Latest / Views and News with Clarence Ford / MTBPS must deliver decent employment for all
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Lisa Mdutiana, welcome. It's great to have you. You're a
- 0:03Speaker 1: researcher with the Institute for Economic Justice. It's good to
- 0:07Speaker 1: have you.
- 0:09Speaker 2: Thank you for having me, Clarence, and good morning to
- 0:12Speaker 2: your listeners.
- 0:13Speaker 1: Yeah, you've heard about some of the push and pulls
- 0:16Speaker 1: in Cape Town. Any comments on that?
- 0:19Speaker 2: No, I don't know too much about that. I'm a
- 0:22Speaker 2: Joburg boy. I could tell you a little bit about that,
- 0:26Speaker 2: but we're here to discuss debt.
- 0:30Speaker 1: Maybe you want to take issue with me? I said
- 0:31Speaker 1: there's very little successes that the ANC can claim on
- 0:34Speaker 1: local government election. You're not taking aim at me on
- 0:37Speaker 1: that one?
- 0:39Speaker 2: I'd rather not for now. Okay.
- 0:43Speaker 1: Let's talk then about the medium-term budget forecast. It's happening
- 0:50Speaker 1: next week, and you've made some very specific demands. You
- 0:56Speaker 1: want to shift from fiscal consolidation to pro-employment growth. Tell
- 1:02Speaker 1: us more about your thinking on that front.
- 1:05Speaker 2: Actually, the medium-term budget policy is happening tomorrow. It's right here.
- 1:11Speaker 1: I'm sorry, I meant this week. I thought it was
- 1:12Speaker 1: last week. It's my problem, yeah.
- 1:15Speaker 2: Yes. So really what we try to demonstrate is that
- 1:20Speaker 2: ever since we've had fiscal consolidation, which is really running
- 1:25Speaker 2: the budget through the lens of let's tighten everything, let's
- 1:28Speaker 2: try to restrain spending as much as we can. Since
- 1:33Speaker 2: we've had that from 2013 onwards, we really have not
- 1:37Speaker 2: seen any improvement in any of the things that truly
- 1:40Speaker 2: matter for South Africans. We have seen the unemployment rate
- 1:44Speaker 2: go up. We have seen GDP growth go down or stagnate.
- 1:49Speaker 2: We have seen, in fact, in manufacturing growth in terms
- 1:53Speaker 2: of the volume and the industrial capacity that the country
- 1:56Speaker 2: has actually go down over those years. And what we
- 2:00Speaker 2: are trying to understand from the government's end is how
- 2:04Speaker 2: does continuing with this same fiscal strategy that has weakened
- 2:09Speaker 2: state capacity, how will it then translate to better outcomes?
- 2:14Speaker 2: Because let's say here, Clarence, the government does achieve its
- 2:19Speaker 2: goal of stabilizing the debt-to-GDP ratio, what would that be
- 2:25Speaker 2: on the back of? It would be on the back
- 2:27Speaker 2: of underfunding public services, underfunding state departments. And what you
- 2:33Speaker 2: then have is, even if you have this narrow conception
- 2:37Speaker 2: of stability, you are leaving the country on a much
- 2:40Speaker 2: weaker footing by which it can embark in terms of
- 2:45Speaker 2: long-term growth. So while it might make sense to try
- 2:50Speaker 2: and stabilize the debt-to-GDP ratio, you cannot do it through
- 2:56Speaker 2: weakening the state by restraining spending. Otherwise, you will not
- 3:02Speaker 2: even realize the long-term growth that you want in the economy.
- 3:06Speaker 1: Yeah, I've just been kind of comparing South Africa's debt-to-GDP
- 3:10Speaker 1: ratio with countries of... of similar size. Brazil, maybe India,
- 3:17Speaker 1: maybe Mexico, maybe Indonesia, maybe not India, maybe not Brazil,
- 3:20Speaker 1: maybe Mexico, maybe Indonesia. But let's look at Poland as well.
- 3:23Speaker 1: South Africa shows a strong performance in fiscal discipline and
- 3:26Speaker 1: debt structure, but lags in GDP growth and debt servicing
- 3:31Speaker 1: efficiency as opposed to the other countries. That's an interesting observation.
- 3:36Speaker 1: But yeah, we are claiming successes in terms of managing
- 3:41Speaker 1: our debt performance to GDP ratio. And you're saying that
- 3:45Speaker 1: is not our priority right now.
- 3:48Speaker 2: It can't be. It can't be. Not when you have
- 3:51Speaker 2: the levels of unemployment that we have. Not when you
- 3:54Speaker 2: have clearly an economy that is still really exposed to
- 3:58Speaker 2: external shocks, as we saw this year when, due to
- 4:02Speaker 2: the U.S. 's war on Iran, South Africa suffered in
- 4:06Speaker 2: terms of the cost of living due to the increased
- 4:09Speaker 2: in the price of oil and in the price of
- 4:11Speaker 2: other goods and services. So that cannot be the priority.
- 4:15Speaker 2: It does make sense in the overall schema of things,
- 4:19Speaker 2: but it cannot be the priority of either our fiscal
- 4:22Speaker 2: authorities or our monetary authorities. The real priority must be
- 4:29Speaker 2: increasing employment. It must be structural transformation.
- 4:34Speaker 1: Okay, let us understand that then because you're saying unequivocally
- 4:38Speaker 1: you don't want this hyper fixation on debt to GDP targets. Instead,
- 4:43Speaker 1: you want public investment that creates employment and funds essential servicemen.
- 4:48Speaker 1: You talk public investment there. Can we talk about public
- 4:53Speaker 1: investment in real kind of investment terms? Is there a
- 4:56Speaker 1: return on investment in this focus that you're seeking in
- 5:00Speaker 1: that is going to positively impact our balance sheet?
- 5:04Speaker 2: So here's the thing. When we think about the society
- 5:08Speaker 2: and when we think about a country, we can't use
- 5:10Speaker 2: the same metrics that a business, for example, would use. Otherwise,
- 5:14Speaker 2: very few things would actually be bankable for the government
- 5:17Speaker 2: to currently undertake. For example, it probably doesn't make much
- 5:21Speaker 2: sense from a financial perspective for the government to have
- 5:25Speaker 2: built a Nelson Mandela Bridge, which is connecting, for example,
- 5:28Speaker 2: Ibram Fontaine and the new town. It wouldn't make sense
- 5:32Speaker 2: financially because no one is paying for it, in a sense.
- 5:37Speaker 2: But it does make sense from a social value aspect
- 5:40Speaker 2: of things, because you need to connect different neighborhoods, you
- 5:44Speaker 2: need to connect different towns. So you do not assess
- 5:47Speaker 2: a social project through its financial return on investment. Otherwise,
- 5:53Speaker 2: there's a lot of things that wouldn't be done. You couldn't,
- 5:56Speaker 2: for example, you can assess whether you should build a
- 5:58Speaker 2: school by looking at whether it will give you some
- 6:01Speaker 2: sort of financial return. When you are investing there, you
- 6:04Speaker 2: are investing in the development of human capital, of skills,
- 6:08Speaker 2: of putting children in places that can allow them to
- 6:12Speaker 2: fulfill their potential. So for us, when we talk about
- 6:16Speaker 2: public investment in these things, We are talking about investment
- 6:20Speaker 2: in clinics, in hospitals, in education centers. And there, you
- 6:26Speaker 2: absolutely cannot use that kind of financial metric. You should
- 6:30Speaker 2: be thinking about how does this develop society in the
- 6:34Speaker 2: long run.
- 6:35Speaker 1: And it has, then, a very direct impact on the
- 6:38Speaker 1: economy and a positive one as well. It's certainly a
- 6:41Speaker 1: long-term investment in your economy. So there is a rationale there.
- 6:47Speaker 1: that it is of benefit, your call, ultimately, to the economy.
- 6:51Speaker 1: But let's go to tax reform and revenue creation. You've
- 6:54Speaker 1: argued for progressive taxation, including wealth taxes and reversing corporate
- 6:59Speaker 1: tax cuts to expand the fiscal envelope. But business groups
- 7:04Speaker 1: warn higher tax on capital in a low-growth environment will
- 7:10Speaker 1: choke off private investment. What is the empirical backing behind
- 7:14Speaker 1: the revenue model that you propose?
- 7:17Speaker 2: So, first of all, just looking at the empirical backing
- 7:21Speaker 2: of what has been done by National Treasury, we'll remember around,
- 7:26Speaker 2: was it 2022 or 2023, when the National Treasury decided,
- 7:32Speaker 2: saying it had evidence, so it decided to lower the
- 7:35Speaker 2: corporate income tax rate from, I think, 28% to 27%.
- 7:40Speaker 2: And by their own estimates, this would have brought about
- 7:45Speaker 2: an increase in fixed investment from companies because when companies
- 7:50Speaker 2: are able to retain more money, then they are able
- 7:54Speaker 2: to invest in fixed capital. What have we actually seen, Clarence?
- 7:58Speaker 2: We have not seen an uptick of fixed investment at all.
- 8:02Speaker 2: And it's not because necessarily it was the worst idea
- 8:07Speaker 2: to decrease taxes or to do something like that. It
- 8:10Speaker 2: is simply because the decisions that businesses or rather the
- 8:15Speaker 2: considerations they make when they're thinking about expanding capital are
- 8:19Speaker 2: not simply are we going to, you know, do we
- 8:23Speaker 2: have more money now? Have we retained more money now?
- 8:27Speaker 2: It's also considerations of things like is there enough demand
- 8:31Speaker 2: for the products that we are producing? And if South
- 8:34Speaker 2: Africa keeps on being an economy which has high unemployment rates,
- 8:39Speaker 2: it has very low median wage rates, around 6,000 a month.
- 8:45Speaker 2: So if you keep on having that kind of economy,
- 8:48Speaker 2: which is demand constraints, even if you give the tax
- 8:52Speaker 2: cuts to these companies, it will not have the effect
- 8:56Speaker 2: of leading them to invest over the long term because
- 8:59Speaker 2: there simply is not enough demand in the economy for
- 9:02Speaker 2: them to have a larger market to sell their product.
- 9:05Speaker 2: Other factors come into play as well. We know this
- 9:08Speaker 2: was also during the time where e-load shedding was at
- 9:11Speaker 2: its highest. And even if then you are shielding them
- 9:15Speaker 2: by decreasing e-tax rates, you still have the issue of
- 9:18Speaker 2: higher cost of electricity. Electricity is less reliable, so they
- 9:22Speaker 2: have to switch to alternatives, which may be more expensive.
- 9:26Speaker 2: So really, just by looking at that action by the government,
- 9:30Speaker 2: which is decreasing corporate income tax rate, we can see
- 9:34Speaker 2: that it has had no effect. On the other hand,
- 9:39Speaker 2: when it comes to wealth taxation, we see that there
- 9:43Speaker 2: are mixed results all across the world because these taxes
- 9:46Speaker 2: have been implemented by European countries. Some have dropped them,
- 9:50Speaker 2: but some still maintain them. We also saw that... During
- 9:55Speaker 2: the time of COVID, a lot of South American countries
- 9:58Speaker 2: undertook this. taxes. And the reason that they undertook is
- 10:04Speaker 2: because they thought it would be a relatively safe way
- 10:07Speaker 2: of securing revenue without making too much damage to the economy. Now,
- 10:13Speaker 2: what truly matters here, Clarence, is the design of the
- 10:17Speaker 2: wealth tax. It's not the fact that there's a wealth
- 10:19Speaker 2: tax or there's no wealth tax. It's the design. So
- 10:22Speaker 2: if you design it in a way which, for example,
- 10:26Speaker 2: prevents people from hiding money offshore, if you design it
- 10:31Speaker 2: in a way such that it is still low enough
- 10:34Speaker 2: for every individual or every corporation that's paying it to
- 10:37Speaker 2: not really feel the brunt of it. So, for example,
- 10:39Speaker 2: if it is set between, let's say, 1% to 3%
- 10:44Speaker 2: annually or maybe once or whatever is decided in terms
- 10:47Speaker 2: of policy, if you set it that way, then it
- 10:50Speaker 2: is able to give much more revenue to the fiscals
- 10:54Speaker 2: without having the negative effect of the capital flight, which
- 10:58Speaker 2: we did see in other countries that tried to embark
- 11:02Speaker 2: on this. So that's why then we are saying when
- 11:05Speaker 2: we want to do things like in wealth taxes, you
- 11:08Speaker 2: also have to put in the right kind of architecture
- 11:12Speaker 2: such that you do not have large amounts of capital.
- 11:15Speaker 2: You do not discourage a capital accumulation.
- 11:19Speaker 1: Okay. I think the other, the other issue is, and
- 11:22Speaker 1: it may stand completely juxtaposed to what you're demanding from
- 11:26Speaker 1: the fine, uh, from the finance minister. Um, Treasury singles
- 11:33Speaker 1: out the public sector wage bill as unsustainable. The IEJ
- 11:38Speaker 1: pushes for fair wages and frontline hiring in education and healthcare.
- 11:43Speaker 1: So how do you restructure public service spending so that
- 11:46Speaker 1: lower-level frontline workers are supported without blowing past budget caps?
- 11:53Speaker 2: I think, one, whatever happens when the public sector... you know,
- 12:01Speaker 2: public sector unions and the National Treasury and the Department
- 12:04Speaker 2: of Public Service going to negotiations, whatever happens there, whatever
- 12:08Speaker 2: is the outcome there, our starting point is that the
- 12:13Speaker 2: National Treasury should not then use that to punish the
- 12:18Speaker 2: rest of the public. Because if you are saying that
- 12:22Speaker 2: the public sector wage bill is unsustainable because public sector
- 12:27Speaker 2: unions have managed to attain higher than inflation increases, then
- 12:32Speaker 2: that's not the problem of my child who needs to
- 12:35Speaker 2: be educated, who can't be in a classroom of 50 children.
- 12:40Speaker 2: The government itself must obviously try to mediate the increases
- 12:46Speaker 2: in wages that are negotiated between themselves and the public sector.
- 12:52Speaker 2: And the other thing is that we know in terms
- 12:54Speaker 2: of the structure of the government The real highly paid
- 12:58Speaker 2: people are at the top, are at the echelons. That's
- 13:01Speaker 2: like management level. It is not your teacher or your
- 13:04Speaker 2: nurse or your police officer. So for us, it really
- 13:08Speaker 2: reflects a structure, first of all, that is a bit
- 13:11Speaker 2: top heavy. It reflects a structure that clearly was not
- 13:15Speaker 2: cognizant enough of the effects of higher than inflation wage increases.
- 13:21Speaker 2: when it did them previously. But also, it reflects a
- 13:25Speaker 2: structure where the National Treasury itself, even though it did accept,
- 13:30Speaker 2: or let me rather say the government, even though it
- 13:32Speaker 2: did accept these wage settlements, it clearly was not prepared
- 13:37Speaker 2: to mobilize sufficient resources in order to finance them. But
- 13:41Speaker 2: what cannot happen is the rest of the public being
- 13:45Speaker 2: punished for that through lower number of nurses, lower number
- 13:49Speaker 2: of educators, lower number of police officers.
- 13:53Speaker 1: Okay, a question in from one of our listeners. Let's
- 13:55Speaker 1: wrap on this question. Cancel broad-based economic, black economic BBBE
- 14:03Speaker 1: to attract foreign investors to invest capital in SA. That
- 14:06Speaker 1: will grow taxes for Treasury to spend on schools and hospitals,
- 14:10Speaker 1: says Graham. Hmm.
- 14:16Speaker 2: Do you want a response for that?
- 14:17Speaker 1: He's advising you to do that. What is your response
- 14:20Speaker 1: to him? Yes.
- 14:21Speaker 2: So I think our response from our end is really
- 14:24Speaker 2: that doesn't even get to the fundamental issues that are
- 14:29Speaker 2: making South Africa a low investment rate economy. It's not...
- 14:34Speaker 2: It's not high wages, which we don't even have. A
- 14:38Speaker 2: lot of the public gets paid very low wages. It's
- 14:41Speaker 2: not any of that. It's the fact that there has
- 14:45Speaker 2: been a trend that has stuck to South Africa, which
- 14:48Speaker 2: is deindustrialization since about 2009. So you have manufacturing declining
- 14:55Speaker 2: as a share of GDP. That's really the problem. So
- 15:01Speaker 2: the question we should be asking is, how do we
- 15:03Speaker 2: make our manufacturing industries more competitive such that it can
- 15:07Speaker 2: attract capital? There are other things that they mentioned, BE,
- 15:10Speaker 2: and some that have been mentioned.
- 15:13Speaker 1: We're going to have to wrap up, unfortunately, Lisa. We've
- 15:16Speaker 1: got news coming from Joburg. So just a closing comment
- 15:19Speaker 1: in 10 seconds, please. Yes.
- 15:22Speaker 2: So the real thing that must be changed is the
- 15:25Speaker 2: deindustrialization trend in South Africa. That must be reversed. We
- 15:29Speaker 2: should be having a situation where capital should be flowing
- 15:33Speaker 2: to the manufacturing sector, which will increase South Africa's resilience
- 15:37Speaker 2: even to global changes.
- 15:39Speaker 1: We appreciate your time and your insights. Lisa Mdutiana, Institute
- 15:43Speaker 1: for Economic Justice Research, joining us. And that's the recommendations
- 15:47Speaker 1: to the Minister of Finance for that medium-term budget speech
- 15:50Speaker 1: expected tomorrow.