Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Forced Treatment And The Charter
Transcript
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: Yeah, this is a very interesting and significant decision.
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: And it comes from a uh challenge brought by a group called the Council for Canadians with Disabilities.
- 0:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and it was a constitutional challenge to the process we have in British Columbia to uh make treatment decisions about administering treatment to somebody who is an involuntary patient under the Mental Health Act.
- 0:56Michael Mulligan: Uh and the particular uh challenge was brought on the basis of an alleged breach of Section 7, which is the right to life, liberty, and security of the person.
- 1:06Michael Mulligan: Um of interest, the challenge brought was not a challenge to the process whereby uh a person can become an involuntary patient in a mental health facility.
- 1:18Michael Mulligan: Uh and broadly speaking, as we've talked about before, there's authority under the Mental Health Act to have somebody involuntarily uh admitted and to become a patient if they have a per if they're a person with a mental disorder, and this is simplifying it a bit, but are a danger to themselves or others, right?
- 1:36Michael Mulligan: There's a bit more flowery language around that, but that's really what it amounts to.
- 1:40Michael Mulligan: Um and there's a process in the Mental Health Act uh that involves various sorts of assessments and reviews to determine whether you are that sort of a person who can be involuntarily admitted.
- 1:52Michael Mulligan: Now, the that was not challenged in this piece of litigation.
- 1:57Michael Mulligan: What was challenged uh was the uh process that's in place to uh then impose involuntary treatment on somebody who has been involuntarily admitted.
- 2:10Michael Mulligan: Um and that's what was challenged.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: And as the judge pointed out, and this is quite a decision, it goes it's uh hundreds of pages, um, it is uh uh the case that the idea that a person has autonomy over their own body and is able to freely determine whether they wish medical treatment is something that is pretty deeply routed rooted in our common law.
- 2:34Michael Mulligan: Uh and that's true, right?
- 2:35Michael Mulligan: I think most people would sort of in instinctively realize that that's so, right?
- 2:39Michael Mulligan: Your ability to say, yeah, I want that treatment, surgery, or whatever it might be, and your ability to say, I don't want that, or stop treating me, uh is pretty integral to a person's sort of autonomy and dignity and so on, right?
- 2:52Michael Mulligan: Um and so that's the starting point that the judge applied when analyzing uh the constitutionality of how that system worked in BC.
- 3:01Michael Mulligan: And when this legislation started, and right up to just before the submissions were being done in this very long, complicated trial, uh, there was a change in the legislation, which was really interesting.
- 3:14Michael Mulligan: The way it worked all the way up to right at the end of this trial, and you have to wonder whether the change might have been perhaps uh prompted by the trial itself, that's uh not an unknown state of affairs, is that when a person became an involuntary patient, right, the the through that process of determining that they're a risk to themselves or others, the legislation then essentially deemed them to have consented to whatever medical treatment the doctors were wanting to impose.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: Now that's pretty broad.
- 3:45Michael Mulligan: Um and some of the uh treatment uh that can be uh imposed on somebody under the Mental Health Act can have pretty significant implications, like you know, medications that have side effects.
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: Uh we even do things like uh, you know, uh uh uh shock treatments are administered to some patients.
- 4:04Michael Mulligan: You know, they can have impacts on the person's, you know, memory and all kinds of things, right?
- 4:09Michael Mulligan: And so those are pretty uh intrusive treatments sometimes that are imposed.
- 4:14Michael Mulligan: Now, there are some cases where you would have a person who would be incapable of determining whether they can consent or not.
- 4:22Michael Mulligan: But the fact that you are have a mental disorder, and indeed the fact that, for example, there's a determination that you might be uh a risk yourself, doesn't necessarily mean that you are incapable of making decisions about the treatment you're gonna receive, right?
- 4:38Michael Mulligan: You know, a person could, you know, have a mental uh health condition which is coming and going, for example, uh, and they could be at some point in the position where they might be able to make a rational choice about, hey, I don't want that medication, it has these terrible side effects, or I don't want the shock treatment, or you know, I want to have this medication or that medication or whatever.
- 4:58Michael Mulligan: Um, and the way this legislation worked is they was just too bad.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: They just do what they want to you once you're admitted as an involuntary patient.
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: That provision the government repealed right as this our thing was being uh uh argued, uh section 31 of the Mental Health Act, they repealed it in the last days of the trial.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: Uh and so you might think, well, surely that's it then.
- 5:21Michael Mulligan: Now where does that leave us?
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: But that's not the end of it, because there's another section of the act that remains, uh, and it's the section that's being relied upon now, and it's the section that allows a uh director to authorize treatments that the person doesn't want.
- 5:38Michael Mulligan: Uh and you know, there's a proceed, there's a scheme those people are to consider when determining whether to approve something, but that doesn't involve the person.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: It involves sort of uh, you know, decision made by uh another individual.
- 5:52Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 5:52Michael Mulligan: Now that part of the challenge continued, and it succeeded.
- 5:58Michael Mulligan: Uh and it succeeded on the basis that uh, first of all, they found that this was a breach of section seven allowing, you know, this director to approve treatments you know contrary to a patient's wishes without any meaningful process to determine whether they are somebody who's capable of making those decisions themselves, or you can have other circumstances.
- 6:18Michael Mulligan: Like, for example, a person could in advance, you know, when they're in a position where they could do those things, express their wishes.
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: That's that's not uncommon, right?
- 6:27Michael Mulligan: A person could express the desire for medical treatment at a point in time in their life when they're uh competent and capable of making those decisions, you know, in terms of what they do and do not want.
- 6:38Michael Mulligan: Or, for example, you could designate somebody else, like a family member or friend or somebody else to make those decisions for you.
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: Uh and the the scheme of having this director make the decisions uh just bypassed all of that.
- 6:52Michael Mulligan: And of interest, as the judge pointed out, BC is an outlier.
- 6:56Michael Mulligan: Every other jurisdiction in Canada uh has a process in place whereby there would be a separate determination about whether the person is competent or capable of making treatment decisions, uh, and whatever variety of different approaches in terms of those other kinds of things, like the advanced direction or family member deciding uh those things, uh trusted person uh for you.
- 7:15Michael Mulligan: And BC had none of that.
- 7:17Michael Mulligan: Um and so the judge found, and I should say the government argued that yes, if this is a breach, it's justified under section one of the charter, right?
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: That's that one about you know reasonable limits and so on.
- 7:30Michael Mulligan: But when analyzing a section one argument, saying, hey, if we breach this, this was a sort of an acceptable limit in a free and democratic society.
- 7:37Michael Mulligan: One of the parts of that test is whether it's kind of like the least intrusive way you could do that, right?
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: And so even though the judge agreed that, yeah, there's a pressing and substantial need to provide treatment to people who may not, you know, maybe in danger themselves or others and may or may not be in a position to um determine those things themselves, uh, that the approach of just saying, sorry, the director's gonna decide isn't the minimally intrusive way to do that.
- 8:04Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the judge found that section one was not sufficient to save uh these uh provisions in in British Columbia, and so found that those the remaining provisions, the impugne provisions in section eight, um uh have been found to be unconstitutional uh and of no force and effect.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: Now, the judge did give the has given the province six months to decide what to do with that, has suspended the uh implementation of this decision for that period of time.
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: And as the judge correctly pointed out, um it's not the court's task to try to make some of those, you know, nuanced public policy decisions about what's the best or most effective or most just uh appropriate way of determining how involuntary medical treatment ought to be provided, right?
- 8:55Michael Mulligan: There are lots of likely constitutionally permissible uh ways you could accomplish that, right?
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: You know, do you want to have some process so the person could appeal at, or some process to determine capacity, or you know, you the government might choose to have some process whereby, you know, if there's something like the representation agreement in place already, or prior uh authorization for some treatment but not others, that those things ought to be taken into account, or that's how it should be sorted out.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: And so even though this is a very detailed assessment of you know what was going on and whether the current scheme of just allowing the director to decide uh these things, uh that's been found to be unconstitutional.
- 9:34Michael Mulligan: But the judge, think quite properly, didn't try to figure out what should replace it, other than to say it's gotta be replaced.
- 9:41Michael Mulligan: You can't just have a blanket process, even though they got rid of that deemed consent to everything.
- 9:47Michael Mulligan: Uh that isn't uh that that doesn't answer what would be permissible, and so it's now over to the government to decide what to do with that.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: Um and so it will be very interesting to see what comes of this, right?
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: One approach the government could take is to say, oh, take this all to heart, say, yeah, okay, we've had this uh 34-day trial with 14 experts and 22 expert reports and uh you know hundreds of pages of analysis of it, and yeah, you're right, we should probably get this thing into uh, you know, this century.
- 10:17Michael Mulligan: Uh that could be an approach.
- 10:18Michael Mulligan: Um, or uh another approach could be uh that they choose to appeal it.
- 10:22Michael Mulligan: And and that may happen as well.
- 10:24Michael Mulligan: As the judge pointed out, there are sort of pretty uh sort of extreme claims uh made by uh counsel in terms of uh how the wheels would come off the bus if this was found to be unconstitutional, although apparently every other province has figured out a way to make it work in a constitutionally compliant fashion.
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: But the other approach could be uh an appeal of it.
- 10:44Michael Mulligan: And so we'll have to wait and see.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: They've got uh the ordinarily of 30 days to appeal the decision, uh, and the judge has given them six months, and so what'll happen now is the province will need to figure out are they going to uh amend the legislation to uh address uh those concerns and come up with a uh a meaningful process to separately determine capacity to make the treatment decisions, uh separate from should you be admitted, right?
- 11:09Michael Mulligan: Doesn't get you out of the hospital, it just means you know they can't force the shock treatment on you uh without some process in place to determine whether you're competent to decide whether that's something you want done to yourself, or some other process in place like the ones we talked about, right?
- 11:25Michael Mulligan: Family member prior uh indication of what treatment is you you wish, uh, or whether they wish to uh challenge this and try to maintain uh a system where a government uh uh person, a director, could uh authorize treatment uh despite the patient's wishes and despite any of those other things uh that the person might uh do to have somebody make that uh decision for them.
- 11:48Michael Mulligan: And so that's the latest out of the BC Court of Appeal on how uh we're going to deal with um involuntary treatment of people who are uh admitted for uh mental health issues into hospitals in British Columbia.
- 12:00Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Morgan Defense Lawyers legally speaking will continue right after this.
- 12:04Adam Stirling: Michael up next to our Canada Supreme Court of Canada finds that the government cannot legislatively prevent judicial review on administrative decisions.
- 12:13Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: It's an important decision, I should say, and the origin of this thing came out of the some uh keen uh uh keen listeners may recall uh a number of years ago now, there was an issue about then Prime Minister Trudeau uh involving himself uh in funding decisions for a charity that he was involved in called the WE Charity.
- 12:36Michael Mulligan: The WE are both capitalized, amusingly, the WE Charity.
- 12:40Michael Mulligan: Um and there was a review of his participation in these funding decisions, given his involvement with the charity itself, uh, under the Conflict of Interest Act.
- 12:50Michael Mulligan: Uh and that act uh provides for a commissioner to do an assessment as to whether there was a conflict of interest in a decision like that.
- 12:58Michael Mulligan: And the conflict of interest commissioner uh determined uh that they it was fine.
- 13:04Michael Mulligan: There wasn't a conflict, that was the conclusion.
- 13:06Michael Mulligan: That uh uh conclusion uh was challenged by a group called Democracy Watch.
- 13:12Michael Mulligan: Um, and they were given public interest standing, and they challenged uh that uh finding of the commissioner.
- 13:18Michael Mulligan: Now, the government, interestingly, relied on a section of that conflict of interest act uh which limits the capacity to uh have a judicial review of factual and legal findings under that uh legislation.
- 13:33Michael Mulligan: Section 66 purported to do that.
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: Um and relying upon that section of the uh conflict of interest uh uh act, uh the court and then the federal court of appeal uh found that uh they didn't have uh jurisdiction to uh conduct a judicial review into uh the decision of the commissioner about whether the prime minister was in a conflict.
- 13:58Michael Mulligan: Um and they suggested that uh the political process would be a uh potentially uh satisfactory way for the public to respond to their views of uh his involvement in making that decision.
- 14:11Michael Mulligan: And so that's the factual matrix that went off to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 14:15Michael Mulligan: And as the Supreme Court of Canada pointed out right at the outset of their decision appropriately, uh, is that the rule of law is a fundamental uh part of our constitutional structure.
- 14:26Michael Mulligan: Um and one of the components of the rule of law is to ensure that when the public power is being exercised, it needs to be possible to determine whether it's being done legally.
- 14:37Michael Mulligan: Otherwise, what does the rule of law really mean, right?
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: And if you could just insert into a piece of legislation a provision that says you can't challenge this by way of judicial review, you would then live in a topsy turvy world where you could have government officials making decisions about things, and there would be no way to go to court and determine whether what they were doing was legal or not.
- 15:00Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the way the court approached this um is uh under the is a consideration of section ninety-six of the uh Constitution Act.
- 15:11Michael Mulligan: And section ninety-six, when you just read it, you say, well, what does this uh say?
- 15:16Michael Mulligan: It says this, section ninety-six.
- 15:18Michael Mulligan: The governor general shall appoint the judges of the superior district and county courts of each province, except those in the court of probate in Nova Scotia, New Brunswick.
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: What does that mean?
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: It's kind of gobbledygook.
- 15:30Michael Mulligan: But it talks about the appointment process, and then there's another section that deals with the protections for those kinds of judges.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: Like they can't just be fired if the government doesn't like them.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: There's a process we've got to have a resolution of the House of Commons and Senate to remove a judge for cause.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: And that section, those sections would be pretty meaningless if you could just take away all the powers of superior court judges or assign all the powers to the you know prime minister's aide or something to uh make those decisions, right?
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: And so courts have over the years found that those sections to be meaningful, uh, and they are meaningful because you then have a superior court with judges that can't just be fired when the government doesn't like what they're doing, for example.
- 16:13Michael Mulligan: Um uh and you also can't have a circumstance where the government could just transfer all the powers to somebody else and then have none of those people, for example.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: That would also be a way to circumvent uh having an independent judiciary.
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: And so the courts have over the years interpreted those sections to say, well, you you can't take away the fundamental powers of those judges, otherwise the section is meaningless if you could then just have a bunch of you know political appointees deciding all the things that the Supreme Court judges used to decide.
- 16:42Michael Mulligan: Uh and so what the Supreme Court of Canada was dealing with here is that whether that uh the jurisdiction to conduct judicial reviews, which are to assess whether, for example, a decision made by the government is is there whether there's jurisdiction for it, right?
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: You know, was this properly federal or provincial, or did the legislation allow this kind of a decision, or was the decision a reasonable one, right?
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: That the uh that is a uh authority of a superior court which cannot be taken away by the government or just transferred to somebody else.
- 17:18Michael Mulligan: Uh and it's not satisfactory to say, well, I guess there'll be some political implication if you decide to pass sub-legislation uh or have uh government officials making decisions that are unreasonable or may or may not be in accordance with the legislation.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: It's not sufficient to say, yeah, there might be a political consequence to those kinds of actions.
- 17:39Michael Mulligan: That section, section 96 of the Constitution Act, uh guarantees things, including uh the power of Superior Court judges to conduct judicial reviews.
- 17:50Michael Mulligan: And uh a judicial review is not just on jurisdiction, it cannot be the case that the government can just legislatively, like section 66 would have provided, to say, well, you just cannot review uh the facts found or the law uh determining whether, for example, a decision was reasonable.
- 18:09Michael Mulligan: You're just not allowed to take that away by just inserting that provision into a piece of legislation.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: Uh and so it's important, I guess I would say that, uh, this decision.
- 18:19Michael Mulligan: And it goes well beyond uh the narrow facts of the case.
- 18:22Michael Mulligan: Uh it just makes clear that there is a constitutional right to judicial review bound up in that uh concept of the rule of law, uh, and you cannot uh substitute the fact that there could be a political consequence, uh, and you're not allowed to just insert uh some legislative provision that says you can't challenge this.
- 18:43Michael Mulligan: I must say, sometimes you see those sort of things in legislation, you're sort of like, really?
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: Did you really think that's how this was going to work out?
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: Did you really think you could just insert some provision that says, you know, this can't be challenged effectively?
- 18:55Michael Mulligan: Did you think that was going to carry the day?
- 18:57Michael Mulligan: And so we now have clear authority from the Supreme Court of Canada uh defining uh what uh the scope of judicial review is and the fact that that is one of the core uh functions of a superior court uh judge, uh, and by oper by necessary implication, Section 96 of the Constitution Act doesn't allow the government to limit or prevent that.
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: Uh and so, with the benefit of that finding, the case has now been sent back uh so that there can be an assessment uh of whether the decision made by the conflict of interest commissioner uh was lawful, uh, and uh the court uh will have clear authority to do that.
- 19:38Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada, uh the case brought by Democracy Watch in uh a decision that will have uh bigger implications in terms of how government can be held uh to uh ensure that their decisions are lawful, reasonable, and uh within their jurisdiction.
- 19:55Adam Stirling: Michael Mulgan with Mulgan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 20:00Adam Stirling: Thanks so much for the time.
- 20:02Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 20:03Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 20:03Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.