Latest / The Path Went Chilly / Lester Garnier Pt. Two
Transcript
- 0:27Welcome back to the Path Went Chile for part two of our series about the
- 0:31murder of Lester Garnier. Robin, do you want to catch everyone up on
- 0:34what we talked about in our previous episode. Well, this case involves the
- 0:39murder of a police officer. It's thirty year old Lester Garnier, who worked
- 0:43as a vice top for the San Francisco PD and he was found shot to
- 0:47death inside his car at a shopping center parking lot in the town of Walnut
- 0:52Creek, which is just outside San Francisco. But the weird thing is is
- 0:56that no one knows what Lester was doing there, because he was planning to
- 0:59go out for a movie with his best friend but then called him up and
- 1:02said that he couldn't come because he was running late. And he had also
- 1:04received two phone calls at his house that his parents witnessed, and they said
- 1:08that one of the callers was a woman. So it seems apparent that for
- 1:11some reason, Lester was asked to come meet someone at that shopping center parking
- 1:17lot and wound up being shot to death. We had two witnesses who reported
- 1:21seeing two blonde women at the scene, one of whom was climbing out of
- 1:25Lester's car, but they could not be identified, and there was speculation that
- 1:30his murder might have been involved with a recent bust of a sex trafficking ring,
- 1:34where a bunch of people, including a city mayoral candidate and a San
- 1:38Francisco police officer, were busted for statutory rape for their actions against some underage
- 1:45sex workers, though neither of them ever saw prison time. They looked at
- 1:48the possibility that Lester's murder could have been connected to this bust, but they
- 1:52couldn't find any tangible connection, and the case remained cold for another two decades
- 1:57until it was announced in two thousand and eight that a fingerprint found on the
- 2:00windshield of Lestra's car had been matched to a Scottish national named Catherine Koons.
- 2:06She did have a criminal history. She had been accused of trying to hire
- 2:08two people to murder her husband, though she wound up being acquitted at her
- 2:13trial. She also had issues with crack cocaine and had been arrested a few
- 2:16times for sex work, but they just could not find any real connection between
- 2:21her and Lester Garnie, even though she had been living in California during the
- 2:24nineteen eighties. After she finished serving a sense for violating her probation, she
- 2:30was deported back to her native Scotland, but investigators declined to file charges against
- 2:35her because even though her fingerprint was found on the windshield, they just cannot
- 2:38figure out a motive. They couldn't actually prove that she was the one who
- 2:43pulled the trigger which killed Lester, So as of right now, she's believed
- 2:46to still be in Europe somewhere, and this case has remained unsolved for over
- 2:51thirty five years now. During the intro to our last episode, I mentioned
- 2:54that when I first covered this case on the Trail Went Cold five years ago,
- 2:59the whole thing turned out to be a much bigger rabbit hole than expected,
- 3:01and I believe it's one of the more underrated cases featured on Unsolved Mysteries.
- 3:07I hate to say this, but I think the main reason the Unsolved
- 3:09Mystery segment never really stuck with me for a long time is because, well,
- 3:14it's a tad cheesy. Instead of their usual creepy music score over the
- 3:17reenactments, the segment plays saxophone music, which often makes this feel like one
- 3:23of those erotic late night movies you'd watch on cinemax during the eighties and nineties
- 3:28rather than an unsolved mysteries episode, But that's a minor nitpick. Lester's murder
- 3:32got quite a bit of media coverage in the Bay Area, and for two
- 3:36decades there was a lot of speculation that his death was the result of a
- 3:39cover up and he was killed because he had stumbled onto something big involving corrupt
- 3:44cops and city officials. But after it was announced that the sole piece of
- 3:47physical evidence from the murder scene was linked to this Scottish national, Catherine Koons,
- 3:53it just through the whole case for a loop. We know that Coons
- 3:57lived in Concord at the time the murder took place, was involved in drugs
- 4:00and sex work, but other than that, there's just nothing to connect her
- 4:04to Lester Garnier. She later became embroiled in an unrelated murder for higher plot
- 4:10involving her husband, but that crime sounded more personal in nature and a far
- 4:15cry from killing a police officer. The only thing we know for certain is
- 4:18that Koot somehow had to be involved in Lester's murder, because I can't think
- 4:23of an innocent explanation for why her fingerprint would be on the window of his
- 4:27corvette, but it's still unclear if she was the one who personally pulled the
- 4:30trigger and shot Lester, as there's a lot to suggest that she wasn't alone
- 4:34on this. Since Lester was an undercover vice officer and Kootz was a sex
- 4:40worker during this time period, the most logical explanation would seem to be that
- 4:44he was shot to death while attempting a bus which went horribly wrong. However,
- 4:48the whole thing seems a lot more complicated than that. I would think
- 4:53that if Koontz was involved in a sex working group, if she was a
- 4:58part of a brothel that he had busted, or if he had been part
- 5:00of a group of women that had been busted by him, that one of
- 5:04those women. Remember, he was known by the women he arrested as being
- 5:09kind and charming and very respectful, and had actually been praised for the fact
- 5:15that citizens and those he arrested did not complain about him, they actually praised
- 5:18him. I feel like someone if they were aware of her actions or whoever
- 5:25did kill Lester, I feel like that community you still might have had somebody
- 5:30come forward and share information had it been something that they were aware of right
- 5:34if it was someone within their group that had murdered him in revenge, because
- 5:39there was a love of him, in respect for him, in his position,
- 5:43even amongst those he was getting in trouble just to play devil's advocate.
- 5:47It is possible that maybe she was giving information to him at an earlier time
- 5:55and she leaned over and touched that window, because like DNA, unless that
- 5:59fingerprint is literally in blood, you don't know when it was put there.
- 6:02We don't know how frequently he washed his vehicle, And just because there was
- 6:06a blonde woman who resembled her doesn't mean that it was necessarily Coons. It
- 6:11could have been another blonde woman who had a similar description. We know how
- 6:15problematic eyewitness identification is. That's not to say that it was innocent, but
- 6:19it's to say that there's a potential that it could be. Oh, there
- 6:24absolutely is a potential that could be. It makes sense when you talk about
- 6:27it's on the top of his car. It's almost as if you pulled up
- 6:30you said, hey, Coons, get over here, and she goes,
- 6:31yeah, what do you want, Lester, And she like leans over and
- 6:33she's talking to him, and then he gets any information he wants from her
- 6:36and he drives off. That's an easy explanation for why her fingerprint could be
- 6:41there. Also, she could have been standing there and killed him or been
- 6:46with someone else who killed him. So it's either or. Yes, she
- 6:49could have been there, but there's no way with just that fingerprint, like
- 6:54you said you was, it wasn't a fingerprint in blood, So we don't
- 6:58know when that was placed there. We just know she was in contact with
- 7:00him at some point. And that's the thing is, she was never considered
- 7:05to be a suspect until the fingerprint match. I've seen nothing to indicate that
- 7:10they got her name at all during the original investigation. And like you said,
- 7:14Lester was a very well liked person among all the local sex workers.
- 7:18And you think that if anyone had any information about how this other woman named
- 7:23Catherine Koontz had a grudge or a vendetta against him, that one of these
- 7:27people would have told the police. But it doesn't sound like her name was
- 7:30brought up at all until they got the fingerprint match. But before we delve
- 7:34into this case any further, we have to discuss Lester himself. During our
- 7:40research, we've read nothing but glowing things about Lester as both a police officer
- 7:45and as a person, and it seems like no one had a bad word
- 7:48to say about him. He was a very devoted son who moved his parents
- 7:53in with him once he got the money to purchase a nice house. He
- 7:57was apparently so likable that many of the sex workers year rested couldn't even bring
- 8:01themselves to hate him. Lester's record during his eight year police career seems spotless,
- 8:07and it doesn't sound like the investigation into his death was able to uncover
- 8:11anything suspicious in his background. Given that he was a police officer who had
- 8:16his own house, swimming pool, and corvette, and was also using a
- 8:20car phone during an era where that type of thing was in common, it
- 8:24would be tempting to believe that Lester had to be involved in something dirty,
- 8:28but he was apparently able to afford all that stuff on his own by working
- 8:31multiple jobs. I know they found evidence that Lester may have been frequenting massage
- 8:37parlors in his off hours, but that's hardly damning, and again, he
- 8:41may have simply been checking out these places as research for a future undercover job.
- 8:46So it is compelling to brainstorm a scenario where Lester is the ultimate straight
- 8:50arrow crop who's attempting to fight back against corruption in his department, but gets
- 8:56in way over his head and winds up being killed for it. At the
- 9:00outset, the Walnut Creek Police Department apparently had these same thoughts, which is
- 9:05why they did not want the San Francisco PD assisting them with their investigation into
- 9:09the murder, given that one of their own was killed. Some members of
- 9:13the SFPD believe the higher apps could have pushed much harder to resolve these jurisdictional
- 9:18issues and get them involved in the investigation, which is why they couldn't help,
- 9:22but speculate that someone in power didn't want the crime to be solved.
- 9:28This isn't meant to tear apart the job the Walnut Creek PD did on the
- 9:31case, as they didn't have a lot of evidence to work with and probably
- 9:35did the best they could given the circumstances. But Walnut Creek was an affluent
- 9:39city which usually only had to deal with an average of one murder per year
- 9:43at that time, and the SFPD had some seasoned homicide investigators who might have
- 9:50been able to contribute something. I definitely think it's valid the concerns that Walnut
- 9:54Creek PD had. You have a vice officer who is part of of an
- 10:00organization that just brought down some pretty nefarious acts that included other fellow police officers.
- 10:07Every police department has the bad eggs, just like any other career does.
- 10:13And so when you're talking about an officer who's involved in the high profile
- 10:18cases that he's doing undercover work that he's possibly contributed to busts that involve fellow
- 10:24officers, I can see the weariness of the Walnut Police Department, Walnut Creek
- 10:28Police Department, But if they thought at all they were over their head,
- 10:33you have to reach out for other resources. I don't know what else they
- 10:39could have helped with. I think it is powerful to say, what did
- 10:41we know at the time. You had an eyewitness who was a carpet layer
- 10:45who several days after the Fourth of July says, I didn't pay attention to
- 10:48these loud noises because I figured it was just fireworks. Well, he didn't
- 10:52get a very good look. He saw two blonde women, and unfortunately that
- 10:58is a very large percentage of the population being blonde women in their twenties and
- 11:03thirties. He wasn't able to provide much detail the cars, very very basic
- 11:09descriptions that he was able to give. And so because of that, like
- 11:13you said, what else was there to know at the time? Are we
- 11:16missing surveillance cameras? Were those available back in the late eighties in that area?
- 11:22Are we missing information from other eyewitnesses that were simply never asked and might
- 11:28not have known what they saw? So, yes, there could have been
- 11:30things that were missed, But this is one of those cases where there's a
- 11:33massive question mark of we just don't have much of anything to go on.
- 11:39As you know, Lestern's murder came on the heels of major bust of a
- 11:43brothel housing a teenage sex trafficking ring, which led to the indictment of several
- 11:48people, including SFPD officer Patrick Miyagishima and political figure Roger Boas. However,
- 11:54they found nothing to tie these two events together, and I'm inclined to think
- 11:58they're not related. If Lester played a significant role in the sting operation and
- 12:03personally arrested some of the people involved, that would be one thing, But
- 12:07it doesn't sound like his role was anything more than performing a stakeout on the
- 12:09brothel on a couple of occasions. At best, Lester was a pretty minor
- 12:15figure in this investigation, and I don't see why anyone would specifically target him
- 12:18for retribution. I know that Lester's partner, Chuck Lofgren, thought their cover
- 12:24was blown during their surveillance in the brothel, but if that's the case,
- 12:28why would they kill Lester and not Chuck. What would be the point of
- 12:31killing a vice cop who really didn't do anything more than watch some buildings for
- 12:35a few days. It is interesting that the head of this sex trafficking ring,
- 12:39Patrick Roberts, was apprehended in Oklahoma, only one day before Lester was
- 12:45killed, but I think that's probably nothing more than the coincidence. And as
- 12:48for Patrick Miyakishima, there really is no evidence that he and Lester even knew
- 12:54each other, and if the closest connection between them is some unsubstantiated rumors that
- 12:58the two men once attended the same stag party together years beforehand, then that's
- 13:03pretty thin. I mean, I don't completely discount the possibility that Lester may
- 13:07have stumbled upon something on his job which put his life at risk, but
- 13:11I don't think it had anything to do with this particular case. And when
- 13:16you think about the fact that Patrick was a fellow police officer and at one
- 13:20point was a security guard in a same area where Lester worked, you have
- 13:26to remember that people who are in security and law enforcement, they tend to
- 13:30have the same schedules. They tend to really stick close to, like circles,
- 13:35and so yeah, of course they attended a similar party, they ran
- 13:37in similar social groups, and so I don't find that to be ironic.
- 13:41The one thing that really throws me for a loop is that he gets these
- 13:46calls, one of them is a female, and he cancels the plans with
- 13:50his friend, drives out and parks in a manner that's similar to the way
- 13:54that police officers are trained to park, so that you know they're not backed
- 13:58into an area where people can't see them. And he does not have either
- 14:01of his weapons with him. To me, that indicates this idea that he
- 14:07felt ultimately safe, And for someone who is a vice officer, even when
- 14:11he's off duty, I feel like there would be the heightened sense of I
- 14:15never know, I never know about people I don't know who could approach us.
- 14:18But he did not have any weapon on him. To me, that
- 14:22screamed volumes and is one of the biggest reasons that I'm saying, was he
- 14:26trying to meet up with someone involved in one of his cases, because if
- 14:30he was, I just don't think someone trained in that series about their job
- 14:33would go without a service weapon. And they said that even when he was
- 14:37off duty, he would carry one of his guns, like even if he
- 14:41was just going out to the movies or something, he would just carry it
- 14:43on them instinctually. So it makes you wonder did he just simply forget his
- 14:48gun or did he have reasons for not bringing you with them. The one
- 14:52thing which seemed to make Lester's family suspicious is that the police found a surveillance
- 14:56videotape in his home office following his death, and they've never disclosed its contents.
- 15:01Well, it is a bit odd that Lester would be keeping a tape
- 15:05like that in his house. It's possible the police kept quiet about what was
- 15:09on it because it contained sensitive information about an ongoing investigation which they did not
- 15:13want to jeopardize. This doesn't necessarily mean Lester was killed because he had secretly
- 15:18filmed something which was going to blow the lid off corruption. Of course,
- 15:22we also have the business from nineteen ninety eight, where former vice cop Vincent
- 15:26Repetto filed a lawsuit against a fellow officer who allegedly told people that Repetto had
- 15:33murdered Lester. It doesn't sound like this lead went anywhere, and it's probably
- 15:37nothing more than a bunch of smoke, since investigators never found any reason to
- 15:41consider Repetto as to be a suspect, both before and after the lawsuit.
- 15:46But even if you completely discount the idea that corrupt cops or people in power
- 15:50were responsible for Lester's murder, there's still a number of unanswered questions about how
- 15:56we wound up in the parking lot of the Wood Creek shopping Center. To
- 15:58begin with, is it possible that he had developed a friendship that someone maybe
- 16:03getting out of sex work, or maybe someone he had actually helped and had
- 16:07an affinity for. Is it possible that he was friends with someone that he
- 16:11thought, you know, we're beyond the criminal component, he was loyal to
- 16:17her in helping her recover from a lifestyle like that and was meeting up with
- 16:21her. Or are we aware that one of the phone calls from a quote
- 16:25woman. Were his parents aware that he was starting to date or talk to
- 16:30somebody, Well, we're going to talk in a few moments. How Lester
- 16:33had recently gotten over a breakup, So I'm not sure if he was involved
- 16:37in a series relationship at this point, but that is a good idea here
- 16:41that maybe it's someone where he arrested this person but he thought, well,
- 16:45I don't want to enter them into the system. I'll give them a second
- 16:48chance and maybe I'll help them get them out of this sex work before they
- 16:52have to spend time in jail. So it could be one of those things
- 16:53where he developed a close relationship with one of the people he arrested and was
- 16:57going to meet them, but for whatever reason, they just decided to kill
- 17:02him instead. I mean, it sort of makes sense because if you think
- 17:06back before there was dating apps, the way that people would often meet people
- 17:10would be at work, and if you're a vice officer, you might end
- 17:14up meeting somebody that you think, oh my gosh, they're in this lifestyle
- 17:18and what can I do to help them? And you could start off being
- 17:21friends and it could develop into something more, and it might not be something
- 17:25that he'd shared with other people in his life. So that seems completely plausible.
- 17:30Ash Leicester was off duty on the night of his death, and I
- 17:33think the fact, like we just said, that he left both of his
- 17:37guns at home discounts the possibility that he was going to Walnut Creek to perform
- 17:41a bust. This is one reason that I believe the rumors about Lester working
- 17:45on something big before he was murdered or overblown. If he was involved in
- 17:49anything which could potentially jeopardize his life, I think he'd be carrying a gun
- 17:53on him at all times for protection, regardless of whether he was on duty
- 17:57or not. Some of Lester's his fellow officers made note of the way his
- 18:02vehicle was parked across three parking spots, which is what cops sometimes do when
- 18:06they're being extra cautious and don't want to be approached from behind. But if
- 18:11he was secretly working undercover, it's still very odd that Lester would keep his
- 18:15badge in his Corvette's glove compartment but not bothered to take either of his weapons
- 18:18along. What we do know is that Lester was planning to go to the
- 18:22movies with his best friend that night, but canceled at the last minute without
- 18:26much of an explanation. Before he left his house, he received two phone
- 18:30calls, so it's reasonable to assume that one or both of these calls paved
- 18:34the way for Lester showing up in the shopping center parking lot. Now,
- 18:38Lester's father, Anthony Garnier, answered one of the calls and claimed the person
- 18:42on the phone was a woman, But I'm not so sure she would have
- 18:47been. Catherine Koontz Cootes apparently had a very noticeable Scottish accent, but I
- 18:52don't believe mister Garnier ever mentioned hearing anything like that in the caller's voice.
- 18:56However, since multiple blonde women were seen in the parking lot later that night,
- 19:00it's still possible that the female caller was involved in the murder, oh
- 19:04for sure. And you know that if the father had heard any kind of
- 19:08discernible accent, or there had been any kind of verbal lisp or anything that
- 19:14he would have reported that it would have been ingrained in his mind that this
- 19:18is that call that my son was on before he left my home and then
- 19:22he was murdered. So we know it. You know, ninety nine percent
- 19:26was not Coon's on the other end of the phone. But like you said,
- 19:30there was another blonde woman supposedly seen near his car when he was shot
- 19:37or possibly shot, and so could have easily been her, could have been
- 19:41someone else setting him up knowing that these two women would go meet him at
- 19:44the car. So and it also, I mean, who knows, Maybe
- 19:48it's unrelated, but that's very unlikely. But what could the female caller have
- 19:53said to Lester to compel him to drive to the shopping center. While Lester
- 19:57was known for being a lady and even though he hoped to possibly get married
- 20:03and have a family someday, he wasn't quite ready to settle down yet.
- 20:07Lester had actually been involved in a three year relationship with a woman which was
- 20:11described as being tumultuous. She was supposedly very possessive of Lester, so they
- 20:17broke up less than two months before he was killed. Now, this ex
- 20:21girlfriend had a pretty solid alibi, so it's very unlikely she was involved in
- 20:26the murder. But given that Lester was currently single, it does open up
- 20:30the possibility that he may have been looking for female companionship on the night that
- 20:34he was killed. Perhaps this late night rendezvous at the shopping center had nothing
- 20:38to do with Lester's police work. He was just there to meet up with
- 20:41a woman who may or may not have been a sex worker, but she
- 20:45wound up killing him instead. Of course, the issue with this theory is
- 20:49that there's no apparent motive for this crime. Lester's wallet was in the glove
- 20:53box, so robbery didn't seem to be the motive, though I suppose the
- 20:57alternative explanation is that the killer planned to rob Lester, discovered he wasn't carrying
- 21:03anything, and never bothered to check the glove compartment. Since Lester was driving
- 21:07a Corvette and parked alone in a dark lot late at night, he could
- 21:11have been an ideal target for a random perpetrator who wanted to rob him.
- 21:17But I find it odd that the only item which appeared to be missing were
- 21:19Lester's car keys. Why would the killer take the keys and leave the car
- 21:23behind, unless perhaps there was another key on that ring which the perpetrator wanted
- 21:29for some reason. Well, let me ask you this. What if they
- 21:33shoot him he was shot what twice? Yeah? Okay, so let's say
- 21:37they shoot him twice. He's maybe moaning or making noises, or they're just
- 21:41saying listen. If there's any chance this guy's gonna survive this or is going
- 21:45to be coherent. We're going to take his key so he can't drive himself
- 21:49somewhere and can't leave this location, and so basically he's going to sit in
- 21:53a simpty parking lot and die in the next few minutes. So we're out
- 21:57of here. You know. Obviously it wasn't so remote that people weren't there,
- 22:03because it's a shopping center. There's a carpet layer working, you know.
- 22:06Some of those stores had lights on, so it could have been that
- 22:08there's these two shots, they panic, they grab the keys, and they
- 22:11run, knowing that he won't be able to get help from anyone. Yeah,
- 22:17that makes sense that maybe they didn't have any interest in the car,
- 22:18but they just wanted to ensure that he wouldn't be able to drive anywhere to
- 22:22get help if he wasn't dead yet by that point. The biggest issue investigators
- 22:26have faced since matching the fingerprint to Catherine Konz is trying to figure out any
- 22:32sort of tangible connection between her and Lester. The closest like anyone could find
- 22:37was that Lester and his family often ate at a restaurant where coons briefly worked
- 22:41as a waitress, but that's pretty tenuous, you know. Coons went on
- 22:45trial in nineteen ninety one for her alleged role in a murder for higher plot
- 22:48to kill her husband, but that took place after she moved to Virginia,
- 22:52and the extent of her criminal activities while living in California are a lot more
- 22:57murky. It seems like one of the reasons Koontz developed a drug addiction was
- 23:02because she was left home alone while her naval officer husband was away at sea
- 23:06a lot of the time, and she probably turned to sex work in order
- 23:10to support her habit. Since Lester's undercover work involved posing as a customer in
- 23:15order to arrest sex workers, it's certainly possible that Kotz could have crossed paths
- 23:18with them. One prevalent theory is that Lester's murderer's retaliation for a prior bust
- 23:25he might have made, but since Kutz had no arrest record during her time
- 23:29in California, I don't think this motive would apply to her. An alternate
- 23:33explanation might be that Lester was using Kootz as an informant and she convinced him
- 23:37to meet her at the shopping center under the guise of supplying them with information,
- 23:41but for whatever reason, she wound up killing him instead. It depends
- 23:45on if this is If this is true, if this is really what happened,
- 23:48who she would have been given information about, who would have been behind
- 23:52the sting that he might have made progress on if she did give accurate information.
- 23:57Remember, if she's addicted to drugs at the time, or if she
- 24:00relies on this sex work to fund a drug habit, you can get pretty
- 24:04desperate. So if you've agreed in reward for not in reward for going to
- 24:11share information, you're not going to go to prison. You might feel very
- 24:17pressured that I have to show up and I have to give information, But
- 24:19if it comes at a cost of not having your drug addiction met or is
- 24:23going to take down the person who supplies you with drugs, does your addiction
- 24:27override that and cause you to kill the person asking you for information. It
- 24:33does make me wonder though, if she would have even had any information to
- 24:37supply, And that's why I wish we knew a lot more about her activities
- 24:41in California and if she connected with anyone while she was working on the streets
- 24:45who was dangerous. I mean, I haven't heard anything about her having a
- 24:48pimp or any handler who operated, or money and stuff like that, so
- 24:53it makes me wonder what she could have had to offer to Lester. But
- 24:56that's why I am intrigued by your theory that perhaps Lester took a shine to
- 25:00were and wanted to help her and get her out of sex work or something
- 25:03like that instead of arresting her and that, but she double crossed him by
- 25:07deciding to kill him. Of course, another issue is that in addition to
- 25:14Koons, there may have also been one, even two other women involved in
- 25:18this crime, and no one knows who they are. We have two key
- 25:22eyewitness sightings from the parking lot that night, the carpet layer who heard what
- 25:26was most likely gunshots before he saw two blond women walking towards separate vehicles and
- 25:30driving away, and the witness who drove through the lot and saw a blonde
- 25:34woman exiting Lester's corvette. But the biggest complication is figuring out the timing of
- 25:41these two sightings and how close they took place to one another. During the
- 25:45Unsolved Mystery segment, one of the investigators acknowledged that these two sightings may not
- 25:49actually be connected to each other, and it's possible that the two blonde women
- 25:55seen by the carpet layer might be two completely innocent bystanders who had no involvement
- 26:00in the crime. It's also possible that three entirely different women were involved in
- 26:04the murder, though when the carpet layer looked at the composite sketch of the
- 26:07blonde scene exiting the corvette, he thought she might be one of the same
- 26:11women he saw. However, it was dark and both witnesses saw these women
- 26:17from a distance, so I'm not sure if either of them could positively identify
- 26:22any of the women as Catherine. Coon's descriptions were also provided the two vehicles
- 26:27the blonde drove out of the parking lot, which were a blue Toyota pickup
- 26:30and a grayish white Toyota or dats in car, but it's unclear of Coons
- 26:34would have had access to vehicles of that type in nineteen eighty eight. I
- 26:38personally think it's too much of a coincidence that all these similar looking blonde women
- 26:44were seen in the parking lot of a closed shopping center late at night around
- 26:48the same time, given that her fingerprint was on the window, the blonde
- 26:52steam climbing out of the corvette was probably Coons, and the carpet layer subsequently
- 26:56saw her and an unidentified female accomplice. Well, this goes along with our
- 27:03age old theory that eyewitnesses are problematic, not because they don't have amazing intent
- 27:07and they don't you know, they're having any kind of ill intent when they're
- 27:12describing what they saw. But we see here that you have two eyewitnesses.
- 27:18They might actually have stories that don't line up and that you say, yes,
- 27:22that looks similar to who I saw. But it's very difficult to find
- 27:26distinct factors that you saw on an individual in a brief moment and then looking
- 27:32at a picture and saying, yes, this is absolutely one hundred percent the
- 27:36same person looking similar, maybe that's the right person. That does not really
- 27:41aid investigators with any kind of momentum to move forward and try to find a
- 27:45person who matches these descriptions. Even the cars weren't quite as clear as we
- 27:49needed them to be when we're asking someone to nail down exactly what kind of
- 27:53make and model they saw, And you also have to account for the fact
- 27:57that when they originally made these sightings, there would have been nothing remarkable about
- 28:02them because they didn't know that a murder had taken place. They didn't find
- 28:04Lester's body till the following morning. And just think of your average night where
- 28:10it's like you might see a blonde woman in a parking lot. There's just
- 28:11going to be nothing out of the ordinary about it. And then the following
- 28:15day here, oh, someone was killed in that same parking lot. Yes,
- 28:18I remember seeing a blonde woman there, and you may place more significance
- 28:22on it, even though it might not even be connected to the crime.
- 28:26And that's why eyewitness identification can be very unreliable. This is a little bit
- 28:30off the topic of the parking lot, but I'm just curious what both of
- 28:33you think. So with regards to Koons, we know that she had an
- 28:38active crack cocaine habit at the time, and she was engaged in sex work,
- 28:42and we know that Boas was busted. What do we think the chances
- 28:47are that those two could have been acquainted and if there was some connection between
- 28:51Coon's and Boas, and maybe Boas was like, Okay, well, if
- 28:56you do this job for me, I will pay you X amount of dollars
- 29:00or give you this amount of drugs some kind of incentive, because even if
- 29:06it was Koons, I'm just having such a hard time, like I'm struggling
- 29:08with what would be the motive exactly, Like I know they didn't find any
- 29:14connection between the drug bust, and I've gone over the points. How it's
- 29:17kind of weird that they would target Lestra because he was just kind of a
- 29:19small cog. He just did some surveillance. He didn't really orchestrate the bus
- 29:23or personally arrest anybody, so I'm not sure why he would be targeted,
- 29:27But yeah, I could definitely see someone if this was murder for higher like
- 29:32getting someone like Kootz who had addiction issues and also a sex work. So
- 29:37I personally think that like maybe Koots didn't even know who Lesterra was. He
- 29:41was just kind of a hired gun. But it's just trying to figure out
- 29:45who would want to kill Lester that has just led the investigation to a dead
- 29:48end because, like you said, Kots doesn't seem to have a motive,
- 29:52and I'm sure through the course of his term as a police officer that Lester
- 29:57may have pissed some people off who could have wanted been dead, but it
- 30:02just seemed surprising that they wouldn't have found someone like that during the course of
- 30:04the investigation. However, the potential involvement of more than one person would make
- 30:11it very difficult for the authorities to build a prosecutable case against Kuts. Even
- 30:17though an unidentified fingerprint was found on the corvette window, investigators did not actually
- 30:22submit it to the FBI for analysis until two thousand and two. They figured
- 30:26that since the print was just a partial it was of no use. While
- 30:30you could criticize this decision, keep in mind that Kots did not have a
- 30:33police record until she was arrested in Virginia in nineteen ninety one, so if
- 30:38they ran the print back in nineteen eighty eight, it wouldn't have made any
- 30:41difference. Once the fingerprint was linked to Kut's, investigators would spend six years
- 30:47thoroughly checking her background, so there was no lack of effort with trying to
- 30:51build a case against Kots and uncover additional evidence implicating her in the murder.
- 30:56There really isn't too much information out there about the murder for higher plot on
- 31:00greg Orycoots, so I really can't come to a definitive conclusion about whether or
- 31:03not Catherine was actually guilty of that crime. But man Greg must have been
- 31:08the most trusting husband in the world if he was willing to testify on behalf
- 31:14of the woman who was accused of hiring people to murder him. While it
- 31:18helped get Catherine acquitted, it didn't exactly save their marriage. Investigators were eventually
- 31:23able to track Greg down and interview him, and they came to the conclusion
- 31:26that he had no knowledge or involvement in Lester's murder. For all we know,
- 31:32Greg was probably away at sea at the time Lester was killed, and
- 31:34since he was gone from home so much, it doesn't sound like Greg had
- 31:38any insights on what sort of criminal activity his wife may have been mixed up
- 31:42in during their time in California. Poor Greg just seems completely oblivious to what's
- 31:49going on. You know. He marries this foreign national who the two accomplices
- 31:56say told them she cannot afford to lose her green cards. She cannot lose
- 32:00her ability to be here in the US. So if she could just kill
- 32:02her husband, she might have the resources and be able to manipulate a way
- 32:07to stay here in the United States and Greg's like, it's okay, she
- 32:12would never do something like this. But while the man's off serving in our
- 32:15country, she's back here. Yes, it's very difficult to be the spouse
- 32:20to a military personnel service man or woman. I'm a proud daughter of a
- 32:25marine, so I know the families also serve with their loved one. But
- 32:31here it's like he went off to see and she went, yeah, I'm
- 32:35not doing this kind of like by myself. And she went and was addicted
- 32:39to drugs, was doing sex work to fund that addiction. And I don't
- 32:44know that Greg really was aware of any of that. So he comes back
- 32:46and of course he thinks, oh, my wife would have nothing to do
- 32:50with a scheme to hurt me. She's just my sweet little wife that I
- 32:54left behind. And clearly it comes to turn out that they didn't have the
- 32:59relationship thought because they got divorced anyway. But kind of blows my mind that
- 33:04she was almost able to live these two double lives while Greg was off at
- 33:07sea. Pretty hard to hide a crack coquete addiction. You'd think that you
- 33:10would come back. And not only is she going to be physically ravaged by
- 33:15this, but I think her mental health is not going to be in the
- 33:19same place that it was when he left. It would be pretty hard to
- 33:22hide that. And although he might not have an idea of exactly what she
- 33:28was into and what criminal activity she was up to, I'm sure that he
- 33:31had to have a pretty good idea. Either that or he's in denial.
- 33:36I mean, a lot of people who are spouses of people with substance use
- 33:40disorders, you see a lot of denial. I mean I saw it when
- 33:44I was at rehab, and you'd see people who really don't want to admit
- 33:47that their loved one has an addiction, because then what does that say about
- 33:52them? And I think then they've got to redefine the relationship and define how
- 33:55they see it and themselves, and that can be an incredibly complex thing.
- 34:00So there's a lot of reasons why people can go, oh, they would
- 34:01never do that, because it is just too hard of a truth to admit
- 34:06that to oneself, that yes, she had an addiction and she tried to
- 34:09kill me. It's maybe easier for his mind at the time to just go,
- 34:14no, she would never do that because that reality is much more comfortable
- 34:17than the alternative. Since investigators made three unsuccessful attempts to convince prosecutors to file
- 34:25murder charges against Kuns. I think they just became desperate for information when they
- 34:30decided to publicly name her as a suspect in two thousand and eight and offer
- 34:35a two hundred and fifty thousand dollars reward. They probably did so out of
- 34:38fear that Coons would be deported back to Scotland following her release from prison,
- 34:43and sure enough, that's exactly what happened, as Ice is a totally different
- 34:47government jurisdiction and will not let an ongoing murder investigation halt their deportation procedures.
- 34:54You might recall an episode we released a few years ago about the nineteen eighty
- 34:59two disappearing of the Solomon family, where the prime suspect, Harvey Rader,
- 35:04was serving time in prison for an unrelated crime and facing deportation back to his
- 35:07native England once his sentence came to an end. That compelled the authorities to
- 35:13work diligently at building a case against Rader. They were able to charge him
- 35:16with the family's murders before he left the country, but the problem was that
- 35:22the case was very circumstantial, and Rader ultimately wound up being acquitted at his
- 35:25third trial. If they had done the same thing with Catherine Kon's, there's
- 35:30a good chance or trial would have had the same result and ended with her
- 35:34walking free. It might seem damning that Kons's fingerprint was found at the murder
- 35:38scene, but think about how a good defense attorney might have spound this a
- 35:43trial. While a witness did see a woman matching Koons's description emerged from Lester's
- 35:47car and looked through the driver's side window, he did not say that he
- 35:52saw her carrying a murder weapon, nor could he confirm if Lester was already
- 35:55dead by this point. Hypothetically, the defense could acknowledge the ko met or
- 36:00stumbled across Lester in the parking lot that night in order to explain away the
- 36:04fingerprint, and then claim that someone else came along and committed the murder after
- 36:07Coon's already left. I don't blame you. You don't ask a DA to
- 36:14take a case like this, or to really press for a case like this,
- 36:16when all you have is this fingerprint, and like we've talked about,
- 36:22you cannot prove when that fingerprint was left. It could have been earlier that
- 36:27afternoon. It could have been that morning, it could have been a couple
- 36:30days before. And Jules, like you said, who's to say she wasn't
- 36:34the blonde lady who was seen by an eyewitness, but the timing was a
- 36:37little bit off. And she walks away, and then someone comes up to
- 36:43this abandoned corvette in the middle of this vacant parking lot and ended up shooting
- 36:49the driver. Lester, I mean, think about it like this. Let's
- 36:52say Coon's was there, and she's trying to give information or something, and
- 36:57when she gets out of the car and walks away, perhaps she's confronted by
- 37:00her pimp or the person who's in charge of collecting money from her for sex
- 37:07work, and he says, what were you doing in that car? Do
- 37:09you get money? Give me money? And she's say no, he wouldn't
- 37:12pay me, he didn't pay me, he tricked me. And then he
- 37:15goes and kills him. I mean, there's a million things that could have
- 37:19happened where the two blonde ladies weren't Coon's or could have been Coons. Coons
- 37:23could be the killer or an accomplice, or maybe wasn't part of that crime.
- 37:29It's as a district attorney. There's no way in heck I could take
- 37:32a case like this and feel confident going to trial for two reasons, I
- 37:37don't think there's enough evidence to prove she did it, and I don't want
- 37:38to take an innocent person and put them on trial either. Yeah, definitely
- 37:44a lot of reasonable doubt. And we just talked about what happened with Harvey
- 37:46Raider and the Solomon family case, where they really wanted to put him on
- 37:50trial even without the victim's bodies being found. And now that he's been acquitted,
- 37:53you can't charge him again. That was your only shot and the case
- 37:58might remain unsolved forever. So at least they didn't do it. The same
- 38:00thing with Lester Garnier's case because there is still a chance to charge Koons again
- 38:06if new evidence should surface. And technically, even if Konz was involved,
- 38:12we really don't even know if she was the one who actually pulled the trigger.
- 38:15Remember, she later went on trial for hiring someone to murder her husband
- 38:20rather than doing it herself. So while Konz could have played a role in
- 38:22learning Lester to the parking lot, her unidentified blonde accomplice may have been the
- 38:28person who shot him. Whatever happened, the evidence just isn't strong enough at
- 38:31this point to convict Kots beyond a reasonable doubt, so I can understand why
- 38:36prosecutors are reluctant to take her to trial. Unfortunately, since Kons is now
- 38:40back in the United Kingdom, it might be more difficult to track her down
- 38:44should new evidence against her surface. But even with the fingerprint evidence, the
- 38:49one thing nobody seems to have figured out after all this time is motive.
- 38:53Like I mentioned earlier, investigators spent six years delving into Kunz's background and never
- 38:59found any tangible link between her and Lester. I know I've already expressed my
- 39:04skepticism about the murder being some massive conspiracy orchestrated by corrupt cops. But even
- 39:08if it was, how would Koonts have become involved. It sounds like the
- 39:13extent of her criminal activity in California was turning tricks to support her drug habit,
- 39:17But how would that escalate it to the murder of a police officer.
- 39:22If someone wanted Lester dead, why would they hire Kots to do it.
- 39:25What's strange to me is that, even though Kotz doesn't strike me as a
- 39:29master criminal, This was a professionally done murder with almost no evidence left behind.
- 39:35If it wasn't for the partial fingerprint, no one would have ever suspected
- 39:38Konz and this would essentially be the perfect crime. I just have a feeling
- 39:44that if there was a massive cover up involving powerful people, Catherine Koontz is
- 39:47not the type of person who would have been selected to pull off this task.
- 39:52No, not at all. And you have multiple people who are there.
- 39:55It's very difficult to have everyone involved in a crime to to keep their
- 40:00mouth shut. There were large, large, large rewards offered for information in
- 40:05this case. So to think that this kind of low level criminal is going
- 40:10to orchestrate the murder of a police officer with other people and not have someone
- 40:16snitch on her. She's not going to have someone turn on her. She's
- 40:20not going to make a mistake and leave incriminating evidence. It seems far fetched
- 40:24to me. It's not impossible, but it seems more difficult than thinking that
- 40:30there could have been something else nefarious going on with someone that maybe he had
- 40:34busted for a crime, or if you think about too, like you said,
- 40:37he is in this parking lot, sitting there, waiting on somebody who
- 40:43I believe called his home and lured him away from the movies. Was his
- 40:47ex girlfriend cleared? She clearly had an alibi for where she was correct she
- 40:52did, yes, And I don't think they found any evidence that this was
- 40:55a murder for hire. So she's never been considered a suspect in the crime
- 41:00because I would know she was really frustrated about their breakup and there was some
- 41:02resentment and anger there. But yeah, there's just too many options and such
- 41:07little information here to say, Okay, let's take this one fingerprint and run
- 41:13with it. As this is our suspect, it's time to make a case
- 41:15against her. All that being said, I don't rule out the idea that
- 41:21someone did hire Coons to commit this murder, but the crime was a lot
- 41:24more personal in nature. One thing we know for certain is that Lester received
- 41:29a call from a woman shortly before leaving his house, and multiple women were
- 41:32seen in the parking lot at the time he was killed. I know that
- 41:36investigators couldn't find any tangible link between Lester and Koons, but what if another
- 41:40woman in either Lester's personal or professional life hired Koons to kill him? Well,
- 41:45there's no record of Lester, ever, having arrested Coons, who's to
- 41:50say that another sex worker he busted didn't want revenge. Sure, some of
- 41:53the women Lester arrested spoke highly of him, but it's safe to say that
- 41:58not all of them would have been overly thrilled about the idea of going to
- 42:01jail. But it is also possible the crime had no connection to Lester's work
- 42:06as a vice officer, and someone wanted him dead for other reasons. Lester
- 42:10was known as a ladies man, he had recently broken up with his longtime
- 42:14girlfriend, and he was apparently frequenting massage parlors in his spare time. He
- 42:19very well could have gotten involved with another woman who, for unknown reasons,
- 42:22decided to kill him. No one knows what was said to Lester during his
- 42:27final phone conversation at home, but it seemed to compel him to break off
- 42:30plans to see a movie with his friend, and the fact that Lester left
- 42:35his house without his guns leads me to believe that he drove to the Wood
- 42:38Creek shopping center for something which had nothing to do with his police work.
- 42:43Even if Lester did not personally know Catherine Kons, the individual who wanted him
- 42:47dead, could have set things up for coons to kill him in the parking
- 42:51lot. I have a deep suspicion that whoever he was going to meet was
- 42:55someone that he really did have a close connection with. I don't think it
- 43:00was an informant. I don't think that it's somebody that he knows had a
- 43:04kind of criminal background, because he was a smart, efficient, responsible law
- 43:09enforcement officer. He always carried his service weapon and he intentionally didn't. Yes,
- 43:15he didn't tell people where he was going. But is it something like
- 43:17what Jules said, like this is a new kind of exploratory hangout date with
- 43:22a girl that he might be trying to date. Is this something else he
- 43:27wants to meet about for a business opportunity? Like what is it that he
- 43:30was so safe in that trip that he didn't feel a need to tell anybody
- 43:35where he was going and he didn't bring his service weapons. Safe enough that
- 43:39you don't bring your surface weapon, but not familiar enough or long standing enough
- 43:45that you feel like you can disclose to your best friend who you're meeting or
- 43:51why you're canceling your movie plans. I just think that it has to be
- 43:54somebody that he felt comfortable with Either that, or it was an oversight that
- 43:59he forgot his weapon, But it just doesn't sound like he would make a
- 44:01mistake like that since he always seemed to carry at least one of his guns.
- 44:06It seems more likely that he was disarmed by the individual. Either they
- 44:09did have some sort of relationship, or somehow he was manipulated into believing that
- 44:15they weren't a threat. If you're wondering why Koontz would have gotten involved in
- 44:21this, it seems like the main reason she turned to sex work to begin
- 44:23with was to support a drug habit. We also know that Koontz and her
- 44:28husband filed for bankruptcy the following year, so things were not good for her
- 44:30financially. If she really was desperate enough for money, Koontz might have agreed
- 44:36to perform this murder for someone, even if she had no personal issues with
- 44:38Lester. If this is what happened, I can't help but wonder if it
- 44:43may have inspired Koontz when she orchestrated a plot to murder her own husband three
- 44:46years later, as she supposedly hired Melinda Cooper, a seventeen year old runaway
- 44:52she had taken under her wing, to perform the job. Who's to say
- 44:54the situation wasn't reversed, and Kountz was in Melinda Cooper's role once someone else
- 45:00hired her to kill Lester, but this time the plan worked pretty well since
- 45:05Coons didn't even pop up on the radar as a suspect for several years,
- 45:07and whoever orchestrated the whole thing has never been identified, so in the end,
- 45:13I definitely think this was a murder for higher plot, but one in
- 45:15which investigators originally looked in the wrong direction. The plot had nothing to do
- 45:21with a major scandal involving the teenage sex trafficking ring, and Lester was murdered
- 45:25for personal reasons. I have no idea where Catherine Coons is today, as
- 45:30the investigation once again hit a standstill after she was deported, But the authorities
- 45:35are still trying to solve the case and seem to think that there's just one
- 45:38or two crucial pieces of the puzzle missing which can tie everything together. It's
- 45:44tragic enough when a police officer is killed in the line of duty, but
- 45:47here we have a very well respected cop being murdered in cold blooded fashion while
- 45:52he was off duty, and no one can understand why. Remember there is
- 45:55still a two hundred and fifty thousand dollars reward being offered for information which leads
- 46:00to the arrest and prosecution of the responsible party. So if you happen to
- 46:04have any information on the murder of Lester Gaargnier, please contact the appropriate authorities.
- 46:09Jules Ashley any final thoughts on the case. I have to go back
- 46:14to the type of person Lester was. Just to start with, there's not
- 46:20a single person that can do a single act other than putting your love when
- 46:23at risk or something that warrants murdering somebody. So but then you look at
- 46:29Lester and you're like, Okay, this is a man who not only avoided
- 46:34his own criminal lifestyle and unethical behavior, but he was actually a law enforcement
- 46:39agent on a vice squad, who was trying to clean up the community,
- 46:45to help people get out of a life of sex work, in human trafficking
- 46:49and drugs and all of these things right to make sure his community is safer.
- 46:52And not only that, but through that job, he was getting opportunities
- 46:58to help his parents by allowing them to live with him in this nice new
- 47:01home he had gotten. He was making plans for a retirement about ten years
- 47:07later, where he was going to have other businesses, such as a hot
- 47:10dog stand in franchise that he was starting with his best friend. He was
- 47:15a dreamer, He was somebody dedicated to a beautiful, successful life with his
- 47:22family, and it was completely cut short, just with no warning. Like
- 47:27we talked about throughout this whole case, it really wasn't like Lester was deeply
- 47:30involved in the apprehension of big time criminals and political figures and things like that.
- 47:37The case we keep referring to, he was doing surveillance, so he
- 47:40wasn't even the big takedown officer. It seems to me that Lester had formed
- 47:47a trust with somebody who didn't actually earn it, and that had manipulated him
- 47:53and used his kindness in his charm against him, making him feel safe enough
- 47:59to leave his house to meet without his service weapon in a place where there
- 48:04weren't going to be that many people around, and they stole his life away
- 48:07from him, and in turn, they stole a lot of people's dreams.
- 48:10His best friend was waiting for him to get paperwork for their new hot dog
- 48:15vending business the morning that he was killed. He was standing there waiting for
- 48:20him to meet him so they could go sign paperwork together. His parents lost
- 48:23their son. You know, who knows what his life would have turned into.
- 48:28And so it's such a sad case. And what's frustrating is if you're
- 48:32going to say a single fingerprint kind of locks down who our main suspect is,
- 48:37I just don't think we can go that route. I think it gives
- 48:40us a lead and a suspect, but I think there is almost a end
- 48:46listless of suspects while having no names on that list. At the same time,
- 48:52Lester had everything going for him. You know, he was thirty years
- 48:55old, he's recently single, he has this really good job at the end
- 49:00SETPD like Ash just said, he wanted to open this hot dog stand with
- 49:04his best friend and maybe franchise it out or expand and have a hot dog
- 49:07empire, and that sounds really exciting. Like we know how popular food trucks
- 49:12are now. That would have been kind of the food truck infancy that it
- 49:15started with hot dogs, and he had this plan, like his future seemed
- 49:19like it was going to be really solid. His parents had moved in,
- 49:22and it really breaks my heart for his parents because it sounds like they were
- 49:27of like a lower socioeconomic status and he brought them up to this nicer home,
- 49:31and then you have to wonder what became of this home and what became
- 49:35of the support of the parents after Lester's death. It just it makes me
- 49:38really sad because they likely were just so proud of their son, everything that
- 49:43he'd accomplished, and then to have him stolen from them, and not to
- 49:46understand who took him and why, and even if it was Catherine Koon's,
- 49:52there is a possibility or potential that it was Katherine Kuon's, but since there
- 49:55was multiple women there, it could have been one of the other women who
- 49:59was Ashley said he could have developed some kind of relationship with and she had
- 50:04disarmed him, because for him to cancel movie plans with the best friend.
- 50:07I'm just more inclined to believe that because he didn't bring his service weapon,
- 50:12that it might have been romantic in nature. Of course, that is a
- 50:15bit of an assumption, but I think we know that he always carried one
- 50:19gun with him and he didn't have that, so I think we can deduce
- 50:22from that that he didn't feel threatened at this point. It just feels like
- 50:27we need a little bit more information for authorities to be able to charge Koons
- 50:31and whomever she was with, you know, potentially three women involved. It's
- 50:37just so frustrating because all the information is kind of tenuous, as are the
- 50:40connections, and we cannot pinpoint, as we've said throughout, when that fingerprint
- 50:45was there. It could have been three blonde women. It may not have
- 50:49even been Kons. Koons could have been there at an earlier time, and
- 50:52then her fingerprint was dusted and they assumed that it was one of the women
- 50:55who were there, but she could have resembled the composite skein that one of
- 51:00the witnesses had drawn up. So it's just so hard to say. I
- 51:04can understand why they didn't go ahead with charging Coons because there just isn't sufficient
- 51:08evidence at this time. But I hope moving forward that somebody comes forward and
- 51:14shares this information with law enforcement. Yeah. I remember watching this on Unsolved
- 51:19Mysteries when it originally aired. It was pretty perplexed by it. But my
- 51:22initial thoughts that this had to be some sort of cover up or conspiracy,
- 51:27and that maybe it had something to do with Lester's police work and that someone
- 51:30in power wanted to have him killed. And then twenty years later I learned
- 51:34about this lead involving this woman named Catherine Kootz, and I'm like, how
- 51:37does she fit into this? How does this Scottish woman with no real connection
- 51:40to Lester? Why is her fingerprint at the scene, What motive would she
- 51:45have to kill Lester? And it just left me more confused. I mean,
- 51:49it is just such a sad story because I remember when I first heard
- 51:52that Lester was doing stuff like driving a Corvette and buying a new house and
- 51:55getting a new swimming pool. I was thinking, Okay, he has to
- 51:59be on the tape if a police officer is able to spend this much money.
- 52:02But they looked into Lester's background, it sounds like he was completely clean
- 52:07and just planning for his future and trying to give his parents a better life
- 52:10before it was stolen from him for reasons that we still don't understand. I
- 52:15mean, given Catherine Kreutz's other criminal history, the fact that she allegedly tried
- 52:20to kill her husband, I am inclined to believe that she is somehow involved
- 52:23in this murder and that she may have been the one who pulled the trigger
- 52:27and may have left her print on the car window while she was killing Lester,
- 52:31but we just don't know for sure. There's some evidence, but just
- 52:36not enough pieces of the puzzle in place to put everything together. Because we
- 52:40have another blonde woman scene at the scene, we have no motive, and
- 52:45it's just so confusing, and they just never found anything on Lester's background to
- 52:49give any insight on why anyone would want to have him killed. So that's
- 52:52just why I hope because they are still offering a two hundred and fifty thousand
- 52:57dollars reward for information, that someone will come forward who knows something, who
- 53:00knows why Lester was killed, and offer maybe just that final piece of the
- 53:06puzzle that will allow them to solve this case and make an arrest. But
- 53:09until then, it will still continue to perplex me because we know some of
- 53:14the pieces, some of the ideas of what might happen, but we just
- 53:16don't know the full picture, and that's what's just so frustrating. Robin,
- 53:22do you want to tell us a little bit about the Trail Went Cold Patreon?
- 53:25Yes, the Trail Cold Patreon has been around for three years now,
- 53:29and we offer these standard bonus features like early ad free episodes, and I
- 53:34also send out stickers and sign thank you cards to anyone who signs up with
- 53:37us on Patreon if you join our five dollars tier Tier two. We also
- 53:43offer monthly bonus episodes in which I talk about cases which are not featured on
- 53:47the Trail went Cold's original feed, so they're exclusive to Patreon, and if
- 53:52you join our highest tier tier free, the ten dollar tier. One of
- 53:55the features we offer is a audio commentary track over class episodes of Unsaved Mysteries,
- 54:01where you can download an audio file and then boot up the original Unsolved
- 54:06Mysteries episode on Amazon Prime or YouTube and play it with my audio commentary playing
- 54:10in the background, where I just provide trivia and factoids about the cases featured
- 54:15in this episode. And incidentally, the very first episode that I did a
- 54:19commentary track over was the episode featuring this case. So if you want to
- 54:23download a commentary track in which I make more smart ass remarks about Jewel Kaylor,
- 54:28then be sure to join Tier three. So I want to let you
- 54:30know a little bit about the Jeweles and Nashty patreons. So there's early ad
- 54:35free episodes of the Path Went Chili. We've got our Path Went Chili mini's,
- 54:38which are always over an hour, so they're not very many, but
- 54:42they're just too short to turn into a series, and we're really enjoying doing
- 54:45those, so we hope you'll check out those patreons. We'll link them in
- 54:49the show notes. So I want to thank you all for listening, and
- 54:52any chance you have to share us on social media with a friend or d
- 54:55rate and review is greatly appreciate it. You can email us at the path
- 54:59Went ChIL at gmail dot com. You can reach us on Twitter at the
- 55:02Pathwin. So until next time, be sure to bundle up because cold trails
- 55:07and chili pass call for warm clothing. Music by Paul Rich from the podcast
- 55:10Cold Callers Comedy