Latest / Her Comeback: Women Who Rebuilt Their Lives / The Radical Power of Saying 'I Don't Know' When Everything Feels Certain | Her Comeback
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of panic that lives in the space between your lips and your teeth when someone asks you a question you cannot answer. It feels like failure, but it is actually the most honest thing you will say all day. We have spent so much of our lives performing competence. I remember sitting in boardrooms for twenty years, watching women nod along to strategies they knew were flawed, just to keep the peace or prove they belonged in the room. We treat uncertainty like a stain on our resume, something to be scrubbed away before anyone notices. But here is the truth I am learning, slowly and painfully: certainty is often just fear dressed up as confidence. When we say 'I know,' even when we don’t, we are trying to control the narrative. We want to be the anchor. We want to be the one who has the map. But life rarely hands us maps. It hands us compasses, and sometimes, it just hands us fog. Let’s sit with that for a second. Think about the last time you gave advice to a friend that you didn’t fully believe in. Maybe it was about a career move, or a relationship, or how to fix a leaking faucet. You probably said it with conviction because you thought she needed stability. But what did it actually cost you? It cost you your integrity. It cost you the chance to be present with her in the unknown. When we fake knowledge, we isolate ourselves. We build walls out of half-truths and assume the role of the expert. But experts are lonely places to live. And more importantly, it denies the other person the dignity of figuring things out alongside you. It creates a hierarchy where you are above, and she is below, needing your guidance. That is not connection. That is performance. Saying 'I don't know' is an act of intellectual honesty, yes, but it is also an act of profound intimacy. It says, 'I trust you enough to show you my gaps.' It says, 'I am not responsible for holding all the answers; we are humans navigating this together.' When I dropped that mask recently, during a conversation with a neighbor whose garden had been ravaged by early frost, I felt my heart hammer against my ribs. She asked if I had any tips for saving the tomato plants. My instinct was to Google it right then and there, to produce a solution. Instead, I took a breath and said, 'Honestly, I don’t know. I’ve never seen anything survive that cold. But let’s look at it together.' The relief on her face was instant. The pressure vanished. We sat on her porch steps, shivering slightly, and looked at the brown leaves without judgment. We weren’t fixing it yet. We were just witnessing it. And that witness was worth more than any gardening tip. What did it actually cost me to admit ignorance? Nothing. In fact, it saved me hours of wasted effort and anxiety. When we claim to know, we often lock ourselves into a path that might be wrong. We waste energy defending a position we’re unsure of. Admitting 'I don't know' opens the door to curiosity. It invites collaboration. It allows for questions that lead to better outcomes. Consider the logistics of rebuilding your life after a major loss, like many of the women I speak with. You cannot follow a script. You cannot rely on a five-step plan. You have to stand in the middle of the rubble and say, 'I don't know what comes next.' That admission is not weakness. It is the prerequisite for any genuine new beginning. If you think you know exactly how your grief should look, you are setting yourself up for shame. If you accept that you don’t know, you give yourself permission to feel whatever arises. We live in a culture that demands constant output. Hustle culture tells us that if we aren’t producing solutions, we are failing. But rest is part of the recovery process, and so is admitting limitation. When you say 'I don't know,' you are creating space. Space for silence. Space for listening. Space for your own intuition to catch up with your mouth. This is gentle challenging for those of us who pride ourselves on being helpful. Being helpful doesn’t mean having answers. It means being willing to sit in the dark with someone until their eyes adjust. It means resisting the urge to light a flare every time the lights go out. Sometimes the best help is simply staying present in the uncertainty. That is radical pragmatism. It respects the reality of the situation over the ego’s desire to be right. You’re allowed to be proud of the small things. Like choosing honesty over ease. Like letting a question hang in the air without rushing to fill it. It feels uncomfortable at first. Your skin might crawl. You might worry that people will think you’re incompetent. But watch what happens. People lean in. They respect the authenticity. They realize you are human, and that makes you trustworthy. Trust is built on reliability, not omniscience. People need to know you will tell them the truth, even when the truth is that you’re lost too. This episode isn’t about giving you a new tool to master. It’s about inviting you to put down the heavy armor you’ve been carrying. It’s okay to be a work in progress. It’s okay to be confused. In fact, it’s the only way to grow. Thank you for sitting with me today. For letting me see your uncertainties, and for trusting me with yours. Until next time, keep showing up, even when you don’t have the answers. I’ll be here, listening.