Latest / Alabama's Morning News with JT / Attorney Kirby Farris talks Supreme Court hearings and Uber lawsuits
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Kirby Ferris in the studio with us, and he'll join
- 0:04us here in just a second to talk about a
- 0:05couple of different stories. One obviously what the Supreme Court
- 0:07went through yesterday and hearing the oral arguments on whether
- 0:11or not men should play in women's sports, and also
- 0:15another case that I want to get Kirby Williams. So
- 0:17he's coming up here in just about six or seven minutes,
- 0:19but he's in the studio already, been here for a
- 0:21little bit. And did you catch any of the k
- 0:24Ivy's State of the State addresses? Did not? I did not?
- 0:28What were you?
- 0:28Speaker 2: I was folding socks and yeah, I think I was
- 0:32binge watching something on Netflix.
- 0:33Speaker 1: There you go. So for your benefit and those that
- 0:36missed it last night, here's a couple of cuts from
- 0:37the State of the State last night.
- 0:39Speaker 2: Folks has no doubt that the best is yet to come,
- 0:42because we all know there's no step two high step up.
- 0:48Speaker 1: No, that's the wrong cut. That was another speech she
- 0:50had given. All right, do we have the right cut? Okay,
- 0:53here's one from last day.
- 0:55Speaker 2: We're getting a excuse me, a slight increase in the
- 0:58number of doses that we've been getting to the state.
- 1:01Speaker 1: Oh my gosh, I mean Mackenzie's got the wrong cuts again.
- 1:07I'll get it right next time. Okay, I apologize for that.
- 1:10I mean you bring in breakfast. Oh you're not familiar
- 1:14with both those no incidents with the governor. Well, the
- 1:17high step for things, I mean legendary.
- 1:19Speaker 2: Well so is the other one high st, but i'd
- 1:22not the other one.
- 1:23Speaker 1: In fact, there's a video that goes with that. She's
- 1:25in front of a podium at a press content speak
- 1:29on television. Yeah it was yeah, live television. And I'll
- 1:32look at jat at least twice a week, and I say,
- 1:34there's no step to off. She's yet the belts like
- 1:38an uncle grandpa. But that I mean that that belt
- 1:41there has some bottom end base.
- 1:43Speaker 2: To listen, right, that came from deep down.
- 1:46Speaker 1: I mean that's like getting up from the table after
- 1:48red eye, gravy and a bunch of strips of bacon
- 1:51for about an hour and some hot coffee on his
- 1:53way out to the barn to finish some work. I'll
- 1:56see all. I'll be back good. Heaven's k all right,
- 2:02that's great. We got to pull the video show, folks,
- 2:06just google it YouTube. I mean, k Ivy belching, Oh
- 2:10it's a dandy. Yesterday the US Supreme Court heard oral
- 2:13arguments rather on transgenders playing in women's sports, and to me,
- 2:18it seems like they're going to be ruling with some
- 2:21common sense in their decision on this as some of
- 2:23the questions that came out were directly about how do
- 2:26you define a boy and a girl, man or a woman,
- 2:29and some of the responses were just I mean typical, Well,
- 2:32it depends on you know, No, I think Genesis one
- 2:36took care of that. God created man, then God created woman.
- 2:41There wasn't a you know in the middle, or it's
- 2:44pretty much black and white. So Kirby Ferris hear us
- 2:48with us in the studio the arguments yesterday. How long
- 2:53normally the Supreme Court will hear arguments and then it's
- 2:55like a couple of months later and they come with
- 2:57their decision or in the summer or something like that.
- 3:00Will they come quicker on these rulings or is this
- 3:03going to be another three four month of de.
- 3:06Speaker 2: Lay I think we can look for this in June.
- 3:08Speaker 1: Really yeah, yeah, Well do they really need that long?
- 3:13Speaker 2: They sort of have a cycle they follow just to
- 3:16do their new inteligence and say, and if you remember,
- 3:18they release a lot of opinions at one time, and
- 3:22so they Yeah, they sort of have a.
- 3:24Speaker 1: There are more states than a none that agree that
- 3:29you should keep them separate men and women in.
- 3:32Speaker 2: Sport now twenty seven or twenty eight, I think we're
- 3:34thirty athy, Yeah, and your.
- 3:38Speaker 1: Thoughts somewhere this may land. I mean, the court leans
- 3:40more conservative these days, but Justice Roberts has surprised us
- 3:43a lot of times. Where do you think they end
- 3:47up on this one? Based on you know, what you've
- 3:49heard in the world arguments from yesterday.
- 3:51Speaker 2: You know, you can't always rely on it, But most
- 3:55of the time, when you look at the questions I
- 3:57ask and kind of review the arguments, it kind of
- 3:59gives you an endo of how they're going to rule.
- 4:01I think here it's pretty clear that they're going to
- 4:04rule in favor of the state laws that separate with
- 4:09purposes of athletics. Yeah, boys and girls.
- 4:12Speaker 1: When you when you're an educated person and somebody says
- 4:16define a woman and they go, well, we don't really
- 4:20have that. You know that that answer right now, it's like,
- 4:24what are you talking about? How do you not come
- 4:26up with that? I don't know, it's just to me,
- 4:31it's just crazy. Let's go with cut seven mackenzie. This
- 4:35is an independent women Ambassador Peyton McNabb reacting to the
- 4:38attorney who failed to answer what defines a man and
- 4:41a woman?
- 4:42Speaker 3: I mean, the insanity of this cannot be overstated. This
- 4:46sounds like some kind of made up play, but this
- 4:49is real life and that's incredibly sad. But this is
- 4:52even having to be at the Supreme Court, the highest
- 4:54court in the first place. The High Court can't even
- 4:57determine what a woman is, I mean saying is that?
- 5:01And how are you going to put a whole case
- 5:03based off of sex and then not even have a definition?
- 5:05That just shows this is an absolute clown show. And
- 5:08it's sad because the women are the ones that are
- 5:10being punished for this.
- 5:11Speaker 1: One hundred percent. Women are not being protected in this physically, emotionally,
- 5:17every aspect of Where are the women's rights groups? I
- 5:20think finally there were some you know, women's rights groups
- 5:23that had signs outside that said, look, we've got to
- 5:25protect women in sports. Justice bread Kavanaugh saying fairness for
- 5:29girls can't be ignored.
- 5:31Speaker 4: Groups who study this issue think that allowing transgender women
- 5:36and girls to participate will undermine or reverse that amazing
- 5:40success for the individual girl who does not make the team,
- 5:45or doesn't get on the stand for the metal, or
- 5:49doesn't make All League. There's a harm there, and I
- 5:54think we can't sweep that aside.
- 5:57Speaker 1: It's just unbelievable that we are at this point in
- 6:00the world, in our society where people have trouble defining
- 6:05a woman versus a man. It's outrageous. Genderness, for you,
- 6:10is not a biological issue. We've talked about this numerous
- 6:13times with experts and doctors. It's a psychological issue and
- 6:18should be dealt with through psychiatry and therapy. It's not
- 6:21dealt with through surgery. And I got to tell you
- 6:24there's going to end up being a Supreme Court case
- 6:25I think Kirby where parents that allow a four year
- 6:31old to decide what they want to be a boy
- 6:33or a girl, and then get a doctor to agree
- 6:36with this and start the process to transition that child
- 6:40based on what. The child may have picked up a
- 6:43barbie because he's got three sisters in the house and
- 6:46all of a sudden, oh, Tommy wants to be a girl.
- 6:48Let's go ahead and get started. I mean, that is
- 6:51child abuse in my mind, and the medical profession should
- 6:54not be jumping on board with this. If you want
- 6:56to do something like that when you're a legal age
- 6:58eighteen have had but a child, Where do you stand
- 7:03on that.
- 7:05Speaker 2: Jay, It depends on what issue were talking about.
- 7:07Speaker 1: I mean the transitioning a child under the age of eighteen.
- 7:10Speaker 2: Yeah, I disagree with that, Okay, wholeheartedly disagree with that.
- 7:14But the purpose and what the Supreme Court is looking
- 7:18at in this case is not the definition of a
- 7:20man and a woman. They're looking at whether there is
- 7:25a legitimate reason why you should keep women out of
- 7:29men's sports and men out of women's sports. And here's
- 7:33the fascinating thing.
- 7:34Speaker 1: About it, j J.
- 7:35Speaker 2: At its core, at its core, if you say to
- 7:40a biological male you cannot participate in that sport, that
- 7:46is a violation of your constitutional rights at its core.
- 7:50But as we've talked about many times on the show,
- 7:53there are reasons your constitutional rights don't always prevail.
- 7:58Speaker 1: Right.
- 8:00Speaker 2: You know the old saying about screaming fire in a
- 8:02movie theater, Right, that's illegal, Well, it's free speech, right,
- 8:07I have a constitutional right to that. Well, somebody could
- 8:09get hurt.
- 8:10Speaker 1: What if I want to play on a you know,
- 8:12six year old t ball you know team this summer
- 8:15and I go to Shades Mountain Ballpark and say, I'm
- 8:17here to play ball. I'm going I need to sign up.
- 8:19Who do I pay my entry fee to? They're going
- 8:21to laugh me out of there, and if I don't go,
- 8:23the cops will take me out of there. Right.
- 8:25Speaker 2: But if you listen to what the court is looking
- 8:28at and what they're saying is it's this is a
- 8:31safety issue and a fairness issue, and that gives them
- 8:35a basis for saying, hey, we get your argument. This
- 8:39this looks unconstitutional because you're saying just because you're your gender,
- 8:43you can't do something. But when they tie a safety
- 8:46concern to it, now they have a legitimate reason for
- 8:49saying these laws are conc it's very dangerous and fairness.
- 8:52So that's that's that's the underlying It's not who's male,
- 8:56who's female?
- 8:56Speaker 1: Okay, but so and you expect the court to rule
- 8:59in that, I think they should quickly. Uber facing lots
- 9:03of lawsuits with a sexual assault case right now from
- 9:08an Uber driver on a woman, and Uber says, look,
- 9:12we're a company that hires independent contractors to drive. We're
- 9:18not liable for that, are they.
- 9:20Speaker 2: I've litigated with ride share companies a good bit. They
- 9:24all contend that these are independent contractors. There's a legal
- 9:28threshold for that. So if they are able to meet
- 9:31that threshold and say these are independent contractors, that gives
- 9:34them a leg up in litigation. But it does it
- 9:40does not absolve them from their duty to hire people
- 9:44who are safe, good to contract with people who are safe.
- 9:48Speaker 1: What court could rule maybe perhaps you need to do X,
- 9:52Y and z before you allow them to work for you,
- 9:54background checks, and I think all of them do it now.
- 9:57Uber didn't initially making sure that there's you know, no
- 10:02red flags popping up on these.
- 10:04Speaker 2: One hundred percent, and they one hundred percent should be
- 10:07made to do that if they're not doing it already,
- 10:10And this is the way you.
- 10:11Speaker 1: Can do that.
- 10:12Speaker 2: If they've got to. If they've hired a pedophile and
- 10:15he assaults somebody, and it would have been clear to
- 10:18them if they had done their due diligence that this
- 10:20was a pedophile, then they should be held mibel.
- 10:22Speaker 1: All right, we'll see where these goes there. Like I said,
- 10:25fascinating a lot of people in a class action on
- 10:28rideshare companies over issues just like this. Kirby, Thank you, buddy.
- 10:31Good to see it, Great to see you.