Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E018: David Zell – Bitcoin's Alignment with American Values
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity.
- 0:10Where the? Supply is unaffected by the
- 0:13demand. If you want to preserve your
- 0:16wealth, you have to convert that currency into an asset that's
- 0:21scarce, desirable, portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:31Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom and I'm happy to welcome you to
- 0:34the 17th episode of Scarce Assets, a show that examines
- 0:38scarcity, the most fundamental driver of economics and markets,
- 0:41and the scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 0:44I'm delighted to be here with my Co host Jesse Myers and our
- 0:47guest David Zell. Now I'm going to start this chat
- 0:50with a reflection on how I felt when I first learned about the
- 0:54Bitcoin Policy Institute, which David runs.
- 0:57I'm not a religious man, but my gut reaction was, thank God, in
- 1:02a sea of grift, you know, here was a serious organization
- 1:06staffed with credible and talented people that was putting
- 1:09out thoughtful balance content on Bitcoin and helping policy
- 1:13makers and average citizens on both sides of the aisle to
- 1:16understand Bitcoin and its benefits and frankly, risks for
- 1:20the US and the world. So ever since finding the
- 1:24organization, I've personally been continually impressed by
- 1:27it. I hope that came out in our
- 1:29recent interviews here on Scarce assets with both Troy Cross and
- 1:33Matt Pines, who are both fellows of the organization.
- 1:36I'm sure it will also when we interview the organization's
- 1:40founder, Ovic Roy next week. But today I'm delighted to be
- 1:44going straight to the top and welcoming its Co Executive
- 1:47director, David Zell. So David, thank you for the work
- 1:50you do and thank you for coming on scarce assets.
- 1:53And how are you? I'm well, yeah, thanks for
- 1:58thanks for having me. On slight correction though,
- 2:00OVIC is an advisor to BPI but not the founder.
- 2:05Oh OK my my my mistake. My mistake.
- 2:08I thought he was a Co founder. I guess I'm wrong you'll.
- 2:11Have to correct a song. Yeah, that would be me and Grant
- 2:15McCarty, who Co founded the the organization.
- 2:18But Ovic's fantastic. He's he's our senior advisor and
- 2:22he is the founder of another think tank in DC, so.
- 2:27And that's free OP. And I'm sure we'll, we'll talk
- 2:30talk with him about that. Well, thank you for the for the
- 2:33correction. You know, let's since you are
- 2:36the founder, let's start with BPI and it's and it's mission,
- 2:40you know, since day one. What does the organization seek
- 2:43to accomplish? Yeah, Well, I honestly think
- 2:48first of all, I'm just like, really happy to be here.
- 2:50It's great to meet you, Jesse. You are the author of probably
- 2:55my favorite article ever written about Bitcoin, and an article
- 2:59that I think actually really explains what BPI is and why it
- 3:03exists. Which is for I guess people who
- 3:05are watching and don't know why the yuppie elite dismiss
- 3:08Bitcoin. I think that article in a
- 3:12nutshell pretty much explains like why we exist.
- 3:16There are. Amazing.
- 3:19Yeah, there are a lot of people who have like brilliant things
- 3:23to say about Bitcoin who communicate those insights in a
- 3:28way that is non standard, right? Whether it's like the early
- 3:32days, like people sort of talking eloquently and, and you
- 3:36know, intelligently about Bitcoin on like the talk forum,
- 3:40you know, whether it's sort of Twitter or podcasts, These
- 3:43aren't the mediums that policy makers are, you know, sort of
- 3:47habituated to, to trust and, and get information from.
- 3:52And so, you know, early on, I often joked with people that
- 3:54like the goal of BPI was to basically take everything that
- 3:57was ever, you know, thoughtful and insightful from the Bitcoin
- 4:01talk forums and just kind of put it in a think tank wrapper so
- 4:04that people would actually read it.
- 4:07I think the organization has matured a lot since then.
- 4:09And you know, one of my initial theses was actually wrong.
- 4:13Like at the time, I kind of had the view of it's impossible to
- 4:16say anything new about Bitcoin and like all of the smart things
- 4:18one could say about it or probably said, you know, no
- 4:21earlier or no later than like, you know, 2013.
- 4:25But I've discovered that there actually are some insightful
- 4:27things that you can say about Bitcoin as the asset grows in,
- 4:32in size and liquidity and number of users.
- 4:35And for us at BPI, the goal has been to sort of help policy
- 4:41makers think through the benefits and risks, like you
- 4:44pointed out that that Bitcoin poses to to America, to, you
- 4:51know, Western liberal democracies writ large.
- 4:54And so our sort of four research pillars kind of I think help
- 4:58explain like the areas that we we focus on as an organization,
- 5:02right, sort of national security and Geo economics, of course,
- 5:06like extremely relevant, you know, in the past few years,
- 5:09right, whether and to what extent nation states will try to
- 5:12utilize crypto rails or Bitcoin specifically to evade sanctions,
- 5:17the use of, you know, Bitcoin or crypto in in illicit finance,
- 5:24you know, North Korea, like the Lazarus group, right, hacking
- 5:27these like shaky sort of defy bridges and essentially
- 5:31bootstrapping a multi billion dollar weapons program by
- 5:34exploiting the sort of move fast break things philosophy of of
- 5:38like crypto and and defy sort of mining and energy.
- 5:43I feel like that one's pretty self-evident financial inclusion
- 5:47and human rights also pretty self-evident, right.
- 5:51I think some of the most obvious benefits of Bitcoin are, are
- 5:55really conferred on people outside of the West, right on,
- 5:58on, on people who don't have the privilege of using like an
- 6:01awesome currency like the dollar.
- 6:04So sort of showcasing the, the human rights use cases of, of
- 6:07Bitcoin, really taking a lot of the stuff that HRF does and, and
- 6:11presenting that to the policy community.
- 6:14And then this sort of sole pillar, which we call sort of
- 6:17the future of money. And that's where we sort of deal
- 6:19with a lot of the the regulatory stuff.
- 6:23So yeah, you know, our formal mission, that's the long winded
- 6:26answer. Our Our formal mission is to
- 6:28educate policy makers and the public on Bitcoin and disruptive
- 6:32digital technologies and to provide nonpartisan, research
- 6:36based insights that inform sound policy in America.
- 6:41At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 6:44asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 6:48right. There are shortcomings with
- 6:50keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 6:53up your own self custody arrangement.
- 6:55On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 6:58Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 7:01minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 7:04remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 7:08inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 7:10well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 7:13for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 7:16for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 7:19set up. For more information, check us
- 7:21out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, that's a that's a lofty
- 7:28and noble goal and I don't want to repeat myself, but you know,
- 7:33I think you guys are the best, the best at it out there doing
- 7:36it. Thank you.
- 7:37Maybe we should maybe. Yeah.
- 7:38No, Appreciate, appreciate your efforts.
- 7:41Maybe a question I should ask at this moment is you just laid
- 7:46out, I don't know, probably 5 areas where you're making an
- 7:51impact. Which of those do you think has
- 7:54seen the greatest progress with respect to either policy makers
- 8:00understanding or the public's understanding?
- 8:04Is there an area where you're where you're making more
- 8:06progress lately and that's exciting?
- 8:10Definitely, I think the national security angle a a few reasons,
- 8:16like why, you know, 1 is that the, the people in the national
- 8:23security and sort of intelligence communities are
- 8:27less political inherently. They're less focused on like
- 8:31elections on sort of short term thinking.
- 8:34Like, you know, there's sort of a cohort of people in Washington
- 8:37whose job it is to think deeply about the sort of grand strategy
- 8:43of the United States and who are of course, sort of accustomed to
- 8:48re calibrating strategies after, you know, disruptive
- 8:51technologies like emerge. And so, you know, I, I think
- 8:55we've had an outsized impact in those spheres.
- 9:01You know, there are, I think a lot of progress has been made on
- 9:05the mining and energy front as well.
- 9:07But I mean those it's like sort of the Brandalini's law thing,
- 9:10right? Like the, the anti Bitcoin
- 9:12argument vis a vis climate is just very simple.
- 9:15It's very sticky. It makes a lot of sense.
- 9:17The counter arguments are a little convoluted sometimes.
- 9:21And you know, the the truth is like obviously like a lot more
- 9:27nuanced than mining is bad for the environment.
- 9:30So it's it's sort of a constant uphill battle there with just
- 9:33like the the asymmetry of ease of argumentation.
- 9:37But yeah, I would say I've been pleasantly surprised by the
- 9:40reception that we've had by members of the national security
- 9:44community who are interested in through bitcoins role in the
- 9:47global S where, you know, some of our biggest adversaries like
- 9:52China are spending a ton of money to onboard people to
- 9:56their. I'm sure this is something that
- 9:57Matt talked about with you guys, like sort of onboarding people
- 10:01in those areas who, you know, really don't have many options
- 10:04when it comes to connecting to the global financial system and
- 10:07are being pushed a fairly authoritarian, you know,
- 10:10technology stack. Whether it's sort of the Huawei
- 10:12like 5G stuff, whether it's, you know, sort of I think down the
- 10:15line trying to push the digital yuan and kind of get these
- 10:19people into a a sort of Chinese central bank digital currency
- 10:24system. So a lot of that stuff is just
- 10:27wonkier, right? It's less politically charged.
- 10:30You know, your average voter is not really thinking about these
- 10:33topics. And so, you know, I, I think
- 10:36there's sort of an inverse relationship between how much
- 10:39attention an issue gets and how easy it is to change people's
- 10:43minds and make a difference with respect to policy.
- 10:46And I, I think we sort of have seen that play out in our
- 10:48efforts to help people think through Bitcoin in the context
- 10:53of sort of geopolitical competition.
- 10:55And and this sort of particular strain of geopolitical
- 10:58competition that we're seeing now, which is competition
- 11:02playing out through through tech networks, whether it's like
- 11:08monetary communications, things like that.
- 11:13And do you think that the progress being made there, I may
- 11:16have missed your point? Is it because of the difference
- 11:20in how much, let's say the mainstream media cover that
- 11:23topic as it relates to Bitcoin versus the environmental issues?
- 11:28Or is it, is it because it's more of a Greenfield area and
- 11:32it's been sort of a jump ball, like less people just have
- 11:35thought about Bitcoin in the context of national security?
- 11:40I think that's part of it, but I think the biggest reason is kind
- 11:44of what I said earlier, right, that like this is a community of
- 11:46people who are, you know, for example, the Internet, you know,
- 11:50when when the Internet became like widely diffused, we we went
- 11:54from a world where people weren't using it unless you
- 11:58couldn't use it unless you had a.millorlikea.edu, you know,
- 12:01domain. So sort of restricted to the
- 12:04government and academia. Then all of a sudden, like, you
- 12:07know, the Internet proliferates and it just changes the game.
- 12:10Like the earliest adopters of e-mail were like drug dealers
- 12:12and terrorists because it was like super easy to plan a
- 12:16terrorist attack or plan a drug drop using e-mail.
- 12:20And it's really like you go back and look at the history of
- 12:23arguments around or Internet, specifically regulation in the
- 12:26early 90s, and they just mirror the arguments against Bitcoin
- 12:29and for Bitcoin, like almost perfectly, right?
- 12:33The concern is that this sort of technology that we don't really
- 12:37control is going to wind up in the hands of malign actors and
- 12:41it'll be sort of a tool for them to achieve malign ends.
- 12:45And then the counter argument is that, hey, there's something
- 12:47kind of like, you know, beautiful about the Internet,
- 12:50right? It's sort of embodies some of
- 12:51these like core American values, like the idea that you can speak
- 12:55your mind anywhere in the world. You know, now it's not so true.
- 12:59But at least at the time, the thinking was, you know, the
- 13:01Internet was this like gateway to, you know, to free speech, to
- 13:05free assembly, that it would be a boon for global capitalism
- 13:09that that, you know, sort of talent and capital could
- 13:13connect. Well, you know, transfer
- 13:14borders. Like there's the sort of the
- 13:15same argument. And so, yeah, I just think
- 13:19people in the three letter agencies in the national
- 13:21security community, I've also been paying attention to Bitcoin
- 13:25for a lot longer than the average person.
- 13:28I mean, we know that like the CIA was having, you know,
- 13:32briefings on on Bitcoin as like early as like 2000 and like 12
- 13:35or whatever. And so, yeah, I think this is a
- 13:39group of people who by and large are fairly clear eyed with
- 13:42respect to disruptive transformations in in society
- 13:47and have sort of asks and incentives that Orient them to
- 13:52paying more attention to like tail risks.
- 13:56You know, their their job is not to sort of decide whether or not
- 13:58Bitcoin is good or bad or even whether it will succeed or fail,
- 14:03but to recognize, hey, like maybe there's a 10% chance that
- 14:06Bitcoin monetizes to reach parity with, say gold.
- 14:09Well, what does that mean? Like we need a plan for that.
- 14:12So I think it's just a bunch of kind of quirks of that community
- 14:17that make. Them more receptive.
- 14:18To the type of stuff that we put out.
- 14:21Yeah, that makes complete sense. The other thing that occurs to
- 14:23me also as we're speaking is it probably doesn't hurt that most
- 14:27of the world's cryptographic talent, you know, up until very
- 14:33recently was employed by NSA, right?
- 14:36Right, yeah. And I mean, there's like
- 14:38credible, there's like credible arguments that you could maybe
- 14:40trace some of bitcoins origins to like research out of the NSA.
- 14:44And so, yeah, I mean, it's a, it's a group of people that I
- 14:48think are are well aligned to thinking about the questions
- 14:52that we're interested in in asking and answering as a think
- 14:54tank. So that makes me curious and and
- 14:59perhaps I'm layering in too much as too many assumptions here,
- 15:02but it sort of sounds like you've enjoyed to date a bit
- 15:09more openness from folks in DC to consider many aspects of
- 15:16Bitcoin as a non partisan topic. Do you fear that that might be
- 15:21shifting and that openness to dialogue may shut down if we
- 15:26continue on the kind of current trajectory we're on?
- 15:29Yeah, truthfully, I'm like really concerned about that.
- 15:34You know, I gosh, there's there's a couple things worth
- 15:39pointing out. One is that I think that
- 15:45Bitcoins most pressing or in consequential public policy
- 15:51decisions and I guess I'll just say Bitcoin, I really get some
- 15:55extra remain Bitcoin users. I, I don't think those are
- 15:59necessarily all going to happen in the next 4 years.
- 16:02And so I think the part of my thinking in this project that's
- 16:06BPI is like, how do we ensure good policy for Bitcoin users in
- 16:11the United States for the next 40 years and not just like the
- 16:15next 4. So I think 1 is kind of like,
- 16:18you know, it, it, it depends on what your goals are.
- 16:20Like, if your goal is to sort of be an industry lobbyist and pass
- 16:26like tax cuts for miners or, you know, whatever it is, you know,
- 16:31your incentives are a little bit different, right?
- 16:32Like if, if a, if a presidential candidate is kind of signalling
- 16:35that, you know, they're willing to pass a bunch of really
- 16:39positive policy for the industry, you know, it's, it's
- 16:41reasonable to, to sort of support that, especially against
- 16:45the backdrop of, you know, the Biden administration who had
- 16:48such a horrendous, you know, crypto and, and, and Bitcoin,
- 16:51you know, policy. But there are really, there are
- 16:54real risks with that strategy. And, and I think the principal
- 16:58risk is turning Bitcoin and crypto into sort of like a
- 17:02partisan football. And I think that would be a bad
- 17:05and unfortunate outcome. If like, you know, you, you
- 17:08mentioned before you started the call, like, you know, some
- 17:10political news may have moved the market up a little bit,
- 17:12right, Like, you know, be kind of hysterical if it's, it's the
- 17:16four year cycle became the four year election cycle.
- 17:19And you know, Bitcoin sort of just trades as like this, you
- 17:22know, privacy for whether or not a Republican will will assume
- 17:25office. I think that's a really
- 17:27undesirable state. I, I really think that part of
- 17:34this is the doing of policy makers and like I, I, I think a
- 17:38lot of the critique online has been levied at individuals who I
- 17:45think are really sympathetic. Like you're you, you, you build
- 17:48a business, you pour your life and soul into it.
- 17:51And one party seems hell bent on regulating you out of existence.
- 17:56And one party is not like, I can't blame anyone for, for
- 18:00voting their, their wallet physical or, or, or, or digital.
- 18:06I think a lot of this is self-imposed by bad policy from
- 18:09the Democrats. And I, I do want to be clear
- 18:11about that. But yeah, I'm, I'm very worried
- 18:14about Bitcoin becoming partisan. And, and it's interesting too,
- 18:17like the split that I'm seeing is crypto is for Democrats,
- 18:23Bitcoin is for Republicans. And I think that's also pretty,
- 18:29pretty bad, right? That's just not the that's just
- 18:34not ideal. I feel like the reasons why are
- 18:36almost not worth getting into. It's just sort of like
- 18:38self-evident, like you, you don't want to live in a world
- 18:41where the ability to prevent seriously deleterious public
- 18:49policy rests on who wins the election every four years.
- 18:52Like that's just a, that's a horrible game to play and I'm
- 18:56very worried about it. And so as a result, like all of
- 19:00our work at BPI is, is tries to be right down the middle.
- 19:04If anything, we try to take sort of more of a center left tone.
- 19:09And it's a huge objective of mine and the organizations to
- 19:15identify Bitcoin champions on the left.
- 19:18And we've had some real success there.
- 19:19I mean, I was really, really excited about Ro Khanna and his
- 19:24participation of the Bitcoin conference in Nashville.
- 19:27He and I were on the news desk together and have had some
- 19:30correspondence like after the conference.
- 19:33He's someone who gives me a lot of hope as a principled
- 19:37progressive Democrat who really does seem to understand the
- 19:40issues at play. So it's, it's definitely a bit
- 19:45of a Sisyphician task, but I'm happy to push this folder up the
- 19:50hill because it, it matters a lot to me that Bitcoin is is non
- 19:54partisan. Yeah, it, it matters immensely
- 19:58that that, you know, I, I, I echo what Andy is saying that in
- 20:03terms of moving the needle for the world, there's nothing more
- 20:05important than Bitcoin. And in terms of securing that
- 20:09that potential, there's nothing more important than policy.
- 20:12So you guys are at the absolute forefront of what's needed right
- 20:15now. And maybe we could talk about
- 20:18the current lay of the land, sort of two questions really,
- 20:22which is how would you frame the political shift of, I don't
- 20:27know, the last year? Some people are saying it's
- 20:30massive, that it's kind of a sea change.
- 20:32I suppose others might consider it massive with respect to one
- 20:36party but not the other. And then related is what are you
- 20:41hearing about what a Kamala Harris administration might look
- 20:46like with respect to policy on Bitcoin and I guess I'll ask
- 20:51crypto as well. Well, I think there are a couple
- 20:57of threads that are worth like sort of pointing out.
- 21:02One big change is I think it's really difficult to like
- 21:08overstate how bad FTX was for, you know, the sort of mainstream
- 21:13view toward crypto and Bitcoin. And I think that it was, you
- 21:18know, an even more sort of outsized event in terms of its
- 21:22impact in policy circles in DC. So I think where we are now, one
- 21:30of the biggest changes is very rarely do I hear the view that
- 21:36Bitcoin's like a scam and that it's going away.
- 21:40Very rarely do I get questions of like, why I run a Bitcoin
- 21:44think tank. When we first started doing
- 21:46this, it was like a little like people were just like what, you
- 21:49know, Bitcoin, like whatever. So I think this view that it's
- 21:52here to stay has become very widely diffused.
- 21:57And in turn, the view that the public policy around it is
- 22:01inconsequential and like important is also like pretty
- 22:04widely diffused, obviously, you know, a sort of former president
- 22:10and a guy running for president again, speaking at the Bitcoin
- 22:13conference like that is just a big deal.
- 22:16You know, sort of absent any like normative judgement about
- 22:20that phenomena of like, that's pretty crazy.
- 22:24Like we went very quickly from being excited that the mayor of
- 22:27Miami was speaking at Bitcoin conference to like multiple
- 22:31senators and like a former president.
- 22:33Like that was a really quick turn around.
- 22:35Like, you know, and I, yeah, I mean, I'm sure you guys are
- 22:38there, right? I remember like Bitcoin Miami
- 22:3920/21. It was like, holy crap, you
- 22:42know, the mayor of Miami is speaking.
- 22:45So yeah, I mean, I think, I think it's sort of relevance has
- 22:48ascended the sort of political hierarchies like really quickly
- 22:54sort of in fitting with in line with with a lot of things like
- 22:57related to Bitcoin. So those are two big through
- 23:01lines. Could that could that continue?
- 23:04I mean, the Bitcoin the the mayor of Miami speaking and then
- 23:10the following year RFK spoke, you know, made and made Bitcoin
- 23:15a major part of his political candidacy candidacy.
- 23:20And that felt like in a huge moment that felt like an arrival
- 23:24of Bitcoin on on the mainstage of American politics.
- 23:28Granted, it was a fringe, you know, not a one of the two major
- 23:33parties candidate. And then Fast forward one year
- 23:38and it just one year like I was expecting that would take at
- 23:41least, you know, one full election cycle.
- 23:44And then maybe we'd we'd have a Democrat or Republican candidate
- 23:47speaking in 20/20/2024. Sorry in 2028, but here we are
- 23:53with Trump this year and, and not to be outmatched, RFK kind
- 23:58of trots out this new idea of of 4 million Bitcoin to match our
- 24:03relative position of our 19% of the world's gold.
- 24:07To match that with Bitcoin. Now that's incepted and out
- 24:11there like it, it feels like the momentum is is unbelievable, but
- 24:15there's no reason why would necessarily stop like this could
- 24:18become this could climb that ladder further to become one of
- 24:22the most important topics in American politics.
- 24:24Do you see that as continuing in that direction?
- 24:28Yeah, I mean, most important issue in American politics
- 24:34that's. Quite a ways to go before that,
- 24:35but. Yeah, that's like a really high
- 24:38bar. I mean, I think like, you know,
- 24:41I would splash a little cold water on that and say that like,
- 24:43by and large, like nobody gives a shit about this.
- 24:46Yeah, but you? Know yeah but yeah, it's sort of
- 24:50the right yeah I mean I think there's like but I do think that
- 24:53like we haven't peaked in that sense right like it would be
- 24:56amazing if like, you know this had been the year where the
- 25:01leaders of both parties had felt that they needed to come to
- 25:04Bitcoin Nashville to assure the community that they had a good
- 25:10head on their shoulders with respect to to crypto policy and
- 25:13Bitcoin policy That didn't quite happen but we sort of saw like
- 25:17that right and so I think that's like a very clear like next step
- 25:20for me is that like, you know when we live in a world where
- 25:24yeah the the leading political people on both parties feel
- 25:29compelled to come to the Bitcoin conference and make their points
- 25:32to big pointers that's going to be like another kind of big
- 25:35check box that I feel like we sort of half checked this year.
- 25:41The although I don't, I don't go ahead.
- 25:45Sorry. You might be reluctant to, you
- 25:46know, to show your own, show your own product.
- 25:49But, you know, I just want to point out that I'd like to see
- 25:52more policy makers already there a lot, but I'd like to see more
- 25:55at your conference because, you know, let's, let's be real,
- 26:00there's also a lot of noise, let's just say noise and other
- 26:05things that surround, you know, the the Bitcoin conference
- 26:09you're referring to. You know, I think yours is a
- 26:13more sober take, more focused at the various issues you outlined.
- 26:19And yeah, so I just want to point out to people, to
- 26:22listeners that you have an excellent conference that gives
- 26:27a sober and useful and mature take on Bitcoin and how it
- 26:32intersects U.S. policy and and geopolitics and, and all the
- 26:37issues that you already articulated.
- 26:40Well, thank you. Yeah, we're really proud of the
- 26:42policy summit. I mean, so the first year we did
- 26:46it, we had a 90 day lead time. We had no money.
- 26:51We had like maybe $100,000 in a bank account.
- 26:54And at the time that was like maybe three months runway.
- 26:59And so we were all sort of like, OK, you know, what, what the
- 27:02heck are we going to do? Is this project going to fail?
- 27:06And when FTX collapsed, it was like that, I guess sort of
- 27:12around that December, that we made the decision to ape the
- 27:17entire balance sheet into a conference.
- 27:20Like we thought that now is the time to sort of strike, right?
- 27:26Like a lot of our theses have been vindicated.
- 27:29We were the only group in DC that was really just exclusively
- 27:32focused on Bitcoin. We had been telling all these
- 27:36people like, look, look, there's a ton of scams in, in crypto.
- 27:40And it's not to say that crypto is, is, is outright bad.
- 27:43I mean, I think if you'd, if, if you'd taken your sort of
- 27:47regulatory cues from like the 99% of early Internet companies
- 27:51that were like pets.com, you would have never had an Amazon.
- 27:55But at the same time, like you need to call a spade a spade.
- 27:58And if you're not willing to kind of look someone in the eye
- 28:00and say, empirically, 9598% of cryptocurrencies that have ever
- 28:04been launched have gone straight to zero, you're just not going
- 28:07to get anywhere. And so I felt like we had a
- 28:10really differentiated message that was kind of like, you know,
- 28:16vindicated when FTX collapsed. And so we sort of just launched
- 28:21the summit and, and said, look, we, we think Bitcoin is here to
- 28:24stay. And we think that they're really
- 28:28serious reasons why policy makers should, should pay
- 28:30attention. Like, you know, just because FTX
- 28:32collapsed does not mean that you get to evade the admittedly
- 28:36difficult task of crafting good regulation.
- 28:39And then the event was just an amazing success.
- 28:41We had like multiple senators, multiple members of Congress,
- 28:46you know, 20 universities. We had like 250 people in the
- 28:49audience that first year. And the statistic I'm most proud
- 28:53of is that like, I don't remember the exact number, but
- 28:56it was like 40. It was like 60% of the audience
- 29:01basically were not the pointers. They were people at think tanks,
- 29:05at advocacy groups, staffers, people at government agencies.
- 29:10And that was like my vision, right?
- 29:11That was like Grant and I the whole team's vision was like,
- 29:15you know, let's make a Bitcoin conference that's not for
- 29:17Bitcoiners. Like I no offense to every
- 29:20other. I mean, David Bailey's a good
- 29:22friend. Like I love the Bitcoin
- 29:24conference, but like there's something kind of insular about
- 29:27that, right? Like it's a really overwhelming
- 29:29environment to if that were like you're, I can't imagine what it
- 29:31would be like if your first touch point to Bitcoin was
- 29:34Bitcoin Nashville or Bitcoin Miami.
- 29:36So the goal was like, let's do a conference that is geared for
- 29:40people who don't know anything about Bitcoin and, and deliver
- 29:44sort of first rate sober analysis and commentary on where
- 29:49we are and where we're headed. And it, it just, it was a
- 29:51smashing success. We developed a ton of
- 29:53relationships with offices in DC, with agencies in DC.
- 29:58We did it again this past April and we've already outgrown the
- 30:01venue. We, we did those at the National
- 30:03Press Club this year. We literally didn't have enough
- 30:06room. We had three tracks of content.
- 30:08People could barely get around. Like it was standing room only
- 30:12in the, in the mainstage for most of the day.
- 30:15And so yeah, we're, we're really excited to do that event again
- 30:19this April. We haven't officially announced
- 30:22the, the dates, but it should be, should be soon.
- 30:24It's going to be in like late April, like either that third or
- 30:28fourth week of the month. And we're kind of expecting to
- 30:31double again. So looking forward to hosting
- 30:34like close to 1000 people and, and really trying to preserve
- 30:38that balance of like we, we want everybody in the room to be
- 30:43people who are serious, people who are, are pretty green and
- 30:50people who care about this professionally.
- 30:52Like it's just, it's like another sort of big thing about
- 30:57that conference is the entire day of Bitcoin content and
- 31:01there's no mention of price, which I thought was like really
- 31:05cool. Love it.
- 31:08Yeah. Like, yeah, well, no mention of
- 31:10price. For your your tremendous success
- 31:14with the event, I was regretful that I couldn't make it this
- 31:17year. I am going to, I am going to try
- 31:20and make it next year because, yeah, I think it's really very
- 31:25important from a policy perspective that, OK, it's great
- 31:29for us rabid Bitcoiners to, you know, have our have our tent
- 31:33over here, which arguably includes a lot of the other
- 31:37conferences. But bridging the gap between
- 31:41between Bitcoiners and the rest of the normies, as we like to
- 31:44say, is very, very important and especially with the policy
- 31:48makers. So hats off to you and looking
- 31:50forward to an even more successful event event next
- 31:54year. Well, let's see.
- 31:57I, you know, with respect to politics and policy, I am
- 32:04probably going to try and try and pin you down on this little.
- 32:08And if the answer is we just don't know, that's fine.
- 32:10But you know, your thoughts on a Kamala Harris administration and
- 32:16likely, you know, effects on Bitcoin policy, maybe also
- 32:22crypto policy, you know, versus the baseline where we are today
- 32:27with the existing Biden administration.
- 32:30Yeah, I guess I should preface by saying I really don't have
- 32:34any particular alpha here. So my, my take is unlikely to
- 32:39reveal anything new to you. I I just don't think we know.
- 32:46I mean, I think there's, there's been a lot of speculation off of
- 32:50very little like sort of core like sort of true information,
- 32:57right? Like, you know, speculating what
- 32:59the crypto policy is going to be based on who economic advisers
- 33:02are. I just don't think we know.
- 33:05I think there are reasons to be bearish.
- 33:07There are reasons to be somewhat bullish.
- 33:10My base case is that very little happens in a Harris
- 33:15administration with respect to crypto and Bitcoin.
- 33:17And I think that's probably OK. I, I think that the odds of any
- 33:25policy passing in, in Congress, like that's going to sort of
- 33:31depend on elections there. But if the last, you know, 10
- 33:36years or whatever have have yield any sort of insight for
- 33:40the future. It's like, you know, the, the
- 33:42baseline probability of any single like policy being passed
- 33:46that isn't just like keeping the government funded and all of the
- 33:48associate riders and associated like riders and, and stuff like
- 33:51that being passed is just inherently low.
- 33:56My hope would be that we see better positions coming out of
- 34:01the regulatory agencies that we don't see a continuation of
- 34:05things like you know, operation joke .2 point O, but like you
- 34:08know, I can sort of give you the wish list, but that's nothing
- 34:10new. I, I, I think the Harris
- 34:13administration has, I, I'll say what's different is the crypto
- 34:17and Bitcoin industries have flexed their political muscles
- 34:22in a really tangible way. And I think the, I, I suspect I
- 34:28should say that the incentives for the sort of palpable
- 34:33incentives for Kamala Harris to be more muted and less anti are
- 34:39just like clearly higher. Like there's just clearly more
- 34:43at stake. It's clear that there are a lot
- 34:45of voters, there's a lot of money that cares deeply about
- 34:50the consequences of, of the actions of her administration.
- 34:53So I guess like looking at it from sort of that perspective,
- 34:57like sort of, you know, like cautiously optimistic that it
- 35:02isn't going to be as bad as it was the past four years, but
- 35:05that may well be wrong. Like I I really the only other
- 35:09sort of benchmark that I have is I think Democrats are more open
- 35:14to talking about this. And you know, if you plot the
- 35:17graph of pro Bitcoin Democrats, it is in fact up and to the
- 35:21right. So like, I think some progress
- 35:24is being made there. You should take some, take some
- 35:28credit personally, I think for, for that outcome.
- 35:31I think you've been helping in that regard.
- 35:33Well, I'm glad to see that there.
- 35:34I'm glad, I'm glad to hear that there's a possibility that the,
- 35:37that the beatings will be slightly less frequent and
- 35:40slightly less severe. We'll see, We'll see how it
- 35:43goes. But you mentioned the, I think
- 35:45the the administrative agencies, you know, if Chevron deference
- 35:49is dead and the agencies are perhaps curtailed somewhat,
- 35:56we'll see based on lawsuits, you know, that are coming, I assume.
- 36:01Do you think that is going to be a significant factor, let's say
- 36:07in yeah, in curtailing the the hostile position that the
- 36:14agencies have taken with respect to the industry up to this
- 36:18point? Maybe, but I think there's a lot
- 36:25that a president can do just via executive order.
- 36:31Maybe it puts like somewhat of a ceiling on things.
- 36:34But I wouldn't count on like the Chevron decision to really be a
- 36:42bulwark against like negative policy.
- 36:45Like I think if we're gonna red team this, like if you're a
- 36:48Harris administration and your goal is to be anti crypto, anti
- 36:52Bitcoin, I think you could achieve that end in the status
- 36:55quo. So no, I mean, I think there's
- 36:59still a lot at stake. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 37:03keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 37:05sitting on an exchange worried about hackers?
- 37:08Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 37:10with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 37:13device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 37:17and our multi institution custody solution.
- 37:20Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 37:23sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 37:27a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 37:32unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 37:35over your coins. With Onramp's multi Institution
- 37:38custody, you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 37:41stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 37:44tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 37:48going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 37:51exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 37:55in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 37:58you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 38:01custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 38:05eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 38:08attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 38:12financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 38:14Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 38:18warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading,
- 38:21and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 38:25asset, secure it right. Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 38:29All right, well, good. Sounds like you're going to be
- 38:31you're going to continue to be busy for the foreseeable future,
- 38:34David Educated. I would love to I would love to
- 38:37not be frankly, it would be. It would be sort of ideal.
- 38:41I always joke that like, you know, our, our incentives as
- 38:44like a, a non profit as an organization are sort of
- 38:47hysterical because most organizations like goal #1 is
- 38:51like stay alive and keep existing.
- 38:54And for us, the goal is like actually inverted, right.
- 38:57The goal is like, you know, how do we get to a world where a, a
- 39:00think tank, you know, about Bitcoin is, you know, pretty
- 39:04much just sort of esoteric and like unnecessary.
- 39:07And so in some ways, like I, I view this project is like
- 39:10working to our own destruction. Like there might still, I think
- 39:15there will still be a need for something like BPI for quite a
- 39:18while. Like, I don't see that that sort
- 39:21of finish line in, in, you know, and on the horizon.
- 39:26But yeah, there's the the the pinnacle.
- 39:28The pinnacle of success would be being able to not run a Bitcoin
- 39:32think tank because it's like completely unnecessary.
- 39:35There are probably not really any Internet think tanks you
- 39:39know there. There are certainly are sub
- 39:41topics within Internet interests, but I I doubt there
- 39:45are general Internet think tanks in in DC anymore.
- 39:50But I'm sure that was a thing for a while in the 90s and.
- 39:53Oh yeah, I mean, the Electronic Frontier Foundation is the best
- 39:56example of this, right? Like they were instrumental in
- 39:58like the Clipper Chip debates in 1992.
- 40:01Like massive deal, they have these huge blow out regulatory
- 40:05battles and the EFF still is sort of an activist, you know,
- 40:08charity, they do a bunch of work on electronic freedom, on
- 40:11privacy and all of that. But like, yeah, like that's sort
- 40:14of the model is that like, you know, they still have the ethos
- 40:19of the Internet that they represent.
- 40:21The stakes are no longer as existential as they were in the
- 40:24in the 90s. So.
- 40:26Yeah, related question, you sort of you sort of mentioned, you
- 40:30mentioned that under Kamala administration that maybe not
- 40:36much would get done. And I wonder are there any
- 40:40advantages in your mind for, for that scenario of, of allowing
- 40:46things to unfold and then developing better regulatory
- 40:52guidance, you know, further down the road rather than too soon?
- 40:58Yes, I think for sure, principally because I I just,
- 41:05and the reason that we are in the Bitcoin Policy Institute, I
- 41:08guess there are a bunch of reasons, but one of the big ones
- 41:11is that Bitcoin just has a completely different set of
- 41:15incentives and, and desiring outcomes in the public policy
- 41:19realm. You know, you've got on the
- 41:22other side of the aisle or not aisle, whatever you want to call
- 41:24it on the crypto side of things, you've got billions of dollars
- 41:28that they've been invested in, things that are ostensibly like
- 41:30unregistered securities, right? Like right, it's like entire
- 41:35funds that are, are they have a lot to be worried about and keep
- 41:42them up at night. In terms of regulation, I think
- 41:46Bitcoin doesn't really need much right.
- 41:49Like I've seen these like things being like sort of like right to
- 41:52right to mine, like right to do well, I, I think those are
- 41:55inherently rights. Like, I think as an American,
- 41:57you just have a de facto right to own Bitcoin and to mine
- 42:00Bitcoin to run a node. Like I, I almost hate like
- 42:03ceding the rhetorical ground that these are like permissions
- 42:07that we have to sort of come before the state to ask for.
- 42:09I think that's just flat out wrong.
- 42:12We have every right to use and operate Bitcoin in the United
- 42:15States. And, and, and there are of
- 42:19course, like regulations and policies that would negatively
- 42:23impact the rate of Bitcoin adoption, that would negatively
- 42:28affect Bitcoin users and Bitcoin companies domiciled in the
- 42:31United States. And I don't mean to downplay the
- 42:33significance of those possibilities.
- 42:35That's like one of the big things that we're working to
- 42:36sort of prevent from happening. But I do see like being this
- 42:42like Canary in the coal mine, being like a watchdog for those
- 42:45bad policies as more of a North star for BPI than trying to
- 42:51advocate for particular legislation that like, say,
- 42:55advantages Bitcoin over crypto that gives carve outs for bit
- 42:59like no, I think that's mostly pretty much totally unnecessary.
- 43:04So yeah, I think like a depending on how you define
- 43:07this, this quote, like we don't want to maintain, you know, the
- 43:12difficulty that that these businesses have in getting bank
- 43:14accounts all of that. But like a do nothing approach
- 43:18from a Bitcoiners perspective is not something to be afraid of.
- 43:22Like that would be that would be pretty solid.
- 43:26But there are sorts of like cool things that, you know, that
- 43:28people are pushing for. Like I'm very excited and
- 43:31energized by Senator Lummus's, you know, strategic reserve
- 43:35bill. I think it would be fantastic
- 43:38for America to have like a meaningful Bitcoin position.
- 43:43So there there are like sort of cool things that could happen.
- 43:47But yeah, no, I, I, I, I think if the question is essentially,
- 43:52you know, should we be concerned about a do nothing approach from
- 43:55the Bitcoin angle? No, like I think that would be
- 43:58kind of awesome. You know, some, but but the
- 44:01truth is like, you know, regulation's going to get
- 44:04passed. We've already seen tons of
- 44:06examples of, you know, ostensibly well meaning
- 44:09regulation like Damla that just effectively nukes everything.
- 44:14So there's a lot to be a watchdog for.
- 44:19But yeah, if, if, if no other public policy was passed in the
- 44:22United States with respect to crypto, I think Bitcoin would be
- 44:25fine. Yeah, that, that, that makes
- 44:28sense. And it would also be interesting
- 44:32you, you, you mentioned how sort of unregistered securities, a
- 44:37lot of, I think pretty much all crypto out is falls under that
- 44:43label. And I, I am bothered by how, you
- 44:51know, the push for Ethereum ETFs went through pretty, pretty much
- 44:57on riding on the coattails of the excitement about Bitcoin
- 45:00ETFs. And, and I think it's my
- 45:05personal belief that that was a, a mistake that you're, that you
- 45:09know, that that was allowed. And now they're sort of starting
- 45:13to draw a line about Solana is, doesn't qualify for an ETF.
- 45:18Now, you know, now you're going to deal with the whole fight
- 45:20there of like, what does that even mean?
- 45:22Only hopefully, hopefully further down the line only to
- 45:26realize, you know what, actually, we should never have
- 45:27done the Etherium thing in the 1st place.
- 45:29Maybe they'll be able to roll that back in some way.
- 45:31Probably not. Anyway, I think that's an
- 45:33example of how, like, if people learn rather than act, I think
- 45:40that ends up in a clearer future where the ways in which Bitcoin
- 45:45is different don't get so muddied up with with crypto
- 45:48trying to ride its coattails. Yeah, I see where you're coming
- 45:53from. I I probably have like a
- 45:55slightly different view, which is that I think the answer, the
- 46:02question of whether or not cryptos are unregistered
- 46:06securities says a lot more about the state of securities
- 46:10regulation than it does about the technologies or the the
- 46:14tokens in and of themselves. Like I, I just generally think
- 46:18that like trying to sort of retrofit like new technologies
- 46:22and 100 year old like policies just is, yeah, it's sort of
- 46:26inherently like fraught. And I also think it's very easy
- 46:30to kind of miss that some of the worst and like griftiest sort of
- 46:38realities of the crypto world are kind of the direct result of
- 46:44the extent securities like regulation.
- 46:46I think that's why like, I think that's like, why a lot of people
- 46:49like, you know, fucking gambling on, on like meme coins or
- 46:53whatever, because there's not this sort of like insider VC
- 46:56cabal, like not endorsing meme coins.
- 46:59But I, I, I think when you look at the incentives that like the
- 47:03sort of current regulatory stack creates for founders of these
- 47:07crypto protocols, it, it, it is in many ways responsible for
- 47:12some of the worst. No, I mean, you're never gonna,
- 47:14no, I'm saying it's responsible for people sort of saying, oh,
- 47:16I've created the next Bitcoin, like sell your Bitcoin and buy
- 47:19my token. Like people have been doing that
- 47:21since, you know, since Bitcoin. But yeah, I, I think the current
- 47:26regulatory stack is insufficient.
- 47:27It's not fit for purpose. There is a need to balance to,
- 47:32to, to care about consumer protection.
- 47:35But I also think that we need to be smart about that.
- 47:39Like we, we don't want to say, well, you know, you know, you
- 47:45need to be an accredited investor to invest, for example.
- 47:47I think that's sort of silly. And so, yeah, my, my hope is
- 47:52that we see to the extent we see regulation with respect to like
- 47:56Icos or, or cryptos that they focus on the actions of people
- 48:04and companies and projects and not on just tech innovation.
- 48:09Like generally, like I am excited about things like 0
- 48:12knowledge proofs. Like I'm excited about some of
- 48:15the pure sort of cryptography innovation that's come out of
- 48:19maybe some non Bitcoin places. And yeah, again, I I kind of
- 48:25just keep going back to this example of likethe.com bubble,
- 48:29right? Like there were so like every
- 48:30one of those companies just a complete scam, just like
- 48:33through.com in the name, the same way that all of these
- 48:35companies threw blockchain in their name.
- 48:38But I think we'd be worse off as a country and as a world if we
- 48:42had let the scams ofthe.com bubble inform regulation that
- 48:47prevented like genuine innovation from happening.
- 48:49Even if the ratio right now is like 99.9% nonsense and point 1%
- 48:55like legitimate, I think you could have pointed to a time in
- 48:59the internet's history where you would have found a similar ratio
- 49:02of burgeoning Internet start-ups.
- 49:03And yeah, I, I am just sort of as a, as a technologist, as
- 49:10someone who has at least some of the core values of like the
- 49:13cypherpunks, like the idea of the government sort of just
- 49:17banning math in any capacity, banning technology wholesale.
- 49:21That sort of gives me some, some trouble.
- 49:24Like I, I'm, I'm not super keen on that.
- 49:26And I do think that there's like a faction of the Bitcoin
- 49:28community that on the one hand loves to espouse their sort of
- 49:32anarchism and like libertarian values and like this sort of,
- 49:36you know, like sort of indifference to to the state and
- 49:43then loves the idea of wielding the state as like a cudgel to
- 49:47punish the like, you know, the evil and unvirtuous, like crypto
- 49:51people. And, you know, I always just
- 49:53find that a bit sort of silly. Like so, yeah.
- 49:56I mean, I'm not not suggesting that was your, your take, but
- 50:00you know, I, I, it's tough like I, I'm not a fan of the sort of
- 50:03rot of crypto and, and think that it has been quite bad for a
- 50:06lot of people, but I'm suspicious reflexively of
- 50:09looking to the state to solve that problem wholesale.
- 50:13Yeah, it fantastic points and and and yeah, you're right.
- 50:18Like ultimately it comes back to we've outsourced our judgement
- 50:24about what is good actors and bad actors to the state, to the
- 50:29how we test, you know, and and we've relinquished the the
- 50:34responsibility of having to judge for ourselves where to
- 50:37deploy our money. And and I am definitely guilty
- 50:41of and and victim of that, you know, school of thought of like
- 50:46I I feel like, well, the there are these rules and pre mines
- 50:50kind of flout that rule. So I think this is bad and I
- 50:54totally fall into that, that trap, that pitfall that has been
- 50:59constructed for us. And it would be a better world
- 51:03if if we had to assume that responsibility on ourselves and
- 51:08maintain that like individual awareness that like you can't
- 51:12trust anything. You got to do your own research
- 51:14and and you know, because nobody's, nobody's playing cop
- 51:17out there. But that would be a better world
- 51:19And and we don't really live in it right now.
- 51:23Yeah, I'd like to examine. I'd like to examine one of the
- 51:28topics earlier which was the strategic reserve idea and of of
- 51:34two minds here. So on the one hand, in the same
- 51:37vein we were just discussing, you know, Bitcoin doesn't need
- 51:40help basically, right? And Bitcoiners don't need help
- 51:46either. Adoption doesn't need help for
- 51:49special treatment. Let's just say, you know, all
- 51:53users of Bitcoin and operators of the network are within their
- 51:56rights, you know, as outlined in the Constitution.
- 52:00We should keep it that way. But you know, we don't need any
- 52:02special hand handouts. So I think I worry a little bit
- 52:05about the perception of strategic reserve pumping the
- 52:08bags of Bitcoiners. Do you have any thoughts about
- 52:12that and maybe how to optimize the messaging with respect to
- 52:17government policy potentially and that issue there?
- 52:21Yeah. I mean, look, I think you have
- 52:24to 1st sort of take a step back and recognize that the United
- 52:29States government has a, a balance sheet that contains like
- 52:35substantial asset holdings, right, of of all different
- 52:38varieties, right? We have a ton of land through
- 52:43our National Park system. We have a ton of oil.
- 52:48We have a strategic oil reserve. We have a ton of gold.
- 52:52The the land that we own is sort of this serves this like public
- 52:55good, right? You can go to national parks and
- 52:58enjoy pristine nature. The oil reserve that we have,
- 53:01you know, gives us this sort of option value in the sense that
- 53:05when, when oil supply is is low or I guess prices are, are high,
- 53:10you know, the government can release some of that reserve to
- 53:13to ease the burden on on Americans and, and consumers.
- 53:18You know, the massive gold position that we have is
- 53:21probably better understood as a result of kind of just this like
- 53:25half dependence. Like when when the, you know,
- 53:28convertibility of the dollar into gold was suspended, we just
- 53:32maintained this this massive, you know, gold supply.
- 53:35And so, you know, right off the bat, I think you have to kind of
- 53:39the very natural question to ask is in so far as we hold
- 53:42substantial, substantial portfolio of assets, what assets
- 53:46should be in that portfolio? And I think like the Bitcoin
- 53:49Reserve conversation has, I think a lot of people have sort
- 53:52of missed that like first essential premise, which is that
- 53:55like, it's not like wholly out of character for the government
- 53:58to buy assets and hold them for strategic reasons.
- 54:01And so then it just becomes this question of like sort of
- 54:05portfolio diversification, right?
- 54:07Like if you're going to construct a portfolio for
- 54:09yourself, for, you know, an investment firm or for a
- 54:12country, well, you want to make sort of rational assessments
- 54:15about the suite of options that you have that you can put money
- 54:17into and think about what risks and what returns you, you know,
- 54:22may may happen as a result. So, yeah, I think like it's not
- 54:26that crazy for the government to ask, you know, what assets
- 54:30should we hold? I don't think it's a question
- 54:32people think about deeply enough, right?
- 54:34Like the the status quo is that we're already making these
- 54:37active investment choices like by not having Bitcoin.
- 54:40That is sort of as much of A statement as holding Bitcoin
- 54:42would be. And so I think you start there,
- 54:45you start there, right? Like the just, OK, we have
- 54:48assets, we invest in things, what should we invest in?
- 54:51Well, then it's like any, you know, it's like an individual,
- 54:53right? Like you, you guys have written
- 54:54about this and talked about this for years, right?
- 54:56A lot of the same reasons that it's prudent for an individual
- 54:59to have, you know, some Bitcoin in their portfolio kind of
- 55:02translate 1 to one with the reasons that it would be prudent
- 55:05for America to like hold Bitcoin in particular.
- 55:10Though I do think that there are more or less like 3 primary
- 55:14benefits of America having a, a Bitcoin position.
- 55:21I really want to get into the specifics of the size or the
- 55:25funding mechanism. I think those are two sort of
- 55:27thorny issues that could like for a giant tree of like sort of
- 55:32possibilities there that, you know, I don't know.
- 55:34So I'm going to restrict these comments specifically to the
- 55:37notion of like America having a meaningful stack.
- 55:41And here I think there are like 3 fairly clear benefits.
- 55:46The the 1st is, is just pureplay, like signaling.
- 55:50I think like America, I think Bitcoin signals very well, much
- 55:55better than any politician good that your rights as a Bitcoiner
- 55:59will be preserved and maintained.
- 56:02That if you run a Bitcoin business, if you mine Bitcoin,
- 56:04if you engage in financial services on top of Bitcoin, that
- 56:08your business will be safe, that you won't have to, you know,
- 56:11exit the country. So I think that there's like a
- 56:14sort of inherent signaling benefit there. 2nd is the sort
- 56:21of option value of having a, a large like Bitcoin position.
- 56:26I, I think that there's a sort of plausible world that having a
- 56:30Bitcoin reserve creates a sort of reinforcing relationship
- 56:36between the growth of Bitcoin and confidence in, in the
- 56:40dollar. I think it's sort of like this
- 56:43inherent hedge against like risk, right?
- 56:46Like in some ways, like I think if you priced Bitcoin or, or a
- 56:51Bitcoin reserve like an insurance contract from the
- 56:55perspective of the government, it's like a very prudent
- 56:57insurance policy to buy. You spend $60 billion, which we
- 57:02who knows, we probably spent that since we started the
- 57:03recording of this like call on on Bitcoin.
- 57:07And your Max downside is that it goes to zero.
- 57:11Well, OK, that's like one fighter plane.
- 57:14Your Max upside is like quite high, right?
- 57:18And we already have more Bitcoin than anybody else in the world,
- 57:22you know, in terms of like most of the Bitcoin is, is held in
- 57:25the United States. And so I think that America
- 57:29stands in those sort of scenarios where the price of
- 57:32Bitcoin rapidly appreciates. We stand to sort of benefit
- 57:35disproportionately to everybody else already, even without the
- 57:39strategic Bitcoin reserve. And I think an SBR kind of could
- 57:42help kick off that that cycle and whether the reserve winds up
- 57:48being something that helps America pay down it's debt or
- 57:51whether it just kind of creates more of a symbiosis between the
- 57:54dollar and Bitcoin. I think those are very desirable
- 57:57like outcomes. And again, like it sounds really
- 58:01radical, but like when you look at the history of of the US
- 58:04dollar in the last 150 hundred 20 years, like we've seen these
- 58:08like sort of pretty crazy shifts, right?
- 58:10Like going from a dollar backed by gold going to a dollar backed
- 58:15by by like debt to a dollar backed by oil.
- 58:20Essentially, the idea of a dollar being backed by sort of
- 58:25hard commodities and energy is not that radical in the context
- 58:29of the pretty significant phase shifts that the backing of the
- 58:33of the dollar, you know, have have underwent.
- 58:36So, and I, and I think third, like there are probably some
- 58:40good geostrategic benefits to be gained from promoting like
- 58:44Bitcoin, Like I already sort of hinted at this, but I think that
- 58:48there's a very clear and compelling argument that the
- 58:52more Bitcoin is diffused in the world writ large, like the more
- 58:59liberal democracy like wins. Like when you give people
- 59:02Bitcoin, you get so much like right off the bat, it's it's
- 59:06almost like you get to live parts of the American dream
- 59:11without having to move to America.
- 59:12You have property or or a claim to property that can't be
- 59:17revoked, can't be stolen from you at least with with
- 59:20meaningful ease like other assets you have the ability to
- 59:24participate in in global commerce like you.
- 59:28It sort of takes some core values that we have as a country
- 59:31in terms of the right to transact, the right to speak,
- 59:33the right to associate. And I think it very clearly
- 59:37benefits liberal democracies and very clearly undermines our
- 59:41authoritarian adversaries. So, you know, in a world where
- 59:45like, you know, in a, in a world where tons of people don't have
- 59:51access to the financial system, who are sort of forced to use a
- 59:54currency that is rapidly inflating, who live in a country
- 59:57that does not offer them strong property rights.
- 1:00:01You know, where, where the rate of change is actually down and
- 1:00:04to the right. Like you look at the rate of
- 1:00:06sort of correspondent banking relationships and it's dropped
- 1:00:08like 50% in the last decade. You've gotten billions of people
- 1:00:12that are desperately searching for monetary alternatives and.
- 1:00:17We as a country are not offering them much, whereas our
- 1:00:21adversaries like China are coming in and saying we'll build
- 1:00:23all of this for you just to use our sort of centralized censored
- 1:00:27commissioned networks for communications and payments.
- 1:00:31And so like the emergence of a non state sort of neutral bearer
- 1:00:39instrument. I think like kind of, it's sort
- 1:00:43of an obvious like when like you, you give people sort of
- 1:00:46sort of who, who are forced to make choices about like what
- 1:00:49monetary stacks they're going to use because their, their country
- 1:00:52and their currency is sort of busted.
- 1:00:54And. From the perspective of America,
- 1:00:57we'd much prefer people around the world hold Bitcoin than buy
- 1:01:00into the Chinese system. So I think those three are like
- 1:01:03very good reasons, like why we should have a Bitcoin reserve,
- 1:01:07right? Like the signaling effect, the,
- 1:01:10the, the sort of option value of just like having a stack and the
- 1:01:13sort of acceleration of global adoption in a way that benefits
- 1:01:17the interests of Western democracies.
- 1:01:19Like, look, that's a great, that's a great sort of bull case
- 1:01:23for, you know, when it's simply just a reallocation of assets.
- 1:01:27Like the question of should we buy a bunch of Bitcoin, like my
- 1:01:30immediate or, you know, that someone says that's crazy, then
- 1:01:32my my immediate response is we'll justify our gold holdings.
- 1:01:36Like, why don't we have that in the Russell 3000?
- 1:01:38Why Why don't we, you know, stimulating economic growth by
- 1:01:41investing in American businesses?
- 1:01:42Like what, what if you're a portfolio manager?
- 1:01:45Why are, you know, just present the rational case for having
- 1:01:48this massive gold holding? And so I know I said I wouldn't
- 1:01:51talk about funding mechanisms, but that is one of the kind of
- 1:01:54obvious ones, right? Like gave off a little gold
- 1:01:56holdings hedge with some Bitcoin.
- 1:01:59It's really not that crazy. It's the same argument that you
- 1:02:01know you guys would make onboarding a high net worth
- 1:02:04individual to Bitcoin. It's like almost riskier not to
- 1:02:06have it just the fractal at the state, nation, state level.
- 1:02:11Shave some gold to buy some digital gold and and you know,
- 1:02:16future proof your portfolio for the 21st digital era, right,
- 1:02:2021st century digital age. I love that framing that you
- 1:02:24that you put put out there of like, and I'm sure you're,
- 1:02:28you're honing this, as you know, in DC circles and that's where
- 1:02:33it comes from. But thinking of, of the US
- 1:02:37embracing Bitcoin as a way to export American values and
- 1:02:43American capitalism to every corner of of the globe without
- 1:02:47any, without ever having to send any direct aid or any, you know,
- 1:02:51involvement like that. In the context of our, you know,
- 1:02:55increasing friction with authoritarian interest in the
- 1:03:00sort of bricks rough alliance that that speaks that that's,
- 1:03:07that's everything like that. Like if you're, if you're in DC
- 1:03:10and you hear that it's, it sounds like a no brainer.
- 1:03:13I, I would think you know that. Oh, I can, I can, I can provide
- 1:03:18a, a bulwark. I can shore up American
- 1:03:21interests just by allowing this thing to, to be out there in the
- 1:03:24world and trying to spread it at no cost to me.
- 1:03:28Really. I think that's like a real way
- 1:03:32to win hearts and minds in DC. I'm I'm I'm sure you're getting
- 1:03:35good traction with that. Yeah, it's exciting.
- 1:03:39I can't say anything really now, but there's going to be some
- 1:03:44exciting stuff coming out in in September and then sort of the
- 1:03:48following the next few months. I also think it's just like a
- 1:03:52very good way of almost incepting the they're not
- 1:03:58accepting. How do I put this?
- 1:03:59It's a very good way of like having the forcing the Bitcoin
- 1:04:01debate, right? Like it's almost like a wrapper
- 1:04:04for asking the question of like, is Bitcoin good for America?
- 1:04:08You know, when, when you have the context of like should
- 1:04:11America like what Lummus did is fantastic, right?
- 1:04:14Just the anchoring, the Overton window shifting of like I'm AUS
- 1:04:18senator and I think it's important for us to have, you
- 1:04:20know, 1,000,000 Bitcoin like that brings people to the room
- 1:04:24and and they want to debate that they want to talk about it.
- 1:04:26And so whether or not that policy winds up passing, I think
- 1:04:30just the proposal alone has had a genuine impact in, in terms of
- 1:04:36people's receptiveness to even listening to arguments like the
- 1:04:40one the ones that I made a minute ago.
- 1:04:44Those are all great to those are all great, excellent reasons.
- 1:04:47I'll, I'll add one more too logistical one, which is for
- 1:04:52sometimes the US government needs to pay people in foreign
- 1:04:56countries and areas and it's actually hard, you know, flying
- 1:05:01pallets of cash on cargo plants. That doesn't always, it doesn't
- 1:05:07always work out. You know, you might just want to
- 1:05:09want to send a Bitcoin. Well, it depends on who you're
- 1:05:12depends on who you're paying, right.
- 1:05:14It's it might might be better to use the briefcase of gold or
- 1:05:18cash when you're gonna, you know, fund some insurgency in
- 1:05:21another country or or, you know, pay off a bunch of drug
- 1:05:23smugglers. Yeah, for sure.
- 1:05:25So, so when it when it comes to stuff like that, the dollar may
- 1:05:29still be the the best Moe. Yes, well, the truth, the truth
- 1:05:35may be inconvenient, but but that's it.
- 1:05:37Well, David, you've been really generous with your time.
- 1:05:41This has been a great discussion.
- 1:05:43Thank you so much. What other parting words, you
- 1:05:47know, where can people find you? How should people engage with
- 1:05:50BPI or the Summit or anything, any other thing else you would
- 1:05:55want to leave us with? Yeah, you can find me on Twitter
- 1:06:00at David Zell under score. My e-mail address is
- 1:06:04dz@btcpolicy.org. We're always looking for, you
- 1:06:09know, for volunteers and for help, especially around the
- 1:06:12summit in late April, which I encourage anyone listening to
- 1:06:16attend. If you are someone who comes
- 1:06:21from the public policy world or have, you know, an academic
- 1:06:24background or a background as a researcher, if the stuff that
- 1:06:27I've talked about today resonates with you, please reach
- 1:06:31out. We're always looking to expand
- 1:06:34the the sort of cohort of people to whom we award fellowships to
- 1:06:38do research and advocacy. And yeah, we're really excited
- 1:06:42about the next couple of years for Bitcoin And, oh, we're
- 1:06:46opening up an office in DC in January.
- 1:06:50So I guess you guys are both formally invited to the launch
- 1:06:53party and so in a couple months you'll be able to swing into the
- 1:06:57BPI office in in DC to to chat Bitcoin.
- 1:07:02That will be phenomenal. I look forward to that.
- 1:07:05Look forward to meatspace meeting in meatspace, talking,
- 1:07:09checking out the new digs and looking forward.
- 1:07:12Well, I'm really excited for everything that you've already
- 1:07:16accomplished with BPI and all the more for the for the future.
- 1:07:20So thank you again, David, and thank you for coming on scarce
- 1:07:24assets. Yeah.
- 1:07:26Thanks for having me guys. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:07:29week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:07:31valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:07:34rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:07:36All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:07:38notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:07:41reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:07:43entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:07:46investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:07:49your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:07:52Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact. To schedule a consultation with
- 1:07:56one of our private client advisors.