government being able to pick the winners and losers. They're saying,
- 7:16we will not regulate algorithms. Well what does it mean, Well,
- 7:20how are you going to do this exactly? I mean you may not be
- 7:23going in and changing the code yourself, but what gets on the homepage is
- 7:28part of the algorithm. So you're going to be influencing in some way.
- 7:30Again, if you weren't, there'd be no point in this. This is
- 7:34about picking winners and losers politically. And by the way, this is just
- 7:40to start, right, This is just to start where they're trying to see.
- 7:43Not scary, right. Do you think they're going to give power back?
- 7:46Do you think they're not going to take more power? No? No,
- 7:49this is just them dipping their toes in the water. And I'll tell
- 7:53you something else. You know, people keep saying that they think Trudeau's gonna
- 7:56resign. He's not gonna resign. No, No, he's in for the
- 7:59long hall. He's going to go down swinging and stuff like this is a
- 8:03reason to give him hope. He's now got the CRTC that's going to be
- 8:07demanding that certain content is going to be promoted put on the homepage on YouTube,
- 8:13and I can tell you right now that is going to be CBC.
- 8:15You're going to see CBC everywhere on YouTube. And obviously the only way they
- 8:20can achieve this is by instructing the social media companies of what they want promoted
- 8:24and what they want on the homepage. And if that's not regulating the algorithm.
- 8:31Well, I guess they given them a list of stuff that they don't
- 8:33want people to see, like maybe Rebel Media, for instance, or True
- 8:37North or anything like my channel. And I guess that wouldn't be regulating the
- 8:41algorithm either, would it. Again, there's no other point to this.
- 8:43This is the entire reason for this bill to exist. It's obvious, and
- 8:50just that it's coming from the Trudeau government alone is enough to recognize that it
- 8:54has sinister intent. And you know, in this tweet from Billboard Christo again,
- 8:58I think it's great, but you know, he says no podcasters have
- 9:01to register yet yet, and it doesn't matter anyway, because they're obviously going
- 9:07to use this bill. They'll see levin to promote their own propaganda and demote
- 9:13anything that dissents from it. So anyway, if you like this video,
- 9:18you'd better subscribe to my channel now, you know, unless you think that
- 9:22the CRTC is going to demand I be on the home page right anyway,
- 9:26please subscribe, like and share sharing really helps me out. I thank you
- 9:31for that. I will see you next time.