Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / The Grief Vampires
Transcript
- 0:00Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheist this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:23book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:56My special guest was featured back in twenty nineteen in The New York Times.
- 1:00She was featured as part of an online sting operation. In fact, they
- 1:07called her a vigilante. That's my kind of guest. She is a skepticism
- 1:12activist. She writes for Skeptical Inquirer. She's a co founder of the Monterey
- 1:19County Skeptics. She has been awarded the James Randy Award for Skepticism in the
- 1:23Public Interest. She is founder of the About Time project, which we'll get
- 1:29into, and that's an umbrella for guerrilla skepticism. On Wikipedia, she is
- 1:36an ambassador for the Center for Inquiry, and she can be heard on the
- 1:40Skeptic Zone podcast. Not enough credits for you, my friend, Susan Gerbick,
- 1:47So good to have you. It's great to be here. It's nice
- 1:49as se sa. So you're dangling psychic bait. I guess we'll just start
- 1:56with this whole sting operation. What are we talking about. Well, we
- 2:00put together a whole series of investigations even before the New York Times article came
- 2:05out. We always call them something operations, something something. So we've had
- 2:08Operation ice Cream Cone, Operation peach Pit, Operation Tater Taught, Operation Onion
- 2:15Ring, and so on, and so we put together all kinds of various
- 2:20stings to expose people who claim to be able to communicate with the dead.
- 2:24We mostly focus on those people who have some some sort of notoriety, maybe
- 2:30enough to be able to have a Wikipedia page or have a TV and have
- 2:32a TV show. Not necessarily the psychic that's down in the corner, you
- 2:37know, the corner of your street that has you know, does readings there?
- 2:40Not that one. We're looking at the more prominent psychics, and we
- 2:46do interchange the word psychic with medium, with grief vampire, because it's all
- 2:52kind of one and the same to some extent. But I specialize mostly in
- 2:57hot readings, and that is a unique how should I say? Most psychics
- 3:04use cold reading and editing if they're on TV to make themselves appear to be
- 3:08real, but a very small subset of them use hot readings, which is
- 3:14where they go in. They investigate the client beforehand, and then they appear
- 3:17to know a lot of information about them. So when you have somebody you
- 3:23suspect of being a hot readers, it's a you can sting am easier once
- 3:29you know the ways they come about getting the information. You can plant information
- 3:35that no way they could know unless they were reading your social media or whatever.
- 3:38And so that's what we've done various times. Okay, well, let's
- 3:43sort of unlayered that those onions real fast cold reading is this audience is going
- 3:47to be well versed in much of this, but I know it might be
- 3:50new material for some. So let's do our due diligence. Where cold reading
- 3:54is what reading your clothing, your retire, your cadence, your gesture,
- 4:01the way you smell, what's in your background on a zoom screen. And
- 4:05then there are warm readings and hot readings. I know that some have actually
- 4:11used Q cards. I know that there were some psychics who before you give
- 4:15them audience, you know, especially some of the celebrities, you're filling out
- 4:17Q cards and they're picking those up, and so they're already sort of pre
- 4:21informed about the things that they're supposed to know psychically. Would that qualify as
- 4:26a hot reading? I mean, help me out. Oh absolutely. Back
- 4:30in the days of faith readers, faith healers and so on, the audience
- 4:33would come in and they would fill out prayer cards, and there's various ways
- 4:38that they would be able to get ahold of those prayer cards. Even Peter
- 4:42pop Off back in James Randy's day, they would get a basket of these
- 4:46prayer cards and he would just have his wife read one of the prayer cards
- 4:51to people, and then he would cast it out to the audience. I'm
- 4:56getting Elizabeth Morgan who's at one five six North Seventh Street, who has arthritis
- 5:00all over her body. Well, she wrote that on the prayer card right
- 5:03before she came in. That's hot reading also. And then once he gets
- 5:08her up on stage or she stands up and the cameras are on her or
- 5:12whatever. Then he just does his speel you know of like, oh God,
- 5:15it is saving you. So faith faith healing has done hot readings,
- 5:20and a hot reading could also be just as simple of my like maybe your
- 5:28sister saying, hey, you've got to see this medium. She's great,
- 5:32and so you go see the medium and this medium knows all about you.
- 5:35Well, yeah, your sister just told you all about about you know,
- 5:40the problems you're having a work and so on. So that's a hot reading.
- 5:43Anytime you have information about a person ahead of time is a hot read.
- 5:47I was interested too. Some of the psychics have a team of researchers.
- 5:51They go out and comb the Internet for information about someone in advance of
- 5:56the visit. By the way, Peter Popaf for those who aren't of that
- 5:59gen ration or familiar, he's still around. I think he's still a millionaire,
- 6:04which is just a travesty, but he would do these faith healing services.
- 6:10And James Randy and another gentleman whose name escapes me were they're scanning radio
- 6:15frequencies and they realized he had a receiver in one of his ears, and
- 6:20his wife was backstage and she would read into his ear so that he could
- 6:26hear it from God miraculously. Hello, Pete, can you here me?
- 6:31If you can't, you're in trouble. Junk pop Off was being prompted by
- 6:36his wife through a wireless earpiece Dearly Johnson. She'd gotten her information from prayer
- 6:48cards filled out by the faithful before the show began to get You want to
- 6:57get rid of this walker, sister, Oh glory, how long have you
- 7:03been walking on that walk? Two years? Three years? She was sixteen
- 7:10twenty seventh tenth Street, sixteen twenty seven tenth Street. That right, burning
- 7:19this athritus bread out of your body. And this is how gullible people are,
- 7:26or at least how much they want to believe maybe yeah, maybe,
- 7:30how much they can't abide the idea that it was all a hoax. They've
- 7:33already emotionally married themselves to the hope is that when he came forward afterwards and
- 7:40said it wasn't an ear piece, it was a hearing aid, no one
- 7:44stopped to ask why a faith healer would have hearing loss. I thought that
- 7:49was a big omission. Um, tell me about grief vampires. That's a
- 7:57term that you use often. Let's flesh it out well Mark Edward, my
- 8:01partner, came up with that term. It is kind of to distinguish between
- 8:07a person who communicates with who says they communicate with the dead, from a
- 8:11person who's doing tarot readings or astrology or you know, tea readings or whatever.
- 8:18It's somebody who's going to try to find your grief and try to latch
- 8:22onto the grief, and your grief could be somebody who has died, or
- 8:26it could be maybe you know that you you have in some sort of inferior
- 8:33complex that you that they can use as a grief they can manipulate to get
- 8:39you to do more readings and to take your money out of you, or
- 8:43to get power over you. It's not always about the money. A lot
- 8:46of it is about power, a lot of it is about manipulation. So
- 8:50a grief empire is somebody who would be trying to find your grief, trying
- 8:56to find a hook into you so that they can manipulate you for whatever reason
- 9:01that they're manipulating you. So beyond the John Edwards types who are shilling these
- 9:07psychic powers for cash, somebody a spouse, a life partner who is maybe
- 9:11a malignant narcissist might be a grief vampire, sort of sucking you dry in
- 9:16that way. Possibly. Yeah, I hadn't thought of it that way,
- 9:20but I suppose so, yeah, I mean, I don't know. I
- 9:22find that manipulators find people when they are vulnerable, or they find their vulnerabilities
- 9:28and prey upon them. Right, The sociopathic part of them does not empathize,
- 9:33and so it really becomes about control and serving the self. That's probably
- 9:39a whole other conversation. You and I could go out for coffee and talk
- 9:41about that, Susan forever. Okay, So you're creating fake social media accounts
- 9:48as bait for the psychics, do I understand that? Yes, we've done
- 9:52it in many different forms. We've done it using email, We've used Facebook.
- 9:58You can do it also just in person to some extent, there's different
- 10:03forms of doing it, depending on which way you think that it will bait
- 10:05the psychic. And also sometimes I've done these stings to the same individual and
- 10:13I don't want them to you know, I would think they'd be wary of
- 10:18Facebook again, but no, we can catch them again using Facebook. I
- 10:22don't quite know why they haven't caught on there. They're fully aware of what
- 10:26I'm doing, but I think they haven't had enough repercussions, and I think
- 10:31that's why they're just continuing because it's very successful for them financially, and there's
- 10:35always another person who's willing to throw money at them. So if you and
- 10:37I are having this very public conversation a burning the undercover agents, you know,
- 10:43by talking about this. No, everything's hidden away, and I don't
- 10:48think it's a problem at all. But people should be wary of what you
- 10:52do. Not that you shouldn't put things on social media, but just be
- 10:54aware that anything on social media can be held against you. Don't assume that
- 11:00you have some privacy controls, because we can find out almost anything about anybody.
- 11:05Anybody who's been alive has had been in the newspaper. Either you mentioned
- 11:09in an obituary for a family member, or you were in a choir in
- 11:15elementary school, or you know, we can find information about you. So
- 11:20don't be so complacent that you can't. Oh, you know, the internet
- 11:22already freaks me out. We were talking about a specific recipe the other day.
- 11:26We were just talking. I wasn't on my phone, we were just
- 11:31in the kitchen, and then I logged onto something and there was an ad
- 11:35for the very type of food we were just talking about, and I was
- 11:39like, yes, Lord, or yes Google or Facebook or somebody's watching or
- 11:46listing. You know. When I brought in our Amazon Echo, I told
- 11:50Natalie, I said, I can't believe I purposefully brought in an active listening
- 11:54device into the walls of my home. But at the same time, I
- 11:58love it, you know. So when you say there is no privacy,
- 12:01sometimes I wonder about the things I don't know about. Do you ever wonder?
- 12:05Do you think maybe it's the stuff we aren't aware of that should be
- 12:09the most terrifying. No, I'm not too terrified. Should be aware that
- 12:15there is no I mean, there's always a way of finding out something or
- 12:18and just pure chance I mean, or coincidence. Well, what's the again,
- 12:22Share only as much as you can or wish to about your methodology.
- 12:26But what is a fake social media account doing? Are you acting like a
- 12:33Mark? Well? Possibly? Okay, So our most recent sting is called
- 12:37Operation Onion Ring, and we infiltrated a social spirit It's called a spirit circle
- 12:45with eight people involved, four hundred dollars per person, and the psychic was
- 12:50Thomas John and I've written about this so I can reveal whatever whatever would be
- 12:56of interest to you. But what we did is I only have four days
- 13:00to pull it off. What he was doing is he was going to the
- 13:03spirit circle was focused on children from five to twelve, So we were kind
- 13:09of not too keen on that idea at all. That was pretty pretty bad.
- 13:13So what he would do is he was you know, they paid four
- 13:16hundred dollars. The parent had to be there with them, and then they
- 13:20came out to a zoom call and then they had he read them. And
- 13:26what he was reading was their social media, their mother's social media presence.
- 13:31Okay, forgive me, I don't mean to interrupt you, but I want
- 13:35to be clear. A spirit circle where the medium was targeting young children.
- 13:41Did I hear that right? Yeah? Well, they the parents paid four
- 13:43hundred dollars for the child to have a reading from the medium. What's the
- 13:48attitude of a parent, Oh, they totally buy it. They want their
- 13:52child to be special. This, this particular spirit circle that we attended was
- 13:58to help the child to understand that they may have mediumship qualities themselves, if
- 14:05they saw spirit people or shadow people or whatever circumstances. Thomas John was explaining
- 14:11to them that they possibly have powers themselves. So the parents were all into
- 14:18it. They loved it, and in a lot of ways, the parent
- 14:20was getting a reading because of course the children don't have social media presence,
- 14:26so what he would do was he would just say your grandmother or your great
- 14:28grandmother when referring to the child. But really what he was doing was he
- 14:33was just reading the parents, the mother's social media and just regurgitating it so
- 14:39it was aimed towards the child. Oh yeah, this is absolutely happening.
- 14:45The parents were all for it. They were sitting right there next to them
- 14:48and proud as heck that their child was getting a reading. Our little timmy
- 14:52seems to have a gift kind of thing. Well, there was more that
- 14:56it was explaining that a couple of the children we're saying that they no longer
- 15:01could, were dreaming about their family member who had died, and they felt
- 15:07egregious, you know, sad about that because the parent obviously is pushing them
- 15:11is you know, the children are growing up and moving on and they don't
- 15:15remember grandma like they did before. But the mothers, and it's always mothers
- 15:20were pushing them again and saying, well, you know what about you know
- 15:24when Grandma used to call you this, or grandma you know, you can
- 15:26feel that the mother is still filling the grief, so they're they're laying it
- 15:31on the child, and the child in at least two of the circumstances.
- 15:35And I mean, I have this all recorded, and it was really hard
- 15:37to watch. These children are crying when they're called on, and they you
- 15:43just want to reach out and hug them. They just feels awful. They're
- 15:46they're feeling like, you know, they're moving on, but the parent wants
- 15:52them to stay in the place where they were, where they're connected to their
- 15:56parents, the grandparents or whatever. It's it's really difficult to watch one twelve
- 16:00year old she was she was she was saying that she couldn't connect like she
- 16:07had in the past, and she felt you could feel that she felt so
- 16:11much guilt about that. And the mother was, you know, kind of
- 16:17like it'll happen again kind of thing, and Thomas down is saying, oh,
- 16:19yeah, you're growing up. You'll move past the stage and then you'll
- 16:22be able to get back to where you're connecting with dead people again. It
- 16:26was It was excruciating to watch Seth. It was really hard. You feel
- 16:32for these children. They're they're easily being manipulated and the parents are buying into
- 16:37it. They loved it. This is great. In one case, one
- 16:41of the parents was a medium herself, and we found her on social media.
- 16:45Because it's on zoom, you could see her name right there. So
- 16:49we just did a quick look on social media and there she was. She
- 16:53had shut up with her six year old. She had an eight year old
- 16:57son who refused to be on the call and so she showed up with the
- 17:02other child instead because he's like, I don't want anything to do with this.
- 17:06But the mother was a medium. While she claims to be a medium,
- 17:08she has a business some known name psychic medium that out there, but
- 17:14she truly believes this is for the best of her children. Interesting. I
- 17:18read an article years ago talking about how children trained to think in magical terms
- 17:26grow up and often have a much more difficult time navigating the real world,
- 17:30differentiating fact from fiction, truth claims that are false from actual truth. You
- 17:37know, I don't know, have you developed an opinion about conditioning young people
- 17:45for this sort of I don't know, for looking for supernatural or magical solutions
- 17:49in the natural world. You know, I really don't know. I was
- 17:53raised in a religious household, totally credulous, totally believing in astrology and all
- 18:00kinds of weird things. But you know, I turned out all right.
- 18:04I think that, Well, I'm glad for that. People say so,
- 18:07but I think that we really don't. We really don't know. I think
- 18:14it just depends in the environment. These kids may rebel completely against their parents.
- 18:18In the long run, we don't know. I think that it's not
- 18:22healthy. I think in there, in there, this childhood, in this
- 18:26time when they're just starting to form their opinions about things, I think it's
- 18:30I think it's dangerous. But I mean, the argument could also be made
- 18:33that Santa Claus is telling them Santa Claus is real. Is dangerous. At
- 18:37the very least, it made me a late bloomer. It took me,
- 18:41you know, an extra few decades to realize that maybe, you know,
- 18:44maybe that a lot of these outlandish, outrageous claims might not be substantiated.
- 18:49But you know, there's hope. I got there. I mean, I
- 18:52got there, so if I can figure it out, maybe someone else can.
- 18:56Um all right, Well, let's say you have experienced grief hypothetical I've
- 19:00lost a child. And I only use that because it is an example.
- 19:04I think of the type of raw grief that people experience when they are preyed
- 19:11upon. And so somebody hangs a shingle and says, I speak to the
- 19:15debt, I can connect you with your lost child. And I go in
- 19:19and pay whatever the fee is, and I sit down. What kind of
- 19:23thing might I experience if a grief vampire targets me? What might I be
- 19:30in for? Well, if it's a local, you know, psychic and
- 19:36so on, they're probably just going to try to keep How do you come
- 19:38in regularly, maybe every month or every week or a few times a year,
- 19:42to come in and get a terror reading or a or whatever and say
- 19:47they're communicating with your child. It could be just that simple that you know
- 19:51it's it's It depends on how you want to evaluate that is, if that's
- 19:56harm or not. I think anytime anybody's lying to you, especially about something
- 20:00as personal and intimate as a death, those people, I don't think necessarily
- 20:07you're going to do hot readings other than once you've gone to a medium,
- 20:14and you go to them again, it's a hot reading because they've already seen
- 20:18you, right, so they can just make a few votes and say,
- 20:21oh, the last time she was here, she talked about her sister who
- 20:22had died, you know, And then the next time you come in,
- 20:26they just say, oh, your sister wasn't she's here again, and now
- 20:29she's wearing a blue coat and she's out in the garden. I mean,
- 20:32that's a hot read obviously when you have it multiple times. But if you
- 20:37are one of these victims that is had lost a child, and I see
- 20:44this all the time on Facebook, where you can see how people are posting
- 20:48over and over. They're posting years even after the death of their child or
- 20:53their other family member, and it's just the posts are very emotional, you
- 21:00know, they're talking about happy times they had with them and so on,
- 21:03and then how much they miss them, and it's it's it's painful to see
- 21:11that. They probably should see a grief counselor of some sort, but not
- 21:15a psychic medium, because what happens is we manipulate the memories. Right.
- 21:22So a lot of these people say they're helping the grief vampires say they're helping
- 21:26out somehow manipulating the grief, you know, helping them to the grief.
- 21:30I don't. I don't think lying to somebody is ever going to be helpful.
- 21:33I think that there are experts who are licensed and trained to be able
- 21:37to do this, to be able to help you with through your grief.
- 21:41And we all grief differently, so it may take a very long time for
- 21:45some people to get over their grief. But when somebody's manipulating it saying,
- 21:51you know, oh, your dad was a really happy guy. He just
- 21:53loved you so much, and you know, these could be very complex emotions.
- 21:57You don't know what actually is behind that. The father may be abusive,
- 22:02and now you feel this a massive amount of guilt over how you spoke
- 22:07to your dad towards the end of his life, when you've always thought he
- 22:10was this, you know, not too great guy, and now the psychic
- 22:12saying, oh, he's he was actually a really good guy. You know,
- 22:17I don't know. It's just wrong for somebody to be telling you a
- 22:19lie about something and reformatting your memories. You know, you're thinking differently now
- 22:26because a memory is apparently, as science tells us, it's not like putting
- 22:30a VCR back in the day, putting a VCR in and it plays at
- 22:34the same time. Every time you listen to that, you access that memory.
- 22:40You tend to rewrite your memories over time, so if somebody is telling
- 22:42you a new memory, then it could be just as real as the real
- 22:48memory. So you know, we really shouldn't be manipulating people like this.
- 22:53Talking here with activist and skeptic Susan Gerbick, who has done a lot of
- 22:59work dealing with learning about and exposing psychics, especially at the celebrity level,
- 23:04do you think they're wrong grifters or do you think some people, some of
- 23:08these readers, psychics, mediums are just deluded, they really believe the bullshit.
- 23:15Well, when you get into the higher levels where they're on TV and
- 23:18they're hot reading, then there's no doubt in my mind that they know darnwell
- 23:26what they're doing, because you cannot go on to somebody's social media account and
- 23:29get some tidbits that you repeat later as if they came from the hereafter or
- 23:33the spirit world and not know that you are totally making this up and that
- 23:37you're grifting them. So a hot reader knows darnwell what they're doing. Same
- 23:42with it when they get into the editing process where you can make things happen
- 23:47and change things around. The real magic happens in the editing room, as
- 23:52you probably know, Seth, So you can make people sound better or you
- 23:56know, take things out or change things around. It's not that difficult,
- 24:02and people have been doing it for a long time since we've been able to
- 24:03do this with TV shows. But there are a few people, and my
- 24:11partner Mark Edward says that probably two point five percent of the population are actually
- 24:15good people who have talked themselves into this and believe that they really are helping.
- 24:22Another two and a half percent, he says, are probably not.
- 24:30They're having some sort of mental problems. They think they're communicating with the dead.
- 24:34But he says, and he's been around a lot longer than I am
- 24:37in this world, ninety five percent are just they know darn well they're fooling.
- 24:42Though some too believe their own bit, you know, they think that
- 24:48sometimes they get sometimes a coincidence happens, or people are gushing all over them
- 24:53about, Oh, what an amazing person you are, Oh my gosh,
- 24:56your gift is amazing, And I think that probably SI they think, you
- 25:00know, maybe I do have a gift here, but we tend to count
- 25:04the hits and ignore the misses, right. I mean, you walk into
- 25:07the grocery store one hundred times, not without incident, and then on one
- 25:11hundred and first time you bump into someone you haven't seen in thirty years,
- 25:15and wow, the universe must have coordinated this encounter. It's everything happens for
- 25:21a reason. You've heard that one, right, So yeah, and you
- 25:23did just earlier in the in the call, you said that maybe the echo
- 25:27was you were in the kitchen and you heard a rest and you were talking
- 25:30about a recipe and then then used to get an ad. That's remembering the
- 25:34hits and forgetting the misses right there, because you've probably see ads all the
- 25:37time for food products that have nothing to do with the conversation you've had earlier.
- 25:44There was a study that was referenced in the New York Times article from
- 25:48twenty eighteen. Nearly ninety five thousand psychic quote businesses exist in this country right
- 25:56now, to the tune of two billion dollars in a well revenue big business.
- 26:00You want to speak to the money. Oh my gosh, that is
- 26:04only what we know about. So a lot of the psychics use cash or
- 26:10they use cash apps, so I'm sure that's not being reported. So just
- 26:14you know, expand that tenfold, and that's probably more what we're talking about
- 26:18as far as finances. And then the pandemic happened and with the lockdown,
- 26:22people have become a lot more insecure. They you know, you had a
- 26:27lot more death, You had a lot of people not able to say goodbye
- 26:32to their family members. They're taking them to the hospital and then you know,
- 26:36maybe you could FaceTime them and that was it. So during the pandemic,
- 26:41psychics moved to zoom and as people lost their jobs and so on and
- 26:45they needed an employment, they would turn to just putting up a Facebook page
- 26:51and doing readings. So it's been really prolific during the last few years that
- 26:57we even have more people who are their psychic and able to do these readings
- 27:02on TikTok. Oh my gosh, you can't. You you can't go five
- 27:07feet without bumping into somebody who's doing terror readings or horoscopes or or that kind
- 27:12of thing. So I'm sure they're not reporting most of that income. So
- 27:18that what was a two billion dollars or yeah, that's probably nothing. I'm
- 27:22sure it's far more than that. By the way, that's the plot of
- 27:26one of my favorite horror movies. It's on Shutter it's called Host, and
- 27:29it's about an online seyance that goes horribly wrong. That of course being fiction,
- 27:34and we know all about it. The whole idea of a zoom I
- 27:40guess the word seyance, you know, the reading whatever. You know,
- 27:42you're supposedly connecting to the spirit world from long distance. You know, what
- 27:48a wild twenty first century phenomenon. Have you been involved? Have you watched
- 27:53in the wings an online zoom thing? What's it look like? What does
- 27:57it feel like? Oh? Absolutely, it's quite emotional. You feel very
- 28:03badly for the parents, for the people in the event. It's it's I
- 28:07mean, they're crying and they're just reaching for anything. If you're in a
- 28:12one of these events, and I've been a many of these events, like
- 28:15you have three hundred people on the zoom screen and the psychicists calling on one
- 28:19or two people in the chat area. You can see people calling out for
- 28:23anything, like maybe the psychic will say I'm getting a Michael and he's got
- 28:29a connection in New York and something about fishing. Well, you can imagine
- 28:33how many people that would, you know, relate to thinking about how many
- 28:37people we actually know. And you see people in the chat going, I
- 28:40have a Michael, I have he fished? Oh my gosh, and yes,
- 28:44he lived in New York or whatever, and they're they're clinging onto anything
- 28:48to try to get the psychic's attention. Me me, me, me,
- 28:51that's my guy, that's my guy, you know, and it's just it's
- 28:55so emotional and they're you know, but you had mentioned or the young child
- 29:00with the the online meeting, and I wondered, had you ever submitted yourself?
- 29:07Have you ever in some way relatively anonymously engaged the medium? Oh yeah,
- 29:15Well that's the whole New York Times article, is that. Mark Edward
- 29:18and myself myself went in Operation I'm setting you up, Susan, I want
- 29:25to hear the story. Oh oh my gosh, I'm full of story.
- 29:27So Operation Pizza role Mark Edward and myself we went to the reading as different
- 29:33characters. We went as Susannah Forsyth Wilson and Mark Wilson because we had id
- 29:41in those names and we my team had created social media. Over ten days,
- 29:48they created social media for the characters of Susannah Forsyth Wilson and Mark Wilson,
- 29:53and in those Facebook pages that told a story about our lives. It
- 29:59was totally fictional and we did not have access to those Facebook pages, so
- 30:03we didn't know what was on those Facebook pages. And when we walked into
- 30:07the venue and we sat down, we know what we did is I texted
- 30:12the team and said I'm in the building, I'm sitting here, and then
- 30:18my team went onto those fake Facebook pages, tagging the psychic saying, Oh,
- 30:22I'm here, I'm so excited to be here, and so on.
- 30:26I really hope to get into contact with my dear twin brother Andy, who
- 30:30died of pancreatic cancer and so on. So they just continued the story.
- 30:34Now, Mark and I were given a little bit of information to attend because
- 30:40we had to know when to raise our hand. When the psychic is up
- 30:42on the stage and he says I'm getting a twin brother who wants to reach
- 30:47out to his sister, I have to know when I'm going to put my
- 30:49hand up. So we were given a basic amount of information him and I
- 30:55for two different stories. And so when the psychic and it was Thomas John
- 30:59again, I mentioned an operation onon ring. He gets up and he says,
- 31:03I'm getting when who wants to reach out to his sister? I raised
- 31:10my hand, and then he says, and then I think he died of
- 31:12something in the stomach area. I think it was pancreatic cancer. And then
- 31:15I said yes, And then I pretend to cry. You know, I'm
- 31:19dabbing at my eyes and so on, and then he went on reading Mark
- 31:23and myself for fifteen minutes about characters we had no idea any information on,
- 31:29and he went in depth, and he kept reading and reading about our family,
- 31:33and we kept pretending to cry, and we didn't have the answers.
- 31:37So sometimes he would say things to us and we would just pretend, Oh,
- 31:41that was my father, No, I think it was my brother.
- 31:45Oh yes, we did live in Michigan for a while. I don't know
- 31:48what's on the Facebook pages. The psychic obviously does. I don't. So
- 31:53how do you reconcile that? Whenever you're all done? And he says,
- 31:57you know, we don't expose yourself at the event. We wait until we're
- 32:01outside of the event, and we do our research and we look at the
- 32:05Facebook pages to see what was recorded and what was actually on the Facebook pages,
- 32:12and he's he's basically reading the Facebook pages back to us that we had
- 32:15no idea what was on those Facebook pages. So that was pretty much the
- 32:20plot of Operation Pizza Role right there. Boo boom. So you he's supposed
- 32:25to have an immediate psychic connection to you the person, but the profile is
- 32:31somebody else, somebody, and he never reads me or Mark. So now
- 32:36I have obviously real dead people in my life. Well that sounded really weird.
- 32:40No, I understand say there are people in my life. I was
- 32:43gonna say, I understood this spirit of what you were saying. But that
- 32:45made it even worse. Susan, go ahead, go ahead, s But
- 32:50he never once said that. He never said anything about my real parents who
- 32:53have died. He never said anything about my sister who has died, or
- 32:58Mark's family. It was it was. He never said, you know,
- 33:01I'm getting something nefarious about you, that you're here under false pretenses, that
- 33:08the money that paid for these readings, which was one hundred and sixty dollars
- 33:13a person, was came out of a fund given to you by James Randy.
- 33:16I mean, my gosh, that should have really alerted him, you
- 33:20would think, But no, he didn't read me, he didn't read the
- 33:23person who was sitting in front of him. He read the Facebook profiles that
- 33:29we had planted as bait for him to find. And so it was so
- 33:34obvious he's hot reading and this isn't the only circumstances. And Operation Onion ring
- 33:39with the children. We planted children in there. We brought children in and
- 33:45he did. It was over zoomed. So he's got eight children there and
- 33:49two of them are from our team. One of them is Bailey Harris that
- 33:53your audience may know her and her mother sat there. She was twelve,
- 33:57well she was fourteen, but played a twelve year old and she sat there
- 34:01the whole time, for two hours with these other students. And then we
- 34:05had a team in New Zealand and they're there and all they were given was
- 34:10I made fake emails and I made the accounts as generic as possible of the
- 34:20email so you wouldn't be able to search for him Joe Martin, and then
- 34:23I gave him a story in the email. I sent them the email and
- 34:28it said just some basic information about the child who was attending. And then
- 34:36he read them, and all he read was what was on those Facebook I
- 34:39mean the emails that I had sent twice, and he went through and just
- 34:44gave them all the information that was on there, just changed a little bit
- 34:47to make it sound like it was coming from the dead, I guess,
- 34:51and then he added a little bit of color. Because what I did is
- 34:52I made it so impossible for him to google those persons, because it was
- 34:59it was a very very narrow amount of information I gave him. And because
- 35:01I'd given him four hundred dollars and were you know, two people out of
- 35:07the other out of a group of eight, he had to he didn't have
- 35:12a lot of information. So he just read that little bit and at no
- 35:15time did he read them personally, like he didn't say, you know,
- 35:19something about the dead persons that would be in their actual lives. He just
- 35:22made generic statements about students, you know, do well in school and all
- 35:27that kind of stuff. And then what information we gave him and that was
- 35:30Operation Onion Ring. Was the four hundred dollars the standard ticket or did you
- 35:35pay extra in the hopes of getting their attention? Well, it was an
- 35:38eight person event, so everybody was going to be read so okay, all
- 35:42right, So it was like a flat fee for the whole crew. I'm
- 35:45trying to I'm trying to understand, like the monetary benefits. You don't blow
- 35:51the whistle. Then you go back, you assemble the info, you organize
- 35:54your thoughts, you get it ready. What's a whistle blowing look like?
- 35:59When you leave a session like that, what do you do? Well?
- 36:02We go back and we make sure that everything that we were recording recorded,
- 36:07because we're recording everything, and we're taking photos, and we interact with the
- 36:12people at the events, trying to talk to them about, you know,
- 36:15their history with the psychic we play. We play the characters, you know,
- 36:21we get in line at the bathroom and talk about how excited we are
- 36:24to be there and who are you here to see? So we're fully in
- 36:29the role, and we do pay the top price because we want to get
- 36:31into the VIP events and schmooz with people. So we're totally in character the
- 36:37whole time. And when we leave the event or if it's a zoom event
- 36:43or whatever, we're in character from the moment you know, you get out
- 36:46of your car necessarily because you never know who's going to be watching You could
- 36:51get in an elevator with somebody and it would be somebody who's who's doing the
- 36:55you know, it was going to follow you to the to the event,
- 36:59and you're talking about your trip to Hawaii and how your daughter just told you
- 37:02she was pregnant, you know, and you're telling your friend. So,
- 37:06I mean, hot reading could happen at any time. I always knew Susan
- 37:09Gerbick was a method actor. You know, she inhabits the character, inhabits
- 37:15the character as all great thespians do. More with Susan Gerbick in just a
- 37:20second, we're going to talk about the Psychic Friends Network. Anybody remember that
- 37:24those nine hundred numbers. We got to talk about that. That and more
- 37:29coming up next. Your support on Patreon so very appreciated. You get the
- 37:39show commercial free, and you get it two days early patreon dot com.
- 37:45Slash Seth Andrews continuing with my special guest Skeptic and de Bunker Susan Gerbick,
- 37:53as we discussed the grief vampires and those who are exposing them. You've mentioned
- 38:01Mark Edward's name several times. Mentalist magician to me, sounds like a Darren
- 38:07Brown type. Can you tell me about the man. Oh well, Mark
- 38:10Edward, he's just a wonderful guy. He's here in the other room.
- 38:15Well, I mean other than he's a sweet fella. But the fire in
- 38:19his belly comes from Since he's not here to defend himself, let's talk about
- 38:22him as as kind of a co skeptic and co exposer of the Charlatan's,
- 38:28you know, like Darren B. Penn Jalette is a great example. Right.
- 38:31He knows how the sausage is made, he knows what's going on behind
- 38:35the scenes. He knows that the tricks and he leads with hey, everybody,
- 38:39these are tricks, and then he does the trick in the audience.
- 38:44All they're all in on it. He never uses this stuff in a disingenuous
- 38:47way. And Darren Brown is great at going out and doing mentalism and specific
- 38:52things that look supernatural. And he will flat out tell you, you know,
- 38:57this is all like I'm messing with you. It sounds like Marked as
- 39:00much of the same stuff. Right, So he's a mentalist. He has
- 39:04performed at the Magic Castle for years and years and years. He is his
- 39:09expertise is in the seance room. He is an expert on the Houdini seance.
- 39:15And he has been doing this and working as a psychic infiltrating the world
- 39:22of psychics. And he wrote a book called Psychic Blues. It's an audio
- 39:24book as well as a print book. It's called Psychic Blues, Confessions of
- 39:30a Conflicted Medium. And so he knows a lot about the business of the
- 39:35psychic world. You know, what's going on probably in the nineteen nineties,
- 39:38nineteen eighties, what was happening in the spirit world businesses. So that's his
- 39:45world of expertise in his book is mainly about that era. The nine hundred
- 39:51lines, the dialis psychic, kind of like the Miss Cleo kind of stuff
- 39:55on the Friends Network. I think he's Actually they did infomercials that played it
- 40:02like two in the morning. So here, no, I forgive me,
- 40:05we are showing our age. I hate to keep interrupting, but I want
- 40:07to make sure that people are tracking as we move forward before I forget the
- 40:12nine hundred phenomenon. For those who are too young to know what that is
- 40:15is you used to dial from a landline, and I think it was maybe
- 40:20you could do it from your cell as well, where you would be charged
- 40:22like a dollar ninety nine a minute, and you would three ninety nine for
- 40:28someone like Miss Cleo. And so they set the hook and they keep you
- 40:31on the freaking phone for as long as they can. HI. This is
- 40:37Lynda George and with a quick reminder about how simple it is to get your
- 40:39own personal psychic reeting on the Psychic Friends Network. By calling the number on
- 40:44your screen, you'll be connected to the home or office of a professional psychic
- 40:49who cares about your future. All calls to the Psychic Friends Network are personal
- 40:52and confidential. So whether you have a question about love, romance, success
- 40:58or money, call the Psychic Friends Network today. All it takes is a
- 41:01telephone and an open mind per minute. But the nine hundred phenomenon, and
- 41:07that was also the Satanic panic, right, So now you've got people worried
- 41:12about the devil, or they're at least they're engaged in these sort of spiritism
- 41:15type conversations. With the Satanic Panic part of Mark's story as well. No,
- 41:20no, he never got involved in that. He was He stayed mainly
- 41:23with the psychic world and dealt with that. So whenever I met up with
- 41:29him in two thousand and nine, I was already interested in psychics, in
- 41:34the psychic world, but we became a lot more involved in doing something about
- 41:40it, trying to expose it and trying to show how it works and the
- 41:46idea of um they call it, which you said with Darren Brown and Pindal,
- 41:52let do where they say a disclaimer, I mean that doesn't necessarily work.
- 41:58You can say to you can say to you're blue in the face that
- 42:00this is all a trick, and people will come up afterwards and they'll still
- 42:04say, I know you said it was a trick, but I want to
- 42:07know how you really did it. So, so a disclaimer of saying it
- 42:10is, it's kind of nonsense. You have to have as far as disclaimers
- 42:17go. Your venue is pretty much your disclaimer. And if you do psychic
- 42:22readings or you do something that looks like you're playing an actor, you're playing
- 42:28a role. If you do seances and they do feel like you're real,
- 42:31well then within thirty seconds they've got your business card or they go onto your
- 42:37website. It's clear that you're a magician. Is somebody who could be hired
- 42:39as a as an actor, you know. So disclaimers are kind of wiggly
- 42:45wobbly dependent. I see people get very upset because people mentalists don't disclaim because
- 42:52but then an actor doesn't disclaim either. If somebody's playing Shakespeare, they don't
- 42:57get up at the end of the movie and say, oh, by the
- 42:59way, I'm an actor just like you. But the human desire to believe,
- 43:02you know, I'm we see it's so often and I totally understand.
- 43:07One of the reason that I'm that I don't go so hard on everyday Christians
- 43:13for being Christians because I were one, but I had a tremendous desire to
- 43:19hold onto it. You know, it was a cherished part of me,
- 43:22my identity, and it's it served me. You can understand, even evolutionarily,
- 43:27how religions in that way may have you know, you understand why people
- 43:31can latch onto them. And I feel the same must be true for the
- 43:35psychic world, the spirit world. You know, we want to believe,
- 43:38right, Do you feel like that's innate? Susan, Absolutely well. I
- 43:44think that we all have something that we hold on too. We can't.
- 43:46You know, people were busy with their lives, were raising our children,
- 43:50were trying to make a living, We're keeping our house clean, we're you
- 43:52know, there's so much that's going on in our lives. We don't have
- 43:55time to be also diving into some of the things in our life that we
- 44:00thought were just natural, like ghosts or you know, going to the moon
- 44:06or pyramid power. You just assume that your parents told you the right thing
- 44:09and you just believe it. Religion, so on. It's part of your
- 44:14culture in a lot of ways, it's your It's just part of you being
- 44:17you. And until you're finally challenged with some of these things, you know,
- 44:22does Bigfoot exist? You know, maybe you always believed, of course
- 44:24bigfoot exists, but why would you even why would you even think that you
- 44:30should challenge it? If until somebody kind of comes head to head and you
- 44:34go, wait a minute, are you telling me that when we used to
- 44:37go out into the woods that was a big foot out there that we could
- 44:40hear knocking on trees or whatever. So people need to believe in something.
- 44:45I think it's it's it's philosophical. I don't really do philosophy that much,
- 44:52as my friends always tell me more of a fact fact the kind of person
- 44:57than this hypothetical world. But I really they do believe that we should probably
- 45:01give and this is problem of one of the problems in the skeptic community.
- 45:07We don't give enough, We don't sympathize enough with the people who are in
- 45:14these situations. It's a very vulnerable situation that you find yourself in at times
- 45:19in your life. And when the medium enters during that moment of time where
- 45:22you're grieving, you're confused about life, your you know somebody your significant partner
- 45:29has left you, or your job, or you know your family's health or
- 45:34whatever it is. When they enter at that moment, that's when you're vulnerable
- 45:37and your your critical thinking skills may not be at the height that they should
- 45:42be. I think we need to be a lot more sympathetic. These are
- 45:45people who are being preyed on, and I use that to mean prey pr
- 45:50e y, not pr a y. And so I think that if we
- 45:54were to look at ourselves as being vulnerable too, maybe not for the specific
- 46:00con but others like it, we can fall for this. It could be
- 46:04a multilevel marketing scheme, you know, for one of us, totally completely
- 46:07different from the psychic role. But again it's somebody manipulating somebody else. I
- 46:13would like to see us turn up the empathy factor you know, I see
- 46:16especially online. I mean, I think in real life it's a little softer,
- 46:20but online it's you know, they're all stupid. Who would be so
- 46:23much of an idiot to fall for this? And we see this in cults,
- 46:28all right, this myth that only dumb people would ever believe what a
- 46:31cult member says or what a cult claims. And then you see people who
- 46:37extricate themselves and talk about what it was like, and they're highly often highly
- 46:42intelligent, thoughtful people who are simply victims, you know, who are brainwashed.
- 46:45And I'm a I'm a fan of your empathetic approach, you know,
- 46:51where we're so reductive online instead to see the whole person and see them as
- 46:55victims first and start there. Let's finish here. How do we I mean,
- 47:00this is your subjective answer. I'm sure a lot of skeptics would answer
- 47:06differently. How do I bullshit proof myself out there? Somebody wants to prey
- 47:09on me. There's a grief vampire or a bank account vampire or whatever,
- 47:15and they relate it to the spirit world. How do I tool myself up?
- 47:21Well, you know, I don't think there's really a great way of
- 47:27doing that because these things happen to people in vulnerable moments, And how do
- 47:31you keep yourself from being vulnerable? I don't know, because you know,
- 47:36right next to the cousin, the kissing cousin of psychics is like these romance
- 47:40scams. So I mean, I think we're all going to be vulnerable to
- 47:45something. Hang on, Susan, I'm sorry. What is a romance scam?
- 47:52Oh my gosh. You know these sweetheart scams where they, oh,
- 47:55everybody out there is getting on social media, somebody approaching you saying that they
- 48:00have a nice smile and I know you better, and then you know,
- 48:05then you enter into conversation with them, and then they have some kind of
- 48:07crisis and then you have to send money to him again, like you're called.
- 48:13There's nobody joined a called. I mean they're joining some movement, right.
- 48:17There's a documentary about a guy like that. It's on Netflix. I
- 48:22want to say, it's like the Worst Person in though I'm trying to think
- 48:23of what the title was. But it was this guy who would come up
- 48:29with this idea. He would claim to be rich and famous, and he
- 48:32would go and find people who were looking for a man who was rich and
- 48:36famous and then he would have some sort of a financial crisis or somebody was
- 48:40coming after him. He was a victim in some way. His bank accounts
- 48:44were locked. I need thousands to get myself out of it. And these
- 48:47people got sucked in, they were groomed right well, absolutely, and only
- 48:52in vulnerable So only some people are going to fall for this. I think
- 48:54you're talking about the tinder swindler. Yeah, yeah, the tinder swindler.
- 48:59Yes, thank people have talked about it, and I've seen catfishing catfish.
- 49:04There's a documentary about that too, Oh of course. And it's only going
- 49:07to happen in vulnerable times. I think the best way people can keep themselves
- 49:13from falling for these kinds of frauds or is to keep good people around you,
- 49:22people who you can talk to, who are you know, legitimately your
- 49:27friends, who are going to tell you to your face that this looks dangerous.
- 49:30You're starting to go down a path that looks like a pyramid scam,
- 49:35or somebody is trying to manipulate your emotions. They're trying to isolate you from
- 49:40your friendships and your past and your family. I think that keeping good people
- 49:46around you, having a great, strong social network around you, and if
- 49:52you don't have this already, you should try to find it. And I
- 49:55think that that's probably the best way of keeping yourself from being vulner vulnerable and
- 50:00falling for these horrible cons that can just devastate to and ring you financially.
- 50:07Rather not to distill it down to a bumper sticker, but I have to
- 50:09think knowledge being power. If I knew the tactic of a faith healer,
- 50:15you know, the lengthening the leg miracle, or you know the crutch is
- 50:20being thrown and all those types of things, if I knew how all of
- 50:23that was done before I was presented with an example of it, I would
- 50:29be looking for the cracks in that facade, right, I'd be looking,
- 50:32and I would think, maybe knowledge is power in the scenario of the psychics
- 50:37and the mediums. If you know to look for it, maybe then you
- 50:42might be looking for it. That's fair and which you think absolutely. We
- 50:45call this pre bunking, or I used to call it an oculation. Innoculation
- 50:50theory is that if you give people the concepts of how people are conned,
- 50:54how things are not what they appear, then you're giving people some sort of
- 51:00skills so that like a toolbox, so that whenever they approach something like this,
- 51:07it may not be the exact same scenario, but they'll be able to
- 51:10feel like, you know, this does seem a lot like a romance scam,
- 51:15but it's not romance. It seems to be connected to something else.
- 51:21You know, maybe you know some other way. So they Because there's so
- 51:25many ways of conning people out there, we can't explain every single way.
- 51:30You know, if it's this, then it's that we can't do that.
- 51:34But I do think that we need to innoculate people with great information, so
- 51:37how they could find information, How do you evaluate a source? How do
- 51:42you trust that? But again, if you surround yourself with people who will
- 51:45help you through this time, then their expertise also will help, because learning
- 51:52about cold reading, learning about hot reading, learning how a video is edited
- 51:57to make it look a certain way, how it's manipulating your emotions as you
- 52:01go through, how the music plays on these TV shows at a certain moment,
- 52:07or they cut right there on a commercial at a time that you will
- 52:10hook you. If we know all that information, that's great. But also
- 52:15sometimes people think they're too smart to be fooled. We see this all the
- 52:20time, James Randy was writing a book called The Magician in a Laboratory about
- 52:23how scientists are some of the easiest people to fool because they think in some
- 52:29cases, they think they're so smart that they're not looking at it in the
- 52:34way that somebody who's got street smarts would probably look at it. So having
- 52:39too much knowledge and thinking that you're just too smart to fall for it is
- 52:44probably a bad way of going about your life. I still think that the
- 52:49best way of doing this is, of course, be curious and to learn
- 52:52all about the world around you, and as we all should for all kinds
- 52:55of reasons. But having a really strong friend family network out there around you
- 53:02that is out there for the best interests of you. Also that means you
- 53:07have to have the best interests of that family member. So we all have
- 53:09to have each other's back. I've got your back, You've got my back.
- 53:15All right, Well, we got each other's back. That's good news.
- 53:17So let's finish with what is the about time project? And how can
- 53:22people connect with your work? Right? So you can find more information about
- 53:27all the things that I'm involved in at about time project dot org. And
- 53:30that's about Time. But what does it mean, what's the project? The
- 53:36project is it's about time we started taking the stuff seriously and started looking into
- 53:40it and bonding together and seeing each other in person and hanging out and all
- 53:45those kinds of things, just getting to know and grow our community. Adamant
- 53:50about let's growing our community. But the about time project. We have our
- 53:54Wikipedia group that is rewriting Wikipedia pages concerning science, scientific skepticism, and claims
- 54:01of the paranormal. We've written over We've written two thousand, one hundred and
- 54:07thirty eight pages. Forty five percent of that is in languages outside of English,
- 54:12and those two thousand, one hundred and thirty eight pages have been read
- 54:15one hundred and thirty two million times. They've been accessed. Are you correcting
- 54:21bad information? What's the work you're doing. Yes, we're creating bad information.
- 54:25We're creating great information. We're translating pages into other languages. You're correcting
- 54:31bad information? Right, I think creating came out, but I want to
- 54:34make sure that the pedantic types don't come into the comment section and say they're
- 54:38creating bad You're correcting bad information, all right? Yes, I have a
- 54:43team of about one hundred people. We're on Facebook, so you have to
- 54:46be on Facebook. The training processes at least four months and it is an
- 54:52extensive fun project. That's the Girls Skepticism on Wikipedia project. I also dabble
- 54:59in a lot of other things. Facilitated communication is in my wheelhouse and with
- 55:05a very really powerful group of people who are bounded together to try to combat
- 55:13facilitated communication. Do you want to explain what that is? Go ahead?
- 55:16Facilitated communication. It's a communication device, they say. I have air quotes
- 55:22around the word communication, mainly affecting people who have difficulty communicating, who've never
- 55:30been able to communicate. I'm talking about people are severely how do I say
- 55:37this, they're severely unable to communicate since birth, you know, since they
- 55:42can't read and write, they've not been able to be educated. And what
- 55:45happens is people there is a small group of people in the world who think
- 55:50they're helping them communicate by holding their hand and placing it over the top of
- 55:53a keyboard, or they hold a letterboard in the air and the person points
- 56:00to the letters, so they're not communicating. The facilitators holding their hand and
- 56:05moving it towards the correct letters. It's it's it's incredible. You can find
- 56:09it on Wikipedia, and there's also a website called Facilitated Communication dot org.
- 56:15It's it's taking the voice away from this person who cannot communicate in writing or
- 56:22speak like that's a whole other show. Oh my gosh, so you and
- 56:25I could, I'm not I've got I'm gonna stop because otherwise it will be
- 56:30here till next Tuesday. What's the website about time project dot org? Susan
- 56:37Gerbick, you are a damn superhero. I just I'm such a fan of
- 56:42you and your work. I'm thankful for your friendship, and I'm sure we'll
- 56:45bump into each other on the road out there, but I'm gonna send everybody
- 56:49to you and your work, and I guess we leave everybody, including ourselves,
- 56:54you know, and the encouragement to stay skeptical. We may not be
- 57:00as invulnerable as we think. Susan, thanks again for talking to me.
- 57:05Thank you so much, Sath. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter
- 57:09for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts
- 57:14featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 57:20on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking
- 57:24Atheist dot com