Latest / The So What? / South Africa's Water Crisis and the Reform Agenda
Transcript
- 0:05Hello, and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jpluntman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:26This conversation goes with JP's newsletter dated
- 0:30the 4th of April 2025 and titled South Africa's
- 0:34Water Crisis and the Reform Agenda. JP, your
- 0:38first point is that we as South Africans don't
- 0:42have water to waste, but we do. What are the
- 0:45facts behind that? Yeah, indeed. South Africa
- 0:48is one of the 30 driest countries in the world.
- 0:51Now, if you consider that there are more than
- 0:53190 countries in the world, It gives you a clear
- 0:56idea where we fit in. It's a dry country and
- 0:58we're dependent on irregular and intermittent
- 1:00rainfall. Why do I say we waste it? Because our
- 1:05average consumption per person in South Africa
- 1:08is running at 233 liters per day per person,
- 1:13per capita consumption, 233. The global average
- 1:17is 173. In Gateng alone, just that province,
- 1:21we... Our consumption is approaching 300 liters
- 1:24per person per day. So consumer awareness about
- 1:27water in South Africa is very, very low, and
- 1:29that will certainly have to change. One of the
- 1:31contributing factors is, of course, the fact
- 1:33that the water is so cheap. If it was the cost
- 1:37of wine or beer, then we wouldn't waste it like
- 1:41that. But the fact remains our consumption per
- 1:44person per day is way above the global average.
- 1:48But there's also something called non -revenue
- 1:50water. What is that and how do we score on that?
- 1:54We score badly. First, what is it? It's water
- 1:58which is billed to municipalities and which municipalities
- 2:01distribute, but for which no income is coming
- 2:04in. And that sits at 47 % of total water supply.
- 2:09That's a very huge percentage. And again, it's
- 2:12almost half. And again, it's way above the global
- 2:15average. Middle -income countries like South
- 2:18Africa, that number is sitting at about 30%.
- 2:21In some countries, it's higher. For example,
- 2:25in Mexico, it's sitting at between 40 % and 50%.
- 2:28In Kenya and Nairobi, it's sitting at 45%. So
- 2:32for South Africa, to sit at 47 % is a higher
- 2:36percentage. And that's burst pipes and that kind
- 2:40of thing? It's burst pipes, it's illegal connections
- 2:44or theft, of which there's a lot, all over society,
- 2:49from residences, from farms, from factories,
- 2:53where people don't actually pay for the water
- 2:56that they extract. So there are a variety of
- 2:59reasons, but I think the main one would be poor
- 3:02maintenance and poor infrastructure. Actually,
- 3:05the infrastructure is not that poor, but poorly
- 3:07maintained infrastructure. That is what's causing
- 3:10a lot of the non -revenue water. Well, at least
- 3:13these days we do know what's going on. There
- 3:16are the so -called drop reports, the blue drop,
- 3:18green drop, no drop reports. They were introduced
- 3:22in 2008, but they were suspended under the Zuma
- 3:25administration in 2014. And then reinstated in
- 3:292022 by Cyril Ramaphosa's government. What do
- 3:33they show us? It goes to the fundamental point
- 3:36that what you measure, you can manage. And if
- 3:39you don't have those reports, well, then you
- 3:40can't manage the problem. The Blue Drop report
- 3:43measures water quality. Is the water that comes
- 3:47out of your tap safe? And does it meet all the
- 3:49standards for water to be consumed? Now, in South
- 3:54Africa, 52 % of water treatment systems failed
- 3:58or barely passed the quality test. They didn't
- 4:02score. Even if they passed, they didn't score
- 4:04very high. 48 % of water distribution systems
- 4:09were found to be okay. There's no risk there.
- 4:13It's fine. So it's a story of two halves. That's
- 4:16blue water. It's the quality of water. No drop
- 4:19is non -revenue water, which we have just discussed.
- 4:23And it reveals in South Africa 47 % losses. And
- 4:27interestingly enough, that's up from 35 % in
- 4:302014 when the reports, the publication of the
- 4:33reports were suspended. And probably if we didn't
- 4:36suspend the publication, we could have, you know,
- 4:40managed the problem earlier. And then the last
- 4:42one is Green Drop, and that measures wastewater
- 4:45treatment. The report found that 64 % of wastewater
- 4:49plants are at a high or critical risk of discharging
- 4:54untreated or partially treated water into the
- 4:57environment. So those three reports helps us
- 5:00to understand what's going on and one can now
- 5:02manage the situation better. Not a pretty picture.
- 5:06No. But how does the system work? How does water
- 5:10get from, say, the Vaal Dam or Steenbras or Theewaterskloof
- 5:14in the Western Cape to the consumer? It starts
- 5:17with strategic water areas, which we find in
- 5:20South Africa in five provinces. Four provinces
- 5:22have got no strategic water areas, so you've
- 5:25got to distribute water to them. How does that
- 5:27work? First of all, these strategic water areas
- 5:31feed water into dams. The Waal River that you've
- 5:33mentioned. the Berggevier Dam and the Western
- 5:36Cape and so on. The dams get filled from the
- 5:40strategic water sources and the dams are run
- 5:42by the Department of Water and Sanitation. And
- 5:44that is what one can call the beginning of the
- 5:47system. Then we have seven water boards in the
- 5:51country. There used to be 15, but they have been
- 5:54rationalized to only seven. Those seven water
- 5:57boards distribute water. They are basically what
- 6:01you can call wholesalers. they distribute water
- 6:04to the country's municipalities. And the municipalities
- 6:07form the third level. Now here we must distinguish
- 6:10between two things. Municipalities are water
- 6:13services authorities. That's the mandate that
- 6:16was given to them in the constitution. They're
- 6:18responsible for ensuring that the citizens in
- 6:21a municipality has got access to water. It's
- 6:24a constitutional obligation. But then most municipalities
- 6:28have also taken on the duty of a water service
- 6:30provider. which actually runs the pipes and the
- 6:34taps in a particular municipality. So there's
- 6:37a water services authority, which has the responsibility
- 6:41to make a plan. And then there's the water services
- 6:45provider. But it doesn't have to be the same
- 6:48entity. It doesn't have to be. But in practice,
- 6:50it is. It mostly is. And that's one of the areas
- 6:53where change is now going to take place, where
- 6:55you separate the authority from the provider.
- 6:58The authority is a constitutional thing and it's
- 7:01a political responsibility to citizens. Provider
- 7:03is the technical function to get water out, to
- 7:06maintain the system and to collect the money
- 7:08for selling water. So let's take it from the
- 7:11top. What's happening with bulk water supply?
- 7:14Quite a lot has actually happened. And in Appendix
- 7:16A to the document, there's quite a list detailing
- 7:21the projects that we've had since 1994 and ongoing
- 7:25projects right at the moment. Right now, government
- 7:29has committed about 150 billion rand to 11 big
- 7:33water projects all over the country in the provinces
- 7:36where there are strategic water supply sources.
- 7:40The biggest one is, of course, the Lesotho Highlands
- 7:43Water Scheme Phase 2. Phase 1 was completed in
- 7:47respectively 1996 and 2003. Phase 2 was supposed
- 7:52to be completed already, but... Corruption allegations
- 7:55in the Zuma time, plus, of course, COVID, plus
- 7:58the fact that you had to resettle communities
- 8:00in Lesotho from land which will now be covered
- 8:03by water, delayed that project. But I must say,
- 8:06again, the Ramaphosa administration has succeeded
- 8:09in getting that thing going. And currently, their
- 8:12three big construction works ongoing. It's the
- 8:15building of the Polyagli Dam. It's the building
- 8:17of a tunnel to transfer water from Polyagli to
- 8:21Dikatsi Dam, which is the biggest dam in the
- 8:23system, and it's the building of roads and bridges
- 8:25to service that. And that scheme delivers water
- 8:28to Gauteng. It will be operational on current
- 8:31planning by 2028, and that will enhance the Gauteng
- 8:37water supply system quite considerably. Some
- 8:40of the other provinces, the one where there is
- 8:42the largest number of The projects and money
- 8:44is KwaZulu -Natal, both the north and the south
- 8:47coast. There are three big projects on the go
- 8:49there. And I think that will make a big difference
- 8:51to the water supply problems on both the north
- 8:54and the south coast of Natal. And then there
- 8:57are two projects in the Western Cape. There are
- 8:59two projects in Mpopo and so on. But all those
- 9:02details are in Appendix A to the document. And
- 9:07if we come to the seven water boards, are they
- 9:10functioning well? One of the reasons why the
- 9:1315 were rationalized to 7 was precisely to cut
- 9:16wastage and expense and try to get them to function
- 9:19better. The Achilles heel there is municipalities
- 9:23who don't pay. And at the moment, municipalities
- 9:26owe the water boards about 22 billion rand in
- 9:32water that has not been paid for. That's a substantial
- 9:35151 % increase over the last five years. And
- 9:39the problem there is that although municipalities
- 9:42receive 62 billion rand annually from National
- 9:45Treasury for water and sanitation projects, not
- 9:50all that money gets spent on water by the local
- 9:53municipality. They spend it on other priorities.
- 9:55So that brings the issue of ring fencing to the
- 9:58fore. It sounds as if the municipalities really
- 10:01are... The weakest link. No, they absolutely
- 10:05are. There's no question. I think bulk water
- 10:07supply, you know, that's going on. The water
- 10:11boards have been reorganized and they are proceeding.
- 10:15The real problem is the municipalities. That
- 10:18is where things are falling apart. What the drop
- 10:21reports tell us is that in December 2023, There
- 10:26were 144 water service authorities in South Africa,
- 10:29in other words, municipalities which are designated
- 10:32as water service authorities. They run close
- 10:35to a thousand water systems, 958 to be precise.
- 10:40Only 26 of those 958 systems, that's 3%, achieve
- 10:46blue drop status. I earlier made a point that
- 10:49about 52 % of systems either failed or barely
- 10:53passed the quality test. But only 3 % got 95
- 10:57% score or scored 95%. So you can see where the
- 11:01problem lies. It lies with the local water systems
- 11:04in various municipalities. Is it just aging infrastructure?
- 11:09No, it's not just aging infrastructure. The same
- 11:12reports found that 85 % of drinking water systems
- 11:16are of an average or better condition, average
- 11:19or better. So it's not so much the infrastructure
- 11:21that's not working. It's more a question of skills.
- 11:24It's more a question of process flow. It's more
- 11:27a question of maintenance. Maintenance is a very,
- 11:29very big story. Treasury requires that 8 % of
- 11:34a budget must be spent on maintenance. But in
- 11:37real life, only about 2 % gets spent on maintenance.
- 11:40So maintenance is really the big problem. Linked
- 11:43to that is simply a lack of management. The Minister
- 11:47of Water, Minister Pemi Majordina. has said in
- 11:50parliament that her department has given a whole
- 11:53lot of very doable tasks to Johannesburg Water
- 11:57and to other Gauteng municipalities, but that
- 12:00they simply do not respond. The water board for
- 12:04Gauteng, Rand Water, which is actually functioning
- 12:07quite well, reported that they had some 40 meetings
- 12:10with Gauteng municipalities to give them practical
- 12:13advice. on how to improve water distribution
- 12:16systems, and there's simply been no appropriate
- 12:19reaction. So no, it's not so much the infrastructure
- 12:21as people. Is there something about this system
- 12:25which could possibly be different to make it
- 12:28better? Yes, most certainly. And that is where
- 12:32a number of reforms have now been initiated,
- 12:35which should change it, and let's go through
- 12:37them. The first and most important one is a licensing
- 12:41system. I've said earlier that we've discussed
- 12:44the fact that there's a water service authority
- 12:45which deals with the constitutional obligation
- 12:48and a water service provider. Legislation has
- 12:51now been amended. It's going through the parliamentary
- 12:54process to compel every water service authority
- 12:58to have a license before they can be a water
- 13:02service provider. And what is the point about
- 13:04the license? The point about the license is certain
- 13:07minimum performance standards and certain...
- 13:10achievements that must be maintained by the water
- 13:13service provider. If the water service provider
- 13:16does not meet those license requirements, then
- 13:19the license can be revoked and given to somebody
- 13:21else. And that somebody else can be the for -profit
- 13:25private sector. It can be the not -for -profit
- 13:28private sector, like an NGO or a community -based
- 13:31organization. It can be a different water services
- 13:35authority. There's no limitation. It can go to
- 13:38any licensee. That is best place to deliver the
- 13:41water and fulfill the water provision functions.
- 13:46That's an important change. Brazil has done this,
- 13:49not so. And what happened? Absolutely right.
- 13:52Brazil has. They've got similar problems than
- 13:54what we've got. They made this change. It led
- 13:57to a huge influx of private service, water service
- 14:02providers coming in. Some for profit, some not
- 14:04for profit. And I've said some community based
- 14:07and so on. and it led to an improvement in both
- 14:10water and sanitation supply in Brazil. In South
- 14:14Africa, we only, or we do have, two examples
- 14:18where the water service provider in a municipality
- 14:21is a private entity. The one is Mombella, in
- 14:25Mupumalanga, and the other one is on the Dolphin
- 14:28Coast, in the northern part of Guazula Natal.
- 14:31And in both those areas, what we see is we see
- 14:33very efficient water provision. Water losses
- 14:37have been cut down, so non -revenue water has
- 14:40come down substantially in both cases. Maintenance
- 14:43is being done, and there's a consistent and reliable
- 14:45water supply. So all we really have to do is
- 14:49to expand the Bombella and Dolphin Coast examples
- 14:54to the rest of the country, and we will see a
- 14:57substantial improvement. But that means that
- 15:00municipalities must give up some of their authority
- 15:05or some of, well, also some of their revenue.
- 15:08And municipalities are set in their ways and
- 15:10constitutionally protected. How are they being
- 15:13chivvied along? That is exactly the problem.
- 15:16They've got a vested interest in the current
- 15:18system and they would like to maintain it. And
- 15:20as I've said earlier, they also get money from
- 15:22National Treasury. for a subsidy for the poor
- 15:25and they use that subsidy for other things like
- 15:28cars and salaries and so on. So yes, the municipalities
- 15:31will have to change their behavior quite considerably.
- 15:34But I think this legislative amendment forcing
- 15:37them to become a licensee and losing their license
- 15:39will do a lot to address that. Also, there are
- 15:43currently both carrots and sticks being employed
- 15:46by government. What are the CARATs? The CARATs
- 15:49are a program the Treasury is running called
- 15:52the Metro Trading Services Reform Program, very
- 15:55long title, which essentially pay incentives
- 15:59to municipalities if they meet certain performance
- 16:01standards. So that's a CARAT, and it looks like
- 16:05it's working quite well. Six of the eight metros
- 16:08in the country have bought into the system and
- 16:11are participating in this Treasury framework.
- 16:15And it's all about... having better control over
- 16:18what's happening. Another carrot which is being
- 16:22employed is that the Department of Water and
- 16:25Sanitation is now being authorized by changes
- 16:27in the legislation that they can take over the
- 16:31water service provider if that water service
- 16:34provider is not doing a proper job. So you take
- 16:36Johannesburg, for example, where Joburg water
- 16:38is really not functioning well. It is possible,
- 16:41it will be possible once the legislation is passed.
- 16:44for the department to step in and take it over.
- 16:46Those are the carrots. How far is the legislation?
- 16:51It's still in the parliamentary process. It takes
- 16:53time to write legislation. You're looking at
- 16:56between six months and a year. You said there
- 16:58were carrots and sticks? Sticks. The most important
- 17:02stick is, I've now several times we talked about
- 17:04the Treasury's equitable share, which is paid
- 17:07to municipalities and then gets misused. The
- 17:11Treasury in December last year started withholding
- 17:14the transfer of equitable shares to municipalities
- 17:17who are in the rears. They were the usual threats
- 17:20of court cases and so on. In South Africa, everybody
- 17:23runs to the courts when they're not happy. But
- 17:25the legal position is quite clear. Treasury has
- 17:28got the authority to do that kind of thing in
- 17:31cases where there's consistent poor performance.
- 17:35So withholding the equitable share is hitting
- 17:37where it's hurt, as you say. And that's an important
- 17:42stick. Another stick is criminal accountability.
- 17:45The Department of Water has started criminally
- 17:50prosecuting municipalities. And 36 cases have
- 17:54been opened against 26 municipalities in six
- 17:58provinces for discharging untreated sewage into
- 18:01public water systems. to the government. Yeah,
- 18:12so those are the main sticks that are around.
- 18:16We've seen stunning success in involving the
- 18:20private sector in electricity. Are there moves
- 18:24to make that happen with regard to water? Yes,
- 18:27absolutely. The Department of Water Affairs,
- 18:30with the help of or in partnership with the local
- 18:33government association, SOLGA, has created a
- 18:37water partnership office in the Development Bank.
- 18:40And the idea of that water partnership office
- 18:42is to help the municipalities to involve private
- 18:45companies in the provision of water. It's run
- 18:49by Johan Libbe, who's an engineer with about
- 18:5120 years experience. And essentially, they run
- 18:55six programs. What do they do? First of all,
- 18:58they develop a model of how you can run things
- 19:00in those six areas so that municipalities don't
- 19:03have to reinvent the wheel. In that way, you
- 19:06want to make projects easier and more bankable.
- 19:09If you take care of the admin and you standardize
- 19:11the standards and you standardize the technical
- 19:13requirements and those things, then you can just
- 19:15copy and paste and it will help to improve projects
- 19:20run. What are the six areas? I think it's important
- 19:23to point them out. It's non -revenue water, which
- 19:26we've already said is one of the biggest problems
- 19:28in the country. It's management contract. It's
- 19:30wastewater treatment. It's the reuse of water.
- 19:34of which we don't do a lot in South Africa, desalination,
- 19:37of which we also don't do a lot, and off -grid
- 19:39water. So if you can get standardized procedures
- 19:43for involving private companies in those areas,
- 19:46helping municipalities, then I think it is a
- 19:49win -win for everybody. And are the municipalities
- 19:51coming on board? The six biggest metros are currently
- 19:55working with the water office, water partnership
- 19:58office, to employ some of those. programs in
- 20:03their areas. Yes, and I think success breeds
- 20:05success. Once you've had two or three places
- 20:08where they can show a demonstrable improvement,
- 20:10you will find other people also coming along.
- 20:13This will have a political impact, not so? In
- 20:16what way? If you have demonstrable success, then
- 20:20it looks good for the municipality. It looks
- 20:23good for the municipality, absolutely. And that's
- 20:26the only thing that the municipalities has got
- 20:28to get their mind around. It is quite possible,
- 20:30as in Bombella and on the Dolphin Coast, to rent
- 20:34your infrastructure out. Infrastructure belongs
- 20:36to the municipality. It's their asset. It's their
- 20:38thing. Rent it out, charge a fee for it, regulate
- 20:42the price at which that private entity can sell
- 20:45the water. You don't want to lose that. And take
- 20:49a part of the equitable portion and pay that
- 20:51over to the... service provider to provide water
- 20:54to poor people. So you really can do everything
- 20:56which is required, but you do it through a different
- 20:59operator, not a municipality. Yes, it can have
- 21:02a big impact. There's also another brand new
- 21:06animal called the National Water Resource Infrastructure
- 21:10Agency. Who are they and what do they do? Yeah,
- 21:13I call it the three -in -one agency because they
- 21:16combine three functions which are currently handled
- 21:19by different people. The first one is they take
- 21:22the functions of the Trans -Caledon Tunnel Authority,
- 21:25which its name belies what it does. The Trans
- 21:29-Caledon Tunnel Authority is responsible for
- 21:31raising money on the capital market for bulk
- 21:34water projects. And that is what they've done
- 21:37for many years now. So this function will go
- 21:40into the National Water Agency, raising capital.
- 21:44The second thing is in the Department of Water,
- 21:47there's a water trading entity. They sell water
- 21:50from the various dams to the seven water boards
- 21:53and from the water boards on to municipalities.
- 21:56That trading of water, collecting the money,
- 21:58making sure everybody pays what they have to
- 22:00pay, that will go into the water resource agency,
- 22:04the three -in -one agency. And lastly, the department's
- 22:07infrastructure branch, engineers and technical
- 22:09people responsible for overseeing the dams. Now,
- 22:12what this reorganization doing is this. It takes
- 22:16the dams and the distribution systems, which
- 22:19has got a value. You build a dam, it's costing
- 22:22millions or billions of rands. It's a real asset.
- 22:26That asset is generating money. You sell water,
- 22:29the water, the income comes in. You take that
- 22:31and you put it on the balance sheet of the agency.
- 22:33Now the agency has got assets, a balance sheet,
- 22:37against which they can go and borrow more money.
- 22:39from banks and insurance companies and so on,
- 22:42to build more dams and to build more water systems.
- 22:46It's quite a clever way of overcoming the fact
- 22:49that government itself, the taxpayer, doesn't
- 22:51have enough money to pay for backwater provision.
- 22:55It works very well in, for example, the case
- 22:57of national roads. We've got Sunroll, the national
- 23:00road agency, and if you travel through the country,
- 23:03all you have to do is compare a national road
- 23:05to a provincial road or a municipal road, and
- 23:07you can't believe the difference. And that's
- 23:10what they do. National roads belong to the National
- 23:12Road Agency. There's income against it, against
- 23:15tolls. You take that income and the balance sheet,
- 23:18you go to the bank, you borrow money and you
- 23:20can build more roads. It's exactly the same idea
- 23:23with water. That legislation has been signed
- 23:26by the president and they're busy setting it
- 23:28up. And the target date to get it going is the
- 23:31beginning of the financial year in 2026. So what,
- 23:34if you have to summarize all of this? I think
- 23:37this first, so what is this? been happening and
- 23:40has happened, especially around bulk water supply.
- 23:44And again, PNXA give a lot of detail, not all
- 23:48of it. It's not exhaustive, but it paints a picture
- 23:51of that something is being done about the fact
- 23:53that we need more bulk water supply. That's not
- 23:56the area that I would be very worried about.
- 24:00The two areas where we actually need huge in
- 24:05progress is on the on the distribution side,
- 24:08on the municipality side, in respect of non -revenue
- 24:11water, as well as poor maintenance. If we can
- 24:14sort just those two things out, it will make
- 24:17a real difference to the lives of ordinary people.
- 24:19It's maintenance and non -revenue water. To achieve
- 24:24those two things, and that's the third so what,
- 24:26is we've got to make legislative changes. And
- 24:29those changes are now in process. So it's not
- 24:32something that will happen. It's something that
- 24:34is happening. We also have changes in the regulations,
- 24:37for example, around not paying the equitable
- 24:40share of municipalities if they fall in arrears
- 24:43with their payments. So there are administrative,
- 24:47legislative, regulatory changes taking place
- 24:49to deal with those two big problems. In the end,
- 24:53it comes down to local government and local municipalities.
- 24:56They have to step up and improve their performance.
- 24:59And the only way that you can really force them...
- 25:02is you can do legislation and you can do regulations
- 25:05and so on, and that's being done. But in the
- 25:08end, it is the voters that must decide who must
- 25:10run the water system in their municipality. They
- 25:13have to exert the pressure on councillors and
- 25:16on municipalities. So let's hope that with the
- 25:19local government elections, that voters will
- 25:22step up and deliver a lesson to their councillors.
- 25:26Thank you very much. You will find two extra
- 25:29sections in the written version of this newsletter.
- 25:32The first is the appendix that JP has referred
- 25:35to. That's not a complete list of projects, but
- 25:38it gives an indication that as far as bulk water
- 25:41supply is concerned, a lot has been done. But
- 25:43then there's a second extra page, which is an
- 25:46executive summary, an overview of all this information.
- 25:51Thank you for listening to the So What Podcast.
- 25:54If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 25:57to leave a review and a rating, and please consider
- 26:00subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 26:03Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find
- 26:07a written version of all JP's content at jplandman