Latest / The Rita Panahi Show / The Rita Panahi Show | 8 October

Transcript

The Rita Panahi Show | 8 October · The Rita Panahi Show

0:02
Speaker 1: On scoring lives Austrodia.
0:05
Speaker 2: This is the Wider Panalty Show.
0:09
Speaker 3: Good evening and welcome to the Rida Panekey Show coming
0:12
Speaker 3: up tonight.
0:13
Speaker 4: Liberal Senator just Into Namba.
0:15
Speaker 3: Jim Proprice lashes out at Susan Lee over damaging party
0:19
Speaker 3: room leaks and talking about leaks, here's another one. A
0:22
Speaker 3: little known Victorian MP launches an astonishing attack against Andrew
0:26
Speaker 3: Hasty in a Liberal party room meeting.
0:29
Speaker 4: Dan While will join me to discuss that.
0:31
Speaker 3: Shortly, Barrista Lama Kolaris will be here to explain why
0:35
Speaker 3: Victorians should be deeply concerned about the state government's Indigenous
0:40
Speaker 3: Treaty bill. The Great Army Horowitz will have the latest
0:43
Speaker 3: from the US, and later in the hour, I'll speak
0:46
Speaker 3: to the man behind a new groundbreaking documentary, and Left
0:50
Speaker 3: Is Losing It features this charming lady getting a dose
0:53
Speaker 3: of instant karma.
0:59
Speaker 4: Start Yeah, but first.
1:06
Speaker 3: Liberal Senator just Into namberjmper Prize has lashed out at
1:09
Speaker 3: opposition leader Susan Lee, demanding that she stop the leaks
1:13
Speaker 3: and get the party under control. Following several instances of
1:17
Speaker 3: anonymous MPs verballying the likes of Andrew Hasty and former
1:21
Speaker 3: leader Peter Dutton in the media.
1:24
Speaker 4: Here's what Center Price had to say.
1:26
Speaker 5: The leaking of a verbal submission to quite frankly lazy
1:33
Speaker 5: journalists is ridiculous. It's another attempt at pylon on Andrew
1:40
Speaker 5: Hasty and also verbaling our former leader Peter Dutton, and
1:47
Speaker 5: something has to be done. I've written to our leader
1:50
Speaker 5: about my concerns about backgrounding and about leaking to the media.
1:56
Speaker 5: Enough to us.
1:58
Speaker 3: Joining me now is deputy executive director at the Institute
2:01
Speaker 3: of Public Affairs and Wild Dance. Senator Price also made
2:05
Speaker 3: it clear in that interview that Andrew Hasty is a
2:08
Speaker 3: man of integrity and conviction and has her full support.
2:13
Speaker 3: They would certainly make a formidable team to take on labor.
2:17
Speaker 6: Yeah.
2:17
Speaker 7: I think that's right. And there's a couple of things here.
2:19
Speaker 7: There's a number of individuals who are on the backbench
2:24
Speaker 7: where it seems a bit strange to Andrew Hasty. Senator Price,
2:28
Speaker 7: plus others like Garth Hamilton or Henry Pike, for example,
2:31
Speaker 7: who have been making important contributions to debate recently.
2:34
Speaker 8: And I just think when you.
2:36
Speaker 7: Look at the current situation, the coalition opposition is not
2:40
Speaker 7: taking the fight to the government in any meaningful way
2:43
Speaker 7: on the big issues that Australians care about, whether it's
2:45
Speaker 7: net zero, migration, Australian values for example, this is completely
2:50
Speaker 7: missing from debate. There is not much time in order
2:53
Speaker 7: to mount a case against the government, and you need
2:55
Speaker 7: your best performers on the front bench engaging in that debate.
3:00
Speaker 7: So you know, the number one thing here is to
3:02
Speaker 7: make sure that these very bad policies are being debated
3:06
Speaker 7: and contested.
3:06
Speaker 8: But at the moment that's just not happening.
3:08
Speaker 7: And I don't think the Coalition Opposition has the right
3:11
Speaker 7: cattle on the front bench.
3:15
Speaker 3: Well further on Andrew Hasty, The Australian reports, Liberal MP
3:20
Speaker 3: Mary Aldred, who no one has heard of her, took
3:24
Speaker 3: aim at Hasty in a party room meeting in Canberra
3:27
Speaker 3: on Tuesday, telling the former front bencher she had no
3:31
Speaker 3: respect for the way he was conducting himself. She said
3:34
Speaker 3: the way he handled his front bench resignation and his
3:38
Speaker 3: campaign on several policies including industry protection, migration net zero,
3:45
Speaker 3: could cause the Coalition to go further backwards at the
3:49
Speaker 3: next election. Dan this attack was set to have left
3:53
Speaker 3: a fellow MP's stunt, possibly because like me, they've never
3:57
Speaker 3: heard of Mary Aldred before.
4:00
Speaker 4: Why would someone such as.
4:02
Speaker 3: Her, who in my mind is never laid at glove
4:04
Speaker 3: on labor.
4:06
Speaker 4: Beverbaling a possible future leader.
4:11
Speaker 7: Look, I'm not too sure, but the point that I
4:14
Speaker 7: would make here is that what we need is more
4:18
Speaker 7: members of Parliament speaking out on more things, more often.
4:21
Speaker 8: Now.
4:21
Speaker 7: The idea that everything has to be kept behind closed
4:24
Speaker 7: doors is not consistent with where the Australian community is.
4:28
Speaker 7: The things that Andrew Hasty has been speaking out on
4:31
Speaker 7: are things that are care about and even if you
4:33
Speaker 7: don't agree with what he's.
4:34
Speaker 8: Saying, debate the issue.
4:36
Speaker 7: Debate the policy issue rather than trying to attack the player.
4:41
Speaker 7: And I think this goes to a problem, which is
4:43
Speaker 7: because the Coalition had a pretty ordinary ten years in government,
4:47
Speaker 7: certainly from twenty fifteen onwards. Whether it was the failed
4:51
Speaker 7: COVID response, whether it was signing up to net zero,
4:53
Speaker 7: whether it was running up hundreds of billions of dollars
4:55
Speaker 7: in debt. They need to have a clean break with
4:58
Speaker 7: the past. They need to show the public that they
5:00
Speaker 7: have changed. They need to show the public they understand
5:02
Speaker 7: the issues facing Australia's future. Instead they're just talking about
5:05
Speaker 7: day to day policy issues that are of little relevance
5:08
Speaker 7: to the person on the street. So I think the
5:10
Speaker 7: one person that's spoken out, Andrew Hasty, is now being
5:14
Speaker 7: the target.
5:14
Speaker 8: It just doesn't make sense to me.
5:18
Speaker 3: It doesn't What about the analysis here that his campaign
5:24
Speaker 3: on issues like net zero, migration industry protection is going
5:29
Speaker 3: to set the party back.
5:31
Speaker 4: I think any sensible.
5:33
Speaker 3: Person would say the party is at rock bottom. They
5:36
Speaker 3: are recording currently the lowest primary figures they've ever had
5:42
Speaker 3: in any News poll since they started measuring the primary vote,
5:46
Speaker 3: and Australians are crying out for real choice. They want
5:50
Speaker 3: a debate on these key issues, not some one party
5:54
Speaker 3: system where Liberal and labor almost indistinguishable from each other.
5:58
Speaker 3: But there is certain a counter view to that that
6:03
Speaker 3: the likes of Andrew Hasty and Senator Price and others
6:06
Speaker 3: who are pushing for Australia to abandon net zero, pushing
6:10
Speaker 3: for low migration, Well that's out of touch with modern Australia.
6:15
Speaker 7: What's your take, Well, that's inconsistent with the last two elections.
6:22
Speaker 8: You know, this is what this is forgets me.
6:25
Speaker 7: The party has never been more to the left and
6:28
Speaker 7: they've never been performing worse.
6:29
Speaker 8: I mean don't forget.
6:31
Speaker 7: I don't think most parliamentarians in the Liberal Party understand
6:35
Speaker 7: how catastrophic the loss was. This is the worst performance
6:37
Speaker 7: of the Liberal Party in its history since nineteen forty
6:40
Speaker 7: three when the UAP got rubbed out of existence. You've
6:42
Speaker 7: got to understand that the community no longer respects the
6:45
Speaker 7: Liberal Party.
6:46
Speaker 8: You know, this has to sink in at some point.
6:49
Speaker 7: And the point that I would make is, Okay, the
6:52
Speaker 7: so called moderates, and I'm not talking about any particular individual,
6:55
Speaker 7: but the so called moderates in the party, what are
6:57
Speaker 7: the policies that you're advocating for? They will run which
7:00
Speaker 7: other people's policies. But let's take net zero. What do
7:02
Speaker 7: you want net zero by twenty forty? Do you want
7:05
Speaker 7: to double immigration? In take do you want to have
7:07
Speaker 7: four flags flying rather than three flags? You know, what
7:10
Speaker 7: are the actual policies that you believe are going to
7:12
Speaker 7: get the coalition back into government at least Andrew Hasty
7:15
Speaker 7: and others like Senators Enterprise are communicating policy views. Why
7:19
Speaker 7: don't you actually have your own policy views and debate that.
7:22
Speaker 7: But instead they hide behind these leaks that are coming
7:25
Speaker 7: out of forever rather than having their own ideas of
7:28
Speaker 7: how to get the Coalition back into government.
7:32
Speaker 3: And they still as a party have no position on
7:35
Speaker 3: these key issues.
7:36
Speaker 4: I mean, how many more reviews? How many more months.
7:39
Speaker 3: Are they going to waste before they actually come to
7:42
Speaker 3: a position.
7:43
Speaker 4: And I know what they stand for.
7:45
Speaker 3: I don't know how they expect dear Electra to know
7:47
Speaker 3: what they stand for when they themselves don't have policies
7:51
Speaker 3: in this area yet and we're still doing endless reviews
7:54
Speaker 3: to figure out who we are.
7:55
Speaker 4: Now, let's move on to real.
7:57
Speaker 3: Estate experts warning that surging crime rates and soaring property
8:02
Speaker 3: taxes are forcing Victorian home buyers to look into state.
8:07
Speaker 3: Speaking at a Property Council event this week, industry leader
8:11
Speaker 3: Andrew Valentine said that while Melbourne offers one of Australia's
8:15
Speaker 3: more affordable markets, it has less appeal due to rising
8:19
Speaker 3: crime and taxes.
8:21
Speaker 4: Dan The problem is also.
8:22
Speaker 3: Affecting retail investors and commercial property builders who are now
8:27
Speaker 3: looking to invest in other cities where crime rates are
8:31
Speaker 3: lower and there's probably a little bit less red tape
8:33
Speaker 3: and less taxes on property.
8:39
Speaker 7: Well, crime and taxes are bad things. Who would have
8:41
Speaker 7: thought that, you know, and this is you know, this
8:44
Speaker 7: is another example of how you know, it's quite stunning
8:47
Speaker 7: actually for someone to say that, well, we're not going
8:49
Speaker 7: to invest or, you know, investment is going to go
8:51
Speaker 7: down in Victoria because of crime. I've not heard that before. So,
8:54
Speaker 7: you know, it seems that every week that goes by,
8:57
Speaker 7: things get worse and worse in Victoria. Now I wonder
9:00
Speaker 7: whether the public now thinks that things are just so
9:02
Speaker 7: bad in Victoria that that has can't be fixed. And
9:06
Speaker 7: the thing that the opposition in Victoria needs to understand
9:09
Speaker 7: is they're going to have to have a couple of
9:10
Speaker 7: big ideas to actually convince people that the state can
9:13
Speaker 7: be fixed. They're a bit obsessed with talking about relatively
9:17
Speaker 7: small things like the cost of machete bins, which I
9:19
Speaker 7: agree it's a total waste of money, and I understand
9:21
Speaker 7: they're trying to say that this goes to the point
9:23
Speaker 7: that the government can't manage money. But you've got to
9:26
Speaker 7: actually show the public that you understand that Victoria is
9:28
Speaker 7: fundamentally broken and convince them that you're going to be
9:31
Speaker 7: able to fix those problems. So now is the time
9:33
Speaker 7: for the opposition in Victoria to be bold with a
9:36
Speaker 7: couple of very big ideas. That will go to the
9:38
Speaker 7: community about how they're going to get Victoria fixed.
9:44
Speaker 4: Absolutely, go tough on crime.
9:47
Speaker 3: That is a vote winner any election, let alone this
9:51
Speaker 3: one when crime has just been a top issue in
9:55
Speaker 3: this state. It leads the news just about every night,
9:58
Speaker 3: it's on the front pages consistently. But also when it
10:01
Speaker 3: comes to taxes, Dan, I mean, have we heard anything
10:04
Speaker 3: about them doing something about land tax or other taxes
10:11
Speaker 3: that are driving mom and dad investors out of the market.
10:14
Speaker 3: It seems to be they're too timid to really tackle
10:18
Speaker 3: those big issues.
10:22
Speaker 8: Yeah, so far that seems to be the case.
10:24
Speaker 7: Now, the charitable view would be that there's I don't
10:26
Speaker 7: know what is at twelve thirty months or the next election,
10:28
Speaker 7: so there's plenty of time to roll this out. But
10:31
Speaker 7: you know, I really think that the issue here is
10:33
Speaker 7: you've got to talk about, as I said, a couple
10:35
Speaker 7: of big things that matter to the community. Taxes is
10:38
Speaker 7: one of them, but clearly the cost of energy and
10:40
Speaker 7: policies like net zero, and this is an area where
10:43
Speaker 7: the Victorian government's gone further than any other jurisdiction and
10:46
Speaker 7: all you have to do is look at the consequences.
10:49
Speaker 7: But I also think, you know, reader. The treaty is
10:52
Speaker 7: a massive deal. It is a massive issue. It affects
10:55
Speaker 7: the lives of every single Victorian. It will permanently change
10:59
Speaker 7: the structure of Victoria to have a two tier in society.
11:01
Speaker 7: And so far the opposition, while they oppose it, they're
11:04
Speaker 7: not going to campaign on it yet. It's one of
11:06
Speaker 7: the biggest negative crazy Victoria in its entire history.
11:10
Speaker 8: So that would be number one for me.
11:15
Speaker 3: You're absolutely right, And later in the program I'll be
11:18
Speaker 3: speaking to a leading barrister about just how impactful that
11:23
Speaker 3: treaty is, and I think Victorians really are not fully
11:29
Speaker 3: aware of how broad its powers are and its influence
11:33
Speaker 3: and how divisive it is now. Earlier today, Senator Claire
11:38
Speaker 3: Chandler asked a rather simple question of sex discrimination Commissioner
11:43
Speaker 3: and a Cody, and she got this astonishing response.
11:48
Speaker 9: There are a range of people who identify as women
11:53
Speaker 9: who are women.
11:54
Speaker 4: Did you mean that biological males can be women.
11:58
Speaker 9: Men? So I think we have different language that perhaps
12:03
Speaker 9: you're using that I would use. So I don't understand
12:06
Speaker 9: the term biological men, right.
12:10
Speaker 4: This might be a short trunch of questions.
12:12
Speaker 3: Then she really says she doesn't understand terms like biological men.
12:19
Speaker 3: I've listened to the full answer, and Dan, it does
12:22
Speaker 3: not get better. In fact, it gets worse. How could
12:26
Speaker 3: someone like her be in that role. She is the
12:30
Speaker 3: sex discrimination Commissioner, she's supposed to be there in part
12:33
Speaker 3: to protect the rights of girls and women, and she
12:37
Speaker 3: doesn't seem to be able to define one.
12:41
Speaker 7: Well, we're governed by morons, and you know, I just
12:45
Speaker 7: don't you know, how much further can this go? How
12:48
Speaker 7: much longer can this go on for? We've send this
12:50
Speaker 7: time and time again. There was that famous one of
12:52
Speaker 7: Senator Antique, you know who stitched up one of the
12:56
Speaker 7: I think it was the health officer who couldn't define
12:58
Speaker 7: what a woman was, and they sort of go on
13:00
Speaker 7: these long and elaborate sort of you know, sort of
13:04
Speaker 7: non answers, and people just look at it. Normal people
13:07
Speaker 7: look at it and go, what you can't tell me
13:08
Speaker 7: what a man or a woman is? I mean, if
13:11
Speaker 7: you can't define what that is, how can you have
13:13
Speaker 7: confidence in anything else that they do? And unfortunately, the
13:18
Speaker 7: governing bodies of our society, in the public service more generally,
13:21
Speaker 7: is just infiltrated with these people that have been completely
13:25
Speaker 7: taken over by this radical gender ideology and it's sending
13:30
Speaker 7: them down all of these bizarre rabbit holes.
13:34
Speaker 3: Well, we went to anacote last week to get some
13:38
Speaker 3: sort of commentary on a male sexual predator who identifies
13:43
Speaker 3: as female being housed with women in a Victorian prison.
13:48
Speaker 3: No comment on that, and I think I can understand
13:51
Speaker 3: why there was no comment on that. Hearing that answer today,
13:53
Speaker 3: it is absolutely shocking.
13:55
Speaker 4: It's not good enough.
13:57
Speaker 3: Now, before you go, I just want to get your
13:58
Speaker 3: take on the story The Daily Telegraph had today on
14:02
Speaker 3: Australian taxpayers funding a multi year project run by the
14:06
Speaker 3: Chinese Communist Party to drive renewables uptake and improve air
14:12
Speaker 3: quality in Shandong Province in eastern China. Australia is helping
14:18
Speaker 3: to fund the six hundred million dollar project through it's
14:22
Speaker 3: thirteen point five million dollars in contributions to the Asian
14:26
Speaker 3: Development Banks Clean Energy Fund, which has put one point one.
14:30
Speaker 4: Million dollars into the initiative.
14:32
Speaker 3: DAN, why should a single Australian dollar go towards a
14:37
Speaker 3: project like this?
14:41
Speaker 7: Well, exactly right, and this is great reporting from Charlie
14:44
Speaker 7: Chawick at the The Daily Telegraph to expose this. I mean,
14:47
Speaker 7: what we need is an audit of all of this
14:48
Speaker 7: money that's going overseas. I mean, we saw what happened
14:51
Speaker 7: in the Trump administration with USAID and the kind of
14:54
Speaker 7: ridiculous things that taxpayer money was going through there, and
14:57
Speaker 7: I suspect we have a proper, full, transparent and audit
15:01
Speaker 7: of where our money is going overseas that it would
15:03
Speaker 7: show similar things as we're seeing now. And look, the
15:06
Speaker 7: reality is that yes, foreign aid can play an important role,
15:09
Speaker 7: but it needs to be in Australia's national interest, needs
15:11
Speaker 7: to be safeguarding our national interests and the interest that
15:14
Speaker 7: we have abroad, and plainly sending taxpayer dollars to China
15:19
Speaker 7: for these kind of activities is well outside the scope
15:23
Speaker 7: of any meaningful definition of what's in Australia's national interest.
15:28
Speaker 4: Dan Wile, thank you for your time tonight.
15:32
Speaker 8: Now.
15:32
Speaker 3: Two years ago, Australians resoundingly rejected the Voice, despite being
15:36
Speaker 3: told it was nothing more than a modest change to
15:38
Speaker 3: the constitution.
15:39
Speaker 4: Well, here in Victoria, we're about.
15:41
Speaker 3: To get not only an Indigenous Voice to stay Parliament,
15:44
Speaker 3: but also a treaty. This new Indigenous only body will
15:48
Speaker 3: be funded by Victorian taxpayers, but it will not be
15:51
Speaker 3: responsible or accountable to Victorian taxpayers or the Victorian Parliament.
15:57
Speaker 3: And far from being a modest change, it is designed
16:00
Speaker 3: to be radical in its ideology and influence. Joining me
16:04
Speaker 3: now is barrister and member of the Victorian Bar Council,
16:08
Speaker 3: Lana Claris. Lana, you wrote about the Voice and Treaty
16:11
Speaker 3: in the Australian newspaper.
16:13
Speaker 4: Explain to my audience why you say.
16:15
Speaker 3: They should be deeply worried by this legislation.
16:20
Speaker 10: Well, thank you for having me here, Rita. The first
16:23
Speaker 10: point to make is that there are two aspects to
16:26
Speaker 10: this legislation. The first is the Statewide Treaty Bill and
16:30
Speaker 10: the second is the Statewide Treaty. So taking the bill
16:33
Speaker 10: to begin with, whilst it's called a statewide Treaty Bill,
16:38
Speaker 10: it is not in fact a treaty at all, because,
16:41
Speaker 10: as we know, a treaty is an agreement between two
16:44
Speaker 10: international states. So the first point is that this is
16:48
Speaker 10: not an agreement, It is a piece of legislation. The
16:51
Speaker 10: second point is that it is not an agreement between
16:53
Speaker 10: two international states. So we need to put out of
16:57
Speaker 10: our minds the fact that this bill is creating a treaty.
17:00
Speaker 4: What in fact it is actually doing.
17:02
Speaker 10: The bill itself is very similar to a found in constitution.
17:07
Speaker 5: Wow.
17:08
Speaker 10: So what this bill is actually doing is it is
17:12
Speaker 10: seeking to establish a new government in our state, an
17:15
Speaker 10: Indigenous only government. It establishes a legislature, which is the
17:19
Speaker 10: first People's Assembly. It also establishes a justice Arm, and
17:23
Speaker 10: it establishes a truth telling Arm. So that's why I
17:28
Speaker 10: say we need to be deeply concerned about this, because
17:31
Speaker 10: this bill is creating an entirely new government in our
17:35
Speaker 10: state and indigenous, a race based government.
17:37
Speaker 3: Yes, and the notion of a treaty suggests there's some
17:41
Speaker 3: negotiation between two parties.
17:43
Speaker 4: There seems to be none of that.
17:44
Speaker 3: It just seems to be a list of demands and
17:47
Speaker 3: a whole lot of taxpayer dollars and powers being given
17:53
Speaker 3: to this new body.
17:54
Speaker 10: Well, absolutely, I think that Victorians are completely unaware of
17:57
Speaker 10: what's going on. I think there have been some negotiations
18:00
Speaker 10: going on, but in secret. There's no way the average
18:04
Speaker 10: Victorian on the street would understand that this bill is
18:07
Speaker 10: creating an entirely new race based body.
18:10
Speaker 3: What are the checks and balances on the powers this
18:14
Speaker 3: body will have?
18:15
Speaker 10: Well, because essentially it is the creation of this new government,
18:21
Speaker 10: it will be funded by us, by Victorian taxpayers. But
18:26
Speaker 10: this new indigenous government will not be accountable to our
18:29
Speaker 10: government in any way, and we don't get a vote
18:32
Speaker 10: in relation to it either, So in other words, we're
18:35
Speaker 10: paying for it, but if we don't like what it's doing,
18:38
Speaker 10: we can't vote it out. Now, this violates the absolute
18:43
Speaker 10: fundamental principle of the Westminster system, which is responsible in
18:46
Speaker 10: accountable government.
18:48
Speaker 4: It's astonishing.
18:49
Speaker 3: How is it going to impact non Indigenous Victorians other
18:53
Speaker 3: than the fact that we're paying for it and there's
18:55
Speaker 3: no accountability.
18:56
Speaker 4: But will they have a say in laws or.
19:01
Speaker 3: Anything that's happening across the state that impacts non Indigenous
19:05
Speaker 3: Victorians as well.
19:07
Speaker 10: So the two aspects, taking the bill as the first aspect,
19:12
Speaker 10: it is creating this new government, so that means everyday
19:18
Speaker 10: Victorians are going to have to deal with two layers
19:20
Speaker 10: of bureaucracy. And this is occurring at a time when
19:24
Speaker 10: investment and business is fleeing our state because of increased taxes,
19:30
Speaker 10: increase bureaucracy, you know, a cost of energy and all
19:33
Speaker 10: these other factors.
19:34
Speaker 4: This is the worst possible time.
19:37
Speaker 10: To create a new government with an entirely new level
19:41
Speaker 10: of red tape around it. But can I also say
19:44
Speaker 10: that in relation to the second aspect, which is the
19:48
Speaker 10: statewide Treaty, which is a separate thirty four thirty four
19:51
Speaker 10: page document, and I note it is the first treaty,
19:55
Speaker 10: so they've made it very clear that there's going to
19:56
Speaker 10: be many, many more treaties. This is just the first one.
19:59
Speaker 10: This will impact everyday Victorians because it requires, for example,
20:04
Speaker 10: truth telling as part of our education system from what
20:08
Speaker 10: they call foundation, which I believe is PREP, but it
20:11
Speaker 10: could be before PREP all the way up until year twelve.
20:14
Speaker 10: So our children are going to be taught truth telling.
20:19
Speaker 3: And that's an interesting term I would use them. I
20:22
Speaker 3: would use the bunny as as well, because it's someone
20:25
Speaker 3: else's truth may be very different to the actual truth,
20:29
Speaker 3: and that can't really be challenged in.
20:32
Speaker 4: The way it's been prescribed.
20:34
Speaker 3: You talk about these two layers of government, How will
20:38
Speaker 3: new legislation be impacted by that? So if you're in
20:42
Speaker 3: the Victorian Parliament, the one we all vote for, and
20:45
Speaker 3: you want to introduce some new legislation, do you have
20:47
Speaker 3: to get some sort of buying from the Indigenous Parliament
20:53
Speaker 3: or at least get some sort of idea If they're
20:57
Speaker 3: going to be approving of whatever it is you're proposing.
21:01
Speaker 10: Yes, So any new bill that is introduced into Parliament
21:05
Speaker 10: must they throughout the bill the mandatory terms such as
21:10
Speaker 10: must so every new bill must have tabled with it
21:15
Speaker 10: what is called a statement of treaty compatibility.
21:19
Speaker 3: Statement of treaty compatibility. That is fascinating. So every new
21:23
Speaker 3: bill must be compatible with the treaty and the ideology
21:29
Speaker 3: behind that. And I noticed that too when you read
21:32
Speaker 3: the document. It's all must must, It's the language.
21:36
Speaker 4: Is very forceful. Indeed, it is so that is going
21:39
Speaker 4: to impact every Victorian.
21:40
Speaker 3: That's not just something that's going to impact indigenous Victorian.
21:43
Speaker 4: Absolutely.
21:45
Speaker 10: I would just note as well, in relation to the
21:47
Speaker 10: statement of treaty compatibility, this involves an element of compelled speech,
21:51
Speaker 10: because if you have an elected representative who doesn't agree that,
21:55
Speaker 10: for example, there are ongoing injustices as a result of colonization,
22:00
Speaker 10: putting words into the mouths of our elected representative. This
22:04
Speaker 10: is a form of compelled.
22:05
Speaker 3: Speech, absolutely, and it is a document that is radical.
22:10
Speaker 4: I think again Victorians.
22:11
Speaker 3: Don't understand that because most of them don't have the
22:13
Speaker 3: time to read the full document and the coverage of
22:16
Speaker 3: it has been pretty scanned because the Liberals, though they
22:20
Speaker 3: say they oppose it, they don't seem to be campaigning
22:22
Speaker 3: on it. So there's not a great deal of debate
22:25
Speaker 3: and analysis of this document.
22:27
Speaker 4: But it is deeply radical in its language. It is.
22:32
Speaker 3: The blackest band view of this country and its history
22:36
Speaker 3: it is.
22:37
Speaker 10: It will completely change the way the state will be governed.
22:41
Speaker 10: As I said, two governments, separate layer of bureocracy. If
22:45
Speaker 10: your audience is sick of acknowledgments of country, the separatism
22:49
Speaker 10: is going to get so much more worse. It's going
22:52
Speaker 10: to be much worse. There will be mandating flying of
22:56
Speaker 10: Aboriginal and torrestrate islander flags on all Victorian government buildings, mandated, mandated,
23:01
Speaker 10: It's part of the treaty. And so the current cohesion
23:05
Speaker 10: split that we're seeing in our state at the moment
23:07
Speaker 10: is only going to get so much worse.
23:09
Speaker 3: And just before you go given the extraordinary power this
23:13
Speaker 3: body is going to have and taxpayer funds, is there
23:16
Speaker 3: going to be any scrutiny on who can participate, who
23:19
Speaker 3: can be elected, Because even within the Indigenous community, there
23:24
Speaker 3: is a fair bit of debate about people who identify
23:27
Speaker 3: as Indigenous and they're not always accepted.
23:29
Speaker 4: How is that going to be handled?
23:31
Speaker 10: Well, this is one of the most shocking parts of
23:34
Speaker 10: the bill.
23:34
Speaker 4: I mean, it's all shocking.
23:35
Speaker 10: But the First People's Assembly, which is essentially the legislature
23:40
Speaker 10: of this new government, will have complete power over who
23:44
Speaker 10: can vote for members of the First People's Assembly and
23:48
Speaker 10: how the elections are to be conducted. So, if Victorians
23:53
Speaker 10: are concerned about our indigenous brothers and sisters, which of
23:56
Speaker 10: course we all are because we show an amazing amount
23:59
Speaker 10: of goodwill towards the Indigenous community, this is not the
24:02
Speaker 10: way to go about fixing it. This is a blueprint
24:06
Speaker 10: for a one party social estate. Yeah, that will govern
24:09
Speaker 10: our Indigenous Victorians. This is not going to help anything.
24:12
Speaker 3: It's not going to help the Indigenous community and it
24:15
Speaker 3: certainly isn't going.
24:16
Speaker 4: To help Victoria.
24:17
Speaker 3: The racial division this would inspire is just frightening. Lana Klaris,
24:22
Speaker 3: thank you so much for your time to thank you
24:24
Speaker 3: very much. Stelterkma left he is losing it. Plus the
24:28
Speaker 3: latest from the US, including a fresh poll showing that
24:30
Speaker 3: Donald Trump has the steadiest approval rating of any president ever.
24:35
Speaker 4: Mi Horowitz has the details.
24:47
Speaker 3: You're watching the Riada panning your show, and it's time
24:50
Speaker 3: for lefties losing it. Let's start with a young deranged
24:53
Speaker 3: woman attacking conservatives David Cat and Cam Higbee and then
24:57
Speaker 3: getting mace.
24:58
Speaker 4: This is what is commonly a refre to us effing.
25:01
Speaker 3: Around and finding out or just instant karma.
25:05
Speaker 11: The whole Charlie, start, start, start.
25:30
Speaker 3: And like any good left us, the cry bully ended
25:33
Speaker 3: up acting like the victim when faced with the consequences
25:36
Speaker 3: of her own actions.
25:38
Speaker 4: You because you evil, You don't take videos, take all
25:49
Speaker 4: you need. You're evil people that they're not question, Yes,
25:53
Speaker 4: they're the evil ones. Lady.
25:55
Speaker 3: Now to our favorite little climate change crazy doom goblin
25:59
Speaker 3: turned anti Israel zealet, Greta Thunberg.
26:02
Speaker 12: Hello, this is going to be a long video, but
26:05
Speaker 12: I have a lot to say, so there with me.
26:09
Speaker 3: No, no, no, nobody's got time for a long rant
26:12
Speaker 3: from Greta.
26:13
Speaker 4: I'd rather hear what President Trump has to say about
26:16
Speaker 4: Sweden's worst export.
26:18
Speaker 13: She's just a trouble maker, you know, I mean, you
26:21
Speaker 13: mean she's no longer into the environment.
26:22
Speaker 12: Now she's a trouble maker.
26:25
Speaker 4: She is an anger management problem. I think she should
26:27
Speaker 4: see a doctor.
26:28
Speaker 12: She needs angry if you ever watch her, she's.
26:31
Speaker 4: A young person.
26:32
Speaker 12: She's so angry, she's so crazy.
26:35
Speaker 4: No, you can have her. I couldn't have sent it
26:38
Speaker 4: better myself.
26:39
Speaker 3: And Donald Trump should know he is responsible for Greta's
26:42
Speaker 3: finest moment. Remember when he ignored her at the un
26:47
Speaker 3: during his first term. Look at that face. That was
26:51
Speaker 3: the day she gave that derange how dare you speech?
26:54
Speaker 3: Good times. Now, let's get a good old.
26:57
Speaker 4: Fashioned dose of crazy from the Lady of the view.
27:00
Speaker 3: Here is Joy Beha claiming Christinome, the Secretary of Homeland Security,
27:06
Speaker 3: is targeting Bad Bunny because his Latino and then Whoopy
27:11
Speaker 3: Goldberg helpfully recommends that.
27:13
Speaker 4: Folks turn up to the super.
27:15
Speaker 3: Bowl in brown face to confuse Ice agents.
27:20
Speaker 14: Anyway, She's threatening to go to the super Bowl when
27:24
Speaker 14: when Bad Bunny is there and round up all these
27:27
Speaker 14: people that are illegal immigrants.
27:29
Speaker 4: Do you think that.
27:30
Speaker 14: She would go if it was god Brooks or Eminem
27:34
Speaker 14: or Taylor Sweat for any other white leers. Understand what
27:37
Speaker 14: you're saying, Because she's going to go to the super
27:40
Speaker 14: Bowl and round up how she got to know who's who?
27:43
Speaker 11: Everybody, get a little Cobba butter set in the Sun.
27:49
Speaker 2: That's the first thing. And then and this is the only.
27:52
Speaker 15: Time you can probably ever do this, give yourself a
27:56
Speaker 15: Latin accident.
27:58
Speaker 4: You know?
27:58
Speaker 8: Whoop?
27:58
Speaker 14: That such a good yeah, I'm seeing if she can
28:03
Speaker 14: tell who true.
28:05
Speaker 4: Even the dim witted view audience did not want to
28:08
Speaker 4: clap that lunacy. As for the claim.
28:11
Speaker 3: From Joy that Christinoam wouldn't be doing this if Garth Brooks,
28:15
Speaker 3: Taylor Swift or Eminem were performing, well, think again, lady.
28:19
Speaker 3: All three are as left as bad bunny and judged accordingly.
28:23
Speaker 4: It's the view that.
28:24
Speaker 3: Seems to be obsessed by skin color, and these ladies
28:28
Speaker 3: have become so desperate, so extreme, that they openly discuss
28:32
Speaker 3: their wacko theories, including one where they say Trump's law
28:37
Speaker 3: and order policies are really about a plot to end
28:41
Speaker 3: elections or distract from Democrat Megadona Jeffrey Epstein.
28:46
Speaker 14: This is a pretext to stop the next election. That's
28:50
Speaker 14: what I think it.
28:51
Speaker 7: I would say it might also be a distraction from
28:53
Speaker 7: the hearing that's going on right now about the Epstein file.
28:55
Speaker 4: Right some things have come up and a G.
28:58
Speaker 6: Pam Bindi was judging questions and attacking back.
29:04
Speaker 3: Whackerdoodles, all of them now to a woman whose politics
29:08
Speaker 3: make her a perfect candidate for the view. Indeed, she's
29:11
Speaker 3: so hard left she makes whoopee and joy look sane.
29:15
Speaker 3: Here is MSNBC anchor Nicole Wallace, and let's be serious
29:19
Speaker 3: here for a second. What you're about to see is
29:22
Speaker 3: utterly appalling. This is misinformation and incitement dressed up as
29:27
Speaker 3: news reporting what.
29:28
Speaker 6: We're learning about the fire that destroyed the home of
29:31
Speaker 6: a South Carolina Circuit Court judge who faced criticism from
29:34
Speaker 6: Trump officials after ruling she meet against the Trump administration.
29:38
Speaker 6: It comes amid a surge in hostility and threats against judges,
29:42
Speaker 6: as well as criticism directly from the Trump administration, including
29:46
Speaker 6: for Judge Goudstein.
29:48
Speaker 3: Just absolutely reckless fake news because the pertinent information is
29:54
Speaker 3: that fire was not arson.
29:56
Speaker 4: But why let that get in the way of a narrative.
29:59
Speaker 3: Let's bring in Mary mccaud to add to the hysteria.
30:03
Speaker 4: She's pointing the finger at Donald Trump.
30:05
Speaker 3: An alleging an act of possible to mixed domestic terrorism.
30:09
Speaker 13: We've talked today already about crossing rubicons, right, and when
30:12
Speaker 13: you're starting to attack judges because of their rulings. We're
30:16
Speaker 13: in a very very dangerous position in this country, and
30:20
Speaker 13: is it makes judges fearful, It makes prosecutors fearful, as
30:24
Speaker 13: we know, it makes others in positions where they could
30:27
Speaker 13: be criticized by Donald Trump fearful. And he needs to
30:30
Speaker 13: know the power of his voice and how people respond
30:34
Speaker 13: to that. We've been saying this for years, Nicole, But like,
30:37
Speaker 13: if this is what this turns out to be, some
30:39
Speaker 13: sort of politically motivated act of domestic terrorism, then the
30:45
Speaker 13: importance and significance of the things that Donald Trump says
30:49
Speaker 13: about a person, just again will be demonstrated in this instance.
30:54
Speaker 3: Let's not forget it's the left that are killing and
30:57
Speaker 3: trying to kill their political opponents, whether it's Charlie Kirk
31:01
Speaker 3: or Donald Trump, or Supreme Court Justice Fret Kavanagh or
31:04
Speaker 3: Republican Stephen Calice. Even in the cases where a Democrat
31:08
Speaker 3: is attacked, it often turns out to be someone from
31:11
Speaker 3: the left, like when Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro's house was
31:16
Speaker 3: set alight by a pro Palestinian activist.
31:19
Speaker 4: Now, it's been a.
31:20
Speaker 3: While since we've featured the asenine content of alleged comic
31:24
Speaker 3: John Oliver here he is encouraging people to harass ICE agents.
31:29
Speaker 2: Absolutely love for that.
31:30
Speaker 1: Woman said, I came to bother Ice because that seems
31:34
Speaker 1: reasonable to me. If Ice can show up and bother
31:37
Speaker 1: some guys at their roofing job, then bystanders should be
31:40
Speaker 1: able to bother Ice at their state sanctioned kidnapping job.
31:44
Speaker 3: It is only felt joining me now is filmmaker and
31:47
Speaker 3: commentator Army Horowitz. Army ICE agents are having their lives threaten,
31:52
Speaker 3: they are having to cover their faces to protect themselves
31:56
Speaker 3: and their families. And we've got a comic, alleged comic
31:59
Speaker 3: incur reaching lifters to confront and harass these agents doing
32:03
Speaker 3: their job.
32:06
Speaker 15: Yeah, Reid, the consent structure allowed by the mainstream media
32:10
Speaker 15: is incredible and it's allowing for these attacks to happen.
32:13
Speaker 2: I'm sorry.
32:14
Speaker 15: There is a causal relationship between what is happening here.
32:18
Speaker 15: When people look at celebrities, at the media, at people
32:22
Speaker 15: they think are within the Overton window, and they hear
32:26
Speaker 15: them speak like this, of course they're going to act
32:28
Speaker 15: in that way. And in reality, what's happening with the
32:31
Speaker 15: media is that they're actually shifting the open to window.
32:34
Speaker 15: They're actually expanding it to allow for physical violence for politics.
32:39
Speaker 2: That's exactly what we're seeing here.
32:42
Speaker 15: Look, this is also with judges Kavanaugh. The person who
32:46
Speaker 15: tried to kill Kavanaugh, right, the Supreme Court justice of
32:51
Speaker 15: the United States, got sent to eight years in prison.
32:54
Speaker 15: There's a couple of things that you get eight years
32:56
Speaker 15: in prison for male fraud and securities fraud. It stays
33:00
Speaker 15: typically gainst eight years in prison, not try to kill
33:04
Speaker 15: a Supreme Court justice. And these ice attacks are happening
33:09
Speaker 15: all across the country. Read that if you again indulge
33:12
Speaker 15: me for another chapter of the World of cod a
33:16
Speaker 15: chat GPT right. Sorry, I'm just I'm workshopping that name.
33:20
Speaker 15: I'll come with a better one next week. But yes,
33:22
Speaker 15: when I did my research, I asked chat GPT, I go,
33:25
Speaker 15: how many attacks on ice agents have we seen in
33:28
Speaker 15: twenty twenty five? That was what I asked it. And
33:31
Speaker 15: then it said it listed three and I said, ah,
33:34
Speaker 15: that does not sound right.
33:36
Speaker 2: Three.
33:36
Speaker 15: I said, well, I witnessed one personally in Los Angeles.
33:39
Speaker 15: I said, Amy, why did you not mention attacks on
33:42
Speaker 15: ice agents in Los Angeles? Chat GPT, You're right to
33:46
Speaker 15: point that out. There actually was an attack lot Angelist
33:50
Speaker 15: that I missed on my earlier list.
33:52
Speaker 2: Are you kidding me?
33:53
Speaker 15: And by the way, it wasn't four attacks. I looked
33:56
Speaker 15: it up myself. There had been a seven hundred percent
34:00
Speaker 15: increase on ICE attacks. From twenty twenty four to twenty
34:03
Speaker 15: twenty five. There have been seventy nine attacks on ICE agents.
34:08
Speaker 15: This is allowed in the left wing democratic consent structure.
34:13
Speaker 15: This is what we're seeing here, okay, And this is
34:15
Speaker 15: not new. We saw this in BLM when I was
34:17
Speaker 15: a kid. The notion, the idea that you would put
34:21
Speaker 15: forgetting when I was a kid five years ago, that
34:24
Speaker 15: you would put a hand on a police officer, never
34:27
Speaker 15: mind a federal official, was pure insanity. But then when
34:31
Speaker 15: we allowed BLM riots to go on, and we allowed
34:34
Speaker 15: them to light cop cars on fire.
34:38
Speaker 2: This is the end result. This is what we're seeing now.
34:41
Speaker 3: Naw me, This next bit of news will need to
34:44
Speaker 3: come with a trigger warning for the left. But despite
34:46
Speaker 3: the relentless bad media, Donald Trump has the steadiest approval
34:51
Speaker 3: writing of any president on record, and would be re
34:54
Speaker 3: elected today if an election were held.
34:58
Speaker 4: Take it away, CNN.
34:59
Speaker 2: Here's the thing to keep in mind.
35:01
Speaker 16: This was good enough to get Trump reelected back in
35:03
Speaker 16: twenty twenty four, and Donald Trump is basically at the
35:06
Speaker 16: same point here right now, which I think would surprise
35:09
Speaker 16: a lot of folks, especially a lot of folks on
35:10
Speaker 16: the left, to very much disagree with a lot of
35:13
Speaker 16: what Donald Trump has done. Is Trump doing what he
35:15
Speaker 16: promised in the twenty twenty four campaign, Yes, fifty two percent,
35:18
Speaker 16: the majority of Americans say that Donald Trump is doing
35:21
Speaker 16: what he promised, compared to forty eight percent who said no.
35:24
Speaker 16: So what essentially is going on here is the voters
35:26
Speaker 16: expected all.
35:27
Speaker 4: Of this from Donald Trump.
35:28
Speaker 16: The majority did, and that is why his favorite ratings
35:31
Speaker 16: simply has not really moved all that much compared to
35:34
Speaker 16: where it was a year ago. Trump is basically doing
35:39
Speaker 16: what the American people thought that he was going to do.
35:42
Speaker 2: Indeed, if you look at the numbers, Trump.
35:44
Speaker 16: Has basically the steadiest favorable rating this much through a
35:47
Speaker 16: presidency of any president on record, and it's basically where
35:51
Speaker 16: he was a year ago, good enough to get him reelected.
35:54
Speaker 3: Ah me, that's all very interesting, But what do you
35:56
Speaker 3: think is going to happen in the midterms?
35:59
Speaker 15: Look traditional in midterms, the party in power loses seats
36:04
Speaker 15: and the Democrats do whatever they can to make sure
36:07
Speaker 15: that doesn't happen this time. The president won the election, right,
36:13
Speaker 15: He won the election because of the two main issues,
36:16
Speaker 15: the economy and illegal immigration.
36:18
Speaker 2: Right, and what has he done well?
36:21
Speaker 15: Illegal immigration is down, the illegal border crossings is down
36:25
Speaker 15: over ninety percent this year, nine percent, nine zero percent.
36:33
Speaker 2: That is an unbelievably incredibly high number.
36:36
Speaker 15: Okay, And an inflation we're down this year forty two
36:42
Speaker 15: percent from the three year average where inflation was three
36:46
Speaker 15: years prior. Okay, that's why if the election was held today,
36:51
Speaker 15: the president would win again. But it's not just the
36:53
Speaker 15: President acting in.
36:54
Speaker 2: A positive way. A lot of.
36:57
Speaker 15: It is the Democrats acting in a negation and losing support,
37:01
Speaker 15: which is the other side of the ledger. Look when
37:05
Speaker 15: they continue to take the wrong side of eighty twenty issues. Right,
37:09
Speaker 15: we talked about it before, We'll continue talking about.
37:11
Speaker 2: It going forward.
37:12
Speaker 15: When they are shutting down the government in now small
37:16
Speaker 15: part because they want illegal aliens to get government funded healthcare,
37:22
Speaker 15: that's a problem for your party.
37:23
Speaker 2: When you're a party calling for cashless.
37:26
Speaker 15: Bail allowing people who committed crimes back into the cities
37:30
Speaker 15: to commit more crimes, that is a problem for your party.
37:35
Speaker 15: So yeah, that's why you're seeing those numbers here. And
37:37
Speaker 15: I'm not sure that the mid term election history will
37:40
Speaker 15: repeat itself.
37:43
Speaker 13: NA.
37:43
Speaker 3: I mean President Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Connie
37:47
Speaker 3: have met to negotiate a trade deal, and the President
37:50
Speaker 3: had the room in stitches with this line.
37:54
Speaker 15: He's a good man, he does a great job, but
37:55
Speaker 15: he's a tough negotiator.
37:57
Speaker 2: So then we'll plus holding things up.
38:04
Speaker 17: If he's a great man and you want to do
38:05
Speaker 17: a deal with Canada, why aren't you?
38:07
Speaker 2: Because I want to be a great man too. Thank you,
38:14
Speaker 2: Thank you.
38:19
Speaker 4: I think you got that one.
38:22
Speaker 17: Thank you.
38:25
Speaker 3: And it was a loving with the Canadian Prime minister
38:28
Speaker 3: calling Donald Trump a transformative president.
38:32
Speaker 18: You kindly hosted me and some of my colleagues a
38:35
Speaker 18: few months ago, and I said at the time, you
38:38
Speaker 18: are a transformative president. And since then, Uh, the transformation
38:43
Speaker 18: in the economy, unprecedented commitments of NATO partners to defense spending,
38:48
Speaker 18: peace from India Pakistan through to Azerbaijan, Armenia, UH, disabling
38:52
Speaker 18: I Ran is a force of terror.
38:54
Speaker 1: UH.
38:55
Speaker 18: And now and I'm running out of time, but this
38:56
Speaker 18: is many respects. The most important uh Mergred of Canada.
39:02
Speaker 18: I knew.
39:04
Speaker 4: That wasn't where I was going.
39:05
Speaker 18: I would know. But you know, on this, on this
39:09
Speaker 18: solemn day of commemoration of the Octo October se horific
39:12
Speaker 18: attacks of October seven, uh, for the first time in decades,
39:17
Speaker 18: hundreds of years, thousands of years, this prospect of peace
39:20
Speaker 18: that you've made possible. Canada stands four square behind those efforts,
39:24
Speaker 18: and we'll do whatever we can to support n Yeah,
39:27
Speaker 18: thank you.
39:27
Speaker 4: Very much, Ahmi.
39:29
Speaker 3: This was Mat Khannie's second visit to the Oval Office
39:32
Speaker 3: ahead of next year's review of the United States Mexico
39:36
Speaker 3: Canada Agreement.
39:37
Speaker 4: The relations seemed to be very positive there.
39:42
Speaker 15: Yeah, look what can I tell you? Can I you
39:45
Speaker 15: a prime minister, welcome to the one eighty club, as
39:48
Speaker 15: I call it, joining.
39:50
Speaker 2: Merch from Germany. He a starmer of England.
39:53
Speaker 15: Even crazy Lulu da Silva said he had a great
39:57
Speaker 15: positive call with President Trump.
40:00
Speaker 2: I think look he.
40:01
Speaker 15: Did, Mark Quiy did a great job listing all or
40:05
Speaker 15: just a number of his foreign policy accomplishments. Maybe he,
40:09
Speaker 15: like others, maybe they smell a nobel peace price coming.
40:13
Speaker 15: I want to get on that train as fast as possible.
40:15
Speaker 15: These otienly are politicians, right, and when they see, particularly
40:20
Speaker 15: when it comes to foreign policy arena, but also the
40:22
Speaker 15: economic arena.
40:23
Speaker 2: When they see the.
40:24
Speaker 15: Success after success after success of the United States and
40:28
Speaker 15: the foreign policy world and the leadership of Donald Trump.
40:31
Speaker 2: I think they want to get aboard that. I think
40:32
Speaker 2: they want to be part of that.
40:34
Speaker 15: So yeah, I think I chalked that up to he
40:36
Speaker 15: just following the line of success, and I think that's
40:39
Speaker 15: where it leads us.
40:43
Speaker 4: Na Ami.
40:44
Speaker 3: This week we observe the second anniversary of the October
40:47
Speaker 3: seven terrorist attacks. Sadly it coincided with more acts of
40:52
Speaker 3: anti Semitism, including right here in Melbourne.
40:56
Speaker 4: You travel extensively.
40:58
Speaker 3: How fearful is the Jewish community in the West right now?
41:05
Speaker 2: Fearful?
41:07
Speaker 15: Look, the reality is is that there have been fear
41:11
Speaker 15: in the Jewish community, attacks in the Jewish community, says
41:13
Speaker 15: Jews first.
41:14
Speaker 2: Walked this earth, right, That's the reality of the situation.
41:17
Speaker 15: And obviously we are now in a particularly acute situation
41:22
Speaker 15: across the globe, not just with our co religionists in Israel.
41:27
Speaker 2: Yeah.
41:27
Speaker 15: Look, we just had a series of holidays for Jews
41:32
Speaker 15: around the world, right Russia, Chhana, you know, Kipper, we
41:34
Speaker 15: call the High Holidays and It's very striking that.
41:38
Speaker 2: And this is not new. It's been like this for many.
41:41
Speaker 15: Years, that in order to go pray to God you
41:44
Speaker 15: have to walk through levels of security at every single
41:49
Speaker 15: synagogue that exists in the world. And I'm not talking
41:53
Speaker 15: about just in Israel or even in Europe, but here
41:55
Speaker 15: in the United States. Look for years, I did volunteer
41:58
Speaker 15: security for my synagogue because it was necessary. It's part
42:02
Speaker 15: of the line item expense. Synagogues have it's security. It's shameful.
42:07
Speaker 15: It's sad that we have to live with this.
42:09
Speaker 3: It is shameful on me and it's and it's evidence
42:13
Speaker 3: right here in Australia. In a country like Australia, they're
42:16
Speaker 3: so peaceful and prosperous and harmonious. You look at the
42:20
Speaker 3: Jewish schools, the synagogues, the security they have is akin
42:24
Speaker 3: to what you see at the airport.
42:26
Speaker 4: Me Horowitz, thank you so much for your time tonight.
42:30
Speaker 2: How was a pleasure?
42:31
Speaker 3: Still to come, I'll speak to the man behind a
42:33
Speaker 3: new groundbreaking documentary.
42:35
Speaker 4: Caine goul Yelm joins me on the desk. Welcome back.
42:51
Speaker 3: My next guest is the director of a new documentary
42:54
Speaker 3: making its world premiere at the Byron Bay Film Festival
42:57
Speaker 3: next week.
42:58
Speaker 4: The documentary is called Wealth. Here's a snake peg.
43:03
Speaker 17: My name is Kine gill yell me. I live in
43:06
Speaker 17: a rural part of Australia on a small farm and
43:10
Speaker 17: being the annoying overthinker that I am, I've been asking
43:12
Speaker 17: myself why why aren't we happy? I look around and well,
43:17
Speaker 17: can't help but think that society as a whole isn't
43:20
Speaker 17: so I called some mates and grabbed a camera and
43:23
Speaker 17: we hit the road.
43:32
Speaker 12: What unaffordable housing is doing to kids is awful. It's
43:35
Speaker 12: making them feel inadequate because they can't buy a house,
43:39
Speaker 12: and it's left them feeling mentally deranged because they feel
43:43
Speaker 12: that they've done something wrong.
43:44
Speaker 3: They haven't joining me now is director Caine gool yell me.
43:49
Speaker 4: Cain.
43:49
Speaker 3: Your documentary has received some high praise, including from President
43:53
Speaker 3: Obama's production company, and is being considered for an actor.
43:58
Speaker 4: What inspired you to make Commonwealth?
44:01
Speaker 17: Well, Reta, I think it started really from a place
44:04
Speaker 17: of frustration off the back of COVID. I guess I
44:10
Speaker 17: came away thinking with a bit of a newfound perspective
44:14
Speaker 17: on how the world functions, and it upset me quite frankly,
44:18
Speaker 17: and it made me very concerned for the future of
44:20
Speaker 17: my family, for my kids and fathers. But I felt
44:24
Speaker 17: completely powerless on what to do. On one guy, I
44:27
Speaker 17: grew up in Western Sydney, and what could I possibly do?
44:31
Speaker 17: And well, I thought, well, I'm a writer, I'm a director.
44:34
Speaker 17: I've only done network TV and movies. Maybe I could
44:38
Speaker 17: do a documentary to explore what plausible alternatives exist to
44:42
Speaker 17: the system in which we live in.
44:44
Speaker 3: Well, let's talk about those plausible alternatives. You travel to
44:48
Speaker 3: eight different countries and looked at alternative economic and political models.
44:54
Speaker 4: What did you find?
44:57
Speaker 17: I found? Honestly, I found a bit of hope because
44:59
Speaker 17: coming ou out of COVID, I guess I had a
45:03
Speaker 17: little bit of a bleak outlook for the future.
45:06
Speaker 3: Yeah, particularly being in Australia, we were particularly COVID crazy.
45:11
Speaker 17: One Yea and my family we experienced it both in Italy.
45:14
Speaker 17: We were living in Italy during twenty twenty and then
45:16
Speaker 17: we came back thinking we were going to come back
45:18
Speaker 17: to some kind of normality here and we went through
45:20
Speaker 17: it all again. And so I guess going on this journey,
45:24
Speaker 17: meeting and interviewing, you know, so many different people of
45:27
Speaker 17: different lines of thinking, different backgrounds, religions and ideologies. I
45:33
Speaker 17: guess one of the things that dawned on me is
45:36
Speaker 17: that we do as humans have a lot in common,
45:39
Speaker 17: and I think that sometimes media have been played a
45:45
Speaker 17: role in creating a little bit more division and amplifying
45:48
Speaker 17: things that. You know, if you actually sit down and
45:50
Speaker 17: have a heart to heart conversation with someone more often
45:53
Speaker 17: than not, I believe that you find some common humanity
45:57
Speaker 17: amongst each other. And that was a huge takeaway from me.
46:00
Speaker 17: In terms of the specific solutions and alternatives, I think
46:03
Speaker 17: I'm going to let people see the film because otherwise
46:06
Speaker 17: you've got no reason to see it exactly.
46:10
Speaker 4: You don't give it away.
46:12
Speaker 3: Normally with documentaries, you don't have that issue, there's no twist.
46:16
Speaker 3: But you've certainly invested a great deal of time and
46:21
Speaker 3: money in this. In the clip we showed, we're talking
46:25
Speaker 3: about the struggles young people face trying to buy property,
46:29
Speaker 3: and it's really a big issue in this country. As
46:33
Speaker 3: we know, housing affordability is a huge problem. What do
46:38
Speaker 3: you think are the long term impacts of that on
46:41
Speaker 3: If you've got a generation who really don't have hopes
46:44
Speaker 3: of owning a property.
46:46
Speaker 17: Well, if nothing changes, the level of despair will only increase.
46:51
Speaker 17: And that's a sad reality. Something has to change and
46:56
Speaker 17: that's some of the things that we explore in the
46:58
Speaker 17: film I find it. You know, just recently, just in
47:03
Speaker 17: the past week, our Prime Minister put a clip on
47:05
Speaker 17: social media, a ten second clip, try to sell five
47:09
Speaker 17: percent mortgages to young people seeing Yeah, five percent deposits
47:14
Speaker 17: for first home buyers. That's all you need to know.
47:18
Speaker 17: That's a quote. All you need to know. You know,
47:21
Speaker 17: it's like the guy is selling him. He thinks that
47:23
Speaker 17: he's selling us beach arges for JB High a ten
47:26
Speaker 17: second clip, you know, but he's selling, you know, a
47:29
Speaker 17: lifetime of slavery to the becks. And that's not okay,
47:35
Speaker 17: yeah it is.
47:35
Speaker 4: It is.
47:36
Speaker 3: It's sort of like a secondhand car salesman technique.
47:39
Speaker 4: Isn't it. That's all you need to know? Sign up
47:41
Speaker 4: five percent?
47:42
Speaker 17: And as Tucker Carlson famously posts the question, I think
47:46
Speaker 17: it was last year on his visit, how much do
47:48
Speaker 17: you think that it might cost to buy a guy
47:49
Speaker 17: like Albanisi? He said, And Tucker said, I think it
47:52
Speaker 17: could be as little as the cost of a new Tesla.
47:55
Speaker 4: I actually disagree with Tucker.
47:56
Speaker 17: Because I think that you could buy him for the
47:59
Speaker 17: cost of a used Tesla.
48:02
Speaker 4: And you can get those cheap.
48:04
Speaker 3: Now, you voluntarily exited talks with Netflix to have your
48:10
Speaker 3: documentary featured there. That's quite a big decision to make.
48:15
Speaker 3: He said it was a matter of principle because of
48:18
Speaker 3: some of the content they've been pushing lately.
48:20
Speaker 4: Just quickly tell me about that decision.
48:23
Speaker 17: I mean, we've been in discussions with quite a few distributors,
48:26
Speaker 17: Netflix being one of them. And yes, it has become
48:31
Speaker 17: more obvious in recent weeks to me, I didn't realize
48:34
Speaker 17: just to the extent of the sexualized and politicized content
48:38
Speaker 17: that is on there, They're not the only ones that
48:40
Speaker 17: are guilty of it. And yes, there had been some
48:43
Speaker 17: conversations with quite high level executive in the US, and
48:50
Speaker 17: I guess read it. Honestly, It's come a time in
48:54
Speaker 17: my career where I feel like I have to put
48:56
Speaker 17: my values and beliefs before my career, and I've been
48:58
Speaker 17: guilty of doing the opposite for two and I draw
49:03
Speaker 17: a line when you start engaging children in adult conversations,
49:07
Speaker 17: and that's where it ends for me. So in terms
49:10
Speaker 17: of a release, now I don't know what the plan is,
49:13
Speaker 17: because I wouldn't be surprised if people try to distance
49:15
Speaker 17: themselves for me for taking that position.
49:18
Speaker 4: No, that's a brave stance to take. Kine Google yell
49:21
Speaker 4: me thank you so much for your time tonight.
49:23
Speaker 3: Thanks you, and that's it from me. Up next, it's Newsnight.
49:26
Speaker 3: I'll see you tomorrow at eleven