Latest / The Film Hobbyist / In the Heat of the Night (1967): Anger and Empathy
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're here in a nook of my attic room. Between
- 0:36us is a window facing the backyard. It's still
- 0:40incredibly cold out, but the sun is shining.
- 0:44Since my windows are south -facing and the trees
- 0:47are bare, we are absolutely baking under the
- 0:50glass, sweltering like it's the middle of July.
- 0:54I don't much appreciate it then, but I just about
- 0:58do now, when the alternative is shivering under
- 1:02several layers. I have a confession to make.
- 1:08There's a hole in my film -watching history,
- 1:11a bear patch, and that would be the mid -1960s
- 1:15to the mid -1970s. This isn't to say I haven't
- 1:20watched films from this era, I certainly have,
- 1:23but I haven't watched many, and the ones that
- 1:27I have are either considered slight entries by
- 1:31most or haven't given me much to talk about.
- 1:35I can see the look on your face. Yes, I'm aware
- 1:40that for many, this was the greatest era in film
- 1:44history. The Hollywood studio system collapsed,
- 1:48making way for real artistic triumph. Films for
- 1:53adults about the real world made by men of vision.
- 1:57This majestic land between the Dream Factory
- 2:01and the corporate takeover. It was the heyday
- 2:05of the auteur, when a director could bring his
- 2:08singular artistic vision to a project and see
- 2:11it through to the end. Coppola, Kubrick, Scorsese,
- 2:16The Graduate, Chinatown, Midnight Cowboy. And
- 2:21largely, I'm not interested. Again, I have seen
- 2:28some of these films that cinephiles and film
- 2:31buffs hold up as the pinnacle of the art. Someday
- 2:35when I'm feeling feisty, we can have a conversation
- 2:38about The Godfather and how it isn't a perfect
- 2:42film. But broadly, I avoid films from this era.
- 2:48I've spoken with you before about how I can't
- 2:51do bleak films or heavy films. How they weigh
- 2:56on me, affecting my quality of life and mental
- 2:59health. And most of these amazing films, the
- 3:03ones held up as pinnacles of achievement, they
- 3:07are bleak, cynical, and depressing. To be fair,
- 3:13this era was a particularly disruptive one in
- 3:16American history. The despair and cynicism come
- 3:20honestly. But I can't live there. Neither do
- 3:26I want to be a tourist. Since you started coming
- 3:31to visit, I thought it was time to fill this
- 3:35hole, to try and find films from this era that
- 3:39I want to talk about. Which has actually proved
- 3:43more difficult than I initially realized. Most
- 3:47streaming services don't have a search category
- 3:49for classic films. If they do, it can be difficult
- 3:54to find anything made before 1980. Disney Plus
- 3:58really only has their classic animated Disney
- 4:01films. Amazon Prime hides old movies further
- 4:05down the page or lumps them under the add -on
- 4:08subscription of MGM Plus. HBO Max, thankfully,
- 4:13has the Turner Classic Movie Collection. But
- 4:16that will go away after Warner Bros. Discovery
- 4:19is split into a film entity and a TV entity,
- 4:24either when it's acquired by Netflix, or if that
- 4:28deal falls through, unless Paramount acquires
- 4:33it instead. Goodness gracious, I'm tired of corporate
- 4:37consolidation. You can find movies if you already
- 4:42know specifically what you want to watch. Ad
- 4:46-supported platforms like Pluto TV and Tubi often
- 4:49stream online without a subscription, but that
- 4:53whole experience is not the same as browsing.
- 4:56In this case, I don't know exactly what I'm looking
- 5:00for. Or perhaps I'm trying to make my way off
- 5:05the beaten path, away from Taxi Driver and One
- 5:09Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. I've spent time
- 5:13at the library as well, discovering that my local
- 5:16library is excellent at collecting recent independent
- 5:20film, but has a far more limited classic collection.
- 5:24And in all this hunting, online and in person,
- 5:29what I most discovered was an outsized representation
- 5:32of films starring Sidney Poitier. Poitier was
- 5:38a Bahamian -American actor most known for his
- 5:41work in the 1960s, notable as the first Black
- 5:45man to win an Oscar for Best Actor for 1963's
- 5:49Lilies of the Field, and the only one to win
- 5:52that award in the 20th century. He had amazing
- 5:55screen presence, a command of the camera that
- 5:59is impossible to deny. His first Oscar nomination
- 6:03was for 1958's The Defiant Ones, which he starred
- 6:07in alongside Tony Curtis. It's a little funny
- 6:11to watch today. That film is largely from Curtis's
- 6:15perspective, with Poitier as the figure of suspicion,
- 6:19because he's black. And it's remarkable how confusing
- 6:23it is for the film to assume its audience will
- 6:26care more about Curtis than Poitier. when Poitier
- 6:30absolutely commands the camera in every single
- 6:33scene. Poitier was an incredibly important figure
- 6:38for civil rights and film, not just because of
- 6:41his Oscar win, but for how he helped change the
- 6:44perception of African Americans, moving away
- 6:47from subservient or comical portrayals to characters
- 6:51of dignity and respect. But today, more than
- 6:5550 years later, his legacy is a little more complicated.
- 7:00It's hard to deny that while he commanded respect
- 7:04with confidence in his portrayals, he also represented
- 7:08a kind of blackness that was more comfortable
- 7:12to white America. Soft -spoken, polite, dignified,
- 7:18dare I say, articulate? Take 1967's Guess Who's
- 7:25Coming to Dinner, about the small uproar in a
- 7:28fairly progressive family when their white daughter
- 7:31brings home her boyfriend, and he's black. For
- 7:35the film to work, for the audience to fully join
- 7:38the father on his journey, the boyfriend Paul
- 7:41has to be utterly wonderful, except for his skin
- 7:46color. That way, the father is most challenged
- 7:50in his prejudices. But this means that a lot
- 7:54of Black culture, which is warmer and more free
- 7:58-flowing than the dynamic between Spencer Tracy
- 8:00and Katharine Hepburn, isn't really present here.
- 8:04Sidney Poitier is everything white, upper -middle
- 8:09-class parents would want for their daughter.
- 8:12Now, none of that is Poitier's fault. In the
- 8:16first case, Poitier lived in the Bahamas until
- 8:19he was 15. A Bahamian accent is literally more
- 8:24soft -spoken than an American one. It's centered
- 8:27in a different part of the mouth, more towards
- 8:30the front, making it closer to an English accent
- 8:34in that respect. While Poitier worked to make
- 8:38his pronunciation more American, he still spoke
- 8:41from the same place in his mouth, and it just
- 8:44literally changes the sound quality. In another
- 8:48case, Poitier originally began his career on
- 8:51the stage, and you can tell. His style reminds
- 8:55me a lot of actors who come out of the Royal
- 8:58Shakespeare Company, like Patrick Stewart and
- 9:01Kenneth Branagh. There's a more upright carriage
- 9:05in that kind of acting style. As for the actual
- 9:09characters, Poitier was very aware of the limit
- 9:14to them. In a 1967 interview, he confessed that
- 9:18he'd actually loved to play villains, but he
- 9:22knew it was important for white Americans to
- 9:25see Black people represented positively as much
- 9:29as possible. And I think he's not wrong. It's
- 9:33easy to be frustrated at the lack of genuine
- 9:36complexity in many roles lauded among the white
- 9:39film establishment. Just look at the current
- 9:42Oscars discourse around the difference in representation
- 9:46between Ryan Coogler's Sinners and Paul Thomas
- 9:50Anderson's One Battle After Another, the latter
- 9:53being the frontrunner for many of this year's
- 9:56Oscar races, despite the former's more authentic
- 10:00representation of Black women. But I don't think
- 10:04we get Sinners taking the record for the most
- 10:07Oscar nominations of all time without Poitier's
- 10:11imperfect representation. Today I'd like to talk
- 10:17about 1967's In the Heat of the Night, directed
- 10:20by Norman Jewison. It won five Oscars, including
- 10:25Best Picture, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best
- 10:29Actor. Not for Poitier, but for his white co
- 10:33-star Rod Steiger. This is one of those movies
- 10:37with a complicated legacy. On the one hand, it's
- 10:42held up as a best picture winner that tackled
- 10:45racism and racial conflict head on. In 1967,
- 10:50just three years after the Civil Rights Act was
- 10:53passed, this meant a lot. But discourse on the
- 10:57film points out how much leeway is given to Steiger's
- 11:02police chief Gillespie, especially with how icky
- 11:06he is, and how the redneck, small -town, southern
- 11:09vibe lets people outside of those communities
- 11:12feel better about themselves. Just look at those
- 11:16dumb hicks. Glad I'm not like them. Also, with
- 11:21the amount of systemic racism in policing in
- 11:25America, even by officers of color, I think there's
- 11:29a bit of critique for how Poitier's character
- 11:31is positioned as the right kind of cop. All of
- 11:36this is why I hadn't watched this movie before.
- 11:41I work really hard to listen to diverse communities
- 11:44and watch the movies they recommend. There are
- 11:48only so many films to watch in a lifetime, after
- 11:51all. but again i wanted to watch films from the
- 11:56nineteen sixties that were available to me and
- 12:00that meant in the heat of the night now having
- 12:04seen it i can understand both perspectives the
- 12:09film has some incredible craft There's a chase
- 12:12sequence in the first half that switches from
- 12:15handheld footage to an extreme wide shot of a
- 12:19bridge with a super long lens that zooms in on
- 12:22a guy running before cutting to a perfectly matched
- 12:26tracking shot of a car. Legendary director Hal
- 12:30Ashby served as the editor for this film, and
- 12:33he did an amazing job putting together the shots
- 12:36filmed by cinematographer Haskell Wexler. also
- 12:41understands the perspectives of those who critique
- 12:44this film. Chief Gillespie makes an awfully quick
- 12:49flip from let's lock this inconvenient black
- 12:52guy in a cell with a violent criminal on the
- 12:55off chance he'll take care of this problem for
- 12:57us, to I'm going to defend this black guy from
- 13:01the dudes trying to lynch him. It's a matter
- 13:04of hours. And as well -spoken as Poitier's Virgil
- 13:09Tibbs is, It does seem like he would be the exceptional
- 13:13Black man in Gillespie's mind, the only one worthy
- 13:18of respect, rather than really challenging how
- 13:22he treats Black people generally. There were
- 13:26also a couple of cringey lines with how members
- 13:28of the Black community talked to each other.
- 13:31Knowing how important dressing well for church
- 13:34on Sunday still is in the Black community, and
- 13:37how important church has generally been in Southern
- 13:41Black communities, I find it highly disingenuous
- 13:45that a Black man would say he'd never seen another
- 13:49Black man in a suit before. Really? Not even
- 13:54the preacher? Even so, there were some things...
- 14:00that surprised me about this film, especially
- 14:03Poitier's performance and characterization. He
- 14:07gets angry in this movie. And for a black man
- 14:12to be portrayed as angry, and for that to be
- 14:15seen as a positive thing and not a thing of scorn,
- 14:18is incredibly rare. I recognize that you probably
- 14:24haven't seen this film either. but I can guarantee
- 14:28you're more familiar with it than you realize.
- 14:31What's important for you to know is that this
- 14:34film is a police procedural murder mystery set
- 14:38in the small town of Sparta, Mississippi, right
- 14:41on the border of Arkansas. One hot summer night
- 14:45while driving out on patrol, a local cop stumbles
- 14:49on the dead body of a Chicago industrialist in
- 14:53town to help build a new factory. His wallet
- 14:56is missing. Police Chief Bill Gillespie helps
- 15:00set up the crime scene and sends this officer
- 15:03out to scour the town to look for any hitchhikers
- 15:06who might be around. At the local train depot,
- 15:10he finds something surprising. A black man, sitting
- 15:15and waiting on a bench at 3am. His wallet full
- 15:19of cash. That's all the evidence he needs. He
- 15:24pulls his gun, arrests the man, and drives him
- 15:27over to the police station for his chief to inspect.
- 15:31The man, Virgil Tibbs, explains that the cash
- 15:35was his money from his weekly salary. When Gillespie
- 15:39questions what kind of job would give this man
- 15:42that kind of money, he answers truthfully. I'm
- 15:46a police officer. Philadelphia homicide detective,
- 15:56just passing through after a visit to his mother,
- 15:59heading home on the 4 a .m. train. But the 4
- 16:04a .m. train has just left, and a call to Tibbs'
- 16:08own police chief yields a strange order. Why
- 16:12don't you stay and help out? Tibbs' police chief
- 16:17is white, right? He's gotta be white. That's
- 16:21the only way any of this makes sense. So Tibbs
- 16:25must stay. And help a bunch of inept, racist
- 16:29cops do their jobs. Black audiences at the time
- 16:34of release nicknamed this film Super Spade vs.
- 16:37the Rednecks. Superspade being a term that referenced
- 16:41what we would now call black excellence, the
- 16:44idea that for a black person to succeed in a
- 16:46white world, they have to go above and beyond
- 16:49in skill, knowledge, and presentation. And yeah,
- 16:53that's pretty much this film in a nutshell. In
- 16:57the first act of this film, Gillespie gets a
- 17:00good deal of amusement out of Virgil's name.
- 17:04In a world where black men are referred to as
- 17:07boy, or worse, it's delightfully incongruous
- 17:11to picture one with such an elegant name. Though
- 17:15eventually, he gets annoyed by it, just as he
- 17:19gets frustrated with Virgil doing a better job
- 17:21than him and his officers at solving the case.
- 17:25In a rageful near accusation, which I will merely
- 17:28paraphrase here, he asks disingenuously how anyone
- 17:33could refer to him as Virgil in Philadelphia.
- 17:35What could they call him up there? And Poitier,
- 17:40eyes smoldering with rage after being referred
- 17:43to by the N -word, declares, they call me Mr.
- 17:48Tibbs. This is a line that you've definitely
- 17:53heard quoted before. It shows up as a joke in
- 17:57a number of sitcoms, and weirdly, in The Lion
- 18:01King, during the final battle. The hyenas are
- 18:06about to eat Zazu and Timon when Pumbaa shows
- 18:09up at the cave entrance. The hyenas call him
- 18:12a pig. Then Pumbaa quotes first Robert De Niro's
- 18:17You talkin' to me? from Taxi Driver before shouting
- 18:20They call me! Mr. Pig! It's a very weird reference.
- 18:27Are we meant to think that Pig is derogatory
- 18:30in this instance? Or a slur? Is there some kind
- 18:34of implied species racism here that Pumbaa is
- 18:37overcoming? Is it a double slur by referencing
- 18:40the fact that both Tibbs and Gillespie are cops?
- 18:44My guess is that it's just a surface reference
- 18:47to get a chuckle out of the adults in the room.
- 18:51but knowing where it comes from only makes the
- 18:53joke weirder, not funnier. And watching the original
- 18:58scene, in context, is pretty powerful. Poitier's
- 19:04delivery is closer to a growl than a shout, but
- 19:08my brain remembers it as a shout because of how
- 19:11powerfully it's said. Anger is a politicized
- 19:16emotion. In film, White villains get angry, but
- 19:22so do white heroes. There's a long history of
- 19:26righteous white anger directed towards other
- 19:29racist white people. But in most films, black
- 19:33anger isn't heroic. There are exceptions. Spike
- 19:40Lee's Do the Right Thing, a valuable example.
- 19:43But that film's portrayal of Black anger lost
- 19:46it to the Oscar to the placid portrayal of racism
- 19:50in Driving Miss Daisy, and many producers thought
- 19:53it would induce riots if Black people watched
- 19:56it. Black anger is usually a sign of villainy,
- 20:01proof that the character is the wrong kind of
- 20:04Black person. or it's relished as a kind of cathartic
- 20:08vengeance, as in blaxploitation. In portrayals
- 20:13of Black women, anger is a common stereotype,
- 20:17proof that Black women are less controlled than
- 20:20white women. The biggest critique against this
- 20:24year's Oscar frontrunner, One Battle After Another,
- 20:28is its portrayal of Black women as angry, violent,
- 20:32sexy objects to be desired and pursued by white
- 20:35men. So it is really, really surprising to see
- 20:40the Black hero of a film accepted by the white
- 20:43establishment get angry and have that be seen
- 20:47as a good thing. And not just a good thing, but
- 20:52a source of shared perspective. In the second
- 20:57half of the film, Tibbs and Gillespie drive to
- 20:59interrogate one of the last men to have seen
- 21:02the victim alive, the wealthy cotton plantation
- 21:05owner Endicott. They find him in his greenhouse,
- 21:09tending to orchids. He's surprisingly polite
- 21:12to both men, offering Tibbs lemonade. Earlier,
- 21:17Tibbs found a clue, a piece of exotic potting
- 21:20soil. As they chat about orchids, Tibbs showing
- 21:24his intelligence and Endicott revealing a sickening,
- 21:28patronizing kind of racism, Tibbs brings up the
- 21:32potting soil in the orchids by name. For the
- 21:36first time, Gillespie lets himself be wowed by
- 21:40Tibbs' detecting skills. Tibbs, having found
- 21:45what he needed, turns to go. And Endicott realizes
- 21:49that he wasn't in control of the meeting. Tibbs
- 21:54lays out his cards, sharing what he knows about
- 21:56Endicott and his connection to the victim. Endicott
- 22:01slaps him. And Tibbs, not missing a beat, slaps
- 22:07him back. The acting by Larry Gates as Endicott
- 22:11is amazing here. He looks like a hurt little
- 22:15boy, absolutely caught off guard that he could
- 22:19be slapped back. That's against the rules. He
- 22:23looks to Gillespie. You saw it? What are you
- 22:27gonna do about it? He pouts. And Gillespie says,
- 22:31I don't know. Outside, Tibbs is positively fuming,
- 22:38swearing that he's absolutely going to nail him.
- 22:42This is not spoiling things. The mystery is more
- 22:45complicated and twisty than that. And Gillespie
- 22:48says, Man, you're just like the rest of us, ain't
- 22:55you? I think the intention of this line, based
- 23:00on the reaction Poitier gives him, was meant
- 23:03to challenge Tibbs that he's being racist too.
- 23:09But intention is not the most important part
- 23:11of interpretation. And I can't help but point
- 23:14out that the literal text is Gillespie realizing
- 23:19that Tibbs is just like him. This is the first
- 23:25time that Tibbs has become human to him. And
- 23:29it wasn't in his calm. And it wasn't in his respectability.
- 23:33And it wasn't in his nice suits. It wasn't even
- 23:37that they were both police. It was his anger.
- 23:42That was what they had in common. After this
- 23:47scene, Gillespie goes from frustrated by Tibbs,
- 23:51or playing nice, to defending him and genuinely
- 23:55collaborating with him. I think the intended
- 23:59turning point... is the soil, the first time
- 24:02he respects Tibbs. But my interpretation is it
- 24:07just opened his eyes wide enough to see Tibbs'
- 24:11anger as familiar. We don't think of anger as
- 24:17unifying. And yes, it can be a terrible, ugly
- 24:22thing, an unthinking impulse to lash out. But
- 24:28anger does have a place. I like the way Pixar's
- 24:32Inside Out describes it. It is good to be angry
- 24:41at injustice. It is good to be angry when the
- 24:46world is out of joint. And I think there is something
- 24:50challenging, in a good way, about the use of
- 24:54anger in this film. All humans have all the emotions.
- 25:01A full human isn't polite and nice all the time.
- 25:05Neither is a full human just a ball of wrath.
- 25:09Humans are both. They are capable of both. This,
- 25:15frankly, is the kind of representation on film
- 25:19minorities in our country are hungry for. Heck,
- 25:23it's still pretty groundbreaking for a white
- 25:26female character to show rage and even rarer
- 25:29for her to show anger and humor and tenderness
- 25:33in the same film. In this film, anger becomes
- 25:38the beginning of empathy. It's when Poitier is
- 25:44at his least respectful, his least polite, his
- 25:47most petty, that Gillespie looks and sees a human.
- 25:53And for all the ways that this film hasn't aged
- 25:56well, That stands out as pretty revolutionary.
- 26:04Thanks for coming.