Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / Gigawaters 03: Working in harmony
Transcript
- 0:02Hello and welcome to the third episode of this season of
- 0:06Gigawatts, a podcast brought to you by Energyvoice Out Loud and
- 0:10paid partnership with Firstdev. These discussions are the first
- 0:16word in the global energy conversation, examining the role
- 0:19of offshore wind and the role it has to play in meeting the UK's
- 0:23clean energy targets. I'm your host, Michael Baer,
- 0:26renewables reporter at Energyvoice, and joining me
- 0:29today is the Crown Estate managing director for Marine,
- 0:32Gus Jasper. Also with me is first state UK
- 0:35country manager bench site. So compared to the early days
- 0:40when the UK's first offshore wind farm went up, the North Sea
- 0:43has become a far busier place. Multiple projects are now
- 0:47generating clean power, each competing with a range of other
- 0:50interests such as fishing, shipping and defense.
- 0:52So as coastal communities and of course the environment itself
- 0:56For the next stage of EU KS offshore wind rollout, wind
- 0:59farms will need to work in harmony with all of these.
- 1:02Gus, could you lay out for me how the UK has come to to this
- 1:06position? Can you give me a bit of
- 1:07background on start of EU KS offshore wind journey and how
- 1:11how we've come to to where we are now?
- 1:13Yeah, sure. So actually first I might just
- 1:15say a little bit about people understand who the Crown of
- 1:18State are and our part in that journey as well because we've
- 1:21been working on managing the seabed.
- 1:23So our role is to to manage the seabed around England, Wales and
- 1:27Northern Ireland as well as much of the coastline.
- 1:29And we do that independently, but on behalf of the nation.
- 1:32So all our profit goes back to to the nation, but we operate
- 1:35with developers in partnership for how we drive these projects
- 1:38and move these projects forward. So 25 years ago when the first
- 1:43turbine went up in in British waters to to now actually,
- 1:47despite noise out there and despite what can sometimes feel
- 1:52is a pessimistic view of the offshore wind sector, it's
- 1:56actually worth us taking a moment just to say wow.
- 1:59You know, look at what we've created in the last 25 years in
- 2:03terms of the offshore wind world we have currently we have 15.9
- 2:08gigawatts operational in UK waters in total.
- 2:13That's powering over half of or the equivalent of over half of
- 2:16UK homes. That's an incredible base from 1
- 2:21turbine in the first turbine spinning 25 years ago.
- 2:24We have the second largest offshore wind deployed fleet in
- 2:28the world, second only to to China.
- 2:30We have, if you look at the whole of Europe, we have 41% of
- 2:34European offshore wind capacity is in UK waters.
- 2:37So we've done some incredible things during that period.
- 2:40We've shown that actually this market can scale, it can grow,
- 2:44it can develop, it can innovate and the partnerships with with
- 2:48developers to to keep that innovation going right across
- 2:52the supply chain as well is really, really impressive.
- 2:56So UK is in a good place. Could it be in a better place?
- 2:58I think as the challenge will come on too.
- 3:00And are there things that it needs to do to make sure that it
- 3:02stays in that good place as those challenges increase?
- 3:06As you talked about, Michael, you know, the the pressures on
- 3:09on the sea space, the pressures on communities, the pressures on
- 3:13the next steps grow. But I thought it's worth just
- 3:15taking a moment actually, as we start to say, we're talking
- 3:18about how do we take the next the challenge?
- 3:20I think about and at the Crown Estate, where we can take that
- 3:22strategic and long term view, we're we're driven by creating
- 3:26lasting and shared prosperity for the country.
- 3:28That's our kind of aim. The challenge that keeps me up
- 3:31is how do we make sure that the next chapter of success is even
- 3:34better than the last 25 years? Binge What do?
- 3:37Do you have anything to add to this from a developer's
- 3:40perspective? Yes, absolutely.
- 3:42There's a lot I think to to unpack here.
- 3:45I would very much echo what Gus has shared in terms of the
- 3:48journey we've been on. Austin is the the biggest
- 3:51operator and in the UK we've got 12 operating wind farms already.
- 3:57We're delivering 7% of Britain's electricity as we speak today.
- 4:02So it's it's a very material part of our energy mix already,
- 4:05but a long way to go. And when I look at the journey
- 4:08we've been on, our first wind farm came online in 2007.
- 4:15That's the Barrow wind farm off off the coast, West Coast of
- 4:19England. That's 90 megawatts.
- 4:22We've hugely scaled up. We're currently building a three
- 4:24GW project out in the North Sea, Hornsey Project 3.
- 4:29So we've seen huge scaling up and progress in the sector.
- 4:33And whilst we've seen a bit of a turn around in the last few
- 4:35years in terms of cost, it's still a very attractive part of
- 4:40the energy mix from a cost as well as an energy security and
- 4:43of course a climate perspective. So we are in a sense victims of
- 4:47our own success. I think as an industry we've
- 4:49innovative, as Gus has said, we've scaled up, we've driven
- 4:52costs down. I think we have always worked in
- 4:57a world where we want to do the right thing in terms of our
- 5:00interaction with nature, with a natural environment and also
- 5:03with other users of the sea, and the North Sea in particular is
- 5:07an incredibly busy place. If you stand on the beach
- 5:11Cleethorpes, as I sometimes do when I'm visiting Grimsby and
- 5:13you look out, you think wow, what a beautiful empty space.
- 5:16But in fact, it's one of the busiest bits of sea in the world
- 5:19in terms of how much activity, infrastructure, transport,
- 5:23fishing and so on, as you've mentioned, is already going on.
- 5:26And as we scale up offshore wind, clearly that's brings a
- 5:30new set of challenges, ones that we're very much ready to tackle.
- 5:36We know offshore wind is going to have to be the backbone of
- 5:38our new energy system. That's very clear.
- 5:42It provides energy security as well as all the other things
- 5:45I've mentioned. And I think what we've learned
- 5:48is that the approach that we set out with back in the about 25
- 5:53years ago, as Gus says, we very much saw this as in some ways an
- 5:58experiment. Is this going to be a technology
- 6:00that's going to be material wasn't clear that the costs
- 6:03which at the time were very high were going to come down anywhere
- 6:06near as far and as fast as they have done.
- 6:08And so the way in which we developed and constructed wind
- 6:11farms is when one wind farm at a time, it's been very step by
- 6:16step. And I think we've reached the
- 6:18point where because of the scale of deployment that we are seeing
- 6:22and we'll need to see in the future, we definitely need to
- 6:25look at a different approach being more strategic.
- 6:27And I'm sure we'll unpack that in this conversation.
- 6:29So what needs to change and also what is driving the need to
- 6:35change? So for me, I think the need for
- 6:37change is very much driven by the need to get offshore wind
- 6:41deployed at scale and as quickly as we can in an appropriate way.
- 6:46We, I know that at the moment power prices for households and
- 6:50businesses are higher than we we want them to be.
- 6:54They're some of the highest around the world.
- 6:57And that is driven by the fact that so much of the time the
- 7:01marginal price, which is the marginal generator is gas.
- 7:04And that's obviously means that the wholesale price in the
- 7:08electricity market every half hour is being set by the gas
- 7:11price. And we have no control over gas
- 7:14prices. We're very much beholden to the
- 7:16international gas markets. And so the more we can deploy
- 7:20offshore wind and other renewable technologies, the
- 7:23sooner we can get away from that reliance on gas and fewer and
- 7:27fewer periods when gas is determining the price of
- 7:29electricity. So we need to press on.
- 7:31We need to press on quickly. And just if I can build on that,
- 7:34so part of my role is having to think about all of the sectors
- 7:38and the users of the sea space. And Benj mentioned earlier about
- 7:40how that's getting busier and more crowded.
- 7:43So we managed 26 different sectors and we from aggregates
- 7:46to linear assets, so cables through to pipelines through to
- 7:49carbon capture storage through to hydrogen through to minerals
- 7:54work through to nature restoration as well and
- 7:56obviously offshore wind. So what's what needs to be done
- 7:59differently is the fact things are different now the sea space,
- 8:02First off, the sea space is more crowded.
- 8:05So, and if we project forward, we know that's going to get more
- 8:10crowded, we know that it's going to get more complex and we need
- 8:13to think about how we do that in a different way.
- 8:16So previously where there's been a largely project by project
- 8:19approach for offshore wind. And as Ben spoke, you know, how
- 8:21does each project develop fantastic work and lots of, you
- 8:25know, bringing down that cost curve, the innovations
- 8:27technology to bring that to get to that result.
- 8:31But it's still been a project by project approach.
- 8:33And one of the things we're looking at is how do we shift to
- 8:35a more systemic approach? We look at the demands on the
- 8:39sea space. So we know we've got, yes, we've
- 8:41got you know, a great proportion or you know, as I talked about
- 8:47earlier, a, a 15.9 gigawatts of offshore wind operational in UK
- 8:53waters. But if we roll forward and NISOS
- 8:571 and NISOS projections, sorry, national electricity system
- 9:00operators projections are to get to 125 gigawatts.
- 9:03So we've got about a, you know, almost a 10 fold increase the
- 9:07amount of offshore wind we need to get deployed.
- 9:09That's a huge opportunity, but a huge challenge at the same time.
- 9:13And the kind of, I've described it a bit of as a 10 * 10 by 10
- 9:17challenge. We also have a 10 times increase
- 9:21in the amount of data cables we need to fit in to keep the UK
- 9:25the most connected country it currently is the most digitally
- 9:28connected country in the world. We are blessed to have lots of
- 9:31landing sites from transatlantic cables here.
- 9:33Data is growing by about 35% a year.
- 9:35Data use. If you think of all of the
- 9:37demands for AI and how we want to keep that as a core part of
- 9:41the UK success story, cables, wind farms, data cables, those
- 9:47things don't always, you know, go perfectly together.
- 9:50The AI drives more, more data, more energy demand as well for
- 9:54that data. So we have a kind of rising
- 9:55tenfold increase on on what we see in terms of infrastructure
- 9:59on the sea bed as well. Then at the same time we've got
- 10:03a need to almost do a 10 times tenfold nature turn around.
- 10:08So if we look at the UK's biodiversity across our sea
- 10:13space and we think also about the kind of nature priorities,
- 10:18we've seen the UK's biodiversity in our waters drop about 90%
- 10:24over the century. So we've seen native seagrass
- 10:27drop, we've seen oysters drop by about 95%, key sort of
- 10:31ecosystems that help to to drive the, the, the natural ecosystem
- 10:36around our waters. So all of these things risk
- 10:41coming from head to head. You know, we've got to get as
- 10:43dentures, even more offshore wind even faster, even more
- 10:47effective, even better pricing, all of those factors at the same
- 10:51time as we drive other sectors and even things like aggregate.
- 10:54So getting we get about, we get about 25% of our U KS building
- 11:00materials, sand and gravel off our seabed.
- 11:03Those are critical. We're going to need those in the
- 11:04future as well. How do we plan all of these
- 11:06different elements together as we go forward?
- 11:11So the the first big shift is moving from a project by project
- 11:15basis and really shifting to a let's a systemic approach or a
- 11:21system approach across all the different sectors and across the
- 11:24whole of the space to plan those together, plan them forward and
- 11:28to think about those trade-offs upfront rather than having those
- 11:31discussions whilst someone's trying to develop or someone's
- 11:34trying to move forward a project.
- 11:37And that's one of the key things we're trying to say.
- 11:39We're developing what we're calling a marine delivery route
- 11:41map and to start to map out the sea space, start to design the
- 11:45pathways for how different sectors can go forward.
- 11:48And then to think about how do we de risk those upfront so we
- 11:51don't have each project coming to deal with those systems
- 11:54issues by themselves. We're actually trying to move to
- 11:56a more strategic approach. I mean, you've, you've talked
- 12:00about this idea of a systemic approach.
- 12:01I mean, could you kind of unpack a bit more about what that would
- 12:06look like for you And I suppose as well, what are the the tools
- 12:10that we need to to deliver such a different approach?
- 12:14Maybe I could jump in on that. I think as Gus has said, we face
- 12:20an immense opportunity here, but we've got to do it right and I
- 12:22think we do have some tools already in the toolbox.
- 12:26I'm sure Gus will talk about the work the Crown Estate is doing
- 12:29on the offshore wind Evidence and Change programme, which is
- 12:33really helpful in in developing some of the tools there.
- 12:37Defra, the environment department is also very focused
- 12:42on this with their offshore wind environmental improvement
- 12:44programme. O weep.
- 12:46Unfortunately, we're full of acronyms in this sector and not
- 12:49least in the environmental space.
- 12:52One thing I would want to touch on that I think is super
- 12:54important is the marine recovery fund.
- 12:57So what we've seen as we've build out offshore wind and of
- 13:01course offshore wind like any development in the, in any
- 13:05marine or terrestrial environment does have an impact
- 13:08on the environment where it's built.
- 13:10And we know that we need to to deal with that.
- 13:13Hornsey Project 3, the one that we're building right now, the
- 13:16three GW project that has developed environmental
- 13:20compensation programme as part of its consent.
- 13:24Now what we're seeing is increasingly as the sea space
- 13:28gets busier, we need more and more compensation for to allow
- 13:32projects to progress in an environmentally compliant,
- 13:35responsible way. What the Marine Recovery Fund
- 13:38does is it moves us from each project coming up with its own
- 13:41solutions and really exciting stuff we're doing on Hornsey
- 13:44Project three with things like Kitty wake nesting structures or
- 13:47Kitty wake hotels as we call them, to compensate for the
- 13:50impacts on that particular species.
- 13:53Moving to a more strategic approach where we can deliver
- 13:56the environmental compensation that we need to put in place for
- 13:59this build out of offshore wind in a much more joined up
- 14:02strategic way so that we we can get firstly the best bang for
- 14:06our buck in terms of not putting any more cost on consumer bills
- 14:11than is absolutely necessary. But also environmentally, if you
- 14:15think about it, it makes a lot more sense to deal with
- 14:17environmental impacts at the largest scale possible rather
- 14:21than ending up with a patchwork of solutions of neighboring wind
- 14:24farms, each doing their own thing.
- 14:25So we are seeing the marine recovery fund coming through
- 14:30good progress. It's been painfully slow, but we
- 14:32are now seeing some progress on that becoming a reality.
- 14:36And I think that will be a real game changer for the industry in
- 14:38terms of being able to deal with those environmental impacts in a
- 14:42smart, efficient way. That means these projects can
- 14:45build out and we can deliver the best possible environmental
- 14:48compensation. So I think the Marine recovery
- 14:51fund is just one example of your, you ask how are we going
- 14:54to do it? I think that's a, that's a
- 14:56really important one. Just one other thing to add in
- 14:59terms of the question that always comes up in this type of
- 15:02conversation is data. Do we really understand the
- 15:05impacts? Do we really understand what's
- 15:07going on in the marine space? I think we have a pretty good
- 15:11idea. Talk to any scientist, they'll
- 15:14always say we need more data. And of course more data is
- 15:16always good. But we have to balance that
- 15:19desire for more data with recognizing how much data we
- 15:22already have. And I'm sure Gus can talk about
- 15:25the marine data exchange and the way in which data is brought
- 15:28together by the Crown Estate from all of these offshore wind
- 15:30farms. But also we need to balance that
- 15:35with the need to get offshore wind deployed for all the
- 15:37reasons I spoke about earlier. And I think there are some great
- 15:41opportunities both with AI to get more out of the data we
- 15:45have, but also the use of modern technology, use of aerial
- 15:49drones, underwater drones to build and keep updated our macro
- 15:55picture of the, the health of the of our marine estate, both
- 15:59the North Sea and, and the rest of EU KS waters.
- 16:03And I think that's a really exciting opportunity to be able
- 16:06to build more data to monitor better at much lower cost and
- 16:10much higher frequency. So it's the early days in that,
- 16:13but I think that's going to be a real game changer over the
- 16:15coming. Years now, I wanted to jump in
- 16:16on what you said about data because it strikes me that
- 16:19gathering and using data is part of the job.
- 16:22We've talked about all the different stakeholders that
- 16:25we're looking to work with. You know, could you talk maybe a
- 16:28bit about the importance of data sharing, not just between
- 16:32developers? Because it strikes me that
- 16:34sharing data between developers will be vital to developing a
- 16:37sort of systematic approach to to offshore wind deployment, but
- 16:41also engaging all the various ocean users that need to be part
- 16:48of the journey. Yeah.
- 16:48Should I come in a bit on that And Ben just touched on some of
- 16:51this. So fully agree and there's a
- 16:53risk we end up agreeing too much better.
- 16:55So I'll, I'll come back on some of it in a second.
- 16:58But the First off data is absolutely critical.
- 17:03Now we what we're doing at the moment is trying to map the
- 17:08seabed. So we're taking the seabed and
- 17:10and getting down to essentially 1 kilometre hexagons as it
- 17:14happens of the whole entire seabed that's mapping
- 17:20essentially an area about three times the size of England's
- 17:22landmass. So the other part of the Crown
- 17:24Estate, we have a property business, We have buildings in
- 17:27central London, across the country.
- 17:28We have holdings on land. We know the value of a building
- 17:33in one part of our portfolio compared to another.
- 17:36And everyone would actually the question is across the sea,
- 17:39what's the value is a different, different question.
- 17:41What's the value for energy, the liberalized cost of energy,
- 17:44what's the value for nature, What's the value potentially for
- 17:46onshore jobs, what's the value for other sectors, whatever
- 17:49that's fishing, etcetera as well.
- 17:52So we are going for a process of through our marine delivery
- 17:57route map of really opening up and trying to get that data in
- 18:00from everyone else to create this kind of digital value map,
- 18:03a digital information map of of the sea bed.
- 18:06As Benyus said, then there's a huge amount of data out there
- 18:08already. So one of the things is how do
- 18:09we get that, make it easier for others to have and use in
- 18:15multiple ways and crucially get to more impact.
- 18:18So if we can prove, for example, bench mentioned O WEC, this is a
- 18:2150 million programme that we've supported at the Crown Estate to
- 18:25drive kind of evidence largely on environmental mitigations
- 18:29around offshore wind. If we can find out actually
- 18:32there's some projects, for example, on, on bird patterns,
- 18:36on measures around underwater noise or sea mammals such as
- 18:39dolphins. You can find out actually once
- 18:41that with this project, this is actually what the mitigations
- 18:44are. This is how it works.
- 18:46Let's not then repeat that for 13 other projects and every
- 18:49single project doing it. Let's make that publicly
- 18:51available, which we do, We have our marine data exchange.
- 18:53So it's all publicly available. But crucially then and a bit
- 18:57where I think we need to go further is if we've proven
- 19:01through data, through AI, through research and evidence,
- 19:04you know, all through one project that it works.
- 19:06Let's not ask every project to go through the same data project
- 19:10proving process when they come to consent.
- 19:13Let's try and actually use that and say, you know what, we've
- 19:15got enough evidence to say this is an approach that works and we
- 19:18can then move faster rather than through the consenting process.
- 19:22We can lower the costs ultimately for consumers as well
- 19:26on those projects. So the data is really, really
- 19:28important, but it needs to be across multiple sectors as well.
- 19:33The bid I think in what we're pushing and I think some of the
- 19:36change that we need to be doing is using that data then to
- 19:38really drive those systems issues upfront.
- 19:41So whilst I think developers are fantastic, they're brilliant at
- 19:46many, many things. They're brilliant at raising
- 19:48capital, you know, they're brilliant at at innovating.
- 19:50They're brilliant at building turbines or managing supply
- 19:53chains around those. They're deploying at sea in
- 19:56incredible conditions, you know, in terms of how they've helped
- 20:01to drive. You know, the, the growth in the
- 20:03UK sector on globally, on offshore wind.
- 20:06We're also asking developers, I have been asking developers to,
- 20:09by the way, could you also be strategic planners for the
- 20:11Ministry of Defence? Could you also be, by the way,
- 20:15planners for environment and nature?
- 20:17Could you also, by the way, be planners for and, and deal with
- 20:21a whole host of other sectors? Now actually if we flip that on
- 20:24its head, we can make this a lot sharper.
- 20:26How could we actually solve some of the systems up issues
- 20:29upfront? So we're planning the space with
- 20:31all those other partners in that front, but potentially we're
- 20:34looking at, you know, how do we get the right data?
- 20:36So maybe some of those surveys are covered in upfront.
- 20:38We maybe have cleared what we call habitats regulation
- 20:41assessments and some of the environmental assessments
- 20:44upfront. We're de conflicting with other
- 20:46sectors. So developers do what you do
- 20:48brilliantly, but actually let's then solve some of the systems
- 20:51issues as a system level. And Ben just talked a bit about
- 20:53this, things like the Marine recovery fund coming in, you
- 20:56know, to take some of the things rather than each project trying
- 20:58to solve something, actually being able to deal with
- 21:01compensation measures in a strategic way, how we deal with
- 21:04some of those systemic issues, that's a really important shift
- 21:08that we need to to drive forward.
- 21:10I hope you don't mind if I start trying to bring in some
- 21:12negativity after you're just far too glowing about the role of
- 21:16the developers. But what would you say are some
- 21:19of the big challenges that we're going to, to need to overcome in
- 21:24order to to move to this new approach?
- 21:27And I'll give you each of you 10 lbs if you see that the other
- 21:30one is the challenge. So I want my tenner.
- 21:33Gus, you're the challenge. No, I think it is a really
- 21:37difficult question this and Gus has talked about the new
- 21:40approach the Crown Estate is taking and I think absolutely
- 21:45right. We need to find smarter ways to
- 21:48get the macro picture of what's going on in the environment.
- 21:51As Gus has said that the North Sea in particular is in a
- 21:54parlour state. Environmentally, we need to work
- 21:56together to solve this. I think the challenge we're
- 21:59working through with the Crown Estate at the moment is exactly
- 22:02as we come to new leasing rounds, how do we split the
- 22:06work? To put it really crudely, how
- 22:08much of the Crown Estate do in terms of getting the macro
- 22:11picture before projects or bits of seabed are made available
- 22:16through whatever process that's going to be to developers to
- 22:19then take forward as project specific activities.
- 22:23And I think one of the challenges that we're wrestling
- 22:25with, and this is a strong debate between the Crown Estate
- 22:28and developers is where is the right line to draw between what
- 22:31the Crown Estate should be doing in terms of environmental
- 22:34assessment, data gathering and, and, and assessment before the
- 22:39seabed becomes available to the developers?
- 22:41Because there's a ton of expertise in the developer
- 22:45community. I mean, my team of, of
- 22:47environmental professionals just in the UK is 50 strong, for
- 22:51example, That's all about consenting through the
- 22:55development, the construction, and then the operational phases
- 22:58of our wind farms. So there's a lot of expertise,
- 23:02but also we know that the data that you need and how you
- 23:05interpret and respond to it is very much driven by the
- 23:08specifics of how you're designing your wind farm.
- 23:10And it's a very iterative process.
- 23:12So we get the data, we look at it and say, OK, how can we
- 23:16mitigate any impacts that are implied by that data by, for
- 23:20example, increasing the height of our turbines so that birds
- 23:23can fly underneath? There are many, many mitigations
- 23:26that we can apply through the mitigation hierarchy, but
- 23:28they're very much driven by how you design A wind farm in
- 23:33detail. So I think that is a debate that
- 23:35carries on. It's a constructive debate and
- 23:37I'm sure we'll land in a good place eventually, but we're
- 23:40we're we're not there yet. Yeah, I I'm sure Gus will have a
- 23:44perspective. On that, yeah, well, Michael, I
- 23:46won't take you up on the 10 LB offer because I'm covered by the
- 23:49Bribery Act. But anyway, yeah, I did my.
- 23:52Business compliance course yesterday so I can't have the.
- 23:5510 lbs Either Michael, I'm joking.
- 23:58Thank goodness, because I'm a journalist so my salary doesn't
- 24:00cover £20 worth of breaks. Between us, between us, we won't
- 24:05take the 10 LB, but we will take the challenge on it.
- 24:08So taking a step back, you know, we we Ben just touch on this a
- 24:12little bit. There is what we essentially my
- 24:14view is we're at this point in time now where and particularly
- 24:17when we look at what's happening across the world, we are seeing
- 24:22a huge opportunity but also a huge risk for the offshore wind
- 24:24market and particularly the offshore wind market in the UK.
- 24:29The huge risk is obviously we're seeing turbulence and volatility
- 24:33in global markets. We're seeing question marks
- 24:35about supply chains, we're seeing tariffs and the impact of
- 24:38those. And we are seeing certain
- 24:41companies and certain investors do a kind of double whammy
- 24:47investment wise or doesn't matter in their decisions.
- 24:49So a lowering the risk threshold and at the same time raising the
- 24:52IRS and that creates a kind of risk of a kind of slowdown or a
- 24:57shutting down of of development and progress.
- 25:02Now the opportunity is, I firmly believe the UK, both with where
- 25:06we started this podcast, incredibly strong position.
- 25:09We've got the track record we've got.
- 25:11And also, you know, it's a stable market.
- 25:13All the things we've got and that we're pushing around how we
- 25:16make it even more attractive in the future.
- 25:18Real moment where actually we can cement the UK as as the
- 25:22country that can carve its way through and become that as many,
- 25:25many developers and or investors around the world are looking
- 25:28for. Where's the safe harbour to do
- 25:30our, you know, investments in and keep that their development
- 25:34chains going in renewable energy, however, and this is the
- 25:39kind of challenge is essentially what we need to be doing, is
- 25:42doing some of that upfront work now to put in place some of
- 25:48those systems issues. And there is potentially a shift
- 25:51that we need to do about who does what in the value chain.
- 25:54A lot of it in the past has been on developers.
- 25:57Not saying it's a simple binary what moves, but it is a really
- 26:00live debate. So we are, for example, at the
- 26:03Crown Estate working with NISO to start panning as part of our
- 26:08leasing rounds, grid connections.
- 26:09So I won't talk about it because we're live at the moment, but
- 26:12just the process on leasing. Round five in the Celtic Sea
- 26:15will be the first offshore wind leasing in the UK that has a
- 26:19target grid connection design, target grid connection dates.
- 26:23Within that we could go further and the Crown Estate, you know,
- 26:26can look at how it supports grid development.
- 26:28I talked about we've also done environmental surveys or
- 26:31geotechnical surveys, for example, in the Celtic Sea.
- 26:34Those are things that traditionally a developer, you
- 26:36know, would do. But we bring that forward to
- 26:39then look at can we solve some of those systemic issues up
- 26:43upfront? Also potentially we are solving
- 26:46some of the bigger systemic issues.
- 26:47You know, do we need to get into a position where we're having to
- 26:50mitigate environmental impact so much?
- 26:52Or can we actually get a forward nature plan for the sea as much
- 26:56as a forward offshore wind plan for the sea to give that
- 27:00certainty, predictability of what's happening and crucially
- 27:04also give a forward deployment plan that also works for supply
- 27:07chain. So I think one of the challenges
- 27:09in the UK is whilst we've got a huge success in terms of turbine
- 27:15spinning, we haven't got a huge success in terms of factory
- 27:20machines spinning or whatever the terminology is.
- 27:22You know, in the UK, you know, there's, there's 32,000 people
- 27:26ish roughly employed in offshore wind around great.
- 27:29That's, that's come from nothing.
- 27:30That's a fantastic success story.
- 27:32But how do we actually show those onshore benefits as
- 27:35crucially as the offshore? Because I think that community
- 27:37connection will be lost and we'll see increasing challenges
- 27:42around community appetite, community support, political
- 27:45support for growing our offshore wind industry if we don't
- 27:51actually also invest into the onshore benefits as well.
- 27:57So from our perspective, we can create some of that forward
- 28:00visibility, show when what's happening whatsoever and we can
- 28:04do some of those systems issues upfront.
- 28:06We can have healthy debates with developers about where that
- 28:09lands, but it also requires developers to take that longer
- 28:13term view as well. These are long term projects and
- 28:17stepping in to actually make those long term improvements to
- 28:20potentially also think about where they can collaborate as an
- 28:22industry as well, particularly when you get to things like
- 28:24ports or when you get to commitments to to the supply
- 28:28chain. And there's you may have seen
- 28:30last year there was a Owick the Wind Industry Council ourselves
- 28:37and Cran City Scotland put a report called the industrial
- 28:40growth plan. There is that collaboration
- 28:42starting. How do we actually move into
- 28:45more of a collaborative place around really driving forward
- 28:48the the onshore benefits and then the sort of system benefits
- 28:52as a whole? Benj, how does all this sound to
- 28:54you as a developer? Is this meeting your needs or is
- 28:59there something that perhaps Gus has not mentioned that you is a
- 29:03key challenge for not just for state as you know a single
- 29:08developer, but for developers in general that that you were
- 29:11hoping that needs to be solved? Yeah, I, I, I would agree with
- 29:15a, a lot of what Gus has just covered.
- 29:17And I think we're, we're touching now on both the need to
- 29:21take the strategic approach for planning the seabed from an
- 29:25environmental perspective, but also from a human interaction
- 29:29perspective. And if you like the, the social
- 29:32and political contract that we have in the UK as we build this
- 29:36offshore wind out to 100 plus gigawatts, I, I think Gus is
- 29:40absolutely right. We need to take a strategic
- 29:43approach. And I'm not going to talk about
- 29:45the strategic spatial energy plan that NISO is doing.
- 29:49I think we've touched enough on that.
- 29:51There is a lot of work that we need to do to be more strategic
- 29:55about other aspects of how offshore wind interacts with the
- 29:59environment. I don't mean biological
- 30:01environment, the whole environment, the human
- 30:03environment where we we operate. And I think we are as a sector
- 30:08ahead of other sectors. If I look at what shipping is
- 30:12doing, if I look at what aggregates is doing, if I look
- 30:14at what oil and gas is doing, I think we're well ahead in terms
- 30:17of the way we approach our impact on the the physical
- 30:20environment. In terms of human interaction.
- 30:23I think we do see progress and we've taken a strategic
- 30:26approach, for example on our interactions with our defence
- 30:29radar through Project New York, working closely with the
- 30:33Ministry of Defence. I think that's really exciting
- 30:35progress that the Industry Council has been able to achieve
- 30:40together with Energy Department and MOD.
- 30:43So we do see these coming through, but there's a lot more
- 30:46to be done across multiple sectors.
- 30:49I would like to touch on fishing because I think it's such an
- 30:51important topic. We it's a challenging area
- 30:57because if you want to talk about defence, you can talk to
- 31:00the MOD. If you want to talk about
- 31:01shipping, there are good trade bodies you can work with.
- 31:04The challenge with fishing is we have the NFFO and the Scottish
- 31:09FFO as well and we work with them, but it's a much harder
- 31:13sector to engage with strategically.
- 31:14And I think we need to do some work there to find better ways
- 31:18of solving the inter interplay between offshore wind and
- 31:21fishing. I mean we've got some great
- 31:23examples that we've done at the project level.
- 31:25For example, on our westernmost rough project off the East
- 31:27Yorkshire coast, we work really closely with the Holderness
- 31:30Fishing Industry Group. We make sure that they know
- 31:34where they can put their pots down because they know where
- 31:36we're operating. And so we can we coexist very
- 31:39successfully there. I think that's a great example
- 31:42of successful coexistence, but there's a lot more we can do.
- 31:46The Crown Estate some years ago put together a process for
- 31:51helping develop offshore wind developers and fishers work
- 31:55together, I think called Flow. I think we need to really get
- 31:59back on, get that back on track. It's very difficult for us as an
- 32:03offshore wind developer to work to solutions because we, we are
- 32:05literally negotiating with every individual Fisher who may have
- 32:10fished or currently fishes in the within the wind farm
- 32:13footprint. So definitely improvements
- 32:15there. And we know fishing is a is
- 32:18whilst economically a small part of the economy is culturally
- 32:22absolutely essential, particularly these smaller
- 32:25Fisher vessels. They're a vital part of coastal
- 32:29communities. And we need to make sure that we
- 32:31we work with them to find solutions that, that are
- 32:34effective and fair across both parties there.
- 32:39I think there's there's so much more that we we can do
- 32:42strategically in other areas. But perhaps I don't want to
- 32:46digress too far from the the topic of environment, but I
- 32:49would just find finally want to touch on some of the supply
- 32:52chain and community work. There is a lot that we're
- 32:57already doing. If I look at what Austin's
- 32:58doing, you know, we're working with over 240 suppliers across
- 33:02the UK. Sixty of them we've already
- 33:04taken into our projects overseas into Taiwan, into the US So we
- 33:09do see some fantastic capability in the supply chain that's all
- 33:13the way from north of Aberdeen all the way down to Cornwall.
- 33:17This is creating jobs right across the UK, but there's a lot
- 33:21more that we can do and I think this strategic approach that Gus
- 33:24mentioned through the industrial growth plan is has the potential
- 33:29to be a game changer, not least now the government has stepped
- 33:31forward and put £300 million through GB Energy to support
- 33:36that. So I'm feeling optimistic there.
- 33:39It's also engaging with communities.
- 33:41We have a massive footprint in Grimsby.
- 33:43We've got about 600 people in our operation space there
- 33:46servicing our North Sea wind farms and we're doing a lot in
- 33:50that local and regional community.
- 33:53Things like 1,000,000 lbs gone into the youth zone programme to
- 33:58support youth through their their journey into adulthood and
- 34:03into the workplace. We have a community benefit fund
- 34:07up and down the East Coast that's helped dozens and dozens
- 34:11of community projects. So we are doing a lot there.
- 34:14Also on education, I think apprenticeships is a big topic
- 34:17as well that the industry needs to step into.
- 34:20We we do have a big apprenticeship program and it's
- 34:22one that is very popular and we have huge interests every time
- 34:25we recruit. So very excited about recruiting
- 34:29into the Hornsey Three team that will be coming soon.
- 34:33So I think we are doing as individual developers quite a
- 34:35lot. The challenge of collaboration
- 34:38is that we do fiercely compete when it comes to the allocation
- 34:43of contracts for different. So we have to find the places
- 34:46where we can collaborate and the places where we need to compete
- 34:50fiercely to make sure that we're giving the best value to
- 34:53consumers as we build that offshore wind.
- 34:55As we come I think to the end of this, I just wanted to make my
- 34:58final question. As you've both mentioned we so
- 35:02UK has a leading position in offshore wind.
- 35:06That one I think that we're looking to keep.
- 35:10We have ambitious clean energy goals, not just for 20-30, but
- 35:14beyond. If we take this new systematic
- 35:16approach that you've been discussing, what from each of
- 35:21your perspectives does that look like for the rest of the
- 35:23country? What are the benefits it would
- 35:25bring? And if you sort of, you know,
- 35:27cast your mind 5-10 years into the future, what are the sort of
- 35:32benefits that it would bring? Gus, you want to go first.
- 35:35So I think if we shift to an approach where we actually have
- 35:38a proper strategic plan going forward, and as Ben just
- 35:41mentioned, we've got that shift happening on our electricity
- 35:44system for the SSEP. We're creating a marine delivery
- 35:47route map for the whole of the sea space.
- 35:49What I'd love to see is that actually we have, we've shifted
- 35:53from 2 core things that are happening at the moment.
- 35:55We have a pass to baton approach to development.
- 35:58You know, so everything starts from when we're at the moment,
- 36:00one part of that baton, here's some sea bed, pass it to the
- 36:02developer, then it moves into consenting, it moves into grid
- 36:05connection, it moves, it's passing the baton all the way
- 36:08along. And then it gets to can we have
- 36:10a port? Well, the port hasn't developed
- 36:11for the last five years. So now we've got the delay there
- 36:14or supply chain hasn't developed till everyone's ready and lined
- 36:17up all of their batons to make a contract to actually a moving
- 36:22with firm fast intent from the beginning.
- 36:25So how do we sort of solve those issues up front as we've been
- 36:28talking about then everybody can move.
- 36:31We can get those that supply chain developing, we can get the
- 36:33big infrastructure investments that we need.
- 36:36With that, I would love to then go round the country and be able
- 36:38to see even more jobs, even more growth.
- 36:41All of those you know, apprenticeships now thriving
- 36:43etcetera as Ben just talked about.
- 36:44There are, you know, great things as Ben just talked about.
- 36:47But we know we can also do more. We for example at the Crown
- 36:49Estate launched last year, a supply chain accelerator, £50
- 36:53million towards launched the first phase and currently in the
- 36:56second phase. The first phase has got us 13
- 36:59different projects and companies investing in to help scale up.
- 37:02But we we know that can be a lot more as we go forward.
- 37:06The other bit then is that we've also broken this kind of head to
- 37:08head approach, head to head between nature and an offshore
- 37:12wind, head to head between say, you know, fishing and, and other
- 37:15sectors or offshore wind. Head to head between, you know,
- 37:18other users of the sea space, whether that's defence,
- 37:20shipping, you know, other, other sectors as well to an aligned
- 37:25view and an agreed plan of we're going to get there and we're all
- 37:28going to do that now. We'll need everybody to actually
- 37:31be open about sharing their data to think longer term about what
- 37:34their sector really needs. And we've touched on some of
- 37:36those sectors to think through, including, you know, the
- 37:38evidence and data of what we need to be doing for natural
- 37:41world or fishing industry as well.
- 37:43But also everybody to maybe accept I'm not going to get
- 37:47everything I want. I may need to actually get a
- 37:50bigger win overall by working out how we play this all
- 37:53together rather than I just want my exact top spot and everyone
- 37:57get out of the way. That's a a challenge we're going
- 37:59to have to approach as an industry as a whole, but across
- 38:01all sectors. If we get that though, I would
- 38:04love us to be able to have the market that has the increased
- 38:08certainty of what's coming and what's being developed,
- 38:13increased predictability that if you get a project, you can
- 38:16develop it. You know, you have close to 0
- 38:19attrition rates on, on offshore developments.
- 38:23We have faster consenting because the issues are solved
- 38:26upfront, aren't there. And we have increased
- 38:29visibility. We set out a forward pipeline of
- 38:31what's coming now when roughly, you know roughly how noting we
- 38:35need innovation as we go because then that can trigger the the
- 38:40certainty or visibility that's needed for someone to invest in
- 38:43a factory, invest in a port, invest in the skills programme
- 38:46or somebody who's saying, I think I want to transition into
- 38:48renewable energy. Are those projects going to be
- 38:50there in 5-10 years as well? So that's what I'd love to see.
- 38:55And I think we are at a turning point where we can push that,
- 38:59but turn this around into, you know, could we sit here in 25
- 39:04years, might all be retired and not talking on a podcast, but
- 39:08could we do but actually reflect that the next 25 years we've
- 39:13gone even further, even faster and got even more benefits out
- 39:16of this incredible industry for the UK than the first 25 years.
- 39:20And I believe we can do it, but we need to switch to some of
- 39:22those more systemic and strategic approaches.
- 39:25If I could jump in on on this point, I would agree with a lot
- 39:30of what like us has just said, we do need and we are taking new
- 39:35approaches, more strategic approaches both to environmental
- 39:41work, but also coexistence and being more of a part of the
- 39:46communities where we operate and being a bigger contributor to
- 39:50the UKPLC bottom line through growth in the supply chain.
- 39:56We just want to come back to environment in particular, we
- 39:59very much see in Austin that offshore winds can be a force
- 40:02for good both for climate and biodiversity.
- 40:06And I think there's a lot of debate about, you know,
- 40:09trade-offs and just there is of course always compromise.
- 40:13But I do believe very strongly that if we deploy offshore wind
- 40:17in the right way, we can use that if we're smart to also
- 40:21enhance the state of nature. And one of the things we've done
- 40:25is in 2021, we set out an ambition that from 2030, every
- 40:29project we Commission will have a net positive biodiversity
- 40:32impact. It's a huge challenge.
- 40:35And I've got a team working on this and we're well on the on
- 40:38the path to being able to deliver that very exciting stuff
- 40:42we've we're doing in terms of how do you measure biodiversity
- 40:45in the marine environment. And we welcome input.
- 40:48You can see that on our website. Please, please give us your
- 40:51thoughts. But we're also running a whole
- 40:53load of programs to test out different tools.
- 40:56And I would just point point people to a couple if they're
- 40:58interested in having a look. One's called RE Coral.
- 41:00It's in Taiwan where we're very experimentally seeing if we can
- 41:04grow coral on the legs of turbines because that puts you
- 41:09in an environment where you are able to be near enough the
- 41:13surface to get the light, but far enough from the coast to get
- 41:18stable temperatures. So in theory, ideal conditions
- 41:22for growing coral, let's see how that goes.
- 41:24But close to home in the Humber, we've got a a whole seascape
- 41:28programme of restoration called Wilder Humber.
- 41:30We're working with the Lincolnshire and Yorkshire
- 41:33Wildlife Trusts and we're planting seagrass, a number of
- 41:36hectares of seagrass, We're restoring salt marsh, we're
- 41:39putting in half a million native oysters into the Humber to help
- 41:42clean it up. And those programmes are are
- 41:45great because they enable us to have that positive biodiversity
- 41:49impact, but they also engage with communities.
- 41:52And we've seen fantastic response, particularly on the
- 41:55north side of the Humber at Spurn Point where we're doing a
- 41:58lot of this work. It's generated a huge amount of
- 42:01interest. It's an opportunity for people
- 42:03in the area to reconnect with nature.
- 42:05We're seeing school trips, we're seeing all kinds of different
- 42:08community groups going there and just understanding how nature is
- 42:12being restored. And I think that's a really,
- 42:14really positive move for us. I look forward to doing a
- 42:20podcast in 2050 with with Gus and seeing where we've got to.
- 42:24I think we are on the right track.
- 42:25And I think long before we get to 2050, we will because we have
- 42:29to solve this. This question of how we'd be,
- 42:32how are we going to take a more strategic approach and deliver
- 42:35for nature as well As for energy security and climate and jobs
- 42:40and communities, I think might sound like Nirvana.
- 42:43But I do believe we can deliver all of that if we take the right
- 42:46approach. And I think we're on the right
- 42:47track now. Thank you very much, Gus and
- 42:49Bend, for joining me. I've been Michael Bayer and this
- 42:52has been Gigawaters. Don't forget to listen out for
- 42:54the 4th episode of the series. But in the meantime, you can
- 42:57subscribe to our regular Energy Voice Out Live series on your
- 43:00podcast platform of choice.