Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Evidence Code § 801.1: Holding Defense Experts to the Same Causation Standard
Transcript
- 0:03I'm Philip Vondra, chair of Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:06Association's personal injury law section. I
- 0:09am delighted to introduce our speakers, Robert
- 0:11Glassman and Joseph O 'Hanlon. Robert Glassman
- 0:15is a trial attorney at and partner at Panache
- 0:18Raviputi where he represents plaintiffs in large
- 0:22complex civil litigation and is widely recognized
- 0:25for securing landmark multi -million dollar verdicts
- 0:29that have driven meaningful safety reforms in
- 0:31both public and private sectors. A leader of
- 0:34influence thriving in their 40s through the Los
- 0:37Angeles Business Journal and a daily journal
- 0:40top 40 lawyer under 40, he has obtained numerous
- 0:44seven and eight figure jury verdicts as lead
- 0:46counsel earning membership in the American Board
- 0:49of Trial Advocates. Mr. Glassman is a three -time
- 0:53Consumer Attorneys of California Consumer Attorney
- 0:56of the Year finalist. a 2023 California lawyer
- 1:00attorney of the year recipient, and an adjunct
- 1:03professor and trustee at Southwestern Law School.
- 1:07Joe Ohanlin is a... an attorney at Panache Raviputi,
- 1:12where he focuses his practice on catastrophic
- 1:14personal injury and wrongful death matters throughout
- 1:17California. A graduate of Southwestern Law School,
- 1:21he distinguished himself as Chair of the Board
- 1:24of the Trial Advocacy Honors Program and earned
- 1:28multiple honors, including the Cali Excellence
- 1:31for the Future Award and the Blue Book Award.
- 1:34Mr. O 'Hanlon is an active member of leading
- 1:38plaintiff side bar organizations and serves on
- 1:40the board of Southwestern Law School's Nickel
- 1:43Club, reflecting his continued commitment to
- 1:46advocacy, mentorship, and professional leadership.
- 1:51And now let's get started. Thanks for that kind
- 1:55introduction, Phil. We're happy to be here. Joe
- 2:00go ahead goes ahead and get started with the
- 2:02actual presentation I just want to make a quick
- 2:05introductory note about kind of why we decided
- 2:09to do this in the first place You know as practicing
- 2:13lawyers we're in court a lot we respond to pleadings
- 2:20a lot we file pleadings in court we're doing
- 2:24a lot with discovery and Something like this
- 2:31presentation talking about an evidence code section
- 2:35801 .1 We weren't just sitting around in our
- 2:38office one day thinking, you know, this would
- 2:40be a good topic to talk to folks about this is
- 2:45something that came up in one of our cases and
- 2:49we had to litigate this issue and we're going
- 2:52to talk about that during the presentation, but
- 2:55you know, we thought after the issue became something
- 3:01that was important in our case, we thought it
- 3:04was a good idea to kind of spread the wealth
- 3:06and tell others about how we used it to our advantage,
- 3:12you know, for our client to win the case, but
- 3:15also because it's kind of a relatively new part
- 3:19of the California Evidence Code, we thought it
- 3:21was a good idea to share it all with you. So
- 3:23that's kind of what all of these things are about.
- 3:26It's about education and it's about taking what
- 3:30we learned in practice and sharing it with others.
- 3:36You can't really get a grasp of these things
- 3:39in the abstract. It's not until you actually
- 3:42deal with it in real life, in a case, where you
- 3:46understand the importance of it. So that's just
- 3:50something that we think about all the time when
- 3:52we're working on cases. Is this a concept? Is
- 3:54this an issue that's worth talking about with
- 3:58others, with other lawyers? And that's why we
- 4:00decided to do this today. Perfect. Thank you
- 4:04for that, Rob. I couldn't agree more. And as
- 4:06Rob mentioned, we are going to be exploring that
- 4:08case that sort of gave rise to us really understanding
- 4:11and appreciating this new code section. Without
- 4:15further ado, let's get it rolling. So as you
- 4:18can see by the title page here, we're going to
- 4:20give a presentation on evidence code section
- 4:23801 .1, which, as we will learn, sort of levels
- 4:27the playing field for the admissibility of expert
- 4:30medical causation opinions on the plaintiff's
- 4:34side and on the defense side. Philip did a great
- 4:39job of introducing us, and so we can just breeze
- 4:41right past this slide, but My name is Joe. I'm
- 4:44an attorney at Panish, Shayarabaputi, clerked
- 4:47at the firm during law school, graduated law
- 4:49school in 2024. I work for Rob, who's a partner
- 4:53here. So a brief agenda for this morning's presentation.
- 5:03We're first going to talk about the pre -evidence
- 5:06code section 801 .1 environment. What sort of
- 5:11medical causation opinions were admissible on
- 5:13the plaintiff's side versus the defense side,
- 5:16and that disparity there that existed. And then
- 5:19we're going to give you a working definition
- 5:22of the evidence code section itself. As Rob mentioned,
- 5:26we're going to walk through a real -life case
- 5:28example. We'll go through some takeaways and
- 5:31then, of course, we'll have time to answer any
- 5:34questions at the end and then if we do have time
- 5:37Robert and I are also going to walk through a
- 5:40little bit of tips and tricks for how to properly
- 5:43research opposing experts before deposing them
- 5:47because this sort of falls into the same category
- 5:49of expert discovery. So let's get into the environment
- 5:56that existed before evidence code section 801
- 6:00.1. plaintiffs retained experts had to offer
- 6:04their medical causation opinions to a reasonable
- 6:07medical probability. In other words, if a plaintiff's
- 6:11medical expert wanted to say, for example, that
- 6:14a client's back pain was a result of a particular
- 6:17car accident, they had to state their medical
- 6:20reputation on that opinion. They would have to
- 6:23say, based on my background training and experience,
- 6:26more likely than not, this car crash caused these
- 6:30symptoms. But on the defense side, before evidence
- 6:35code section 801 .1, an expert could say, for
- 6:39example, well, the plaintiff's cognitive symptoms
- 6:42could be related to a possible learning disability
- 6:45that was mentioned one time in her educational
- 6:48records, but was never actually diagnosed, not
- 6:51this thing that we're here to litigate. And they
- 6:55essentially could... testified to mere possibilities
- 6:58and not true medical causation. And that level
- 7:03of probability was often enough for the defense
- 7:06side to get that opinion in front of a jury.
- 7:12So what was the practical effect of what really
- 7:17was a double standard? I think she sort of sums
- 7:21it up there. That's a great meme, Joe. Great
- 7:24meme. Thank you. You know, it's a boring topic.
- 7:26You got to light it up just a little bit. Trying
- 7:28to keep it interesting here. So the practical
- 7:35effect, again, is that plaintiffs, medical experts
- 7:38were held to a much higher standard. But for
- 7:43jurors, a juror could see this double board certified
- 7:47doctor for the defense with this incredible CV.
- 7:51really give what amounts to a speculative causation
- 7:55opinion, but because that doctor was so credentialed,
- 7:59really take that opinion to heart perhaps more
- 8:02than they should. And the rationale for this
- 8:06double standard was that while a plaintiff in
- 8:08a case of course has the burden of proof, they
- 8:10actually have to prove causation, whereas of
- 8:13course the defense has no such burden. And so
- 8:17this double standard was sort of understood.
- 8:20for decades. It was something that was reinforced
- 8:24time and time again at the trial court level
- 8:26until 2022 when Klein versus Zimmer was published.
- 8:33Let me just say something too, Joe. I mean, like
- 8:36it should be the case that the plaintiff has
- 8:38the burden. You know, we're bringing the case.
- 8:41It's our obligation to prove every element of
- 8:43our case. That's the way it should be. And obviously,
- 8:46that's the way it was. That's the way it still
- 8:49is. But what was going on here was, you know,
- 8:53we would put forward an expert who would give
- 8:55his or her opinion about causation, and rightfully,
- 9:00that expert should be held to a standard in order
- 9:04to get that opinion in, and that was what's,
- 9:08you know, reasonably like, you know, reasonable
- 9:11probability. That's the standard. And the defense,
- 9:17you know, they shouldn't have the standard. They
- 9:19shouldn't have a burden because they're defending
- 9:23the case. They're not bringing it. And so if
- 9:25they were just to argue in this pre -801 .1 environment,
- 9:30hey, look, plaintiff didn't prove their case.
- 9:33There's no competent evidence that this incident
- 9:36caused this issue. That's totally fine. They
- 9:41don't need to prove anything. all they have to
- 9:44say is plaintiff didn't meet his burden. But
- 9:48it's a little bit different when the defense
- 9:50was saying, hey, not only did the plaintiff not
- 9:54prove his burden, but we actually think that
- 9:58this other thing that happened either before
- 10:01or after the subject incident is the reason why
- 10:05plaintiff is now experiencing the symptoms that
- 10:08he is. So that's they're going kind of Beyond
- 10:12just the hey plaintiff didn't prove his case.
- 10:14They're saying plaintiff didn't prove their case,
- 10:17but there's also another reason why plaintiff
- 10:21is experiencing what's he's experiencing and
- 10:24that's the thing that You know 801 .1 came along
- 10:29and said if you're gonna do that if you're gonna
- 10:32put forward another hypothesis or another reason
- 10:36why plaintiff is experiencing what he is then
- 10:41you should be held to the same standard and burden
- 10:43that the plaintiffs experts are too. You can't
- 10:46just say, you can't just pluck things out of
- 10:49thin air and say, oh, this is the reason why
- 10:51this is happening. There has to be some kind
- 10:53of, you know, standard that the expert is held
- 10:58to in order to give such an opinion. Exactly.
- 11:03And so this double standard persisted for quite
- 11:07a while, just sort of informally. There was no
- 11:09real case law on it until Klein versus Zimmer
- 11:13in 2022, which was a personal injury case that
- 11:17involved a defective hip replacement. So it was
- 11:21a product liability personal injury case. And
- 11:25the trial court here sort of went against the
- 11:27grain against what most trial courts were doing
- 11:31at the time and actually excluded one of the
- 11:35defendant's experts opinions that was not stated
- 11:38to a reasonable medical probability. And then
- 11:42the Court of Appeals remanded for a new trial.
- 11:44And then you can see in this quote here, they
- 11:49formalize that double standard. The court says
- 11:52the reasonable medical probability requirement
- 11:55applies only to the party bearing the burden
- 11:58of proof on the issue, which is the subject of
- 12:01the opinion. So it becomes law at this point.
- 12:09In response, the CAOC successfully sponsored
- 12:14a bill which became evidence code section 801
- 12:18.1 and it was enacted on January 1st, 2024. So
- 12:24here's the important part of the code section.
- 12:27That bolded part basically says that now even
- 12:31the party not bearing the burden of proof, if
- 12:34they want to offer some alternative causation
- 12:37theory, what Rob was just talking about a few
- 12:39minutes ago, they can't just throw it out there.
- 12:41They have to offer it to a reasonable medical
- 12:45probability, just like the plaintiff's experts
- 12:48do. So what does this look like in practice?
- 12:56So as we mentioned at the top of this presentation,
- 13:00this a new law came into play in a case called
- 13:05Hyde versus SVM transportation. It was in late
- 13:092024 that we were about to go to trial in this
- 13:12case. It was a rear -ender case where an employee
- 13:16in the course and scope rear -ended our client
- 13:18in a semi truck. And during the pendency of the
- 13:23case, our client was involved in a subsequent
- 13:26car crash and was actually hospitalized. for
- 13:29that car crash. Of course, the defense gets the
- 13:33records and then the defense's retained orthopedist
- 13:37really wanted to opine at his deposition that
- 13:41that car crash following the one that we were
- 13:44litigating about really was the cause of our
- 13:47client's pain, his need for treatment, et cetera.
- 13:51At deposition, we asked the expert, well, can
- 13:58you offer that opinion to a reasonable medical
- 14:02probability to the proper standard? And as you
- 14:05can see, the defense expert doesn't really give
- 14:07a straight answer. He kind of prevaricates and
- 14:10wants to do his lawyer a solid, but he can't
- 14:14really stake his medical reputation and say,
- 14:17well, to a reasonable medical probability, this
- 14:20subsequent crash is why our client has back pain,
- 14:23because the records don't support it. Where in
- 14:26the past you could sort of get in evidence of
- 14:28this subsequent crash now It's much more difficult.
- 14:32So now is a good time to underscore this point
- 14:35Joe if you go back to that slide Anyone taking
- 14:39a deposition in a case involving In an injury
- 14:44case and you're taking the deposition of an expert
- 14:47needs to obviously ask this question If they're
- 14:52giving opinions about causation, the opinion
- 14:56better be given to a reasonable degree of medical
- 15:00certainty or reasonable degree of medical probability
- 15:03is another way of saying it. And if the doctor
- 15:08gives a equivocal answer like this one here,
- 15:13This is what you have to use to tee up emotion
- 15:17and lemonade to exclude that alternative causation
- 15:21opinion. So this is this is this for lawyers
- 15:28for litigators This question in every expert
- 15:33deposition that you take on every single opinion
- 15:39that the witness is giving about alternative
- 15:45causation. Exactly, you just got to use that
- 15:48language, just make it a routine part of your
- 15:51practice. Because it comes up a lot, you know,
- 15:53in an injury case, we're all human beings, we
- 15:56go through a lot of stuff in life, you know,
- 15:58sports, other accidents, whatever. And it's not
- 16:03uncommon for an expert to say, well, you know,
- 16:05this person was a football player in high school
- 16:09and college and they you know we're injured and
- 16:13we have records showing that and you know there's
- 16:15a lot of strain on the person's back playing
- 16:18those sports high contact sports whatever it
- 16:22is even if the expert doesn't explicitly give
- 16:27the opinion at the deposition or writes it in
- 16:30his report you still better ask the question
- 16:33at deposition well doctor are you saying that
- 16:36the football injuries or you know, the the the
- 16:43fact that he was playing football in high school
- 16:46is a cause of Mr. Jones's ongoing pain and issues.
- 16:56And, you know, if he's like, well, you know,
- 16:59it could be. Well, then the follow up question
- 17:02is, Doctor, are you giving the opinion that his
- 17:07football playing in his football injuries were
- 17:12a cause of his injuries to a reasonable degree
- 17:15of medical certainty. And whether he says yes
- 17:21or no, if he says yes, that's sort of a gift
- 17:23because it's kind of a ludicrous position to
- 17:25take. And you could polarize the case that way.
- 17:28But if he says no, then move on. You got it.
- 17:32You're going to file a motion in Lemonade. You're
- 17:34going to cite 801 .1, say you can't give that
- 17:37opinion in court. And you'll find that when you
- 17:41introduce that language, that standard to the
- 17:43question, doctors really will retreat off of
- 17:47that opinion that they maybe planned on giving
- 17:50because they don't want to stake their reputation
- 17:53on this case or on their next case on an opinion
- 17:57that they probably know deep down is really actually
- 18:00speculative. And this new evidence code just
- 18:02sort of allows plaintiff lawyers to call that
- 18:07out a little bit and exclude on that basis. If
- 18:09anyone wants a copy of the full transcript, obviously
- 18:12you can email Joe or myself and we're happy to
- 18:15provide it. As well as briefing too, and we'll
- 18:19get into the briefing a little bit further on
- 18:22in the presentation, but of course we're happy
- 18:24to provide that too. So this is another excerpt
- 18:28from the same deposition. The lawyer for the
- 18:32defense attempted to sort of rehab the doctor,
- 18:35give him another chance. To offer his opinion
- 18:39to a reasonable medical certainty And really
- 18:44all the doctor can say is yeah appears to be
- 18:46a significant accident, you know, he's trying
- 18:48to He's trying to throw The lawyer for the defense
- 18:52of bone here, but he really can't offer his opinion
- 18:56to that standard because the records Just don't
- 19:00support it We got it. So we got a question asking.
- 19:05I think we just kind of brushed on is the depo
- 19:09question use certainty instead of probability.
- 19:13Was that an issue? I mean, that's a good question.
- 19:17You know, I think that, you know, the case law,
- 19:21obviously, in the 801 .1, the statute says probability,
- 19:26it doesn't say certainty. I think that lawyers
- 19:30get in the habit of using both interchangeably
- 19:33and they think it's synonymous. Certainty sounds
- 19:35a little bit more scary. Can you give that with
- 19:39absolute or reasonable certainty? It didn't come
- 19:44up in this case. I can foresee it being an issue.
- 19:50If opposing counsel wants to... nitpick and say,
- 19:54hey, look, that's not the standard, the standard's
- 19:57probability. I do think it's a better practice
- 20:02to track the language of the statute, which is
- 20:06probability. What do you think, Joe? I agree.
- 20:09As you said, Rob, in this case, it didn't come
- 20:12up. And obviously, the word certainty maybe sounds
- 20:16a little bit more scary than probability. But
- 20:19really, it's about reasonable taking into account
- 20:24their medical background. And so I think that
- 20:27may be why it wasn't an issue in this case in
- 20:31dealing with this opinion. And just sort of going
- 20:34forward, for whatever reason, I'm not seeing
- 20:36the questions as I come up. So Rob, please, if
- 20:38you see a question that you want to address and
- 20:40I'm not doing that, it's because I can't see.
- 20:42So feel free to just jump in. And so the defense
- 20:46lawyer, again, tries to rehabilitate his witness
- 20:51not able to do it. And so we moved to exclude
- 20:56any evidence of this subsequent car crash that
- 21:01our client was involved in. And the basis for
- 21:04that motion was this doctor can't offer his alternative
- 21:09causation opinion to a reasonable degree of,
- 21:13in this case, medical certainty, but medical
- 21:15probability. And therefore, any evidence of this
- 21:20subsequent crash is completely irrelevant to
- 21:22the issues in the case. It has nothing to do
- 21:24with liability or his damages. And on that basis,
- 21:29you know, the court kind of said, you know, not
- 21:35so fast on that opinion. Another great meme.
- 21:40Yeah, I'm not. Is that to Kenbe Motombo? I'm
- 21:42trying to figure out who that is. If someone
- 21:44knows, please put it in the chat. I've been trying
- 21:47to figure it out. It's a little blurry, so it's
- 21:49tough to tell. But, you know, here's the minute
- 21:54order from the judge excluding any evidence at
- 22:02all of that collision, which is obviously, you
- 22:05know, it's really, really valuable on a lot of
- 22:08fronts. You know, number one, it nips any alternative
- 22:12causation in the bud. The only thing that could
- 22:15have caused our client's injuries now is this
- 22:17crash that we're all here to talk about. And
- 22:19you never want the jury to hear about your client
- 22:22being in some other car crash when you're there
- 22:25to talk about a case where he's involved in a
- 22:29different car crash. It just makes your case
- 22:31a little messier, maybe makes your plaintiff
- 22:33a little more, sorry, a little less sympathetic.
- 22:37And so it was a really, really strong result
- 22:43for us. And I think it helped the case resolve
- 22:46right before trial. And so... And you can't assume
- 22:53that the judge is gonna always be up to speed
- 22:59on new developments in the law. know that 801
- 23:04.1 exists. You can't assume that. I would say
- 23:10even if an issue doesn't come up during expert
- 23:13depositions on this issue, it's probably a good
- 23:20idea to just do a pocket brief on 801 .1 in case
- 23:25an expert starts to talk about alternative causation
- 23:29opinions in court. I mean, you run into a Kennermer
- 23:33issue perhaps too, which is you can't articulate
- 23:36an opinion in court that you didn't in your deposition,
- 23:40but it might just be a good pocket brief to file
- 23:44with the court leading up to your trial as well,
- 23:47just to educate her about the new law. We do
- 23:55that a lot. I mean, just pocket briefs on a lot
- 23:57of different issues just to make sure the judge
- 24:00is up to speed on the issues in case something
- 24:03comes up during the trial. So as Rob was just
- 24:13saying, you know, some basic practice tips here,
- 24:16we've covered using that 801 .1 language at deposition.
- 24:19And as Rob said, it's really, really important
- 24:22to educate the judge in briefing on sort of where
- 24:27this bill comes from, how it came about, when
- 24:29it was enacted, et cetera, because it's been
- 24:33around since January of 2024. It's still pretty
- 24:36new. And there are judges who have been on the
- 24:38bench for decades who have probably been ruling
- 24:41on these issues a certain way for most of their
- 24:45careers. And so it's extremely important, as
- 24:48Rob mentioned, to be very thorough in your briefing.
- 24:52And I think a pocket brief's a great idea. That's
- 24:54something that we do quite a bit in our cases
- 24:56that are about to go to trial. It's a great way
- 24:58to sort of tee off a discussion on an issue that
- 25:01we think is going to be important during the
- 25:05trial, and this would be a great candidate for
- 25:07something like that. And on the defense side,
- 25:12you know, it's extremely important to understand
- 25:15this new standard as well, because, you know,
- 25:17it should, if you're a defense lawyer, affect
- 25:20your evaluation of a case. You know, whereas
- 25:24three years ago, you may be able to introduce
- 25:27some potential alternative causations that may
- 25:30devalue a case that may not be so anymore. And
- 25:35so you need to take that into account when you're
- 25:37preparing a case for trial, taking stock of what
- 25:40opinions or experts are going to be able to render
- 25:42at depot and to testify to in front of a jury.
- 25:46So it's a really, really important new law for
- 25:50both sides of the personal injury bar to Take
- 25:54note of We have a couple more questions before
- 25:57we get to the next slide Joe So first one is
- 26:00why couldn't the subsequent? Accidents be presented
- 26:03to the plaintiff's expert to inquire whether
- 26:06they can exclude the subsequent Accident as a
- 26:10contributing factor to a reasonable medical probability,
- 26:13and I think that's a good Good approach to take
- 26:18and you can you can In this particular case,
- 26:27because the plaintiff's expert had already considered
- 26:31that possibility and testified at deposition
- 26:34that the subsequent accident was not, to a reasonable
- 26:38degree of medical probability, a factor in his
- 26:42ongoing issues. and the defense expert likewise
- 26:47couldn't articulate that opinion, the judge ruled
- 26:52on the motion and eliminated or excluded altogether.
- 26:55So you couldn't even bring up the fact of the
- 26:58subsequent accident with plaintiff's expert because
- 27:02that issue was in fact presented to plaintiff's
- 27:07expert. During expert depositions and and he
- 27:11testified that it was not so But but I think
- 27:15that's a good idea that You know if you have
- 27:19an opposing expert If you have an opposing expert
- 27:23who's giving alternative causation opinions You
- 27:27should then pose those Opinions and really hypotheticals
- 27:37to your own expert to comment on during their
- 27:41deposition so that you don't run into an issue
- 27:45at the trial, right? So, you know, I think that's
- 27:51a really good thing to do, you know, to clean
- 27:54up at the end of the deposition of your own expert.
- 27:57After the other lawyer is done, you can then
- 28:00say, hey, look, doctor, the other doctor in this
- 28:03case who is hired by the defense, they're saying
- 28:06this, they're saying that there is a subsequent
- 28:09accident and that accident Was the reason why
- 28:13the plaintiff needed the surgery or that subsequent
- 28:16accident is the reason why the plaintiff is still
- 28:18in pain Do you have an opinion on that and? Get
- 28:23your experts opinions out at the deposition So
- 28:28that you can then show the judge hey judge look
- 28:30not only does the defense expert opinion Say
- 28:34that the subsequent accidents not an ongoing
- 28:36factor, but the plaintiff's expert Also says
- 28:40that it's not He can't give that opinion to a
- 28:44reasonable degree of medical probability So you
- 28:48should you should address it with your own expert
- 28:50too. I think that's a good question and a good
- 28:52point That way you're covering all your bases
- 28:56There's another question Joe. Do you have anything
- 28:59to say about that? No, no, let's go ahead with
- 29:02the other question. The other question is how
- 29:04do you define medical probability? like to a
- 29:10jury, to a retained expert, to a deponent. That's
- 29:13a good question too. To me, it's sort of like
- 29:18the standard that we're held to in court to prove
- 29:23our case. We have to prove our case by preponderance
- 29:30of the evidence. And we always define what that
- 29:34means to the jury to help them better understand
- 29:39what we need to do in order to prove our case.
- 29:43And I think that they're pretty synonymous. I
- 29:46mean, a reasonable degree of medical probability
- 29:49to me is, is it more likely than not? Is the
- 29:59opinion backed by a 50 .1 % probability? just
- 30:08a little bit more than um half you know i think
- 30:14that that's that's what it really means is it
- 30:16is it more likely than not is it just you know
- 30:20just a little bit more than 50 and if it is then
- 30:26uh it can come in and that that's the standard
- 30:30just like that's our standard uh to prove our
- 30:33case that's our burden to prove um so I think
- 30:38that that would be the way to articulate it in
- 30:43court to a jury. Right. When you strip it all
- 30:46down, it really just means more likely than not.
- 30:51And, you know, again, that's significant because
- 30:53before this evidence code section existed, that
- 30:58really wasn't the standard for experts on the
- 31:02defense side. testify, well, this person's symptoms
- 31:06could have been X or it could have been Y. And
- 31:10so the real, yeah, the new standard for everyone
- 31:14is just more likely than not, just like it is
- 31:16for the plaintiff to prove the rest of their
- 31:18case. Any more questions, Rob? Not right now.
- 31:34Just some takeaways here to round things off
- 31:37on this topic. Again, 801 .1 is an essential
- 31:41tool for plaintiff's lawyers. You need to be
- 31:45using it at deposition. You need to be educating
- 31:48your judge on exactly what the law means, its
- 31:52history, why it was enacted. Defense lawyers,
- 31:56of course, need to incorporate this new standard
- 31:59for their experts into their practice as well.
- 32:03And really it clarifies the landscape for both
- 32:06sides because before, you know, there was no
- 32:09appellate or statutory law on that disparity
- 32:12in the medical causation standard. And so you
- 32:17would see sort of broadly consistent results
- 32:19on what defense expert opinions were admissible.
- 32:23But of course, you know, it varies from judge
- 32:25to judge. And so this statute, this new evidence
- 32:29code introduces some clarity. for both sides,
- 32:33which I think hopefully will drive more resolutions
- 32:38before trial, allow sides to evaluate their cases
- 32:42more consistently and with more confidence. And
- 32:47I think my personal biggest takeaway, and Rob,
- 32:51when I'm done here, I'd love to hear if you have
- 32:52any takeaways, but personally, my biggest takeaway,
- 32:55just from the whole story of this evidence code
- 32:57and how it... came about is that it's a really
- 33:00important reminder for lawyers on both sides
- 33:04of the personal injury bar in any area of practice
- 33:07to support those advocacy organizations like
- 33:11the CAOC, for example, who sponsored the bill
- 33:14that became this evidence code. It's important
- 33:17to support those advocacy organizations who you
- 33:21feel are doing the work that is going to secure
- 33:26the long -term future of your practice and make
- 33:28a difference for your clients. Because that really
- 33:32was how this evidence code came to be is that
- 33:37the plaintiff's bar saw what they thought was
- 33:40an issue here with this standard and then they
- 33:44took action to change it and were successful
- 33:47in doing so. Yeah, and actually so there is another
- 33:51question and it's a good one too Is there a case
- 33:55law agreeing with the 51 % standard? for reasonable
- 34:01medical probability great question and You know
- 34:05what what I what I've been able to Track down
- 34:09is that actually in the legislative history for
- 34:12the law? It was Senate Bill 652, and I think
- 34:17this is something that you can cite to in your
- 34:20briefing if it ever comes up, if you ever get
- 34:22pushback, that reasonable medical probability
- 34:26is in fact 51 % or more likely than not. You
- 34:33can cite to this legislative history from the
- 34:35actual Senate bill that ended up being 801 .1,
- 34:39but it's Senate Bill 652, and it says that Basically,
- 34:47the new provision to hold all experts to this
- 34:50standard must be made to a reasonable medical
- 34:53probability, meaning the injury, quote, was more
- 34:57likely than not, end quote, a result of the alternative
- 35:01cause. So that's in the legislative history behind
- 35:05the law. It also says that in the legislative
- 35:11history, the law heightens the bar to which experts
- 35:16will be held to ensure this particularly impactful
- 35:20testimony is reliable and not misleading. So,
- 35:24again, if you ever get pushed back on the, you
- 35:27know, what does it actually mean, you can cite
- 35:30to the legislative history and when it gives
- 35:34you that more likely than not language, that's
- 35:37the language obviously that tracks the KC jury
- 35:41instruction on plaintiff's burden or proof on
- 35:44the preponderance of the evidence. The jury's
- 35:47told this means more likely than not. And the
- 35:53policy rationale there that's described in the
- 35:56legislative text, you know, really sort of aligns
- 35:58with what we were talking about earlier. This
- 36:01expert testimony, you know, when you hear an
- 36:03opinion from, again, a doctor with an incredible
- 36:06CV, who has all these impressive accolades, that
- 36:10is, as they put it in SB 652, very impactful
- 36:15testimony. And so you want that opinion to be
- 36:18rendered to a reliable degree of certainty. And
- 36:24so, yeah, that would be great material for a
- 36:27brief, as Rob said, if you do get some pushback
- 36:29and you need to really explain to the judge why
- 36:32it's important that we adhere to this new standard.
- 36:40Yeah, any other questions from anybody Let's
- 36:46see if the focus of the defense opinion was that
- 36:51the second accident was a contributing factor
- 36:53as opposed to the sole cause How do you think
- 36:57that plays out? Well in this case Maybe I should
- 37:02have been a little more clear that was the defense
- 37:05experts opinion that he hopes to offer was that
- 37:09this subsequent accident was contributing to
- 37:13his symptoms, not that it was the sole cause.
- 37:16And so we actually saw that scenario play out
- 37:18in this case, and the judge was able to, you
- 37:22know, the judge chose to exclude it. Yeah, it
- 37:25doesn't matter if the alternative causation opinion
- 37:28is, this is just one. factor in contributing
- 37:32to the injury or the sole factor, if it's an
- 37:36alternative causation at all, it has to be given
- 37:40to a reasonable degree of medical probability.
- 37:42Doesn't matter if the doctor is saying this is
- 37:45the only reason why plaintiff is having these
- 37:47issues or this is just part of it. I agree that
- 37:51the subject incident is a cause, but I also think
- 37:56that the subsequent accident is another cause.
- 37:59If you're going to give that alternative causation
- 38:03opinion, even if it's just part of it, it has
- 38:05to be given to the reasonable degree of medical
- 38:08probability standard. And from what we've seen,
- 38:12that's typically almost always how this plays
- 38:15out. It's not a defense expert trying to pin
- 38:18every single one of a plaintiff's symptoms on
- 38:22some, for example, subsequent accident. They
- 38:24say, well, this was probably part of the equation.
- 38:26So that's almost always what it looks like. Yes,
- 38:30again, we will will send the transcript of this
- 38:34particular expert and the motion and lemonade
- 38:37itself that we filed to exclude that alternative
- 38:41causation opinion Okay, well if we don't we don't
- 38:49have any more questions on this topic Rob and
- 38:54I were going to spend the next few minutes diving
- 38:57into, since it is sort of in the same realm,
- 39:01a few tips and tricks for how to quickly and
- 39:04effectively research opposing experts before
- 39:07you take that depot. So I'll go ahead and stop
- 39:12sharing my screen for a second to get a piece
- 39:14of that presentation up. And we just thought
- 39:33it made sense to include this in today's presentation
- 39:36because, again, you know, this is all under the
- 39:39realm of expert opinions, making sure you maximize
- 39:42the impact on that expert depot, score as many
- 39:45points as you possibly can, position your case
- 39:48for trial as advantageously as you possibly can
- 39:51during that expert discovery stage. So we put
- 39:58together this presentation as well to give you
- 40:02a quick little checklist to run through as you're
- 40:08getting familiar with an opposing expert before
- 40:10deposing them. And I tried to throw a couple
- 40:12of cool memes and gifs in here, too. So we'll
- 40:14see if those land. Right. Before you go on to
- 40:19that, I kind of want to go back to just, again,
- 40:23how do you articulate the burden or the standard
- 40:27in court? I think it's a good question. And you
- 40:32know, if everyone looks at Casey 200 in the jury
- 40:38instructions, it's called obligation to prove
- 40:41more likely true than not true. And that Casey
- 40:46applies to not just the plaintiff, but to the
- 40:49defense as well. The text of the actual jury
- 40:53instruction says the parties must persuade you,
- 40:57the parties must persuade you, not the plaintiff.
- 41:01The parties must persuade you by the evidence
- 41:04presented in court that what they are required
- 41:08to prove is more likely to be true than not true.
- 41:13This is referred to as the burden of proof. So
- 41:16when the defense has an alternative causation
- 41:20argument to make, or when their expert has an
- 41:25alternative causation opinion to give, under
- 41:30801 .1 they have to give it to a reasonable degree
- 41:32of medical probability but because it's because
- 41:36now it's their basically affirmative defense
- 41:38they now bear the burden of proving that you
- 41:41go back to casey 200 that says all right you're
- 41:45trying to prove something to us in court we know
- 41:48you have to prove it you have to in order for
- 41:51it to even be articulated in order for you to
- 41:54even give it in court you have to get past the
- 41:57threshold standard which is reasonable degree
- 42:02of medical probability but now in order for the
- 42:05jury to believe in it and agree that you've proven
- 42:10that it's more likely than not true. So I think
- 42:17you use the KC 200 and 801 .1 in conjunction
- 42:24if you ever confronted with an issue of, well,
- 42:27what does 801 .1 really mean? What does the standard
- 42:30really mean? And I think that using 200, KC 200
- 42:35as a compliment to that will help the judge and
- 42:41help the jury understand. Perfect. Thanks for
- 42:46that, Rob. So just briefly diving in here to
- 42:51this expert research topic. for the next few
- 42:55minutes. Westlaw is a great, great tool to learn
- 43:00about an expert's testimonial history, whether
- 43:03they've been excluded, which obviously is extremely
- 43:06valuable to know. If you can get evidence in
- 43:08front of a jury that the opposing expert has
- 43:11been excluded from testifying before and your
- 43:14expert hasn't, that immediately puts your expert
- 43:16ahead in that credibility battle. So again, this
- 43:20is low -hanging fruit luckily because it's quick
- 43:22and easy to do. on Westlaw. And also, a quick
- 43:26internet search can never hurt either, and we're
- 43:29going to walk through exactly why sometimes that
- 43:32can give you a big benefit. So we'll use a real
- 43:38-life example to illustrate sort of how useful
- 43:40Westlaw and a simple Google search can be. This
- 43:44was a case that Robert and our colleague Nadine,
- 43:47who also works here at Panache Rabaputi, had
- 43:50against Target. It was a premises liability case
- 43:54and they had this corporate security expert who
- 43:58was sort of their main liability expert. He's
- 44:01a consultant and he also does expert work. And
- 44:05so we sat down to research him and the way that
- 44:10you can sort of find those prior exclusions,
- 44:13his testimony history, et cetera, is if you just
- 44:16go to the Westlaw homepage and you hit expert
- 44:19materials, And you'll see from there, you can
- 44:25take a look at their depositions, for example,
- 44:29search the person's name in the field. And then
- 44:33there's this treasure trove of prior testimony
- 44:35that you can look through to see whether any
- 44:38opinions that he's rendering in these previous
- 44:40cases maybe conflict with what he's offering
- 44:43in your case. Again, all about trying to find
- 44:46ways to call into question their credibility
- 44:49when they testify. We talked about standard of
- 44:53care as litigators earlier about you have to
- 44:56ask that question at every single expert deposition
- 44:59of a medical expert. Are you giving this opinion
- 45:01to a reasonable degree of medical probability?
- 45:04That's standard of care. So is this. Doing this
- 45:07kind of Westlaw research on an expert who you're
- 45:12about to depose. You owe it to your client to
- 45:15do this you owe it to your case and to your cause
- 45:19to do this because I mean this really gives you
- 45:23the ammunition to Dismantle really the Oftentimes
- 45:32the experts qualifications and opinions in a
- 45:34case. So I know you know we get busy and there's
- 45:38a lot of stuff that we we do as we're gearing
- 45:41up for trial. But doing this type of research
- 45:50and these types of exercises is really, it proves
- 45:55very, very beneficial in the case. Absolutely.
- 46:02And just going back here, you can see, you can
- 46:05find prior expert reports. as well, reports they've
- 46:10authored or affidavits they've signed maybe in
- 46:12support of an MSJ, et cetera. And, you know,
- 46:15maybe a more recent example, Robert and I had
- 46:18a trial last year where it involved an auto collision
- 46:22involved the speeding police officer who was
- 46:25going 80 miles an hour in a 35. And they had
- 46:28this liability accident reconstruction expert
- 46:31who basically tried to opine in our case. that
- 46:36the officer's excessive speed actually wasn't
- 46:38that dangerous and it wasn't really a huge contributing
- 46:42factor. And Frank, essentially, it wasn't a huge
- 46:45deal that he was going more than double the speed
- 46:47limit on this surface street. And we found a
- 46:50report in Westlaw where he says the exact opposite
- 46:54thing. He actually cites a study that provided
- 46:57that the... For every mile an hour you go over
- 47:01the speed limit, it increases your chance of
- 47:04being in a collision by this much, this scientific
- 47:07study that directly refutes what he's opining
- 47:09in our case that he cited in some other case
- 47:12previously. And so it really, really undercut
- 47:15his credibility because at that point, if you're
- 47:17a juror, how are you going to believe anything
- 47:19else this guy has to say? And again, that took
- 47:22probably a half an hour of research on Westlaw.
- 47:24It's something that we do before every single
- 47:26trial for every single expert is be... sort of
- 47:28dive in and see what we can find. And so in this
- 47:32case, Mr. Grusman, back to the target case example,
- 47:36he's their premises liability expert, we found
- 47:40out that he'd been excluded back in 2018. And
- 47:46then you can actually get the exclusion itself.
- 47:48And so that's obviously, you know, a pretty good
- 47:50moment. That's something that is really material
- 47:53to the outcome of your case. And then what's
- 47:58cool is you can actually get the order itself,
- 48:02the exclusion order that lays out, yes, this
- 48:05defense expert is being excluded from testifying
- 48:09at trial, which again, really, really hurts their
- 48:13credibility. This is now an exhibit at Depot
- 48:15and you can get them to sort of face the music
- 48:17on it. We can't hear the sound. see if I can
- 48:33figure this out. Meanwhile, there's a question.
- 48:37Do you start Westlaw search with your own experts?
- 48:41Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. You know, not just with
- 48:46our experts, but, you know, we will do investigation
- 48:49into our clients, into percipient witnesses who
- 48:55we want to use at trial. you have to make sure
- 48:58you got to do that too. I mean, because of course
- 49:02you're asking your clients and you're asking
- 49:04family members or friends of your client, you
- 49:07know, hey, is there anything we need to know
- 49:09before you get up there and testify any criminal
- 49:13issues, any restraining orders, any, you know,
- 49:16anything at all. And, you know, sometimes They
- 49:20may, even though they're trying to be honest,
- 49:23they may just not remember or they don't think
- 49:25that what happened to them 10, 15 years ago is
- 49:29important, but it may not be important until
- 49:33they get caught in a lie about it. And then all
- 49:37of a sudden it's now important. And that's what
- 49:40we always tell our clients too. It's, hey, if
- 49:45you got arrested for a DUI, And for whatever
- 49:50reason, if that issue is relevant in our case,
- 49:54or if we let them answer that question, they
- 49:58better answer it truthfully. Because if they
- 50:00answer it truthfully and they say, yes, I was
- 50:02arrested for DUI, we're going to file a motion
- 50:05and eliminate to exclude that. And because it's
- 50:08just not relevant, and let's just say it's very
- 50:10remote in time, the judge is going to grant that
- 50:12motion. And it's not going to be an issue. But
- 50:16if they say, no, I've never been arrested for
- 50:20a DUI, but in fact they were, now all of a sudden
- 50:23they're putting their credibility at issue, and
- 50:26that is relevant. Their credibility is always
- 50:30relevant. And so don't make a non -issue become
- 50:34an issue in these cases. And so that's why To
- 50:42get back to the question, yes, we do research
- 50:44on our own experts. We do research on our own
- 50:50clients. Really, you're doing it so you can get
- 50:52ahead of the issue. If you've got a problem with
- 50:56your expert, if it's really bad, maybe you should
- 51:00consider not using them. But if it's not terrible,
- 51:03but it's still an issue, just get ahead of the
- 51:05issue. You you know shape the narrative on it
- 51:09you extract it on direct before the defense can
- 51:13expose it on cross Exactly. I mean coincidentally
- 51:17two days ago. We just retained an expert in a
- 51:21really tragic school drowning case and it was
- 51:25an expert we never worked with before and so
- 51:26before I Got on the phone with her. I looked
- 51:29her up on Westlaw, you know gave her a quick
- 51:31Google And just made sure that she didn't have
- 51:34any you know skeletons that were gonna heard
- 51:36us down the line. So, you know, I think maybe
- 51:39I got the sound to work, but if not, it's fine.
- 51:41We'll just move on. And Mark, as exhibit two.
- 51:44Do you guys hear that? Yes. Just another document
- 51:48here. I'll show you. This appears to be an order
- 51:51in a case in Texas from 2018 in which the judge
- 52:00ordered that you're going to be excluded from
- 52:03testifying in this case. Do you remember this?
- 52:06as well. I do remember that. Yes, it was a shooting
- 52:11outside in the parking lot of a an adult entertainment
- 52:15club. So just for the sake of time, I'll move
- 52:20on, but he doesn't really have anything that
- 52:23you can say to sort of rehabilitate himself after
- 52:27that. And another step here is just do a quick
- 52:31Google, do sort of a Google mini deep dive on
- 52:36this person to see if there's anything out there
- 52:38that may suggest some sort of bias. Because a
- 52:41lot of these people that have extensive histories
- 52:45as expert witnesses, they're going to have something
- 52:49out there that is relevant to your case in many
- 52:52instances that may not be the best for them when
- 52:55it comes to, again, the facts of your case. In
- 52:59this Target case, one of these articles that
- 53:02Mr. Grusman wrote, sort of to market himself
- 53:05it seemed like, kind of bit him in the end. So
- 53:09he writes here in this article, never admit that
- 53:13you or your company acted negligently or recklessly.
- 53:17And the title of the article is not great for
- 53:20me either. Pre and post -incident actions to
- 53:23rebuff negligent security lawsuits. So right
- 53:26off the bat, it's very clear to everybody. This
- 53:28guy is completely in the bag for the defense.
- 53:33He's biased. And so it's not easy to take what
- 53:36he says seriously, which becomes a problem for
- 53:42him when he's trying to come into this case as
- 53:45this objective expert who's here merely to offer
- 53:48his unbiased opinion on the facts. This expert
- 53:56wrote down on an article that he puts out to
- 54:01the world that in these types of cases, you should
- 54:05never admit that you or your company acted negligently
- 54:08or recklessly. I mean, at that point, there's
- 54:12nothing they can do to unring the bell. And the
- 54:16jury is going to think, no matter what he says,
- 54:22Daddy's bias like Joe said I mean it is such
- 54:25a unequivocal statement that you know. You just
- 54:30never should do this so before even heard the
- 54:33facts of this case that's his opinion I mean
- 54:36you just never admit that the company did anything
- 54:39wrong so it doesn't matter if they in this case
- 54:43actually in fact did do something wrong. You're
- 54:47going to still say that they. They didn't and
- 54:52that you're you're advising them that they shouldn't
- 54:55ever admit that and you're gonna tell us yourself
- 54:57that they weren't So there's there's really no
- 55:00coming back from such a unequivocal statement
- 55:03like that Did we get a question or am I Okay.
- 55:10Well, I don't even I don't know what I'm seeing
- 55:11then And of course Rob brought this up to mr.
- 55:16Bruce been during his depo at this presentation,
- 55:20which is also encompassed here in this republication,
- 55:25is never to admit that you or your company acted
- 55:29negligently, correct? Yeah, that's one of the
- 55:32tips that we gave, mainly talked about by one
- 55:36of the attorneys that was on the panel. There
- 55:38were two attorneys on the panel. Negligence,
- 55:42I don't need to tell you, can be a legal term.
- 55:47And so, what we were trying to express to the
- 55:51attendees who were asset protection folks from
- 55:53many different companies was, you know, what
- 55:56you may think as negligent may not be the same
- 55:58thing that a lawyer thinks or that a court thinks.
- 56:02So it's being careful with words. Okay. And you
- 56:05also said in this presentation, never to admit
- 56:08that you or your company acted recklessly, correct?
- 56:12And again, for the same reason, so that there's
- 56:14not a misinterpretation between what a layman
- 56:17would think of in terms of reckless versus a
- 56:21court or a lawyer potentially. And he can try
- 56:26and clean it up with, you know, all that backtracking
- 56:28there in his answer. But as Rob said, the damage
- 56:31is done. I mean, he wrote down, never admit basically
- 56:34that you did anything wrong. And so the clear
- 56:37impression there is that this guy came into this
- 56:40case and already had his opinion formed before
- 56:44he even heard the facts, which is all the jury
- 56:46needs to know in deciding whether or not they
- 56:48should believe this guy. At this presentation,
- 56:55which is also encompassed. It's like it might
- 56:59be the same slide. Any questions on this topic?
- 57:10It doesn't look like on this topic, we have a
- 57:12long question. Let me read it from RJ. All right,
- 57:15going back to 801 .1. And Joe, I think you could
- 57:19take down that slide now. Yeah, thanks. But going
- 57:22back to 801 .1, what about emotional distress
- 57:26damages in an employment case? In those cases,
- 57:30there is an issue of whether there is evidence
- 57:32of emotional distress. And then there's the question
- 57:35of what caused it and unlike an accident, which
- 57:37usually is not. Disputed occurred whether a person
- 57:41was harassed is often in dispute and the psych
- 57:44expert has no ability to say What happened or
- 57:47not? Is there an argument? Would 801 .1 preclude
- 57:50a psych expert from opining that certain emotional
- 57:54distress was caused by harassment if that expert
- 57:57acknowledges that they do not know that harassment
- 58:01occurred I mean, look, 801 .1 is in the evidence
- 58:07code. It's not a personal injury statute. It's
- 58:11all evidence. Joe, can you put up 801 .1 again,
- 58:17the actual language of the statute? Sure. RJ,
- 58:20I think that that expert in that particular scenario
- 58:25is subject to the same standard that any expert
- 58:28would be giving. about an alternative causation.
- 58:34Whether it's an employment case and they're saying,
- 58:36well, if the opposing expert's saying, hey, look,
- 58:41this person's experiencing emotional distress,
- 58:43or if they are experiencing emotional distress,
- 58:47it's not from harassment at work. Okay, sir,
- 58:51so what is it from? Well, I don't know. Well,
- 58:55okay, so that expert might, that opinion might
- 58:58be precluded. because it lacks foundation and
- 59:01it's speculative, because an expert can't give
- 59:04an opinion that's speculative or lacks foundation.
- 59:07But if that expert were to say, well, this person
- 59:10is dealing with what they are with all this distress,
- 59:13not because of the harassment, but because they
- 59:15have marital problems with their spouse, then
- 59:21that would be subject to 801 .1 because distress
- 59:30and emotional distress from being talked about
- 59:35by a psych. I mean, that is a medical issue and
- 59:40that's a medical causation issue. So if they
- 59:43can say that the distress is being caused by
- 59:51disagreements or a bad relationship with their
- 59:54spouse instead of the harassment that they experienced
- 59:56at work, They need to be able to say that to
- 1:00:00a reasonable degree of medical probability under
- 1:00:04801 .1. So I think it would apply equally in
- 1:00:07an employment case in that kind of context as
- 1:00:10well. Especially if it's a psych. If it's the
- 1:00:14psych who's giving that opinion, that's a medical
- 1:00:16expert. So medical experts are subject to 801
- 1:00:19.1, whether it's an employment case or a physical
- 1:00:24injury PI case. So I was going to say, yeah,
- 1:00:26I mean, the psych is a medical expert. OK, I
- 1:00:30finally caught up to where we see the questions.
- 1:00:34And it looks like it only took me an hour. It
- 1:00:37looks like we don't have any more. And we are
- 1:00:41past time. So unless anybody has any last second
- 1:00:44questions, then we'll close things up and say
- 1:00:47thank you to everyone for coming. Really appreciate
- 1:00:48it. Yeah, thank you, everyone. And again, I mean,
- 1:00:51in order to effectively cross -examine these
- 1:00:55experts at their depositions or trial. You just
- 1:00:57need to know what's out there. And 801 .1 is
- 1:01:00something that you need to know. And the Westlaw
- 1:01:03research that we showed you is also a very effective
- 1:01:06tool in learning about your opposing experts'
- 1:01:10weaknesses and soft spots. So, you know, everyone's
- 1:01:13capable of doing this. You just need to know
- 1:01:15where to look and what's out there. So hope this
- 1:01:18was beneficial to everyone. And again, if anyone
- 1:01:21has any follow -up questions or examples, please
- 1:01:24email or call Joe or myself. Thanks so much.
- 1:01:30Yeah, thank you everyone so much. Really appreciate
- 1:01:32it.