Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Mega Edition: Judge Berman's Opinion And Order Denying Jeffrey Epstein's Bail Attempt (Part 3-5) (7/4/26)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're picking up where we
- 0:06left off with the order denying Jeffrey Epstein's request for bell.
- 0:11The section fifteen ninety one presumption a pre trial remand
- 0:15reflects the seriousness of mister Epstein's alleged crimes. The significant
- 0:19harms and dangers of sex crimes involving miners animated Congress
- 0:24to create the statutory presumption of detention United States versus
- 0:28Harty twenty nineteen w Well at ten. The presumption or
- 0:33remand reflects congress substanative judgment that particular classes of offenders
- 0:38should ordinarily be detained prior to trial. Other serious offenses
- 0:42that are accompanied by the presumption or remand are kidnapping,
- 0:46aggravated sexual abuse, sexual abuse offenses resulting in death, sexual
- 0:52exploitation of children, selling or buying children, production of sexually
- 0:56explicit depictions of a minor for importation in the United States,
- 1:01coercion and enticement, transport of miners, use of interstate facilities
- 1:06to transmit information about a minor. The presumption of remand
- 1:10does not appear even when rebutted if the defendant comes
- 1:15forward with evidence that he will not endanger the community
- 1:18or flee the jurisdiction. The presumption is not erased see
- 1:21United States versus Domingues, nineteen eighty six. Rather, the presumption
- 1:26remains in the case as an evidentiary finding militating against
- 1:30release to be weighed along with other evidence Us versus
- 1:34Her five, seventeen Ninth Circuit two thousand and eight. The
- 1:38concern underlying the presumption applies to the general class of
- 1:41defendants charged with one of the specified offenses, not merely
- 1:45to defendants who failed to produce rebuttal evidence, where the
- 1:50presumption to vanish upon any showing courts would be given
- 1:54to little deference to Congress findings Regarding this class, The
- 2:00pre Trial Services Department recommends to the court that mister
- 2:03Epstein continue to be remanded. The pre Trial Service Report
- 2:07dated July eighth, twenty nineteen concludes, following pre Trial Services
- 2:12interview of mister Epstein, that there is no condition or
- 2:15combination of conditions that can reasonably assure the safety of
- 2:19the community if mister Epstein is released. Pre Trial Services
- 2:23Report dated July eighth, twenty nineteen at four. Pre Trial
- 2:28Services also concluded that mister Epstein's a flight risk and
- 2:32recommends that he be detained for that reason as well.
- 2:35In support of its assessment of mister apstein dangerousness, pre
- 2:39Trial Services cites the following the nature of mister Epstein's
- 2:43currently charged intent offense ie sex trafficking and conspiracy involving
- 2:47minor girls, mister Epstein's prior arrests in Florida in two
- 2:51thousand and six, mister Epstein's history and conviction involving a
- 2:55sexual offense which principally refers to defendants two thousand and
- 2:59eight can for procuring a minor for a prostitution a felony,
- 3:05and for solicitation a prostitution also a felony. Mister Epstein's
- 3:10status as a registered offender in New York, Florida and
- 3:13the Virgin Islands, and mister Epstein's pattern of similar criminal
- 3:16activity history. The seriousness of the crimes that mister Epstein
- 3:21has been charged with is also reflected in the fact
- 3:24that the crimes involve minor children. Mister Epstein is said
- 3:28by the government to be a serial sexual predator who
- 3:31allegedly victimized dozens or more of minor girls, including a
- 3:35fourteen year old he was involved in and undertook the
- 3:39alleged sexual activity in several locations, including his mansion in
- 3:43Manhattan and is the state in Palm Beach, Florida. By
- 3:47actively encouraging certain of minor victims to recruit additional girls
- 3:51to be similarly sexually abused, mister Epstein is said to
- 3:54have created a vast network of underage victims for him
- 3:58to exploit. The government alleges that mister Epstein intentionally sought
- 4:02out and knew that he was abusing minors. Indeed, in
- 4:06some instances, the victims expressly told them that they were
- 4:10under age before during the period in which he abused them.
- 4:14The crimes with which mister Epstein is charged carry a
- 4:17maximum sentence of forty five years incarceration. The deprivation of
- 4:21liberty imposed by imprisonment makes the penalty the best indicator
- 4:25of whether the legislature considered an offense to be serious.
- 4:29Us versus Dugan five eighteen three, twenty two, three twenty six,
- 4:34nineteen ninety six, and the crimes mister Epstein has been
- 4:37charged with are among the most heinous in the law,
- 4:40principally in the court's view, because they involved minor girls.
- 4:44US Code eighteen, Section thirty one forty two. Researchers widely
- 4:49agree that observed recidivism rates or underestimates of the true
- 4:54reoffense rates of sex offenders hidden offending presents significant challenges
- 4:59for professionals w working in sex offender management, as it's
- 5:02difficult to know whether offenders who appear to be non
- 5:06recidivius based on official records are truly offense free wood
- 5:11chippers for all of them, mister Epstein or his representatives
- 5:15have intimidated, threatened, and or made payments to potential witnesses.
- 5:20The government's evidence includes Florida police reports describing harassment and
- 5:24intimidation of witnesses involved in the Florida State criminal investigation
- 5:29of mister Epstein in two thousand and six. Emails dated
- 5:32September thirteenth, two thousand and seven and September nineteenth, two
- 5:36thousand and seven from mister Epstein's former council to federal
- 5:40prosecutors in Florida discussing the option of mister Epstein pleading
- 5:43guilty to witness tampering, harassment, and or obstruction of justice.
- 5:48Upon Beach Police incident report dated July nineteenth, two thousand
- 5:52and six states that one of mister Epstein's victims reported
- 5:55that mister Epstein's representatives said to her, those who helped
- 5:58mister Epstein will be compensated and those who hurt mister
- 6:01Epstein will be dealt with. The report also states that
- 6:05mister Epstein's representative assured the victim that she would receive
- 6:09monetary compensation for her assistance in not cooperating with law enforcement.
- 6:15Another undated pom Beach Police incident report states that the
- 6:18parent of one of mister Epstein's alleged victims contacted the
- 6:22Palm Beach Police to report that mister Epstein's private investigator
- 6:26had aggressively driven the parent's car off the road. The
- 6:29same report states that the parent of another victim reported
- 6:32being followed aggressively by mister Epstein's private investigator. The government
- 6:37contends that these reports together suggests that an associate of
- 6:41Epstein was offering to buy victim's silence during the course
- 6:44of the prior investigation, and demonstrates mister Epstein's willingness to
- 6:49use intimidation and aggressive tactics in connection with a criminal investigation.
- 6:55The government also submits email evidence attached to this order
- 6:58as Exhibit one of plead discussions in two thousand and
- 7:01seven between Florida federal prosecutors and mister Epstein's attorneys that
- 7:06confirm that mister Epstein considered pleading guilty to witness tampering, harassment,
- 7:10and or obstruction of justice in a case involving alleged
- 7:14sex crimes with minor girls. On September thirteenth, two thousand
- 7:18and seven, prosecutors wrote to mister Epstein's council that they
- 7:21had been spending some quality time looking for misdemeanors that
- 7:25mister Epstein could plead guilty to, including US Code eighteen
- 7:29section fifteen twelve D, a federal witness tampering statute a felony,
- 7:34and US Code eighteen, section four h three, a federal
- 7:37statute criminalizing the violation of the privacy protection of child
- 7:41victims and child witnesses, a misdemeanor do vers us Florida
- 7:47Docket thirty six eleven. Epstein's council replied already thinking about
- 7:53the statutes. On September eighteenth, two thousand and seven, a
- 7:56federal prosecutor told mister Epstein's council that if missedster Epstein
- 8:00pled guilty to obstruction of justice. The factual proffer could
- 8:04rely on the incident where mister Epstein's private investigators followed
- 8:08the victim's father, forcing them off the road. On September nineteenth,
- 8:13two thousand and seven, mister Epstein's council proposed that mister
- 8:16Epstein admit that he verbally harassed victims of the family
- 8:20of victims in connection with his attempt to delay their
- 8:23voluntary receipt of process in civil action against mister Epstein
- 8:27in violation of a federal witness tampering statute, and the
- 8:31government has recently contended that on November twenty eighth, twenty eighteen,
- 8:36and on December third, twenty eighteen, very soon after the
- 8:39publication of a three part investigative report in the Miami
- 8:43Herald authored by Julie K. Brown, relating to mister Epstein's
- 8:47Florida non prosecution agreement dated September twenty fourth, two thousand
- 8:51and seven, mister Epstein paid one hundred thousand dollars to
- 8:54a company founded and run by Individual Ie, and he
- 8:58paid two hundred and fifty thousand dollars to Individual two.
- 9:02The government states the Individual one was a potential co
- 9:05conspirator from whom Epstein obtained protection in the NPA. The
- 9:10individual one was named and featured prominently in the Miami
- 9:14Herald Julie K. Brown, even from jail, sex abuser manipulated
- 9:19the system his victims were kept in the dark. The
- 9:21government states that Individual two was a potential co conspirator
- 9:26for whom Epstein also obtained protection in the NPA. She
- 9:30is one of the employees identified in the indictment, which
- 9:33alleges that she and two other identified employees facilitated the
- 9:37defendant's trafficking of miners by, among other things, contacting victims
- 9:42and scheduling their sexual encounters with a defendant at his
- 9:45residence in Manhattan and pom Beach, Florida. Individual two was
- 9:50also named and featured prominently in the Miami Herald report.
- 9:55The government states that there's no good reason to infer
- 9:57that mister Epstein was attempting to influence saint these two individuals,
- 10:01who are close to him during the time period charged
- 10:04in this case, and who might be witnesses against them
- 10:07at trial. Neither of these payments appears to be recurring
- 10:11or repeating during the approximately five years of bank records
- 10:15presently available to the government. This course of action, and
- 10:20in particular, its timing, suggests the defendant was attempting to
- 10:24further influence co conspirators who might provide information against them,
- 10:28and light of the recently re emerging allegations, the court
- 10:32may order detention if there's a serious risk that the
- 10:35defendant will attempt to threaten, injure, or intimidate a prospective
- 10:39witness or a juror even a single incident of witness
- 10:42tampering has been a traditional grounds for pre trial detention
- 10:46by courts. Lafontaine two ten f. Three d At one
- 10:51thirty two through thirty four, affirming then U. S. District
- 10:55Judge Michael B. Muckesie's denial of bail to a defendant
- 10:59who had met with a bristil active witness in an
- 11:01effort to persuade the witness to give untruthful testimony, and
- 11:05where there was no evidence of influence, harassment, or intimidation.
- 11:09See also US First Singh twenty twelve at three. All right, folks,
- 11:14we're gonna wrap up right here, and in the next episode,
- 11:17we're gonna pick up where we left off. Mister Epstein
- 11:20has not always been compliant with his legal obligations. As
- 11:23a registered sexual offender. All of the information that goes
- 11:28with this episode can be found in the description box.
- 11:31What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 11:34Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're getting right back to
- 11:38Judge Berman's decision to deny Jeffrey Epstein Bell. Mister Epstein
- 11:43has not always been compliant with his legal obligations as
- 11:47a registered sex offender. Defense counsel has contended that mister
- 11:51Epstein has been scrupulously fulfilling his obligations in every jurisdiction
- 11:57in which he was required to register as a second
- 12:00defender since his two thousand and eight Florida convictions. Council
- 12:04argues that this shows that he is no longer a
- 12:06danger to anyone and will faithfully obey all conditions of
- 12:10release if ordered. The record shows that mister Epstein has
- 12:14challenged his sex offender level and at least one jurisdiction
- 12:17since two thousand and eight in an effort to minimize
- 12:20his reporting obligations, and one recent press release states that
- 12:25Epstein is not in compliance in New York State. New
- 12:29York Post, July tenth, twenty nineteen. Jeffrey Epstein never once
- 12:34checked in with City cops in eight plus years since
- 12:37a Manhattan judge ordered him to do so every ninety days.
- 12:41Mister Epstein is a Level three sex offender in New
- 12:44York State, which is the highest category of risk to reoffend.
- 12:48This designation requires that mister Epstein report his presence in
- 12:52New York to law enforcement authorities every ninety days, as
- 12:56discussed at the July fifteenth, twenty nineteen Bell Hearing. Council
- 13:01for mister Epstein made an application in New York State
- 13:04Supreme Court in twenty eleven to reduce epstein sex offender
- 13:08registration status from Level three to level one. If granted,
- 13:13this reduction would have allowed mister Epstein to avoid reporting
- 13:17obligations In a Sex Offender Registration Act hearing on January eleventh,
- 13:22twenty eighteen, held before Honorable Ruth Pickholtz, mister Epstein's application
- 13:28was firmly denied principally because it had been established by
- 13:32the Board of Examiners of Sex Offenders see People Versus Epstein,
- 13:36Indictment number three zero one two nine, twenty ten. At
- 13:42the hearing, New York County Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Gaffney
- 13:46joined in defense Council's appeal to review and overturn the
- 13:49decision of the Board of Examiners of Sex Offenders and
- 13:53achieve a downgrade modification of mister Epstein's sex offender status.
- 13:58Judge Pickholtz appeared to be stunned by the Joint Defense
- 14:01Council District Attorney application, stating, I'm just a little overwhelmed
- 14:06that the people are making this application. I have done
- 14:10many soras much less troubling than this one, where the
- 14:14people would never make a downward adjustment argument like this.
- 14:18I have never seen the Prosecutor's office do this. I
- 14:21have to tell you, I'm shocked. Judge Pickholtz also ordered
- 14:25mister Ebstein to report as a Level three sex offender
- 14:28every ninety days in New York. I'm sorry, mister Ebstein
- 14:32may have to come here every ninety days. He can
- 14:34give up his New York home on E seventy first
- 14:37Street if he does not want to come every ninety days.
- 14:40Epstein appealed the judge's decision and was unanimously affirmed on
- 14:45November seventeenth, twenty eleven, by a panel of five judges
- 14:49of the Appellate Division of the New York State Supreme
- 14:52Court notwithstanding Judge Pickholts order. According to a July tenth,
- 14:57twenty nineteen investigative report by The New York Post, is
- 15:01noted mister Epstein has never reported as a sex offender
- 15:05to New York law enforcement. See July tenth, twenty nineteen
- 15:09New York Post article. The NYPD cop assigned to monitor
- 15:13Epstein as repeatedly complained to the New York County District
- 15:16Attorney Sex Crimes Unit that Epstein wasn't in compliance. According
- 15:21to a source familiar with the matter, mister Epstein's alleged
- 15:25failure to comply with his New York sex offender obligations
- 15:28would appear to undermine defense counsels premise that mister Epstein's
- 15:33perfect compliance and meticulous obedience to his sex offender registration
- 15:38obligations should lead to his release. The court also read
- 15:42the story on July seventeenth, twenty nineteen New York Post
- 15:46in which Attorney Brad Edwards contends a while Epstein was
- 15:50serving his Florida state sentence after repleading guilty to procuring
- 15:54minor under eighteen for prostitution and solicitation of prostitution, Epstein
- 16:00was allowed to leave the jail on work release. While
- 16:03on work release, he was having female visitors and continuing
- 16:06to engage in sexual conduct while he was in jail.
- 16:10Mister Edwards, his counsel to one of mister Epstein's victims,
- 16:14c royven Fenten and Kate Chehe, Jeffrey Epstein had then
- 16:18sex while serving time. The court is also aware of
- 16:22an article published by Palm Beach CBS Local News which
- 16:25reports that the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office disputes the
- 16:29claim that Jeffrey Epstein had sex on work release. A
- 16:33spokeswoman for the Sheriff's office is quoted as saying, if
- 16:36he violated any conditions of his release, he would have
- 16:39been brought back to the stockade and work release would
- 16:42have been terminated. New Mexico, Florida, and the Virgin Islands.
- 16:48With respect to mister Epstein's sex offender status in New Mexico,
- 16:52Defense Council has submitted a letter dated August nineteen, twenty
- 16:56ten from Regina Chacone, Assistant Bureau Chief Law Enforcement Record
- 17:02Bureau of the New Mexico Department of Public Safety, which
- 17:05states that mister Epstein is not required to register as
- 17:09a sex offender with the State of New Mexico at
- 17:12this time for his two thousand and eight Florida conviction
- 17:15of procuring a person under eighteen for prostitution. The Court
- 17:19requested from the defense all application materials that mister Epstein
- 17:23may have submitted to the New Mexico Department of Public Safety,
- 17:28believing that the department would not initiate the waiver of
- 17:31mister Epstein's sex offense registration on its own. No such
- 17:35materials have been received by the Court as of this date.
- 17:39The Court understands that mister Epstein is also registered as
- 17:42a sex offender in the Virgin Islands Level one and
- 17:45Florida Level one. It has received no material from the
- 17:49defense regarding sex offender application or proceedings in those two jurisdictions.
- 17:55In some based upon all the profits and evidence set
- 17:58forth above, the Court finds by clear and convincing evidence
- 18:02that mister Epstein poses a danger to other persons and
- 18:06the community g mister Epstein also poses a risk of flight.
- 18:13In the section that follows, the Court considers risk of
- 18:15flight even though it has already been determined that mister
- 18:18Epstein presents a danger to the community a finding of
- 18:22either danger to the community or risk of flight will
- 18:25be sufficient to detain the defendant pending trial United States vers. King,
- 18:30eleventh Circuit nineteen eighty eight. The Court finds that the
- 18:34government is shown, by a preponderance of the evidence, that
- 18:37mister Epstein is a flight risk. The factors to be
- 18:41considered in analyzing risk of flight are the same factors
- 18:45that apply when analyzing dangerousness. They are one the nature
- 18:49and circumstances of the crimes charged. Two the weight of
- 18:53the evidence against the defendant. Three the history and characteristics
- 18:57of the defendant, including the person's character and financial resources,
- 19:02and four the seriousness of the danger posed by the
- 19:06defendant's release. The weight afforded to each factor under section
- 19:10three one four to two G is within the special
- 19:13province of the District Court Polino, three thirty five at
- 19:17six ten. At the outset. It should be noted that
- 19:20the pre trial Service report dated July twelve, twenty nineteen,
- 19:24concludes that the defendant poses a risk of non appearance
- 19:29for the following reasons. One mister Epstein's extensive foreign travel
- 19:33and possession of travel documents. Two mister Epstein's residential and
- 19:38financial ties outside this district and country. Three mister Epstein's
- 19:43employment ties outside this country. Four mister Epstein's unexplained assets.
- 19:48Five mister Epstein's criminal history, including his conviction for a
- 19:53sex offense with miners in Florida in two thousand and eight.
- 19:57The crimes charged against mister Epstein Mister Epstein has been
- 20:01charged with among the most serious crimes recognized by US
- 20:05federal law. The government has alleged that mister Epstein intentionally
- 20:09sought out and sexually abused minor girls, including those particularly
- 20:14vulnerable to exploitation. He did this in multiple locations, including
- 20:18New York and Palm Beach. Mister Epstein allegedly worked with
- 20:23and conspired with others, including employees and associates, who facilitated
- 20:28his unlawful conduct by contacting victims and scheduling their sexual encounters.
- 20:34These crimes, as already noted, carry a maximum sentence of
- 20:37forty five years of incarceration and give rise to a
- 20:41presumption of pre trial remand the significant harms and dangers
- 20:46of those crimes animated the Congress to create the statutory
- 20:50presumption of detention. The nature and circumstances of the crimes charged,
- 20:55and the severity of the potential punishment, support of finding
- 20:59that defendant poses a serious flight risk and that no
- 21:02condition can be set reasonably to assure his appearance for trial.
- 21:08Weight of the evidence. The government's evidence against mister Epstein
- 21:11appears strong. Yeah, tell that to Donald Trump. The evidence
- 21:15includes testimony of victims, some of whom were a minor
- 21:18girls when they were allegedly sexually abused by mister Epstein.
- 21:23Other witnesses, including potential co conspirators, physical evidence including passports
- 21:28reflecting extensive foreign travel, sexually suggestive photographs of nude underage girls,
- 21:35plea discussions, and police reports describing witness tampering and intimidation
- 21:41see United States vers. FAMA SDN Y, June seventh, twenty thirteen.
- 21:45The Court recognizes the difficulty inherent in assessing the government's
- 21:49case before trial, and is mindful not to reach any
- 21:52conclusion about the defendant's guilt or innocence. Indeed, some courts
- 21:57have described the weight of the evidence factor as the
- 22:00least important of Section thirty one forty two g factors
- 22:04for these reasons. All right, we're going to wrap up
- 22:07this episode right here, and in the next episode dealing
- 22:10with the topic, we're gonna pick up where we left off.
- 22:13All of the information that goes with this episode can
- 22:16be found in the description box. What's up everyone, and
- 22:19Welcome to another episode of the Epstein Chronicles. In this episode,
- 22:23we're going to get back to Judge Berman's order denying
- 22:26Jeffrey Epstein as bell history and characteristics of the defendant,
- 22:31including his financial resources. Mister Epstein pled guilty to two
- 22:36state felonies involving minor girls in Florida. He also held
- 22:40lead discussions regarding whenness tampering in Florida in two thousand
- 22:43and eight. He is registered Level three sex offender in
- 22:47New York and a registered sex offender in Florida Level
- 22:50one and the Virgin Islands Level one. Mister Epstein sixty
- 22:54six is reported to be a self made multimillionaire. He
- 22:57did not graduate from college. Mister Epstein's vast wealth including
- 23:02substantial liquid assets, multiple residences, private plane, a eight million,
- 23:07six hundred and seventy two thousand, eight hundred and twenty
- 23:10three dollars, residence in Paris, France, and relatively limited family
- 23:14ties to the United States in the sense that he
- 23:17is single with no children and his parents are deceased
- 23:20he has a brother, who defense Council asserts has offered
- 23:23to serve as a guaranteur for mister Epstein by pledging
- 23:27his home in West pom Beach, Florida. The court notes
- 23:30that the pre trial service report dated July twelve, twenty nineteen,
- 23:34states that the defendant stated he maintains minimal contact with
- 23:38his brother, Mark Epstein, and that his exact location is
- 23:41unknown at this time. Mister Epstein engages in extensive oversea travel,
- 23:47often relying on his own plane. The government argues persuasively
- 23:51that there is an extraordinary risk of flight, particularly given
- 23:54the defendants exorbitant wealth, his ownership of and access to
- 23:59private planeans capable of international travel, and it significant international ties. Indeed,
- 24:06the arrest of the defendant occurred when he arrived in
- 24:09the United States on his private jet after having returned
- 24:12from a multi week stay abroad. In the past eighteen
- 24:15months alone, the defendant has traveled abroad via private jet,
- 24:20either into or out of the country on approximately more
- 24:23than twenty occasions. In a recent search of defendant's New
- 24:27York home, law enforcement seized and expired Austrian passport bearing
- 24:32mister Epstein's photo and not his name, the passport is
- 24:36in another name. The Austrian passport lists residence in Saudi Arabia.
- 24:41According to the government, Defense Council declined to respond when
- 24:45asked by the government if the defendant is currently or
- 24:49has been in the past, a citizen or legal permanent
- 24:52resident of a country other than the United States. Defense
- 24:56Council contends that defendant has one active passport that was
- 25:00surrendered and that mister Epstein had no foreign passports. With
- 25:04regard to the Austrian passport, the defense explains that Epstein
- 25:07acquired the passport in the eighties when hijackings were prevalent
- 25:11in connection to the Middle East travel. The passport was
- 25:14for personal protection in the event of travel to dangerous areas,
- 25:19only to be presented to potential kidnappers, hijackers, or terrorists
- 25:23should violent episodes occur. Details about how the passport was
- 25:27procured by mister Epstein in the name of another individual
- 25:31were not provided and are not known to the government.
- 25:34The government is attempting to obtain additional information about the
- 25:37foreign passport, including how it was obtained and whether the
- 25:41passport is genuine or fabricated, but the defendant's possession of
- 25:46what purports to be a foreign passport issued under an
- 25:49alias gives rise to the inference of the defendant knows
- 25:53how to obtain false travel documents and or assume other
- 25:56foreign identities. This adds to the serious r risk of
- 26:00flight posed by the defendant. The government also argues that
- 26:04the passport contains numerous ingress and egress stamps, including stamps
- 26:09that reflect use of the passport enter Spain, France, the
- 26:13United Kingdom, and Saudi Arabia in the nineteen eighties by
- 26:18submission date of July eighteenth, twenty nineteen. The defense explains
- 26:23Epstein was given the passport at issue by a friend.
- 26:26He never used the document to travel internationally and never
- 26:29presented it to any immigration or customs authority. The passport
- 26:33stamps pre dating that his receipt of the document do
- 26:36not reflect mister Epstein's entrees or exits. Defense Council is
- 26:41submitted a one page document called Asset Summary June thirtieth,
- 26:45twenty nineteen. It indicates that Epstein has cash in the
- 26:49amount of fifty six million, five hundred and forty seven thousand,
- 26:53seven hundred and seventy three dollars fixed income valued at
- 26:56fourteen million three hundred and four thousand, six hundred and
- 26:59seventy nine dollars, Equities valued at one hundred and twelve thousand,
- 27:03six hundred and seventy nine dollars, hedge funds and private
- 27:07equity valued at one hundred ninety four million, nine hundred
- 27:10and eighty six thousand, three hundred and one dollars. Property
- 27:13is located at East ninth seventy first Street in New York,
- 27:17valued at fifty five million, nine hundred and thirty one
- 27:20thousand dollars. Forty nine Zoro Ranch Road, Stanley, New Mexico,
- 27:25valued at seventeen million, two hundred and forty six thousand,
- 27:28two hundred and eight dollars. Property in Palm Beach, twelve million,
- 27:32three hundred and eighty thousand, two hundred nine dollars. Property
- 27:36in Paris, France valued at eight million, six hundred and
- 27:40seventy two thousand, eight hundred and twenty three dollars. The
- 27:44USVII Island Little Saint James valued at twenty two million,
- 27:48four hundred ninety eight thousand, six hundred dollars, and the
- 27:52Court has advised the Defense Council that this cursory asset
- 27:56statement is insufficient to support bell package for the reasons
- 27:59among that is not verified and does not show expenses, indebtedness,
- 28:04or liabilities. Law enforcement has informed the government that a
- 28:08safe in the defendant's New York home very recently contained
- 28:11more than seventy thousand in cash, forty eight loose diamond
- 28:15stones ranging in size from approximately one carrot to two
- 28:19point three eight carrots, as well as a large diamond ring.
- 28:23The government is currently unaware of whether the defendant maintained
- 28:26similar amounts of cash and lord jewels at his multiple
- 28:30properties or in other locations. Such ready cash and loose
- 28:34diamonds are consistent with the capability to leave the jurisdiction
- 28:39at a moment's notice. The defendant's vast wealth and influential
- 28:43contacts have provided them with the means to pay individuals
- 28:46to a system and unlawful endeavors, including potentially fleeing the jurisdiction.
- 28:52In the past, the defendant work with others, including employees
- 28:55and associates, who facilitated his exploitational miners by, among others things,
- 29:00contacting victims and scheduling their sexual encounters with the defendant,
- 29:05both in New York and Florida. David Boys as noted
- 29:09represents identified victims in the case advised the court that
- 29:13while the civil case was preceding against the defendant, we
- 29:16had situations in which we had a witness who were
- 29:19cooperating with US and then were contacted by either mister
- 29:22Epstein or as lawyers and then stopped cooperating with US.
- 29:27Transcript at seventy one. See also US versus Bustani, three
- 29:31fifty six ft supp. Three D two forty six e
- 29:35d n Y, twenty nineteen. The combination of defendants alleged
- 29:39deceptive actions, access to substantial financial resources, frequent international travel,
- 29:45complete lack of ties to the United States, and extensive
- 29:49ties to foreign countries without extradition demonstrates defendant poses a
- 29:54serious risk of flight. US verus Epstein, one fifive Dot supp.
- 29:59Two D three twenty three three twenty six Eastern District
- 30:03of Pennsylvania, two thousand and one. The crucial factor, however,
- 30:08is defendant's lack of ties to the United States and
- 30:11his extensive ties to Brazil, with which no extradition treaty exists.
- 30:16In our view, his forfeiture of one million dollars worth
- 30:19of vassets in the US will not deter him from
- 30:21flight when in Brazil he has significant wealth, a lucrative job,
- 30:25the presence of his family, and insulation from ever being
- 30:29forced to stand trial. Viewing the totality of the circumstances,
- 30:33the Court finds that the government has shown, by a
- 30:36preponderance of the evidence, that defendant is a serious risk
- 30:39of flight, and that no conditions can be set that
- 30:42will reasonably assure his appearance at trial. While other judges
- 30:46in the district have found that armed security guard may
- 30:49be sufficient to assure a defendant's appearance even when he's
- 30:52a serious risk of flight, this Court does not believe
- 30:55that the condition, even coupled with the additional conditions proposed,
- 31:00would be sufficient. United States twenty thirteen w L three
- 31:04eight zero two one two at three. The danger opposed
- 31:09by the defendant's release, as demonstrated Infra. Mister Epstein's dangerousness
- 31:14is considerable, and it includes sex crimes with minor girls
- 31:18and tampering with potential witnesses. The discussion at page ten
- 31:23through twenty one is incorporated here by reference Simnizschi one
- 31:27twenty eight at eight, twenty nine, and thirty. The alleged
- 31:30activities were of an addictive sexual nature that cannot be
- 31:34suppressed simply by a restrictive set of Bell conditions. Also
- 31:38Ci Milan four dot f three d At ten forty nine,
- 31:42the protection of the community can be assured only by
- 31:45continued detention. The Court has carefully considered the issue of
- 31:50defendant's ability and motivation for fleeing U as jurisdiction. The
- 31:54Court finds that the government has proven, by a preponderance
- 31:58of evidence, at, among other things, the defendants limited family
- 32:02ties in the US, his residence in Paris, his extensive
- 32:06oversea travel, his significant wealth and his substantial resources, including
- 32:11private planes, and the potential forty five year term of
- 32:15imprisonment that may be imposed should there be a conviction
- 32:18in the case, provide incentive, motive and wherewithal to flee. Indeed,
- 32:23these factors render him a classic flight risk. The defendants
- 32:27proposed Bell package. Having determined that mister Epstein's a flight
- 32:31risk and also a danger to the community, the Court
- 32:34next examines the defendants proposed Bell package. The Court finds
- 32:39that the defendants proposed Bell package is inadequate, and among
- 32:42its deficiencies are these The Bell package is not accompanied
- 32:47or supported by audited or certified financial statements, including details
- 32:51of income and expense and debt obligations. There's no affort
- 32:55David from mister Epstein is noted. Defense counsels submitted a
- 32:58cursory one page asset summary June thirtieth, twenty nineteen on
- 33:03mister Epstein's behalf, in which he discloses several categories of
- 33:07assets totaling five hundred and fifty nine million, one hundred
- 33:10and twenty thousand, nine hundred and fifty four dollars. The
- 33:14defense states that it would be impossible for Epstein, given
- 33:17among other impediments as detention, inability to quickly access pertinent records,
- 33:22and inability to quickly make a precise valuation of particular assets,
- 33:27to provide a sufficient financial statement by the court's five
- 33:30PM deadline. The absence of accurate and comprehensive financials sworn
- 33:35to by the defendant does not allow the court to
- 33:38meaningfully assess defendant's own proposed bell package, nor would it
- 33:42enable the court to fashion a bell package on its own.
- 33:45The court would not be able to determine what level
- 33:47of bail in relation to Epstein's finances would reasonably assure
- 33:52the defendant's appearance. Defense Council proposed at ball hearing on
- 33:56July fifteenth, twenty nineteen, that it would take a few
- 33:59days to prepare accurate financials for mister Epstein. He also
- 34:03suggested that he would do so only if the Court
- 34:06were agreeable to granting him Bell. This offer appears disingenuous
- 34:11for a person as wealthy and experienced in financial matters
- 34:15as mister Epstein. That mister Epstein does not have a
- 34:18financial statement including liabilities and expenses readily available is difficult
- 34:24to understand. The defense Bell package proposes excessive involvement of
- 34:29the court in routine aspects of mister Epstein's proposed home confinement.
- 34:33This is not the court's function. The defense package components
- 34:39would embroil the Court in issues, among others, relating to
- 34:42the level of force that may be used to secure
- 34:44the defendant who may enter the residence, daily reporting by
- 34:48mister Epstein, and reporting by so called trustees designated to
- 34:52live with and supervise mister Epstein. The defense proposal to
- 34:57give advanced consent to extradition and waiver of extradition rights is,
- 35:02in the Court's view, an empty gesture, and it comes
- 35:06into play only after mister Epstein has fed the court's jurisdiction.
- 35:10According to the government, the Department of Justice, Office of
- 35:13International Affairs is unaware of any country anywhere in the
- 35:16world that would consider an anticipatory extradition waiver binding, and
- 35:21of course, the defendant could choose to flee to a
- 35:24jurisdiction with which the United States does not have an
- 35:27extradition treaty. Although the defense is stated that mister Epstein
- 35:31would be agreeable to putting up any amount of collateral
- 35:34or signing any bond the Court would require, there has
- 35:38to date been no concrete pledge of any real assets,
- 35:41or any concrete proposal to turn over deeds to real property,
- 35:45or to provide any specific amount of cash. The Court,
- 35:49as noted, has no detailed information regarding the extent of
- 35:53defendant's assets, including the nature of value and location of
- 35:57all of his assets. There is no mention of any
- 35:59excpt defenses, liabilities, or indebtedness, and there has been no
- 36:03persuasive defensive counter to the government's argument that even were
- 36:07the defendant to sacrifice literally all of his current assets,
- 36:11there is every indication that he would immediately be able
- 36:14to resume making millions or tens of millions of dollars
- 36:17per year outside of the United States. He already earns
- 36:20at least ten million per year, according to records from
- 36:23Institution IE while living in the US Virgin Islands, traveling
- 36:26extensively abroad, and residing in part of Paris, France. There
- 36:30would be little to stop the defendant from fleeing, transferring
- 36:34his unknown assets abroad, and then continuing to do whatever
- 36:37it is he does to earn his vast wealth from
- 36:40a computer terminal beyond the reach of extradition. The defendant,
- 36:44it should also be noted, is already at risk of
- 36:46losing some of his real property because the indictment contains
- 36:49a forfeiture allegation regarding any property that was used or
- 36:53intended to be used to commit or facilitate the sex
- 36:56trafficking offenses, and that includes, but is not limited to,
- 37:00ue the property located at nine East seventy first Street,
- 37:03New York, New York. The appointment and role of trustees
- 37:07who will presumably live with mister Epstein and monitor his
- 37:10compliance with BEIL conditions are unacceptably vague. They do not,
- 37:15for example, address the conflict that's created by the salary
- 37:19of the trustees or earning from the defendant and their
- 37:22purported role as independent monitors. The same problem arises in
- 37:26relation to private twenty four to seven security guards. This
- 37:30is especially problematic where as here it is alleged that
- 37:33employees of the defendant may have engaged in unlawful acts
- 37:37with and on behalf of the defendant. According to the government,
- 37:41the defendant worked with others, including employees and associates, who
- 37:45facilitated his exploitational miners by, among other things, contacting victims
- 37:50and scheduling their sexual encounters with the defendant, both in
- 37:53New York and in Florida. As a fallback, the defense
- 37:57suggests the utilization of and the funding of a private
- 38:01security guard agency to virtually guarantee mister Epstein's presence in
- 38:05court and presumably able to supervise his behavior. This contingency
- 38:10plan is not part of mister Epstein's fourteen point proposal. Nevertheless,
- 38:15the court is asked by the defense to revisit its
- 38:18legal viewpoint as expressed in an earlier decision concerning twenty
- 38:22four to seven private home security guards. Each bell package
- 38:26in each case is considered and evaluated on its individual
- 38:30merits by the court and in view of the court
- 38:32its findings of dangerousness. A new Bell proposal likely would
- 38:36be futile. Conclusion and order based upon the foregoing, the
- 38:41government's motion for remand is granted and the defense motion
- 38:45for pre trial release is denied. This document was dated
- 38:49July eighteen, twenty nineteen, and was assigned by Richard Berman.
- 38:54All of the information that goes with this episode can
- 38:57be found in the description box