Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / How Ancient Histories Guide Future Sustainability With Professor Sean Ulm
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the Human
- 0:07Side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and will discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:51Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating
- 0:54the Human Side. where we explore the stories
- 0:56behind the science and how they connect to our
- 0:59everyday lives. Today, we have the honor of introducing
- 1:02Professor Sean Ulm, whose work brilliantly captures
- 1:07the fusion of ancient wisdom and cutting -edge
- 1:10research. Professor Ulm is not just an expert
- 1:12in archaeology. He's a visionary in how we understand
- 1:15the deep relationship between people, land, environmental
- 1:18histories, and futures. Our guest's work is dedicated
- 1:22to integrating... Indigenous Knowledge with Modern
- 1:25Science. His research dives into the long -term
- 1:28interactions between humans and the environment,
- 1:31revealing lessons from the past that are crucial
- 1:34to addressing the environmental challenges of
- 1:36today. With over 25 years of experience, his
- 1:39leadership in interdisciplinary research is shaping
- 1:43new approaches to manage our ecosystems, grounded
- 1:46in both history and forward -thinking strategies.
- 1:50His contributions have redefined the way we look
- 1:53at land management, bringing indigenous perspectives
- 1:56to the forefront. Welcome, Professor Ong, and
- 1:59it's a privilege to have you here today. The
- 2:03privilege is all mine. Very happy to be with
- 2:05you. To start, what you can tell us about your
- 2:08background and why did you decide to study archaeology?
- 2:12Are you interested in archaeology and the interaction
- 2:14with indigenous knowledge and environmental sciences?
- 2:19Well, that's a big question. I think my upbringing
- 2:24really informed what I do today. I grew up in
- 2:29a family, a rural area in the middle of Queensland
- 2:34in northeastern Australia, a very rural town
- 2:37based on a sugar industry and farming with a
- 2:42very large Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
- 2:44population and Pacific Islander population as
- 2:47well. I was very cognizant growing up of Indigenous
- 2:52issues at the time, but no one in my family had
- 2:58gone to university. So I was the first in family
- 3:02to go to university, and it was a big move to
- 3:05move from a regional area down to the city. But
- 3:09when I went to university, I was really interested
- 3:11in history, and I thought I would become a historian
- 3:15and probably a high school teacher. And in my
- 3:19first year, I took some history subjects and
- 3:22some English subjects, but I also took some anthropology
- 3:25subjects. And it turned out by the end of my
- 3:29first year, I was totally hooked around anthropology.
- 3:33And the way anthropology was taught at the University
- 3:36of Queensland, where I went to school, was a
- 3:39four -field approach, that there was social anthropology,
- 3:43linguistics, physical anthropology, and archaeology.
- 3:47And I was really drawn to the way archaeology
- 3:50meshed my interests in Indigenous self -determination
- 3:55and also with history. And in my first year,
- 3:59I had the opportunity to go out onto Indigenous
- 4:03country with research teams. And I think from
- 4:06that moment, I was hooked and I knew that that's
- 4:09what I wanted to do for the rest of my life.
- 4:11And here I am now, 35 years later, still doing
- 4:16that. That's amazing. How is this connection
- 4:20that you have with Indigenous communities? How
- 4:23do you start this connection with them? Because
- 4:26we always talk in like a bigger picture, like
- 4:29with Indigenous communities, but how is this
- 4:31approach with them? I think that's a really important
- 4:34question. I feel very fortunate in my academic
- 4:40career to have those opportunities. I guess I
- 4:44had kind of a unique pathway that for the first
- 4:4820 years of my academic career, I actually worked
- 4:52in an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander support
- 4:55unit in a university. So my major job was working
- 5:00alongside Indigenous students to help them succeed
- 5:04at university. So that gave me a lot of opportunities
- 5:07to meet different people and learn about. where
- 5:11they come from and their communities and their
- 5:13histories and their particular journeys through
- 5:15the academy. And while I was doing that job,
- 5:21I did my PhD part -time working on Indigenous
- 5:25country with an Indigenous supervisor. So those
- 5:29two experiences allowed me to learn a lot about
- 5:32diversity. And I think it's really important
- 5:35when we're working with Indigenous communities
- 5:38not to homogenise their aspirations or their
- 5:44histories of invasion and colonization, that
- 5:47every community has had a very different experience.
- 5:51So the way that Indigenous and non -Indigenous
- 5:54researchers engage with different communities
- 5:56needs to be contextually specific as well to
- 5:59acknowledge and respect that different history.
- 6:03But Linda, I didn't answer your question there
- 6:07specifically, but... I think it's really important
- 6:10in establishing relationships with Indigenous
- 6:12communities that we bring our whole selves to
- 6:15those relationships. Otherwise, it can be simply
- 6:19transactional that I've got a research project
- 6:22and you might take it to a community and ask
- 6:24them to approve it. For many decades, I've been
- 6:29working towards an authentic co -design research
- 6:31process and I'm very invested these days in working
- 6:37in partnership with communities to create research
- 6:39programs that support their aspirations. And
- 6:43I think wherever I look, particularly across
- 6:46Australia, but across the globe, there are more
- 6:49and more research projects being done in these
- 6:51authentic kind of co -design ways. Now, they're
- 6:55foundationally based on authentic, rich relationships
- 6:59between Indigenous communities and research members.
- 7:04they grow into a relationship that supports a
- 7:08very healthy research structure. And I think
- 7:11I see a lot of research heading that direction.
- 7:13And I think it's a very positive thing. That's
- 7:17fantastic. It's a different approach, actually,
- 7:20and a different perspective. I'm excited. And
- 7:23would you mind to explain a little bit to us
- 7:28why it's important to... to take into account
- 7:31these bridges that history and anthropology create
- 7:34between the ancestral knowledge of these indigenous
- 7:38communities and the present? Look, this is a
- 7:42really important philosophical space to explore
- 7:44as researchers in any discipline. I think we've
- 7:49created a false dichotomy between elevating Western
- 7:53approaches to knowledge creation and indigenous
- 7:57knowledges and sciences. And I think... We've
- 8:00often elevated Western ways of knowing above
- 8:05Indigenous ways of knowing. And I think we have
- 8:08to recognise, harking back to my earlier comment
- 8:11about acknowledging diversity and respecting
- 8:14that diversity, that all cultures have developed
- 8:19ontologically different ways of being in the
- 8:23world and understanding the world and reproducing
- 8:25the world. None of them are better or worse than
- 8:28any others. They coexist in time and space. So
- 8:31I think when we enter into an authentic co -design
- 8:35research process, we are inherently acknowledging
- 8:39the value of bringing together all those valid
- 8:42but different ways of understanding the world.
- 8:46And I think the reality is that our understanding
- 8:49of the world is not only richer for bringing
- 8:52those knowledge systems together in a respectful
- 8:55way, But we're honouring and respecting the owners
- 8:59of those knowledges. So I think it's a really,
- 9:03you know, even though I often reflect and think
- 9:06the pace of change has been very slow, when I
- 9:10take a moment to reflect on the last couple of
- 9:12decades, I see that things have moved a lot.
- 9:17But, you know, quite understandably, many Indigenous
- 9:20communities are impatient that things haven't
- 9:22changed enough. And we have a long way left to
- 9:25go on that journey for particularly non -Indigenous
- 9:29researchers to really support the self -determination
- 9:32aspirations of Indigenous community partners.
- 9:36And you point out a super important point of
- 9:38view, Annie, is that we have recently Dr. Leanda
- 9:42Mason, that she came up with this new idea of
- 9:46ecology and how we research ecology. Because
- 9:51we have the traditional point of view that is
- 9:53from the Western point of view, but then we leave
- 9:56aside all the traditional knowledge when it has
- 9:59been for thousands of years and we are just recently
- 10:02incorporated. Or, for example, the Mayans are
- 10:05working hard with different researchers, but
- 10:08then it's not only imposing, it's not imposing,
- 10:11it's about imposing the research, but it's about
- 10:14working with the communities and trying to tackle
- 10:16the... problems that they have in the ecosystem
- 10:18and a different perspective, but not like a diminishing
- 10:22or putting them down like, oh, yeah, they don't
- 10:24know. We have the science, but it's just like
- 10:27giving them a voice and talking about, hey, they
- 10:31have this knowledge. Why don't you bring together,
- 10:34we bring together something that is innovative
- 10:37and can have a better approach? Absolutely. And
- 10:40look, I think there's a big challenge there.
- 10:43You know, ecology is grappling with it like many
- 10:46other disciplines that, you know, unfortunately,
- 10:50often ecological management, ecologically informed
- 10:55management plans and conservation strategies,
- 10:57even though they engage Indigenous partners,
- 11:01often Indigenous partners are not engaged on
- 11:04an equal power footing. So that often Indigenous
- 11:08partners are employed to... do on the ground
- 11:12programs that are guided by Western ways of knowing.
- 11:17And in my mind, that's putting a gloss over the
- 11:20process that's actually not elevating Indigenous
- 11:23knowledges and, you know, indeed privileging
- 11:27Indigenous knowledges in this space. And I'd
- 11:31like to think that power relationship can be
- 11:33remediated to be a lot more equal. You know,
- 11:37I'd personally like to see a lot more Indigenous
- 11:40-led programs in this space. But, you know, I
- 11:44genuinely think many disciplines are grappling
- 11:46with a long colonial history of scholarship and
- 11:51intellectual development that has excluded Indigenous
- 11:54knowledges. So there's a lot of decolonization
- 11:58that needs to be done across our different disciplines.
- 12:01Genuinely, too, I think... We need to step outside
- 12:04our disciplinary silos. If we're really committed
- 12:09to harnessing the transformative power of all
- 12:12these different knowledge systems and ontological
- 12:15frameworks, we need to enter into a genuinely
- 12:19transdisciplinary space. And that means coming
- 12:22from a place of strength, knowing our own knowledge
- 12:25framework, but being able to surrender some of
- 12:29that power to enter into a genuinely you know,
- 12:32productive dialogue with other knowledge holders.
- 12:35And it's kind of easy when you say it like that.
- 12:38But in my experience, it's been quite challenging
- 12:42for many people to see some of their disciplinary
- 12:44power and their disciplinary expertise to authentically
- 12:49enter those types of processes. Yeah, that's
- 12:53a really good point. And actually, We just recently
- 12:57learned, Dani already knew about it. We have
- 13:00a guest that is Arit, Dr. Arit, and she's working
- 13:04in an intercultural university that actually
- 13:07they work with the indigenous and the researchers
- 13:11go to work into the indigenous communities projects
- 13:15that they have. It's not that they came up with
- 13:17this idea and they try to develop with the communities.
- 13:20No, they are the ones that have to listen. What
- 13:22is the issue that a community has? and trying
- 13:25to join forces. So I learned about the Mayan
- 13:29Milpa. It was so cool because actually they were
- 13:33trying to provide different approaches and tools
- 13:36to the knowledge that they have. So that for
- 13:40me was like a wow. I think, Linda, that's a really
- 13:46good point. And I think funding agencies in Western
- 13:50countries often work against developing those
- 13:54types of approaches that, you know, whether it's
- 13:57the Australian Research Council system in Australia
- 13:59or the National Science Foundation in the United
- 14:03States, you need to create an application that
- 14:06says what you're going to do before you have
- 14:08the money. And often these community -led approaches
- 14:13require years of discussions and relationship
- 14:18building to define those. co -designed outcomes
- 14:21that support the aspirations of communities.
- 14:24And it's very difficult for researchers of any
- 14:27career stage, but particularly for early career
- 14:30researchers and PhD students. How do you resource
- 14:34spending several years living in a community
- 14:38and developing those relationships before you
- 14:41even apply for a grant? So I think the current
- 14:44funding system works against those outcomes and
- 14:47we really need to think of different approaches
- 14:50to funding work that respects the way those relationships
- 14:53need to unfold to be authentic and that those
- 14:58funding applications are requesting funds for
- 15:00work that actually match the aspirations of the
- 15:03community and working through what the community
- 15:05want to do with those data and how Indigenous
- 15:09cultural and intellectual property will be protected
- 15:12and managed under those sorts of research arrangements.
- 15:17Yeah. And with that remark, I'm curious, and
- 15:21maybe some of our listeners too, how is the research
- 15:27process in terms of the methodology to gather
- 15:30the information and everything? Can you share
- 15:32a little bit how is this process of gathering
- 15:36the data from the indigenous communities? Do
- 15:40you go to the field and talk to representatives
- 15:42of the community? Or how is that process? Daniel,
- 15:47that's a really good question. And I mean, the
- 15:49short answer is it's really diverse. You know,
- 15:53the way that different communities want to partner
- 15:56with researchers is very different. Increasingly,
- 15:59Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities
- 16:02in Australia have researchers in their own communities
- 16:05who do have PhDs and understand how Western research
- 16:10frameworks work. So there's very increasingly
- 16:14strong knowledge about rights and responsibilities
- 16:17in these spaces. But the model that we're increasingly
- 16:22adopting in the research teams I work as partnership
- 16:25with is having an extended period of co -design
- 16:29workshops. So this is where we visit and sit
- 16:32down on country, on Indigenous land, and listen
- 16:37to the country and listen to elders, listen to
- 16:41what the community want to do. We have multiple
- 16:45meetings kind of defining the types of projects
- 16:48the community want to do. But most importantly,
- 16:51those discussions are not only about what the
- 16:53project is, but who the community want involved.
- 16:56So, you know, which family groups or which Indigenous
- 17:00landowners need to be involved, what knowledge
- 17:02holders, what the product would be, whether it's
- 17:06a confidential report or a policy document or
- 17:10a research article. And really importantly, what
- 17:15the Indigenous data sovereignty arrangements
- 17:17are around the data produced. So is this data
- 17:22to be shared with others? Is it to be restricted?
- 17:27Which members of the community will be co -authors
- 17:30on any publications? Indeed, does the community
- 17:33want any publications? So it's actually not thinking
- 17:37about the research process in isolation. It's
- 17:39thinking about... whole research cycle from the
- 17:42beginning to the end. And looking into the future,
- 17:46one of the problems we have, and I'll just mention
- 17:50specifically the Indigenous data governance space,
- 17:53that if we put data in a repository now, in a
- 17:58data repository now with certain conditions around
- 18:00it, what happens in 10 years' time if people
- 18:03change their mind about how they want to manage
- 18:06their data? Now, the current You know, the mainstream
- 18:09system we use is that when you deposit research
- 18:13data, you set the restrictions and that's it.
- 18:16But that doesn't honour, you know, the vitality
- 18:19of Indigenous culture and the fact that knowledge
- 18:22holders and aspirations change over time. So
- 18:27when we're designing these Indigenous data governance
- 18:30structures, we need to allow, they need to be
- 18:33amenable to be responsive to those sorts of changes
- 18:36in the community. and acknowledge that Indigenous
- 18:39cultures are living cultures and changing. And,
- 18:43you know, just to give you one example that one
- 18:47community I work closely in, senior women have
- 18:51now taken over some of the knowledge responsibilities
- 18:55of senior men because many of the senior male
- 19:00knowledge holders have passed away. And I did
- 19:02want to expand on this a little bit. It's one
- 19:04of the things I think we really need to confront
- 19:08as researchers that in the communities where
- 19:11I work, Indigenous life expectancy is up to 30
- 19:16years younger than non -Indigenous people. So
- 19:21many of the people I'm very proud to call brothers
- 19:25and sisters and mothers and grandfathers have
- 19:29passed away. You know, people I've been working
- 19:33with over the last three decades. you know, it's
- 19:37really, it weighs heavily on me, the responsibility
- 19:41researchers have to support the knowledge aspirations
- 19:46of communities. And researchers play a really
- 19:50important role in being allies to Indigenous
- 19:53communities to support how they want to record
- 19:57and maintain and govern their data. And I think,
- 20:00you know, a lot of us, me included, you know,
- 20:05felt we would always have an opportunity in the
- 20:07future to talk to that old man again. And the
- 20:12reality is sometimes we don't have that opportunity.
- 20:15I mean, the fact that there's such a gap in longevity
- 20:22and Australia is not isolated in that really
- 20:26rams home that many of the places we work have
- 20:32a long way to go to remediate that. gap in life
- 20:35expectancy and health outcomes and infant mortality
- 20:39rates, but indeed all the way through the research
- 20:43process to reproducing cultural data and making
- 20:47sure that researchers are supporting what communities
- 20:52want to do to ensure the reproduction of their
- 20:55cultural information. And you point out a really
- 20:58important issue, and it's that when you work
- 21:02with the across different cultures and generations.
- 21:06How do you build up this trust and mutual understanding
- 21:10with the Indigenous elders and the knowledge
- 21:14holders? How do you build up this trust with
- 21:18Indigenous communities and in your experience
- 21:20and specifically in your field? Look, it's a
- 21:23good question. And I think there's some fundamental
- 21:25principles that I hold dear. I mean, you know,
- 21:29the first one is that it's about a relationship.
- 21:32It's not a transactional thing. It's not a one
- 21:35-off thing. So that relationship building might
- 21:40go on for many years before any research is conducted.
- 21:46And even after you get a research grant and you
- 21:49do a research grant with a community and you
- 21:52do all the reporting, your responsibilities to
- 21:56that relationship don't end there. They're a
- 21:59lifelong commitment. I think a lot of people
- 22:02don't appreciate. So, you know, starting from
- 22:04that basis that it's all about relationship,
- 22:06it's about being authentic and entering those
- 22:10relationships that it's not transactional that,
- 22:13you know, I'm entering into this relationship
- 22:15because I want to do this research. It's entering
- 22:18into a reciprocal bond which binds you into a
- 22:23certain set of obligations that don't end when
- 22:27the research money is spent. I'm very proud to
- 22:30say that I still have close relationships with
- 22:34the very first community that I ever worked with
- 22:3730 years ago. And I feel those responsibilities
- 22:41very keenly to service those responsibilities.
- 22:45And when community members, frankly family members
- 22:50to me, ask for something, I will do everything
- 22:54I can to support. support their request because
- 22:58that's part of servicing that relationship with
- 23:01those people. You know, and when you frame research
- 23:04as relational in like that, it's quite different
- 23:08to a, you know, in a Western academic framework
- 23:11where you talk about our networks and we talk
- 23:14about leveraging our networks for our career
- 23:17advantage and this sort of thing. That's not
- 23:19what I'm talking about here. You know, I'm talking
- 23:22about genuinely entering into a personal relationship
- 23:25with community. And if you'll indulge me, I'll
- 23:28give a little personal, you know, anecdote. About,
- 23:34well, I know exactly when it was. About 15 years
- 23:37ago, I was living with the Kydelt community in
- 23:42an outstation called Nilnuki on Bentic Island
- 23:45in the Gulf of Carpentaria. So one of the most
- 23:49remote places you can get to in Australia and
- 23:51still be in Australia. And my partner was due
- 23:56to give birth to our first daughter about a month
- 24:00after that fieldwork ended. And I think I was
- 24:03living in the village at that time for about
- 24:05two months. And a couple of days before we were
- 24:09due to charter off the island, my partner's waters
- 24:13broke and the satellite phone rang and it was
- 24:18at night time. And there was no lighting on the
- 24:22dirt airstrip, so we couldn't get an aircraft
- 24:24in to get me off the island until the next day.
- 24:28And so all night, the senior Kydelt women sang
- 24:33songs to help the labor progress smoothly and
- 24:37for the baby to be born healthy and for the mother
- 24:40to be born healthy. And there was a lot of debate
- 24:43about what that baby should be called. And so
- 24:48all night. There was an active discussion amongst
- 24:51all the senior knowledge holders about what that
- 24:54baby should be called. And the women decided
- 24:58her name should be Baranka, which is the edible
- 25:01part of the water lily. So the next day I was
- 25:07able to charter off the island and I made it
- 25:09for the birth of our first daughter four hours
- 25:12or something before she was born. But the women
- 25:15made me promise to bring that girl back to country.
- 25:18And, you know, we spent her first birthday back
- 25:22on country and her sister was conceived on country.
- 25:27And that's a very important part of Kydok culture
- 25:31where you're conceived. And the older women knew
- 25:36that we were pregnant before we did. And for
- 25:39several months, you know, talked about what that
- 25:43girl should be called. And they felt that that
- 25:46girl would be very strong and needed a strong
- 25:48name and strong in story. And they called her
- 25:53Juwan, which is the black -nosed dolphin. And
- 25:57when that daughter was born, when she was three
- 26:01months old, we took her back to country to meet
- 26:04her extended family. and understand her obligations
- 26:08to country. But I've been very fortunate in my
- 26:13career to have such loving, generous, welcome
- 26:17family. And that's just an example of the many
- 26:21places I work and have had the enormous privilege
- 26:24to work. And I have to say those experiences
- 26:27have fundamentally changed the worldview I bring
- 26:31to every piece of research I enter into. That's
- 26:35a beautiful experience. Thank you for sharing
- 26:38it. They're probably going to be shamed that
- 26:42I told that story, but I'm very proud of that
- 26:46story. No, it's a beautiful story. It's just
- 26:49unique. It is, it is. Yeah, it is. And precisely
- 26:54within these personal relationships and beyond
- 26:59the data and the research. What do you think
- 27:02is the most important message or lesson that
- 27:05indigenous stories like this can teach us about
- 27:08how to live sustainably and harmoniously with
- 27:11the environment and with the planet in general?
- 27:14Yeah, look, and I think this is, you know, a
- 27:17clear and present challenge for, you know, all
- 27:20researchers. And it doesn't matter whether we're
- 27:22working in the archaeological or paleoecological
- 27:26or ecological or indeed health and medical research,
- 27:30all of us should be attentive to the enormous
- 27:34reservoir of indigenous knowledges that have
- 27:37really been marginalized in our understandings
- 27:41of the world from a Western perspective. And,
- 27:43you know, I mean, we often hear these stories
- 27:46of, for example, detailed indigenous plant knowledge.
- 27:51being used for everything from wound dressings
- 27:55on battlefields to cancer treatments. I have
- 27:58to say a lot of that research has been very exploitative
- 28:01and the benefits of the patents and income earned
- 28:07has not necessarily flown back to the Indigenous
- 28:10knowledge holders. But I think we have to be
- 28:12a little bit careful about essentialising Indigenous
- 28:15knowledges. You know, we talk a lot about sustainability
- 28:19and that's really important. And I think, you
- 28:22know, in many of the Indigenous countries I collaborate
- 28:27with, there is very long -term evidence of sustainable
- 28:30management of country. But that sustainable management
- 28:34has been very adaptive. So to give an example,
- 28:37in Australia, there's very sophisticated use
- 28:40of fire technologies to manage ecological, floral
- 28:44and faunal diversity. But people often simplify
- 28:48that into that traditional owners burn their
- 28:51country once a year. And that's far from the
- 28:54truth, that those use of fire technologies are
- 28:58drawing on a very deep knowledge of the climate,
- 29:02seasonal changes, observing very detailed observation
- 29:07of flora and fauna, and tailoring the use of
- 29:10fire technologies to those changing conditions.
- 29:13you know, that might be ENSO frequency and intensity,
- 29:16like La Nina, you know, seasons in Australia,
- 29:21that the way that that sustainability has been
- 29:25maintained has only been possible through the
- 29:28application of that very detailed knowledge.
- 29:30And I think we often simplify that into thinking
- 29:34about it as a very blunt instrument, but it's
- 29:36not the case. And for my own part, I specialize
- 29:41in coastal and island archaeology. So I'm very
- 29:44interested in the way that people sustainably
- 29:48harvest shellfish and finfish resources. And
- 29:52one of my frustrations is that, for example,
- 29:55fisheries permitting and restoration targets
- 29:58are exclusively based on historical fishery records.
- 30:02And in Australia, we're very lucky if those records
- 30:05go back 60 years. Whereas, of course, indigenous
- 30:09traditional owners have been managing their fisheries
- 30:12for thousands of years before European industrialized
- 30:17fishing. So my view is that if we can't understand
- 30:22that long -term management of country and how
- 30:25it articulates with more recent use of those
- 30:28resources, we can't possibly have effective management
- 30:32systems if we ignore... Indigenous management
- 30:35and Indigenous knowledges. And every domain you
- 30:40can think of fits into the same boat, whether
- 30:43it's fisheries or dugongs or whales or ecological
- 30:48diversity of trees and things. We really, we
- 30:54have been for decades ignoring the past. And
- 30:58I think... more and more we're recognising that
- 31:01we need to understand the past to inform the
- 31:04present and the future, and that by not doing
- 31:06that, we're facing the future with one hand tied
- 31:10behind our back. And now that you mention this,
- 31:13what is the best approach to change this way?
- 31:17Because our research continues based on that,
- 31:21this westernising and colonising point of view.
- 31:27We haven't changed anything. Nothing has been
- 31:30changed. We know the problems, we say the problems,
- 31:33and we have the communities. It's changing in
- 31:36some places, but how we can extend this in the
- 31:40way that the people and the general public also
- 31:43participate and put the pressure on that, because
- 31:45that's one of the constraints that we have as
- 31:48scientists and also the communities have, because
- 31:51there's not a communication. There's not a big
- 31:54communication between all the parties. I agree.
- 31:57And I think there's three central pillars where
- 32:00we need to work. One of them is supporting capacity
- 32:03building of Indigenous researchers across the
- 32:06world. And that is building a pipeline from primary
- 32:11school through to higher schooling and university.
- 32:15And that is not an easy task because High school
- 32:23completion rates for many Indigenous people is
- 32:25quite low. So there's a lot of work to be done
- 32:28to support, to meaningfully support Indigenous
- 32:33communities to achieve those outcomes. And I
- 32:35think all of our disciplines could use many more
- 32:40Indigenous researchers. So that Indigenous researcher
- 32:43capacity building is very important. I think
- 32:46it's also very important to build the cultural...
- 32:49capabilities and capacities of non -Indigenous
- 32:51researchers, because non -Indigenous researchers
- 32:54are the majority of researchers. And for the
- 32:58foreseeable future, non -Indigenous researchers
- 33:00will be really important allies to supporting
- 33:04the aspirations of Indigenous communities. So
- 33:07each and every one of us can take a personal
- 33:09responsibility for upskilling our cultural capabilities.
- 33:13And that could be through you know, undertaking
- 33:17formal cultural awareness programs or seeking
- 33:22out Indigenous mentors, for example, and also
- 33:26reflecting on decolonizing our own practice.
- 33:29So reflecting on the way we've always done things
- 33:32and questioning why that is so. Many researchers
- 33:36reproduce the kind of approaches that their own
- 33:39supervisors have adopted. And unfortunately,
- 33:42that can simply you know, reproduce the same
- 33:46ways of doing things. So I think, you know, each
- 33:49of us can challenge that. The final pillar is
- 33:52the one you mentioned, Linda, and the one your
- 33:54podcast leans into, that every researcher has
- 33:58a responsibility to change the narrative. And
- 34:01I think all of us, you know, I always agree to
- 34:05do public outreach. I always do agree to do interviews
- 34:08because I think, you know, every one of those
- 34:11interviews will reach someone. And they help
- 34:15people challenge their own way of comprehending
- 34:18the world. And I think, you know, the reality
- 34:20is that many people, many non -Indigenous people
- 34:23do have a deficit of knowledge. And that deficit
- 34:27of knowledge about the complexity and sophistication
- 34:30of Indigenous cultures leads to a homogenization
- 34:34of Indigenous experiences rather than respecting
- 34:36diversity and often leads to quite uninformed
- 34:40views. of Indigenous people and culture. And
- 34:44I think, you know, the more, you know, evidence
- 34:46-based and culturally appropriate information
- 34:49we can put into the public domain, the stronger
- 34:53we will be. And I think research communication
- 34:56is a critical pillar of achieving that. I agree.
- 35:01Yeah, and actually in that point, how do you
- 35:04see the evolution of this relation with the ancestral
- 35:08knowledge has been in the recent years? Look,
- 35:11you know, I see it being more pervasive in discussions.
- 35:16I think many people, many Indigenous communities,
- 35:20many non -Indigenous research agencies are grappling
- 35:24with this. For example, just a few weeks ago,
- 35:26the Australian Commonwealth government announced
- 35:29its new national science and research priorities.
- 35:34And out of the list of five priorities, number
- 35:36three is elevating Aboriginal and Torres Strait
- 35:39Islander knowledges. So, you know, that's a recognition
- 35:42that's never been on the national stage before,
- 35:46which has been building over a long time. And,
- 35:48you know, I'm well aware in other major research,
- 35:51you know, agencies are contemplating similar
- 35:54things. So there's been a groundswell. I mean,
- 35:56I think there's a lot of experimentation happening
- 35:59at the moment, and I think that's a really good
- 36:01thing. I think it's a very contested space. And
- 36:05I think, you know, this is not an easy space
- 36:07to work in. And I think people need to be really
- 36:10aware that to authentically engage in this space,
- 36:15you will be challenged. And that's not a bad
- 36:17thing. But often researchers can find that very
- 36:20confronting and shut down. And I think, you know,
- 36:23my appeal is that we should expect to be challenged
- 36:28and we should... Frame that as a very productive
- 36:31part of the dialogue that, you know, for too
- 36:35long, Indigenous knowledge systems have been
- 36:38marginalised in research. Indigenous scholarship
- 36:41has been marginalised in research. So those voices,
- 36:45you know, need to be strident to be heard. And
- 36:49sometimes that can be very challenging when it's
- 36:52framed in a, you know, it can be framed in a
- 36:55combative way, for example. But I think the confronting
- 36:59part of it is that in Western research training,
- 37:03we're trained to engage in very polite forms
- 37:06of dialogue and respectful, very, what would
- 37:12you say, vanilla ways of having dialogue. And
- 37:17we're not used to being robustly challenged.
- 37:20And I think the reality is that we need to enter
- 37:23a space where our very... The very ontological
- 37:26underpinnings of how we comprehend the world
- 37:29are being challenged. And, you know, we need
- 37:33to be open to that challenge and we need to be
- 37:35open to challenging some of those pillars of
- 37:38self -belief we all carry with us that have been
- 37:42socialized in our education, probably from kindergarten,
- 37:47throughout, you know, the values our parents
- 37:50and society has given us. This is a very, I think
- 37:55we shouldn't sugarcoat that it is a difficult
- 38:00space to work in, but I'd like everyone to think
- 38:03about that as a source of a productive space.
- 38:08And it's that by entering into that space with
- 38:11kindness and authenticity, and it harks back,
- 38:17Danny, to what we were talking about earlier
- 38:18about authentic relationship building. If we're
- 38:23entering into these conversations with authenticity,
- 38:26that they're not transactional, that we're bringing
- 38:30hope and kindness to service, that they're the
- 38:34pillars that will see those discussions being
- 38:37productive. And I think it's also being cognizant
- 38:41that you're entering into a relationship that
- 38:43will likely last the rest of your life. And,
- 38:48you know, my colleagues, my non -Indigenous colleagues
- 38:51who work in this space very similarly, feel keenly
- 38:55their responsibilities to their Indigenous partners
- 38:59that they work with, that, you know, it's well
- 39:03beyond research. It's a wholism about, you know,
- 39:08that partnership is about familial obligations.
- 39:12And yes, it is about doing the research, but
- 39:15it's doing the research in a way that honours
- 39:20the aspirations and ways of knowing and doing
- 39:22of the partner. And that means you can't develop
- 39:26a one -size -fits -all approach because of that
- 39:29fundamental diversity of different Indigenous
- 39:32communities. And that's important because our
- 39:36system, as you mentioned before, how the grants
- 39:39are, how you obtain the funding is not a continuity.
- 39:43There's not a continuous project, but it's not
- 39:46only about the project, but the relationships
- 39:47and how we relate with the indigenous communities,
- 39:50but also how we relate actually with the project
- 39:53that we are doing, where we are working, for
- 39:55example. I have the perfect example with the
- 39:57spiders because they are not even in the Conservation
- 40:01Act. So they are not even the importance. But
- 40:04then actually, if we join all this past knowledge
- 40:08about these animals, if we acknowledge how they
- 40:12live, that they can be even older than me and
- 40:16other people, and then how we relate with them,
- 40:19how we do this continuous project, that's a different
- 40:23approach. Not only starting from the... ecological
- 40:26or behavioral point of view or all the science
- 40:29and how it's approached in a short term because
- 40:32it's like a five year period or two year period
- 40:35where you have to squeeze everything leave everything
- 40:38apart and then oh start another one you can't
- 40:40give continuity to this project that's that's
- 40:44one of the biggest challenge that we have that
- 40:46we we are not Seeing the continuity of the projects
- 40:50and even less the continuity of the relationship
- 40:52with the people and how we relate within that
- 40:55place where we collect or where we do the measurements
- 40:59and how we relate with the people that is helping
- 41:01us around. We just leave it apart. Look, I think
- 41:05it's a big challenge. And look, I think there's
- 41:09a couple of things here that are really important.
- 41:10I mean, you know, there's a lot of mid -career
- 41:13researchers at the moment and early career researchers.
- 41:16who are global leaders working in this space.
- 41:19And they inevitably will become senior researchers.
- 41:25And the way they undertake their research will
- 41:28socialise new generations of researchers. And
- 41:31I think that's how we get generational change
- 41:33in the academy and we change the way we're doing
- 41:37things. And those senior researchers become...
- 41:41reviewers of grants and publications. So when
- 41:44they're undertaking peer review, they're approaching
- 41:47it with a different way of seeing those applications.
- 41:50So when those applications are asking for money
- 41:53to undertake partnership building and co -design
- 41:57processes, hopefully those requests will be looked
- 42:00on more favorably by assessors. Look, and I think
- 42:04the other part of it, I think, you know, realistically,
- 42:08I know many early career researchers who self
- 42:13-fund continuing their relationships with Indigenous
- 42:16partners in between grants and indeed in between
- 42:20jobs when they're employed on precarious sessional
- 42:25contracts. But that just underscores to me how
- 42:30people elevate the importance of the relationships,
- 42:33that just because you don't have a job or a grant
- 42:35doesn't mean... your obligations to service that
- 42:38relationship go away. And to me, that's just
- 42:43the heart of enacting an authentic relationship,
- 42:46that if it was just about the research grant,
- 42:50it could be purely framed as transactional. But
- 42:54look, I think the academy and the funding agencies
- 42:57need to do a lot of work in this space to understand
- 43:01how we honour those relationships. You know,
- 43:05we talk a lot about elevating these knowledge
- 43:07systems, but we need a lot of scaffolding of
- 43:10infrastructure in the research agencies, in the
- 43:14academy, to really work alongside, to support
- 43:17in Indigenous communities to elevate their knowledges
- 43:21in the way they want them to be elevated and
- 43:23managed. Yeah, that commitment is crucial for
- 43:27any project in any field. Will you share a memorable
- 43:32experience with... Your daughters. That was amazing
- 43:36that that changed, I guess, your life. But what
- 43:42message would you send to the public researchers
- 43:46from this amazing interview? What message do
- 43:50you send to them? Look, I feel extraordinarily
- 43:54fortunate to have been mentored by so many Indigenous
- 43:59knowledge holders. Simple act of generosity has
- 44:05totally, I often say, I said earlier that it's
- 44:09transformed my worldview, but it's actually enriched
- 44:12my life and enriched the lives of my family members
- 44:18as well. And a lot of the communities I collaborate
- 44:23with specifically ask that I bring my family
- 44:28with me when we're doing research. But they also
- 44:32extended that invitation for PhD students to
- 44:36bring their children as well. So we've often
- 44:39had fieldwork where there's many young children
- 44:43and, you know, it's been an extraordinary opportunity
- 44:48for those students to have that opportunity and
- 44:51to have that invitation. So, look, the message
- 44:55I guess I'd send is that, you know, we really
- 44:58need... to understand how little most of us have
- 45:03had the opportunity to know about Indigenous
- 45:06cultures around the world. And my experience
- 45:09has been that the mainstream public has a very
- 45:14homogenised view of Indigenous culture, and it's
- 45:18often framed around knowledges that are not accurate.
- 45:23And the problem is that... you know, homogenizing
- 45:27knowledges that easily gets harnessed into devaluing
- 45:31Indigenous knowledge systems. So, you know, one
- 45:35of my projects is really digging down into that
- 45:38diversity. And it's not just historical diversity
- 45:42that we know in the past Indigenous cultures
- 45:45all around the world have changed dramatically,
- 45:48but also every Indigenous community has experienced
- 45:52has had a different experience of invasion and
- 45:55colonization. So some people have been dispossessed
- 45:59from their country or forcibly removed. Some
- 46:02of them don't even live on their own country
- 46:05anymore and have many barriers for them returning
- 46:09to their country and maintaining it. So as a
- 46:13general public, I think it's really important
- 46:15to appreciate those diverse histories and really
- 46:18come to terms with truth -telling and come to
- 46:21terms, with the genuine trauma and loss that
- 46:25many Indigenous communities have been subjected
- 46:28to. And to me, that is a fundamental starting
- 46:33point for building for the future, that if we
- 46:37continue to whitewash the past and pretend it's
- 46:40so distant in the past, it doesn't matter to
- 46:43today, we're never going to move forward. The
- 46:46reality is that there are many Indigenous people
- 46:49living today. who were directly subject to those,
- 46:53you know, controlling regulations that controlled
- 46:57their behaviours and, you know, indeed, if they
- 47:00could have children or not, or controlling their
- 47:03movements. That's people living today. It's not
- 47:06their grandparents or great -grandparents. That's
- 47:10part of our contemporary lived experience of
- 47:13Indigenous people. So I get very frustrated when
- 47:16some people... attempt to distance that type
- 47:20of distensation of Indigenous experience to belittle
- 47:24its significance for contemporary dialogue. So,
- 47:28you know, I think truth -telling is an extraordinarily
- 47:31important part of it. And researchers need to
- 47:34be, you know, have a self -responsibility, you
- 47:38know, encouraging and supporting those processes
- 47:40in our own research communities. You know, each
- 47:44of us can be proactive. each of us can have agency.
- 47:48But really importantly, all of us should be active
- 47:52bystanders. We're hearing racist commentary,
- 47:57for example. We shouldn't just let it go. We
- 48:00should be challenging, finding safe ways to have
- 48:04a respectful conversation that challenges framings
- 48:08that are derogatory or are unsupportive. If we're
- 48:13really committed, to changing the narrative and
- 48:16improving the research space to be more welcoming
- 48:19to elevating Indigenous knowledges in the future,
- 48:22each and every one of us has a personal responsibility
- 48:24for making that happen. And part of that is that
- 48:28kind of corrective behaviours. There's a challenge
- 48:32for you. Yes, I agree. And I'm going to add something
- 48:36else. When I arrived to Australia, I didn't have
- 48:38much knowledge about the... Aboriginal and Torres
- 48:42Strait Islander. But then it just was, I came
- 48:47up with a course about their history. Because,
- 48:50of course, you listen and hear different comments
- 48:53from different opinions. But the good advantage
- 48:56of being a scientist is I have a critical thinking
- 48:59and I want to read. But it doesn't come up for
- 49:03every person. I'm pretty sure 100 % that most
- 49:07of the Australians don't know anything. about
- 49:10the past and about the culture that they have
- 49:13in this country. And actually, I feel quite ignorant
- 49:15with my own culture and the indigenous communities
- 49:18from Colombia because the history that tell us
- 49:22is more like a colonization history. So when
- 49:26I end up knowing a little bit about the communities,
- 49:29it was until I started the university. So something
- 49:34that has to be changed is the way how we can
- 49:37get the information, not only for us, but how
- 49:40can achieve that information and grasp that information
- 49:43and the general public seeing what happened to
- 49:46the communities, what happened to the indigenous,
- 49:50and also knowing how to step forward, how to
- 49:54be resilient, how to help them. It's our responsibility
- 50:00and it's also responsibility of each of us trying
- 50:03to reach that knowledge, but it's also responsibility
- 50:07how to put it there for them. Look, and I think
- 50:09that's a really good point, Linda, I think. And
- 50:13the reality is that different members of the
- 50:15public and indeed all of us consume knowledge
- 50:18in different ways. So some people will listen
- 50:21to a podcast, some will, you know, see it on
- 50:24a news program or their social media feeds. So
- 50:27I think. It's important in terms of this attempting
- 50:31to change the narrative that research communication
- 50:33is multiplexed across many, it's pervasive. It's
- 50:39also really important that Indigenous voices
- 50:42are elevated, you know, in all of these forums
- 50:45so that it's normalised to see Indigenous people
- 50:50in all sorts of roles, you know. that Indigenous
- 50:54people make up about 4 % of the population in
- 50:57Australia, but they make up a much lower proportion
- 51:00of university students or professionals in every
- 51:05field. So, you know, there's a lot of issues
- 51:09to deal with here. Look, and I deliberately use
- 51:12the term research communication. I don't like
- 51:15the term science communication because science...
- 51:20has a certain elitism and has been elevated as
- 51:23a way of knowing. Whereas, you know, what we're
- 51:26actually talking about is research communication
- 51:28and research communication is more holistic and
- 51:32doesn't marginalise Indigenous ways of knowing
- 51:35and it doesn't marginalise the humanities and
- 51:38social sciences or creative arts, which are also,
- 51:42you know, also vital fields in this space. So,
- 51:46you know, I think... There are courses you can
- 51:48do on science communication. And I always bristle
- 51:51a little bit being a humanities scholar that
- 51:54even the language is exclusionary. That, you
- 51:58know, I think in that training we can do a lot
- 52:00better in, you know, language is very important.
- 52:04You know, language reflects our cognitive structures
- 52:08and the way we communicate. And even the general
- 52:12population hearing the word science multiple
- 52:14times a day. is reinforcing this reification
- 52:18of science. And, you know, when you think about
- 52:21it, that can work to exclude and denigrate other
- 52:25ways of knowing the world. So there's a lot of
- 52:27things we need to think about in this space.
- 52:29I completely agree. Yeah, yeah. It's an interesting
- 52:33topic to think about. Thank you. Thank you very
- 52:37much. Thank you very much. Happy, really a pleasure
- 52:41to speak with you both today. And we covered
- 52:43a lot of ground. We hope that you have enjoyed
- 52:45this episode. This episode was inspired by curiosity.
- 52:49If you want to know more about our host, we will
- 52:53leave the references in the podcast description.
- 52:56Remember that this podcast is self -funded, unsealed,
- 53:00edited by its presenters. You can support us
- 53:03by listening to this episode and sharing the
- 53:06episode with your friends. Also, remember that
- 53:09you'll find this episode on YouTube and Spotify.
- 53:12Follow us in all our social media, Instagram,
- 53:14and X. Original music by our colican friend Bernardo
- 53:18Aguirre. And the health and drinking advice by
- 53:21our amazing friend Rafael Giordani.