Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / ICBC Privacy Breach, Royal Bank Sues over Visa Bill and Looses, and a Tree Dispute
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, legally Speaking, joined by Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Morning, michael.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: Some interesting stories on the agenda this week, including an update on a story that we previously discussed regarding the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia and personal privacy.
- 0:21Michael Mulligan: Indeed, it's a troubling case that's been working its way through the court system for quite some time now information to a very problematic individual in order to identify the addresses and owners of cars which were parked around the Justice Institute and that's where they'd be doing training for police and others.
- 0:57Michael Mulligan: And the individual who was purchasing the information was eventually engaged in really troublesome he and others.
- 1:07Michael Mulligan: He was using the personal information that he was purchasing from the ICBC employee in order to go and commit arsons and shootings at the homes of the people who had parked near the Justice Institute and ultimately, that individual that was purchasing the information from the ICBC employee engaged in 13 incidents of arson and shootings at the homes of these people.
- 1:35Michael Mulligan: Very problematic that that person was described as having a drug-induced paranoid belief that he was being targeted and controlled by the Justice Institute paranoid belief that he was being targeted and controlled by the Justice Institute.
- 1:47Michael Mulligan: Ultimately, that person was convicted of.
- 1:52Michael Mulligan: He pled guilty to 18 different criminal charges and was sentenced to 13 and a half years in prison back in 2016.
- 1:55Michael Mulligan: The next issue then became the ICBC claims adjuster who was selling the information, apparently for $25 per person, and the claims adjuster wound up being charged as well.
- 2:11Michael Mulligan: He wound up on probation and then the next step was a civil claim against ICBC, and the basis of the civil claim was alleging that ICBC had responsibility for what their employee did which is not a particularly novel concept and that was commenced as a class action on behalf of 78 individuals who had their personal information improperly accessed by the claims adjuster and, in many cases, sold for 25 bucks a shot.
- 2:53Michael Mulligan: And that concept is vicarious liability.
- 2:56Michael Mulligan: The idea is, if you had an employee and you're not properly supervising them and they're off doing something like this, you, the employer, can wind up on the hook for it.
- 3:05Michael Mulligan: So that's the basis of it, ICBC.
- 3:09Michael Mulligan: This is, I think, one of the really interesting things about this is it demonstrates the culture of ICBC, which ties in with the changes recently about moving to a no-fault system and what that means and what I mean by the culture of it.
- 3:25Michael Mulligan: It's demonstrated by this piece of litigation over the privacy breach by the insurance adjuster.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: Icbc insurance adjuster and ICBC fought this thing tooth and nail.
- 3:40Michael Mulligan: They took it to the Court of Appeal four times, appealing various parts of this claim, and what ICBC eventually settled on is they thought that they should have to pay no more than $500 to each of the people affected by this privacy breach occasioned by their employee, and the decision which just came out from the judge, after these various appeals back and forth fighting over various things, going to the court of appeal, was a conclusion that that was wholly inadequate and the judge awarded $15,000 per class member for having their information accessed in this way, permitting that very troublesome arson and shooting attacks.
- 4:27Michael Mulligan: And I guess what that really demonstrates is the importance of there being a remedy whereby somebody who is aggrieved can go to court and have an independent judge make the decision at the end of the day and that has been in ICBC's case as a result of no fault taken away and so people who are now subject to decisions by IC's lives where the only remedy are things like appealing to a civil resolution tribunal with a bunch of people on it who are short-term government contractors, or making complaints to an ombudsperson, you can appreciate that when you combine that with an institution like ICBC that has a demonstrated culture of taking positions like that demonstrated in this case, it is not hard to understand why we are seeing repeated examples of people who are seriously hurt and just are treated terribly and don't wind up with the compensation that they require, compensation that they require, and so it's hard to imagine perhaps a clearer case of that than this, when you have an employee of ICBC who is engaged in this conduct, selling personal information, causing just this awful series of crimes.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: Once those people had been identified and ICBC taking the position that the appropriate compensation for each of them would be $500.
- 6:11Michael Mulligan: And so that's the end of that, hopefully, this saga.
- 6:16Michael Mulligan: Hopefully there isn't some effort to go to the Court of Appeal a fifth time complaining about the $15,000 award for all of these people who went through all of this, and hopefully that is at least, after much litigation, the final chapter of this very unfortunate and dangerous circumstance that flowed from privacy breaches.
- 6:39Adam Stirling: Our next story is particularly I think it's unusual, or at least I hope it's unusual.
- 6:44Adam Stirling: It's troubling regarding a claim brought against a 74-year-old widow on the matter of the payment of her late husband's visa bill.
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: Yes indeed, and I must say this is one of those cases when you read that gives you at least gives me cause for a bit of a smile in terms of just a little bit of justice coming out in the decision.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: And the background of it is the Royal Bank of Canada issued a visa card to a husband of this woman many years ago and over a period of time.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: Eventually there was a balance on the card and, very sadly, the husband who applied for it passed away in 2019, and at that time there were some $25,000 owing on the card.
- 7:33Michael Mulligan: But the Royal Bank, of course, calculated the 20% interest 19.99% and was therefore suing the 74 year old widow for $51,764.09, and there were several elements to it.
- 7:50Michael Mulligan: One element to it the widow realized that her late husband had been paying for balance protector insurance on the credit card for many years on a yearly basis.
- 8:04Michael Mulligan: That was something which was supposed to pay off the credit card if somebody died.
- 8:08Michael Mulligan: But I guess the widow didn't know about that and so hadn't made a claim in time for that kind of insurance.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: She was claiming that the bank should have told her.
- 8:18Michael Mulligan: The bank's position was that they had no duty to assist her because this was a third-party insurer.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: Even though the bank sold the insurance, that part of the claim didn't get anywhere for the widow.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: But the bank then ran into a bit of trouble and, as the judge in this case pointed out, when you are someone who is the person doing the suing, you are the person who bears the evidentiary burden of proving all the things you need to prove.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: It's not for the other person to disprove it.
- 8:48Michael Mulligan: That's similar to a criminal case, but in a civil case, of course, you only need to prove it on a balance of probabilities.
- 8:54Michael Mulligan: And here one of the central issues was what is the widow's status in relation to the credit card?
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: And the Royal Bank took the position that the widow was a co-applicant for the credit card, and that's a concept in the cardholder's terms, and the bank relied on things like well, we send out notices of things from time to time, but what the bank did not have was the original application for the credit card, and they provide no cogent explanation for why they didn't have that.
- 9:28Adam Stirling: Bizarre.
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: Their witness was somebody who worked at the bank but simply couldn't find the original application form.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: And the credit card contemplates not only a co-applicant but another concept of a quote authorized users close quote, which is somebody who's permitted to use a credit card like one's been issued in their name, but they're not responsible for the balance.
- 9:51Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 9:51Michael Mulligan: If somebody got a you know a credit card for their child or somebody else you know, that doesn't necessarily make them responsible for the payment.
- 9:59Michael Mulligan: It could be just the person who's you know applied for the credit card.
- 10:02Michael Mulligan: And the judge first of all found that the bank just wasn't in a position to prove that the widow had ever applied for this credit card or was a co-applicant.
- 10:13Michael Mulligan: In fact, her evidence was no, I didn't have anything to do with that.
- 10:16Michael Mulligan: My late husband did that.
- 10:17Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found first of all that the Royal Bank had just failed to prove that she was a co-applicant for it.
- 10:24Michael Mulligan: They just didn't have any paperwork to prove that, and pointing to various bills and things they sent out also wasn't sufficient.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: Furthermore, there's a provision in the Carlson agreement that the judge obviously read very carefully that provides that if there are increases to the credit limit, there has to be consent from the parties in order for them to be liable for it.
- 10:47Michael Mulligan: Right, even if you had somebody who was a co-applicant to a credit card under this agreement, if one of them managed to increase the credit limit but didn't get your approval to do so, you would be on the hook for the increased debt they might run up.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: And again, on that point, the judge found that the Royal Bank had just not produced any evidence to show that the widow had agreed to the various credit increases that had occurred over the life of the credit card, and so she wasn't.
- 11:17Michael Mulligan: For that reason as well, she wasn't responsible for the debt.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: And so the outcome of all of this, after some Supreme Court litigation, is that the Royal Bank of Canada failed to meet its burden to prove that the 74-year-old widow was a co-applicant to this credit card, and the net result and a little piece of justice is that she will not be on the hook for the $51,000 the World Bank was trying to get from her.
- 11:44Michael Mulligan: And so a useful case, both in terms of just bearing in mind who has to prove what, and not necessarily accepting the conclusion that a large institution has come to and if you are a large institution.
- 11:59Michael Mulligan: You better keep some records around, or else you might find that you're unsuccessful in trying to collect money.
- 12:06Michael Mulligan: So that's the little justice smile from the failure of the Royal Bank and the 74-year-old widow with her deceased husband's visa card.
- 12:17Adam Stirling: Legally speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers a perfect time for a break.
- 12:21Adam Stirling: We'll continue right after this, back on the air here at CFAX 1070, as we continue with Legally Speaking, joined as always by Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 12:30Adam Stirling: Up next, michael, let's see.
- 12:32Adam Stirling: We have, is it?
- 12:33Adam Stirling: Three litigants, small claims court and a precious, precious little amount of success, if any.
- 12:42Michael Mulligan: That's exactly right, and I guess this is a case involving three neighbors suing each other over trees and trespass and offense, and I guess the first legal tip for everyone listening would be this Don't sue your neighbors in small claims court over trees or fences, sort it out.
- 13:02Michael Mulligan: And so this is somebody who didn't have the benefit of that advice and decided to commence small claims court litigation over exactly those sorts of issues.
- 13:14Adam Stirling: Very well.
- 13:16Michael Mulligan: And there are, in addition to that, pearl of wisdom and as well, I should say, this case may also offer some insight into why there may be a decreased number of applicants to take positions as provincial court judges, who can spend their days doing things, including sitting on small claims, neighbors disputes over trees and tree roots.
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: So there is that.
- 13:39Michael Mulligan: But there are some legal concepts embedded in that decision which I think people should be aware of, and they include the concept of concepts involving who's responsible for what with trees and what judges in small claims court are in fact able to do.
- 13:58Michael Mulligan: And starting with the issue of what judges in small claims court are able to do, legal authority for judges is not, of course, unlimited and in particular for provincial court judges, where all of their authority has to be found somewhere in statute right, unlike the BC Supreme Court, which is sometimes referred to as a court of inherent jurisdiction, where some of their authority doesn't derive from some piece of legislation somewhere.
- 14:29Michael Mulligan: They are independent constitutional actors and they do not rely in all respects on legal authority found in statute somewhere.
- 14:37Michael Mulligan: Some things they can just do inherently, whether the legislature likes it or not, but with respect to provincial court judges, they have to find some legal authority in statute somewhere to do something, and that includes their authority when they're sorting out small claims disputes.
- 14:56Michael Mulligan: And so the provincial court small claims division has authority to deal with disputes up to $35,000.
- 15:04Michael Mulligan: And that's actually, as we've, I think, mentioned before, a constitutional limitation.
- 15:09Michael Mulligan: One of the reasons, one of the ways we preserve the independence of the superior court, which has all kinds of constitutional protections, like when you can remove a judge and when you can't, and so on is to restrict legislature's ability to just transfer all of their authority to someone else who you could then boss around or fire or whatnot.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: But they have a jurisdiction up to $35,000, and they have some limited authority to require people to do specific things.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: But here, for example, one of the neighbors involved in this litigation was asking the provincial court judge to do things, including to order a municipality to issue a permit to remove a tree, and that's something that the provincial court judge just doesn't have authority to do and was also trying to get an order to order one of the neighbors to apply for a permit to remove a tree.
- 16:09Michael Mulligan: There's also no authority to do that.
- 16:10Michael Mulligan: So that couldn't go anywhere and the neighbor was trying to get an order that the neighbor be ordered to hire a contractor to take out trees.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: You can't do that either, and so you can make a claim for money or damages, right?
- 16:25Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found, first of all, that list of various things that the plaintiff was asking the judge to do.
- 16:32Michael Mulligan: He just couldn't do them and so those were just dismissed out of hand.
- 16:37Michael Mulligan: And I should say, with respect to one of the trees and indeed this was a dispute over more than one tree, as you might imagine One of the neighbors, actually at the request of the litigious neighbor, removed a bunch of trees because he was complaining about their impact on his driveway or septic system or something.
- 16:56Michael Mulligan: So they went and removed a number of trees because he was complaining about their impact on his driveway or septic system or something.
- 16:57Michael Mulligan: So they went and removed a number of them.
- 16:58Michael Mulligan: But when that person wrote to the municipality asking for permission to remove one final tree, the municipality told them no, you're not allowed to do that.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: And so they didn't.
- 17:11Michael Mulligan: And on that litigation over that tree, the judge said well, what else is the neighbor supposed to do?
- 17:16Michael Mulligan: And so found they were not liable and nuisance for things that last tree might be doing or dropping or creeping or whatever else it might be doing, because they just weren't had no ability to remove that tree.
- 17:27Michael Mulligan: They tried and were told no, and the judge can't make the municipality give them a permit.
- 17:32Michael Mulligan: So there's that issue of sort of what can be done and what can't be done by a judge and the fact that it's actually quite restricted.
- 17:39Michael Mulligan: Then the judge also goes on to review some of the specific law concerning who's responsible for what in terms of trees, and this is something I think people should be aware of.
- 17:51Michael Mulligan: The judge pointed out and there's authority for this from the Court of Appeal there is the concept of what's referred to as a border tree as opposed to a tree, which would be a shared tree.
- 18:05Michael Mulligan: The difference here would be a border tree would be a tree which is entirely so good, which is.
- 18:12Michael Mulligan: We got the Court of Appeal, they're working hard for us everyone, right?
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: Yep?
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: So a border tree would be a tree which is entirely like rooted and growing out of one piece of property or the other, but hangs across into your lot, for example, or where the roots come under and come up you know, maybe under your driveway or into your septic system or whatnot and come up, you know, maybe under your driveway or into your septic system or whatnot.
- 18:37Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal and this judge in provincial court points out that where you have things like branches hanging over into your property or roots coming up, that ordinarily is going to be your problem for the border tree.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: And furthermore, the Court of Appeal has pointed out that there is limited it's not unlimited authority, but there is limited, if not unlimited authority, but there is some limited authority to engage in what the Court of Appeal has referred to as self-help, which would be essentially this Like, let's say, a big branch is hanging over from the tree growing entirely in your neighbor's yard and it's, I don't know, poking into your window or something.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: Yes, you're free to cut it off right Now.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: You'd be well advised to maybe talk to your neighbor about that if that might be in any way controversial, but the limb hanging over and dropping stuff or the roots coming up under your driveway.
- 19:26Michael Mulligan: The starting point is that's a border tree.
- 19:28Michael Mulligan: Yes, I appreciate the thing starts over in your neighbor's yard, but that's really your problem.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: Sort it out and you can, and there's authority to do that.
- 19:36Michael Mulligan: There's also a concept, as distinct from a border tree, of a shared tree which indeed straddles the property line.
- 19:44Michael Mulligan: So that would be.
- 19:45Michael Mulligan: The trunk literally comes up and half of you know, part of it's on your property, part of it's on your neighbor's property.
- 19:51Michael Mulligan: That's a little different from the border tree and with that kind of a shared tree in order to, you can still engage in those sort of self-help remedies, which are somewhat restricted.
- 20:01Michael Mulligan: Right, you couldn't just destroy the thing.
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: But if you've got to trim branches or stop them getting in your gutter or whatnot, that's your problem.
- 20:07Michael Mulligan: You can do that.
- 20:08Michael Mulligan: But if you want to remove that kind of a tree completely, the neighbors have to agree, right, you want to remove that kind of a tree completely, the neighbors have to agree, right, and so that's the law surrounding the trees.
- 20:21Michael Mulligan: And another element of this case was that, as you might imagine, once this sort of thing winds up in the Small Claims Court and goes on for an extended period of time.
- 20:31Michael Mulligan: Other things sort of work their way into the obviously completely degraded neighbor relationship, including, for example, one of the neighbors perhaps in, perhaps connected to the tree litigation, perhaps not sold their property to some new owners.
- 20:46Michael Mulligan: That produced the litigious person complaining about the trees to amend his claim to claim that selling the property was somehow an additional cause of damage to him because it made it harder to sue over the trees.
- 21:00Michael Mulligan: That didn't get anywhere, uh.
- 21:02Michael Mulligan: But uh, the new owners, uh, who were quite, it sounds like they were quite accommodating.
- 21:07Michael Mulligan: They removed most of the trees, except for the one that the municipality said no, you can't take that one out, and so it.
- 21:13Michael Mulligan: It doesn't seem like they were unreasonable in that regard.
- 21:16Michael Mulligan: It seems like he's sort of accommodating.
- 21:17Michael Mulligan: While they were building a new house on the property, apparently somebody operating an excavator drove onto the property of the litigious neighbor.
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: Oh, no, now, uh-oh is right.
- 21:33Michael Mulligan: So that got added as a claim for trespass.
- 21:35Michael Mulligan: Oh there we go.
- 21:37Michael Mulligan: So on that point, the judge found that the new owners of the property who were building the new home had expressly told their contractors people working for them do not drive onto the neighbor's property.
- 21:49Michael Mulligan: We've got this litigation going on over the trees.
- 21:52Michael Mulligan: Don't do that.
- 21:53Michael Mulligan: And if you need to go over there, you've got to get his permission.
- 21:56Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found that you know the neighbors are not on the hook for somebody ignoring their express direction.
- 22:02Michael Mulligan: Don't go over there.
- 22:03Michael Mulligan: And so that claim as well wound up being dismissed.
- 22:09Michael Mulligan: There were then various other claims that made its way into this saga, including a claim over a damaged fence and whether that should result in $900.06 or whether it had been fixed.
- 22:20Michael Mulligan: The ultimate outcome of all of this, after many years and much grief and time spent in court and machinations, was that everyone was unsuccessful, and the judge ordered the various people to pay the $25 filing fee for each other, and so the entire outcome was two of the people had to pay $25 to each one, one to the other.
- 22:39Michael Mulligan: That was offset, leaving nothing.
- 22:41Michael Mulligan: Unfortunately, new property owners who had removed many of the trees and had built the new house also had to pay $25 on the filing fee, and there wasn't anything to set it off against.
- 22:52Michael Mulligan: And so the litigious guy, after many years and all of this heartache, is going to get $25.
- 22:57Michael Mulligan: And so, as I said at the beginning, the number one takeaway is sort it out with your neighbors.
- 23:02Michael Mulligan: If you find yourself considering a small claims action over a tree or a fence, think again.
- 23:07Michael Mulligan: It's a bad idea.
- 23:08Michael Mulligan: So that's the border tree and the unfortunate outcome of years of small claims court litigation.
- 23:15Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 23:20Adam Stirling: Michael, pleasure as always.
- 23:22Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 23:23Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 23:24Adam Stirling: All right, you too.