Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / An Update To Your Evidence Preservation Demands And How To Advise Your Clients Of Their Own Preservation Obligations
Transcript
- 0:02I am delighted to introduce our speaker, Andrew
- 0:08Owen. My name is Neda Sagafi. I am BHBA co -litigation
- 0:14chair. I'm here introducing Andrew Owen. He is
- 0:20an attorney and a colleague of mine at Panache
- 0:23Rabaputi. His practice focuses on litigating
- 0:27and trying catastrophic personal injury and wrongful
- 0:30death cases, including matters involving commercial
- 0:34vehicles, aviation incidents, dangerous conditions
- 0:37of property, and complex industrial and construction
- 0:41accidents. He has secured numerous multimillion
- 0:45-dollar verdicts and settlements, including impressive
- 0:49recoveries exceeding $60 million, and is recognized
- 0:52by best lawyers in America for personal injury
- 0:55litigation, for plaintiffs, and as a Southern
- 0:58California rising star by super lawyers. Prior
- 1:03to joining the firm, Mr. Owen handled complex
- 1:06high -stakes litigation across state and federal
- 1:08courts, and he remains an active member of the
- 1:12Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles.
- 1:16So now let's go ahead and get started. Thanks,
- 1:19Andrew. Very good, Nada. Thank you so much. My
- 1:22mom would love you for that huge wind -up. My
- 1:25dad would say, enough, enough. Jeez, oh, Pete.
- 1:29Anyway, let's get this party started. And let
- 1:35me fix that. All right. Good morning, everyone.
- 1:41I greatly appreciate you joining me on what I
- 1:45think is a very, very important topic, evidence
- 1:48preservation. And my intention here is to walk
- 1:52you through how I go about preserving evidence
- 1:56as best I can, not only with respect to the demands
- 2:00that I make of the potential future defendants
- 2:03in my case, but also my own clients. And evidence
- 2:07preservation, early action really truly can make
- 2:11or break your case. And the reason is the trite
- 2:15expression the clock is ticking with each passing
- 2:18day is so very true. And the reason is a lot
- 2:21of the evidence that we're seeking to preserve
- 2:24on our cases is time sensitive, meaning the people,
- 2:28the companies that have this evidence, whether
- 2:31it's a tow yard that has a car or the Linux company
- 2:36that has a audio and video recording of your
- 2:40crash, they're under a time commitment or a time
- 2:44limitation to either you know, crush the car
- 2:48and sell it for scrap or to just delete the video
- 2:53because our contract says, hey, we only need
- 2:55to keep this video for, you know, 10 days, 30
- 2:59days, whatever it may be. And so you're obligated
- 3:04in my view as a lawyer to take as prompt action
- 3:10as you can once you sign a new case to, you know,
- 3:16turn the screws on those deadlines that these
- 3:18companies or the tow yards or your future defendants
- 3:21that they have with respect to this evidence.
- 3:24And look, you're going to have cases where, you
- 3:27know, it's going to be too late. That's just
- 3:29the reality, right? You're going to have a client
- 3:31who calls you six months later after the crash.
- 3:34And by that time, the insurance company for the
- 3:38defendant and perhaps your own client, the insurance
- 3:40company got the car. and they totaled it and
- 3:43it's gone. In those situations, there's nothing
- 3:45you can do. So we're not here to talk about what
- 3:50you can't do. We're talking about what you hopefully
- 3:52can do. So draft and send your evidence preservation
- 3:56letter ASAP. That is something that should be
- 3:59obvious. But what I want to discuss is what goes
- 4:02in this letter? And it doesn't need to be complex.
- 4:07It doesn't need to be you know, filled with case
- 4:10law. I'm going to talk about the fairly recent
- 4:14case concerning evidence preservation that must
- 4:17go in your letter. But really, truly, these are
- 4:22the items that should go into all of your evidence
- 4:26preservation letters. Obviously, the claim and
- 4:28case identifying information. Identify the accident
- 4:32so you can refer to it throughout the letter
- 4:34in a simple way, like the subject crash, the
- 4:36subject collision. Legal authority, as I mentioned,
- 4:39will talk about the cases that concern preserving
- 4:44evidence and evidence spoliation. Obviously identifying
- 4:48the specific evidence you want retained. Demand
- 4:52that the recipient acknowledge receipt of your
- 4:55letter and state their intent to either, you
- 4:58know, preserve the evidence as you're demanding
- 5:00or As I talked about, and you'll see, I extend
- 5:05the offer, I say, look, if you don't wanna stow
- 5:07the car or save the car, I'll get a towed to
- 5:11rest your case up in Irwindale, make it easy
- 5:15on the defense or the defendant's insurance company
- 5:17so they have no reason to push back and say,
- 5:19well, it's costing us $40 a day or a hundred
- 5:22bucks a day to store it. And then finally, You
- 5:27know show proof that you have a basis to actually
- 5:29send this letter on your client's behalf Attaching
- 5:33your you know attorney designation and supporting
- 5:36documentation Relating to whatever you're asking
- 5:40to preserve and we'll talk about that in detail
- 5:42So let's go through this claim identifying information
- 5:46pretty straightforward stuff, right? I like to
- 5:48put this right at the top of the letter If you
- 5:51have the information, hopefully you do with respect
- 5:54to the insurance company that's involved. If
- 5:56there's a claim number already, great. A lot
- 5:59of times if you act early and you get the case
- 6:02early, there's not a claim number yet. You'd
- 6:05identify data loss, who's involved, and some
- 6:08information about where this incident occurred.
- 6:13The foundational information about the crash,
- 6:17this is the traditional introduction. into every
- 6:22evidence preservation letter. And really, it's
- 6:25something I would use if I was just sending a
- 6:27letter to notify a potential defendant and or
- 6:31their insurance company that the plaintiff or
- 6:35the injured party is represented, I'm their lawyer,
- 6:38and here's what this case is about. So identify
- 6:44the incident, identify at least, and this is
- 6:49Obviously, with respect to this letter, this
- 6:52is a car crash, specifically identified the vehicle,
- 6:58whether it's a car, a helicopter, plane, motorcycle,
- 7:02bicycle, whatever it is, identified that specifically.
- 7:07All right. Legal authority, and I'm going to
- 7:10go into detail specifically about this case,
- 7:13the Valley Union High versus Superior Court.
- 7:16This is the current state of evidence preservation
- 7:20and a lawyer's obligation and your client's obligation
- 7:29and a party's obligation to preserve evidence
- 7:32and when that obligation is actually going to
- 7:35be triggered. Like I said, we'll talk specifically
- 7:39about that case and its impact on us as lawyers
- 7:43and on your clients. But there's the legal authority
- 7:47and you don't need to, when you're writing this
- 7:51letter, do a case brief on the legal authority.
- 7:55The point is to cite the main holding of Valley
- 8:00Union High, just so you're putting the recipient
- 8:03on notice that, hey, hey, It's not just me as
- 8:07a lawyer screaming for you and demanding for
- 8:09you to preserve this evidence. It's actually
- 8:11required by law because there's a lawsuit that
- 8:14is most assuredly either already filed or that
- 8:19is imminent. And that's one of the holdings of
- 8:22the Valley Union that we'll talk about. The next
- 8:26portion of the letter, evidence that you want
- 8:28retained, try to be as specific as possible.
- 8:30You don't need to go crazy, right? You can write
- 8:33broadly, but also be specific. Here with respect
- 8:38to this case and the letter that's on the screen
- 8:43now, there was obviously a BMW involved and I
- 8:47use V7 for virtually every single auto crash.
- 8:54that I have, you know, specifically number two,
- 8:58you know, dash cams, video audio recordings.
- 9:02It's not very often that you're going to have,
- 9:07you know, just a regular passenger car that has
- 9:09a dash cam, but you never know, right? So you
- 9:12include all of these items in the chance that
- 9:16you know maybe they do and if they do you you've
- 9:20certainly demanded that it be maintained the
- 9:22video and audio recordings and as you'll see
- 9:26later in this presentation those video and audio
- 9:30recordings you know tell you exactly what happened
- 9:34and also tell you whether you have a case or
- 9:36you don't photographs a lot of people who are
- 9:42involved in the crashes if they're serious enough,
- 9:45or even if they just cause minor damage. Cell
- 9:48phones are ubiquitous. People typically take
- 9:52photos of what happened, not with the intent
- 9:55of knowing that it's going to be part of a lawsuit
- 9:58later, but usually most people have the wherewithal
- 10:01to understand that, oh man, this is going to
- 10:04be an insurance issue, so let me document the
- 10:07damage. The biggest one for me, obviously video,
- 10:13dash cam, if they have it, great, but most vehicles
- 10:16today, it varies between manufacturer and year,
- 10:21but most vehicles have these electronic control
- 10:26modules or electronic data recorders, lots of
- 10:30different names for the same thing. I like to
- 10:33refer to it when I'm taking depositions of experts
- 10:35as a vehicle's black box. And so that's why number
- 10:39five is to me, if not the most, if there's no
- 10:44video and audio, but if there is none, it's the
- 10:47most important data because it shows speed, it
- 10:54shows braking, it shows acceleration, which we
- 10:58all know is critical information when we're assessing
- 11:02a case, the good and the bad. I always request
- 11:08that they preserve texts and emails that they
- 11:12send about the collision. Oftentimes when an
- 11:16involved party sends texts or emails or other
- 11:21correspondence to their insurance company, those
- 11:23are privileged and that's fine. But I'm still
- 11:26gonna demand all of that gets preserved. But
- 11:28if they're at the scene and they're texting their...
- 11:32you know, boyfriends or their friends and, oh
- 11:35my god, I just got in a crash, I was speeding,
- 11:37I couldn't, I wasn't paying attention, I was
- 11:39on the phone with you, you know, those are the
- 11:42types of things that I'm going to ask that they
- 11:44preserve because of course, you know, that that
- 11:47type of communication could be very impactful.
- 11:50And then the last one, accident or incident reports,
- 11:54you know, obviously you're not going to expect
- 11:55a private citizen to create their own accident
- 11:58or incident report. However, if the law enforcement
- 12:03responded to the same, most likely they're going
- 12:05to create a traffic collision report. And oftentimes
- 12:08they give the face page or something related
- 12:11to the report to the involved parties. So I demand
- 12:15that they keep that. I include number seven in
- 12:18the event that, you know, there's a course and
- 12:20scope issue. And as part of their employment,
- 12:24they're using either a company car or their own
- 12:27private car. And there's something about a company
- 12:29policy that requires them to create or fill out
- 12:33an accident or incident report if they've been
- 12:36involved while on the job. So I always include
- 12:39that. The next, demanding that the recipient
- 12:45acknowledge they've received your letter and
- 12:47get them to commit. send me some type of confirmation
- 12:52that you're going to abide by what I'm asking
- 12:56you to do. Usually, when I do get a response,
- 13:02and I would say I probably get a confirmation
- 13:05less than 20 % of the time, and I don't believe
- 13:11I have a continuing obligation to continue with
- 13:14it. continuously remind them to preserve the
- 13:18evidence. I think this one letter suffices so
- 13:23that they don't respond and confirm, okay, I've
- 13:27put you on notice. I fulfilled my obligation
- 13:30to myself and to my clients and to the court.
- 13:34And so it's on you now that I've put you on notice
- 13:38to take care of what I'm demanding. And if you
- 13:40just sit on your hands and watch that car knowingly
- 13:44get scrapped, well, that's going to be a different
- 13:46issue. That's going to be a motion for monetary
- 13:50sanctions, issue sanctions, and we'll see in
- 13:53just a little bit for potentially terminating
- 13:55sanctions, depending on how egregious the conduct
- 13:58is. In the times that I do get a response, to
- 14:03my demand letter, it's usually, we've got the
- 14:06car, insurance, it's usually from an insurance
- 14:10company. State Farm says, hey, we will pay for
- 14:14whatever, 10 more days to keep it secure and
- 14:19safe at the tow yard. Are you able to come out
- 14:22and do your inspection within those two days?
- 14:24If you can, great. Otherwise, I say, I'm not
- 14:28gonna be able to do that, but my own cost, all
- 14:32have the vehicle towed to rest your case, which
- 14:35I'm sure a lot of you have used. It's up in Irwindale.
- 14:38It's a wonderful facility. It's well respected.
- 14:42You're not gonna get pushback from the insurance
- 14:45company that it's an inappropriate place to take
- 14:47the vehicle. They're more than happy to get rid
- 14:49of it so long as you pay for it. But the point
- 14:53is to me that if you actually get a response
- 14:56and the insurance company says, hey, we'll give
- 14:59you 10 days, That is less sort of like giving
- 15:02notice to you. So you still need to continue
- 15:05to be on top of your game. You still need to
- 15:07act. So either retain your expert to go out and
- 15:10do that inspection within those 10 days. One,
- 15:13two, call them back and say, hey, I can't do
- 15:16it in 10 days, but I can do it in 20 days. Maybe
- 15:19that won't be an issue. If it is, then you go
- 15:21to option three. Hey, all right, within the 10
- 15:24days, I'm going to call, rest your case. And
- 15:26they'll come out and get towed that vehicle.
- 15:29from wherever it is to their facility in Irwindale,
- 15:33of course, you're going to pay for it. But it's
- 15:35worth it. It's a small cost to pay for what evidence
- 15:38could be revealed. And then, as I mentioned,
- 15:41the authority to make the demand, I always include
- 15:44my designation of attorney. And then whatever
- 15:49information I have about the crash, this here,
- 15:52I got the face page because the law law police
- 15:58officer at the scene gave it to all of the involved
- 16:01parties and so I was able to you know attach
- 16:04it but anything even if it's a a photograph of
- 16:09the business card the police officer gives with
- 16:11the report number on it. Just something to give
- 16:14you more foundation for the letter and what you're
- 16:17asking the recipient to do so you can say, hey,
- 16:21look, this is real and here's all the information
- 16:23I have about the crash. And look, if you have
- 16:26photos, include those. A lot of times I have
- 16:30my own clients send me photos and I include everything
- 16:35that I have. the more information, the better,
- 16:38in my perspective, when you're sending out these
- 16:40evidence preservation letters. Okay, so let's
- 16:44talk about the law. In this Valley Union High
- 16:50case from 2023, you know, the primary holding
- 16:54about, okay, when does the duty to preserve evidence
- 16:58begin? And it's somewhere between knowledge of
- 17:01the dispute and direct specific threats of litigation.
- 17:07And I always include, and this is one of the
- 17:10primary holdings of this case, and we'll talk
- 17:12about what exactly this means, but I always end
- 17:16it with, okay, listen, your duty to preserve
- 17:19evidence, it started the moment that the, whatever
- 17:23this incident was, the moment it happened. And
- 17:26I continue in the letter and I say, lest there
- 17:29be any doubt, understand that what I'm asking
- 17:32you to preserve, is critical evidence in either
- 17:37a lawsuit that I already filed or in a future
- 17:40lawsuit that will be filed, you know, imminently
- 17:44against your insured. So that type of magic language
- 17:48is, to me, sufficient to satisfy this criteria
- 17:52about when evidence preservation begins. So before
- 17:59the Valley Union High case, there were two cases
- 18:02that dealt primarily with when did this duty
- 18:06to preserve evidence begin? Is it before a lawsuit's
- 18:10filed? Is it after? Do we just defer to what
- 18:13the civil procedure statutes provide? And so
- 18:19there were conflicting holdings. With respect
- 18:21to CEDARS, this was a great case. I used to side
- 18:24all the time before Valley Union because the
- 18:29One of the primary holdings of CEDARS was describing
- 18:35a misuse of discovery as destroying evidence
- 18:40in anticipation of a discovery request. And I
- 18:44would stretch this holding to argue that, look,
- 18:48there's no requirement that a lawsuit actually
- 18:51be filed or an RFP or a demand for inspection
- 18:55be hanging out there. You should know, insurance
- 18:59company, and involve driver that the second the
- 19:03crash occurred and, you know, considering the
- 19:06nature and extent of all the damage that you
- 19:09should be have been anticipating a discovery
- 19:12request from me eventually. So this was a case
- 19:16I would cite all the time and, you know, because
- 19:20of its perceived favorable holding. But then
- 19:24along came new Albertson. and New Albertson,
- 19:28another Court of Appeal case, and it was critical
- 19:33of cedars. And it described that language that
- 19:37I liked to cite so much as dicta. And New Albertson
- 19:43said, look, if we're going to talk about duties
- 19:46to preserve evidence and when that duty will
- 19:50arise, we can't just create it out of whole cloth.
- 19:53Let's turn to the Code of Civil Procedure. to
- 19:57tell us when that duty arises. And of course,
- 20:00spoiler, there is none. There's no statutory
- 20:03guideline. There's no code of civil procedure
- 20:06that says the duty to preserve that smashed up
- 20:09car started on this day. It's just not in there.
- 20:12It doesn't exist. And so there was always this
- 20:16conflict between New Albertsons and Cedars. And
- 20:21so, you know, there was a, and you can buy, you
- 20:24can, compare the two together. CEDARS, there's
- 20:29the duty to preserve evidence. There's a pre
- 20:33-lawsuit risk that you could be, you know, spoiling
- 20:36evidence even though there's no lawsuit filed
- 20:38or pending discovery request. And New Albertson
- 20:41that said, no, no, you have to have a statute
- 20:43that tells us how to handle this and I don't
- 20:46want any. Okay, so then Valley Union comes in,
- 20:50another appellate court case. So you have three
- 20:53Appellate court cases, you know, so which one
- 20:58is is precedential. None of them have been expressly
- 21:01overruled or Cedars and New Alberts haven't been
- 21:05expressly overruled by Valley Union. Maybe someday
- 21:08the California Supreme Court will take up evidence
- 21:10preservation. Probably not. But here comes Valley
- 21:15Union. And it was a it was a very sad case. This
- 21:18minor student who It was undisputed, required
- 21:22a constant adult supervision, you know, had some
- 21:25issues and was known to wander and every teacher
- 21:32and the principal, everyone knew that this boy
- 21:35needed constant supervision. Well, of course,
- 21:40someone dropped the ball and he wandered and
- 21:43then he was sexually assaulted by another student.
- 21:47A security camera near the scene. recorded the
- 21:51assault. And it was learned through discovery
- 21:55that the assistant principal and the security
- 21:58guard actually watched the video and confirmed
- 22:01the assault. But the video was erased. They didn't
- 22:06preserve the video. It was automatically overwritten.
- 22:10I can't remember what the... I think it was probably...
- 22:14two weeks, maybe it was 10 days, but it was overwritten
- 22:18in the normal course of however they maintain
- 22:21these video recordings. In other words, it was
- 22:23not intentional. No one, not the assistant principal,
- 22:27not the security guard went in there and went
- 22:29delete. In the case, I believe what the testimony
- 22:35was, it was one of those things where the assistant
- 22:37principal said, I thought the security guard
- 22:40did it or was going to keep the video and the
- 22:45security guys started, I thought the assistant
- 22:47principal was going to, so it was, you know,
- 22:49two fingers pointing at each other. Obviously,
- 22:52it's not an excuse for them not to preserve this
- 22:55video when they knew it, you know, recorded critical
- 23:00evidence in this case. But what the court of
- 23:03appeal found was that the deletion was not intentional.
- 23:09the assistant principal, the security guard,
- 23:11they didn't go in there and affirmatively delete
- 23:13it. They just didn't preserve it. And that was
- 23:17an important factor in this decision. The plaintiff
- 23:21at the trial court sought monetary and terminating
- 23:24sanctions and the trial court granted them. And
- 23:27so that's why the... the school district saw
- 23:32a writ and got this, and it did get some relief.
- 23:35So the issue in this case is, when does the duty
- 23:39to preserve evidence arise? And of course, wildly
- 23:43vague, reasonably anticipated. That's when you
- 23:47see the duty, okay, well, please tell me, what
- 23:51does that mean? What does reasonably anticipated
- 23:55mean? So I, as a lawyer, know what to how to
- 24:01counsel and advise my client. And also when I'm
- 24:04sending these letters, how I can put this information
- 24:06in a letter and know that I'm in a reasonable
- 24:08position. So litigation is reasonably anticipated
- 24:16when it's probable or likely to arise from a
- 24:20dispute or incident. Something more than just
- 24:23the mere existence of a potential claim. and
- 24:28also reasonably foreseeable. That standard, it
- 24:31does not require that future litigation be imminent
- 24:35or probable without significant contingencies
- 24:39or even cert. Okay, that provides a little bit
- 24:43more clarity. I mean, so does this crash that
- 24:48you're dealing with as a lawyer representing
- 24:50your client? Would this be something that would
- 24:53typically lead to a lawsuit? Well, sure. I mean,
- 24:56because they hired you. So it's easy for us as
- 24:59plaintiff lawyers to say, well, of course a crash
- 25:01like this always results in a lawsuit. But that's
- 25:04just frankly, it's not the case. And so you have
- 25:07to look at it using these four factors. So that's
- 25:13one of the helpful things about the Valley Union
- 25:15case. It starts pretty broad, reasonably anticipated,
- 25:19gives some more confines to what that means.
- 25:21And then the court finally says, OK, look, use
- 25:24these four factors when you're considering whether
- 25:28the duty to preserve evidence has sprung. So
- 25:34the type of injury or severity, how often similar
- 25:37kinds of incidents lead to litigation, course
- 25:41of conduct between the parties, whether the parties
- 25:44have been involved in litigation in the past.
- 25:46I interpret number three to also include, in
- 25:50terms of the course of conduct between the parties,
- 25:52me on behalf of my client sending an evidence
- 25:56preservation letter to the insurance company
- 25:59or to the driver, his or herself. So that's what
- 26:04I think satisfies number three. And then number
- 26:07four, what steps did the parties take? after
- 26:10the accident, before the loss of evidence, including
- 26:14whether the defendant initiated an investigation
- 26:16into the accident themselves. So this is some
- 26:20helpful guidance. And to Valley Union's credit,
- 26:24they also gave some specific examples. Slip and
- 26:28fall in prison incidents predictably result in
- 26:31litigation. I mean, if it were me, and it is
- 26:34me, I'm a plaintiff's lawyer, I would say, well,
- 26:36look, if a slip and fall incident predictably
- 26:38results in litigation, so too does a serious
- 26:41car crash that results in property damage that
- 26:47results in potentially paramedics being called
- 26:49to the scene and your client being taken to urgent
- 26:53care or the emergency room for care. But that
- 26:59alone must is not enough, okay? It must be combined
- 27:04with other circumstances and the other circumstances,
- 27:08I'll just go back to the four factors, okay?
- 27:12Because I equate like the slip and fall and the
- 27:15prison incidents to fall under that factor number
- 27:18one. I also think it falls into factor number
- 27:21two, but I think, you know, to me what the ballot
- 27:25union is emphasizing, it's gotta be, okay, It's
- 27:28not just the accident itself. You have to have
- 27:30more information in order for this duty to arise.
- 27:34They distinguished, understandably, because it
- 27:37was a school district case. They said they used
- 27:41school district cases in general because of their
- 27:45heightened duty. The reporting of a student on
- 27:49student sexual assault alone without any of the
- 27:53other factors, that alone weighs heavily in favor
- 27:57of finding that it was reasonably foreseeable
- 28:00litigation was going to commence. And so as a
- 28:02result, the duty to preserve evidence sprung
- 28:05then. OK, so what happened was in Valley Union,
- 28:12the Court of Appeal, it affirmed the trial court's
- 28:16finding that the school reached the duty to preserve
- 28:20But it found the terminating sanction because
- 28:22I think my memory is the court struck the school
- 28:26district's answer. And the Court of Appeal found
- 28:32that that was too much because the destruction
- 28:35was not on purpose. It was not willful. So it
- 28:39remanded it to the trial court to consider for,
- 28:42you know, other alternatives. Now, you draft
- 28:48your evidence preservation letter, you're good
- 28:53to go. So what do you do now? You send it in
- 28:58some way that you can show if you need to later,
- 29:02if you're going to file a motion for monetary
- 29:07issue and or terminating sanctions, show proof,
- 29:11affirmative proof that you sent it and that they
- 29:14received it. And that creates a verifiable record
- 29:18of service. So that's not one of those. I never
- 29:21caught it. You send it by regular U .S. mail.
- 29:24You know, I don't wouldn't be comfortable going
- 29:28back to my law school days saying the mailbox
- 29:31rule, Your Honor. I think you'd get some eye
- 29:34rolls considering the infinite number of ways
- 29:37that you could send. an evidence preservation
- 29:40at a reasonably cheap price, including for free
- 29:43by email, considering the ubiquity of emails.
- 29:49So, you know, so create a verifiable way to record
- 29:54service. And so as we talked about who gets it,
- 29:57I'm telling you, everyone, just like Oprah giving
- 29:59away cars that one time to her studio, I'm sending
- 30:02this evidence preservation letter to anyone.
- 30:08identified in, you know, the traffic collision
- 30:10report, in any document, the insurance company,
- 30:16and this is who I'm talking about. Of course,
- 30:19the driver, and I have no reservations, even
- 30:23though Ultimately, if I haven't already filed
- 30:26a lawsuit against the driver that I'm going to,
- 30:28I have no reservations of directly communicating
- 30:32with the driver because typically at this point
- 30:34in time, when I'm sending the evidence preservation
- 30:37letter, the driver's not represented. And I'm
- 30:41not sending any correspondence that's unethical.
- 30:45I'm not extorting any future defendant. It's
- 30:50entirely proper. to send evidence preservation
- 30:54letters to unrepresented parties. Obviously,
- 30:57if you know a party is represented, when you
- 31:01want to send your evidence preservation letter,
- 31:03you send it to their counsel and not to the driver
- 31:05directly. But in situations where you know that
- 31:09they are not, send it directly to that driver.
- 31:13Also, the registered owner. You put that registered
- 31:16owner on notice in the event it's someone else
- 31:19than the driver. A lot of times you'll learn
- 31:25from the face page of the traffic collision report
- 31:30or maybe your client overhears something or the
- 31:33driver of the other vehicle tells your client
- 31:35at the scene and causes you to see that this
- 31:38might be a course and scope issue, that there
- 31:41might be an employer who needs to get my evidence
- 31:43preservation letter. And the tip off is usually
- 31:46when the face page of the traffic collision report,
- 31:49the registered owner you know, is whatever Viacom
- 31:55or a company. And so when you see that, my reaction
- 32:00is usually two things. One, commercial policy.
- 32:04Two, that company is getting my evidence preservation
- 32:08as well. And next, the tow yards, if the collision
- 32:14is often serious enough, the vehicles would be
- 32:18towed. These tow yards will only keep it for
- 32:24as long as they're continuing to be paid by the
- 32:27insurance company. They have the least regard,
- 32:30in my experience, of your evidence preservation
- 32:33letters. And the reason is you can't separately
- 32:38sue a person or a company for destroying evidence,
- 32:42not a separate tort. It's usually, you know,
- 32:45it comes up in motions for sanctions, monetary
- 32:49issue, or terminating sanctions against a party.
- 32:53But I still, you know, send it to the tow yard
- 32:56and I always follow up to the tow yard once I
- 33:00send it because I want to know what their clock
- 33:03is. And usually they tell me. I have pretty good
- 33:05success when I send a letter to the tow yard.
- 33:08I say, hey, How long are you going to be keeping
- 33:12it at your tow yard? And they'll say, oh, well,
- 33:14at State Farm, it'll be 30 days or 10 more days
- 33:17or whatever it is, or it's indefinite. I've had
- 33:19criminal cases where law enforcement puts a hold
- 33:23on it because it's evidence. And in those situations,
- 33:27you find that car's not going anywhere because
- 33:29the criminal case will subsume your civil case,
- 33:32at least for the time being. Insurance companies,
- 33:36obviously, the insurance company that's identified
- 33:39on the traffic collision report or in an exchange
- 33:43of information between your client and the other
- 33:45involved party at the scene. And then I also,
- 33:49depending on where this crash occurred, I do
- 33:53try to myself, I go Google Maps, Google Street
- 33:58View, see where it happened. Again, we talk about
- 34:01ubiquity of cell phones and emails. security
- 34:05cameras, ring cameras, external cameras. They're
- 34:10almost all over the place now for good and bad.
- 34:12But I, you know, do a Google street view, see
- 34:15if there are businesses that may have cameras
- 34:17in the area that might have captured our crash
- 34:21or, and or I send out a private investigator
- 34:24to do that work for me. If something, my investigation
- 34:28or my investigators investigations investigators,
- 34:32investigation reveals stores, then I send out
- 34:35evidence preservation letters to those stores.
- 34:39And then equally as important, you have to send
- 34:44your evidence preservation, not a letter, we'll
- 34:47talk about what to send, but you got to put them
- 34:49on notice to immediately. And the reason is,
- 34:54You know as much as we like to send these letters
- 34:57out to the future defendants or the actual defendants
- 35:00that duty arise It's not a one -way street. It
- 35:03goes both ways and Valley Victor emphasized or
- 35:06Victor Valley emphasized That duty and it said
- 35:10when a party, okay, so it's not just the defendant.
- 35:14It's your plaintiff They have a vehicle that
- 35:17was likely involved in the crash that vehicle
- 35:21is evidence that EDR on their vehicle is evidence,
- 35:26that dash cam, et cetera, et cetera. So if your
- 35:31client is represented, your knowledge will be
- 35:35imputed on them. So let's say they retain you,
- 35:39all right, and you learn, oh, your car, Ms. Plaintiff,
- 35:43is that the tow yard? Okay, I'll handle it, Ms.
- 35:46Plaintiff, don't worry about it. And you don't
- 35:49contact the tow yard? and notify them that it's
- 35:52evidence, it needs to be preserved, and it gets
- 35:54destroyed, you know, two weeks later. That could
- 35:58be, you know, very bad for your case, very bad
- 36:01for your client. So it's very important that
- 36:04you act quickly, not only with respect to sending
- 36:07it out, but notifying your client and taking
- 36:09action on your client's behalf to protect them
- 36:12and to protect you and your case. And so what
- 36:16I do, I don't send the letter, I call them, of
- 36:19course. Client communication. I mean we can do
- 36:22a whole seminar on and webinar on client communication,
- 36:26but this is one of those where You get on the
- 36:29phone with them you talk them through everything
- 36:31that I'm talking about right and You talk about
- 36:34their obligations you ask them what they have.
- 36:37Hey, what happened your car? Where's your car?
- 36:40Who's your insurance company? You need to contact
- 36:42them. Hey, did you take any photos at the scene?
- 36:45Take any videos? Send me those, please. Send
- 36:47me the original JPEG images, everything. And
- 36:50then, you know, send a follow -up written confirmation
- 36:55for your own edification as a lawyer and as a
- 36:59reminder to your client. This is part of representation.
- 37:03This is part of client communication. But just
- 37:06follow up with a written email that just reminds
- 37:09them of what you talked about and reminds them
- 37:12of their obligations and just confirms that you're
- 37:16going to take prompt action on their behalf.
- 37:23Let me go back to this. I'm going to show you
- 37:27some examples of evidence that's that have been
- 37:30critical in cases that I've had, and focus on
- 37:36pictures, okay? We talked about EDR, and I'm
- 37:41going to show you an example of that in a moment,
- 37:44but pictures are so critical. Again, you know,
- 37:50the trite expression, pictures worth a thousand
- 37:52words, it is. Pictures and videos. you know,
- 37:57humans like the path of least resistance. They
- 38:00like to see things. They only listen to so much.
- 38:04So as clever and well -spoken as we all think
- 38:07that we are, it's a lot more persuasive and a
- 38:11lot more impactful if you get, you know, videos
- 38:14and photos. And so getting back to this point,
- 38:19if your client and my client, if they have taken
- 38:22photographs either at the scene or whatever,
- 38:25taking photographs of something related to our
- 38:28case, please, please get the original JPEG images.
- 38:35Don't rely on them to text them to you. You need
- 38:39the original JPEG images because sometimes when
- 38:43they get texted, the quality gets compressed
- 38:45and they're still usable, but they're not great.
- 38:50Sometimes when you send them by text, Or you
- 38:54embed them into the email itself. You lose the
- 38:57metadata that shows the date and time that the
- 38:59photos were taken. So do yourself and your client
- 39:05a favor and to say, look, if you can't separately
- 39:08attach the original JPEG images to an email because
- 39:12of the file size or you just don't feel comfortable
- 39:14doing it, send them a Dropbox link because you
- 39:18really genuinely want all of the original JPEG
- 39:23images because they will become the best evidence
- 39:28in your case for the most part. So just one tip
- 39:32about the JPEG images and the same thing with
- 39:35the videos. If you send it sometimes, when you
- 39:38send videos by text or by attachment emails,
- 39:42the video gets compressed and pixelated and it
- 39:44just doesn't... do you the good that it could
- 39:47do when it's something so easy and simple as
- 39:49sending your client a Dropbox link. All right.
- 39:53So let me show you some examples of how an evidence
- 39:58preservation demand genuinely and materially
- 40:06helped my case. So this was, many of you have
- 40:12seen reports like this. And this is referred
- 40:17to as a crash data report. And it's generated
- 40:21when there's a download performed of an electronic
- 40:26control module or electronic data recorder on
- 40:30a car. And as I mentioned how important this
- 40:34is, this was a case where the defendant hit and
- 40:40killed two children in a crosswalk. She was convicted
- 40:44of two counts of murder and she's serving 15
- 40:46years to life, civil cases continuing. But this
- 40:50information here, there was a wild dispute about
- 40:55speed of the vehicle at the time. And interestingly,
- 41:00but not surprisingly, there were eyewitnesses
- 41:02not to the crash, but to the speed of the vehicle
- 41:06leading up to the intersection, because where
- 41:08the intersection was, was not within the necessarily
- 41:12the view of some of the eyewitnesses. And so
- 41:15eyewitness testimony, as we all know, is not
- 41:18the most reliable. Everyone likes to say they
- 41:20saw everything and they know. But I had testimony
- 41:24of one eyewitness who said, oh, yeah, the speed
- 41:26of that vehicle probably going 30 to 35 miles
- 41:29per hour. Another person who was across the street,
- 41:33you know, saw the same vehicle and said that
- 41:35vehicle was going 120 miles per hour. So, eyewitness
- 41:40testimony is only so good. So, EDR data and speed
- 41:45data from the black box, you know, it's material
- 41:50data. It cannot be disputed. And this is one
- 41:53of those cases where I was able to learn that
- 41:56the vehicle, you know, was traveling at these
- 41:59speeds, you know, one and a half seconds before
- 42:02impact going 81 miles per hour in a 45 mile per
- 42:05hour zone. And to get to that speed, the driver
- 42:11had to accelerate or step on the gas pedal 98%,
- 42:16which all the experts testified. In the case
- 42:19that's like you floor it. I mean, sometimes you
- 42:22get to literally 200%, but 98 % is flooring it.
- 42:26And in terms of service brake activation, that's
- 42:30where the brakes ever applied. And the answer
- 42:33was no. And then it shows the speed of impact
- 42:38at 0 .0 at 73 miles per hour. So I sent this
- 42:43evidence preservation letter the moment that
- 42:47we signed the case and the tow yard that had
- 42:52it said, hey, the police have it. We're getting
- 42:55ready to transfer it to their secure facility.
- 43:00Would you like to come out and inspect it and
- 43:03offer accepted? You don't know what's going to
- 43:06happen, right? Not to say that it would be destroyed
- 43:12or intentionally destroyed later, but if you
- 43:16have an opportunity to access that data. with
- 43:20an expert, you take it. And I got that quick
- 43:23access because I sent that evidence preservation
- 43:26letter and the tow yard called me. They said,
- 43:28hey, we got it. You know, we're gonna send it
- 43:30over to the police tow yard soon, but we'd like
- 43:32to have access to it. And so we were able to
- 43:34get prompt access to it. I mean, the reality
- 43:36is the police got it. They did their own downloads
- 43:40and they gave everyone access to it again later.
- 43:44My fear is sometimes And it hasn't happened to
- 43:47me yet, but who knows? Sometimes during the handing
- 43:50off of this vehicle to some other tow yard or
- 43:53some other person, who knows what can happen?
- 43:57It could get corrupted. It could break. The electronic
- 44:01data record, who knows? It could vanish. So it
- 44:05helped me in this situation. Here's another one.
- 44:09This is from a Lytics camera system. And it's
- 44:12a dash cam. And let me forward it to... Let's
- 44:18go to right at a minute. Okay, so this, I'll
- 44:23get back up. This is a camera system on a FedEx
- 44:27vehicle. And you'll see the forward facing dash
- 44:31cam. Let me press play. And the vehicle's coming
- 44:36and the decedent pulls out from the curb and
- 44:39bam. Okay, so obviously it was a fatal collision.
- 44:44involving a FedEx truck and just watching that
- 44:47video, you think, oh my goodness, well, that's
- 44:50not good for my client because he just pulled
- 44:52that way from the curb and the FedEx driver didn't
- 44:55have a chance to react. Well, I sent an Evans
- 44:59preservation letter to Lytics and I said, hey,
- 45:03I need all of the dash cam because I know the
- 45:06Lytics camera system has both the forward facing
- 45:10camera but the simultaneous driver facing camera,
- 45:16okay? And so I got this first video that we just
- 45:20watched in response to my demand letter to FedEx.
- 45:25They produced just the dash camera. And I got
- 45:30the video and I thought, oh man, this is going
- 45:32to be a tough case. Just watching that video
- 45:35alone, that isn't a great fact for me. But then...
- 45:41in response to my evidence preservation letter
- 45:45to Lytics, I got the driver camera. And the Lytics
- 45:50camera system, I'll talk more about that in just
- 45:52a moment, it records simultaneously and it records
- 45:56continuously. In other words, the moment the
- 46:00engine starts, it's recording. All right? And
- 46:04so let me go to, let's go to 40 seconds. Okay?
- 46:13And you'll get a sense of what the driver was
- 46:17doing. So, in his right hand, he has his phone
- 46:29and he's looking up, looking down, scrolling
- 46:32on Instagram, looking up, looking down. Texting
- 46:39on his phone, doesn't see my client. Boom. Okay,
- 46:58so once I got this video from Linux, it was,
- 47:06of course, a total game changer. I mean, in a
- 47:09really material way to the point where I was
- 47:12able to allege punitive conduct and, you know,
- 47:17I was able to sustain a summary or a defeat,
- 47:21a summary judgment motion or motion for summary
- 47:23adjudication as to punitive damages based solely
- 47:26on this video. And as you can imagine, that can
- 47:29be very impactful when you're going into a mediation.
- 47:34All right, so. And I want to emphasize the Lytics
- 47:41camera system and how important it is and how
- 47:45impactful it can be. The Lytics dash cam system,
- 47:53it's a preferred recording system that's used
- 47:57by major companies and international and national
- 48:02companies. It's FedEx, Amazon, JB Hunt. My understanding
- 48:08is UPS is either they're started or they're going
- 48:15to use Lytics. But it is a camera system that
- 48:21not only records as we looked at the simultaneous
- 48:25recording of the driver and the dash cam, but
- 48:30it really records everything. It records the
- 48:37GPS, the actual location. It records speed of
- 48:43the vehicle at any increment that you set. If
- 48:48you want to perform your search, it does braking.
- 48:52There are trucking companies who use the Lytics
- 48:54system to do their logbooks. And so the Lytics
- 48:58system, depending on the subscription that the
- 49:01company gets, They use those for virtually everything
- 49:07that can be meaningful to you if your client's
- 49:10been involved in a crash with one of these entities
- 49:12and companies. And the typical preservation for
- 49:19the Linux dash cam system is 30 days to one year.
- 49:23And it's like, well, how helpful is that? That's
- 49:25the issue, right? You just don't, it depends
- 49:28on the subscription. that the company buys or
- 49:33licenses with Lytics. I believe that default
- 49:36with Lytics is 30 days, but depending on the
- 49:42contract, it could be up to one year. And that's
- 49:46why I emphasized in the very beginning, why it's
- 49:52so critical to get these preservation letters
- 49:55out immediately. because if it's 30 days, what
- 49:59happens is you send the evidence preservation
- 50:01letter. And Linux's counsel, who I have a great
- 50:04relationship with, they're always very nice.
- 50:06They write back and say, hey, just so you know,
- 50:08we got your letter. It's very important to us
- 50:10that we preserve evidence. But the contract we
- 50:14have with whatever, FedEx, and I can't remember.
- 50:17I'm making this up. But the contract we have
- 50:20with FedEx, it's only for 30 days. You sent your
- 50:24letter three months. too late. And so we, Lytics,
- 50:31do not have access to whatever you're requesting
- 50:34because as it relates to our cloud system, we
- 50:38are only contractually obligated to keep it for
- 50:4030 days. And after that, we're sorry. Now, important
- 50:44point. Just because Lytics doesn't have it doesn't
- 50:47mean FedEx or Amazon or JB Hunt doesn't mean
- 50:51that they don't have it. Because what I've learned
- 50:55in doing in my cases against these entities is
- 50:59when there's a recordable event, a crash, something
- 51:04that requires the reporting of an accident up
- 51:06the chain of the corporation, that the risk management
- 51:10department gathers and collects all of this Lytics
- 51:15data, whether it's the driver and the dash cam,
- 51:19the GPS, speed, et cetera, they collect it and
- 51:23they preserve it, or at least they save it into
- 51:27their own unique system. And that's why, going
- 51:31back, that's why if you learn that it's a commercial
- 51:35defendant or a course and scope issue, Amazon,
- 51:39FedEx, JB Hunt, they get those evidence preservation
- 51:42letters. So they know that, you know, hey, risk
- 51:45management, we just got this letter from, you
- 51:49know, Susie plaintiff's lawyer. You know, we've
- 51:53downloaded the crash data and the crash recordings.
- 51:57We need to continue to maintain it. So all hope
- 52:00is not lost. If for some reason, you know, Linux
- 52:05tells you that They don't have the recording
- 52:07anymore, but it's one of those where there are
- 52:10some situations, you're just going to be out
- 52:12of luck. Some corporate defendants have a document
- 52:21retention policy that can vary from six months
- 52:26to one year. So if your client is coming to you
- 52:30a year and a day after the crash. And for whatever
- 52:33reason, it's not to blame our clients for coming
- 52:36to us too late. And look, as lawyers, what can
- 52:38we do? We can't be omniscient and learn what
- 52:44a client may be calling us, but you're going
- 52:47to run into situations where your client comes
- 52:50to you a year and a day too late, and you learn
- 52:53about the crash, you send out those evidence
- 52:55preservation letters, and it's all going to be
- 52:57for naught. I mean, usually. And that's just
- 53:00the way it is. But you still have the duty, even
- 53:04if you get the case late and you think, well,
- 53:06there's no chance there's going to be anything
- 53:08available. Doesn't mean you don't send out the
- 53:10letters. You still do it because you never know.
- 53:13And you have an obligation. In my humble opinion,
- 53:16you have an obligation and a duty to your client
- 53:18that even though they may have come to you untimely,
- 53:23you should still reach out just to see. what
- 53:26could potentially be out there. So, you know,
- 53:32the bottom line is, and I hope you can take this,
- 53:37you know, home with you and to your practice,
- 53:42you have to be diligent. You have to act quickly.
- 53:46I know, you know, there's a lot that goes into
- 53:50just signing a client, right, because there's
- 53:53a lot of us out there and a lot of you know,
- 53:56plaintiff's personal injury lawyers. And there's
- 53:59a lot of choices and a lot goes into signing
- 54:03a client. And you think, whoo, I finally signed
- 54:06with them. My heavy lifting, at least for now,
- 54:09is done. But it's not. It's just started. Now,
- 54:13once they have affirmatively signed with you,
- 54:15your obligation to them is to send out those
- 54:19evidence preservation letters. One, two, and
- 54:22remind your client. about their obligation. And
- 54:27three, take whatever reasonable steps you believe
- 54:31you need to take in order to preserve your client's
- 54:33evidence, which is effectively writing that letter
- 54:37that you're sending to the defendants to yourself.
- 54:40Do you need to ensure that your client's insurance
- 54:44company maintains that vehicle? I've had cases
- 54:47just the same situation where a defense insurance
- 54:50company or the tow yard says, hey, be insured.
- 54:54They'll only keep it. They'll only pay for 30
- 54:55days. I've had my own clients insurance companies
- 54:58call me and say, Andy, we're not paying for more
- 55:02than 15 days. You need to take this off our hands.
- 55:04And I say, I'll be happy to. It's one of the
- 55:06costs. It's part of being a lawyer. So take action.
- 55:13And it can really, early action can win. And
- 55:17I adhere or lose. cases before discovery starts
- 55:22and that related to that, you will be rewarded
- 55:26in good and bad ways. And what do I mean by that?
- 55:30No case is perfect, right? Every case has some
- 55:34issue. I mean, every case, maybe there's a unicorn
- 55:37or two out there, which is slam dunk liability,
- 55:40perfect clients and unlimited insurance. You
- 55:43know, those are, as I said, those are unicorns.
- 55:47But the reality is, with evidence preservation
- 55:50and prompt action, you can learn the bad facts
- 55:55of your case. You can get your own client's EDR
- 56:01data from their vehicle and think, oh, man, so
- 56:05my client told me that they were going 50. It
- 56:08shows they're going 85. And at least you're learning.
- 56:13of these bad facts early on, and it'll help you
- 56:19plan your case, plan your case strategy, your
- 56:22discovery strategy, and equally as important,
- 56:25tell your clients. It'll help you counsel your
- 56:27clients, manage their expectations, and say,
- 56:31hey, Suzy Plain, if I hadn't my expert go out
- 56:36and inspect your car, we're able to do a download.
- 56:40And we've got some issues here about speed. I
- 56:42wanted to go over these with you and share my
- 56:46thoughts and how we move forward. So as we talked
- 56:50about through this presentation, there's good
- 56:55and the bad, but ultimately both will help you
- 57:00work up your case properly, help you counsel
- 57:04your client. help manage their expectations and
- 57:08hopefully help you get reasonable and fair value
- 57:12going into a mediation. And then if you have
- 57:15to try the case, it'll give you that evidence
- 57:17that will hopefully help you get a great verdict
- 57:22that you can come on here and share with everyone
- 57:25else. So with that, why don't we turn to some
- 57:32of the questions. All right, and let's see Okay,
- 57:39so one of the questions here is so we have question
- 57:42from Michael Lloyd What is the name of the company?
- 57:45That you'd said you pay to move your car to its
- 57:48rest your case It's in Irwindale If you call
- 57:54them It's a it's a family -owned company Wonderful
- 57:59folks who work there and it's a it's it's like
- 58:02a massive footprint of property where they store
- 58:06all kinds of evidence, bikes, vehicles, washing
- 58:11machines, airplane parts. And depending on the
- 58:16level of protection you need, they have it. They
- 58:18can store it out in the open, no big deal. But
- 58:21if you need something safe and secure, they have
- 58:22that. And as I mentioned, they'll come out and
- 58:25pick up whatever the property is. Of course,
- 58:27it's going to cost you. But that's a client cost.
- 58:31And that's how You know you advise your client,
- 58:35you know, that's gonna be one of the case costs
- 58:38that they pay in the event You secure a positive
- 58:41result for them. But yeah rest your case in Irwindale
- 58:46and then how do you handle advising your clients
- 58:50to preserve? His emails and texts regarding the
- 58:54collision and that is that that is such an important
- 58:57question because you know the RFP is coming from
- 59:03defense, all non -privileged emails and communications
- 59:06and texts about the subject collision. And I
- 59:09do it at the same time I'm advising them of their
- 59:14duty to preserve the car, the bike, the photos
- 59:18that they have taken. And it's one of those to
- 59:22me, like the emails and texts, that's one of
- 59:24those where you say, hey, look, don't ever, ever.
- 59:28You know destroy these the good or the bad. I
- 59:31don't care if you've sent bad texts It's going
- 59:34to be an issue if you destroy them So send send
- 59:37them to me so that's in an email or first rather
- 59:41with a phone call You know when you're doing
- 59:43the introduction After they've signed with you
- 59:46you go through the whole spiel and that's something
- 59:48that i'm big on when I first sign a client or
- 59:51a case gets referred to me and I'm taking it
- 59:54over. I always have a meeting either in person
- 59:58or by Zoom with a client. And I spend an inordinate
- 1:00:03amount of time with them going over all of this.
- 1:00:08But that is something that's very important.
- 1:00:13So short answer, phone call or the Zoom meeting,
- 1:00:16however you make your introduction, and then
- 1:00:18follow up with a written confirmation, hey, Forward
- 1:00:22to me and my team all of the texts all of the
- 1:00:26emails everything else again if you need help
- 1:00:29Doing that because some of our older clients
- 1:00:31are comfortable Locating their texts or email
- 1:00:33whatever it is. I'm here to help you We'll figure
- 1:00:36it out But the point is you have to get that
- 1:00:38evidence because you do not ever want hanging
- 1:00:41over your head a motion for monetary issue or
- 1:00:46terminating sanctions against your client for
- 1:00:49something that could have been avoided because
- 1:00:51those motions are such a powerful tool to steering
- 1:00:56settlement, especially if they're hanging out
- 1:00:58there during the pendency of a mediation or even
- 1:01:01better, if you get a favorable ruling before
- 1:01:05a mediation going into it. Last question is,
- 1:01:11preservation demands in the employment law context.
- 1:01:14And Eric, I thank you for that question. I have
- 1:01:18to sort of punt on this one only because I don't
- 1:01:23practice employment law. But let me just throw
- 1:01:26it out there that I wouldn't, if it's the same
- 1:01:30type of situation. where my client was harmed,
- 1:01:35but I'm sending that evidence preservation letter
- 1:01:37to everyone. Unless I know affirmatively a recipient
- 1:01:42is represented, you know, everyone like Oprah
- 1:01:45giving you those cards, everyone's going to get
- 1:01:48one of those letters. I'm sorry I can't give
- 1:01:50more light or information on employment law cases,
- 1:01:54but I appreciate your question. And with that,
- 1:01:59I think that is it. So thank you everyone for
- 1:02:04coming today. I hope, you know, this information
- 1:02:07is helpful to you. Please reach out to me. I
- 1:02:10have, you know, my information is here. That's
- 1:02:16my cell phone number and my email. I'm always
- 1:02:19available. I have, if you ever need anything
- 1:02:22in any type of case, pleading discovery, oppositions,
- 1:02:26motions, call me, call me, email me. Let's talk
- 1:02:29about your case. I'm here to help you. People
- 1:02:33helped me throughout my career. And we all get
- 1:02:37better when we help each other. So I thank you
- 1:02:39guys all for coming today and participating for
- 1:02:42all your great questions.