Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 178 - Author Paul A Thomas on his book Exploring The Land of Ooo
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening, you've Forgotten Hollywood with Doug hess here on j LJBDIA. Hello
- 0:21everyone, and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcast and memories of Yesteryear.
- 0:26My name is Doug Hesson. If you're tuning in to Forgotten Hollywood for the
- 0:29first time, what they do on this podcast is take you on a journey
- 0:32back in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may
- 0:36not know about. And in this episode, we have a very special guest
- 0:40with us today, author Paul A. Thomas, with his recent book Exploring
- 0:45the Land of Ooh, an unofficial overview and production history of Cartoon Networks Adventure
- 0:52Time. Paul, Welcome to Forgotten Hollywood. Thanks for having me. I'm
- 0:57excited to be here. It's our pleasure to have you, and we thank
- 1:00you again just for spending a few minutes with us today to talk about your
- 1:03book Exploring the Landevous and pause. I guess we'll just kind of start off
- 1:10by asking you to provide an overview of the book with the audience. Sure
- 1:15thing, So, this book is a labor of love that looks at the
- 1:19show Adventure Time through a largely historical lens. In the sense that I discussed
- 1:26the history and the production of it, but I also incorporate a little bit
- 1:30of critiquing and reviewing from the perspective of both a fan and a media scholar.
- 1:37I look at the show and I discussed its strength and weaknesses. I'll
- 1:41talk about its fandom, I talk about its reception, but really the bulk
- 1:44of it is on how the series came to be, how the characters were
- 1:48developed, how the writers and producers sort of managed to capture lightning in a
- 1:53bottle and make a television show that's resonated with so many viewers. And it
- 1:57was a real fun experience to put together. There lots of serendipity, but
- 2:02I'm very happy with the with the final results. Absolutely, and when I
- 2:08was reading the book and definitely the intro, this is kind of something that
- 2:14was kind of really up your alley as a kid. You were a big
- 2:17fan of cartoons and animation, and this is kind of like a labor of
- 2:23love that that you have with this. Yeah. Absolutely, And it's it's
- 2:28strange because, Yeah, the origin for it kind of stretches back, honestly
- 2:34years because it all sort of started when I put a blog together on Tumblr
- 2:38where I was would share my thoughts on episodes and review you know, the
- 2:43new seasons and stuff like that. And at one point I thought, you
- 2:46know, maybe I could reach out to some of the writers and see if
- 2:49they would answer, you know, five questions through email. And I think
- 2:53every single writer that I reached out to agreed, and so, you know,
- 2:58I was putting out these little mini interviews every couple months, and then
- 3:01when the show ended for the first time, I thought, hey, I
- 3:06wonder if I could do something a little more substantial. With these contacts I've
- 3:10made. They seemed pretty willing to talk to me, and maybe they'd be
- 3:13willing to talk to me even more, and so just reached out one more
- 3:16time and said, Hey, I'm thinking about putting together some sort of manuscript
- 3:20or project. Would you be interested? And I think only one or two
- 3:24people said no, but the vast majority of the people I reached out to
- 3:29were like, yeah, let's do it. And so then one thing led
- 3:31to another, and I ended up with a with a book that I'm really
- 3:36really proud of and really excited for the world to read. But you're right,
- 3:38yeah, it's it's been kind of a snowball almost right in terms of
- 3:44talk to us a little bit about the popularity of this because it was really
- 3:47meant for kids children, but the humor, some of the stuff that they
- 3:54were talking about really started to catch the attention of teenagers, young adult,
- 4:00etc. And can you just kind of talk to us a little bit about
- 4:03that process and how that evolved. Absolutely, And this is a great question
- 4:08because it's something that I've thought a lot about and I've tried to kind of
- 4:12pinpoint why exactly so many people that are not kids gravitated towards the show.
- 4:17In addition to kids and the book, I talk a little bit about the
- 4:21the idea that the show is very nostalgic, and so I do think it
- 4:26appeals to people's memories of childhood or or their their sort of idealized thoughts of
- 4:32what childhood could or should be like. But I also think that there is
- 4:39that the the show is also subversive in an interesting way where it takes goofiness
- 4:45and zaniness and cuteness and kind of subverts expectations with it. And so I
- 4:48also kind of synthesize that idea of the nostalgia factor with this idea of as
- 4:55I as I put it, you know, like acuteness is sort of an
- 4:57aesthetic of of not resistance necessarily, but a way to kind of push back
- 5:04and reinvent the world. And I think that's something that is a very appealing
- 5:09to young people right now, Gen Z and millennials. There's a lot of
- 5:12issues that we're facing, and to be able to see a show like this
- 5:15where you have characters doing things that are both kind of this might sound strange
- 5:24to say, kind of realistic on one hand, but also goofy and off
- 5:26the wall on the other is just very refreshing and different. I also think
- 5:30that there is an appeal the art style is appealing. That's another thing that
- 5:35I didn't really talk too much about in the book until like near the very
- 5:40end, But I do think that the style it's sort of inaugurated with the
- 5:44sort of noodly limbs and the minimalistic faces, is very much a throwback to
- 5:53old school cartoons from you know, like the thirties, and it's such a
- 5:58throwback that it seems like new and exciting in a way, you know,
- 6:00the whole there's nothing new under the sun sort of thing. But yeah,
- 6:04I feel like cartoons as I was growing up followed a very distinct or all
- 6:09had a very distinct style, and Adventure Time came along and really sort of
- 6:13shifted things, and that, of course, in and of itself, I
- 6:15think just made it something that people were kind of keeping an eye on,
- 6:19or at least aware of. Yeah. No, And it's funny that you
- 6:24talk about the nostalgia aspect of that. I have a senior in high school
- 6:28and an eighth grader at home, and they're in the animation cartoons and they'll
- 6:33have it up on the big screen, and as an adult and as old
- 6:36as I am, I think you're right, there's a little bit of that
- 6:40nostalgia that that just kind of gets you sucked in. When they have it
- 6:44out in the living room they're watching, it's kind of hard not to want
- 6:46to stop and watch. Even at my age, cartoons still kind of appeals
- 6:51to that youth that you had at one time, and then that nostalgia of
- 6:58just kind of memories. Yeah. And I also one thing that I particularly
- 7:02like about Adventure Time is that it's it's obviously was written for children, but
- 7:06it wasn't written only for children, you know. It's one of those shows
- 7:10that I started watching it when I was twenty years old, and I was
- 7:15really really impressed with how obviously there was a lot of silliness to it,
- 7:18but that there was a lot of cleverness. It was very clever, and
- 7:21I could tell that the writers who were putting it together were very talented people.
- 7:26And the show just got more and more complex as it went along,
- 7:29and that sort of creativity and intelligence came came to the forefront in a way
- 7:34that I hadn't seen in a long time. And that's another thing that I
- 7:36think really appeals to a lot of people is that you know, you can
- 7:40put it on and the kids will I don't want to say the kids will
- 7:45just pick up on the silly jokes, because kids are smarter than we often
- 7:46give them credit for. But you know that appeals to them, and then
- 7:50adults can watch it and be like, oh, you know, this actually
- 7:53is pretty that was a pretty funny joke, right, No, I absolutely
- 7:59agree with that. Now, in the book, the way I took it
- 8:01is you kind of write about, you know, season one through season eight
- 8:05in that process, and there was a i'm going to say growth from season
- 8:11one to the end. It wasn't necessarily, I don't want to say not
- 8:16necessarily a hit from the from the start, but there were some drawing pains,
- 8:20if I can say that, Yeah, I think that's a good ways
- 8:24in season one to lead up to where it is today. Yeah. Absolutely,
- 8:31It's very much the case where when it started, Cartoon Network was in
- 8:37an interesting place and they sort of gave Pendleton ward in his his his friends,
- 8:41his creative partners, I don't want to say free reign to do what
- 8:45they wanted, but they kind of just you know, threw them the keys
- 8:46and said figure this out. And so they fresh out of uh, you
- 8:50know, art school, we're trying their best to make a show, not
- 8:54quite knowing what they were doing. And the network was both supportive but also
- 9:00apprehensive, like they thought that there was some good ideas here, but they
- 9:03didn't quite think that that it was getting, you know, developed, quite
- 9:07right. So they brought in some industry veterans, a lot of folks from
- 9:09SpongeBob and Nickelodeon from the nineties productions, and so things started to stabilize,
- 9:15and a big thing was just figuring out the tone of the show, because
- 9:18there was sort of the they were at war with trying to either do like
- 9:22a goofball off the wall, comedy or like a little more of a grounded
- 9:26sitcom sort of feel. And once they figured out that they didn't have to
- 9:31go like total bonkers off the wall, just random comedy, and they could
- 9:37kind of make the characters a little more real, I think that's when things
- 9:39started to settle down and become more consistent. Also at that point, once
- 9:43the first season debuted and it was met with critical you know, praise,
- 9:48and ratings were good, Cartoon Network did kind of start to say, Okay,
- 9:52well, I think they know what they're doing, you know, we
- 9:54we don't have to like hover over them and micromanage every single thing. And
- 10:00then, of course the crew learned as they went along, and I think
- 10:03the whole process just got more and more streamlined to the point where they were
- 10:07at a place by about maybe the middle of the show's run, where they
- 10:11were they knew where they wanted to go, they knew the tone that they
- 10:15were looking for, they knew, you know, what did and didn't work,
- 10:18And at that point the show just kind of became more and more coherent
- 10:22in its philosophy and it's in its approach to things. At least that's my
- 10:26understanding of the situation, especially when you watch the show, you can definitely
- 10:31see that progression from sort of mad cap goofball off the wall zaniness of like
- 10:35seasons one and two too, then a little more grounded parts of three and
- 10:39four, and then from five to the end it becomes progressively. I don't
- 10:45like the word darker because that often has like an edgy sort of energy,
- 10:48but but it became more lifelike. Again, that seems kind of like a
- 10:54weird term to use a little more real to the human experience, maybe I'll
- 10:56put it that way. Yeah, yeah, absolutely so. It sounds like
- 11:01about midway through that's kind of when they really hit their stride and, like
- 11:05you said, really figured out where they were going with the show. When
- 11:11you were talking doing your research, was there a turmoil within the the process?
- 11:18I know a lot of times when you get you know, a lot
- 11:22of these creative minds together, everybody wants to go his or her own way
- 11:26in that process. Was there any controversy with that? Yeah, that's also
- 11:33a good question. I think that the fascinating thing about the production of Adventure
- 11:37Time is that the creator, Pendleton Ward's big sort of a genius, I
- 11:43would say, is was his ability to find artists who kind of had their
- 11:48own style and then sort of nurture that style and encourage them to do their
- 11:52own thing. Like obviously he had rules and like guidelines for the series about
- 11:56how characters should and shouldn't behave, but he was very interested in seeing his
- 12:01artists sort of develop their own voices, and so he brought on a lot
- 12:05of storyboard artists who contributed to the show's sort of voice and created their own
- 12:11unique approaches to Adventure Time and to the point where a lot of times fans
- 12:16can say like, oh, you know, this is a this is a
- 12:18you know, Jesse moynihan episode, or this is a Tom Herbeck episode or
- 12:20something like that. And when he stepped down as showrunner and and Adamudo took
- 12:26over, that's when I think the vision started to crystallize. And Adam was
- 12:33really good at taking that sort of vision that he had and working with the
- 12:37tools that that penn Ward had assembled and kind of streamlining it all into one
- 12:43coherent thing. So interestingly enough, I'm sure there I'm sure there were you
- 12:46know, there was turmoil and issues and stuff like that, but from what
- 12:50I gather, it sounds like the working environment while you know, stressful,
- 12:54and three High Stakes was relatively supportive for individual artistic voices, which I feel
- 13:01like is kind of rare in terms of a major production, cartoon production.
- 13:05You know, this isn't like a indie indie cartoon or anything like that.
- 13:09This is a major, major production from a major cable network. So all
- 13:16things considered, I think I think it probably was a pretty pretty solid working
- 13:20environment. That's great. You know, you talked about voices, and I
- 13:24want to kind of turn a little bit and talk about some of the voice
- 13:26actors that gave personality, gave life to the characters in terms of that was
- 13:35there. Obviously there's a process trying to find that voice was How was that
- 13:43process in terms of just casting characters? Yes, thank you, yeah,
- 13:50yeah, yeah, no problems. Well, it sounds like from what I
- 13:52understood that the pin Word and the writers and the producers kind of had an
- 13:58idea of the voice and the sort of characterization of the various you know,
- 14:05individual players in the in the show, and then they brought in some industry
- 14:09people, you know, people with like Tom Kenney, you know, people
- 14:13with with the experience, and they also just tried out relatively new voice actors
- 14:20like Olivie Olson, you know. And I think it was one of those
- 14:24things where they just would listen to the performances and then if it just like
- 14:28felt right. It's harder to describe other than that. Like, I think
- 14:31Olivia Olson is the great, great example of Marcelling. She's a voice of
- 14:35Marcellin. Penn Ward hurt her on I believe it was an episode of Phineas
- 14:39and ferb and said, that's that's Marcellin. Who is that person? You
- 14:43know? And then they brought her in and and then he said, yep,
- 14:46that's this works. And so it was just a matter of kind of
- 14:50getting people who sort of understood intuitively that maybe without there even realizing it,
- 14:56you know, the sort of energy of the care. Yeah. And sometimes,
- 15:01like you said, you don't know what you want until you hear it
- 15:05or you see it. Yeah. And and in fact, hinden Walt's the
- 15:09Voice of Princess Bubblegum was interesting to talk to you because she mentioned how when
- 15:13she went in and got the role, the initial voice director was trying to
- 15:16say which thing, like, you know, you need to play it up,
- 15:18like you need to be a princess, you know, hoiti TOI do
- 15:22that kind of thing, and she was saying, No, I just feel
- 15:24like there's there's something more to Princess Bubblegum, Like she's a little more unstable
- 15:28than we're giving, like we think it's a little darker, And so she
- 15:31was trying to add that in and then as the show went along, that's
- 15:35exactly where the character went, and she felt very vindicated in the sense like,
- 15:37Yep, this was exactly what I thought was going to happen, and
- 15:41I just sort of felt it and and tuited it and that's where it went.
- 15:46And who's to say, maybe her performance inspired that writing. But at
- 15:48the same time, yeah, it didn't hurt the process exactly. Yeah,
- 15:54in terms of that, Well, I know we're getting close here on a
- 15:56time, but a couple other questions are here for you. Number one is
- 16:00did anything surprise you during your research in the writing of this book. Ooh,
- 16:07that's a that's an interesting one. I guess it depends on how you
- 16:10describe like surprises, because on one sense and one sense, you know,
- 16:15just learning about the behind the scenes of a show that I that I've adored
- 16:21and loved and followed for so many years, and learning things that were completely
- 16:26wild to me that I would have never guessed, you know, things like
- 16:30like potential episodes that never happened and that sort of thing. How how specific
- 16:34guests episodes came to be. These sort of things. We're just really fascinating
- 16:40and fun. In fact, that's like part of the joy I got from
- 16:42writing this was finding those little nuggets of information that no one else knew,
- 16:47or at least a few other people knew, and kind of putting them out
- 16:49there so that other people could could enjoy them. There was also I was
- 16:55surprised with the I guess reluctance that Cartoon Network had with me working on this.
- 17:04Granted, I know this is an unofficial burk, but I approached them
- 17:10and I said, you know, I'm working on just a scholarly manuscript kind
- 17:12of looking at the history of the show. You know, it's not going
- 17:15to be like plot summaries or anything like that. You know, could I
- 17:19could I talk to some of the higher ups, like I had actually managed
- 17:23to get in contact with Adam Muto and he was like, yeah, let's
- 17:26we could do an interview, but you know, you need to do it
- 17:27through or get Cartoon Network's permission, since he was still working there at the
- 17:32time, and I was like, okay, that's fine. And so they
- 17:34were initially working with me, and I sent him a list of my questions
- 17:37and they told me which ones I could and couldn't ask, and then suddenly
- 17:41they were just like, no, this is our property. You can't can't
- 17:45do anything with it. And what confused me there was I was like,
- 17:48okay, maybe it is a copyright worry. I understand that. So I
- 17:52reached out. And this was before I was I had a contract with the
- 17:53University Press of Mississippi, and I said, would it make anything better or
- 17:57would it fix things if I just released it for free? You know,
- 18:00I'm not interested in making money off of this. This is just entirely a
- 18:03labor of love and I'm enjoying doing this. And they said, nope,
- 18:07it's our property. And at the time, I worked at the University of
- 18:11Kansas Libraries and our dean at the time was a copyright lawyer, and he
- 18:15I told him about this, and he said, well, you know,
- 18:17this doesn't make a ton of sense, so I would just go ahead and
- 18:19release it. And so I released an initial version for free online a couple
- 18:23of years ago and met with pretty good reception, and then so then I
- 18:27took it and revised it and expanded and added to it, and you know,
- 18:32rewrote sections and that's the version that's getting published now. But it was
- 18:34just a very strange experience because I never wanted to, like, I never
- 18:40wanted to cause Cartoon work any trouble. Like I feel like I am a
- 18:42little critical of the network at points in the book, but I the book
- 18:47in and of itself is a you know, I'm praising one of its one
- 18:49of its creations. So I don't know what that was about. That was
- 18:52the most surprising thing, the most frustrating thing too, because I would have
- 18:57loved to talk to, you know, the show runner and and learned about
- 19:03the experience from this point of view. Well, you know, it's funny
- 19:06that you said that. You know, you're you're trying to you're praise and
- 19:08you're not trying to hurt Cartoon Network. But in any film that I've come
- 19:14across and talked to anybody, there's always a negative side to everything. Yeah,
- 19:19And it's not like you're trying to show dirt. It's just that you're
- 19:23trying to present the facts and say this wasn't a better roses and not everything
- 19:29went perfect and there was some struggles and trials and tribulations in the process.
- 19:33So which is very interesting that you said that they kind of give you a
- 19:36little pushback on that process. Yeah, and I could, and it could
- 19:40because I was going through HR and or not HR pry through their PR department,
- 19:48and you know, maybe they were just very leary about sure anything that
- 19:52could be conceived as negative because like in the book, I do talk about,
- 19:56like, for instance, the Marcellyon and Princess bubble Gum relationship being that
- 19:59was a big controversy that we sort of knew about behind the scenes but never
- 20:03had gotten official confirmation. And I and then I got to talk to Rebecca
- 20:07Sugar, who told me like, yeah, this was supposed to be,
- 20:10you know, a queer relationship, but the networks that we can't do that.
- 20:14And part of me wonders if that was the reason why they were really
- 20:17kind of reluctant to work with me, is because I was asking some questions
- 20:19about that and you know, that could look pretty bad depending on how it's
- 20:25framed. But again, you're right, I didn't want to like air any
- 20:26dirty laundry. I just wanted to tell the story because it's just it's just
- 20:30history, that's all it is. I'm not I'm not making necessarily any moral
- 20:33judgments on Cartoon Network. It's a giant corporation that is many people. I
- 20:38know that. It's not like one person did all of this right, yes,
- 20:42or sets the tone for the whole group or anything like that. But
- 20:47I have to agree with you. I'm really fascinated in how the process has
- 20:52made, you know, and the trivia, and it was very interesting to
- 20:56hear you talk about special episodes and episodes that never got developed that were talked
- 21:03about. And I'm a big fan of that trivia behind the scenes aspect of
- 21:08that, and so I really appreciate that. So one final question before we
- 21:14let you go off, Paul, is do you have a favorite episode?
- 21:18Oh? Man, that's a tough one. I'd say that of the original
- 21:22series the seasons one through ten, or nine seasons one through nine, depending
- 21:26on how you defied this series, probably I would say season two's premiere.
- 21:32It came from the Nidosphere, which we've introduced Marcelline's dad. I just have
- 21:37a really good memory of watching that and that was a very very funny episode
- 21:41and I love Marcelen. She is my hands down, my favorite character.
- 21:44And that was the song that introduced or that was an episode that introduced the
- 21:47Fry song. So lots of good things in that episode. But I think
- 21:49of the entire sort of Adventure Time Extended universe, it's a tie between the
- 21:56Obsidian Special that came out a couple of years ago or Together Again Special that
- 22:00came out a couple of years ago after the original series finale. Both of
- 22:06those sort of were victory laps on what the series had done and wrapped up
- 22:11some character arcs that I thought they did a really great job with the city
- 22:15and was Princess Bubblicoman Marceline and we got to learn about their sort of romantic
- 22:19backstory. And then Together Again was the sort of finale Defend and Jake's story
- 22:26where spoiler alert took place in the afterlife. It was all about how you
- 22:30know they're dead and so this is the story of you know, after that,
- 22:33And that seems really dark and depressing, but when you watch it,
- 22:37it's it's very much a triumphant sort of like the fun will Never end kind
- 22:41of idea, And I just loved it. I thought it was a beautiful
- 22:44sort of season series finale, Part two almost so yeah, those I'd say
- 22:49those are probably the three kind of the up there. I also have a
- 22:52list of others that are just I'm fond of, but I think those are
- 22:55the three that I would consider my favorite favorite out there. Excellent. Well,
- 23:00Paul, I wanted to say thank you for spending a few minutes with
- 23:03us today and talking about your book. I want to strongly encourage our listeners
- 23:10to go out and get a copy of paul a book explaining the Land of
- 23:14Ooh, the Unofficial Overview on production history of Cartoon Networks Adventure Time, and
- 23:19as Paul said, it's through the University Press of Mississippi, but also it's
- 23:25out there on Amazon and other anywhere else that you find your books and purchase
- 23:29your books. But please go out and support Paul and get a copy of
- 23:32his book. I don't think you're going to be disappointed. And again,
- 23:34Paul, thank you so much for spending some time with us today. We
- 23:37really appreciate it. Absolutely, Like I said, thank you so much for
- 23:41having me. It was a pleasure to talk. Absolutely. I want to
- 23:45thank you for listening to this episode. For Donn Hollywood, just search for
- 23:48doug Hester Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find me on Twitter or Instagram and
- 23:52hes dug fourteen. If you listen to this podcast on iTunes another podcast service,
- 23:56please subscribe, or rate and review this episode. Tune in next time
- 24:00for the latest episode Forgotten on Hollywood. Thank you for listening and we will