Latest / Building Real / Rebuilding Cold Chain for Southeast Asia's Priciest, Least Reliable Power Grid | Joe Khoo
Transcript
- Joe Khoo: two months ago, we still had trouble filling up our boxes. we had like 50% inventory still available. but where we are now today, it's it's almost 90, 95% filled. So that's kind of a good place to we are around 24 boxes right now in the Philippines, and I expect by the end of the year we will hit around 89, 90, 100 boxes by the end of the year. Arjun Thomas: So Joe, thanks for taking the time to have this chat with me. And good morning. Yeah. we had Joe Khoo: Thanks for having me. Good morning. Good morning. Arjun Thomas: originally planned this, I think, about a week or two ago, and then I guess life and and work happened. and I think what cemented what you're doing in my head quite vividly is that picture you sent to me I think yesterday or day before, stuck in Manila traffic with I think half Joe Khoo: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: the road underwater. and I'm like, damn, Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: that's a great hook to start this conversation on, which is what Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: on earth does polar cold do and why is it important or necessary in Manila, given what you sent me, the picture that you sent me. I think maybe that's a good place to start. Joe Khoo: Mm. So I think if you've ever been to Manila, first of all, I think the traffic there is one of the worst in Southeast Asia or at least in the world. I think there's some CNA documentary that kind of showed like how bad the traffic was. so that's first. And then I think Philippines being a tropical country and so near the the ocean, right? And it gets all these typhoons that comes every I would say every month or even even every two months they will have like some typhoon that's gonna come. It passes, it goes out to Taiwan, but the rain all comes, and then everything gets flooded. And then I think a lot of this flooding news comes on top of Manila, right? So given the logistic problems and then the flooding that comes, actually transporting things in the Philippines is actually not the easiest. and I think something very local to Philippines is that. Within certain timeframe, there's also a ban on large trucks entering into the city. So actually, if you're like trying trying to transport goods on a larger trucks, like 20, 20 footer, 40-footer, you cannot enter the cities during certain timings. So that really kind Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: of s screws up your your planning, right, for for logistics. Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Joe Khoo: So I think why Polar Coal found an age in the in this coal chain space that we are working in is that. The traditional model of coal was that I'm gonna build a large mega facility near the port. I'm gonna receive 10,000 pallets of goods, a lot of people coming in, and then I'm gonna transport it out to the country. I think that was the traditional logistic model. All right, you have this Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Joe Khoo: way of doing things, and then That works. That works actually for a lot of the larger companies like in Philippines, like San Miguel, Central Pacific, all these large companies, they do pretty good. but when you look at the smaller people who are running SME businesses, which is actually the backbone of every country, right? They don't get access to this kind of Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. In this region, yeah. Joe Khoo: they don't get access to this kind of facilities. And then the only options that they have is like chess reasons that they can buy. Which are one, not energy efficient, two, it's not very reliable. and maybe every 10 days you'll have one day that it that it is down because you have to kind of remove the ice from the chest freezer. Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: so those are the options that they have. I mean, I think where polar coal really sits now is in a very sweet spot of we are bigger than the chest freezers, but we are not. As inflexible as a third-party large warehouse that is far away. Because what we deploy is modular cold storages that can move and grow with your business. We can deploy it very quickly in any locations as long as we have the inventory on hand. And it's large enough for people to actually run a legitimate distributing business if they want to. One other option that they have in the Philippines is okay, I can build my own coal room. But with the traffic, the floodings and things like that, building also takes time. So actually, those are a lot of factors that people consider. So for us, we like to term this this we like to coin this term for the Philippines coal chain is that it's very lumpy. It's like you're trying to do something, but you have so many barriers that's kind of pulling on you, making it hard to move. that it becomes very lumpy and slow. But I think the polar box is in a good space, that it is highly modular, super flexible. And I think as we speak today, I think in the morning we have one polar box that's going down south of the Philippines to be deployed, to be tested with one of the larger corporations that I talked about. and then once that goes through, then they will look to kind of deploy this around the Philippines, right? So Yeah, I think that the polar box has has its own unique advantages in in this space. and that's what we think. Arjun Thomas: Right. So so maybe kind of let me sum sum this up at least s for my understanding. So what you're saying is that the traditional large players who Need the infrastructure to support their existing business are capital rich, have the ability to kind of build this together, these large facilities at the port, and they have these larger facilities at certain key distribution nodes across the country, taking Philippines as an example. And they're able to kind of manage that efficiently because again, they have the ability to deep, dig deep into their pockets and and kind of deploy that capital. And you have at the other extreme end are these you know ice boxes. That MSMEs use because they have not neither the capital nor the expertise to kind of build this complicated supply chain. And you guys kind of sit in the middle, which is offering something larger, more reliable. and maybe this is a good time to kind of talk about before we get into the technology, why did you choose the Philippines? Because this is I guess, if you look at the problem, which is Dense metros, which is present. I mean, Singapore is probably the exception in the rule in this whole region, for a whole whole whole range of reasons. but you would find no shortage of this problem in any metro in in the in the developing world or the emerging markets. So I'd be interested to understand why the Philippines. And we can talk about the technology, obviously, I'm very excited about it, but but why why the Philippines? Joe Khoo: I think that's a long story actually in itself. So so there's a there's a few things, but Arjun Thomas: That tha that's why I asked the question, because I know it's an interesting story. Yeah. Joe Khoo: But I think it it went back to the fact that we in all transparency, if I had to do all do do this all over again, I would not have started with the Philippines. I would have started in in some Arjun Thomas: Where would you have started? Joe Khoo: other countries. I think Indonesia or Malaysia would have been easier for us. One one is because of the distance. Two is because Indonesia, like Philippines, faces the very similar problems of traffic, right? and the market itself in the Indonesia is also much larger than the Philippines. and the bureaucratics of it is just makes makes Indonesia slightly better than Philippines. yeah. So back to your question. Why we started in the Philippines is actually when polar coal was So ProCo was a company that was built out of a venture studio. in all transparency, I think it's quite public as well. We were built out of the ENGIE kind of venture studio. and ENGIE as an energy company has a focus on energy efficiency. So it started out as an idea of say, hey, we're gonna build cold rooms, but we're gonna build the most energy-efficient co room in the world. and then we're gonna sell that to people, and then that's how we Can kind of say that hey, we are doing a climate kind of focused startup in a coal chain that is based on energy savings, right? And then based on that theory, when you look at Southeast Asia, between a coal room in Indonesia and coal room in the Philippines, they're gonna be the same. I'm gonna save save the same amount of energy, let's say 40%. But the reality of it is that in Indonesia, 40% of energy might be like 10 cents per kilowatt hour. And then the Philippines, it's like 30 cents. So with the same amount of energy that you save per kilowatt, our Philippines has the most bang for the pub. So it makes Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: sense to say, hey, if I'm gonna convince people to do energy saving, what's the number one thing they think about? They think about money. And then if you speak to people in the in in Indonesia, they're like, how much does this save? 40%? Wow, great. And then they calculate and it's like, I can kind of live with this. It's because it's like heavily subsidized by the government and things like that. but when it comes to the Philippines, They'll be like, okay, this is a real actually real cost for me. and that's how we say, like, hey, okay, we sh maybe we should start looking at the the Philippines. that's how we. Arjun Thomas: So sorry, before you continue, I wanna maybe push maybe probe a little bit further, because you said you Joe Khoo: Mm-hmm. Arjun Thomas: left your own devices you would probably do Indonesia first. But from what you're saying, there seems to be a a a threefold benefit improvement if you were to do Manila anyway. So is it because of the the operational headache and that's l and that's the reason why you feel that Philippines was was more of a problem? Because value proposition Philippines seems to be a lot better, from what you're telling me. Joe Khoo: Yeah, yeah. But I I'm saying I'm saying that in in retrospective, right? Because right now Arjun Thomas: Okay. Joe Khoo: our business is also very different from purely energy savings. So right now, Arjun Thomas: right, okay. Joe Khoo: so right now, if I were to take our current business, I would do Indonesia because it's it's just I think better in that sense. another point to that is that in the Philippines, it was very hard to get things started. Like as a new startup. There without any Philippine connections. It took us actually nine months to get our business registered and legalized, right? So in between, you can't really collect payments and stuff because you weren't actually a legal Philippine entity. And then once we got the business started, you wanted to have, you wanted to start collecting payments. In Singapore, when you sign up for Stripe, it takes like a day, and then you can start like collecting payments anytime, right? Or maybe three or four days max, because they need to do their TD. In the Philippines, it took us six months to to get to the stage where we could collect credit card payments. Cause first you you have to s open an account, they do all the due diligence. And then once you are in it, you cannot collect anything except like some simple payments from the QR codes. If you want credit card, you have to s you have to request for it and then you go through another due diligence process. and then even we got a credit card. Yes. Arjun Thomas: So was it nine plus six months? Sorry, was it nine plus six months that you had to wait before you actually were able to kind of collect credit card payments? Jesus. Joe Khoo: Yes, yes, yes. Arjun Thomas: So the first nine months were you kind of offering this like free service just to kind of validate the product and the market? No? Joe Khoo: No, no, no, no. Like we had to we have to do business somewhere, right? So we used our our Singapore company to s to kick start to kind of validate things. Yeah, yeah. But we Arjun Thomas: To charge them. right. Okay, okay. Joe Khoo: know that in the future we have to kind of transition to the Philippine entity anyway. but we didn't know that it was gonna take us that long. yeah. So so this whole process was was was a pain, was like you were like walking through mud, I would say it's like So it's a dreadful process. But I think looking back, I think nonetheless this also provides a moat in itself to anybody that say, why can't someone Arjun Thomas: The Joe Khoo: just come in, come in and copy your business? I'm like, sure, you can come in in the Philippines, you can try it. yeah, it's gonna be one hell of a journey for anyone that's trying to come into this space. Arjun Thomas: Right, I can imagine. I wanna pick up on the point that you talked about and the only reason I'm doing this is because the first ten episodes that went out and the subsequent ones that I'm talking to are pretty pretty much all founder led as in founder ventures in the wild. There are a couple that I'm talking to that are C V C or corporate venture backed. and for the for the audience who might not know what a corporate venture building is all about, if you could just walk us through the process of of w how is this different from a venture in the wild as a founder in the wild and maybe kind of set that stage. and then we can talk about the transition, but but but I want to kind of get get a sense of how building it this way is different from what people normally associate with a founder basically having an idea and just, you know, let's just get s get started. Joe Khoo: Yep, yep. in all honesty, I I did not go through the the entire process. I came in once the idea was settled, there was funding and they needed a technical person. but I've been inside long enough to know how the process looks like. So basically, the entire premise is that they will they hire for talent, for people who let's say they identify a vertical that say, hey, I want The corporates are basically say, I want to find something to do in the coaching space. Then they started, they will start looking for people or talent, basically, usually it's two founders, to come on board and say, We will give you three months to figure out what you can do in this coaching space. And you have three months to test and validate that idea. So basically they will hire these two people and then together with the venture building team, which are usually veterans in Startup world, right? Either they have founded something, exited, or they are VCs themselves, which kind of give you feedback, which kind of accelerate this entire process. Because if you are to do it by yourself, you have to validate it by yourself. You have to find people to speak to. But here it's in a closed space. You get all the legal advice that you need, you get all the feedback that you need, and you also get support in terms of like for the in this case, ENGIE was the one running it. has a wide network of locations across Southeast Asia, Singapore, Philippines, and some other areas. you can easily tap into the network there to say, hey, I want to test something. Can you help me with this? And then they will kind of find some people to help you. So usually that was the process. Something else is that. Once this process is over, you kind of pitch your idea, and then they have a committee that says whether it's a goal or no goal. And once it's a goal, they actually provide you the initial seed fund that you need. So that is very helpful. Because, in my knowledge, a lot of climate tech doesn't get through that first phase because climate tech is not so sexy as a business, it's capital intensive and things like that. But because it was from ENGIE, and ENGIE as a company. Is used to dealing with CapEx heavy stuff, they see things very differently from other companies. So in this case, if you are working on a capex heavy business, they would still be able to see the benefit of that and invest in it in the long term. Compared to if you were to run outside and you were to speak to some of the more traditional VCs, those VC look at number purely, right? Like How big is your market? How can you how fast can you get the returns? Can I exit in five years? Yeah, but so it's it's very different. and I feel like in this climate space, going with the corporates has its own benefits. yeah, but if you have some AI wonderful idea they can do with climate, then maybe you can go with the traditional VCs. So I think that was one of the key differences. Why we were able to start in the first place. Yeah, but I mean through the through the two years that we had, we pivoted the idea so much that I think it it's something that truly belonged to the founders, that we we kind of morphed this initial idea into something that is truly our own now. Arjun Thomas: And and that and that's fascinating and I think mirrors a lot of what founders go through in the zero to one stage where you kind of Pick a theme like cold storage, for example, and that's a very wide lane. But as you experiment, Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: you kind of narrow focus. Okay, do we go on the left lane, the middle lane, the extreme right Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: lane? And that's where the expertise and the practical experience that you have trying to build this venture kind of guides your guides your path. so it's so f from what I'm understanding, because of the nature of the problem that was selected, which is something that is capital intensive, an asset heavy kind of kind of business, the fact that returns would take a long time. So you need someone with patient capital, a long-term view of the business that was kind of building, the fact that it's in an energy sector, you want someone who can give you that deep expertise and tap into their networks. And given that you are doing this in a region that's quite broad like APAC, you want ideally someone that has Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: a network access that can get you into one or many locations. And that sweet spot of I think four things kind of aligning is probably one of the reasons why you feel that working with with a corporate venture like ENGIE in this p specific space made a lot of sense. Alright. Okay. Very cool. Joe Khoo: Yes. Yes. Cause I mean honestly I've tried doing my own startups before, but it was just difficult, right? So coming into ENGIE, I saw these things that you pointed out and I believe that yeah, it it makes a difference. let's let's give it a shot. yeah. Arjun Thomas: And what made you attract what attracted you to this problem? Because maybe let's just kind of unpack your journey. because you know, you've you've kind of worked Joe Khoo: Mm. Arjun Thomas: in very intelligent locks, you kind of moved into cold storage. you've been an I guess a hardware guy for a for a for a fairly decent amount of time. Maybe just pack unpack, you know, the kind of businesses, the products that you worked on and what specifically about Joe Khoo: Mm-hmm. Arjun Thomas: this problem drew you to ENGIE beyond these four things because you know, these are it's like safety nets and and and and Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: things that can increase Joe Khoo: Hm. I think it goes back it goes back maybe almost seventeen years ago when I when I kinda first started university. I think at the beginning of of that university phase, I was really contemplating what what I wanted to do with my life, you know, because you have your army and then you you finish army and then you some of us has kind of a long break before university starts. So actually I I took maybe a one month break to to kind of travel across Japan, across all the Zen temples, to really sit down and kinda think about what I wanted to do with my life. I think it was through that journey that I decided that hey, I I wanted to contribute something. I wanted to make something, but I also want wanted it to be something very personal and something that I really cared for. the conclusion of that was that I was gonna work in sustainability and I want to Arjun Thomas: Hm. Joe Khoo: kind of tackle this problem of climate change. And then that kind of led me to what I studied in university. which was electrical engineering. And that was because if you thought about like maybe 17 years ago, I think solar panel was was like starting to take off. And I believe that you know solar panels being free energy and stuff had a lot of potential. And I wanted to understand it fully. Because I kind of also thought that you know electricity as a part generates a lot of greenhouse energy and things. That was where I really wanted to kind of focus. So it was then that I kind of went into electrical engineering there. And then I met the NOC program from NUS. managed to get a spot to go to Silicon Valley. And then that was where it really exposed my eyes or exposed me to all the startup things that people are building and and that if you wanted to build something you can. It's just you have to take BC BC money for that. Which is Which is in itself has its own problems, but it is what it is. Like you see all this success story and then you come back and then you believe that, hey, I wanna I wanna do it, do that too. So I think it was that that kind of led me down the first path. But I think when I graduated from university, I realized that all I had was like theoretical knowledge. Like I don't have any kind of physical experience. So I tried reaching out to try to apply for Jobbox Waiver. but it was not kind of getting through, like because had no practical experience and things like that. So actually I started intern, I grabbed any internship that I could find that was close to what I wanted to do, which that time was an internship in a VR company. they were looking for some electronics person. went there, I kind of interned for about three months and then I got converted to kind of a full-time role. then I was there working on VR. Which is very different from sustainability. But I the thinking back then was that I'm gonna dedicate two years of my life or whatever early part of my life to be really good technically in the things that I do. and back then I could see that I was working with really smart people and was kind of a good place to learn. And because it was a s I was a second employee, there was a lot of freedom to try different things, to learn different things. Yeah, and then I get I got exposed to like computer vision software, the coding stuff behind and all the algorithms. So that was good exposure. and then for good or for bad, As the first startup I joined, at the end of it, we were acquired by Facebook. So that was Arjun Thomas: Okay. Joe Khoo: that was a good experience. But it was an equi hire kind of process that that I didn't get acquired in that sense. So I was here in Singapore and then I was kind of looking for my next role. And I was there for about two years. And then after four years of kind of doing technical things. and being in the kind of hardware space for a bit, I felt like, hey, I think it's time a bit I'm ready to kind of try my own things. So I left to join Entrepreneur First, which back then was still running here in Singapore. I was there for a while, tried to do something, nothing came out of it, but I was determined to kind of run my own idea because they gave you three months to figure out what you want to do, find an idea Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: that you want to pursue. I came out, I was like, okay, I'm gonna do this by myself and I'm gonna try to figure things out. I did that for about a year. yeah, I went through the usual mistakes that people make, like selling to farmers, you realize that you can sell to one, but how do you scale this beyond the the capacity they're trying to build? and was and I was Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: running on my own money back then, right? and then you reach a point where you don't have enough money and then you kind of start working again. So that was what led me back to the workforce. But also coincidentally, I was always working on things. And then when Angie, the recruiter from ENGIE, kind of reached out to me to say, Hey, we have this startup that is working on coaching. will you be interested to kind of interview for it? And then I have the funny thing is when I had this call. One week ago, like just one week before that, I stopped working on another idea that I was working with with Arjun Thomas: All right. Joe Khoo: another like with with someone from the EF batch, like we were working on some how were we working on? AI powered device for the blind people. So, like because Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Joe Khoo: people when they blind people can't use the phone very well, you know. If you realize that they always listen to it and they do it in a very specific manner. But if you can speak to your phone to do things for you, then I think that would that will have kind of changed how they interacted. So we're working on that, but it was also because of a hardware CapEx heavy thing. we couldn't really do much with that, even though it was in the AI space. yeah, so. I ended that and then one week later I got this call and then I'm sitting there thinking, do I want to like go through this again? And then I'm like, sure, I think I think one week break is enough. Let's try to interview Arjun Thomas: Ha ha ha ha. Joe Khoo: for this and see where this goes. but also because it is in a coaching space, right? That that I know is linked to kind of sustainability. So I took up the offer, I went down and then I never looked back. and then have always been kind of pushing Pol Call forward. Yeah. So that's kind of my journey on like kind of how it transitioned and what led me to where I am today. but I would say that a lot of the decision has been fueled by my determination to do something in the climate space, which was actually kind of anchored way, way back when I decided that this is something that I wanted to pursue. Arjun Thomas: Right. And it's interesting. It's like a it's it's almost like a man in search of a vision around sustainability and climate and your journey f building the blocks that allowed you to take over the CTO role at polar cold. are all these kind of I I guess small, very separate experiences in building VR systems, in building digital locks, in tinkering with some sort of sustainability. project and then you know lo and behold a large conglomerate like ENGIE says that we want to tackle coal storage as a space and you just happen to be available at that point of time. I'm curious about there's no shortage of Hard things you've had to do, especially given that you've chosen the Philippines. you've chosen a space that is asset asset heavy. And I'll talk we'd love I'd love to talk about the business model and the technology itself in in a little bit. so there's no shortage I'm sure of the the hard list of things that you've had to kind of accomplish. what did you find that was surprisingly easy, that you thought might have been hard in everything that you've done since you've got polar code up and running? Surprisingly easy, th that you thought it might have been harder. Joe Khoo: I think like you said, majority of it has been very hard. I think raising the money, and accepting the fact that we had to pivot the idea. and even like working in the Philippines has been has been very hard. But I think something that was very easy. was also actually something that made us kind of pivot hard into where we are today. Because I think I think like I said, we were st we started with energy efficiency. And then we started to say that we're gonna finance people's cold room. But I think the biggest problem back then was that each of these cold room projects that we get for six months to eight months sales cycle. Like it wasn't it wasn't sustainable. And they were not bringing enough cash to sustain the business. So when we looked at this and then we realized that hey, okay, we needed to pivot We need to pivot to something that's more fast-paced, exciting. And that's where we kind of landed on this modular cold storage idea and that we wanted to do a rental business out of it. I think where I am now, the easiest thing is that once you figure out that the market has an acceptance of rental, because rental has been so prominent across so many generations, and you bring in a relatively new product, actually people start coming for it. So something that was has been very easy is like Because previously when we were doing the the co room sales, we had to look for people, we had to push sales, we have to push, we have to find people to get it. But now I run a Facebook ad and I get like 70 leads in like three hours. And then I'm like, I'm done for for today. I will just work on this 70 leads tomorrow, right? And the 70 leads are actually high-quality leads because we actually ask them to fill up a form. Arjun Thomas: Right, okay. So so high intent leads, very high intent Joe Khoo: So they fill in the few in like a set, Arjun Thomas: leads. Joe Khoo: yeah, side seven questions, seven questions to like how much space they need and when they want it, things like that. And then we filter them through that. and then I think this idea has legs because it's slowly picking up. I can see that you know we are closing deals every week. it's and we are starting to get larger clients as well. Even the larger people that we used to speak to. They were very hesitant to jump aboard on what we provided previously. But now it's it's rolling, right? So I think that has been something that I felt. Has been easier on our end. Like we are not pushing so hard against what the market is fighting against. We are really pushing something that people really want. They really need it. They need it now. And the intake is just kind of happening. And then for us, we just have to kind of figure out how do we prioritize the people. And then now, two months ago, we were still having like extra inventory. in the Philippines. I think currently where we are now, I think we are almost running out of inventory. and then it will be a new problem, like because we need to get more of it to come in. We need to find the money for it. which is a good problem to have. yeah, but at least I would say that aspect of pushing this new idea has been relatively easy. and we needed we don't need to do kind of too much. I think for me I spend maybe three hours on a weekend to do do an advert advert with ai and then it gets like 500 leads over the next like few days so the conversion there is really good and i think each of the leads is costing us around 20 cents now Arjun Thomas: Wow. Joe Khoo: and then i think from what we see a lot of our the customers that can't come aboard they're renting it for about six to nine months or even one year so actually the RI is actually very good. in this aspect. So when you solve one problem, another problem arises. But I think the one that arises right now is a good problem to have. Arjun Thomas: So so what you're saying essentially is that the lessons of figuring out the business model essentially is once you figured out which business model worked for your specific ICP, which is a combination of convenience, which is the flexibility in giving them short, long term, medium term kind of rental opportunities, as well as flexibility in choosing, I guess, the size of s of space that they wanted. I think that and plugging that into a subscription model, which is a very common, well understood behavior for a s especially the SMAs and SMEs that you go after, I guess I guess the friction all disappeared. It all the barriers to say yes slowly kind of disappeared and that's why I think it's become a more PLG driven adoption cycle, which is which is a great problem to have. out of curiosity, Joe Khoo: Yeah yeah. Arjun Thomas: what is the the monthly rental costs? Like how do you figure out the model? Is it per square foot, per cubic foot? Like how do you determine what the outlays given there's so much variability in the size of the the space that they can take. And if you can just help me contrast from an OPEX point of view how a traditional business would actually be spending money if they had their own small little gold storage set up with all its inefficiencies, just for me to get a get a sense of the the business viability or the business value proposition Joe Khoo: Okay. Arjun Thomas: for a small business owner. Joe Khoo: So I think it's easier to talk in pesos. So I don't have to kind of constantly convert it. convert it between US dollars. Yeah, yeah. Arjun Thomas: Pesos. Okay. Right. Okay. Pesos. Great. Numbers are numbers are the same. Pesos are fine. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's fine. Joe Khoo: so if you're a small business today, you want to build your call room, right? You want to build a core room for your site. first of all, you need to make sure that you have the space for it. so that's one. You either have to rent additional space for that, or you have to cut up some space from your business to kind of build that. Correct. So that's one loss that they eat up front. And then a simple cold room like that can easily cost between 600 to 1 million pesos. So in in US dollars term it's about maybe 10,000 to maybe about 15,000 US dollars up front. Like you have to build this. Then in Philippines, there's usually a long delay for this. Like you have to get the floor, the the flooring done, and then the people have to bring the things down and then they send people to fix it up and then they test it and then they hand it over to you. then you kinda pay everything up front. So that's a heavy cost for people. And then beyond that, when you have a colorom running, usually people who use this are not technical. They are like salespeople, they are food businesses. But your colorom part of a part of your process, right? And colorom something that is actually high wear and tear kind of equipment because it runs all day. and if it spoils, you are like. Okay, what am I gonna do with my cold cold stuff? So it is something that sh cannot go down. So that you need that, so that so you start spending money to get it fixed. And then the maintenance part, because if it's inefficient, so it's a kind of a vicious cycle. If it's inefficient, something is wrong with the unit, you don't really know what's wrong. It spoils, Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: you get it fixed, but if you don't fix the root cause of it, it kind of cycles. Arjun Thomas: Hm. Joe Khoo: And then a lot of the businesses that we see. Once they grow in scale, they actually build extra cold rooms to have extra capacity in case something goes wrong. So that's for the kind of larger people. Arjun Thomas: Okay. Joe Khoo: But the smaller people, if something goes wrong, they revert back to chest freezers because that's like the most easily accessible items for them in the market. And then they leave their cold room to kind of hang and dry until they can kind of fix it. Correct. So it's a very Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: complicated problem for them. But if you look at our model, we come in and say we can give you a relatively sized cold rooms that is equivalent to five of your chest freezers. The energy efficiency Arjun Thomas: Give me give me a sense in terms of cubic feet, how how much is that? How large is that? Joe Khoo: So it's for for the polo box is around three square meters. and then the height is about one point eight meters. So it's a slightly taller, taller kind of fridge. like your fridge at Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: home is gonna be there, but it's gonna be much wider. And then the chest Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: freezers is like A two-door chest freezers is pretty much if you kind of swap that out, the space equivalent is five. Five of that chest freezers can fit into one polar box. But if you look at the the space that you claim back, actually five chest freezer actually take more more land space because they cannot be stacked. Correct. So Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: actually by converting to the polar box, you're actually reclaiming back some space. and then the polar box itself, because it has one single unit cooling the whole room, is actually more energy efficient than having five separate units. the energy efficiency that comes. Arjun Thomas: Yeah, with five times the parts I guess. Joe Khoo: Yeah. So so that's where they come in. And then the funny thing about the pricing is actually it took us maybe also around six to eight months to kind of figure out what is the sweet spot or what can we get people to pay. So right now I think we are charging around 23,000 pesos per month. But with this 23,000 Arjun Thomas: Okay. For what? Joe Khoo: for the rental of the unit at your location. So we rent it to you, we place it at your site, you pay us 23,000 a month to use it. Yeah. Arjun Thomas: Okay, so this is for the whole unit, right? So this is for the whole i it's it's it's almost like a container size form factor, but much smaller, right? Joe Khoo: It's a it's a much smaller, so we have a 20-foot container. I would say that the polar box that we rent out is maybe one quarter of the size. Arjun Thomas: Okay. Joe Khoo: But it's it's sizable enough to store up to two tons of food, which is what a lot of the small businesses actually kinda sit around. So it's kind of good sweet spot for them. Yeah. And Arjun Thomas: Okay, so by two tons, yeah. Right. Joe Khoo: then they pay about 23,000 a month. And then with this 23,000, they don't have to worry about maintenance ever. Like we monitor it for them, we fix it for them, they just use it, which is what they want for their business. and separately, because this is where a little bit of the tech part comes in, where people see value in it, is that all of these are monitored by us, but they also get access to it to see at least the basic kind of data of the cold rooms. And then for larger companies, where they see value is having this placed around all of their distributors. And using our platform to actually monitor all their distributors' temperature and in one single platform, which is unheard of in the current market because cold room is such a traditional kind of market. And especially in the Philippines, Arjun Thomas: industry. Joe Khoo: not everybody has kind of sensors installed in their colorooms. So by having us, they don't have to rebuild all the colorums. They can just deploy it ready today in two days, get it up and running, and then have the visibility of all of the colorums under that network. So I think that's a few of the benefits that we present to our customers. And a lot of them have feedback that actually it allows them to generate more revenue. So because previously they were constrained by how much they can order, because they are all very small, but now with a slightly larger co-room, they can order more. First of all, the cost goes down, and because now they can store more. the logistic cost goes down because they don't have to have so many trips. and then by having more, they can sell more as well. So the revenue goes up. So you Arjun Thomas: Some Right, I should double click on that, which is you've got this a quarter size of a of a full shipping container as a cold room, about two tons of products that they can use to store at any given point of time. what percentage of your customers rent the whole box or maybe multiple coal coal boxes and what and do you have a model where there's sharing within the same box? When there's if Joe Khoo: Mm-hmm. Arjun Thomas: for example there's a smaller MSME who does not need two tons, for example, do you guys play around with that? Joe Khoo: So we thought about that at the beginning. and we decided to not dabble in that for the moment because we weren't super convinced in the Philippine market. Arjun Thomas: Hm. Joe Khoo: yeah, because a lot of our business revolves around having a very lean team. And if you were to do that, it actually Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: you need someone there to kind of monitor that nothing goes wrong and nobody takes anybody's things. And I think we've spoken Arjun Thomas: True. Joe Khoo: to a few people and they said that Filipinos like their own privacy. They don't want people to see Arjun Thomas: Yeah, okay. Joe Khoo: what other people are storing. So we decided to rent Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: this as like a your own private cold storage. Like even though you're sharing this space Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: with like maybe five to six other people at our locations, you can have this as your own private storage. Nobody knows what you're storing. You come in and out as you want. Arjun Thomas: Okay. Right. Joe Khoo: So that's one model. but I think recently we pivoted to more, we're gonna set it up at your site. You can have all the privacy you want. You can use it as you want. We're just going to help maintain it for you. So so that's how that's where we are today. Arjun Thomas: Okay, so twenty three thousand pesos per month, you get this box. it's currently you have multiple boxes co located. Each box is allocated to a c customer so they can access it whenever they want. you're pivoting about pivoting, you're also adding optionality today for customers to have the cold storage at their own location. So it's convenient for them anywhere in the Philippines I would assume. you talked about maybe let's talk a little bit about the technology itself. So from what I understand there are sensors, you can monitor it anywhere in the in the world again it's it's it's it's connected on data. given that it's a system that never structurally should never ever switch off because it has to keep things at a certain specific temperature, and you are in a country where there are power issues, How do you deal with the practicalities of maintaining your hardware? I mean, given that you guys have been doing this for a bit, w what are the things that cons that keeps you up most at night? you know, infrastructure falling apart, power going down. I'm sure there's a laundry list that you have, but but what's the things that concerns Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: you most? Joe Khoo: I think right now the thing that keeps me up at night is actually whether our coloroms are hitting the temperature that our customer needs. it could be for various reasons why it doesn't. but when I spot something, it it does keep me up at night. For example, if a customer requires minus 18 degrees, but your call room is only like hitting maybe minus 12, minus 13. yeah, that that kind of keeps me up at night currently because What we have transitioned to is we are now a very customer-facing business. Like, and we know that when customers use our cold storage, it could mean like if your cold storage doesn't work, it could mean like a few tens or twenty thousand dollars worth of product that goes back. So in our line of business, there is this kind of risk when it comes to to cold storage. and it's actually very scary when you start dealing with Arjun Thomas: Mm. Joe Khoo: the bigger companies. So we have clients that have rented up to four units to store all their cold stuff for their commissary. And that becomes a liability if we are not able to provide what we what we provide. So on the technology. Arjun Thomas: And because they can monitor the temperature so accurately, I guess, they know, right, at any point of time. If it's eighteen and they see twelve one they're yeah, quite quite quite quite visible. Joe Khoo: Yes. So actually yeah, they will be able to tell and they will kind of question like, hey, this is not kind of hitting hitting where I need it to be, like, why is it so? so that's that's what keeps me up at night. and also because I wouldn't say that I'm an expert in cold storage, because I only actually really joined this this field like nearly two years ago, right? So there's still a lot of things to learn. but I think what we are doing slightly different from the market is that we're taking a very data-centric approach to this. And this is where kind of the technology stuff comes in. a lot of the coloms today, you have no idea what's going on. Like in order to find out what's wrong, you have to send someone down first to check what's wrong. And even before that, right? How they are doing it today is they get someone to manually record the temperature every hour. And if your cold room is at minus five and the next hour it's it's still at minus five, is it working or not? You can't really tell. Because you do not know what has happened within this one hour. Whether it went down to minus 18 and then it came up to minus five, you wouldn't know. But the guy is gonna tell you, okay, it's at minus five, I go in, it's cold, it's working. But it's not hitting the minus 18 because what could have really been is that your cold room has only dropped from minus six to minus five in the last five hours. Wouldn't you be able to tell if you're doing this manually. You'll only be able to tell if you are consistently tracking it minute by minute. Then you can kind of see the curve. But no one is gonna send someone to stand at the color to record it every minute. So a lot of this actually Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: goes unnoticed. And because of that, the colorom working like triply or doubly hard to keep the temperature. That kind of causes problems when something breaks because it's working harder than it should. So a lot of this compounds Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: to being able to see patterns in a color and trying to figure out what's wrong before it becomes a real problem. So a lot of things that we saw in the colorooms are little signs that start building over time. And then if you can get someone to kind of fix it early, then you'll be able to kind of mitigate a bigger problem down the road. So that's where kind of the data-centric approach comes in. Where right now, at any given time, we are collecting up to 15, 16 variables in a color. Like the pressure, the heat, the current, all these kinds of different areas of it. And then through all these data points, we actually kind of triangulate what's wrong with your colorums. Because if I know that this colorom been cooling down at a rate of like four. 0.4 degrees every minute. this shouldn't change if the cold room is working perfectly fine. But if for whatever reason it drops to 0.2, 0.1, and it becomes slow, then I know that something is wrong. So so we are using this approach and then we we analyze all the kind of values to see to see what could potentially be the problem. for example, I'm monitoring the exhaust temperature. If the exhaust temperature is too high. It means that the cold room is not able to push out the hot air. It could just mean that the filter is dirty and needs to be Arjun Thomas: Mm. Right. Joe Khoo: cleaned. And this kind of like, I would say a lower priority thing. Like we can schedule it one week in advance for someone to go down anytime because it's like not a killer problem. But if it's something like there's a leak in the refrigerant, like the refrigerant is slowly leaking, I can actually start seeing that the pressure that the cold room can build up drops. Then I know that okay, it's a refrigerant leak. And then this becomes a bigger problem because within one or two days it's gonna leak and then it's no longer able to cool the room. So before that happens, I was I will tell the technician, okay, we need this to be fixed. It is like 90% a refrigerant leak. So you have to bring your refrigerant with you and check it when you're down there. So when we talk to our technicians that go down, we give them a brief update about what are the data that we see, what needs to be looked at. So when they go down they specifically look at these issues and then they get it fixed. Arjun Thomas: Maybe it it's Since you've kind already started outlining it, a layman's perspective of how a cold room actually works. So I know there's obviously, you know, the it's it's a heat exchange system essentially. but but Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: but if you can just kind of break that down in layman's terms of what the components are and how all all kinds of works together, because you said you contain con collecting Joe Khoo: Mm. Arjun Thomas: about fifteen to sixteen variables. just for people to understand the complexity of of of a cold room in its essence, basically it's a way of understanding how your fridge fridge works at home in a way, right? So but but at a at a much larger scale. that would be kind of useful if you can do that. Joe Khoo: Yeah. So actually, just like what you mentioned, cold rooms work purely on the concept of heat exchange. in a whole system of a cold room, there's always a compressor and then there's an evaporator. compressor is where the hot gas is compressed, or the gas is compressed to provide the cool temperature that they need. and then when it runs through the pipes. There's air circulating in the cold rooms that is being pushed across all these pipes, where it exchanges out the hot air from the room with its cold temperature and it starts to evaporate because it's gaining heat from the cold rooms. So as it evaporates, it moves back to the compressor as a gas, and then the compressor compresses it back to a liquid to remove out all the heat. So Arjun Thomas: So liquid, yeah. Right. Joe Khoo: that's why the exhaust site is always hot because They are compressing the gas back to liquid and it's trying to remove all this hot air from the system and then it kinda kinda circulates. And then if you have not enough refrigerant inside the systems, like the pressure is too weak. there's not enough gas that's going through the the evaporator or the liquid, and then you can't really cool down the room enough because it's not as efficient as it could be. and then I think basically that's just a very quick summary of cold rooms and how it works, right? And then throughout all this, there's a lot of valves here and there that gets controlled. because you have to control the amount of gas or liquid that goes inside the system. If it's too much and the liquid doesn't evaporate fully, it goes back to the system as a liquid, it kind of screws up your system. So Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: there's a lot of control that goes behind the scene where you're controlling the amount of liquid that's going in. Yeah, controlling the amount of gas that's going out, things like that. Right. So all this becomes variables to how well a system works. And that's why in every kind of system that we deploy, we have around like 15 sensors inside that's constantly measuring like different things in the cold rooms. Arjun Thomas: Right. And and and again given that this is essentially a delicate dance as it were between two states of the liquid essentially of of of the of the of of the refrigerant essentially, a liquid state and a and a gas state, and you try to manage that very delicately to maximize efficiency, that's where predominantly I'm guessing the gains come from. So your system compared contrasted with a standard, you know, constructed cold room, the ener energy efficiency is how much? Is it forty percent? Or d was that a different number? Joe Khoo: 40% is if we put in the full suite of things that we have developed. but because for the containers we can do 40% because we can there's more space to put things inside. but for the polar boxes, I would say that it's around 15 to 20 percent. and the f the interesting thing is as long as your unit is efficient and good, I can kind of save up to 50% of the energy. Because I've seen some units from my system that are not efficient and they are running a lot. I think they are using twice as energy, twice as much energy than another unit that is like having its own efficiency. So I think efficiency apart is really about making sure that the unit has no problems and is running as it should be, so that the energy is as low as it can. And then once it's efficient, then we can talk about okay, how much more can I push this? and then with Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: the technology that we deploy, I can kind of push this for another 10-15%. But I would say that part of the energy lost or energy wasted comes from inefficient systems that is using like extra energy to run. yeah. Arjun Thomas: And I'm curious because given that maintaining this delicate dance one requires you to capture a lot of that data to anticipate problems, which is what you guys are doing, and that's I think the big USP, what does the maintenance schedule look like over the course of say one year for these kind of units? Is it very ad hoc? Is it dependent on external temperatures and variables or along those lines? Or is there like a schedule that says, Hey, on average I end up cleaning my filter, changing my filter five times in a year, my my my gas refrigerant seems to kind of leak twice in a year. Is there are there any patterns that seem to kind of emerge? Just for me to get a sense of operationally how complicated this thing to kind of keep on the fine edge Joe Khoo: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: of performance. Joe Khoo: So I think when we came into this market, the standard was every six months you should have it maintained. And by maintained, it means that you should get it the filter clean, you should get the refrigerant checked, topped up, and then every other thing. So it's like everything in in in six months, right? and then I also heard people saying that if your environment is a little bit more dusty and stuff, you should do it every three months. So those was kind of the industry standard. So for us, we don't like to set these kind of standards because Arjun Thomas: Mm. Joe Khoo: it is an operating cost on our balance sheet. So for us, we really look at what are the most common issues that people face. How can we detect this early in our system? And we will we will only really clean it when it needs to be cleaned, or we will only send people down when it really needs to be looked at. If it's working fine, the variables and the performance has been constant throughout, then more or less this unit is going to be fine. So we don't have to touch it. So I have units that have been running for a good six to eight months that we haven't really touched. I have some units that have been running for one year that we haven't really touched, because everything seems fine. So I think we are doing things a little bit differently. And I cannot give you a clear schedule because we don't do it that way. Like we don't follow a timetable. Yeah, we follow kind of a date, Arjun Thomas: No, it makes sense. Joe Khoo: the kind of a data-backed solution. And also the fact that In the Philippines, traveling is a pain. Like some of the locations are like four hours away, five hours away, which is not like Singapore where you can do in 30 minutes. So Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: these are things that we try to anticipate and then we kind of plan out our schedule to make sure that we can find people to go down. But basically, yeah, we we do it kind of on an ad hoc basis, depending on how urgent the problem is. Arjun Thomas: And I want to touch upon one last thing. two two things. One is the kind of digital locks you guys kind of built. I think lessons from your previous experience. I think be good to understand how that works. and the the energy inconsistency. So how much of a problem is it in in the Philippines or at least the areas that you've deployed where you have power going down? Like how often does it happen? and how do you kind of mitigate that? I'm assuming it's a as with most third world or well. developing world develop developing market metros that is a a prevel prevalent problem. Joe Khoo: Yeah, so to be honest, through the business, through this rental model that we started since about maybe eight to nine months ago. Haven't really seen a true blackout event or a brownout event until yesterday. Yesterday night when I was on the flight back from the Philippines, I landed, I looked at the data, and I saw that one of Arjun Thomas: d Right. Joe Khoo: my units had an alarm. I looked into it, it was Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: it was an over voltage kind of alarm. And I went to the data and I saw that the power, the voltage of the system went from your 220 down to about 1890 volts. means that something happened. So and the unit was not coming back online by Arjun Thomas: Great. Joe Khoo: itself, right? So I told my team like, hey, I have some, I think this unit has some problem. Could you check in with the customer on like how's the unit? Is the unit like, is it okay? Is it damaged? Because like too low a voltage will also kind of damage your kind of equipment. So I my team checked in, came back around 11 pm and said that they actually had a brownout. But the people there are dealing with it. Like they know that these kind of things happen. So they what they did is actually they moved their goods to some other places for the meantime and then they plan to bring it back tomorrow morning. So when it comes to brownouts, I think the people in the Philippines are very, very used to it. For good or for bad, they are very, very used to it, and they usually have this at the back of their head. for food. It's less troublesome because the food can stay cold for up to eight, eight, nine hours in a freezer room. and you'll still be fine. but I think for more sensitive products, which some of the customers that we deal with, dealing with pharmaceutical vaccines and stuff, they will start asking about is there any backup power that comes with this? Right. So so those are the services that we are also starting to look at. because it is a demand from the market and knowingly because cold chain is such a intense kind of environment thing if it breaks it breaks and you lose all your goods people have thought about kind of backup power for the longest time yeah and so that's something that we do that we are looking into now that i think would be kind of a complementary service to to what we offer as well but roundups how we detect that that's a good question also so for our systems We actually deploy a 4G router with all of our columns. And we run this 4G router on backup power that is very small, like a box kind of backup power that's connected to the columns. So whenever power cuts, right, the 4G router will still be working. We can actually check in with the 4G router whether the 4G router is still working. And if the 4G router is working but the polar box is not working, we know that okay, something has kind of broke here. And that is how we kind of see whether is this a brownout issue or not. Because technically, if everything is working, everything has power, the you the backup power shouldn't kind of switch on, things like that. So something that we did previously was also we installed cameras together with this backup power that supplies power to both our router and our cameras. So when something happens, we will check by going into the camera to take a look at around the site to see what's happening. and then we can determine whether it's the whole site down or things like that. for places that have a little bit more deployments, we can actually check across units. If I only have one unit that is down instead of three, then I would suspect that this is more of a Wi-Fi issue than a power issue. But if all the units are down, then okay, this might be a power issue. So I think from what we are deploying, we are slowly trying to learn all these kinds of patterns. And then we're trying to integrate this all into our algorithm to help make it smarter to say, is this site experiencing just Wi-Fi problems or is this site experiencing electrical problems or like is this unit experience what kind of problems? So I think with all the data that we're collecting and how our users are using it, we are trying to enhance the algorithm to be able to work better. one, it is to help us because we are the one that's managing all these units. But secondly, I think with all this data, we can also kind of provide some assurance to our customers that we are we are doing things in a very scientific way and a very data backed way. and if they are ever interested, they can also get access to the data to kind of strengthen their own operations if ever needed. Yeah. Arjun Thomas: And the la the last thing that I wanted to touch upon on the technology was the smart locks. we had a conversation a while ago. I'm not sure if I'm entirely accurate in recalling this, which is you had some digital smart locks on on on the on the boxes itself. so what are they and why do you need them? you you said there were some military grade rocks, like i i i Joe Khoo: Yes. Arjun Thomas: is there specific reason you guys went so hardcore on that? Joe Khoo: I mean the reason why it's a military great military grade log is because in my previous company I I was working as a product manager there and I was in charge of kind of the padlock category. and then the first padlock they ever built had a lot of issues and then I was kind of tasked to kind of work on a new generation of padlocks. And then I mean as someone that's technical, you want to kind of build the best lock in the market. So we try to kind of try to kind of Arjun Thomas: She went all in. Joe Khoo: Try to push a little bit on the on some of the specs. But I think for us in this point of time, the the padlock has also taken a little back seat because we are moving away from a rental hub concept. And we are trying to deploy it at people's location, right? When we deploy it at people's location, Arjun Thomas: Okay. Yeah, then locks become less. Joe Khoo: the locks become less important, but the locks right now Arjun Thomas: Right. Joe Khoo: at some of our hubs are actually pretty useful. In the sense that I have a customer that has rented our call room for three days. Three days only. I I issued him a pin code that works for three days. Correct? And then on the third day he came, or actually on the fourth day he came and he said, I need to take my goods, but my pin code is not working. Can you extend my rental for another day? So I told him, okay, I'm gonna give you another pin code, but this time it will only be a one-time pin code. Means you use it one time and it stops working. He gets his stuff and he leaves. And then the next time I told him like if you're ever gonna do this again, you have to pay. So the padlock gives me unprecedented control over who comes in and out of the codes. and that becomes a gating feature for us to make sure that we get paid for the services that we are providing. Because if not, the people leave their goods inside and they abandon it and then they kind of suffer some losses on their end as well. if then if they want to get access to it, they have to pay up and then they get access and then they can kind of go. So I think in that sense the the padlock has been very useful in that particular category, in to kind of control how people come in and out and making sure that people pay before before they get their goods. But other than that, it's very useful to have this kind of technology at the end of the day because you never know when someone wants to rent something, right? Like I have a guy that can comes in today and says, hey, I want to rent it for one week. Can I start today? And he comes in in the night to bring his goods. So with all this kind of technology in place, you can actually do it on the go. I can do it from my phone today to give him a pin code. it doesn't require me to be there. So it really enables the team to be very lean because technically you can communicate with this guy through the phone and say that, okay, you're on site, okay. I'm gonna generate a pin code now. use this to get access. And then you don't need To send someone from your team to go down to kind of like process all this kind of usually very kind of admin heavy, tedious task. So I think on the Padloc side, it has allowed us to do this. and I'm actually very grateful for that. yeah, but I think as we pivot away from this hub model for now, because it just makes more sense to not deal with the hubs at the moment, I think we will revisit it in the future. And when we revisit in the future, I think we would still rely heavily on the padlocks to kind of enable these kind of features. Yeah. But not to say that for our larger customers, there is no need for this because the larger customers has a need for traceability, who's coming in and out and things like that. So I still see some deployments potential for the padlocks, but it's very much dependent on the client now rather than us in this case. Arjun Thomas: Very interesting. it makes sense. I mean all the the cost savings that you have operationally go into I guess the technology and therefore in a way your bottom line. which brings me to my next question. With all this tech that you've packed into essentially a refrigerator in the form of a form factor of a shipping container, how much does that cost for you guys to kind of build this together? And how does that contrast in terms of something similar without all this loaded tech? just to kinda get a sense of what the CapEx needs are for a Joe Khoo: I think that Capex is not. Super expensive. So to get a container built is maybe about 10,000 US dollars. And then for a for a polar box, which is a smaller variant, it's only around 2,000 plus. It's pretty affordable. But I think the biggest challenge into the Philippines is usually a custom custom clearance and trying to bring it into the country. That's the number one problem you'll face because you'll get quoted for like X amount of dollars. And then you pay and then it lands and then the guy say, Okay, the custom guy charged me more, like 2x your what you paid me. Pay me now, then I can release your items. And then you're like, what the hell? Is it gonna pay? Then so it's it's also a little bit Arjun Thomas: Yes. Yeah. Joe Khoo: about the the things that are going on in the pots are also like questionable. so yeah, then that kind of changes the cost and everything. But overall, I think we've managed to shrug a good deal with our supplier as well. Like this is just kind of a volume volume thing, right? If you can order more, the price is gonna go down further. So that's why we're trying to hit for our for our next batch of orders. Then I can we can kind of bring it at a lower cost to lower the cost further for us. Arjun Thomas: And this is based manufactured all in China. Great. I think you know we've probably gone an hour in. we've covered pretty much everything that I had to. and I do really appreciate the time. I know how difficult it is to carve out an hour or more as a busy founder and you're juggling I wouldn't say jet lag but the after effects of dealing with the Manila traffic, I think which is tiring enough in its own fashion. what's the plan for polar cold next? What are you guys you said you were looking at potentially raising more capital. are you guys looking at another funding round? Are looking at expanding more aggressively in the Philippines, given that you seem to have iden figured out the production model, are you toying with the idea of deploying in another country that might be easier? where's your head at? Joe Khoo: I think where we are where we are right now, we are in a good place. two months two months ago, we still had trouble filling up our boxes. we had like 50% inventory still available. but where we are now today, it's it's almost 90, 95% filled. So that's kind of a good place to to be. I think we have also kind of figured out how to kind of talk to the market, how to sell these kind of things. And a lot of the corporate side is also starting to move. so we anticipate a larger scale that's gonna come. So I think I would say that we are around 24 boxes right now in the Philippines, and I expect by the end of the year we will hit around 89, 90, 100 boxes by the end of the year. So that's where our projection is gonna be. but right now, I like I told you, the biggest problem is is money capital on how are we gonna pay for these boxes to bring them in to start kinda increasing our revenue. So in the near term, Philippines will still be the place that we're gonna be. because beyond Metro Manila, it's very easy to look at Mindanao and Cebu, which is still part of Philippines but very separate market. so there's like big opportunities there. And we believe that by building our reputation in Metro Manila, it makes us easy to go into Mindanao and and and Cebu area. So I think in the near future we're gonna be here. and right now, actually, we are in the midst of going into fundraising mode again because now we are super confident of our numbers. the numbers look great. the payback, the payback period for all our capex has been reduced from 22 to about 10 months. So so Arjun Thomas: Wow, it's a huge jump. Joe Khoo: that so that's a huge jump. So I think we believe that right now we are we are a bit More comfortable in our numbers. And we're gonna go into fundraising to kind of raise just enough money for us to hit break-even. and that's where we want to be by the end of the year. So I think that's the goal for for this year to really break even and to make this an attractive business. and I think judging by where we are going and how much we are growing, I I think it's valuable. Arjun Thomas: And on that positive note, I think we're good to go unless there's something else that you want to discuss. Joe Khoo: No, I think I think I had a good time kinda sharing sharing this with you. So thank you for kinda having me and I hope this is useful for anyone who kind of listens to it. Arjun Thomas: for sure. I think as always, understanding how a new business is built, understanding it from a f first person perspective, which is the founder, I think is immensely valuable for anyone attempting to try to build this themselves or even someone curious about how coal storage works or or why does anyone care about cold storage or the complexities of cold storage in emerging markets. I think is it's just a fascinating read and it w it it was a great experience for me. I learned a lot of a lot of things I didn't know. so appreciate the time again. And And yeah, looking forward to catching up maybe in in person again. I know you run run into you and your kids on National Day, but love to g Joe Khoo: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: catch up for a coffee or a beer. and and and best of luck on on the fundraise. I'm happy to kinda connect you with anyone that I know. so if you need any Joe Khoo: Thank you, thank you. Arjun Thomas: network reach, feel free to reach out to me. it is a very interesting space. and you guys seem to have all the fundamentals in place, which is, you know, which is ninety-nine percent of the work. So congratulations. Joe Khoo: Yeah, took a took us a long time to come to reach this part, but I think we're in a good place. like I always say, compared to where we were eight months ago, I think we are more sure about ourselves. and we are convinced that you know there is a there's a space for this modular idea that we are kind of work working on at the moment. Arjun Thomas: All right, Joe. Thanks a ton. have a wonderful day and we shall speak soon. Bye bye. Joe Khoo: Right, thank you, Arjun. See you. Bye-bye.