Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Power of Apologies
Transcript
- 0:03Good morning, everyone. I'm Bob Cohen, and I'm
- 0:06co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:09ADR section together with my co -chair, Jeff
- 0:11Kravitz, who's not here this morning. He's out
- 0:13of the country. But I'm pleased to introduce
- 0:16to you Sidney Kanazawa, who I've known for about
- 0:18five years now. He is a consummate mediator.
- 0:23He's been really successful at everything he's
- 0:25done in his life. I'm not going to embarrass
- 0:28him and tell him about the awards or positions
- 0:31that I know he has held. I know he's on the board
- 0:34of directors of SCMA, I believe. He teaches at
- 0:37Pepperdine University, and he was a very successful
- 0:42big law trial lawyer for many, many years. But
- 0:45he has now switched his focus to mediation. And
- 0:48he said to me earlier this morning, as we were
- 0:51talking, he finally feels like mediation is what
- 0:56he set out to do when he first went to law school
- 0:58at USC. And I align with that, and I'm sure you
- 1:02do too. And he loves the process of making people
- 1:10appreciate each other, be kind, come to an agreement
- 1:15and move on with their lives. And he's a very
- 1:17deep thinker. He wasn't on Law Review at SC,
- 1:21but I told him I thought he was. because he has
- 1:24a great command of the law and of studies and
- 1:29histories and facts. And today we're going to
- 1:32talk about a subject that is very dear to my
- 1:34heart. It's about apologies and apology, forgiveness
- 1:39and reconciliation is the title of this program.
- 1:42And he actually teaches a course at Pepperdine
- 1:45on that, started by Professor Peter Robinson,
- 1:49who was the inspiration behind that course at
- 1:53Pepperdine and taught it for many, many years.
- 1:55And he's taken over, and he is the right guy
- 1:57to be teaching this for everyone I know. So anyway,
- 2:00we'll get right on with the program. And I want
- 2:03this to be a really interactive program. It's
- 2:05going to be very free flowing. Sidney and I had
- 2:10a discussion this morning. We've had many different
- 2:12discussions over the years. And I think the whole
- 2:14idea of apology is so instrumental. in trust
- 2:20building and in the mediation process. And Sydney,
- 2:23I'm just going to turn it over to you now. Let's
- 2:25start talking. Why are apologies important in
- 2:28mediation and in life? Apologies, I think, are
- 2:35an opening to a dialogue and an opening to building
- 2:41trust. And so I think we're reluctant to apologize.
- 2:50And I think that reluctance comes from the Western
- 2:56philosophy that is the basis of our legal system.
- 3:00I was telling Bob earlier that during this course,
- 3:06this is the second time I'm teaching the course,
- 3:09I had a guy come in, Michael Hawash. who talked
- 3:14about the going to the battlefields in Russia
- 3:19and Ukraine and all those areas to learn about
- 3:22the history of war in that area. And he was going
- 3:27there several times after Gorbachev opened up
- 3:30the Soviet Union. And he stopped going there
- 3:35when Putin started to come into power because
- 3:38they were restricting their ability to get access
- 3:41to information and talk to people and all that.
- 3:45And so he went to Vietnam to take these group
- 3:51of scholars to study war and battlefields and
- 3:58talk to the soldiers and different people that
- 4:01were involved. And he tells his story about how
- 4:06he was sitting in front of a lake. And a little
- 4:10boy came down and sat next to him and started
- 4:14asking him questions about his country. And he
- 4:18started asking him questions about himself and
- 4:23all of that. And he fully expected that this
- 4:26would lead to the little boy asking him for money
- 4:29or for something or just selling him something.
- 4:31But he never did. And he realized in all of his
- 4:37discussions in Vietnam that the atrocities in
- 4:42Vietnam were as great as the atrocities in the
- 4:46Eastern Front during World War II. But the Russians
- 4:52and the people that were involved there had this
- 4:57attitude of a grievance because they were not
- 5:00appreciated for how much they sacrificed to win
- 5:04World War II. By contrast, in Vietnam, the people
- 5:11there were looking forward. And they concede
- 5:16that it was a horrible time during what they
- 5:18call the American War. But they were looking
- 5:28forward and trying to repair relations and going
- 5:32forward. It dawned on him that this perspective,
- 5:38the perspective of looking backwards versus the
- 5:41perspective of looking forward was really a difference
- 5:45in the way that the Russians perceived their
- 5:49role and where they were stuck in the past and
- 5:54where Vietnam was in terms of being in the present
- 5:58and looking forward. Kind of like keeping score.
- 6:02Yeah. And that made me think about why we find
- 6:08it so difficult to apologize. And this is not
- 6:13a form thought yet. I'm still working on thinking
- 6:17about it. But it dawned on me that in the Western
- 6:21philosophy, we have a philosophy of one way,
- 6:26one truth, one God. And on the Eastern philosophy,
- 6:30it is more about many roads to the top of the
- 6:34mountain. And it's about the relationship that
- 6:37we have with each other in moving forward through
- 6:41life. It's an appreciation of change. And there's
- 6:46constant references in Eastern philosophy about
- 6:49how we evolve and change and go from a bud to
- 6:53a flower to dropping off the trees and the like.
- 6:58this perspective is very, very different. But
- 7:02the more I thought about it, I realized that
- 7:06we all are really the same. And that although
- 7:10in the Western philosophy, we believe that there
- 7:13is one objective truth. And therefore, it becomes
- 7:17hard to say, I'm sorry, because it's like conceding
- 7:20that I'm wrong or I'm at fault is the way that
- 7:23people think of it. And the reason that that
- 7:28occurs is because of this philosophy about a
- 7:31static truth, a static one way that we have to
- 7:37think about things. And in reality, though, in
- 7:44terms of our jurisprudence, we don't really find
- 7:49that one truth. We settle 98 to 99 percent of
- 7:53the cases without finding that one truth. We
- 7:56allow juries to decide nine three so that three
- 8:00people disagree with whatever the rest of the
- 8:03jury decided. We agree with a Supreme Court that
- 8:06decides five four so that there's basically four
- 8:09people that don't agree with what the other five
- 8:13have said. And so in reality, we acknowledge
- 8:19in some ways that we have different ways of looking
- 8:23at the world and that there is no one truth.
- 8:27And there's no one perspective. I mean, one of
- 8:29the most famous films is Rashomon, and it's about,
- 8:34you know, taking one incident and showing that
- 8:39incident in different perspectives, that everybody
- 8:42had a different memory and recollection about
- 8:44what happened in the same incident that occurred.
- 8:48And we recognize this in our trial work as well,
- 8:52that people have different perspectives depending
- 8:54on where they're standing. But it's also based
- 8:58on our own biases. And our biases come from where
- 9:02we were born, where we grew up, you know, the
- 9:06friends that we had, the families that we had.
- 9:09I mean, all kinds of things affect how we see
- 9:13the world. And as a result, apologies are kind
- 9:18of a way of of acknowledging, you know, we're
- 9:21all in this together and we're all imperfect
- 9:24and we all deserve some amount of grace and we
- 9:29all need to find a way that we can trust each
- 9:33other because it's a very lonely world if we
- 9:35can't trust each other and one of the greatest
- 9:39skills or inherent abilities of human beings
- 9:46is that we can get together. we can come together
- 9:49and form alliances and work together toward building
- 9:53bigger things. And that's what apologies kind
- 9:57of opened the door to is how do we work together?
- 10:01Oh, so, Sid, the reason why I reached out to
- 10:04you was because a few months ago, and this is
- 10:07not just then, but it's trying not to be political,
- 10:11but Trump said some very horrible things about
- 10:13some people that died. He was wrong and he would
- 10:16never apologize. And I was thinking, you know,
- 10:19it's more than just Trump. There's something
- 10:22involved in our culture. What's the difference
- 10:24between our culture, the American culture and
- 10:27apologies and say Japan or Asian cultures with
- 10:32regards to apology? And how does that impact
- 10:34the people? You know, I never thought about it
- 10:36too much as I started teaching this class. You
- 10:41know, in Japan, executives apologize all the
- 10:46time for all kinds of things that they had nothing
- 10:48to do with. And so if a plane crashes, the president
- 10:54will apologize on behalf of the company and go
- 10:57to the families and apologize to the families
- 11:01for the loss of their loved one. And they don't
- 11:06think of it in terms of that someone's at fault
- 11:09or anything like that. It's more a sign of respect,
- 11:14of acknowledging the harm and loss that someone
- 11:18else has suffered, empathy for that person. And
- 11:24there is a concept called procedural justice,
- 11:30which Tom Tyler has written about, and he said
- 11:35Yale. And basically, the concept of pursuit to
- 11:40justice is that if you have four elements, if
- 11:44you give people voice, if you give them respect
- 11:48and dignity, if you give them a neutral set of
- 11:52rules that is not affected by people's whims,
- 11:58and if you have trust worthy people administrating
- 12:02those rules. People will abide by the decisions
- 12:07regardless of whether they're in their favor
- 12:10or not. And it's because those four elements,
- 12:13if you have them, people feel that they've been
- 12:18treated fairly. And that allows us to live together
- 12:23without killing each other without fighting all
- 12:26the time and working together towards some greater
- 12:30purpose. And so this concept of apologizing in
- 12:36the Eastern area and being reluctant to do it
- 12:41on the Western side is, I think, clouded by this
- 12:46philosophy of one way, one truth, one... one
- 12:49God, and that we need to kind of appreciate that
- 12:53we all see things a little bit differently, that
- 12:55we're all imperfect. In fact, it's in our Constitution,
- 12:59and ironically we don't appreciate it. that we
- 13:02are attempting to form a more perfect union.
- 13:08It assumes our imperfection. And so it is part
- 13:13of our foundation. And I think our founding fathers
- 13:16actually appreciated this by keeping religion
- 13:19out of the governance and separating church and
- 13:25state and the like. It appreciates that we have
- 13:30different perspectives and works to try to set
- 13:34up systems in which our different perspectives
- 13:36can work together as opposed to against each
- 13:39other. Sid, let's go back to your class. Tell
- 13:43us about the key elements of your course. I assume
- 13:46it goes for a semester. And tell us some of the
- 13:50stories and situations you've come across from
- 13:52your students. I'd like to hear about those.
- 13:55I think everybody would. Well, it's hard to capitalize
- 14:02what we talk about in the class. But it's a class
- 14:06about imperfection. It's a class about building
- 14:10trust. And it's a class about trying to find
- 14:15ways in which we can acknowledge a common set
- 14:19of values that we all live by. apologies and
- 14:26forgiveness and reconciliation is to acknowledge
- 14:29what we have in common. And we do it in different
- 14:35ways, and I think that the class kind of talks
- 14:39about the different kinds of apologies and how
- 14:43forgiveness allows us to be unshackled from the
- 14:46past and how reconciliation requires a tremendous
- 14:50amount of acknowledgement by both sides and that
- 14:54there is these concepts about restorative justice
- 15:00where we start to think about what we were thinking
- 15:06when we caused the harm. and on the other side,
- 15:10how that harm has caused what is done to us.
- 15:15And they're incredible stories about how people
- 15:19have reconciled over time. And these stories
- 15:25range from, you know, sons being killed and the
- 15:32father of the son embracing and adopting the
- 15:37killer. And there's stories of people who have
- 15:43found ways in which to not only forgive, but
- 15:46to embrace those who have caused harm to their
- 15:50families. And it's just, it's a very rich area.
- 15:56And probably the most important concept is this
- 16:02concept called moral elevation. And the idea
- 16:06is that what we do inspires others to do the
- 16:11same thing. It's like in Hawaii, we have this
- 16:13concept called aloha. And traditionally, it's
- 16:18thought of as being giving without expectation
- 16:20of return. And then I realize that's not true.
- 16:25We don't give without an expectation of return.
- 16:27We give, not expecting something right back,
- 16:32but we give with an expectation that people will
- 16:36appreciate our giving, that they will appreciate
- 16:40that giving and will be inspired to give to others,
- 16:44and that that's what creates that culture of
- 16:47aloha, is to give without expectation of return
- 16:50and to expect others to appreciate that and give
- 16:54on. So a corollary would be not only to give
- 17:00without hesitation, but even to forget, to apologize
- 17:04without hesitation. That's right. And one of
- 17:07the most dramatic examples of this is a few years
- 17:12ago when a white man sat in a black church Bible
- 17:17study in South Carolina and sat there for an
- 17:21hour with them. and put out a gun and killed
- 17:25nine of the parishioners hoping to start a race
- 17:28war. And he was caught the next day and he was
- 17:32brought to a bond hearing. And one of the sisters
- 17:35and several of the relatives of the people that
- 17:38were killed the night before forgave him. You
- 17:42know, they forgave him out of a religious belief
- 17:45that is their their goal to forgive. And and
- 17:51that that amazing grace that they displayed by
- 17:57forgiving the day after this man killed their
- 18:01relative. Eventually, in a couple of weeks, caused
- 18:06the state legislature and governor of South Carolina
- 18:11to take down the Confederate flag and to remove
- 18:14the Confederate monuments from the state grounds.
- 18:20people that forgave, the family members that
- 18:22forgave, they didn't ask for this. They didn't
- 18:24expect it. But there was kind of a moral elevation
- 18:31that took place that basically compelled the
- 18:35legislature and the governor to feel compelled.
- 18:39Even though this had been a controversial issue
- 18:41for years and years and years, they felt compelled
- 18:45to take down the flag and to remove the Confederate
- 18:48monuments. So there are further impacts from
- 18:52the actions of apologies and forgiveness and
- 18:55all of that, and that's very interesting. And
- 19:00it would seem to me that, I'd like you to comment
- 19:02on this, apologizing and forgiveness is a part
- 19:07of doing grace in society. How do you feel about
- 19:09that? That act of grace that we give each other
- 19:19is an act of respect and acknowledgement of the
- 19:25dignity of the other person. So no, I agree.
- 19:29But so why do we have such trouble here in America
- 19:32with especially the youth? I think at least that's
- 19:35been my experience. They just cannot say they're
- 19:37sorry. I found that with employees. I found that
- 19:40with other people where they've made huge mistakes.
- 19:44done things that have hurt others and they will
- 19:46not even for one moment say I'm sorry and I once
- 19:50had an employee do something that was terrible
- 19:52and impacted this medical office with regards
- 19:55to discovery I was doing got everybody upset
- 19:59and they just were besides themselves and I explained
- 20:02it to her and I said well how do you what do
- 20:05you think about that she goes okay I said well
- 20:09don't you feel sorry and she said let's move
- 20:12on. That was your comment. Let's move on. Well,
- 20:16I think it's a reflection of our feeling that
- 20:26to apologize is to show weakness. To apologize
- 20:30is to... uh to admit fault to apologize is to
- 20:35somehow diminish your stature and and people
- 20:38who are confident are not as concerned about
- 20:42that but people who our feeling on the margins
- 20:45are very worried about that. When I first was
- 20:49going to teach this class, I asked everybody
- 20:52I could find for stories about apologies, forgiveness,
- 20:57and reconciliation. And one of the first guys
- 20:59that I asked was somebody who was shadowing me
- 21:02for mediation. I asked him and he said, well,
- 21:08yeah, I got a good story for you. And he says,
- 21:09I said, yeah, what was it? And he says, I committed
- 21:12malpractice. And I said, okay, I got to hear
- 21:14this story. It's a good one. And he told me that
- 21:18he had blown the statute of limitation and he
- 21:23went to his client and he apologized and he said,
- 21:25you know, I'm sorry about this whole thing and
- 21:28you can sue me. You can sue the insurance company.
- 21:30We can, you know, whatever it is, but I blew
- 21:32it. And I said, I apologize. And she felt badly
- 21:36that he had to apologize and had to do all these
- 21:39kinds of things. And they worked it out. And
- 21:44then she referred him a new client. You know,
- 21:48when you think about that, you think, how can
- 21:50that be? But you know, there's a mediator by
- 21:53the name of Sanaj who has this trust equation.
- 21:57He says trust equals and he has on the other
- 21:59side an equation, a fraction. And on the top
- 22:03of that fraction is credibility. You know, if
- 22:07you if you're credible, people trust you. Yes.
- 22:10Plus reliability. If you do what you say, people
- 22:14trust you. plus vulnerability. The more vulnerable
- 22:18you are, the more you put yourself out there
- 22:21and be vulnerable, the more people trust you.
- 22:24And on the bottom of that equation is self -concern.
- 22:28The more you're protecting yourself, the less
- 22:31people trust you. The more you try to look out
- 22:34for yourself and avoid any kind of... criticism
- 22:43and all that the more people less people trust
- 22:45you and and i've seen this over and over again
- 22:48where a realtor that i had Blue did not look
- 22:54at the paperwork when I was selling some land.
- 22:58So there wasn't addresses. There was only the
- 23:00tax key numbers. And the tax key numbers got
- 23:03transposed a little bit. I had several lots involved
- 23:06in this particular thing. And the buyer transposed
- 23:11the number at some point during the back and
- 23:13forth of all the paperwork. And they were going
- 23:16to buy a more valuable land at a lesser price.
- 23:21And so the realtor immediately called me up when
- 23:24they realized what the error was. They called
- 23:27me up and they told me what happened, and they
- 23:29apologized for messing up. And they offered to
- 23:33pay the difference between the price of the other
- 23:37property and the price of the one that they messed
- 23:42up on, they changed the numbers on and all that.
- 23:45And I listened to them and my reaction was, no.
- 23:49I'm not going to let you pay that difference
- 23:51because I suspected that the buyer knew exactly
- 23:54what they were doing. And they were trying to
- 23:57take advantage of this situation and take advantage
- 24:00of the mistake of the realtors that were involved
- 24:03in this transaction. So I said, no, I'm not going
- 24:05to do that. And I said, instead, we're going
- 24:08to You know, talk directly with the buyer and
- 24:10we're going to try to cancel this transaction.
- 24:13And we went through the whole process and eventually
- 24:16in a very quick mediation and all that, we got
- 24:19a resolution and there was a slight payment,
- 24:23but that payment was far, far less. And I said,
- 24:26OK, you can pay that that difference, you know,
- 24:28and all that. But but it made me not want to
- 24:33simply go along because of their. their honesty
- 24:37and their willingness to expose themselves to
- 24:41be vulnerable and to not be concerned about themselves
- 24:44but to be concerned about me and my well -being
- 24:47and all that. Yeah and I want to say two things.
- 24:50One, I'll align with that and I'll give you an
- 24:53example of myself from like 45 years ago when
- 24:55I was a baby lawyer and then I'd like us to open
- 24:58it up to everybody and see if they have questions
- 25:00or comments or thoughts because clearly this
- 25:03is an open -ended discussion. It's an issue that's
- 25:07so significant to our American society and so
- 25:11important in terms of understanding the mediation
- 25:14process. So about 45 years ago, I'd been practicing
- 25:17about five, six years, and I had done a commercial
- 25:22eviction of a small Chinese restaurant in the
- 25:24Wilshire area, and they never came back for their
- 25:28property. And I had a judgment, and I decided,
- 25:32well, let's have a sheriff's sale. Well, again,
- 25:35I was a baby lawyer and I stupidly didn't do
- 25:38a UCC one search to realize that the Bank of
- 25:40Toronto had a security interest in their cups
- 25:44and spoons and teapots and all of that. And so
- 25:49I got a call about a year later from the attorney
- 25:53in LA for the bank. And I realized that I had
- 25:58messed up. So the very first thing I did was
- 26:01call my client. who was my biggest client and
- 26:04was my biggest client for about 30 years. And
- 26:07I said, Michael, I've made a significant mistake.
- 26:11And I want to come down and discuss it with you.
- 26:14And I laid it all out for him. And I said, our
- 26:17firm will take care of this. We'll be responsible
- 26:19for any lien claim of the bank. And he said,
- 26:22no, you're not. I go, why? I thought he was going
- 26:25to say you're fired. He said, because no one's
- 26:28ever treated me this way. He said, I have big
- 26:31firms that I work with. They never admit that
- 26:33they're wrong. They always try to delay and play
- 26:37games. He said, I just am so pleased that you've
- 26:40come and told this to me now. Simmer down, Bob.
- 26:42It's going to be OK. I met with the attorney
- 26:46for the bank, and we talked about UCLA sports,
- 26:48and he'd been a Bruin and all that. And you know
- 26:51what? He said, OK, I understand. Forget it. Have
- 26:53a nice day. And it turned out fine. But I think
- 26:58that apologies can make such a difference in
- 27:01your life in terms of client relations with complaints
- 27:05to the bar and in every phase of your life, your
- 27:08children, et cetera, your spouse. So OK, enough
- 27:11of my philosophizing from a working man's level.
- 27:15We have a big group here, over 50 people. Anybody
- 27:18have any questions or comments for Sid? Nelson
- 27:24Timken. is a very well -known mediator, author,
- 27:30who puts out wonderful, wonderful articles on
- 27:34the theory of mediation and different aspects.
- 27:37Edward, do you have anything you'd like to say?
- 27:40I mean, Nelson, excuse me. He lies. That's embarrassing,
- 27:50but thank you so much. for the kind words. It's
- 27:56been my experience, and please don't all start
- 28:00firing arrows at me, that many people in the
- 28:04ADR community are loathe to apologize. In fact,
- 28:12I apologize because I make so many mistakes and
- 28:17say so many things that I shouldn't have said.
- 28:22I was told by one person that it's no good to
- 28:28say the wrong thing or something that shouldn't
- 28:31be said at all and then apologize. And that's
- 28:35the reason that I have the bad reputation that
- 28:38I have. And so sometimes my comment is that sometimes
- 28:43when you do apologize, People tell you that you
- 28:47should be more careful in the first instance
- 28:50in what you do and that Apologizing after the
- 28:54fact is no good What about that? Well, I think
- 29:00it's You know people try to build patterns and
- 29:09they try to try to interpret what you're doing.
- 29:14And to this extent that they think that you're
- 29:19intentionally not thinking and trying to make
- 29:22up for it by apologizing or something like that.
- 29:24Maybe that's something that they would, you know,
- 29:28be thinking about when they're doing. But here's
- 29:30what I found as a mediator, is that whatever
- 29:36you think someone else is thinking, or whatever
- 29:40you think is the motivation behind what somebody
- 29:42else is doing, you don't know until you ask them.
- 29:47And you might suspect all kinds of things about
- 29:51the other person, but until you ask them, and
- 29:54ask them with an open -ended question that allows
- 29:57them to tell you what they're thinking, not verifying
- 30:01or denying what you think they're thinking, you
- 30:05don't know. I think a lot of this has to do with
- 30:09us learning how to not just give grace, but be
- 30:14open to hearing what other people are really
- 30:18thinking. And sometimes they don't even know.
- 30:21When they say things, they don't know what they're
- 30:23thinking. But if you probe a little bit, you
- 30:25start to help them to understand what they're
- 30:28thinking. I think that's a very good point, the
- 30:32idea of open -ended questions. And for some of
- 30:34us who have been litigators, it's hard to kind
- 30:37of do that. We're not trained to ask, why did
- 30:40you do this? That's the exact opposite of what
- 30:43we ever do in court. So I think that's a wonderful
- 30:46point. And I also think that people that say
- 30:49that are judgmental and probably quick to criticize
- 30:53others. And all right, what about judgment? Well,
- 30:58you got another hand up here, Alberto. OK, go
- 31:01ahead. Alberto. Hi, everybody. What about, you
- 31:08know, non -apology apologies or like phony apologies?
- 31:12Something like, well, I'm sorry you felt that
- 31:14way. How do you think about that and how do you
- 31:17deal with them? Well, it's exactly what you say.
- 31:21It's a phony apology. It's not a real apology.
- 31:23And part of apologies is the sincerity behind
- 31:28it. You know, and so, you know, non -apologies
- 31:33is you know, fake apologies is almost worse than
- 31:39not saying anything. And so I think it comes
- 31:44right back to that that formula is that why are
- 31:47we doing this? Why are we apologizing at all?
- 31:50And I think that why we do this, if we are sincere
- 31:55about it, is to to readjust the relationships
- 32:01between everybody. and to try to reestablish
- 32:04trust among everybody. And so one of the analogies
- 32:09that we use in class is the idea of an elevator,
- 32:14that our apology allows us to humble ourselves
- 32:17a little bit in order to bring ourselves down
- 32:20from being the perpetrator of harm to someone
- 32:23who is saying, hey, I'm sorry. I'm sorry that
- 32:26I caused this particular harm. And the sorries
- 32:30can be all different kinds of sorries. Sorries
- 32:32can be sorry, that I had nothing to do with this
- 32:35situation. I'm sorry about the weather, you know,
- 32:38kind of thing. And it's more empathy that you're
- 32:42expressing in that particular setting. Or it
- 32:44might be, I'm sorry that I'm giving you this
- 32:49shot and it's hurting you because it... It is
- 32:55hurting you and all that. But I think this is
- 32:58important. And you need this shot. And we do
- 33:00those kinds of things. But there's all different
- 33:02kinds of apologies. But fake apologies, you're
- 33:05right. It doesn't count as an apology. No, it's
- 33:12actually worse. And it just occurred to me, maybe
- 33:16we need to teach children in school what apologies
- 33:20are about. and conditional apologies can be devastating.
- 33:24Yeah. And but, you know, there's still the apology
- 33:27where your mother says, you go over there and
- 33:30apologize. All right. What you're doing there
- 33:32is really not acknowledging the other person
- 33:35or respect the other person. You're you're basically
- 33:37respecting your mother and basically saying,
- 33:40you know, I'm going to please my mother by going
- 33:42over there and apologizing. You know, so it's
- 33:45it's apologies and forgiveness and and reconciliation
- 33:50are all context -based. There's not a single
- 33:55way of doing things and all that. And part of
- 33:59this class is, in fact, I start the class with
- 34:03a picture of a Japanese ceramic bowl that is
- 34:09cracked, and the cracks are repaired by gold.
- 34:14you know, very bold gold leaf, but it's basically
- 34:21you can see it throughout all the cracks. And
- 34:24this art form is called kintsugi. It's, you know,
- 34:28you actually make a bowl, you break it and then
- 34:30you patch it up with this gold leaf and all that.
- 34:33And the idea is to emphasize the imperfection.
- 34:37to emphasize not the beauty of the perfection
- 34:43of the bowl, but rather the imperfection of the
- 34:46bowl, because it's through imperfection that
- 34:48we learn, it's through imperfection that we appreciate,
- 34:52it's through imperfection that we can empathize
- 34:54and understand each other, because we're all
- 34:56imperfect. And once we appreciate that, it's
- 35:01a lot easier to make enemies into friends. Abraham
- 35:07Lincoln once said that the best way to destroy
- 35:10an enemy is to make him a friend. And in order
- 35:13to make them a friend, you have to admit to or
- 35:19appreciate that their imperfections are not because
- 35:24you are perfect, but it's because we all have
- 35:27those imperfections. So when you mediate, Sidney,
- 35:31do you ever Discuss with the attorneys, maybe
- 35:34in a separate room, or even the parties, maybe
- 35:38in a joint session, the concept of apology. Does
- 35:41that ever come up? How do you integrate apology
- 35:44into the mediation process? If ever. And then
- 35:48one of our attendees said the power of apology
- 35:52or even acknowledgement of harm in mediation
- 35:55really helps move settlement forward. And so
- 35:59many organizations are afraid of admitting any
- 36:01liability. And I think there are some journal
- 36:04articles about apologies in legal settings and
- 36:06how they can be fostered and not cause harm to
- 36:11the person making the apology. But do you ever
- 36:13get into that issue when you mediate? Yeah, I
- 36:18got to think back. But I think, you know, there
- 36:21have been several instances where people wanted
- 36:24to apologize. And so, you know, I given free
- 36:29rein to do that. But I think that when people
- 36:32think it's transactional, that if I apologize,
- 36:37I'll get a better deal. If I apologize, I'll
- 36:40be forgiven. If they think of it in transactional
- 36:44terms, then it doesn't usually have the desired
- 36:50effect. I think it has an extremely powerful
- 36:56effect. But it has to be sincere. And it has
- 37:00to be not about, I'm doing this for me. I want
- 37:05to get this off my chest. I'm doing this to get
- 37:08a better deal or something like that. It's that
- 37:11same samadhi equation, that the more you're focused
- 37:16on yourself, the less effective the apology is.
- 37:21The more you're focused on the other, the more
- 37:24effective the apology is. That's really the key
- 37:30to the whole thing. I don't do divorce mediation,
- 37:33although I went through divorce, and that made
- 37:35me realize I don't want to be a divorce mediator.
- 37:37But it would seem to me that that would become
- 37:39a very important concept in those sorts of mediations.
- 37:46The opening scene of Wedding Crashers is a mediation,
- 37:50is a divorce mediation. It's actually really
- 37:54good. I recommend it highly to people because
- 37:57it's about reminding people about telling a different
- 38:06story. We get locked into a story where we hate
- 38:12the other person for whatever reason, for something
- 38:14they did or whatever it is. Sometimes when we
- 38:18get locked into that story, we forget all the
- 38:21other stories that are associated with this relationship.
- 38:26And when you help people to remember those other
- 38:29stories, it helps them to be much more compassionate,
- 38:35much more forgiving, much more empathetic towards
- 38:38the other side. I started the mediations in the
- 38:42children's court, where parents were fighting
- 38:44about the joint parenting of the child. And basically,
- 38:48they had a lot of baggage with each other. They
- 38:51hated each other. They just wanted to do harm
- 38:57to each other, really. And we get into the mediation.
- 39:02And one of the tricks that we came up with was
- 39:06basically to ask each of the parents for a picture
- 39:10of their child. And usually these were joint
- 39:12sessions. And they would usually have it on their
- 39:16phone. And we would ask them, show us a picture
- 39:20of the child that we're talking about, or the
- 39:22children that we're talking about. And they would
- 39:24show us the pictures. And it did two things.
- 39:27One, it gave us a picture of what kind of activities
- 39:32they have fun engaging, because it's not just
- 39:37children that are engaged in some kind of activity.
- 39:39And two, it focused the parents on why we're
- 39:43here. We're not here for you to fight this battle
- 39:47that you've had for a long period of time and
- 39:50all the mistakes that you've made a long time
- 39:52in the past. We're here for the future of this
- 39:56child, for the next 18 years or however long
- 39:59it's going to take for this child. We're here
- 40:03to work out a plan for this child. And it really
- 40:06did an amazing job of refocusing the discussion
- 40:10to the point where people would say, oh, no,
- 40:15that's not going to work for her. And they'd
- 40:16be much more compassionate in understanding and
- 40:19to work things out and all that. Because it was
- 40:21changing their story from, I hate this person,
- 40:25to I have to do the best for my child for the
- 40:28future. Interesting. Let's see, Nelson, you again
- 40:35made an interesting comment about how you think
- 40:39apologies can be integrated into the process.
- 40:42Do you want to comment on that? Oops, you're
- 40:49muted. You are muted. Going to what Sydney just
- 40:52said about how you harken back to better times,
- 40:58which is a technique that's frequently used.
- 41:02And when you harken back to better times, you
- 41:06remind people that they weren't always locked
- 41:10in dispute mode, that there were times when they
- 41:15actually got along fairly well. And reminding
- 41:20them about the better times is often a way of
- 41:25steering the conversation to a desire to renew
- 41:33those relationships. And so once you're there,
- 41:39you say to them, well, you guys are part of a
- 41:43small community, assuming it's a commercial transaction.
- 41:47You know, you guys are in construction and you
- 41:49run into the same people over and over again
- 41:52in construction, as you know, and you're going
- 41:56to have to deal with these people. in the future,
- 42:00and you guys used to get along, let me ask you,
- 42:05what would it take for that relationship to go
- 42:10back to the way it was? And let them tell you,
- 42:16well, I guess I could apologize for my role in
- 42:19it. And that's one way of kind of steering things
- 42:26to where an apology might work well. And in that
- 42:31situation, I've seen it work very well where,
- 42:35look, you know, look, John, we were both wrong.
- 42:39I'll apologize for my role in this. You know,
- 42:42if you apologize for your role in this, we'll
- 42:45just work it out. You know, one of the things
- 42:50that comes up in our class is whether you have
- 42:53to get an apology in order to forgive and all
- 42:56the kind of things and who goes first, basically.
- 43:00And I think that that is an unnecessary. I mean,
- 43:08it is an obstacle where that takes courage to
- 43:12go first, but it's the courage to to try to create
- 43:16the culture. that we want for ourselves. And
- 43:20in Hawaii, there's a dispute resolution system
- 43:25called Ho 'oponopono. And it's a system where
- 43:31the ohana, the family, gets together. A family
- 43:34is not just relatives. It's like friends and
- 43:37all kinds of people that are connected. But the
- 43:40idea is that whatever that ohana is, it gets
- 43:43together. The main rule in Ho 'oponopono is that
- 43:48nobody points to anybody else. Nobody says they
- 43:52did this or says what somebody else did. Everybody
- 43:56only can talk about what they did to contribute
- 44:00to the problem. And so the people that are fighting
- 44:03usually are not the ones that go first. It's
- 44:06usually other people that say, you know, I knew
- 44:07that they were really upset and I didn't step
- 44:09in, you know, or, you know, I overheard them
- 44:14yelling at each other and I didn't do anything
- 44:17to try to calm the situation or something like
- 44:19that. And eventually you almost shame the people
- 44:23into to admitting how they contributed to the
- 44:27problem kind of thing. The primary people contributed
- 44:30to the problem. And there's a lot of crying and
- 44:32all kinds of things like that. But the idea being
- 44:35that other people, nothing is just between a
- 44:42couple of people. Everybody's affected in some
- 44:44way. And when you start to show people how you're
- 44:49affecting a lot of people, It helps them to realize
- 44:54that this is not just me and you. I'm affecting
- 44:57a whole bunch of people. And you're almost compelled
- 45:00to admit to your contribution how you can make
- 45:07things better. And that's, in part, kind of the
- 45:12idea behind procedural justice, where you're
- 45:15talking about What did you think when you were
- 45:19doing this? And what were you thinking? And on
- 45:22the other side, what were you thinking when you
- 45:24heard that you were when you realized that you'd
- 45:27been harmed in this fashion and all that? And
- 45:29it can have extremely dramatic effects where
- 45:34people you don't think would ever reconcile would
- 45:38reconcile. And one of the most prominent ones
- 45:42is a book called Picking Cotton, and it's with
- 45:45Ron Cotton and Sorry, I can't remember the woman's
- 45:50name, but the woman was in North Carolina and
- 45:53she got raped, got him into her bedroom and raped
- 45:57her. And, you know, she went to a lineup and
- 46:01picked out this guy Ron Cotton and said that
- 46:04he was the rapist, you know, and he was the wrong
- 46:07guy. And he went through trial. beyond a reasonable
- 46:12doubt and was convicted and was sentenced to
- 46:15prison. And he spent, I think, 16 years in prison.
- 46:18And eventually the Innocence Project would test
- 46:21his DNA and things like that and find out that
- 46:24he's not the right person. And so he could have
- 46:28come out bitter and angry. And he did. He was
- 46:33bitter that he had to spend all that time in
- 46:35jail. But something About him and her she Felt
- 46:43horrible that she'd convicted the wrong person
- 46:47because she was so certain that he was a person
- 46:50that she reached out and and basically they Talked
- 46:56and became friends and understood each other
- 46:59and they started going around the country talking
- 47:02about this the dangers of limited lineups and
- 47:07things like that, and eyewitness identification
- 47:10and different things, but showing that there
- 47:14is a way that you can reconcile with people that
- 47:17you would think you'd hate for the rest of your
- 47:19life. Right, and make peace. So going back to
- 47:22your class, do you have any, I know that you're
- 47:24just in your second semester now teaching your
- 47:26class, is that right? Yes. Do you have any goals
- 47:30for the students about changing the way Others
- 47:34look at apologies and forgiveness and reconciliation.
- 47:38How do we change the temperature amongst lawyers
- 47:43and amongst our population? Do you have any goals
- 47:46on that regard? Well, what I keep talking about
- 47:50in class is the idea that culture is created
- 47:55by individuals. That what we do and like your
- 48:00driving along and a car wants to cut into your
- 48:04lane. Do you slow down and let them come in and
- 48:08give them that cutting in? You're getting out
- 48:12of a parking lot from a big event and you're
- 48:14trying to get home. Everybody's kind of bunching
- 48:16up trying to get out and somebody's trying to
- 48:18back out of a stall or something like that. Do
- 48:20you give them room to come out or do you just
- 48:23drive by and keep on going close to the bumper
- 48:26of the car in front of you? to not let them get
- 48:29in. That is culture. That is sending a message
- 48:34to other people that this is the way it is, that
- 48:38it's every man for himself, it's me first, or
- 48:42it is a culture of kindness. giving grace and
- 48:47allowing people to come in. It is thanking people
- 48:50when they do something nice for you. It's just
- 48:54with the wave of the hand or allowing people
- 48:56to come in to cut into the line as we're going
- 49:00along and things like that. Those little things
- 49:03are what create our culture. And as lawyers,
- 49:11you know, the Shakespeare's, you know, Anarchists
- 49:17said, the first thing you do is let's kill all
- 49:19the lawyers, was a testament to how important
- 49:22we are in creating culture, in creating a system
- 49:28where we keep the society together. Our job as
- 49:32lawyers is not to be warriors. Our job as lawyers
- 49:36is to be agreement makers. That's what we do.
- 49:39We go to the jury and we... try to get them to
- 49:42agree with us. We'd go to the judge and we try
- 49:45to get them to agree with us. We go to our opponents
- 49:47in 98 to 99 percent of the cases, and we try
- 49:51to reach an agreement. Not necessarily agree
- 49:54in what we want, but an agreement that we jointly
- 49:58agree on and going forward. In essence, whether
- 50:04we're in court, in negotiation and litigation,
- 50:09whether we're transactional in terms of building
- 50:11projects for the future, or whether it's regulatory
- 50:14where we're going to the government, we're trying
- 50:17to reach agreements in all these settings. And
- 50:20so our job, in large part, is to remind our fellow
- 50:24citizens of the agreements that we have, the
- 50:26conventions that we have, the constitution, the
- 50:29statutes, the contracts, the social norms that
- 50:33we have. We are the leaders of this reinforcing
- 50:39these agreements that we have so that we can
- 50:41live together, that we can work together, so
- 50:44that we don't have to fear each other. You know,
- 50:46Pew did a study a few years ago, not a few years
- 50:49ago, just a few weeks ago, I think it's last
- 50:52month or something, that they surveyed 25 countries.
- 50:58And out of the 25 countries, only one country
- 51:02Had a majority of the population thinking that
- 51:05their fellow citizens were morally bad only one
- 51:09out of 25 and that one was the United States,
- 51:13you know and and The majority of people thought
- 51:17that their fellow citizens were morally bad in
- 51:19all the other countries Going up to Canada where
- 51:2390 % of the people thought their fellow citizens
- 51:26were morally good We have to stop thinking of
- 51:33things as warriors, because warriors can't be
- 51:37trusted. Warriors, if they're doing their job,
- 51:41will kill you no matter what. And so if we think
- 51:45of ourselves as warriors, and we encourage others
- 51:49to think of themselves as warriors. Our ABA started
- 51:52off talking about integrity and having everybody
- 51:59believe in our system of justice and things like
- 52:02that in 1909. In 1983, they changed the model
- 52:06rules to include this concept of zealous advocacy.
- 52:12And that zealous advocacy concept didn't exist
- 52:15in the prior model rules, but that 1983 version
- 52:18of zealous advocacy has created this mentality
- 52:21that we can be warriors and somehow justice will
- 52:24be done. In fact, it says that in the preamble,
- 52:26that if there are two warriors against each other,
- 52:28we can assume that justice will be done. But
- 52:32we can't assume that, that we have to actively
- 52:36try to create those kind of conditions, we have
- 52:38to, in little individual acts, build our culture,
- 52:44build our culture of trust, not a culture of
- 52:47fear and disdain and separation of us versus
- 52:53them in whatever other context. It's up to us.
- 52:58And so I think that, you know, We have a serious
- 53:04obligation to help our fellow citizens become
- 53:08friends and talk to each other and listen to
- 53:12each other and try to find a way in which we
- 53:14can work together. Interesting. There's certainly
- 53:18a dichotomy there between the successful trial
- 53:22lawyers to win at any cost and what you're talking
- 53:25about. Well, even successful travelers, if you
- 53:30really listen to very successful travelers, they
- 53:36have to get the jury to join them. And Aristotle
- 53:45said there's three elements. There's ethos, pathos,
- 53:47and logos. And ethos is the credibility and believability
- 53:50of the speaker. And pathos is the emotional connection
- 53:54of the speaker to the audience. and logos is
- 53:57logic. And one of the problems for lawyers is
- 54:02that logic justifies the result, but logic does
- 54:06not persuade. And you will find the logic. Once
- 54:12we believe in the speaker, once we feel the speaker
- 54:15is right, we'll find the logic to justify following
- 54:19the speaker's lead. But when we go to law school,
- 54:22That model of persuasion that has lasted for
- 54:25thousands of years is turned on its head. And
- 54:29we start to think that logic is most important,
- 54:32that passion shouldn't matter, and that all people
- 54:34are created equal. And in essence, our legal
- 54:38education that helps us to think like a lawyer
- 54:40makes us dumber. And so all these trial institutes
- 54:45that are out there, in part what they're doing
- 54:47is helping us lawyers become people again. become
- 54:51people like everybody else. They understood that
- 54:53it is the credibility, the belief, you know,
- 54:56the passion, and that logic just justifies, we
- 55:01can justify any kind of situation once we believe
- 55:05and we feel that someone's right. And so that's,
- 55:10I think, what we have to get back to. It's not
- 55:13that people are not logical. Daniel Kahn had
- 55:16got a Nobel Prize. showing that even when we
- 55:21think we're logical, we're not really logical.
- 55:23It's all driven by emotion. And if we don't have
- 55:26that emotion, then we won't be able to make any
- 55:30decisions. It's emotions that are driving us,
- 55:32you know, by and large. And so appreciating that,
- 55:38we have to find a way in which we can come back
- 55:42to what our founders really understood that in
- 55:46order to make a more perfect union, that we have
- 55:50to find a way to bring everybody together to
- 55:53be equal and to join together and to want to
- 55:57join together. That's a very nice thought and
- 56:02it seems to me that what we need to do as lawyers
- 56:06and as people is just remind ourselves and others
- 56:10when we can of the power of apology and how that
- 56:15can mend fences. and help people move on. I think
- 56:21we're going to wrap it now for today. I think
- 56:23it's been a very deep conversation. And Sydney,
- 56:25you can tell, is a deep thinker. And I'd like
- 56:28to thank those of you that have contributed.
- 56:32And this is a subject that basically is open
- 56:35-ended. It's something that I think we need to
- 56:39think about and try to practice in our lives.
- 56:42And anything that we can do in that regard I
- 56:45think helps. people. So I want to thank you very
- 56:48much for attending today. I hope you feel that
- 56:51you got something out of it. Perhaps some inspiration
- 56:54from Sydney and some good thoughts from our contributors.
- 56:58And I wish you well. And we'll be back again
- 57:00next month with another mediation program, an
- 57:04ADR program. So Sydney, thank you so much. And
- 57:07thank you all for participating. I found it very
- 57:09interesting today. A lot of food for thought.
- 57:12Take care, everybody. Thank you. Bye.