Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP311: Replatforming 2.0 - Innovative Approaches for Today's Technology Migration Challenges
Transcript
- 0:00I recently saw something where someone showed a completely
- 0:03different art direction leading with photographer using AI and
- 0:07it looked really cool. And being able to show that like
- 0:09Israel's like communicate in a much better ways.
- 0:13I think it's interesting and I think vendors AI is the first
- 0:17question that comes up now in terms of like software.
- 0:20I think we'll see that more and more.
- 0:23You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:26and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:29and re platform specialist James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:31Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:34industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:36practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:41This episode is sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:43We are returning back to what was the guess the the genesis of
- 0:48this entire podcast. Before we replat, we rebranded
- 0:51to inside commerce, which is around re platform and managing
- 0:55projects, running projects. The reason we're doing it now is
- 0:58that it's been relatively quiet on the re platforming front for
- 1:00the past like 12 to 18 months. The cadence of projects has been
- 1:04slower. There have been fewer big
- 1:07projects in the works have been fewer like legacy business
- 1:10migrations. And this is Paul and I talked
- 1:13about this a lot, obviously because it's, it's part and
- 1:15parcel of the, the, the service we provide.
- 1:17So we're obviously very keen to see what will happen in the
- 1:19market. Also lots of other people we
- 1:20know agency side, consultancy side, it doesn't mean things
- 1:23have stopped. It's just that the volume of new
- 1:25projects coming in has slowed down and we start to see that's
- 1:29picking up a bit more. So we wanted to look through
- 1:32about like what, what are the, what's changed?
- 1:34What's evolved? How do you run projects
- 1:37nowadays? What are some of the the things
- 1:38you can do to make projects more efficient, I guess to help
- 1:41people plan, understand better how to deliver them.
- 1:44Is that that was my rambling summary, Paul, Anything to add
- 1:47to that? No, I don't think so.
- 1:49Yeah. I think as you rightfully point
- 1:51out, I think this is probably a bit of a peak as well in the RE
- 1:55platforming world where people start to think about starting
- 1:58projects in January or yeah, start to think about launching
- 2:03pre peak next year. So yeah, it's just kind of,
- 2:08yeah, kind of mapping out best way to approach over projects
- 2:10and kind of de risking those types of projects.
- 2:13Why do you think we're starting to see?
- 2:14But I know, yeah, seasonality, a lot of people are coming into
- 2:17new financial years next year. They're looking the way CapEx
- 2:20commitments and that has an impact.
- 2:22But this time last year, I didn't see as much coming up.
- 2:28I've seen, I'm seeing not just like your your classic, what I'm
- 2:31going to call like the SAS brands, people who would go to
- 2:34the likes of a Shopify centre or big commerce.
- 2:37But I'm seeing some more complex businesses with I guess more,
- 2:41more behind the scenes complexity and legacy stuff
- 2:43going on that are starting to consider this as well.
- 2:46So why, why do you think that is happening is what are you
- 2:49seeing? What are you hearing?
- 2:51So I think there's a few reasons.
- 2:53So I think one would probably be the amount of people now on the
- 2:59SAS platforms and like maybe the speed at which those businesses
- 3:03are moving. So I think some of the brands
- 3:05I've spoke to are probably one of the main drivers is just kind
- 3:10of, you know, them having this huge kind of backlog of projects
- 3:13they've not been able to start, their competitors being on one
- 3:17of these more kind of agile platforms and it's kind of
- 3:21seeing the speed that they're moving.
- 3:23I think that's one. I think also just like industry
- 3:27trends around kind of given how many people are on these
- 3:31platforms now and maybe there's some shifts in the industry
- 3:35around level of engineering resources needed and general
- 3:40kind of views on cost of these kind of infrastructure, all of
- 3:44that kind of stuff. And then I also think over the
- 3:48last kind of 12 months, there's been a lot of uncertainty in a
- 3:51lot of different areas. So it feels like maybe quite a
- 3:54few people just skipped that that time and maybe, you know,
- 3:58renewed their license on a legacy provider or a different
- 4:03platform by 12 months. I definitely feel that I saw a
- 4:07few of those projects where people were kind of, you know,
- 4:10at one point really focused on starting a project and then
- 4:13suddenly, you know, the business has had other priorities.
- 4:17I also think not this time last year, but I think the tariffs
- 4:20paused a lot of stuff as well. And I think some of those
- 4:23projects are starting to happen again.
- 4:25And I think the other one, the other thing is maybe like, I
- 4:29mean, to be honest, I think as much as we've obviously agnostic
- 4:34and you know, there's so many different players.
- 4:38I also think that Shopify is probably at a point now where
- 4:41quite a few people have just been waiting to feel comfortable
- 4:45that they can actually service complex retailers.
- 4:49And I think that's probably part of it as well.
- 4:51Regardless of whether they actually are not moving to
- 4:53Shopify or not, I feel like there's probably been some
- 4:57people that have just wanted to wait.
- 5:00Yeah. And again, part of that would be
- 5:02because of the competition in their market or just, you know,
- 5:05the marketing around Shopify or whatever else.
- 5:08But yeah, probably a combination, combination of all
- 5:10of those. Any others that you think?
- 5:13No, I think that I think that's actually spot on.
- 5:15I think the the reality is that Shopify is incredibly noisy in
- 5:19terms of its market. I'm not critically, but they are
- 5:22really on it. They are one of the most
- 5:24proactive in terms of how they invest in their marketing and
- 5:27how they build out their go to market stuff.
- 5:28And there's been a huge amount of information that's come out
- 5:31from them about how they are the best, how they get the best cost
- 5:34model. And there's been quite rightly a
- 5:37level of scepticism because you should always be sceptical about
- 5:40claims and you should look to validate it.
- 5:42But you're right. The the point you made about
- 5:44there are more case studies now demonstrating beyond simple mass
- 5:48market direct to consumer retail e-commerce.
- 5:51You know, in you've got like the world world of books, for
- 5:53example, going live, things like that where you go, oh, millions
- 5:57and millions of skews, like massive two way data flows,
- 6:01stock and pricing updates on a on a massive enterprise level.
- 6:04That starts to change the dynamic.
- 6:06And I think you're right, that's probably starting to make people
- 6:08think we should be looking at this now.
- 6:10And even if the decision is no, we're OK, but it's for, I think
- 6:13it's forcing people to be more proactive into into looking and
- 6:18considerate now. Yeah, absolutely.
- 6:21But let's let's look at the before we get into like, you
- 6:23know, our views on like how you run these projects and what's
- 6:26change, Let's look at I wanted to talk about in the market, in
- 6:29the technology space and in terms of delivery, what has
- 6:31changed in the last 1212 months, 24 months.
- 6:35And that's having an impact in terms of I guess what how people
- 6:38look at tech, what tech they look at what they're thinking
- 6:41about in their project beyond just let me replace my platform
- 6:43because for me it's, it's really moved from I want to replace.
- 6:48Yeah, pick your platform, Salesforce, Shopify, Adobe to to
- 6:52Salesforce, anyone to Adobe and it doesn't matter.
- 6:56But I the discussions now aren't and shouldn't be.
- 7:00I want to change my platform. It's about what impact is moving
- 7:04platform going to have in my ecosystem and what do I need to
- 7:06invest in to get the most out of that.
- 7:08So I'm seeing, I'm seeing a lot more change not just in the
- 7:11agency consultancy side talking about, but in the client side
- 7:14understanding that and realising that there is an adaptive
- 7:17process here and that actually there's a wider implication it
- 7:20might mean greater change than just the econ platform.
- 7:23I think that's the primary thing that I'm seeing difference.
- 7:26There's a greater maturity of understanding developing amongst
- 7:30client side teams. Yeah, completely agree with
- 7:32that. Yeah, I completely agree.
- 7:35I also think there's a lot more and I don't know if you agree
- 7:38with this, but I think two years ago there was there was a lot
- 7:42less platform to merchant direct communication.
- 7:47And I think now there is a lot more dialogue and yeah,
- 7:53connection between be that industry events, be that private
- 7:57events, whatever else. I think there's a lot more of a
- 7:59direct relationship there. I still think, I mean, another
- 8:05thing that I think is I mean, I still see TCO and cost reduction
- 8:10is like the main driver behind these projects like 75% of the
- 8:14time. I think in the end, like I think
- 8:17that's the main kind of or at least the biggest component of a
- 8:20business case. And then alongside that, you've
- 8:23got any additional value that can come from it.
- 8:25And you know, often a board or want to see projections of
- 8:29uplift against certain KPI is another thing cows.
- 8:33But I still think, I just wanted to say that just based on what
- 8:35you said, because I think I see both of those things, but I
- 8:38still think that like cost and OpEx reduction is still the big
- 8:45kind of motivating factor on a lot of these projects.
- 8:49What do Mattel, Victoria Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 8:54all have in common? They power their businesses.
- 8:57With. Shopify Shopify is the most
- 9:01innovative and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 9:05It also happens to have the best converting check out on the
- 9:08planet Shopify Powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 9:14Find out more at Shopify dot. Com slash Enterprise yeah, I I
- 9:18find it interesting. I, I agree, and it always should
- 9:20be in every CFR out there should be pushing for what's the cost
- 9:23efficiency. But what I'm seeing is I still
- 9:26think there is a, a lack of understanding that change might
- 9:31not deliver you a positive ROI as quickly as you expect because
- 9:36of let's look at the dependency. So yes, you can quickly cut
- 9:40license fees depending on what legacy high license version you
- 9:43might be on. But you might be in a world
- 9:46where you're on an open source non license fee and you'll
- 9:48switch, you're switching to an ecosystem which has a platform
- 9:51license fee. And if you're 100 million pass,
- 9:53that's a significant chunk you just added into your cost specs.
- 9:57And it's, I still find that that that understanding of the
- 10:02nuances of cost model and reduction of cost versus
- 10:05investment and optimization of where you spend your money and
- 10:09the return you get from it and value versus cost.
- 10:12I still think people don't get it enough because it's, it's
- 10:15hard. Some use cases, you know, it's
- 10:19very easy to go, we can save money and others it's actually
- 10:21harder because you've got other issues that that where the money
- 10:24that you're off, you're reducing needs to be reinvested because
- 10:27of challenges you got, whether that's plug in resource gaps or
- 10:30it's adding third parties because you just can't deliver
- 10:32stuff in the Roper completely. Great.
- 10:34And I think I've seen many brand, I've had many a
- 10:39conversation where I've been speaking to someone and they'll
- 10:42say this platform, you know, the significant more expensive than
- 10:45what I'm paying now or, you know, chain price, whatever
- 10:50else. But they're on an open source
- 10:52platform with no license fee. They've got like a, you know,
- 10:56terrible payment provided there's really low cost, but
- 10:59it's also just not a brilliant service.
- 11:02Maybe there's fundamental issues in that service as well.
- 11:07And and yet as you say, there's so much more value from like in
- 11:12every commercial aspect to a more modern approach.
- 11:18And actually often it's just a hard comparison.
- 11:22I mean, even even the modern comparisons now that I think
- 11:25both of us would say the two platforms we're comparing most
- 11:28to century Shopify. And even with that, like
- 11:31there's, there's just a lot of variables and it's still
- 11:34complex. Even if the people, I mean even
- 11:37just the payment to piece of loan and I think a lot of people
- 11:41there's a lot of room for like misconception that basically.
- 11:44I think fundamentally there isn't.
- 11:46I mean, I'll give 111 really good tangible example where you
- 11:50can actually add cost to your project, which makes your
- 11:54project TCO look look less favourable bar you're actually
- 12:00taking out cost and improving efficiency somewhere else.
- 12:03But that's accounted for a different budget.
- 12:04So I was having a conversation today about post post order
- 12:08editing and we know in the Shopify space order editing,
- 12:10Hamish and team are smashing out the part doing a brilliant job.
- 12:13So many brands on boarded order editing exists in other
- 12:15ecosystems and not, not quite simple to set up and install, of
- 12:19course, but you're adding costs because you're adding, you're
- 12:22either adding. So if you use an order editing
- 12:24the app in the Shopify world, you're adding app license fees.
- 12:28And some, you know, there's probably some potentially in
- 12:31some cases you might need to do a little bit of ERP work to
- 12:33support it. You might, you might not.
- 12:37If you're doing it in another environment, you're probably
- 12:39doing custom coding and that's going to add, but you're
- 12:42stripping cost out of customer services because they're not
- 12:44having to field all these enquiries.
- 12:46You're potentially getting greater commercial rate because
- 12:52people are happier, they've got exactly what they want, they can
- 12:55edit their order, they don't get frustrated, they don't cancel.
- 12:58You got all these other shifts in cost and benefit that aren't
- 13:02modelled at a project level unless you get into the
- 13:05granularity of it. So I think I, I still believe
- 13:08that this is an area that people haven't adapted their thinking
- 13:11enough to. Yeah.
- 13:12That's and there's so many of those as well.
- 13:15Yeah, it's a headless, like headless.
- 13:16Our headless is really expensive, but actually, yes.
- 13:19So they might introduce additional costs somewhere, but
- 13:22it's going to improve capabilities in other areas and
- 13:25and maybe it's going to save you time and effort because you've
- 13:27got so headless CMS in the central world, you've now got
- 13:30much greater granularity of control over publishing
- 13:32workflows. Well actually that's probably
- 13:34saved you loads of manual effort and might have improved the
- 13:37efficiency of the pub. Then you're like, well, OK, so
- 13:39there's pros and cons and yeah, it's nuanced.
- 13:42Exactly. And then I think one of the one
- 13:44of the other variables, so this isn't in your list here, but I
- 13:48think one of the other variables in the ecosystem.
- 13:53So I think we talked about how loud Shopify is and kind of
- 13:58dominant from a kind of community and ecosystem
- 14:00perspective. I think one other thing that's
- 14:03had quite a big impact is that I would say a high proportion of
- 14:09the agencies that were selling against Shopify.
- 14:12So largely the Adobe big commerce and sales force
- 14:17agencies are now also selling Shopify, which and I think a lot
- 14:21of that is because there's like critical mass in the shop fire
- 14:24world. But I think that's also having
- 14:26quite a big impact on games personally.
- 14:28Like there's not that many voices anymore because there's
- 14:33not the volume outside of central, I would say.
- 14:36And I think we both agree on that.
- 14:38But I think a lot of the agency or like, you know, the little
- 14:41kind of ecosystems have would have been still pushing
- 14:43Salesforce, Adobe, big commerce, commerce layer commerce tools.
- 14:49I feel like a lot of those are now actually in the Shopify camp
- 14:54as well. And I think that's having a bit
- 14:56of an impact. Yeah, it isn't.
- 14:58And we know that some of those are deliberately done that
- 15:01because they want to be part of the conversation, even if, even
- 15:06if they don't believe that Shopify is right for many
- 15:09projects, which is it isn't, you know, it's a brilliant platform,
- 15:11but no platforms perfect for every use case.
- 15:14Actually having the, the the badge on your website can be,
- 15:18there's been being talked to and not being talked to and at the
- 15:21early stage that's huge. Yeah, completely.
- 15:24Well, yeah. Let's look at the other thing
- 15:26that I'm seeing that's a bit different at the moment is
- 15:28timelines. And I'm I'm going to speak away
- 15:30from large complex businesses like, you know, high end
- 15:35manufacturing and B to B. But I definitely think that the
- 15:40way that the, the growth of, of platforms like Shopify Centre
- 15:45and big commerce as well and the standardisation, I think of
- 15:50middleware as part of a solution rather than a, oh, we need to
- 15:53use middleware, do we now? It's more like, what middleware
- 15:55are we using? You know, patch works well
- 15:58embedded in a Shopify ecosystem and that's used outside of that
- 16:01high cohesion's doing really well.
- 16:02There's loads of them. There's loads of middlewares
- 16:04depending on where you are in the world.
- 16:06But I'd think that it just feels that the the middlewares have
- 16:10built out their capabilities quite quickly.
- 16:12The number of like connectors and pre-existing like basic
- 16:16flows that speeds up adoption for integration cycles is, is
- 16:20just way better now. And actually the time to
- 16:23market's coming down as a result.
- 16:25So you know, it's you've probably shade a few months off
- 16:28of projects by and it's not just the middleware there, it's
- 16:31obviously platform capabilities and automation and Lono Cam
- 16:34tooling, but definitely feels like going to market quicker is
- 16:39feasible for more people now. Yeah, completely agree.
- 16:41I think the integrations piece, you know, back 678 years ago
- 16:46when we would be involved in project, that would have been
- 16:49the more complex thing to manage.
- 16:50And now, yeah, it feels like the barrier to entry and the amount
- 16:54of work there has come down a lot.
- 16:57And the same applies to data migration to a certain extent as
- 17:00well. I think that's got a lot, a lot
- 17:03simpler and people are a lot kind of better at it as well.
- 17:08So, yeah, I mean, I think, you know, you see these, I mean you
- 17:10see pretty big brands moving in weeks and whether or not it's
- 17:13arriving the big question mark and we could probably do an
- 17:16episode on this easily between ourselves is the pros and cons.
- 17:21Because I've also seen a lot of brands that have moved in 6-8
- 17:26weeks when actually, you know, the cost would have been very
- 17:30similar if they moved in, you know, six months.
- 17:33And then they would have been able to go for a full redesign
- 17:35process and, you know, put a lot more rationale behind decisions
- 17:40and put a lot more time into like bend the selection and
- 17:43everything else and actually get more value.
- 17:45And I think often people kind of create their own reasoning for
- 17:49that or there's someone seeing you in the business that's
- 17:51driving it. There's not enough time put into
- 17:54counter arguments. But I actually think you see
- 17:56that so often and, you know, at least 50% of the time there's
- 18:00not the need isn't, but it's not that big a need to move that
- 18:03quickly. But I completely agree.
- 18:05Like I think timeline's, yeah, pretty crazy now.
- 18:08Yeah. I spoke to a few people recently
- 18:10that want to move this year, and they're only now starting to
- 18:13look at the project. Yeah.
- 18:16And I think, as you rightfully said earlier, that there's
- 18:19usually room to bring some value to a business in this project.
- 18:23But in order to do that, you need time.
- 18:25Yeah. And actually interestingly
- 18:27having said that, the overall project timelines are
- 18:29condensing. So I mean 6 to 9 months for a
- 18:33shopified big commerce bit, you know a non legacy vendor has
- 18:38been pretty common. But yeah, four to six months in
- 18:43terms of development time, including full development UAT,
- 18:47yeah, QAOT, the whole thing to be ready four to six months now
- 18:51is, is the average I'm working on.
- 18:52But what I am seeing, which I'm I'm really grateful for and
- 18:56maybe I'm just lucky with who I'm working with, but I'm a
- 19:00greater investment in discovery. So I see the agencies in that
- 19:03space mature. And so if you go to like legacy
- 19:05vendors, the the the like big Adobe projects, Salesforce is
- 19:09what used to be IBMH. All of those are on Tibrus.
- 19:12Long detailed discovery was just standard.
- 19:15It wasn't a 2 discovery. Discovery.
- 19:19Yeah, exactly. Let's solve things in build
- 19:21phase that IT was so risk averse and actually there's a lot of
- 19:24benefit there especially at enterprise level.
- 19:26But now I'm seeing as I'm now seeing what was two to four week
- 19:28discoveries being 6 to 8 weeks more spent on IT.
- 19:33Clients invest in IT, more people involved, greater depth
- 19:35for technical assessment, and greater level of specking out
- 19:39solutions and doing proper due diligence.
- 19:42Yeah, that's interesting. I think that's an interesting
- 19:45discussion as well. I think where it's needed, I
- 19:49think that's that's really valuable.
- 19:51But I think a lot of it depends on the teams as well because the
- 19:55hardest thing about discovery in my opinion, or a lot of the
- 19:59time, especially if you've got, you know, and a consultant in
- 20:03there as well and everything cars is that is calendars.
- 20:06And I think I have done some project for Oka was a good
- 20:09example where that was a relatively short discovery that
- 20:13the hours were in it. It was just kind of everything
- 20:16kind of aligned and it was quite as planned quite well.
- 20:19The time was ringing fenced on both sides.
- 20:22But I think, yeah, I mean, I completely agree with your
- 20:25point, I think. I think you can't rush discovery
- 20:28and there's always going to be benefit from being more thorough
- 20:32and obviously less risk. Yeah, it's, it's just
- 20:37interesting like with how the timings around these projects
- 20:41have changed and like, I mean, I think it varies basically and
- 20:46like. It, it does.
- 20:48I just think I see on average and I guess we work with, with
- 20:51different portfolio people, but I see on average more time
- 20:53spent. I, I see agencies being more
- 20:55structured and disciplined in discovery.
- 20:58If I go back five years, the agencies needed a lot more
- 21:02handholding and cajoling, not not because they didn't want to
- 21:05do a good job, because they didn't have the project delivery
- 21:07expertise in house. They sharpen that up.
- 21:10They've got more senior people and the the quality and depth of
- 21:13analysis and input is far higher.
- 21:15I just think the ecosystems are maturing basically.
- 21:18Yeah, I do agree with that. Yeah, I completely agree with
- 21:20that. Yeah.
- 21:23And I definitely think, I mean, historically, we would have done
- 21:26projects where we would have driven a lot of that kind of
- 21:28stuff. And I think that's probably
- 21:29needed less and less. But I do also think the projects
- 21:32are getting simpler and like the technologies are getting simpler
- 21:35as well. So it's, yeah, kind of coming
- 21:37from both sides. It is and let's let's let's riff
- 21:40on that because I think that's a good point is there are certain
- 21:43certain things where as you spend a lot more time working on
- 21:48storefront design piece. Well, actually, if you're if
- 21:50you're taking a modern SAS platform with a theme, there's
- 21:53loads of stuff that you're not having to spend as much time
- 21:55accessibility, right, yes, you have to think about it, but core
- 21:58accessibility is baked in mobile first.
- 22:01Yes, you got design like that, but actually from a template in
- 22:04and the code based point of view that So there's a lot of stuff
- 22:07where you used to spend a lot more technical time defining,
- 22:10making sure it was understood what it meant and now you don't
- 22:13need to that actually the bits I see more time being spent on
- 22:16which is the the value added things like product data model
- 22:19and architecture where that can be the difference between having
- 22:22a site where you can sell and having a site where it's bloody
- 22:24easy to find stuff. Search and product discovery
- 22:27work effectively. Well, filtering is nailed down.
- 22:30You structured data from an SEO point of view and also now from
- 22:34AI agent point of view is it is improved and it just feels like
- 22:39there's that that more time time's shifting to value add
- 22:42tasks. Yeah, I completely agree.
- 22:45Yeah. I think the other one
- 22:47historically, I think most of the projects again both of us
- 22:51probably would have worked on would have been like, you know,
- 22:54this is your scope and you know, things are being pushed to fast
- 22:58follow or you know, all the way through.
- 23:01Whereas now it feels like, you know, you get some pretty meaty
- 23:04additional net new functionality in some of these projects.
- 23:08Like loyalty has been a big one that we've had across a few more
- 23:12projects recently, new markets, all that kind of stuff.
- 23:16And I think, yeah, a lot of that is just how the amount of time
- 23:21in different areas has changed, I guess.
- 23:24But yeah, I completely agree. There's almost like, yeah, there
- 23:27is like almost like a standard approach and certain platforms
- 23:30to check out. Yeah, as you say, I think it
- 23:32depends on the agency, but I think accessibility is one that
- 23:36you don't need to put the same level of effort into anymore.
- 23:38And I can't remember the other thing you said, but yeah,
- 23:42there's loads of those areas. And I mean, ultimately what
- 23:44we're saying is I do think the level of resistance and yeah,
- 23:49the amount of complexity in these projects is cut, is coming
- 23:53down. And it just allows you to put
- 23:55the time into the things that are actually going to have an
- 23:57impact on the business. Let's let's go into like the
- 24:01discovery phase because we, we, we talk a lot about this.
- 24:03We both get involved. We either run it or we support
- 24:06on lots of discoveries and I guess things always change like
- 24:10this. The core principles of run a
- 24:12discovery are always going to be the same.
- 24:14In fact, that you need to know what what the scope is.
- 24:16You need to know what your goals are.
- 24:20You need to know all the capability areas.
- 24:21You've got to capture info. You need to know who gets
- 24:23involved strike, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 24:24Let's yeah, we've already done this in the past.
- 24:26Let's talk about some some interest areas because you made
- 24:29a comment earlier about what, what, how people need to be
- 24:33prepared, what they need to do now to speed up discovery to de
- 24:36risk. Do you want to talk people
- 24:37through that? Like, what are the things that
- 24:39that client teams can and should be doing ahead of the start of
- 24:41the discovery? Yeah.
- 24:42I think again, a lot of this will depend, but I think it's
- 24:45more of the things that can be done that can help to reduce
- 24:49risk, speed up discovery, get more from discovery.
- 24:55And I think all of the kind of core documentation would be 1
- 24:58obvious thing. So like systems diagrams, you
- 25:01know, kind of definition around roles and responsibilities,
- 25:06stakeholder mapping, like organization of like steer Co
- 25:10and that whole thing. I think for me, the types of
- 25:14projects we work on, again, some of this might be down to the
- 25:17types of clients we work with, which is largely premium fashion
- 25:20and kind of lifestyle brand. But the creative side of the
- 25:24project and the design elements of the project, the things that
- 25:28bring a lot of the risk around timeline and that can just be a
- 25:33nightmare. And there's a lot of room for,
- 25:34you know, really vocal stakeholders to change their
- 25:37minds throughout the project. And you know, for sessions to
- 25:41not be ran too efficiently to one thing that we've done in the
- 25:46past is in kind of parallel to some of the kind of upfront
- 25:53functional discovery to like enable agencies to be able to
- 25:56provide an accurate timeline in quo.
- 25:58And we've also done some sessions on the creative side
- 26:02and just basically started trying to manage some of those
- 26:05stakeholders early on and kind of trying to feed information to
- 26:09them, trying to extract information from them.
- 26:12Start to kind of get some level of documentation against key
- 26:16areas of the site on what these stakeholders are looking to
- 26:18achieve, examples from them, everything else.
- 26:23And then basically just try to get to a point where there's
- 26:26less risk going into sessions in the design process can take 10
- 26:30weeks instead of 16 weeks. Yeah, I think that would be a
- 26:35good one. I think an equivalent around
- 26:37integration. I mean, to be honest, any area
- 26:39of risk in the project, I think if you know, if you've got time
- 26:43and you've got parallel strings of work happening, the more kind
- 26:48of discussion you can have beforehand and the more kind of
- 26:53definition you can get together even if you're not making final
- 26:56decisions. That's just like kind of, you
- 26:59know, pre reading for agency stakeholders, pre discussion
- 27:04around, you know, things like payments or yeah, kind of
- 27:08anything else that can have an impact on the project.
- 27:11I think it's just, and the other thing would be like pulling out
- 27:17anything that could impact timelines and even like resource
- 27:21planning as well internally, just anything you can do to just
- 27:24make that discovery easier. And yeah, make it easier to kind
- 27:29of manage resources for whoever's kind of taken the lead
- 27:33the most, the the highest level. Yeah, I think there are there
- 27:37are two things that as a independent consultant, I I
- 27:40think add a lot of value. So for to help because my
- 27:43obviously my role is, is basically it's like the Babel
- 27:46Babble fish. I sit between the agency and the
- 27:48client that help them be as efficient as they possibly can
- 27:50together rather than get in the way, which is not what a good
- 27:54consultant should ever do. But the first bit is basically
- 27:59prior to engaging with agency for any discovery is, is sitting
- 28:03down with a client being very concise about Skype, what has to
- 28:06be delivered and what isn't, looking at the to be the issues,
- 28:10the what they like the frustrations, where they want to
- 28:13get like what they want to achieve, what's in their road
- 28:16map? What have they not been able to
- 28:17ship on the cloud? All of these stuff and to and to
- 28:19just probe in a positive way and say, but do you really need
- 28:22that? Is that important?
- 28:23What's going to and get to the point of, of being very succinct
- 28:26about what has to be there on day one for MVP and what, what,
- 28:30what is a nice to have luxury. But you know what?
- 28:32We don't have a a business proposition for a business case
- 28:34for it and other stuff, which is we need to deliver it, but it
- 28:36doesn't have to be. I think if you the more succinct
- 28:39you can be on that, the easier it is for an agency to, to focus
- 28:42on where the importance is in discovery.
- 28:44And it doesn't mean you don't have to have the other
- 28:46conversations, but you can almost it's almost like
- 28:48discovery 1A1B that A is the priorities B can find.
- 28:53It can come later because it's you don't have to ship it.
- 28:55Therefore, the sign up for discovery and the cost model and
- 28:58stuff doesn't have to be predicated on it.
- 29:00Don't get in the way. Get streams like integrations
- 29:03going early. Anything that's not impacting
- 29:06those key streams, you can then pick up and A and a follow up
- 29:09and then fold that back into the project depending on
- 29:11availability, cost timeline. That's one thing that works
- 29:14really well. The the other bit is definitely
- 29:19the, the support in getting ready for each session by
- 29:22working with the agency to get very succinct set of questions
- 29:25that they've got to answer and helping them by saying you might
- 29:27also answer this. And then work in the business
- 29:30teams to get data and insights so that the agency has stuff at
- 29:33least like, you know, ideally a week before the workshop because
- 29:37you can suddenly go from this in a workshop to this and then this
- 29:41gets more detail. Yeah, completely, very, both of
- 29:44them. And they're fun as well, aren't
- 29:46they? Because it's, it's good, because
- 29:47you're helping people speed up decision making.
- 29:50Have you, is there anything else that you've noticed in
- 29:52Discoveries? Is there anything changing the
- 29:54way people are delivering them, running them, the techniques,
- 29:56the tools? I feel I think it depends.
- 30:04A lot of it depends on the scope of the project and the goals of
- 30:09the project. Like I think every and most of
- 30:12the projects we work on are relatively tight timeline and
- 30:17the main goal is to migrate over to a new tech stack as
- 30:20effectively as possible and usually like elevate the brand
- 30:25and like, you know, improve the front end.
- 30:27I think where you've got the every now and then when we've
- 30:30worked on like bigger, more complex, broader projects, I
- 30:35think, you know, there's a lot more room for like broader kind
- 30:40of mirror board type sessions around kind of different ideas
- 30:46around how to like architect things.
- 30:48But I mean, to be honest, I don't feel that ours have
- 30:50changed that much in recent times working across, yeah,
- 30:56different agencies. I think maybe the only other
- 30:59thing would be, I think the agencies we work with, some of
- 31:03them have really levelled up maybe on the design side in
- 31:07terms of like using real customer data, doing customer
- 31:10surveys, like some of that kind of stuff more around how they
- 31:15kind of map out different journeys.
- 31:17I think the other thing would be Figma actually makes, that's a
- 31:22not necessarily functional discovery, but I think
- 31:24prototyping is something that helps a lot in terms of the
- 31:28design phase and getting people comfortable with certain kind of
- 31:33interaction design and then also kind of seeing different
- 31:37journeys first hand. But beyond that, I feel like I
- 31:46feel like a lot of it's still very similar to me.
- 31:50But that being said, I'm probably not as close to some of
- 31:53the ones we've ran recently as I used to be.
- 31:56Yeah, they were framing. It's definitely something that's
- 31:58a good value add to discovery because you're not in design
- 32:02yet, but you want to be able to you want to you want to
- 32:05understand the the structural impact of technical decision.
- 32:09So I just in a recent one where we had three or four different
- 32:13PDP specifications because of the different product data
- 32:16models, having that as a as a what basic wire frame to show
- 32:19how what that meaningfully means the difference in a room when
- 32:22you've got multiple of stakeholders to see that rather
- 32:25than somebody technical conceptually talking through a
- 32:28data model. So way, way better.
- 32:31Yeah, I don't see, I, I think what I see a bit more of is it
- 32:36it well, a bit more What I see as a key difference is fewer
- 32:40massive sessions. I remember years back all day
- 32:44and I was guilty of this. I was guilty of this.
- 32:46I used to run all days, all day sessions broke up into small
- 32:49breaks in between. But actually, do you know what
- 32:51it's a really, really shit use of time because you're too
- 32:54tired. And if if you've got a product
- 32:56data architecture one at 3:00 in the afternoon after being in
- 32:59meetings for 5-6 hours, your brains like so I'm seeing, I'm
- 33:03seeing days focus generally onto a specific topic with a maybe 2
- 33:07hour with time for like discussion afterwards.
- 33:10And then more agile follow up of, OK, we've got 8 questions to
- 33:14resolve. And this is the price of dinner
- 33:17and we need another call on this and we might need documentation
- 33:20on this and been been a little bit more flexible in how you
- 33:23capture the data rather than interim all day long.
- 33:26Yeah, Yeah, I think I've seen that as well, to be honest.
- 33:29Yeah, probably. I think some of that is
- 33:31actually, and I don't know if you agree with this, but I think
- 33:34some of it is also working with Shop Fire that I feel like.
- 33:37Sure, I've always kind of seen Shop Fire is more like broken
- 33:40down into chunks, whereas I think with some of the other
- 33:43platform and again, maybe that's maybe that's not fair, maybe
- 33:46it's changed a bit more. But I think back in the Adobe
- 33:48days, it would be full on, yeah, kind of, you know, full day
- 33:52sessions. There'd be a lot more nuance.
- 33:56And as you say, like, I think that'd be a lot more kind of
- 33:59openness in different areas that would kind of extend a lot of
- 34:04those sessions. And also there'd probably be a
- 34:07bit more nervousness around scope creep as well, just
- 34:10because there's less standardization.
- 34:13And also you've got the back end side of things as well.
- 34:16Yeah, I, I think it's a fair thing to say that that legacy
- 34:20implementations which were more complex and technically
- 34:23challenging, and also a lot of those were in larger businesses
- 34:27with more teams and more, more like diverse teams.
- 34:31And it ended up being a get everyone together to talk about
- 34:35it. I don't in hindsight wasn't the
- 34:37most effective use of time, but I get, I totally get why I was
- 34:40at House of Fraser in 2015 through this process.
- 34:43I totally get why it was done in that way.
- 34:46But also the, the, the big, the big shift now is post COVID,
- 34:50people have got used to working remotely and realising you can
- 34:53deliver work effectively and you don't have to all be in an
- 34:55office all day long to go through all the workshops
- 34:58because that's the only time you can get your calendars aligned.
- 35:01Because trying to get people for the one hour, 2 hour sessions
- 35:03all in an office across multiple days doesn't work.
- 35:06Right. So you, that's why I used to do
- 35:08one day, we'll get, we're all in on Tuesday, we're all all day
- 35:10long. But actually now people know do
- 35:13it on Teams, do it, whatever it is.
- 35:15You've got AI transcript writers and note takers.
- 35:18You've got the session recordings, the the ability to
- 35:22do that remotely. Do do critical ones where you
- 35:25really need some brain power and some like turn and fro and
- 35:28disagreement and discussion and white board and stuff out that
- 35:31in person. But everything else can be done
- 35:33remotely. Yeah, yeah, great.
- 35:38Let's one other, one other kind of discussion point I wanted to
- 35:41go into is about I, I definitely see re platforming now, not
- 35:46about change your platform, but about evolve your ecosystem.
- 35:50And that is more of a strategic lens on technology selection.
- 35:53Because if you change whatever it might be Adobe to Shopify,
- 35:59Salesforce to a big commerce or a big commerce to a Salesforce,
- 36:02whatever the path you're going is, it's going to have an impact
- 36:06on, on the other third parties you're using.
- 36:07Because each platform has its strong connectors, right?
- 36:12It has the, the tools that it's really well integrated with to
- 36:15enable all the data phase you're on versus ones where you have to
- 36:17do a lot of configuration or custom development to get all
- 36:19the functionality working. So I see this small now as an
- 36:24ecosystem play and and this been a big shift in how people need
- 36:28to be educated and bought into the project to understand that
- 36:30just because a platform is changing and it's not their part
- 36:33of the business, it's actually their part of the business,
- 36:35there could be a dependency and an impact on the tech that
- 36:38they're using. Yeah, yeah, I agree.
- 36:42I guess this varies a bit as well.
- 36:44Like some of the bigger projects we work on, there might be
- 36:47slightly less room to, you know, discuss certain things.
- 36:53So like a lot of projects we've worked on recently have had a
- 36:55PIM involved. I think in a lot of cases,
- 37:00there's not as much need for PIM these days.
- 37:03I think it's very rare recently that we've done project where
- 37:07the only, maybe the only additional basically less people
- 37:13are looking at some of those kind of isolated like specialist
- 37:16PIM product. And maybe the only time it is
- 37:18being looked at as net new is more air table and it's more an
- 37:21efficiency play or the team are particularly comfortable with
- 37:26air table. But it's not necessarily due to
- 37:30oh, I guess if it's like proper multi channel implementation and
- 37:34your passing data between other systems, I guess we've just not
- 37:38really had a project where there's a net new need for PIM.
- 37:42Yeah. So I guess in terms of PIM, I
- 37:43see this as well. And the main reason is outside
- 37:46of complex use cases where you might have huge numbers of
- 37:50translations, multiple storefronts, different views of
- 37:54catalog and product for different audience types that
- 37:59actually the the E com native product models have gotten much
- 38:02deeper and better. So with with meta fields, data
- 38:07fields, custom fields, extensions, you can actually
- 38:10build out a really robust data model now and you can do that
- 38:13through bulk imports and you can manage it through bulk edits.
- 38:18So there are I think some of the use cases where a PIM was really
- 38:20helpful 3, five years ago, it was not so needed.
- 38:24But then there are always ones where trying to do it through
- 38:28e-commerce is just too convoluted.
- 38:29The data models too, too complex for you to be able to do light
- 38:33bulb editing in any efficient way.
- 38:36But the other, the main, the other main change I'm seeing in
- 38:39in the way that people approach these projects now is AI mean
- 38:43it's inevitable. It's focus on AI and demanding
- 38:46of the vent, the platforms and the agencies.
- 38:49How is AI being used to improve automation, to reduce manual
- 38:53effort, to strip unnecessary cost out and allow efficiency?
- 38:57I don't know how how key you'll find in these discussions, but I
- 39:01hear this more and more of you know how to an agency.
- 39:03So how are you in ERP status? How are you using AR to improve
- 39:07like your your code management, your testing?
- 39:09And then that's obviously has an influence in terms of The Who
- 39:13they select the project and then in terms of how the project is
- 39:15run. Yeah, I think we haven't really
- 39:17seen that come up load. But the only reason I think is
- 39:21because, however, like the last few projects we've worked on, I
- 39:27think that's probably been a bit more like the agencies are quite
- 39:31familiar. I think the agencies talk a bit
- 39:34about that. But I think most of the projects
- 39:36we've done, the focus has been really on the front end of the
- 39:40site. And it's more about
- 39:42demonstrating like the quality of the front end experience and
- 39:47from an AI perspective, maybe more around kind of how they
- 39:50prototype, how they can, you know, like illustrate how
- 39:56different photography could work and like create kind of it's
- 40:00more, I would say it's more basically where I've seen
- 40:03agencies talk around AI, it's been more the design and
- 40:07creative side. But that being said, I think,
- 40:10like I said, I just don't think I've worked with a brand, but
- 40:13there's been like an RFP of like kind of new, complete the new
- 40:17agencies for quite a while. It feels like we've had, there's
- 40:20been a lot of familiarity between, you know, agencies.
- 40:24Stakeholders and stuff. So it's not been like completely
- 40:27not new for a while. But yeah, I think that's, I do
- 40:30agree though, there's a lot of value that can be, there's a lot
- 40:35of value there. And I think that is something
- 40:37that agents who should be leaning into.
- 40:40Then you see on LinkedIn, like you see agencies talking about
- 40:42how they're using AI in different areas.
- 40:44And to be honest that that creative side, I have definitely
- 40:47seen some really cool stuff that I recently saw something where
- 40:51someone basically showed a completely different art
- 40:54direction leading with photography using AI and it
- 40:58just, it did literally cool. And being able to show that that
- 41:00is just layers, you know, communicate in something in a
- 41:05much better way. So yeah, I think it's
- 41:08interesting. And I think we'll probably see,
- 41:10I think vendors and AI is like the first question that comes up
- 41:14now like in terms of like software.
- 41:16But I think agencies, I think we'll see that more and more
- 41:19and. Yes, indeed.
- 41:21So let's, let's wrap this up on our we love doing these kind of
- 41:25like rambling episodes with a loose structure talking about
- 41:28what we're seeing at how things are changing.
- 41:30But I think in my summary would be there there there's an
- 41:33approach shift from like Big Bang relaunches to a bit more
- 41:37like modular incremental. Getting speed to market is
- 41:40important to get into market light, but being able to roll
- 41:43stuff out quicker afterwards, we are seeing technology shift and
- 41:48composability is definitely the leading strategy going forward,
- 41:51whatever that means. And in terms of like the text
- 41:55act that's built out. But as a strategic approach,
- 41:58that is fundamentally the right one because it's about
- 42:01flexibility in your text stack. And then we talked about the
- 42:05fact that discovery is timelines and projects might be shrinking,
- 42:10but in some cases more time is being spent in discovery because
- 42:13of that to get into more detail, to have a better stronger spec
- 42:16before you hit bill phase. I guess those are the overall
- 42:18summaries. Anything else you want to add to
- 42:20that? Don't think so.
- 42:22No, I think that's a good, I think that's a good summary.
- 42:25And I think, yeah, we covered loads of interesting points.
- 42:28So I think, yeah, as we kind of pointed out all the way through,
- 42:31I think just quite a few areas are getting simplified now and
- 42:34the areas where you can add value and yeah, just more
- 42:38important and there's more room to, yeah, kind of bring that
- 42:41value in those areas. Yeah, I think this is it, adding
- 42:44value, focusing on where you add value and where you spend your
- 42:47money. Well, that brings us to end.
- 42:49I hope people have enjoyed listening.
- 42:51Anything that Peter interests you want to chat to us about, do
- 42:53reach out. Anything where you think we
- 42:54talked to us a nonsense, do challenges on it.
- 42:57We always love to be challenged. Until next week, everyone.
- 43:01You're listening to the Inside Comments podcast, hosted by
- 43:03experienced consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers.
- 43:06Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 43:09featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 43:12industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 43:14explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 43:17and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 43:19really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 43:22to help fine tune your e-commerce strategy and text.
- 43:25Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 43:28like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 43:30We hope you enjoy the latest episode.