Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Chaos in Court: Overturned Contempt Conviction and Medical Negligence Explored
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment with Michael Mulligan, Barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers, legally Speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Morning, Michael, how are you doing?
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning,
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: And some interesting items on the agenda.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: This week.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: We start with a conviction and a one-year sentence for contempt of court overturned on appeal.
- 0:19Adam Stirling: What is contempt of court itself?
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: Well, this particular form of contempt of court itself.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: Well, this particular form of contempt of court is different from some that we've seen in the news not too long ago.
- 0:30Michael Mulligan: There is a form of contempt of court that we've seen play out, for example, with the trials of people alleged to have breached Supreme Court injunctions telling them to do things like don't block the logging road where there would be a trial and determination about whether the person is guilty of breaching a court order.
- 0:50Michael Mulligan: This particular case deals with a different form of contempt and when it's described sometimes it's described as infaci, but that's just sort of Latin for in the face of the court, and the idea is a contempt finding for doing something right there in the courtroom, not contrary to some order that was made.
- 1:10Michael Mulligan: And the background of this particular case is this fellow who refers to himself as a man known as Carmen Hardy, and he's one of these group of people.
- 1:22Michael Mulligan: They have various terms.
- 1:24Michael Mulligan: They've come up with free men on the land, or sovereign men, or sovereign citizens, and it's become a bit of a problematic cadre of people that the courts and others have had to deal with in British Columbia, all these people with these just completely cockeyed, harebrained ideas about how the legal system works, have been referred to as a group of people that are engaged in sort of like an organized or a type of sort of pseudo-organized, pseudo-legal commercial argument litigants how the courts have described them, because they go by various different names, so OPCA litigants and I must say this particular case is not exactly an advertisement, as the province tries to persuade people to sign up to become a provincial court judge, and it was this poor provincial court judge who was hearing a trial of one of these people who was charged with a breach of the COVID restrictions for refusing to wear a mask in a liquor store back in 2021.
- 2:37Michael Mulligan: And then the police showing up to deal with them and allegedly getting in some kind of a scuffle with the police, resulting in, ultimately, obstruction charges.
- 2:47Michael Mulligan: And so the judge was trying to hear the trial of this guy charged with obstructing a peace officer for trying to give him a ticket or do something about not wearing a mask in a liquor store.
- 2:58Michael Mulligan: That was the essential background, and this fellow, being one of these characters, started with the day before the trial, trying to file a whole bunch of material with these kind of pseudo-legal arguments and one of the, I should say just a bit of a tangent.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: These people have all these pseudo-crazy legal arguments, but they seem to put real stock on things like stamps and seals, and so there's this whole trend of these people trying to show up in front of notaries and trying to assist on things being notarized and how that's making them Anyways.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: You can just imagine what that looks like, right, some poor notary in some little community and some person is in there insisting that you put their stamp on some page of nonsense, and then the person thinks that the page of nonsense has some meaning.
- 3:44Michael Mulligan: Anyway, it's one of these guys.
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: So he files all this stuff, and then the judge at the commencement of the trial tells the guy sorry, no, there is zero chance of any of these things that you filed having any success.
- 3:58Michael Mulligan: We're not going to hear any arguments about your stack of pseudo legal arguments.
- 4:03Michael Mulligan: And the man just doesn't want to accept that.
- 4:08Michael Mulligan: He refers to himself as a man known as Carmen Hardy, not Carmen Hardy.
- 4:13Michael Mulligan: And eventually this discussion goes on where the judge eventually tells the man known as Carmen Hardy, tells him one more word and I'm going to hold you in contempt.
- 4:21Michael Mulligan: And the man just wouldn't stop interrupting the judge and talking.
- 4:25Michael Mulligan: And eventually the judge just has had enough of this guy and tells the sheriff to take him into custody.
- 4:31Michael Mulligan: And so he's taken out into custody in cells and they let him sit there for a bit.
- 4:38Michael Mulligan: They bring him back up and the judge tells the guy, look, if you apologize for it, we'll be able to just move on.
- 4:43Michael Mulligan: And the guy just won't do it and just won't take the hint and just persists in making these completely harebrained arguments.
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: The judge, having been interrupted again and again, sends the man okay, we're going to get going on the trial sends the man down into cells and hooks him up by a video connection so he can't talk and interrupt what's going on.
- 5:02Michael Mulligan: The man is sitting down there facing away from the camera with his fingers in his ears, not listening to anything that's going on.
- 5:10Michael Mulligan: The case gets adjourned.
- 5:12Michael Mulligan: The judge tries doing things, including appointing an amicus, like a lawyer, to come in and try to sort of make arguments to ensure that there's a fair hearing on this obstruction charge, which is what the judge is trying to deal with.
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: All of that's not working.
- 5:26Michael Mulligan: The man just won't be quiet.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: He's, you know, will not respond to things.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: You will not listen.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: All of this.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: And then eventually the judge finds the man to be in contempt, and again it's this kind of contempt for like contempt in the face of the court.
- 5:42Michael Mulligan: You know, just won't be quiet, we'll just keep interrupting things, keeps talking nonsense, and the judge convicts him and sentences him to one year in prison, and so that decision is what wound up just before the court of appeal.
- 5:59Michael Mulligan: The man served two months in jail 60 days I guess, before getting released on bail.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: And then there's an appeal about whether the judge should have found the man in contempt in the face of the court in the way that the judge did.
- 6:16Michael Mulligan: And indeed that power exists and the Supreme Court of Canada has made reference to it.
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: It's a little obscure when you read it in the criminal code.
- 6:24Michael Mulligan: It talks about in there and sort of the power to appeal from a contempt finding.
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: And part of the idea here is that sort of an inherent jurisdiction of the court in the sense that it has to have some capacity to control its process.
- 6:38Michael Mulligan: Right, you can't have a trial if somebody could just come in and begin, you know, screaming at everyone, you know whatever it's just you can't.
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: That just wouldn't work.
- 6:47Michael Mulligan: So it's necessary for a judge to be able to control the courtroom, to sort of make the system function.
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada said, yes, indeed this power does exist.
- 6:58Michael Mulligan: But the Supreme Court of Canada has also said that this sort of idea of like this sort of instant conviction or the conviction and the finding of contempt and then the judge convicting the person sentencing them, they said, should only be used, in their languages, urgent and imperative circumstances where a judge must act immediately, heritive circumstances where a judge must act immediately.
- 7:24Michael Mulligan: And so it is also clear that it's an error of law to use this sort of instant contempt procedure.
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: And I should say, in fairness, it was not as if the judge did this instantly, it was after like a couple of days of this conduct that eventually the judge just had enough and convicted and sentenced the man.
- 7:39Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeals said, no doubt the judge was frustrated, that's probably an understatement, but found in this case, and I should say in fairness, the Crown agreed that it shouldn't have been done in the way that it was done here.
- 7:52Michael Mulligan: It said, first of all the judge should have explained more carefully the nature of the contempt although a little hard to do when somebody is not listening, with their fingers in their ears and looking the other way should have explained that the result of the contempt could be a jail sentence Again a little tough to do with a person who won't listen.
- 8:09Michael Mulligan: And he also said the judge should have considered other remedies.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: And the one pointed out, and in fairness, there is this section.
- 8:17Michael Mulligan: There's a specific section of the criminal code section 650, which provides for exceptions from the general proposition that most people would understand, which is, you know an accused person which should be in the courtroom.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: You know they're having a trial.
- 8:31Michael Mulligan: That seems kind of basic, but there is specific authority to have an accused person removed and kept out of the courtroom where they are engaged in misconduct, by interrupting the proceedings so that the proceedings can continue where it would not feasible to keep the person in the courtroom.
- 8:48Michael Mulligan: There are a few other provisions where you can excuse somebody, like, for example, there's a specific one where you're having a hearing into the mental fitness of a person to stand trial, having a hearing into the mental fitness of a person to stand trial and the judge is satisfied that not doing so, like not excusing the person from the courtroom might adversely affect the medical condition of the accused.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: So you can imagine some circumstance where there's some really sensitive things being discussed about a person's mental health, where a doctor says hey, if this person hears what's going on, it's going to make them worse, for example.
- 9:18Michael Mulligan: There are a few other specific examples.
- 9:20Michael Mulligan: But here the judge could have just said look, you just cannot control yourself, you will not listen.
- 9:25Michael Mulligan: The judge could have just ordered him into cells and carried on, or just told him get out of the courtroom and carried on, I suppose.
- 9:33Michael Mulligan: And furthermore, the Court of Appeals said the judge should have told him, reminded him about his right to counsel, but again, in fairness, pointed out that multiple times it was suggested to the man that he should get a lawyer and he didn't want to listen to that either.
- 9:46Michael Mulligan: And so, while this power exists and while there's no doubt this man was engaged in contemptuous conduct, the Court of Appeal found that there should have been some additional sort of procedural steps and protections followed, because a finding of contempt or a charge of contempt is just like a criminal charge in and of itself right, and we have some basic rules that would surround rules of fairness, that would surround trying and convicting somebody.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: And here they found that a new trial needed to be ordered, but interestingly the Crown was of the view that it was not necessary to conduct another trial and they made that clear.
- 10:22Michael Mulligan: They said they would be directing a stay of proceedings.
- 10:25Michael Mulligan: Probably that is taking into account the fact that the man served two months in jail already for what he's done.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: So hopefully he's learned his lesson and will pass that along to other people engaged in organized, pseudo-legal commercial arguments.
- 10:39Michael Mulligan: They are not going to work and if you engage in them you may wind up with all kinds of things, including being held in contempt.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: Courts have also done things to get the stuff under control, like ordering full costs, like paying the full costs of other people that are impacted by what these people are doing, ordering these people to pay security for costs before they can proceed so that if they lose, as they inevitably will, there'll be money there to pay the other side imposing aggravated damages.
- 11:07Michael Mulligan: So anyways, the courts will get it under control.
- 11:09Michael Mulligan: But it's an interesting example, because it's a rare use of this power and an example of what happens.
- 11:17Michael Mulligan: If you just won't take the hint and be quiet in court, you might find yourself ultimately with a very long sentence or the judge using that section 650 and just putting you into cells and carrying on with your trial.
- 11:29Michael Mulligan: You're not going to prevent your trial from happening by filing a bunch of nonsense and continuing to talk over the judge.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: That will not work, and so that's the latest from the Court of Appeal on the free men on the land.
- 11:42Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Legally Speaking.
- 11:44Adam Stirling: We'll take a quick break and we'll return right after this.
- 11:46Adam Stirling: All right back on the air here at CFAX 1070.
- 11:49Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, as we continue with Legally Speaking Fresh off a contempt of court case onto a medical negligence claim A broken needle in the back does that say here that sounds painful, what happened?
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: indeed it sounds painful and I must say, reading some of these things, you sort of realize medical things that you never even thought of could go wrong do indeed go wrong, apparently with some frequency.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: But it's a case that demonstrates that not every medical you know unfortunate event is going to result in a successful legal claim.
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: And so this, the fact pattern of this one, was a woman who was giving birth to her first child and she was in no doubt discomfort, and the first thing they tried were providing her intravenous oxycontin which I must say that's some negative and concerning elements, given what we see on Pandora every day in Victoria.
- 12:47Michael Mulligan: But they tried that that wasn't enough, and so an anesthesiologist was brought in to administer a obstetric epidural, which is an injection into your back to reduce pain, and so you have to get stuck with this needle and the doctor administering that.
- 13:06Michael Mulligan: It didn't work.
- 13:07Michael Mulligan: The first time it struck a blood vessel, and then the doctor tried again in a different location and very unfortunately and this is the thing I didn't even realize could happen in life the tip of the needle broke off, which then led to just an awful sounding process it took about half an hour where they had to surgically remove the tip of the needle from this poor woman's back, and so they got it out.
- 13:31Michael Mulligan: And then, after all of this, the woman alleged that ever since she suffered from back pain, that ever since she suffered from back pain, and so she sued the doctor that tried to administer this epidural.
- 13:49Michael Mulligan: And with that background, the important thing to know here is sort of what is necessary to succeed in a medical negligence claim, and it's very similar to other kind of negligence claims somebody might make.
- 13:58Michael Mulligan: And so the first element is you need to show that the person you're suing owed you a duty of care.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: Right, and a doctor performing a medical procedure on you would owe you a duty of care.
- 14:08Michael Mulligan: So, yeah, tick.
- 14:09Michael Mulligan: Then you have to show that the doctor breached the applicable standard of care.
- 14:15Michael Mulligan: Right, and the standard of care is not perfect, perfection, right.
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: Like when you have a medical procedure, you don't have a guarantee that it's going to work out for you.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: Sometimes needles will break off or other bad things will happen, and so what you would look for there is you look, you know sort of what standard of care would be expected of a reasonably competent, you know doctor performing this sort of procedure.
- 14:36Michael Mulligan: Then, if you get over that threshold.
- 14:39Michael Mulligan: You have to show that if there was a breach of that standard of care, that the person suffered loss like damages, and then you have to show that the damage was caused by the breach of the standard of care.
- 14:51Michael Mulligan: Those would all be the elements.
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: Here called other people who were medical doctors, who were specialized in doing this work, to provide expert evidence to the court about, well, what is expected you know what is the standard of care, and the two doctors that were called had different opinions about whether what was done here met the standard of care.
- 15:20Michael Mulligan: But ultimately the judge found that on all of the evidence, even though this was obviously a very unfortunate event, the plaintiff had not proven that the doctor administering the needle had reached what their standard of care was.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: And again, not everything works out right, and so the other interesting thing here is that there was a at least anecdotal report from a person who was the head of the Department of Anesthesiology in Victoria who described numerous experiences with epidermal needles from the same manufacturer being quote overly ductile close, quote, close, quote and that a higher than normal incidence of bent or deformed needle tips had been occurring.
- 16:09Michael Mulligan: All of which is very worrisome, but ultimately here, the judge found that the plaintiff had not met the required their burden, and it's the person's burden who's doing the suing right to prove these things.
- 16:23Michael Mulligan: Yeah, uh, they just hadn't established that the doctor doing this, even though it went wrong.
- 16:27Michael Mulligan: I had failed to live up to the required standard of care, and so the result was the claim was dismissed, and so that's the uh salacious from medical.
- 16:38Adam Stirling: On the medical negligence file all right, and I think our last one.
- 16:42Adam Stirling: It's police wanting to keep things they seize for longer than three months without a charge and the permission that's required to do that.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: So what's going on is this the police, as most people would understand, are permitted to seize exhibits or evidence in a case.
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: Right, like if the police run down and tackle the alleged bank robber and they've got a gun in their pocket and a mask on their head.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: The police could take those things right.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: Most people, of course they can right, and the of course you can also carries on to keeping those things, assuming the person is charged with an offense like robbery.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: Right, the police do need to fill out and file with the court a report indicating the things that they've seized, either in an investigation or through a search warrant.
- 17:32Michael Mulligan: But if a person's charged, that's fine.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: Those things which are evidence in the case can be kept until the case is done and the appeal period would be over.
- 17:40Michael Mulligan: Most people would think, well, yes, of course they can right, yeah, where it gets a little messy is when the police sees things but they do not charge.
- 17:48Michael Mulligan: Somebody is not charged.
- 17:50Michael Mulligan: And then the question is well, how long can they just hang on to stuff for right?
- 17:53Michael Mulligan: Not forever, happily, right.
- 17:56Michael Mulligan: We don't want to live in that world.
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: And so there's a whole scheme in the criminal code.
- 18:01Michael Mulligan: It's under section 4, 490 that deals with.
- 18:04Michael Mulligan: Well what happens when the police see stuff and they don't, nobody's charged and they have to file a report about it.
- 18:09Michael Mulligan: But if they want to keep the stuff they've taken and they want to keep it for longer than three months, they need to ask for permission.
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: Permission and that permission comes in the form of making an application either in provincial court and they are often heard by a justice of the peace or judicial justice or ultimately, if they're contested, they can be heard by a provincial court judge.
- 18:31Michael Mulligan: And the provincial court judge or justice has authority to allow the police to keep things longer, up to a year.
- 18:40Michael Mulligan: If it's longer than that and there still is no charge, then the police would need to apply to a Supreme Court judge where there's some authority to keep stuff even longer.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: Now here's the rub in this particular case that or at least from their perspective, under Section 490, it says very clearly that the police can apply to keep things longer than three months from the date of seizure.
- 19:05Michael Mulligan: But when they're applying they need to give the person three clear days notice.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: So they need to tell the person from whom they took the stuff.
- 19:16Michael Mulligan: We want to keep it longer and that's so that the person could show up and object to it.
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: Right, and that's so that the person could show up and object to it, right.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: Hey, you shouldn't just get to keep my gold bars or my computer or my gun or whatever you took.
- 19:28Michael Mulligan: You haven't charged me and the idea here is that the courts will sort of supervise what police are doing.
- 19:35Michael Mulligan: You don't want police just scooping up a bunch of people's things and keeping them forever.
- 19:38Michael Mulligan: That's not on now.
- 19:40Michael Mulligan: The issue here, what the police were asking for, is that in this particular case they said that and I should say the judge intentionally didn't provide the details of this, but they said that the police said that telling the person from whom this case was, electronic devices were seized would interfere with the investigation, because some of the people being investigated were not aware of the investigation and the police wanted to engage in what they described as quote non-conventional investigative techniques, whatever that might be Something taking longer than three months.
- 20:15Michael Mulligan: So the police argued that we don't want to have to tell the person that we took these electronic devices from, that we're applying to keep them because it might tip them off to something and interfere with our non-conventional investigative techniques.
- 20:30Michael Mulligan: And so the issue for the judge is.
- 20:32Michael Mulligan: The section says very clearly that the application can be made after three clear days' notice and the argument the police were making is this argument of statutory interpretation, referred to sometimes as necessary implication, the idea that you know if you say you could do X and you just have to do Y to do X.
- 20:52Michael Mulligan: Parliament must have intended that that be permitted and so that's the argument they made and in fact there have been some judges who have found that there is some authority to do that.
- 21:05Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, and it's controversial is not all the judges have agreed on it, but in the Supreme Court, where police are trying to keep things for longer than a year, where they have to go to Supreme Court, there is a decision that some judges have followed saying that the BC Supreme Court has inherent jurisdiction to dispense with the idea of providing notice.
- 21:27Michael Mulligan: And that's the concept there is that superior court judges do have inherent jurisdiction to do things which are not found in legislation anywhere.
- 21:35Michael Mulligan: That is not the case for provincial court judges.
- 21:37Michael Mulligan: Provincial court judges, all of their authority must be found in statute and here the provincial court judge deciding this application found that this was not a circumstance whereby necessary implication they should have some authority to not tell the person that their stuff, that police are trying to keep their stuff longer.
- 21:55Michael Mulligan: Because in this case there is clear statutory language saying what has to happen and there just isn't a basis to say well, I'm going to interpret that to mean the exact opposite of what it says.
- 22:06Michael Mulligan: And they distinguish, for example, a case where a judge decided that they could go ahead with the hearing where a person hadn't been served, but in that case it was because police made every effort to serve the person who was evading service of the notice, saying they wanted to keep the stuff longer.
- 22:21Michael Mulligan: So that was an example.
- 22:23Michael Mulligan: The judge said okay, you know, it cannot be that the Parliament intended that they cannot make the application to keep the stuff, that the person just avoids receiving the piece of paper.
- 22:32Michael Mulligan: You know you can't hide somewhere and then stop the police from keeping your mask and gun right.
- 22:39Michael Mulligan: But this case, there's clear and unequivocal language and the judge said look, look, that has to be changed, that's for parliament.
- 22:44Michael Mulligan: I cannot say you didn't think about this, you thought about it.
- 22:47Michael Mulligan: You said it must be three days, you must give notice, and so if it has to be changed don't look at me, I'm just a provincial court judge go talk to parliament, uh, and so that is the state of affairs, notice has to be given, uh, and that's what that concept of necessary implication is and why it didn't work here to let the police do this without telling the person.
- 23:05Michael Mulligan: So $4.90.
- 23:06Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 23:11Adam Stirling: Thank you so much as always.
- 23:12Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 23:13Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 23:13Adam Stirling: All right, we'll take a quick break Back right after this.