Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E015: Bitcoin + NOSTR + AI: Utility Beyond Digital Gold with Max Webster
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless
- 0:131974198792972 thousand. Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 0:27when we sell. All right.
- 0:31And we're live really excited for this episode, gentlemen.
- 0:35We're joined by Max Webster from Hivemind Ventures.
- 0:37And a really excited for this episode because it's going to be
- 0:41a bit of a different conversation to date.
- 0:45This is episode 15. We've had a lot of institutional
- 0:49investors, allocators, other venture fund.
- 0:54Types on the show, but we've really been focusing in on
- 0:57Bitcoin, the asset and how it will fit into your portfolio,
- 1:00how it should fit into your portfolio with the digital gold
- 1:03thesis. And we've hinted at it in many
- 1:06episodes since we launched in May.
- 1:09But I think everybody on this call truly believes that that is
- 1:13just the surface layer of what Bitcoin has to offer the world
- 1:16and again. We brought Max on this week
- 1:19because he's on the cutting edge of where Bitcoin is really
- 1:22becoming a meeting of exchange in the digital age, becoming the
- 1:26payments layer of the Internet. And so with that monologue, Max,
- 1:31I'll throw it to you to introduce yourself.
- 1:34Tell us how you got to where you are today and and what you're
- 1:38doing in Hide by Adventures. Yeah, I mean very high level.
- 1:42I first read about Bitcoin in 2011 when I was a student
- 1:45university. And, you know, grew up, I would
- 1:47say, with a more nontraditional sort of out there, parents who
- 1:51question a lot of things and has to die.
- 1:53So I thought it was a really cool idea.
- 1:54But yeah, frankly, I thought I had very little chance of
- 1:57working. So I didn't buy any, which I had
- 2:00and kind of forgot about it for many years.
- 2:02My other big obsession was with energy.
- 2:03And I think that's maybe one of these sort of unique
- 2:06perspectives I brought to this space.
- 2:08I also really just enjoy like finding exponential curves or
- 2:11finding you know where the cost of something is falling very
- 2:13rapidly and so. As I was graduating from
- 2:16university around 20/11/2012, I became pretty obsessed with the
- 2:19cost of solar falling off of a Cliff and for every doubling of
- 2:21cumulative capacity employee as all the levelized cost of energy
- 2:24was coming down, I thought like 20% turns out was more like 40%.
- 2:27And so I got really excited about that, jumped in the energy
- 2:31industry, you know, did a couple of things, startups totally
- 2:33bombed. Then moved down to Mexico in
- 2:36early 2015 as the first hire startup called Bright, which was
- 2:41Yc's first investment in solar in Mexico.
- 2:43I was down there for almost five years.
- 2:45We're now, you know, the largest residential solar company in
- 2:47Mexico. While I was down in Mexico I got
- 2:49two kind of Eureka moments that got me read I guess acquainted
- 2:52with Bitcoin. The first was I started seeing
- 2:55Bitcoin as energy backed money and this was my big thesis and I
- 2:59was very interested in crypto. I started reading in 2016 about
- 3:01some of these Ethereum projects for like decentralized energy
- 3:04trading. Thought that was cool.
- 3:05Eventually it hit me though that Bitcoin is essentially like a
- 3:08Ledger of energy and I think this is one of the things I I
- 3:10take slightly different than the most people.
- 3:12My hero is Buckminster Fuller, he called for energy backed
- 3:15money. Tesla did forded all these
- 3:17people and so when I started. Seeing, you know, thinking about
- 3:20that the university energy, that the currency of the energy is
- 3:22calories. And wherever you choose to
- 3:23demarcate it, Bitcoin is the purest form I've ever had on
- 3:26that. That started to help me separate
- 3:27the signal from the noise and realize I think it's going to be
- 3:30Bitcoin. I also, around that time in
- 3:322017, read the lightning white paper.
- 3:34And you know, watch Lola and some of these guys talk about
- 3:36what could happen scaling from that.
- 3:38And you know, I had some familiarity with how the
- 3:40Internet scale with the OSI model.
- 3:41And so I started thinking, I think that a lot of these other
- 3:44crypto projects are piloting interesting ideas.
- 3:48But maybe this is kind of like a little bit like the web van
- 3:50moment, like this is not the right rails to do it on or it's,
- 3:52you know, a little too early adoption wise.
- 3:54It's probably going to happen at higher level of abstraction on
- 3:57Bitcoin. But at that time, I was
- 3:59certainly not smart enough to be participating in Lightning
- 4:01network development. It was super hard to run a node.
- 4:03So I just kind of. I kept in the back of my head.
- 4:05Meanwhile, while I was living in Mexico, I saw that, you know, a
- 4:09bunch of my friends, you know, their parents were literally
- 4:11just like storing in USD under the mattress because they didn't
- 4:14have access to, you know, you know, bank accounts in the
- 4:16United States. And half of the country was
- 4:18unbanked. I had friends from Argentina and
- 4:20Venezuela going through hyperinflation.
- 4:22And so for them it was a lot easier to explain Bitcoin.
- 4:24And that kind of helped me realize that, you know, in
- 4:26emerging markets this was going to be probably more of a fit
- 4:30earlier on. So that all got me really
- 4:32excited about Bitcoin. Did some work with Bitzo and the
- 4:34big exchange in Mexico around payments with Bitcoin in 2018.
- 4:37Quickly realized it could never scale on layer one.
- 4:39Kind of became re, I guess, committed to the Lighting
- 4:42Network is like this is our best chance of scaling and making
- 4:44Bitcoin actually useful? And so around that time, I went
- 4:47back to San Francisco. I worked at a different venture
- 4:50fund, version 1 Ventures, for about a year and a half there I
- 4:53did all of our sort of climate energy stuff, as well as our
- 4:56crypto projects. And I tried to go with a pretty
- 4:58open mind. We invested in all of the big
- 4:59Ethereum projects, Uniswap, Open Nexus, all this stuff.
- 5:04And I, and I really did try and you know, say, well, maybe
- 5:06there's a chance some of these other networks will be
- 5:08interesting for other kinds of computation.
- 5:10Basically became very jaded with that.
- 5:12When I would ask all the other entrepreneurs, you know, all of
- 5:15them, I'd say I asked one question like do you run a full
- 5:17node for your ecosystem? You know, it was basically told
- 5:19by all of them that they were exactly 0 full nodes being run
- 5:23other than by Infura or Alchemy. And so that's why I started
- 5:27realizing. I started feeling Michael Burry
- 5:29and Big Short and I was like, I don't think any of this is real.
- 5:31So I knew I had to come back to Bitcoin, and I knew that what
- 5:34was interesting to me was Bitcoin becoming interesting as
- 5:36the currency of the Internet and the currency of the world.
- 5:38And so in about two years ago, I started hiding my ventures and
- 5:42the thesis was essentially that the Lightning Network is what's
- 5:44gonna make Bitcoin useful. And so Fund one was very focused
- 5:47on Lightning Network infrastructure we invested in.
- 5:50A number of companies, almost 40, almost exclusively Lighting
- 5:52network companies. Lighting Labs, River Light
- 5:55Spark, a whole bunch of early ones.
- 5:58Open source projects like Ellen Betts, a whole bunch of that
- 6:01haven't been announced yet. And then over time I started
- 6:05realizing that it wasn't just going to be infrastructure, but
- 6:07as we move into Lighting Network application phase that the
- 6:09things that were most interesting for lighting Network
- 6:11in addition to cross-border payments, which is I think
- 6:13pretty pretty clear was going to be around Gnoster and around AIS
- 6:20using lighting for payments. And those are two like really,
- 6:22radically new areas where lighting network applications
- 6:25can thrive. And so today I kind of think as
- 6:28I move into my sort of next fund is we're moving into the
- 6:31lighting network or Bitcoin application phase.
- 6:34And I think that my sort of protocol stack that I'm
- 6:37investing on is Bitcoin is the decentralized monetary network,
- 6:41Lightning as the decentralized payments network and Noster as
- 6:44the decentralized data network. And those three things together,
- 6:47we'll be able to build all the ideas that you saw on crypto and
- 6:50many, many more. And the decentralized A I steps
- 6:52can be a bit part of that and I'm sure we'll talk a lot about
- 6:54that today as well. Yeah, one thing that I may
- 6:59embarrass Max a little here, but Max, when we met a little over
- 7:03two years ago, that was what really stuck out when you were
- 7:06coming out of the transition from the crypto and web and
- 7:08UNISWAP and I hadn't. I don't think I've have met
- 7:12somebody that has gone through that kind of like.
- 7:16I don't know if it's trial by fire because we've all been
- 7:18there. We have stories about first
- 7:20going to crypto, but also like really investing in being like
- 7:23full in it and taking that step back and being honest with
- 7:26themselves, like, wait, maybe this isn't the right thing.
- 7:28And then also having that lens, we're chatting before the the
- 7:31pod with your, I don't know what you call them if it's a cohost
- 7:35or if it if it's official with the David King, but similarly
- 7:39coming from the Silicon Valley background.
- 7:43It's not a it's it's not always a given, but it's a nice
- 7:46heuristic in my mind when you see folks coming from the quote
- 7:49UN quote legacy world because there's like institutional, like
- 7:53tribal baked in standards built into whether it's Tradfi or the
- 7:57Googles of the world. And then they come in and find
- 7:59their way into Bitcoin that it always was like, OK, this guy's
- 8:02on to something. So it's been awesome to see the
- 8:04past two years and navigating that and then going to the very
- 8:07edges, which I think of like Nostra at the very edge of like
- 8:10all of this, but. I think everybody that's looked
- 8:12at it would agree there's a lot happening there that ties into
- 8:15Bitcoin, so it's also to have you on the show.
- 8:18Thank you. Really appreciate it.
- 8:19And yeah, I'd be kind of all you guys, so excited to be here.
- 8:22I'm I'm curious actually just want to jump in there if like
- 8:26what was it like like what was that, that journey for you?
- 8:30Like when you realize that Eunice Swap wasn't the thing.
- 8:34Like was there? Was it you just kind of woke up
- 8:38one day and it was clear or? Were there a couple touch points
- 8:42or like what was your experience like there?
- 8:46Yeah, well, I mean, I think I, you know, I should be clear in
- 8:49this and that prior to quote UN quote, investing professionally
- 8:53in those ecosystems, you know, I was already on the path to
- 8:55becoming a Bitcoin. Like I mentioned, you know, I
- 8:57read about Bitcoin 2011 and did some pretty serious
- 9:00investigations in 2016 and 2017 and I wasn't 100% sold, right.
- 9:05Like I still thought other projects like at the time Monero
- 9:07was pretty interesting and some other things.
- 9:10And so I really did try and keep an open mind.
- 9:13And so I thought, you know, there are a lot of really smart
- 9:15people and funds frankly that are investing these other
- 9:18ecosystems. You know, maybe I'm really
- 9:19missing something. And so I went in, I would say
- 9:22with more of a Bitcoin lens to begin with, but open minded
- 9:26enough to say. What am I missing?
- 9:27And to be frank, I mean, you know, just asking all those
- 9:30questions, literally finding that no one's running nodes,
- 9:33it's getting more difficult to run nodes.
- 9:34Like I think the way I described to people is like very simple.
- 9:36Like I guess one of the middle models of crystallized from you
- 9:38is if you think about, you know, two curves, right?
- 9:40There's the rate of like the size of your blockchain growing,
- 9:44right, that has a certain steepness.
- 9:45And then there's a cost of consumer hardware to run a full
- 9:48node. And that's the bandwidth, the
- 9:49storage, all that. That is a certain steepness.
- 9:51And if this one is steeper than this one, I E if your blockchain
- 9:53is growing way faster, then it's getting cheaper and easier to
- 9:55run a node, then it has to centralize.
- 9:57It's just a question of when. And so I kept like formalizing
- 10:00that thought process over my year and a half, like trying to
- 10:02like see where I was wrong and no one could tell me I was
- 10:04wrong. I looked into all the D5 stuff.
- 10:06I tried to understand where is the actual coming from.
- 10:09I just couldn't identify it. And you know, I I really
- 10:12thought, well maybe I'm missing something.
- 10:13And then after a while, you know, I will say this, it
- 10:15definitely gave me a certain degree of confidence where like
- 10:18you know, I'm seeing and not saying I don't respect these
- 10:20guys. These are all fantastic funds
- 10:22that are incredible in many ways.
- 10:23But you know, you're looking at these funds you used to idealize
- 10:26like A16Z or? Things of Quay, like investing
- 10:28in FDX and stuff and you start thinking, well wait a second,
- 10:30you know, maybe maybe a lot of people aren't thinking from
- 10:34first principles. Truly, if you do that, then
- 10:37there's huge alpha and you know, fuck it, I'm gonna do, you know,
- 10:40I'm gonna do it on my own and see what happens.
- 10:41So. Yeah, it's so interesting how
- 10:44there's this, this misconception among alt coiners and the
- 10:49broader crypto world that Bitcoin maximalists haven't
- 10:52looked into alt coins enough. Like that's the assumption on
- 10:57that side of things is they'll they'll get to altcoins because
- 11:03you know there's so much excitement here and they just
- 11:05don't know about it. They're still on version one
- 11:07with the boring Bitcoin and and then you are are proof positive
- 11:13that it's actually the the the other way.
- 11:15There's a There's a hero's journey of you start with
- 11:18Bitcoin, you go into the wilderness and you end up coming
- 11:21back. Oops, sorry.
- 11:25Go for mine. No, I was gonna say I think, I
- 11:28think this conversation like this, what we're talking about
- 11:31right now, really reminds me of my favorite blog post of all
- 11:34time about Bitcoin, which is Gwern's 2012 post Bitcoin is
- 11:40Worse, is Better. And I think to give the audience
- 11:43like a better of understanding about what we're meant by that,
- 11:46I think you began to touch on it with how.
- 11:50These systems, if they're going to be successful, need to be
- 11:52sufficiently distributed at the end of the day.
- 11:55Like what in your mind gives you confidence that Bitcoin at the
- 11:58base layer has that sufficient distribution, whether it be full
- 12:02nodes, hash rate, private key ownership?
- 12:07It's full nodes. Yeah, but full nodes and hash,
- 12:09right? I think, you know, again might
- 12:12be. And again I'm not saying there
- 12:13aren't other things that shouldn't have different degrees
- 12:15of centralization or decentralization.
- 12:17Like I'm, we'll talk a lot about this, but that's why I'm so
- 12:19excited about master. I do think they're interesting
- 12:21things. Like I do think the idea of a
- 12:22quote UN quote decks, a decentralized marketplace is
- 12:24absolutely fascinating. I just don't think that needs to
- 12:26be on a blockchain. I think it can be done perfectly
- 12:29well with Noster. I think decentralized social
- 12:31media is amazing, again, doesn't need a blockchain.
- 12:33So I really like a lot of those ideas and was very much looking
- 12:37for something like Noster that would say the only thing that
- 12:39really, really needs. Because if you think about it
- 12:41like to have sufficient decentralization of the base
- 12:44layer, I think if I did choose one thing, it's the nodes and
- 12:47then the hash, right? And so to run a whole bunch of
- 12:49nodes, I mean, it's very expensive to be able to audit
- 12:53that whole system and have some form of global state.
- 12:55And so I think something like the base economic unit, the
- 12:59money is probably the only thing you really need that for.
- 13:01If you're just doing communication, you need some way
- 13:03to sign a private message. Have enough different nodes out
- 13:06there, enough different servers or relays saying yes, this data
- 13:08exists, yes, it was signed on private key, but you don't need
- 13:11everyone to agree on the exact same global state for that.
- 13:14So anyway, so that was kind of always in the back of my head,
- 13:16but with Bitcoin at that base layer, you do need radical
- 13:19decentralization. And I think you guys are way
- 13:23deeper than this than I am. But the history of money and
- 13:25it's pretty clear that it always gets debased and you need to
- 13:29fight the fight to keep that one layer decentralized, truly, and
- 13:31I think. Number of nodes, making sure
- 13:34that you know, I remember the 2017 block wars, making sure
- 13:37it's super easy for anyone that wants to run a node to be able
- 13:39to run a node whether they're in, you know, Ecuador or the
- 13:41United States. It needs to be cheap enough,
- 13:43easy enough, that's super important.
- 13:44And then the amount of hash going up, like whenever people
- 13:47are concerned about Bitcoin, like look if if my thesis is
- 13:49right and this is just energy backed money, then you know as
- 13:53long as hash rate continues to go up over time, I'm not
- 13:56concerned. It's funny you bring that up
- 13:58because those two I think nobody would dispute.
- 14:01But the one that I think is like directly one to one is private
- 14:04keys and nodes. Because I think if you have
- 14:07infinite number of nodes in the private key sit between Coinbase
- 14:10and and name the other one, it doesn't really matter the number
- 14:13of nodes because the private keys in a similar.
- 14:16I think those are the that's the one that doesn't get talked
- 14:19about a lot. And I'm curious, do you have any
- 14:22thoughts on like private key ownership?
- 14:24You know, I haven't thought. Distribution really, right?
- 14:27Like outside of a core contingent of, you know,
- 14:30institutions holding a large subset of the private keys.
- 14:34Well, I definitely think more people holding private keys is
- 14:38definitely a better thing. What would the argument be?
- 14:40I haven't really thought about this one too much.
- 14:42Why would that be as important as nodes auditing the Ledger
- 14:45itself? So in my mind that if you have
- 14:49let's say 10 nodes auditing the network.
- 14:53In 10 separate large entities holding the keys, you want it to
- 14:58grow in proportion because if you have an infinite number of
- 15:02nodes. So we get the centralization
- 15:04there and decentralization of hash, but you end up with let's
- 15:08call it 5 entities holding the majority of the keys.
- 15:11So I think about it similar like what you mentioned, digital gold
- 15:14In my mind like kind of started to go to this anchor point of
- 15:16like one of the big and it's almost cute to say it's not the
- 15:19only thing but the big difference between Bitcoin and
- 15:21gold is multi seg. Because you're able to not have
- 15:25this centralization of the asset because if we break down like
- 15:27from a first principle level of where gold failed it centralized
- 15:30with banks and they were able to start mucking with the supply of
- 15:34the the claims on the gold. And so that's where I like
- 15:38anchor to this like keys and stuff we work on it on ramps.
- 15:41I'm obviously like talking my book but it's also like an
- 15:43important thing. I don't think a lot of folks
- 15:44talk about is like the key ownership and they it's.
- 15:48It's about getting as many out in the network almost to the
- 15:51edges similar to nodes in the sense that you want to like
- 15:56especially from like I don't know if they're they're the most
- 15:58appropriate is tyranny. But like you want it, you want
- 16:01to have that cost of violence as far and distributed to go and
- 16:06take possession of the asset. And if it was centralized within
- 16:11510, even 100 identifiable institutions.
- 16:15Or entities. It gets a lot easier to
- 16:17basically Co opt the asset independent of how many nodes
- 16:21are out there. Yeah, I think that's a very fair
- 16:25point. I think, yeah, I mean, in
- 16:27general, more people holding more keys also is good for less
- 16:30volatility, which has happened over time.
- 16:32I think that's gonna keep happening as well.
- 16:34So, yeah, I mean, I certainly say that's another important
- 16:36point. Yeah, luckily the data here is
- 16:39in our favor too. Hash rates going up full node.
- 16:42Owners are going up and then Bitcoin held off exchanges is
- 16:47going up as well. There's been a complete exodus.
- 16:50Not a complete exodus, but a material exodus off of exchanges
- 16:54last two years. That's sort of the beauty of
- 16:56Bitcoin has its antifragile system.
- 17:00I mean, the antifragility works at the protocol layer, but then
- 17:03the social layer. People see an FTX to sell CSA
- 17:05block 5, blow up and they go, oh wow, like, maybe my Bitcoin
- 17:09isn't safe on this exchange. I should get it.
- 17:11Into keys that I that I actually possess.
- 17:13So I mean, the old adage that everything's good for Bitcoin,
- 17:17even if it's an exchange blow up, seems to be playing out.
- 17:20In real shot. And one thing I would add on
- 17:22here, just sort of my realist point of view this, I think it's
- 17:24amazing and I tell everyone like owning your own keys is an
- 17:28incredible, you know, step in the journey for a lot of people.
- 17:31But, but I do think that there will always be you know, various
- 17:34forms of centralized institutions, right, Like there
- 17:36could be multi saying there would also just be like you
- 17:38know, single, you know. Custodians, and I think that on
- 17:44Bitcoin Center, if if they do start to hold that, ideally with
- 17:47a lot more transparency and they go under, well then they go
- 17:50under it and people learn overtime which ones are much
- 17:53more trustworthy, which ones are not.
- 17:55I do think it's important for everyone to kind of evaluate and
- 17:57where they are in their journey like because if you do hold your
- 17:59own private keys, right, like a lot of people I know have just
- 18:02lost those too. I think that that's a really
- 18:03real risk. But I think for me the most
- 18:05important thing is that it should be very easy to move
- 18:08between yourself and a custodian, should be very easy
- 18:10for everyone. To be transparent, what they
- 18:12hold, what they don't hold. And then from there I guess over
- 18:16time it probably becomes easier for people to hold their own.
- 18:18But I think interoperability and transparency are probably the
- 18:22things I most value there. Yeah, auditability is important
- 18:26from the market just going back to reputation based.
- 18:30So then you mention about the crypto, I think there's a high
- 18:34form of alpha that's just looking at crypto firms that had
- 18:37quote UN quote traction and then.
- 18:39And then you just like literally put, you just insert sats into
- 18:42it. That was the one that they sold
- 19:03shoes that had like. Like the one that always comes
- 18:43to mind is the step, the step in thing.
- 18:45Remember like step in in 2021, it was the thing you got like
- 18:48tokens and it turned into like people just trading it.
- 18:50But it was like to incentivize going and working out.
- 18:53It's like that's kind of interesting, like if you can
- 18:55like gamify that, but you don't need an alt coin.
- 18:59But yeah, there's so many. Like what do you call them?
- 19:07Accelerometers in them, right? To count how many steps you were
- 19:10taking, and then you were paid tokens based on how many steps
- 19:14you were taking every day, which is such a bizarre distribution
- 19:17mechanism, but it got a lot of hype.
- 19:19Totally. I actually joke with people and
- 19:21like you say that kind of tongue in cheek.
- 19:23And as do I. But also just like truthfully, I
- 19:25love to like go like look at the multicoin portfolio, see what
- 19:28gets traction. Just like, OK, imagine this, but
- 19:30done without a shit coin, right? Like just imagine this done with
- 19:32money. And I think, for example, This
- 19:34is why I was so excited to see Nostra.
- 19:35I do think, you know, we want decentralized messaging to be
- 19:38able to build those marketplaces.
- 19:39But again, there's no reason you need a blockchain for that.
- 19:40So three of the things I'm most bullsh on and in fact I've just
- 19:43invested in one of these and you know.
- 19:45Continually hunting for other ones are decentralized markets
- 19:48for bandwidth, storage and compute.
- 19:49These are all great ideas, don't need their own token, and for
- 19:53many reasons like having your own token.
- 19:55Obviously there's many reasons why it's a bad idea, but one is
- 19:57just you don't have liquidity. If I get paid with Helium, what
- 19:59the hell am I supposed to do with this helium token?
- 20:01If I get paid with Sats, well over time there's more and more
- 20:03exchanges. I can get that into whatever my
- 20:05local currency is or. Recently just trade that for
- 20:07goods and services. But like, yeah, I'm super
- 20:09bullish on a lot of those quote UN quote crypto ideas and that's
- 20:12why I said it's kind of like I saw 20-17 and you know the the
- 20:15years after that, it's kind of like the web band moment, like
- 20:17online grocery delivery, really good idea.
- 20:19Infrastructure wasn't there yet, and this is maybe a little bit
- 20:22scammier and more, you know, dangerous man, yeah.
- 20:25So Max, let's like let's slow that one down and play it out a
- 20:29little bit of like okay, so why don't you need file coin, you
- 20:32know like so or whatever the other set of storage on your
- 20:38computer being used and and by decentralized, like a WS,
- 20:44decentralized a WS instance basically and you get paid for
- 20:50lending, for renting out your storage space.
- 20:53That's basically the model, right?
- 20:55And then so then they've created these tokens like File, Coin and
- 21:00others that are variants of the same idea to be the currency
- 21:06that you're paid out in. So why don't you need that to be
- 21:10baked into the system? And then how do Sats replace
- 21:13that? I think there's two different
- 21:16ways you can look at this. One is you can just like have a
- 21:18very sort of like simple business file and like I'm sure
- 21:21you guys have heard value for value, which to me is really
- 21:24funny because it's like it's like such an obvious idea.
- 21:26It's like ways. Like, you mean like I do
- 21:28something valuable and you pay me something valuable?
- 21:30Like it's almost like so obscenely simple.
- 21:33Like, of course that's what the economy should be, right?
- 21:35And so if you take this idea that Bitcoin is the best money,
- 21:38it's energy backed money and you're producing some kind of
- 21:40valuable work, well that has some caloric value and you're
- 21:44gonna pay me in that. Now there's two models I can see
- 21:47working with this model. Number one is I just pay you for
- 21:50the service you provide and in that world the reason Bitcoin is
- 21:53so much better and it gets keeps getting better with every month
- 21:55over time is frankly liquid. Right.
- 21:57I can pay you out in sats and now and I know for a fact
- 22:00because I've invested in many of these companies, companies like
- 22:03Neutron pay pouch, ibex, bit knob, all these different
- 22:06companies that are kind of like lightning to Fiat rails around
- 22:08the world. You can cash that out to your
- 22:10local currency or cash that out for goods and services, right.
- 22:13If I pay you in helium token, what the hell are you supposed
- 22:15to do with the helium token? Where can you trade that?
- 22:17Like where can you get, you know, goods and services that
- 22:19and again, I'm not saying we're perfect there with Bitcoin yet.
- 22:21Actually think something like Taro probably offer U.S. dollars
- 22:24on top of it is going to help us a lot in the short run.
- 22:26But as a monetary network, Bitcoin and lightning continues
- 22:29to grow and gain more and more interoperability.
- 22:32Another way of saying that is Bitcoin and lightning to me are
- 22:35the Internet of value. All these other, you know, quote
- 22:38UN quote, cryptocurrencies are intranets.
- 22:40They're not interoperable. And so I'm always going to bet
- 22:43all day, every day on the network that's open,
- 22:45interoperable and keeps growing, right.
- 22:48And and that's Bitcoin of lightning in my mind.
- 22:49So that's the first reason. The one thing that I will say
- 22:51that I'm open to where this is going to go is I do think you
- 22:54know what Helium and some of these other things try to do was
- 22:57essentially give people equity, right.
- 22:59So not just pay you in cash, which I think cash can work just
- 23:02fine. But you know say hey, if you
- 23:04have earlier ownership in this network, perhaps it's more
- 23:06valuable. And I am interested to see how
- 23:08people are going to do and maybe this will come with Taro or
- 23:09something, but the ability to basically give you like Sats
- 23:13flows over time. I think if you think about what
- 23:15equity is, it's just a claim on future cash flows.
- 23:18And so if there's some way that you can get a bigger claim by
- 23:21being earlier on future Sats flows, Bitcoin flow into the
- 23:25network, I think that's pretty interesting.
- 23:27And so I'm curious how people are gonna experiment with that.
- 23:31Yeah, yeah, one thing. You said the value for value and
- 23:36I think. When we go through that, I think
- 23:39it's probably helpful to explain why there's a problem and you
- 23:42can probably do it better than than anybody.
- 23:44But it's just like breaking down from 1st principles like how
- 23:47fundamentally the Internet was it.
- 23:49It it's relatively new, it's 20, you know consumer Internet,
- 23:52let's call it 2000s, maybe even 95.
- 23:54So you have 20 to 3025 to 30 years.
- 23:56But then we look at like the status of Facebook, Twitter and
- 23:59and the way things were were made and people assume like this
- 24:01is what will always be if you can help break down like where
- 24:06things. Fell apart there because I think
- 24:09that actually helps. And then as we start thinking
- 24:11about value for value NOSTER and some of the stuff that is is
- 24:15being created because I think of it similarly with like venture
- 24:18and just like capital formation in today's world, it's like the
- 24:21value for value isn't actually going to the most valuable.
- 24:26It's there's this like latency in the signal because of all the
- 24:30muckiness and that's similar to like what we see in the Internet
- 24:33today. Do you want to break that down
- 24:36and then we can riff post that? I don't want to hijack Marty's,
- 24:41but you signal the value for value and there's a lot there.
- 24:46Yeah. I mean, so I mean, I think one
- 24:47way of looking again, value for value, right.
- 24:49It's just like to me, it's just, it's an exchange of like it's
- 24:53proof of work. You do work and I give you this
- 24:55digital proof of work, IE energy, potential energy for
- 24:57your actual energy or your active energy, kinetic energy.
- 25:02And so I think that the way I think about Bitcoin and
- 25:06lightening is it's, you know, it's a currency for the
- 25:09Internet. And when the Internet was formed
- 25:13there, you know these various HTTP error codes.
- 25:16Most people have seen like 404 errors as an example page not
- 25:19found. But if you go to 402, right,
- 25:22that was the error for payment not received.
- 25:24So it's not like these are new ideas.
- 25:26People were really curious and planning for currency.
- 25:29The Internet, it just wasn't a solved technological problem of
- 25:31how to do it yet. And I the reason my fun, for
- 25:35example, is called hive mind is I think humanity is at this just
- 25:39really exciting evolutionary point.
- 25:41We're about to enter the next stage of human evolution.
- 25:43And that next stage is if you think about how, like how
- 25:48evolution flows or how everything in the universe
- 25:51flows, there's this idea of like holons, right?
- 25:53Like things are parts and then they're holes.
- 25:55So holes become parts of new holes all the way up and all the
- 25:58way down. This is true from, you know,
- 26:00molecule, our cells and molecules and organs, organ
- 26:03systems and bodies and ecosystems, the planet all the
- 26:06way up and all the way down. And So what I think we're about
- 26:09to do, we're living through this crazy time where you know,
- 26:13historically we've had nation states which I think in like you
- 26:17know, a couple, 100 years are going to look kind of like a
- 26:18little silly. I'm not saying they're going to
- 26:20totally die. And I think it's it's kind of
- 26:21like the Catholic Church used to have a lot more power of the
- 26:24world still around but much less so it's probably what's gonna
- 26:26happen nation states. But yeah I think our kids, kids
- 26:28are gonna be like it's kind of weird like why is it that, you
- 26:30know, just cuz I was born on like the wrong side.
- 26:33You were born in Mexico and I was born in Brownsville, TX.
- 26:35We couldn't do like you know projects together and exchange
- 26:38value together like that. That's just like just seems
- 26:40really weird when you think about that from future
- 26:41generations perspectives. And so I think that you know we
- 26:45started by laying the best version of the Internet that we
- 26:47could. And when I say laying that
- 26:49actually mean like the physical infrastructure of the cables and
- 26:51then obviously all the services that came on top of that without
- 26:55having native currency for the Internet.
- 26:56And kind of trying to like make this like kind of Frankenstein
- 26:58system work with all of our legacy Fiat currencies and
- 27:02payment networks that we're just never meant for the for the
- 27:05Internet, right. Like, I mean if you have, you
- 27:07know an ACH transfer that takes you five days to clear or a wire
- 27:10that takes a couple of days and $15 like like everything else on
- 27:14the Internet allows information to spread, to spread at the
- 27:16speed of light. And so money just can't, can't
- 27:18match that right now. So you have this just just
- 27:20bizarre mismatch of information wanting to be free and being
- 27:24free but not being able to develop business models around
- 27:27that because the monetary and payment networks don't work with
- 27:29it, right. And So what I think is going to
- 27:32happen next is we've kind of laid this first version of all
- 27:36of the neurons that are connecting humanity into a hive
- 27:38mind. And I think we're actually in a
- 27:40bit of a turning .1 model of the hive mind is more I guess if
- 27:44like a Chinese type model where it's very top down state
- 27:46controlled and and that's pretty, pretty scary in my mind.
- 27:50Another version of the high mind is a very decentralized sort of
- 27:52markets driven high mind where it's it's self emergence, it's
- 27:56self forming. And that's what I think Bitcoin
- 27:58represents, that's what I think lightning represents, that's
- 28:00what I think Nostra represents. And so I think the next big
- 28:03phase is, you know, Bitcoin as a currency on the Internet is
- 28:06great. And I think we're going to see a
- 28:07lot of really cool business models emerge with just using,
- 28:11you know, Lightning payments, for example, companies like
- 28:13Stacker News and Investor. And there's a lot of cool stuff
- 28:15happening with those kinds of sites.
- 28:17But then I think the even the phase beyond that is we start
- 28:19thinking, well, if we now have this new currency and payments
- 28:23network for the Internet, why don't we build an Internet
- 28:25itself that's more in that shape or form.
- 28:28And that's what I think Nostra is.
- 28:29We can talk about the architecture of that, but a more
- 28:31decentralized version of the Internet.
- 28:33And then I think the far version even beyond Nostra is an idea
- 28:36that Drew Bansal's talked a lot about, which is that eventually
- 28:39we're going to use these new primitives to actually go back
- 28:42and probably relay new physical infrastructure itself that's
- 28:46more in line with a decentralized Internet and a
- 28:49decentralized payment system. And so like actually having
- 28:52packets themselves need to have payments associated with them.
- 28:55I think that's going to come in the far future, but I think
- 28:57that's the direction that we're moving in.
- 28:59We're going to have one sort of like, you know, energy exchange
- 29:03system or as he calls it, metabolic system.
- 29:04And that's what the new Organism is composed of, all of us as
- 29:07individual organisms within it. Yeah, we're getting Cosmic here.
- 29:13So no, I completely agree with everything you just said,
- 29:17because I've seen it play out in real time.
- 29:21Like podcasting 2.0 Perfect example.
- 29:24RSS sends out our podcast. We can put a lightning network.
- 29:28Address in there, people can scream of sats, boost of sats as
- 29:32they listen. Obviously Nostra notes and other
- 29:35stuff transferred over relays. That's what Nostra stands for.
- 29:39For anybody who's wondering what we're talking about, I think
- 29:41we'll dive deeper into Nostra. But I think to really set the
- 29:46tone for the rest of the conversation, let's let's let's
- 29:50like build it up where particularly around the
- 29:52Lightning Network. So we're 5 1/2 years after the
- 29:54Lightning Network launched in March of 2018.
- 29:59It launched too much fanfare. However, there are many out
- 30:02there who think for some reason or another that Lightning has
- 30:05not been successful. So I think, Max, I'm curious,
- 30:09just starting at Lightning five years in, like, where is it and
- 30:13why do people have these misconceptions?
- 30:16And then obviously we've mentioned NOSTER and Podcasting
- 30:182.0, and you mentioned AI earlier.
- 30:21Where is it now? And then how?
- 30:23What are you seeing in terms of it being integrated into these
- 30:26other open protocols? Yeah.
- 30:29So I think the first thing I would say that is like
- 30:30obviously, you know, I would love to see this go even faster.
- 30:33I like who wouldn't like I wish everyone was using Lightning
- 30:36Wall and I can't say that you know we're anywhere near that.
- 30:39We have a ways to go. If you think about, you know, I
- 30:41don't know what the the most recent numbers are, but I've
- 30:43seen estimates somewhere in the order of like 2-3 hundred
- 30:46million people ish that have interacted with Bitcoin in some
- 30:48way. I'm assuming that includes 20
- 30:50days. Maybe you guys have better date
- 30:51on that, but let's call it in that like low hundreds of
- 30:531,000,000 that's around 97 Internet level penetration.
- 30:58And so I think kind of my big bet is that from 97 to 2007 is
- 31:02when you saw Google and Facebook and Twitter.
- 31:05I guess Twitter came around a little later than that, but
- 31:07that's when you saw a huge wave of all of these big successful
- 31:10Internet companies first form Amazon.
- 31:12And I think we're about, I think we're living through that right
- 31:14now literally as we speak. And so as I think about my fund
- 31:17as an investor, right, like you know one of the tricky things is
- 31:20timing like I'm pretty confident in where all this direction is
- 31:23going to head trying to time the wave is tricky making sure that
- 31:27companies are well enough capitalized be able to ride it.
- 31:29But I think that, you know, my last two years was very heavily
- 31:32focused on infrastructure, right.
- 31:34And we've come such a long way. I don't think people realize
- 31:36now. Like if anyone wants to
- 31:38understand how easy Lightning is to use, I would say download
- 31:42cash app, buy Bitcoin, go to El Salvador and like pay for a lot
- 31:45of things instantly for free from cash app.
- 31:48That's a wild statement. A US publicly traded company's
- 31:50payment app is my wallet in El Salvador right now.
- 31:53Not theoretical, right? So that's one crazy example.
- 31:56An even better example, because I think that some of the nation
- 31:58state adoption stuff is cool but honestly happened faster in some
- 32:01ways than I thought it would, is using it again as the currency
- 32:04of the Internet. And so I would say the two most
- 32:06interesting projects for anyone to get an idea of what's
- 32:08happening here Albee get albee.com.
- 32:11And on Albee you can basically download a Chrome extension
- 32:14which is your lightning wallet and use that for all kinds of
- 32:16experiences on the Internet. One would be Stacker dot news,
- 32:20which is like Reddit but you upload with Bitcoin and there's
- 32:22a lot of interesting implications around surfacing
- 32:25value and information and all kinds of other things.
- 32:27But again, that just works, right?
- 32:29Like, there's no questions around theory.
- 32:32I load up $20 worth of Sats, gotta come on 100,000 Sats, and
- 32:36I go and ZAP articles instantly I see it leave my wallet and go
- 32:40to someone else's wallet instantly, real time for free.
- 32:44That's a real experience. So I think the last two or three
- 32:47years were kind of about laying the initial infrastructure.
- 32:51Another way that I sometimes think about this is like we're
- 32:53kind of like, I think the Lightning Network.
- 32:55I think, I don't think people have seen it like this, but it's
- 32:56kind of like we're laying the next railroad track.
- 32:59And I true truly believe, you know the like the Vanderbilts
- 33:02and Morgans, like really big industrialists are going to be
- 33:05those that can kind of take advantage of frankly and
- 33:08capitalize on laying the track correctly owning you know the
- 33:13some of the Grand Centrals that are sitting there routing.
- 33:15And I think those companies, probably a lot of them already
- 33:17exist. I think companies like River,
- 33:19Neutron, Pay Pouch Block, Ibex, you know, Bitknob, and a lot of
- 33:25them are going to be in different sort of zones.
- 33:26Like that infrastructure is pretty developed right now.
- 33:30So then I think the next thing we're missing is the actual
- 33:32application base. Stacker news is 1 incredible
- 33:35example, But you know that that was a little bit ahead of its
- 33:38time. That's because Ken's not only an
- 33:40application developer but a protocol developer as well.
- 33:42But now you're starting to see the libraries, for example,
- 33:45Albee's libraries, Breeze's libraries are getting good
- 33:48enough that a JavaScript level developer can come in and start
- 33:51to build applications with lighting.
- 33:53And that's when things start to get really interesting, because
- 33:55once the developers can build new experiences, that's going to
- 33:58bring on way more users because they can go out and build
- 34:01specific apps for their users. And I do think the two areas,
- 34:04the three areas I'm most bullish on are international payments.
- 34:06That's already happening. That's a bit of a slog, but it's
- 34:08gonna keep happening. Companies like Strike, all the
- 34:11companies I mentioned are focused there, but the two areas
- 34:13that I'm most excited about are when you look at investment
- 34:16waves, what is brand new, not trying to like tag on the old
- 34:21activity with the new substrate but literally build up a new
- 34:24activity in a new substrate. And so I think Nostra based
- 34:27applications where you natively ZAP any piece of content or can
- 34:31natively conduct payments in any kind of Nostra and I'll talk
- 34:36about that means next or whatever you want that's going
- 34:38to be huge. And then the A I is paying each
- 34:40other, which I know sounds very scifi and crazy.
- 34:43But you know, the TLDR there is like you're about to live in a
- 34:47world with, you know, if we have billions of humans, I think
- 34:49trillions of artificial intelligences and JP Morgan is
- 34:52not banking them, right? Like this is not going to
- 34:54happen. And so the ability for AI is to
- 34:57be able to interact with each other and other Internet
- 35:00services at the speed of light, like information can happen.
- 35:03That just can't happen with the old payment rails.
- 35:04So that's why I'm so focused on on Noster and AI use cases right
- 35:09now, cuz even that's where we see the brand new novel concepts
- 35:12that take the infrastructure from lighting that's already
- 35:14built and just like bring it into the mainstream.
- 35:18Yeah, This is something, Marty. This is something Marty and I
- 35:21talked about a lot. It's like we try to pontificate
- 35:23or figure out, is it the Aster that goes up or the utility And
- 35:27it feels like it's and it's what's exciting about what we're
- 35:29talking about. It happens in levels at the same
- 35:31time. Where you're referencing and
- 35:33there's stuff like Vita and others that are building like
- 35:36this native app that can be used in real applications.
- 35:41The example that always anchor to just because they're annoying
- 35:44I think for everybody. It's like Robo calls from spam
- 35:47and if you can set up a way that they can ping a server to figure
- 35:51out if it is spam or not and you have it a fractional amount of
- 35:56sats that are paid. And it just becomes a better
- 35:59experience for somebody to download that figure out how to
- 36:01top up the wallet and you you, you know, you mentioned AI and
- 36:05these other utilities or other projects that can be used.
- 36:09And and at the same time that you're downloading this
- 36:11application, you're referencing Sats or you're seeing this like
- 36:14token and the price is appreciating and they're
- 36:17happening in parallel and they kind of just like meet in the
- 36:20middle as at least that's how I started to think about it the
- 36:23past 12 months as seeing all this like crazy things that can
- 36:26just be built. Inherently better because now
- 36:28you have a token that's native the Internet versus having this
- 36:31like clunky version of buying credits or figuring out how it
- 36:33can programmatically interact with an application that's
- 36:38that's newer or form fit for like where we're at today. 100%
- 36:43agreement and maybe it would be helpful if you guys are good
- 36:46with this name. We can do a deep dive on Noster
- 36:48and why Lightning will thrive there and then AI.
- 36:52Cute. Cute.
- 36:52Before before we do that, one of the things that I wanted to
- 36:56reference or just like tie it back because I think we're so
- 36:58far down there. I hold that it makes sense to
- 37:00us, but that it's like it's anchoring back to like where why
- 37:05there's a problem like you reference yield in the same way
- 37:08that we talk about like yields a problem in the sense of there's
- 37:11the joke. We'll probably give it to Phil
- 37:13Geiger is like if you if you don't know where the yields
- 37:15coming from, it's coming from you, you are the yield.
- 37:17Yeah, we know in the same way like if you're getting the
- 37:22service, it's your attention is the yield, like you were giving
- 37:26it, you're providing it. And when the Internet came
- 37:29about, when you think about Google Adwords and Facebook, all
- 37:32that infrastructure costs. And so that's where the Internet
- 37:35was built, based on ads. And you see all this crazy, just
- 37:38like. It's just like I just keep
- 37:40waiting here. This where like tumor it just
- 37:41like looks nasty because it doesn't make sense.
- 37:44You don't know how it came about but somebody's subsidizing that
- 37:46and you are via your attention in these other formats and so
- 37:50and we can go down the other use cases.
- 37:52But I think that's an important aspect because I was listening
- 37:55to one of the pods you did with David and I knew there was a lot
- 37:59here inherently just cuz he knew the Internet was messed up.
- 38:02But then one about Google and the highlighter and it really
- 38:05like hit me. That Google's whole job is to
- 38:08crawl and surface, quote, UN quote, valuable information on
- 38:12the web. But it isn't because of that
- 38:15inherent, latent like between the the value and then the value
- 38:19that's on the Internet. So you get shit at the top and
- 38:22that's via like blogs and pot and like all the stuff that's
- 38:25there. So what's people paid or what's
- 38:26gone versus what do people find the most interesting or the most
- 38:30valuable? And the second you can highlight
- 38:32or input some proof of work tied to what somebody really is
- 38:36willing to give away to your point on the high line, you
- 38:39start to surface the best information and it rearchitects
- 38:42what's actually happening in people and that can go across
- 38:45all mediums. It doesn't have to be a blog
- 38:46post. It can be a how to.
- 38:47It can be music. And so anyway, I just think of
- 38:50it, it's like an interesting aspect to like break down, like
- 38:53where how information isn't actually coming in the right
- 38:55direction, value isn't going there.
- 38:58And so that inherently has to be fixed if we want it to be the
- 39:01most efficient And then that's where Noster and these things
- 39:03like come about or at least that's our I believe our thesis
- 39:05on the on this totally. And I would just say two quick
- 39:11reactions that I mean I'm sure you've read this Gigi's piece is
- 39:13really good on this about he kind of goes into into great
- 39:16detail about why a credit based monetary system doesn't work for
- 39:19the Internet and why attention became the pseudocurrency and
- 39:23you know, very high level. I would recommend everyone to
- 39:26read it. It's an excellent piece.
- 39:27But like if you're using Stripe, you have whatever the 2.9% fee
- 39:32plus 25% transaction fee like you just can't do micro
- 39:35transactions and without micro transactions it limits the types
- 39:40of business models that you can pay for.
- 39:42And so if your subscriptions work, and they work in a lot of
- 39:45cases, but it limits the creative ability of developers
- 39:48and entrepreneurs to test. And So what has emerged is like,
- 39:51people want easy, frictionless things.
- 39:53But as you said, nothing's free, right?
- 39:55Like, they have real server cost.
- 39:56And so in order to pay for that, yeah, attention has become the
- 40:00default pseudocurrency. You know, Facebook is quote, UN
- 40:02quote free, but how free is it really if it, you know, warps
- 40:05your mind and sucks your time? And and I think it's just like
- 40:08one thing that I hope Bitcoin helps solve, is like attention
- 40:11is the most valuable thing everyone has.
- 40:12Full stop. And to give it away for free is
- 40:15just it's wild to me. I don't even like these like
- 40:17micro pay things. I know some people like this
- 40:19like, oh, you know, you you give your attention, you get paid a
- 40:21couple of sats. Like, I think your attention is
- 40:23like so much more viable. Like your attention is like is
- 40:26it's more valuable than Bitcoin. Like attention is the only thing
- 40:29that really matters at the end of the day.
- 40:30And so my hope is that Bitcoin is a much, is a much better,
- 40:34better money for the Internet. So we can come up with new
- 40:37business models that are much fairer and save your attention.
- 40:40So that's where I hope we're at it.
- 40:42Yeah, I think it all comes down to centralization versus
- 40:44decentralization. Like AWS and Netflix are great
- 40:46examples. They're inefficient models.
- 40:48To send all the data to a major server, it has to get fed back.
- 40:53But then ultimately, there's also just like the the natural
- 40:57censorship that can come with it.
- 40:59And so there's a lot like that ends up when you have just
- 41:01inefficient, like systems of architecture set up.
- 41:05And this would tie in all that, yeah, one thing.
- 41:08Oops, sorry. Did you wanna?
- 41:10Say no, no, go ahead. One thing that I wanted to just
- 41:13also add on there is even before we jump into Nostrin AI, you
- 41:18were kind of talking about this a little bit.
- 41:19One of my big obsessions and one of the things I've been kind of
- 41:23spear phishing for as a VC for the last year and a half is this
- 41:28idea of how to create a better algorithm for indexing
- 41:32information. And so I put out this piece
- 41:36about a year and a half ago called or maybe it was a year
- 41:39ago now, I don't know, but it called it How to Disrupt Google.
- 41:42And the thesis of the piece is very simple.
- 41:45Google came about in the early days of the Internet when they
- 41:50basically they started by backlinking.
- 41:52They had this concept of Pagerank, which is basically
- 41:55trying to say if a piece of information links to another
- 41:57piece of information, if you can borrow from that first piece of
- 41:59information's reputation, then you can better index what's
- 42:04valuable and what's not. And so the way they kind of
- 42:06bootstrap that to the best of my understanding hearing this from
- 42:08DK, is they basically just start with stanford.edu.
- 42:11If you link back to stanford.edu is like okay.
- 42:13This must be legit. And they kind of grew out from
- 42:15there. And that's worked for a while
- 42:17and obviously it was a big breakthrough.
- 42:18That's why Google beat out Yahoo and all these other worse
- 42:22indexed information repositories.
- 42:25But even, you know, prior to me really getting into Noster, I've
- 42:30been noticing for years that Google is just becoming, like
- 42:33really terrible, right? Like anytime I Google something,
- 42:36I'm getting SEO crap. It's not like real information.
- 42:40And So what I noticed myself doing was inputting whatever it
- 42:44is I wanted to search for plus Reddit at the end of.
- 42:47Time. I do that too.
- 42:49Well, it turns out we're not alone.
- 42:51Like as I was going down this rabbit hole last summer, I found
- 42:53there's a Hacker News article, I think it's the 11th most
- 42:57uploaded Oracle Hacker news ever.
- 42:59And basically like all the nerds do this like literally all of us
- 43:03and or they add Reddit or Stack Overflow or whatever form
- 43:07because you want real human information.
- 43:09And so I started reading different people's takes on this
- 43:11and I think some people had some really good ideas, but they were
- 43:13missing the Bitcoin piece. But my big take away was what if
- 43:16we could do something like value rank or market rank, right,
- 43:19which you basically can take information.
- 43:21And now that we have the only things that are scarce, human
- 43:23attention institutions. And once we have Satoshi's, we
- 43:26can now associate information. Satoshi's together, that's a
- 43:28brand new human construct, a brand new fundamental construct.
- 43:32And with that we can build much better indexing, you know,
- 43:36systems. And it's not coincidental, just,
- 43:39you know, as Bitcoin came about, as the financial system was in
- 43:41ruins and collapsing, I think that this ability to associate
- 43:45information with scarce value is coming about just as LL M's are
- 43:49about to increase the amount of like information out there by
- 43:51orders and orders and orders of magnets.
- 43:53I don't think that's coincidental.
- 43:54And so that's like one of the big ideas that I'm spending a
- 43:57lot. I have been spending a lot of
- 43:59time investing in different companies, taking different
- 44:01approaches to that. Yeah, that is so interesting
- 44:06because the big theme here that you're hitting on is that the
- 44:13micro transaction currency that has been possible to have on the
- 44:17Internet is attention. And that's And then your ad
- 44:22payouts happen. You know when you 1000 people
- 44:24have seen something for you know, scrolling past the page
- 44:28for a fraction of a second and that's what has been possible.
- 44:33But one for one it's not the best system.
- 44:39And then two machines don't give a shit about you know what ad is
- 44:44on a page. They they want the value and and
- 44:47I think. I mean I guess we'll get into
- 44:49that a little bit more with a I stuff here.
- 44:51But you know that mega trend is just right there under the
- 44:55surface of like if the Internet as we know it is based on on add
- 45:02on eyeballs and attentions and attention you know from
- 45:07eyeballs. But that's not how it's going to
- 45:10be when when machines are trying to find valuable information in
- 45:14Exchange. You know what they need with
- 45:18other machines or or resources in the physical world, and now
- 45:23there's an Internet Internet native currency that can travel
- 45:27at the speed of light and can be fractionalized, you know, to to
- 45:322.1 quadrillion sats and probably even beyond there.
- 45:40In order to satisfy every single possible use case of a
- 45:43fractionalized you know machines needs and and when you put it in
- 45:49those terms which I think you've done a great job of like that
- 45:52end state becomes so clear. I think we struggle to see like
- 45:55how is you know how is the Internet going to be different
- 45:58510 years from now. But if you think about that that
- 46:0130 plus year time frame it, it's almost easier to see you know
- 46:06what? End state things move towards,
- 46:09in that sense at least. And ladies and gentlemen, Jesse
- 46:12has been Noster BTC AI pilled in 25 minutes.
- 46:18I mean it's provide is providing a good segue into Noster because
- 46:23the sort of value indexing that you just explained Max is is
- 46:27beginning to materialize on Noster via Zaps and you can find
- 46:32trending topics or notes. That surface because people have
- 46:38sent Sats to that particular post and so that's used as an
- 46:42index to say, hey, there's probably some signal here people
- 46:44are parting ways with Bitcoin to give a give a nod of approval or
- 46:52acceptance to a particular post. And so with that jumping off
- 46:55point, we brought up Nasr a lot. But the help.
- 46:59The audience, who may be a bit ignorant to what Gnoster is and
- 47:01what it's trying to achieve, what is it?
- 47:04How does it work and how does Bitcoin fit into it?
- 47:08Yeah, so I think Gnoster is very simple, and because it's so
- 47:14simple, that's why I'm so excited about it.
- 47:17So it's nodes and other stuff transmitted by Relay, which of
- 47:20course created by, you know, a shadowy super coder like Satoshi
- 47:24that's someone of a pseudonym via job.
- 47:26And I think that's a great sign, right?
- 47:28It wasn't like some corporations like that and it was a little
- 47:31bit even tongue in cheek with the name, which I like.
- 47:33But the the concept behind it is really simple, which is that our
- 47:36current Internet works on a client server model.
- 47:39And what that means is I have my client i.e., I have like
- 47:42whatever the Twitter app on my phone or Instagram or whatever
- 47:44it is, and I send a message, I'm sending that message from my
- 47:49client, my phone to their server.
- 47:51And that's a server controlled by a company, Facebook or
- 47:54whoever. Then another client, another
- 47:58your friend that wants to see your post, makes a call.
- 48:01Their phone does to the Facebook server saying give me this
- 48:04message right now in the early days of Twitter background,
- 48:09whatever it was 2011, 2012, 2013, a lot of people may
- 48:12remember the Twitter API was open.
- 48:15And because it was open, you had all these really cool
- 48:17experiences that were built on top of it.
- 48:18Developers could basically take all that data, all that rich
- 48:21data from Twitter that had a huge social graph and all kinds
- 48:24of people using it, and then they could build their own
- 48:26experiences, things like Tweetdeck or whatever it is.
- 48:29Then around that time, I know that basically they realized,
- 48:35well, shit, the only business model that we see right now, or
- 48:37at least the ones that a lot of people in the company were
- 48:40pushing for it was attention right?
- 48:42Ads. And if the eyeballs to your
- 48:44point, Jesse, that was the currency's eyeballs.
- 48:46If the eyeballs are going to tweet back instead of Twitter,
- 48:48well now all of a sudden we don't have a business model,
- 48:50right? And so they basically closed
- 48:53down the API and the third party development basically stopped or
- 48:59they didn't totally close all the API, but it was no longer
- 49:02open. And permissions.
- 49:03And you know, obviously Jack's spoken a lot about this and you
- 49:06know, he and others there seemed to have been pushing a lot more
- 49:09for it as a protocol. But it was a business and you
- 49:11know, that's just the the nature of the incentives and where it
- 49:13was at that time. What Noster then proposes is, is
- 49:17there a way that we can basically rebuild every
- 49:19application on the web so that the data is always
- 49:22permissionlessly available to build whatever experience you
- 49:25want on top of that? Oh by the way, can we have a
- 49:27shared identity and social graph between all those different
- 49:30apps? Now one approach to doing
- 49:32something like this would be to build a completely either a
- 49:35completely peer-to-peer system or a system where you kind of
- 49:39like Bitcoin, everyone has a shared global state and this is
- 49:42where all the web 3 crypto token projects tried to do.
- 49:47The problem is that's extremely expensive for everyone to agree
- 49:49on a shared global state, you know, that's why you have all
- 49:53this hash rate with mining, adding a new block every 10
- 49:56minutes and still you don't know if it's really quote UN quote
- 49:58the truth of the world until many minutes later.
- 50:01And we can go on a whole rabbit hole of just.
- 50:03By the way, there is no such thing as global state or truth
- 50:04anyway. So that's that's like impossible
- 50:07to achieve. But peer-to-peer or you know
- 50:09something where you have a global state that everyone
- 50:11agrees on, is very difficult to scale and basically hasn't
- 50:14scaled. Projects like Urban have tried
- 50:16to do this also. There's a lot of reasons that's
- 50:19very difficult too. So what Fiat Jaffe realized
- 50:22though is that maybe there's a middle ground.
- 50:24And the middle ground is we can still have effectively a client
- 50:27server model. But instead of having one server
- 50:30controlled by a company, what if we have any arbitrary number of
- 50:33servers basically on marketplace for servers And it really is not
- 50:36exactly a server, but you can think of it like that.
- 50:39So the way Nobster works is it says OK, you know from any of my
- 50:42applications, my identity is a public key, so it actually uses
- 50:46the same ECDSA Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm that
- 50:50Bitcoin uses. So my my my identity in Noster
- 50:52is literally just a Bitcoin public key.
- 50:54It doesn't have any Bitcoin, but it's kind of interesting because
- 50:56that gives you a lot of cool properties and from that I can
- 50:59sign any message with my private key and people can know what the
- 51:02100% certainty until ECDSA gets broken that whoever owns that
- 51:06public key signed that message. But instead of sending that to
- 51:09Twitter server or Facebook server, I send it to 15
- 51:12different servers and maybe some of those are in the US and some
- 51:15are in Singapore and some are in El Salvador and some are in
- 51:18Nigeria. And it's pretty distributed.
- 51:21And so because of that you have all these different messages you
- 51:24can think of it use like have this giant global data pool.
- 51:27And with this giant global data pool anyone can then go and
- 51:30access those messages and build whatever experience they want on
- 51:33top of it. And there's just like this
- 51:35allows for so, so many things. Like I I don't think, I don't
- 51:39think anyone realizes how big of a deal in Austria is yet.
- 51:42In fact, I think it's what's going to bring Bitcoin
- 51:44mainstream. But what people have been
- 51:46focused on today is primarily social media.
- 51:49And so today you've got, you know, these various clients like
- 51:52Domus, Primal, Amethyst, all these different clients that
- 51:56basically take all that data that's published, all these
- 51:59different relays and then surface that as essentially a
- 52:03Twitter like experience. Now there's two key differences
- 52:06between the Twitter experience that you had on the centralized
- 52:09app and in Nostra. One of those key experiences is
- 52:13that you can port your identity and social graph with you.
- 52:16So as an example, I created my private key that I currently use
- 52:20on Nostra in Doms. I then exported that, put it in
- 52:24my LB wallet extension. I was able to go and log on with
- 52:26Primal online or now on my phone with the same identity, I have
- 52:30the exact same followers and followers.
- 52:32That's very, very powerful, right?
- 52:34That's the first, like, mind blown, aha moment.
- 52:37The second thing that we've seen is, and this didn't have to
- 52:41happen, but because all the Noster developers were lightning
- 52:43developers, we've seen what are called Zaps.
- 52:45And this is like what I was talking about, Stacker news.
- 52:47The same concept where you upload a piece of content.
- 52:49Zaps are natively integrated into most of these apps as well.
- 52:53And So what that means is all of a sudden now, you know, unlike
- 52:57with Twitter, where all I can do is pay with attention or hearts,
- 53:00now I can actually pay with value.
- 53:02And so there's so many other things this is going to open and
- 53:05we can talk more about this. But like, the Google indexing
- 53:06idea is going to work much, much, much better than I had
- 53:09even originally imagined in an old web world.
- 53:12I thought in the old web world that you would need to build a
- 53:14new form like Reddit, which is, you know, stagger news.
- 53:17Or you would use something like Albion, drop Satoshi's on the
- 53:20old web and create what I call the Satoshi depth layer.
- 53:23But in this new Nostra world, because zaps are natively
- 53:26integrated, you have not only the value graph, which is who's
- 53:30at 2:00, but you have a social graph and a persistent social
- 53:32graph. So, you know, oh, this person.
- 53:34Like for example, if a random account spins up and zaps, you
- 53:39know, a study saying smoking is good for you, well, maybe that's
- 53:41like Marlboro or something. You shouldn't give him a whole
- 53:42lot of trust. But if Jack Dorsey zaps
- 53:44something, OK, that's interesting.
- 53:46Even if he's apps a lot less because he's reputation.
- 53:48So there's a lot more you can do with that.
- 53:50But this is all just kind of phase one in social media.
- 53:54The next phase is where things get really crazy.
- 53:56I don't think this is what people have realized fully yet.
- 53:59Any application that you can imagine on your phone or on the
- 54:02web is strictly better as an Oscar app, full stop.
- 54:07And the reason is because if you can take that identity and graph
- 54:10with you to that app, you can now not only reduce friction
- 54:14like sign in, but you can have brand new product experiences
- 54:17that were not possible before. So first it was social media,
- 54:22but then you're starting to see music apps.
- 54:24Wave Lake is integrated. Gnoster, it's an app where you
- 54:26can listen to music. Stemster is doing really cool
- 54:28stuff where you can build like tracks from the ground up like
- 54:31you can lay down a beat, someone can wrap on top of it, remix it
- 54:35all happening over Gnoster. You're going to then see you
- 54:39know good reads could get rebuild there, LinkedIn,
- 54:42whatever you want. And the crazy thing is then
- 54:44imagine you could build a new experience where you say, you
- 54:47know, it could be a hiring app or a dating app or just
- 54:50whatever, a friend app, whatever you say, recommend to me the 10
- 54:53people I should meet based on what they listen to on Spotify,
- 54:56who follows them on Twitter and what books they've reviewed.
- 55:01Pretty interesting. And you can't do that in the old
- 55:02web. So those are some of the kinds
- 55:04of new product experiences that I'm waiting for.
- 55:06And the last thing I just went throughout and I'm going on a
- 55:08bit of a monologue. But I think this is like very
- 55:09important is marketplaces. And I think people are going to
- 55:13be blown away with how big of a deal marketplaces are on Oscar.
- 55:16Because if you think about what is a marketplace, all it is is
- 55:19it's text, it's a bid and an ask.
- 55:21That's when. And so if I can publish my bid
- 55:25and my ask to multiple relays, all of a sudden what's going to
- 55:28happen there? I think is you're going to get a
- 55:30shared back in a shared order book or shared liquidity pool.
- 55:33And so if you for example, imagine local bitcoins, there
- 55:36are companies that are playing with this idea.
- 55:38You do everything you know instead of 1 company that's oh
- 55:41by the way, easy to shut down. You can send your bid and ask to
- 55:46buy and sell Bitcoin to 15 or 20 different servers in 15 or 20
- 55:50different countries and lots of front ends can pop up to be, you
- 55:56know the easy way people interact with that all of a
- 55:58sudden that shared protocol level marketplace is going to
- 56:01destroy any company. Like imagine if all of a sudden
- 56:04finance, Kraken and everyone else shares the same order book
- 56:08but Coinbase doesn't. Coinbase is going to get
- 56:09trounced and that I think that's the world we ran it for, for all
- 56:12marketplace. Like when you describe it that
- 56:16way, it's going to force like company's hands to actually
- 56:20participate in the network. And I and I think you really
- 56:24highlighted the benefits on the user side, but likewise on the
- 56:28company side, it's crazy because if you can actually build a good
- 56:31client, a good front end, produce a good service for
- 56:34Nostra users, you can bootstrap a user base much quicker than
- 56:39any of the incumbent tech firms out there.
- 56:42The amount of time it took Twitter, Instagram, Facebook.
- 56:45The bootstrap a user base is significantly diminished on
- 56:49Oscar if you're providing a good service.
- 56:54Yeah, it's network, it's network effects, the protocol instead of
- 56:56the app which 100% like. Imagine if you build some super
- 57:01weird niche music app like or even like.
- 57:04I remember like the feature Doms put in for like left-handed
- 57:06users. Twitter's never going to put a
- 57:07left-handed feature on there because there's not that many
- 57:09left-handed users. People don't care about it, but
- 57:11like the people that are left-handed love it.
- 57:13So now if I wanted to do just I could even do my own super weird
- 57:16left-handed music app. And maybe there's only 1000
- 57:19people in the world that like it, but you know all the people
- 57:22that already have access to the old Twitter apps or the old
- 57:25sorry Nostra apps for Twitter. And then the Nostra Marketplace
- 57:28is whatever all of those users, I inherit all of them
- 57:30potentially to log into my new weird app.
- 57:32And if I happen to bring on, you know, 10 new people just for my
- 57:35left-handed weird long tail music app, they can now log into
- 57:39any of the other Gnoster apps. Like once you understand the
- 57:42Super network effects that are spinning here, I think this is
- 57:44the new web. Like, I think the old web is
- 57:47like, I think Gnoster eats the web.
- 57:49Max, can you pull on more of you said a very bold statement.
- 57:52It sounds correct, but just like help us understand me understand
- 57:55like it basically creates a better app than anything else if
- 57:59it's interoperable. Well, like how did that in
- 58:02practice? Like, would it play out?
- 58:04Or I guess in theory, how would it play out?
- 58:09Well, first of all, there's just less friction, right?
- 58:11So imagine you don't have to create a special account to log
- 58:14into Spotify, or you don't have to log into Facebook, cuz you
- 58:17haven't used Facebook in 25 years or whatever it is.
- 58:20And so just the login experience, you have one
- 58:23universal login for everything and you control it.
- 58:25It's not dependent on a centralized company which may go
- 58:29under or get bought and change hands and like whatever.
- 58:32So that's the first just like super obvious way and then you
- 58:35can start to build really cool kind of weird experiences on top
- 58:38of it, right? So again, the example I give of
- 58:40like, imagine if you're trying to hire someone or you had a
- 58:45dating app or something, you said I want a recommendation.
- 58:47But based across these ten different apps, music, books,
- 58:51work experience follows. That's an experience that cannot
- 58:54be built in today's world. And so and then not to mention
- 58:58you have the payments baked in, how crazy is it going to be when
- 59:01you start to see some of these, like, you know, influencer types
- 59:05or whatever, start realizing, wait, I can like post my music
- 59:07here and just get paid directly and I can make way more than I
- 59:10can make on YouTube. Like, this is a value for value
- 59:12for podcasting idea on steroids. So there's just like, I think if
- 59:16I had to like, sum it up in one idea, permissionless development
- 59:22allows for like all kinds of like, it's a Cambrian explosion
- 59:29of creativity. We don't even know what the big
- 59:31apps are going to be. And that's what excites me as a
- 59:32venture capitalist is we've no idea.
- 59:34I mean the ones I'm coming up with are cool, but like I'm sure
- 59:36there's people like Pablo are going to come up with things
- 59:38that are 100 X cooler than I could ever imagine.
- 59:41And so the point is now you've unleashed the global creativity
- 59:45of anyone that can code. And by the way, it's, you know,
- 59:47the the Noster protocol. I think it's like a JSON BLOB
- 59:51with 7 fields. It's like super basic.
- 59:53So almost anyone, if they know JavaScript, they can get on
- 59:57there and start playing around and experimenting.
- 59:58As you lower the barrier to experimenting, the like number
- 1:00:01of weird experiments that can get run is just going to be
- 1:00:04wild. Yeah, I think music will end up
- 1:00:07and I know you're on. There's like music will be the
- 1:00:09Canary in one of the Canaries in the coal mine because it's been
- 1:00:11so messed up for so long. And I remember Marty and I were
- 1:00:15chatting with Michael in the Wavelake team and it's just like
- 1:00:17inherently you knew there was something a better way.
- 1:00:19You just didn't know what. And it was basically getting out
- 1:00:22of the getting rid of the middleman was a part of that.
- 1:00:25And it feels like there's there's definitely like one of
- 1:00:27the first use cases would be here.
- 1:00:29Yeah, and for listeners too, like so Wavelake there.
- 1:00:34Essentially a music player with Lightning Network baked into it
- 1:00:39do pure value for value. As Max mentioned, they're hooked
- 1:00:41in a Noster as well. So like to play you through the
- 1:00:45user experience on the artist side, like historically, as
- 1:00:49Michael mentioned, they've gotten the shit end of the stick
- 1:00:51when it comes to dealing with their labels and their
- 1:00:53distributors of their music and then the streaming platforms
- 1:00:57like Spotify. Now what we're seeing is this
- 1:00:59robust environment. Now a noster, different clients,
- 1:01:03music clients popping up and all an artist has to do is put their
- 1:01:09Lightning Network address in and they can get paid directly by
- 1:01:13their listeners as they're listening to the music.
- 1:01:15They can put a pay wall and say, hey, if you want to listen to
- 1:01:17this song, pay a cent worth of Bitcoin, then it gets really
- 1:01:20interesting too. Like all these artists, they
- 1:01:22have bands, they have producers. The managers like you can
- 1:01:26literally get granular. So granular that you can put not
- 1:01:30only your lightning address and as an artist, but your band
- 1:01:32mates, your producer, your manager on a person on basis and
- 1:01:37automatically distribute revenues to them as they're
- 1:01:42coming in. Which is pretty pretty insane to
- 1:01:44think. And the Max, I think we could
- 1:01:46tie Lightning Network, Gnoster and.
- 1:01:51AI into one theme here, building on something that Pablo built,
- 1:01:55who you mentioned earlier, which is data vending machines.
- 1:01:58And this is, in my mind, one of the most exciting things going
- 1:02:01on in Bitcoin, AI and Noster, and the intersection of the
- 1:02:05three is this idea of data vending machines, the ability to
- 1:02:09essentially tap into a market of AI agents that'll do tasks for
- 1:02:14you Well before jumping in there.
- 1:02:17I think the music thing where there's like good examples is
- 1:02:20we're the music industry from like an actual utility.
- 1:02:24You have like, and I'll mess up in some of this, but it's just
- 1:02:26like you had the not a track. What's the spinning?
- 1:02:33Yeah, yeah, you had a vinyl and then you went to like whatever,
- 1:02:36a track, cassette, CD. And then when it went into
- 1:02:39digital form, like, how do we consume music?
- 1:02:43You have like these different formats, whether it's like
- 1:02:45touring or you just go and buy it directly via Apple, or you
- 1:02:49just pay for Spotify. And so it's starting to take
- 1:02:52these different forms of the Internet and it's still broken.
- 1:02:55Like it's still the. I mean, I think musicians
- 1:02:58probably have to get the Waveleg guys on because they'd be able
- 1:03:00to explain this better than us. But it's just like it's been
- 1:03:02fucked for for a long time, not just, you know, 20 years.
- 1:03:06It's been even before that when it comes to the labels and the
- 1:03:08ownership and the distribution and who owns the rights.
- 1:03:10And so it's still like that, but now you start moving that
- 1:03:13further and further the edges of like the value to it.
- 1:03:16So I think we can you start just it sounds so crazy when we talk
- 1:03:18about it because it seems so far off, but but in the past 10 to
- 1:03:2120 years that whole industry has completely changed.
- 1:03:24Totally. And yeah, before we dive in the
- 1:03:26eyes, I just want to comment on the music stuff as well, because
- 1:03:28I think this is, this is really important to me on many fronts.
- 1:03:311 Some of you guys may know I I make my own music as well.
- 1:03:34I rap. And so one of the big challenges
- 1:03:37that musicians want is not just getting paid.
- 1:03:40Like my buddy and I, we put out, we release under a couple of her
- 1:03:44names and one is AI, interestingly enough.
- 1:03:46And you know we put it out there and somehow we started getting a
- 1:03:51lot of people listening in France.
- 1:03:52I'm gonna say a lot of like 10s of people.
- 1:03:53Like we have a huge following everything, but we have no way
- 1:03:57of contacting these people. We have no idea who they are,
- 1:03:59how they found us. They listen to us every month,
- 1:04:02which is super cool. But Spotify is not sharing that
- 1:04:04information with us, right? So in this world, it's not just
- 1:04:07the payments. But it's also by having a
- 1:04:10platform where we can have that relationship with our audience
- 1:04:12and be able to message them that would be like extremely valuable
- 1:04:14to us and for every musician out there.
- 1:04:16So I think there's a lot of ways this is going to suddenly
- 1:04:18change. I also think the music industry
- 1:04:21is right for some pretty major business model disruptions.
- 1:04:24I was talking this weekend with my buddy who is a music fan
- 1:04:27obviously, but also like a more traditional hedge fund guys.
- 1:04:31I would not say he's as open on some of these crazy ideas like
- 1:04:33Gnoster, but you know, I forget the exact numbers, but something
- 1:04:36like. You know, movies are obviously
- 1:04:38worth some multiple of the total music market right now, and
- 1:04:42esports and gaming is maybe like an order magnitude more.
- 1:04:44It was a lot more. But his general point, I was
- 1:04:46like, look like music is still very important to lots of
- 1:04:48people. For me, it's certainly the most
- 1:04:50important medium. A lot of people have strong
- 1:04:52emotional connection to it. The old business model just got
- 1:04:54rocked by Napster and the Spotify model kind of worked.
- 1:04:57But these guys still aren't profitable.
- 1:04:59So, like, no one's really figured out a sustainable way
- 1:05:01for artists to thrive yet, and yet they're producing this thing
- 1:05:04for society, which I think many people would argue music is one
- 1:05:06of the. Those fundamental, I don't know,
- 1:05:08like pieces of humanity. And we would love to see a long
- 1:05:11tale of really good artists continue to thrive.
- 1:05:14And so I think we're gonna see with Noster because again, it's
- 1:05:17open, you're gonna see all kinds of new experiments around
- 1:05:20business models. So one of them is the ZAP splits
- 1:05:22for sure. But also, Waverly recently
- 1:05:25launched this demo with Adam Curry's new podcast where he is
- 1:05:29the DJ. I mean, obviously he was the
- 1:05:31original VJ for MTV as well, which is kind of cool, coming
- 1:05:34first full circle where he's quote UN quote licensing these
- 1:05:38songs. And so anyone that zaps the
- 1:05:40songs while he's playing them, you know, he takes a cut for
- 1:05:43being the curator. And then obviously then you
- 1:05:46could have Zaps all the way back down for whoever worked on that,
- 1:05:48on that track. And I think it's also going to
- 1:05:50create this, like really interesting business model
- 1:05:52around being a curator. I think part of my big thing
- 1:05:55around this disrupting Google. Is human curation.
- 1:05:58Finding the quote UN quote weights of what a model should
- 1:06:01be is something that I think humans are going to be sort of
- 1:06:03the best at still for a very long time.
- 1:06:05And I think that allowing you know people to curate books and
- 1:06:10music and all this stuff, it's going to create a big sort of
- 1:06:13new job opportunity there. I think we're just scratching
- 1:06:16the surface of that. So I'm I'm pretty bullish.
- 1:06:18Oh, and by the way, with Stemster, you know, wave like is
- 1:06:20dope because it's just like taking music and you know.
- 1:06:22Opening up new business model Stemster.
- 1:06:24They're doing even crazier stuff because they're actually using.
- 1:06:28People are building tracks on Stemster, right?
- 1:06:30So I share a file and it's just a beat and I share it openly.
- 1:06:33But then that beat and the way it's released, I forget it's MIT
- 1:06:36license or some kind of open copyright.
- 1:06:39Anyone can use it, remix it, and soon they'll add in zaps.
- 1:06:43So you add in a beat, 10 different people wrapped on it.
- 1:06:45You now have a marketplace for which of those tractions are
- 1:06:48blowing up the most, and you get paid for all of them, right?
- 1:06:50Like these are brand new concepts that just did not exist
- 1:06:53before and it's as well, this is such an exciting conversation
- 1:06:58because like I think about one of the big things in in venture
- 1:07:00and in Bitcoin is like the thing that most it gets lost on people
- 1:07:03is user experience. And what is gonna change
- 1:07:06somebody's user experience or not user experience but user
- 1:07:09behavior in what they do and you reference like humans and
- 1:07:14curation. And it was like when Marty, when
- 1:07:17I got really excited wave like because I remember during COVID,
- 1:07:19it's like the one thing that people will depart their money
- 1:07:22for when you go to like a restaurant or they did it on
- 1:07:24YouTube is you put your cash app and you would send them dollars
- 1:07:27via it because there's some like deep meaning there.
- 1:07:29And so it's like of course they pay for this at any form because
- 1:07:32they're just tied to it and it doesn't matter if they have to
- 1:07:34like download a crazy application they will do it to
- 1:07:36get the value to them. And then something else that
- 1:07:40I've never heard, but you mentioned about like humans and
- 1:07:42curation and it's like always gonna be there no matter what AI
- 1:07:46or programmatic. And it's like a business is the
- 1:07:47highest form and that just hit me in curation like you're
- 1:07:51curating these individuals and you're going out to the market
- 1:07:55to produce value. And so that's like the micro or
- 1:07:57like a subset of that. Totally.
- 1:08:00And by the way, there's something I think a lot about as
- 1:08:02an investor as well. There's a lot of factors you
- 1:08:05want to look for in a good entrepreneur and the biggest
- 1:08:07thing is just timing the way of right which that that's tricky
- 1:08:10to do. But you know part of what I ask
- 1:08:12is this person super smart? Are they in the right place at
- 1:08:14the right time or I think that it's close enough to the right
- 1:08:16time they can last, you know for for the way to hit.
- 1:08:19But then in my opinion the truly great companies right like the
- 1:08:23ones that last for decades, Apple being the greatest example
- 1:08:26of this ever and it comes down to taste.
- 1:08:30It's always taste you want. Like the the best investments
- 1:08:33are people with the best taste. Full stop, yeah, and pause.
- 1:08:43Well, that's, well, that's. The other thing too, now
- 1:08:45thinking about this as well like particularly with Gnoster, like
- 1:08:50what is this gonna do in terms of like unlocking people with
- 1:08:54good taste that maybe weren't able to surface their taste in
- 1:08:59in the incumbent system. Like.
- 1:09:01In terms of like human capital being unlocked via this network
- 1:09:04topography, like it's it's gonna be insane.
- 1:09:07You're gonna have anons on Noster that are just
- 1:09:10tastemakers, and maybe they weren't comfortable doing that
- 1:09:13in the incumbent system because they have to tie their identity
- 1:09:16to it to some form or another A. 100% and and you know and a lot
- 1:09:21and like yeah it's gonna unleash you.
- 1:09:23People from all over the world can do this and like a lot of
- 1:09:25like you know taste that. That's how it's happened around
- 1:09:27the Internet like. A lot of you know, modern taste
- 1:09:30came from weird you know, corners of Tumblr, probably 4
- 1:09:33Chan at first, or weird tumble, you know corners of Reddit.
- 1:09:36And then they went mainstream and like yeah, this is gonna
- 1:09:38accelerate all of that. And by the way, someone else I
- 1:09:40saw like an investor about had some pretty good ideas.
- 1:09:43You know, one of his big ideas is that the meme economy still
- 1:09:45has not been well monetized, like people that are able to
- 1:09:49make good memes. There's a huge opportunity
- 1:09:50around that. I'm not sure what it is yet, but
- 1:09:51if you're an entrepreneur working on that and you think
- 1:09:54you have a way to help the great meme monitor makers monetize,
- 1:09:57I'm very interested. That's why Fiat's such as
- 1:09:59travesty, because everybody always thinks it's like this
- 1:10:01dogmatic or whatever. It's like, it's the old Peter
- 1:10:04Teal quote of like we were promised flying cars and we got
- 1:10:07the 240 characters. It's like you have these 80,000
- 1:10:09or now it's probably 180,000 employees at Google.
- 1:10:12They could be doing taste making.
- 1:10:14They could be doing like what they really want to be doing,
- 1:10:16but it's just like the golden handcuffs and all the other
- 1:10:18things that you know are from that.
- 1:10:21So yeah, we're just like, we're just on the the edges of seeing
- 1:10:25what that all will look like. Totally.
- 1:10:29Yeah. And that I mean, I guess we can
- 1:10:34talk about a I now too like because that's great.
- 1:10:38Like we're talking about human experiences here.
- 1:10:40And this is when Cody Cody Lowe first explained what was going
- 1:10:44on with a I and L 402. So Lightning 402 specification
- 1:10:50that Lightning Labs dropped years ago.
- 1:10:54Formerly LSAT, but the the wall. Industry came after them for
- 1:11:00running with that, so it got rebranded L402.
- 1:11:03What we're talking about is just like humans interacting and
- 1:11:07sending Bitcoin to each other over these networks.
- 1:11:10But once you begin to grok what's going on at the
- 1:11:15intersection of the Lightning Network, in AI particularly,
- 1:11:18that's where things get really heavy, because especially for
- 1:11:21the audience listening to this one of the.
- 1:11:24Concepts in their mind is total addressable market.
- 1:11:27Like the total addressable market is moving beyond humanity
- 1:11:30and into this machine world with AI which is literally
- 1:11:35unfathomable. We don't know the end state of
- 1:11:38the impact that AI will have and how much activity will be going
- 1:11:41on in aggregate A decade from now, two decades from now,
- 1:11:45century from now. But it's become pretty clear to
- 1:11:48me and I'm pretty sure the others sitting here.
- 1:11:51On this show right now that the AI, like you said earlier, is
- 1:11:54not going to have a bank account with JP Morgan.
- 1:11:57They're gonna want the native currency of the Internet.
- 1:12:00And so, yeah, Max, like how are you viewing this intersection
- 1:12:05and the potential opportunity that lays before everybody?
- 1:12:09Well, I mean, look, there's so much to say here and so I'll
- 1:12:12give maybe a little overview, but happy to go into any of the
- 1:12:14areas you want. I put out a piece on my blog.
- 1:12:17Or an essay hivemind dot BC/AI where I kind of go into
- 1:12:21everything in more detail, high level.
- 1:12:23I think again we're at a turning point.
- 1:12:24I think we're at a turning point in many different areas AI And
- 1:12:30when we say I, there's a lot of different, you know, things that
- 1:12:33can mean large language models are getting most of the
- 1:12:36attention today. And you can think of that as
- 1:12:37just like a way to compress all of the world's information and
- 1:12:41like, get information out of it faster than you can, for
- 1:12:44example, with the Google search. And then obviously do in a way
- 1:12:47that's chainable with other a eyes and but you know, again
- 1:12:49it's like in some ways I think it's both under height and
- 1:12:52overhyped. Overhyped.
- 1:12:53And then I think this has very little to do with like
- 1:12:55consciousness or like you know, whatever like super
- 1:12:57intelligence. I'm very skeptical of a lot of
- 1:12:59those things. I keep an open mind, but I do
- 1:13:01think it's a very powerful tool. And it's a powerful tool that
- 1:13:04can, for the right users, amplify their own intelligence
- 1:13:07by orders of magnitude. So for you know, really good
- 1:13:10software engineers are already becoming 10X or 100X engineers
- 1:13:13for that and it'll probably be thousand X engineers.
- 1:13:15Same is going to be true for whatever it is you're good at.
- 1:13:17Like you're going to have a personal assistant that can
- 1:13:20amplify your own intelligence and abilities quite a lot.
- 1:13:22But I I personally am just, I don't really buy into all of
- 1:13:25this like AGI stuff very much, although I'm happy to talk more
- 1:13:28about that if you guys want. But the term, sorry.
- 1:13:32I was just like, oh, that's interesting that I would, I
- 1:13:35would have thought that you would subscribe to that AGI, you
- 1:13:40know, super intelligence, Nick Bostrom, School of thought.
- 1:13:44But no. Interesting.
- 1:13:45No, I mean, I I read all of that back in the day.
- 1:13:48Like I read Super Intelligence back in 2014.
- 1:13:50I remember at the time I was terrified.
- 1:13:51That messed me up at the time. Yeah, I know exactly.
- 1:13:54Literally, I couldn't sleep for a week and and like, I have a
- 1:13:57bit of a weird, you know? Taking all this and that, I, you
- 1:14:00know, in 2018 I was kind of deciding do I go all in on AI or
- 1:14:04Bitcoin at the time. And now it's kind of coming back
- 1:14:05around. But a lot of my roommates, you
- 1:14:07know, I'm here in San Francisco, they were all, you know, at open
- 1:14:10line your news at Google or Define.
- 1:14:12And so I've kind of had like a, you know, observer seat just
- 1:14:16listening to them. And you know, look to be clear,
- 1:14:18all these people are way smarter than I am.
- 1:14:19So like I take this with a giant grain of salt.
- 1:14:21I'm just kind of going my own intuition, but I think that.
- 1:14:25Well, I think first of all one of the the people that I really
- 1:14:27respect the most, like there's few, there's a few thinkers that
- 1:14:29are really shaking. Buckminster Fuller is 1, Kevin
- 1:14:32Kelly is another. I think Kevin Kelly is just like
- 1:14:34generally almost always right, or at least on those topics.
- 1:14:37I've seen him and he is this basically he's a lot of
- 1:14:40interesting concepts. But one of them is that, you
- 1:14:42know, if I had to summarize, he's like more, you know, he's
- 1:14:46not utopian. He calls it Protopia, which is
- 1:14:47that we can make progress without being perfect, like
- 1:14:49whenever we have a big new technological breakthrough.
- 1:14:52It it opens up lots of new possibilities and it also opens
- 1:14:55up lots of new bad things too of course it's it's just like the
- 1:14:58Internet allows for all kinds of incredible collaboration and it
- 1:15:01allows for really fucked up things too and like that's just
- 1:15:03that's technology it's a tool But his general kind of like
- 1:15:06just which I don't know why I just like intuitively agree with
- 1:15:08is that over the long arc it's you know a tiny percentage when
- 1:15:12even if it's only 1% quote UN quote good and and I think one
- 1:15:15way you can define good is by if you think about like.
- 1:15:19If you think about the universe as like an evolutionary force,
- 1:15:21and I think humanity is kind of just an arbitrary piece of all
- 1:15:24of this, but like if you think that there was a force that
- 1:15:27existed or some point of energy that then expanded into all that
- 1:15:31is now. What it appears from my vantage
- 1:15:36point that the universe, quote UN quote, wants is novelty.
- 1:15:40And more options, right? Like if you're a single point of
- 1:15:43infinitely intense energy or something that's like kind of
- 1:15:45boring. But the more you expand out and
- 1:15:47the more possibilities are open, the more different kinds of ways
- 1:15:50you can be yourself interacting with yourself or the more kinds
- 1:15:54of movies you can watch. And I think that's kind of
- 1:15:56what's happening. I think what he calls the
- 1:15:57technium, which is the technological force.
- 1:15:59I would just call it the. The life force behind
- 1:16:03everything, of which both humanity and technology are both
- 1:16:06parts. It's pointing in a direction of
- 1:16:09more options, more choices, more possibilities, which I think on
- 1:16:13a compounding long time scale is generally good.
- 1:16:16Now, one of the points he makes with AI, which I think is really
- 1:16:18important that I agree with, is that.
- 1:16:20You know, a lot of the AGI folks, first of all, they're
- 1:16:23they have this concept that there's one thing that is
- 1:16:25intelligence and that humans are, quote UN quote, generally
- 1:16:28intelligent. And I just completely disagree
- 1:16:30with that. There's no such thing as general
- 1:16:31intelligence, and humans are not the top of the food chain
- 1:16:34either. Like, if you think about it,
- 1:16:36first of all, what does it mean to be generally intelligent,
- 1:16:38right? Evolutionarily speaking,
- 1:16:41everything that's alive and here today and thriving.
- 1:16:43Is kind of equal like I saw, instead of having like an
- 1:16:46evolutionary like ladder, a better way of describing
- 1:16:49evolution is like a disk that as it spreads out in time, if it's
- 1:16:53still here, it's just as evolved as we are.
- 1:16:55It's gone down a different pathway.
- 1:16:59So fungi and bacteria and cockroaches and alligators and
- 1:17:02all these things have been around a really long time and we
- 1:17:04all have different kind of types of intelligence.
- 1:17:07And I'm not saying there's not something particularly
- 1:17:09interesting about humans, clearly there is.
- 1:17:11But like. You know, squirrels, to the
- 1:17:14example he used, they have this remarkable ability to remember
- 1:17:18where exactly where they buried thousands of different acorns
- 1:17:22for many, many years. Humans can't do that.
- 1:17:24Is that not intelligence? It's a form of intelligence,
- 1:17:26right. And so I think this is one of
- 1:17:28the big things I just take. You know, major issue with is
- 1:17:31like I know people that are extremely intelligent, you know,
- 1:17:34like on tests, right. Like they, you know one guy
- 1:17:36knows an alternate for the US national math team, incredibly
- 1:17:40intelligent, way more analytically smart than I will
- 1:17:42ever be able to sniff. But I wouldn't say he's
- 1:17:44necessarily socially adapt as much and that's a different kind
- 1:17:47of intelligence, right. So I I just think there's many
- 1:17:49different kinds of intelligences and I I think it's going to go
- 1:17:53much more like evolution where there's going to be ecosystems
- 1:17:56of different intelligences both cooperating and competing.
- 1:18:00And the big heartbeat of life goes on and anyway so that's why
- 1:18:05I'm skeptical of AGI. But yeah I think what's much
- 1:18:09more like so but I do think we're at a turning point.
- 1:18:11One option is we have these centralized top down companies
- 1:18:15that I am kind of afraid of. I'm not afraid of the AGI take
- 1:18:19off. I am afraid of.
- 1:18:21You know, imagine the Chinese government or opening eye or
- 1:18:24someone, even if they have good intentions becoming so powerful
- 1:18:27and deciding, no, actually we know it's best for all the other
- 1:18:30humans and we're going to use this new superpower because it
- 1:18:32is a very powerful tool to you know restrict people from
- 1:18:36experimenting and trying things. And I think that's really
- 1:18:38dangerous and that that's my kind of fear.
- 1:18:41On the other end of the spectrum, you have a world where
- 1:18:43you say look you know the kind of like E ack led a rip camp.
- 1:18:46But I'm not saying I'm all the way there.
- 1:18:47Like, obviously, like they're, I don't know, like.
- 1:18:50Nothing is completely black and white.
- 1:18:51But but I'm generally in the camp of, you know, the human
- 1:18:55mind is marvelous, but it's a subset of evolutionary
- 1:18:57intelligence. And the best way to, like, guard
- 1:18:59against something really bad happening is let evolution run
- 1:19:02its course, let you know competing artificial
- 1:19:05intelligences evolve along with the Super powerful ones you're
- 1:19:08thinking of and blah blah. And that's kind of the the, the
- 1:19:11mode that I'm looking for is a more decentralized community of
- 1:19:14a IS that work in tandem with each other.
- 1:19:18And with humans. And together, we build this
- 1:19:21decentralized hive mind with, call it, 8 billion human minds,
- 1:19:248 trillion artificial minds or more.
- 1:19:27And we're using something like Gnoster as our open protocol for
- 1:19:30communication and something like Bitcoin and lightning as our
- 1:19:34open protocols for commerce. And that's the direction I see
- 1:19:37adding. Yeah, that's a more optimistic.
- 1:19:41I forget exactly how biology frames this.
- 1:19:44But I think he said like this decade or the century is going
- 1:19:48to be you know, a story of of a I and and China centralizing a I
- 1:19:54versus Bitcoin and libertarian values in the West decentralized
- 1:20:00in a decentralized approach. And what you're presenting there
- 1:20:03is really the decentralized version of super intelligence in
- 1:20:07the future and. That's a much more optimistic
- 1:20:09one than the dystopian top down authoritarian you know Chinese
- 1:20:15dream that that you know they will be heading towards and
- 1:20:21hopefully you know the free market capitalist nature of a
- 1:20:26decentralized version can beat out that top down authoritarian
- 1:20:31style. Because if it doesn't then it
- 1:20:33then it is the dystopian dark future.
- 1:20:36But you know, I think that the history of of how communism lost
- 1:20:42to free markets might play out again over this century too.
- 1:20:48I took a very left barbell approach to this one morning.
- 1:20:52I was like thinking about all this and freaking out cuz I
- 1:20:53think Marty attacks me. He's like, I just went down this
- 1:20:55deep dark rabbit hole on on AGI and it was like, well, if if
- 1:21:01Bitcoin fixes this, if Bitcoin's money, somebody has to plug in
- 1:21:03the computers. Like they need fuel so and you
- 1:21:08that's how you keep everyone honest in that world where you
- 1:21:11have infinite number of money as like in in the proxy for today's
- 1:21:15world is like the military industrial complex where you
- 1:21:17print these dollars and you take them from other individuals and
- 1:21:19that's how you power you know this like you know dictator
- 1:21:24slash kind of like overarching form of government versus in
- 1:21:30this world that we're talking about like if you need to power.
- 1:21:35Whatever there's nefarious or positive, like you need a form
- 1:21:38of money that cannot be printed and they need to consume it to
- 1:21:41be able to function to do whatever's needed.
- 1:21:43That is like the the balancing act in that whole world.
- 1:21:47And if you don't have that, then we're basically not in a good
- 1:21:49spot. But if you have this unit that
- 1:21:50is it's equally or is equally as possible distributed that you
- 1:21:54can't print more of it, that starts to weigh the checks and
- 1:21:57balance on like what? How you can impose that.
- 1:22:01Yeah, and. Kind of goes back to what I was
- 1:22:03saying in the very beginning which for me Bitcoin like forget
- 1:22:06crypto. Forget what everything we think
- 1:22:08we know about money. Like if Bitcoin is just a Ledger
- 1:22:10of energy, it's an energy backed money and energy is the currency
- 1:22:14of the universe. And you know we just look at
- 1:22:16evolution and how it's played out like again, the hole on
- 1:22:18thing, holes become parts of a new hole, which become parts of
- 1:22:24a new hole. We're just getting, we're laying
- 1:22:25the the neural, you know, whatever, like.
- 1:22:29Infrastructure for that next whole and my guess is energy is
- 1:22:33still going to be the currency of that because it's the
- 1:22:36currency of everything. And I think I mean this is you
- 1:22:38know Drew gave that excellent talk at the last Picline
- 1:22:41conference. I think he's just he's just like
- 1:22:42crack like this is a new Organism forming with metabolism
- 1:22:47and Bitcoin is going to be the sort of digital representation
- 1:22:50of energy in that metabolism so. That's right.
- 1:22:53I do think it's maybe worth just mentioning sort of like some of
- 1:22:55the really cool stuff that can that can happen.
- 1:22:57Like Marty, you brought up the Dvn's.
- 1:23:00I don't know if you guys wanna dive into that.
- 1:23:02Yeah, no, I think. Just.
- 1:23:05Running off of what we just discussed like and I completely
- 1:23:09since Michael we had that discussion, I've completely
- 1:23:11backed away from the AGI domerism.
- 1:23:14I'm not gonna be a Luddite about AI.
- 1:23:16I think it's here, It's gonna happen, and it's good for
- 1:23:20humanity. But with that being said, like
- 1:23:23the intersection of Bitcoin and AI, there's many ways in which
- 1:23:26it's materializing like going back to the energy, the L402
- 1:23:30payment required, pay walls that you can put in front of these
- 1:23:34API token calls. Like that is actually like a
- 1:23:37step function improvement in how these AI companies can monetize.
- 1:23:42They know that they can ping their GPUs, present their end
- 1:23:47users. With responses and do that
- 1:23:50profitably because they can get the money up front with
- 1:23:52lightning. But then that's just the tip of
- 1:23:54the iceberg. That's just a mechanism to to
- 1:24:01guarantee that there's going to be a payment.
- 1:24:02You're going to be able to pay your electricity bill at the end
- 1:24:04of the day. But once you get into things
- 1:24:06like data vending machines, that's when things get really
- 1:24:09heady, when you can actually like enter a market as an end
- 1:24:13user for competing Ai's that will do tasks for you.
- 1:24:17Totally. And I think it's worth noting,
- 1:24:21there's a couple of big opportunities I see for Bitcoin
- 1:24:24and Ai's. I think the DVM stuff falls kind
- 1:24:28of under the agent sort of area. And I'm, I'm looking very close
- 1:24:31to that. But even taking a step back
- 1:24:33before we dive in that I think maybe one thing that's important
- 1:24:35for listeners to understand is the way that quote UN quote AI
- 1:24:40works is very different than the way that other software has
- 1:24:43worked historically and the last big like let's say enterprise
- 1:24:46software wave. You had you know X amount of
- 1:24:49money invested to create this new software product and then
- 1:24:52you had effectively 0 marginal cost of distribution.
- 1:24:55It's not the way AI works because the way AI works is
- 1:24:59essentially what you're doing is you're taking all of this data
- 1:25:01and you're you know using math. You don't fully understand
- 1:25:05exactly how it all works. But to compress that into what's
- 1:25:08called a model and you're basically using these Gpu's
- 1:25:12graphics processing units to do these matrix multiplications
- 1:25:16that. Take the data and train the
- 1:25:18model. That's, that's what opening eye
- 1:25:21and enthropic. And all these companies, Google
- 1:25:23have spent, you know, billions of dollars training these really
- 1:25:26big and complex models. But then it's not like you just
- 1:25:29have this model and anyone can use it for free, right?
- 1:25:32So there's the training phase of that.
- 1:25:34Then there's there's there's really two more phases. 1 is
- 1:25:36fine tuning it with your own data, which also, you know,
- 1:25:38requires either electricity or humans doing that.
- 1:25:41When you talk more about that, Bitcoin's interesting for both,
- 1:25:43but then you have what's called inference.
- 1:25:44Inference is OK, I actually want to run the model.
- 1:25:47And so if I want to run the model, like every time you ask
- 1:25:49ChatGPT a question for anyone that's used the ChatGPT
- 1:25:52interface. And if you haven't done it yet,
- 1:25:53anyone that's listening to this, I'd definitely recommend you do
- 1:25:56it because it is pretty mindful. It's a very cool technology, but
- 1:25:59every time that's that's happening, Open AI is running a
- 1:26:03GPU on their end, and that answer doesn't already exist.
- 1:26:08They have to run the GPU. That's interesting because every
- 1:26:11time you run the GPU, that's real world computation and
- 1:26:14electricity, which has real world costs, right?
- 1:26:16And so when I do that, you know, I don't know the exact numbers,
- 1:26:19but I've heard on the order of two to $0.10 per inference,
- 1:26:24let's say that's expensive. And so if you have a computer
- 1:26:27with an API that's calling or, they're calling your API rather
- 1:26:30to do a whole bunch of inferences on your GPU.
- 1:26:34The cost of that can run up super fast and it's not 0
- 1:26:37marginal cost distribution. It's like oh shit like I just
- 1:26:40spent $1,000,000 you know using all these GP U's.
- 1:26:44Oh by the way there's a major GPU shortage.
- 1:26:46This is why NVIDIA stock has just gone to the moon over the
- 1:26:48last couple of months for anyone that's that's that's following
- 1:26:51along and this is one of the reasons opening eye you know Sam
- 1:26:54Allman's come out and discuss multiple times that they they
- 1:26:56just they straight up hey don't have enough GP U's to be able to
- 1:27:00do all the inference that people are asking right now.
- 1:27:03Now a second problem which it's unclear to me if this is
- 1:27:06actually a problem for them or not.
- 1:27:08I've seen anecdotal evidence that suggested this, but we'll
- 1:27:10see is in a credit based monetary system.
- 1:27:13There's a trick there, which is if you're doing calls with Visa
- 1:27:18or MasterCard. As Gigi discussed in the article
- 1:27:20we mentioned, with credit based money you can have chargebacks
- 1:27:24and so. If you're some random on the
- 1:27:26Internet, they're not just going to front you a bunch of credit
- 1:27:29to use their GPU. Well, first of all, if you're
- 1:27:30random on the Internet, chances are you're born in a country
- 1:27:32where you don't even have access to a credit card anyway, and so
- 1:27:36you have no way of using the system.
- 1:27:37And even if you do, you know they're going to be like, what
- 1:27:40is this random whatever, Turkish credit card or something.
- 1:27:43And you may or may not get credit.
- 1:27:45I know at least one instance of someone who's got a pretty
- 1:27:49reputable person whose car has been denied over and over.
- 1:27:52I don't know if that's a problem at scale or not, but it it could
- 1:27:54be, and it's currently limiting their total addressable market.
- 1:27:58And part of that is if you were able to, instead of doing a
- 1:28:01credit based monetary system where you could charge up
- 1:28:03100,000 or $1,000,000 worth of GPU cycles instead, if you send
- 1:28:08a bearer asset i.e. Bitcoin, and even if it's
- 1:28:11denominated as U.S. dollars with Taro something in the future,
- 1:28:14that's totally fine. But if you're sending real
- 1:28:16Bitcoin as the underlying. And that can't be clawed back.
- 1:28:19Well, then you can do You can increase the total addressable
- 1:28:22size of your market radically, because now you know your profit
- 1:28:27margin's already baked in and guaranteed.
- 1:28:29So if it costs you $0.02 an inference, and you're charging
- 1:28:31three cents an inference, then your cost and your profit is all
- 1:28:36locked in. So I think that that's a really
- 1:28:38important concept both for the big companies and the
- 1:28:40decentralized AI. But I think if that's one of the
- 1:28:43key concepts, everyone first of all just has to understand is
- 1:28:45that there is no 0 marginal cost of distribution here.
- 1:28:50Yeah. And then to like throw an
- 1:28:51anecdote on top of that example, I mean, Cody Lowe, who we
- 1:28:55mentioned earlier is the head of developer support at Fetty.
- 1:28:59Which is a company building in the Bitcoin space and one of the
- 1:29:02modules that they're going to put in their app is Ln chat
- 1:29:05which essentially allows you to get access to open a eyes chat
- 1:29:09GB T after paying a lightning network invoice and he he
- 1:29:13launched like the the prototype for that called Matador and
- 1:29:19didn't even market it really just put it on some like obscure
- 1:29:21dev. Forums and put it out on Twitter
- 1:29:25and he went to bed one night and woke up and realized he had
- 1:29:29$2000 worth of charges on his open A I account.
- 1:29:33It didn't matter to him, he had $2200 worth of Bitcoin.
- 1:29:36So he made a little bit of money.
- 1:29:38But he said the most fascinating thing that he found from from
- 1:29:41launching this and running this was he was getting DM's from
- 1:29:44developers and Nigeria and the Philippines were saying thank
- 1:29:48you for launching this. I've been watching.
- 1:29:51People in the West use these models and I haven't been able
- 1:29:54to because I don't have a bank account.
- 1:29:55And so to Max this point, there like just this one developer
- 1:30:01hacking around on a prototype for just to prove that this
- 1:30:04could actually be a use case, opened up ChatGPT to markets
- 1:30:08that previously did not have access to it.
- 1:30:11And we've already Don't you need it?
- 1:30:12Don't you need a token for that? Yeah, that's called Sats.
- 1:30:17That bring it whole circle. You need to bring it all,
- 1:30:20certainly. You need Sats and you need the
- 1:30:22the AI API token as well. It is.
- 1:30:26It is an interesting point because like when we when we've
- 1:30:30been talking about all of this stuff like a question that keeps
- 1:30:33coming in my head is who's going to do that?
- 1:30:35Like who's really going to, you know, we can't even figure out
- 1:30:41how to use the Internet as it is.
- 1:30:43Like, you know, switching to Nostra is going to be really
- 1:30:46hard for the average person, but but there's a solution right
- 1:30:50there. There's the answers.
- 1:30:51It's it's entrepreneurial endeavors to like, create
- 1:30:54workarounds that that help people get things that they
- 1:30:58want, even if it doesn't feel like you're using Gnoster.
- 1:31:01Like it feels like you're just using the web.
- 1:31:04Yeah, it's just gonna be a better experience.
- 1:31:08Exactly. I mean, this is my thesis is a
- 1:31:10fun, right? Is like.
- 1:31:12How to make like my dream world is like, the average person
- 1:31:16didn't even know what the word noster means, or even
- 1:31:18necessarily Bitcoin. Like, they're just like, hey, I
- 1:31:22have an app that I make money on and it's open and it's cool and
- 1:31:26that's it. And so when you say, you know,
- 1:31:29it's it's hard for the average person to come, Dude, we're so
- 1:31:32early in all this. And so that difficulty is our
- 1:31:36alpha. Like, that's like what I see my
- 1:31:37fun doing is like, how do I now invest in the companies that
- 1:31:40solve those problems? Yeah, just obvious, Gates.
- 1:31:43It was something that I remember in early days and helping people
- 1:31:47hold their keys and unchain and getting the devices.
- 1:31:49They get so angry, like you're making them go through that
- 1:31:51process. And I likened it back to like
- 1:31:53the 90s and the alpha. There was setting up the modem
- 1:31:56and the router and you got access to the World Wide Web.
- 1:31:58And in this version it's like you're actually securing an
- 1:32:01asset. You can put like value around
- 1:32:03that. If you secure it, you're gonna
- 1:32:04have it in the future. It's gonna accrue.
- 1:32:06In the same way here, it's just gonna look a little foreign and
- 1:32:08clunky for the early adopters. And if you invest in you're
- 1:32:11allocating your building in the space, you're gonna get outsized
- 1:32:14returns and then in the future state it's just gonna be like,
- 1:32:16you know, obvious, gated all the way and it's just like water
- 1:32:18flowing and down the stream. It's not.
- 1:32:20It's gonna be natural state of things.
- 1:32:23Yeah, everybody's gonna be like, oh, it was easy.
- 1:32:24It was always gonna be this way. Yeah, we like Google and
- 1:32:29Facebook, like, yeah. No, but I mean.
- 1:32:33And I think to I mean we're definitely tapping into like why
- 1:32:35Bitcoin is uniquely suited to serve this simple use case of
- 1:32:40ping, paying a pay wall and then getting access to an API token.
- 1:32:45But like where it gets really heavy going back to data vending
- 1:32:47machines and AI agents particularly like this is really
- 1:32:52highlights why Bitcoin, particularly over the lighting
- 1:32:55network, is uniquely suited to serve the AI agent use case is
- 1:33:01because. AI agents, you want them to
- 1:33:05complete a task, they go out on the Internet and they do it.
- 1:33:07And when I think of this use case particularly and how
- 1:33:10Bitcoin fits into it via the Lightning Network, for anybody
- 1:33:14listening who's not familiar with like the technical aspects
- 1:33:17of it, like Lightning Network has what are called like
- 1:33:20macaroon permissions. So you can essentially inject
- 1:33:24permissions into how Bitcoin is sent and received.
- 1:33:27Over the lightning network and what we're going to be able to
- 1:33:29do, what you can already do but is very nation right now we'll
- 1:33:33get more mature moving forward is you can use these Macroom
- 1:33:36permissions and then give these a I agents like allowances and
- 1:33:39say hey go out and book me a ticket back to Austin between
- 1:33:43these dates. Between these prices, you load
- 1:33:46up the wallet and then eventually when all the airlines
- 1:33:49adopt Bitcoin and accept it, it'll be able to go out and use
- 1:33:52the Bitcoin it has as an allowance to go complete that
- 1:33:55task for you. And when you think about the
- 1:33:59amount of time that's going to unlock for individuals, that's
- 1:34:02insane, number one. But then #2, like, you're going
- 1:34:07to give that AI an allowance and it's going to go out and spend
- 1:34:10it, and it can spend it with another AI agent.
- 1:34:12Like, if it can't complete the task, it's like, all right, I
- 1:34:15know that you may be able to complete the task.
- 1:34:16Here's the Bitcoin to go do it. And when you think about the
- 1:34:20insane market dynamics that can evolve from that?
- 1:34:24It's hard to even think about. It's hard to even fathom.
- 1:34:27Yeah, I know Max you talked about this previously on like
- 1:34:30Your Dream and it's I think like when we breakdown like basically
- 1:34:34managing your own Gpu's from a data privacy perspective and
- 1:34:37then ingesting the data you're allowing from your personal just
- 1:34:40kind of ecosystem of applications that you use
- 1:34:44sending an agent to go complete task or be able to manage all of
- 1:34:48that. And that goes from a micro
- 1:34:50example of an individual, but then to like businesses.
- 1:34:52In the data that they have that's unique to them to wrap
- 1:34:55around a model, it's just on forecastable the amount of like
- 1:34:58efficiency that will come from that.
- 1:35:00Well, so yes, 100%. And I think the other thing that
- 1:35:04it allows for so efficiency, data privacy, all those things
- 1:35:07are great and they will be big. But I think the really big
- 1:35:10opportunity here is gonna come from the long tail.
- 1:35:13And what I mean by that is, and so going back to the data
- 1:35:16vending machine, Pablo came up with this construct where?
- 1:35:21I can send out a job request to the Nostra network for anything
- 1:35:26and anyone can come and fill that request for me or compete
- 1:35:29to fill that request for me. It's basically it's just a way
- 1:35:32of bringing markets to completing any task.
- 1:35:35And so if you want to call something closer to AGI, it's
- 1:35:37this. It's taking any task.
- 1:35:39Deconstructing it to its constituent parts, farming each
- 1:35:42of those parts out to an open free market, IE Gnoster, and
- 1:35:46then paying that. And you know, I think it's going
- 1:35:49to end up being Bitcoin. And so to give you guys an idea
- 1:35:51of like what this could be, right, So the first thing that
- 1:35:54he was doing with the data vending machine.
- 1:35:56Was he has this really cool app called highlighter.com.
- 1:35:58And highlighter.com is kind of like if you guys were a Rap
- 1:36:01Genius back in the day. I was pretty big on that side
- 1:36:04and basically is like a crowd source annotation for rap songs.
- 1:36:07Then they raised a whole bunch from Andreessen and try to do
- 1:36:09everything and then you know it never really went anywhere.
- 1:36:11But I think noster, you know, with highlighter.com, it's
- 1:36:14really cool because you can basically have.
- 1:36:16Any text or book or whatever PDF's and you can annotate them
- 1:36:21and people can see this in pub, this identity.
- 1:36:23Max highlighted this and then you can start to build cool
- 1:36:26experiences around. You know, this is going back to
- 1:36:28my Noster suite. You can have like a social
- 1:36:29network based on I want to meet everyone in my community or in
- 1:36:33my in San Francisco or in Austin that highlighted this particular
- 1:36:36document. Anyone that highlighted the GG
- 1:36:38document about money, probably someone that I'd like to talk
- 1:36:40with. Cool, so you can build all those
- 1:36:42cool experiences around. So one of the things that Pablo
- 1:36:44then wanted to do was, OK, well, I want to.
- 1:36:46I'd be able to bring audio into highlighter, right?
- 1:36:48And so instead of just doing this for text, could we do this
- 1:36:50for podcasts? But obviously podcasts are in
- 1:36:55voice. It's audio format.
- 1:36:57And so his first idea for the dating the new machine was what
- 1:37:00if I could just drop a link to a YouTube video or a podcast like
- 1:37:05this one we're doing right now, and you could basically have the
- 1:37:07entire Gnoster network compete to run models to do
- 1:37:10transcription for me. And so someone could run like
- 1:37:13Whisper or whatever open source model or closed source, like
- 1:37:15whatever they want. Or they can have a human do it
- 1:37:17right, but that's probably not going to be cost competitive.
- 1:37:19But try and create these different podcast transcriptions
- 1:37:23for me so you can have like an open market for podcast
- 1:37:25transcription. They can have different prices,
- 1:37:27They can have reputation that builds up over time.
- 1:37:29So as your reputation goes up, maybe you can increase your
- 1:37:32prices, blah blah blah. And then you can like have your
- 1:37:34bot or agent set parameters around how much reputation
- 1:37:37matters to you, how much cost all these different things.
- 1:37:39But then what's really crazy? Because of the way this works,
- 1:37:42everything in Nostra is just a kind, or it's just like an event
- 1:37:46you can chain with other events. And so then you can start to
- 1:37:49have all kinds of, well, you can have very specialized versions
- 1:37:53of what we just talked about chained together with other
- 1:37:54really, really interesting events.
- 1:37:56So the first example he gave was OK podcast transcription.
- 1:37:59You know, maybe Open AI has a pretty good podcast transcriber.
- 1:38:03But what if I want to get super specific and I want to have a
- 1:38:07Bitcoin podcast only transcriber?
- 1:38:10Because there's Bitcoin vocabulary that the open AI
- 1:38:12model just may not know about. And so this is what I was
- 1:38:14talking about, fine tuning. You take a model off the shelf
- 1:38:16and then you basically, you know, wrap your own data into
- 1:38:20that or the data that you're interested in.
- 1:38:21And so then you can literally have someone that says, hey,
- 1:38:24I'll run the generic podcast Transcriber for this cost, and
- 1:38:26it's pretty good. But then you could have someone
- 1:38:28that says, actually I only do Bitcoin podcasts.
- 1:38:31So if I hear a term like The Happening, I know like what that
- 1:38:34means and how to transcribe it, whereas the generic model might
- 1:38:37not. But then you could then have
- 1:38:39someone else that comes and says, yeah, that's really great,
- 1:38:42but you know what? I want to have a model that only
- 1:38:46transcribes podcasts for the last trade and that's it.
- 1:38:50That's it. But we, because we've trained
- 1:38:52only on listening to you guys, to Michael and Marty and Jesse
- 1:38:55talking, like we know exactly what phrases they like to use.
- 1:38:58And so we're just the best in the world.
- 1:38:59No one can beat us at transcribing the last trade.
- 1:39:03And in the current world that just like there's no way open it
- 1:39:05would ever do that. It doesn't make any economic
- 1:39:07sense. But if it's a giant free market,
- 1:39:09this is exactly what happened with the Internet, with Amazon,
- 1:39:11when they said, OK, you know, books.
- 1:39:14In a bookstore, you can't have these weird niche long tail
- 1:39:16books because it doesn't make economic sense in Barnes and
- 1:39:18Noble. But you can On the Internet,
- 1:39:19same thing's going to happen here.
- 1:39:21You can have all this weird long tail niche kinds of models that
- 1:39:25maybe the only 10 people in the world will ever use, but
- 1:39:27whatever, you're still making money off of it and you're
- 1:39:29running the computer at your house.
- 1:39:30Who cares? So I see, first of all, that's
- 1:39:34like the first big area this is going to unlock is like the long
- 1:39:36tail niche, but very interesting or successful models.
- 1:39:39Then you start to chain those together and this is where stuff
- 1:39:42gets wild. Today, one of the biggest kind
- 1:39:45of darlings of Silicon Valley is Lane Chain.
- 1:39:48Lane chain started as an open source framework for cheating
- 1:39:50various data sources and bots or agents together.
- 1:39:54Lane chain, after they got, you know, like whatever 10s of
- 1:39:56thousands of stars. Benchmark invested very quickly.
- 1:39:58A week later, Sequoia dumped another 20 plus mill or
- 1:40:00something crazy in there and they're off to the races.
- 1:40:03But lane chain is a way to string data and agents together.
- 1:40:05But it's very top down, right? What Dbm's are promising is you
- 1:40:09can now do kind of what they're doing, but you can do it in a
- 1:40:12completely open and interchangeable way and
- 1:40:15obviously with Lightning payments.
- 1:40:17So you could say as an example, OK, I want to post this podcast
- 1:40:22link today. Now I want a couple of things
- 1:40:24done. Number one, I want it
- 1:40:25transcribed, then I want it summarized, then I want it
- 1:40:30translated to Spanish and I want someone to create a logo for my
- 1:40:34site based on this, right? And so you can literally have
- 1:40:37all these different jobs done each by different agents, some
- 1:40:39sequentially, some not, depending on.
- 1:40:41Like if one job is required to be done before the other and
- 1:40:44anyone can compete for it. And you can do it the first week
- 1:40:47and then week two. Maybe a better model comes for
- 1:40:49the stable diffusion to create the logo, and you can keep the
- 1:40:52other three models the same but set that model out.
- 1:40:55Basically what this is doing, it's bringing free markets to
- 1:40:58the world of Labor, and increasing labor is going to be
- 1:41:00done by Ai's. And maybe some of it's still
- 1:41:02going to be human tasks too. That's fine.
- 1:41:03Humans can be in there too, but it's just going to be super wild
- 1:41:07and very cool, yeah. It's kind of mind blowing.
- 1:41:15It is mind blowing. When you think about it, this is
- 1:41:18very satisfied, but yeah. No, but I think.
- 1:41:21To bring it back to like our audience like who we're speaking
- 1:41:24to. I think the reason we brought
- 1:41:26Max on is to highlight like this part of the Bitcoin and kind of
- 1:41:31like Bitcoin is beginning to leak out of the bubble that it's
- 1:41:35been confined to for the 1st 15 years of its existence.
- 1:41:38And really fine product market fit at the medium of exchange
- 1:41:42level with these other open systems and I I think in the
- 1:41:46context of. The high net worth individuals
- 1:41:50and institutions that are looking at Bitcoin, I don't
- 1:41:52think any have really dug this deep into what Bitcoin can
- 1:41:56offer. They think of it again as
- 1:41:57digital gold, this inert asset that'll sit in a wallet and a
- 1:42:01crew value overtime. But I think it's really
- 1:42:03important I've said this in the past, but I think this episode
- 1:42:06really reinforces it, is that the distributed network and the
- 1:42:10layers being built on top of it enable things that were
- 1:42:13literally impossible. 15 years ago until Bitcoin launched.
- 1:42:17And that when you're trying to value Bitcoin and put a total
- 1:42:20addressable market on it, like again what Max just described, I
- 1:42:24don't even think we can fathom what the total addressable
- 1:42:26market is. At the end of the day because we
- 1:42:28don't even know the type of UK use cases that are going to be
- 1:42:32enabled by AI, we can't, we literally can't think of them
- 1:42:38And and just to bring it to your to your audience on all of that,
- 1:42:40right, like I mean obviously I think there's you know if you're
- 1:42:43thinking about this from an investor perspective, there will
- 1:42:45be Google size companies that are built out of this no doubt,
- 1:42:48right. Like, think about it like if you
- 1:42:50have the opportunity, you know, even if you just wanted to train
- 1:42:54the really big model out there, right, to compete with opening
- 1:42:56eye, I think one big seeker right now is, you know, there's
- 1:42:59this whole concept of hallucination, which is
- 1:43:01sometimes the models just like makes it up, which to be fair so
- 1:43:05to humans. But like, you know, it's going
- 1:43:07to be very hard to go from like 80 or 90% reliability to 100%
- 1:43:11reliability. And the big reason for that is
- 1:43:13because what does a model train on?
- 1:43:15It's train on the Internet, right.
- 1:43:16And like, you know, there's a lot of great stuff on Reddit.
- 1:43:19There's also a lot of crap and how do you distinguish, you
- 1:43:22know, what's good and what's not.
- 1:43:23So I think a secret that the Nostrian Lightning community has
- 1:43:25is we have this market rank or value rank concept.
- 1:43:28So I'm pretty bullish on big models, finding some way to
- 1:43:32incorporate marketing to basically create the best
- 1:43:35foundation models in the future. So that's one thing.
- 1:43:37I think it's going to be very useful for fine tuning.
- 1:43:40This is something that stack work has kind of done like, hey,
- 1:43:42I want you to say like which of these options is better?
- 1:43:46Like not just image labeling, but like which poem do you like
- 1:43:50more or whatever? And you can pay people's ads to
- 1:43:52do that. I think that's going to be very
- 1:43:53interesting. So there's going to be all kinds
- 1:43:54of interesting investment opportunities.
- 1:43:56That's what I spend, you know basically full times trying to
- 1:43:59find what are the 1000 or 10,000 accidents or opportunities.
- 1:44:03On the other hand, the very simple TLDR for anyone is just
- 1:44:07buy Bitcoin and hold it. Why Obviously not investment
- 1:44:10advice, blah blah, don't see me blah blah.
- 1:44:12But but I mean the the general gist there is like you know, to
- 1:44:17your point about total addressable market already like
- 1:44:19I I think what people are going to be shocked about is Bitcoin.
- 1:44:23It really does have no top. I know that's somewhat of a
- 1:44:26cliche now, but if you think about Bitcoin is GDP, coin and
- 1:44:31all. Bitcoin is, is a representation
- 1:44:33of the total economic pie for the planet, which is what I
- 1:44:35think it is. And which is another way of
- 1:44:37saying the the potential energy of the human species or human
- 1:44:42plus whatever species we collaborate with, that's all
- 1:44:44Bitcoin is. It's just a representation of
- 1:44:46that potential energy pie, OK? And we're about to take whatever
- 1:44:51the global economy is today, and we're going to open it up to 6
- 1:44:56billion additional people that are pretty much cut off from it.
- 1:44:59We're going to open up all kinds of new micro payment use cases,
- 1:45:02which we haven't even dreamed of.
- 1:45:03And oh, by the way, the 8 billion humans that are using
- 1:45:07this, they'll be like one one thousandth of the total number
- 1:45:10of Ai's that are out there doing stuff with economic activity and
- 1:45:13doing IoT payments and whatever else.
- 1:45:15Like whoever has the single, like anytime you see an
- 1:45:18exponential curve and you see someone making a really bullish
- 1:45:20prediction, like I've never once seen it be like, oh, they were
- 1:45:23too bullish, right? If you go over A10 plus year
- 1:45:26time rising and even like 10% of the stuff that I'm talking about
- 1:45:30comes true, then the total global GDP is going to be so
- 1:45:35many orders of magnitude bigger than we can imagine.
- 1:45:37Like. And that's going to accrue to
- 1:45:38Bitcoin because it's the, it's the, you know, the
- 1:45:41representation of that potential energy, so.
- 1:45:43Max, but Larry Fink said it's digital gold.
- 1:45:47It's it 10 trillion is the Max. It's it's the literal Max.
- 1:45:53The other thing that I think is important is, is not only where
- 1:45:57like investable opportunities, but it's also where like
- 1:45:59disruption will happen because we've seen this and people be
- 1:46:02displaced when the past, you know 20 years since the
- 1:46:04Internet. It's just recognizing earnestly,
- 1:46:07at least giving enough of you know.
- 1:46:10Inkling, like to look into music, telco, all the things
- 1:46:14that we know essentially will this will touch.
- 1:46:16So you can start preparing or at least knowing that you're the
- 1:46:20model that you've lived in the past 20 years will look very
- 1:46:23different than the next 20 years.
- 1:46:25And so, yeah, I think that's an important function of all of
- 1:46:28this because the world's going to change faster than we could
- 1:46:31ever expect. It is.
- 1:46:34If I had to leave one additional message on that like obviously
- 1:46:38you know bullish long Bitcoin, that's cool.
- 1:46:39But I think that all the like fear and stuff that I hear and
- 1:46:44it's easy like believe me like through COVID and being in a sad
- 1:46:48like believe me I I've got on my own like fear and doom cycles
- 1:46:50and it's very easy to do that. I think it's it's frustrating
- 1:46:53and sad or whatever. But like man, like anyone that's
- 1:46:56really afraid of you know a guy run away and all this stuff
- 1:46:59happening. Like, I just think it's, man,
- 1:47:01it's such a lack of imagination. Like the future is going to
- 1:47:04change and it's going to be exciting.
- 1:47:06And like, you know, look, at the end of the day, nothing is
- 1:47:08guaranteed. Like all of us, we're not going
- 1:47:10to be here forever. So, like, enjoy it.
- 1:47:12Like, I think that, you know, there there's obviously ways to
- 1:47:16profit, but it's just going to be like, this is going to be
- 1:47:19quite an adventure, right? Like you'll be able to tell your
- 1:47:21grandkids you live through a transition bigger than the
- 1:47:25industrial revolution, probably on scale.
- 1:47:27The agricultural revolution. Like this is, I don't know, like
- 1:47:30I wouldn't want to be alive any other time.
- 1:47:31This is awesome. So I'm I'm pretty excited.
- 1:47:35I don't know. You don't seem too excited.
- 1:47:39No, I mean, this is like considering the macro backdrop
- 1:47:45right now, very contentious election season here in the
- 1:47:48United States. Obviously, there's war that's
- 1:47:50broken out different parts of the world.
- 1:47:53And I'll be the first to admit, I'm very easily pulled into the
- 1:47:57dumerism that exists out there. But I think.
- 1:48:00Having this conversation like and just extremely optimistic,
- 1:48:03it's all right there in front of us.
- 1:48:05We can build our way out of the strength that many people find
- 1:48:09themselves in today with the combination Bitcoin, open
- 1:48:13communications protocols, artificial intelligence.
- 1:48:16It's all right there. Yeah.
- 1:48:18I was just saying, Marty, like you've probably been the closest
- 1:48:21to this industry for the longest and have you seen like the past,
- 1:48:25let's call it, 18 to 24 months more building?
- 1:48:28Like actual, just things go in market than you've ever.
- 1:48:31It's just insane for the price action and the the sentiment in
- 1:48:33the market. It's just been insane to watch.
- 1:48:36No. And I think it's a bit ironic
- 1:48:37too, because I think technically speaking, this is the longest
- 1:48:40bear market that we've seen. I think it's only 490 days now
- 1:48:44at this point. And I got in 2013 and 2015.
- 1:48:48Comparing this bear market to 2015, I mean 2015, I mean, I was
- 1:48:52pretty plugged in back then. People thought Bitcoin was going
- 1:48:54to die. They were convinced.
- 1:48:57Everybody had exited Bitcoin Twitter.
- 1:49:01Nobody was talking about it like you had to go to bitcointalk.org
- 1:49:05or the dev mailing list to see anybody who's still excited
- 1:49:08about it. And again, it's ironic because
- 1:49:11this bear markets longer, but there's never been a more
- 1:49:14bullish fundamental landscape within Bitcoin than there is
- 1:49:19today. What's going on?
- 1:49:20I've said this. Well, on episodes in the past,
- 1:49:23but like the inflection points that were hitting on multiple
- 1:49:26points, whether it be custody at the protocol level or building
- 1:49:30at the lightning level. Like like Max mentioned earlier,
- 1:49:33like the dev kits are all hitting a point of maturation
- 1:49:36where it's easy for anybody to plug in at Lightning to their
- 1:49:40businesses, their services. The implementation diversity
- 1:49:45that exists out there is pretty robust.
- 1:49:48The amount of eyes that are on the code bases is larger than
- 1:49:51it's ever been. And then true companies
- 1:49:54providing actual value and utility through individuals like
- 1:49:58the the landscape of the the industry has never been more
- 1:50:03robust which is? Again, ironic that we're
- 1:50:06suffering through the longest bear market of all time.
- 1:50:09But again, as Max has mentioned many times where the alpha lies,
- 1:50:13like being able to recognize and see through the noise of people
- 1:50:18saying that Bitcoin can't scale, can't do these things, is is
- 1:50:21where the alpha is because we see it every day.
- 1:50:24It's happening whether you realize it or not.
- 1:50:26One question I would like to ask you because I do want to say
- 1:50:29like obviously I'm very optimistic, but but I am also a
- 1:50:31realist. And like I do think one of the
- 1:50:32things that I think can help things just really pop in the
- 1:50:36next 12 months. And I'm curious, you're always
- 1:50:38taking this like obviously like happening goes off the price
- 1:50:40runs like that's probably going to get a lot of more interest.
- 1:50:42It's probably a good thing, but I will say that you know this
- 1:50:47kind of bottoms up adoption of like actually using SAS and
- 1:50:50being able to get in and out of sass, your local currency in
- 1:50:52emerging markets. I think that that to me can be a
- 1:50:55pretty clear path forward. I think for some of the older
- 1:50:58more legacy for example tech companies like you know, I've
- 1:51:00chatted a lot with Cody as well and I sponsored this last
- 1:51:02hackathon like following all that pretty closely.
- 1:51:05I mean the engineers love it. They want to do it.
- 1:51:07A lot of like compliance people are just like dude, we don't
- 1:51:09want to deal with. It's just it's a pain in the
- 1:51:11ass. Like, it's cool, but like, we
- 1:51:12just don't want to deal with it. And I do wonder if getting easy
- 1:51:17interoperability with dollars, at least in the short term, I
- 1:51:20don't know if that's going to come through tomorrow.
- 1:51:21I don't know if it's going to come through better interactions
- 1:51:23from river and strike and blah, blah, blah.
- 1:51:25I do feel like that would probably just make it a lot
- 1:51:29easier for some of the legacy tech companies to interact.
- 1:51:31And so on the one hand, I think if that happens maybe it runs
- 1:51:34the next 12 months, not not price, but just adoption.
- 1:51:38On the other hand, it could just go all bottoms up from places
- 1:51:41like emerging markets and like the US is later to adopt just
- 1:51:44because you know they see it happening somewhere else since
- 1:51:47okay we need to change our tune. I'm curious if you guys have
- 1:51:50opinions on that. I I I just have to say it on the
- 1:51:54record because I already get in trouble enough behind the
- 1:51:57scenes. I fundamentally don't believe
- 1:52:00any of the adoption happens without the top down and capital
- 1:52:04coming in because the price is the the ultimate arbiter of it.
- 1:52:08And liquidity matters, right? So like a billion people having
- 1:52:11a dollar in an emerging market versus one person putting $10
- 1:52:14billion enhances the liquidity profile and making it useful as
- 1:52:18money from just swinging around in different directions.
- 1:52:21And it's very widely unpopular because it's always the nice
- 1:52:25thing to talk about of, you know the quote UN quote, I think it's
- 1:52:29a sigh out. But the term global S like
- 1:52:31emerging markets and. Weird, But this idea of that,
- 1:52:35it's like Bitcoin should be for everybody, but it's also our
- 1:52:37refocus, like in this part of the market, at least
- 1:52:39specifically. I'll speak for myself.
- 1:52:41It's because the reality is like we and I forget where we were
- 1:52:44talking about it. It may have been the last pot.
- 1:52:46Yeah. With Brian that we haven't
- 1:52:48figured out like this silver bullet or this way to explain
- 1:52:51everything we're talking about here and how you wrap it up into
- 1:52:54like why Bitcoin is an asset that an institution should plug
- 1:52:56a billion dollars into or 10 billion or whatever the
- 1:52:59percentages and why they need it.
- 1:53:01And that's where like we're focused on there is cuz it's
- 1:53:03seeing that and it's also where I don't like it, but it just is
- 1:53:06what it is like this ETF is that signal to the market that like
- 1:53:09you go there and then everybody benefit benefits from it, the
- 1:53:12whole 8 billion or whatever number of people on the planet.
- 1:53:15Yeah. And I'll take the middle of the
- 1:53:17road answer, which I think it's gonna happen from both ends at
- 1:53:19the same time. It's going back to what we said
- 1:53:21earlier like going back to the example of Cody basically
- 1:53:24launching that product and opening up that AI market to
- 1:53:28people who. Previously didn't have access to
- 1:53:30it. That's gonna continue happening
- 1:53:31and that's and again, that's a really exciting part.
- 1:53:35Like, I think the UX around Bitcoin products, particularly
- 1:53:38over the Lighting Network, has improved significantly over the
- 1:53:41last couple years, and there's going to be use cases that
- 1:53:45people really want to leverage that will only be possible if
- 1:53:49you have Bitcoin and are able to pay for it.
- 1:53:52But the. The example, sorry just that is
- 1:53:54like if the money increases then the awareness goes so 10X the
- 1:53:58number of people build the utility, but if like the utility
- 1:54:01increases but the price doesn't then they don't actually use it
- 1:54:04because the utilities there but you still need like the value to
- 1:54:07be flowing through the system. The great That's why I think, I
- 1:54:11think it happening from both ends at the same time.
- 1:54:14Like is jet fuel for it. And to clarify, I mean I I
- 1:54:17totally hear what you're saying on like I hear both what you're
- 1:54:20saying bottoms up, adoptions plugging to be pretty fast.
- 1:54:22But like you need the real capital come in to to make the
- 1:54:25transition complete and probably disper it.
- 1:54:27But I guess my bigger question is specifically, and this is
- 1:54:30what I'm still running into and seeing more and more as a lot of
- 1:54:33these at least U.S. companies being like we love the Instant
- 1:54:36Payment Network at least at this stage in our life.
- 1:54:40Like we don't want to put in the extra time and hassle to figure
- 1:54:43out how to deal with the compliance of accepting.
- 1:54:47How do we get this into dollars? And I'm curious if you guys
- 1:54:49think that like some easy access in and out of dollars is no
- 1:54:53critical next? Yeah, I think we more need more
- 1:54:56strike like API's where somebody wants to pay a Bitcoin invoice
- 1:55:01they can pay dollars from their account directly and then vice
- 1:55:03versa if somebody. Wants to cater to customers want
- 1:55:07to pay in Bitcoin but they want to take on that that risk of
- 1:55:10holding it on their balance sheet and immediately convert it
- 1:55:12to dollars. That'll be that'll be big and
- 1:55:14then it'll be interesting to see like if that that where he is
- 1:55:19driven more by the exposure to Bitcoin directly or in the
- 1:55:24volatility or just a regulatory risk about around interacting
- 1:55:28with it at all. If it's the former, it'll be
- 1:55:32interesting to see like. If stablecoins on Tarot fine
- 1:55:37product market kit fit, excuse me, or something like stable
- 1:55:40Sats, stability pools within Fediments are able to to fulfill
- 1:55:45that need, yeah, I do see it and obviously historically has been
- 1:55:51a big problem. It's going to be a problem for a
- 1:55:53bit. But I would just say like again,
- 1:55:57everything we've been discussing here like it's their loss, it's
- 1:55:59going to happen eventually. You're going to adopt Bitcoin in
- 1:56:01some form or another. It's just a matter of.
- 1:56:04When you do that, then at that's where you throw it back on them
- 1:56:07and like, hey, do you want to be an innovator?
- 1:56:09Do you actually want to like move the world forward like
- 1:56:11you're going to move first or or wait because you're worried
- 1:56:14about what the government's going to say We need more
- 1:56:17maverick builders out there. Just say fuck it then.
- 1:56:20I I I do believe it's a bit contrarian and people don't like
- 1:56:25when I say, but I think if we build fast enough and make it so
- 1:56:28useful in a timely manner and just people.
- 1:56:32Begin using it like the regulatory and compliance stuff
- 1:56:36will figure itself out in the end here.
- 1:56:37Literally like I think about a podcasting 2.0.
- 1:56:40Like people are streaming me 8 sats a minute every minute of
- 1:56:44every day. They vary between 8 and 100 sats
- 1:56:49every minute. Like the accounting like that
- 1:56:50I'm just going to at the end of the day I'll do like a monthly
- 1:56:55aggregate of the Sats have been streamed to my node and then
- 1:56:59like pick the highest price of the month and then pay.
- 1:57:02Income tax on that, but I think eventually at scale it's going
- 1:57:06to be so all-encompassing that it's going to be impossible for
- 1:57:12for compliance to catch you up and you're just figured out on
- 1:57:14the back end and Tony the builders out there a bit
- 1:57:18apprehensive. Like I would just say stop being
- 1:57:20a pussy. And you know with the plan, like
- 1:57:24it's happening, you can get it now or get it later.
- 1:57:30Yeah. And I guess I have to weigh in
- 1:57:33too since since we we had two opinions there and I I'm pretty
- 1:57:37much towards the the Michael camp of you know I I think these
- 1:57:42are kind of independent things that are going in parallel.
- 1:57:46And for example, like if there was no having and if you also
- 1:57:50said all right first world people, nobody else will be
- 1:57:54allowed to buy any more Bitcoin or adopt anymore.
- 1:57:59Beyond what's, you know, mined every day so that you can have
- 1:58:04the price go sideways. So then you sort of like freeze
- 1:58:08Bitcoin in terms of its value as digital gold, but then?
- 1:58:15Then the utility would start to catch up like and and that's
- 1:58:18like a slow exponential curve. I think I like it very early in
- 1:58:21an exponential curve such that, you know, the 6 billion people
- 1:58:25in the world that are cut off from banking or really I guess
- 1:58:27it's probably 3 billion. But the 6 billion you referred
- 1:58:30to earlier of, you know, aren't really plugged into the Internet
- 1:58:34as we know. It can become plugged into the
- 1:58:37Internet as we know it and can be productive and grow the value
- 1:58:41of Bitcoin. Because of their productivity,
- 1:58:45using Bitcoin as their unit of account there and and then that
- 1:58:50productivity would turn into the the growth of Bitcoin, Bitcoin's
- 1:58:54value, even if, you know, the West wasn't plowing money into
- 1:58:58it. But that that would take a long
- 1:59:01time. I think that's a decade plus to
- 1:59:05really see the measurable effect, I think.
- 1:59:09But luckily we have the having and we have.
- 1:59:13And we have the Fiat currencies be eroding every year and and
- 1:59:193300 billion dollars, $300 trillion in bonds that are going
- 1:59:24to just be lit on fire over the next decade as we have to print
- 1:59:29more money to pay down the sovereign debt such that Bitcoin
- 1:59:33becomes the best asset, the the fastest horse for this decade.
- 1:59:36And and I think that is the 99%, maybe it's 95%.
- 1:59:41Of where the the value will be coming from for Bitcoin holders
- 1:59:48this decade. And then I think all of the the
- 1:59:51long tail, all of the growth will be coming long term from
- 1:59:55the GDP growth that comes from this sort of system.
- 1:59:58But first, it's about onboarding all of the world's capital, or
- 2:00:02as much of it as as wants to be in a good store value asset.
- 2:00:10I think it's going to happen much quicker.
- 2:00:11I think I recorded with Matthew Mazing just yesterday to go over
- 2:00:16the Q 2/20/23 monetary base update and he had just a
- 2:00:20stunning set, which is like the compound annual growth rate of
- 2:00:23the global money supply, physical cash over the last 50
- 2:00:28years is 13% and rising. And so that's like a having a
- 2:00:33doubling of the physical amount of cash in the world every 5.7
- 2:00:38years, so 5 1/2. And so that that number is only
- 2:00:43rising. And when you consider the state
- 2:00:48of the banking sector here in the US and the debt situation
- 2:00:52that everybody's facing globally, it's hard not to
- 2:00:54imagine that that's going to continue.
- 2:00:57And when you like say that like the the money supply is going to
- 2:01:00double by 2028 potentially even sooner if they turn the money
- 2:01:05printer on more aggressively when the Fed needs to step in
- 2:01:08next time, like I don't think people understand how quickly
- 2:01:12this is happening I. Was just gonna say people don't
- 2:01:14even use cash anymore. That was the status shared this
- 2:01:17morning. It's not true though, if you
- 2:01:19like. No, no, I was talking about
- 2:01:21Target with Target earnings that like one out of every $20 this
- 2:01:24past earnings was like out of just like being shoplifted, like
- 2:01:27people just stealing from stores.
- 2:01:29Yeah, yeah, I'm, I'm, I'm pretty bullish especially after this
- 2:01:36conversation. Happy to.
- 2:01:40Happy to help start the fire. Well, thank you, Max.
- 2:01:44It's getting dark here. The sun's about to fall where
- 2:01:47I'm at, Obviously I'm on the back deck, Last back deck
- 2:01:51episode of the season here. I'll be back in Austin next
- 2:01:54week. But before we wrap up here, any
- 2:01:56closing thoughts? Start to Michael and Jesse
- 2:01:59first, then we can end it with Max.
- 2:02:03I'm sorry, Yeah, this is a head spinning conversation that that,
- 2:02:08you know, put me into my own head quite a bit.
- 2:02:10So you know, might be the kind of thing I have to listen back
- 2:02:13to again to to to think through all this stuff more.
- 2:02:17So thanks to Max for bringing a ton of information and
- 2:02:22excitement and and a lens that I think, you know, I'm a digital
- 2:02:26gold guy. I think that's.
- 2:02:29What's so exciting about Bitcoin And and I I think that's
- 2:02:32exciting enough for my lifetime. You know, so I don't even spend
- 2:02:36much time thinking about all of this other utility stuff and and
- 2:02:39and Max points out that this is, this is this is Promethean fire
- 2:02:46really that you know Bitcoin is granted this gift to the to the
- 2:02:50world. To the world of machines.
- 2:02:51Really the the world the digital age as we know it and.
- 2:02:57What we can build with that is going to be incredible to watch
- 2:03:00unfold over the next few decades.
- 2:03:02Yeah, you can't say it better than Jesse, but they echo those
- 2:03:06sentiments. And then Max, if you this was
- 2:03:10one of the first going into the AI topic, but would love in the
- 2:03:13back with us letting us know other folks that are deep in
- 2:03:18this space as we think about other guests to have on.
- 2:03:21And then just feel very fortunate like all the stuff
- 2:03:23we've been thinking about talking about behind the scenes
- 2:03:25and to get to be able to discuss it in a forum where other
- 2:03:28individuals can start to pull on these threads.
- 2:03:30It was rewarding to see Jesse kind of noodling on some of the
- 2:03:33thoughts you shared Max and thinking through it.
- 2:03:36And so I think that this will be a good kind of entry point for
- 2:03:40folks when they've been hearing about Noster or how AI plays in
- 2:03:43and Bitcoin and AR and Inoperable as a good entry point
- 2:03:47to that. And then ideally we can continue
- 2:03:49to to pull on the different angles.
- 2:03:52Totally, Yeah. Well, first of all, thank you
- 2:03:53guys for having me. This was a lot of fun.
- 2:03:55I mean, I also very much appreciate you hearing your
- 2:03:58takes on some of the macro stuff.
- 2:03:59And and look, I still think capital going into Bitcoin, like
- 2:04:01that's huge. I like the good news is, like
- 2:04:03you said, all this is happening in parallel and so you know.
- 2:04:07It's really all a lot of the. For a lot of this conversation,
- 2:04:13I kept thinking about how you're talking about fat protocols.
- 2:04:15That concept from Union Square Ventures that was really about
- 2:04:18Ethereum, but it was really about Bitcoin at the end of the
- 2:04:21day, yes. And that This is why just
- 2:04:28holding a slice of the Bitcoin supply.
- 2:04:32Is such an incredible asymmetric difference from the Internet
- 2:04:35revolution because you couldn't hold the slice of the Internet,
- 2:04:39and here you can just hold the underlying asset and get to
- 2:04:43participate in the growth of all of this utility that happens on
- 2:04:47top of it. Totally.
- 2:04:48I couldn't say it better, in fact.
- 2:04:51Even though I've only formerly been in VC for the last, you
- 2:04:54know, whatever, it was two years of my fund and two years before
- 2:04:57that. I followed all this landscape
- 2:04:59very closely for a long time. And in the early 2010, I
- 2:05:01actually followed USB very closely.
- 2:05:03And you know, I'm still friends with a lot of those guys there.
- 2:05:05My last fun, we Co invested with them a lot.
- 2:05:07And I kind of think in many ways like my fun thesis is, I'm just
- 2:05:10kind of looking back and using the USB playbook.
- 2:05:13Again, but this time with Bitcoin, Lightning and Noster.
- 2:05:15And so I think they call things right back in the 20 tens and I
- 2:05:19think they got a little distracted with some of the
- 2:05:21Ethereum stuff, although they are, all of them are on Noster
- 2:05:24at least looking at pretty closely, which is cool cool.
- 2:05:27But yeah, like, literally all the stuff they were investing
- 2:05:30and I'm kind of. I'm kind of cribbing their place
- 2:05:33a little bit so but but yeah, but thank you guys and this was
- 2:05:35a lot of fun. The last two things I would just
- 2:05:37mention if people want to learn more about this stuff.
- 2:05:40And Jesse, you mentioned you want to go back and just listen
- 2:05:42to some of this stuff again on my website Hideline dot VC.
- 2:05:44I have all my writings on there so I've gone in pretty great
- 2:05:47detail about a lot of these topics and I'm always open.
- 2:05:50You can also find me on Noster. Obviously go to noster dot band
- 2:05:53and just type in Max or primal. And type in maxpanel.net I
- 2:05:57believe. The other thing I would just say
- 2:06:00is for people that are really interested in the AI stuff
- 2:06:02specifically one cool project I meant to mention earlier, but
- 2:06:05I'm, I'm really excited about this is actually my last I guess
- 2:06:09announced investment is GPU Topia that that's the brand
- 2:06:13they're going to market with. They literally just announced
- 2:06:16this yesterday, but next week you if you download Albee.
- 2:06:22And you have, you know, their lightning wallet.
- 2:06:26You can rent out any spare GPU capacity that you have.
- 2:06:32Now this is going to be, I think people are going to be pretty
- 2:06:34wild by what all this looks like because right now as I mentioned
- 2:06:37the reason NVIDIA just went to the moon is there are there are
- 2:06:39just not enough GPUs in the world, full stop.
- 2:06:42And so, and not to mention some people wanted GPU access for
- 2:06:45inference that maybe they want uncensored inference or
- 2:06:47whatever, not, you know, fine-tuned by opening app.
- 2:06:50And so this is one of the short term ideas I would encourage
- 2:06:52everyone to check out and just play with cuz I think it's gonna
- 2:06:54blow a lot of people's minds as you look at the number of GPUs
- 2:06:59that were produced by NVIDIA. I forget the exact numbers, but
- 2:07:02it's some multiple. That is all of the new end chips
- 2:07:06that Apple has put out in their iPads, their Macbooks and their
- 2:07:08iPhones. And so the concept here is in
- 2:07:12the future, the way the Apple end chips work.
- 2:07:15Is they can basically that they're going to be much better
- 2:07:17for machine learning that people realize for.
- 2:07:19Some of this inference stuff is like, imagine a world where you
- 2:07:22can just click a button and say make money and just rent out
- 2:07:25your GPU or your Apple MM2 or whatever you have when you're
- 2:07:28not using it and just start earning Sats for free.
- 2:07:32I think this is going to be a really big idea, and if anyone's
- 2:07:35interested in the AI, stuff like this is the one to watch in the
- 2:07:37next couple weeks. Yeah.
- 2:07:38If you drop it, send us the e-mail on the thread we're in,
- 2:07:41we can drop it in the show notes along with your blog.
- 2:07:46Yeah, Exciting times. Gentlemen.
- 2:07:49Max, thank you for joining us. I'm pretty bullish.
- 2:07:55This will end in a lot of fun. See everybody next week.
- 2:07:59See you.