Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / Scarce.City
Transcript
- 0:02It is 10:41AM
- 0:03Pacific Daylight Time. It is the last day of the fourth month
- 0:08of twenty twenty five already.
- 0:10And this is episode good lord. What is it? It's gonna be October.
- 0:16However, I'm going to bring you
- 0:19an older
- 0:20interview that I did with a gentleman from Scarce.city.
- 0:24His name is Chris Trammout.
- 0:26And Scarce..city
- 0:27is still going on. And if you've never heard of it, go to scarce.city.
- 0:32You can it's auctions. It's sorta like eBay.
- 0:36But it it
- 0:38it always
- 0:39captured my imagination. And this is this is actually pre Nostr,
- 0:44and I do not know if scarce.city
- 0:47has taken up the Nostr mantle and given us, like, you know, insect logins and whatnot like that. But I still think that it's important to go back and revisit
- 0:59some of the people that have been working all this time towards,
- 1:04well, a circular Bitcoin economy.
- 1:06Because scarce dot city, you can buy the the auction items for for Bitcoin.
- 1:11And
- 1:12they were you know, they've been doing this for, like, a long time.
- 1:16I have the circle p. We're all trying to to do this circular Bitcoin economy,
- 1:21and it's proving to be difficult.
- 1:24So I think it's important to go back and listen to the words of Chris Trammout
- 1:30as he talks about scarce dot city.
- 1:33Back in the day, guys, this was like this was when I was still living in Canyon, Texas.
- 1:38This is like well over three years ago.
- 1:41We've been
- 1:43ever forging ahead on the Bitcoin circular economy.
- 1:47So let's go back in time
- 1:49and let's talk to my friend,
- 1:52Chris Trammelt
- 1:54one more time. Chris, welcome to Bitcoin and how are you doing today, man? David, doing well, man. It's good to be here. What is your last name, unless you don't want to say it? Oh, no. I'm fully doxed already.
- 2:06Chris Trammelt.
- 2:08Okay. How do you spell that anyway?
- 2:11T r a m o u n t.
- 2:15Okay. Just wanted to make sure because I have this tendency. I have not only do I mispronounce people's names, I also misspell them often. I'm a terrible speller. Anyway,
- 2:26so, you
- 2:28so you are the founder, I am guessing,
- 2:31of this new thing called a scarcity. Is that correct?
- 2:35That's right. One of two founders. I have a, technical cofounder, Arjan Jabari.
- 2:40Okay. Alright. So, before we get into scarcity, let's let's set some tone and get some context of
- 2:47who you are and kinda where you come from. So
- 2:51take yourself back to high school. What did you wanna do when you grew up?
- 2:56Oh, man. That's a great question.
- 2:59You know, it's funny. Like, I think back about on it, and I grew up in Charleston, South Carolina.
- 3:05And,
- 3:07you know, I just wasn't exposed to a lot of, like, the really interesting careers,
- 3:12at that time.
- 3:13So, you know, for me, like, I was good at math. So I was like, you know, I guess I'll just be an engineer because that's what
- 3:20math people did
- 3:21as far as my environment goes. Mhmm. You know, of course, there was, like, the business route, but I was like, I I don't really see myself as a business type of guy, at least the way I I thought of it then, which was, like,
- 3:32you know, in Charleston, it was like the bankers. Right?
- 3:36Right.
- 3:37So,
- 3:38you know, I had no no concept of
- 3:41tech startups, not that anyone really did back then or anything, like, you know, related to technology.
- 3:48I will say that I did go through,
- 3:51I did go through a small phase where
- 3:54I wanted to be a fashion designer
- 3:57Nice.
- 3:58Which which has, like,
- 4:00become almost relevant now.
- 4:03So
- 4:04Well, yeah, we we will we will see that a little bit later on in the interview. That's awesome, though, man. Not Not many people wanna do that. I have this weird thing about high I just got this weird thing about high fashion when I'm looking at, like, you know, I don't know, Dior, you know, releases the spring line or whatever, and I'm looking at the the models on the cat on the catwalk, and I'm looking at the stuff going,
- 4:25nobody's gonna wear that. I don't understand.
- 4:29Yeah. No. And to be fair, like, I was always interested more in, like, the streetwear stuff, and I don't even know, like, you know, high end.
- 4:37Gotcha. Gotcha.
- 4:38So fashion designer. Nice. So okay. So you're you're you're bumping along in high school
- 4:43thinking about either fashion or possibly engineering.
- 4:47And,
- 4:49woah, where did you run up against you know,
- 4:52When did you run into Bitcoin, or did it run over you? Some people have that.
- 4:57Oh, man. You know,
- 4:59I think I first heard about it back in 02/2012, '2 thousand '13.
- 5:05Totally wrote it off from the beginning.
- 5:07And it's, you know, it's
- 5:09everybody has a similar story, but it's always kind of embarrassing.
- 5:12Yep. And for me, like, I'm I'm most embarrassed because, like, I understood
- 5:17the supply cap,
- 5:18and that's why I wrote it off because I had this, you know, idea that
- 5:23a deflationary currency
- 5:24will never be used. Right? People are disincentivized
- 5:28from spending it,
- 5:30so it'll just you know, it'll it'll never work. And I just I didn't have the the understanding of the different functions of money.
- 5:38It didn't occur to me that, you know, money could be a pure stored value or, you know,
- 5:44unit of account. I just wasn't thinking like that. And, of course, I just I I never gave Bitcoin my full attention to really understand it.
- 5:53Right. Up until, you know, I came in, the flip switched for me in 02/2017.
- 5:59So, you know, still consider my myself a a freshman in the space.
- 6:03Uh-huh.
- 6:05But, you know, I think what really did it for me was
- 6:09I came to the realization that, you know, the Fed was just never gonna stop printing.
- 6:14And I started thinking about, you know, where's the money gonna go? Like, only so much can go into
- 6:20gold.
- 6:22Like and, you know, it's it's just a rock. Like, there's only so much we can do with that, so there's gotta be another place for it to go. And that's when I gave Bitcoin a second look. I had also
- 6:34been really into just studying technology and software
- 6:38at that time and had seen the progression play out over and over where,
- 6:42you know, you see some initial technology. It looks
- 6:46really clunky.
- 6:48It's really hard to use.
- 6:50But then, sure enough, over time, it gets better and better, and all of a sudden, it becomes somewhat ubiquitous.
- 6:57So kind of being trained through that lens
- 7:00Yeah. Looking looking into the future of how
- 7:05the current systems were gonna play out,
- 7:08I finally wisened up to what was going on.
- 7:11Well, you know, to be fair, none of us were taught what money was. I mean, you know, even back in in my high school days, which was quite a while ago,
- 7:19you know, it it it was it was almost as if it was a theme. You go to economics class and you do other homework
- 7:27or you snooze or you just space, you know, space totally out.
- 7:33And
- 7:34I start like hell, I mean you could even watch movies where they had like you know, there's a a Ferris Bueller's Day Off. One of the most famous scenes in that movie is the snooze fest in economics class because it was just this droning on of this guy who actually the actor that did that was a speechwriter for Nixon.
- 7:54Right.
- 7:55Yeah. And I always I always found that, like, just really, really odd. But,
- 7:59you know, it's almost as if it was almost as if it was on purpose because none of us know what money is. So, you you know,
- 8:06you certainly can't be blamed, man. Right. That was the assumption. It's like, okay. We have money. Don't question that. And I will tell you every how it works. Like, everything to do everything you can do with that money. But, like, we're not gonna talk about
- 8:20what's really at the foundation of this thing.
- 8:23Yeah. And I think a lot of us start you know, when when we got into Bitcoin, the very first you know, one of the very first things that we started doing was started asking ourselves questions about
- 8:33the one thing that we always took for granted and that everybody knew about, and that was money. And then once that door opened, it was like you just start seeing just how messed up everything else is, because half of all transactions in human existence
- 8:49is value transfer
- 8:51with money. You know, it's so yeah. So okay. So now you're you're you're firmly kind of planted into Bitcoin. You're you're you're chugging along. You've been slapped in the face a couple of times. You get into '20, you know, 2017.
- 9:04You start really freaking out about the bull run, and then
- 9:09scarcity happens.
- 9:11Where where did that where did that come from?
- 9:15Well, there was, like, a whole bear market in between there, which Of course. Hard to hard to just brush over. But,
- 9:22yeah, you know, it it,
- 9:25I I think, my path is not too dissimilar from many Bitcoiners where you get into Bitcoin,
- 9:32it just takes up all of your attention.
- 9:34Got it. It becomes hard to focus on anything else.
- 9:39And,
- 9:40I realized as I'm, like, in my regular job that I just can't I can't focus
- 9:46on anything that's not related to Bitcoin. And, like, as a professional, I'm just not gonna be using,
- 9:53this my skills to the best of my ability or my time the best that I can if I'm not doing something related to Bitcoin.
- 10:02So I was looking for a way into
- 10:05the space.
- 10:06And, you know, my background before then, a lot of it had been centered around
- 10:12retail ecommerce.
- 10:13So it's it's an area that I have a decent understanding for.
- 10:17Mhmm.
- 10:19And I was in touch with,
- 10:21a Bitcoin artist, and we were just chatting. And they wanted to sell some clothing that
- 10:27fit
- 10:28with some of the properties of Bitcoin
- 10:30such
- 10:31as verifiable
- 10:32authenticity
- 10:33and supply.
- 10:35Mhmm.
- 10:36And just kinda, like, you know, being a total pleb at the time, I I assumed that was a solved problem.
- 10:42Yeah. And it was only after looking into it some more that I realized that's actually a pretty hard problem
- 10:48Yep. And, far from
- 10:50solved. So I started looking into it, and, you know, we came up with a rudimentary
- 10:57solution that we tested out with some face mask sales.
- 11:00And, you know, from there, we've been able to build a little bit of the community,
- 11:05and,
- 11:06that's helped us come up with, I think, some better ideas.
- 11:10Yep. And, it's kind of brought us to where we are right now. You know, we've just been testing a few things out, and we have some big ideas for the future.
- 11:19So how long has this baby of yours been crying? I mean, when did you you know, when was opening day, so to speak?
- 11:27You know, opening day was, I think, in March.
- 11:30Actually, no. It probably wasn't because it we we started building in March.
- 11:34I my cofounder,
- 11:36he and I were working together at the same startup before we got laid off of COVID.
- 11:41And,
- 11:42I I kinda talked him into
- 11:44trying this out with me. So I think we were building for maybe two
- 11:48ish months before we launched anything. So it's probably May. It's probably May.
- 11:53Late May, I think. But, you know, the idea had been cooking for at least
- 11:59six months before then.
- 12:01Okay. So now now that we've talked about your you know, the the birthing of that which is scarcity,
- 12:07it's time for us to talk about what scarcity is. So can let let's start out with a nutshell description like your five minute elevator pitch. What what is scarcity?
- 12:18Sure. So, you know, I'll start out with the the twenty second elevator pitches. Okay. Scarcity scarcity is a
- 12:25marketplace that uses Bitcoin,
- 12:28lightning,
- 12:29hopefully future
- 12:31layer three protocols
- 12:33to support Bitcoin culture and adoption.
- 12:36Okay. Alright. So now,
- 12:40this is based seems to be based around the Lightning Network and Lightning Auctions, and I'm I'm looking at the,
- 12:47your,
- 12:48scarcity
- 12:49you know, or scarce.city
- 12:52website right now. And this seems to be you know, what I'm seeing is, like, hey. Look. You know, I read your white paper, so it's looks like, you know, it's like, hey. Look.
- 13:02I'm gonna sell you this T shirt, and we're gonna take a lightning payment for it. But there's much more to it than that because, a, it's auctions.
- 13:11It involves the lightning network
- 13:14and
- 13:15third parties
- 13:16shipping and stuff. So
- 13:18what's let's start with
- 13:20a lightning auction. So you got, you know, you got some artists.
- 13:25They wanna sell t shirts. They come to you and say, I wanna sell my shirt
- 13:29at at auction. How
- 13:32let's kinda dive in or put our toes in the water right around there. Can you kinda start detailing this out a little bit?
- 13:38Yeah. Absolutely. So, you know, the clothing we did in the past, that wasn't auction based. That was just Okay. Fixed fixed price. And because we did have a mechanism for,
- 13:47verifiable supply, we were, like, increasing supply with each item sold and doing some full stuff there.
- 13:54But our newest, what I would call product, is lightning auctions, and we're gonna be focused on
- 14:01original art and specifically Bitcoin art, at least in the beginning here. Okay.
- 14:06And, you know, we're still a few weeks away from putting this out into the wild, but,
- 14:12we have it in our test notes working great. The idea here is that we're using
- 14:17we're running auctions
- 14:21that use lightning payments to keep bidders accountable for their bids,
- 14:27while requiring
- 14:28minimal fees and minimal personal information from bidders.
- 14:34So the the way this works step by step is, you know, we're trying to keep this as simple and
- 14:40clean-cut as possible.
- 14:42You go into the auction site. You check out the product.
- 14:45You check out the bids that have already been placed. You see how much time is left in the auction.
- 14:50You decide you wanna place a bid.
- 14:53You input your bid amount and put it into sats. You know, we're keeping that as the standard, but we do the auto calculation for you to US dollars.
- 15:02And you put in an email address. And, you know,
- 15:06we really don't want people to be putting in their, like, personal email address. It can be Right. Any email address. We just need it to,
- 15:14verify that
- 15:16the winning bidder placed, you know, the winning bid,
- 15:21and also to refund your collateral back to you.
- 15:25And if it's your first time placing a bid with that email address, you input a display name, which you only input once when you make subsequent bids with that email address that auto populates.
- 15:36And once you submit that information, you're you're brought to,
- 15:40pay a lightning invoice, which can range anywhere from
- 15:455 to, you you know, on the very high end,
- 15:48$50,
- 15:50which is a percentage. It's a it's a small percentage of the amount you actually
- 15:56bid,
- 15:58and it acts
- 16:00as your collateral for that bid. So Okay. At the end of the auction, once it's all said and done, everybody gets their collateral back
- 16:08except in the case where the auction winner
- 16:11does not pay the amount they said they would pay.
- 16:15And in that case, they lose their collateral.
- 16:18And the the next highest bidder would be become the winner of the auction.
- 16:24Okay. So I've got like, let's say that I've got I don't know. I've got something like a piece of bitcoin bitcoin art. I put it up for auction, and I get notified that somebody has bid on it. And then I continuously get notifications that somebody's bid higher, bid higher until
- 16:39time runs out and the the winning bidder,
- 16:44does one of two things,
- 16:45pays
- 16:46all of the rest aside from the collateral that he already put up. Like, I think what what did you say was, like, 5% of the total price?
- 16:55We're still playing with the percentages, but on Okay. At at a very minimum, it would be $5.
- 17:00If it's a very expensive bid,
- 17:04we're willing to push it up to, like, $50, but that's about as high as we wanna go. Okay. Yeah. I I I get it. So now
- 17:11if the now does the bidder the winning bidder that chooses to pay and be honorable and all that, do they go ahead and complete with another Lightning transaction?
- 17:20Or at one point or another, do they have to break away and go to the main chain and do a full Bitcoin main chain transaction?
- 17:27Yeah. So the items we're gonna be auctioning off here, we expect to be in the hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars in in total value. So these would be on chain transactions
- 17:36once you're actually paying the full amount.
- 17:39So at that point, only
- 17:41the Lightning Network is only leveraged to make sure that people play fair. Right?
- 17:47That's exactly right. Okay. That's I just wanna I just wanna make sure that that I'm clear on that because I sometimes
- 17:53I'm not clear with myself on on certain things.
- 17:58So
- 17:59now
- 18:01are you so are you guys running your own
- 18:04lightning node to do this, or are you leveraging
- 18:08someone else?
- 18:11We are using BTC pay server, which makes it easy for us, but, yes, we are running
- 18:15our own. No.
- 18:17Now is have you guys done a, you know, any kind of simulation as to let let's say this thing just really takes off and you've got multiple
- 18:25auctions going on. I'm talking, like, let's say let's
- 18:29pie in the sky. Let's say you've got, like, 100 auctions that are live at the exact same time. Have you guys simulated at what point you might need to actually start, you know, either leveraging,
- 18:40an outside source? Somebody's like, you know, I can't remember who it was, just announced that was it
- 18:46oh, I almost I almost had the name, but they're, spinning up lightning
- 18:51lightning nodes in the cloud that you can rent.
- 18:54Have you figured out at what point?
- 18:57Yeah. That's it. Thank thank you. Yeah. They're fantastic. Yeah.
- 19:01Would there be a point at which, you know, running it, you know, shake and bake on your desktop is just not gonna cut it anymore? Do you know when that point is or if that point even exists?
- 19:13You know,
- 19:14it's not a near term problem for us. So I should clarify that we are taking a
- 19:20curated approach to this. Okay. So it's not gonna be, like, self serve. Anybody can start an auction, at least not anytime
- 19:27soon. Okay. We want to,
- 19:30very carefully control
- 19:31what is being put up for auction. And it's not just us. We have a community that helps us make these decisions.
- 19:38Right.
- 19:39But, yeah, I mean, we're gonna be taking this baby steps from the beginning.
- 19:44It would be fantastic if in, like, sometime within the next few months, we get to one auction a week.
- 19:51But, you know, part of this is we want to get as much attention around each individual auction auction as possible.
- 19:57Okay. So there is a certain limitation there. And, you know, as far as, like, growing the business, we think there's, like, interesting
- 20:04ways to bundle other sales from most likely the same artist
- 20:09into
- 20:10the auction.
- 20:12Right. Now I'm looking at this, and I'm, you know, I'm I'm I used to run
- 20:18a guy's
- 20:19I was helping a buddy of mine out at his business a couple of different times, and
- 20:23he actually had he was
- 20:26he was modifying Dish Network units and then reselling them on eBay, mostly to Canada. And I won't get into the parameters of the modification because, you know, it's probably not a good thing to talk about. But,
- 20:39you know, but we moved into, you know, auctioning all kinds of solid goods. I mean, things that that are, you know, fairly meaty.
- 20:47Is this gonna like, is I know that I would imagine that your answer in the near term is it's just gonna be art, but do you
- 20:55have any further thoughts of, like like, I got I got a Fender twin amplifier.
- 21:01I don't really use it anymore,
- 21:03and I'd like to be able to auction that off. Is that something that you might do in the future? Go past close, you know, light,
- 21:12you know, lightweight
- 21:13shippable goods,
- 21:15to where we get into some some heavier items, or is that just like, nope. We're not even gonna touch it?
- 21:21I certainly wouldn't shut it down completely.
- 21:24I will say, like, you know, our
- 21:26mission that we do wanna stay
- 21:28as true as possible to is, like, everything we do, we want it to be for Bitcoin adoption and culture.
- 21:35Right. So if we find that there's a demand for something that aligns
- 21:40with that mission, we're totally open to
- 21:43it. Yeah. Now
- 21:47Oh, go ahead. Was just gonna say, yeah. You know? But the demand
- 21:51portion is really important. Right? Like and what is important to us is that all of our transactions
- 21:57are in Bitcoin.
- 21:58And,
- 22:00certainly, at this point in time, there there are only a few types of transactions that really make sense to be made
- 22:07in Bitcoin.
- 22:08Mhmm. And
- 22:10where we're seeing that is in
- 22:13Bitcoin collectibles,
- 22:14Bitcoin art.
- 22:17It's absolutely fascinating to go into the Bitcoin talk forums and see
- 22:24auctions for some of these Bitcoin collectibles
- 22:27being done in, like, you know, a very rudimentary,
- 22:30web one point o forum. And it's because the people in these forums, like, they are purists. Like, they only want to sell and buy with Bitcoin when it comes to Bitcoin collectibles.
- 22:42So to us, that's the, you know, first sweet spot that we wanna go after.
- 22:48I think over time, the
- 22:52types of transactions happening over
- 22:55Bitcoin will expand,
- 22:57and, you know, those will become addressable for us. But, you know, we wanna make sure that that, you
- 23:05know,
- 23:07the the desire to transact in Bitcoin is already there before we move into that.
- 23:12So I I'm assuming that you guys are reaching out to some of the, you know, more well known artists,
- 23:17directly and saying, hey. We got this thing. Will you kind of, you know, help help us out, like, you know, consider, you know, putting some stuff up like Lucio Paletti and some of those guys?
- 23:28Yeah. We have, we have an all star cast of, Bitcoin artists,
- 23:32in our Telegram group. You know, we're
- 23:35battle testing all of our ideas and
- 23:38and,
- 23:39prototypes
- 23:40against them. They've been
- 23:43hugely helpful in just
- 23:45helping us understand what's important to them.
- 23:49And,
- 23:51yeah, we have a process for admitting new members.
- 23:54Everybody votes on it.
- 23:56I my vote is worth the same amount as any other person in the group.
- 24:01So, yeah, it's, you know, we wouldn't have a chance without having
- 24:06the
- 24:07acceptance of the Bitcoin artist community, and they've just been hugely helpful already.
- 24:13Okay. So,
- 24:15let's see. Let's take a I was just marking stuff off my list here. Shipping and delivery.
- 24:20The white paper mentioned something about integrating with tracking the package.
- 24:25Is it did I read that wrong, or is that indeed what you guys are doing?
- 24:30So the white paper probably could use an update. And Okay. We're kind of we're we're really focused on the auctions now. And depending on how that goes,
- 24:38you probably see a pretty significant update to the white paper. Okay. But the way we the way we are structuring
- 24:45the auctions is we act as an escrow service.
- 24:50So when the auction is complete,
- 24:52the winner of the auction, they pay us.
- 24:55And then we work with the artist to make sure that the
- 25:00artist
- 25:01is packed securely.
- 25:03And once it's put into the mail and and, you know, sent to
- 25:07the auction winner,
- 25:09We receive tracking for that, and that's kind of our verification that, you know, the artist has done their point their part at that point. Right. And we pay them. Now, of course, there's still plenty of risk in the process from there of
- 25:24of the art getting from point a to point b,
- 25:27and that's where we offer insurance
- 25:29service.
- 25:30And because we are
- 25:32working with the artist to make sure that art is the art is packed securely,
- 25:36we're comfortable taking that risk. Of course, we are getting compensated for it.
- 25:42But the point here is we wanna give the buyer
- 25:45as much security as possible that,
- 25:48you know, they're not at risk of the item
- 25:50being damaged or lost in transit.
- 25:53Right.
- 25:54Do you guys leverage, like, the postal service,
- 25:57insurance
- 25:58stuff, like, where,
- 25:59you know, you get the artist to say, hey. You know, this thing cost this, with the tracking number. We need you know, it'd be nice to have proof of insurance that in case it does get lost, that there's some kind of recompensation.
- 26:11Do y'all do any anything like that?
- 26:14It's it's the same basic idea.
- 26:17But we're just we're taking it on ourselves.
- 26:20Okay. Because we used to do that well, that was mandatory when we were shipping stuff
- 26:25around The United States. Everything was insured that way. Worst case scenario, we could ping the post office or, you know,
- 26:32whoever was doing our shipping that offered insurance. We all I think we only shipped with,
- 26:37USPS for that reason because they were the only ones that had a good insurance thing. But,
- 26:43so so the the let's say that, you know, it's not it's not a digital piece of art. It's a physical piece of art.
- 26:50Auction has been won.
- 26:52The guy has acted, you know,
- 26:55in in an ethical manner, has gone ahead and paid the the full price for winning the auction.
- 27:00Now it's up to the artist to ship that thing and pack it well, and then you guys are taking on that, you know, the beat space risk.
- 27:07So when the package actually arrives to the person
- 27:11the the winning bidder,
- 27:13does the winning bidder, is it do they, you know, have
- 27:16a obligation to contact you and say, yes. It it arrived. Here's a, you know, screenshot of it. Or, yes. It arrived, but it's damaged, and here's where the damage is. Is that how you would assess that, you know, that those kind of issues on their end?
- 27:31Yeah. It would be more of, like, we don't need to know anything unless something went wrong. Uh-huh. Okay. And and, of course, we would need
- 27:40proof of that in some form. And it's a it's a great question,
- 27:43and something that we're thinking through really closely right now and and the best way to do that.
- 27:49But if everything goes well, we don't need to hear from the buyer from them.
- 27:54Okay. Okay. That well, that that does that actually does make sense.
- 27:57We we would never hear from our customers unless there was, you know, something wrong either. But,
- 28:02yeah, that that whole thing with, you know, the the the interconnection between, you know, Bitcoin,
- 28:09Lightning Network, you know, all this stuff, and MeetSpaces,
- 28:12I think is much trickier than we're giving it credit for. And, you know, as the problems
- 28:18continuously pop up, you know, it'll be like whack a mole, and we'll you know, eventually, we'll just crush them when they come down. But, you know, the minute that that
- 28:26that edge
- 28:27between
- 28:29Bitcoin and and actual space is just
- 28:32I think there's a whole lot of growth potential in in figuring out how to solve logistical problems there. And I don't see anybody actually doing it. I mean, you guys are, you know, are there at the edge because you have to do stuff in meat space. But I think there's going to be a lot of opportunity for Bitcoiners to go, you know, there's there's a, you know, million problems here that could be solved, and here's the solution. So,
- 28:56yeah. We're thinking along the same lines. You know? The the challenge in solving the problem is our opportunity.
- 29:03So when,
- 29:04when is are you guys gonna
- 29:06you I think you guys you're you're saying that you're pretty much in the still in the testing phase. Is there a beta coming up that people can look forward to? Is there some way for, you know, listeners to take part of this?
- 29:18Yeah. We're, I wanna say two to three weeks out from launching our first lightning auction.
- 29:24Okay. We have,
- 29:26we have a,
- 29:28a a very special
- 29:30work of, fine Bitcoin art that's, just finishing up production.
- 29:36We're still kind of keeping that close to the vest, but there will be a big announcement once it's ready to show.
- 29:42Okay. Well, do me a favor. You know, let me help out. When that when you're about ready to release, if you'll ping me on that,
- 29:51on that tweet or whatever social media that you're you know, all that stuff,
- 29:55I'll help, you know, relay that message because I know it's, you know, it's it's hard to get traction in in a space that's filled with so much noise.
- 30:04That's for sure. I appreciate that. I'll definitely keep that in mind. Thank you. Okay. So now we're gonna shift gears. There's some things that that you wanted to talk about.
- 30:13And one of the first ones because we're we have been talking about art,
- 30:17and sometimes they're a meat space, but often we're seeing this stuff the the these non fungible token art,
- 30:24and it's coming it's been
- 30:27kinda coming to Bitcoin more and more and more.
- 30:30And you wanted to say how it's creating a new renaissance.
- 30:34I'm really interested in pulling those thoughts out of your head.
- 30:38Yeah. So I figured if we're gonna talk for an hour, I have to have one point where I try to stir the pot up up a little bit and
- 30:44say something controversial.
- 30:46Oh, no.
- 30:48But, you know,
- 30:49when I first heard of NFT art, I thought it was totally crazy,
- 30:55but I felt
- 30:57a responsibility to do some due diligence here. Like, we're at least in a tangential space. I need to understand what this thing's all about.
- 31:04So
- 31:05got into it,
- 31:07bought a piece of,
- 31:09NFT art,
- 31:11And,
- 31:12you know, it certainly has many pitfalls, which I'm happy to go into.
- 31:17But the one thing that I realized
- 31:20really quickly is that the community of artists and collectors
- 31:25are just so unbelievably
- 31:27enthusiastic.
- 31:28And
- 31:29I I've learned the hard way to,
- 31:32not discount something that looks silly with a really,
- 31:35enthusiastic
- 31:36community.
- 31:37Mhmm. And, you know, it's it's gotten it it's
- 31:41what's been proven for sure is that there's
- 31:45demand from real collectors for this type of art, and what that has incentivized
- 31:51is their creation of
- 31:54just incredible works of art. And now they are purely digital, but because they are digital, they're able to create entirely new experiences
- 32:02that just aren't aren't possible in the real world. Right. And, yeah,
- 32:07in my mind, the flywheel has already
- 32:10kind of taken shape,
- 32:12where
- 32:14the art is getting better, which is gonna attract
- 32:18different types of collectors.
- 32:20And at the same time, you know, one of the biggest knocks on this thing is, you know, I can just copy and paste this and view it in my phone browser just the same.
- 32:29But you have this whole
- 32:31infrastructure
- 32:32layer that's being built around it because there is real demand here.
- 32:37And there's gonna be new ways to interact with this type of digital art that just wasn't possible before.
- 32:43So I think all of this is it's it's in motion. Now, like, the format of it, I have no idea. I think we're just scratching the surface of Yeah. What's possible here.
- 32:54And,
- 32:56you know, there's
- 32:57there's a ton of problems in the space. There's, you know, straight up fraud. There's plenty of wash trading.
- 33:03And it's, you know, it's all
- 33:07at the foundation,
- 33:08it's on Ethereum, which,
- 33:11I think probably many
- 33:13of your listeners and, you know, I would share with you that that's that's shaky foundation.
- 33:17Yeah.
- 33:19So,
- 33:20you know, it's it's interesting going through the experience of buying one of these things because what it felt like to me is that I'm holding
- 33:27basically,
- 33:29ether, but in a more expressive
- 33:31way,
- 33:34which is kind of cool, but also comes with a whole lot of risk. Right? Like, you're not only betting on the work of art. You're betting on the artist. You're betting on, like, the NFT
- 33:46concept,
- 33:47and you're betting on the blockchain that it's all on.
- 33:51Yeah. And, you know, like, the platform has already shifted. I don't know if you remember the the rare peeps or rare pepe's or I don't know how to pronounce it. Yes. I do. I remember the rare pepes very well.
- 34:03Yeah.
- 34:05So, like, you know, some of that art's
- 34:07really cool. Some of the artists are great, but I don't think those rare pepes are gonna be worth too much going forward because that
- 34:15platform is just kind of become you know, it's become less relevant. Right? So Right.
- 34:22My point here is that,
- 34:24I think there's a really interesting potential, but
- 34:27a whole lot of risk. And I think it becomes
- 34:30it can become much more interesting
- 34:32if it becomes if it comes to Bitcoin because then,
- 34:36you know, you're
- 34:38not just holding Bitcoin. You're you're you have ways to hold Bitcoin in more expressive ways,
- 34:44and you've been derisked
- 34:47somewhat
- 34:48by holding it on
- 34:50a blockchain that, in my mind, is much more secure.
- 34:54Yeah. I agree. I was talking the first interview that I did, was with Samson Moe and,
- 35:00his art director, Wayne Won Chong, for from the, Infinite Fleet game. You familiar with that?
- 35:07I'm not familiar with that one specifically.
- 35:09Yeah. You know who Samson Moe is?
- 35:12Yeah. Yeah. Hey. A guy from Blockstream. Lizard lizard person apparently gonna kill us all, but, no, he's actually a really nice guy.
- 35:20But, you know, he's he's chief
- 35:23to chief strategy officer at Blockstream.
- 35:26But in, you know, in I guess in the you know, at night, he becomes video game developer. And if you haven't checked out Infinite Fleet, it's definitely worth take taking a look at. But they're using the the liquid side chain inside
- 35:39their
- 35:42their game,
- 35:43with the what's called the INF token, which is a token pegged to Bitcoin
- 35:48on, you know or it's it's pegged in a way to Bitcoin
- 35:52because it's through the Liquid Network.
- 35:54Now they
- 35:56are actually doing NFTs
- 35:58in a way.
- 36:00And the way that they're, you know, the way that they're approaching it is as video game, you know, items like buying a new ship. But there's also the potential for art to come in there, too. One of the things that I think about a lot is, you know, some of the best art that I've ever seen in my entire life is in video games.
- 36:17And like my favorite game ever,
- 36:20and it took me years to to actually play it. I'd heard about it, but I
- 36:24by the time that I played it all the way through, it was already, like, seven years old.
- 36:28And that's Bioshock.
- 36:30And some of the art inside that game,
- 36:33the the architecture,
- 36:36the way that they did things is was absolutely
- 36:39just brilliant.
- 36:40And I keep thinking about the fact that I can only experience that art either by firing up the game
- 36:48or,
- 36:49looking for screenshots or firing up the game and taking my own screenshots. That's the only way you're getting that art out of that game.
- 36:56Well, here comes NFTs.
- 36:59And what I think about that is that, you know, being able to play, you know, new games that come online,
- 37:05like maybe from Satoshi's games or Donner Lab,
- 37:08the guys that are, you know, really working with Bitcoin and other video games is to be able to pull art out and you buy that as an NFT
- 37:17and it's sort of
- 37:18kind of licensed
- 37:20to you. Not that you own it, but it's licensed to you. And then there's the other way that goes in.
- 37:25And I'm thinking, you know, what you're talking about,
- 37:29and, you know, NFT artists
- 37:31creating one of these things and then being able to license their art
- 37:36and have it appear in a video game
- 37:39where their art
- 37:41is actually selected by one of the art developers
- 37:44or, art directors at a video game saying, you know, dude, Lucho's stuff
- 37:48would be perfect in this room because it has this kind of architecture. And they contact Lucho, and he says, yeah, dude. I'll I'll I'll either license you these that I've got on the shelf or I'll or I'll do you a custom piece. And then all of a sudden, the artist gets paid.
- 38:02Never had to do anything with you know, to fly to Amsterdam or wherever these companies are and, you know, hang out with them just
- 38:10and all of a sudden, you can crowdsource all the art that you need
- 38:14and have licensing
- 38:15potential
- 38:17on all of it. So I I don't think you're far from the truth that this is helping to create a new renaissance here, man.
- 38:24Yeah. I agree. You know, at the end of the day, this is software. Right? So it's it's it's essentially just programmable
- 38:30art. And that's why I think we're just scratching the surface at at what's possible here. When you start getting into commercial rights and,
- 38:37you know, exclusive content that comes with that NFT, there's just a world of possibility.
- 38:43And already, what I think is so fascinating is already you have hundreds, if not thousands, of artists all around the world that now are able to make a living off of
- 38:53not just selling art, but, like, selling art that they really wanted
- 38:58to make. You know, I brought up I brought up the renaissance because I think about, like, you know, some of the great artists from the renaissance, like Leonardo da Vinci.
- 39:07From my understanding, a lot of his money was made through
- 39:10commissioned work. Like, he wasn't even,
- 39:13you know, that wasn't even that wasn't coming straight from the heart,
- 39:17you know, some of these works.
- 39:18Right. Because we have this,
- 39:21you know, token model
- 39:23where there is
- 39:25ownership
- 39:26associated with the art now. And you can argue about, like, how legitimate that ownership is. But, you know, as a social construct, we've kind of agreed that, okay. Yes. You own this. I own that. We can trade them, whatever.
- 39:39And because we have these open marketplaces
- 39:42where we can reach an infinite number of people,
- 39:46buying and selling these
- 39:48digital art tokens,
- 39:51you know, now
- 39:53an artist, if they're talented, they can create
- 39:55the art that they want to create. And if it's good, they just need to find one buyer, and these marketplaces make it possible.
- 40:03So to me, that's just that's a a beautiful thing, and it's going to do amazing things for
- 40:09creatives, and what's great for creatives is great for everyone.
- 40:14Yeah. Absolutely. And and what you were talking about, the the commissioned works of people and the artist in the, you know, the the original renaissance,
- 40:22You know, those people were bounded by borders,
- 40:25distance.
- 40:26There was no telecommunications.
- 40:28Letters took, you know, god only knows how long it took a letter to get from Italy to, like, I don't know, you know, Germany or something like that.
- 40:36You know, now
- 40:38with commissions, you know, commissioned works at this point,
- 40:42there are no borders. Communication is instantaneous.
- 40:46It's gonna be real interesting to see how this one rolls out. I'll tell you that, man.
- 40:51Yeah. I mean, we're super excited about it, and that's why we wanna be pioneers in bringing it to Bitcoin. We think it's a huge opportunity.
- 40:58Yeah. Absolutely, man. So now we go from from NFTs.
- 41:02Let's talk about punk rock.
- 41:04What what what you what you got bait what what's bacon in your brain about punk rock? Yeah. This one's been on my mind. You know, I, that's not for me. It's, I listened to,
- 41:13Peter McCormick,
- 41:16podcast he had on, this dude from The Clash. I think his name's, Keith Keith Levine. Did you listen to that? Oh, I listen I actually had to listen to that one twice because I was
- 41:27had an emergency I had to make an emergency
- 41:29run from Panhandle Of Texas to Southwest Colorado because my sister had broken her foot.
- 41:35I started at 04:00 in the afternoon to basically
- 41:39embark on a ten hour drive that was gonna put me somewhere in Colorado around 02:00 in the morning.
- 41:46And,
- 41:47Yeah. Keith was Keith and Peter were my wingmen on that particular trip. That was a baller's
- 41:53interview, man, because that dude that dude got it. He just understood, and I'm like, man. Punk rockers. Check him out.
- 42:02Absolutely. And he's just he's the type of guy too where he could just keep talking and you're like, yeah. Just keep talking. I'm listening. Whatever you got to say, like, I wanna hear. He's just such a fun guy to listen to.
- 42:13Yeah. But
- 42:14but, like, you know, it really resonated
- 42:17with me hearing him talk about it because he's talking about the pump movement and whatever. And I I wasn't around for that.
- 42:23But, you know, I I did kind of come of age in, like, the grunge period, which had a similar, like, stick to the man type of vibe.
- 42:31Right. And when I look back on that, what what was really interesting is, like, that whole movement was broadcasted
- 42:37to the public through MTV.
- 42:39Mhmm. Right? Like, all, you know, all the music videos, all the live performances, Kurt Cobain, totally strong outlook flipping off the camera. Like, that was all. We saw all of that. Right. It was amazing.
- 42:51But then I don't know what happened first,
- 42:53but, you know, like, grunge kind of ended. And around the same time, MTV stopped playing music videos, and they started playing the real world, whatever. But it was almost it almost feels like it was like a form of censorship.
- 43:04And maybe this is just me how I remember it.
- 43:08And, you know, I can't think of
- 43:10a single counterculture
- 43:13movement.
- 43:14Like, since then, that's been widely broadcasted through the mainstream media.
- 43:19And,
- 43:21you know, of course, mainstream media has become much less relevant since then. But even now in social media, we have cancel culture. So, like, anything that's controversial,
- 43:30it faces some type of censorship.
- 43:33So Right. Coming back to Bitcoin, like, Bitcoin is the ultimate
- 43:38counterculture
- 43:39movement. It's the ultimate
- 43:41stick to the man, but Bitcoin is
- 43:44not censorable.
- 43:45And, you know, of course,
- 43:47most directly in its transactions, but also in its its culture and its narratives. Like,
- 43:53we have what what does,
- 43:55what's Michael Saylor call it? The cyber hornets. Right? Like, we're the
- 43:59decentralized pack of cyber hornets.
- 44:03You know
- 44:04Mhmm. If we're going to keep talking about Bitcoin
- 44:07Yeah. You know, we of course, we have Twitter, which is kind of a a central point of failure. Thankfully, we have Jack on our side there. But, you know, if Twitter gets shut down, like, we're gonna find a way to continue talking about Bitcoin.
- 44:18Yeah. So I feel like,
- 44:20you know, there's a lot of parallels there. And just like with, you know, punk rock and grunge, like, the cultural movement was was so important, and I feel
- 44:30like Bitcoin,
- 44:31along with being a
- 44:34financial revolution,
- 44:36is a cultural revolution.
- 44:39And as part of that culture, there's, you know, there's, like,
- 44:44physical items. Like, I want T shirts. I want art
- 44:48so that I can, you know, represent my tribe here.
- 44:53I keep seeing the guy, you know, the guy on Twitter who, like, just goes in the middle of the street and starts yelling Bitcoin. I can't think of it. Dude. Yeah.
- 45:01But, like, I've been thinking about it recently. It's like, I get this guy. Like,
- 45:07if you're into Bitcoin, you just have this urge to start yelling Bitcoin. You know? Like, all of our normie friends are sick of hearing about it from us, but
- 45:16there's a strong need to express
- 45:20enthusiasm for Bitcoin.
- 45:22Yeah. So, anyway, this is what we want to help
- 45:25support and promote.
- 45:27Yeah. You know, I I think I get what you're saying. You know? Because you could you know, back in the punk rock days and even in the grunge days, if you had something to you know, if you
- 45:36if you were feeling particularly, you know, I don't know, salty or whatever
- 45:41and, you know, put on the clash and that sort of making a statement, It's playing that song loud is is in a way
- 45:48not only just because you wanna hear it in many other ways. It could be, you know, the old lady next door, you know, bitch me out for walking on the sidewalk even though that's not her property. So I'm gonna open my windows and play
- 46:01fuck you from whoever. You know? Sure. That's you can make that you can make that statement. And here, every time I make a Bitcoin transaction, I'm making a statement. Not only in my trans
- 46:12yeah. I'm not just transmitting
- 46:14value. I'm transmitting
- 46:16my absolute and utter disdain for all the stuff that I grew up with
- 46:21that was an actual lie,
- 46:24but was never told to me that it really was a lie because there was nobody around who believed anything, you know, anything different.
- 46:31And they all believe the same lie. We've been lied to since before your grandmother
- 46:36was a baby.
- 46:38I we've been lied to a lot longer than that, probably. But, you know, definitely in my time
- 46:43when I grew up, I grew up thinking
- 46:46so much stuff. And now, you know, once you get into Bitcoin, like I said, once that
- 46:51first question pops about, well, what is money? It doesn't take you long to figure out what it was and how we screwed it up.
- 46:59So every transaction is like me playing a song very loud for the lady next door of The Clash.
- 47:05Yeah. That's exactly it.
- 47:08And we we need to,
- 47:11shift in
- 47:12to, something else that you put on the list, which was the psychology of buying with Bitcoin, and we kinda touched on that just a little bit. What what's your thoughts?
- 47:22Yeah. So my experience was, you know,
- 47:25as I kinda mentioned, I I initially wrote off Bitcoin because I thought it would never be used for transactions.
- 47:30But, eventually, I wanted to buy some Bitcoin socks, right, from the, I think it's the the Mount Mount Sox guys. I probably got it wrong.
- 47:39Mount Mount Sox.
- 47:40Mount Socks. Yeah. And,
- 47:42you know, after I bought them, like, I've never been more excited to get socks or, like, maybe any piece of clothing for that matter. Uh-huh. And it just it it made me realize there there's a psychological impact of
- 47:55spending with Bitcoin, especially for something that can only be bought with Bitcoin.
- 48:01Right. Oh, it made me feel, like, nostalgic as a kid when my mom would take me to Toys R Us once a month, and I could spend $5 on a
- 48:09a toy. Like, when I got that toy, I really valued that toy because I used, like, my, like, scarcest resource to get it. And I kinda felt the same way with these socks. Like, I spent, like, the money that I really value to get these socks.
- 48:21So look. I mean, I think,
- 48:23as I kinda mentioned, I think we're a long way from using
- 48:27Bitcoin for everyday purchases.
- 48:30You know, generally, like, fiat goods should be bought with fiat.
- 48:34But I think there's, there's plenty of special purchases specifically in Bitcoin
- 48:39culture
- 48:40that, you know, not only do people wanna sell them for Bitcoin, but people actually appreciate
- 48:47buying them with Bitcoin.
- 48:49So, yeah, that's what that's why I think that's the most interesting area for us to go after. Did you take part in the, Citadel 21 physical magazine,
- 48:59when they launched that?
- 49:01Yeah.
- 49:02Yeah. No. I I've got, I've got a issue one and issue two. Yeah. It's to say that it it ties back to, you know, kind of the crunch stuff too. Like, this is all these are the cultural elements of this revolution.
- 49:14And, getting these things, it just it just having it in your hands feels amazing.
- 49:19Yeah. And it wasn't you know, for me, it was, you know,
- 49:22getting the magazine, and I don't want, you know, Huddl or not and and Katya to take this the wrong way, but getting the physical magazine was
- 49:30wasn't anywhere close to the rush
- 49:33that I had when I was sitting there with my finger
- 49:36on the button,
- 49:38and then the countdown
- 49:39stopped. And I, like, hit buy
- 49:43immediately. I logged it, you know, got it. I was already logged in, but I was like, I I got to the to the store page, and I'm just waiting for the auction to actually start. Starts up,
- 49:52go there, hit buy,
- 49:54and all their servers burnt to the ground.
- 49:57Because every they had one server that they had from what I understand, they had one server that was handling the load,
- 50:03and we, like all the Bitcoiners, had spread the news
- 50:07so majestically
- 50:09for free
- 50:10that the response
- 50:12was
- 50:13way more than their, their little server could handle. So it burns to the ground.
- 50:18We start, you know, we're having a good time on Twitter
- 50:21talking about
- 50:22how this is, you know, it's amazing and look at what's happening and all that kind of stuff. And then they bring three more servers
- 50:29plus the original one online,
- 50:31and I felt no more I felt I've never felt
- 50:35so much joy in purchasing something, especially for $21
- 50:39than I did at that moment. So because I'll go to, like, you know, not eBay,
- 50:44you know, Amazon to buy something.
- 50:47I don't get charged up. I don't like, I'm just god. I gotta spend more money.
- 50:52Really?
- 50:53You know? And it's just a drag.
- 50:55And this from a psychological
- 50:57standpoint,
- 50:59I kind of like spending money
- 51:02or spending Bitcoin, but I only do that through the LNStrike
- 51:06so that I can convert dirty fiat immediately to, you know, Bitcoin that is then sent to the vendor. That I don't mind, but I I don't like spending out of my cold storage. So there's that. So, yeah, there's some some real intricacies here.
- 51:20Yeah. And you bring up Ellen Strike. I haven't been I haven't been able to use it yet. It's, you know, not available in New York, but that takes it to the next level. You know? Not only are you spending money that you value, but you're burning that money that you told,
- 51:34in exchange for money that you value.
- 51:36Again, yeah, that's a perfect way to put it. Not only are you buying something of value that you want with money that that you're excited about and at the same time, putting
- 51:45this lie into a brown paper bag, pouring diesel on it, and lighting it on fire.
- 51:51There's nothing there's a that's a that's a great that goes back to the whole punk rock thing, honestly. Exactly.
- 51:57Yeah.
- 51:58So now it's the now it's the future. So you,
- 52:01you got something about,
- 52:03you know, the the future of Bitcoin and LN for more than just payments. This seems like a good place to transition to that.
- 52:11Sure. Yeah. So,
- 52:14you know, it was interesting when we did our first sale. We sold some face masks.
- 52:19And,
- 52:20like,
- 52:21going into that sale, we weren't even
- 52:24sure we were going to support Lightning,
- 52:27because, you know, we saw it as, like, MVP, minimum viable product.
- 52:30We wanted to keep it as bare bones as possible,
- 52:33but it just so happened to be during a time when,
- 52:37fees were spiking. Actually, I think it was just after the halving, so it was late May. So fees were up,
- 52:43and we're like, okay. We gotta support Lightning. Right?
- 52:46And we were we were blown away
- 52:50that over a third of our transactions were in Lightning.
- 52:53Yep. And up to that point, I had just been a passive
- 52:57observer of Lightning.
- 52:58And from that moment, I was like, okay. I gotta try this thing out and see what this is about. So, you know, got set up on a lightning wallet, and it was the first payment that I made. I'm not even sure what it was for, but, like, that was it was just
- 53:11a total
- 53:12moment. Like, oh, well, this is definitely the future of at least Bitcoin payments, if not, you know, much more.
- 53:20So that kinda took me down the whole
- 53:23lightning rabbit hole and, like, saw all the use cases that were being tested
- 53:28with microtransactions
- 53:30and the whole primordial
- 53:31soup going on there. But then,
- 53:34you know,
- 53:35at some point in my research, I came across,
- 53:38it was actually Ryan Gentry's piece.
- 53:41Yeah.
- 53:42He wrote a piece for
- 53:44Multicoin when he was back there.
- 53:47And,
- 53:48I I can't remember the name of it exactly,
- 53:50but it was something like lightning as,
- 53:54you know,
- 53:55web three
- 53:56infrastructure.
- 53:57We actually wrote a blog post on it that, like, totally dumbed it down and made it, you know, memeified
- 54:03because it it is a pretty dense document. But it just Right. It totally
- 54:07opened
- 54:08the possibilities
- 54:10in my mind for, you know, what could be done with Lightning, and it goes way beyond payments.
- 54:15So it goes into, for example,
- 54:18decentralized IDs.
- 54:20So
- 54:21you can use your
- 54:23lightning node public key as basically a
- 54:27a
- 54:28digital identification
- 54:29and get all the benefits of a digital identification
- 54:32with that
- 54:33without, you know, all of the KYC and friction associated with it.
- 54:38So,
- 54:40this is becoming
- 54:41very real right now.
- 54:44LN Markets
- 54:45has
- 54:47created a really great experience
- 54:50with their
- 54:51web app where, you know, you can log in either with
- 54:55your Jewel,
- 54:57Lightning browser wallet,
- 54:59if you're running your own node, or even
- 55:01with
- 55:02most other wallets at this point, you can use ln URL auth. And either way, you're just scanning
- 55:07a QR code and you're logged in. Boom. And not only are you logged in and, you know, you have access to all of your
- 55:14your history with that app,
- 55:16but
- 55:19by default, you're making
- 55:21lightning transactions, which is that just opens up
- 55:24so much possibility.
- 55:26Yep. So so that's one thing we're really excited about implementing.
- 55:30I think we're gonna have it
- 55:32ready for v two of our auctions.
- 55:34And there are a bunch of other things too. You know?
- 55:38You know, I think the,
- 55:40DLCs
- 55:41is maybe something we can use to,
- 55:44you know, minimize the trust in returning our collateral payments,
- 55:48some kind
- 55:49of smart contract,
- 55:51on Bitcoin.
- 55:53There's
- 55:54there's these, like, TLV payments, which if you're familiar with, you know, anything really about Lightning, you know that
- 56:01payments
- 56:02can have a data payload attached to them. And, you know, in the most simple terms, that is
- 56:08text.
- 56:09So you can actually
- 56:11there's this website, TLVshop.com,
- 56:14I think, and they did a test run of this where they sold sticker packs.
- 56:18And all you did was you made a TLV payment, which is just like any other lightning payment, and you're putting in your shipping address into the memo field of the payment.
- 56:27And what this enables is, like, you know,
- 56:30your shipping address is never touching
- 56:33a database,
- 56:35and it's only being sent from, you know,
- 56:38sender to receiver. And through the privacy of lightning, no one else is seeing that. Like, it's as private
- 56:45as it gets.
- 56:46So that's something we wanna test out. We're super excited about.
- 56:51You know, there's a bunch of other stuff that I'm probably not thinking about. But the the point is, like, Lightning is so much more than
- 56:59payments, and I think a lot of the tools that it makes
- 57:03possible
- 57:04are really interesting for
- 57:07app developers, and I think we can bring a lot of it to life with, our ecommerce web marketplace.
- 57:15Well, so, you know, speaking of that,
- 57:17you know, I guess the way to to approach this, you know, this this question is
- 57:24if the question is gonna be,
- 57:26how are you gonna deal with,
- 57:30oh, the changes that are gonna come in the future? Let me caveat that a little bit. We're seeing
- 57:36this I mean, the the rapidity
- 57:39of
- 57:40development and releases of
- 57:43different things.
- 57:44Lightning is not gonna be the last.
- 57:47So, you know, there's gonna be another second layer or or or it could end up being going above lightning and turn into a third layer that puts its hooks into the lightning layer. And then lightning puts its hooks into the Bitcoin main chain, as we know. So,
- 58:00you know, I'm not I'm going to try very hard not to say it this way, but, you know, what if something better comes along? And no, I'm not talking about a shit coin, guys. So give me, you know, give me a break if you're if you're, like, you know, killing me. No. But, I mean, like, new technologies are gonna be built on on on Bitcoin because this ain't stopping.
- 58:19Yeah. You know, it's totally possible.
- 58:22And we're, you know,
- 58:25we're totally unbiased as to what we're using as long as it is based on Bitcoin.
- 58:30Right. My my personal
- 58:32view is that
- 58:35Lightning has
- 58:37achieved
- 58:38kind of platform status.
- 58:40Yeah. Where where there's just so much development on it at this point,
- 58:44and even the l three protocols
- 58:47are depending on Lightning.
- 58:50So I have a hard time seeing
- 58:52Lightning going away.
- 58:54Yeah. And, you know, part of this is also I just believe so much in the community and the people that are working on it.
- 59:02I think it's here to stay. And,
- 59:04but, yeah, look. There's gonna be l three
- 59:07protocols. We're really excited about what's happening with RGB. That's gonna open up, hopefully, a world of possibilities for us.
- 59:14And, you know, all of this is just so early. We can't even imagine what's gonna become possible.
- 59:20Right. It just it's so difficult to keep track of all the developments that are going on in the space that that's where reason I was asking the question is it must
- 59:28you know, it's gonna be it's already at the point and will continue to be the point that if you are, you know, in retail and you're using you know, decided, you know, I just don't wanna take fiat payments anymore.
- 59:39You know, the amount of research
- 59:41that would have to be ongoing
- 59:43just as we enter this space, it's like, okay, you're gonna take part of this space. You're gonna take Bitcoin payments. You're gonna do lightning payments.
- 59:50Buckle up because you're gonna have to know almost everything that goes on, and it's impossible to know everything that goes on even if you're not, you know, doing you know, having to do the business part of it. So, yeah, know, that's one of the reasons I was trying to kind of gauge what, you know, where you were at on on on that because the just the sheer amount of research that I have to do
- 1:00:10every day and I feel like I'm falling further and further behind. It must be really scary thinking,
- 1:00:16what if something else comes out? How could we, you know, transition? How long would that take? And, of course, there's no way of knowing unless the technology actually presents itself. So
- 1:00:25okay. Yeah. It's absolutely true. You know, it's
- 1:00:29we're living in the primordial soup, and you never know what's gonna really come to life here. So you gotta be ready for whatever. That that is really challenging
- 1:00:37for product builders like ourselves. Like, so much of this is out of our control, So we have to be really flexible
- 1:00:44and nimble,
- 1:00:47in the decisions we make and and the moves that we make. You know, I think that's that that nimbleness,
- 1:00:53having to be nimble in the light of what we were just talking about is gonna really train
- 1:00:57some next generation
- 1:00:59business minds to be able to be
- 1:01:01way flexible, way more flexible than they are right now. So I think that that'll feed into second generation effects
- 1:01:09that Bitcoin has even if Bitcoin doesn't touch the business that is built by the people that had to actually wade through this. Although, I'll bet Bitcoin will probably be part of everyday life soon, but you get what I'm saying.
- 1:01:22It is Chris, it's time for ShillFest.
- 1:01:25You gotta shill your stuff, man. Is there any announcements that you wanna, that you've been holding back or anything you wanna say about scarcity?
- 1:01:33You know, check us out on Twitter, scarce.city.
- 1:01:36You gotta spell out d o t.
- 1:01:39Check out our website,
- 1:01:41scarce.city.
- 1:01:44Sign up for our newsletter. We got some really big announcements on the way, the lightning auctions.
- 1:01:50It's gonna be wild. You know? You never know what's gonna happen until you throw something out there. And once we do, it's out of our hands. So, you know, stick around and watch. Whether you're into it or not, it's gonna be entertaining.
- 1:02:02Nice. So how do they get, people get in touch directly with you? You gotta,
- 1:02:06surely, you know what what's your Twitter handle?
- 1:02:10My Twitter handle is,
- 1:02:12c Tremont.
- 1:02:13DMs are open. DMs are also open on the scarcity Twitter. So, you know, I'm easy to find. Feel free to hit me up, however.
- 1:02:20And that Telegram group, is there a do you wanna give that one out, or is that by invitation only to people that you want to
- 1:02:27come in?
- 1:02:28Yeah. That one's invitation
- 1:02:30only at this point. But, hey, if you're a Bitcoin artist and you're doing cool things, let us know. We'll
- 1:02:36we'll take a look. And, you know, we vote as a group to see who we we let in.
- 1:02:40Alright. So we're always That's so excited to, check out new artists.
- 1:02:44Sounds good, Chris. So if you are an artist out there and you wanna get into this,
- 1:02:49contact the guys over at Scare City,
- 1:02:52or see Tramont on Twitter,
- 1:02:55and maybe you can get entry into the super secret club.
- 1:02:59Yeah. I hate to hate to make it sound exclusive like that. But yeah. We No. No. No. It's
- 1:03:05curation and and, quality control is is really important.
- 1:03:09Well yeah. Yeah. And, it same same to be said for, like, you know, the auctions that you guys choose to do because, you know, if, you know, if you were to say, hey, man. Anybody can start their own auction, and we're the platform. Next thing you know,
- 1:03:21sex toys are being sold or, god, no. You know, god, something you don't wanna see is all over the screen. It is like, I don't wanna do it. So, yeah, curation.
- 1:03:30Yeah. There's a difference between curation and censorship, and I think we can
- 1:03:35we know that I think we know the difference there.
- 1:03:38So alright, Chris. It was, awesome. I enjoyed learning more about scarcity,
- 1:03:44yourself, your just the the punk rock stories. You know? But,
- 1:03:48it was it was a great discussion, and I really appreciate it. Thank you for your time, sir.
- 1:03:53Likewise, David. This has been amazing. Thanks so much for having me on. Oh, absolutely. And if you ever need to announce something, hit me up. My DMs are always open.
- 1:04:01I will. Thank you. Alright. See
- 1:04:03you later, Chris. Alright. See you.
- 1:04:16I'd like to thank Chris again
- 1:04:18for giving me a long
- 1:04:21a long interview. He was very gracious with his time, and I very much appreciate that. So again, Chris Tremont, thank you,
- 1:04:28for telling us all about scarce.
- 1:04:31City.
- 1:04:32That I'm really I'm really excited about that.
- 1:04:36I, you know, especially if it goes into,
- 1:04:38you know, either them doing it or somebody else doing it. Somebody, you know, developing a full blown auction platform
- 1:04:44that uses,
- 1:04:45Lightning Auctions.
- 1:04:47You know, it was kind of tried, you know, Brian Hoffman
- 1:04:51was kind of doing a little bit like that.
- 1:04:56Well, not really. Open Bazaar is, you know, different than just a full blown auction, I think. But,
- 1:05:02he kind of screwed up by
- 1:05:04going the side of
- 1:05:06Bitcoin Cash
- 1:05:07and I think then he started accepting bsv and
- 1:05:11you know that thing is almost dead.
- 1:05:14That's what you do when you tangle with
- 1:05:17you know, Bitcoin.
- 1:05:19And, I mean, I became very much not interested in using that platform at all the minute that that Brian started, talking about how some of these other things might be better than Bitcoin.
- 1:05:30Like,
- 1:05:31you know, you're you're not being a very good steward of this of the technology. You're you're in it for yourself. You're not in it for anybody else that, you know, and he I'm sure that Brian doesn't believe that. But I mean,
- 1:05:43everybody who's, you know, all these companies that have done that,
- 1:05:47are not doing well. Y'all's.
- 1:05:49Well, not y'all's.org.
- 1:05:51Yours Org.
- 1:05:53I can't remember the guy's name because he's already slipping out of all of our collective memories.
- 1:05:57It's dead. I mean, I can't even go to, like, if I go to the website foryours.org,
- 1:06:03it's it's completely dead. It's a dead gateway. Doesn't go anywhere.
- 1:06:07And then he did money button, which is also on the rocks. And this is yet somebody else. Was it Charles or Charles x or I can't
- 1:06:16anyway, he did the exact same thing that Brian Hoffman did only way more vocal.
- 1:06:22And he also completely dropped any kind of support for Bitcoin and went completely b s v, that
- 1:06:29all those projects were almost dead too.
- 1:06:32Yeah. Don't don't do that. It's just that you're playing with your life anyway. So,
- 1:06:37there's not much else going on. Again, I'm gonna bring you some more interviews this week, for the week of Thanksgiving,
- 1:06:44and I'll see you on the other side.
- 1:06:47This has been Bitcoin, and and I'm your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 1:06:55Have a great day.