Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Auto Dealers Around the World Are Doing Things Differently (And What The US Should Learn From Them)
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Thursday, September 17th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. Michael Cirillo and I are both back at our desks in [laughs] our offices.
- 0:08We're so excited to hear about his trip with dealers all around the world in Istanbul. Everywhere I go. We have a lot of other stuff to talk about.
- 0:16Who I is and- And before we get there- I can't be stopped, it's too imminent... Nathan, I don't know if you have this loaded up, but I'm gonna ask you for an ASOTU CON West graphic in, like...
- 0:22Oh, he's got it right up there. Let's go. Announced two days ago, we are having ASOTU CON West.
- 0:29It's a one-day fly in, fly out event in Los Angeles, West LA, one of the coolest places in the world, on November 18th, and we want you to be there. Uh, very limited seating on this one, so...
- 0:41But again, we designed this so it could be fly in, fly out. You should just see the speaker list on this. Uh, Jack Hollis, you know who he is, from Toyota. Vic Keller. If you don't know who he is, you're about to.
- 0:51Answer directly to Warren Buffett. We also have Alex Lawrence with EV Auto coming in hot. Um, I, I wasn't planning on doing this a ton, but, uh... Who- We have speakers that I'm missing. Um... Steve Greenfield.
- 1:05Steve Greenfield. How could I forget? Because Michael- How could you forget Steve?... just was Steve Greenfield. Um, Steve is gonna talk about something that we haven't heard here on Frame Up.
- 1:12It's called the profitability stack.
- 1:14Basically, we took all the things we've been hearing from dealers and saying, "Here are ways they can move the needle on some specific action items to affect profitability, future operations, and stability."
- 1:24Everybody in one room, one stage, West LA. We're gonna have this at Plugg's brand-new headquarters and have, uh, a welcome reception or a closing reception across the street at the historic LA Motoring Club.
- 1:37We're also... This is the first time I'm saying this, I think, publicly. Everybody who gets a ticket to ASOTU CON West also gets a free ticket to LA Automobility, which is the day- Ooh... before the auto show in LA.
- 1:49So, you can come along with us for free to that event. It's usually like a 3 or $400 event. Um, [lips smack] and I might add, if you have a significant other that likes to shop and likes some...
- 1:59Right down the street from Rodeo Drive. Go to Rodeo, have something nice to eat. If you're the kind of person that stays in the Beverly Hills Hotel, stay in the Beverly Hills Hotel. Dang.
- 2:08LA in November is a great place to be. I'm gonna bring my Richard Gere wig. You sh- [laughs] I'm gonna bring my Richard Gere squinty eyes and, like, big cheek smile, right?
- 2:19[laughs] Be like, "They didn't have a wig, but I do have a pretty red dress I can wear." [laughs] You can go to ASOTU CON West and check that out.
- 2:28We wanna thank our friends at Mia, Plugg, and Kirby, and Dealer DMV who, uh, stepped up early when we had this idea for ASOTU CON West, and this is gonna be one to remember. We're super excited and pumped about it.
- 2:41But we make- It's gonna be epic... a lot of content. We do a lot of shows. I'm doing a lot of talk 'cause Michael's about to do a lot of talking on his trip.
- 2:46But, uh, we wanna thank our friends at AutoHub for being the sponsor of today's podcast. Here's a radical used car acquisition strategy. Buy cars from people who are already at your dealership.
- 2:56Wild, I know, but somebody write it down quick. AutoHub is gonna help you find, appraise, make offers, and acquire vehicles from your own customers in the showroom, service drive, and online in just minutes.
- 3:08Real market data, smarter offer, and less auction dependency. Head to autohub.io, because sometimes the best source of inventory is your own customers. It's weird, I know, but, you know, it is what it is.
- 3:20[laughs] Uh, Michael, you are back in your seat. You just traveled halfway around the world, I can literally say that, to Istanbul, Turkey, to participate in a, a global event with international dealers.
- 3:31Spent some time out there with Chip Perry, and Brian Binstock, and, uh, Steve Greenfield, and Danny Zablotsky. A lot of people who are friends, friends of the show and friends of the More Than Cars community.
- 3:42What were you doing out there? And tell us more. Oh, my gosh. First, I have to say, it was tremendous to be able to share time with all of the names you just mentioned.
- 3:50Uh, specifically, I w- I, I didn't recognize him when he walked in, because it was the first time I'd ever seen Brian Binstock not wearing his black suit. I saw, I saw a picture of this.
- 4:02He, he even covered himself up, though, because he's like, "Nobody can see me in a T-shirt," so he, he- He was embarrassed. [laughs] No. And I was like, "Wait, who, who is that? He looks familiar."
- 4:11And I'm like, "Oh, it's Brian." Brian Binstock's one to, not one to cover himself up. I mean, have you seen his Instagram feed? That is fair. [laughs] That is fair.
- 4:19Um, he, yeah, he's, he's the kind of individual that lands, uh, off of a flight that flew all night and found the closest gym. Fully- And- Yeah, and then comes out in a fully pressed suit. Yeah, that's right.
- 4:30I don't know how he does it. He's a magician. He's a genius.
- 4:32Um, so it was great to share time with him, but also, you know, these moments where you get to take a peek behind the curtain of what's happening globally outside of the United States, it's always, it's always great perspective to have.
- 4:46Um, there were, I, I think, just a few big takeaways for me. Number one, I think you'll find this interesting. Marketplaces in the Russian market are the dominant player still.
- 5:01They control so much of the marketing, the listings- Hm... HR training. What? One of the things that I thought was bonkers, we were talking to our, uh, to our pal Dmitri, who you know, who's 400 feet tall.
- 5:14He's my favorite. Um, and I'm like, "Wait, how, how much do they pay for this HR training?" Guys, we're talking like $200,000 for 90 days, and the dealers pay it. Uh, huh? And I said, "Well..."
- 5:27He says, "They guarantee results." And I'm like, "Well, what if they don't achieve those guaranteed results?" He says, "Well, then they just make you pay for 50%."
- 5:33[laughs] Um, but it was interesting to see that here we are in a, in a major area of the world that marketplaces still are the dominant presence. They still control so much, and I think that's...
- 5:46You can see them maneuvering out there, especially how do we deepen and widen our moat, especially in the advent of AI. Mm-hmm. So I, I thought that was kind of interesting.
- 5:55Of course, a marketplace was the title sponsor of, of this event, and so there was a lot of-...
- 6:00commentary and narrative about things they're building and thinking about, um, whi- which was- Why do you think, why do you think that is?
- 6:07Is it just that the dealers don't have the resources or the time or the energy to, like, find new solutions or internal solutions, or they're not just big enough maybe?
- 6:17No, I think what it is is that in America, we do have an insatiable appetite to control as much of our ecosystem- Yeah... as we possibly can. Mm-hmm. And that doesn't really prevail in other parts of the world.
- 6:26I mean, I've seen it in Europe. When I, when I've spoken in Holland, marketplaces are the dominant voice there as well, uh, as, uh, similar to Germany- Do you think-... and, and some other markets...
- 6:36do you think it's something we take for granted as Americans in the United States is that the entrepreneurial environment is so pervasive that we just naturally have that mentality, like, we can...
- 6:47Like, there must be a better way, and I, I think I'm the one to make it or find it- Yeah... figure it out? I, I think it's... I mean, being kind of the outsider that has come as an immigrant to this country- Yeah.
- 6:56No, you have a great perspective that- I, yeah... most people don't have... I, I think it's a cultural thing that started from our, from the foundation of the United States.
- 7:04It's like put your stake in the ground and claim your spot- Figure it out... and control that spot. Yeah. Mm-hmm. And that, that doesn't, that's not prominent in other parts of the world.
- 7:11Even in Canada, we, we kind of get the splash-off of that, but it's not as dominant as it is here. And so what does that mean? It means that the dealers there, th- their stress is there.
- 7:25They experience stress, but it's angled in a different direction. Our stress is predominantly from like, what am I not controlling that I should be controlling? Um, what can I take in-house, right? Mm-hmm.
- 7:36So, and this'll kind of segue into the second takeaway. You know, you, we've interviewed dealers who are cr- you know, creating AI teams internally- Mm... to control the AI ecosystem- Mm...
- 7:49compliance, infrastructure, all of those sort- sorts of things, which is an indicator of this, this appetite we have in the West to control our ecosystem. Mm-hmm.
- 8:00Um, there, I think they're just comfortable with, oh, you're gonna give me all of the infrastructure and tools that I need to just keep operating my business? Great.
- 8:09Also inherent in that is this idea of, like, I do want to grow my business. Obviously, I'm in business to make money, and these dealers are making great money, by the way. Uh, this
- 8:21appetite to be number one, it's like, ah, that's... The top 10 make really good money. [laughs] Yeah. [laughs] Right. Why try so hard to get from five to six or- Right... five to three? Speaking of AI,
- 8:35th- I would say what I've learned is outside of the United States, uh, the conversation is early still.
- 8:43They are aware of all of the news headlines, just like we are here, but there is a degree of skepticism still that reflects where we were maybe 18 months ago, like wh- I was gonna say, I was gonna ask you how early.
- 8:5418 months ago. Yeah. In, in an AI world- So basically putting us back to the beginning of 2025. Yeah. Maybe late 2024, which is crazy to think about. Yeah.
- 9:05It would be, it would be so- And, and especially with how fast things are developing... it would be absolutely insane if I could just take a snapshot of my work and what I spent my time doing in late 2024.
- 9:17Like, from the very beginning of the day, when I woke up, what I checked in with, what tools I used to build, I think it would, I think we would actually be shocked. 'Cause now it's the frog in the pot.
- 9:27I mean, that's a negative, you know, metaphor. [laughs] Maybe that is what we are, we just don't know yet. But a lot of conversation about AI annihilating civilization.
- 9:35But, but it's like maybe it's just like the progress has been so slow that, like, you don't, you don't see yourself getting stronger or you don't feel that way, but, like, you're like- Yes...
- 9:44oh, man, people see you that haven't seen you.
- 9:46And so you're saying that long ago, 18 months back, even though they have today's news, they're like, "I don't know if this is hype or if it applies to me and my business," and so they're- Yeah... skeptical.
- 9:56What, what's the tangible adoption of this? What's the ROI? Who has a real proof po- proof, uh, uh, proof point that this enhanced the business actually? We don't wanna deal with hypothetical.
- 10:13That's kind of their position, right? We, we don't, don't, don't talk to me about the hypothetical could. I wanna know what is. How- And so- What's their- Uh, it- What's their adoption of, like, tools, right?
- 10:24Obviously, this is making more sense, like why there's so much of a leaning on the third-party marketplaces to figure- Yeah...
- 10:29these things out, and then they bring them a package solution that says, "Hey, here are the results," or, "We'll guarantee the results," or at least give you some evidence. How, how many third-party vendors do they use?
- 10:39Do they use a h- a lot, like we do here?
- 10:42Uh, I would say probably not as many as we have here, primarily based on my observation that the marketplace sponsor that was there has divisions that pretty much cover everything. Got it.
- 10:53CRM, DMS, marketplace, advertising, HR consulting, leadership training. Like, it's all one- Wow...
- 11:01it, it's kinda one stop, and so they, the, if anything, those marketplace companies have done a really good job at widening their moat- It's interesting. It almost feels like-...
- 11:09and making it difficult for other entrants... it almost feels like a franchise within a franchise, right? Like, it's like here are the h- like, the, the OEM is like, "Here's the product you sell.
- 11:16Here's the, here's the, the building you have. Here's kinda how you need to staff it." The marketplace will say, "Here's how you run the system that can sell and service an OEM's product." Yeah.
- 11:26And they're like, "That's a winning formula. I can make money-" Yeah... "doing that, so why would we have to change?" Yeah.
- 11:33How much- The other thing I, I did love culturally, I'll just say, is that the audience was not afraid to push back in the middle of a presentation, and I was like, oh, I, I know this pushback terminology.
- 11:44[laughs] Let's see what it looks like in real, like real time and- Real time while you're on the stage. How did your keynote go? Um, I, well, I didn't get any pushback. [laughs] Why is that?
- 11:55Um, I, I, I think because y- you guys know, the things that I speak about tend to be what you already know you should be doing but haven't thought about perhaps in a practical way. Like, how do I make it real for me?
- 12:06Yeah. But I didn't speak about anything that they could really push back or disagree on. I spoke about the-
- 12:13U- utilizing tools and resources that you already have at your disposal, that you don't need to spend more money on, that you could implement right now, and I gave them just three tangible takeaways.
- 12:21So here, for example, we have Google Business Profile. There they have Yandex Business Profile. Mm-hmm.
- 12:26The, the, the way that you get more visibility doing those things, essentially the same as you would on a Google Business profile. And, and so it's like, "Who here is familiar with Y- Yandex?"
- 12:35And they're like, every hand goes up. And it's like, "Who here has thought about how to optimize that so you can get more visibility from maps, from, uh- And 20% of the leads go up... AI, for..." Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
- 12:46But they can't disagree with it, and so I think- Yeah... I think that's kind of where I hedged, uh, in the right direction, maybe made a good call preparing for that talk.
- 12:54Um, I, I will say, we did visit a couple of different dealerships, two very different models which I thought were interesting. The first one was a place called Otobid, O-T-O bid.
- 13:04And what they do is they basically pro- created an outlet in which private sellers can consign their vehicle to Otobid. You made a post about this one, right? I made a post about this one.
- 13:13They had the marked vehicle in the light box, and it was being auctioned. And it was being live auctioned. So they basically allow-- It's a consignment auction.
- 13:21And what was cool about it is they've created the infrastructure where once that vehicle is sold to the dealer, the private seller basically gets their money near instantly.
- 13:31And so it creates a, a really interesting thing. They've got lifts there. They inspect the vehicle. They do all those sorts of things.
- 13:37Steve Greenfield did bring up a good point on location in which he said, "Well, what does this mean for arbitration if, if the dealer actually ended up buying a vehicle that wasn't what they- Yeah... thought?"
- 13:46H- you know, Otobid, as the middle point, obviously has to absorb some measure of risk there. Mm-hmm. But as far as how it's working for consumers, the consumers really gravitate towards it.
- 13:57I think they said they will have 25 or 26 locations throughout that, that region- Okay... uh, by next year. Wow. Well,
- 14:08I, I'm just-- [laughs] What a wild experience to be able to go out there and see the similarities in people, but also the vast difference in the way a culture approaches selling the same product. Yeah.
- 14:21So what, what, what do we have to learn from that here? Like, what, what is in your mind? Like, you come back to the US. We're leaning in. We're having a ASOTU CON West.
- 14:28Uh, like, we're bringing all these people together. What do we have to learn? Is there an encouragement, uh, of sorts, or is there, like, a watch-out? What, what is your, like, your bring it all back home? Yeah.
- 14:36I think the enc- the encouragement is this: Oh, boy. Saying it on a news program, I'm just gonna say it. Nathan, you can turn my screen off, my microphone. But I'm gonna say it. Do it.
- 14:47The, the media wants to talk about the things that they believe will divide us.
- 14:52And being in a room with Russian dealers covering Russia, Kazakhstan, uh, Saudi Arabia, I will say that this great industry actually does more to bring us together.
- 15:02The, the commonalities are much more common when you're sitting in the same room.
- 15:05Hospitality, customer experience, uh, wanting to do right, sell a good product, and grow your business so you can take care of your people.
- 15:14That, that was the big mic drop kinda moment for me, where I was just like, "We're all people." Yeah. "We're all living under the same sky, and we all kinda care about the same things in this business," so.
- 15:22Well, then I think that is a perfect parting word for a Thursday. It is amazing. When you get people together, magic things happen. We want you to be with us. Go to asotuconwest.com. Get your ticket.
- 15:34Be with us in November. [upbeat music]