Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Vaccines and Medications
Transcript
- 0:14Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:15Shaw, and we thank you so much
- 0:17for joining us this evening.
- 0:19Our topic tonight vaccines and
- 0:20medications. Tonight we've
- 0:23assembled a panel of physicians
- 0:24to take a deep dive into these
- 0:26critical health issues. There
- 0:28are different perspectives on
- 0:29vaccine and health policies.
- 0:30And those perspectives are
- 0:33represented here. This evening
- 0:35on September 22nd, the Trump
- 0:37administration announced it was
- 0:38discouraging pregnant women
- 0:40from taking acetaminophen, the
- 0:42active ingredient in Tylenol,
- 0:43because of possible links or
- 0:45connections to autism. It was a
- 0:47move denounced by many in the
- 0:49scientific community, who say
- 0:50the evidence of a link or
- 0:51causation just isn't there.
- 0:53President Donald Trump has also
- 0:56questioned vaccine safety,
- 0:57suggesting changes in how
- 0:59children receive vaccinations
- 1:00and when they get them. As
- 1:02vaccine supporters continue to
- 1:04say that overwhelming evidence
- 1:06shows vaccines save lives. To
- 1:09discuss all this, we have three
- 1:10guests in our Lexington studio
- 1:12this evening Doctor Michael K
- 1:14paddock, a pediatric
- 1:16hospitalist at Kentucky
- 1:18Children's Hospital and past
- 1:21president of the Kentucky
- 1:23Medical Association. Doctor Coy
- 1:27Flowers, an obstetrician
- 1:28gynecologist and former chair
- 1:29of the American College of
- 1:31Obstetrics and Gynecology in
- 1:33Kentucky, and doctor Molly
- 1:35Rutherford, a primary care
- 1:37physician, addiction specialist
- 1:38and senior fellow with the
- 1:39Independence Medical Alliance.
- 1:41And joining us by Skype from
- 1:44Saint Petersburg, Florida,
- 1:45doctor Kimberly BIS, an
- 1:46obstetrician gynecologist and
- 1:49also a senior fellow with the
- 1:50Independence Medical Alliance.
- 1:51We thank them for being with us
- 1:54this evening. We do want to
- 1:55hear from you. So we welcome
- 1:57you to send your questions and
- 1:59comments by X, formerly Twitter
- 2:00at Pub Affairs KET. Send an
- 2:02email to Katie tonight at
- 2:04ket.org or use the web form at
- 2:08ket.org tonight. Or you can
- 2:12simply give us a call at one
- 2:13800 494 7605. Once again, a
- 2:17welcome to all of our guests in
- 2:20the studio. And for Doctor BIS,
- 2:21thank you for joining us from
- 2:23Saint Petersburg, Florida. So
- 2:25before we hear from the
- 2:26Secretary of the Kentucky
- 2:29Cabinet for Health and Family
- 2:30Services, whom I spoke to just
- 2:31last week about some of these
- 2:33questions, we're going to be
- 2:34teasing out tonight. I do want
- 2:35to get from the panel. How do
- 2:38you assess Doctor Flowers, some
- 2:39of the health recommendations
- 2:40of late that have been coming
- 2:42from the white House?
- 2:43>> Sure. You know, as an ob gyn
- 2:46who takes care of of patients
- 2:48every single day in the office,
- 2:49but also involved in advocacy
- 2:51and policy work in the state of
- 2:53Kentucky and across the region
- 2:53and country. It's important to
- 2:56look at science and evidence
- 2:58and data to be able to look at
- 3:00the risk benefit ratio as to
- 3:02each individual treatment, and
- 3:04then in the exam rooms and with
- 3:07individual patients and
- 3:07families, use a shared decision
- 3:10making process to be able to to
- 3:11to educate those individuals on,
- 3:14on, on the data, on the science,
- 3:16on the studies and then be able
- 3:18to tailor it to their own
- 3:20individual needs, for their own
- 3:21family and for their own selves.
- 3:23>> So what do you think about
- 3:24some of the policy decisions or
- 3:25recommendations that are coming
- 3:27from the Trump administration?
- 3:29>> So in this day and age,
- 3:30where so many people are tied
- 3:32to social media and a wealth of
- 3:34information coming in,
- 3:35overwhelming amount of
- 3:36information coming in at any
- 3:38minute of the day. It can be
- 3:40really confusing to be a
- 3:41consumer of health care in 2025.
- 3:43And so to add any type of of
- 3:48fear factor or anxiety with
- 3:51changes in policies or the
- 3:52questioning of policies or the
- 3:54inference that something is not
- 3:56healthy or safe, whenever we
- 3:58know that the evidence is
- 3:59provides even more anxiety and
- 4:01confusion for patients, and
- 4:02they potentially will make
- 4:03decisions based on faulty
- 4:05information that are not best
- 4:07for them or for their family.
- 4:09>> Doctor Rutherford, I want to
- 4:09come to you and ask you the
- 4:12same question. How do you size
- 4:13up some of the recommendations
- 4:14that are coming from the Health
- 4:16and Human Services Secretary,
- 4:17Robert Kennedy Jr, and from the
- 4:19Trump administration? Do you
- 4:20think these are good questions
- 4:21to be asking at this particular
- 4:23time?
- 4:23>> I do. I agree with Doctor
- 4:25Coy that it needs to be a
- 4:27decision between the doctor and
- 4:28the patient, and that's
- 4:29actually what the HHS website
- 4:31says. It says we recommend
- 4:32judicious acetaminophen use,
- 4:35lowest effective dose, shortest
- 4:37duration under medical guidance,
- 4:38tailored to individual risk
- 4:41benefit assessments. So the the
- 4:45study was based the information
- 4:47is not new. But the most recent
- 4:49study was a review of 48
- 4:52different studies. And 27 of
- 4:54them found kind of an alarming
- 4:57correlation between Tylenol use
- 5:01and pregnancy and autism.
- 5:02>> So was there a correlation
- 5:04or causation.
- 5:06>> With any epidemiological
- 5:08study? You cannot prove
- 5:09causation. So that's that's the
- 5:12best that we have, especially
- 5:13in pregnant women. That's often
- 5:15the best that we have. It's
- 5:17very hard to design a
- 5:18randomized controlled trial in
- 5:20in pregnant women.
- 5:21>> That's and that's very true.
- 5:23There needs to be more research
- 5:26that's actually focused on
- 5:26pregnant women so that we have
- 5:28some of these answers. But we
- 5:30know this answer with Tylenol.
- 5:32It's been studied over and over
- 5:34and over for over 20 years. And
- 5:36we know based on the science
- 5:38and the evidence, acetaminophen
- 5:39does not cause autism or other
- 5:42neurological disorders. Period.
- 5:44And to imply which is what this
- 5:46administration is doing, that
- 5:48it might that that there could
- 5:49be a link is dangerous for
- 5:52patients for so many other
- 5:54downstream effects in this
- 5:55country.
- 5:56>> I want to come to Doctor
- 5:58Kuduk, but I also want to point
- 5:59out that even the Health and
- 6:01Human Services Secretary,
- 6:02Robert Kennedy Jr, tried to
- 6:02clarify that it was an
- 6:04association that he was
- 6:05intimating, not a causation or
- 6:07a link. Do you are those just
- 6:09teasing out words and semantics
- 6:10in your view?
- 6:11>> Absolutely. Those words are
- 6:13designed to stoke fear and
- 6:15doubt in people's minds. In Dry
- 6:16Ridge or in Somerset, that
- 6:19don't have the access to all of
- 6:21the data that physicians and
- 6:23scientists do that study this
- 6:24every single day. It's
- 6:26purposefully done and it's
- 6:28wrong.
- 6:29>> Doctor, what do you say?
- 6:30>> My thought would be, I think
- 6:32we need to wonder why women are
- 6:33taking Tylenol in pregnancy. So
- 6:35I think if you are feeling if
- 6:37you are pregnant and you are
- 6:38feeling fine, you don't have
- 6:39anything wrong with you. You
- 6:41don't need to be taking Tylenol.
- 6:43But if you are taking Tylenol,
- 6:44it's for some reason so. And if
- 6:46an epidemiologic study you
- 6:47can't really make any. The draw
- 6:49that many conclusions from it.
- 6:50You're looking at big chunks of
- 6:52data. It could be really hard
- 6:54to kind of suss out exactly
- 6:56what's going on. But I think,
- 6:57you know, we need to look at
- 6:59maybe it's not the Tylenol,
- 7:00maybe it's the diseases that
- 7:01the moms have, the chronic
- 7:03diseases that the moms have, or
- 7:05other things that they have.
- 7:06You know, infections can cause
- 7:07fever. Infections are a prime
- 7:08cause of problems in newborn
- 7:09babies and in children. I think
- 7:11we need to look at those things.
- 7:13>> Right. But Tylenol is
- 7:14probably is it considered the
- 7:15most effective pain reliever or
- 7:17fever reducer?
- 7:17>> It may be the only one that
- 7:19you can take during pregnancy.
- 7:21You really can't take
- 7:22non-steroidal
- 7:22anti-inflammatories because
- 7:23they do things to the ductus
- 7:24arteriosus and the child.
- 7:26>> So. So what does that mean?
- 7:28Please explain.
- 7:29>> I apologize. For throwing.
- 7:31Out some.
- 7:31>> Medical terms. That's my
- 7:32role is to make sure that we
- 7:34talk and accessible.
- 7:35>> A medical educator, I was
- 7:36hoping not to do much medical
- 7:38education on the show tonight,
- 7:39but yeah, that's actually an
- 7:40important duct, which actually
- 7:41helps preserve the fetal
- 7:42circulation while the baby is
- 7:44inside developing. So it closes
- 7:45when babies are out so that
- 7:46they can use their lungs.
- 7:47>> Doctor, I want to come to
- 7:49you and ask you, what are your
- 7:51thoughts about particularly
- 7:52about the Tylenol issue and the
- 7:53the language that we're getting
- 7:54about? There could be some
- 7:56connection to autism. Do you
- 7:57believe this?
- 7:58>> Yeah. I didn't hear that.
- 7:59You know, we shouldn't be
- 8:01giving pregnant women Tylenol
- 8:03at all. I just heard that maybe
- 8:05we should consider that
- 8:08something we've considered safe
- 8:09for many, many years may be
- 8:12associated with some, you know,
- 8:14conditions moving forward. I
- 8:17mean, if you read the package
- 8:18insert of the Tylenol, you know,
- 8:22product, the the classification
- 8:25and the FDA class is class C,
- 8:27meaning the studies that the
- 8:29Tylenol company did was on rats.
- 8:31And by the way, what they look
- 8:35for is fetal malformations in
- 8:38the rats. They're not following
- 8:40these rat babies and seeing if
- 8:42they develop in normal fashion
- 8:44moving forward. And they also
- 8:45comment in the in their own
- 8:48package insert that most of the
- 8:50safety data has been
- 8:53epidemiologic meaning looking
- 8:53backwards not forwards in time.
- 8:56And we all know that that can
- 8:58be flawed with other
- 8:59confounding issues and biases.
- 9:01I, I have been a practicing
- 9:05obstetrics for over 31 years. I
- 9:07did tell a lot of my patients
- 9:10to take Tylenol, and I'm not
- 9:11saying that we shouldn't allow
- 9:13that to be given to pregnant
- 9:15women, but I just think we
- 9:16shouldn't be so quick to
- 9:19discard some findings that the
- 9:22government is saying they see
- 9:24without maybe looking into that
- 9:26a little bit deeper, maybe
- 9:29saying pregnant women should
- 9:30take Tylenol when they have a
- 9:33fever of a certain level, not
- 9:34when it's just 99°F, etc. There
- 9:38are other ways to bring down a
- 9:40fever other than taking
- 9:41medication, but I just think to
- 9:43quickly jump and just discard
- 9:46what's been said. I think that
- 9:48can be very dangerous.
- 9:49>> So you are still you still
- 9:51recommend Tylenol use for your
- 9:52pregnant patients?
- 9:55>> I mean, in certain
- 9:56indications, I feel that it can
- 9:59be given. I think maybe some of
- 10:00the data is based on people
- 10:02that were taking this in long
- 10:05term. And and just just for
- 10:09clarification, pregnant women
- 10:09can take ibuprofen, you know,
- 10:13not a lot of it and not on a
- 10:15continued basis and not close
- 10:17to term when they're going to
- 10:18deliver. But, you know, we
- 10:20usually recommend Tylenol, but
- 10:22maybe some of this data is on
- 10:23women who took it for a
- 10:25prolonged period of time. But I
- 10:27will say Acog was quick to
- 10:29generate a statement the
- 10:30following day and quoted a
- 10:32study that was published in
- 10:34Jama last year. But if you look
- 10:36at that study, a supplemental
- 10:37table of that study did show a
- 10:41possible correlation with use
- 10:42of acetaminophen and autism and
- 10:45ADHD. So even the the reference
- 10:48that was utilized did show a
- 10:49possible correlation.
- 10:51>> Doctor flowers, I want you
- 10:53to comment because you have
- 10:54been associated as the Kentucky
- 10:56Acog, as they call it for short.
- 10:58>> Sure. That's a
- 10:59misinterpretation of that study.
- 11:01That study was over was a study
- 11:03of over 200,000 children who
- 11:05had been exposed to
- 11:07acetaminophen during pregnancy,
- 11:08and there was absolutely no
- 11:10causal link to autism, ADHD, or
- 11:12other neurological
- 11:14developmental disorders. Period.
- 11:16>> The other thing the study
- 11:16did was it controlled for
- 11:18siblings. So as we know,
- 11:20there's a lot of evidence
- 11:21that's accumulating that says
- 11:22autism is related to genetics.
- 11:24So there's an increasing
- 11:26accumulation of that. So and
- 11:27that study controlled for
- 11:29siblings. So when they looked
- 11:30at the sibling controls there
- 11:32was no change.
- 11:33>> Right. Well we got a chance
- 11:34to talk with the Kentucky
- 11:37secretary of the cabinet for
- 11:39Health and Family Services,
- 11:40Doctor Steven Stack, last week
- 11:41about his views on vaccines and
- 11:43the use of Tylenol by pregnant
- 11:44women. And here's what he had
- 11:46to say.
- 11:47>> Well, there's long been a
- 11:47subset of people who have their
- 11:49concerns or skepticism, right?
- 11:51That's that's always the case.
- 11:52There's a small percentage who
- 11:53will feel that for whatever
- 11:55reasons, they lack confidence
- 11:57in or certainty in the
- 11:58recommendations that are given
- 11:59by their health care providers
- 12:01or other experts, that's always
- 12:03the case. What's unique now is
- 12:05that there's a growing number
- 12:07of people who are becoming
- 12:09uncertain, because the very
- 12:10basis of fact and reality is
- 12:13being distorted for them.
- 12:14They're being told information
- 12:16that is objectively wrong. It's
- 12:18objectively false. Take, for
- 12:19example, the Tylenol issue
- 12:21that's recently come up.
- 12:23Tylenol is one of the only
- 12:25medications felt to be
- 12:26generally safe for women with
- 12:28fever and pain who are pregnant.
- 12:30One of the only things
- 12:32generally felt to be safe, and
- 12:33now they've been told in no
- 12:35uncertain terms don't take it.
- 12:37Just tough it out. That's
- 12:38negligent, that's reckless.
- 12:40It's wrong. It's going to cause
- 12:42people to get hurt that don't
- 12:44need to get hurt, or people to
- 12:46suffer that don't need to
- 12:47suffer. And now when women who
- 12:49are pregnant go to see their
- 12:50physicians, some portion of
- 12:52them are going to be skeptical
- 12:54of their physician when they
- 12:55recommend. What modern medical
- 12:56science has long said is one of
- 12:59the safest medications they can
- 13:00use to help control fever and
- 13:01pain in pregnancy, which is
- 13:03acetaminophen or Tylenol.
- 13:04>> Is there a study or a series
- 13:06of studies that point to the
- 13:09the suspect nature of
- 13:13acetaminophen use during
- 13:14pregnancy? I mean, it had to
- 13:16have started from somewhere.
- 13:17What is the origin story of
- 13:18this speculation?
- 13:19>> Yeah, there are lots of
- 13:20studies about acetaminophen in
- 13:22pregnancy. One of the things in
- 13:23studies for pregnant women,
- 13:24because it's considered not to
- 13:27be ethical, to withhold
- 13:29treatment from one half of
- 13:31women and, and test one half
- 13:32and withhold from the other
- 13:34half. And so there's not great
- 13:36research specifically on
- 13:36pregnant women because of
- 13:38liability and ethical reasons.
- 13:40So what we have to rely on is
- 13:41what we call observational
- 13:43studies, where we look at large
- 13:45numbers of pregnant women who
- 13:47have made their own choices and
- 13:48then see how they responded
- 13:50differently to different
- 13:52choices. Those raise other
- 13:54problems, though, because a lot
- 13:56of other variables can come
- 13:58into play that confuse or
- 13:59confound the interpretation.
- 14:01There have been many
- 14:02observational studies for women
- 14:03who are pregnant using
- 14:05acetaminophen. They have. None
- 14:07of them showed a causal
- 14:09relationship where
- 14:10acetaminophen has in any way
- 14:12contributed to or caused autism,
- 14:14and one of the largest ones
- 14:16with millions of women in
- 14:17Scandinavia showed absolutely
- 14:19no relationship whatsoever to
- 14:21the diagnosis of autism and the
- 14:22use of acetaminophen in
- 14:24pregnancy. It is entirely
- 14:27irresponsible to suggest
- 14:28otherwise. What we have now,
- 14:30Renee, used to be that if you
- 14:33had 100 hundred scientific
- 14:35studies in 99 of them all lined
- 14:38up in a cluster and one was an
- 14:40outlier, you would say, well,
- 14:42that's the outlier. But but
- 14:43scientific evidence says this
- 14:44is clearly the right choice. We
- 14:47have a group of people now that
- 14:49are saying that one outlier,
- 14:50that's the truth. All the other
- 14:5299 are lying and hiding
- 14:53something. This is the truth.
- 14:54It's entirely backwards. And
- 14:57it's like I said, it's going to
- 14:58cause people to get hurt.
- 15:00>> All of this is consequential
- 15:02not just to access, but to
- 15:03affordability, to vaccinations,
- 15:05to medications. Talk about how
- 15:08this becomes an access issue if
- 15:10it keeps progressing the way we
- 15:12see this conversation
- 15:13progressing.
- 15:13>> So if this keeps progressing,
- 15:15people who don't need to get
- 15:16sick, get sick, instead of
- 15:17paying pennies to, you know,
- 15:19relatively speaking, to
- 15:20immunize people or give simple
- 15:23and safe medications like
- 15:24acetaminophen or Tylenol. In
- 15:25pregnant women, what we end up
- 15:27doing is having complications.
- 15:29You have kids who get diseases
- 15:30that we had previously
- 15:32eliminated, and they end up in
- 15:33the hospital, you know, with
- 15:35dehydration or pneumonia or
- 15:36problems they didn't need to
- 15:37have. You get a small number of
- 15:39them who die. And that's a real
- 15:41tragedy because the
- 15:42immunization could have
- 15:43prevented that entirely. You
- 15:44have elderly folks who, if they
- 15:46become skeptical and they don't
- 15:47get recommended immunizations,
- 15:48things for Covid or the flu,
- 15:51end up in the hospital or end
- 15:52up in an ICU or end up on a
- 15:55ventilator, or end up deceased
- 15:56because they get serious
- 15:57diseases that they might
- 15:59otherwise have been protected
- 16:00against. Renee. I would say in
- 16:01human history and all of our
- 16:03human history, and maybe
- 16:04there's 10,000 years of
- 16:05recorded human history one way
- 16:06or the other. The average human
- 16:08life expectancy is recently is
- 16:101900 worldwide, was about 32
- 16:12years of age in the United
- 16:14States. It was probably in the
- 16:16late 40s. Over the last one and
- 16:18a quarter centuries, 125 years
- 16:21or so, life expectancy has more
- 16:23than doubled globally and
- 16:24increased by 30 or more years
- 16:26in the United States. That's
- 16:27all because of science. It's
- 16:29all because of medicine. If you
- 16:30want to see what it looks like
- 16:32to eat an organic diet, not see
- 16:34a doctor, and have no medicines,
- 16:35all you have to do is go back
- 16:37to 1900 and we can all die
- 16:39under the age of 50 on average,
- 16:41because that's what we had
- 16:42before that. Antibiotics.
- 16:44Penicillin first came around in
- 16:461940s. The first
- 16:47antihypertensive medication in
- 16:48the 1950s, immunizations. We
- 16:50had some back at 1800. You know,
- 16:54when George Washington
- 16:55immunized his troops against
- 16:56smallpox. So that's not brand
- 16:58new. But the more commonly used
- 17:00ones, really, the 40s, 50s, 60s
- 17:02is when those really started to
- 17:04emerge. Modern medical science
- 17:06has been what has made it
- 17:08possible, along with sanitation
- 17:09and other things like that, to
- 17:12have longer, fuller, healthier
- 17:14lives.
- 17:14>> Is there any benefit, in
- 17:16your view, of having this
- 17:18healthy skepticism about modern
- 17:20medicine, about vaccinations,
- 17:22about long policies that we've
- 17:24had and have adopted, that have
- 17:28given way to this longer life
- 17:30expectancy and better health
- 17:31outcomes? Is there some benefit
- 17:33to having a skeptical
- 17:34conversation about it?
- 17:35>> I think there's always
- 17:36benefit for people asking
- 17:39questions. I think there's
- 17:40benefit for experts who analyze
- 17:41the same data and reach
- 17:43different conclusions. To have
- 17:44an informed discussion and
- 17:45debate about where truth may
- 17:47most likely lie. I think all of
- 17:49us need to be willing to
- 17:52revisit our conclusions when
- 17:53presented with evidence that
- 17:55suggests that our conclusions
- 17:56should be adjusted. I think
- 17:58that's the scientific process.
- 17:59I think that's just the
- 18:01hallmark of an enlightened,
- 18:02educated society. So yes,
- 18:03there's always a role for that
- 18:05kind of discussion. That the
- 18:06challenge comes in is when you
- 18:08have real experts who have
- 18:10studied and devoted their
- 18:12entire lives to studying and
- 18:14trying to find truth. And when
- 18:15they make recommendations based
- 18:17on a scientific method and do
- 18:19it in an open, transparent way.
- 18:21What really gets alarming is
- 18:22when we now have our very
- 18:24public institutions
- 18:25deconstructed, when we have
- 18:26experts fired from panels and
- 18:29replaced sometimes with cranks,
- 18:31and we have people who are
- 18:33substituting quackery for real
- 18:35science and doing it all in a
- 18:38very opaque way, where they're
- 18:39not consulting experts and not
- 18:40dealing in the open. That stuff
- 18:43is a recipe for real harm for
- 18:45all of us.
- 18:46>> Doctor, I want to come to
- 18:47you and ask you to give us your
- 18:51reactions to what Doctor Stack
- 18:52just shared.
- 18:54>> Yeah, I, I think that there
- 18:57needs to be more dialog because
- 19:01there's very much a in the in
- 19:05the last few years, there's the
- 19:07instant rejection of some
- 19:09things that are suggested. And
- 19:11again, I didn't hear from the
- 19:14announcement last week or
- 19:15whenever it was, but I'm times
- 19:17escaped me a bit that we should
- 19:19absolutely not be providing
- 19:21vaccines or give pregnant women
- 19:23Tylenol. I just think we need
- 19:25to be able to question these
- 19:28things and not be called a
- 19:29quack. I think that's pretty
- 19:32offensive. There's a lot of
- 19:34things in my years of doing
- 19:36obstetrics for over three
- 19:37decades that we don't do any
- 19:39longer. We don't provide IV
- 19:41alcohol for preterm labor. We
- 19:42don't put women on bedrest. We
- 19:45don't allow them to smoke. I
- 19:47mean, look, look how long, how
- 19:50many decades it took to prove
- 19:51that smoking caused lung cancer.
- 19:54Doctors and pregnant women used
- 19:55to advertise cigarettes. I mean,
- 19:57things change in medicine, and
- 19:59we should be able to question
- 20:00and not just instantaneously
- 20:03ignore something that's said
- 20:05and call it quackery.
- 20:08>> Doctor flowers.
- 20:08>> Yeah, she's she's got it all
- 20:11backwards there. This is the
- 20:13problem. The implication is, is
- 20:16that those of us who are
- 20:18physicians, who are clinicians
- 20:20and researchers and scientists
- 20:22at heart, that we create a
- 20:24policy and then we shut the
- 20:26research factory down. We it's
- 20:28dogma now that we don't think
- 20:31it's always an evolving topic
- 20:32that we want to continually
- 20:34research. We are it's a nonstop
- 20:3624 over seven, 365 process that
- 20:39we evaluate what we're doing
- 20:40every single day in every
- 20:44single, every other patient
- 20:44that comes through our office.
- 20:46We're reexamining what we do.
- 20:48And so the implication that, oh,
- 20:49you know, we're quacks. No.
- 20:51Whenever you put something out
- 20:53there that is not been proven
- 20:56to be a solid advice or
- 20:58protocol or procedure, there
- 21:01are implications. For example,
- 21:03I have held the hand of
- 21:04patients who have had fevers of
- 21:06102, 103, 104 who miscarry in
- 21:10the first trimester. I've been
- 21:12there with them. There are so
- 21:13many situations where just the
- 21:16simple use of Tylenol can help
- 21:17patients avoid fetal neurologic
- 21:21development disorders later on
- 21:21in life, miscarriage and other
- 21:23things. And so for the
- 21:25implication, it's a show a lot
- 21:27with this administration. It's
- 21:28a show they like. They like the
- 21:30attention. Be smart about it.
- 21:33Continue the research behind
- 21:34the scenes. And if there's
- 21:35something that's concrete, move
- 21:36forward with it. But don't
- 21:38scare people into making
- 21:39decisions that are not in their
- 21:41best interest.
- 21:42>> Doctor Rutherford, do you
- 21:44think that this administration
- 21:44is scaring people? Fear
- 21:46mongering?
- 21:46>> I think I don't like to get
- 21:49political, but I think the
- 21:52there are many of the
- 21:53administrations have been
- 21:53guilty of that. Do you think it
- 21:56was appropriate for President
- 21:57Biden to tell people they were
- 21:59facing a winter of illness and
- 22:01death if they didn't get the
- 22:02Covid 19 vaccine? I didn't get
- 22:03the Covid 19 vaccine. Four
- 22:07years of four winters of death.
- 22:08Here I am.
- 22:11>> So I did, Renee, and it kept
- 22:12me alive.
- 22:13>> I think, you know, I think
- 22:15that that that is what we
- 22:16should be talking about. Why
- 22:19don't people trust the medical
- 22:20establishment? Why don't people
- 22:22trust our institutions? They
- 22:24don't trust those institutions,
- 22:27and they don't trust their
- 22:29doctors because they were lied
- 22:31to over and over during the
- 22:34pandemic. They were lied to
- 22:36about six foot distancing.
- 22:38Turns out that was just made up.
- 22:40They were lied to about masking.
- 22:42They were lied to about the how
- 22:45the pandemic came about. It was
- 22:47created in a lab. They were
- 22:49lied to about the efficacy and
- 22:51the safety of the vaccine. I'm
- 22:54on the board of an organization
- 22:56called react 19, which is
- 22:58comprised of at least 37,000
- 23:02Americans who were injured by
- 23:02the Covid vaccine, and they are
- 23:05being ignored by the medical
- 23:08establishment. Why do you think
- 23:09I'm on the board? Why do you
- 23:10think I see patients who are
- 23:12who are damaged by Covid and
- 23:14the vaccine? Because I'm
- 23:15independent, I don't have a job
- 23:18to lose. Nobody's going to fire
- 23:19me for telling the truth.
- 23:20>> Did you ever recommend the
- 23:22vaccination, the Covid
- 23:23vaccination for those who were
- 23:25immunocompromised or had other
- 23:28preexisting conditions that
- 23:28could put them at greater risk
- 23:29if they were to contract the
- 23:31disease?
- 23:32>> At the very beginning, when
- 23:33the vaccines came out in
- 23:36December of 2020, I cautiously
- 23:40recommended to a few patients,
- 23:41including, unfortunately, my
- 23:43elderly parents. But within 4
- 23:46to 6 weeks it was very obvious
- 23:49that the vaccine didn't work. I
- 23:51had people coming to me in my
- 23:54office who got the vaccine and
- 23:55developed Covid within two
- 23:58weeks, so it didn't work. And
- 24:00then secondly, I was seeing
- 24:01people who were injured. I had
- 24:03many young patients who got the
- 24:05vaccine and came to me with
- 24:07shingles and with neurologic
- 24:09damage. I had a I have a few
- 24:12patients who got atrial
- 24:13fibrillation, and we know they
- 24:15knew in February of 2021 that
- 24:17that vaccine caused myocarditis
- 24:20in young men. And they and they
- 24:22buried it. And as a result, a
- 24:23friend of mine lost his son. He
- 24:26got the Pfizer vaccine and died
- 24:28five days later when he was 16
- 24:30years old. And our government
- 24:31buried that information. So I
- 24:34don't blame anybody for not
- 24:37trusting the medical
- 24:37establishment, public health
- 24:39officials or any government
- 24:41entity. I'm not taking medical
- 24:44advice from Joe Biden. I'm not
- 24:44taking medical advice from
- 24:47Donald Trump. But this study
- 24:49came out of Harvard. It's not
- 24:51like Secretary Kennedy and
- 24:54President Trump just brought it
- 24:57out of the ether. It was a
- 24:59study done at Harvard.
- 25:00>> Concerning the Tylenol. Yes,
- 25:02yes. I want to go to you,
- 25:04doctor. What do you think about
- 25:06talk about the Covid
- 25:07vaccinations. We'll start there
- 25:07and then.
- 25:08>> Everybody's experience with
- 25:09Covid is a lot different. My
- 25:11experience was different than
- 25:11other people. I was board chair
- 25:13of the Kentucky Medical
- 25:14Association at the time, and
- 25:15all this really hit. And I
- 25:16remember sitting on a
- 25:18conference call with some
- 25:20physicians in Bergamo, Italy,
- 25:20and this is the very beginning
- 25:22of the pandemic, before the
- 25:24country had shut down. And we
- 25:25got a chance to have some
- 25:27question and answer with the
- 25:29folks that were over there,
- 25:29because we heard about this new
- 25:31disease. I followed it over
- 25:33time, and it was in China, I
- 25:33noticed, well, you know, if
- 25:35Wuhan is putting up a really
- 25:37big hospital in a week, this
- 25:38must be a big deal, right? And
- 25:40yeah, we got to talk to some of
- 25:42the folks that were in Italy.
- 25:43We found out, yes, this is a
- 25:45respiratory illness. It's
- 25:46supportive care. We asked them
- 25:47what they did for advanced
- 25:49illnesses. They said we put
- 25:49patients on ventilators. And we
- 25:51asked them, did you have enough
- 25:52ventilators? They said, no. And
- 25:54I think that's a physician's
- 25:55worst nightmare is to have to
- 25:56decide who gets a life saving
- 25:58treatment, who doesn't. So that
- 26:00really changed my expectations
- 26:01of Covid and what it was about.
- 26:02So I understand that, yes,
- 26:05people got mixed messages of
- 26:06many different things and Covid
- 26:08made you sick. It made it made
- 26:10some people deathly ill. It
- 26:12killed people. The life
- 26:13expectancy in our country was
- 26:14down two years during the
- 26:15pandemic. Hopefully it's on the
- 26:17way back up, but and other
- 26:18people maybe got a runny nose
- 26:19or no symptoms at all. So I
- 26:22think it was very crazy in the
- 26:23way it did that.
- 26:24>> So do you believe vaccines
- 26:26the Covid vaccine works.
- 26:27>> The Covid vaccine is not
- 26:28going to prevent illness, but
- 26:30it will prevent you from
- 26:31getting critically ill. And I
- 26:32have personal experience with
- 26:33that. I brought I made it a
- 26:35long time without getting Covid,
- 26:36and I finally brought it home
- 26:37for a medical conference. Last
- 26:39year I had 103 fever. I had
- 26:41shaking chills. My wife had to
- 26:42change the bed a couple times a
- 26:44night. My my night sweats were
- 26:45so bad, and those were all the
- 26:47symptoms that we would see in a
- 26:49hospitalized patient before
- 26:50they went to the ICU.
- 26:51>> You were vaccinated.
- 26:52>> I was vaccinated, I honestly
- 26:54believe I would not be talking
- 26:55to you today without the
- 26:56vaccine.
- 26:56>> Doctor Rutherford, to say
- 26:58that a vaccine doesn't work, is
- 26:59it because they still got Covid
- 27:01in your experience, or because
- 27:02the disease that they
- 27:02contracted wasn't life
- 27:03threatening? I think Doctor
- 27:05Stack had said on our airwaves
- 27:07on many times that it wasn't
- 27:07perhaps going to prevent
- 27:09getting the disease. It just
- 27:11prevented the deadly, possibly
- 27:13the deadly consequences of it.
- 27:14>> Right. They changed the
- 27:16narrative once they realized
- 27:17that it didn't stop
- 27:19transmission. But Pfizer
- 27:20executives under oath admitted
- 27:21that they never tested it for
- 27:23transmission to prevent
- 27:24transmission. And the original
- 27:26Pfizer trial actually showed a
- 27:28higher all cause mortality in
- 27:30the treatment arm than in the
- 27:33placebo arm. So I we can
- 27:36disagree, but in my opinion,
- 27:39the evidence is that it's not
- 27:40effective and it's definitely
- 27:41not safe. If you look at the
- 27:43various data, there are over
- 27:471,600,000 adverse event reports
- 27:49in the various data for the
- 27:51Covid 19 vaccine. So I don't
- 27:53understand why it's still on
- 27:54the market, to be honest.
- 27:55>> That range from what the
- 27:57from kind of.
- 27:58>> 1 in 1 study by Freeman et
- 28:00al. It was 1 in 800 people had
- 28:04a serious adverse event to that
- 28:05vaccine that they had to seek
- 28:07medical care. And and I know
- 28:10people say you can't rely on
- 28:11various data, but most of the
- 28:14analyzes, including by the
- 28:15Institute of Medicine, found
- 28:15that there's actually
- 28:17understates the damage from
- 28:21from vaccinations.
- 28:23>> Does this cause you to
- 28:24question other vaccines as well,
- 28:26not just Covid.
- 28:28>> It definitely led me to look
- 28:30deeper into that issue, and I
- 28:32was not aware prior to Covid
- 28:34that there's there's there was
- 28:37an act passed in 1986 that
- 28:38protected pharmaceutical
- 28:40companies that make vaccines
- 28:42from any liability if someone
- 28:44is injured by a vaccine. When I
- 28:46learned that, just my critical
- 28:48thinking went into overdrive
- 28:50and sort of alarmed me because
- 28:51how are they? How are people to
- 28:55get relief when they are
- 28:56injured? And the whole reason
- 28:58we have react 19 is because
- 29:00people are not getting any help
- 29:02from our government. So Doctor
- 29:04Joe Walzog, he's an orthopedic
- 29:06surgeon in Ohio. He helped
- 29:08found react 19. He was injured
- 29:10by the vaccine. He got
- 29:11transverse myelitis.
- 29:14>> Which is.
- 29:15>> Oh, I'm sorry, it's. A it's
- 29:17a neurologic condition. It's an
- 29:18autoimmune condition that
- 29:21causes you to lose feeling
- 29:24sometimes. And some people
- 29:25aren't able to walk. And just.
- 29:28Brian Dressen is another
- 29:31injured individual. She was
- 29:32injured in the AstraZeneca
- 29:34trial. I take care of Maddie
- 29:35Gary, who was injured in the
- 29:37Pfizer trial at Cincinnati
- 29:38Children's Hospital, and they
- 29:40gaslit her family and made her
- 29:41think that it was all in her,
- 29:43her mind. And she still doesn't
- 29:45walk to this day.
- 29:46>> So doctor bis care to weigh
- 29:49in at this particular juncture?
- 29:51>> Yeah. I'm glad Molly brought
- 29:53up the original Pfizer trial,
- 29:54because if you look at the
- 29:57absolute risk reduction of
- 29:58severe Covid in the, you know,
- 30:00in the results of the study, it
- 30:02was 0.037%. So that's not very
- 30:07effective. If a patient asks
- 30:08you if I take this injection,
- 30:11what are the risks or what is
- 30:12the success, that it's going to
- 30:14prevent the infection. It's not
- 30:16even 1%. And there were no
- 30:18pregnant women enrolled in that
- 30:20trial, by the way. Men were
- 30:22told to wear two condoms. A
- 30:24woman was supposed to be on an
- 30:25adequate form of birth control.
- 30:27There were, however, some
- 30:29accidental pregnancies during
- 30:31the trial, and out of those
- 30:33women, it was a 12% miscarriage
- 30:35rate, which most of my
- 30:37obstetric colleagues would say
- 30:38that falls under the realm of
- 30:40normal. However, Nair et al. In
- 30:432022 published a study showing
- 30:44that the average miscarriage
- 30:47rate in the first 20 weeks of
- 30:48pregnancy is actually 5 to 6%.
- 30:52So that was almost double a
- 30:53normal miscarriage rate, and
- 30:55that should have raised a red
- 30:57flag. And when we when the
- 31:00American College of Obstetrics
- 31:01and Gynecology and the society
- 31:04for Maternal Fetal Medicine
- 31:05made their joint statement in
- 31:06July of 2021 saying these
- 31:10vaccines were safe and
- 31:11effective, this was not based
- 31:13on any long term study. Granted,
- 31:15we supposedly didn't have time
- 31:18to do that. And, you know, they
- 31:20were telling us to inject every
- 31:24patient that was thinking of
- 31:25getting pregnant, pregnant or
- 31:26breastfeeding based on not very
- 31:28safe data. If anything, there
- 31:31were signals suggesting there
- 31:32might be some danger.
- 31:34>> Doctor flowers, I'll allow
- 31:36you to respond.
- 31:37>> Sure. So during Covid, along
- 31:40with the flu vaccine, there's,
- 31:42what, 43 to 47,000 people who
- 31:44die in this country every year
- 31:46from the flu, the the highest
- 31:47per capita rate of deaths in
- 31:50flu and in Covid were in
- 31:52pregnant patients who are
- 31:53immunocompromised or in their
- 31:56pregnancy. And we were seeing
- 31:56with the onset of Covid
- 31:58pregnant patients dying at
- 32:00alarming rates from Covid
- 32:00throughout the country. And so,
- 32:03absolutely, we didn't have an
- 32:05extensive research on the Covid
- 32:06vaccine at that point. And we
- 32:08want pregnant patients to be to
- 32:10have access to the full
- 32:13spectrum of medical treatments
- 32:13that are out there to save
- 32:16lives. We also were seeing, I
- 32:18think, the first birth registry
- 32:19study that came out was from
- 32:21Mississippi, showing that women
- 32:23who contracted Covid during
- 32:26pregnancy were at higher risk
- 32:27for a whole host of things,
- 32:30including severe preeclampsia
- 32:31and eclampsia, intrauterine
- 32:33fetal death, spontaneous death,
- 32:36intrauterine growth restriction,
- 32:37all kinds of things. And so the
- 32:40American College of OBGYN did
- 32:41the smart thing, which was to
- 32:43allow women to have the choice
- 32:45to be able to take Covid and to
- 32:46say that that based on the data
- 32:49that we had, that it was safe
- 32:51for them to take in pregnancy.
- 32:52>> Doctor, I think you would
- 32:54like to respond.
- 32:54>> Yes. I would like to point
- 32:57out that Beth Pinellas, who is
- 32:59a high risk obstetrician in the
- 32:59Houston area, published a study
- 33:02in May of 2022. She completed
- 33:05that study a year prior. She
- 33:07studied 23,574 women aged 15 to
- 33:1244, had two arms where half
- 33:15were pregnant, half were not
- 33:17pregnant, admitted to the
- 33:17hospital with severe Covid and
- 33:20with statistical significance,
- 33:21showed that if you were not
- 33:24pregnant, you had a higher rate
- 33:26of mortality. So I feel that
- 33:30there may even be something
- 33:32protective in patients when
- 33:34they're pregnant. With regards
- 33:36to Covid, I was chief of staff
- 33:40of my hospital, which is a high
- 33:41risk referral center. I was on
- 33:44many calls with many health
- 33:45departments across the Tampa
- 33:47Bay area during that early time.
- 33:49We had not an increased risk of
- 33:52maternal death. As a matter of
- 33:53fact, we had no maternal deaths.
- 33:55At my institution that delivers
- 33:57almost 4000 babies a year. If
- 33:58there had been an increase in
- 34:01maternal mortality from Covid
- 34:02in the surrounding communities,
- 34:04I would have been made aware of
- 34:06that or been aware of that at
- 34:07that time. The other thing that
- 34:09Doctor Flowers brought up was
- 34:12everything he just stated was
- 34:15increased. If you were to
- 34:17contract Covid infection, I
- 34:18actually, as did my anesthesia
- 34:20colleagues and nurse midwife
- 34:23colleagues and labor and
- 34:24delivery nurse colleagues
- 34:25noticed all of those things
- 34:27seem to increase after 2021,
- 34:29when the injections were rolled
- 34:31out. And as a matter of fact,
- 34:33in our green journal, there was
- 34:34an article published showing
- 34:36that pre-term labor rates were
- 34:38not increased at all when you
- 34:39compared 2020 to 2019. In a
- 34:44huge population of patients. So
- 34:47I think, you know, we don't
- 34:48want women to become fearful
- 34:50and we don't want to, you know,
- 34:52create fear when we make
- 34:54recommendations. But I think a
- 34:56lot of things pregnant women
- 34:57were told really scared them
- 35:00into getting this injection.
- 35:01You know, we tell our women,
- 35:03don't smoke, don't eat tuna
- 35:05fish, don't color your hair.
- 35:06But go get this brand new
- 35:09injection. That's not like any
- 35:11vaccine they had ever had in
- 35:13the past. And, you know, I
- 35:16think that a lot of that was
- 35:18based on fear, because I'm sure
- 35:19Doctor Flowers would admit that
- 35:22over the years we've both
- 35:23practiced, it's sometimes hard
- 35:25to get pregnant women to take
- 35:28any medication, especially
- 35:29aspirin, if they have a history
- 35:31of pre-eclampsia, which is a
- 35:33high blood pressure condition
- 35:34in pregnancy. Aspirin has been
- 35:36shown to prevent that in a
- 35:37subsequent pregnancy. We have
- 35:39many patients that don't want
- 35:40to take that because they don't
- 35:41want to take anything that's
- 35:43going to harm their baby, but
- 35:4565% of my pregnant population
- 35:47willingly lined up and got this
- 35:49injection because they were
- 35:51very afraid.
- 35:53>> Doctor flowers, I'll let you
- 35:54respond.
- 35:54>> Yeah. You know, my mother
- 35:57and her eight sisters raised me.
- 35:59And in rural West Virginia. And
- 36:01my dad will say, your mother
- 36:04didn't take anything unless she
- 36:05grew it in pregnancy. So that's
- 36:08the perspective that I take
- 36:10with me to medicine. You do the
- 36:13least possible to be able to
- 36:16get the desired effect for your
- 36:18patients. The least invasive,
- 36:19the least risky, all those
- 36:21things. But at some point you
- 36:23have to be able to have a full
- 36:27armamentarium of of of options
- 36:28to be able to offer patients,
- 36:31given their particular
- 36:33individual situation and going
- 36:35back to Tylenol. And we can we
- 36:36can we can correlate this to
- 36:38the vaccine discussion.
- 36:40Whenever you throw out
- 36:41something in a public forum
- 36:45like is being done from
- 36:46Washington, D.C. from the Oval
- 36:48Office, and you scare the heck
- 36:51out of people, you're taking
- 36:53important tools away from
- 36:54physicians because patients
- 36:56come into the conversation with
- 36:58such a bias that's already
- 37:00there that they may have have
- 37:02harmful effects because they no
- 37:04longer will even consider
- 37:06something that potentially
- 37:07could be life saving for them.
- 37:08>> Doctor Rutherford, I'll
- 37:10allow you to respond before we
- 37:11talk a little bit more vaccine
- 37:12injury, I'd like to first talk
- 37:14a little bit more about that.
- 37:15>> You want to talk about
- 37:17vaccine injury?
- 37:18>> I do, and if you had a
- 37:20comment to Doctor Flowers. But
- 37:21I'll go ahead and jump into
- 37:22this because last night,
- 37:24perhaps many may have seen the
- 37:2560 minutes report on CBS about
- 37:26vaccine injury. And of course,
- 37:28there is a national vaccine
- 37:29court, which I was not aware of.
- 37:31Founded in the 1980s, 12,000
- 37:33Americans have received almost
- 37:34$5 billion in payouts for
- 37:36claiming injury after getting a
- 37:37vaccine. This really was
- 37:38established after diphtheria,
- 37:40tetanus and pertussis, or DTP
- 37:43DTaP vaccine, that there was
- 37:43some negative response to that.
- 37:47Do you know about this national
- 37:49vaccine court?
- 37:51>> I do unfortunately they it
- 37:54does the Covid vaccine injured
- 37:55have a whole separate process,
- 37:57which is kind of.
- 37:57>> So it doesn't go through
- 38:00this same process.
- 38:00>> No, but I but I am aware and
- 38:03the vaccine actually that
- 38:04federal vaccine court declared
- 38:06in in two separate cases of
- 38:07children I think around 2010
- 38:11Hannah Poling they they awarded
- 38:14her family $1.5 million and
- 38:16they and they actually
- 38:18acknowledged that her autism
- 38:19was caused by vaccines. So we
- 38:23have a couple of cases from
- 38:25that very court that
- 38:26acknowledges that an
- 38:28encephalopathy, encephalopathy,
- 38:29which is a brain inflammation,
- 38:33ensued after vaccinations,
- 38:34which later led to autism in in
- 38:37a few children. So they did
- 38:38find that she had an underlying
- 38:41mitochondrial disorder which,
- 38:43which predisposed her. Right.
- 38:45So I think that hopefully we're
- 38:46going to move into a more
- 38:49nuanced discussion with parents
- 38:51and with patients and a more
- 38:55individualized approach. For
- 38:56example, I have a gene mutation
- 38:59called Mthfr, which. Which
- 39:01means I have, a I have.
- 39:04>> Methylenetetrahydrofolate
- 39:06reductase deficiency.
- 39:06>> It's an enzyme that helps us
- 39:09process process folate. And so
- 39:11I don't do it very well because
- 39:13I'm homozygous for which means
- 39:15I have two genes anyway. So in
- 39:17my case I don't detox very well
- 39:20if, if I'm I have toxins on
- 39:22board. And so there are
- 39:25children who fall into that
- 39:26category as well. So I think
- 39:28hopefully eventually we can
- 39:29have a more nuanced discussion
- 39:31with parents. And we can we can
- 39:32identify the children that
- 39:35maybe should do, you know, take
- 39:37a different approach.
- 39:38>> Well, because they may
- 39:40already have a predisposition
- 39:41that's, you know, already
- 39:43existing. Exactly. It may be
- 39:45not it may be exacerbated by
- 39:46the vaccine because, as the CBS
- 39:4860 minutes report found, that
- 39:49vaccine injury is hard to
- 39:50quantify, really. But they say
- 39:53it's been likened to lottery
- 39:54odds and lightning strikes. So
- 39:57these are rare occurrences that
- 39:58such things do happen. Would
- 40:00you agree with that?
- 40:01>> I can shed some light on the
- 40:03whole vaccine court issue. So
- 40:04that came around in the 70s,
- 40:06because at the time, actually,
- 40:07if you look in journals, look
- 40:08in the Pediatrics journal, some
- 40:10other things they the science
- 40:12at the time accepted that the
- 40:15DTP vaccine caused brain damage.
- 40:17Okay. This is they had a
- 40:18medical word for it. And yeah,
- 40:21this was this was part of what
- 40:22they what they looked at. So
- 40:25anyway, it turns out that with
- 40:27modern genetic analysis later
- 40:28on, what happens with the DTP
- 40:30vaccine, you would get the DTP
- 40:32vaccine, you'd have fever, and
- 40:34with fever you would have
- 40:35seizures. And seizures were a
- 40:37marker for other things,
- 40:39perhaps further seizure
- 40:39disorders. So it turns out that
- 40:42a lot of the people that had
- 40:44issues with the DTP vaccine
- 40:44actually had genetic diseases.
- 40:47There's something called Dravet
- 40:48syndrome, so that kids would
- 40:49get the DTP vaccine, which is
- 40:51what it's a genetic disease
- 40:53that causes seizures and
- 40:54developmental delays. So and
- 40:56people said, oh, it's the
- 40:57vaccine. But actually they had
- 40:58the patient had fever from the
- 41:00vaccine that led to a seizure
- 41:02and that led to the onset of
- 41:03the illness. So the fever could
- 41:06have just as easily come from
- 41:07the flu or RSV or another
- 41:09infection that's out there.
- 41:10>> So perhaps testing these
- 41:12children for these types of
- 41:12markers in these genetic
- 41:14disorders or predispositions
- 41:16would be a first step.
- 41:18>> I think that's true. Many
- 41:19days we have children that we
- 41:20see in the hospital that we
- 41:22used to say, oh, this person
- 41:24has a seizure disorder. Now
- 41:25their seizure disorder has a
- 41:26name or they have a genetic
- 41:28mutation that's attached to it.
- 41:29So there's a strong genetic
- 41:30basis for that.
- 41:31>> And so a vaccine would not
- 41:33be recommended. I mean, in many
- 41:33ways that you and Doctor
- 41:35Rutherford are maybe singing
- 41:37from the same. Perhaps.
- 41:38>> But I think one of the
- 41:39things I think we have lost
- 41:41totally in this discussion is
- 41:42we have not talked about the
- 41:43diseases we're preventing. So a
- 41:44lot of people would not argue
- 41:46with me when they said, okay,
- 41:47the decision to get a vaccine,
- 41:49it's risk and benefit, right?
- 41:51So you're not going to get a
- 41:52Covid vaccine. I'm going to
- 41:54because I do not want to go to
- 41:56the ICU. So and that should be
- 41:57my decision. So but with with
- 41:59the diseases that we're trying
- 42:00to prevent, measles is out in
- 42:01the news. People know what
- 42:03measles look like. We see
- 42:04pictures of this. But measles
- 42:05and some other things, that's
- 42:06not really what I'm worried
- 42:08about. I'm worried about
- 42:09bacterial meningitis. Okay. I'm
- 42:10a hospitalist. I see and treat
- 42:11kids with bacterial meningitis
- 42:12from time to time. If parents
- 42:14are not taking vaccines and
- 42:16they're not taking all the
- 42:17vaccines, there's a couple of
- 42:18vaccines out there called Hib
- 42:20and Prevnar, which protect
- 42:21specifically against bacterial
- 42:22meningitis. We're going to
- 42:23start to see more cases and
- 42:25kids are going to get it
- 42:26because we carry that as adults.
- 42:28We have Haemophilus influenza B
- 42:29on our person. We are going to
- 42:31be the person that infects our
- 42:32children. So I go way back. So
- 42:34during my intern year at Texas
- 42:37Children's Hospital, we saw a
- 42:39lot of bacterial meningitis. I
- 42:41think at any given point in
- 42:42time, there are at least two
- 42:44kids in the ICU getting treated
- 42:45acutely for meningitis, which
- 42:46have to be very careful with,
- 42:48and probably another 20 or so
- 42:49on the floor that were getting
- 42:51IV antibiotics. It was a big
- 42:52hospital, but still, and
- 42:54probably 20 to 25% of kids that
- 42:55survive bacterial meningitis
- 42:56have some sort of hearing loss.
- 42:58So acquired hearing loss used
- 42:59to be something that was really,
- 43:01really common. And we just
- 43:02don't see it anymore because we
- 43:04have good vaccines to prevent
- 43:05bacterial meningitis. So I
- 43:06think we need to talk more
- 43:08about the the illnesses that
- 43:09are here. You know, polio is
- 43:11something we don't see or hear
- 43:12anymore. But boy, in the 1950s
- 43:14you can see it. And it was a
- 43:16big topic of discussion. The
- 43:18president had it. And I often
- 43:20wonder what would happen if
- 43:20Salk and Sabin came back today
- 43:22and were in your studio tonight
- 43:24listening to this conversation
- 43:25and, you know, kind of what
- 43:26they would think because they
- 43:28were national heroes at the
- 43:29time for creating that vaccine.
- 43:30Right. And we.
- 43:30>> Do hear some questions about
- 43:32some of these vaccines that
- 43:34doctor is discussing, right? I
- 43:35mean, hepatitis B, polio
- 43:38vaccines. I mean, what's your
- 43:39skepticism around any or all of
- 43:41these?
- 43:41>> Well, one thing that Doctor
- 43:44Stack said was that medicine is
- 43:47is to credit for our increased
- 43:48life expectancy. Expectancy,
- 43:51excuse me, but from 1900 to
- 43:561960, the death rate from
- 43:59measles had already declined by
- 44:0198%. The measles vaccine did
- 44:02not become available until 1963.
- 44:06So really, it's public health
- 44:08measures that should get the
- 44:10credit for a lot of that
- 44:12increase.
- 44:12>> As what kind of.
- 44:15>> Sanitation, refrigeration,
- 44:17better nutrition medicine
- 44:19definitely deserves some of the
- 44:20credit. Antibiotics for sure,
- 44:23but and the hepatitis B vaccine
- 44:26was added to the schedule, to
- 44:28the infant schedule because the
- 44:29high risk groups were not, the
- 44:32uptake in the high risk groups
- 44:34was not satisfactory to our
- 44:35government, so they figured
- 44:37they could could get it on the
- 44:38childhood schedule. It would
- 44:41protect the company from
- 44:42liability. Did you know that
- 44:43the recombinant hepatitis B
- 44:46vaccine was studied in 147
- 44:48children? And it was they
- 44:50followed those children for
- 44:51five days, five days for the
- 44:54safety studies. Are you okay
- 44:56with that?
- 44:57>> Yeah.
- 44:57>> Actually, I'm okay with that.
- 44:59I'll tell you, my experience
- 45:00with that is completely
- 45:01different. And again, I go way
- 45:03back. So I remember before we
- 45:04were giving the hepatitis B
- 45:05vaccine to infants, one of the
- 45:06things that we we did there was
- 45:09you want to try, you want to
- 45:10give the hepatitis B vaccine
- 45:12early on to prevent vertical
- 45:13transmission. So if a mom has
- 45:15hepatitis B, the odds they're
- 45:17going to infect their newborn
- 45:18baby are pretty good. So there
- 45:19are some things that we do at
- 45:22delivery. We give hepatitis B
- 45:23vaccine. We give hepatitis B
- 45:24immune globulin to prevent
- 45:26transmission. Those were both
- 45:26really important. So so when I
- 45:28was in practice all right. This
- 45:30was back before electronic
- 45:31records and paper charts. And
- 45:35okay. So someone would come in
- 45:37and deliver Saturday night the
- 45:38office is closed. You don't
- 45:39have access to the mom's
- 45:41hepatitis B records. You draw a
- 45:42blood sample, it takes a couple
- 45:44hours to run. The baby comes
- 45:45out. What do you do? Right.
- 45:47We're like, okay, we don't know.
- 45:48We're not going to get an
- 45:49answer back until Monday or say,
- 45:51you're in working in the
- 45:52hospital where this lab is
- 45:54going to take a while to come
- 45:56back. You know, we went ahead
- 45:57and give the hepatitis B
- 45:58vaccine, and we gave the H the
- 46:00hepatitis B immune globulin.
- 46:01And we found out, yeah, we were
- 46:03giving a lot of hepatitis B
- 46:04vaccine to babies and they were
- 46:06doing fine. So they weren't
- 46:07having any issues.
- 46:07>> With it. You can ask risk
- 46:09factors. You can you can base
- 46:11it on risk factors. You can
- 46:13still take a history from a
- 46:13patient and find out if the
- 46:16mother was had some high risk
- 46:17behaviors that would put her
- 46:18baby at risk. You don't just
- 46:20automatically jab a one year
- 46:21old baby.
- 46:21>> Well, the other thing is.
- 46:23>> That I think.
- 46:24>> We've lost sight of the fact
- 46:26that the hepatitis B vaccine
- 46:27and the HPV vaccine are there
- 46:28to prevent cancer. Cancer. And
- 46:30if you told me when I started
- 46:31medical school we'd have
- 46:32vaccines against cancer, I
- 46:34would have said, you were crazy.
- 46:35But we do.
- 46:35>> And HPV, human
- 46:37papillomavirus talked more
- 46:37about that. I mean, that's not
- 46:39something that's mandated or
- 46:40recommended for certain youth.
- 46:42>> Yes, the hepatitis B vaccine,
- 46:44the HPV vaccine, again, we're
- 46:45trying to decrease the viral
- 46:47load of hepatitis or hepatitis
- 46:49HPV, human papillomavirus in
- 46:51the community. So that's the
- 46:52cause of cervical cancer. And
- 46:54it makes sense that if you are
- 46:56acquiring the cervical cancer,
- 46:57you are at risk for cervical
- 46:58cancer. Through acquiring this
- 46:59virus, it makes sense to stop
- 47:01it.
- 47:01>> But it's recommended as
- 47:02young as nine years old.
- 47:04>> The whole point is to
- 47:06decrease the burden of the
- 47:07virus in the population.
- 47:08>> Doctor Rutherford, how do
- 47:10you feel about that?
- 47:11>> Well, the HPV vaccine is
- 47:12kind of controversial as well.
- 47:13There have been many reports of
- 47:16injuries from that vaccine, and
- 47:18there are some studies that
- 47:19show that it's not preventing
- 47:20cancer. So there have been
- 47:23debates among experts that have
- 47:24a lot more credentials than me,
- 47:26where they where people
- 47:28disagree on whether or not to
- 47:30give that vaccine.
- 47:32>> Is there injury from that
- 47:33vaccine that you're aware of?
- 47:34>> There are injuries from that
- 47:35vaccine, documented injuries
- 47:37from that vaccine. You can see
- 47:38and you can if you open a
- 47:41package insert. And I would
- 47:42encourage parents to do this.
- 47:43They're available on the FDA
- 47:45website. You can see all of the
- 47:47reactions that are that are
- 47:50possible. You can see the
- 47:52ingredients and you can even
- 47:53look at the clinical trial data.
- 47:55And most people are smart
- 47:56enough to do the math to decide
- 47:58if they if they think it's
- 48:00worth the risk. And I say that
- 48:02as a mom who who vaccinated
- 48:04both of my kids, I even gave my
- 48:06boys the HPV vaccine. In
- 48:08hindsight, I would not do that
- 48:09again. But I just want to come
- 48:12clear that, you know, my mind
- 48:14has been changed from doing a
- 48:16lot of research on this topic,
- 48:19and what bothers me also is
- 48:21that there's a lot of panic and
- 48:24a lot of discussion about
- 48:26replacing the members of ACIp.
- 48:27That committee.
- 48:29>> And that committee.
- 48:30>> That's that's the, the, the
- 48:32committee that with with HHS
- 48:34that discusses vaccines and
- 48:37decides what to do with the
- 48:38childhood schedule. So they've
- 48:39been meeting lately and and
- 48:41they took the Covid vaccine,
- 48:42for example, off of the
- 48:44childhood schedule. And they
- 48:45said leave it to individual
- 48:46discretion, which is a good
- 48:49step anyway, the prior to this
- 48:51particular board that that RFK
- 48:54Jr has assembled, there were
- 48:56members of the board with major
- 48:59conflicts of interest. So they
- 49:01they are getting paid by the
- 49:03very pharmaceutical industries
- 49:04that they are making decisions
- 49:08about that is known. And that
- 49:10was one of the things that when
- 49:13Bobby Kennedy was running for
- 49:14president, that he talked about,
- 49:16that he wanted to change. And
- 49:17that is one of the reasons
- 49:19people don't trust those those
- 49:22entities. And if you if you
- 49:23talk about people that are
- 49:24labeled anti-vax, which I don't
- 49:27like that term, many of them
- 49:29have PhDs, many of them are
- 49:31very highly educated. And so
- 49:32they go and they do their own
- 49:35research. So I am really happy
- 49:37that we're finally getting to
- 49:39talk about all of these issues,
- 49:40because it's been taboo for so
- 49:42long. And, you know, these
- 49:45parents are being treated with
- 49:47contempt sometimes in
- 49:48pediatrician offices. They're
- 49:49getting kicked out.
- 49:51Pediatricians won't even take
- 49:53care of these children because
- 49:54they because their parents are
- 49:56skeptical of these vaccines. So
- 49:58I'm I'm ecstatic that we
- 49:59finally get to talk about it.
- 50:01>> Yeah. The wisdom in
- 50:02scrapping the board and
- 50:04replacing with others that we
- 50:06heard the character
- 50:06characterization by Doctor
- 50:08Stack is wasn't as flattering
- 50:09as Doctor Rutherford had just
- 50:11expressed.
- 50:12>> It was an entirely poor
- 50:13decision to scrap the Advisory
- 50:16Committee on Immunization
- 50:17Practices Board. Everything I
- 50:19just heard again was a spin on
- 50:23on how the health care system
- 50:26is not functioning to be able
- 50:28to best serve patients and
- 50:29their families. The people that
- 50:32were replaced on ACIp that have
- 50:34now on the go read their
- 50:36resumes, go read where they've
- 50:38come from. Whatever background,
- 50:40the anti-vaxxers, individuals
- 50:43who who, who have very
- 50:45controversial views outside of
- 50:47scientifically evidence based
- 50:50proven health care benefits for
- 50:52different practices.
- 50:53>> But they don't have
- 50:54conflicts with being tied to
- 50:56pharmaceutical companies.
- 50:57>> They're there were most of
- 50:58those individuals who were on
- 51:00ACIp for years and years had to
- 51:01disclose what they what what
- 51:03those their relationships were
- 51:05with individual pharmaceutical
- 51:07companies. I almost everybody
- 51:09in this country at that level
- 51:11has some type of affiliation
- 51:13with, with an organization, an
- 51:16association, a corporation. And
- 51:18and I didn't have any issue or
- 51:20problem, nor did the American
- 51:22College of OBGYN in believing
- 51:25in the recommendations they put
- 51:27forward. I can't point to, and
- 51:28I would challenge anyone to put
- 51:31forward any recommendation,
- 51:33because the implication is when
- 51:34that's said is that these
- 51:36individuals were pocketing
- 51:36money because and being
- 51:38influenced by what
- 51:40pharmaceutical companies wanted
- 51:41them to do, point to something
- 51:44that shows that that's not true.
- 51:45This is another tactic to stoke
- 51:47fear and doubt in the American
- 51:49public over scientifically
- 51:51proven, data driven protocols
- 51:54and recommendations. It's wrong.
- 51:56>> Doctor BS.
- 51:59>> Well, I think Molly could
- 52:00speak volumes on the fact that
- 52:03the whole opioid crisis we have
- 52:04today is because of the
- 52:06shenanigans that occurred
- 52:08between a pharmaceutical
- 52:08company and the FDA. But I
- 52:11wanted to bring up the fact
- 52:14that the hepatitis B vaccine, I
- 52:17think in today's age, where we
- 52:19do have electronic records, we
- 52:21have the the ability within an
- 52:22hour to determine if a pregnant
- 52:25woman has hepatitis B infection
- 52:27or previous exposure, if we
- 52:30don't have access to her
- 52:31prenatal records, which we
- 52:33screen all of our pregnant
- 52:34patients for hepatitis B,
- 52:35there's no reason in today's
- 52:39society to be given a less than
- 52:4224 hour year old baby, the
- 52:44hepatitis B vaccine. We have
- 52:46all that information. And now,
- 52:48because a lot of patients are
- 52:49questioning this and they
- 52:51should be able to question this,
- 52:52and they shouldn't be told on
- 52:53the wards that their baby is
- 52:56going to die if they don't get
- 52:57this injection. That, again, is
- 52:59by fear, and that's coercion.
- 53:00And a patient cannot make that
- 53:02violates ethics. And they
- 53:04shouldn't be told that. But now
- 53:05it's probably going to happen
- 53:07is because the parents are
- 53:08refusing these vaccines in
- 53:09their babies. We're now going
- 53:11to start vaccinating pregnant
- 53:12women so that we can at least
- 53:15get this in their system and
- 53:17get the antibodies to the baby.
- 53:18And I just find that
- 53:20incredulous.
- 53:20>> Well, as we have a little
- 53:22bit more than three minutes
- 53:23remaining, I want to kind of go
- 53:25a round robin. And Doctor
- 53:26Rutherford, if you want to talk
- 53:28about that, because you are an
- 53:29addiction specialist. Right?
- 53:30Right. Doctor, this was making
- 53:31about you could speak volumes
- 53:33about that pharmaceuticals and
- 53:34the I mean.
- 53:35>> The people of Kentucky. I
- 53:37don't understand why the people
- 53:38of Kentucky would, would
- 53:39blanket have blanket trust for
- 53:42pharmaceutical for the
- 53:43pharmaceutical industry. After
- 53:43how our people were targeted,
- 53:46our doctors were targeted by
- 53:48Purdue Pharma, and it was
- 53:51devastating for our state. So I
- 53:54just I just encourage people to
- 53:56use their critical thinking.
- 53:58Look at look what happened.
- 54:00Like I said in 1986, where they
- 54:03gave these these pharmaceutical
- 54:05companies who make vaccines,
- 54:06they gave them immunity from
- 54:09liability, essentially. And the
- 54:11the woman who ran the CDC from
- 54:152002 to 2009, she was
- 54:16responsible for that Merck
- 54:18Gardasil vaccine being approved
- 54:20largely. And then she went to
- 54:23work for Merck and has made
- 54:24millions of dollars since. So I
- 54:27don't know, I'm just more
- 54:28skeptical of those
- 54:29relationships.
- 54:31>> Yeah.
- 54:32>> I went to medical school to
- 54:33ease suffering in patients. I
- 54:35mean, that sounds corny, but
- 54:36that's really kind of why we
- 54:37went to medical school is just
- 54:39to heal and to do better. And I
- 54:41worry that if we're telling
- 54:42pregnant moms, you can't take
- 54:43Tylenol, you can't do this, you
- 54:45can't do that. You know, when
- 54:46does when does it stop? So
- 54:48we're putting all the blame for
- 54:49autism and all these other
- 54:50things on mom, and I just don't
- 54:52think that's fair. So I would
- 54:54like that to end. The other
- 54:55thing is, I agree with you,
- 54:56Doctor Rutherford, in terms of,
- 54:58you know, the decision to
- 54:59vaccinate your children, being
- 55:00being a shared thing, it's
- 55:01something that you should talk
- 55:03about the risks and benefits of.
- 55:04And we're hearing a lot about
- 55:06the risks. We don't hear about
- 55:07the benefits because we're not
- 55:09hearing about the diseases that
- 55:09we that we should be preventing.
- 55:11I've seen most of them. I can
- 55:13tell my patients, listen, this
- 55:14is going to happen. If your kid
- 55:16has bacterial meningitis, this
- 55:17is going to happen if your kid
- 55:18has has has mumps. So and I
- 55:21think that needs to be part of
- 55:22the conversation. Also, I don't
- 55:23hear that in the modern
- 55:25vernacular. I didn't hear a lot
- 55:26of that tonight. I'm probably
- 55:27the only person who brought
- 55:29that up. But it's really,
- 55:30really important.
- 55:31>> Yeah. Doctor flowers, a few
- 55:32seconds, please.
- 55:32>> Absolutely. So science is
- 55:34always ongoing. We are always
- 55:35we are in this, in this, in
- 55:36this career path. We we didn't
- 55:38spend all of these years
- 55:39studying and and and training
- 55:43to stop learning. We are
- 55:44constant lifelong learners as,
- 55:46as as physicians. All of us are.
- 55:49And so there never should be an
- 55:51implication that because we
- 55:53have a policy that's in place
- 55:55or a recommendation based on
- 55:57science and evidence, that the
- 55:58research behind the scenes is
- 56:01continuing to make sure that
- 56:02that it continually is safe in
- 56:03the patients that we're
- 56:05treating and to be to, to to
- 56:07get ahead of the ball, to ahead
- 56:10of the curve, to to stoke fear
- 56:12in the communities and populace
- 56:14is just a wrong tactic. And we
- 56:16need to bring more civility and
- 56:19more calm to be able to make
- 56:20rational decisions for patients.
- 56:22>> We'll have to leave it there.
- 56:24We do thank our physicians for
- 56:25being with us. This is a very
- 56:27good discussion, and if you
- 56:29want to see it again, it'll be
- 56:30on our website at ket.org. I'm
- 56:32Renee Shaw, thank you so much
- 56:33for watching and I will see you
- 56:34soon. Take good care. Well
- 56:40something fell, but you know,
- 56:42we can't really we can't look
- 56:44for it in the middle of the
- 56:46show.