Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Tyrion Lannister (Game of Thrones)(2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Whenever people ask me to do episodes about Game of Thrones characters, they usually
- 0:11asked me to talk about and analyze the psychopaths, the Geoffrey Barrathians, the
- 0:18Ramsay Boltons, the Circey Lanisters, these kind of people. Have also done
- 0:23episodes on Sandra Klegan, the Hound, and theon grade Joy, and also
- 0:28just general diagnosing all the characters of Game of Throats. And I thought that
- 0:35I would today do an episode on one of the non psychopaths, one of
- 0:39the good guys, Tyrian Lanister. I at first thought, well, you
- 0:44know, what could I really say about Tyrian? People ask me to do
- 0:47episodes on all the characters, you know, including Uron, grade Joy and
- 0:53all these kind of people, and I'm always thinking, well, you know
- 0:55what could I talk I mean, if I did an episode on the Mountain,
- 0:59what could I say about him other than that he's just a terrible person.
- 1:03If I'm going to do a full episode about a character on any show
- 1:07or any movie, I feel like I need some data to be able to
- 1:11comment on. And at first I thought I didn't have enough data to go
- 1:15off with Tyrian, but actually I do. There's a lot that can be
- 1:19said about Tyrian's development and how his personality came to be and some of the
- 1:26traumas that he's been through that influenced his life. That is consistent, I
- 1:32think, And that's one of the wonderful things about George Martin's writing is that
- 1:37his characters are rich and consistent and makes sense psychologically. Not all the time,
- 1:42of course, but generally speaking they do. There's a through line,
- 1:48even on someone like Ramsey Bolton, if you listen to that episode, there's
- 1:52a through line through his life, through his childhood that leads him to where
- 1:57he was at at the time. He doesn't just immerge urge as a monster.
- 2:00He was created and Tyrian's personality was also created, and so I thought
- 2:08I would do an episode on him. This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast.
- 2:14I'm your host, doctor Kirk Honda. I'm a therapist and a professor.
- 2:19Today's episode is sponsored by Talkspace. Talkspace is an online therapy service that
- 2:24lets you choose from hundreds of licensed therapists who are trained specifically in online counseling.
- 2:30And if you guys sign up for Talkspace this week, We're in August
- 2:36twenty seventeen, and you use the promo code kirk ki RK. They chose
- 2:43that promo code, not me. By the way, If you use the
- 2:46promo code Kirk, then talkspace might become an ongoing sponsor, which will mean
- 2:53greater revenue for the podcast, which will mean we can spend more time on
- 2:57this podcast, which will mean we can have more deep dive episod which I
- 3:00know that's what you guys always want. So if you're looking for a therapist,
- 3:05or if you just want someone to vent to every day and you want
- 3:07some support around those kinds of things, go to talkspace and use the promo
- 3:14code Kirk for a discount. And it's always weird to say my name out
- 3:17loud, Kirk. Use the promo code Kirk at talkspace. Do it come
- 3:22on all right? If you want to hear all the episodes in which I've
- 3:28been talked about Game of Thrones, go to Psychology and Seattle dot com and
- 3:31under the episodes tab click on the Game of Thrones episodes. I've compiled a
- 3:36page on Psychology and Seattle dot com in which all the Game of Thrones episodes
- 3:42are I'm not sure, but this might be the last Game of Thrones episode,
- 3:46I do not sure, but you know, people ask me to do
- 3:50Jora Mormont or like I said, you're on Great Joy and other people like
- 3:54that, and I just think, I don't know. I just don't think
- 3:58there's enough there. If someone can make an argument, that'd be great.
- 4:01And if you ever do make a request for another character, don't just like
- 4:05shout out the name, like really make a case for it, because I
- 4:10don't know if there's other characters that have enough information that provides enough for me
- 4:15to comment on. But anyway, so this episode is coming out in July
- 4:21of twenty seventeen, which means that I've I have information obviously from the first
- 4:27five books and also from season seven episode up through episode two. So I
- 4:32just watched earlier this week season seven episode two. So all of this episode
- 4:39will spoil up to that point. So if you don't want anything to be
- 4:43spoiled, don't listen to this, or you know, get yourself caught up,
- 4:46kid and then come back, all right. So Terran Leanister played by
- 4:50Peter Dinklage. I remember seeing Peter Dinklidge for the first time in a movie
- 4:57with with Steve Buscemi, movie called Living an Oblivion. It's actually kind of
- 5:02a cool movie. But the movie I really remember him from was from The
- 5:05Station Agent in two thousand and three. I remember just being amazed at his
- 5:12acting. He's a brilliant actor. You've seen that obviously in Game of Thrones,
- 5:17but in his other roles he's very effective. I mean even in Elf.
- 5:20If you remember him in Elf, he's great. He just has a
- 5:25really, I don't know, just authentic way of acting or something. He's
- 5:30also just an interesting person if you ever have interviews with him. When he
- 5:34was on Saturday Night Live, he was hilarious. The space Pants that was
- 5:41brilliant. Every once in a while when I want to cheer myself up,
- 5:44I just watched space Pants this Saturday Night Live skit when he did that naked
- 5:50and afraid with what's her face? I think her name's Jones. That was
- 5:57hilarious too. So anyway, Petered English, all right, So Terry Lanister
- 6:01in the books, he appears much differently in my mind's eye than the way
- 6:09Peterdenkledge is. He seems in the books to be much uglier than the TV
- 6:15show, and this is really true to many of the characters on the TV
- 6:18show. Brienne in the books. I remember when I remember reading the books,
- 6:23I remember just being like, man, brien must be just ugly,
- 6:27but she, you know, the actress who plays Brian on the TV show
- 6:30is actually pretty, you know, and not ugly at all. Theon when
- 6:34Theon becomes reek after being tortured by Ramsey, he is described as one of
- 6:41the most gnarly disgusting people around. But on the TV show Theon the actor
- 6:48who plays him looks the same, looks a little messed up, but not
- 6:51much. Ramsey's armor is another thing that was in the books that when you
- 6:59when it's described it's described like a flayed man. It's that his Ramsey Snow's
- 7:03armor was made to look as though he himself was being flayed. If that
- 7:08makes him there was all this like red. I don't know, it's hard
- 7:11to describe, but that wasn't depicted in the In the TV show also,
- 7:16Sandor clagain, the hound's face is way more hideous in the books than it
- 7:23is on the TV show. And you know, it makes sense because they're
- 7:25not because they're trying to make it be watchable, I suppose. But at
- 7:30any rate, Jerryan in the books, the way I had it in my
- 7:33mind's eye he was not an attractive person. And and beeterd Inklidge is that,
- 7:39you know, he's an attractive dude when you put that coaff of blonde
- 7:43hair on his on his head like he you know, he's a good looking
- 7:46guy. But in the books he's not that way. Especially after he is
- 7:50injured in the Battle of Blackwater and has his nose cut off, I think
- 7:57he he looks even more hideous. But anyway, he is described in the
- 8:03books as a dwarf with stubby legs and a jutting forehead, So imagine a
- 8:09forehead that you know, juts forward. In the books. He has mismatched
- 8:15eyes of green and black, you know, and they don't depict that in
- 8:18the TV show. And he has his hair is a mixture of blonde and
- 8:24black, pale blonde kind of like Denari's hair and black like John Snow's hair.
- 8:31So and you know, there might be some foreshadowing there in that if
- 8:35you're into those kind of conspiracy theories regarding Tyrian Lanster possibly being a Tigerian.
- 8:43But more than that later, Okay, So Tyrian was born in two seventy
- 8:46three AC and that meant that during Robert's rebellion, he was nine years old
- 8:54and at the beginning of the first Game of Thrones book First Song of by
- 9:00the Fire book Game of Thrones, he was twenty five. He's the third
- 9:03born child in to Taiwan Lanister and Lady Joanna Lanister. His mother, Joanna
- 9:09died giving birth to him, and his father Taiwan blamed Tyrian for this his
- 9:16entire life, which he just got to figure, like, why would you
- 9:18blame the baby. That's just awful, And so did Circe. Circe blamed
- 9:22Tyrian for Joanna's death, their entire lives, and you know, it's just
- 9:28terrible to do to Tyrian. After Tyrian was born, rumors spread that Tyrian
- 9:35was a terrible monster. The way he was described as a as a bit,
- 9:39as a baby, as a newborn was you know, he was hideous
- 9:43looking with all these strange elements to him. But as the rumor spread,
- 9:50the the you know, because he had this you know, he had different
- 9:52colored eyes, his hair was different colored, and he had this jutting forehead,
- 9:56and he was small, and and then the rumors started to pile on
- 10:03and add more details, like people said that he had a tail, and
- 10:07that he was born with a beard and you know that the black eye was
- 10:11evil and he had lot he was born with lions claws and long teeth that
- 10:18you know, like a sabertoothed tiger kind of teeth. And they also rumors
- 10:24spread that he had both a penis and a vagina when he was born.
- 10:28So people were, you know, the rumors are spreading like man, you
- 10:33know, because the young twins of Jamie and Circe, there's beautiful twins and
- 10:39blah blah blah and Joanna's beautiful and then they give birth to this like hideous
- 10:43monster. And people were saying that Tyrian being born was an omen to famine
- 10:48and plague and war and like just really it was just a bad omen.
- 10:54Many people, including the Mad King Aris at the time, said that Tyrian
- 10:58was a punishment for Taiwan's arrogance. People saw Taiwan as being uh, you
- 11:07know, rising above his station, you know, going too far, because
- 11:11you know, tay the Mad King was the king and Taiwan was just the
- 11:16hand and because the Mad King was off his rocker, Taiwan had to you
- 11:22know, be the real king in some ways. And so people, people
- 11:26including the Mad king were saying that because he was being arrogant in that way,
- 11:31he was given a child that was a monster that killed you know,
- 11:35his his beloved wife. Also, no one expected Tyrian to live as long
- 11:41as he did. They thought, well, this this abomination is going to
- 11:45die quickly. And because of all these bad omens, they called Tyrian Lord
- 11:52Taiwan's Doom or Lord Taiwan's Bane. So they they the community thought that Tyrian
- 11:58was like, I don't know, the gods coming back to haunt Taiwand in
- 12:03some way. Okay, so let's talk about Tyrian's childhood now. As a
- 12:07child, Tyrian was a lonely child at Castle Rock. You know, his
- 12:15mother was already dead, his father was off at King's Landing being hand of
- 12:20the king. His sister Circe left Castle lely Rock for the court at King's
- 12:26Landing, which is probably a good thing for Tyrian since she hated him and
- 12:31tortured him all the time. Tyrian's brother Jamie left Castle Rock to serve as
- 12:37a squire somewhere, and Jamie was the only person that Tyrian could really trust.
- 12:43So Tyrian was lonely. He was often by himself. He could hang
- 12:48out with his uncles, who I think were good to Tyrian in some ways.
- 12:52For instance, at the age of six, one of his uncles taught
- 12:56him how to tumble. I'm not sure exactly what they're talking about, like
- 13:01tumbling around, like gymnastics maybe or something. And Tyrian as a young child
- 13:05really liked tumbling. But when his father Taiwand found out about it, he
- 13:09forbade him from doing it anymore. Not sure why. Maybe Tyland thought it
- 13:13was a silly thing to do. As a child, Tyrian knew he would
- 13:18never be a knight, which was the dream of most noble boys. You
- 13:22know, most noble boys were thinking, Oh, I'm going to grow up.
- 13:26I'm going to be a I'm going to be a knight in shining armor
- 13:28like the Night of Flowers or Redley or something. But Tyrian knew, based
- 13:35on his you know, stature, that he would never he would never be
- 13:39a knight. And he also knew that he would never inherit anything because his
- 13:43father would wouldn't give him anything at all like that. And he knew that
- 13:46no one he and he probably suspected that no one would really want to marry
- 13:50him. So as a young person, he's thinking well, what am I
- 13:56going to be? Who am I? Where? Where is my self esteem?
- 13:58Where? What's my purpose in life? And he discovered early on that
- 14:03he was smart compared to other people, and he thought, well, what
- 14:07job requires intelligence and also requires not being a knight and not being married?
- 14:13Well, the High Septum a priest. Essentially, the High Septem is the
- 14:16head of the faith of the Seven in the cathedral in kings Landing, the
- 14:22one that blew up in season six against Spoiler, and he wanted to be
- 14:26a priest. He wanted to be the head priest of Westros. So he
- 14:30decided to study a lot and he was very dedicated to becoming a a priest
- 14:37the High Septum Septum. He as a young child also had dreams of escaping
- 14:43his terrible family. He desperately wanted a dragon and asked his uncles for one
- 14:50as a name day present. He pretended a lot of times that he was
- 14:54a lost Targerian child or a dragon lord from Valeria. He daydreamed about his
- 15:03father burning in a fire and his sister burning in a fire, and he
- 15:07dreamed that one day he would travel the world again, just going into those
- 15:13conspiracy theories that Tyrian is actually a targarian. This seems to be hints at
- 15:18that anyway, dreaming that he, you know, has a dragon, or
- 15:24really wanting a dragon, or pretending that he was a targarian, or daydreaming
- 15:33about his enemies burning in a fire. This is all targarian stuff. Okay,
- 15:37So let's go into a teenager. And by the way, the conspiracy
- 15:41theory basically is that the Mad King in pregnant. I think it's the Mad
- 15:46King impregnated Joanna while Taiwan was not around or something. And I think there's
- 15:52actually documented, you know, documents or you know, there's there's reference to
- 16:00an affair between the Mad King and Joanna Tirett, Taiwand's wife. But anyway,
- 16:07okay, so let's go to Tyrian as a teenager at the age of
- 16:11thirteen or fourteen, Tyrian and Jamie the ok So, this is a critical
- 16:15critical story in the development of Tyrian's personality, and I should highlight a previous
- 16:23critical bit of his development, which was that because he could not rely on
- 16:29his brawn, on his body and his looks, he had to turn to
- 16:36his mind and he had to make it sharp, and he had to develop
- 16:40his intelligence, which he had a natural ability for anyway, but he really
- 16:44honed that early in life because he knew that he wouldn't be able to you
- 16:48know, It's like, if you're deaf, you become very good at seeing
- 16:53things, you know, reading lips in this kind of stuff, and if
- 16:56you're if you can't see, you become very good at hearing things. And
- 17:02if you lose the use of your arms, you become very good at using
- 17:04your feet for things. Well, since he couldn't depend on his looks or
- 17:08his body to get him the sort of life he wanted he had, he
- 17:12really you know, got his brain gone, which you know comes into play
- 17:17later in life. So anyway that this another major event or circumstance that shaped
- 17:22Tyrian's personality happened when he was a young teenager. Tyrian and Jamie were traveling
- 17:30together in the country near Castley Rock, and they came upon a common girl
- 17:33who was about I think they say a cost it or something, but from
- 17:38I think she was about to be raped by a bunch of bandits. These
- 17:42bandits were were, you know, accosting this young girl that on the road,
- 17:48and Jamie and Tyrian rushed to the rescue and since Jamie was the warrior.
- 17:55Jamie ran off the bandits single handedly, and Tyrian ran to help the
- 18:00girl. This girl's name was Tysha. Tysha is described as being dark haired,
- 18:07as being slender, and as being beautiful. She was a year older
- 18:11than Tyrian and she was the farmer's daughter nearby, and her parents had died
- 18:18recently, so she was an orphan. Upon meeting Tyrian and being saved by
- 18:26him, she fell in love with him. She genuinely fell in love with
- 18:30him. And this was a new experience for Tyrian. For the first time
- 18:33in his life, someone liked him. A pretty girl actually liked him.
- 18:37This must have been mind blowing for Tyrian, and Tyrian fell in love with
- 18:42her. Tyrian was so in love with her that he immediately wanted to marry
- 18:48her. So this meant that he had to throw away his lifelong dream of
- 18:52becoming the High Septum, as you know, because priests weren't allowed to get
- 18:56married. So he was willing in that, and that, you know,
- 19:00in those seconds upon meeting her, was willing to throw away everything for her.
- 19:07But he couldn't get married to her without his father's approval, and he
- 19:11knew that he would never get his father's approval, so he bribed a drunken
- 19:15priest to marry them in a secret ceremony, and there weren't any witnesses,
- 19:21so they used pigs as witnesses. So I'm guessing they were in some kind
- 19:23of farmhouse or something. Tyrian, after getting married to Tysha, bought a
- 19:29college, not a college, a cottage, bought a little house near the
- 19:33sunset seat, and they lived there for two weeks in Bliss. Their honeymoon
- 19:38was wonderful. Tyrian for the first time was happy he had someone who loved
- 19:44him, truly. He was no longer around Circe or Tywin or the game
- 19:51of Thrones, so to speak, and he was happy. I just loved
- 19:55to think about this time for Tyrian and how wonderful it must have felt for
- 20:00him to finally have the love of someone, someone close to him. But
- 20:06two weeks later, his father, Taiwan, found out about the secret marriage.
- 20:10And so let's pause the story here and get some background on Taiwan,
- 20:15because Taiwan will take a terrible action against Tyrian in this moment, and we
- 20:22need to understand to understand why Taiwan reacted this way, we need to understand
- 20:27where Taiwan was coming from. So, at the time Tyrian's father was handed
- 20:33the King, he was the true ruler of the Southern Kingdom since the mad
- 20:38King was mentally ill. So even though he was just handed the King,
- 20:41he was essentially you know, king king. And the mad King was becoming
- 20:47more and more paranoid. And Taiwan had his beautiful twin children, Jamie and
- 20:53Circe. But and he also had this deformed youngest child who quote unquote killed
- 21:00his beloved wife. And so in the circumstances, Taiwan comes home to find
- 21:07that his son, Tyrian had secretly married a common girl, an orphan,
- 21:12and you know, a daughter of a farmer, you know, the lowest
- 21:18of the low. And I'm wondering what's going through his mind at the time.
- 21:22So this is a critical crossroad in the story of Taiwan's life and a
- 21:27critical crossroad in Tyrian's life. In a way, this was a critical crossroad
- 21:33in the entire fate of west Ross for reasons I'll go into later. So
- 21:40on one hand, Taiwan was probably happy for his son. I'd like to
- 21:44think that anyway. I mean, Taiwan wasn't a psychopath like Gregor Cogaine or
- 21:48Ramsey. He you know, he was he was ruthless, but he wasn't.
- 21:52He wasn't a sadistic psychopath. Presumably he cared about people, including Tyrian.
- 21:57So on one hand, Taiwan was probably sort of happy for his son.
- 22:02There's no evidence of this, but I'd like to think that Taiwan was
- 22:06at least partially happy for a son for a son. Also, on the
- 22:10same hand, Taiwan probably thought, well, good riddance. Now I don't
- 22:12have to figure out what to do with this boy. You know. Good,
- 22:17Now Tyrian will live his life in that stupid cottage on the Sunset Sea,
- 22:21and this boy will no longer embarrass me. He's away from kings Landing,
- 22:26he's away from Cassier Rock. So again, there's no evidence of this,
- 22:29but I just would imagine that he might think that. But on the
- 22:33other hand, you know, Tyrian's marriage to a common girl was a disgrace
- 22:37to his family name. The Lanisters are terribly vain, probably the most vain
- 22:44people in this world. And now one of the Lanister Boys, even though
- 22:48he's considered to be a monster, but one of the Lanster boys, has
- 22:52eloped with a common girl, and Taiwan could not stand for that, so
- 22:56he needed to take action against Tyran in this moment. But I also think
- 23:03that it runs deeper than that. For Taiwan. I think that Taiwan was
- 23:07terrified. I think he was scared because I believe that Taiwan actually cares about
- 23:12people. I try to think, why would why would Taiwan be such an
- 23:18abusive dick in this moment because I haven't said what he does, but when
- 23:22I say what he does, You're going to be like, oh my god,
- 23:25that's awful. And I try to figure out, well, if I
- 23:30assume that Taiwan is not a psychopathic sadist, why would Taiwan allow himself to,
- 23:37you know, to bury his good nature and his altruism and do such
- 23:44a terrible thing. Well, usually it's because people are terrified. When people
- 23:48are terrified, they're capable of overriding their empathy. And let me explain.
- 23:52So to understand why Taiwan was afraid about Tyrian marrying a common girl, we
- 23:57have to understand Taiwan's childhood. So before the first book, before Game of
- 24:03Thrones, Tywant's father, Titos, was the Lord of Cassley Rock and the
- 24:07head of cow House Slanister, So this is Tyrian's grandfather. Titos presided over
- 24:12a period of decline for House Lanister. So House Lanister was one of the
- 24:17great houses. But Taiwan's father was not a good leader and not a good
- 24:22head of the household, and the Lanister house was falling into demise and Titos,
- 24:30Tywant's father, lost much of the family's fortune on poor investments. So
- 24:34Titus was investing in all these things and just losing money left and right,
- 24:38and people started to make fun of him, and they started to think of
- 24:42him as being weak, and this perception of weakness resulted in some of the
- 24:48lesser houses in the area rising against House Lanister. So they all rose up
- 24:52and said, we're gonna you know, House Lanister is dead. Titos is
- 24:56a weak, stupid leader, and so let's go kill them all and let's
- 25:02put one of us as lord of castlely Rock. So basically, when Taiwin
- 25:07was a teenager, because of the way society saw his family, they thought
- 25:11his family was weak, and therefore people rose up against them and tried to
- 25:17kill all of them. So in this time, during this time of Taiwan's
- 25:22life, Taiwan learned that image is everything. If people see you as weak,
- 25:26then they will try to kill you and everyone you love. They will
- 25:30try to kill everybody. They'll destroy your family if people see you as weak.
- 25:37So Taiwan, as a teenager in this moment, had a choice.
- 25:41He could have followed his father, but he didn't. He decided to strike
- 25:45off on his own, basically, and he decided to command the Lanister armies
- 25:51himself, and he battled with the houses that were trying to overthrow the Lanisters,
- 25:56and the young Taiwan put down the rebell He won the battle, and
- 26:02he was ruthless in this effort. He was assertive. He did not wait
- 26:08for people to you know, he didn't compromise, he didn't parley, he
- 26:15didn't have conversations. He killed. He took action, and this saved the
- 26:18family. So his ruthlessness during this time gave a darker meaning to the common
- 26:26phrase for the Lanisters, A lanister always pays his debts. This a lanister
- 26:32always pays his debts used to refer to just money, just literally, you
- 26:36know, paying debts. But after Taiwin had put down this rebellion against House
- 26:42Lanister, a lanister always pays his debts. That changed meanings to also refer
- 26:48to revenge. So again, Taiwan grew up in this falling house. He
- 26:55grew up internalizing the shame of having a weak father, and Taiwan's pride and
- 27:00fierceness and ruthlessness brought the house back from the dead, and as a result,
- 27:06Taiwan learned that images everything, and ruthlessness is good, and being ruthless
- 27:11protects the family from harm. So there was Taiwan. He just learns that
- 27:17one of his sons is married a common girl, and his son didn't ask
- 27:21for permission, and this is going to look very bad for the family.
- 27:23It's going to make him look weak. It's going to make Tyrian look like
- 27:27a fool, and this may spark another rebellion against his family, which would
- 27:33mean that him and everyone he loves would get killed, including Tyrian. So
- 27:38what did Taiwan do Well? He called upon his ruthlessness as as influenced by
- 27:45his fear. But before I reveal what Taiwan did, let's take a break.
- 27:56All right, we're back from the break. I just want to reminder
- 28:00one that today's episode is sponsored by Talkspace. Talkspace is an online therapy service
- 28:04that lets you choose from a bunch of licensed therapists who are specifically trained in
- 28:11online counseling. The talk Space, as far as I can tell, it's
- 28:14pretty buttoned up regarding ethics and confidentiality and training their counselors and making sure that
- 28:18all of them are fully licensed and all that kind of stuff. I know
- 28:22other sites don't necessarily do that. And also I'm really hoping that if people
- 28:27are interested in online counseling that they'll sign up for it this week by going
- 28:32to talk space and using the promo code Kirk. Because if we can get
- 28:36a bunch of people doing that, then this week in early August twenty seventeen,
- 28:41then talkspace will be like, oh, okay, well maybe it's worth
- 28:44having Psychology in Seattle as a sponsor for the service, and they'll become an
- 28:49ongoing sponsor for us, which we've never had before, so it'd be And
- 28:55I think that talkspace is a perfect match for us in a lot of ways,
- 28:59where an online podcast thing and they're an online counseling thing, and I
- 29:06think that if we can spread the word about online counseling in general, Talkspace
- 29:11included that a lot of people can get services that wouldn't get otherwise. So
- 29:17if you're looking for a therapist, or if you're just curious about online counseling,
- 29:21or if you just want to vent to someone every day, because their
- 29:26model is you get contact with your counselor every day. So if you just
- 29:30need to vent to someone every day, go to talk space and use the
- 29:34promo code Kirk for a discount. Do it now? All right? So
- 29:37what did Taiwin do? Taiwind's scared. He's learned his lesson from his father
- 29:44being weak. He needs to be ruthless. He needs to save his family.
- 29:48And so he has this son who has married this common girl, and
- 29:53he has to figure out a way to save the family name because he can't
- 29:57just command your to divorce this girl because it makes Taiwan look still weak,
- 30:04so Tyran. So Taiwan needs to figure out a way to make this work,
- 30:11at least as a neutral and maybe even in his favor. So Taiwan
- 30:15pulls Jamie aside and commands Jamie to go to Tyrian and lie to him.
- 30:22He's you know, Tywin, says Jamie. You and Jamie was always very
- 30:26loyal to his father. He always wanted us all the all the kids were
- 30:30always trying to get Tywin's very limited approval, and so Jamie would absolutely do
- 30:37whatever his father did. And so Taiwan commanded Jamie to say that Taysha was
- 30:45a prostitute, even though she wasn't a prostitute. But so so Tywan says,
- 30:49Jamie, I want you to go to Tyrian and tell tell Tyrian that
- 30:56you hired this prostitute and that this pros as tricked Tyrian. So Tiwin makes
- 31:03Jamie lie by saying that Tyshaw was a prostitute and that Jamie hired her to
- 31:08take Tyrian's virginity. This story is much better for the family image. Young
- 31:15Nobles did this sort of thing all the time, so it would look much
- 31:18better for the Lanisters if this girl was a prostitute and that Jamie just hired
- 31:23her to take away Tyrian's virginity. So Jamie followed his father's orders and lied
- 31:32to Tyrian, which broke Tyrian's heart. For the first time, Tyrian thought
- 31:37he was lovable and for the first time he had a relationship with someone,
- 31:41a mutual, loving relationship. But after Jamie lied to him, his world
- 31:47was turned on its end. Not only did he think that his wife had
- 31:51tricked him, because that's what Jamie was telling him, but he also thought
- 31:55that his brother tricked him into believing that this girl was not a pride.
- 32:00That must have been humiliating for Tyrian. He must have felt like such a
- 32:05fool. He had thrown away his dream of becoming the High Septum to marry
- 32:12a prostitute who was hired by his brother to trick him. This is a
- 32:16humiliating experience and devastating to his trust in other human beings. Imagine that.
- 32:22Imagine you fall in love, you get married, and then your brother comes
- 32:27to you and said, I'm sorry, but your wife has been tricking you
- 32:30this whole time. She's actually a prostitute, and she just tricked you into
- 32:35marrying her. I mean, how awful that must have felt for him.
- 32:39So that's what Tyrian did. That's what Taiwan did to Tyrian. But Taiwan
- 32:45was still afraid for the family image, because now the story would be that
- 32:51a prostitute managed to trick a lanster into marrying her. So Taiwan wanted everyone
- 32:57to know that people will be punished when they are from the family, so
- 33:00he went back to his ruthlessness as a protective defense for the family image.
- 33:07So Taiwan had his guards rape Taysha and each pay Taysha a silver you know,
- 33:14a silver coin. So imagine that one your your father has a bunch
- 33:21of random dudes rape your wife in front of you. By the way,
- 33:27but that wasn't all that Taiwan did. He also made Tyrian rape her as
- 33:30well. So imagine that one you you're Tyrian, you fall in love,
- 33:37you get married, you move to a cottage, you're having bliss for two
- 33:43weeks, and then your brother comes to you and says, actually, your
- 33:49wife has been tricking you. She's a prostitute. And you're like, what
- 33:52what do you mean? And he's like, well, she's you know,
- 33:54I hired her to have sex with you and to act like she was in
- 33:59love with you. You so it's Tyrane. You're like, so, so
- 34:02you've been tricking me and this girl's been tricking me. Then taiwand comes in
- 34:07and proceeds to have a bunch of men rape your wife in front of you
- 34:14and pay her money to demonstrate that she's a prostitute even though she was not.
- 34:20Then your father makes you have sex with this woman that you thought was
- 34:24tricking you, who was actually not tricking you. But imagine Tysha in that
- 34:30moment, just what she was going through, so traumatic and so awful and
- 34:37so devastating and long lasting personality issues as a result of that one right.
- 34:45Incidentally, in the books, Taysha is mentioned a few other times. She's
- 34:50not mentioned in the TV show very much, but in the book she's mentioned
- 34:52a number of times. For instance, in the first book, A Game
- 34:54of Thrones, Rian tells Braun about Tysha. Tyrian befriends Bron while they're traveling
- 35:01together, and Bron says that he would have killed the man who did that
- 35:07to him. So Bron's like, whoa, whoever did that to you?
- 35:10I would have killed him, And Tyrian says that he might just do that
- 35:15since the lanister always pays his debts. This is of course foreshadowing to when
- 35:21Tyrian later killed his father In A Clash of Kings, Tyrian confides with Shay,
- 35:27his second love, about his history with Taysha. Also, after nearly
- 35:32being killed at the Battle of the Blackwater, Tyrian dreams about Tysha. In
- 35:38the book A Storm of Swords, after Tyrian and Sansa got married. Tyrian
- 35:45told sans that he was once briefly married to Lady Tysha of house Silverfists,
- 35:52whose banners depicted a gold coin and a hundred silver coins on a bloody sheet.
- 36:00He's speaking ironically, of course, but and this is the beauty of
- 36:05George Martin's writing. It's just it's so great. I mean, so Tyrian's
- 36:09talking to young Sansa and doesn't want to traumatize Sansa with this terrible story,
- 36:15and he says, yeah, I was once married to Lady Taysha, even
- 36:21though she was not a lady of house Silverfist whose banners depicted a gold coin
- 36:27and a hundred silver coins on a bloody sheet. So this is of course
- 36:30referring to her being raped by a bunch of guards. And that's where the
- 36:37hundred silver coins comes from. And Taiwan made Tyrian pay her a gold coin
- 36:44because because lanisters are are more worth it, and so the one gold coin
- 36:51is him raping Tysha. After the Purple Wedding and a storm of swords,
- 36:58when Little Finger will Sansa away from kings Landing, Sansa told little Finger that
- 37:05Tyrian did not poison Jeoffrey. So, you know, Tyrian was accused of
- 37:10poisoning Jeoffrey and Little fingers taking Sanso away, and little Finger wants to be
- 37:17with Sansa because little Finger loves Sansa and Santa. At this point, is
- 37:23is defending Tyrian and little Finger doesn't like that because he's jealous essentially, so
- 37:30little Finger tells Sansa that Tyrian was an evil man who grew bored of his
- 37:37first wife and made his guards rape her. So little Finger turns the story
- 37:42around to his benefit, or maybe that's the rumor that went around. I
- 37:47don't know. Also, in a Storm of Swords, when Jamie rescued Tyrian
- 37:53from prison, he confessed that Tysha. Jamie confessed that Tysha was not actually
- 38:00a prostitute. So in the last interaction that we know of between Jamie and
- 38:07Tyrian, Jamie finally comes clean. Jamie told Tyrian that Taiwan made him lie
- 38:13about Taysha. That's when Tyrian decided to turn back towards King's Landing and confront
- 38:17his father. So, so Tyrian is, you know, he's been accused
- 38:23of killing Jeoffrey. He's being he did the you know, the what do
- 38:29you call it about a trial by combat. He loses. He's about to
- 38:32be killed. The next day, Jamie and Verus come and save him,
- 38:37and then Jamie's like, by the way, I just wanted to tell you
- 38:40I might not ever see you again because you're going across the row ce.
- 38:44I just have to tell you that that Taysha was not actually a prostitute.
- 38:49You know, Dad made me lie about that. And at that point,
- 38:52Tirian becomes very angry, angry with Jamie and is very spiteful towards Jamie,
- 38:59which is natural, and Tyrian also decides I'm going to turn back. I'm
- 39:02going to get my father, so he goes back to king so he risks
- 39:06getting caught and being killed himself because he wants revenge on his father. Tyrian
- 39:12got a crossbow and found his father in the toilet. Tyrian demanded that his
- 39:15father tell him what happened to Taysha. Tyrian's like, tell me what happened
- 39:20to Tysha? Tell me the truth, and Tiwan said, ah, I
- 39:23don't remember that, and then Terrian's like, you do remember, You're going
- 39:28to tell me. And Taiwan referred to Taysha as a quote unquote whore and
- 39:32Tyrian warned Taiwan to not refer to her as a whore, and Taiwan again
- 39:37referred to Taysha as a whore, and that's when Tyrian killed him with the
- 39:39crossbow. So we all remember that scene from the TV show, right,
- 39:44So remember that critical decision that Taiwan made earlier in the story when he tricked
- 39:49Tyrian into thinking his first wife with a prostitute who was paid to trick Tyrian.
- 39:54If Taiwan hadn't done that, if Taiwan hadn't made Jamie lie about that,
- 39:59Tyrian would not have killed Taiwan, right because presumably Tyrian might still be
- 40:06married to Tayyah. I don't know, and you know, so because Taiwan
- 40:10did this, Tyrian decided to kill Taiwan his father. If Tyrian hadn't killed
- 40:16Taiwan, Circe never would have taken power, right because Taiwan would have still
- 40:23been in power basically and might have made Toman and Do a good king,
- 40:28and everyone would still be alive. Marjorie would still be alive, you know,
- 40:32all this people would still be alive, and Taiwan probably wouldn't have allowed
- 40:37the High Sparrow to gain power because Taiwan is smart. It's interesting to think
- 40:43about also, when Denaries crosses the Narrow Sea, the Tyrrells and the Dornish
- 40:49people would probably still be allied with the Lanisters, So Denarius might not have
- 40:54been able to do much when she crossed with the unsullied and the death Racky.
- 41:04But the things that would be the same if Taiwan wouldn't have, you
- 41:08know, didn't make that lie about Tysha, the things that would be the
- 41:13same is that John would still be king in the North and the Army of
- 41:15the Dead would still be marching south. So none of that would have been
- 41:20different. So in a way, it wouldn't have made that much of a
- 41:22difference, but it would have been a huge difference anyway. Also, in
- 41:25a Dance with Dragons, as Tyrian traveled towards Danny, Tyrian thought about Tysha
- 41:34and how his father treated her. So there's moments in a Dance of Dragons
- 41:37where Tyrian thinks back to Tysha and Taiwan. All right, so let's get
- 41:45back to the timeline here. When when Tyrian was sixteen, so this is
- 41:52before the books, Tyrian wanted to take a tour of the Nine Free Cities.
- 41:58He was very interested in touring around the world, but Taiwan forbade him
- 42:04to go and instead put him in charge of all the cisterns and drains at
- 42:07Castly Rock. And this was just another example of the mistreatment that Taiwan did
- 42:12to Tyrian, presumably because Taiwan was still grieving the loss of his wife and
- 42:16still blamed Tyrian, but it's unsure. As Jamie and Tyrian were getting older,
- 42:23Taiwan began thinking about how to marry them off as an alliance with different
- 42:29houses. Taiwan tried to broker a marriage between Jamie and Lisa Tully. You
- 42:36remember Lysatoly with the moon door and all that stuff. So Taiwan was like,
- 42:39well, if I get if I get my son to marry Lisa Tully,
- 42:44that'll bring the Tully household into the power of the Lanisters. But the
- 42:49Mad King was paranoid and jealous of Taiwan his hand of the king, so
- 42:53he made Jamie enter the King's Guard, which meant that Jamie could not marry
- 42:58anyone Dentally. Jamie and Cecy both wanted Jamie to become part of the King's
- 43:04Guard because they didn't want to be a part so anyway, when Taiwan offered
- 43:08Tyrian as a replacement to marry Lisa Tolley, Lord Hostra Tulli, her father
- 43:15and Catlin's father, by the way, said that Lisa Tully required a quote
- 43:22unquote whole man, not a half man. A lot of people called him
- 43:25the imp or half man. So so the you know, Lord Tully was
- 43:32like, well, my daughter is fine to marry Jamie, but not not
- 43:37Tyrian. Taiwan later tried to offer Tyrian to Lord Royce and Lord high Tower,
- 43:44but they both rejected Taywan's offer, you know, presumably for the same
- 43:50reason. Tywin even offered Tyrian to marry Delenna Florent, not a very powerful
- 43:57person uh and was even known to have been deflowered by King Robert without being
- 44:04married to him. But again the father refused. So imagine that. Imagine
- 44:10that you're Tyrian and you're being rejected by all these people just because of the
- 44:15way you look. I mean, how awful is that? Because you know,
- 44:17being married to it a lanister. Being married to Tyrian would mean that
- 44:22your children would be some of the most powerful children in all of Westros.
- 44:25They would inherit house lanister. I mean, if Lysa and Tyrian had married.
- 44:35Their children would inherit Casley Rock and the Airy, and you know,
- 44:40it's a big deal, but they still didn't want to Mary Tyrian just because
- 44:46of the way he looked. It's crazy, all right. So now we're
- 44:50at the point of the books, A Song of Ice of Fire books,
- 44:53and the first one is The Game of Thrones. By this point, Tyrian
- 44:57developed a stable personality, and as state will approach to others. He comes
- 45:01across as very arrogant to people, but he also comes across as thoughtful.
- 45:07He no longer dreams of having prestige in his life. He doesn't. He
- 45:14doesn't want to be high high septum. He doesn't want to be a knight.
- 45:16He doesn't. He's just he just has realized that there's nothing he can
- 45:22do in life. He doesn't he doesn't have any options, and so he
- 45:24basically just drinks a lot and has sex with prostitutes. He parties, he's
- 45:29a partier. He's twenty five. But he doesn't fall in love. You
- 45:34know, he enjoys women, but he you know, never falls in love,
- 45:38and he tolerates it when people make fun of him, and you know,
- 45:43it's it seems as though everyone attacks him for for various reasons because they
- 45:49think that he's weak, or they think that he's a monster, or they've
- 45:52heard all these terrible rumors. There were a lot of rumors about him as
- 45:55just being a terrible, terrible human being. I mean it's almost like and
- 46:00in doubt, like blame it on Tyrian kind of a thing, which,
- 46:04uh, you know, followed through to blaming Tyrian for the death of Jeoffrey.
- 46:09And he really only had one good relationship and that was with Jamie.
- 46:13He didn't there was no one else that he had a good relationship with.
- 46:16So at the beginning of the book, at Game of Thrones, he goes
- 46:19north to Winterfell as part of King Robert's royal procession when Robert wanted to convince
- 46:23Edward to be handed the king after John Aaron died, and then brand falls
- 46:29from the from the tower and Tyrian makes Prince Jeoffrey offer his sympathies to Eduard
- 46:35and Catlin. This is depicted in the TV show. You know, Tyrian's
- 46:42like, Jeoffrey, You're going to go to the family and you're going to
- 46:45offer your condolences, and Jeoffrey's like, no, I'm not you know he
- 46:50deserved it or something like that, and so Tyrian hits Geoffrey across the face.
- 46:55This is one of the best scenes of the TV show. Tyrian just
- 47:00starts smacking him around, and then Jeoffrey agreed to give the Stark's condolences for
- 47:07Brand's fall from the tower. After that, Tyrian went north with John Snow
- 47:12to see the Wall because John Snow is gonna join the Night's Watch and Tyrian
- 47:15was curious about the Wall. It was during this time that Tyrian befriends John
- 47:22Snow and says that he can identify with John since they are both outcasts.
- 47:28There's a great scene between John and Tyrian in this way. Tyrian returned to
- 47:34Winterfell, and even though Rob Stark and the other Starks treat him really poorly,
- 47:38he gives Catlin a design for a saddle that Brand can use to ride
- 47:43a horse, even though Brand can't use his legs anymore. Tyrian heads south
- 47:50and Catlin catches up to him and arrests him for harming Brand, even though
- 47:53he didn't. They go to the Erie and Lisa Aaron Lysa Tulley. Lisa
- 48:00Aaron accuses Tyrian of killing her husband John Aaron so Tyrian just gets blamed for
- 48:07everything. Brand falls from tower. Oh, it's Terran's fault. John Aaron
- 48:12died, Ah, it's Tyrian's fault. So Tyrian is tried for both John
- 48:15Aaron's murder and Brand's attempted murder, though he's innocent of both of them.
- 48:21And if you remember from the TV show in the books, Lisa locks him
- 48:24up in a sky cell, which are these terrible prison cells without one wall.
- 48:30It's just like off a cliff, and the floor is like sloped toward
- 48:35the cliff, so that even when you sleep, you might accidentally roll off,
- 48:38roll off the edge. God just makes my hands sweat thinking about it.
- 48:43Tyrian, in this moment, demands trial by combat, and Braun volunteers
- 48:46and kills Lisa's champion and Tyrian goes free. Tyrian and Bron leave the Eerie
- 48:54and are surrounded by men of the mountain clans. This is a little side
- 49:01jag in the story of Tyrian that I forgot until rereading the books. But
- 49:07Tyrian and Braun run into these mountain clans who are going to kill Tyrian and
- 49:12Braun. But Tyrian uses his quick wits to win them over and they end
- 49:16up he promises them weapons and armor and glory, and these these mountain men
- 49:22say okay, and so they join Tyrian and they become like Tyrian's little army
- 49:28in some ways. At this point, Tyrian meets the young prostitute Shay,
- 49:35whom Tyrian becomes fond of and one might even say falls in love with.
- 49:40Tyrian hires her as a permanent prostitute for him, and over time they develop
- 49:45a really strong relationship. He stops being with other prostitutes and he thinks at
- 49:52this moment in the books that he might be finally over Taysha, even though
- 49:58this is one is going to go even worse for him. Tyrian fights against
- 50:02rob Stark's army during this time, and Lord Taiwan retreats to Heron Hall and
- 50:08sends Tyrian to King's landing to be hand of the King for Geoffrey. So,
- 50:14because of the fight with rob Stark, Taiwan's like, I need to
- 50:20be leading the armies. How about you, Tyrian go be handed the king
- 50:23because we can't have Geoffrey running the kingdom. Taiwan wants Tyrian to control Joffrey
- 50:30and prevent him from making further mistakes like the one he made when he cut
- 50:32off Ned's head. Tyrian tells sorry. Taiwan tells Tyrian he cannot bring Shay.
- 50:40So, you know, Taiwan's like, look, I know that you've
- 50:44been hanging out with this one prostitute for a long time, and I forbid
- 50:47you from bringing her to King's landing because it makes the family look bad.
- 50:52But Tyrian brings her anyway, Okay. A clash of Kings the book A
- 50:58clash of Kings, Tyrian becomes handed the King and Circe is furious about this.
- 51:04In the TV show, they kind of make Circe and Tyrian out to
- 51:07be friends, but in the books they're I mean, they definitely portray their
- 51:12animosity between the two of them, but in the TV show they also kind
- 51:17of try to make them a little bit more friendly than I felt that they
- 51:20were. In the books, they hated each other, well, mainly Circe
- 51:23hated Tyrian, and Tyrian was just kind of like, in some way sort
- 51:28of indifferent to Circe. And so during this time, Kay, you have
- 51:34Geoffrey the King, and then you have Tyrian the hand of the King,
- 51:37and then you have Circe, and Circe and Tyrian are playing all these games
- 51:42with each other, Tyrian becomes friends with Varies during this time the Spider.
- 51:47During this time Varies Varius, Tyrian uses his intellect to remove hostile people from
- 51:57power. Tyrian sends Mars to Dorn to be married to Prince Tristaine Martel.
- 52:02To get support from Dorn, Tyrian prepares the city for the siege from Renley
- 52:08and or Stanis. He uses the alchemist guild to synthesize a large quantity of
- 52:15wildfire. When Renley is murdered by the smoke Baby, Tyrian tries to bring
- 52:21the Tyrrels into the fold by offering the Queen's ship to Marjorie. So Tyrian
- 52:27was the one that uh managed to get the Tyrrels into the family. When
- 52:34Stanis attacks King's landing in the Battle of the Blackwater, Tyrian manages manages to
- 52:38blow up all the ships and defend the city. He not only you know,
- 52:45used the wildfire very effectively, but he also you know, literally led
- 52:50the men into battle during During the battle, Geoffrey runs away because he's a
- 52:54weakling, and Sander Kagane the hound ran as well because of the fires.
- 53:00So in that moment, Tyrian didn't have a good leader to lead the army,
- 53:02so he led the soldiers in the battle. During the battle, Sir
- 53:07man and Moore of the King's guard tried to kill Tyrian and sliced off his
- 53:12nose. Presumably Circe tried to. You know, Circe hired Sir Moore to
- 53:19kill Tyrian during the battle, but Tyrian was saved by his squire, Padrick
- 53:23Payne Padrick good Old Padrick. In the TV show he just has a nasty
- 53:29scar, but in the books he loses his nose and Tyrian passed out at
- 53:35the end of the book and we didn't know if he lived or died,
- 53:37But at the next book, A Storm of Swords, we find out that
- 53:40he did live. So after the Battle of Blackwater, Taiwan took all the
- 53:45glory, even though it was all the glory was all Tyrians, and Taiwan
- 53:52resumes being handed the king and Tyrian is named Master of Coin instead. Taiwan
- 53:58tells Tyrian that he has to marry Sansa so the Lanisters can claim Winterfell.
- 54:05Tyrian and Sansa get married, Sansa is repulsed by him. Taiwan pushes him
- 54:10to consummate the marriage with Sansa for the good of the house, but Tyrian
- 54:15never does because Tyrian is a nice guy. Over time, Santsa learns that
- 54:19Tyrian is actually a nice person. So there's a lot of that depicted in
- 54:23a Storm OF's Swords, And that's a common theme in Tyrian's life is people
- 54:30who are repulsed by him and who believe all the rumors about him, but
- 54:32once they get to know him, they realize that he's a great guy.
- 54:37The Purple Wedding happens, Jeoffrey hates Tyrian for humiliating him while Tyrian was handed
- 54:43the king. There were many moments in which Tyrian as handed the king humiliated
- 54:49Jeoffrey, including at the Battle of Blackwater. So Jeoffrey at his wedding because
- 54:54he's you know, and because Tyrian is all no longer handed the king,
- 54:59Jeoffrey gets in to a fight with Tyrian during the wedding, and during this
- 55:02time, Jeoffrey is murdered by little Finger and Oleana. But everyone thinks that
- 55:10Tyrian did it because again, when in doubt, blame, blame the monster,
- 55:15right, It's just ridiculous. So Santsa escapes kings landing, but Tyrian
- 55:21is caught and imprisoned by Circe because at this point, since you know,
- 55:28at this point Circe is is Circe and Taiwan are you know, in control
- 55:32at this point. So there's a trial and everyone presents evidence for the trial
- 55:40that Tyrian is guilty. Everyone's you know, comes forward and starts lying essentially
- 55:45and saying, yep, I have evidence that that Tyrian was conspiring to murder
- 55:52Joffrey because blah blah blah, and there's a fair amount of circumstantial evidence that
- 55:57kind of points towards Tyrian. Actually some stuff that there were a lot of
- 56:00witnesses too, but again, Tyrian didn't do it. Even Shae, even
- 56:07his second love, you know, he loved Shae. Even Shay, testified
- 56:13against Tyrian. So this is another this is another critical moment in the development
- 56:17of Tyrian's personality. But before we get into that, let's take a break.
- 56:29All right, we're back from the break. Just to remind everyone that
- 56:31today's show is sponsored by talk Space. Talkspace again, as I said earlier,
- 56:37as an online therapy service, and we're really trying to get them as
- 56:40an ongoing sponsor. So if you're interested in online counseling or if you're just
- 56:45curious about it, or you want someone an event to every day, because
- 56:47as I said earlier, their model is the sort of therapy that you get
- 56:52to. You get contact with your therapist every day. You send them a
- 56:55message and they send a message back, and the messages can be quite long
- 57:01and at higher levels, if you pay more per week, then you can
- 57:06contact your therapist multiple times a day and maybe even get live video chat and
- 57:12that sort of thing. So it's different from in office counseling, and they're
- 57:17pros and cons to online counseling as opposed to in office Both I think have
- 57:22their place in society. You know, it's a lot more convenient. You
- 57:25don't have to drive to therapy, you don't have to shop around. It's
- 57:31much easier to shop around online because if you don't like somebody, I'm guessing
- 57:35you could easily just jump ship and go to another counselor on talkspace And it
- 57:39costs us little thirty two dollars per week, which you know, compared to
- 57:44in office therapy is pretty cheap. So go to talk space and use the
- 57:47promo code. Kirk. That's important. You got to use the promo code
- 57:51because if you don't, then talks Space doesn't necessarily doesn't necessarily know that that's
- 57:57where you got the message from. And that's important for them being convinced to
- 58:01become an ongoing sponsor. So well, I don't know, we'll see what
- 58:04happens with that. But again, go to talk Space, use promo code,
- 58:07Kirk, let's get into okay. So even Shae, even Shae,
- 58:10testified against Tyrian. And I have to say, when Shaye did this in
- 58:15the books, I was devastated because I thought I thought Shae was better than
- 58:19that. But it seems as though Shae was never better than that. It
- 58:22seems as though I, as a reader was just as delusionally hopeful as Tyrian
- 58:30was about this woman. She was never really nice to Tyrian in a way,
- 58:37and it's just another example of George Martin never allowing any happiness to happen.
- 58:45So Tyrian's second love, Shae, completely betrays Tyrian and testifies against against
- 58:52him, and this is a critical moment for Tyrian. So again to recap
- 58:58Tyrian as a person, and he was growing up, no one would love
- 59:00him. He didn't have a mother, his father was always gone and treated
- 59:05him poorly. His sister was a tyrant to him. He only had his
- 59:08brother, which was good, and he might have had his uncle's kind of
- 59:12And then he falls in love with Taysha, and he's told that she tricked
- 59:16him, so he divorces her. Then he meets Shay, who seems to
- 59:22like him, but it's hard to say if she really liked him or not
- 59:24because you know of what happened. But Terrian was so desperate for love that
- 59:30he thought he found love with Shae. Then when he needs her most,
- 59:34when he's being accused of killing the king and he's you know, he's about
- 59:38his sentence, the sentence is death, when he needs her both, she
- 59:42totally betrays him, and not only betrays him, but betrays him in public,
- 59:46and not only betrays him but also humiliates him. She brings up all
- 59:52these like little stories about you know, little jokes that they had between the
- 59:57two of them as a way of humiliating him in front of you know,
- 1:00:00all the public because it's the public trial. He didn't know this at the
- 1:00:05time, but Circe offered Shae a house in King's landing and a night to
- 1:00:08wed in exchange for testimony. So Circe bribed Shae, but again it seems
- 1:00:16like Shae was a shady person and might have done it anyway. I don't
- 1:00:21know. So Tyrian in this moment realizes, oh, Shae never loved me.
- 1:00:29And in the TV show Peterdinklidge, this is one of the most amazing
- 1:00:34acting scenes of all time. This, this whole trial is so amazing.
- 1:00:38The faces that Tyrian makes and that speech he has, it's just so it's
- 1:00:44so moving and also just kind of relevant to today because people are treated like
- 1:00:50monsters all the time today and you know, his speech really speaks to that.
- 1:00:55So this would have been a huge blow to Tyrian. For years,
- 1:00:59he had protected himself from being hurt again, and here he was getting betrayed
- 1:01:01yet again by another, by the second woman that he loved. That must
- 1:01:06have been really hard on him. So then going forward in the story,
- 1:01:09Prince ober and Martel offers to serve as his champion in a trial by combat
- 1:01:16Tyrian. Tyrian demands a trial by combat over and fights the mountain and dies.
- 1:01:22So Tyrian is sentenced to death. The night before he is to be
- 1:01:25executed, Tyrian is freed from prison by Jamie and and berries. Jamie reveals
- 1:01:32that Taisha had not been a prostitute as I was talking about earlier, and
- 1:01:37that she had genuinely loved Tyrian, and that Taiwan had forced Jamie to lie
- 1:01:40about it. So this is another critical point in Tyrian's life. He's being
- 1:01:51sentenced to death by his father and his sister, and he's being ridiculed and
- 1:01:55condemned by a city that he just saved from death from Stanis's army. And
- 1:02:01now the second love of his life, Shay, has testified against him and
- 1:02:05he humiliated him in front of everybody, and he's tried so hard to be
- 1:02:12a good ruler. At this point, he was handed the king, he
- 1:02:15was master of coin, and he did a really good job. He he
- 1:02:22literally saved everyone in the city, but people still thought of him as a
- 1:02:27monster, and his sister tried to have a knight murder him in the Battle
- 1:02:32of Blackwater. And he just learned that his father ruined his first marriage through
- 1:02:37lies and having a bunch of men rape his first wife. So at this
- 1:02:40point Tyrian has nothing. Even his own brother betrayed him by lying to him
- 1:02:45those many years ago. But he can do one thing. He can murder
- 1:02:52his father, so on his way to find Tywin. He finds Shae in
- 1:02:58Taiwan's bed, one more final blow to his eagle, and so Tyrian strangles
- 1:03:04her and then he kills his father. All right, next book, A
- 1:03:08Feast for Crows. We don't hear about Tyrian in this book, other than
- 1:03:14that Circe is offering a lordship to anyone who brings her Tyrian's head. Skipping
- 1:03:19forward to a Dance of Dragons, Tyrian flees across the Narrow Sea. Tyrian
- 1:03:23begins drinking a lot. Tyrian decides he has to find Denaries. Presumably Tyrian
- 1:03:30thinks that maybe Denaries could use his knowledge to overthrow Westros and his sister Circe.
- 1:03:37Tyrian is captured in a brothel by Jora Mormont and brought to Denaries,
- 1:03:42just as in the TV show, Tyrian and another little person are forced to
- 1:03:46perf this is I don't think this is in the TV show, but Tyrian
- 1:03:51and another dwarf are forced to perform a mock joust in the fighting pits of
- 1:03:57Marine and is watching this in Marine the fighting pits. Remember that whole plot
- 1:04:03line of the fighting pits were important to the people, and Denarius was like
- 1:04:08no. And then the people are like yes and da da da. So
- 1:04:11Denarius is in the watching the fighting pits, and Deenarius is sitting there watching
- 1:04:15this, and these these two dwarves come out and do a comedic jousting with
- 1:04:23each other. And what what Gnaris knew but Tirian did not know, was
- 1:04:30that at the end of this comedic act, a bunch of lions were going
- 1:04:33to come in and eat them. But Denarius was like, no, no,
- 1:04:39no, no, you can't do that and called off the lions.
- 1:04:42So Denaris saved Tyrian's life in this way. So that's all that we know
- 1:04:49about Tyrian at this point. So from from the from that's that's what we
- 1:04:56know now. In the in the TV show, we know that Tyrian becomes
- 1:05:00hand of the Queen to Genaries and eventually makes his way to Westros to help
- 1:05:11Genaries overthrow West Ros. But in the books we don't know that. We
- 1:05:15could probably presume that George Martin was helping to develop a story for the TV
- 1:05:21show, but we know that the TV show sometimes takes a very different direction
- 1:05:27than the books, and so it's just hard to know. But we do
- 1:05:30know what's in the TV show. So a little bit about predictions. I
- 1:05:34just want to provide a little bit of predictions for the future. It's just
- 1:05:41so hard to say, because it would it would be a very strange story
- 1:05:45if Deenaries did not become Queen of Westros. I mean, imagine, imagine
- 1:05:50the entire story arc that Denaries has been a part of building up to this
- 1:05:55moment, and then imagine her just her and her dragons get killed. You
- 1:05:59know, it just doesn't seem like a likely story. But again, with
- 1:06:02George Martin, you just never know. So now you know Tyrian's fate that's
- 1:06:10hard to tell too, But it's also hard to imagine that he would be
- 1:06:13involved in any kind of combat. So if Denari's lives, which is likely,
- 1:06:17it seems like Tyrian would also live. But again, you never know.
- 1:06:21The other thing, the other big prediction question that has yet to be
- 1:06:26answered is is Tyrian a secret targarian? You know, as I've been talking
- 1:06:30about, there are some hints that that he that he is. And also
- 1:06:34there's a certain symmetry to Tyrian being a targarian in that there are three dragons,
- 1:06:42and you would, you know, one for Danny and one for John
- 1:06:45and maybe the third one for Tyrian. You know, there's a certain symmetry
- 1:06:48to that, and there's there's things in the book that point to that,
- 1:06:53in that each of the dragons sort of corresponds with Danny John and Tyrian.
- 1:07:00And there's a viable way that Tyrian is not actually Taiwan's son and is actually
- 1:07:04the son of a of a targarian because uh, Tywan's wife had an affair
- 1:07:11with a targarian. So so we'll see. But I would I would if
- 1:07:15I was a betting man, and I am, because I like betting on
- 1:07:20things, I would say that, yes, it will come out that Tyrian
- 1:07:25is actually a Targarian. I think it'll feel a little schlocky in some ways
- 1:07:30because it's like, you know, who isn't a targarian at this point?
- 1:07:35But I can imagine that happening. Okay, So what can we say about
- 1:07:40Tyrian's personality. We see consistent personality traits throughout the books. He's super smart.
- 1:07:47He's perhaps one of the smartest people in all of Westro's. He can
- 1:07:53read people very well. He's very empathetic, he's very intuitive. He's very
- 1:07:58good about understand how other people work. And this has proven time and time
- 1:08:02again. It's probably his best survival skill is understanding what people want and how
- 1:08:09to convince them that he can get them what they want to save his life,
- 1:08:15and he does this all the time. He also doesn't trust people very
- 1:08:19well, you know, for very good reasons. Right, He's been betrayed
- 1:08:24and lied to and harmed by people his entire life. But once he learns
- 1:08:30he can trust someone, he does actually trust them. And we see that
- 1:08:34in his relationship with Shay. He shouldn't have trusted her, but he did
- 1:08:39because he was so desperate. And there's a lot of signs. I remember
- 1:08:43every time Shaye was on, you know, in the books and in the
- 1:08:45TV show, I'd always I always had the sense like, I don't know
- 1:08:48if I like this person. Because again, the way that George Martin is
- 1:08:55so brilliant is that he he left her ambiguous and we had to write,
- 1:09:00we had to see, we had to read it between the lines, and
- 1:09:02blah blah. Anyway, Another part of his personality is that he's very caring
- 1:09:06about people. He's a very altruistic, nice person who cares about other people.
- 1:09:13In some ways. He's one of the most empathetic people in the books.
- 1:09:15He's one of the most caring, altruistic people. In the books,
- 1:09:18he sees society for what it is. This is another, you know,
- 1:09:21part of his intelligence. He understands that society is bullshit. For instance,
- 1:09:28when he fell in love with with the common girl Taysha, you know,
- 1:09:31he didn't care about the bs of society. He wanted what was good in
- 1:09:35life, and that was love. He also deeply wants love, but he
- 1:09:41can never find it. Another part of his personality is that he's actually very
- 1:09:45brave. He's portrayed as being this you know, cowardly person who can't fight,
- 1:09:51but you know, he's actually quite brave, and he proves himself as
- 1:09:56being brave in a lot of instances, particularly in the Battle of black Water.
- 1:10:00He another another you know, evident piece of evidence of his bravery is
- 1:10:05that even though Circe was constantly trying to kill him and you know, undermine
- 1:10:12him, while he was hand in hand of the king, he stayed in
- 1:10:15King's land and he didn't have to do that. He could have done something
- 1:10:17else, but he stayed there in the midst of all that. He's also
- 1:10:23incredibly persistent and dogged and dedicated and resilient. He he never gives up or
- 1:10:31rarely anyway, And the only time he really ever gave up was when he
- 1:10:36was across the Narrow Sea and he's just like, well, okay, this
- 1:10:40is my life now. I guess it's just alcohol. But but he quickly
- 1:10:43bounced back and went to Denarius, and throughout the story he just continues to,
- 1:10:50you know, pick himself up after falling down, and he keeps going.
- 1:10:56He's also a true Lanister in that he always pays his debts, both
- 1:11:00through figuratively and through money. He's ruthless when he needs to be. When
- 1:11:05the Battle Blackwater was happening, he was ruthless and he needed to be.
- 1:11:11He's an excellent ruler, just like many other Lanisters. He's fierce in battle,
- 1:11:15and he's vain and arrogant, and he uses money to gain power.
- 1:11:20I have a suspicion that he is George Martin's favorite character. He is.
- 1:11:30I could absolutely imagine George. I don't know, maybe George Martin even comments
- 1:11:33on this, but I could actually imagine George Martin saying like, if there's
- 1:11:38one character that's me, it's Tyrian. Although authors rarely say such things,
- 1:11:43but I could imagine that being true. Tyrian is a dreamer. His entire
- 1:11:48life has been dreaming of you know, far away lands and dragons and you
- 1:11:54know, seeing the world, and he eventually does the world. All right.
- 1:12:01How about some quotes from Tyrian from the books. So here's a conversation
- 1:12:08between Tyrian and John snow Terrian says, let me give you some Let me
- 1:12:13give you some counsel, bastard, never forget who you are, for surely
- 1:12:17the world will not make it your strength. Then it can never be your
- 1:12:21weakness. Armor yourself with it, and it will never be used to hurt
- 1:12:26you. And John says, what the hell do you know about being a
- 1:12:30bastard? Tyrian said, all dwarfs are bastards in their father's eyes. All
- 1:12:34dwarves are bastards in their father's eyes. Another quote here, My mind is
- 1:12:42my weapon. My brother has his sword, King Robert has his warhammer,
- 1:12:45and I have my mind. And a mind needs books as a sword needs
- 1:12:50a whetstone if it is to keep its edge. That's why I read so
- 1:12:56much, John Snow Another quote here, I never liked you, Circe,
- 1:13:02but you were my own sister, so I never did you harm. You've
- 1:13:06ended that I will hurt you for this I don't know how yet, but
- 1:13:11give me time. A day will come when you think yourself safe and happy,
- 1:13:15and suddenly your joy will turn to ashes in your mouth, and you'll
- 1:13:18know the debt is paid. So when I read that quote, I think
- 1:13:24like, ooh, does Tyrian have some tricks up a sleeve? With regards
- 1:13:28to Circe and season seven of the TV show, we shall see all right,
- 1:13:32Well, what's the final analysis on Tyrian and his personality and his psychology.
- 1:13:38As I said before, he's extremely resilient. Not only was he considered
- 1:13:42a monster his entire life, but his father was terribly abusive to him,
- 1:13:45as was many other people. And yet he rose to become hand of the
- 1:13:49Queen to Denaries and if things go according to plan, he will become one
- 1:13:54of the most powerful people in Westro's. So many times he could have given
- 1:13:58up, but he just kept going. He's extremely resilient, as many of
- 1:14:02the other characters are, like Ariya and John Snow and Sansa. He's also
- 1:14:09a very very moral, good person. He continually acts in an altruistic manner.
- 1:14:15He wants peace, he wants people to thrive. He continually he continually
- 1:14:20cares about others, even though they treat him so poorly. So that's another
- 1:14:28part of his personality. Another part of his personality that we can talk about
- 1:14:31is he has He has been deeply wounded by his loved ones. His father
- 1:14:38abused him, his sister abused him, his brother tricked him. For a
- 1:14:41while he thought his first wife had tricked him. His second love, Shay,
- 1:14:45completely betrayed him. His father and sister accused him of killing Jeoffrey and
- 1:14:49try to get him killed. He wants love in his life, but at
- 1:14:55every turn he has betrayed and shunned. So it's another really important part of
- 1:15:00his personality, and he hides it well through drinking and through humor and by
- 1:15:06distancing himself from other people, as people often do. Alcohol is a wonderful
- 1:15:12way to numb one's attachment injuries, and he does that. The last thing
- 1:15:17I can say about Tyrian is that I think I know why we love him
- 1:15:24so much. It's because we can relate to him. We've all been hurt
- 1:15:29by people close to us. We've all felt like a monster, we've all
- 1:15:34felt like no one would ever love us. But he doesn't give up,
- 1:15:39and he doesn't hold a grudge, and he just keeps going. He puts
- 1:15:42the pass behind him, and he just keeps going. He just keeps trying
- 1:15:45to make the world a better place and hopefully he will. Well. That
- 1:15:49does it for that episode of Psychology and Seattle. Thanks for joining me out
- 1:15:53there. Please take care of yourself because you deserve it to