Latest / The Film Hobbyist / 1917 (2019): Immersive, Environmental Storytelling
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're here in my basement, on opposite sides
- 0:35of a tan sectional. Across the room from us is
- 0:40my TV, sitting atop a modified buffet. We pulled
- 0:45off the wooden back for cord access, so the cabinets
- 0:49which once held collections of fine china now
- 0:52hold a number of video game consoles. We have
- 0:56a PS4 and a PS2, an Xbox 360, a GameCube, even
- 1:02an original Atari. On top, to the left of the
- 1:07screen, is our Switch and Wii U. My favorite
- 1:11part is the top drawer. It's lined in velvet,
- 1:14originally designed to hold silverware. But the
- 1:18slats are the perfect size for controllers. I
- 1:22take great delight in the juxtaposition of finery
- 1:25and nerddom. As you can see, we're a gaming family.
- 1:30It's a big part of our life, though we mostly
- 1:33only play on the weekends. Most of our time is
- 1:36spent on the main floor, which is TV -free. So
- 1:40if we're down here, it's intentional. We're trying
- 1:44our best to provide a broad gaming education
- 1:47to our kids. Old games and new games, big titles
- 1:52and small indie projects. And there are a lot
- 1:55of games that just my husband and I play. Often
- 1:59he plays and I watch, but I have my favorites
- 2:02that I've spent a lot of time getting really
- 2:05good at. Most recently, the indie masterpiece
- 2:08Claire Obscure Expedition 33. We come by this
- 2:13all pretty honestly, though. My husband, Caleb,
- 2:17is a game designer. He'd always been very into
- 2:21gaming, particularly Mega Man, and spent some
- 2:24time in early middle school designing a ball
- 2:27maze game. But it wasn't until grad school that
- 2:31he really woke to a full appreciation of the
- 2:34craft of a game, digging into the discourse and
- 2:37analytical understanding. If you'll recall, I'm
- 2:42a novelist, so I have a background in literary
- 2:45analysis and the craft of writing, as well as
- 2:49my understanding of film, but I didn't know much
- 2:52about the art of video games and game design
- 2:55and interactive storytelling. When we got married,
- 2:59partway through his master's program, we spent
- 3:02some really intentional time watching an educational
- 3:05series on YouTube that explained a lot of really
- 3:08good concepts about understanding and appreciating
- 3:12the art of game design. It gave us a shared vocabulary,
- 3:16which has been invaluable in our journey together
- 3:20as artists. We're storytellers of a different
- 3:24kind, and I'm so glad to be able to respect his
- 3:28craft and his medium. In a book, you are wielding
- 3:34the reader's imagination. Stephen King, in his
- 3:37memoir of craft on writing, argues that writing
- 3:41is telepathy. A writer is using words to transfer
- 3:45their same image in their mind to the reader's.
- 3:50Written text is best for connecting with a character's
- 3:54inner life or allowing the reader to conjure
- 3:57far more visceral imagery than could be shown
- 3:59on a screen. Film, however, has the magic trick
- 4:04of the edit, where the juxtaposition of images
- 4:08can create deeper meaning for its viewers. An
- 4:12edit can compress both time and space, where
- 4:15we can see multiple points of view or facets
- 4:18of a room. We can also travel from reality to
- 4:22fantasy fairly easily by repeating shots or scenes.
- 4:26And we can't discount the magic of the montage,
- 4:29where we watch the passage of time, or can contrast
- 4:33the past and the present, skipping over the boring
- 4:36bits and focusing on the important details. Video
- 4:42games have the opposite strength. In a video
- 4:45game, you get to live out the length of a story.
- 4:49You are walking the whole length of a room or
- 4:51a dungeon or a city. You get to spend hours living
- 4:56inside a character's body, seeing the world they
- 4:59inhabit. Depending on the game, you get to make
- 5:03the character's choices, having to own their
- 5:06violence or their fear or their mistakes. Or
- 5:09you have to build or destroy a world, watching
- 5:12your planning make or break things. The stakes
- 5:16become personal without the distance written
- 5:20text or an unconnected screen provide. But the
- 5:23biggest value to game storytelling is immersion.
- 5:27The long build of intensity in a level or boss
- 5:31fight. The breath of fresh air of a save point.
- 5:36And here's the thing most people miss. While
- 5:39plenty of video games have linear stories, cinematic
- 5:43cutscenes, and scripted conversations, that's
- 5:47not the height of video game storytelling. That
- 5:51would be the interactivity, the mechanic of the
- 5:54game, and the environmental storytelling. What
- 5:58does the experience of the gameplay tell you
- 6:01about the story of the game? What does the landscape
- 6:05you're moving through tell you about the story
- 6:08of the game? And again, this is the thing that
- 6:12causes problems in video game adaptations. They
- 6:16usually try to adapt the overt story of the game,
- 6:20not the experience or the environment. Even adaptations
- 6:24that are deemed successful, like HBO's The Last
- 6:28of Us, miss things. I've heard critiques over
- 6:32how that show misses the hours and hours you
- 6:35spend with Joel and Ellie, how important that
- 6:39relationship is to you, which is what fuels the
- 6:42ending, especially as your typical agency is
- 6:46stripped away. Today, I'd like to make an argument
- 6:51that one of the best video game movies ever made
- 6:54is not an adaptation of a game, nor some experimental
- 6:58narrative piece. that doesn't think it's a video
- 7:03game at all and might be confused by the connection.
- 7:07Nevertheless, I think the greatest video game
- 7:11movie is the 2009 Academy Award -nominated film
- 7:151917, written and directed by Sam Mendes. 1917
- 7:22is a World War I film with a distinct gimmick.
- 7:25It was made to feel like it was shot in one take.
- 7:29Or two takes? as there is only one distinct time
- 7:33cut in the film. Of course, the movie wasn't
- 7:37actually filmed in one go. There are a number
- 7:40of cuts throughout, hidden as someone walks in
- 7:43front of the camera or as the camera moves past
- 7:46an object. But the story is riveting enough that
- 7:50even the nerdiest of film people don't notice
- 7:52all the cuts. It follows two young British lance
- 7:57corporals, Blake and Schofield. in April of 1917,
- 8:02who are given orders to deliver a message to
- 8:05a separate battalion, telling them that their
- 8:08intelligence is incorrect and they cannot advance
- 8:11as planned. The young men have only until the
- 8:15following morning and must travel through no
- 8:17man's land and enemy territory to save the lives
- 8:21of 1 ,600 soldiers, including Blake's older brother.
- 8:26I am not the first person to make the connection
- 8:29that this movie feels like a video game. It was
- 8:33the thrust of the comedic, honest trailer of
- 8:35this film after it was released, but I came to
- 8:39this conclusion on my own, in the theater, and
- 8:42not for the same reason they did. The honest
- 8:45trailer argument for this being a video game
- 8:47is its story structure. Blake and Schofield move
- 8:51from cameo of famous British actor to famous
- 8:55British actor, beginning with a Colin Firth exposition
- 8:59cutscene as they're given their orders. Then
- 9:02through the trenches to Andrew Scott giving a
- 9:05comedic supporting performance as an officer
- 9:08who's been out here too long and has lost it
- 9:11a little, casually anointing the young men with
- 9:14alcohol as they prepare to go over the top across
- 9:17no man's land to the hopefully abandoned enemy
- 9:20line. There's even a part later in the film where
- 9:24a character is able to help someone with an item
- 9:27they've picked up along the way, as though it's
- 9:30a quest item in an adventure game. But this is
- 9:33only the result of the real reason this film
- 9:37feels like a video game. It's a movie mostly
- 9:42about characters traveling in real time from
- 9:45scene to scene to scene, where the power of the
- 9:49storytelling comes from the experience of walking
- 9:52through a designed environment packed with story
- 9:56and emotionally resonant imagery. This is because...
- 10:01This film abandons the most important piece of
- 10:05filmic storytelling, the edit. 1917 is not the
- 10:12first film to use this single -cut gimmick. That
- 10:16would be Alfred Hitchcock's 1948 film Rope. It's
- 10:20a psychological thriller set in a single room,
- 10:23in a single location, in real time. Two young
- 10:27men, convinced of their own superior intelligence,
- 10:30murder a classmate, hide the body, and invite
- 10:34over a bunch of guests for a dinner party, all
- 10:36to prove they can get away with the perfect murder.
- 10:39The film was based on a stage play. Theater -based
- 10:43storytelling is often reliant on a single location,
- 10:47though I would argue that theater has the advantage
- 10:50of warping space in a way no other medium can
- 10:53quite get away with, as it has the fullest buy
- 10:57-in of a suspension of disbelief. The play is
- 11:01meant to be one long sequence, in one place,
- 11:04during one time. And Hitchcock decided he wanted
- 11:08to try and make that experience happen on film.
- 11:12Later he called this a mistake. The film wasn't
- 11:16very well received and is remembered as a lesser
- 11:19Hitchcock work, which Hitch himself agreed to.
- 11:22It's because he discounted the importance and
- 11:25value of the edit. how much it matters to skip
- 11:29around in time and space. And learning this lesson
- 11:33was incredibly valuable for the future. So much
- 11:36of Hitchcock's greatest contribution to film
- 11:39rely on edits, whether that's the innuendo of
- 11:43a well -timed train running through a tunnel
- 11:45in North by Northwest, or the deeply unsettling
- 11:48shower scene of Psycho. Edits are really important
- 11:52in film communication. And 1917... abandons them.
- 11:59The filmic reason has to do with tension. Though
- 12:05a succession of quick edits can create tension,
- 12:08they also provide relief. In cinematic language,
- 12:12an edit is a chance to look away. Hold a shot
- 12:16too long and you risk making a scene feel awkward
- 12:20and uncomfortable. As humans, we have to blink
- 12:24all the time. We're used to the breaking up of
- 12:27imagery. Holding on a shot can feel a little
- 12:31bit like a staring contest. And the longer a
- 12:34shot goes on, the bigger that unsettled feeling
- 12:37grows. In certain films, this can create a sense
- 12:41of overwhelm. In others, suspense. Here, it puts
- 12:47you into the urgency of these two young men.
- 12:52Blake and Schofield don't get to skip the scary
- 12:56parts, or the gross bits, or the boring bits.
- 12:59They have to walk every single harrowing step.
- 13:04They have to snake through the trenches, the
- 13:07horrors of no man's land, a German bunker, and
- 13:11they have no idea what's ahead. We can't see
- 13:15it either. Not if there are still any German
- 13:18soldiers left, not if there are any booby traps.
- 13:22We have to keep our eyes open. unblinking, trying
- 13:26to catch sight of any threats on the horizon.
- 13:31But this, of course, is how you play a video
- 13:34game. Take my current favorite, Expedition 33.
- 13:39It's a third -person game, so the camera hovers
- 13:42behind the main character, though you can move
- 13:46the camera to take in the whole of the landscape
- 13:48as you go. Most of the game's paths are straightforward,
- 13:53but sometimes there are secrets off to the side
- 13:56where you'll find hidden items, money, recordings
- 13:59from the past, new skills or upgrades. Maybe
- 14:03there's a challenging fight that will give you
- 14:05cool outfits or weapons. It behooves you to keep
- 14:09an eye out for shiny things, or to listen for
- 14:11strange sounds. That may mean a hidden enemy
- 14:15around the corner. In some games, you have to
- 14:18keep an eye out for traps or hidden entrances.
- 14:21You are walking through every step, and a good
- 14:24game won't leave corridors or paths empty for
- 14:27too long. What would be the point of that? You
- 14:30want a game loop that involves interaction with
- 14:33the world, maybe signs to read or buttons to
- 14:36push, puzzles to solve. That's what makes a game
- 14:40a game. And while the player is searching around
- 14:43for interaction points or collectibles, they
- 14:46are actually taking in story. There are people
- 14:50who would argue that the difference between a
- 14:52film and a video game is that in a film, a director
- 14:56and cinematographer build shots to provide the
- 15:00imagery of a story, while in a game, players
- 15:03build that themselves. This is, in fact, untrue.
- 15:08Good game design provides the illusion that you
- 15:12yourself picked the angle by which you interact
- 15:15with the story. In actuality, Every frame you
- 15:19see was designed by somebody on purpose, using
- 15:23design principles and psychological trickery
- 15:26to get you to the same angles and perspectives
- 15:29so that you are understanding where you need
- 15:32to go, what you need to do, and what all this
- 15:35has to do with the plot. This is actually Caleb's
- 15:39area of expertise, which makes sense. He got
- 15:43started with a ball maze, after all. But level
- 15:46design is more than just making a maze. It's
- 15:50making a maze that feels good and gives the player
- 15:53the sense of control and independence. For example,
- 15:57level designers use light all the time to indicate
- 16:01where a player should go. The best designers
- 16:04have the light fall so naturally that you didn't
- 16:07even realize you were following it. Also, Designers
- 16:12will use small, cramped spaces to create contrast
- 16:15with open vistas that contain important story
- 16:19or path information. Caleb once made this level
- 16:24that led you through a series of hallways to
- 16:27a decently large room where story details were
- 16:30arranged like a magnificent Renaissance painting.
- 16:33The sight lines created giving you a really clear
- 16:37sense of what happened here and where to go next.
- 16:40The difference being that a player gets to walk
- 16:43through it to highlight more clearly the information
- 16:46needed without a single word of dialogue. And
- 16:50this, really, is where 1917 is playing. Production
- 16:56designer Dennis Gassner, set decorator Lee Sandals,
- 17:01and cinematographer Roger Deakins are the miracles
- 17:04of this film. Gassner and Sandals built these
- 17:08amazing mazes filled with story, and Roger Deakins
- 17:12captured them, his camera following the story
- 17:15told in the environment. We don't have much context
- 17:19before the film begins. We don't know how long
- 17:23these trenches have existed, how the battle has
- 17:25been fought, but we do have a half -decomposed
- 17:29horse corpse showing that this ground used to
- 17:32be level enough for an animal to travel over,
- 17:35and that was a long time ago. But something accelerated
- 17:40the process, as the horse has skin on one side,
- 17:43exposed bone on the other. Or there's the long,
- 17:48unbroken shot of a field of dead cows, telling
- 17:52a whole story of war's disrespect for life. These
- 17:56aren't accompanied by much exposition or discussions
- 17:59of the landscape. We just know that something
- 18:02happened here, and our brain starts doing an
- 18:06intense amount of work trying to fill in the
- 18:08stories. It's actually the No Man's Land sequence
- 18:12specifically that cued me into the game design
- 18:15side of this film, because it reminded me heavily
- 18:18of a sequence in the game Brothers, A Tale of
- 18:22Two Sons. It's a nearly wordless game where you
- 18:26play as a pair of brothers. controlling them
- 18:28on separate joysticks, a really crazy mechanic
- 18:32of getting the two to work together to solve
- 18:34problems. They are traveling on a journey to
- 18:38obtain a cure for their ailing father and must
- 18:41traverse a variety of landscapes and settlements
- 18:44to get to their destination. At one point, they're
- 18:48dropped into a giant's battlefield, filled with
- 18:51dead bodies. We have no understanding for what
- 18:54happened here. Who fought whom? Why did they
- 18:58fight? Clearly, it was fought recently enough
- 19:01that blood is still flowing into the rivers,
- 19:04but long enough that the vultures have begun
- 19:07to do their work. The boys must traverse the
- 19:10landscape by pushing away oversized limbs, triggering
- 19:14weapons, and navigating the bodies. It's an incredibly
- 19:18visceral experience, and it's all I could think
- 19:22of as I watched Blake and Schofield traverse
- 19:25their own battlefield, interacting with the remains
- 19:28of war. There are other comparisons to video
- 19:33games I could make here. The way we don't actually
- 19:36know much about Blake and Schofield, so they
- 19:40can become blank slate protagonists, like many
- 19:43video game heroes. The few character details
- 19:46we do get coming up environmentally, through
- 19:49small interactions or environment -triggered
- 19:52conversations. There are the ways each scene
- 19:56feels like a level. different, unique environments
- 20:00with their own challenges and problem -solving.
- 20:03But I wouldn't say any of this was a flaw. Hitchcock's
- 20:08rope failed because it was trying to capture
- 20:11the suspension of disbelief of a stage play,
- 20:14a feat of impossibility. 1917 succeeds because
- 20:21it seeks to give us the harrowing experience
- 20:24of World War I messengers. based on the stories
- 20:28told by Sam Mendes' own grandfather, Alfred.
- 20:31It wants us to understand the danger they experienced,
- 20:36the fortitude they expressed to keep on, the
- 20:39ingenuity of how they overcame obstacles. And
- 20:43the best way for understanding the specificity
- 20:46of an experience is immersion, letting us see
- 20:50the world as they did, its horrors, its beauties.
- 20:55all while letting us experience the thrill of
- 20:58success and the humiliation of defeat. It's not
- 21:03too dissimilar from watching Caleb play a video
- 21:06game. I might not be pushing the buttons on the
- 21:09controller, but I am equally invested in looking
- 21:12out for the environment clues and storytelling,
- 21:15pointing out when he's missed a key detail, trying
- 21:18to stay calm when he's under attack. It becomes
- 21:21my experience too. If you like video games already,
- 21:26You should watch 1917. You will have all the
- 21:30tools to appreciate how it's telling its story.
- 21:35But if you like 1917 and don't have much experience
- 21:39with games, may I suggest you try? You don't
- 21:45even have to use a controller. Many games use
- 21:48a keyboard and mouse. You might want to try what's
- 21:52called a walking simulator. where the only mechanics
- 21:55are moving and perhaps picking up a few objects.
- 22:00The game Dear Esther was a sort of pioneer of
- 22:04this kind of storytelling, where you move through
- 22:06an environment as a story of tragedy and regret
- 22:10is told. But What Remains of Edith Finch, an
- 22:14exploration of a family curse, and Firewatch,
- 22:18about a firewatcher in Wyoming, are also highly
- 22:22respected. If you played Mario games as a kid
- 22:26and have some experience with games where you
- 22:29jump on platforms, I highly recommend Grease,
- 22:33G -R -I -S, a metaphorical exploration of grief.
- 22:38If you were a gamer as a teenager and haven't
- 22:42really thought about it as an artistic medium,
- 22:44maybe you could try picking up Zelda Breath of
- 22:47the Wild, which has some amazing environmental
- 22:50storytelling. or the aforementioned Expedition
- 22:5333, which has an easier mode of combat if you
- 22:57need it. In either case, I hope you can take
- 23:01some time to appreciate the difference in storytelling
- 23:04mediums and how cool it is when they learn from
- 23:09each other. Thanks for coming.